Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved....

27
Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography Patent Hatchery LLC http://us- patent.ru July 14-17, 2014, Seattle, USA

Transcript of Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved....

Page 1: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Nadya Reingand, PhD

Yan Hankin, Esq.

Washington DC, USA

© Copyright. All rights reserved.

Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography

Patent Hatchery LLC

http://us-patent.ru

July 14-17, 2014, Seattle, USA

Page 2: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Patent Hatchery Company

Page 3: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Intellectual Property Protection

Registered IP (most common)

PatentsTrademarksCopyrights

Other types of IPTrade secrets

IP rights give the owner a right to exclude others from making, using, offering for sale or selling the

invention

Utility patentsDesign patents

Page 4: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Invention: from idea to business success

patent licensing

acquisition

Company revenue

Page 5: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Role of patenting

patenting

Two options:Licensing IP via Office of Technology TransferCreating a start-up and starting business yourself

In both cases patenting is a key element of achieving revenue

“Up to 75% of the company value is in its intellectual

property”

Page 6: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Early publicationT. S. Huang, "Digital Holography," Proc. IEEE

59(9), 1335-1346 (1971) {Leonid Yaroslavsky, in his book, "Introduction to Digital Holography“}

Scanned hologram

Optical reconstruction

Computer reconstruction

Page 7: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

You searched for: ((digital) AND holography)

IEEE Explorer 751Google Scholar 54,300

Page 8: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Digital Holography @ Google Scholar

Page 9: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Early days: 1968 patent on digital recording and the reconstruction of optical waves

U.S. Patent No. 3,606,515, invented by Hirsch et al. originally assigned to IBM Corporation

Page 10: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.
Page 11: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Continuity data

In the patent:

Page 12: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

National application– PCT- US patent

Page 13: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Assignee #1 Daewoo Electronics

Page 14: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Assignees: 2 - 20

Page 15: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Patenting in digital holography: continents

Page 16: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Patent protection is territorial

If you file patent application in one country, It is NOT protected in other countries Nobody in other country can get a patent for the invention which copies your

patented in your country invention

BUT Anyone can produce and sell your invention in other country, for example, for US

patented product it is legal to manufacture it in China, sell in Germany

IF THE INVENTION NEEDS TO BE PROTECTED WORLDWIDE, IT HAS TO BE FILED IN ALL COUNTRIES OF INTEREST

Page 17: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

International patent application

serves to coordinate efforts on filing,

searching and the examination

of patent applications does not grant international patents.

142 countries are in PCT

After the PCT examination:• inventors can see the examination report, and • make a conscious decision on filing or not filing patents in a number of countries • the patent rights are granted by national offices

Entering national stage

PCT (Patent Cooperation Treaty) is an agreement for international cooperation in the

field of patents

Page 18: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Patenting in digital holography: countries

Page 19: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.
Page 20: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Largest owners of patents in the "microscopy" category of digital holography

Page 21: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

21

World intellectual property organization

• is a specialized agency of the United Nations• dedicated to developing a balanced international intellectual property (IP) system

Remember that WO patent documents are

patent applications

Patents: WIPO PCT Publications

start with letters WO

Page 22: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Once again about timing and sequences

Generally:

Sometimes:

Almost never

National patent filing

PCT patent filing

National patent filing

Other country patent filing

PCT patent filing

National patent filing

Other country patent filing

National patent filing

National patent filing

Page 23: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Patent filing in foreign countries Working with licensed practitioner in each country Paying annuity fees ($100-$500) in each country Some countries have PPH program with USA In some countries – IP rights enforcement is problematic

Patents of different countries

Page 24: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

U.S.Patent Office encourages PPH patent filings

Patent Prosecution Highway Program: Allowed in the foreign country -> allowed in USA

Allowance of PPH

application is much

higher

Page 25: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Intellectual Property ownership

IP ownership

1. Typically the employer owns IP ; Employee agreement IP assignment

2. Joint ownership of the intellectual property joint ownership means that each owner has independent right to exploit

the intellectual property

If IP is owned by two companies, can one of them sell IP without asking permission of the other side?

Yes, both own 100%

Page 26: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

Nathan Myhrvold formerly Chief Technology Officer at Microsoft, is co-founder of IV

Patents as assets

Page 27: Nadya Reingand, PhD Yan Hankin, Esq. Washington DC, USA © Copyright. All rights reserved. Intellectual Property and Business Aspects of Digital Holography.

ConclusionsPatents:TrademarksCopyrightPrior art search (next)

Thank you for your attention

[email protected]