53

52

OCHOBHbIE CTAllIU I MOPAJlb HOM

COQMAJIH3AQMM

O A FYJleeul

COCTORHl1e MOpaJIbHOrO C03HaHIll1 - OnHa 113 OCHOBHhIX n p 06JIeM 06shy

CY)K1IaeMbIX B XO1le 06~eCrneHlIlgtlX lII1CKYCCHH fa K n p aBI1JIO peL[b

l111eT 0 laquonalleHUI1 MOpaJIUWIO yp013H l1 vI laquoHe06 xoAHMOCTI1 M OpaJIbHOshy

ro pa3BI1TI1Rraquo rpa)K1IaH B lJeM OHO 3aIJl]O1 lt1 en n ~I I(tK rrpoI1CXO1ll1T

TICI1XOJIorl1 I1CKaJII1 OTBeT Ha 3TO1 Bon r oc IIlt I1P QTIDflteHl1l1 60JIbIllei1

QaCTI1 XX B

Cy~ecTBylOT pa3HbIe orrpe1leJIeHl1lt Mvpa JUL O1lJlaKO KaK npa Bl1JIO

no1l HeH IIOHI1MaeT CR cOBoKynHOCTlgt I-lOPM (Tp c60 naW 1H 11 3aupeTOB)

peryJII1PY lO11II1 X OTHOIIleHl15I Me)1Iy )1 fOAbMH Hapywe Hl1e KOT OPbIX

paCCMaTpl1BaeTCH B TepMHHax laquoxopollt o - nnoxobull laquolI06pO-3JIOraquo OHI1

CY11leCTBYlOT JIl1IIlb Ha ypOBHe rrpe1lCTaUl te t t HH IltfX middottOCJfTeJIeH T e He 3ashy

CP I1KCl1pOBaHbI ocpl1l~HaJIbHO a KOHTpOJlb 3a l-II[MT OCYll~eCTBJIHIOT OTshy

1IeJIbHble JUOllH 11 He cpopMaJIbHble 06beAI1HeHl~ H

TaKl1e HOPMbI UXO1l51T B COCTaB MOpaJIbJ-torn COl11aHH51 KOTopoe

peryJIl1pyeT Me)JIl1IHOCTHbIe OTHOJIIeHl15I a Tlt1IOKC I1rpaeT 6 0JIbWYlO

pOJIb B npaBoBoi1 (Block 2003 d e Vries W a lker 1986 M c Farland

Mathews 2005) 11 IIOlI l1TJfte cKoi1 (Emler 2002 Ja rfee H y d e 2000) )113HI1 06~ecTBa B 03Hl1KaeT Bonpoc KaKl1M 06pa30M OHO CP OPMWPYshy

eTC5I KaKl1e cTa1lIHI npOXO1lHT B CBoeM pa3BHTHH

TIepnbIM OTBeT Ha 3TOT Bonpoc nOI1bITaJICH 1IaT gt )1 nl1ruKe ITo ero

MHeHl1lO OCHOBY MOpaJIbHOrO C03HaHHfI COC1aB1I5110l 3a IIpeTbI onpe shy

1Ie1lHIO~l1e q TO laquoXOP OIllOraquo a lJTO laquoIIJIOXOraquo KaK CJIellltlBl1e MOpaJlbli Oe

pa3BI1TI1e CBH3 aHO C 113MCHe Hl1eM OTHOIlleHI151 K HYiM n J1ruJlte pa3611JI

3TOT npo~ecc Ha ABe CTaNIH - M o palIb npHY)l(J1eHlUI Ii MOp a JIb Koorreshy

pa~1111 ( HHKOJIaena 1995) llJIfi pe6eKKa HaXOllfImerOCH Ha CTa1lI1H laquoMOp31Il[ n p H HY) 1IeHI1H

xapaKTepeH 3rO~eHTp113M OH He M O)eT rcOCMOTPCTb n a JTPOI1CXO1lfI~l1e

C06bITI1H C n03H~fH 1Ipyroro 1eJlOBeKa o~eHHTb ero )ena HI1H 11 M OTI1BbI

OCHOBHbLe cmaouu MOpaJLbHoi1 cOl~uaJLu3a4uu

nOBe1leHI1H B 3TOM B03paCTe ero CY)1IeHI1H CI1JIbHO 3aBI1CHT OT MHeHHH

1i3pOCJIOro 1eJIOBeKa 06JIa1lalO~ero BJIaCTblO 11 aBTOpl1TeTOM TI03TOMY

CO1lep)aHHe MOpaJlbHoi1 ccpepbI COCTaBJIHlOT 3a rrpeTbI YClIblIllaHHbIe

OT B3POCJIbIX OHI1 BOCnpI1HHMalOTC5I K aI( H e H36e)HbIe 11 a6COJr1OTHble

S1aJIfIlO~l1eCH L[aCTbIO cpI1311lJeCKOrO MHpa a I1X HapYIlleHl1e KaK nOJIashy

rae T pe6eHOK Bbl3bIBaeT cepbe3Hble 113MeHeHI1H B oKpy)alO~ei1 cpe1le

1oHI1MaHl1e ~eHHOCTI1 n paBI1JI I1CXO1lfI~I1X OT B3pOCJIOro YCl1JIHBaeTCH

HaKa3aHl1eM ClIe1lylO~I1M 3a I1X HapyweHl1eM

Pe6eHOK nepeIlle1lIllI1H Ha CTa1lHIO laquoMopaJII1 KOOnepaUI1I1raquo y)e cnoshy

co6eH K 1IeueHTpa~l1l1 3TO 03HaqaeT lITO OH MO)KeT BCTaTb Ha MeCTO

lJpyroro L[eJIOBeKa rrpe1lCTaBI1Tb ero )KeJIaHI1H 11 MOTI1BbI rrOBelle Hl1fI

C OOTBeTCTBeHHO nOCTeneHHO 113MeHHeTCH ero OTHOIlleHl1e K 3anpeTaM

O H nOHI1MaeT ITO OHI1 OTHOClITeJIbHbI HO CQI1TaeT HY)KHbIM BblDOJIshy

HHTb I1X pa1l11 COXpaHeHI1H OTHOIlleHI1H C oKpy)KalO~I1MI1 3TO 03Ha lJaeT

ITO I1CTOL[HI1KOM 3anpeTOB CTaHOBI1TCH He Tpe60BaHI1e aBTOpl1TeTHOro

JU1ua a npl13HaHI1e I1X He06xo1lI1MOCTI1

COBpeMeHHbIe CTOPOHHI1KI1 MOlleJII1 gtK TIHa)e nOJIaralOT QTO JIIO1II1

H aXOllH11II1eCH Ha pa3HblX CTa1lI1HX MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BJ-fTHH OTJIHalOTshy

CH 1Ipyr OT 1Ipyra He TOJIbKO OTHOWeHl1eM K 3anpeTaM HO cnoc060M

O~eHKI1 nocTynKoB HaHOCH~HX y11lep6 OHI1 YTBep)lIa lOT L[TO p e6e shy

HOK HaXO1lH11I1IHCH Ha nepBOH CTa1ll1l1 oueHFlBaeT rrOBe1leHl1e lelIOBeKa

n o pa3M epy HaHeceHHoro 11M ywep6a TOr1la KaK 1IJlH H aXO1lH11IerOCH

Ha BTOPOi1 CTa1l1111 Ba)HYlO pOJIb I1rpalOT HaMepeHHH lIeRTeJIH TaK lIeshy

TI1 HaXO1lH~l1eCH Ha nepBoi1 CTall HI1 CpaBHI1Bafi nOBelleHI1C MaJlbQHKa

ll3BI111a KOTOPbli1 pa3611JI O1lHy laIllKY 6e3 cnpoca TaCKaH 113 IllKacpa

KOHcpeTbI 11 ll)OHa pa3611BIllero IlleCTb lJaIlleK rrblTafiCb nOMOlb MaMe

CQI1TalOT 60JIee BI1HOBaTbIM n)OHa a 1IeTI1 Ha BTOPOi1 CTalJlIH - n3BI111a

(Leman Duveen 1999) COrJIaCHO TIl1a)e 1IJIR Toro QT06bI rrepeXO1l C nepBoi1 Ha BTOPYIO CTashy

lJHIO COCTOHJICH He06xo1lI1MO C06JIIO1IeHl1e Tpex OCHOBH hI X YCJIOBI1H

nOBbIIlleHl1e ypOBHH lIHTeJIJIeKTyaJIbHOrO pa3BFlTI1H oCB060)KAe HlIe

OT nO1llI1HeHFlH aBToplITeTHoMY JII1~y 11 B3aI1MO1lei1cTB11e co c nepCfshy

HHKaMI1 B L[aCTHOCTI1 no ero MHeHl1lO Qe1l0BeK He MO)e T lIOCTMl HYfb

BT OPOH CTa1ll111 illOpalIbHoro pa3BI1TI1H rrOKa OH He llepeilleJI Ha ypo shy

BeHb cpopMaJIbHbIX orrepa~I1i1 He 06peJI HeKoTopoH CClMOCTOHTeJIbHOCTH

11 He BCTynl1JI B aKTI1BHOe B3aI1MOJeHCTBl1e CO CBepCT H I1KaMI1 Ha OCHOBe

npl1H~l1na paneHCTBa MMeHHO 3TI1 Tpl1 YCJIOBl1fI 06eCneQl1BalOT B03MO)Kshy

HOCTb 1Ie~eHTpa~111111113MeHeHl1fI npellCTaBJIeHI1H 0 npl1pOlJe 3anpeTOB

TIOCKOJIbKY I1HTeJIJleKTyaJIbHOe pa3BI1THe 1eJIOBeKa l1l1e T B CTporo

onpe1leJIeHHOM HarrpaBJIeHFlI1 CTa1l1111 MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BI1THH CM eHHlOT

55 54 ITCUXOJl OZULI eCKtLe MeXaHU3JvlbL nOOOepMaHU51 HpaBCmBeHHOCmU

npyr npy ra OnI1H pa3 3TO 0 3HaIaeT ITO 06paTHoe pa3BI1Tl1e T e rrepeshy

xon CO BTOPOH CTall1111 Ha rrepBylO HeB03MO)f(HO

KOHeIHO MoneJI b K 11l1a)f(e HeonHOKpaTHO rronBepraJIaCb KpI1TI1shy

Ke B KaIeCTBe OCHOBHoro ee HenOCTaTKa paCCMaTpl1BaJIaCb HeonHOshy

POnHOCTb MOpaJIbHOH COlI1aJII13alI111 B IaCTHOCTI1 Me)f(KYJIbTypHble

I1CCJIenOBaHI15I rrpOBeneHHble rro MeTonI1KaM 3Toro aBTopa rrponeshy

MOHCTpl1pOBaJII1 OTHOCI1TeJIbHYIO 060c06JIeHHOCTb npyr OT npy ra TaKI1X

HarrpaBJIeHI1H MOpaJIbHOrO pa3Bl1TI15I KaK rrOHI1MaHl1e MOTI1BOB 11 Hashy

Mepel-II1H npyrl1x JIIOneH crroc06HOCTb rrpl1H5ITb I1X TOIKY 3peHI15I Heshy

3aBHCHMOCTb OT aBTOpl1TeTa 11 rrOHI1MaHl1e leJII1 HaKa3aHI15I 1l03TOMY

rrOCJIenoBaTeJII111l1a)f(e rrOCTaBI1JI11 Borrpoc 0 3aMeHe TepMI1Ha laquoCTanI15Iraquo

Ha rrOHHTl1e MOpaJIbHOrO C03HaHI15I KClK cOBoKyrrHocTI1 OTneJIbHbIX rrashy

paMeTpOB ( HI1KOJIaeBa 1995) llpy rl1M HenOCTaTKOM MoneJII1 Ie 11113)f(e CII1TaeTC5I ee rrpocToTa

BeCb rrp0lecc MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BI1TI1H YKJlaLbIBaeTC5I B LI13 C CTanI1I1 3TOT

rr p06eJI 6blJI BOCrrOJIHeH B MoneJII1 J1 KOJr6cpla H13JI5I5ICb rrOCJIenOBaTeshy

JIeM Moo TIl1a)f(e OH COXpaHI1JI l1nelO 3a nl1Cl1MOCTII MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BI1TI15I

OT I1HTeJIJIeKTyaJIbHoro OnHaKO B ero npeLICT aDJreHl1l1 MOpaJIbHOe pa3shy

BI1Tl1e 5IBJI5IeTC5I nOJIrI1M 11 CJIO)f(J-IbIM np0ICCCOl[ (AHlblltpepoBa 1999 HI1KOJIaeBa 1995)

J1 KOJI6epr rrOJIaraJI ITO OCHOBY MOpaJl bHOrO C03HaHl15I COCTaBJI5Ishy

lOT He 3arrpeTbl a HOPMbl c rr paBenJIl1 l30CTvl - paBeHCTBO 11 B3al1MHOCTb

B COOTBeTCTBl1l1 C KOTOPblMI1 rrpOI1CXO[lHT pacn p e rCle Hl1e rrpaB 11 065Ishy

3aHJ-IOCTeH 11 KaK CJIenCTBl1e pa3peUle HI1C MOpaJIbHbIX KOHltpJII1KTOB

B03HI1KalOllI1X B pe3YJIbTaTe CTOJIKHOBe HI15I I1 t rrepCCOB p a 3HblX JlIOneH

3TI1 HOPMbI He YCBaI1BaIOT C5I laquoaBTOMaTI1IeCKI1raquo 11 H e CKJIanbIBaIOTC5I

BCJIenCTBl1e orrblTa HaKa3aHI15I 11 B03Harpa)f(neHI1H C1 ULlpa6aTbIBa1OTC5I

B xone COll1aJIbHOr O B3aI1MoneHCTBI15I rrOCKOJIbKY Dec K y JIbTYPbl I1MelOT

06lll1e OCHOBbl COll1aJIbHOrO B3aI1MoneHCTBl15I a rrpOlCCC MOpaJIbHOrO

pa3BI1TI15I BO Bcex 06lleCTBa X rronII1HHeTC5I 06llI1M 3C1KOHOMepHOCTHM

KOJI6epr BblneJII1JI Tpl1 y pOBHH MOpaJIbHOrO pa3DHTI15I nOKOHBeH-

1110HaJIbHbIH KOHBeHI110HaJIbHblH 11 rrOCTKOHBeH1110HaJIbHbIH (AHshy

II1ltpepoBa 1999 Bore et aI 2003 Kohlberg 1984) BeJIc t( 3a TIl1a)f(e OH

CII1TaJI ITO 3Tl1 y pOBHI1 YHI1BepCaJIbHbI 11 CMeH5IIOT npyr npy ra B CTporo

orrpeneJIeHHOM rrOp5InKe Ka)f(nbIH 113 ypOBHeH OH pa3611J1 Ha nBe CTanI1I1

4oKoH BeHllUOHaJlbHbLU ypOBeHb lJeJIOBCK tJaXOrHllHHCH Ha 3TOM

ypOBHe rrpl1 orrpeneJIeHHH laquoMopaJIbHOCTI1raquo rrocTyrrKa I1CXOnI1T H3 Toro

HaCKOJIbKO OH y nOBJIeTBOp5IeT ero c06CTBeHHble IIOTpe6HOCTH 3TOT

ypOBeHb BKJIlOIaeT B ce6H lDe CTanI1I1 TIepBa5I CTanHH xapaKTepH3yeTcH

opHeHTalHeH Ha H a Ka3aHI1e H rrOCJI Y llIaHHe eCJIH pe6eHOK COBepliiaeT

OCHOBHble cmaouu M OpaJlbHOU COlluaJlU3alluu

o npeneJIeHHbIH rrocTy rroK 11 ero 3a 3TO HaKa3bIBa1OT OH neJIaeT 3aKJlIOshy

ICHIle ITO lIa HHOe rrOBeneHHe aMOpaJIbHO TaKI1M 06pa30M OCHOBHblM

A BI1raTeJIeM rrOBeAeHHH pe6eHKa Haxon5IllerOC5I Ha rrepBOH CTanHH

MOpaJIbHOr O pa3BHTH5I 5IBJI5IeTC5I CTpax rrepen HaKa3aHHeM lJeJIOBeK

HaXOlVIllHH Cll Ha BTOPOH CTa fTHH B KaIeCTBe laquoMopaJIbHororaquo paCCMaTpHshy

BaeT TO rrOBelleHHe KOTopoe y nOBJIeTBOpHeT ero c06CTBeHHbIe HY)f(nbl

11 JII111Ib CJIY IaHHO - rroTpe6HOCTH npy rHx JIIOneH TaKHM 06pa30M OCshy

HOBHblM nBHraTeJIeM ero rrOBeneHH5I 5IBJI5IeTC5I C06JIIOneHHe 6aJIaHCa

MC)f(LY HaK a3aHHeM H B03Harpa)f(neHl1eM

K OHBeHllUOHaJlbH blU y pOBeHb lJeJIOBeK HaxonHllI1HC5I Ha 3TOM y pOBshy

He MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTH5I rrOHHMaeT He06xonHMOCTb BbIITOJIHeHH5I

p Ra rrpaBI1JI nJIH coXpaHeHI15I leJIOCTHOCTI1 06lleCTBa 3TOT YPOBeHb

TaK)f( r BKJllOIaeT 13 ce6H nBe CTanHI1 1-(JIH IeJIOBeKa HaxonHllerOCH

ri a TpeTbeH CTanHH OCHOBHbIM pery JI5ITOpOM rrOBeneHHH HBJIHIOTCH

Tp e60BaHI15I MaJlO11 rpynnbl (ce MbH npY3eH KOJIJIer) IJIeHOM KOTOPOH

OJ-] 5IBJIHeTCH lJeJIOBeK n p oxon5IllI1H IeTBepTYIO CTanHIO p y KOBOnCTBy shy

eT C5I B CBoeM n OBelle HHH He Tpe60BaHH5IMH KOHKpeTHbIX IJIeHOB CBoeH

rpynnbl a HopMaMH 06lleCTBa BbIITOJIHeHl1e KOTOPbIX He06xonHMO

[VIR nonnep)f(aHHH )f(H 3HeCnoc06HOCTI1 COIHaJIbHOH CHCTeMbl Ero rJIaBshy

HOM lJeJIblO CTaHOBHTC5I nOlIep)f(aHl1e c Y lleCTBY IOllerO COIHaJIbHOrO

rrop HnKa

ocmKOHBeHlluOHaJlbHbLU ypoBeHb - caMblH BbICOKI1H ypoBeHb MOshy

pa JIbHOrO pa3BHTI15I lJeJIOBeK Haxon5IllHHC5I H a 3TOM ypoBHe p y Koshy

BOllCTByeTC5I Y)f(e He co6CTBeHHbIMH I1HTepecaMH H He Tpe60BaHH5IMH

COUl1aJlbHOH rpymIbl K KOTOPOH OH npHHanJle)f(HT a 6e3J1HIHbIMH MOshy

pa JIbHblMI1 HopMaMH Ha n5ITOH CTanHH MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTI15I OH noshy

HH M aeT OTHOCI1T CJIbH OCTb l1norOBopHOH xapaKTep HOPM T e OC03HaeT

n o OHH 3a BHC5TT OT rpynrroBolf npHHa nJIe )f(HOCTH HOCHTeJI5I H npHnaeT

6 0 JIblIlO C 3HaIeHI1e c06mOlle HHIO HHnHBHnyaJlbHbIX npaB 1l03TOMY

llJUI Hero oc060e 3HaleHHe npH06peTaeT cnpaBenJIHBOCTb npaBHJl B coshy

OTBeTCTBHH C KOTOPbIMH rrpHHHMaeTC5I TO I1JIH I1Hoe pellIeHHe - TaK

lIa 3bIBaeM aH np0leAypHa5I cnpaBenJlHBOCTb lJeJlOBeK Ha caMOH BbIshy

COKOH - llIeCTOH CTan11 11 - caMOCT05ITeJlbHO Bbl6HpaeT enHHCTBeHHY IO

CHCT eMY M OpaJlbHblX HOpM H CJIenyeT eH

BC7Ie l( 3 a llHa)f(e KOJI 6 epr CIHTaJl ITO nJlH nepexona C Of(HOI1 CTashy

llHH MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTI15I Ha IPyrylO He06xonHMO C06JlIOneHl1e nByX

YCJIOBHI1 - nOBbllUe Hl1e HHTeJlJleK Ty aJIbHOrO y pOBH5I H CTHM YJl5IUH5I

M3 BHelllHeH cpe nbI YpOBeHb pa3BI1TH5I HHTeJIJleKTa HrpaeT Ha1160JIbshy

IlIYto POJlb Korna BTOpa5I CTanHR CMeHlleTC5I TpeTbeI1 T e npH nepex one

C l(OKOH Be lil110lia lIbHoro ypOBH5I Ha KOHBeHIHOHaJlbHblI1 3TO CMeHa

56 llCUXOJlO2U leCKUe MeXQHU3M bl nOOOepJICQHUfi HpaBCmBeHHOCmU

HeB03MO)Ha rrOKa tfeJlOBeK He [(OCTl1r ypOBHH centOpMaJIbHbIX orrepaQI1H

Ho qT06bJ OHa [(eilcTBHTCJlbHO rrp0I13 011IJIa eMY Heo6xo [(H M rrpl1Mep

Ha KOTOPblH OH Mor 6bl paBHHTbC5J

BMeCTe C TeM HaqHHaH C TpeTb eH CTa[01H MOpaJIbHOe pa3BHTHe

H[(eT He3aBHCH MO OT HHT eJIJIeKTya JIbHo ro 3 TO 03Ha -laeT ITO qeJIOBeK

C rrOJIHOCTblO CcentOpM l1pOBaBmHMCH mrreJIJleKTOM M O)eT He llOCTlITHYTb

rrHTOH M meCTOH cTall11if MOpaJlbHOTO pa3BMTH5J T eM He MeHee Y Bcex

JIIOlleii 3TOT rrpoQecc H[(eT B O[(HOM 11 TOM Ke HarrpaBJIeHMH 1--113 3TOshy

ro CJIe[(yeT ITO [(JI5J [(OCTl1)eHHH 60JIee BblC01WH CTa[(MH MOpaJIbHOrO

pa3BHTWI qeJIOBeK [(OJI)eH rrpOHTH Bce rrpellmeCTBYIOIQHe eH a TaK)e

ITO pa3BHTHe B 06paTHOM Ha npaBJIemm HeB03MO)HO 3TY H[(elO rro[(shy

TBep)[(alOT pe3YJIbTaTbi HEKOTOPbIX KPOCC-KYJIbTYPHblX HCClellOBaHHH

(Snarey 1985) HeCMOTp5J Ha rrorrYJI5JpHOCTb MOlleJIH KOJI6epra l1[(e5J 0 TOM ITO MOshy

paJIbHOe pa3BHTHe rrpepCTaBJIHeT C060H nOCJlepOBaTeJlbHYIO cMeHY CTashy

[(HH YPoBHeH Bce qaIQe rrOllBepraeTC5J COMHe H11l0 KPWrHKH YTBep)[(ashy

lOT ITO JIIO[(H lleM OHcrpHpYIOT pa3Hbie YPOBR M M OpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTHH

pa3pelllaH pa3JIHqHble MOpaJIbHble [(HJIeMMbI KpOMe Toro OHl1 MorYT

laquoB03BpaIQaTbC5J Ha3allraquo BblcTyna5J C rI 0 311JJI1J1 Toro y pOBHH KOTOPblH

y )e 6b1Jl rrpOHpe H I1MM paHbme 3TO CTaBMT rroll Borrpoc CTa[(HaJIbHOCTb

MOp aJIbHOrO p a 3BHTHH ITo HX MHeHMIO p eme HMIO 3 TOI1 11p06JIeMbi crroshy

c06cTByeT 3aMeHa M[(eH ypOBHHraquo Ha rrOlurnfe laquocxeMblraquo

B claCTHOCTH HeKOTopble rrOC]IellOBaTeJIl1 KOJl6 epra rrOJIaralOT

ITO MOpaJlbHOe pa3BH T He n p ellCTaBJIHeT c060l1 He rrOCJIellOBaTeJIbHOCTb

ypOBHeH H cral(l1if a CMeHY KorHHTHBHbIX cxeM (Rest et a1 2000) HanpHMep l) P eeT Bbl[(eJI5Ie T TpH TaKHX cxeMbI cxeMY JIW-IHoro HHshy

Tepeca KOTopaR co o TBeTcTByeT ST OPOH H TpeTbeH CTallHH M rro KOJIshy

6epry cxeMY YCBoeHHl HOPM cooTBeTcTBYIOIl(YIO qeTBepToif CTa lll1M

rrocTKoHBeHl~MOHaJIbHYIO cxeMY cooTBeTcTBYIOIQYIO w n oH F1 lllecToH

CTa[(IH I M Y poBeHb M Opa JIb HOrO pa3BHTHH paccMaTpMBaeTCl Ka J( COBOshy

KynHocTb KorHHTHBHhIX o rrepaQHl cOllepJKaHl1e KOTOPblX YHHBepCaJIbshy

HO T e He 3aBl1CH T OT KYJIbT YPbI 3TH orrepaQHM CMe HlIOT [(pyr [(PYshy

ra B 3apaHee 3a[(aHHOM rropH[(Ke MOpaJlbHOe pa3BHTHe 3aKJIIO-IaeTCll

B pe3Koi1 CM eHe CTa[(Hl1 MJIH ypOBH5J

B TO)e BpeM5J KorHHTHBHaH cxeM a - 3TO COBOI(yrrHOCTb rrpe[(CTaBJleshy

HHif HMelOIQl1X K)lIbTYPHYIO crreQHcentHKY MOpaJIbHOe pa3BHTHe MO)eT

rrpOHCXOllHTb B p a3HbIX HarrpaBJIeHHHX H 3aKJIlOqaeT C5I B rrOCTeneHshy

HOM 113MeHeHl1H 1aCTOTbl HCnOJlb30BaHM pa3HblX cxeM 3TO 03HaqaeT

ITO 1eJIOBeK MO)feT HCnOJIb30BaTb HeCKOJlbKO MOpaJlbHbIX cxeM O[(HO-

BpeMeHHo (Krebs Demon 2006)

OCHOBHble cmaouu MOpaJlbHOU C04UaJlU3auuu ~i7

B COOTBeTCTBHH C JIOrHKOl1 PeCTa y poBeHb MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTHH

onpellCJI5JeTCH TpeM5J napaMeTpaMI1 c xeMoH centa30H H HarrpaBJIeHHeM

( D e rryberry T homa 2005) TaK Y qeJlOBeKa KaK rrpaBMJIO eCTb Beshy

I YIl3 H cxeMa Ha OCHOBa HHH KOTOPOI~ OH pa3pelllaeT 601IbllIl1HCTBO

MOpaJIb HblX [(I1JIeIVlM rIPI1 3 TOM OH MO)eT HaXO[(HTbCH B centa3ax KOHCOshy

JI HtaQHH T e rrO CT05JHHO I1CnOJIb30BaTb O[(HY H Ty)e cxeMY HJIH rrepeshy

xo[(a T e HCrrOJIb30BaTb pa3Hble B QeJIOM MOpaJlbHOe pa3BI1TI1e MO)eT

HATH rro rrYTI1 BbI60pa 60JIee HJIH MeHee CJIO) Hoif cxeMbl T e H[(TH

unepe[( MJIH Ha3a[(

I1HTepecHo ITO B pa MKax Mo[(eJIl1 l) PeCTa OhlJla peaHHMHposhy

Ba B a M[(eH 0 CBH3H MOpaJIbHOrO C03HaHH5J CO crrpaBeAJIl1BOCTbIO EbIshy

JIO rrOKa3aHO ITO llJIll JlIOT(ei1 HCnOJIb3YIOIl(I1X cxeMY YCBoeHHH HOpM

11 rrOCTKOHBeHQMOHaJIbHYfO cxeMY 60JIblllOe 3HaqeHMe npH06peTaeT

TaK Ha3hlBaeMa5JnpOQe[(yp Ha5JCrrpaBe[(JlHBOCTb-coBoKyrrHocTbHOPM

p e rYJll1pYIOIQMX rrpoQecc BhlHeceHHH p emeHH5J 3TO B rrepBylO Olepe[(b

KacaeTCH HOPM CBJ13 a HHbIX C C06JlIO[(eHHeM rrpaB Bcex yqaCTHl1KOB

B3 aHMo[(eHCTBH5J - Hei1TpaJIH3aQHH rrpelly 6 elK[(eHHH 0[(Ho06pa3 HH

n pOQe[(ypbI YBa)eHH5J K rrapTHepy JIIO[(H HCrrOJIb3YlOIQI1e cxeMY JIHqshy

Horo HHTepeca npH oQeHKe cnpaB efJII1BOCTI1 B3aHMOCHCTBHl npHshy

[(a1OT 60JlhmOe 3HaqeHHe lJm rpH6YTMBHoi1 CnpaBellJIMBOCTI1 CBl3aHshy

HOM C xapaKTep oM rrOJI y qeHHOrO -ICJIOB eKOM B03Harpa)lleH M5I (Myyry

H e1kama 2002 Wendorf Alexander Firestone 2002) O[(HaKo 3aMeHa ypOBHH M OpaJIbHOrO C03HaHMHraquo Ha laquocxeMYraquo He peshy

m a eT Borrpoc 0 TOM AeHCTBHTeJIbHO JIM HarrpaBJIeHMe MOpaJIbHOshy

r o pa3BHTMH OAMHaKOBO y npeACTaBMTeJIeH pa3HbIX COQMaJIbHbIX

r pynn ECJIH ITHa)e 11 KOJl6epr OTBeqaJII1 Ha 3TOT Borrpoc YTBepi(HTeJIbshy

HO TO HX rrOCJJellOBaTeJII1 rrO[(BeprJIH 3TOT Te3HC COMHeHMIO

TIepBblM m a rOM B [(OKa3aTeJIbCTBe rpyrrrroBoH Cn eIIl1centlliltH MOpaJIbshy

Ho ro pa3Bl1THH CTaJlO rr pOBCAeI-IHe M e)KYJIbTypHbJ X HCCJIeflOBaHHH

OHl1 rrpo[(e MOHCTpI1pOBaJrH ITO M OlJeJIb 10JI6epra OTpa)aeT HarrpaBshy

JIe HHe MOpaJIbHOH COQHaJIl13aQHM npe[(CTaBHTeJJR I1HlIHBI1llyaJIHCTCKOH

KYJlbTypbl lJl5I rrpe[(CTaBHreJIeH KOJIJIeKT HBHCTCKI1X KyJlbTYP OKa3aHI1e

nOMOIQH6Jll1)HeMY HBJIleTCl 60JlblUeH l~eH I-IOCTblO Ie M lleMOHCTpaQHl

cBoeii YHHKaJIbHOCTH IT03TOM) llJJJI HJ1X CaMblM BblCOKHM lBJIHeTU KOHshy

BeHQI10HaJIbHbIH a He rrOCTKOHBeH QHOHaJlbHblH y p OBe Hb MOpaJlbHOrO

pa3BI1THH HanpHMep XOTH KHTaHcKl1e oeTH KaK H HX a MepHKaHCKHe

p OBeCHHKH C B03paCTOM rrepexO[(HT C n epBoif H BT OpOl1 cTa[(HH Ha Tpeshy

TblO OHH HCnblTbIBalOT 60Jlblllee YBa)KHll1e K BJIaCTM 60Jlee opHeHTHshy

pOBaHbl Ha rrOMOIQb H qaIl(e Y1HTbIBalOT I1HTepecbl 6m13KHX JIIO[(eH

ltreM aMepHKa HQbl (Fang e t aI 2003)

55 54 ITCUXOJl OZULI eCKtLe MeXaHU3JvlbL nOOOepMaHU51 HpaBCmBeHHOCmU

npyr npy ra OnI1H pa3 3TO 0 3HaIaeT ITO 06paTHoe pa3BI1Tl1e T e rrepeshy

xon CO BTOPOH CTall1111 Ha rrepBylO HeB03MO)f(HO

KOHeIHO MoneJI b K 11l1a)f(e HeonHOKpaTHO rronBepraJIaCb KpI1TI1shy

Ke B KaIeCTBe OCHOBHoro ee HenOCTaTKa paCCMaTpl1BaJIaCb HeonHOshy

POnHOCTb MOpaJIbHOH COlI1aJII13alI111 B IaCTHOCTI1 Me)f(KYJIbTypHble

I1CCJIenOBaHI15I rrpOBeneHHble rro MeTonI1KaM 3Toro aBTopa rrponeshy

MOHCTpl1pOBaJII1 OTHOCI1TeJIbHYIO 060c06JIeHHOCTb npyr OT npy ra TaKI1X

HarrpaBJIeHI1H MOpaJIbHOrO pa3Bl1TI15I KaK rrOHI1MaHl1e MOTI1BOB 11 Hashy

Mepel-II1H npyrl1x JIIOneH crroc06HOCTb rrpl1H5ITb I1X TOIKY 3peHI15I Heshy

3aBHCHMOCTb OT aBTOpl1TeTa 11 rrOHI1MaHl1e leJII1 HaKa3aHI15I 1l03TOMY

rrOCJIenoBaTeJII111l1a)f(e rrOCTaBI1JI11 Borrpoc 0 3aMeHe TepMI1Ha laquoCTanI15Iraquo

Ha rrOHHTl1e MOpaJIbHOrO C03HaHI15I KClK cOBoKyrrHocTI1 OTneJIbHbIX rrashy

paMeTpOB ( HI1KOJIaeBa 1995) llpy rl1M HenOCTaTKOM MoneJII1 Ie 11113)f(e CII1TaeTC5I ee rrpocToTa

BeCb rrp0lecc MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BI1TI1H YKJlaLbIBaeTC5I B LI13 C CTanI1I1 3TOT

rr p06eJI 6blJI BOCrrOJIHeH B MoneJII1 J1 KOJr6cpla H13JI5I5ICb rrOCJIenOBaTeshy

JIeM Moo TIl1a)f(e OH COXpaHI1JI l1nelO 3a nl1Cl1MOCTII MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BI1TI15I

OT I1HTeJIJIeKTyaJIbHoro OnHaKO B ero npeLICT aDJreHl1l1 MOpaJIbHOe pa3shy

BI1Tl1e 5IBJI5IeTC5I nOJIrI1M 11 CJIO)f(J-IbIM np0ICCCOl[ (AHlblltpepoBa 1999 HI1KOJIaeBa 1995)

J1 KOJI6epr rrOJIaraJI ITO OCHOBY MOpaJl bHOrO C03HaHl15I COCTaBJI5Ishy

lOT He 3arrpeTbl a HOPMbl c rr paBenJIl1 l30CTvl - paBeHCTBO 11 B3al1MHOCTb

B COOTBeTCTBl1l1 C KOTOPblMI1 rrpOI1CXO[lHT pacn p e rCle Hl1e rrpaB 11 065Ishy

3aHJ-IOCTeH 11 KaK CJIenCTBl1e pa3peUle HI1C MOpaJIbHbIX KOHltpJII1KTOB

B03HI1KalOllI1X B pe3YJIbTaTe CTOJIKHOBe HI15I I1 t rrepCCOB p a 3HblX JlIOneH

3TI1 HOPMbI He YCBaI1BaIOT C5I laquoaBTOMaTI1IeCKI1raquo 11 H e CKJIanbIBaIOTC5I

BCJIenCTBl1e orrblTa HaKa3aHI15I 11 B03Harpa)f(neHI1H C1 ULlpa6aTbIBa1OTC5I

B xone COll1aJIbHOr O B3aI1MoneHCTBI15I rrOCKOJIbKY Dec K y JIbTYPbl I1MelOT

06lll1e OCHOBbl COll1aJIbHOrO B3aI1MoneHCTBl15I a rrpOlCCC MOpaJIbHOrO

pa3BI1TI15I BO Bcex 06lleCTBa X rronII1HHeTC5I 06llI1M 3C1KOHOMepHOCTHM

KOJI6epr BblneJII1JI Tpl1 y pOBHH MOpaJIbHOrO pa3DHTI15I nOKOHBeH-

1110HaJIbHbIH KOHBeHI110HaJIbHblH 11 rrOCTKOHBeH1110HaJIbHbIH (AHshy

II1ltpepoBa 1999 Bore et aI 2003 Kohlberg 1984) BeJIc t( 3a TIl1a)f(e OH

CII1TaJI ITO 3Tl1 y pOBHI1 YHI1BepCaJIbHbI 11 CMeH5IIOT npyr npy ra B CTporo

orrpeneJIeHHOM rrOp5InKe Ka)f(nbIH 113 ypOBHeH OH pa3611J1 Ha nBe CTanI1I1

4oKoH BeHllUOHaJlbHbLU ypOBeHb lJeJIOBCK tJaXOrHllHHCH Ha 3TOM

ypOBHe rrpl1 orrpeneJIeHHH laquoMopaJIbHOCTI1raquo rrocTyrrKa I1CXOnI1T H3 Toro

HaCKOJIbKO OH y nOBJIeTBOp5IeT ero c06CTBeHHble IIOTpe6HOCTH 3TOT

ypOBeHb BKJIlOIaeT B ce6H lDe CTanI1I1 TIepBa5I CTanHH xapaKTepH3yeTcH

opHeHTalHeH Ha H a Ka3aHI1e H rrOCJI Y llIaHHe eCJIH pe6eHOK COBepliiaeT

OCHOBHble cmaouu M OpaJlbHOU COlluaJlU3alluu

o npeneJIeHHbIH rrocTy rroK 11 ero 3a 3TO HaKa3bIBa1OT OH neJIaeT 3aKJlIOshy

ICHIle ITO lIa HHOe rrOBeneHHe aMOpaJIbHO TaKI1M 06pa30M OCHOBHblM

A BI1raTeJIeM rrOBeAeHHH pe6eHKa Haxon5IllerOC5I Ha rrepBOH CTanHH

MOpaJIbHOr O pa3BHTH5I 5IBJI5IeTC5I CTpax rrepen HaKa3aHHeM lJeJIOBeK

HaXOlVIllHH Cll Ha BTOPOH CTa fTHH B KaIeCTBe laquoMopaJIbHororaquo paCCMaTpHshy

BaeT TO rrOBelleHHe KOTopoe y nOBJIeTBOpHeT ero c06CTBeHHbIe HY)f(nbl

11 JII111Ib CJIY IaHHO - rroTpe6HOCTH npy rHx JIIOneH TaKHM 06pa30M OCshy

HOBHblM nBHraTeJIeM ero rrOBeneHH5I 5IBJI5IeTC5I C06JIIOneHHe 6aJIaHCa

MC)f(LY HaK a3aHHeM H B03Harpa)f(neHl1eM

K OHBeHllUOHaJlbH blU y pOBeHb lJeJIOBeK HaxonHllI1HC5I Ha 3TOM y pOBshy

He MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTH5I rrOHHMaeT He06xonHMOCTb BbIITOJIHeHH5I

p Ra rrpaBI1JI nJIH coXpaHeHI15I leJIOCTHOCTI1 06lleCTBa 3TOT YPOBeHb

TaK)f( r BKJllOIaeT 13 ce6H nBe CTanHI1 1-(JIH IeJIOBeKa HaxonHllerOCH

ri a TpeTbeH CTanHH OCHOBHbIM pery JI5ITOpOM rrOBeneHHH HBJIHIOTCH

Tp e60BaHI15I MaJlO11 rpynnbl (ce MbH npY3eH KOJIJIer) IJIeHOM KOTOPOH

OJ-] 5IBJIHeTCH lJeJIOBeK n p oxon5IllI1H IeTBepTYIO CTanHIO p y KOBOnCTBy shy

eT C5I B CBoeM n OBelle HHH He Tpe60BaHH5IMH KOHKpeTHbIX IJIeHOB CBoeH

rpynnbl a HopMaMH 06lleCTBa BbIITOJIHeHl1e KOTOPbIX He06xonHMO

[VIR nonnep)f(aHHH )f(H 3HeCnoc06HOCTI1 COIHaJIbHOH CHCTeMbl Ero rJIaBshy

HOM lJeJIblO CTaHOBHTC5I nOlIep)f(aHl1e c Y lleCTBY IOllerO COIHaJIbHOrO

rrop HnKa

ocmKOHBeHlluOHaJlbHbLU ypoBeHb - caMblH BbICOKI1H ypoBeHb MOshy

pa JIbHOrO pa3BHTI15I lJeJIOBeK Haxon5IllHHC5I H a 3TOM ypoBHe p y Koshy

BOllCTByeTC5I Y)f(e He co6CTBeHHbIMH I1HTepecaMH H He Tpe60BaHH5IMH

COUl1aJlbHOH rpymIbl K KOTOPOH OH npHHanJle)f(HT a 6e3J1HIHbIMH MOshy

pa JIbHblMI1 HopMaMH Ha n5ITOH CTanHH MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTI15I OH noshy

HH M aeT OTHOCI1T CJIbH OCTb l1norOBopHOH xapaKTep HOPM T e OC03HaeT

n o OHH 3a BHC5TT OT rpynrroBolf npHHa nJIe )f(HOCTH HOCHTeJI5I H npHnaeT

6 0 JIblIlO C 3HaIeHI1e c06mOlle HHIO HHnHBHnyaJlbHbIX npaB 1l03TOMY

llJUI Hero oc060e 3HaleHHe npH06peTaeT cnpaBenJIHBOCTb npaBHJl B coshy

OTBeTCTBHH C KOTOPbIMH rrpHHHMaeTC5I TO I1JIH I1Hoe pellIeHHe - TaK

lIa 3bIBaeM aH np0leAypHa5I cnpaBenJlHBOCTb lJeJlOBeK Ha caMOH BbIshy

COKOH - llIeCTOH CTan11 11 - caMOCT05ITeJlbHO Bbl6HpaeT enHHCTBeHHY IO

CHCT eMY M OpaJlbHblX HOpM H CJIenyeT eH

BC7Ie l( 3 a llHa)f(e KOJI 6 epr CIHTaJl ITO nJlH nepexona C Of(HOI1 CTashy

llHH MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTI15I Ha IPyrylO He06xonHMO C06JlIOneHl1e nByX

YCJIOBHI1 - nOBbllUe Hl1e HHTeJlJleK Ty aJIbHOrO y pOBH5I H CTHM YJl5IUH5I

M3 BHelllHeH cpe nbI YpOBeHb pa3BI1TH5I HHTeJIJleKTa HrpaeT Ha1160JIbshy

IlIYto POJlb Korna BTOpa5I CTanHR CMeHlleTC5I TpeTbeI1 T e npH nepex one

C l(OKOH Be lil110lia lIbHoro ypOBH5I Ha KOHBeHIHOHaJlbHblI1 3TO CMeHa

56 llCUXOJlO2U leCKUe MeXQHU3M bl nOOOepJICQHUfi HpaBCmBeHHOCmU

HeB03MO)Ha rrOKa tfeJlOBeK He [(OCTl1r ypOBHH centOpMaJIbHbIX orrepaQI1H

Ho qT06bJ OHa [(eilcTBHTCJlbHO rrp0I13 011IJIa eMY Heo6xo [(H M rrpl1Mep

Ha KOTOPblH OH Mor 6bl paBHHTbC5J

BMeCTe C TeM HaqHHaH C TpeTb eH CTa[01H MOpaJIbHOe pa3BHTHe

H[(eT He3aBHCH MO OT HHT eJIJIeKTya JIbHo ro 3 TO 03Ha -laeT ITO qeJIOBeK

C rrOJIHOCTblO CcentOpM l1pOBaBmHMCH mrreJIJleKTOM M O)eT He llOCTlITHYTb

rrHTOH M meCTOH cTall11if MOpaJlbHOTO pa3BMTH5J T eM He MeHee Y Bcex

JIIOlleii 3TOT rrpoQecc H[(eT B O[(HOM 11 TOM Ke HarrpaBJIeHMH 1--113 3TOshy

ro CJIe[(yeT ITO [(JI5J [(OCTl1)eHHH 60JIee BblC01WH CTa[(MH MOpaJIbHOrO

pa3BHTWI qeJIOBeK [(OJI)eH rrpOHTH Bce rrpellmeCTBYIOIQHe eH a TaK)e

ITO pa3BHTHe B 06paTHOM Ha npaBJIemm HeB03MO)HO 3TY H[(elO rro[(shy

TBep)[(alOT pe3YJIbTaTbi HEKOTOPbIX KPOCC-KYJIbTYPHblX HCClellOBaHHH

(Snarey 1985) HeCMOTp5J Ha rrorrYJI5JpHOCTb MOlleJIH KOJI6epra l1[(e5J 0 TOM ITO MOshy

paJIbHOe pa3BHTHe rrpepCTaBJIHeT C060H nOCJlepOBaTeJlbHYIO cMeHY CTashy

[(HH YPoBHeH Bce qaIQe rrOllBepraeTC5J COMHe H11l0 KPWrHKH YTBep)[(ashy

lOT ITO JIIO[(H lleM OHcrpHpYIOT pa3Hbie YPOBR M M OpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTHH

pa3pelllaH pa3JIHqHble MOpaJIbHble [(HJIeMMbI KpOMe Toro OHl1 MorYT

laquoB03BpaIQaTbC5J Ha3allraquo BblcTyna5J C rI 0 311JJI1J1 Toro y pOBHH KOTOPblH

y )e 6b1Jl rrpOHpe H I1MM paHbme 3TO CTaBMT rroll Borrpoc CTa[(HaJIbHOCTb

MOp aJIbHOrO p a 3BHTHH ITo HX MHeHMIO p eme HMIO 3 TOI1 11p06JIeMbi crroshy

c06cTByeT 3aMeHa M[(eH ypOBHHraquo Ha rrOlurnfe laquocxeMblraquo

B claCTHOCTH HeKOTopble rrOC]IellOBaTeJIl1 KOJl6 epra rrOJIaralOT

ITO MOpaJlbHOe pa3BH T He n p ellCTaBJIHeT c060l1 He rrOCJIellOBaTeJIbHOCTb

ypOBHeH H cral(l1if a CMeHY KorHHTHBHbIX cxeM (Rest et a1 2000) HanpHMep l) P eeT Bbl[(eJI5Ie T TpH TaKHX cxeMbI cxeMY JIW-IHoro HHshy

Tepeca KOTopaR co o TBeTcTByeT ST OPOH H TpeTbeH CTallHH M rro KOJIshy

6epry cxeMY YCBoeHHl HOPM cooTBeTcTBYIOIl(YIO qeTBepToif CTa lll1M

rrocTKoHBeHl~MOHaJIbHYIO cxeMY cooTBeTcTBYIOIQYIO w n oH F1 lllecToH

CTa[(IH I M Y poBeHb M Opa JIb HOrO pa3BHTHH paccMaTpMBaeTCl Ka J( COBOshy

KynHocTb KorHHTHBHhIX o rrepaQHl cOllepJKaHl1e KOTOPblX YHHBepCaJIbshy

HO T e He 3aBl1CH T OT KYJIbT YPbI 3TH orrepaQHM CMe HlIOT [(pyr [(PYshy

ra B 3apaHee 3a[(aHHOM rropH[(Ke MOpaJlbHOe pa3BHTHe 3aKJIIO-IaeTCll

B pe3Koi1 CM eHe CTa[(Hl1 MJIH ypOBH5J

B TO)e BpeM5J KorHHTHBHaH cxeM a - 3TO COBOI(yrrHOCTb rrpe[(CTaBJleshy

HHif HMelOIQl1X K)lIbTYPHYIO crreQHcentHKY MOpaJIbHOe pa3BHTHe MO)eT

rrpOHCXOllHTb B p a3HbIX HarrpaBJIeHHHX H 3aKJIlOqaeT C5I B rrOCTeneHshy

HOM 113MeHeHl1H 1aCTOTbl HCnOJlb30BaHM pa3HblX cxeM 3TO 03HaqaeT

ITO 1eJIOBeK MO)feT HCnOJIb30BaTb HeCKOJlbKO MOpaJlbHbIX cxeM O[(HO-

BpeMeHHo (Krebs Demon 2006)

OCHOBHble cmaouu MOpaJlbHOU C04UaJlU3auuu ~i7

B COOTBeTCTBHH C JIOrHKOl1 PeCTa y poBeHb MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTHH

onpellCJI5JeTCH TpeM5J napaMeTpaMI1 c xeMoH centa30H H HarrpaBJIeHHeM

( D e rryberry T homa 2005) TaK Y qeJlOBeKa KaK rrpaBMJIO eCTb Beshy

I YIl3 H cxeMa Ha OCHOBa HHH KOTOPOI~ OH pa3pelllaeT 601IbllIl1HCTBO

MOpaJIb HblX [(I1JIeIVlM rIPI1 3 TOM OH MO)eT HaXO[(HTbCH B centa3ax KOHCOshy

JI HtaQHH T e rrO CT05JHHO I1CnOJIb30BaTb O[(HY H Ty)e cxeMY HJIH rrepeshy

xo[(a T e HCrrOJIb30BaTb pa3Hble B QeJIOM MOpaJlbHOe pa3BI1TI1e MO)eT

HATH rro rrYTI1 BbI60pa 60JIee HJIH MeHee CJIO) Hoif cxeMbl T e H[(TH

unepe[( MJIH Ha3a[(

I1HTepecHo ITO B pa MKax Mo[(eJIl1 l) PeCTa OhlJla peaHHMHposhy

Ba B a M[(eH 0 CBH3H MOpaJIbHOrO C03HaHH5J CO crrpaBeAJIl1BOCTbIO EbIshy

JIO rrOKa3aHO ITO llJIll JlIOT(ei1 HCnOJIb3YIOIl(I1X cxeMY YCBoeHHH HOpM

11 rrOCTKOHBeHQMOHaJIbHYfO cxeMY 60JIblllOe 3HaqeHMe npH06peTaeT

TaK Ha3hlBaeMa5JnpOQe[(yp Ha5JCrrpaBe[(JlHBOCTb-coBoKyrrHocTbHOPM

p e rYJll1pYIOIQMX rrpoQecc BhlHeceHHH p emeHH5J 3TO B rrepBylO Olepe[(b

KacaeTCH HOPM CBJ13 a HHbIX C C06JlIO[(eHHeM rrpaB Bcex yqaCTHl1KOB

B3 aHMo[(eHCTBH5J - Hei1TpaJIH3aQHH rrpelly 6 elK[(eHHH 0[(Ho06pa3 HH

n pOQe[(ypbI YBa)eHH5J K rrapTHepy JIIO[(H HCrrOJIb3YlOIQI1e cxeMY JIHqshy

Horo HHTepeca npH oQeHKe cnpaB efJII1BOCTI1 B3aHMOCHCTBHl npHshy

[(a1OT 60JlhmOe 3HaqeHHe lJm rpH6YTMBHoi1 CnpaBellJIMBOCTI1 CBl3aHshy

HOM C xapaKTep oM rrOJI y qeHHOrO -ICJIOB eKOM B03Harpa)lleH M5I (Myyry

H e1kama 2002 Wendorf Alexander Firestone 2002) O[(HaKo 3aMeHa ypOBHH M OpaJIbHOrO C03HaHMHraquo Ha laquocxeMYraquo He peshy

m a eT Borrpoc 0 TOM AeHCTBHTeJIbHO JIM HarrpaBJIeHMe MOpaJIbHOshy

r o pa3BHTMH OAMHaKOBO y npeACTaBMTeJIeH pa3HbIX COQMaJIbHbIX

r pynn ECJIH ITHa)e 11 KOJl6epr OTBeqaJII1 Ha 3TOT Borrpoc YTBepi(HTeJIbshy

HO TO HX rrOCJJellOBaTeJII1 rrO[(BeprJIH 3TOT Te3HC COMHeHMIO

TIepBblM m a rOM B [(OKa3aTeJIbCTBe rpyrrrroBoH Cn eIIl1centlliltH MOpaJIbshy

Ho ro pa3Bl1THH CTaJlO rr pOBCAeI-IHe M e)KYJIbTypHbJ X HCCJIeflOBaHHH

OHl1 rrpo[(e MOHCTpI1pOBaJrH ITO M OlJeJIb 10JI6epra OTpa)aeT HarrpaBshy

JIe HHe MOpaJIbHOH COQHaJIl13aQHM npe[(CTaBHTeJJR I1HlIHBI1llyaJIHCTCKOH

KYJlbTypbl lJl5I rrpe[(CTaBHreJIeH KOJIJIeKT HBHCTCKI1X KyJlbTYP OKa3aHI1e

nOMOIQH6Jll1)HeMY HBJIleTCl 60JlblUeH l~eH I-IOCTblO Ie M lleMOHCTpaQHl

cBoeii YHHKaJIbHOCTH IT03TOM) llJJJI HJ1X CaMblM BblCOKHM lBJIHeTU KOHshy

BeHQI10HaJIbHbIH a He rrOCTKOHBeH QHOHaJlbHblH y p OBe Hb MOpaJlbHOrO

pa3BI1THH HanpHMep XOTH KHTaHcKl1e oeTH KaK H HX a MepHKaHCKHe

p OBeCHHKH C B03paCTOM rrepexO[(HT C n epBoif H BT OpOl1 cTa[(HH Ha Tpeshy

TblO OHH HCnblTbIBalOT 60Jlblllee YBa)KHll1e K BJIaCTM 60Jlee opHeHTHshy

pOBaHbl Ha rrOMOIQb H qaIl(e Y1HTbIBalOT I1HTepecbl 6m13KHX JIIO[(eH

ltreM aMepHKa HQbl (Fang e t aI 2003)

56 llCUXOJlO2U leCKUe MeXQHU3M bl nOOOepJICQHUfi HpaBCmBeHHOCmU

HeB03MO)Ha rrOKa tfeJlOBeK He [(OCTl1r ypOBHH centOpMaJIbHbIX orrepaQI1H

Ho qT06bJ OHa [(eilcTBHTCJlbHO rrp0I13 011IJIa eMY Heo6xo [(H M rrpl1Mep

Ha KOTOPblH OH Mor 6bl paBHHTbC5J

BMeCTe C TeM HaqHHaH C TpeTb eH CTa[01H MOpaJIbHOe pa3BHTHe

H[(eT He3aBHCH MO OT HHT eJIJIeKTya JIbHo ro 3 TO 03Ha -laeT ITO qeJIOBeK

C rrOJIHOCTblO CcentOpM l1pOBaBmHMCH mrreJIJleKTOM M O)eT He llOCTlITHYTb

rrHTOH M meCTOH cTall11if MOpaJlbHOTO pa3BMTH5J T eM He MeHee Y Bcex

JIIOlleii 3TOT rrpoQecc H[(eT B O[(HOM 11 TOM Ke HarrpaBJIeHMH 1--113 3TOshy

ro CJIe[(yeT ITO [(JI5J [(OCTl1)eHHH 60JIee BblC01WH CTa[(MH MOpaJIbHOrO

pa3BHTWI qeJIOBeK [(OJI)eH rrpOHTH Bce rrpellmeCTBYIOIQHe eH a TaK)e

ITO pa3BHTHe B 06paTHOM Ha npaBJIemm HeB03MO)HO 3TY H[(elO rro[(shy

TBep)[(alOT pe3YJIbTaTbi HEKOTOPbIX KPOCC-KYJIbTYPHblX HCClellOBaHHH

(Snarey 1985) HeCMOTp5J Ha rrorrYJI5JpHOCTb MOlleJIH KOJI6epra l1[(e5J 0 TOM ITO MOshy

paJIbHOe pa3BHTHe rrpepCTaBJIHeT C060H nOCJlepOBaTeJlbHYIO cMeHY CTashy

[(HH YPoBHeH Bce qaIQe rrOllBepraeTC5J COMHe H11l0 KPWrHKH YTBep)[(ashy

lOT ITO JIIO[(H lleM OHcrpHpYIOT pa3Hbie YPOBR M M OpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTHH

pa3pelllaH pa3JIHqHble MOpaJIbHble [(HJIeMMbI KpOMe Toro OHl1 MorYT

laquoB03BpaIQaTbC5J Ha3allraquo BblcTyna5J C rI 0 311JJI1J1 Toro y pOBHH KOTOPblH

y )e 6b1Jl rrpOHpe H I1MM paHbme 3TO CTaBMT rroll Borrpoc CTa[(HaJIbHOCTb

MOp aJIbHOrO p a 3BHTHH ITo HX MHeHMIO p eme HMIO 3 TOI1 11p06JIeMbi crroshy

c06cTByeT 3aMeHa M[(eH ypOBHHraquo Ha rrOlurnfe laquocxeMblraquo

B claCTHOCTH HeKOTopble rrOC]IellOBaTeJIl1 KOJl6 epra rrOJIaralOT

ITO MOpaJlbHOe pa3BH T He n p ellCTaBJIHeT c060l1 He rrOCJIellOBaTeJIbHOCTb

ypOBHeH H cral(l1if a CMeHY KorHHTHBHbIX cxeM (Rest et a1 2000) HanpHMep l) P eeT Bbl[(eJI5Ie T TpH TaKHX cxeMbI cxeMY JIW-IHoro HHshy

Tepeca KOTopaR co o TBeTcTByeT ST OPOH H TpeTbeH CTallHH M rro KOJIshy

6epry cxeMY YCBoeHHl HOPM cooTBeTcTBYIOIl(YIO qeTBepToif CTa lll1M

rrocTKoHBeHl~MOHaJIbHYIO cxeMY cooTBeTcTBYIOIQYIO w n oH F1 lllecToH

CTa[(IH I M Y poBeHb M Opa JIb HOrO pa3BHTHH paccMaTpMBaeTCl Ka J( COBOshy

KynHocTb KorHHTHBHhIX o rrepaQHl cOllepJKaHl1e KOTOPblX YHHBepCaJIbshy

HO T e He 3aBl1CH T OT KYJIbT YPbI 3TH orrepaQHM CMe HlIOT [(pyr [(PYshy

ra B 3apaHee 3a[(aHHOM rropH[(Ke MOpaJlbHOe pa3BHTHe 3aKJIIO-IaeTCll

B pe3Koi1 CM eHe CTa[(Hl1 MJIH ypOBH5J

B TO)e BpeM5J KorHHTHBHaH cxeM a - 3TO COBOI(yrrHOCTb rrpe[(CTaBJleshy

HHif HMelOIQl1X K)lIbTYPHYIO crreQHcentHKY MOpaJIbHOe pa3BHTHe MO)eT

rrpOHCXOllHTb B p a3HbIX HarrpaBJIeHHHX H 3aKJIlOqaeT C5I B rrOCTeneHshy

HOM 113MeHeHl1H 1aCTOTbl HCnOJlb30BaHM pa3HblX cxeM 3TO 03HaqaeT

ITO 1eJIOBeK MO)feT HCnOJIb30BaTb HeCKOJlbKO MOpaJlbHbIX cxeM O[(HO-

BpeMeHHo (Krebs Demon 2006)

OCHOBHble cmaouu MOpaJlbHOU C04UaJlU3auuu ~i7

B COOTBeTCTBHH C JIOrHKOl1 PeCTa y poBeHb MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTHH

onpellCJI5JeTCH TpeM5J napaMeTpaMI1 c xeMoH centa30H H HarrpaBJIeHHeM

( D e rryberry T homa 2005) TaK Y qeJlOBeKa KaK rrpaBMJIO eCTb Beshy

I YIl3 H cxeMa Ha OCHOBa HHH KOTOPOI~ OH pa3pelllaeT 601IbllIl1HCTBO

MOpaJIb HblX [(I1JIeIVlM rIPI1 3 TOM OH MO)eT HaXO[(HTbCH B centa3ax KOHCOshy

JI HtaQHH T e rrO CT05JHHO I1CnOJIb30BaTb O[(HY H Ty)e cxeMY HJIH rrepeshy

xo[(a T e HCrrOJIb30BaTb pa3Hble B QeJIOM MOpaJlbHOe pa3BI1TI1e MO)eT

HATH rro rrYTI1 BbI60pa 60JIee HJIH MeHee CJIO) Hoif cxeMbl T e H[(TH

unepe[( MJIH Ha3a[(

I1HTepecHo ITO B pa MKax Mo[(eJIl1 l) PeCTa OhlJla peaHHMHposhy

Ba B a M[(eH 0 CBH3H MOpaJIbHOrO C03HaHH5J CO crrpaBeAJIl1BOCTbIO EbIshy

JIO rrOKa3aHO ITO llJIll JlIOT(ei1 HCnOJIb3YIOIl(I1X cxeMY YCBoeHHH HOpM

11 rrOCTKOHBeHQMOHaJIbHYfO cxeMY 60JIblllOe 3HaqeHMe npH06peTaeT

TaK Ha3hlBaeMa5JnpOQe[(yp Ha5JCrrpaBe[(JlHBOCTb-coBoKyrrHocTbHOPM

p e rYJll1pYIOIQMX rrpoQecc BhlHeceHHH p emeHH5J 3TO B rrepBylO Olepe[(b

KacaeTCH HOPM CBJ13 a HHbIX C C06JlIO[(eHHeM rrpaB Bcex yqaCTHl1KOB

B3 aHMo[(eHCTBH5J - Hei1TpaJIH3aQHH rrpelly 6 elK[(eHHH 0[(Ho06pa3 HH

n pOQe[(ypbI YBa)eHH5J K rrapTHepy JIIO[(H HCrrOJIb3YlOIQI1e cxeMY JIHqshy

Horo HHTepeca npH oQeHKe cnpaB efJII1BOCTI1 B3aHMOCHCTBHl npHshy

[(a1OT 60JlhmOe 3HaqeHHe lJm rpH6YTMBHoi1 CnpaBellJIMBOCTI1 CBl3aHshy

HOM C xapaKTep oM rrOJI y qeHHOrO -ICJIOB eKOM B03Harpa)lleH M5I (Myyry

H e1kama 2002 Wendorf Alexander Firestone 2002) O[(HaKo 3aMeHa ypOBHH M OpaJIbHOrO C03HaHMHraquo Ha laquocxeMYraquo He peshy

m a eT Borrpoc 0 TOM AeHCTBHTeJIbHO JIM HarrpaBJIeHMe MOpaJIbHOshy

r o pa3BHTMH OAMHaKOBO y npeACTaBMTeJIeH pa3HbIX COQMaJIbHbIX

r pynn ECJIH ITHa)e 11 KOJl6epr OTBeqaJII1 Ha 3TOT Borrpoc YTBepi(HTeJIbshy

HO TO HX rrOCJJellOBaTeJII1 rrO[(BeprJIH 3TOT Te3HC COMHeHMIO

TIepBblM m a rOM B [(OKa3aTeJIbCTBe rpyrrrroBoH Cn eIIl1centlliltH MOpaJIbshy

Ho ro pa3Bl1THH CTaJlO rr pOBCAeI-IHe M e)KYJIbTypHbJ X HCCJIeflOBaHHH

OHl1 rrpo[(e MOHCTpI1pOBaJrH ITO M OlJeJIb 10JI6epra OTpa)aeT HarrpaBshy

JIe HHe MOpaJIbHOH COQHaJIl13aQHM npe[(CTaBHTeJJR I1HlIHBI1llyaJIHCTCKOH

KYJlbTypbl lJl5I rrpe[(CTaBHreJIeH KOJIJIeKT HBHCTCKI1X KyJlbTYP OKa3aHI1e

nOMOIQH6Jll1)HeMY HBJIleTCl 60JlblUeH l~eH I-IOCTblO Ie M lleMOHCTpaQHl

cBoeii YHHKaJIbHOCTH IT03TOM) llJJJI HJ1X CaMblM BblCOKHM lBJIHeTU KOHshy

BeHQI10HaJIbHbIH a He rrOCTKOHBeH QHOHaJlbHblH y p OBe Hb MOpaJlbHOrO

pa3BI1THH HanpHMep XOTH KHTaHcKl1e oeTH KaK H HX a MepHKaHCKHe

p OBeCHHKH C B03paCTOM rrepexO[(HT C n epBoif H BT OpOl1 cTa[(HH Ha Tpeshy

TblO OHH HCnblTbIBalOT 60Jlblllee YBa)KHll1e K BJIaCTM 60Jlee opHeHTHshy

pOBaHbl Ha rrOMOIQb H qaIl(e Y1HTbIBalOT I1HTepecbl 6m13KHX JIIO[(eH

ltreM aMepHKa HQbl (Fang e t aI 2003)

59 58 nCUXOJ02U1eCKUe MeXaHU3MbL nOOOep)IWHUR Hpa eC mBeHHOCmU

EllIe 60JIbIllee 3HaIeme I1MeeT 06HapYgtKeHl1e nOJIOBblX pa3JII1II1H

B HanpaBJIeHl111 MOpaJIbHOH COll1aJII13all1l1 OHI1 OTpagtKeHbI B MOlleJII1

gtKeHCKOH cOll1aJII13alJ111 K rl1JIJIl1raH (Gilligan 1982) ECJII1 B OCHOBe

KOHlenl1111 KOJI6epra JIegtKI1T 0pl1eHTall1lI Ha I1CnOJIHeHl1e npaBI1JI TO

COrJIaCHO rJ1JIJIl1raH KOHeIHaH leJIb MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BI1T I1H gtKe HIlJHH shy

YMeHl1e COBMelllaTb npl1HHTHe OTBeTCTBeHHOCTl1 3a Ilpyrl1x JIIOIleH

11 c06CTBeHHbie nOTpe6HOCTI1 ITo ee MHeHI1IO pa3J1l1me B HanpaBJIeshy

HI1I1 MOpaJIbHorO pa3BI1TI1H MygtKIl1H 11 gtKeHllII1H OCHOBaHO Ha pa3JII1II111

nOJIOpOJIeBbIX CTepeOTl1nOB COrJlaCHO KOTOPblM OCHOBHOH pOJIblO gtKeHshy

IlJI1HbI HBJlHeTClI IIO-1UJepgtKaHl1e XOPOIllI1X OTHOIlleHI1H MegtKIly J11OIlbMI1

11 OKa3aHI1e 11M nOMOIlI1 3TO npl1BOlll1T K TOMY ITO nepeXOllH Ha HOshy

BblH ypOBeHb MOpaJIbHOrO pa3Bl1TI1H gtKeHIlI1Ha ocymeCrBJIHeT Bbl60p

He MegtKIlY pa3HbIMI1 Cl1CTeMaMI1 HOPM a MegtKIlY 06beKT aMI1 OTBeTCTshy

BeHHOCTl1 B XOlle MOpaJIbHOH cOl(l1aJII13al1111 gtKeHIlI1HbI HaII1HalOT

IYBCTBOBaTb OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a IlPyrl1x JIIOIleH 11 YIaTClI COBMellaTb

ee npl1HHTl1e C IlOCTI1gtKeHl1eM c06CTBeHHblX l(eJIeH TaKl1M 06pa30M OHI1

npOXOllHT Tpl1 ypOBHH MOpaJIbHOrO pa3Bl1TIHI

ITepBblH ypOBeHb - opHeHTalI1H Ha I1HIlI1BI11lyaJIbHOe BhDK I1BaHl1e

HaxollHcb Ha 3TOM ypOBHe gtKeHllIl1Ha I1CXOllI1T 113 JII1~IHbIX nOTpe6HOCshy

TeHI1 KaK CJlellCTBl1e 06beKTOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTI1 CTaHOBl1 TCR OHa cashy

Ma BTopoH ypOBeHb MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BI1TI1H CBlI3aH C OC0 3H aHI1eM 6JIara

npl1HeCeHI1H ce6H B gtKepTBY npl1HHTl1eM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTI1 3 a Ilpy rl1 x

JIIOIleH 11 HaKOHel Ha TpeTbeM ypOBHe Ke HIlI1Ha o CY lleCrBJIHeT Bbl shy

60p MegtKIlY OTBeTCTBeHHOCTblO nepell C060H 11 nepell OKpYgtKaIOIlI1M I1

HaxollHcb Ha 3TOM ypOBHe OHa OllI1HaKOBO XOPODlO npellCTa BJIHeT ce6e

KaK CBOI1 nOTpe6HocTI1 TaK 11 nOTpe6HOCTI1 IlpyrHx JllOIleH

l1HTepecHo ITO ypOBeHb MOpaJIbHOrO pa3Bl1TI1H no llJK f I1 JIJUIraH

TaK gtKe KaK 11 no KOJI6epry CBH3aH C I1HTeJIJIeKTyaJIbHIIM pa3BI1Tl1eM

OH BblIlle Y KOrHI1TI1BHO CJIOgtKHblX JIIOIleH KOTopble c11oc06HbI K IleleHshy

TpalI1H 11 JIerKO yCBal1BalOT 3HaHI1H Ha a6CTpaKTHOM ypOBHe (Jaffee

Hyde 2000 White Manolis 1997) 3TO 03HaiaeT ITO npl1HHTl1e OTBeTCTBeHHOCTI1 HI3JIHeTCH a JlbTepshy

HaTHBHblM I1YTeM pa3Bl1Tl1H l1MeHHo n03ToMY B HaCTOHruee BpeM H

rOBopHT 0 IlBYX MOpaJIhHhIX 0pHeHTaUHHx - Ha CJIellOBaHHe HopMaM

H Ha 3a60TY npHHHTHe OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH BbHICHHJlOCb ITO lIpH BbIshy

HeCeHl1H MOpaJIbHblX CYgtKeHI1H JIIOIlH KaK npaBl1JIO BblcTyna lOT C 110shy

3HlHI1 OllHOH H3 HHX ITO He I1CKJIlOIaeT B03MOgtKHOCTl1 me OllHOBpeMeHshy

Horo HC110JIb30BaHI1H (Jaffee Hyde 2000) ITepBOHaIaJIbHO CIHTaJIOCbYTO MOpaJIbHble opHeHTallHH TeCHO

CBH3aHbl C nOJIOBOH npI1HallJIegtKHOCTblO IeJIOBeKa 11 Ilei1c TBHT eJIbHO

OCHOBHbLe cmaouu lHOpaJlbHOii C04UaJlU3a4uu

)eHllI1Hbl HeMHoro 60JIbIlle 11 60JIee nOCJIellOBaTeJIbHO IeM MYgtKshy

1I1 Hbl opHeHTHpoBaHbl Ha 3a60TY H OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb a MYgtKIHshy

Hbl - Ha CJIellOBaHl1e HopMaM (3HaKoB 2004 Barnett Quackenbush

Sinis i 1995 Bjorklund 2003 Ford Lowery 1986 Wark Krebs 1996 W hite Manolis 1997) 3aTeM BbIHCHl1JIOCb ITO peIb HAeT He 0 6110JIOshy

rl1 IeCKI1X oc06eHHocTHX IeJIOBeKa a 0 ero reHIlepHOH HIleHTHIHOCTH

B IaCTHOCTI1 TpallHlHOHHble nOJIOBble pa3JII1II1H npOHBJIHIO TCH TOJIbshy

KO B TOM CJIYIae KOrlla JIIOIl11 3allYMbIBaIOTCH 0 CBoeH nOJIOBOH npl1shy

lIallJIegtKHOCTI1 T e Y HI1X aKTyaJII1311pyeTcH reHIlepHa5I l11leHTHIHOCTb

( Ryan David Reynolds 2004) KpoMe Toro BagtKHYIO pOJIb HrpaeT qeshy

MHHHOCTb I1JIH MacKYJIHHHOCTh IeJIOBeKa 0pHeHTalHH Ha CJIellOBaHHe

npaBI1JIaM 60JIee xapaKTepHa IlJIH MacKYJIHHHblX JIIOeH a Ha 3a60TY

H npl1HHTl1e OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH - IlJIH qeMI1HHbIX (Ford Lowery 1986) IT03gtKe 6blJII1 06HapYgtKeHbl He TOJIbKO nOJIOBble HO MegtKKYJIbTypHble

pa3JII1II1H B MOpaJIbHOH 0pl1eHTall1l1 BbIHCHI1JIOCb ITO Y npellCTaBI1Teshy

JleH KOJIJIeKTI1BI1CTCKI1X KyJIbTYP CI1JIbHee BblpagtKeHa 0pl1eHTalI1H Ha 3ashy

60TY 11 MeHbIlle - Ha CJIellOBaHl1e HopMaM YeM Y npellCTaBI1TeJIeH I1Hshy

Il I1B I11lyaJII1CTCKI1X KYJIbTYP (Miller Bersoff 1992 Miller Bersoff 1998 Miller Bersoff Harwood 1990) ITPI1 3TOM nepBble ylleJIHIOT 60JIbIllee

BHI1MaHl1e 3MOl110HaJIbHoMY COCTOHHI1IO YIaCTHI1KoB MOpaJIbHorO KOHshy

qJII1KTa IeM BTopble (Baek 2002 Bersoff Miller 1993) TaKI1M 06pa30M nOJIOBaH npI1HallJIe gtKHOCTb 11 KYJIbTypa 3allalOT

OCHOBHoe HanpaBJIeHl1e MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BI1TI1H B paMKax KaKI1X HHshy

CTHTYTOB COUHaJII13aUHH OHO npOHCXOllHT MOgtKHO C YBepeHHocTblO

YTBepgtKIlaTb ITO Hal160JIbIllee 3HaIeHI1e I1MelOT IlBa TpallI1lHOHHbIX

I1HCTI1TYTa - ceMbH 11 06pa30BaTeJIbHbie YIpegtKIleHI1H

Kpl1Tl1IeCKI1M napaMeTpOM ceMeHHoro BOCnl1TaHI1H HBJIHIOTCH

KOHTPOJIb 3a IleHCTBI1HMI1 pe6eHKa 11 OTHOIlleHl1e K HeMY IeM BblIlle

KOHTPOJIb 11 -eM xY gtKe OTHOIlleHl1e TeM HI1gtKe ypOBeHb MOpaJIbHOrO

pa3BI1TI1H BepoHTHo 3TO npOI1CXOllI1T nOCKOJIbKY pOllHTeJII1 He npellOshy

CTaBJIHIOT pe6eHKY caMOCTOHTeJIbHOCTI1 11 nOllIlepgtKKI1 KOTopble He06shy

XOllI1Mbl IlJIH ero nOBblIlleHI1H (CTenaHoBa 2004 Palmer Hollin 2001) [poMe TOro onpelleJIeHHYIO pOJIb I1rpaeT npl1BH3aHHOCTb pe6eHKa K pOshy

t I1TeJIHM KOTopaH TaKgtKe CHI1gtKaeT BepOHTHOCTb COBepIlleHI1H caMOCTOshy

HTeJIbHblX IleHCTBI1H Oc06eHHO CI1JIbHOe BJII1HHl1e CTHJIb BOCnl1TaHI1H

OKa3blBaeT Ha MOpaJIbHOe pa3BI1TI1e IleBo-eK yeM CI1JIbHee KOHTPOJIb

co CTOPOHbl pOllI1TeJIeH 11 npl1BH3aHHOCTb K HI1M Ilo-epl1 TeM HI1gtKe

ypOBeHb ee MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BI1TI1H (Palmer Hollin 2001) 06pa30BaHl1e TaK gtKe KaK ceMbH MOgtKeT cnoc06cTBoBaTb MopaJIbHOshy

M y pa3BI1TI11O I1JII1 npenHTCTBOBaTb eMY B ueJIOM -eM BbIllie ypOBeHb

61 60 nCliXOl102IIlleCKue JtexaHU3MbL nOOOepJlcaHuR HpaBcmBeHHocmu

06paaOIlB HlJR TeM BbIIlle ypOBeHb MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTHfL 3TO B rrepByIO

o~epelb K3CaeTCJl npe~CTal3l1TeJIeH COLHaJIbHbIX HayK B TOM qHCJIe nCHshy

xonorOB H COqHaJIbHbIX pa60THHKOB H B ropa3~0 MeHbIlleH CTeneHHshy

CTjAeHTOB crrelT1aJI113HpYIOllHXC5I B 06JIaCTH 6H3Heca TIoBbIIlleHHIO

YPOIHH MOpaJIhHOro pa3BHTH5I crroc06cTByeT He TOJIbKO 06yqeHHe B Leshy

]10M HO 11 OBe(CHl1e OT~eJIbHbIX cneLHaJIH3HpOBaHHbIX KypCOB B paMKax

KOTOPhlX 06C)ltAaIOTCfI 3THIeCKHe acrreKTbI B3aHMoneHCTBH5I Me)ny

]lJO1lbMIf 11M npaKTJ1KyeTC5I 06palleHHe K CBoeMY BHYTpeHHeMY MHpy

TaKUM 06pa30M C O~HOH CTOPOHbI BbICIllee 06pa30BaHI1e naeT JIIO~5IM B03MOlKHOCTb YBHleTb pa3Hble TOIKH 3peHH5I H cpaBHHTb HX Me)ny

c060([ cnoco6cTByeT CPOpMHpOBaHHIO CJIO)HOH KapTHHbI MHpa a C lpyshy

roii YBe1lJ1lJl1BaeT I1HTepec K 3THqeCKOH COCTaBJI5IIOlleH qeJIOBeLlecshy

K[X OTHOllleHI1H (AI-Ansari 2002 Bunch 2005 Chandler Alexander

Heaton 2005 King Mayhew 2002) O~HaKo 06yqemre MO)eT npHBeCTl1

K speMeHHoMY YMeHbIlleHHIO ypOBH5I MOpaJIbHOro pa3BHTH5I KaK 3TO

npOHCxOll1T Hanpm1ep y cTYAeHTOB-MelHKOB Ha nepBblx Kypcax (Pateshy

naude Niyonsenga Fafard 2003) Co BpeMeHeM 3TOT 3cpcpeKT HCqe3aeT

CeMblll1 IlIKOJIa CPYHKLHOHHPYIOT B p a MKax 06lleCTBa H n03ToMY

m lJ)[1HlH11e BO MHorOM 3aBHCHT OT ero CTpyKTYPbl LeM pa3Ho06pa3Hee

OKpYlKeHl1e IeJIOBeKa IeM C 6 OJIbill ltM KOJIHqeCTBOM pa3HbIX JIIOneH OH

craQ KHBaeTCR TeM 6bICTpee rrpOHcxonHT MOp aJIbHOe pa3BHTHe I1MeHHo

n03TOMY ) ) lrreJIeH H30JIHpOBaHHblX HaCeJIeHHbIX rrYHKTOB a TaK)e

YTex KTO lKl1SeT B OlHOPOlHOH KYJIbTYPHOH cpe~e 3TOT rrpOLeCC rrposhy

TeK8eT MeAJIeHHee (Magsud 1977) BMeCTe C TeM He KoTopble C06bITH5I rrpOHCXO~5IIlHe B 06lleCTBe MOshy

rYT3aropMa)HBaTb MOpaJIbHOe pa3BHTHe KaK rrpaBHJIO OHH CB5I3aHbI

c Hapyme~lHeM MOpaJIbHbiX HOpM H JlBJI5IIOTC5I HCTOIHHKOM TpaBMaTHshy

qeCKOro OllbITa HarrpHMep 60JIee HH3KHH ypoBeHb MOpaJlbHOrO pa3shy

rutTMR J1MeIQT JTiQlH KOTopble B ~eTCTBe rrepe)HJIH BOHHY B pe3YJIbTaTe

qeroYH11X B03HHKITocTTpaBM aTl1qecKI111 CHH~pOM (Taylor Baker 2007) BepoHTHO K nopo6HbIM rrOCJIe~CTBH5IM MorYT rrpHBOlHTb H ~pyrHe 06shy

UeCTBeHHbJe C06bITH5I pa3pYIllaIOllHe CTpyKTYPY 06lleCTBa B 3TOH

ClfT)all111 Heo6xo~HMOCTb BbI)HBaHHJl crroc06CTBYCT rrepexo~y Ha rrepshy

BblH ypOBeHb MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTHJl

TaKI1M 06pa30M MOpaJIbHa5I COLHaJIH3aLH5I - 3TO rrpOl(eCC KOTOPbIH

AMITe ropaMH fIPH 3TOM MOpaJlbHa5I 0pHeHTaLIUI MO)eT H3MeH5IThCl1

H3 npOfll lKeHI1H BceH )I13HH IeJIOBeKa (Jaffee Hyde 2000) I1HTepecshy

HO 4TO B llepBylQ oLlepe~b cpopMl1pyeTCl1 0pHeHTaLI1H Ha CJIe~OBaHHe

HopMaM BbJpa)eHHOCTb 0pHeHTaLHH Ha 3a60TY H OKa3aHHe rrOMOllH

pamr Me(JleHHee (Quackenbush Barnett 2001)

OCHoBHbLe cmaouu MopanbHou co~uanU3a~Ull

TIocTerreHHoe CPOPMHpOB8HI1e MOpaJIbHOrO C03HaHH5I rOBopHT 0 ero

llTHOCHTeJIbHOH cTa6HJIbHOCTH Ha rrpOT5I)eHHH KopOTKoro rrepHOla

IIpeMeHH ero CO~ep)aHHe ~OJI)HO OCTaBaThC5I nOCT05IHHbiM O~HaKO

1I03MO)HOCTb pa3peIlleHH5I M OpaJIbHbIX KOHCPJIHKTOB C rr03HLHH pa3shy

IJbIX opHeHTaLHH y pOBHCi1lf c x eM ~aeT B03MO)f(HOCTh rrpe~rrOJIO)HTb

t lTO H eKOTOpylO pOJIb B 3TOM npouecce HrpaeT TeKYlLaH cHTyaUHH

CpeAH ee oc06emWCTeH 5IpKO BbIAeJI5IJOTC5I

- rrapTHep rro B3aHMo~eHCTBHIO opHeHTal(H5I Ha 3a60TY qalle rrp05IBshy

JI l1eT CJl rro OTHOIlleHHIO K CBoeMY - 3HaKOMOMY qeJIOBeKY lfJIH LJJIeshy

HY CBoeH COLHaJIbHOH rpynnhI (Ryan David Reynolds 2004) ~ x apaKTep Tpe60BaHI1H JIIO~H qalle 0pHeHTHpYIOTCJl Ha 3a60TY

rrpH pa3peWeHI1H lHlIeMM B KOTOPbIX K qeJIOBeKY rrpe~b5IBJI5IIOTC5I

rrpoTHBOpeqHBbJe Tpe60 BaHH5I H Ha C06JIIO~eHHe HOpM - B cHTyashy

LH5IX rAe OHH HapYIllaIOTC5f (Haviv Leman 2002) - cepbe3HocTb cHTyaLHH JIIO~H q8lle 0pHeHTl1pYIOTC5I Ha C06JIIO~eshy

HHe MOpaJIbHbIX HOPM KOma OleHI1BalOT Hecepbe3HYIO cHTyaLHlO

H Ha 3a60TY - rrplf OLeHKe cepbe3HoH (Bjorklund 2003) - 3 MOLHOHaJIbHa5I o KpacK a pa~ocTHble HJIH CIaCTJIHBble JIIO~H ~eshy

MOHCTPHPYIOT 60JIee HH3KHH ypoBe Hb MOpaJlbHOrO pa3BHTH5I (H HCshy

rrOJlb3YIOT cooTBeTcTBYOllHe eMY cxeMbI) qeM cnoKoHHble HJIH pacshy

cTpoeHHhle CZarinpoush Cooper Moylan 2000) - BpeMeHHbre OrpaHMQeHl15I B YCJIOBlfX JIHMI1Ta BpeMeHlf J1IO~H qalle

0pHeHTHpY IOTCH Ha C06JlIO~eHHe MOpaJIbH bIX HOPM qeM rrpH ero

OTCYTCTBHH (Bjorklund 2003) H ~p

TaKliM 06pa30M pa3Hble JIlO~H rrorraBIllHe B pa3Hble CI-nyaLHH CTaHOshy

BflTC5I o6-beKToM p a3JIHqHbIX MOpaJIbHbiX cy)~eID1I1 (Wark Krebs 1996) 310 03HaqaeT ITO M OpaJIbHa5I COLHaJIH3aLH5I H~eT rrYTeM YCBoeHH5I

pa3HbIX HarrpaBJIe l fHH H c xeM M OpaJIbHOrO C03HaHH5I rrpH YCJIOBHH ~Oshy

MI1H HpOBaHH5I 0~Hoi1 113 HHX TIPH 3TOM y)e YCBoeHHble 3JIeMeHTbl

lie 3a6bIBaIOTCn COEceM a aKTyaJIH3HpYIOTC5I B orrpeneJIeHHhI X cHTyashy

LH5IX B03Mo)HO fTO rrpaBHJIa I1X aKTyaJIYf3a IJHH YCBaHBaIOTcfl BMeCTe

c HX cO~ep)aHHeM

T aKHM 06pa30M K HaCT05IlleMY J3peMeHH B rrCHXOJIOnm HaKOrrJIeHa

o6W HpHa5I I1HcpopMaLH5I KaCaIOll35IC5I MOpaJIbHOIO pa3BHTH5I TIorrposhy

6yeM C ee rrOMOllbIO OTBeTHTb H8 ~Ba n onp oca KOTopble rrOCT05IHHO

iaTparHBaIOTC5I B 06lleCTBeHHblx AHCKYCCHl1 X Heo6xollHMO JIH cneUHshy

aJIbHO pa3BHBaTb MOpaJIbHOe c03HaHMe H eCJIH ~a TO KaK 3TO ~eJIaTb

Ha rrepBbIH Bonpoc TpYAliO AaTb 0~H03HaIHbIH OTBeT C O~HOH CTOshy

POHbI pa3Hble ypOBHH MOpaJl h HOrO p a3BHTlf5f OpraHHqHO BnHCbIBaIOTC5I

61 60 nCliXOl102IIlleCKue JtexaHU3MbL nOOOepJlcaHuR HpaBcmBeHHocmu

06paaOIlB HlJR TeM BbIIlle ypOBeHb MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTHfL 3TO B rrepByIO

o~epelb K3CaeTCJl npe~CTal3l1TeJIeH COLHaJIbHbIX HayK B TOM qHCJIe nCHshy

xonorOB H COqHaJIbHbIX pa60THHKOB H B ropa3~0 MeHbIlleH CTeneHHshy

CTjAeHTOB crrelT1aJI113HpYIOllHXC5I B 06JIaCTH 6H3Heca TIoBbIIlleHHIO

YPOIHH MOpaJIhHOro pa3BHTH5I crroc06cTByeT He TOJIbKO 06yqeHHe B Leshy

]10M HO 11 OBe(CHl1e OT~eJIbHbIX cneLHaJIH3HpOBaHHbIX KypCOB B paMKax

KOTOPhlX 06C)ltAaIOTCfI 3THIeCKHe acrreKTbI B3aHMoneHCTBH5I Me)ny

]lJO1lbMIf 11M npaKTJ1KyeTC5I 06palleHHe K CBoeMY BHYTpeHHeMY MHpy

TaKUM 06pa30M C O~HOH CTOPOHbI BbICIllee 06pa30BaHI1e naeT JIIO~5IM B03MOlKHOCTb YBHleTb pa3Hble TOIKH 3peHH5I H cpaBHHTb HX Me)ny

c060([ cnoco6cTByeT CPOpMHpOBaHHIO CJIO)HOH KapTHHbI MHpa a C lpyshy

roii YBe1lJ1lJl1BaeT I1HTepec K 3THqeCKOH COCTaBJI5IIOlleH qeJIOBeLlecshy

K[X OTHOllleHI1H (AI-Ansari 2002 Bunch 2005 Chandler Alexander

Heaton 2005 King Mayhew 2002) O~HaKo 06yqemre MO)eT npHBeCTl1

K speMeHHoMY YMeHbIlleHHIO ypOBH5I MOpaJIbHOro pa3BHTH5I KaK 3TO

npOHCxOll1T Hanpm1ep y cTYAeHTOB-MelHKOB Ha nepBblx Kypcax (Pateshy

naude Niyonsenga Fafard 2003) Co BpeMeHeM 3TOT 3cpcpeKT HCqe3aeT

CeMblll1 IlIKOJIa CPYHKLHOHHPYIOT B p a MKax 06lleCTBa H n03ToMY

m lJ)[1HlH11e BO MHorOM 3aBHCHT OT ero CTpyKTYPbl LeM pa3Ho06pa3Hee

OKpYlKeHl1e IeJIOBeKa IeM C 6 OJIbill ltM KOJIHqeCTBOM pa3HbIX JIIOneH OH

craQ KHBaeTCR TeM 6bICTpee rrpOHcxonHT MOp aJIbHOe pa3BHTHe I1MeHHo

n03TOMY ) ) lrreJIeH H30JIHpOBaHHblX HaCeJIeHHbIX rrYHKTOB a TaK)e

YTex KTO lKl1SeT B OlHOPOlHOH KYJIbTYPHOH cpe~e 3TOT rrpOLeCC rrposhy

TeK8eT MeAJIeHHee (Magsud 1977) BMeCTe C TeM He KoTopble C06bITH5I rrpOHCXO~5IIlHe B 06lleCTBe MOshy

rYT3aropMa)HBaTb MOpaJIbHOe pa3BHTHe KaK rrpaBHJIO OHH CB5I3aHbI

c Hapyme~lHeM MOpaJIbHbiX HOpM H JlBJI5IIOTC5I HCTOIHHKOM TpaBMaTHshy

qeCKOro OllbITa HarrpHMep 60JIee HH3KHH ypoBeHb MOpaJlbHOrO pa3shy

rutTMR J1MeIQT JTiQlH KOTopble B ~eTCTBe rrepe)HJIH BOHHY B pe3YJIbTaTe

qeroYH11X B03HHKITocTTpaBM aTl1qecKI111 CHH~pOM (Taylor Baker 2007) BepoHTHO K nopo6HbIM rrOCJIe~CTBH5IM MorYT rrpHBOlHTb H ~pyrHe 06shy

UeCTBeHHbJe C06bITH5I pa3pYIllaIOllHe CTpyKTYPY 06lleCTBa B 3TOH

ClfT)all111 Heo6xo~HMOCTb BbI)HBaHHJl crroc06CTBYCT rrepexo~y Ha rrepshy

BblH ypOBeHb MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTHJl

TaKI1M 06pa30M MOpaJIbHa5I COLHaJIH3aLH5I - 3TO rrpOl(eCC KOTOPbIH

AMITe ropaMH fIPH 3TOM MOpaJlbHa5I 0pHeHTaLIUI MO)eT H3MeH5IThCl1

H3 npOfll lKeHI1H BceH )I13HH IeJIOBeKa (Jaffee Hyde 2000) I1HTepecshy

HO 4TO B llepBylQ oLlepe~b cpopMl1pyeTCl1 0pHeHTaLI1H Ha CJIe~OBaHHe

HopMaM BbJpa)eHHOCTb 0pHeHTaLHH Ha 3a60TY H OKa3aHHe rrOMOllH

pamr Me(JleHHee (Quackenbush Barnett 2001)

OCHoBHbLe cmaouu MopanbHou co~uanU3a~Ull

TIocTerreHHoe CPOPMHpOB8HI1e MOpaJIbHOrO C03HaHH5I rOBopHT 0 ero

llTHOCHTeJIbHOH cTa6HJIbHOCTH Ha rrpOT5I)eHHH KopOTKoro rrepHOla

IIpeMeHH ero CO~ep)aHHe ~OJI)HO OCTaBaThC5I nOCT05IHHbiM O~HaKO

1I03MO)HOCTb pa3peIlleHH5I M OpaJIbHbIX KOHCPJIHKTOB C rr03HLHH pa3shy

IJbIX opHeHTaLHH y pOBHCi1lf c x eM ~aeT B03MO)f(HOCTh rrpe~rrOJIO)HTb

t lTO H eKOTOpylO pOJIb B 3TOM npouecce HrpaeT TeKYlLaH cHTyaUHH

CpeAH ee oc06emWCTeH 5IpKO BbIAeJI5IJOTC5I

- rrapTHep rro B3aHMo~eHCTBHIO opHeHTal(H5I Ha 3a60TY qalle rrp05IBshy

JI l1eT CJl rro OTHOIlleHHIO K CBoeMY - 3HaKOMOMY qeJIOBeKY lfJIH LJJIeshy

HY CBoeH COLHaJIbHOH rpynnhI (Ryan David Reynolds 2004) ~ x apaKTep Tpe60BaHI1H JIIO~H qalle 0pHeHTHpYIOTCJl Ha 3a60TY

rrpH pa3peWeHI1H lHlIeMM B KOTOPbIX K qeJIOBeKY rrpe~b5IBJI5IIOTC5I

rrpoTHBOpeqHBbJe Tpe60 BaHH5I H Ha C06JIIO~eHHe HOpM - B cHTyashy

LH5IX rAe OHH HapYIllaIOTC5f (Haviv Leman 2002) - cepbe3HocTb cHTyaLHH JIIO~H q8lle 0pHeHTl1pYIOTC5I Ha C06JIIO~eshy

HHe MOpaJIbHbIX HOPM KOma OleHI1BalOT Hecepbe3HYIO cHTyaLHlO

H Ha 3a60TY - rrplf OLeHKe cepbe3HoH (Bjorklund 2003) - 3 MOLHOHaJIbHa5I o KpacK a pa~ocTHble HJIH CIaCTJIHBble JIIO~H ~eshy

MOHCTPHPYIOT 60JIee HH3KHH ypoBe Hb MOpaJlbHOrO pa3BHTH5I (H HCshy

rrOJlb3YIOT cooTBeTcTBYOllHe eMY cxeMbI) qeM cnoKoHHble HJIH pacshy

cTpoeHHhle CZarinpoush Cooper Moylan 2000) - BpeMeHHbre OrpaHMQeHl15I B YCJIOBlfX JIHMI1Ta BpeMeHlf J1IO~H qalle

0pHeHTHpY IOTCH Ha C06JlIO~eHHe MOpaJIbH bIX HOPM qeM rrpH ero

OTCYTCTBHH (Bjorklund 2003) H ~p

TaKliM 06pa30M pa3Hble JIlO~H rrorraBIllHe B pa3Hble CI-nyaLHH CTaHOshy

BflTC5I o6-beKToM p a3JIHqHbIX MOpaJIbHbiX cy)~eID1I1 (Wark Krebs 1996) 310 03HaqaeT ITO M OpaJIbHa5I COLHaJIH3aLH5I H~eT rrYTeM YCBoeHH5I

pa3HbIX HarrpaBJIe l fHH H c xeM M OpaJIbHOrO C03HaHH5I rrpH YCJIOBHH ~Oshy

MI1H HpOBaHH5I 0~Hoi1 113 HHX TIPH 3TOM y)e YCBoeHHble 3JIeMeHTbl

lie 3a6bIBaIOTCn COEceM a aKTyaJIH3HpYIOTC5I B orrpeneJIeHHhI X cHTyashy

LH5IX B03Mo)HO fTO rrpaBHJIa I1X aKTyaJIYf3a IJHH YCBaHBaIOTcfl BMeCTe

c HX cO~ep)aHHeM

T aKHM 06pa30M K HaCT05IlleMY J3peMeHH B rrCHXOJIOnm HaKOrrJIeHa

o6W HpHa5I I1HcpopMaLH5I KaCaIOll35IC5I MOpaJIbHOIO pa3BHTH5I TIorrposhy

6yeM C ee rrOMOllbIO OTBeTHTb H8 ~Ba n onp oca KOTopble rrOCT05IHHO

iaTparHBaIOTC5I B 06lleCTBeHHblx AHCKYCCHl1 X Heo6xollHMO JIH cneUHshy

aJIbHO pa3BHBaTb MOpaJIbHOe c03HaHMe H eCJIH ~a TO KaK 3TO ~eJIaTb

Ha rrepBbIH Bonpoc TpYAliO AaTb 0~H03HaIHbIH OTBeT C O~HOH CTOshy

POHbI pa3Hble ypOBHH MOpaJl h HOrO p a3BHTlf5f OpraHHqHO BnHCbIBaIOTC5I

63 62 llCUXOJI02U 4eCKUe MeXaHU3Mbl nOOOepJKaHUJl HpaBCmB eHHOCm U

B pa3JIHIHble 06IleCTBeHHble CTpy KTYPbI HanpHMep B 06IleCTBe rlle

CYIleCTByeT )(eCTKa5I BepTHKaJIb BJIaCTH a l1CTO1HHK OM laquoepHHCTBeHshy

HO npaBHJIbHororaquo MHeHHH HBJIHeTCH OPHH 1eJIOBeK HJII1 He60JIblIIaH

rpynna JIlOlleH rlle aJIbTepHaTHBHble TO1KH 3peHH5I paCCMaTpHBalOTC5I

KaK He COOTBeTCTBYlOIlHe lleHCTBHTeJIbHOCTH H n OTOMY HeHY)(H ble

rlle CYIleCTByeT CHJIbHa5I CHCTCMa KOHTPOJIH H npHHY gtKaeHHH JIY1lIIe

Bcero allanTHpYlOTCH JIlOllH C nepBbIM ypOBHeM MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHshy

THH no JI KOJI6epry B TO )(e BpeMH TeM KTO HMeeT TpeTHH ypOBeHb

llJIH nOJIHOleHHoro CYIleCTBOBaHH5I He06xollHMO 06IleCTBo rAe leHHTshy

C5I JIHyHoe MHeHHe H HHllHBHllyaJIbHa5I HHHIHaTHBa

C llpyroH CTOPOHbI ypoBeHb MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTHH OKa3bIBaeT BJIHshy

5IHHe Ha Bep05ITHOCTb Toro 110 1eJIOBeK 6YlleT BeCTH ce6H B COOTBeTCTshy

BHH C MOpaJIbHbIMH HopMaMH TaIlt OH MO)(eT npH3HaBaTb He06xollHshy

MOCTb HX C06JIlOlleHH5I HO BeCTH ce6R cOBeplIIeHHo HHbl M 06pa30M

llJIH Toro 1T06bI CB5I3b Me)(llY MOpaJIbHbIM cy)(aeHHeM H nOBelletTHeM

CTaJia O1eBHllHOH He06xollHMO C06JIlOlleHlle HeCKOJIbKMX YCJIOBHH (AHshy

IHltpepoBa 1999 HHKOJIaeBa 1995 Arnold 2000 Rest et al 2000 Skoe

Eisenberg Cumberland 2002)

- BKJIlO1eHHe 1epT CB5I3aHHblX Cpa3JIHIHbIMH MOpaJlbHblMH HOpMaMH

B )1-KOHlenIHlO OC03HaHHe CBoero n Oll06Hf 1eJIOBeKY K OTOPbIH

06JIallaeT P5IllOM COIHaJIbHO-He)(eJIaTeJIbHbIX 1epT

- npHHHTHe 1eJIOBeKOM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 3a CBo e nOBelleH H e H lle HCTshy

BHH llpymx JIlOlleH

- OTCYTCTBHe KBa3H-06JI3aTeJIbCTB - 06H3aTeJI bCTB n epen llpyrHMH

1JIeHaMH CBoeH rpynnbI 3KcnepHMeHT3TopOM H T a ) npOT H Bopeshy

1aIlHX MOpaJIbHbIM HopMaM HanpHMep npH3HaHHlO leHHOCTH 1e shy

JIOBe1eCKOH )(H3HH

3MnaTHH no OTHOIlleHHlO K )(epTBe cnoc06HOCTb nOHITTb e e o r o pye shy

HHe HJIH rHeB

- YMeHHe npaBHJIbHO HHTepnpeTHpOBaTb KOHltpJIHKTHYIO cHTy a lHlO

nOHHMaTb xapaKTep OTHOIlleHHH M C)(l1y yqacTHHK aMl1

- HaJIH1He nOBelleH1eCKHX HaBbIKOB He0 6XOllHM bIX llJIH COBepme HHH

lleHCTBHH

- HaJIHyHe COIHaJIbHOrO KOHTPOJIH co CTOPOHbI llpyr Hx JI lOlleH

EOJIbIIIHHCTJlO 3TH X YCJIOBHH oc06eHHO OTCYTCTBHe KBa3H - 06fl3ashy

TeJIbCTB H YMeHHe npaBHJIbHO HHTepnpeTHpOBaTb CHrya uHlO ltP0PMHshy

PYlOTC5I MellJIeHHO H nOCTerreHHO 3TO 03Ha1aeT -lT O M aKCHMaJlbHOe

COOTBeTCTBHe Me)(ay MOpaJIbHbIM CY)(lleHHeM H IlOBelle HHeM Ha6JIlOshy

llaeTC5I y JIlOlleH HaXOllHIlHXCH B KOHle BToporo H Ha TpeT beM ypOBHHX

OCHOBHbte cmaouu MOpaJlbHOii col1uaJlU3al1uu

M o paJIbHOrO pa3BH THH HanpHMep 1eM BbIllie ypOBeHb MOpaJIbHOrO

pa 3BHTHH CTYlleHTOB TeM pe)(e OHH 06MaHbIBalOT npenOllaBaTeJI5I

wreM 1aIle HCnOJIb3YlOT npe3epBaTHBbi (King Mayhew 2002) qeM Bblshy

we y poBeHb MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTH5I Y1HTeJIeH TeM 1aIle OHH HCnOJIb3Yshy

lOT lIeMOKpaTHyeCKHH CTHJIb PYKOBOllCTBa H TeM OXOTHee BbICJIYIllalOT

p33Hble MHeHHH Y1eHHKOB (Reiman Peace 2002) 3TO oc06eHHo HpKO

tlp05IBJIHeTC5I y Tex KTO HaXOllHTC5I B ltpa3e KOHCOJIHllaIHH (Derryberry

T homa 2005) TaKHM 06pa30M BblCOKHH ypoBeHb MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHshy

HH 06eCrreyHBaeT caMOCT05ITeJIbHOe BbIflOJIHeHHe 1eJIOBeKOM MOpaJIb shy

IIbIX HOPM 1TO oc06eHHo Ba)(HO rrpH OTCYTCTBHH )(eCTKOro H nOCT05IHshy

110ro KOHTPOJIH 3a ero lIeHCTBHHMH

B 3TOM cJIY1ae B03HHKaeT BTOPOH Bonpoc KaKHe YCJIOBH5I cnoc06cTshy

OyIOT nOBbIIlleHHlO ypOBHH MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BHTH5I HaH60JIee Ba)(HYlO

p OJIb 3lleCb HrpalOT caMoCTOHTeJIbHOCTb B03MO)(HOCTb BHlleTb pa3Hble

rOlJKH 3peHHH H HaJIH1l1e npl1Mepa Ha KOTOPbIH MO)(HO Opl1eHTl1pO shy

naTbC5I KaK npaBI1JIO 60JIee BbICOKI1H ypoBeHb HMelOT JIlOlll1 KOTopble

6 JIallalOT HeKoTopoH cB060ll0H lleHCTBI1H OllHaKO 3TOT ltpaKTop OKa3bIshy

l)aeT BJII15IHl1e TOJIbKO B TOM CJIYIae eCJII1 IeJIOBeK BI1llI1T 1TO MHeHI15I

Kp y )(alOIlHX pa3JII11alOTC5I 11 rrpH 3 TOM CTaJIKHBaeTC5I C HOCHTeJI5IMI1

60JIee BbICOKoro ypOBHH MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BI1TI15I K 3TOMY He06xollHMO

0 6aBl1Tb onpelleJIeHHbIH ypoBeHb 3MOlHOHaJIbHOrO 6JIarOnOJIYIHH

nO-BHllI1MOM Y nCHXOJIOrHIeCKl1e TpaBMbl H llOJIra5I llenpI1BaIH5I OCHOBshy

IIblX nOTpe6HOCTeH cnoc06CTBYlOT laquo3aCTpeBaHHlOraquo 1eJIOBeKa Ha paHHI1X

CTallHHX MOpaJIbHOrO pa3BI1TI1H C06JIlOlleHHe 3THX YCJIOBHH B paMKax

OCHOBHbIX HHCTHTYTOB COlHaJIH3all1l1 YCKOp5IeT MOpaJIbHOe pa3BHTHe

JIHTepaTypa

AHl1bUj5epoBa JI U CBH3b MOpaJIbHOrO C03HaHHH C HpaBCTBeHHblM rro shy

BelleHl1eM 1eJIOBeKa (no MaTepl1aJIaM HCCJIellOBaHHH JIoypeHca KOJIshy

6epra Hero IIIKOJIbI) II TIcHXOJIOrH1JeCKHH )(ypHaJI 1999 T 20 NQ 3 C 5-17

HaKOB B B TIOJIOBble reHllepHble H JIH1HOCTHble pa3JIH1HH B nOHHshy

MaHHH MOpaJIbHOH llI1JIeMMbl II TIcI1XOJIOrH1eCKHH )(ypHaJI 2004 NQ 1 C 41-51

-uKOJlaeBa 0 n TIpaBoBaH H MOpaJIbHa5I 3peJIOCTb JIH1HOCTI1 II Cy6beKT

H COll1aJIbHaH KOMneTeHTHOCTb JIH1HOCTH M 1995 C 109-137 (menaHOBa A c CBH3b pOllHTeJIbCKOrO OTHOlIIeHH5I C MOpaJIbHbIM pa3shy

BHTHeM nOllpOCTKOB KypcOBaJI pa60Ta VITI prry 2004 I-Ansari E M Effects of gender and education on the moral reasoning of

Kuwait university students II Social Behavior and Personality 2002 V 30 P 75-82

65 64 llCUXOJlO2U4eCKue MeXQ-lU3MbL nOOOepJfca HU51 HpaecmeeHHocmu

Arnold M L Stage sequence and sequels changing conceptions of moshyrality post-Kohlberg II Educational Psychology Review 2000 V 12 NQ 4 P 365-383

Baek H J A comparative study of moral development of Korean and Britshyish children I I Journal of Moral Education 2002 V 31 NQ4 P 373shy39L

Bamett M A Quackenbush S w Sinisi C S The role of critical experishyences in moral development implications for justice and care orientashytions II Basic and Social Psychology 1995 V 77 P 137-152

BersoffD M Miller J G Culture context and the development of moral accountability judgments II Developmental Psychology 1993 V 29 P664-676

Bjorklund F Differences in the justification of choices in moral dilemmas effects of gender time pressure and dilemma seriousness II Scandishynavian Journal of Psychology 2003 V 44 P 459-466

Block G The moral reasoning of believers in animal rights II Society ampAnimals 2003 V 11 P 167-180

Bore M Munro D Kerridge l Powis D Libertarian and communitarian moral orientations and Schwartzs individual and collective va lue types Australian Journal of Psychology Supplement 2003 P 35

Bunch W H Changing moral judgement in divinity students II Journal of Moral Education 2005 V 34 P 363- 370

Cha ndler H M Alexander C N Heaton D P The transcendental meditashyLion program and postconventional self-development a 10-year lonshygitudinal study II Journal of Social Behavior and Personality 2005 V 17 P 93-121

De Vries B Walker L J Moral reasoning and attitudes toward capital punishment II Developmental Psychology 1986 V 22 P 509- 513

Derryberry W P Thoma S J Functional differences comparing moral judgement developmental phases of consolidation and transition II Journal of Moral Education 2005 V 34 P 89-106

Emler N Morality and political orientations an analysis of their relationship 1 Europea n Review of Social Psychology 2002 V 13 P 259-29l

Fang G Fang F Keller M Edelstein w KehletJ Bray MA Social moral reasoning in Chinese children a developmental study II Psychology in the Schools 2003 V 40 P 125-138

Ford M R Lowery C R Gender differences in moral reasoning a comshyparison of the use of justice and care orientations 1 Journal or Pershysonality and Social Psychology 1986 V 50 P 777-783

OCHo6Hble cmaouu MOpaJlbHOzl CO~UaJlU3a~UU

ri[igan C In a different voice psychological theory and womens develshyopment Cambridge 1982

laviv 5 Leman P J Moral decision-making in real life factors affecting moral orientation and behaviour justificarion II Journal of Moral

ducation 2002 V 31 N22 P 121- 140 IlIffee 5 Hyde J S Gender differences in moral orientation a meta-analshy

ysis II Psychological Bulletin 2000 V 126 P 703-726 d ng P M Mayhew M J Moral judgement development in higher educashy

tion insights from the Defining Issues Test II Journal of Moral Educashytion 2002 V 31 NQ 3

(ohlberg L Essays on moral development N Y Toronto 1984 ebs D L Denton K Explanatory limitations of cognitive-developmental

approaches to morality II Psychological Review 2006 V 113 P 672shy675

I man P J Duveen G Representations of authority and childrens morshyal reasoning II European Journal of Social Psychology 1999 V 29 P 557-577

1ugsud M The influence of social heterogeneity and sentimental credshyibil ity on moral judgments of Nigerian Muslim adolescents II Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology 1977 V 8 P 113-121

~IrFa rland S Mathews M Do Americans care about human rights II Journal of Human Rights 2005 V 4 P 305-319

~Tiler J G Bersoff D M Culture and moral judgment how are conflicts between justice and interpersonal responsibilities resolved II Jourshynal of Personality and Social Psychology 1992 V 62 P 541-554

IlIler J G BersoffD M The role of liking in perceptions of the moral reshysponsibility to help a cultural perspect ive 1 Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 1998 V 34 P 443- 469

1 fi ller J G Bersoff D 11 Harwood R L Perceptions of social responsibilities in India and the United States Moral imperatives or personal decisions II Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1990 V 58 P 33-47

Iyy ) L Helkama K Moral reasoning and the use of procedural justice rules in hypothetical and real-life dilemmas II Social Justice Research 002 V 15P 373-391

ltI rner E J Holl in C R Sociomoral reasoning pewptions of parenting a nd self-reported delinquency in adolescents II Applied Cognitive Psychology 2001 V 15 P 85-100

lIcnaLLde J Niyol1senga T Fafard D Changls in the components of moral reasoning during students medical education a pilot study II Medical Education 2003 V 37 P 822-829

66 nCUXOJl02UtleCKUe MexaHU3idbL noooepxcaHU51 HpaBcmBeHHocmu

Quackenbush S w Barnett M A Recollection and evaluation of critical experiences in moral development a cross-sectional examination II Basic and Applied Social Psychology 2001 V 23 P 55-64

Reiman A J Peace D S Promoting teachers moral reasoning and collaboshyrative inquiry performance a developmental role-taking and guided inquiry study II Journal of Moral Education 2002 V 31 P 51-66

Rest J R Narvaez D Thoma S J Bebeau M J A Neo-Kohlbergian apshyproach to morality research II Journal of Moral Education 2000

V 29 P 381-395 Ryan M K David B Reynolds K J Who cares The effect of gender and

context on the self and moral reasoning I I Psychology of Women Quarterly 2004 V 28 P 246-255

Skoe E E A Eisenberg N Cumberland A The role of reported emotion in real-life and hypothetical moral dilemmas II Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2002 V 28 P 962-973

Snarey J R Cross-cultural universality of social-moral development a critical review of Kohlbergian research II Personality Bulletin 1985

V 97 P 202-232 Taylor J G Baker S B Psychosocial and moral development of PTSDshy

diagnosed combat veterans II Journal of Counseling amp Development

2007 V 85 P 364-369 Wark G R Krebs D L Gender and dilemma differences in real-life moral

judgment II Developmental Psychology 1996 V 32 P 220-230 Wendorf C A Alexander S Firestone I J Social justice and moral reashy

soning an empirical integration of two paradigms in psychological research II Social Justice Research 2002 V 15 NQ 1

White J Manolis C Individual differences in ethical reasoning among law students II Social Behavior and Personality 1997 V 25 P 19-48

Zarinpoush F Cooper M Moylan S The effects of happiness and sadshyness on moral reasoning II Journal of Moral Education 2000 V 29

P 397-412

YHMBEPCAJIbHbIE KPMTEPMM l(EHHOCTHOrO

M HPABCTBEHHOrO Ol(EHMBAHMH

M COnYTCTBYIOIIJME nCMXOJIOrMqECKME

ltlgtEHOMEHbI

11 A HUKOJlaeBa

YI 1I1BepCaJIbHbie QeHHOCTHble KpHTepHH

II lIHlIHBHlIyaJIbHOM C03HaHHH H KyJIbType

LJeJlOBeK BbIHOCHT ueHHOCTHbe oueHKH BceM 06beKTaM H flBJleHHflM

11pa KaKHMH KpHTepHflMH OH npH 3TOM PYKOBOllCTByeTcR C OllHOH CTOPOHb caMblMH MHoro06pa3HbllVIHH MaKCHMaJlbHO HHlIHshy

IIllllyaJlH3HpOBaHHbIMH C03HaHHe H nOllC03HaHHe Ka)f(lIOro IeJlOBeKa IOnOJlHeHblraquo orpOMHblM KOJlHIeCTBOM ltPYHKUHOHaJlbHbIX MOllaJlbHOCshy

lii onpelleJleHI1f1 3HaIeHHHH H3MepHTeJlbHblX lllKaJl pa3Horo THna II ITOMY ITO lIJlflfeJlOBeKa HeT HHIerO Ba)f(Hee IeM opraHH3aUHfI cBoero 1I1UHMOlleHCTBHH c oKpY)f(alOIleH lIeHCTBHTeJlbHOCTblO a OHO HeB03MO)f(shy11 11 6e3 onpelleJleHHH 3HaIeHHHraquo (AJlHllleB 2001 c 77) ITpHpaBHHBaH

IIllHOCTHble ueHHOCTH K cy6beKTHBHbIM 3HaIeHHHM K CMblCJlY cHTyashy11li l1 aBTop nOllIepKHBaeT HX KpaHHlO1O HHlIHBHlIyaJlH3HpOBaHHocTb itHcTBHTeJlbHO CHHlIHBHlIyaJlH3aUHeH JlHIHOCTHbIX ueHHocTeH H coshy

IEeTcTBYIOIlHX Kpl1TepHeB oueHKH HeJlb3R He COrJlaCHTbcH COUHaJlbHOe B3aHMOlleHCTBHe c He06xollHMOCTblO ltp0pMHpyeT 06shy

(He rpynnoBble KYJlbTypHble HOPMbI H CTaHlIapTbI KOTopble cOCTaBshyIIUOT oCHOBaHHe lIJlH ueHHocTHOH oueHKH cy6beKT-cy6beKTHblX OTHOshy

II1CHI1I1 (EaTypHH 1989) XOTH B lIaHHOM cJlyIae B03HHKalOT np06JleMa lipI1HRTHHraquo I1HlIHBHlIOM rpynnoBoHueHHOCTHHJlI1 HOPMbl np06JleMa l~aeMororaquo H peaJlbHO lIeHcTBYIOIleroraquo KpHTepHH oueHKH KyJlbTypshy

i 11le KOJlJlH31111 onpelleJleHHfI HpaBCTBeHHoro H MOpaJlbHoro Pa3JlHIHe KYJlbTypHblX ueHHocTeH npl1BollHT K nOHcKY 06IleIeJlOBeshy

IlCIGIX ueHHOCTHbIX KpHTepHeB 3Ta np06JleMa pelliaeTcfI B nCHXOJlOrHshyil CKHX TeopHHx H 3MDHpI1Ke r lle 060cHoBbIBalOTcR pa3JlHIHble CHCTeshy 1I16a30Bblx YHHBepCaJlbHblX ueHHocTeH B ltpHJlOCOltpI1H KYJlbTypOJlOrI1H II 06paIleHI1I1 K MHPOBblM peJlHrHHM - B KaIeCTBe 06IleIeJlOBeIeCKHX II fllbIBalOTCfI ueHHOCTH lI06pa I1CTHHbl KpacoTbl CnpaBellJlHBOCTI1

67

66 nCUXOJl02UtleCKUe MexaHU3idbL noooepxcaHU51 HpaBcmBeHHocmu

Quackenbush S w Barnett M A Recollection and evaluation of critical experiences in moral development a cross-sectional examination II Basic and Applied Social Psychology 2001 V 23 P 55-64

Reiman A J Peace D S Promoting teachers moral reasoning and collaboshyrative inquiry performance a developmental role-taking and guided inquiry study II Journal of Moral Education 2002 V 31 P 51-66

Rest J R Narvaez D Thoma S J Bebeau M J A Neo-Kohlbergian apshyproach to morality research II Journal of Moral Education 2000

V 29 P 381-395 Ryan M K David B Reynolds K J Who cares The effect of gender and

context on the self and moral reasoning I I Psychology of Women Quarterly 2004 V 28 P 246-255

Skoe E E A Eisenberg N Cumberland A The role of reported emotion in real-life and hypothetical moral dilemmas II Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin 2002 V 28 P 962-973

Snarey J R Cross-cultural universality of social-moral development a critical review of Kohlbergian research II Personality Bulletin 1985

V 97 P 202-232 Taylor J G Baker S B Psychosocial and moral development of PTSDshy

diagnosed combat veterans II Journal of Counseling amp Development

2007 V 85 P 364-369 Wark G R Krebs D L Gender and dilemma differences in real-life moral

judgment II Developmental Psychology 1996 V 32 P 220-230 Wendorf C A Alexander S Firestone I J Social justice and moral reashy

soning an empirical integration of two paradigms in psychological research II Social Justice Research 2002 V 15 NQ 1

White J Manolis C Individual differences in ethical reasoning among law students II Social Behavior and Personality 1997 V 25 P 19-48

Zarinpoush F Cooper M Moylan S The effects of happiness and sadshyness on moral reasoning II Journal of Moral Education 2000 V 29

P 397-412

YHMBEPCAJIbHbIE KPMTEPMM l(EHHOCTHOrO

M HPABCTBEHHOrO Ol(EHMBAHMH

M COnYTCTBYIOIIJME nCMXOJIOrMqECKME

ltlgtEHOMEHbI

11 A HUKOJlaeBa

YI 1I1BepCaJIbHbie QeHHOCTHble KpHTepHH

II lIHlIHBHlIyaJIbHOM C03HaHHH H KyJIbType

LJeJlOBeK BbIHOCHT ueHHOCTHbe oueHKH BceM 06beKTaM H flBJleHHflM

11pa KaKHMH KpHTepHflMH OH npH 3TOM PYKOBOllCTByeTcR C OllHOH CTOPOHb caMblMH MHoro06pa3HbllVIHH MaKCHMaJlbHO HHlIHshy

IIllllyaJlH3HpOBaHHbIMH C03HaHHe H nOllC03HaHHe Ka)f(lIOro IeJlOBeKa IOnOJlHeHblraquo orpOMHblM KOJlHIeCTBOM ltPYHKUHOHaJlbHbIX MOllaJlbHOCshy

lii onpelleJleHI1f1 3HaIeHHHH H3MepHTeJlbHblX lllKaJl pa3Horo THna II ITOMY ITO lIJlflfeJlOBeKa HeT HHIerO Ba)f(Hee IeM opraHH3aUHfI cBoero 1I1UHMOlleHCTBHH c oKpY)f(alOIleH lIeHCTBHTeJlbHOCTblO a OHO HeB03MO)f(shy11 11 6e3 onpelleJleHHH 3HaIeHHHraquo (AJlHllleB 2001 c 77) ITpHpaBHHBaH

IIllHOCTHble ueHHOCTH K cy6beKTHBHbIM 3HaIeHHHM K CMblCJlY cHTyashy11li l1 aBTop nOllIepKHBaeT HX KpaHHlO1O HHlIHBHlIyaJlH3HpOBaHHocTb itHcTBHTeJlbHO CHHlIHBHlIyaJlH3aUHeH JlHIHOCTHbIX ueHHocTeH H coshy

IEeTcTBYIOIlHX Kpl1TepHeB oueHKH HeJlb3R He COrJlaCHTbcH COUHaJlbHOe B3aHMOlleHCTBHe c He06xollHMOCTblO ltp0pMHpyeT 06shy

(He rpynnoBble KYJlbTypHble HOPMbI H CTaHlIapTbI KOTopble cOCTaBshyIIUOT oCHOBaHHe lIJlH ueHHocTHOH oueHKH cy6beKT-cy6beKTHblX OTHOshy

II1CHI1I1 (EaTypHH 1989) XOTH B lIaHHOM cJlyIae B03HHKalOT np06JleMa lipI1HRTHHraquo I1HlIHBHlIOM rpynnoBoHueHHOCTHHJlI1 HOPMbl np06JleMa l~aeMororaquo H peaJlbHO lIeHcTBYIOIleroraquo KpHTepHH oueHKH KyJlbTypshy

i 11le KOJlJlH31111 onpelleJleHHfI HpaBCTBeHHoro H MOpaJlbHoro Pa3JlHIHe KYJlbTypHblX ueHHocTeH npl1BollHT K nOHcKY 06IleIeJlOBeshy

IlCIGIX ueHHOCTHbIX KpHTepHeB 3Ta np06JleMa pelliaeTcfI B nCHXOJlOrHshyil CKHX TeopHHx H 3MDHpI1Ke r lle 060cHoBbIBalOTcR pa3JlHIHble CHCTeshy 1I16a30Bblx YHHBepCaJlbHblX ueHHocTeH B ltpHJlOCOltpI1H KYJlbTypOJlOrI1H II 06paIleHI1I1 K MHPOBblM peJlHrHHM - B KaIeCTBe 06IleIeJlOBeIeCKHX II fllbIBalOTCfI ueHHOCTH lI06pa I1CTHHbl KpacoTbl CnpaBellJlHBOCTI1

67