Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with...

19
Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status First International Renewable Energy Storage Conference (IRES I)

Transcript of Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with...

Page 1: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status

First International Renewable Energy Storage Conference (IRES I)

Page 2: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

Electricity Storage Association

Formerly the Energy Storage AssociationTrade Association with 60+ members from three continentsUtilities, suppliers of energy storage equipment and services, research institutionsMission: To promote the development and commercialization of competitive and reliable electricity storage delivery systems …

Page 3: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

Battery technologies

Conventional batteriese.g. Lead-acid, Ni-Cd,

Ni-MH

Removewater Lithium batteries

e.g. Li-ion, Li-polymer,Li-metal polymer, Li-S

Addheat

High-temperature batteriese.g. Na-S, Na-NiCl2

Separate powerfrom energy

Flow batteriese.g. Vanadium redox, Zn-Br

Page 4: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

Non-battery technologies

Flywheels (conventional & high-speed)Electric double-layer capacitors

Super / ultra capacitorsSymmetric / asymmetric

Large-scale storagePumped hydroCompressed air (CAES)

Superconducting magnetic (SMES)

Page 5: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

Application issues

Power vs. energyHigh-power, short-duration dischargesHigh-energy, long-duration discharges

ScalabilitykW MWkWh MWh

Cycling capabilityElectricalThermal

Page 6: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

kW ←

Pow

er →

MW

kWh ← Energy → MWh

Power, Energy & Scale

SMES EDLC/flywheel

Conventional

Flow

NAS

Seconds Minutes

Hours

Lithium

Approximate information. Installed systems as of mid-2006.

Page 7: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

Power & energy with wind power

Seconds of dischargeSmoothing of wind output

Minutes of dischargeLoad followingRamping controlBridging to conventional generation

Hours of dischargeDispatch and commitment

Page 8: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

Battery storage systems in action

Several examples of technical success storiesWide application spectrum

Seconds / minutes / hours

Many are also commercially viable,or close to being so

Page 9: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

Seconds, minutes & hours - Utsira

Norsk Hydro projectEnercon wind turbinesSeconds of storage

Enercon flywheel

Minutes of storageSaft Ni-Cd battery

Hours of storageElectrolyzerFuel cellHydrogen ICE generator

Source: Norsk Hydro

Page 10: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

Seconds – Hawaii “ESA”

Hawaii Electric Co conceptElectronic Shock Absorber

S&C Electric demonstration project

Lalamilo wind farm40 x 100 kVA wind turbines2 x 250 kVA converters

Ultracapacitor storageMaxwell & Epcos

Stabilizes grid frequencyLocal reactive power support

Source: S&C Electric

Page 11: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

Frequency problems in weak grids

Source: S&C Electric / HECO

Page 12: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

Minutes – remote power grids

Isolated grids with diesel powerSolar power station

Allows diesels to be turned off

Short-duration battery system

100’s kW / 5 minutesSmoothes solar outputBridges to diesels

Source: Solar Systems Pty Ltd

Page 13: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

Hours – Sorne Hill wind farm

Tapbury Management32 MW wind farm

VRB Power flow battery1.5 MW / 12 MWhPossible expansion to add 50 MWh

EconomicsBetter prices for conditioned powerAvoiding curtailment

Source: VRB Power

Page 14: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

Hours – Subaru project, Hokkaido

Tomomae wind farm30.6 MW rated output

VRB demonstration system

Sumitomo / J-Power4 MW / 6 MWh

NEDO funding to optimize control strategy

Source: J-Power

Page 15: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

Hours – Hachijojima Island

TEPCO demonstrationNEDO sponsored500 kW wind turbine400 kW NGK NAS battery

Largest NAS battery installed to date

Hitachi parts plant8 MW / 7 hours

Source: NGK Insulators

Page 16: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

Weeks – Iowa Stored Energy Park

Iowa Association of Municipal Utilities25 to 200 MW wind generationCAES system

Underground aquifer storage of compressed air and natural gas200 MW x 8 hours, 30 to 45 days

Estimated to be on-line in 2011

Page 17: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

Gathering momentum…

Installation of storage with renewables is accelerating

Demonstration systems‘Low-hanging fruit’

More installations help lower costsBringing more installations

The technology is ready…

Page 18: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

Overcoming barriers

Barriers still existGovernment subsidiesRegulatoryTariff-basedCultural

The storage industry must work with all parties to overcome these barriers

GovernmentsRegulatorsUtilitiesOperators

Page 19: Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status · Implementation of Storage with Renewables – Industry Status ... Bridging to conventional generation ... Electronic

For further information…

Any questions:[email protected]

Electricity Storage Associationwww.electricitystorage.org(includes links to ESA member companies)