METHODOLOGICAL ISSUES IN METHODOLOGICAL ISSUES IN AGRICULTURAL DATA AGRICULTURAL DATA

GENERATION / COLLECTIONGENERATION / COLLECTION

Dr. G. N. Amahia

Department of Statistics

University of Agriculture, Abeokuta, Nigeria

OUTLINEOUTLINE

Introduction

Basic Concepts

Methodological Issues

INTRODUCTIONINTRODUCTION

In African economies, over of the

Population engage in agricultural activities.

Ability to support the African populace largely depends on the success of the agricultural sector, requiring strategic planning which leans on AGRICULTURAL STATISTICS

Role of Agricultural StatisticsRole of Agricultural Statistics

Note:

Agricultural statistics are important when studied independently and also when they are studied in relation to the other sectors of the economy.

BASIC CONCEPTSBASIC CONCEPTS An insight into the basic agricultural structure of a country

can be obtained by breaking down the total area of the

country according to land utilization.

The broad categories of land utilization are arable land

(normally used for growing rotation crops), land under permanent crops, land under woods and forests, and all other land such as built-up areas, roads, parks, etc.

The total arable land can be further broken down as land under major crops, under market and kitchen gardens, temporary fallow (left idle for a brief period to recoup before cultivation starts again), and all other arable land.

The category of land under major crops includes crops such as millet, guinea corn, groundnut, beans, yam and cotton.

BASIC CONCEPTS (contd)BASIC CONCEPTS (contd) Another useful breakdown of the total area is by tenure.

The important categories are area owned by the holder

(who operates the land) or held in owner like possession,

area rented from others, area operated on a squatter basis,

and area under tribal or communal tenure form.

A further useful indicator of the efficiency of production is the fragmentation of agricultural holdings (a holding is all land operated by a single person).

METHODOLOGICAL ISSUESMETHODOLOGICAL ISSUES Methodological issues in agricultural data collection

seek to identify principles about data collection that are

linked to the cost and quality of data that promote precise

estimates of parameters.

METHODOLOGICAL ISSUES (contd)METHODOLOGICAL ISSUES (contd)

The various problems encountered when contemplating conducting an agricultural survey are in nature

conceptual definitional

relating to the concepts employed in collecting the data

practical

In dealing with conceptual problems, substantial adjustments had to be made by the Food and Agricultural Organisation (FAO) in 1969 to adapt the programme for the 1960 World Census of Agriculture to the special pattern of agriculture and social conditions prevalent in Africa.

Egero (1973), noted that household data on agricultural Egero (1973), noted that household data on agricultural activities proved quite difficult to interpret, partly due to activities proved quite difficult to interpret, partly due to

the uncertainties resulting from how polygamous the uncertainties resulting from how polygamous

households had been treated, but mainly related to households had been treated, but mainly related to

problems in the translation. problems in the translation.

He observed that what was called “main” and “secondary” He observed that what was called “main” and “secondary” agricultural produce was never really clear. agricultural produce was never really clear.

Koley (1973) remarked that the data of economically

active women were extremely unreliable due to the confusion arising from the definition of economic

activity and hence uniformity in definition could not be maintained.

While he noted that the number of employees for both males and females may be regarded as reliable, he remarked that a lot of confusion arose in classifying people, particularly women, into own-account or family workers.

But it was noted also that among economically active males, agriculture was by far the most predominant occupation, keeping 85% of the population engaged.

To solve the problems noted by Koley, an African To solve the problems noted by Koley, an African programme is suggestedprogramme is suggested

1. The African programme should provide alternative

items in the questionnaire, namely:

Agricultural occupation, and Agricultural and other occupation

2. In order to compare the output of such holdings with those under the continuous supervision of the holder, the required programme suggested that the

information should be classified as follows:

Holdings under the continuous supervision of the holder, and Holdings where the holder worked away from the holding

during a continuous part of the year.

3. in order to assess the progress of the work undertaken in agriculture, the required programme required

separate information on:

Holdings operated under a definite plan, and Holdings operated under the traditional system.

4. To solve issues in data collection, the African programme added two questions:

“Does the holding consist of communal grazing land?” “If not, has it access to communal grazing land?”

5. The compromise solution adopted in the African programme was to subdivide land under temporary crops (as well as land under permanent crops) into:

Land exclusively under temporary/permanent crops, and Land mainly under temporary/permanent crops.

6. In addition to the total area under production, the African programme proposed that, in the case of mixed and associated crops, the following areas should be reported under individual crops.

Area of the crop grown as a single crop, and Area of the crop grown as an associated crop.

Limitations of World Programme in the African Limitations of World Programme in the African ContextContext

1. The major change with regard to the farm population was the adoption of the concept of household to the African

conditions.

2. The criteria also do not apply in cases where the fields away from the village are operated by the members of

the household, living in small camps near the field for the crop seasons, or even for the whole year in the case

of permanent crops.

Accordingly, the household for the purposes of enumerating the farm population was defined as the aggregate of persons generally bound by the ties of kinship, who normally reside together, not necessarily under the same roof.

Challenge for the Survey MethodologistChallenge for the Survey Methodologist

1. To figure out how to balance the investments in each of the components of a survey to maximize the value of

the data that will result.

2. To decide which of a set of imperfect options is best.

3. To consider the various ways that the options will affect the quality of the resulting data and choose the one that, on balance, will produce the most valuable data.

CONCLUSIONCONCLUSION

Survey methodology is about having the knowledge to make these tradeoff decisions appropriately, with as much understanding as possible of the implications of the decisions.

When a practical experienced methodologist makes these decisions, it is with a total survey error perspective, considering all the implications of decisions that are at stake and how they will affect the final results.

ReferencesReferences

Egero, B. (1973). Non-sampling errors, in Egero, B. and Hanin, R. A. (1973)

Koley, C. (1973). Agricultural data, in Egero, B. and Hanin, R. A. (1973)