Nike Checkpoint 2
-
Upload
brendan-m-coughlin-mu-student -
Category
Documents
-
view
1.019 -
download
0
Transcript of Nike Checkpoint 2
BO A M E N T , C O L I N B E S T , B R E N D A N C O U G H L I N , D A R R I E N H O R N , C H A S E F R E R K I N G ,
D A N I E L J O N E S , DY L A N M O R G R E T , A A R O N P L AT T S
NIKE INC.CHECKPOINT 2: STRATEGY FORMULATION, IMPLEMENTATION, FIT & PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY FORMULATION & IMPLEMENTATION: 7S FRAMEWORK
SOGs,SGs, VMPGs,
Strategy(as Plan)
Strategy(as Position)
Structure(OS)
Style(OC)
Systems(VCA)
Skills(VRIO/CC)
Staff(OL, VCA)
StrategyFormulation
StrategyImplementation
• Main Idea: Greater fit amongst subsystems leads to
greater organizational effectiveness
CHECKPOINT 2: PRESENTATION OUTLINESTATEGY FORMULATION
SOG’S: Vision, Mission, Purpose, Goals, and “Mantra”STRATEGY: Business-Level Strategic Positioning
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATIONSKILLS: VRIO Framework/Core CompetenciesSTYLE: Organizational Culture AnalysisSTRUCTURE: Organizational Structure Analysis
STRATEGY FIT AND PERFORMANCEFIT: Modified 5S AnalysisPERFORMANCE: Financial Analysis
APPENDIX AND REFERENCES AT END
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY FORMULATION: SUPERORDINATE GOALS
SOGs,SGs, VMPGs,
Strategy(as Plan)
Strategy(as Position)
Structure(OS)
Style(OC)
Systems(VCA)
Skills(VRIO/CC)
Staff(OL, VCA)
StrategyFormulation
StrategyImplementation
• Main Idea: Greater fit amongst subsystems leads to
greater organizational effectiveness
STRATEGY FORMULATION: SUPERORDINATE GOALS
Mission Vision Purpos
e Goals Mantra
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY FORMULATION: SUPERORDINATE GOALS
Mission: “To bring inspiration and innovation to every athlete in the world.”
Mission Vision Purpos
e Goals Mantra
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY FORMULATION: SUPERORDINATE GOALS
Vision: “If you have a body, you are an athlete.”
Design a shoe for everyone Using high quality materials Made ethically (wages and work conditions) Safe for the Planet
Purpose: “Nike is dedicated to serving athletes and helping them reach their full potential”
‘Continually innovate to remain sustainable’Create value for shareholders Missio
n Vision Purpose Goals Mantr
aSTRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY FORMULATION: SUPERORDINATE GOALS
Goals: We Strive for Innovation that: Serves the athlete Grows the company Delivers inspiration Minimize Waste (Recycling ‘Reuse a Shoe’
program Promote Social Responsibility Focus on innovation, collaboration,
transparency and advocacyMissio
n Vision Purpose Goals Mantra
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY FORMULATION: SUPERORDINATE GOALS
• Tagline: “Just Do It!”• Mantra: “Authentic, athletic
performance”
Mission Vision Purpos
e Goals Mantra
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY FORMULATION: SUPERORDINATE GOALS
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
S T R E N G T H S Great customer loyalty
High profitability
Sponsorship Pride
Global environmental recognition
W E A K N E S S E S Too geared towards
the athlete and less towards their average consumer.
Mission statement is too broad, needs to be more specific
STRATEGY FORMULATION: SUPERORDINATE GOALS
CHECKPOINT 2: PRESENTATION OUTLINESTATEGY FORMULATION
SOG’S: Vision, Mission, Purpose, Goals, and “Mantra”STRATEGY: Business-Level Strategic Positioning
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATIONSKILLS: VRIO Framework/Core CompetenciesSTYLE: Organizational Culture AnalysisSTRUCTURE: Organizational Structure Analysis
STRATEGY FIT AND PERFORMANCEFIT: Modified 5S AnalysisPERFORMANCE: Financial Analysis
APPENDIX AND REFERENCES AT END
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY FORMULATION: STRATEGY AS POSITION
SOGs,SGs, VMPGs,
Strategy(as Plan)
Strategy(as Position)
Structure(OS)
Style(OC)
Systems(VCA)
Skills(VRIO/CC)
Staff(OL, VCA)
StrategyFormulation
StrategyImplementation
• Main Idea: Greater fit amongst subsystems leads to
greater organizational effectiveness
Broad Differentiation
Broad Low Cost
Focused Differentiation
Focused Low Cost
Broa
d Na
rrow
Differentiation Low Cost
Scop
e of
adv
anta
ge
Type of AdvantageStrategy: Porter’s Strategy Typology
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY FORMULATION: STRATEGY AS POSITION
Type of Advantage: Differentiation• Perception of uniqueness:
• Nike gives the customer the ability to customize their own shoes with colors, shapes and their name on the shoe.
• Nike’s brand is used by top athletes around the world• Willingness to pay a premium price:
• On average Nike’s customers pay over twice the world average price for a running shoe
• Over 50% of the shoe sales greater than 85% are Jordan’s• Exclusive/Original content:
• Nike’s designers are constantly coming out with original and new designs of shoes that competitors then copy, such as: Shocks, Nike SB, Air Max, etc.
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY FORMULATION: STRATEGY AS POSITION
Strategy Formulation: Business Level Strategic
Positioning Scope of Advantage: Broad
• Diverse Demographic: • People of all ages, race and sex wear Nike shoes and
apparel for a wide variety of uses.• Wide Geographic:
• Nike has a presence on every continent and provides its products to every country in the world, touching a wide base of different cultures.
• Variety of Usage: • Nike makes all sorts of shoes that serve a variety of
purposes such as shoes for: Runners, Soccer, Skateboarding, Leisure, Formal, etc. There is a shoe for everybody.
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY FORMULATION: STRATEGY AS POSITION
Strengths & Weaknesses: Business Level Strategy
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY FORMULATION: STRATEGY AS POSITIONS T R E N G T H S
• High differentiation allows Nike to reach a wide variety of consumers that look to be unique.
• Globally positioning themselves all over the World makes it fast and easy to produce and deliver products.
W E A K N E S S E S
High prices make switching costs lower for some consumers; potentially switch to lower cost rivals.
CHECKPOINT 2: PRESENTATION OUTLINESTATEGY FORMULATION
SOG’S: Vision, Mission, Purpose, Goals, and “Mantra”STRATEGY: Business-Level Strategic Positioning
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATIONSKILLS: VRIO Framework/Core CompetenciesSTYLE: Organizational Culture AnalysisSTRUCTURE: Organizational Structure Analysis
STRATEGY FIT AND PERFORMANCEFIT: Modified 5S AnalysisPERFORMANCE: Financial Analysis
APPENDIX AND REFERENCES AT END
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: SKILLS
SOGs,SGs, VMPGs,
Strategy(as Plan)
Strategy(as Position)
Structure(OS)
Style(OC)
Systems(VCA)
Skills(VRIO/CC)
Staff(OL, VCA)
StrategyFormulation
StrategyImplementation
• Main Idea: Greater fit amongst subsystems leads to
greater organizational effectiveness
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: SKILLS
Resources Valuable Rare Inimitability Organization
Leadership XDiversity XAccessibility XProduct Differentiation XCustomer Service XSupply Chain X XCulture X XEndorsements X XCorporate Social Responsibility X XMarketing/Advertising X X XResearch & Development X X XBrand Awareness X X X XInnovation X X X XEfficiency X X X XConsumer Loyalty X X X X
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
VRIO ANALYSIS
CORE COMPETENCIES METAPHOR
The Approach:
Core Competen
cies
• Brand Awareness
• Innovation• Efficiency• Consumer Loyalty
The Dunk: End
Products
•High quality Footwear/Apparel
•Advanced technological products
•Equipment
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: SKILLS
The Grip: Core
Products
• Soles• Fabrics
VRIO AND CORE COMPETENCIESS T R E N G T H S
Nike’s combination of financial resources, global supply chain, and decades of established vendor relationships makes the firm incredibly efficient.
Few companies are as globally recognized as Nike. This is in part due to their extensive marketing campaigns.
Nike has an extensive R&D program. This allows them to stay at the forefront of their industry, as they consistently release innovative and technologically advanced products.
W E A K N E S S E S Although Nike has strived to
better their image of CSR, there are still allegations of abuse and mistreatment of employees in some factories
While Nike is incredibly profitable, their income is heavily dependent on their share of the footwear market. If for some reason their market share were to diminish, the company may face financial hardships.
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: SKILLS
CHECKPOINT 2: PRESENTATION OUTLINESTATEGY FORMULATION
SOG’S: Vision, Mission, Purpose, Goals, and “Mantra”STRATEGY: Business-Level Strategic Positioning
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATIONSKILLS: VRIO Framework/Core CompetenciesSTYLE: Organizational Culture AnalysisSTRUCTURE: Organizational Structure Analysis
STRATEGY FIT AND PERFORMANCEFIT: Modified 5S AnalysisPERFORMANCE: Financial Analysis
APPENDIX AND REFERENCES AT END
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: STYLE
SOGs,SGs, VMPGs,
Strategy(as Plan)
Strategy(as Position)
Structure(OS)
Style(OC)
Systems(VCA)
Skills(VRIO/CC)
Staff(OL, VCA)
StrategyFormulation
StrategyImplementation
• Main Idea: Greater fit amongst subsystems leads to
greater organizational effectivenessSTRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE ANALYSIS
Cohesive Strong
Non-cohesiveWeak
Focus on “Production”Impersonal
Focus on “People”Humanistic
BureaucraticStability
AdaptiveChange
Risk-seekingInnovative
Risk-averseSecurity
Focus on “Performance” Pressurized/Get Results
Focus on “Effort” (or not)Enjoy the Process
Outcome Orientation
Support Orientation
Change Orientation Risk Orientation
Strength Orientation
5
4
5
4
5
4
5
45
4
1
2
11
2
1
1
2
2
3
1
3
3 3
3 2
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: STYLE
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE: STRENGTH ORIENTATION: 4
• Cult-like culture • Nike’s tribal identity: “We have the best-kept secrets”• Employees are said to quote the 11 Maxims of Nike
– Similar to the Ten Commandments• Nike’s story and history is embedded into employees
• Quote from one of Nike’s GMs:– “It’s about making sure that every person in the system adopts a different
world view, sense of purpose and approach to their job.”
1 2 3 4 5Non-CohesiveWeak
CohesiveStrong
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: STYLE
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE: CHANGE ORIENTATION: 3.5
1 542 3Bureaucratic
Stability Adaptive Change
• “To fulfill our potential we know we need to operate in completely new ways, making sustainability integral to our innovation and performance.” (Mark Parker, Nike President
& CEO)• After trouble regarding illegal manufacturing practices, Nike became the 1st company in the
industry to voluntarily disclose names of all contract factories producing Nike products.• Nike launched Making, which is an app that helps designers and product creators make
informed decisions about the environmental impacts of materials they choose.• 33,000 employees worldwide, yet only 14 (board of directors) make the important decisions
regarding the company.• Every year Nike requires all employees to read and verify they read the code of ethics, “Inside
the Lines”
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: STYLE
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE: SUPPORT ORIENTATION: 2.5
1 2 3 4 5Focus on “People”Humanistic
Focus on “Production”Impersonal
• During the 1990s and early 2000s, people accused Nike of sweatshop labor: This proved to be an impersonal process stated by then Nike director, Todd McKean, “Hey, we don't own the factories. We don't control what goes on there.
• Forbes ranked Nike #317 on the list of America’s best employers, significantly lower than other billion dollar companies such as, Google(1). This position shows Nike is more concerned with production than what will make the employees happier.
• Four core principles for Nike management team:- Lead - Coach - Drive - Insprire
• "Figure out where you want your career to go, and when you see something that would help you get there, ask us for it.” (Nelson Farris, Nike’s head of corporate education)
Nike is a company that aims to foster creativity and innovation amongst its employees, yet the results do not always coincide with that belief. Using the four principles and the 11 maxims to guide their
employees, Nike works to be humanistic, but when the company is as large as Nike, ideas and get lost in the shuffle, allowing for numerous impersonal moments.
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: STYLE
ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE ANALYSIS
S T R E N G T H S
Strong cult-like culture
Focus on helping employees grow
Industry leading results
W E A K N E S S E S
Bureaucratic decision-making
High R&D costs from risk seeking
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: SKILLS
CHECKPOINT 2: PRESENTATION OUTLINESTATEGY FORMULATION
SOG’S: Vision, Mission, Purpose, Goals, and “Mantra”STRATEGY: Business-Level Strategic Positioning
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATIONSKILLS: VRIO Framework/Core CompetenciesSTYLE: Organizational Culture AnalysisSTRUCTURE: Organizational Structure Analysis
STRATEGY FIT AND PERFORMANCEFIT: Modified 5S AnalysisPERFORMANCE: Financial Analysis
APPENDIX AND REFERENCES AT END
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: STRUCTURE
SOGs,SGs, VMPGs,
Strategy(as Plan)
Strategy(as Position)
Structure(OS)
Style(OC)
Systems(VCA)
Skills(VRIO/CC)
Staff(OL, VCA)
StrategyFormulation
StrategyImplementation
• Main Idea: Greater fit amongst subsystems leads to
greater organizational effectiveness
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE ANALYSISHIERARCHY OF AUTHORITY DIMENSION
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIC STRUCTUREFlat, horizontal
hierarchy.
HIERARCHY OF AUTHORITY
The extent to which there are many (or few) levels in the
organization’s hierarchy.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
MECHANISTIC STRUCTURE
Tall, vertical hierarchy.
• PHILLIP H. KNIGHT (CHAIRMAN OF THE BOARD OF DIRECTORS)• MARK PARKER (PRESIDENT AND CEO, NIKE, INC.)• TREVOR EDWARDS (PRESIDENT, NIKE BRAND)• DAVID AYRE (EVP, GLOBAL HUMAN RESOURCES)• DON BLAIR (EVP AND CFO)• JEANNE P. JACKSON (PRESIDENT, PRODUCT & MERCHANDISING)• HILARY KRANE (EVP, CHIEF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICER)• JOHN SLUSHER (EVP, GLOBAL SPORTS MARKETING)• ERIC SPRUNK (CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER)• CORPORATE GOVERNANCE• BOARD OF DIRECTORS
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: STRUCTURE
ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE ANALYSISFORMALIZATION DIMENSION
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIC STRUCTUREFew (formal)
written rules and regulations; more
informal approach.
FORMALIZATION
The extent to which rules exist in written form and
cover a wide range of contingencies.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10
MECHANISTIC STRUCTURELots of (formal)
written rules and regulations; “by
the book” approach.
• Nike’s subsidiaries reap minor independence within definitively set boundaries.
• Projects that exceed limits placed by regional headquarters or global headquarters do need approval of the region
• Nike’s contracted manufactures are required to comply with their “code of conduct”
• Environmental and sustainability requirements – suppliers
• The 11 Nike Maxims that all employees follow
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: STRUCTURE
ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE ANALYSISSPECIALIZATION DIMENSION
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIC STRUCTURE
Employees perform a wide
range of tasks in their job; fluid
roles; overlapping tasks.
SPECIALIZATION
The extent to which tasks are
subdivided into separate jobs.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
MECHANISTIC STRUCTUREEach employee performs only a narrow range of tasks; rigid roles;
task are separated with little/no overlap.
• Nike uses a functional structure to divide up activities and decentralizes control within the design process to individual teams
• Nike’s specialization within the company has lead to departmentalization (footwear, apparel, equipment, marketing/sales)
• Nike has succeeded by remaining flexible in a volatile market by using subcontracting relationships overseas in low labor-cost countries
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: STRUCTURE
ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE ANALYSISOVERALL STRUCTURE ANALYSIS
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
FORMALIZATION8
CENTRALIZATION 5
STANDARDIZATION5
SPECIALIZATION 8
HIERARCHY OF AUTHORITY3
OVERALL STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS5.8
AMBIDEXTROUS
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: STRUCTURE
ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE ANALYSISSTRENGTHS AND WEAKNESSES
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRENGTHS• Standardization: Nike gives its employees flexibility (with
specific guidelines) to continuously innovate• Formalization: Employees know exactly what is expected from
them (11 Nike Maxims)• Centralization: The structural levels throughout the
organization overall make Nike more efficientWEAKNESSES• Specialization: Most of the income comes from footwear
segment – may need to emphasize moreszk on other segments• Hierarchy of Authority: Nike’s matrix structure places multiple
responsibilities within reporting lines throughout various business units which can prove problematic
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: STRUCTURE
CHECKPOINT 2: PRESENTATION OUTLINESTATEGY FORMULATION
SOG’S: Vision, Mission, Purpose, Goals, and “Mantra”STRATEGY: Business-Level Strategic Positioning
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATIONSKILLS: VRIO Framework/Core CompetenciesSTYLE: Organizational Culture AnalysisSTRUCTURE: Organizational Structure Analysis
STRATEGY FIT AND PERFORMANCEFIT: Modified 5S AnalysisPERFORMANCE: Financial Analysis
APPENDIX AND REFERENCES AT END
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIZATIONAL FIT & PERFORMANCE
SOGs,SGs, VMPGs,
Strategy(as Plan)
Strategy(as Position)
Structure(OS)
Style(OC)
Systems(VCA)
Skills(VRIO/CC)
Staff(OL, VCA)
StrategyFormulation
StrategyImplementation
• Main Idea: Greater fit amongst subsystems leads to
greater organizational effectivenessSTRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIZATIONAL FIT & PERFORMANCE
MODIFIED 5S ANALYSISSuperordinate Goals Position Structure Style Skills
Superordinate Goals
Position
Structure
Style
Skills
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIZATIONAL FIT & PERFORMANCE
MODIFIED 5S ANALYSISBest Fits
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
SOG’s & PositionSkills & Position
Both “best fits” relate to Nike’s extremely strong positioning
Reaching every athlete everywhere made possible through broad differentiation
“PUPPY” achieved through effectively communicated SOGs, top-down
Excellent core and end products teamed with top-notch distribution & manufacturing system = SOGs satisfied
ORGANIZATIONAL FIT & PERFORMANCE
MODIFIED 5S ANALYSISWorst Fits
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
Structure & SOGs
Style & SOGs
Both weaknesses point to issues with compatibility of the flat, mechanized, sometimes-bureaucratic organization with the goals of CSR, inspiration, and advocacy
ORGANIZATIONAL FIT & PERFORMANCE
MODIFIED 5S ANALYSIS
Overall Subsystem Fit Very Good
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
If 7S Thesis holds, then financial performance should be “very good” as well
CHECKPOINT 2: PRESENTATION OUTLINESTATEGY FORMULATION
SOG’S: Vision, Mission, Purpose, Goals, and “Mantra”STRATEGY: Business-Level Strategic Positioning
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATIONSKILLS: VRIO Framework/Core CompetenciesSTYLE: Organizational Culture AnalysisSTRUCTURE: Organizational Structure Analysis
STRATEGY FIT AND PERFORMANCEFIT: Modified 5S AnalysisPERFORMANCE: Financial Analysis
APPENDIX AND REFERENCES AT END
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIZATIONAL FIT & PERFORMANCEFINANCIAL ANALYSIS
Key takeaway: Nike is turning over inventory at a rate at least 30% greater than key industry competitors, implying strong sales and effective inventory
management practices.
2010 2011 2012 2013 20140
1
2
3
4
5
6
Activity: Inventory Turnover
Nike Under Armour Puma Adidas/Reebok
COGS
/Ave
rage
Inve
ntor
y
Activity - Inventory Turnover2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Nike 4.64 4.77 4.5 4.21 4.16Under Armou
r2.93 2.82 2.97 3.03 3.13
Puma 3.45 3.1 3.11 2.98 2.9Adidas
/Reebo
k3.49 3.04 3.13 2.87 2.95
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIZATIONAL FIT & PERFORMANCEFINANCIAL ANALYSIS
2010 2011 2012 2013 20140
5
10
15
20
25
30
Profitability: Return on Equity (ROE)
Nike Under Armour Puma Adidas/Reebok
NI a
s a %
of E
quity
Key takeaway: Nike has set the bar for the Textile and Apparel industry, achieving ROE greater than 20% every year with consistent and stable growth. Nike’s ROE indicates it is effectively using shareholder funds to
generate profits.
Profitability - ROE (%)2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Nike 20.67 21.77 21.92 23.08 24.5
Under Armour
15.27 17.1 17.67 17.36 17.31
Puma 15.4 15.38 4.38 0.34 4.11
Adidas/Reebok
13.52 13.5 9.87 14.58 8.82
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIZATIONAL FIT & PERFORMANCEFINANCIAL ANALYSIS – SUMMARY
Overall Financial Performance = Excellent
At or near industry leader in almost all financial ratio analyses
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIZATIONAL FIT & PERFORMANCE
S T R E N G T H S
SOG & Position fitSkills & Position fitROEInventory Turnover
W E A K N E S S E S
Skills & Style Structure & SOG
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIZATIONAL FIT & PERFORMANCEMODIFIED 5S & FINANCIAL ANALYSIS SUMMARY
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
Modified 5S Analysis:
Over fit = Very Good
Financial Analysis:Financial
Performance = Excellent
7S Framework holds
CHECKPOINT 2: PRESENTATION OUTLINESTATEGY FORMULATION
SOG’S: Vision, Mission, Purpose, Goals, and “Mantra”STRATEGY: Business-Level Strategic Positioning
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATIONSKILLS: VRIO Framework/Core CompetenciesSTYLE: Organizational Culture AnalysisSTRUCTURE: Organizational Structure Analysis
STRATEGY FIT AND PERFORMANCEFIT: Modified 5S AnalysisPERFORMANCE: Financial Analysis
APPENDIX AND REFERENCES AT END
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
APPENDIXComplete Organizational Culture AnalysisComplete Organizational Structure AnalysisComplete Financial AnalysisReferences
ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE: OUTCOME ORIENTATION: 5
• “Because we are Nike, we have a very powerful and very high profile brand. Along with those come extremely high expectations, as well as very high
demand with a very low timeframe” (Shawn Browning, Nike Facility Manager).• Quote from Professional Retailstore Maintenance Association
– “Working with Nike, Inc.’s Facilities maintenance department to changing a tire on a car going 65 miles per hour down the road” (Former Supplier of Nike).
• Accelerated innovation to maintain sustainability
1 2 3 4 5Focus on “Performance”Pressurized/Get Results
Focus on “Effort” (or not) Enjoy the Process
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: SKILLS
ORGANIZATIONAL CULTURE: RISK ORIENTATION: 5
1
52 3 4
Nike’s culture stresses risk, and more importantly, innovation. Using a highly differentiated mindset, Nike aims to be the first company to expand its products
and is unafraid of risks.
Risk-seeking Innovative
Risk-averse Security
• Expanded to Canada in 1972 (Giving Nike their global recognition), now located in +24 countries
• According to Fast Company, leading business media brand, Nike was the #1 most innovative company of 2013
• “My fear is being this big, slow, constipated, bureaucratic company that’s happy with its success.” (Mark Parker, Nike President & CEO)
• Example of innovation: Flyknit Racers, which are lightest running shoe at 5.6 ounces
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: SKILLS
ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE ANALYSISSTANDARDIZATION DIMENSION
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIC STRUCTUREPeople are free to
create and introduce new ideas which
means their organizations are less likely to routinely do things the same way
after time.
STANDARDIZATION
The extent to which things are done the
same way, time after time.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
MECHANISTIC STRUCTUREOrganization
consistently and routinely does
things the same way, time after
time.• “Nike can respond to changes in sports shoe fashion very quickly.
Using its global computer system, it can, literally overnight, change the instructions it gives to each of its suppliers so that, within a few weeks, its foreign manufacturers are producing new kinds of shoes.” – Hill, Jones
• The Nike Swoosh is used as a pattern standardization tool among all levels of promotional/advertising functions
• Nike divides product lines into specific customer categories – specific, individual customer groups
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: STRUCTURE
ORGANIZATIONAL STRUCTURE ANALYSISCENTRALIZATION DIMENSION
STRATEGY FORMULATION STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION FIT AND PERFORMANCE
ORGANIC STRUCTURE
Decision making is delegated to empowered
individuals at lower levels in the organization.
CENTRALIZATION
The extent to which decisions are
made at or near the top of the organization’s
hierarchy.1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10
MECHANISTIC STRUCTUREDecisions are
made at or near the top of the organization.
• Global headquarters is at the top of the hierarchical decision-making matrix and also manages Nike’s regional operations/all major markets
• Regional headquarters adds an additional layer to make the structure more effective/efficient by reducing complexity
• Regional headquarters allows for leverage in financial/management operations and also enhances supply chain management
STRATEGY IMPLEMENTATION: STRUCTURE
ORGANIZATIONAL FIT & PERFORMANCEFINANCIAL ANALYSIS
SG&A expenses cover everything from direct selling expenditures to salaries of non-sales personnel, rent, etc. When normalized against revenue and compared to other industry firms, SG&A expenses can give insight into whether management is spending efficiently or wasting
valuable cash flows.
Key takeaway: Over the past five years, Nike has consistently spent a lower percentage of its revenues on SG&A expenses, suggesting efficient sales and effective monetary controls in
comparison to industry firms.
2010 2011 2012 2013 201405
101520253035404550
Selling, General, & Administrative Expenses (% of Revenue)
Nike Under Armour Puma Adidas/Reebok
% o
f Rev
enue
Selling, General, & Administrative Expenses (% of Revenue)
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Nike 34.45 33.14 30.34 30.80 31.53Under Armou
r39.30 37.45 36.55 37.27 37.55
Puma 38.02 37.65 42.70 42.97 40.82Adidas
/Reebo
k41.23 40.54 42.36 41.87 42.57
ORGANIZATIONAL FIT & PERFORMANCEFINANCIAL ANALYSIS
Liquidity ratios, such as the Quick and Current ratio, provide a look into a firm’s ability to pay off its short-term debt obligations. The higher the liquidity ratio, the larger the margin of safety from insolvency.
Key takeaway: Quick Ratio (QR) was used to eliminate significant inventory differences, as Nike carries noticeably less of its current assets in inventory (25-28%) than other key industry competitors (34-41%). Nike has remained at or near the top of its industry in terms of QR, suggesting strong management of short-term
assets and sufficient protection against bankruptcy in the short term.
2010 2011 2012 2013 20140.00
0.50
1.00
1.50
2.00
2.50
Liquidity: Quick Ratio
Nike Under Armour Puma Adidas/Reebok
Quick
Ass
ets/C
urre
nt L
iabilit
ies
Liquidity Ratio - Quick Ratio
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Nike 2.32 1.94 1.82 2.31 1.71
Under Armour 2.00 1.64 2.02 1.29 2.05
Puma 1.19 1.22 1.18 1.23 1.15
Adidas/Reebok 0.83 0.79 0.87 0.77 0.92
ORGANIZATIONAL FIT & PERFORMANCEFINANCIAL ANALYSIS
Leverage ratios provide a measure of how indebted the firm is. The Debt/Equity (D/E) ratio in particular depicts how aggressive firm’s are with financing its activities with debt, versus equity. Aggressive debt
financing can amplify shareholder returns, but can also contribute to volatile earnings.
Key takeaway: Nike’s D/E ratio is similar to other key industry competitors, and indicates Nike is no more/less aggressive with debt financing than most industry competitors (exception: Adidas). The graph
does depict Nike, and the industry, becoming more aggressive with debt financing over time.
2010 2011 2012 2013 20140
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
Leverage: Debt/Equity Ratio
Nike Under Armour Puma Adidas/Reebok
Tota
l Deb
t/Tot
al Eq
uity
Leverage - Debt-to-Equity Ratio (total debt/total equity as a %)
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Nike 47.84% 52.37% 48.97% 57.62% 71.78%
Under Armo
ur35.81% 44.50% 41.62% 49.76% 55.19%
Puma 70.71% 60.87% 58.99% 55.24% 59.02%
Adidas/
Reebok
129.83%
113.54%
119.96%
111.48%
120.91%
ORGANIZATIONAL FIT & PERFORMANCEFINANCIAL ANALYSIS
Profitability ratios such as ROE and ROA provide a metric to analyze a firm’s ability to generate earnings relative to various balance sheet accounts. ROA gives an idea of how efficient
management is at using assets to generate income, with a higher ROA implying more effective use of assets.
Key takeaway: While Under Armour is setting the industry standard, Nike is right behind, exhibiting strong and consistent returns on assets compared to industry firms.
2010 2011 2012 2013 201402468
101214161820
Profitability: Return on Assets (ROA)
Nike Under Armour Puma Adidas/Reebok
NI a
s a %
of A
sset
s
Profitability - ROA (%)2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Nike 13.78 14.5 14.55 15.04 14.89Under Armo
ur15.27 17.1 17.67 17.36 17.31
Puma 9.23 9.3 2.75 0.22 2.64Adida
s/Reebo
k5.82 6.1 4.56 6.77 4.08
REFERENCES"1.3 About Nike Inc - NIKE, Inc." 1.3 About Nike Inc - NIKE, Inc. N.p., n.d. Web. 4 Apr. 2015.Barbara, Brenner. Inside the NIKE Matrix * (n.d.): n. pag. Jörn Ambos and Bodo B. Schlegelmilch, The New Role of Regional Management , 2010, Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan, 2010. Web. 2015.Brown, Melanie. "“It’s Not About the Shoes”: How Nike’s Advertising Crosses Borders and Transcends Nationality." Melanie Brown, 19 June 2011. Web. 14 Apr. 2015.Chiles, Todd. "Management 4970 - Strategic Management." Columbia, January 2015. 11. 05 April 2015.Farfan, Barbara. "Company Mission Statements." About Money. N.p., n.d. Web. 3 Apr. 2015.Hill, Charles, and Gareth Jones. Strategic Management: An Integrated Approach. N.p.: Cengage Learning, n.d. Cengage Learning, 27 Oct. 2007. Web. 14 Apr. 2015.Jackson, Lisa. "How Nike Drives Innovation & Change." Corporate Culture Pros. N.p., 03 June 2013. Web. 15 Apr. 2015.Jay, Mary Lou. "Nike, Inc.: High Profile Brand, High Expectations." January 2015. ServiceChannel. 14 April 2015. <http://corp.servicechannel.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/PRSM-JanFeb2015-Nike-High-Profile-Brand-High-Expectations-1.pdf>.Kollegian, Les. Nike's 11 Maxims. 22 June 2010. 14 April 2015. <http://www.jacobtyler.com/nikes-11-maxims/>.Loth, RIchard. Profitability Indicator Ratios. n.d. 12 April 2015. <http://www.investopedia.com/university/ratios/profitability-indicator/>.Mergent Online. n.d. 9 April 2015. <http://www.mergentonline.com/login.php>.“Nike. Corporate Social Responsibility.” Workers and Factories. Overview - NIKE, Inc. N.p., n.d. Web. 10 Apr. 2015. http://www.nikebiz.com/crreport/content/workers-and-factories/3-1-0-overview.php?cat=overviewNike Inc FInancial Statements. n.d. 09 April 2015. <http://financials.morningstar.com/balance-sheet/bs.html?t=NKE>"Nike Makers." Nike Makers. N.p., n.d. Web. 15 Apr. 2015.Nisen, Max. "At Nike, Workers Quote The Company's Maxims Like The Ten Commandments." Business Insider (2013)."Nike Sustainability Timeline." Nike Sustainability Timeline. N.p., n.d. Web. 15 Apr. 2015.Pradhan, Phoebe. "Nike Strives to Overcome Sweatshop Abuse - The Borgen Project." The Borgen Project. N.p., 15 Feb. 2014. Web. 10 Apr. 2015. http://borgenproject.org/nike-strives-to-overcome-sweatshop-abuse/Riper, Tom V. "Nike Risks Millions Going All In With McIlroy." Forbes. Forbes Magazine, 15 Jan. 2013. Web. 7 Apr. 2015. http://www.forbes.com/sites/tomvanriper/2013/01/15/nike-risks-millions-going-all-in-with-mcilroy/"The Secret To Brand Loyalty We Can All Learn From Nike." Social Media Agency Social Control. N.p., 07 Jan. 2015. Web. 6 Apr. 2015. http://socialcontrol.com/the-secret-to-brand-loyalty-we-can-all-learn-from-nike/Vogel, Lorrie. "Nike's Gameplan for Growth that's Good for All." 11 May 2012. Management Innovation eXchange. 14 April 2015. <http://www.managementexchange.com/story/nike%E2%80%99s-gameplan-growth-that%E2%80%99s-good-all>.Wharton Research Data Services. n.d. Wharton University of Pennsylvania. online database. 8 April 2015. <https://wrds-web.wharton.upenn.edu/wrds/ds/finstate/indexqtr.cfm>."Working at NIKE." Glassdoor. N.p., n.d. Web. 7 Apr. 2015. http://www.glassdoor.com/Overview/Working-at-NIKE-EI_IE1699.11,15.htm