New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350...

31
1 3M Abrasive Systems Division © 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved. New Grain Development Precision Shaped Grains (PSG) High Performance Grinding

Transcript of New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350...

Page 1: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

1

3M Abrasive Systems Division

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.

New Grain Development

Precision Shaped Grains (PSG)

High Performance Grinding

Page 2: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

2

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Definition of Grinding

German DIN Standard 8580

Grinding = Machining with geometrically undefined

cutting edges

Milling / Turning = Machining with geometrically

defined cutting edges

Page 3: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

3

3M Abrasive Systems Division

3M™ Cubitron™ II (made of Precision Shaped Grain) DIN definition of grinding is no longer valid! New = Grinding can be machining with geometrically defined cutting edges

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.

Page 4: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

4

3M Abrasive Systems Division

3M™ Cubitron™ II Wheel Structure (PSG Grain)

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.

Page 5: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

5

3M Abrasive Systems Division

3M™ Cubitron™ II Wheel Structure

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.

Standard Ceramic Wheel Structure

(3M™ Ceramic Abrasive Grain 321)

3M™ CubitronTM II Wheel Structure with PSG

Page 6: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

6

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Cutting Behavior of Conventional Abrasive Grains

Page 7: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

7

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Chip Formation with 3M™ Precision Shaped Grain

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.

Idealized image

Page 8: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

8

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Flowing Chips

Grinding swarf that looks like the chips generated by turning or

milling operations.

Page 9: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

9

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Chips generated with a 3M™ Cubitron™ II Wheel

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.

Page 10: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

10

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Grinding Parameters for Single Rib Gear Grinding with PSG

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.

• Surface speed vc (m/s)

• Feed-rate vw (mm/min)

• Speed ratio (wheel – workpiece) qs

• Dressing: Overlap ratio ud

• Specific material removal rate (Q-prime) Q‘w

(mm3/mm/sec)

• Specific chip volume V‘w (mm3/mm)

Page 11: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

11

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Surface speed vc

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.

Hardened steel: 30 m/s

Quenched and tempered steel : 35 m/s

Page 12: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

12

3M Abrasive Systems Division

High Feed-rates Vw Reduce Risk of Burning

Standard Machines: vw = 3,500 mm/min, new machines ≥12,000 mm/min

Source: Höfler Maschinenbau

Increase of performance by increasing feed-rate Vw

Burning

Page 13: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

13

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Speed Ratio qs for Different Grinding Processes

- Creep-feed grinding

- Reciprocal grinding Cylindrical grinding

Single rib

gear grinding

Page 14: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

14

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Range of Speed Ratios qs

Gear Grinding

Page 15: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

15

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Feed-rate Vw and Speed Ratio qs

High speed ratio qs at feed-rate vw 3,500 mm/min = risk of burning!

Low speed ratio qs at feed-rate vw 12,000 mm/min = low risk of burning!

Page 16: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

16

3M Abrasive Systems Division

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.

Idealized image

Dressing Behavior: 3M™ Ceramic Abrasive Grain 321 versus 3M™ CubitronTM II

Page 17: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

17

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Dressing Strategy

For roughing:

Overlap ratio ud = 1, synchronous 0.6

For finishing:

Overlap ratio ud = 4 to 6, asynchronous – 0.6 to – 0.8

Dressing interval compared to 3M Ceramic Abrasive Grain 321

Rule of thumb: 2 x fewer dressing cycles, at ½ dressing depth

Page 18: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

18

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Specific Material Removal Rate (Q-Prime) Q‘w Q’w as a benchmark

Material removal in mm3 per mm

wheel width per second

Page 19: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

19

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Q’w Values Single Rib Grinding with 3M™ CubitronTM II

PSG PSG

Hardened: 24 – 30 20 – 24

Tempered: 20 – 24 16 – 20

Page 20: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

20

3M Abrasive Systems Division

V’w (Specific Chip Volume in mm3/mm)

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.

This value refers to the volume of material removed

mm3 per mm wheel width until the wheel has to be

dressed again.

In other words: it is a factor of the process

economics.

The higher this factor, the more economic is the

grinding process.

Page 21: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

21

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Formula for the Specific Chip Volume V’w

Spur Gear Helical Gear

ae = total radial infeed (mm)

v’w = material removal per mm wheel width (mm3/mm)

zb = face width of gear (mm)

z = Number of teeth until redress (number)

Page 22: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

22

3M Abrasive Systems Division

V’w Values Single Rib Grinding with 3M™ CubitronTM II PSG Roughing 3,000 – 5,000 mm3/mm Finishing 300 – 700 mm3/mm PSG Roughing 2,000 – 4,000 mm3/mm Finishing 300 – 500 mm3/mm

Page 23: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

23

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Advantages of High Chip Volume Values V’w

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.

- Lower wheel wear (longer wheel life)

- Higher gearing quality

- Possible to grind all teeth

in one dressing cycle

Page 24: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

24

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Economic and Quality Benefits of 3M™ Precision Shaped Grain

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.

• No grinding burn if used properly

• More uniform surface finish

• Half of standard production time

• Half of dressing amounts

• Half the number of dressing cycles

Page 25: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

25

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Case History: Grinding from Solid

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.

Gear Data

Material: 30CrNiMo6, soft state

Module 14, number of teeth z 123

Face width zb 400 mm

Helix angle b 6.6642

PSG 3M™ Cubitron™ II wheel

Machine power 37 kW

Feed-rate vw: 600 mm/min

Infeed ae: 4.5 mm

Material removal rate Q’w: 45 mm³/mm/s

Chip volume V’w: 5,000 mm³/mm

Page 26: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

26

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Case History: Internal Gear

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.

Gear Data

Material: 30CrNiMo6, soft state

Modul 16, number of teeth z 89

Face width zb 293 mm

Helix angle b 8.25

PSG 3M™ Cubitron™ II wheel

Machine power: 50 kW

Feed-rate vw: 4,000, 2,000, 1,000 mm/min

Infeed ae: 0.54, 0.12, 0.05 mm

Material removal rate Q’w: 30 mm³/mm/s (roughing)

Chip volume V’w: 4,000 (roughing), 1,600 mm³/mm

Surface finish Rz: 4 mm

Page 27: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

27

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Case History: Planet Gear

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.

Gear Data

Material: 18CrNiMo7-6 hardened 58 HRc

Modul 16, Number of teeth z 34

Face width zb 380 mm

Helix angle b 7.5

PSG 3M™ Cubitron™ II wheel

Machine power: 24 kW, 95% spindle load

Feed-rate vw: 12,000, 2,500, 2,000 mm/min

Infeed ae: 0.15, 0.06, 0.04 mm

Material removal rate Q’w: 30 mm³/mm/s (roughing)

Chip volume V’w: 2,000 (finishing), 400 mm³/mm

Surface finish Ra: < 0.4 mm

Page 28: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

28

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Case History: Planet Gear

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.

Gear Data

Material: 18CrNiMo7-6 hardened, 58 HRc

Module 3.5, Number of teeth z 35

Face width zb 72 mm

Helix angle b 0

PSG 3M™ Cubitron™ II wheel

Machine power: 24 kW, 40% spindle load

Feed-rate vw: 12,000, 3,000, 2,500 mm/min

Infeed ae: 0.12, 0.06, 0.04 mm

Material removal rate Q’w: 28 mm³/mm/s (roughing)

Chip volume V’w: 1800 (roughing), 400 mm³/mm

Surface finish Ra: < 0.4 mm

Page 29: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

29

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Q max = mm3/s

Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s

Q max = (ae max * hev*nss*g*fz max) / (cos b / 30)

ae max: max. depth of cut per flank and per stroke (mm)

hev: ground height of profile (mm)

nss: rpm of threaded wheel

g: Number of starts on threaded wheel

fz max: max. axial feed rate in mm/rev.

cos b: cosine of helix angle

Material Removal Rate Qmax

30

45 15

0Swiss made

30

45 15

0

min.

6

9 3

0

h

Page 30: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

30

3M Abrasive Systems Division

Case History: Continous Generating Grinding

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.

Gear Data

Material: 16MnCr5, 58 to 60HRc

Module 9.0, Number of teeth z 67

Pressure angle 20

Helix angle b 10

PSG 3M™ Cubitron™ II

99DA120/60 H15VPMF901W, 2-start

Machine: Liebherr LCS 700

RPM wheel: 3520, 3520, 3520 (3 passes)

Feed-rate vw: 1.2, 1.2, 0.45 mm/rev (3 passes)

Infeed x1: 1st 0.45, 2nd 0.36, 3rd 0.30 mm

MRR Qmax: 883 mm³/mm/s (roughing)

Grinding time: reduced from 0:45:00 to 0:09:47.

Page 31: New Grain Development...29 3M Abrasive Systems Division 3Q max = mm /s Standard Ceramics: max of 350 mm3/s Q max = (a e max * h ev *n ss *g*f z max) / (cos b / 30) a e max: max. depth

31

3M Abrasive Systems Division

© 3M 2011. All Rights Reserved.