10-Dec-2012-cesg-1

Joint CMC-CESG MeetingAerocampus Aquitaine, Bordeaux, France

Hosted by CNES

22 April 2013

CCSDS Engineering Steering Group (CESG):report to the

CCSDS Management Council (CMC)concerning the Spring 2013 Technical Plenary

10-Dec-2012-cesg-2

CESG Spring 2013:CCSDS Overview

10-Dec-2012-cesg-3

Data Archive IngestionNavigation Spacecraft Monitor &

ControlDigital Repository

Audit/CertificationTelerobotics MiddlewarePlanning and Scheduling

Mission Ops &Info Mgt Services

Asynchronous Messaging IP-over-CCSDS LinksMotion Imagery & AppsDelay Tolerant NetworkingVoiceCFDP over Encapsulation

Space InternetworkingServices

CS Service ManagementCS Transfer ServicesCross Supt Service Arch.

Cross SupportServices

RF & Modulation Space Link Coding & Sync. Multi/Hyper Data Compress.Space Link Protocols Next Generation UplinkSpace Data Link SecurityPlanetary CommunicationsOptical Coding and Mod

Space LinkServices

Onboard Wireless WGApplication Supt Services (incl.

Plug-n-Play)

Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services

MISSION CONTROLCENTER

MISSION CONTROLCENTER

End Users

End Users

Applications/Archives

SecuritySpace Assigned Numbers Auth.Delta-DORTime Correlation & Synchronization

Systems EngineeringSix Technical Areas;Twenty six active topics

Active Working Group (producing standards)Working Group (in process of closing Birds-Of-a-Feather (pre-WG approval)Special Interest Group (pre-BOF integration forum)

Current CCSDS Working Groups, BOFs and SIGs

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-4

Members of the CESG

Chair Adrian HookeDeputy Nestor Peccia

SE Area Peter ShamesDeputy Takahiro Yamada

MOIMS Nestor PecciaDeputy Roger Thompson

CSS Area Erik BarkleyDeputy Margherita di Giulio

SLS Area G-P CalzolariDeputy Gilles Moury

SIS Area Keith ScottDeputy Dai Stanton

SOIS Area Chris TaylorDeputy Stuart Fowell

Data Archive Ingestion

Navigation Spacecraft Monitor &

Control Digital Repository

Audit/Certification Telerobotics

Mission Ops &Info Mgt Services

Asynchronous Messaging IP-over-CCSDS Links Motion Imagery & Apps Delay Tolerant

Networking Voice CFDP over Encapsulation

Space InternetworkingServices

CS Service Management

CS Transfer Services Cross Supt Service

Arch.

Cross SupportServices

RF & Modulation Coding & Sync. Multi/Hyper Data Comp. Space Link Protocols Next Generation Uplink Space Data Link Security Planetary Comm Optical Coding and Mod

Space LinkServices

Onboard Wireless WG Application Supt

Services (incl. Plug-n-Play)

Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services

MISSION CONTROLCENTER

MISSION CONTROLCENTER

End Users

End Users

Applications/Archives

Security Space Assigned Numbers Auth. Delta-DOR Time Correlation & Synchronization

Systems Engineering

CESG Chairs

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-5

CCSDS Adoption by Missions

CCSDS haspublished73 CurrentlyActiveStandardsand Practices

596 space missions have adopted and used various

CCSDS standards199

9200

0200

1200

2200

3200

4200

5200

6200

7200

8200

9201

0201

1201

2

Cumu-la-tive Missions

108 155 205 221 271 308 330 371 387 416 435 461 544 596

2575

125175225275325375425475525575625

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-6

Standards Production in CY12Completed:

CCSDS 660.1-G-1, XML Telemetric and Command Exchange (XTCE)—Element Description (Green Book, Issue 1, May 2012) CCSDS 912.11-O-1, Space Link Extension—Enhanced Forward CLTU Service Specification (Orange Book, Issue 1, July 2012) CCSDS 873.0-M-1, Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services—File and Packet Store Services (Magenta Book, Issue 1, September 2012) CCSDS 702.1-B-1, IP over CCSDS Space Links (Blue Book, Issue 1, September 2012) CCSDS 650.0-M-2, Reference Model for an Open Archival Information System (OAIS) (Magenta Book, Issue 2, June 2012) CCSDS 121.0-B-2, Lossless Data Compression (Blue Book, Issue 2, May 2012) CCSDS 131.2-B-1, Flexible Advanced Coding and Modulation Scheme for High Rate Telemetry Applications (Blue Book, Issue 1, March 2012) CCSDS 123.0-B-1, Lossless Multispectral & Hyperspectral Image Compression (Blue Book, Issue 1, May 2012) CCSDS 881.0-M-1, Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services—RFID-Based Inventory Management Systems (Magenta Book, Issue 1, May 2012)

Ready to Release: CCSDS 651.1-R-1, Producer-Archive Interface Specification (PAIS) (Red Book, Issue 1, February 2012) CCSDS 734.2-R-1, CCSDS Bundle Protocol Specification (Red Book, Issue 1, February 2012) CCSDS 734.1-R-2, Licklider Transmission Protocol (LTP) for CCSDS (Red Book, Issue 2, February 2012) CCSDS 355.0-R-2, Space Data Link Security Protocol (Red Book, Issue 2, February 2012) CCSDS 352.0-R-1, CCSDS Cryptographic Algorithms (Red Book, Issue 1, February 2012) CCSDS 508.0-R-1, Conjunction Data Message (Red Book, Issue 1, March 2012) CCSDS 211.0-P-4.1, Proximity-1 Space Link Protocol—Data Link Layer (Pink Book, Issue 4.1, March 2012) CCSDS 211.1-P-3.1, Proximity-1 Space Link Protocol—Physical Layer (Pink Book, Issue 3.1, March 2012) CCSDS 211.2-P-1.1, Proximity-1 Space Link Protocol—Coding and Synchronization Sublayer (Pink Book, Issue 1.1, March 2012) CCSDS 521.0-P-1.1, Mission Operations Message Abstraction Layer (Pink Sheets, Issue 1.1, July 2012) CCSDS 521.1-R-3, Mission Operations Common Object Model (Red Book, Issue 3, July 2012) CCSDS 506.1-R-2, Delta-DOR Raw Data Exchange Format (Red Book, Issue 2, July 2012) CCSDS 401.0-RP-21.1, Radio Frequency and Modulation Systems—Part 1: Earth Stations and Spacecraft (Red/Pink Sheets, Issue 21.1, August 2012) CCSDS 131.3-R-1, CCSDS Space Link Protocols over ETSI DVB-S2 Standard (Red Book, Issue 1, August 2012) CCSDS 882.0-R-1, Spacecraft Onboard Interface Systems—Low–Data-Rate Wireless Communications for Spacecraft Monitoring and Control (Red Book, Issue 1, August 2012)

In progress: CCSDS 735.0-G-0, Asynchronous Message Service (Green Book, Issue 0, November 2012) CCSDS 312.0-G-0, Reference Architecture for Space Information Management (Draft Green Book, Issue 0, November 2012) CCSDS 871.2-R-0, Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services—Device Virtualization Service (Proposed Red Book, Issue 0, November 2012) CCSDS 850.0-G-1.1, Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services (Draft Green Book, Issue 1.1, January 2008) CCSDS 522.1-R-2, Mission Operations Monitor & Control Services (Red Book, Issue 2, August 2012) CCSDS 871.3-R-0, Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services—Device Enumeration Service (Proposed Red Book, Issue 0, November 2012) CCSDS 350.8-G-1, Information Security Glossary of Terms (Green Book, Issue 1, October 2012) CCSDS 871.1-M-1, Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services—Device Data Pooling Service (Magenta Book, Issue 1, October 2012) CCSDS 875.0-M-1, Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services—Message Transfer Service (Magenta Book, Issue 1, October 2012) CCSDS 722.1-R-0, Operation of CFDP over Encapsulation Service (Proposed Red Book, Issue 0, August 2012) CCSDS 523.1-M-0, Mission Operations Message Abstraction Layer—JAVA API (Draft Magenta Book, Issue 0, September 2012) CCSDS 351.0-M-1, Security Architecture for Space Data Systems (Magenta Book, Issue 1, October 2012) CCSDS 352.0-B-1, CCSDS Cryptographic Algorithms (Blue Book, Issue 1, October 2012) CCSDS 730.1-G-0, Solar System Internetwork (SSI) Architecture (Draft Green Book, Issue 0, September 2012) CCSDS 524.1-R-0, Mission Operations Message Abstraction Layer—Space Packet Binding (Red Book, Issue 0, October 2012) CCSDS 871.0-M-0, Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services—Device Access Service (Draft Magenta Book, Issue 0, November 2012) CCSDS 131.3-B-0, CCSDS Space Link Protocols over ETSI DVB-S2 Standard (Draft Blue Book, Issue 0, November 2012)

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-7

CESG FALL 2012:items brought to attention

of the CMC

10-Dec-2012-cesg-8

Ethical Breach

• A serious breach of professional ethics was uncovered in a CCSDS working group • A member of this group attended one meeting and did not contribute anything• This individual then used his private CWE access to write a journal paper that:

• Appears to have plagiarized work• Misrepresented the work of other WG members in potentially damaging ways and

exposed WG-internal debates that were not meant to be made public and which took place at a meeting that the member in question did not attend

• We intercepted this paper only because one of the other WG members happened to be on the pre-publication technical review board of the journal. The plagiarism issue is being handled by the journal. However, because of the professional confidentiality issues involved, no action can be taken on the misrepresentation of CCSDS work.

• Instead, the CESG recommends that the CMC should adopt a slightly-modified version of the ISO code of ethics, which would then be impressed on every member of a CCSDS working group.

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-9

Work for the net benefit of the international community

We recognize that the development of International Standards is for the net benefit of the international community, over and above the interests of any individual or organization. We are committed to advancing International Standards within their agreed scope and we will not hinder their development.

Uphold consensus and governance

We will uphold the key principles of International Standardization: consensus, transparency, openness, impartiality, effectiveness, relevance, coherence and the development dimension.

Agree to a clear purpose and scope

We are committed to having a clear purpose, scope, objectives, and plan to ensure the timely development of International Standards.

Participate actively and manage effective representation

We agree to actively participate in standards development projects. We will make our contributions to the work through the official procedures in accordance with the ISO/IEC Directives.

Escalate and resolve disputes

We will identify and escalate disputes in a timely manner to ensure rapid resolution. We will uphold the agreed dispute resolution processes.

Behave ethically We will act in good faith and with due care and diligence. We will avoid collusive or anticompetitive behaviour. We will promote a culture of fair and ethical behaviour.

Respect others in meetings

We are committed to respecting others and the professional culture of international standardization within ISO. In meetings we are committed to: • conducting ourselves in a professional manner • respecting others and their opinions • accepting group decisions • ensuring that the views of all (including those whose first language is not that of the meeting) are heard and understood

Considering the role of CCSDS as ISO Technical Committee 20 Subcommittee 13, CCSDS fully adopts the ISO Code of Conduct. This Code of Conduct (Code) is to facilitate ISO's work which is carried out in an international, multi-stakeholder, multi-sector environment. It applies to people who choose to participate in an ISO committee, working group or other consensus group. The Code is an obligation for participation in the above groups that work in the framework of the ISO/IEC Directives. As participants in ISO work, we acknowledge the responsibility and value of participating in developing International Standards. We therefore adhere to this Code in accordance with the terms below.

Respect Intellectual Property We will not plagiarize the work of other working group colleagues that is revealed during the standards development process. We will notify our colleagues of our intent to publish and provide them with a courtesy summary of the content before proceeding with any publication related to our standardization work.

Confidentiality of pre-decisional technical discussions

We will keep internal group discussions/tradeoffs/disputes in confidence, and will not publish such tradeoffs in public fora until agreed to by the technical working group community. When such matters are publicly represented, the individual positions of our technical staff will not be personally identifiable without their permission.

Further, CCSDS also adopts the following augmentation to the ISO Code of Conduct.

The CESG recommends the followingas the CCSDS Code of Conduct

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-10

Periodic Review and Deprecation• The following documents are up for periodic review

• CCSDS 620.0-B-2: Standard Formatted Data Units¬ Structure and Construction Rules • CCSDS 622.0-B-1: Standard Formatted Data Units¬ Referencing Environment • CCSDS 630.0-B-1: Standard Formatted Data Units ¬ Control Authority Procedures • CCSDS 632.0-B-1: Standard Formatted Data Units ¬ Control Authority Data Structures • CCSDS 641.0-B-2: Parameter Value Language Specification (CCSD0006 and CCSD0008) • CCSDS 643.0-B-1: ASCII Encoded English (CCSD0002) • CCSDS 647.1-B-1: Data Entity Dictionary Specification Language (DEDSL)-Abstract Syntax (CCSD0011) • CCSDS 647.2-B-1: Data Entity Dictionary Specification Language (DEDSL)¬PVL Syntax (CCSD0012) • CCSDS 647.3-B-1: Data Entity Dictionary Specification Language (DEDSL)¬ XML/DTD Syntax (CCSD0013 )

• This was to be their last planned re-affirmation. However, there are no resources available to perform the reviews• The CESG’s first thought was simply to re-affirm the whole suite without review and to add a disclaimer that they will be deprecated to Historical

(Silver Book) status in five years.• However, Silver Book status puts them on the Non-Normative track. But we have data stored in SFDU format with the intention of it being stored

for the long-term, possibly 50 + years. An argument has been made that the SFDU family should not be deprecated to Silver any more than the Fortran or the even older COBOL language standards are disposed of

- The standards for the computer languages remain standards, even when other computer languages are adopted for wide-spread use.

• A number of the members of the suite (such as DEDSL and EAST) are actively being used and there is no proposed replacement for them at this point. Certainly these should remain Blue Books until there is a defined replacement.

• Other standards (such as SFDU and XFDU) are more problematic, since they aren't totally replacements for one another. The WG would generally recommend XFDU for totally new systems although SFDU could also still make sense for NEW projects, especially if the data were binary formatted rather than character oriented. This is sort of like determining what computer language you use to program in. We can use either one of them to write almost any system, but your particular project needs (and the choices within your programming environment) determine which tool you will use.

• The general feeling of the CESG seems to be to just go ahead and reaffirm the suite without review. Does the CMC have any comment?

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-11

Removing Overlaps

• CCSDS areas and working group products continue to have disconnects:

• We still do not have a common architecture nor a common information model (RA SIG was cancelled)

• Multiple XML schema using different formats, namespaces, and vocabularies (old XSG SIG problem that was never completed)

• We may be able to help guide recurring XML issues by (finally) publishing the RFC & XML Guidelines from the XSG SIG

• An Information Model is a candidate for inclusion in the proposed Timeline Standard BOF: need to confirm along with resources

• We simply don’t have adequate resources to get these overlaps properly resolved

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-12

Future Messaging Standards (Again)• As noted at the Spring 2012 meeting, there are two potentially-competing standards, at a key cross

support interface, that are proceeding independently• ESA’s Packet Utilization Standard (PUS), which is firmly rooted in the ECSS but which was not admitted into

the CCSDS program of work.• NASA’s ex-Constellation Data Exchange Message (DEM), which has a lot of traction in NASA’s new Exploration

systems (MPCV, SLS, etc.)

• The PUS and the DEM are both “middleware” standards which define the semantics and syntax for passing control and state information to and from remote devices. Further complicating the situation is that CCSDS is embarking on Telerobotics middleware development, which also assumes that the physical transfer will occur using the CCSDS Asynchronous Messaging Service (AMS) protocol• Yet we have no forum or resources in CCSDS for discussing these issues

• If this situation persists unchecked, the potential exists in the 2015 timeframe for serious interoperability issues if Europe and the US try to integrate international exploration missions with different ways of passing data between systems• This problem may not be limited to human exploration missions. Some international exploration scenarios

involve a blend of robotic and human systems

• This is another instance where lack of resources now may lead to serious future repercussions. Does the CMC want to attempt a “fix”, for instance by making another overture to the International Space Exploration Coordination Group (ISECG)? Rumor has it that the ISECG is now starting to take communications architectures more seriously.

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-13

• The CESG received generally favorable reviews of the Cleveland location, hotel and meeting support

• However, a major issue – and this was a big one – was the absence of a break area and refreshments where the working groups could mingle and network mid-morning and mid-afternoon

• This isn’t a luxury: the ability to cross-pollinate and network with peers in other working groups is a key facet of face-face Plenary meetings

• As a minimum, a lounge-style room should be provided where people can bring back their own coffee/snacks and socialize with others during the breaks

Meeting Hosting and Support

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-14

CESG FALL 2012:Area Reports

10-Dec-2012-cesg-15

Chris Taylor (AD)Stuart Fowell (DAD)

SPACECRAFT ONBOARD INTERFACES SERVICES

(SOIS) AREA

10-Dec-2012-cesg-16

1. Application Support Services WG

2. Wireless WG

3. Subnetwork Services WG (Inactive)

SOIS Area Report - Current Working Groups

The SOIS area covers onboard communication services with the intention of standardising H/W and S/W interfaces between avionics elements & devices.

Wireless activities cover intra-spacecraft communication, AIV and RFID

A considerable part of our work is outside of the CCSDS where we perform a harmonising role for avionics related development

10-Dec-2012-cesg-17

SOIS Area Report B. Meeting Demographics

Wireless App Supt Svcs

ASI    

CNES    

CNSA 1 1

CSA 1  

DLR    

ESA 2 2

INPE    

JAXA    

NASA 4 8

RFSA    

UKSA   2

Other    

TOTAL 8 13

Meeting Duration 4 4

Agency Diversity 4 4

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-18

Application Support Services Working GroupGoal: Develop SOIS Application Support layer services and if appropriate protocols

Working Group Status• Device Data Pooling, Device Access and Message Transfer Magenta Books published Nov 2012 – Mar 2013

• RIDs raised from CESG from poll to publish Green Book Issue 2• Device Enumeration and Device Virtualisation Red Books completing updates following RIDs raised from

CESG for poll for 1st Agency Review• Progressing Electronic Data Sheets Red Book & associated XML Schema• Progressing Common Dictionary of Terms Red Book & associated ontology• Some attendance via WebEx – problems with microphones in meeting room so not great solution

Status: OK CAUTION PROBLEM

Comment: Finalizing number of books. New books progressing to plan

SOIS Area Report

10-Dec-2012-cesg-19

Application Support Services WG (cont.)Progress • All 1st set of SOIS APP service specifications are either published, or with Secretariat for publishing or

for Agency review process• Exploratory prototyping of XML schemas for device EDS by ESA proceeding, two alternatives

produced• ESA and NASA planning to experiment with using both XML schemas for defining example device

data sheets (SpaceWire camera, star tracker, gyro, GPS receiver, SDR)• Relationship with Common Dictionary of Terms defined• Process for development of device data sheets defined• Explored a couple of issues of how to use SOIS architecture (remote interface units, polled data

acquisitions on 1553, use of result metadata in indication service primitives)• Explored how SUMO, NASA-JSC and NASA-GRC can contribute to this process, e.g. US industry

outreach, example real-world ICD transformations to EDS

Planning• Publish remaining Green and Magenta Books• Continue fortnightly telecons• Produce experimental device EDS for Fall 2013 meeting, using Common DoT terms, to complete

exploratory prototyping of XML schema• Extend Common DoT taxonomy with common terms for examined ICDs for Fall 2013 meeting

SOIS Area Report

10-Dec-2012-cesg-20

Application Support Services WG

Near Term Planning

SOIS Area Report

Activity Milestone Planned end dateXML Specification for Electronic Data Sheets for Onboard Devices Blue book

Draft 1 – Fall 2013 Blue Book End 2014

Electronic Data Sheets XML Schema Draft 1 – Fall 2013 SANA XML End 2014

Common Dictionary of Terms for Onboard Devices Blue book

Draft 1 – Fall 2013 Blue Book End 2014

Common Dictionary of Terms Taxonomy Draft 1 – Fall 2013 SANA End 2014

10-Dec-2012-cesg-21

status: OK CAUTION PROBLEM

comment: On schedule

Wireless WGGoal: Develop wireless recommendations for onboard space applications

Working Group Status:• Did not meet due to NASA travel issues

SOIS Area Report

Progress

Planning• LDR MB RID responses to originators to be composed and completed by November 2nd.• LDR MB RID closure-related updates to be completed by November 30th.• Green book updates covering high rate use cases and technology evaluation to be completed by

April 8th, 2013.• Continue monthly telecons

10-Dec-2012-cesg-22

Wireless WG (continued)

Near Term Planning

SOIS Area Report

Activity Milestone Planned end dateWireless Green Book issue 2 Draft 1 - end 2012 April 2013

Low Rate Wireless Magenta Issue 1 - end 2012 November 2012

10-Dec-2012-cesg-23

SOIS WGs Telecon Usage

SOIS WG Input

WirelessWG

The Wireless WG has had regular telecons since its inception. This is on average every two week. This will be continued.

APP WG The Application Support Services WG hold regular telecons on average every two weeks. This will be continued subject to continuation of ESA funding for WG chair to coordinate.

10-Dec-2012-cesg-24

APP WG

• Remaining Magenta books (almost) under publication or ready for Agency review• Electronic data sheet activities on schedule• Possibly the biggest issue is the success of Electronic data sheets – every one wants to use them but in their own way! By Fall 2013 we should have completed exploratory prototyping

Wireless WG

• Did not meet

SOIS Area Report: Summary

10-Dec-2012-cesg-25

SYSTEMS ENGINEERING(SE) AREA

Peter Shames (AD)Takahiro Yamada (DAD)

10-Dec-2012-cesg-26

System Engineering Area (SEA)

• Objective• Guide overall CCSDS architecture for space mission communications, operations, and

cross-support• Support the CESG in evaluating consistency of all area programs of work with the

defined architecture• Create cross-cutting working groups and BOFs as required to progress the work of

CCSDS• Focus

• Define reference architectures for describing space mission communications, operations, and cross-support standardization

• Coordinate and collaborate with other areas about architectural choices and options • Define standards for cross cutting topics such as security and discrete architecture

frameworks, and for those that cross cut multiple layers of protocols• Support other working groups and BoFs that are addressing cross cutting issues

• SEA Working Groups• Security Working Group• Delta-DOR Working Group • Space Assigned Numbers Authority (SANA) Steering Group (operational)

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-27

SE Area ReportB. Meeting Demographics

Plenary Security D-DOR

ASI      

CNES   1  

CNSA      

CSA      

DLR 2 2  

ESA 4 2 2

INPE      

JAXA 1   1

NASA 5 4 2

RFSA      

UKSA   1  

Other      

TOTAL 12 10 5

Meeting Duration 1 1.5 4

Agency Diversity 4 5 3

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-28

Security WGGoals: • Develop security overview & threat assessment, and security architecture,

framework and related standards• Current focus (security architecture, glossary, algorithms, key management)Working Group Status:• Progress

• Algorithms BB, Security Architecture MB, and Information Security Glossary GB have passed final CESG poll ready for publication.

• Update the Algorithm Yellow Book to include the hash function to be used for digital signature testing. DLR will document the testing they have already accomplished.

• Reviewed draft of Algorithm Green Book.• Discussed Threat Green Book revision and agreed on updated outline.• Agreed to go forward with the writing of an adaptation profile of IPSec for

CCSDS.• Security Glossary complete, to review against CCSDS Glossary, update,

remove any issues, and publish.• WG agreed to request new work programs: update of Threat GB, adaptation

profile of IPSec, create Algorithms GB.• Good joint progress on Space Data Link Layer Security WG, produced by SecWG

members, reported in SLS

Systems Engineering Area Report

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-29

Delta-DOR WG

Goals: • Develop delta differential one-way ranging (Delta-DOR) service • Coordinate work in other WGs (SLS/Ranging, CSS/CSTS, MOIMS/Nav, CSS/SM)• Develop integrated service, interoperability points, and standards

Working Group Status:• Delta-DOR Raw Data Exchange Format (RDEF) Blue Book draft (Red-2): all RIDs resolved,

ready to be published as Blue Book• Interoperability validation 75% done (ESA, JAXA, NASA), YB test report to be complete,

expect final 02/13.• DDOR Green Book updates final, publish by 11/12.• SANA Quasar Catalogue candidate created (Ka band, currently only S & X), discussed YB

to define SANA registry and update policy. YB draft to be ready 06/13.• SMWG, expect D-DOR to be covered by next version of SM BB, no new issues, no

discussion at this meeting.• Discussion with RF&M WG (mods to 2.5.6B, 25.5-27GHz), need note about power for

DOR tones

Systems Engineering Area Report

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-30

SANA Operations & SANA Steering Group (SSG)Goals:

• Operate the Space Assigned Numbers Authority (SANA) • Support CCSDS WG use of the registry functions

Operations Status:• SANA operator in place, web site operational, thirty-two (32) approved

registries, seven (7) candidate registries not yet approved, most waiting on final Blue Book publication

• Met this week with SIS-DTN, SLS-SLP• SCID registry and SANA were out of sync, official registry had many

abnormalities and is hard to use. Suggest change of policy to leave assignment at official registry but use SANA as the actual registry. See http://sanaregistry.org/r/spacecraftid/spacecraftid.html vs http://standards.gsfc.nasa.gov/ccsds/ccsds_id.txt

• SANA Steering Group met• CMC Chair, SEA AD, DLR reps only• SANA appears to be working well, several new registries in discussion• Agreed on approach for resolving SCID issue• Agreed to develop a prototype RESTful programmatic interface to

SANA registries, SCID access is a driver• SANA Yellow Book procedure, CCSDS 313.0-Y-1, published, July 2011

Systems Engineering Area Report

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-31

• Mission Planning SIG• Participated in Mission Planning SIG, several presentations and excellent discussions• Appears to be significant interest in continuing the MP discussions, leading to a BoF,

and there was also expressed interest in the NASA Timeline Standard proposal• Timelines are cross-cutting, potentially touching several working groups: MOIMS SM&C

/ MP, MOIMS Nav, CSS SM, SIS DTN• Introduces need to arrive at a common CCSDS information model to permit data

interoperable exchange and data comparisons• SEA proposes to create a BoF to explore defining a compact, extensible, interoperable

timeline data exchange standard, to be carefully coordinated with other WGs (see NASA Timeline Standard proposal for details)

• Sec WG - SDLS Meeting• Joint meeting continues to be productive and work is largely on track• Have identified no “show-stoppers” • Details reported by SDLS WG chair in SLS report

Systems Engineering Area Report: Cross Area Meetings

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-32

Nestor Peccia (AD)Roger Thompson (DAD)

MISSION OPERATIONSAND INFORMATION

MANAGEMENT SERVICES(MOIMS) AREA

10-Dec-2012-cesg-33

MOIMS Area Report B. Meeting Demographics

Plenary Navigation Mission Planning SM&C T-Rob

ASI          

CNES 6 2 5 5  

CNSA          

CSA     1   1

DLR 2 1 1 1 1

ESA 7 2 6 4 4

INPE          

JAXA 2 1 2 2  

NASA 9 10 9 8 6

RFSA 1   1 2 1

UKSA     1 1  

Other          

TOTAL 27 16 26 23 13

plus 16 via webex

Meeting Duration 1 4 0.5 3 0.5

Agency Diversity 6 5 8 7 5

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-3418-Oct-2012

Navigation (NAV) Working Group

• Conjunction Data Message (CDM)• Continued detailed planning for prototype testing by 5

organizations• Updated and more or less finalized the draft test plan• Discussed the schedules for testing and analysis of results• Discussed the document completion schedule• Conducted a detailed proofreading of the document

• Navigation Green Book• Continued discussion of Green Book Version 4 volume 1

updates and supplements• Initiated identification of new content for the Version 4 volume

2 related to CDM and TDM• Pointing Requests Message (PRM)

• Continued discussion of PRM• Discussed detail of the inertial pointing template and an

example thereof• Previewed other planned templates

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-3518-Oct-2012

• Tracking Data Message (TDM)• Continued reconfirmation review with discussion of 2 sets of

proposed changes from 2 agencies• Initiated identification of requirements for new features, with

some updates confirmed• Initiated identification of prototypers for new features

• Navigation Hardware Message (NHM)• Completed discussion of NHM White Book 5• Completed presentation of NHM concept to SM&C WG

• Spacecraft Maneuver Message (SMM)• Initiated discussion of SMM Requirements

• Events Message (EVM)• Completed discussion of the System Engineering Area

involvement in the “event” construct and postponement of EVM• Spacecraft Perturbations Message (SPM)

• We propose to delete the document from the Project Framework• We propose to retain the document in the WG Charter

Navigation (NAV) Working Group

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-3618-Oct-2012

• CROSS-AREA Meetings & Technical Issues

• AGI/CSSI/Space Data Center liaison was in attendance Mon-Wed. Input was very helpful to Navigation WG goals. No current issues.

• Met with Spacecraft Monitor & Control WG to discuss Flight Dynamics Service

• Administration

• Updated Charter: N/A... no changes necessary at this time

• Initiated updates to project resources in the Framework

• Insufficient time for review of Navigation Working Group 5 Year Plan

Navigation (NAV) Working Group

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-3718-Oct-2012

• Met top priority goal for meetings (significant progress on CDM), made some progress on others (TDM Review, Green Book, PRM, NHM, SMM)

• Excellent participation in this meeting… 16 attendees most days

• 4-Day Meeting: Navigation WG has occasionally concluded its work in 4 days, but this time again felt constrained (as at Darmstadt) due to the volume of work in progress

Status: OK CAUTION PROBLEM

x

Navigation (NAV) Working Group: Assessment

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-3818-Oct-2012

• Skype/GoogleVoice: GoogleVoice worked reasonably well on a limited scale (one person, one hour) at Darmstadt in Spring 2012. Attempted a Skype telecon (voice only) during the Cleveland meetings with less success.

• Heavily prioritizing one document to the exclusion of others has both advantages and disadvantages.• Advantages: can “fast track” the standards development process• Disadvantages: can delay progress on projects with lower priority; can

affect enthusiasm of members not directly involved in the “priority” document

• The WG broke at 1730 most days (1745 on Wednesday)... the attempt to squeeze in more progress by routinely working until 1830, while it sounds desirable, can actually reduce productivity.

Navigation (NAV) Working Group: Observations

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-39

Attendance More than 20 people on average from 10 different agencies/organisations Overall a very successful meeting

SM&C WG thanks NASA for the excellent organization of the workshop. More coffee would have been appreciated!

MOIMS REPORT - SM&C WG Overall Status

Xcomment:

PROBLEMCAUTIONOKstatus:

Xcomment:

PROBLEMCAUTIONOKstatus:

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-40

• MO Reference Model (MB, ESA)• Published

• MO Common Object Model (BB, ESA)• Completed Agency Review 3: 60 RIDs (12 ESA, 2 CNES, 46 NASA) received to be discussed this week • Major RIDs have been discussed and disposed. No showstopper

• MO COM Testing (YB, ESA/CNES)• Work is on-going and waiting for the final version of the document to produce the final prototype

• MO Message Abstraction Layer (BB, ESA)• Issue 1: published• Issue 2 (pink sheet to adapt to new COM and correct a few minor mistakes): completed Agency Review

with 45 RIDs (19 ESA, 1 CNES, 25 NASA) received to be discussed this week• Major RIDs have been discussed and disposed. No showstopper

• MO MAL Testing (YB, ESA/CNES)• Issue 1: published• Issue 2: needs updates following MAL issue 2, which are on-going

• MO M&C Service (BB, ESA)• Submitted to Secretariat for Agency Review• Discussed operational issue on check service• Agreed on measures to make the MO Service standards more “user friendly”

• MO M&C Service Testing (YB, ESA/DLR)• Needs to be produced

MOIMS Report - SM&C WG Books Status (1)

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-41

• MO Common Services (BB, ESA)• Needs to be adapted to new MAL/COM. This will be the next document to be tackled after M&C

• MO Java Language API (MB, CNES)• Completed Agency Review 1: responded internally to CESG clarifications. No showstopper.• Proposed updates will be verified with the authors

• MO Space Packet Binding (BB, CNES)• Resolution submitted by MOIMS AD requesting Agency Review

• MO C++ Language API (MB, NASA)• Is on-going and the C++ API is being used in several projects. However, NASA/JSC cannot yet commit to the

production of the document because of lack of resources

• XTCE 1.2 (BB pink sheet, NASA)• Upgrade to be done by OMG first by Dec 2012. Review in parallel with OMG• Changes are minor and should not require prototyping.

• XTCE Element Description (GB, NASA)• Published in May 12

• XTCE Conformance Profiles (OMG, NASA)• Renamed on OMG request from Tailoring Guidelines. • NASA has submitted their GovSat Conformance Profile to OMG which has published an RFC with

due date 24Oct12

MOIMS REPORT - SM&C WG Books Status (2)

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-42

Presented MO Usage in Projects ESA METERON

Implementation of the Action, Parameter and Activity services over Web Services.

! Suite of MO Service Resources to aid potential users Organise existing material, create new material Effort

MOIMS Report - SM&C WG General Points

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-43

Joint Meeting with Telerobotic BOF MO Framework explicitly referred to into the BOF concept paper

Joint SM&C-NAV Meeting Improved mutual awareness and understanding Identify potential use of MO Service s for Hardware Message. TN will be produced.

MOIMS REPORT - SM&C WG Joint Meetings

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-44

Large attendance (about 26 persons at the meeting plus 8 via WebEx) General consensus on need for standardisation of Mission Planning Services Keep the level of standardisation simple, at least at the beginning

Fast track (suboptimal solution) useful also to focus and consolidate the opinion of the planning experts

Identified standardisation priorities Priority 1: Terminology + MP system context + data model Priority 2: Planning Request Management (and reporting) Priority 2: Plan/Timeline Management (and reporting), including the possible usage of JPL

Timelines as exchange format To be done in cooperation with NAV: Flight Dynamics Event Management Rules & Constraints Management (and reporting): this was considered more difficult to agree

upon Way forward

After 2 sessions, the SM&C WG recommends that the MOIMS AD forms a new BOF to standardise Mission Planning Services based on the MO Service Framework with the priorities highlighted above

JPL has agreed to evaluate the relevance of the “JPL Timeline” as exchange format for selected planning data based on the MO Service Framework. The results shall be reflected in a draft update of the Mission Planning concept paper

MOIMS REPORT - SM&C WGCall for Interest in Standardization of Mission Planning Services

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-45

MOIMS Area Report: SM&C WGSchedule (updates in Red)

TaskMO MAL BB (Pink Sheet)

MO COM BB

MO MAL Java API MB

MO Common Services BB

MO M&C Services BB

Space Packet Binding BB

XTCE BB Pink Sheet

Project Approved * 01-Mar-09 01-Jan-06 01-Jan-06 01-Jan-06 01-Jan-06 01-Jan-06Internal WG Review - First draft circulated to WG * 20-Oct-10 24-Aug-07 01-Dec-09 01-May-11 30-Apr-11 01-Sep-09- First draft comments due * 28-Oct-10 21-Sep-07 22-Dec-09 31-May-11 31-Oct-11 22-Sep-09- Second draft circulated to WG * 31-Dec-10 07-Jan-09 01-Apr-13 15-Aug-11 30-May-12 06-Oct-09- Second draft comments due * 15-Jan-11 21-Jan-09 22-Apr-13 31-Aug-11 30-Jun-12 31-Dec-10- Final WB submitted to AD for further processing *   31-May-11 18-May-11 06-May-13 30-Oct-11 14-Jul-12 01-Aug-12Secretariat Document Processing 30-Jul-11 17-Jul-11 05-Jul-13 29-Dec-11 12-Sep-12 30-Sep-12First Agency Review 28-Sep-11 15-Sep-11 03-Sep-13 27-Feb-12 31-Mar-13 29-Nov-12RID Resolution 24-Apr-12 15-Oct-11 03-Oct-13 05-May-12 30-Apr-13 29-Dec-12Secretariat Document Processing 23-Jun-12 04-Jul-12Final Agency Review 30-Sep-12 30-Sep-12 28-Feb-13RID Resolution 30-Oct-12 31-Dec-12 15-Aug-12 30-Mar-13First Prototype Development/YB 31-Dec-12 31-Dec-12 03-Oct-13 30-Mar-13 30-Apr-13Second Prototype Development\YB 31-Dec-12 31-Dec-12 03-Oct-13 30-Mar-13 30-Apr-13Document Approved * 30-Jan-13 30-Jan-13 13-Nov-12 02-Nov-13 29-Apr-13 30-May-13 27-Feb-13

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-46

MOIMS Area Report: SM&C WGContribution by Agencies (TBC in Red)

TaskMO MAL BB (Pink Sheet)

MO COM BB

MO MAL Java API MB

MO Common Services BB

MO M&C Services BB

Space Packet Binding BB

XTCE BB Pink Sheet

Book editors: which Agencies have committed the resources to edit the books to completion?

ESA ESA CNES ESA ESA CNES NASA

Prototypers: which Agencies have committed the resources to do the interoperability prototypes?

1. ESA2. CNES

1. ESA2. CNES

N/A1. ESA2. CNES

1. ESA2. DLR

1. CNES2. DLR

N/A

Technical Contributors: which Agencies have committed to support the necessary engineering and provide specification text for documents?

CNES, DLR, NASA, UKSA

CNES, DLR, NASA, UKSA

DLR, ESA, NASA, UKSA

CNES, DLR, NASA, UKSA

CNES, DLR, NASA, UKSA

DLR, ESA, NASA, UKSA

CNES, DLR, ESA, UKSA

Technical Monitors: which Agencies have committed to watch and comment only, with no direct contribution to producing the document?

ASI, CSA, INPE, JAXA, RFSA

ASI, CSA, INPE, JAXA, RFSA

ASI, CSA, INPE, JAXA, RFSA

ASI, CSA, INPE, JAXA, RFSA

ASI, CSA, INPE, JAXA, RFSA

ASI, CSA, INPE, JAXA, RFSA

ASI, CSA, INPE, JAXA, RFSA

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-47

Goal: Develop a CCSDS/ISO standard for a Submission Information Package (SIP) for transfer and validation of information submitted to an archive Working Group Status: Active

Working Group Summary Situation:

WG met via webex. No physical meeting at Darmstadt

status: OK CAUTION PROBLEM

comment: PAIS BB v2Being produced

NASA funding has ceased

ESA is now funding the Proto 2

MOIMS REPORT - DAI WG

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-48

• PAIS Blue Book, Issue 2- WG is updating the BB- WG is updating the prototypes and will complete testing report by

March 2013

• WG recommends to reaffirm the following documents (and asociated ISO docs) due to lack of resources• CCSDS 620.0-B-2: Standard Formatted Data Units Structure and Construction Rules

• CCSDS 622.0-B-1: Standard Formatted Data Units Referencing Environment

• CCSDS 630.0-B-1: Standard Formatted Data Units Control Authority Procedures

• CCSDS 632.0-B-1: Standard Formatted Data Units Control Authority Data Structures

• CCSDS 641.0-B-2: Parameter Value Language Specification (CCSD0006 and CCSD0008)

• CCSDS 643.0-B-1: ASCII Encoded English (CCSD0002)

• CCSDS 647.1-B-1:  Data Entity Dictionary Specification Language (DEDSL) Abstract Syntax (CCSD0011)

• CCSDS 647.2-B-1:  Data Entity Dictionary Specification Language (DEDSL) PVL Syntax (CCSD0012)

• CCSDS 647.3-B-1:  Data Entity Dictionary Specification Language (DEDSL) XML/DTD Syntax (CCSD0013 )

MOIMS REPORT - DAI WG

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-49

Goal: Obtain ISO approval of a standard that establishes the criteria that a repository must meet to be designated an ISO Trusted Digital Repository

Working Group Status: Active __X_ Idle ____

Working Group Summary Situation:

No physical meeting. Wiki based activity.

status: OK CAUTION PROBLEM

comment: Green book on best practice due Spring 2013. Significant material was collected during the test audits and white book draft in progress

MOIMS REPORT - RAC WG

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-50

MOIMS REPORT - Telerobotics BOF Status

• Remote participation was enabled by Webex and

Teleconference

- 16 Local attendees

- 3 Remote attendees

- Meeting Length < 2hours

• Meeting Results

• Telerobotics Concept Paper is of sufficient quality and content

• Draft Charter is of sufficient quality and content

• Working Group will produce 1 Green Book and 1 Blue Book

• Sufficient resources were committed by 4 agencies to enable the start of the

Telerobotics Working Group

- 37 MM of the required 48 MM were committed

- CSA, DLR, ESA, NASA

- NASA will act as Book Captain

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-51

MOIMS REPORT - Telerobotics BOF Status

• Meeting Summary (Continued)• Telerobotics BOF resolved to start the process for the creation of a

Telerobotics Working Group pending the resolution of the following minor actions- Update the Telerobotics Concept Paper with minor contributions

from participants- Create the required artifacts for new project in the CCSDS

Management Framework from source material- Create the required artifacts for resources assigned to new projects

in the CCSDS Management Framework- Provide the final source documents to the MOIMS Area Director - Actions will be completed within 48 hrs

• AD will issue 2 resolutions

- CESG resolution to nominate Lindolfo Martinez as Tel WG Chair- CMC resolution to approve charter, projects and resources.

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-52

CCSDS Software Licence Agreement/Repository ESA has requested authorisation to release MAL implementation in Java as Open Source Software for

world-wide distribution It is recommended to use a “weak copyleft” open source license Proper governance of the OSS will be a second phase

Adoption on MO Services and Usage of MO framework by 3rd parties (e.g. other WG) Appropriate resources to fully cover this are currently not fully accounted for CESG to take note of this

Recommendation to establish new Mission Planning BOF AD will create the BOF. R. Thompson proposed as Chair(tbd)

The SM&C WG consider that CSS/SM should seriously consider the use of the MO Service Framework in the refactoring of Service Management

There is confusion in the community on the use of SM&C and MO terms SM&C is the name of the WG MO (Mission Operations) is the name of the framework and of the services We recommend to rename the WG from “Spacecraft Monitoring & Control WG” to “Mission Operations

WG” Assume only editorial Search & replace operation (no new charter, …)

MOIMS is pleased to express appreciation to NASA HQ and GRC for their outstanding hosting of this meeting series. Accommodations and internet access were exceptional.

MOIMS REPORT – Issues & More

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-53

• DAI WG• PAIS BB BB Final issue/ Proto 2 being developed.

• NAV WG• CDM Good Progress. • TDM Initiated 5 Year review

• RAC WG• GB At work

• SM&C WG• MAL Issue 2 RIDs processed. Proto being updated.• Java API CESG conditions discussed.• COM BB 3rd Agency Review completed. RIDs processed.

Protos being developed• M&C RB delivered to Secretariat for Agency review• Space Packet Binding RB delivered to Secretariat for Agency Review• XTCE BB 1,2 To be reviewed in OMG (Dec 12)• XTCE GB Published• XTCE Tailoring Renamed on OMG request to Conformance Profile.

RfC published for GovSat (due date 24Oct12)• MPS Interest Group Mission Planning Services BOF to be created

• Telerobotics BOF Revised Charter / Concept Paper / Resource Planning Request for WG creation to be issued by end Oct 12

MOIMS SUMMARY

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-54

Erik Barkley (AD)Margherita di Giulio (DAD)

CROSS SUPPORT SERVICES(CSS) AREA

10-Dec-2012-cesg-55

1. Cross Support Service Management WG (New)

2. Cross Support Transfer Service WG

3. Cross Support Service Architecture WG

CURRENT GROUPS WITHIN AREA

CSS Area Report

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-56

CSS Area ReportMeeting Demographics

Plenary CSA Svc Mngt CSTS

ASI        

CNES 2   1 1

CNSA       1

CSA 1      

DLR 3   1 2

ESA 7 1 2 5

INPE        

JAXA 3 1 3  

NASA 5 2 6 2

RFSA        

UKSA        

Other        

TOTAL 21 4 13 11

Meeting Duration 1 1.5 4 4

Agency Diversity 6 3 5 5

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-57

Cross Support Service Management (CSSM) WG

Goals: Develop Specifications for cross support management for TT+C services

Working Group Status:

• Good progress at inaugural meeting

• Defined three projects• Green Book (Concept)

• To include roadmap • Schedule of Services (BB)

• To be a relatively simple (but not simplistic) data format recommendation

• Extensible/Scalable Framework (BB)

status: OK CAUTION PROBLEM

x

CSS Area Report

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-58

CSSM Planning

Concept GB – First Complete Draft* February 2013

Concept GB – Final Draft (for CESG Review) September 2013

Schedule of Services – First Draft (WB) February 2013

Schedule of Services – Candidate Red to Secretariat June 2013

• Scalable/Extensible Framework project can not start until this has been completed

CSS Area Report

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-59

Cross Support Transfer Services (CSTS) WGWorking Group Summary Situation:

• Framework: Updates to forward side are close enough temporally to merit review with full complement of capabilities (rather than Red-2, followed by Red-3).

• MD-CSTS (Monitor Data) and TD-CSTS (Tracking Data) need to be updated based on framework revisions

• MD-CSTS, to be updated via NASA resources

• No resources identified for updates to TD-CSTS

• RUFT (Return Unframed Telemetry) -- no progress (as planned) -- lack of resources

• Prototypes:

• Framework prototypes: plans identified -- return services: CNES/ESA – provider NASA/GSFC user; forward services via NASA resources (MSFC provider /GSFC user)

• MD-CSTS: plans identified -- ESA, CNES resources;

• TD-CSTS: no resources identified/available

• SLE Orange Book (Enhanced Forward CLTU Service): Published July 2012.

status: OK CAUTION PROBLEM X(Given Available Resources)

CSS Area Report

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-60

The Good News Updated Roadmap – Moving Directly to Red-2 with all Updates

April 2013

December 2013 + Publishing

Spring 2014 + Publishing

Forward spec.

available ?

YES

NO

RED-2 with Return and

Forward Services

Blue-1 with Return and

Forward Services

Blue-1 with Return Services

only

RED-1A with Return and

Forward Services

Blue-2 with Return and

Forward Services

Spring 2013 + Publishing

Fall 2013 + Publishing

December 2012

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-61

CSTS WG Planning (1/2)Name Book Type Milestones (Projected) Date Comments

CSTS Specification Framework

BlueRe-submit for

publishing as Red-2

April 2013 (assuming resources hold)

Includes Forward + Return Services

Guidelines for Specification of CSTSes

MagentaCandidate Red-1 to

SecretariatFeb 2014 (Work differed to 2013)

To be aligned to Red-2 of CSTS FW

CSTS Framework Concept GreenG-1 to be released

coincident with Red-2 of CSTS SF

April 2013  To be aligned to Red-2 of CSTS FW

Monitored Data CSTS Blue

Candidate Red-1 to Secretariat after

completion of CSTS SF Review

April 2013  To be aligned to Red-2 of CSTS FW

Tracking Data CSTS Blue

Candidate Red-1 to Secretariat after

completion of CSTS SF Review

TBD. Resources not available currently

To be aligned to Red-2 of CSTS FW

Prototypes Report and Test Plan

YellowUpdated Report after

completion of prototypesDecember 2013

Done for the first version of Prototypes. The final version will be produced after updates of the

prototypes

CSS Area Report

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-62

CSTS WG Planning (2/2)

Name Book Type Milestone (Projected) Date Comments

Return Unframed Telemetry

Blue First draft White Book Unknown No resources

SLE API Magenta Books Magenta Updates circulated to WG December 2012

The books are being dated to correspond to the current set of SLE

Blue Books

CSS Area Report

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-63

Cross Support Services Architecture (CSSA) WGGoals: • Develop, produce best practices recommendation for cross support services architecture

(MB) – Space Communications Cross Support Architecture Requirements Document (SCCS-ARD)

• Provide concept, rationale re cross support services architecture (GB) – Space Communications Cross Support Architecture Description Document (SCCS-ADD)

WG Summary Situation:• Draft GB Reviewed specifically re

• Enterprise model + CSS Area in general• Functional Resources notion (being used both in CSSM and CSTS)• Common terminology• Alignment with SIS SSI Architecture GB has been done

• Draft MB on hold during this meeting (as Planned; resource constraints)

status: OK CAUTION PROBLEM

X(Given Available

Resources)

CSS Area Report

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-64

CSSA WG Planning

Activity Date

Update the GB (SCCS-ADD), release to AD for consideration as Green-1 for CESG

January 2013

Update MB (SCCS-RM) to be consistent with GB updates, release to Secretariat for preparation as Red-1

May 2013

CSS Area Report

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-65

CSS Area General Notes

• Functional Resources Emerging as common infrastructure for Area

• ISO Object Identifiers being utilized for Functional Resources will be revised for Area Level Coverage

• Monitor Data Parameters at SANA Level will be need an Area Level Policy for SANA Management

• Schedule information is a good candidate for Timelines “payload”

• Service Agreement and Service Catalog projects deleted from CSA WG• Consistent with Re-Chartering

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-66

• CSTS• Framework Specification has progressed well, expect full

capabilities candidate Red-2 by spring meetings

•CSSM• Chartered• 3 Projects defined

• Concept (to include roadmap)

•CSA• Good progress on alignment work re CS ADD and

CSSM• Expect some further refinements to emerge

CSS Area Report: Summary

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-67

Gian Paolo Calzolari (AD)Gilles Moury (DAD)

SPACE LINK SERVICES(SLS) AREA

10-Dec-2012-cesg-68

CURRENTLY ACTIVE WGs, BOFs & SIGs WITHIN AREA

1. RFM WG Radio Frequency & Modulation

2. C&S WG Coding & Synchronisation

3. SLP WG Space Link Protocols

4. NGU WG Next Generation Uplink

5. MHDC WG Multi/Hyperspectral Data Compression

6. SDLS WG Space Data Link Security (Joint with SEA)

7. PlaCom SIG Planetary Communications

8. OCM SIG Optical Coding and Modulation (No Meeting in Cleveland)

SLS AREA REPORT

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-69

SLS Area ReportMeeting Demographics

Plenary C/S SLP RFM C/S+NGU NGU+C/S+RFM+SLP SDLS PLACOM BoF MHDC

ASI                  

CNES 3 3 1 3 4 3 3 3 1

CNSA     1            

CSA               1  

DLR 1 2   1 2 1 2 2  

ESA 4 6 1 5 5 5 2 5 1

INPE                  

JAXA           1      

NASA 3 7 2 5 6 6 5 4 3

RFSA   2 1 1 2 2   2  

UKSA 1   1   1 1 2 1  

Other                  

TOTAL 12 20 7 15 20 19 14 18 5

1 telecon

Meeting Duration 0.5 1 1 1 0.5 0.5 1.5 0.5 1.5

Agency Diversity 5 5 6 5 6 7 5 7 3

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-70

SLS AREA REPORTRadio Frequency and Modulation (RFM) WG – Goals vs Status

1. Recommendation on high rate telemetry and PN ranging (NEW)• Additional independent work finished, one of the supporting Agencies cannot fund required station modifications – study if system

can work without these changes and report at next meeting

2. Recommendations on 26 GHz modulations for SRS (NEW)• Blue rec ready for CESG/CMC publication approval

3. Green book on 2 GHz (CDMA) modulation for missions supported by data relay satellites (NEW)• Green book submitted for CESG/CMC publication approval before Cleveland meeting

4. Recommendation on 32 GHz modulations (Updated)• Blue rec ready for CESG/CMC publication approval along with companion rec on impairments

5. Recommendation on 8 GHz modulation for EESS (2.4.18)• No input for this meeting – DVB-S2 based Blue Book not yet published

6. Recommendation on 4D-8PSK TCM impairments• No input for this meeting

7. Prox-1 PL BB and GB• BB RIDs disposed of , PICs Proforma remain to be addressed, GB not addressed yet

8. White recommendation on comms requirements in emergency• No input for this meeting

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-71

RFM WG SummarySome activities (26 and 32 GHz SRS modulations, CDMA green book, Prox-1 PL BB) are on schedule;

Some activities (revised EESS recs, 4D-8PSK TCM impairments, emergency communications) are behind schedule since no inputs were submitted;

High rate TLM and PN RNG recommendation on hold pending verification of performance with no station modifications.

401 book is a collection of individual recommendations; some updated recently follow the new CCSDS nomenclature (shall, should, etc.), some still use old format. It will be done gradually. Disclaimer recommended.

SLS AREA REPORT

status: OK CAUTION PROBLEM

comment: Some delays experienced due to technical issues and missing resources

Funding problem may result in no recommendation for GMSK/PN

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-72

SLS AREA REPORT

RFM WG – Resolutions

Recommendations on 26 GHz modulationsSubmit to CESG/CMC Blue rec 2.4.12ASubmit to CESG/CMC Blue rec 2.4.21A

Send Pink rec 2.3.2 back to WG for another lookKeep Blue rec 3.3.3A (was to be suppressed) until new Blue 2.3.2

Recommendation on 32 GHz modulationsSubmit to CESG/CMC Blue rec 2.4.20BSubmit to CESG/CMC Blue rec 2.4.12B

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-73

C&S: Coding & Synchronization WG

• Achievements before this meeting:

• RIDs discussion and proposed disposition for 211.2-P.1-1

• TC Green Book 230.1-G and TM Green Book 130.1-G reviews concluded, resolutions for publication issued by SLS/AD

SLS AREA REPORT

status: OK CAUTION PROBLEM

comment: Good progress

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-74

C&S: Coding & Synchronization WG - Working Group Summary progress (1 of 2)

DVB-S2 Standardization

Finalization of Agency review for 131.3-R, with RIDs discussion and agreed disposition.

CNES will produce an update of the book based on the agreed disposition (1 week after the meeting)

WG consensus, resolution for publication will be issued after the WG has received the updated book and verified the correct implementation of the dispositions (2 weeks after received the book)

Proximity-1 Review & Upgrade

Proposed RIDs disposition discussed and agreed at the meeting.

PICs remain to be addressed

SLS AREA REPORT

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-75

C&S: Coding & Synchronization WG - Working Group Summary progress (2 of 2)

Long Erasures Codes

DLR presented an initial proposal on a class of non-binary codes for erasure channels.

A new version of the Orange Book will be provided by DLR.

Short (64, 128, 256 bit ) LDPC codes for uplink - Orange Book

NASA produced an update of the Orange book, with some details of the implementation (SCaN testbed) of TC decoders for short and longer codewords.

The book will be updated by DLR with material relative to other alternative codes for uplink

TM Coding Green Book (issue 3)

Initial discussion on the structure of SCCC Green Book contribution

SLS AREA REPORT

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-76

SLS Space Link Protocols (SLP) WG

Goals:1. RID resolution of 5-year review version of Prox-1 Space Data Link

Protocol (in concert with RF&Mod and C&S WGs)2. Interoperability Lessons Learnt to be added to Proximity-1 Green

Book, PICs Proforma to be added to Blue Book3. Changes to AOS/TM/TC due to SDLS requirements4. 5-year Review of AOS and TM5. Presentation of NASA proposal for a singular all encompassing CCSDS

Link Layer protocol for future replacement of TM/AOS/TC/Proximity-1

status: OK CAUTION PROBLEM

comment: Good progress

SLS AREA REPORT

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-77

SLP WG Summary Progress:

• RID resolution of Prox-1 Space Data Link Layer Protocol Blue Book• Consensus reached on RIDs submitted by ESA and SLS AD• SLP also provided comment to C&S and RF&MOD on Prox-1 related RIDs

• PICS Proforma accepted into the Prox-1 Data Link Layer book provided by UK Space Agency pending WG Review

• Updates to Proximity-1 Green Book due to 5- year review of Prox-1 Blue books• UK Space Agency/NASA Lessons Learnt as described at this meeting to be

factored into the GB• Changes to AOS/TM/TC due to SDLS requirements will have to be synchronized

with SDLS approved changes • Pending AOS/TM previously approved pink sheets and 5-year Review

• WG Approved AOS & TM 2008 pink sheets (OID frame etc) pending• SDLS affected sections in AOS, TM, TC Space Data Link books have been

identified by G. Kazz and Marjorie De Lange Long • Interface between Packet Processing and Virtual Channel Generation Function

has been examined but still needs further checking • NASA presented a refined proposal for a single future all encompassing link layer

protocol to be used by all future missions• Merges the best of all the CCSDS link layer protocols into one

SLS AREA REPORT

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-78

SLS-SLP WG (cnt’d)

Problems and Issues:• None

Planning:

• Joint discussion for PICS Proforma for Proximity-1 with RF&MOD and C&S WGs for next meeting.

• AOS/TM/TC updates due to SDLS requirements, 5-year Review of TM/AOS, and pending AOS and TM changes to go under Agency Review so that RIDs can be resolved with SDLS protocol update at the Spring 2013 meeting.

• Update Proximity-1 GB and review it at Spring 2013 meeting• WG encouraged to consider forming a BOF for the development of a single

unified link layer protocol (also presented in NGU meeting). NASA will provide for BOF discussion a Concept Paper including an analysis of cost savings to justify such a proposal.

SLS AREA REPORT

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-79

Next Generation Uplink (NGU)

Goal:• Provide Status of NGU Green Book on functionality, performance,

application profiles, trade offs, etc. for Next Generation Uplink• Verify consensus on whether or not WG is willing to propose upgrade

to the CCSDS Telecommand Standard based upon NGU recommendations – NASA/JPL

• Present latest work on NASA short non-binary LDPC codes for uplink• Present latest work on DLR short non-binary LDPC codes for uplink

status: OK CAUTION PROBLEM

comment: Good progress

SLS AREA REPORT

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-80

NGU WG Summary Progress

• Status of NGU Green Book

• DLR material on LDPC codes added to this book.

• Book to be split into:

• Part 1 to contain all of the higher level system engineering aspects of NGU

• Part 2 to contain all of the coding & synchronization specific information

• NASA presented a proposed NGU upgrade to TC Sync & Channel Coding Blue book

• Fundamental approach is to add TBD LDPC code as optional to the standard for deep space missions given large performance gains (up to 6.3 dB) over BCH in SEC mode. Example Pink sheets have been provided to the NGU CWE.

• NASA presented status and results on short non binary LDPC codes for uplink application

• DLR presented status and results on short non binary LDPC codes for uplink application

SLS AREA REPORT

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-81

NGU WG Summary Progress

Planning :

• Restructure NGU Green book into two major parts (High Level System Engineering and Uplink Coding).

• Propose Concept Paper to SLS-C&S to recommend upgrades to TC Sync & CC standard to determine a new CLTU format (e.g. LDPC encoded) in addition to the traditional BCH CLTU. This requires investigating e.g.

• Reviewing the TBD recommendation below of the Applicable Coding Scheme (including performances, complexity, randomization, etc.)

• Required Message Start Sequence

• Required Message Tail Sequence

• Update the NASA and DLR study of short length LDPC codes for uplink and provide an input paper working towards a recommendation for NGU by Spring 2013 meeting.

SLS AREA REPORT

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-82

Multispectral & Hyperspectral Data Compression (MHDC) WG1. 120.0-G Lossless Data Compression Green Book:

• Revisions proposed to reflect updates in recently published 121.0-B-2.

2. 120.2-G Lossless Multispectral & Hyperspectral Image Compression Green Book:

• Significant new text added

3. Proposed updates for Issue 2 of 122.0-B Image Data Compression to support pre-processing stage to provide Lossy Compression of multi-/hyperspectral images

• Only minor changes needed to existing chapters of current 122B (primarily extending the bit depth supported and minor revisions to headers)

• New White Book chapters delivered that document pre-processing stage (lengthy technical discussions)

Working Group Status: Active

status: OK CAUTION PROBLEM

comment: Good progress

SLS AREA REPORT

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-83

SLS AREA REPORT

MHDC WG (con’t)Problems and Issues:• NonePlanning :• 120.0-G Lossless Data Compression Green Book:

• WG members to review and confirm approval of current draft (Nov); deliver to AD & Editor (Dec)

• 120.2-G Lossless Multispectral & Hyperspectral Image Compression:

• Review of current chapters and writing of new chapters (several deliverables staged between now and Spring 2013 WG meeting)

• Pre-processing stage for 122.0-B to support lossy multi-/hyperspectral image compression:

• White Book to be revised based on feedback provided at this meeting

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-84

Space Data Link Security (SDLS) WGWorking Group Status: Active - Progress report:1. SDLS core protocol

• Coherency of SDLS protocol specification with SLP protocols specification• Discussion of ESA proposal to describe SDLS specification as an SLP embedded function• Discussion of SLP WG proposal for introducing SDLS security function into SLP books (TM, TC and

AOS)• Decision on way forward : Simultaneous update and agency review of SDLS and SLP books for

coherency check by independent reviewer (target : Spring 2013)

• Interoperability testing: No firm planning for simulator development. Only firm commitment : CNES

• SDLS core protocol green book : 75% complete 2. SDLS extended procedures : User Requirements Document reviewed and finalized, outline and

framework for future recommendation agreed.

SLS AREA REPORT

status: OK CAUTION PROBLEM

comment: Good progress Interoperability testing

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-85

SLS AREA REPORT

Space Data Link Security (SDLS) protocol (cont’d)Problems and Issues:• no firm commitment for development of second independent implementation of

core protocol : could delay even further SDLS blue book publication

Planning:• SDLS core protocol:

• Red-3 book incorporating SLP coherent SDLS function specification: December 2013

• Red-3 agency review, RIDs disposition and finalization of SDLS specification : Spring 2013 meeting

• Interoperability testing: by Fall 2013• Green book ready for publication : June 2013

• SDLS extended procedures:• Red-1 expected end 2013• Blue book end 2014

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-86

SLS Planetary Surface Communications (PLACOM) SIG

Goal:• Survey and report on agencies needs and planning for lunar and Martian local

communications/navigation infrastructure (surface coms/nav and surface-orbit coms/nav)

• Establish a preliminary coarse inventory of communications/navigation requirements (URD)

• Identify the way forward, e.g. proposal for the creation of a WG, type of book needed (BB, MB, GB, …)

status: OK CAUTION PROBLEMX

SLS AREA REPORT

PLACOM SIG Summary Progress:

• Member agencies lunar/martian exploration plans under redefinition; New inputs before Spring’13 meeting

• Applications Profiles document produced and discussed• Decision to set-up a BOF for submission of proposal for a WG for GB development

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-87

SLS Planetary Surface Communications (PLACOM) SIG

Progress• The SIG has accumulated a large amount of data for planetary

communications/navigation• No mechanism to archive and exploit these data• SFGC is preparing to publish a recommendation on frequency

bands to use in lunar environment• Some members of the SIG are of the opinion that some key

frequency bands are missing in the SFCG suite• PCOM SIG members agree that situation is not mature to start

developing a standard• A BOF has been put in place to submit to the SLS-AD at the

Spring’13 meeting a proposal for the creation of a WG for the development of a Green Book

SLS AREA REPORT

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-88

SLS-OCM: Optical Coding & Modulations (SIG)Goals:

• Provide a discussion forum for cooperation and cross-support

• Prepare creation of a WG

status: OK CAUTION PROBLEM

comment: Future depends on IOAG recommendations

SLS AREA REPORT

Summary Progress:• OCM SIG did not meet in Cleveland according to the conclusions from the Spring

2012 Meeting in Darmstadt, i.e.: "If the IOAG does not recommend standardization, the OCM SIG activities will stop. If the IOAG has positive recommendations on standardization, the OCM SIG will meet again as BOF to prepare concept paper(s) and charter for WG creation.”

• Mailing List open as Forum for posting by MembersPlanning:• OCM SIG will move towards BoF and WG if IOAG recommends to start

standardization.See details on next page(s)

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-89

SLS-OCM: Optical Coding & Modulations (SIG)• OLSG recommendations will only be available (earliest) at IOAG-16

Meeting in December 2012, therefore no OCM SIG Meeting in Cleveland.

• OLSG Report to be updated with more analysis mostly on operational issues such as impact of clouds, airplanes, laser safety, etc.

• OLSG Standardization Guidance Addendum to contain recommendations for what parameters should be tackled by CCSDS (e.g. modulation; coding; point, acquisition, and tracking approaches, etc).

• Possible timeline as per attached OLSG Roadmap presented at IOAG-15b.

SLS AREA REPORT

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-90

SLS-OCM: Optical Coding & Modulations (SIG)

SLS AREA REPORT

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-91

RFM WG Radio Frequency & Modulation• 26 and 32 GHz SRS modulations, CDMA green book, Proximity-1 Physical Layer BB are on

schedule;• Revised EESS recs, 4D-8PSK TCM impairments, emergency communications are behind schedule

since no inputs were submitted; • High rate TLM and PN RNG recommendation on hold pending verification of performance with

no station modifications.

C&S WG Coding & Synchronisation• TC Green Book 230.1-G and TM Green Book 130.1-G reviews concluded, resolutions for

publication issued• Agency review for 131.3-R DVB-S2 Standardization finalized and publication imminent• Update of Proximity-1 Coding BB under finalization• Work in progress for Orange Books on Long Erasures Codes and Short LDPC codes for uplink, and

Telemetry Coding GB Issue 3

SLP WG Space Link Protocols• Update of Proximity-1 Data Link BB under finalization• Update of TM/TC/AOS protocols BB’s to undergo Agency Review in spring taking into account

SDLS integration too.• Proximity-1 GB update in agenda for Spring 2013 meeting• WG encouraged to consider forming a BOF for the development of a single unified link layer

protocol.

SLS AREA REPORT – SUMMARY (1 of 3)

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-92

NGU WG Next Generation Uplink• NGU Green book in work and going to be restructured into two major parts (High Level System

Engineering and Uplink Coding).• Possible NGU upgrade to TC Sync & Channel Coding Blue book discussed. TO inestigate for

proposing Concept Paper to SLS-C&S to recommend upgrades to TC Sync & CC standard to determine an additional new CLTU format (e.g. LDPC encoded).

MHDC WG Space Link Protocols• 120.0-G Lossless Data Compression Green Book under revisions to reflect updates in recently

published 121.0-B-2.• Significant new text added to 120.2-G Lossless Multispectral & Hyperspectral Image Compression

Green Book:• White Book proposes Lossy Compression of multi-/hyperspectral images to be defined as pre-

processing stage update in 122.0-B Image Data Compression

SDLS WG Space Data Link Security• Coherency of SDLS protocol specification with SLP protocols will be addressed describing SDLS

specification as SLP embedded function for security. Simultaneous update and agency review of SDLS and SLP books will ensure coherency check by independent reviewer (target : Spring 2013)

• Only one firm commitment for Interoperability testing: may delay SDLS blue book publication.• SDLS Extended procedures in progress.

SLS AREA REPORT – SUMMARY (2 of 3)

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-93

PLACOM SIG Planetary Surface Communications• The SIG has accumulated a large amount of data for planetary communications/navigation and

Applications Profiles document produced and discussed• PCOM SIG members agree that situation is not mature to start developing a standard• BOF has been put in place to submit to the SLS-AD at the Spring’13 meeting a proposal for the

creation of a WG for the development of a Green Book.

OCM SIG Optical Coding & Modulations• No Meeting in Cleveland.• Waiting for IOAG output on “OLSG Standardization Guidance Addendum”• Possible timeline foresees OCM BoF expected to work during 2013 (Spring and Fall Meetings) for

WG start by Spring 2014

SLS AREA REPORT – SUMMARY (3 of 3)

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-94

Keith Scott (AD)Dai Stanton (DAD)

SPACEINTERNETWORKING SERVICES

(SIS) AREA REPORT

10-Dec-2012-cesg-95

SIS Area ReportMeeting Demographics

Plenary MIA DTN DTN-Interop Test Voice

ASI          

CNES     1 1  

CNSA     2 1  

CSA   1 2    

DLR   1 1 1 1

ESA     1    

INPE          

JAXA     1 1  

NASA 3 7 7 9 5

RFSA     2 1 1

UKSA     1    

Other*     1 1  

TOTAL 3 9 19 15 7

*Greece *Greece

Meeting Duration 0.5 1 1.5 0.5 1.5

Agency Diversity 1 3 9 6 3

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-96

Goals:• WG review of ‘Digital Motion Imagery’ book (Blue) – more resolution on referenced standards• Update book schedule (from Magenta to Blue – framework schedule updated)• Discuss future projects • Develop preliminary interoperability testing plan

Working Group Status:• Ready to move forward now that CESG has resolved book color question• Expect resolution to publish by end of November

Remarks• Productive meetings and good participation (ESA and JAXA responsive via email but have not participated in face-to-face meetings in two

years)• How do we change the document type in the Framework?

Plans• Quickly complete last changes and move forward with Red Book 1• Planned ESA / NASA video test early CY2013 will likely become the first prototype interoperability test• Should be ready to review Digital Motion Imagery RIDS during April technical meetings• Will begin more intensive discussion of future work for MIA during April technical meetings

• Start process of revising Green Book

SIS Area Report

status: OK CAUTION PROBLEM

Comment:Productive Meetings On schedule

Working Group Summary Situation:

Motion Imagery Applications (MIA) WG

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-97

Goals: • Review and agreement on the all new chapter 3 of the Magenta Book (will be changed to Blue per discussion with

CESG)• Review and update of the security annex of the Magenta Book• Proposal to update the Green book postponed until after finishing the Magenta Book

• Proximity Operations and Docking Voice added and reviewed, need more information• Search and Rescue Voice added and reviewed, more information is needed.• Audio File Formats added and reviewed.

• Establish plan and schedule for MB completion (schedule in framework updated)• EVA and Vehicle to Vehicle voice will be added, more information is needed.• New crew IP voice conference, IP phone calls from Space and Audio files handling and voice/text conversion

added, need to be review and more information is also needed

Working Group Status:• Tasks assigned for final update of Magenta Book for review by Spring meeting

Plans

• Propose a joint meeting with DTN in the Fall (2013) to discuss streaming service over BP

• Rework the book to add Blue-Book specific material

status: OK CAUTION PROBLEMcomment: MB Schedule in

CWE UpdatedNO

Working Group Summary Situation:

Voice WG

SIS Area Report

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-98

Goals: • Review Solar System Internetworking Architecture Green Book

• Go through BP Red-1 RIDS and finalize

• Formulate interoperability test plan for BP

• Review progress on DTN interoperability

Working Group Status:

• LTP testing ready to begin (2 implementations ready, testers identified – expect completion by early 2013)

• Coordination of registries between IANA / SANA worked out and moving forward (needed to finalize BP book; expect January 2013)

Joint / Cross-Area Meetings• Informal coordination between SSI Architecture Green Book and CSS-CSA Architecture

Plans

• Proceed with LTP Testing• Finish resolutions to BP Red-1 RIDs and start test plan / execution

status: OK CAUTION PROBLEMcomment:

Working Group Summary Situation:

SIS Area ReportDelay/Disruption Tolerant Networking (DTN) Working Group

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-99

1. Need to spin up WGs for Book Renewals:• CFDP• SCPS-TP

2. Closing out WGs:• AMS (waiting on Green Book approval)

3. Voice WG book color – will they be made Blue?• [CESG asserts yes]

4. Interoperability testing• Do we need to test the service specifications (e.g. test that all the

indications are in fact produced?)- [CESG asserts yes]

• Malformed field testing? E.g.:- Conformant implementations will silently discard PDUs with malformed headers.’

- [CESG asserts that representative testing of ‘negative’ results is OK; logging, or at least instrumentation of the test implementations to detect e.g. silent discard of malformed headers is required.]

- What about ‘The value 11 in this field is reserved’?

SIS Area Report: Other

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-100

1. Asynchronous Message Service Working Group• Awaiting publication of Green Book before disbanding WG; it’s in CESG final poll now…

2. CFDP-over-Encapsulation Working Group• CESG PIDs resolved; ready to be submitted for RED-1 Agency review

3. IP Over CCSDS Working Group• Blue Book done; working group closing

4. Motion Imagery and Applications Working Group• Very close to having book ready for Red 1, Agency Review• Opportunity for real-world interoperability test between NASA & ESA in early 2013• Beginning plans for future MIA books

5. Delay Tolerant Networking Working Group• About to start LTP interoperability testing• Reviewed BP for CCSDS book; started building interoperability test requirements and test cases

6. Voice Working Group• Revising Magenta Book (will be changed to Blue); general agreement on the content of the all

new book• Target publication in 2 meetings (Fall 2013)• Green Book was reviewed, proposal to update after finishing Magenta Book

• Other• Need to spin up working groups for CFDP and SCPS-TP refresh

• Would like for CFDP refresh to include moderate changes• SCPS-TP refresh may be pro-forma

SIS Area Report: Summary

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-101

CESG FALL 2011MEETING STATISTICS

10-Dec-2012-cesg-102

Fall 2012 Total Attendance

020406080

100120140160180

Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday

Spring 2012 Fall 2012

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-103

Fall 2012 Attendance By Sponsoring Agency

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

Spring 2012 Fall 2012

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-104

Fall 2012 Daily Attendance By Area

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday

SEA

SLS

MOIMS

SIS

CSS

SOIS

UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-105

Fall 2012 Daily Room Utilization

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri

Requested

Used

Used Spring 2012UPDATE

10-Dec-2012-cesg-106

Many thanks to NASA for meeting hosting during the CCSDS Fall 2012 meetings!

We’re done!

Data Archive Ingestion

Navigation Spacecraft

Monitor & Control

Digital Repository Audit/Certification

Telerobotics

Mission Ops &Info Mgt Services

Asynchronous Messaging

IP-over-CCSDS Links

Motion Imagery & Apps

Delay Tolerant Networking

Voice CFDP over

Encapsulation

Space InternetworkingServices

CS Service Management

CS Transfer Services

Cross Supt Service Arch.

Cross SupportServices

RF & Modulation Coding & Sync. Multi/Hyper Data

Comp. Space Link

Protocols Next Generation

Uplink Space Data Link

Security Planetary Comm Optical Coding

and Mod

Space LinkServices

Onboard Wireless WG

Application Supt Services (incl. Plug-n-Play)

Spacecraft Onboard Interface Services

MISSION CONTROLCENTER

MISSION CONTROLCENTER

End Users

End Users

Applications/Archives

Security Space Assigned Numbers

Auth. Delta-DOR Time Correlation &

Synchronization

Systems Engineering

UPDATE