Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality...

54
March 14, 2018 Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated

Transcript of Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality...

Page 1: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

March 14, 2018

Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated

Page 2: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Agenda

Emily PlagmanProject ManagerPublic Library Association

Welcome & Intro

Why measure outcomes

Project Outcome toolkit

From-the-Field: Sacramento

Measuring Libraries Illuminated

Tips for Getting Started

Q&A

Page 3: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

What kind of programming are you planning for Libraries Illuminated?

Please share in chat

Page 4: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Why Measure Outcomes

Page 5: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Demonstrating Library Value

Needs Assessment Patron Satisfaction

Outputs Outcomes

Page 6: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Measuring the Good We Do

Patron-reported changes/effects/impacts programs are having in/on…KnowledgeSkillsAttitudesOpinionsBehaviorsActions Status

Page 7: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

What kind of outcome data would help demonstrate the value of Libraries

Illuminated?

Learning gained about virtual reality

Technology facilitates increased confidence about use of a new language

Increased use of coding skills used for professional or school purposes

Awareness of additional technology available at the library

Page 8: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

But, How?

PLA’s got your back!

Page 9: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Project Outcome Goal

Outcome measurement becomes “business as usual” for public libraries

Supply standardized outcome measures that any library can use and learn from

Provide easy-to-use tools for measuring

Offer resources to support implementation

Supply “from-the-field” cases to demonstrate usage and lessons learned

Page 10: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Project Outcome Toolkit

Page 11: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Project Outcome Toolkit

Access to:

Standardized surveys

Survey management tool

Custom data reports

Interactive data dashboards

Resources & training

From-the-field

It’s FREE!

www.ProjectOutcome.org

Page 12: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Toolkit: Standardized Outcome Measures

What did patrons like most?What can the library do to improve?

Knowledge

Confidence

Behavior Change

Awareness

Page 13: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Toolkit: Survey Management

Page 14: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Toolkit: Custom Data Reports

Page 15: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Toolkit: Data DashboardsOverview

Matrix

Detail

Page 16: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Toolkit: Resources

Getting Started Surveys Data Collection Data Analysis Taking Action Outcome

Measurement Guidelines

www.ProjectOutcome.org

Page 17: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Toolkit: From-the-Field

Page 18: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Toolkit: Becoming Business-as-UsualToolkit supports progression from registration to sustained outcome data collection & use

Page 19: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

From the Field: Sacramento Public

Library

Page 20: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

CHRISTOPHER TREWPUBL IC SERVICES SUPPORT SUPERVISOR

Page 21: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

@

Page 22: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Library Strategic Planning Approach Understanding Outcomes

Questions to Answer:

Strategic Plan Monthly service Patron Surveys Patron Surveys

measures

Page 23: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

• Job Coach In Service

• Survey Period: - September 1st - December 9th, 2016

• 14 Branches Offer Job Coach

• 16 Job Coaches

Page 24: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Job Skills Survey

Immediate Survey

Page 25: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

• Paper survey offered at completion of each job coach session

• Completely voluntary

• Completed survey placed in envelop addressed to Volunteer Services

• Envelop turned into service desk – not back to job coach

Page 26: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

• 209 sessions conducted during the survey period

• 83 surveys returned – 38%

Page 27: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Survey Results: Quantitative

• 96% felt more knowledgeable about the job seeking process.

• 93% felt more confident about the job seeking process.

• 99% indicated they will use what they learned.

• 90% were more aware of library resources and services.

Page 28: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Survey Results: QualitativeWhat did you like most about the program?

• It gave me more tips to help me build a resume.

• I learned a lot about how to be presentable at a job interview.

• The job coach was very knowledgeable, helpful and friendly.

• The program provides people seeking guidance for their future, a safe place where they can get help and advice without judgment.

• I have more confidence now.

Page 29: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Survey Results: Qualitative What can the library do to better assist you?

• Offer more dates and times

• Post open library positions

• Host a job fair

• More literature on local jobs

• Provide additional technology training

• More opportunities to practice interviewing

Page 30: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Measuring Libraries Illuminated

Page 31: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Measuring Libraries Illuminated

What to measure? Libraries Illuminated programming

What not to measure? Collections, use of technology

Make it your own! Survey customization

Page 32: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Standardized Surveys Options

Page 33: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Education/Lifelong Learning Survey

1. You learned something new that is helpful

2. You feel more confident about what you just learned

3. You intend to apply what you just learned

4. You are more aware of resources and services provided by the library

What did you like the most about the programs?What could the library do to better assist you in learning more?

Page 34: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Education/Lifelong Learning Survey

Program examples include: Coding Virtual Reality STEM-activities Computer/technology classes English literacy programming Job-training or skills Tutoring/mentoring

Page 35: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Measuring Libraries Illuminated

www.ProjectOutcome.org

Page 36: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Measuring Libraries Illuminated

Page 37: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Measuring Libraries Illuminated

Begin program name with “LI:” Example – “LI: Coding for Kids”

Page 38: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Measuring Libraries Illuminated

Add your own custom intro & footer messages

Page 39: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Measuring Libraries Illuminated

Page 40: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Adding Survey Questions – CA DRAFT The library has the technology I need to do things.

The library has technology that I can’t access elsewhere.

I use technology in the library to... Checklist: Research, find information, do homework, communicate with others, create things, play, learn, other? Please check all that apply.

Other technology I would like to see in the library is... (Open)

The library is relevant to me.

I intend to return to the library.

California libraries have the technology to deliver information and services in the ways their communities expect and need.

Page 41: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Measuring Libraries Illuminated

Page 42: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Measuring Libraries Illuminated

Page 43: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Measuring Libraries Illuminated

Page 44: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Measuring Libraries Illuminated

Aggregate Libraries Illuminated results in report builder

Page 45: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Using Data to Take Action

95% Learned something new About using virtual reality technology

92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English

87% Intend to use what they learned Application of coding for a job task

75% Are more aware of library resources Patrons are more aware of other technology-related

programs

Page 46: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Using Data to Take Action

State-level staff: Aggregate data across all libraries To communicate the value of Libraries

Illuminated Use data to advocate for new support Future program planning purposes

Page 47: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Tips for Getting Started

Page 48: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Tips for Libraries

Page 49: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Identify Needs

What do you hope to do with what you learn?Programming changesCommunication/AdvocacyFundingStrategic planningPartnerships

Page 50: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Measure Outcomes

Prepare ahead of time: Use paper survey Print survey ahead of time Anonymous drop box Explain the WHY Allow time for responses

Page 51: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Review Results

o Read through paper responseso Recruit a volunteer to help with data entryo A little bit of data can say a lot

Page 52: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Take Action

Target one key activityProgramming changesCommunication/AdvocacyFundingStrategic planningPartnerships

Take Action!

Page 53: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Ready, Set, Measure!

Register for FREE at www.projectoutcome.org

Tutorial videos to help you get started

Case studies to learn more about how libraries are using their data to take action

Follow us on social media

#ProjectOutcome www.projectoutcome.org

Page 54: Measuring Outcomes & Libraries Illuminated · 3/14/2018  · About using virtual reality technology. 92% Increased their confidence Using ESL programming to learn English. 87% Intend

Questions?