law Alumni Journal

Editor: Barbara Kron Zimmerman, '56*

Associate Editor: James D. Evans, Jr.

Design Consultant: Lou Day

Alumni Advisory Committee: Robert V. Massey, '31 J. Barton Harrison, '56

The COVER shows an original William Penn deed to a tract of Pennsylvania land dated August 2,1681 which was acquired by the Biddle Law Library in 1963. The conveyance is on the original vellum and bears Penn's signature. The deed augments the library's important collection of early American deeds and provides an interesting example of a seventeenth century local conveyance. It is the only such deed owned by a University of Pennsylvania library.

*Editor's Note:

As I am resigning effective next issue, I want to thank all who have cooperated so wholeheartedly with me in getting this new publication started.

PICTURE CREDITS

page 1 Harris & Ewing

page 3 USIS Bogota

page 19 (top) Walter Holt

page 19 (bottom) 20 Frank Ross

B.K.Z.

page 22

page 23

James D. Evans, Jr.

Merlin Studios

The Law Alumni Journal is published three times a year by the Law Alumni Society of the University of Pennsylvania for the information of its members.

Please address: all communications and manuscripts to:

The Editor Law Alumni Journal University of Pennsylvania

Law School Thirty-fourth and Chestnut Streets Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104

Printed at the University of Pennsylvania Printing Office.

'law Alumni Journal VOLUME II NUMBER 1 FALL 1966

TABLE OF CONTENTS

THE STATUS OF INTERNATIONAL JUDICIAL ASSISTANCE IN THE UNITED STATES

by Philip Werner Amram, '27

PROFESSOR OLIVER RETURNS FROM AMBASSADORIAL POST

FACULTY NOTES

Amsterdam Commended in Supreme Court Opinion

Dean Fordham Chairman of New A.B.A. Section Professors Lead Seminars on Rights of the Poor Wolfman Appointed General Counsel

3

4

Goodman to Clerk for U.S. Supreme Court Justice 4

LAW SCHOOL ALUMNI ANNUAL GIVING-FINAL REPORT 1965-1966 5

Annual Giving for 1966-1967 Launched 19

Gowen Fellows Study Here and Abroad 19

Students from Broader Geographic Area 19

Historic Antique Desk in Law School

Walter Alessandroni Fund Started

Law School to Be Host for Trial Judges College

Alumni Play Key Roles in New Legal Program

Schwartz Authority for Word Usage

CONFERENCE ON MUTUAL FUNDS PLANNED FOR FEBRUARY

ALUMNI NOTES

20

20

20

20

20

21

22

THE STATUS OF INTERNATIONAL JUDICIAL ASSISTANCE IN THE UNITED STATES

As the result of the enormous increase in the foreign intercourse of the United States since the end of World War II, with nearly a million Americans living abroad and with many billions of dollars annually in our export-import trade, international private litigation has reached a high level of importance. The field of international judicial assistance, or international judicial cooperation as it is sometimes called, has reached a parallel importance.

The names international judicial assistance and international judicial cooperation are, in part, misnomers. The title usually includes four topics-(1) the service of documents in a foreign country in aid of domestic litigation; (2) the taking of testimony and the production of evidence in a foreign country in aid of domestic litigation; (3) proof in the forum of foreign official documents ; and ( 4) the proof in the forum of foreign law. Although these are often lumped together, e.g. in the Act of Congress P. L. 85-906, which created the Commission and Advisory Committee on International Rules of Judicial Procedure, two of them present problems quite different from the other two.

In the first two, the service of documents and the taking of evidence abroad, a formal judicial act must take place in the foreign country and permission, under that country's laws, may have to be secured. These two activities are often treated as part of the judicial sovereignty of each country, and many countries claim the sovereign right to decide how much permission they will give to strangers to perform these acts on their territory without authorization and the cooperation of their judicial officers. The point of view varies from the utmost freedom, e.g. the United States under P. L. 88-619 of October 4, 1964, to almost complete prohibition, e.g. Switzerland.

These two activities therefore may require the positive assistance or cooperation of the judicial agencies of a foreign country, by providing the facilities of their courts and officers to serve the documents or summon the witnesses and produce the evidence that is requested. In such cases, the courts and functionaries of the foreign country become directly involved in the conduct of litigation which is pending in another country. Here there is truly cooperation with, and assistance to, one judicial organ by another judicial organ.

In the case of the latter two items, the proof of foreign official documents and the proof of foreign law, the situation is quite different. No judicial act takes place in a foreign territory which can have any impact on its judicial sovereignty. The problem is rather how to comply with the rules of evidence of the forum where

Fall 1966

by Philip Werner Amram, '27

the action is pending, and how certain matters are to be proven there. With respect to official documents, the question is whether the party at the forum, who wants to introduce the document in evidence at the trial, can secure a copy from the official custodian abroad so certified or authenticated as to meet the requirements of authenticity and admissibility of the rules of evidence of the forum. If the foreign custodian will not, or cannot, produce a copy so certified or authenticated the proponent of the document will be stymied at the trial. Here the problem of assistance or cooperation is whether the laws of the place of the document will permit the custodian to provide a certification or authentication to meet the requirements of another country, even though those requirements are different from those of his own country. If this cannot be done, there is not much left except to liberalize the rules of evidence of the forum so as to permit the introduction of the document, with appropriate safeguards, if the proponent has gotten from the custodian the best that is available, for example such a certification or authentication as is acceptable in the courts of the country where the document lies.

Finally, as to the proof of foreign law, the situation is even farther removed. Here there is nothing but a question of the domestic evidence law of the forum; -how do you prove the law of another country? The only thing that can possibly be asked from the foreign sovereign is to provide a free, or paid, advisory service, which will give legal opinions on its law for the use of litigants in foreign litigation. But the normal practice is to prove foreign law by books, articles and commentaries, which are introduced into evidence or referred to in briefs or by the testimony of expert witnesses either

We are privileged to publish the accompanying article by Mr. Amram, an illustrious alumnus who is Chairman of the Advisory Committee to the United States Commission on International Rules of Judicial Procedure.

1

in depositions or affidavits or by testimony at the trial. All four problems have a reciprocal character.

From the point of view of the United States, for example, it is just as important to decide what assistance and cooperation we will furnish to foreign courts and litigants as it is to decide what assistance and cooperation we want abroad in aid of our courts and litigants. The more we offer, the more we can justifiably ask; the less we offer, the more difficult it becomes for us to ask generous help from others.

When the Congress passed P. L. 85-906 in September, 1958, and created the Commission and Advisory Committee on International Rules of Judicial Procedure, this fundamental question was the first to be resolved. The decision was reached to ignore for the time being all questions of foreign techniques, all questions of foreign law and procedure, and all efforts to negotiate international agreements or treaties. Before any approach was made to others, the United States would first put its own house in order and provide the world's most modem and generous open system of assistance to others, wholly unilaterally and without any requirements of reciprocity by others. Then, with this model in existence, the United States could justifiably ask some or all foreign countries for similar grants of assistance and cooperation in connection with litigation pending in this country.

This project took until 1966 to complete and its success is unparalleled. We now have a system unmatched anywhere for the grant to others of cooperation and assistance. The system is contained in the Act of Congress, P. L. 88-619 and 28 U.S.C. §§1696, 1781 and 1782; in the amended Federal Rules of Civil Procedure Nos. 4 (i) and 28 (b), effective July 1, 1963 and Rules 44 and 44.1, effective July 1, 1966; and in the amended Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure No. 26.1, effective July 1, 1966. Act No. 88-619 and the amended Rules of July 1, 1966 do more than merely provide the procedures for cooperation and assistance to others; they also modernize and improve our domestic procedures in many respects. But for the purpose of this paper, I will deal only with the former and will put the latter to one side.

The purpose and intent of the Act are emphasized in the legislative history (printed in U. S. Code Congressional and Administrative News, 88th Congress, page 3 7 82). Both House and Senate Reports state, in unequivocal terms, the specific effects of the Act and the basic principles of international judicial assistance behind it. The effect of the Act may be summarized as follows:

2

( 1) Documents in connection with foreign litigation may be freely served in the United States by anyone on anyone without the need of any permission or participation by any local authority.

(2) If the foreign litigant or tribunal wishes to have the document served in a formal manner, the federal courts are given authority to entertain requests for such service and to enter orders

for formal service by court officers. The authority of the federal courts is all-inclusive and encompasses all requests, so that assistance by state courts is no longer needed in any situation. There is a "federal" area everywhere in the United States, and there is a federal district court, a federal judge and a federal marshal with jurisdiction over every square foot of the country. The state courts, of course, remain open to receive requests for assistance to the extent that they will grant it, but it is unlikely that a foreigner would utilize them in the face of the specific statutory grant to the federal courts in the Act.

(3) Testimony of any witness anywhere in the United States may be freely taken by anyone and evidence may be produced without the need of permission or participation by any local authority.

( 4) If the foreign litigant or tribunal wishes to have the testimony taken or the evidence produced in a formal manner, or if a subpoena is needed with respect to an unwilling witness, the federal courts are given authority to enter orders for the appearance of the witness and the taking of the testimony or the production of the evidence by court officers or appointees. Here again, the authority of the federal courts is all-inclusive and geographically covers every part of the country. Here again, state courts may also be open as additional sources of assistance, but, as in the case of service of documents, it is unlikely that they will be much used.

( 5) The Department of State is given statutory authority to act as the transmitting agent for letters rogatory and letters of request emanating from abroad, to the extent that the domestic law of the foreign tribunal may require that the acts be performed in the United States pursuant to this formality. The State Department will receive the letters, transmit them to the appropriate authority in the requested geographical area and will return them to the applicant abroad when they have been fulfilled. This means that the foreign applicant may, at his option (a) perform the act himself within the United States, (b) employ a local lawyer or other unofficial agent to perform it for him, (c) apply directly to a federal court in the United States for an order of assistance, or (d) use letters rogatory or letters of request through the State Department channel.

Since all the foregoing is available unilaterally and without any requirement of reciprocity on the part of the foreign country, we may safely say that there is nothing more that the United States can do in this area.

A foreigner may act on his own within our territory in connection with the service of documents and the

continued on page 24

LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL

PROFESSOR OLIVER RETURNS FROM AMBASSADORIAL POST Professor Covey T . Oliver has returned to the

Law School after serving as United States Ambassador to Colombia for two years. Congressman Bradford Morse (R.-Mass.), who was a member of the United States delegation which attended the inauguration ceremonies for the new President of Colombia, stated, "A measure of Ambassador Oliver's distinguished service in Colombia is the unprecedented tribute paid him by the retiring President of Colombia, Guillermo Leon Valencia, in his final message to the Congress of Colombia on July 20, 1966" on inserting that statement in the Congressional Record of August 15, 1966. The statement of President Valencia is as follows:

"I wish to say of the Embassy of the United States of America in Colombia that there we have always found comprehension, sympathy and help when we have gone there in search of support. I wish especially to recognize the American Ambassador to Colombia, Mr. Covey T. Oliver, as one of Colombia's best friends, not only in his role as Ambassador of the United States but also as a person who has applied his extraordinary intelligence, his vast erudition, and his splendid character, along with a thorough understanding and all good will, which make him permanently outstanding among his peers . For these reasons, I wish to state today, when I have nothing to expect from him, that he merits the admiration, the gratitude, and the affection of the Republic and its people."

Representative Morse then commented: "This is a remarkable tribute to a remarkable Ambassador."

Professor Oliver believes that his American university tie was as important a factor as his knowledge of Spanish and of Spanish culture in the success of his mission, as Colombians place a high value on intellectual attainment and culture.

Professor Oliver previously served with the Foreign Service and the Department of State from 1942 to 1949. During his recent Ambassadorship he saw the great improvement in the coordination and integration of official American field activities relating to a particular country. The situation had changed in large part because of President Kennedy's insistence that the Ambassador be the chief executive of the United States in the host country. There had also developed a "Country Team" approach on the part of the field representatives of the various United States agencies having responsibilities in foreign affairs operations.

Ambassadorial life has three major aspects. General diplomatic duty is not only hard and demanding work, but it also shatters family life. Professor Oliver was able to have dinner with his family only about twice a month. The second aspect of an ambassador's life consists of relationships with people in all walks of life in the country in which he is serving. Because of the changes noted above, the third major block of time is devoted to executive duties. Most of Professor Oliver's time in this

Fall 1966

Ambassador Oliver at his desk in Colombia.

latter sphere was concerned with different aspects of the Alliance for Progress. Soon after Professor Oliver's arrival, Colombia ran into trouble on the fiscal and monetary fronts. Professor Oliver then became heavily and successfully involved in a number of activities directed toward the adoption by Colombia of policies in this area that would permit Colombia to grow without running into serious inflation and foreign exchange difficulties.

Now that he is back, Professor Oliver intends to continue working as a private individual to help Colombia in two important areas which he believes merit immediate attention. These are improvement of higher education and modernization of the internal marketing process.

The universities in Colombia are of prime importance because they produce the decision-makers. The public universities in Colombia are the major engines of social mobility in the country. As the population is demographically young, the university trained man comes to the fore early in life. The prime targets of the efforts of international communism are the universities for these reasons. Under the present underdeveloped educational system, students are fairly amenable to the distractions the trained subverters put forward. Professor Oliver believes "substantive improvement" of university education requires a crash effort. University teaching in Latin America is rarely a full time pursuit, and the part time lecturing is for the most part not intellectually challenging or stimulating. The usual approach is historical and syllogistic. Data research is very rarely relied upon. The full range of alternatives open to free societies is not adequately presented in the various social disciplines such as law, economics, and political science. In them the student usually learns only of the alternatives of pure capitalism and Marxism. He is taught nothing of the regulatory processes of government. For example, he has no understanding of how the United States system actually works

continued on page 21

3

FACULTY NOTES

Amsterdam Commended in Supreme Court Opinion

Mr. Justice Stewart cited a noteworthy law review article written by Professor ANTHONY G. AMSTERDAM, '60, in the following complimentary way: "For a remarkably original and comprehensive discussion of the issues presented in this case ... see Amsterdam, Criminal Prosecutions Affecting Federally Guaranteed Civil Rights: Federal Removal and Habeas Corpus J urisdiction to Abort State Court Trial, 113 U. Pa. L. Rev. 793 (1965)." Georgia v Rachel, 384 U.S. 780,786, ft. note 4. (See excerpt from this article in I Law Alumni Journal 1 [1965].) "

As Professor Louis B. Schwartz pointed out in bringing this reference to the editor's attention, "It is not often that the Supreme Court throws bouquets such as were thrown-at Professor Amsterdam in this case."

Amsterdam argued and won the case of Georgia v Rachel, supra, before the Supreme Court. It establishes the proposition that when a state prosecutes somebody for behavior which defendant claims to be protected by a federal civil rights statute, the defendant is entitled to have the case removed from the state court to a federal court, where this federal defense might be viewed more sympathetically.

Professors Lead Seminars on Rights of the Poor Law School Professors have played a significant

role in making the new Community Legal Services, Inc. of Philadelphia an effective organ for securing for the poor of Philadelphia access to the law by their participation in Seminars on the Legal Rights of the Poor offered to lawyers by the Philadelphia Bar Association. Professor JAN Z. KRASNOWIECKI took part in the three seminars on problems arising under housing; Professor HowARD LESNICK participated in the three seminars on welfare, and Professor CuRTIS R. REITZ, '56, explained various aspects of consumer purchasing. Professor ROBERT H. MuNDHEIM led the seminar on employment, and Assistant Professor STEPHEN R. GoLDSTEIN, '62,

Dean Fordham Chairman of New A.B.A. Section

The House of Delegates of the American Bar Association voted without a single dissent to approve the establishment of a new Section of Individual Rights and Responsibilities at the Annual Meeting held in Montreal in August. Dean Jefferson B. Fordham, who had been chairman of the Organizing Committee, was named first Chairman of the new section. Over 1100 A.B.A. members from all parts of the country had indicated their intention to join the section.

Dean Fordham considers the creation of the new section an historic event "because the establishment of the Section is institutional recognition of the Association's concern for the highest values in our societyvalues associated with the integrity and fulfillment of the individual human personality without regard to group characteristics, and the meeting of man's responsibility as a social being." He pointed out in a statement made at the first meeting of the new section that the range of interest of the section is broad, including, as it does, concern with basic substantive rights and with rights to fair procedure upon which the safeguarding of substantive rights depends . The Section will provide a forum for discussions and also serve an educational purpose both within the profession and among the public.

Wolfman Appointed General Counsel Professor BERNARD WoLFMAN, '48 , has been ap

pointed General Counsel to the American Association of University Professors. He had previously served the Association as Chairman of the Association's Subcommittee on Taxation.

conducted the session relating to education. Professor ANTHONY G. AMSTERDAM, '60, was one of the leaders of the seminars relating to criminal questions.

FREDERICA KOLLER, '64, Assistant Professor, Wayne State Law School, also participated in the seminar devoted to questions relating to the family.

GOODMAN TO CLERK FOR U. S. SUPREME COURT JUSTICE Stephen Goodman, '64, who had been a law clerk

for Chief Judge David L. Bazelon of the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia, has been selected by Supreme Court Justice William J. Brennan, Jr., as one of his law clerks for the current year.

Recently the trend has been for more graduates to clerk for judges upon graduation, and about one-eighth of the Class of 1966 is clerking in various federal , state, and local courts. Four of these graduates are with judges on the United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, and two are with judges for the Fifth Circuit. Four

4

men are with Federal District Court Judges in Pennsylvania and New York, and one alumnus is serving as a clerk in the Tax Court of the United States. Three alumni are clerking for judges of the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, and one is with the Superior Court. There are also graduates clerking in the Supreme Courts of Arizona, Connecticut, and New Jersey. There are two others in the Superior Court of New Jersey.

Four men are clerking in Common Pleas courts in Pennsylvania-three in Philadelphia, and one in Chester County.

LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL

UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA

LAW SCHOOL

Alumni Annual Giving

FINAL REPORT 1965-1966

Seventeenth Annual Campaign

EDWIN HAINES 8UROI:SS

J700 HQJITH CH411lll. 5UI!U

8"-UI .. OIII:III,~AIInANO

Dean Jefferson B. Fordham The Law School University of Pennsylvania Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104

Dear Jeff:

September 16 , 1 966

I consider it an honor to be able to report to you that Law School Alumni Annual Giving has crossed the $100 , 000 . mark. The total figures moved to a new high of $102,124.64 , which surpasses last year ' s total of $87,164 . 20 by $14,960 . 44 , or an increase of 14 . 7% . Contributions were received from 1920 Law Al umni th i s year compared to 1860 last year , or an increase of 3.4%. The per cent participation moved up one point on the scale to 43% , which is also our highest level.

From past knowledge and experience, it is realized by the Alumni that annual giving proceeds are essential to continuing and furthering the excellence of the legal educati on the Law School is now providi ng . The support given this year proves once again the strength and enthusiasm of the Alumni for the program and faculty of the Law School under effective leadership .

On behalf of my associated chairmen and all who worked on the campaign , I wish to extend best wishes for future successes to you and your colleagues.

Sincerely,

~ jcr. General Chairman

Law School Alumni Annual Giving

Fall 1966

UN IVERSITY of PENNSYLVANIA PHILADELPHIA 4

T he Law School

OF~ ICE OF TH£ D EAN

Edwin H. Burgess , Esquire 3700 Nor t h Charles Street Baltimore , Maryland 21 218

Dear Ed:

Sept ember 17, 19 66

I was de lighted t o r eceive your report a s Genera l Chairman on the r esults of the 1 96 5-66 La\<1 Sc hool Alumni Annual Giving Campaign. You and yo u r co-work ers h ave done a tremendous job in achieving t he new h i gh of $102,12 4. 6 4 in Annu a l Gi v i ng . Expr essed i n t e rms o f endowment with a y i eld of f i ve per centum , t h i s ma t ches over $2, 000 ,000 i n capi tal funds .

We he r e a t t he School deepl y appr e ciate yo u r e fforts. Without t he outs tan ding l eade r sh i p p r ovi d e d by you, Morr i s M. Wexler, Chairman fo r Benj amin Franklin As soci a t es , Loui s J. Coffman, Ch a irman fo r Cen t ury Club , Hilton B. Gar ner , Chairma n for Cl i\ss Agents , J . Pe nning t on Straus , Chai riTlan for Regi ons , the Class 1\gent s a nd the r e g iona l chairmen , t he task coul d no t have been accoMpli s hed . On behal f of a l l of us a t the School , I ext end s incer e st t hank s fo r your devot i on and high l y effective support.

JBF : rdb

5

BENJAMIN

FRANKLIN

ASSOCIATES

THE BENJAMIN FRANKLIN ASSOCIATES ARE A UNIVERSITY-WIDE GROUP OF ALUMNI AND FRIENDS WHO CONTRIBUTE ONE THOUSAND DOLLARS OR MORE TO THE ALUMNI ANNUAL GIVING FUND. LISTED ARE LAW SCHOOL ALUMNI WHO JOINED THE BENJAMIN FRANKLIN

ASSOCIATES.

Chairman for the Law School -MORRIS M. WEXLER, L'27

Edwin H. Burgess, L'14 Sylvin M. Cohen, L'38 Ralph W. Crowell, L' 15 Robert L. Dechert, L'21 L. Leroy Deininger, L'14 Meyer & Rosaline Feinstein

Foundation Robert Gray John F. Headly, L'27 J. H. Ward Hinkson, L'22 Charles M. Justi, L'27 Harold E. Kohn, L'37 Melvin G. Levy, L'50

In memory of Albert Blumberg Robert C. Liggett, L'17 Arthur Littleton, L'20 W. James Macintosh, L'26 Baldwin Maul, L'25 David F. Maxwell, L'24 John L. McDonald, L'40 J. Wesley McWilliams, L'15 Albert B. Melnik, L'27 Morton Myers, L'25 Benjamin H. Oehlert, Jr., L'33 Edmond H. Rogers, L'12 Estate of Alexis Rosenberg Maurice B. Saul, L'05 Yale Schekter, L'14 William A. Schnader, L'12 Bernard G. Segal, L'31 Harry Sherman, L'09 Morris M. Wexler, L'27

6

0 ~NTURY

EACH MEMBERSHIP IN THE CENTURY CLUB IS AWARDED IN RECOGNITION OF A CONTRIBUTION OF ONE HUNDRED DOLLARS OR MORE TO THE LAW SCHOOL ALUMNI ANNUAL GIVING FUND.

THE SUSTAINING F ELLOWS OF THE CENTURY CLUB ARE THOSE MEMBERS WHO CHOSE TO GO BEYOND THE BASIC REQUIREMENTS FOR MEMBERSHIP AND ASSISTED THE SCHOOL BY CONTRIBUTING TWO HUNDRED AND FIFTY DOLLARS OR MORE.

Chairman-Louis J. Goffman, L'35

SUSTAINING FELLOWS OF CENTURY CLUB

William B. Arnold, L'29 Mitchell Brock, L'53 Richard P. Brown, Jr., L '48 F . William Carr, L'35 Alan H. Cassman, L'49 Clive S. Cummis, L'52 John J. Dautrich, L'41 Charles H. Dorsett, L'35 Herman M. Ellis, L'28 Jefferson B. Fordham Wesley P. Frysztacki, L'41 Milton B. Garner, L'36 Robert McCall Gilkey, L' 15 Louis J . Goffman, L'35 The Late Edward Hopkinson, Jr., L'lO Edward A. Kaier, L'33 William H. Kresch, L'30

Robert L. Lingelbach, L'34 Daniel Lowenthal, L'31 Edward S. Lower, L'29 Paul Maloney, L'33 Desmond J . McTighe, L'25 David H. Nelson, L'49 Henry R. Nolte, Jr., L'49 G . Ruhland Rebmann, L'22 Lipman Redman, L'41 Theodore 0. Rogers , L'40 Marvin Schwartz, L'49 G. William Shea, L'36 Nathan C. Staller, L'36 Robert S. Trigg, L'51 Wendell E. Warner, L'24 Thomas R . White, Jr., L'36 Ira J. Williams, L'97

CENTURY CLUB MEMBERS

Alvin S. Ackerman, L'57 Arlin M. Adams, L'47 Alexander B. Adelman, L'31 Sadie T. M. Alexander, L'27 Philip W. Amram, L'27 David F . Anderson, L'33 James R. Anderson, Jr., L'31 Erich 0. Angermann, L'26 George F. B. Appel, L'27 Mrs. M. Corson Applegarth, L'41 Vincent J. Apruzzese, L'53 Harris C. Arnold, L'25 S. Samuel Arsht, L'34 William D. Balitas, L'37 Henry W. Balka, L'26 Harry Norman Ball, L'28 Frederic L. Ballard , L'42 J . William Barba, L'50 Hon . Alexander F . Barbieri, L'32 Ralph M. Barley, L'38 Max M. Batzer, L'33 Walter W. Beachboard, L'32 Robert Beckman, L'56 Thomas J. Beddow, L'39 Paul Bedford, L'OO Sanford D. Beecher, L'28 Hon. John C. Bell , Jr., L' 17 Robert K. Bell, L'24 Milton Berger, L'29 Nathan Berlant, L'51 Leonard J. Bernstein, L'34 Marshall A. Bernstein, L'49 Robert M. Bernstein, L'14 Franklin H. Berry, L'28 James E . Birdsall , L'36 Samuel A. Blank, L'32 James C . Bly, L'46 William Carson Bodine, L'32 Francis H. Bohlen , Jr. , L'21 Rodney T. Bonsall, L' 17 Bernard M. Borish, L'43 Clifford M. Bowden, L'28

John P . Bracken, L'39 Raymond J. Bradley, L'47 Floyd E. Brandow, Jr., L'54 Esther Greenberg Brandschain, L'28 Hon. Jasper Yeates Brinton, L'Ol Sol Brody, L'26 Gerald Broker, L'59 Wallace Bromley, L'IO Hon. Francis Shunk Brown, Jr., L'l6 Hon. Hazel H. Brown, L'24 John C. Bruton, Jr. , L'32 Herman Buck, L'35 Edward V. Buckley, L'24 Walter M. Burkhardt, L'l4 Harold F. Butler, L'22 J. Russell Cades, L'28 Milton Cades, GL'37 Francis J . Carey, Jr., L'49 James D. Carpenter, L'08 Meyer L. Casman, L' 17 Sidney Chait!, L'33 Keron D. Chance, L'38 E. Calvert Cheston, L'35 Morris Cheston, L'28 HeathS. Clark, L'16 Hon. JosephS. Clark, Jr. , L'26 Roderick T . Clarke, L'36 Hon. Herbert B. Cohen, L'25 Marvin Comisky, L'41 William H. Conca, L'34 John P. Connors, L'52 Charles R. Cooper, Jr. , L'47 Stuart Coven, L'51 Dorian Cowan, L'22 Cassin W. Craig, L'49F Harold Cramer, L'51

In memory of Hirsh W. Stalberg Albert J. Crawford, Jr., L'39 John Douglas Cummings, L'57 Guy W. Davis, L'27 Herman S. Davis, L'41 J. Lawrence Davis, L'28 Hon. John Morgan Davis, L'32

LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL

William R. Deasey, L'49F Daniel DeBrier, L'29 Philip Dechert, L'30 Guy G. deFuria, L'28 Joseph W. deFuria, L'35 Richard M. Dicke, L'40 Park B. Dilks, Jr. , L'51 Ralph B. D'Iorio, L'49 M. Carton Ditman, Jr. , L'38 James B. Doak, L'35 David H . W. Dohan, L'41 Hon. James H. Duff, L'07 Arthur M. Eastburn, L' 11 Robert J . Eby, L'06 William S. Eisenhart, Jr. , L'40 Hon . Harold L. Ervin, L'20 Bernard Eskin, L'35 Harold Evans, L' lO John Kennedy Ewing, III, L'27 Samuel B. Ewing, L'30 William Benner Farran, L'41 Richard J. Farrell , L'41 Albert J. Feldman, L'53 Barton E. Ferst, L'44 Joseph First, L'30 Eugene C. Fish, L'34 Joseph P. Flanagan, Jr., L'52 Peter Florey, L'50 Bernard Frank, L'38 Benjamin 0. Frick, L'05 Harry Friedman, L'27 Fred T . Fruit, L' II Carl W. Funk, L'25 John J. Galbally, L'51 Isaac S. Garb , L'56 Sylvester S. Garrett, L'36 Robert S. Gawthrop, L'39 Jacques H. Geisenberger, L'27 Morris B. Gelb, L'29 Frank H. Gelman, L'35 Kenneth W. Gemmill, L'35 Hon. Morris Gerber, L'32 Lewis M. Gill, L'36 Frederick P. Glick, L'35 Samuel A. Goldberg, L'23 Hyman Goldberg, L'37

In M emory of Ethel and Isaac Goldberg Th e Late George S. Goldstein, L'22 Joseph K. Gordon, L'51 Mortimer E. Graham, L'25 Philip R . Grant, L'50 Joseph A. Grazier, L'28 Oliver F . Green, Jr., L'51 Harry A. Greenberg, L'38 Albert M. Greenfield, L'06 Harold D. Greenwell, L'27 W. Edward Greenwood, Jr. , L'29 Hon. George W. Griffith, L'23 Miss Mary E. Groff, L'32 Bernard M. Gross, L'59 Joseph H . Grubb, Jr. , L'19 Paul I. Guest, L'41 Bernard M. Guth, L'58 John C . Hambrook, L'47 Louis S. Hankin, L'37 Perch P. Hankin , L'43 William D. Harkins, L'22 Robert A. Hauslohner, L'50 John F. Healy, L'51 Jesse G. Heiges, L'38 George K. Helbert , L'11 Estate of George M. Henry, L'04 Charles J . Hepburn, Jr., L'35 Hon. Carl J. W. Hessinger, L'40 Donald E. Hittle, L'42 Benjamin B. Hoar, L'l6 Edward B. Hodge, L'31 Abraham Hofferman, L'34 Leon C. Holt, Jr., L'51 John 0. Honnold, Jr. Hubert J. Horan, Jr., L'll William S. Hudders, L'29

Fall 1966

Richard M. Hughes, II, L'41 Daniel H. Huyett, III, L'48 Hon. William F. Hyland , L'49J Thomas M. Hyndman, L'll Joseph G. Jackson, L'29 Charles S. Jacobs, L'36 Myron Jacoby, L'31 Paul L. Jaffe, L'50 Ja,mes L. Johnson, L'33 Robert B. Johnson, L'27 Thomas M. Johnston , L'24 Edward L. Jones, Jr. , L'61 Ralph V. Jones, L'54 Vernon S. Jones, L'l6 John Pemberton Jordan, L'28 Lewis Kates, L'59 Solomon Katz, L'48 Ernest R. Keiter, L' l9 Hon. Bernard J. Kelley, L'26 Robert G . Kelly, L'36 William F. Kennedy, L'29 Lewis H . Kirk, L'15 Emanuel H . Klein , L'40 Richard H . Klein, L'24 Benjamin M. Kline, L'l6 John P. Knox, L'53 Robert C. Koury, L'41 Meyer Kramer, L'44 Otto Kraus, Jr., L'08 Herman H. Krekstein, L'22 David H . Kubert, L'32 Hon. Gregory G. Lagakos, L'38 George C. Laub, L'36 SamuelS. Laucks, Jr., L'42 Nathan Lavine, L'31 Bernard V. Lentz, L'36 Hon. Herbert S. Levin, L'3 I Louis Levinson, L' 14 Hon. Louis E. Levinthal , L'l6 Arthur Levy, L'55 Edward J . Lewis, L'62 Hon. Thomas M. Lewis, L'l6 William Barclay Lex, L'l2 Joseph H. Lieberman, L'l7 Peter P. Liebert, III, L'41 Herbert M. Linsenberg, L'51 Hon. Abraham H . Lipez, L'29 Louis Lipschitz, L'27 SamuelS. Logan, Jr., L'41 Hon . JosephS. Lord, III, L'36 Wilfred R. Lorry, L'30 David P. Loughran, L'62 Edwin A. Lucas, L'17 Hon. Alfred L. Luongo , L'47 John T. Macartney, L'49 Donald M. Maclay, L'61 Harry K. Madway, L'36 D. Arthur Magaziner, L' 14 DavidS. Malis, L'11 Richard B. Malis, L'40 Robert H. Malis, L'47 Frank H. Mancill, L'14 Otto P. Mann, L'20 Robert Margolis, L'48 Jerome L. Markowitz, L'33 Albert J. Marks, L'17 Francis E. Marshall, L'48 William B. Marshall , L'40 Thomas A. Masterson, L'52 William L. Matz, L'29 Daniel J . McCauley, Jr., L'41 Thomas McConnell , III, L'22 Jack J. McDowell, L'31 Hugh P. McFadden, L'28 Hon. Thomas C. McGrath, Jr. , L'57 William B. Mcintosh, L'l7 Leon Meltzer, L'26 Raymond W. Midgett, Jr. , L'50 Thomas P. Mikell, L'27 A. Arthur Miller, L'34 Samuel W. Morris, L'49

Emanuel Moss, L'20 John C. Mueller, L'59 Paul A. Mueller, Jr., L'55 Philip F. Newman, L'l7 Eugene A. Nogi, L'32 Leon J. Obermayer, L'08 Thomas A. O'Boyle, L'40 John J. O'Brien, L'08 Jerome A. O'Neill, L'36 Michael A. Orlando, III , L'58 Hon. Arturo Ortiz-Toro, L' 17 Isidor Ostroff, L'30 Gilbert W. Oswald, L'34 George Ovington, Jr. , L'07 George Ovington, III, L'40 Israel Packel, L'32 Charles C. Parlin, Jr., L'49 James Patterson, L'24 Hon. Harold L. Paul, L'24 Henry N. Paul, L'25 James C. Peacock, L'l2 Raymond Pearlstine, L'32 Morris Pfaelzer, II, L'38 Hon. FrankL. Pinola, L'l5 Th e Late Raymond Pitcairn, L'08 Harry Polikoff, L'31 Herman I. Pollock, L'27 Robert E. Porter, L'41 Franklin Poul, L'48 Herman B. Poul, L'38 Howard I. Powell, L'16 Ernest D. Preate, L'34 R. Stewart Rauch, Jr., L'41 W. Foster Reeve, III, L'l7 Pace Reich, L'54 George H. Reid, L'48 P. Herbert Reigner, L' 17 Paul H . Rhoads, L'31 Grover C. Richman, Jr., L'35 Victor J. Roberts, Jr., L'37 Hon. Herman M. Rodgers , L'47 Milton W. Rosen, L'41 David H. Rosenbluth, L'33 Max Rosenn, L'32 William Rowe, L'27 William M. Ruddock, L'25 W. Albert Sanders, L'31 Alex Satinsky, L'37 H. James Sautter, L'l4 Joseph H . Savitz, L'58 Hon. Harold D. Saylor, L'l7 James W. Scanlon, L'30 John N. Schaeffer, Jr., L'37 Nathan J. Schneider, L'27 Andrew J. Schroder, L'30 Lloyd J. Schumacker, L'30 Louis B. Schwartz, L'35 Emanuel G. Scoblionko, L'34 Ernest Scott, L'29 W. Frazier Scott, L'39 Irving R . Segal, L'38 David V. Shapiro, L'44 Milton H. Shapiro, L'40 W. Simms Sharninghausen, L'39 Robert M. Shay, L'61 G. William Shea, L'36 Nathan Silberstein, L'33 Charles D. Smeltzer, L'24 Alan J. Smith, L'29 Carl D. Smith, L'07 D. Hays Solis-Cohen, L'lO Elvin R. Souder, L'42 Samuel L. Sperling, L'32 Hon. Maurice W. Sporkin, L'l7 Irving Stander, L'29 Alan Steinberg, L'64 Sigmund H. Steinberg, L'24 Lee N. Steiner, L'49 Philip Sterling, L' I 0 Hon . Horace Stern, L'02 Guy K. Stewart, L'32

7

CENTURY CLUB (Continued)

Charles C. Townsend, L'27 Robert L. Trescher, L'37

J. Tyson Stokes, L'31 Eugene K. Twining, L'33 J. Pennington Strauss, L'35 Leonard Sugarman, L'55 AaronS. Swartz, Jr., L'll Hon. 0. Jacob Tallman, L'27 Leonard A. Talone, L'30

Robert W. Valimont, L'49 Frederick VanDenbergh, Jr. , L'37 Charles B. P. Van Pelt, L'49 Hon. Joseph Varbalow, L'l7 Theodore Voorhees, L'29

S. Robert Teitelman, L'41 Herbert Toff, L'38 .

Murry J. Waldman, L'52 Howard K. Wallace, L'16

H. Hurlburt Tomlin, L'47 Benjamin R. Townsend, L'40

Guy E. Waltman, L'29 Stewart E . Warner, L'27

CLASS PERFORMANCES GREATEST NUMBER

OF DOLLARS CONTRIBUTED

Class Agent Amount

1927 Herman I. Pollock $5,942.50 1941 Paul A. Wolkin 4,481.13 1922 E. Perry Campbell 4,441.50

GREATEST NUMBER OF CONTRIBUTORS

Class Agent Number

1962 E. Barclay Cale 90 1963 John L. Harrison 75 1964 William J. Levy 65

BEST PER CENT OF PARTICIPATION (Classes of 25 or more)

Class Agent Per Cent

1962 E. Barclay Cale 71 1916 Martin Feldman 63 1917 Philip F. Newman 56

BEST PER CENT OF PARTICIPATION (Classes of less than 25)

Class Agent Per Cent

1921 William I. Woodcock, Jr. 71 1908 Isaac Ash 69 1901 Edwin C. Emhardt (Deceased) 67

Mrs. Helen Moran Warren, L'30 Richard Warren, L'51 Hon. Gerald J. Weber, L'39 Wilton E. Webster, L'12 Joseph Weinfeld, L'31 Jerome B. Weinstein, L'34 Lewis Weinstock, L'40 Sydney L. Weintraub, L'25 H . John Weisman, Jr., L'42 Morris Weisman, L'27 Aaron Weiss, L'16

William White, Jr., Esq., L'38 William C. Wise, L'33 Morton Witkin, L'l7 Marvin M. Wodlinger, L'60 Morris Wolf, L'03 Hon. Charles A. Wolverton, L'OO H. Albert Young, L'29 John R. Young, L'30 Judah Zelitch, L'27 David B. Zoob, L'27 Frank J. Zugehoer, L'35

Carroll R . Wetzel, L'30

ABOVE AVERAGE These Classes Equalled or Bettered the Over-all

Alumni Participation of 43%:

Year Agent Per Cent

1921 William I. Woodcock, Jr. (Under 25 members) 71 1962 E. Barclay Cale 71 1908 Isaac Ash (Under 25 members) 69 1901 Edwin C. Emhardt, Deceased

(Under 25 members) 67 1907 Stanley W. Root (Under 25 members) 63 1916 Martin Feldman 63 1911 (Handled by Class Agent Chairman)

(Under 25 members) 60 1900 William S. Allen (Under 25 members) 57 1906 John Martin Doyle (Under 25 members) 57 1917 Philip F. Newman 56 1957 Richard Schneider 55 1922 E. Perry Campbell 53 1924 William C. Ferguson, Jr. 53 1949J Louis J. Carter 53 1939 Arthur R . Kane, Jr. & James Hunter, III 52 1963 John L. Harrison 52 1927 Herman I. Pollock 51 1958 George B. McNelis 51 1961 Raymond K. Denworth, Jr. 51 1918-19 (Handled by Class Agent Chairman)

(Under 25 members) 50 1925 Desmond J. McTighe 48 1935 Frank E. Hahn, Jr. 48 1946 John L. Esterhai & James C. Bly 48 1923 George W. Griffith (Under 25 members) 47 1960 John F . Dugan, II 47 1941 Paul A. Wolkin 46 1944 Barton E. Ferst (Under 25 members) 46 1955 Robert L. Kendall , Jr. & Irving M . Hirsh 46 1964 William J. Levy 45 1951 John J. Galbally 44 1902 Joseph Sternberger (Under 25 members) 43 1914 Frank H. Mancill 43 1938 Raymond J. Broderick 43

CONTRIBUTORS NON-ALUMNI Number Giving 10 Amount $4,410.00 Myer & Rosaline Feinstein

Foundation John 0. Honnold, Jr. Jefferson B. Fordham Estate of Alexis Rosenberg In memory of Edwin C.

Emhardt In memory of Edwin C.

Emhardt

*Deceased

8

In memory of Edwin C. Emhardt



Robert Gray

CLASS OF 1897-99

Number Giving Per Cent Giving Amount

3 38

$290.00

Charles E. Blackburn Ira J. Williams Charles Kuschke

CLASS OF 1900 William S. Allen, Agent


William S. Allen Paul Bedford

4 57

$225.00

Albert N. Garrett Hon. Charles A. Wolverton

CLASS OF 1901

The Late Edwin C. Emhardt, Agent

Number Giving 2 Per Cent Giving 67 Amount $125.00 Hon. Jasper Yeates Brinton

*Edwin C. Emhardt Continued on page 10

LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL

REPORT OF CLASSES Chairman-Milton B. Garner, L'36

1965--66 1964--65 No. in No. Per Cent No. in No. Per Cent

Class Agent Class Giving Giving Amount Class Giving Giving Amount Non Alumni 10 $4,510.00 4 $1,355.00

1882-99 Milton B. Gamer 8 3 38 290.00 14 5 36 430.00 1900 William S. Allen 7 4 57 225.00 8 6 75 165.00 1901 Edwin C. Emhardt, dec'd 3 2 67 125.00 4 2 50 125.00 1902 Joseph Sternberger 7 3 43 115.00 6 2 33 15.00 1903 Hon. L. Stauffer Oliver, dec'd 12 2 17 125.00 16 4 25 170.00 1904 Milton B. Garner 4 1* 25 6 3 50 30.00 1905 Benjamin 0. Frick 11 3 27 1,110.00 13 3 23 1,020.00 1906 John Martin Doyle 7 4 57 225.00 9 4 45 125.00 1907 Stanley W. Root 8 5 63 400.00 12 6 50 345.00 1908 Isaac Ash 16 11 69 682.00 18 9 50 590.00 1909 Joseph J. Tunney 14 4 29 1,030.00 14 3 21 25.00 1910 Wallace Bromley 23 9 39 696.00 28 13 46 651.00 1911 Milton B. Garner 20 12 60 805.00 21 9 43 685.00 1912 Milton B. Gamer 27 5 18 1,420.00 27 6 22 1,538.73 1913 Samuel R. Rosenbaum 23 6 26 165.00 24 8 33 270.00 1914 Frank H . Mancill 35 15 43 2,803.94 39 37 95 11,430.00 1915 James F. Masterson 27 9 33 1,010.00 31 12 39 1,270.00 1916 Martin Feldman 30 19 63 1,215.00 33 22 69 993.00 1917 Philip F . Newman 50 28 56 2,245.00 51 30 59 2,295.00 1918-19 Milton B. Garner 6 3 50 320.00 14 3 21 165.00 1920 Otto P. Mann 18 5 28 350.00 17 9 53 1,600.00 1921 William I. Woodcock, Jr. 17 12 71 1,340.00 19 15 79 910.00 1922 E. Perry Campbell 40 21 53 4,441.50 42 18 43 1,978.00 1923 Hon. George W. Griffith 19 9 47 297.00 20 10 50 217.00 1924 William C. Ferguson, Jr. 34 18 53 1,856.25 36 15 42 1,311.88 1925 Desmond J . McTighe 42 20 48 3,180.00 42 21 50 2,325.00 1926 Joseph G. Feldman 39 11 28 1,192.50 38 13 34 1,221.00 1927 Herman I. Pollock 82 42 51 5,942.50 81 39 48 5,852.50 1928 Herman M. Ellis 79 30 38 1,780.00 76 30 40 1,705.00 1929 Alan J. Smith 81 30 37 2,285.00 88 31 35 2,045.00 1930 J. Russell Gibbons 96 34 35 2,195.00 98 35 36 2,229.50 1931 Knox Henderson 114 46 40 4,360.00 114 46 40 3,030.00 1932 Walter W. Beachboard 95 34 36 1,872.50 97 27 28 1,770.00 1933 Nathan Silberstein 87 34 39 2,220.00 89 39 44 2,842.50 1934 Roland J. Christy 85 27 32 1,476.38 85 32 38 1,864.44 1935 Frank E. Hahn, Jr. 93 45 48 2,780.00 93 42 45 2,055.00 1936 Milton B. Garner 100 39 39 2,843.20 101 36 36 2,069.00 1937 Joseph Bell 100 32 32 2,354.00 101 32 32 1,291.00 1938 Raymond J. Broderick 86 37 43 2,274.00 85 35 41 1,971.00 1939 Arthur R . Kane, Jr. &

James Hunter, III 89 46 52 1,791.00 88 43 49 1,625.00 1940 Lewis Weinstock 98 32 33 4,083.75 96 36 37 1,712.50 1941 Paul A. Wolkin 103 47 46 4,481.13 102 45 45 1,256.00 1942 Frederic L. Ballard 71 24 34 850.00 72 24 33 890.00 1943 Robert Hachenburg 49 10 20 305.00 48 8 17 220.00 1944 Barton E. Ferst 24 11 46 395.00 23 11 48 425.00 1945 Milton B. Garner 9 3 33 50.00 9 7 78 400 .00 1946 John L. Esterhai &

James C. Bly 27 13 48 265.00 27 12 45 225.00 1947 Robert M. Landis 76 19 25 990.00 75 18 24 605.00 1948 Raymond Jenkins 131 46 35 1,605.00 131 46 35 1,350.00 1949F Henry N . Platt, Jr. 89 37 42 1,685.00 87 36 41 1,216.00 1949J Louis J. Carter 73 39 53 1,894.50 75 40 53 1,318.50 1950 Stephen J . Korn 102 42 41 2,431.00 100 46 46 1,340.00 1951 John J. Galbally 133 59 44 2,451.49 130 58 45 2,028.00 1952 Joseph P. Flanagan , Jr. 121 44 36 1,387.50 121 44 36 912.50 1953 Leonard Barkan 135 56 42 1,427.00 137 59 43 1,161.00 1954 Morris M. Shuster 90 38 41 875.00 90 42 47 830.50 1955 Robert L. Kendall, Jr. &

Irving M. Hirsh 103 47 46 1,190.00 103 50 49 963.00 1956 Alan G . Kirk, II &

Carl W. Schneider 125 53 42 1,025.50 125 62 50 846.00 1957 Richard Schneider 100 55 55 1,026.50 101 54 54 664.00 1958 George B. McNelis 129 66 51 1,236.00 129 50 39 759.50 1959 Joseph Beller 156 51 33 1,062.00 152 53 35 1,006.77 1960 John F . Dugan, II 115 54 47 902.50 117 35 30 435.00 1961 Raymond K. Denworth, Jr. 112 57 51 943.00 112 61 55 848.50 1962 E. Barclay Cale 127 90 71 1,039.00 127 76 60 744.50 1963 John L. H arrison 144 75 52 849.00 144 64 45 768.00 1964 William J . Levy 145 65 45 824.00 145 67 46 633.38 1965 Harvey Bartle, III 148 61 41 503 .00

4,458 1,920 43 % $102,124.64 *Gift made in prior year.

4,374 1,860 42% $87,164.20

Flill 1966 9

CLASS OF 1902 Joseph Sternberger, Agent Number Giving 3 Per Cent Giving 43 Amount $115.00 Hon. Edwin 0. Lewis Hon. Horace Stern Joseph Sternberger

CLASS OF 1903 The Late Hon. L. Stauffer

Oliver, Agent Number Giving Per Cent Giving Amount

2 17

$125.00 Benjamin Dintenfass Morris Wolf

CLASS OF 1904

Number Giving 1 Per Cent Giving 25 Estate of George M. Henry

CLASS OF 1905 Benjamin 0. Frick, Agent Number Giving 3

27 $1 ,110.00

Per Cent Giving Amount

Benjamin 0. Frick Eugene S. Richardson Maurice B. Saul

CLASS OF 1906 John Martin Doyle, Agent Number Giving 4

57 $225.00

Per Cent Giving Amount John Martin Doyle Robert J. Eby Albert M. Greenfield Isaac W. Roberts

CLASS OF 1907 Stanley W. Root, Agent Number Giving 5

63 $400.00

Per Cent Giving Amount Hon. James H. Duff Louis M. Fleisher George Ovington, Jr. Stanley W. Root Carl D . Smith

CLASS OF 1908

Isaac Ash, Agent Number Giving Per Cent Giving Amount Isaac Ash John Arthur Brown James D. Carpenter Robert T. Fox T . Walker Gilkyson Otto Kraus, Jr. Leigh M. Morss Leon J. Obermayer John J. O'Brien

*Raymond Pitcarin Arthur M. Widdows

CLASS OF 1909

11 69

$682.00

Joesph J. Tunney, Agent Number Giving 4

29 $1,030.00


*Deceased

10

Louis W. Robey Harry Scherman Joseph J. Tunney Russell Wolfe

CLASS OF 1910 Wallace Bromley, Agent Number Giving Per Cent Giving Amount Wallace Bromley Harold Evans

9 39

$696.00

*Edward Hopkinson, Jr. Sidney Loewenstein

*Isaac T. Porter Hon. Forrest R. Shanaman D. Hays Solis-Cohen Philip Sterling Hon. W. Butler Windle

CLASS OF 1911 Number Giving Per Cent Giving Amount Ralph J. Baker Arthur M. Eastburn Nelson P. Fegley Fred T. Fruit

12 60

$805.00

Ge0rge K. Helbert Hubert J. Horan, Jr. Samuel L. Howell Tho!I\as M. Hyndman David S. Malis C. Edward Paxson Joseph Rosenstein AaronS. Swartz, Jr.

CLASS OF 1912


5 18

$1,420.00

Harry N. Brenner James C. Peacock Edmund H. Rogers William A. Schnader Wilton W. Webster

CLASS OF 1913

Samuel R. Rosenbaum, Agent


Schofield Andrews Isidore Baylson

6 26

$165.00

Ralph S. Croskey Edward T. Curry Percy C. Madeira, Jr. Samuel R. Rosenbaum

CLASS OF 1914

Frank H. Mancill, Agent


15 43

$2,803.94

Robert M. Bernstein Edwin H . Burgess Walter M. Burkhardt L. Leroy Deininger Lewis J. Finestone Domenic Furia

William Ginsburg Robert D. Hughes Louis Levinson D . Arthur Magaziner Frank H. Mancill Mark T. Milnor Theodore S. Paul H. James Sautter David R. Tomb

CLASS OF 1915

James F. Masterson, Agent

Number Giving 9 Per Cent Giving 33 Amount $1,010.00

Justin S. Bamberger Ralph W. Crowell R. McCall Gilkey David D . Goff Hon. James F . Henninger Lewis H . Kirk Hon. Frank L. Pinola Thomas Reath Alexander N. Rubin

CLASS OF 1916

Martin Feldman, Agent


19 63

$1,215.00

Hon. Francis Shunk Brown, Jr.

Heath S. Clark Joseph L. Ehrenreich Harry Feinstein Martin Feldman Benjamin B. Hoar Vernon S. Jones Benjamin M. Kline Harry G. Lenzner Hon. Louis E. Levinthal Hon. Thomas M. Lewis Howard I. Powell Thomas E. Shipley Elmer D . Simon Moses J. Slonim Edward Stone Paul C. Wagner Howard K. Wallace Aaron Weiss

CLASS OF 1917

Philip F . Newman , Agent


Harry E. Apeler Hon. John C. Bell, Jr. Rodney T . Bonsall Meyer L. Casman Edward Davis Raymond K. Denworth John J. Goldy M. Joseph Greenblatt Hon. T. Linus Hoban Joseph H. Lieberman Robert C. Ligget Edwin A. Lucas Albert J. Marks Marshall H. Morgan

Philip F . Newman Hon. Arturo Ortiz-Toro Mrs. Rose Lerner Perlman W. Foster Reeve, 3rd P . Herbert Reigner Paul M. Robinson Maurice Saeta Hon. Harold D. Saylor Claude C. Smith Hon. Maurice W. Sporkin Edward J. Swotes Mervin R. Turk Hon. Joseph Varbalow Morton Witkin

CLASS OF 1918-19


Ernest N . Votaw Joseph H. Grubb, Jr. Ernest R. Keiter

CLASS OF 1920 Otto P . Mann, Agent

3 50

$320.00

Number Giving 5 Per Cent Giving 28 Amount $350.00

Hon. Harold L. Ervin Otto P. Mann Emanuel Moss Harry Polish Eugene H. Southall

CLASS OF 1921 William I. Woodcock , Jr. ,

Agent Number Giving Per Cent Giving Amount

12 71

$1 ,340.00 Samuel J. Becker Francis H . Bohlen, Jr. A. Samuel Buchman Robert Dechert R. Sturgis Ingersoll Benjamin C. Jones Armand L. Koethen Clarence G. Myers John Russell , Jr. Joseph Smith Isadore S. Wachs William I. Woodcock, Jr.

CLASS OF 1922 E . Perry Campbell, Agent Number Giving 21

53 $4,441.50

Per Cent Giving Amount Norris S. Barratt, Jr. Franklin H . Bates Harold F. Butler E. Perry Campbell Dorian Cowan W. Meade Fletcher, Jr.

*George S. Goldstein William D. Harkins J. H. Ward Hinkson A. Bernard Hirsch Frederick H. Knight Herman H. Krekstein Thomas McConnell, 3rd Hon. Leo H . McKay Clarence A. Patterson

LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL

Edward A. G. Porter G. Ruhland Rebmann, Jr. Henry D. M. Sherrerd Arthur B. Vanbuskirk Miss Sybil U. Ward Allen H. White

CLASS OF 1923 Hon. George W. Griffith,


9 47

$297.00 Miss Felice E. Darkow Hon. E. Arnold Forrest Samuel A. Goldberg Cadmus Z. Gordon, Jr. Hon. George W. Griffith Henry R. Heebner Penrose Hertzler Holman G. Knouse Hon. Felix Piekarski

CLASS OF 1924 William C. Ferguson, Jr. ,


18 53

$1,856.25 Robert K. Bell Benjamin N . Brown Hon. Hazel H. Brown Edward V. Buckley Mrs. Ida Oranovich Creskoff William C. Ferguson, Jr. Edward H . P. Fronefield Thomas M. Johnston Harry Kaufman Richard H. Klein David F. Maxwell James Patterson Hon. Harold L. Paul Philip S. Polis Hon. W. Orvyl Schalick Charles D. Smeltzer Sigmund Steinberg Wendell E. Warner

CLASS OF 1925 Desmond J. McTighe, Agent Number Giving 20 Per Cent Giving 48 Amount $3, 180.00 Harris C. Arnold Laurence Brunswick Hon. Herbert B. Cohen Meyer E. Cooper Francis I. Farley Carl W. Funk Mortimer E. Graham Samuel R. Greenwald George E. Hackney Charles P. Larkin, Jr. Baldwin Maull Desmond J. McTighe Morton Meyers Henry N. Paul, Jr. William M. Ruddock James B. Sayers Walter Seiler Geoffrey S. Smith Sydney L. Weintraub Hon. J. Colvin Wright

CLASS OF 1 926 Joseph G. Feldman, Agent Number Giving II Per Cent Giving 28 Amount $1,192.50

*Deceased

Fall 1966

Erich 0. Angermann Henry W. Balka Julius C. Baylinson J. Warren Brock Sol Brody Hon. JosephS. Clark, Jr. Hon. Bernard J. Kelley W. James Macintosh

*Louis Marion Leon Meltzer Frank M. Travaline, Jr.

CLASS OF 1927 Herman I. Pollock, Agent Number Giving 42 Per Cent Giving 51 Amount $5,942.50 Herman P . Abramson Mrs. Sadie T. M. Alexander Philip W. Amram George F. B. Appel Francis J. Beckley J . Glen Benedict Alvin W. Carpenter Rabbi E. Lewis Cooper GuyW. Davis Herman Eisenberg John K. Ewing, 3rd Harry Friedman Jacques H. Geisenberger Emil F. Goldhaber Nathan Goldman Harold D. Greenwell Michael H . Gurbarg John Harper John F. Headly Harold H. Hoffman Robert B. Johnson Charles M. Justi Louis Lipschitz Albert B. Melnik Thomas P. Mikell Herman I. Pollock John Byron Prather Rev. Elwood F. Reeves, Jr. William Rowe Nathan J. Schneider Manuel Sidkoff Hon. Frederick B. Smillie C. Leo Sutton Hon. 0. Jacob Tallman Charles C. Townsend Stewart E. Warner Morris Weisman William N. West, 3rd Morris M. Wexler John H. Wharton Judah Zelitch David B. Zoob

CLASS OF 1928 Herman M. Ellis, Agent Number Giving 28 Per Cent Giving 35 Amount $1,780.00 Harry Norman Ball Alexander S. Bauer Sanford D. Beecher Franklin H. Berry Clifford M. Bowden J. Russell Cades William V. Cherry Morris Cheston J. Lawrence Davis Guy G. deFuria Herman M. Ellis David H. Frantz Stuart B. Glover Joseph A. Grazier Martin Greenblatt Jesse Hyman

John P . Jordan Harrison G. Kildare Samuel P. Lavine Hon. Paul S. Lehman Abraham Levin Hugh P. McFadden James A. Montgomery, Jr. Benson N. Schambelan Lawrence M. C. Smith Leon Sobel Joseph Weintraub Edward S. Weyl

CLASS OF 1929 Alan J. Smith, Agent Number Giving 30

37 $2,285.00

Per Cent Giving Amount William B. Arnold John H. Austin Milton Berger Herman Cohen Stanley B. Cooper Daniel DeBrier Thomas M. Parr Lawrence E. Frankel B. Graeme Frazier, Jr. Morris B. Gelb Walter E. Greenwood, Jr. Gilbert G. Harris Albert M. Hoyt, Jr. William S. Rudders Joseph G. Jackson William F. Kennedy Hon. Abraham H. Lipez Edward S. Lower Samuel Marx William L. Matz Nathan I. Miller William L. Rubin Sidney Schulman Ernest Scott Louis Sherr Alan J. Smith Irvin Stander Theodore Voorhees Guy E. Waltman H. Albert Young

CLASS OF 1930 J . Russell Gibbons, Agent Number Giving 34 Per Cent Giving 35 Amount $2,195.00 Samuel A. Armstrong George M. Brodhead W. Frederic Colclough Philip Dechert George C. Denniston Samuel E. Ewing Joseph First Edward W. Furia J. Russell Gibbons Samuel E. Gilbert Robert W. Greenfield Stanley Jakubowski Joseph Kaplan Herman Krakovitz William H. Kresch T. Harry Levin Herbert M. Levy Wilfred R. Lorry Elias Magi! George W. McKeag Clarence Mesirov I sidor Ostroff Lawrence Potamkin Samuel M. Rosenfeld James W. Scanlon Andrew J. Schroder, II Lloyd J. Schumacker

Norman Snyder Alexander T. Stein Leonard A. Talone Mrs. Helen M. Warren Carroll R. Wetzel John R. Young Bernard M. Zimmerman

CLASS OF 1931 Knox Henderson, Agent Number Giving 46 Per Cent Giving 40 Amount $4,360.00 Alexander B. Adelman Nathan Agran Philip I. N. Alperdt James R. Anderson, Jr. Arthur W. Bean John H. Bertolet William R. Bready, 3rd Natt M. Emery, Jr. Edward L. Frater Hon. Theodore R. Gardner Frank E. Gordon Elihu A. Greenhouse Samuel Handloff Edwin S. Heins Knox Henderson Edward B. Hodge Myron Jacoby Israel I. Jamison Alexander Katzin George D. Kline Ashby M. Larmore Nathan Lavine Hon. Herbert S. Levin Abraham J. Levinson Daniel Lowenthal John B. Martin Robert V. Massey, Jr. Jack J. McDowell Alex L. Nichols Martin H. Philip Harry Polikoff Col. Shalon Ralph Hon. Augustine Repetto Paul H. Rhoads George M.D. Richards Hon. Samuel J. Roberts W. Albert Sanders Willis H. Satterthwaite Adelbert S. Schroeder Bernard G. Segal J. Tyson Stokes Allen C. Thomas, Jr. William H. Vincent Harry P. Voldow Joseph Weinfeld Mrs. Edith H. West Harry H. Wexelblatt

CLASS OF 1932 Walter W. Beachboard.

Agent Number Giving 34 Per Cent Giving 36 Amount $1,872.50 Hon. Alexander F. Barbieri Walter W. Beachboard M. Robert Beckman Samuel A. Blank William C. Bodine John C. Brutton, Jr. Harold J. Conner Hon. John Morgan Davis Saul Finestone Mrs. Esther Oshiver Fisher Harry V. Fritchman Hon. Thomas C. Gawthrop Hon. Morris Gerber Miss Mary E. Groff

11

David H. Kubert Mrs. Rose Kotzin Landy Benjamin Levin Harold C. Lohren Miss Elizabeth C. Lownsbury Eugene A. Nogi Israel Packel Raymond M. Pearlstine Calvin H. Rankin Harold M. Rappeport Max Rosenn Bernard Schwartz Daniel G. Smith Harold S. Soltman Samuel L. Sperling Sidney S. Stark Guy K. Stewart Harold B. Wells, Jr. William H. S. Wells Edward Z. Winkleman

CLASS OF 1933

Nathan Silberstein, Agent


David F. Anderson Max M. Batzer Robert J. Callaghan Sidney Chait William H. Doerr, Jr. Martin B. Ebbert Eugene H . Feldman Edward First Joseph H. Flanzer Austin Gavin Henry Greenwald Sidney E. Jaffee James L. Johnson Edward A. Kaier Joseph M. Leib William Lipkin Carl P. Lundy Paul Maloney Jerome L. Markovitz Samuel Mink Francis J. Morrissey, Jr. Benjamin H. Oehlert, Jr. Henry B. Oestreich John B. Pearson Samuel Popper John E . Power, Jr. David H. Rosenbluth Col. Francis M. Sasse Nathan Silberstein James L. Stern Edward G. Taulane, Jr. Eugene K. Twining William C. Wise Samuel R. Wurtman

CLASS OF 1934

Roland J. Christy, Agent


Arthur L. Adams

27 32

$1,476.38

S. Smauel Arsht William D. Barfield JohnS. Bernheimer Leonard J. Bernstein Roland J. Christy William H. Conca Louis W. Cramer Mrs. Irene R. Dobbs Philip B. Driver, Jr. Anthony G. Felix, Jr.

*Deceased

12

Eugene C. Fish Edward I. Fishman Solomon Freedman Abraham Hefferman C. Sumner Katz Robert L. Lingelbach George W. McKee, Jr. Howard S. McMorris A. Arthur Miller Ernest D. Preate ClayM. Ryan Harold B. Saler Emanuel G. Scoblionko Milton C. Sharp Morris Smith Jerome B. Weinstein

CLASS OF 1935 Frank E. Hahn, Jr., Agent Number Giving 45 Per Cent Giving 48 Amount $2,780.00 Herman M. Buck Henry M. Canby F. William Carr E. Calvert Cheston Joseph W. deFuria James B. Doak Charles H. Dorsett Sylvan D. Einhorn Bernard Eskin Samuel Fessenden Solomon Forman Calvin J. Friedberg Gordon W. Gabell Frank H. Gelman Kenneth W. Gemmill Fred P. Glick Louis J. Goffman Frank E . Hahn, Jr. Leonard Helfenstein Charles J. Hepburn, Jr. Gilbert P. High Donald V. Hock Emanuel Laster Robert F. Lehman A. Harry Levitan Daniel W. Long Josiah Macy, Jr. William M. Maier Daniel F. Marple Harry R. Most John M. Ranck Harry S. Redeker Nathan L. Reibman Grover C. Richman, Jr. John Ross Louis B. Schwartz Boyd L. Spahr, Jr. Harry E. Sprogell J. Pennington Straus T. F . Dixon Wainwright Albert C. Weymann, Jr. Richard T. Williamson Irving Wilner Arnold Winokur Frank J. Zugehoer

CLASS OF 1936 Milton B. Garner, Agent Number Giving 39 Per Cent Giving 39 Amount $2,843 .20 Hon. Alfred C. Alspach James Andrews, Jr. Samuel Bard James E. Birdsall John Bishop, VI Hon. S. Thomas Bucciarelli Roderick T. Clarke

Alfred F. Conard Harry B. Davidson Harry T. Devine Herbert G. Du Bois Wayland F. Dunaway, 3rd Milton B. Garner Sylvester S. Garrett, Jr. Lewis M. Gill Ron. Edward J. Griffiths Alfred W. Hesse, Jr. Ron. J. Sydney Hoffman Charles S. Jacobs Robert G. Kelly George C. Laub Bernard V. Lentz Berthold W. Levy Ron. Joseph S. Lord, 3rd Harry K. Madway Edwin S. Maimed Jerome A. O'Neill John N. Osterlund Joseph Rhoads Ron. Charles A. Shea, Jr. G . William Shea Morris H. Sheer David Shotel Nathan C. Staller Karl H. Strohl Thomas Raeburn White, Jr . C. Martin Wood John K. Young

CLASS OF 1937

Joseph Bell, Agent Number Giving 32 Per Cent Giving 32 Amount $2,354.00 William D. Balitas Mrs. Anne Fleming Baxter Joseph Bell Claire G. Biehn Lawrence M. Bregy Milton Cades Harrison H . Clement Edward I. Cutler Ivan M. Czap Mrs. F . Schwartz Davidow Albert B. Gerber Hyman Goldberg Louis S. Hankin Lester E. Kabacoff Herman F. Kerner Harold E. Kohn Frederick E. Lark Benjamin S. Loewenstein Randal Morgan David M. Perskie Norman L. Plotka Paul Port Bayard H . Roberts Victor J. Roberts, Jr. Alex Satinsky John N. Schaeffer, Jr. Lester J. Schaffer C. Tracy Taylor Robert L. Trescher Frederick A. VanDenbergh,

Jr. Ernest R. Von Starck Benjamin Weinstein

CLASS OF 1938 Raymond J. Broderick, A gent Number Giving 37 Per Cent Giving 43 Amount $2,274.00

* Hon. Walter E. Alessandroni Ralph M. Barley Samuel B. Blaskey Raymond J. Broderick

Theodore L. Brubaker Richard D. Case Keron D. Chance Richard N. Clattenburg Sylvan M. Cohen J. Harry Covington, 3rd M. Carton Dittmann, Jr. Leonard L. Ettinger Myer Feldman Robert N . Ferrer Lockwood W. Fogg, Jr. Bernard Frank Richard W. Goslin, Jr. Harold P. Gould Harry A. Greenberg William R. G. Hamilton Jesse G . Heiges Hon. Gregory G. Lagakos Maurice Levin Richard M. Martin Barron P . McCune John L. Owens Irwin Paul Morris Pfaelzer, 2nd Herman B. Poul Solon L. Rhode, Jr. Roger Scattergood Irving R. Segal JohnS. Simpson Charles M. Solomon James A. Sutton Herbert Toff William White, Jr.

CLASS OF 1939 James Hunter, III, Agent Arthur R. Kane, Jr. , Agent Number Giving 46 Per Cent Giving 52 Amount $1 ,791.00 Roxana Cannon Arsht Thomas J. Beddow Thomas R. Bevan John W. Beyer Henry M. Biglan John W. Bohlen John P. Bracken Philip A. Bregy Joseph W. P. Burke Thomas R. Butler T. Sidney Cadwallader, 2nd Alexander Cohen John T. Conner Leo T. Connor Albert J. Crawford, Jr. Fronfield Crawford William H. Egli Leon S. Forman William L. Fox Robert S. Gawthrop, Jr. Thomas P. Glassmeyer Seymour L. Green Carl E. Heilman James Hunter, III Arthur R. Kane, Jr. H. Allen Lochner William H. Loesche, Jr. Ralph S. Mason Leroy S. Maxwell Sherwin T. McDowell Walter P. McEvilly Miss Doris E. Montgomery Robert C. Porter W. Frazier Scott W. Simms Sharninghausen John P. Sinclair W. Lloyd Snyder, Jr. Eli as W. Spengler Benjamin F. Stahl, Jr. AaronS. Swartz, 3rd Howard W. Taylor, Jr.

LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL

Frank J . Toole Robert Ungerleider Nelson D . Warwick Hon. Gerald J. Weber Roy Wilkinson, Jr.

CLASS OF 1940

Lewis Weinstock, Agent Number Giving 32 Per Cent Giving 33 Amount $4,083.75 Oakford W. Acton, Jr. Robert D. Branch Samuel A. Breene John C. Decker Richard M. Dicke Robert J. Dodds William S. Eisenhart, Jr. Jay M. Frye, Jr. William P . Gregory, Jr. Carl J. W. Hessinger Francis Hopkinson Andrew Hourigan, Jr. Emanuel H . Klein Richard B. Malis William B. Marshall John L. McDonald Samuel V. Merrick P aul V. Miller Edward J . Mingey, Jr. Arthur E. Newbold , 3rd Thomas A. 0 . Boyle George Ovington , 3rd Anderson Page William R. Reynolds Theodore 0. Rogers David J. Salaman Robert W. Sayre Jacob Seidenberg Milton H. Shapiro Benjamin R. Townsend Lewis Weinstock David L. Wilson

CLASS OF 1941

Paul A. Wolkin, Agent


Mrs. M. Corson Applegarth Edmund Backman S. Lester Block Herbert Brener Horace R. Cardoni Paul M. Chalfin Frederick J . Charley John R. Clark Walton Coates Marvin Comisky A. Lynn Corcelius Robert I. Cottom John J . Dautrich Edward M. David Herman S. Davis David H. W. Dohan William B. Farran Richard J. Farrell Wesley R. Frysztacki Hon. Paul B. Greiner Paul I. Guest Alvin E. Heutchy Chester C. Hilinski Richard M. Hughes, II Robert C. Koury Vincent J. Labrasca Peter P . Leibert, ITJ William E. Lindenmuth

Fall 1966

Samuel S. Logan, Jr. William J. Lowry, 3rd Daniel J . McCauley Robert E. Porter R . Stewart Rauch, Jr. Lipman Redman Milton W. Rosen George B. Ross Leonard Sarner William J. Scarlett Norman Seidel Bernard J. Smolens John M. Stocker Wilson Stradley Edwin K. Taylor S. Robert Teitelman Edmund P. Turtzo Roy J. Waychoff Paul A. Wolkin

CLASS OF 1942 Frederic L. Ballard


24 34

$850.00 Norman H. Abrahamson Frederic L. Ballard Philip E. Barringer Pershing N . Calabro Watson S. Campbell John R. Graham Donald E. Hittle Albert E. Holl, Jr. Hon. Robert W. Honeyman Edmund Jones Samuel S. Laucks, Jr. A. Leo Levin Robert L. Miller Charles E . Rankin Mrs. Mabel D . Sellers Craig M. Sharpe Samuel P. Shaw, Jr. Elvin R. Souder Thomas B. Steiger Joseph W. Swain, Jr. Paul C. Van Dyke H. John Weisman, Jr. Thomas H . Wentz George C. Williams

CLASS OF 1943

Robert Hachenburg, Agent

Number Giving 10 Per Cent Giving 20 Amount $305.00 Bernard M. Borish William J. Dickman John A. Geisz Richard D . Grifo Robert Hachenburg Perch P. Hankin Allan W. Keusch Mrs. E . Hatton Landis Joseph Shanis Ellis W. VanHorn , Jr.

CLASS OF 1944

Barton E. Ferst, A gent


11 46

$395.00 Mrs. Trudell Green Brown Theodore A. Evans Barton E. Ferst Frederick G . Kempin, Jr. Meyer Kramer

L. Stanley Mauger Carl F . Mogel G . Selden Pitt David V. Shapiro Michael Waris, Jr. PaulL. Wise

CLASS OF 1945

Number Giving Per Cent Giving Amount S. Harry Galfand

3 33

$50.00

Mrs. Jane Mahady Mcintyre Mrs. M. Charleston White

CLASS OF 1946

James C. Bly, Agent John L. Esterhai, Agent Number Giving Per Cent Giving Amount John C. Bell, 3rd James C. Bly Ralph T . Buchsbaum William M. DeLong John L. Esterhai John K. Hanrahan John R. Miller

13 48

$265.00

Mrs. Emma Forry Mullen Louis B. Nielsen Col. David H. Pepper Albert B. Sharp Harold Tull William H. G. Warner

CLASS OF 1947

Robert M. Landis, Agent


19 25

$990.00

Arlin M. Adams Raymond J . Bradley Francis Shunk Brown, 3rd James E. Carr Charles R. Cooper, Jr. Emerson L. Darnell T . Crawley Davis, Jr. Robert B. Doll Justin G. Duryea Leon Ehrlich John C. Hambrook Robert M. Landis Hon. Alfred L. Luongo Robert H. Malis William H. Mann Alfred W. Putnam Hon. Herman M. Rodgers H . Hurlburt Tomlin Morris L. Weisberg

CLASS OF 1948

Raymond Jenkins, Agent

Number Giving Per Cent Giving Amount James G . Aiken

46 35

$1 ,605.00

Joseph G . Ansel Walter Y. Anthony, Jr. Martin M. Bell James C. Bowen James F. Brown, Jr. Richard P. Brown, Jr . James E. Buckingham Charles M. DonneJiy Mark R. Eaby, Jr.

Thomas G . B. Ebert Melvin C. Fisher Robert P. Frankel William J. Fuchs Joseph F. Harvey Daniel H. Huyett, 3rd Raymond Jenkins Solomon Katz Eugene W. Lederer Noyes E . Leech Harvey Levin Robert Margolis Francis E. Marshall John E. McCarthy, Jr. WalterS. Peake Marvin D. Perskie Franklin Poul Henry T. Reath George H. Reid Donald Reuter George R. Rittenhouse Samuel B. Russell Lester H. Salter Herbert W. Salus, Jr. Scott W. Scully Charles S. Shapiro E. Eugene SheJiey John A. Shrader George W. Thompson James J. Walsh Mrs. M. Lubich Weisberg Elkins Wetherill Thomas E. Wilcox Bernard Wolfman Milton A. WoJiman John F. ZeJier, 3rd

CLASS OF 1949 February

Henry N. Platt, Jr. , Agent


37 42

$1 ,685.00

Francis Ballard Hyman L. Battle, Jr. Lewis B. Beatty, Jr. William F. Bohlen Edward F. Canfield Alan H. Cassman Samuel B. Corliss Cassin W. Craig Clifford C. David William R. Deasey Ralph B. Diorio George C. Eppinger Bernard A. Fischer Robert B. Frailey Alex L. Fricke Roy A. Gardner Gordon W. Gerber M. Stuart Goldin James W. Hagar Edward M. Harris, Jr. Alexander Hemphill A. C. Reeves Hicks Will iam F . Lynch, 2nd John T. Macartney Milford L. McBride, Jr. Samuel W. M6rris Henry N . Platt, Jr. Charles B. Ruttenberg Philip M. Smithers Lee N . Steiner Caspar W. B. Townsend, Jr. William D. Valente Charles B. P. Van Pelt William T . Walsh Henry M. Wick, Jr. Carl A. Wiker Howard Yarus

13

Under$

GIFT ANALYSIS Per Cent of Per Cent of

Total Givers Total Dollars

$ 5.00 to 5.00 9.99

24.99 49.99 99.99

2.45% 0.88

43.59 22.64

5.65

.07% 1.68 8.07

10.10 5.07

38.08 7.52

10.00 to 25.00 to 50.00 to

100.00 to 250.00 to 500.00 to

249.99 499.99 999.99

21.40 1.58

1,000.00 to 4,999.99 .65

1.16 5.98

23.43

100.00% 100.00%

CORPORATE GIFT PROGRAM The names of corporate donors who have partici

pated in this year's Law School Annual Giving Program are listed below. These corporations have generously matched, wholly or in part, the gifts of our alumni in their employ. The number of the companies and the amount received from them increased significantly again this year as more join the matching gift program.

Alumni who are eligible to have their gift matched are urged to send in their company's form in order that the Law School may benefit from it. The matching amount is also credited to you, your class and your region.

At present there are about 300 corporations known to have adopted a plan for matching gifts made by employees, officers, and, often, directors to their schools and universities. The Alumni Office will be glad to supply information to any alumnus who may be in a position to influence the establishment of a matching gift plan in his company.

14

AIR PRODUCTS AND CHEMICALS, INC.

ARMSTRONG CORK COMPANY

ARTHUR ANDERSON & COMPANY

BRISTOL-MYERS COMPANY

CAMPBELL SouP CoMPANY

CLEVELAND ELECTRIC ILLUMINATING FOUNDATION

Esso EDUCATION FOUNDATION

FORD MOTOR COMPANY

HooKER CHEMICAL CoRPORA noN

INSURANCE COMPANY OF NORTH AMERICA

J. WALTER THOMPSON COMPANY, INC.

KIDDER, PEABODY & COMPANY, INC.

MARINE MIDLAND GRACE TRUST COMPANY OF NEW YORK

MERCK & COMPANY, INC.

OLIN MATHIESON CHEMICAL CORPORATION

PENNSYLVANIA POWER & LIGHT COMPANY

PHIL CO CORPORATION

ScoTT PAPER CoMPANY

SMITH, KLINE & FRENCH LABORATORIES

STANDARD OIL COMPANY OF INDTANA

THE CHASE MANHATTAN BANK

WORTHINGTON CORPORATION

A GLANCE AT TEN YEARS OF ANNUAL GIVING

Number of Year Contributors

1956-57 1027

1957-58 1096

1958-59 1365

1959-60 1281

1960-61 1250

1961-62 1498

1962-63 1680

1963-64 1791

1964-65 1860

1965-66 1920

CONTRIBUTORS (Continued)

CLASS OF 1949 June Louis J. Carter, Agent Number Giving 39

53 $1,894.50

Per Cent Giving Amount Richard L. Baker William H. Bayer Marshall A. Bernstein Francis J. Carey, Jr. Louis J. Carter Basil S. Cole, Jr. George B. Francis Marvin R. Halbert Mrs. Doris May Harris Bancroft D. Haviland William M. Hebrank James A. Hemstreet Hon. John F. Henderson Hugh H. Howard James F. Hyde, Jr. Hon. William F. Hyland Franklin E. Kepner Paul R. Kramer Frederick H. Law, Jr. William D. Lucas Herman H. Mattleman Thomas A. Mcivor William E. Miller, Jr. Mrs. Harriet M. Mims Robert I. Morris Edward W. Mullinix David H. Nelson Henry R. Nolte, Jr. David W. O'Brien Martin J. O'Donnell Charles C. Parlin, Jr. Hon. DanielL. Quinlan, Jr. Francis M. Richards, Jr. Harry C. Rockey Marvin Schwartz Murray L. Schwartz Edward M. Spector Robert W. Valimont Peter M. Ward

CLASS OF 1950 Stephen J. Korn, Agent Number Giving 42

41 $2,431.00


Per Cent Amount Participation Contributed

28 30,078.

29 37,635.

34 45,000.

32 50,096.

31 50,812.

37 53,325.

41 63,389.

42 72,935.

42 87,164.

43 102,124.

Morton Abrams William W. Atterbury, Jr. J. William Barba Francis J. Bowden, Jr. Arthur C. Dorrance, Jr. John W. Douglass Daniel H. Erickson David A. Falk Peter Florey John R. Gauntt Richard J. Gordon Phillip R. Grant Charles H. Greenberg Robert S. Grodinsky Robert A. Hauslohner John F. Heinz Theodore H. Husted, Jr. Thomas M. Hyndman, Jr. PaulL. Jaffe Hon. D. Donald Jamieson Louis J. Kober Stephen J. Korn Joseph T. Labrum, Jr. Robert W. Leech, Jr. Melvin G. Levy Frederick C. N. Littleton Joseph L. Loughran Merton J. Matz Charles F. Mayer J. Grant McCabe, 3rd Raymond W. Midgett, Jr. Ernest L. Nagy William G. O'Neill Peter Platten Stanley W. Root, Jr. Harold S. Rosenbluth Sylvan H. Savadove James H. Scheck Alvin R. Schomer Lawrence E. Stengel John J. Tinaglia Mrs. Virginia B. Wallace

CLASS OF 1951 John J. Galbally, Agent Number Giving 59 Per Cent Giving 44 Amount $2,451.49 Clyde W. Armstrong C. Thomas Attix, Jr.

LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL

Marvin K. Bailin Harold Berger Nathan Berlant Joseph S. Bobman Christopher Branda, Jr. Neil W. Burd Crede C. Calhoun Harold Caplan William J. Carlin Stuart Coven Harold Cramer Harold W. Demopulos Richard S. Denny Park B. Dilks, Jr. Charles E. Dillon John L. Dolphin John F. A. Earley Paul M. Eyster Joseph B. Farrell Jay S. Fichtner John J. Galbally Sidney Ginsberg Martin S. Goodman Joseph K. Gordon Oliver F. Green, Jr. Francis B. Haas, Jr. Gerald J. Haas John P. Hauch , Jr. George J . Hauptfuhrer, Jr. John F. Healy Leon C. Holt, Jr. Henry M. Irwin David Kittner Robert L. Leininger Herbert M. Linsenberg Jerome Lipman John H. McKeever Edward B. Meredith Mrs. Regina Haig Meredith George J. Miller Donald G. Oyler James C. N. Paul James H. Peters Louis C . Pulvermacher Francis H. Pykon David M. Satz, Jr. Joseph J. Savitz Henry G. Schaefer, Jr. Edward M. Seletz J. Marlin Shreiner Robert M. Smith John D. Smyers Thomas J. Sullivan William F. Trapnell Robert S. Trigg Thomas A. Walrath Richard H. Warren

CLASS OF 1952

Joseph P. Flanagan, Jr., Agent

Number Giving Per Cent Giving Amount Saul P. Baker John G. Bartol, Jr. Robert F. Blanck

44 36

$1 ,387.50

Mrs. Juliet T. Brace John P. Chandler Ira B. Coldren, Jr. John P. Connors George H. Conover, Jr. B. Patrick Costello Clive S. Cummis Frank S. Deming Allen I. Dublin JohnS. Fisher, 2nd Edward L. Flaherty, Jr. Joseph P. Flanagan, Jr. Kiefer N. Gerstley

Fall 1966

Maxwell P. Gorson Robert S. Hass Richard A. Huettner Alvin J. Ivers Robert M. Johnson George B. Kaiser William A. Kelley, Jr. Allan M. Kluger Benjamin Kuby Edwin R. Lowry William J. Lubic Edward W. Madeira, Jr. Thomas A. Masterson Anthony S. Minisi Casper W. Morris, Jr. Marion D. Patterson, Jr. Benjamin F. Schweyer Jules Silk Jack Sirott George V. Strong, Jr. Walter I. Summerfield, Jr. John T. Synnestvedt William J. Taylor Robert E. Wachs Seymour C. Wagner Murry J. Waldman Seth W. Watson , Jr. Mintern T. Wright. 3rd

CLASS OF 1953

Leonard Barkan , Agent Number Giving 56

42 $1,427.00

Per Cent Giving Amount John T . Acton Miss Margaret P. Allen Vincent J. Apruzzese Leonard Barkan Walter L. Bartholomew, Jr. Richard A. Bausher Frederick T. Bebbington Don B. Blenko Jack Brian Mitchell Brock James S. Cafiero Mrs. Elizabeth Hill Carson Gordon Cavanaugh William F. Chester, Jr. Lee F. Driscoll, Jr. Albert J. Feldman Louis S. Fine A. Theodore Flum Joseph H. Foster John C. Garner G. Taylor Hess James R. Hornick Edward H. Huss Bernard M. Kimmel John P. Knox Louis E. Levy Henry C. Maiale Donald R. McKay Ellis H. McKay William J. McLaughlin, III William E. Mikell George A. Moore, Jr. Edgar E. Moss, 2nd Ronald B. Myrter Roderick G. Norris C. Lee Nutt, 3rd Thomas N. O'Neill , Jr. Stanley M. Poplow Samuel F. Pryor, 3rd Irwin E. Robinson David N. Savitt William B. Scatchard, Jr. Richard B. Smith Arthur R. G. Solmssen Alan M. Spector George A. Spohrer

Stanley P. Stern Donald P. Vernon William W. Vogel David E. Wagoner Sheldon M. Weiss C. Norwood Wherry S. Donald Wiley Karl E. Wolf William A. Wyatt George C. Xakellis

CLASS OF 1954 Morris M. Shuster, Agent Number Giving 38 Per Cent Giving 41 Amount $875 .00 Paul C. Astor Jerome R. Balka Edward J . Blake Stanley W. Bluestine F loyd E. Brandow, Jr. Aims C. Coney, Jr. Chester T. Cyzio Carl A. Frahn Marvin Garfinkel William L. Glosser Manuel H . Greenberg Lt. Col. Bennet N. Hollander Merton E. Jones Ralph V. Jones Richard J. Jordan Richard H. Knox Samuel M. Lehrer S. Gerald Litvin James P. Markle Albert F. McGee, Jr. Henry C. McGrath Murray Milkman Gerald J. Mongelli Mrs. Melva Long Mueller Lloyd I. Paperno Michael J. Piarulli Willi am J. Purcell Pace Reich Raymond C. Schlegel Robert Montgomery Scott David Seliger Morris M. Shuster Barry R. Spiegel James F. Swartz William Thatcher Willi am A. Whiteside, Jr. Mrs. Joan P. Wohl Edward A. Woolley

CLASS OF 1955 Irving M. Hirsh, Agent Robert L. Kendall, Agent Number Giving 47 Per Cent Giving 46 Amount $1,190.00 Philip E. Berens Thomas J. Calnan, Jr. Joel C. Coleman James R. Cooper Samuel Diamond Christian E. Erb, Jr. Milton A. Feldman Stephen M. Feldman William Goichman David J. Goldberg Bernard J. Goodheart Manuel Grife David C. Harrison Charles A. Harvey Donald R. Haws Robert L. Hesse Memory of W. Hensel

Brown, Jr. James M. Howley

W. Scott Johns, 3rd David J . Kaufman Robert L. Kendall, Jr. Norman M. Kranzdorf Edwin Krawitz Charles D. Lemmond, Jr. Arthur Levy John P. Mason Arthur H. Moss Paul A. Mueller, Jr. Bertram S. Murphy Joseph V. Reaph, Jr. S. White Rhyne, Jr. Angus M. Russell Henry S. Ruth, Jr. Hon. Ralph F. Scalera Murray M. Schwartz Hon. William T. Shea Harry A. Short Edward L. Snitzer Alvin L. Snowiss Joseph H. Stanziani Leonard Sugarman D. Charles Valsing Joel H. Weinrott 1\f ervin M. Wilf Alfred T. Williams , Jr . Barry B. Wohlman Norman P. Zarwin

CLASS OF 1956 Alan G. Kirk, IT. Agent Carl W. Schneider. Agent Number Giving 53 Per Cent Giving 42 Amount $1 ,025.50 Herbert J. Abedon Harry D . Ambrose, Jr. Louis D. Apothaker Edward F. Beatty , Jr. Robert M. Beckman George L. Bernstein Donald K. Bobb Richard L. Bond Hugh P. Connell Paul C . Dewey Angelo A. Di Pasqua John A. Erickson Richard H. Floum Leon H. Fox, Jr. A. Fred Freedman Isaac S. Garb J. Barton Harrison HermanS. Harvey. Jr. Jerome H. Harwitz Samuel L. Hirshland Richard V. Holmes Seymour Kanter Alan G. Kirk , II Miss Dolores Korman Ronald I. Kravitz George J. Lavin , Jr. Arthur W. Leibold, Jr. Charles F. Ludwig Richard L. McMahon George H. McNeely, HI Mrs. Mercea Panfil Mears James W. Moore Milton 0. Moss Robert Neustadter Harris Ominsky Edmund S. Pawelec Charles K. Plotnick Mrs. G. Woodward

Ponomareff Curtis R. Reitz John S. Schmid Carl W. Schneider Leonard S. Slavit Donn P. Slonim Dominic P. Toscani

15

John A. Vuono John M. Wajert Howard A. Wiener Robert J. Williams Norman M. Wilson, Jr. Vincent X. Yakowicz Robert K. Young Wray G. Zeit, 3rd Mrs. Barbara Kron

Zimmerman

CLASS OF 1957 Richard G. Schneider, Agent

Number Giving 55 Per Cent Giving 55 Amount $1,026.50 Alvin S. Ackerman Maurice Axelrad John E. Backenstoe William M. Barnes Daniel B. Brandschain Isaac H. Clothier Robert S. Cohen Memory of Judge Gerald F.

Flood Michael M. Dean Nicodemo De Gregorio James N. Diefenderfer Charles M. Farbstein Mrs. Patricia H. Frankel Mahlon M. Frankhauser Gerald P. Garson Samuel L. Glantz Robert E. Glaymon Larry J. Goldsborough George C. Greer Ronald H. Isenberg Gerald E. Kandler John 0. Karns Richard Kirschner Goncer M. Krestal Seymour Kurland William W. Lanigan Charles H. Laveson William G. Malkames James F. McClure, Jr. Stephen J. McEwen, Jr. Hon. Thomas C. McGrath,

Jr. Edward M. Medvene Joseph S. Moloznik Jerrold V. Moss James M. Mulligan D. Frederick Muth Jay G. Ochroch Russell R. Reno, Jr. Thomas B. K. Ringe, Jr. Richard M. Rosenbleeth Edward E. Russell Joseph W. Salus Richard G. Schneider Raymond Schwartz J. Earl Simmons, Jr. Mrs. Ellen P. Queeney Suria John R. Suria Myles H. Tanenbaum Michael L. Temin Parke H. Ulrich, Jr. E. Norman Veasey Ronald P. Wertheim Hardy Williams Fred B. Ziesenheim Simon R. Zimmerman

CLASS OF 1958

George B. McNellis, Agent Number Giving 66 Per Cent Giving 51 Amount $1,236.00

16

Irwin Albert Duffield Ashmead, 3rd Bennett I. Bardfeld Albert R. Beal Harold J. Berger S. David Brandt A. Balfour Brehman, Jr. John Harold Brydon Benjamin E. Carter Martin Cohen Philip Cohen Joseph A. Damico, Jr. Martin S. Evelev J. Harold Flannery, Jr. Michael V. Franciosa Stanley Frank Philip R. Frieder Jacques H. Geisenberger, Jr. Arthur T. Gillespie, Jr. Howard Gittis Melvin D. Glass Louis Goldhirsh Sidney R. Granite Ives Grappotte Richard T. Gross Bernard M. Guth John G. Harkins, Jr. Henry R. Heebner, Jr. I. Leonard Hoffman Raymond L. Hovis Baron E. Kessler Harry A. Kitey William G. Klenk, 2nd Charles F. Knapp George D. Knapp Michael G. Kurcias John P. Leemhuis Harvey Levin Stephen E. Levin Willard D. Lorensen James A. Loughran Alan W. Margolis John P. McKenna, Jr. George B. McNellis Milo G. Miller, 3rd T. Weldon Monteith, Jr. Ramon R. Obod Michael A. Orlando, 3rd Robert L. Pfannebecker John W. Roberts Littleton W. Roberts, Jr. Ronald R. Rosenberg Mortimer D. Rubin John J. Runzer John F. Salisbury Joseph H. Savitz Allan B. Schneirov Edwin W. Semans, Jr. David J. Steinberg Richard W. Stevens Louis G. Tarantino, Jr. Friedrich J. Weinkopf Marvin Weiss William H. Wolf, Jr. Elliott Yampell Robert H. Zimmerman

CLASS OF 1959

Joseph Beller, Agent Number Giving 51

33 $1 ,062.00

Per Cent Giving Amount Alan I. Aberman Louis J. Adler L. Carter Anderson Donald Beckman Sanford D. Beecher, Jr. Joseph Beller Paul E. Bomze John W. Brock, Jr.

Gerald Broker H. Donald Busch Richard L. Cantor Philip Cherry Jonathan S. Cohen William Congreve, 3rd Thomas S. Conlon Wallace P. Cooney George C. Corson, Jr. Murray S. Eckell J. Earl Epstein William J. Geen Murray C. Goldman Arthur R. Gorr August E. Grashof Bernard M. Gross Henry G. Hager, 3rd Jack G. Handler JohnS. Hayes Selwyn A. Horvitz John R. Rudders Samuel H. Karsch Lewis Kates Albert W. Laisy William T. Lynam, 3rd Thomas B. Moorhead John C. Mueller Allen 0. Olin Herbert L. Olivieri Martin B. Pitkow George F. Reed Jack A. Rounick Marshall A. Rutter Boris Shapiro Allen P. Silverman Oscar F. Spicer Alan R. Squires Joseph F. Strain Louis M. Tarasi, Jr. Ira P. Tiger David R. Tomb, Jr. Herbert A. Vogel John D. Wilson

CLASS OF 1960

John F. Dugan, II, Agent Number Giving 54 Per Cent Giving 47 Amount $902.50 Anthony G. Amsterdam Edward L. Batoff Michael Bernstein Anthony J. Caiazzo Ralph H. Clover Edward I. Dobin John F. Dugan, II Frank Federman Melvin S. Feldman Mrs. Ruth M. Ferrell Miss Cherie A. Gaines Lewis J. Gordon Frank E. Greenberg Robert J. Hastings Edmund G. Hauff Charles A. Heimbold, Jr. John H. Higgs Edward Hoopes, 4th Richard S. Hyland E. Glenn Isaacson John R. Jakubowski Allan Katz Mark K. Kessler Charles G. Kopp Gerald G. Kramer Randall D. Luke James P. MacLean, 3rd Robert A. Miller Samuel W. Newman Benjamin S. Ohrenstein Robert E. Penn

Samuel J. Reich Richard D. Rivers Edward Robin George F. Robinson Samuel W. Salus, 2nd C. Zachary Seltzer David E. Seymour David S. Shrager William C. Smith Edwin L. Solot Silas Spengler Lowell S. Thomas, Jr. Thomas T. Trettis, Jr. Nicholas Vadino, Jr. Michael F. Walsh Joseph T. Vodnoy Charles M. Weisman Alvin M. Weiss Michael J. Wherry David L. Williams Marvin M. Wodlinger Frederick D. Wood Ronald Ziegler

CLASS OF 1961 Raymond K. Denworth, Jr.,

Agent Number Giving 57 Per Cent Giving 51 Amount $943.00 Benjamin R. Achenbach Edward N. Adourian, Jr. James H. Agger Paul K. Allison Paul R. Anapol Lewis Becker Alan Cooper Lawrence F. Corson Raymond K. Denworth, Jr. Jack Emas Arthur J. England, Jr. Mrs. Ruth Morris Force Michael D. Foxman Fredric J. Freed Robert A. Freedman Bernard Glassman Rayner M. Hamilton Mrs. Ann Epstein Harrison James N. Horwood Howard M. Jaffe Edward L. Jones, Jr. Anthony L. Joseph Malcolm B. Kane Charles K. Keil Daniel M. Kristol Lewis S. Kunkel, Jr. Kenneth H. Lang Herbert W. Larson Henry W. Lavine Anthony S. Leidner Paul G. Levy Wilfred F. Lorry Donald M. Maclay William B. Moyer Spencer G. Nauman, Jr. David F. Norcross William B. Pennell Frederick D. Pettit Ronald Pinsky Paul B. Pollack Arthur D. Rabelow David B. Randall Robert A. Rosin Patrick J. Salve Robert J. Sann James M. Scanlon William R. Shane Robert M. Shay Anthony J. Sobczak A. Grant Sprecher David L. Steck

LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL

Marc L. Swartzbaugh Harold B. Wells, 3rd David H. Wheeler Lawrence E. Wood Roger S. Young Edward K. Zuckerman

CLASS OF 1962

E. Barclay Cale, Jr., Agent Number Giving 90 Per Cent Giving 71 Amount $1,039.00

Milton D. Abowitz Richard D. Atkins Paul Auerbach Mrs. A. Cafiero Balliette William Balliette, Jr. Joseph F. Battle, Jr. Leigh W. Bauer William M. Baumgartner Frank C. Bender Martin M. Berliner Mrs. B. Petchenik Berman Richard R. Block Stuart S. Bowie R. David Bradley Jonas Brodie Earl E. Brosius Donald Q. Bunker Phillip R. Burnaman E. Barclay Cale, Jr. William B. Christy, 4th R. Wayne Clemens Robert B. Cohen Alfred W. Cortese, Jr. James D. Crawford Kenneth M. Cushman William J. Dale Mrs. Judith Norvick Dean George C. Decas Richard D. Ehrlich Alexander Endy Burton H . Finkelstein NickS. Fisfis Joel P. Fishbein Frederick J. Francis Joel Friedman Robert F. Y. Garrett, 3rd Bernard R. Gerber John E. Gillmor Francis E. N. Gleeson Donald F. U. Goebert Herbert Goldfeld Gersham Goldstein Stephen R. Goldstein Harold Greenberg Gerald E. Haughey Martin G. Heckler John A. Herdeg Heinz K. Hintermann Burton Hoffman Jerome A. Hoffman Paul D. Horger Garry Hyatt Steven D. Ivins David M. Jones Warren J. Kauffman John P. Kelley Edmond M. Kirby Jerold G. Kievit Daniel J . Lawler Larry Lefkowitz Edward J. Lewis David P. Loughran Spencer A. Manthorpe Robert W. Maris Edwin S. Moore, 3rd Stephen J. Moses Alexander Neave Stephen L. Newnham

Fall 1966

Hans C. Nolde Thomas P. Nugent PhilipS. Nyman Lewis F. Parker Robert M. Philson Alan J. Pogarsky Martin M. Pollock John H. Potts Charles B. Pursel David E. Rapoport Leigh S. Ratiner Robert M. Rowlands Alan E. Saltzman Miss Suzanne R. Schiffman Richard J. Sharkey M. Michael Sharlot Louis P. Silverman Edward D. Slevin Martin W. Spector Charles H. Thomas, Jr. Galen J. White, Jr. Arnold Zenker

CLASS OF 1963

John L. Harrison, Agent


William N. Appel Steven A. Arbittier David E. Auerbach David C. Auten

75 52

$849.00

Donald V. Berlanti Aaron D. Blumberg Harold Bogatz Joseph M. Bowman A. Richard Caputo Abraham J. Chasnoff Henry B. Cortesi Thomas F. Cunnane Morton F. Daller Nicholas P. Damico Mrs. Joanne R. Denworth Lowell H. Dubrow David M. Epstein Mrs. Myrna Paul Field Melvyn H. Freeman Nathan G. Ginsburg Edward M. Glickman Jay L. Goldberg Michael A. Grean Frederick P. Hafetz John L. Harrison, Jr. Harold Jacobs Richard I. G. Jones Arthur S. Karafin Morris C. Kellett Martin N. Kroll Robert Kruger Judah I. Labovitz John J. Langenbach Gerald M. Levin Arthur L. Levine Steven M. Lipschutz Robert C. Littman Thomas Lumbard Thomas F. Macaniff Arnold Machles David H. Marion Sidney G. Masri Francis G. Mays John H. McGrail Paul R. Melletz Henry F. Miller John R. Mondschein Joseph L. Monte, Jr. Louis H. Nevins Robert S. O'Hara, Jr. John W. Packel Robert J. Partlow

Earle J. Patterson, 3rd Thomas E. Quay Herbert Riband, Jr. Lt. J. Ashley Roach Mrs. Ruth B. Rosenberg Michael J. Rotko Michael J. Rutenberg Peter M. Ryan Peter C. Schwartz Charles A. Shaffer Stephen A. Sheller Max Spinrad Albert M. Stark Jonathan R. Steinberg Robert J. Stern David C. Toomey Michael D. Varbalow J. Kirkwood White Thomas R. White, 3rd Mrs. Faith Ryan Whittlesey Miss Susan P. Windle Edwin D. Wolf Stephen G. Yusem

CLASS OF 1964

William J. Levy, Agent


John T. Andrews, Jr. Richard A. Ash Steven T . Atkins Peter F. Axelrad

65 45

$824.00

Frank B. Baldwin, 3rd Michael M. Baylson George W. Bissell George C. Bradley Earl T. Britt Andrew B. Cantor Robert L. Coles Nicholas D. Constan, Jr. Stephen A. Cozen Mrs. Beryl Richman Dean David Dearborn Marshall A. Deutsch Neil K. Evans Peter A. Eveleth H. Robert Fiebach Eugene E. Pike, 2nd Lt. Dennis M. Flannery Michael 0. Floyd Michael H. Frankel Jra H. Freedman Robert A. Fuller Robert G. Fuller, Jr. John R. Gibbel L. Anthony Gibson Royal B. Giffen Henry A. Gladstone Oscar B. Goodman Richard J. Haber Cary R. Hardy HenryS. Rilles, Jr. James G. Hirsh George H. Jackson, 3rd Richard A. Jacoby John W. Jeffers William J. Levy Richard A Lippe Richard K. Mandell Michael M. Maney Charles M. Marshall Richard C. Montgomery Francis J. Murphy Samuel H. Nelson Bruce S. Nielsen Michael A. O'Pake Franz F. Opper Miss Marian R. Pearlman Paul D. Pearson

Mrs. Roselyn Prager Ramist Martin F. Robinson Christopher R. Rosser Melvyn B. Ruskin Herbert F. Schwartz Howard Shapiro Thomas A. Shumaker Henry R. Silverman Burton K. Stein Alan Steinberg James H. Stevens James A. Strazzella Peter C. Ward Richard D. Wood, 3rd

CLASS OF 1965

Harvey Bartle, III, Agent Number Giving 61 Per Cent Giving 41 Amount $503.00 Anthony P. Baratta, Jr. Harvey Bartle, III Anthony G. Bateman Robert E. Benson RobertS. Blank Harold P. Block Malcolm M. Blumberg George G. Breed Paul J. Bschorr Gurdon H. Buck Mrs. Lita Indzel Cohen Robert F. Dakin Albert L. Doering, 3rd Neil G. Epstein William H. Ewing Michael A. Feldman James A. Freyer Meritt B. Gavin Richard Gordimer Allan B. Greenwood David D. Hagstrom Gilbert W. Harrison Paul C. Heintz Gilbert P. High, Jr. Richard M. Horwood Stephen L. Hymowitz James W. Jennings James H. Johns, Jr. Richard F. Katz William M. Labkoff William H. Lamb Elias B. Landau Miss Raulette M. Lemay Alan M. Lerner Benjamin Lerner Albert L. Lingelbach James J. Martin William J. Morehouse Albert C. Oehrle, Jr. Morgan L. Pape Stephen W. Peters CarlS. Raub Harry E. Reagan, 3rd David F. Richardson Louis W. Ricker Rodman M. Rosenberger David P. Ross Joseph A. Ryan Blair L. Sadler Miss Natalie I. Salkind David N. Samson Sheldon N. Sandler Peter V. Savage Arthur R. Spector Harvey Steinberg Norman F. Strate, Jr. Welsh S. White John T. Williams Parker H. Wilson James A. Wimmer Frank L. Wright

17

SUMMARY OF REGIONS (Areas, other than Philadelphia, with 15 or more alumni)

Chairman-J. Pennington Straus, L'35

Region Chairman Cleveland, Ohio Henry W. Lavine, L'61 Lancaster County, Pa. Robert L. Pfannebecker, L'58 Atlantic City, N.J. Robert Neustadter, L'56 Lehigh County, Pa. Emanuel G. Scoblionko, L'34 Delaware County, Pa. Guy G. deFuria, L'28

Melvin G. Levy, L'50 Chester County, Pa. Thomas R. Butler, L'39 San Francisco, Calif. Ronald Pinsky, L'61 Camden, N.J. William F . Hyland, L'49 Northampton County, Pa. John C. Hambrook, L'47 Burlington County, N.J. Edward N. Adourian, Jr., L'61 Wilmington, Del. Herbert W. Larson, L'61 Washington, D.C. Charles B. Ruttenberg, L'49 Allegheny County, Pa. George J. Miller, L'51 Chicago, Ill. Richard J. Farrell, L'41 New York, N.Y. Richard M. Dicke, L'40 York County, Pa. SamuelS. Loucks, L'42 Los Angeles, Calif. Marshall A. Rutter, L'59 Trenton, N.J. Edward B. Meredith, L'51 Luzerne County, Pa. Andrew Hourigan, Jr. , L'40 Lackawanna County, Pa. James W. Scanlon, L'30 Montgomery County, Pa. Victor J. Roberts, L'37 Dauphin County, Pa. Francis B. Haas, Jr., L'51 Berks County, Pa. Richard T. Williamson, L'35 Boston, Mass. Philip G. Nyman, L'62 Schuylkill County, Pa. Calvin J. Friedberg, L'35 Bucks County, Pa. Charles M. Marshall , L'64 Erie County, Pa. Mortimer E. Graham, L'25

Totals

Burgess Urges Higher Alumni Participation in Annual Giving

In the last ten years of Law School Alumni Annual Giving, the number of contributors has almost doubled, and the amount contributed has more than tripled. Yet the percentage of alumni contributing has risen by only about 15 percentage points and stands this year at a high of 43 % .

Even a modest gain in the number of alumni contributing, to the point where a majority of Law School alumni were participating in Annual Giving, would bring significant gains for the Law School. For example, if 53% of the alumni (instead of 43% ) had given the average gift of $52 last year, the result would have been an additional $25,000.

Edwin H. Burgess, '14, General Chairman for the Law School Annual Giving program, points out that, "Although we all face the problem of choosing among a multitude of fund-raising appeals, the Law School should have one of the prime claims for a contribution. Think of the library books, student aid, and research materials that the additional $25 ,000 could provide!" He urges all alumni to include the Law School as one of their philanthropies.

18

No. Per Cent of No. of Partici- Participation Amount Alumni pating 1965-66 1964-65 1965-66 1964-65

17 13 77 69 $ 200 $ 190 43 28 65 58 1,527 1,510 42 26 62 55 1,186 430 54 33 61 54 1,165 1,200

118 71 60 50 7,644 5,546

66 34 52 71 2,096 1,594 20 10 50 38 187 285 95 46 49 43 2,656 1,712 42 20 48 45 890 670 33 15 46 37 365 235 72 33 46 54 785 947

172 78 45 49 2,843 1,987 73 33 45 27 1,305 675 16 7 44 37 505 275

367 157 43 39 7,843 5,642 21 9 43 35 385 355 40 16 40 45 975 753 39 15 38 48 295 354 69 26 38 31 2,954 811 49 18 37 33 812 725

216 79 37 33 2,658 4,442 52 18 35 35 398 715 55 18 33 29 471 601 32 10 32 45 140 100 22 7 32 20 471 220 67 20 30 40 743 787 30 6 20 38 160 401

1922 845 44% 42% $41,659 $33,162

ABOVE AVERAGE These Regions Equalled or Bettered the Over-all

Alumni Participation of 43%:

Region Chairman Per Cent Cleveland, Ohio Henry W. Lavine, L'61 77 Lancaster County, Pa. Robert L. Pfannebecker, L'58 65 Atlantic City, N.J. Robert Neustadter, L'56 62 Lehigh County, Pa. Emanuel G. Scoblionko, L'34 61 Delaware County, Pa. Guy G. deFuria, L'28

Melvin G. Levy, L'50 60 Chester County, Pa . Thomas R. Butler, L'39 52 San Francisco, Calif. Ronald Pinsky, L'61 50 Camden, N.J. William F. Hyland, L'49 49 Northampton County, Pa. John C. Hambrook, L'47 48 Burlington County, N.J. Edward N. Adourian, Jr., L'61 46 Wilmington, Del. Herbert W. Larson, L'61 46 Washington, D.C. Charles B. Ruttenberg, L'49F 45 Allegheny County, Pa. George J. Miller, L'51 45 Chicago, Ill. Richard J. Farrell, L'41 44 New York, N.Y. Richard M. Dicke, L'40 43 York County, Pa. SamuelS. Loucks, L'42 43

LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL

ALUMNI ANNUAL GIVING FOR 1966-1967 LAUNCHED AT LUNCHEON

. The Law School Alumni Annual Giving Cam-paign got off to an enthusiastic start on Saturday, October 22 at a meeting and luncheon in the Law School. About 60 alumni and guests visited the Law School for the occasion. The event concluded with the PennsylvaniaPrinceton football game.

Edwin H . Burgess, '14, General Chairman reported on the outstanding success of last year's campaign when the Law School exceeded $100 000 in Annual Giving for the first time, and reached' a new high of $102,124. He also indicated that these unrestricted funds were being allocated in varying amounts to strengthen faculty and student research, the Law Review, student aid, the library, and alumni relations. He reminded those present that these and other contingencies cannot be supported adequately within the general University budgetary framework.

Mr. Burgess announced that the goal for this year had been set at $115,000, which is an increase of about 1~% and about equ~I to what was realized last year. He satd that an equally Important goal for this year was to have 50% or more of the alumni participate in Annual Giving. Last year this reached a high of 43%.

Mr. Burgess also said that he was delighted to be able to announce that the same fine leadership team had conse~ted to serve for another year including, with a few exceptwns, Class Agents and Regional Chairmen. The Vic~ Chairmen for this year are: Morris M. Wexler, '27, Chairman for Benjamin Franklin Associates; Louis J . Goffman, '35 , Chairman for the Century Club; Milton B: Garner, '36, Chairman for Class Agents, and J. Penmngton Straus, '35 , Chairman for Regional Chairmen.

At the luncheon in Horace Stern Hall following the business session, Mr. Burgess presented the Class Performance Awards to the following Class Agents: Herman I. Pollock, '27, Greatest Number of Dollars Contributed; E. Barclay Cale, '62, Best Per Cent of Participation (classes of 25 or more); William I. Woodcock, Jr., '21 , Best Per Cent of Participation (classes of less than 25); E. Barclay Cale, '62, Greatest Number of Contributors . Dean Fordham then thanked those present for their efforts on behalf of the Law School and presented the General Chairman and Vice Chairmen with tokens of appreciation for their devotion and assistance.

Students from Broader Geographic Area . Although the first year class is composed pri

marily of students from the eastern seaboard, in recent years there has been a broader geographic spread particularly illustrated by the fact that a lower percentage of students come from Pennsylvania. Dean of Admissions, William R. Shane, '61, pointed out that this year 31 % of the first year class are residents of Pennsylvania last year 39% were and, as recently as 1964, 45% wer~ from Pennsylvania.

Fall 1966

Edwin H. Burgess, '14, and Dean Fordham discuss Annual Giving.

GOWEN FELLOWS STUDY HERE AND ABROAD

There are three Law School graduates to whom Gowen Fellowships have been awarded for the current academic year. Robert P. Lawry, '66, is studying jurisprudence at Cambridge University this year, and William Onorato, '64, is also at Cambridge University for the second year-his fellowship having been renewed for this year. He is studying international law. Joseph Elmaleh, '52, working on applications of computer technology in law research , has also had his fellowship renewed and he is again using it at the Moore School of Electrical Engineering.

Gowen grants vary in amount from $2000 to $5000 annually depending on such factors as marital status, tuition, travel expenses, etc. The Graduate Committee again welcomes applications for Gowen Fellowships from any alumni. They are only available to graduates of the Law School and are available for study either here or abroad.

A birdseye view of graduation exercises May 23 , 1966.

19

HISTORIC ANTIQUE DESK IN LAW SCHOOL

The handsome breakfront desk pictured above which is now in Dean Fordham's office was originally owned by James Wilson, the first Professor of Law at the University of Pennsylvania. James Alan Montgomery, Jr., '28, presented it to the school in 1944.

On the death of James Wilson, the desk descended to his son, the Reverend Professor Bird Wilson of the General Theological Seminary, who had also been a federal judge in Pennsylvania. From him it passed to his niece, the granddaughter of James Wilson, Miss Emily Hollingsworth. She bequeathed it to Thomas H. Montgomery. From him it passed to his youngest daughter, Emily Hollingsworth Montgomery, who gave it by her will to her nephew, James Alan Montgomery, Jr.

20

WALTER ALESSANDRONI FUND STARTED

The Class of 1938 has started a fund to honor the memory of their classmate, Pennsylvania Attorney General Walter Alessandroni, who lost his life in an airplane accident. A substantial amount has already been contributed by classmates and others including Governor Scranton. The funds will be used to provide an appropriate memorial at the Law School. Sylvan Cohen is in charge of this project.

Law School to Be Host for Trial Judges College

The National College of State Trial Judges which provides training courses for the newly elected or appointed state trial judges will start giving sessions in the East next summer. The Law School will serve as the first host school, Harvard will be the site for the session in 1968, and the third session will be held at the University of North Carolina in 1969. A grant of $174,000 from the W. K. Kellog Foundation will finance this three-year extension of the program.

Alumni Play Key Roles in New Free Legal Program

Philadelphia established a non-profit corporation, Community Legal Services, Inc., to administer the federally financed program of free legal services to the poor. A grant of three-quarters of a million dollars was made by the Office of Economic Opportunity to finance the program. Robert M. Landis, '47, Robert V. Massey, Jr., '31, Francis Hopkinson, '40, and City Controller Alexander Hemphill, '49F, are members of the Board of Trustees. Henry T. Reath, '48, is one of four Philadelphia Bar Association appointees to the Board of Trustees. Professor Robert H. Mundheim is also a trustee. Herman I. Pollock, '27, chief of the Defender Association, will be in charge of the criminal division of the program.

Schwartz Authority for Word Usage

The compilers of Webster's Third New International Dictionary, Third Edition, in carrying out their policy that "a definition, to be adequate, must be written only after an analysis of usage" have quoted and cited Professor Louis B. Schwartz, '35 , in connection with the definition of the word "expertise." The example of usage given for the first definition of "expertise," "expert opinion or commentary," is "is there an (expertise) on the question of the relative importance of preserving competition which should induce judges to defer to commissioners? L. B. Schwartz" at page 800.

LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL

Conference on Mutual Funds Planned for February Following publication of the exhaustive report on

mutual funds soon to be issued by the Securities and Exchange Commission, a major two-day Conference on Mutual Funds is planned for consideration of that report on February 8 and 9 under the combined auspices of the Law School and the Joint Committee on Continuing Legal Education of the American Law Institute and the American Bar Association. Professor Robert H. Mundheim, who was formerly Associate Special Counsel to the SEC on Investment Company Matters, and who, in that capacity, spent a year and a half working on this report, is arranging the Conference. It will consist of four morning and afternoon panel discussions to be held in the auditorium of the Annenberg School of Communications. There may be additional smaller meetings held on Saturday morning, February 10.

The Wharton School was commissioned by the SEC to make a comprehensive study of the effect of size on mutual funds and on the securities market. Professor Irwin Friend, who will be a panelist at the Conference, directed the study. That report was issued in 1962. The SEC then began to work on its report. The Office of the Special Counsel to the Commission on Investment Matters was organized to analyze and assess the conclusions of the Wharton report and to determine what changes in legislation or rules might be desirable.

The Conference will focus on the regulatory problems presented by this 35 billion dollar industry. The first panel on Thursday morning, February 8, will analyze the regulatory implications of selected aspects of the economic impact of mutual fund activities-for example, do the new breed of performance funds accentuate price movements in an undesirable way; can the large mutual fund complexes retain sufficient flexibility in their portfolio to permit them to claim that they provide investment management? On Thursday afternoon another panel will discuss management fees and the structure characteristic of the mutual fund industry under which the investment adviser and the principal underwriter of the fund are closely affiliated with fund management. Friday's discussion will relate to the financing of fund share sales . These panels will include discussion of the size of sales loads, the contractual plan method of selling fund shares, reciprocal business practices, and the retail price maintenance structure characteristic of the mutual fund industry.

In the hope of stimulating a dialogue between the SEC and the mutual fund industry, each panel will consist of representatives both from the industry and the SEC. There will be top level representatives from the leading mutual funds in the country, and SEC representatives will include Commissioner Francis M. Wheat, Philip A. Loomis, Jr. , General Counsel of the SEC, and Richard M. Phillips, Esq .. who has had the major responsibility for drafting the report.

The panels will also include practicing lawyers such as Alfred Jaretzki , Jr., a senior partner in the New

Fall 1966

York law firm of Sullivan and Cromwell, who was one of the principal draftsmen of the present Investment Company Act; Abraham L. Pomerantz, of the New York law firm of Pomerantz, Levy, Haudek and Block, who has conducted extensive litigation challenging fee structures of mutual funds; Gordon D. Henderson, now a partner in the New York law firm of Root, Barrett, Cohen, Knapp and Smith, who had previously been Special Counsel on Investment Company Act Matters to the SEC; and Allan F . Conwill , partner in the New York law firm of Willkie, Parr, Gallagher, Walton and Fitzgibbon, who was Director of Corporate Regulation at the SEC at the inception of this report.

As mentioned above, Professor Friend, of the Wharton School, will also be a panel member. Professor Mundheim will moderate all of the panel discussions.

All those interested in this subject are welcome to register for the sessions. Attendance, however, will be limited and applications will be accepted in order of their arrival. There will be a charge of $75. Luncheons will be served at the Law School, and there will be a dinner Thursday night, February 8, at the University Museum for those attending the Conference. Further details of the program will be announced in November.

PROFESSOR OLIVER continued from page 3

and hence sees us as defending a system which is to him unpalatable for its erroneously assumed extreme laissezfaire approach.

On the economic front, Professor Oliver does not want to see the Alliance for Progress stalled "at the banker's level," i.e., mere monetary and fiscal stabilization. Real development of the country requires changing and improving institutions within a country, and Professor Oliver intends to direct his efforts toward encouraging a "new stage of the Alliance." Professor Oliver points out that experience now shows that just increasing the gross national product does not result in an immediate improvement in everyone's lot-there is no "instant trickle down." Achieving the needed changes may require new legislative bases for the Alliance for Progress here and in the developing countries-new laws that will permit us to assist in institutional changes brought about by related new law in the developing countries.

In the fall term Professor Oliver is teaching courses in International Law and Admiralty. In the spring semester, he will offer Conflict of Laws and International Transactions Practice. The last of these is the course that most closely relates to his Ambassadorial experiences.

RE: LAW ALUMNI TIE The handsome navy blue silk tie (with an all

over pattern of the Law Alumni Society wig and gavel insignia in red and white) is still available through the Law School by mail order. Price $5.00.

21

ALUMNI MEET IN MONTREAL

Section of head table at luncheon in Montreal: (l. tor.) Robert Dechert, '21, Trustee of the University of Pennsylvania; Robert L. Trescher, '37, Trustee of the University of Pennsylvania, Dean Jefferson B. Fordham; Carroll R. Wetzel, '30, president of the Law Alumni Society; and Harold Cramer, '51, vice president of the Law Alumni Society.

The Law Alumni Society sponsored its annual luncheon during the American Bar Association meeting in Montreal on August 10. Seventy-five alumni and guests attended. Carroll R. Wetzel, '30, Law Alumni Society President, acted as toastmaster. Dean Jefferson B. Fordham told about various Law School activities including the problems encountered in getting the renovation of the old building under way.

(Plan now to join fellow alumni at the luncheon to be given during the American Bar Association's meeting in Hawaii next year.)

LOCAL ALUMNI HOLD MEETINGS

Herbert W. Larson, '61, arranged for the third annual alumni dinner held by the Wilmington, Delaware alumni group in April. Professor John 0. Honnold was the guest speaker on this enjoyable occasion.

The Southern New Jersey Alumni also held their alumni dinner in April. James P. MacLean, III, '60, headed the committee on arrangements. The Honorable W. Orvyl Schalick of the Superior Court of New Jersey and Dean Jefferson B. Fordham were the principal speakers at this successful and well-attended meeting held at the Cherry Hill Inn.

The New Jersey alumni give an annual luncheon at the conclusion of the New Jersey Bar Association's Annual Meeting. This year a large turnout came to hear Professor Noyes E. Leech, '48 , discuss the legal problems involved in the VietNam war. Daniel DeBrier, '29, made the arrangements for and acted as toastmaster for this occasion.

The Washington Area Alumni hold their annual luncheon at the time the American Law Institute meets. The guest speakers on this occasion in May, 1966 were Dean Fordham and Manuel F. Cohen, Chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission . Solomon Freedman, '34, President of the Washington Law Alumni Association, acted as toastmaster. Charles B. Ruttenberg, '49, handled the arrangements for this genial occasion.

22

ALUMNI 1899

MARCUS S. HoTTENSTEIN, of New York City, celebrated his 90th birthday in August. In 1943 Muhlenberg College awarded him an honorary Doctor of Laws degree.

1923 HoN. E. ARNOLD FoRREST, of Penn Valley, Pa. , President Judge of Montgomery County Court, has retired as of September 30 for reasons of health after seventeen years on the bench.

1928 FRANKLIN H. BERRY, of Toms River, N. J., is the new President of the New Jersey State Bar Association.

1931 HoN. AUGUSTINE REPETTO, of Atlantic City, N. J. , was appointed a judge in the Atlantic County Court. He was Prosecuting Attorney for Atlantic County prior to his appointment.

BERNARD G. SEGAL was awarded an honorary Doctor of Laws degree by Dropsie College.

1933 GusTAVE G. AMSTERDAM will receive the 1966 National Human Relations Award of the National Conference of Christians and Jews at that organization's annual banquet on December 1.

1935 J. PENNINGTON STRAUS was elected president of the James Wilson Law Club Alumni Association.

1936 FRANK ZAL, Arbitration Commissioner in the City of Philadelphia, is national president of Brith Sholom.

1937 MARGARET L. MYERS was recently made president of Penn Steel Castings Company. She had formerly been executive vice president and treasurer of the company.

1939 LEROY S. MAXWELL, of Waynesboro, Pa. , was elected vice president of the Franklin County Bar Association.

1943 PERCH HANKIN was honored in June at a testimonial dinner in recognition of his untiring efforts in the development of the Willow Grove area. The gala dinner dance attended by more than 500 guests was held in the Bellevue-Stratford Hotel in Philadelphia.

1949 FRANCIS J. CAREY, JR. , of Spring House, Pa., has been elected president of the Board of Trustees of Germantown Academy. He has been a member of the Board since 1961.

LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL

NOTES RoBERT W. LEES has been named chairman of a new committee of the Philadelphia Bar Association organized to investigate unethical practices by lawyers in all fields of law. The panel of fourteen members will also study the adequacy of existing legislation in this area, the Canons of Ethics, and the regulatory machinery within the association.

1951 RICHARDS. DENNY, of Fairmount. N.J., has been elected secretary and assistant general counsel of Bankers Trust Company inN. Y.

JoHNS. RENNINGER, of Newtown, Pa., is a member of the Pennsylvania House of Representatives representing a district in Bucks County.

1955 FRANK M. CoLLINS is vice president and trust officer of the Continental Bank and Trust Company in Norristown, Pa.

IRVING M. HIRSH, of Plainfield, N. J., is now a partner in the law firm of Lyness, Bedell & Hirsh.

1956 HuGH P. CoNNELL is now General Counsel for the J. Walter Thompson Company in New York.

THEODORE S. DANFORTH is head of the Lancaster County Public Defender Office in addition to his general practice.

LEONARD ETz, of Trenton, N. J., is president of New Jersey Codes, a municipal ordinance revision service corporation. He is also chairman of the Section of Municipal and School Law of the New Jersey State Bar Association.

HoN. IsAACS. GARB, of Yardley, Pa., was recently named to the Bucks County Common Pleas Court by Governor Scranton.

1966 RoGER GoLDMAN will spend one year working with the District of Columbia Juvenile Court as a VISTA Volunteer.

Fall 1966

ALUMNI SONS IN CLASS OF 1969 The following alumni have sons in the current first year class:

James Summers Doak James Yard Garrett

James Burney Doak '35 Sylvester S. Garrett '36 Robert C. Koury '41 David M. Perskie '37 Harold S. Soltman '32 Frederick VanDenbergh '37

Peter Lawrence Koury, Stephen P. Perskie Nelson Arnold Soltman Ross Van Denbergh

FIFTIETH ANNUAL REUNION HELD The Class of 1916 celebrated its 50th Anniver

sary at a dinner on June 8, 1966 at The Barclay in Philadelphia. It was the intention of the class to honor one of its classmates-Ron. Thomas M. Lewis, who recently retired after eighteen years service as a Judge of the Court of Common Pleas of Luzerne County, Pennsylvania. Unfortunately, his illness prevented his attendance.

The class has had at least one reunion each year since its graduation and many of the class have come from distant cities. Hon. Francis Shunk Brown, Jr., President of the class since 1916, presided. Joseph L. Ehrenreich, Martin Feldman, Harry Feinstein, Albert J. Fleming, David L. German, Jr., Harry Gottlieb, Benjamin M. Kline, James F. McClure, Samuel Moyerman, Howard I. Powell, Elmer D. Simon, Edward Stone, Edward J. Swotes, Paul C. Wagner, Howard K. Wallace, Hon. Charles A. Waters, and Hon. Leo Weinrott attended.

Eleven members of the class have been admitted into the 50-Year Club of the Philadelphia Bar Association at a quarterly meeting and were given certificates for fifty years of legal services at the Philadelphia bar.

COCKTAIL PARTY PLANNED FOR JANUARY 20

The Law Alumni Society will give a cocktail party at the Bellevue-Stratford Hotel in Philadelphia on Friday, January 20, at the time of the Pennsylvania Bar Association meeting which is being held in Philadelphia.

Alumni Make Clean Sweep of Bar Offices

All the officers of the Mon~gomery Bar Association, Montgomery County, Pa., for the year 1966 are Law School alumni. Cornelius G. Sullivan, '41, was elected president; Donald A. Gallagher, '36, vice president; Harry M. Sablosky, '30, treasurer, and Walton Coates, '41, secretary.

Officers of the Class of 1966: (l. to r.) Gurney P. Sloan, treasurer; Harry 0. Boreth, president; James F. Bell, class agent; Carol Rubovitz, secretary; Peter Stern, vice president.

23

JUDICIAL ASSISTANCE continued from page 2

taking of testimony and production of evidence. In addition, authority is granted to the federal courts to furnish assistance that may be appropriate.

On the two latter topics in our group, proof of official documents and proof of foreign law, the Act of Congress provides no assistance to foreigners. 18 U.S.C. § 3491, 28 U.S.C. § 17 41 and Fed. R.C.P. No. 44 now provide improved procedures for proving foreign documents in our courts, but no suggestion is made that federal, state, county and municipal authorities in the United States must maintain their local recording offices in some different fashion that may better suit the domestic law of some foreign country. Nor is any suggestion made that federal and state authorities must maintain a legal advisory service to give opinions on local law for the use of foreign courts and litigants. These matters remain as they are. However, the blanket scope of the authority of the State Department to handle letters rogatory and letters of request is such that a request for a certified or authenticated copy of some official record in the United States may be made by such a letter, and it will be transmitted by the State Department to the appropriate official for compliance and return.

We may therefore take some pride in the accomplishments of the organized bar of the United States, which was the initiator and the sponsor of this wise and long-range program.

However, this is only half the battle. Since our grants are unilateral and non-reciprocal, we may be supplying privileges to courts and litigants abroad in countries where courts and litigants of the United States are given no comparable or parallel privileges. Here the Act and the amended Federal Rules of Civil Procedure go as far as they can, but they obviously cannot do the full job.

First, I might mention the problems of proof of foreign official documents and proof of foreign law in United States litigation. Here we have adopted the alternative which I mentioned earlier, namely, we have, through the Act and the amended Rules, changed our domestic local rules of evidence in the federal courts to correspond to the practical possibilities of what can be done abroad, to avoid total frustration in our local litigation. Further, through the cooperation of the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws and the American Bar Association, a Uniform Interstate and International Procedure Act has been approved and circulated to the states, which provides for a similar change in the rules of evidence of the state courts. To the extent that this Act is adopted, the situation in the state and federal courts will be identical.

As to the proof of foreign official documents, Fed. R.C.P. No. 44, 28 U.S.C. § 1741 and §5.02 of the Uniform Act provide a simplified system for certification and authentication of foreign official documents, which avoids many of the difficulties which frustrated their production under the prior practice, and, more importantly, provide a novel system of investigation of authenticity, subject to rebuttal, which may be used

24

in the odd case where it is impossible to meet even these simplified requirements for certification and authentication.

As to proof of foreign law, Fed. R.C.P. No. 44.1 and §§4.01 to 4.03 of the Uniform Act ·eliminate the last vestiges of the rule that foreign law is a "matter of fact." Instead, it is now a matter of law, to be proven by any conventional or informal method which the court may permit, including the private research of the judge, and it is to be reviewed as a matter of law.

Second, as to service of documents and the taking of testimony and production of evidence, we have made similar improvement in domestic practice to take into account the problems of difficulties abroad.

As to service of documents, Fed. R.C.P. No. 4(i), and §2.01 of the Uniform Act provide that, in connection with domestic litigation, any documents to be served outside the United States may be served in a wide variety of ways, including any method permitted by the local law of the foreign country for the service of documents on its own citizens in its own domestic litigation. We may assume that every country in the modern world has a method in such cases which is reasonably designed to give actual notice to the defendant or recipient; but, to be on the safe side, the Rule and the Uniform Act make this a condition precedent.

As to the taking of testimony and the production of evidence, Fed. R.C.P. No. 28(b) and §3.01 of the Uniform Act contain equally effective provisions. Here again, a variety of technques is permitted. Most important, however, is the explicit provision which recognizes that, in many foreign countries with different evidentiary systems, it may not be possible to have evidence taken in the form of examination and crossexamination with a verbatim stenographic transcript. In order to prevent frustration in such case, it is provided that the court may not reject a deposition taken abroad for the sole reason that it does not meet this formal requirement.

We hope, of course, that foreign courts will take testimony "American fashion" to help us in our litigation, in the same way that we will endeavor to take testimony "foreign fashion" to help them in their litigation. (28 U.S.C. §1782 and §3.02 of the Uniform Act.) But this may not always be possible, and Rule 28 (b) protects the proponent in such a case.

I need not emphasize that our domestic legislation and rules can only scratch the surface of the problems of serving documents and taking testimony abroad in connection with United States litigation. We may loosen our rules of service and our rules of evidence to the elastic limits of due process, but it will mean nothing if the foreign country forbids the service or the taking of the testimony. Many countries limit their grant of judicial assistance to courts and litigants of countries with which they have treaty arrangements covering these topics.

The United Kingdom has for years had a network of bi-lateral treaties with the countries of the Con-

LAW ALUMNI JOURNAL

"See Gilberg v. Goffi ... ; Comment, 114 U. Pa. L. Rev. 241 (1965)." Mr. Justice Brennan speaking for the Supreme Court.

Rosenblatt v. Baer, 383 U.S. 75 (1966).

YOU TOO MAY FIND US USEFUL A law school is known by the law review it keeps. It

is our belief that the University of Pennsylvania keeps a good one.

Of course, the L'aw Review insures that you will remain abreast of new trends and developments in the law; so also will its articles entertain and stimulate. But more

than this, each new subscription enables you, the alumnus, to make sure that the face your law school shows the world continues to be recognized - just as it has for the past 114 years.

Oliver Wendell Holmes once said: "The life of the law has not been logic: it has been experience." We agree .

THE UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA LAW REVIEW Subscription form included in center insert

tinent covering these topics; the United States has had none. The task imposed by the Congress on the Commission and Advisory Committee in P. L. 85-906 was therefore not completed by the domestic reforms which were made. But the Commission will expire on December 31 of this year and the work must continue independently of the Commission.

The Department of State will have to assume this remaining task, the negotiating of the appropriate international agreements, to complete the modernization of our system. At the Tenth Session of the Hague Conference on Private International Law in October, 1964, the United States delegation, under the leadership of the Deputy Legal Advisor of the Department, assisted in the drafting of a Convention on the Service Abroad of Judicial and Extra-judicial Documents in Civil and Commercial Matters. This Convention is explained in some detail in my article in the A.B.A. Journal for July, 1965 and has received the unanimous support of the Association's House of Delegates. The United States Ambassador at the Hague has signed the Convention, and it is hoped that the President will shortly send it to the Senate for ratification. If it is ratified, it will mean the end of the task with respect to service of documents as to every other country which ratifies. It also will mean that the United States will have officially approved a pattern for solving this problem which will be available for bi-lateral or multi-lateral negotiation with individual foreign countries not members of the Hague Conference, or with groups, such as the Organization of American States.

This still leaves open the important problem of the necessary international agreements respecting the taking of testimony and the production of evidence abroad, in aid of United States litigation. The ideal situation, from our point of view, would be the enactment in other countries of domestic legislation as generous as our new 28 U.S.C. ~ 1782, which the House and Senate Committees hoped would serve as a model for this purpose. This may prove too much to hope for in the immediate future .

At the close of the Tenth Session of the Hague Conference, and foilowing the completion of the very satisfactory convention on service of documents abroad,

F all 1966

the United States delegation proposed that the topic of the taking of evidence abroad be included in the agenda for the Eleventh Session to be held in 1968. The Netherlands State Commission, which is responsible for the selection of the agenda for the Conference, has not yet reached a decision. If this topic can be included on the agenda of the Eleventh, or even a later, Session, it can be hoped that a satisfactory convention can be negotiated, which will meet with the approval of the organized bar of the United States and which the Department of State can support for ratification by the Senate. If the Hague Conference determines not to undertake this problem at all, the United States will have to proceed by bi-lateral or multi-lateral negotiations with selected countries, a less satisfactory program.

A brief summary of the foregoing will indicate the magnificent progress that has been made in this field in the short period of ten years.

( 1) The practice and procedure in the federal system has been completely rewritten and modernized. Nothing further can be done to provide foreign courts and litigants with the maximum of assistance and cooperation in this country.

(2) A program for the modernization of the practice and procedure in the state system has been prepared in the form of the Uniform Act which is available for adoption by all the states of the Union.

(3) The Department of State is undertaking the solution of the international aspects of the problem, to secure parallel assistance abroad, for our courts and litigants. It has approved and signed the Hague Convention on the service of documents which now awaits ratification. It has recommended to the Hague Conference that the topic of the taking of evidence abroad be undertaken as an item on the agenda of the 1968 Session. We can confidently say that the status of inter

national judicial assistance in the United States is superbly improved when compared with the situation ten years ago, and that the prognosis for the problems which must still be resolved is excellent.

25

"<t 0

0\

~

~ <(

E ...... z <(

;::s >

~ f-<......1 ~~ ~z

·~ ~z

~ f-<~ VJA.. f-.; ~

0

T"""~ ::J::S "' z:::r: f-

(/)

~ f-<A.. "' VJ......) :::J

~~ 0

"'

~ :::r:o a: U<t:: z 0 ......) a: 0 - :::J

:::r: f-"<t "' ~ 0... a:

law Alumni Journal

Documents

Transcript of law Alumni Journal