I Survived a Cult

8/9/2019 I Survived a Cult

1/142

"

! #$%&'&() * +$,-./(%0123, 4,'560(0 17 32 891)$0

#$ %&'( )&**+(,


2/142

-

./0 ,'1** 2314 53&6 7'0 '0137 &5 ,85503+(9 +7,0*5

7'0 601(, &5 +(,:+317+&( 1(2 ,83;+;1* /+(,7&( )'83?'+**


3/142

@

:3;,( 17 +12-(2-0

A3&6 B A17'03 C& D+, E&(


4/142

F

"#$% & "'()*# +$ ,-. /$0


5/142

O

.E&(L 7'030 130 74& :0&:*0 J '170 6&,7 +( *+50[ 1

7'+05 1(2 1 *+13


6/142

K

7301?'03$< .B** 60( '1;0 51**0( ,'&37L= 1(2 .J5 40

,1$ 40 '1;0 (& ,+(L 40 20?0+;0 &83,0*;0,L 1(27'0 7387' +, (&7 +( 8,1(2>4'+70

,07 &5 6&31* ,71(2132,< C'030 ?&8*2 #0 (& 931$L5&3 9&&2 1(2 0;+* ?1((&7 6+\< C'0 .7'+05 1(2 7'0

*+13= :3&;03# ?1( #0 1::*+02 7& 1*6&,7 0;03$

?+3?86,71(?0< J5 7'0 (0+9'#&3 31( &87 &5 ,:1?01(2 8,02 $&83 731,' #+(L '0 41, ,701*+(9 53&6

$&8< J5 7'0 ,1*0, 30:30,0(717+;0 2+2 (&7 58**$0\:*1+( 7'0 '+220( 500,L ,'0 *+02 7& $&8< /'0(

7'0 9&;03(60(7 2061(202 +(?&60 71\ 7&

:3&;+20 :3&70?7+&(L :1;02 3&12,L 1(2 &7'0353002&6,L 7'0$ 4030 7'0 4&3,7 &5 7'+0;0,< ^1?'

1(2 0;03$ :03,&( 7'17 ?&60, +( ?&(71?7 68,7 51**

+(7& 5&83 ?1709&3+0,[ 7'&,0 4'& ,7&*0L 7'&,0 4'&*+02L 7'&,0 4'& 2+2 #&7'L 1(2 7'&,0 4'& 2+2

(0+7'03


7/142

T

C'0 6&31* ;1*80, ?&(71+(02 +( 7'+, :3&;03# 130

:&40358* 7& 1 ?'+*2< J( 1 4&3*2 4'030 6&31*;1*80, 1::013 7& 20?*+(0L ?'+*230( (002 1 ,73&(9

5&8(217+&( 53&6 4'+?' 7& 205+(0 7'0 :&,+7+;0 ,+20&5 7'0+3 :03,&(1*+7$< J5 :130(7, 4&8*2 ?&6#+(0

7'+, :3&;03# 4+7' &7'03, ?&(71+(+(9 0\16:*0, &5?&6:1,,+&(L *&;0L 5&39+;0(0,, 1(28(203,71(2+(9L 7'0$ ?&8*2 01,+*$ ?30170 :01?0 &(

0137'<

J (0;03 301*+]02 _8,7 '&4 68?' 7'0 4&32, 1#&87

7'0 7'+05 1(2 7'0 *+13 4&8*2 +6:1?7 6$ *+50<C'0,0 4&32, 4&8*2 #0 7'0 6&31* ?&20 J ,73+;02

7& 61+(71+(L #87 7'0$ 4030 68?' 6&30 7'1( 7'17<

J( 7'0 :3&?0,, &5 *013(+(9 #1*1(?0 #07400( '1701(2 ?&6:1,,+&(L 7'0$ #0?160 1 7+?R+(9 7+60

#&6# 41+7+(9 7& 0\:*&20


8/142

G

1)2#3) +$ 1)2#3)


9/142

W

C'0 213R(0,, 13&8(2 60 50*7 *+R0 1 *&4L #+**&4+(9

5&9 +( 7'0 6+2,7 &5 ,?8302 6&&(*+9'7< J7 41, 1?&(,86+(9 7'+?R(0,,` '+2+(9 0;03$7'+(9 +7

?&;0302< B(2 '+220( +( 7'0 '0137 &5 7'0 5&9 41,7'0 8(R(&4(< J7 41, 1 213R(0,, 7'17 &7'03,

?&8*2 (&7 ,00< a&+?0, 13&8(2 60L *189'+(9 1(2?'00358*L &570( #*0(202 7&907'03 +(7& 1(&;034'0*6+(9 683683 &5 +(2+,7+(98+,'1#*0

4&32, 7'17 0;0(781**$ 51202 +(7& 1 *&4>*0;0*

'86<

E+*0(?0 41, #&7' ?&65&37 1(2 7&37830< C'0:01?058* 6&60(7, +( ,0?*8,+&( &570( *02 7&

1771?R, &5 1(\+07$< C'0305&30L ,+*0(?0 41, #0,7

5+**02 4+7' 0+7'03 68,+? &3 7'0 30:07+7+;0 #017+(93'$7'6 &5 7'0 30?&3202 ;&+?0 JI2 *013(02 7&

0(_&$< B ;&+?0 4'&,0 ,&57 7&(0, *012+(9 7& ,'3+**?&661(2, J 4&3,'+::02 1(2 12&302L 8(1413021(903 #83+02 200: #0(017' +7, ,?3016,<

C&,,+(9 1(2 783(+(9 +( 7'0 #02L J ,:0(7 '&83, +(

7&360(7< H1$,L 400R,L 6&(7', 40(7 #$L 4+7'&87

7'0 '01*+(9 J *&(902 5&3 &5 #&2$ 1(2 6+(2<M02+717+&( 1(2 :31$03 4030 6$ 602+?+(0L 7'0

#017+(9 ;&+?0 41, 6$ 7'031:$L 1(2 V&2 41, 6$?830< /'$ 41, D0 41+7+(9b /'$ 2+2 7'0 '01*+(9

(0;03 ?&60b

Q(0>#$>&(0L 7'&,0 13&8(2 60 ,713702 7& 5120

141$< C'0 :0&:*0 J *01(02 &( 6&,7L 4'&

:3&6+,02 7& #0 4+7' 60 7& 7'0 0(2L #091( 7&*01;0< /1, 7'+, 7'0 0(2b J #091( 7& 4+,' 7'17 +7

4030< C'030 41, (&7'+(9 +( 7'+, *+50 4&37' *+;+(95&3L &(*$ &(0 7'+(9 +( *+50 4&37' 2$+(9 5&3L 1(2 7'0

:3&6+,0 &5 1 (04 *+50 7& ?&60< B (04 *+50 4+7'&87


10/142

"X

,+?R(0,, &3 2017'L 1 *+50 (& *&(903 #8320(02 4+7'

7'0 :1+( 1(2 ,85503+(9 7'17 '12 #0?&60 1 41$ &5*+50<

)&*2L ,700* R(+;0, ,00602 7& :+03?0 7'3&89' 6$

706:*0, +( 1 3'$7'6+? #017< U3+9'7 *+9'7, 4&8*2&570( ?87 7'3&89' 7'0 :8:+*,L 1, 7'&89' *&&R+(9 171 5*8&30,?0(7 *+9'7 #8*# 4030 *&&R+(9 2+30?7*$ 17

7'0 ,8(< D&7 ?'+**,L ?&*2 ,4017L 7&,,+(9 1(2

783(+(9 53&6 1 :1+( 7'17 2+2 (&7 0\+,7 c 1**,$6:7&6, &5 1 2+,01,0 J ?&8*2 (&7 0\:*1+(<

/1, J 2$+(9b /'17 +5 +7 +, 1 #31+( 786&3 ?18,+(9

7'0 :1+(b B30 6+931+(0 '0121?'0, (&361*b

E'&8*2 7'0 '0137 500* *+R0 +7I, #017+(9 &87 &5 7'0?'0,7 ?1;+7$ 4+7'&87 :'$,+?1* 1?7+;+7$b J 40(7

7'3&89' 61($L 61($ d80,7+&(, 7'17 '12 (&1(,403 4+7'&87 0\70(,+;0 602+?1* 0\16+(17+&(<B(2 J 41, 1531+2 &5 4'17 7'17 0\16+(17+&( 6+9'7

30;01*e

E&607'+(9 41, 43&(9< J '12 7& .907 &;03 +7


11/142

""

Q83 516+*$ 41, :137 &5 1 30*+9+&8, 6&;060(7 7'1731+,02 7'0 ?83+&,+7$ &5 7'&,0 13&8(2 8,< J7 4&8*2

#0 ;03$ 01,$ 7& ,+6:*$ 70** 7'06L ./0I30N0(70?&,71*= 1(2 ?'1(90 7'0 ,8#_0?7L #87 6$

6&31* ?&20 4&8*2 (&7 1**&4< /0 4030 ,+6+*13 7&7'0 N0(70?&,71* 6&;060(7L #87 40 '12122+7+&(1* .7387',= 7'17 &7'03 N0(70?&,71*, 2+2

(&7 '1;0< /0 R(04 2+;+(0 6$,703+0, 1(2 '12

+(,+20 +(5&3617+&( &( 7'0 +6:0(2+(9 20,738?7+&(&5 61(R+(2< /0 R(04 '&4 +7 4&8*2 '1::0(L

3+9'7 2&4( 7& 7'0 4&3*2 0;0(7, *012+(9 8: 7&B3619022&(<

C'+, 4&3*2 41, (&7 &83 '&60< J7 41, 706:&313$L3+9'7 2&4( 7& 7'0 5&83 41**, 7'17 ,0:131702 8,

53&6 7'0 &87,+20 1+3< C'030 41, &(0 ?&(,71(7 +(*+50L 1(2 7'17 ?&(,71(7 41, 30*&?17+&( 53&6 ?+7$ 7&?+7$ &3 ,7170 7& ,7170L 53&6 &(0 0(2 &5 7'0 ?&8(73$

7& 7'0 &7'03< )'83?' 41, 1( +(70931* :137 &5 &83*+;0,L 1(2 40 '12 7'0 &::&378(+7$ &5 #0+(9 :137 &5

,0;031* ?'83?'0, 7'17 5&**&402 &83 ,160 #0*+05

,$,706< C'0$ 4030 &83 #3&7'03, 1(2 ,+,703,L 1(2?&6#+(02L 40 4030 7'0 .U3+20 &5 )'3+,7


12/142

"-

)'3+,7+1( V&,:0*L #87 #0?18,0 40 R(04 1#&87

.C'0 N3&:'07


13/142

"@

0\:03+0(?0,L #87 '1;+(9 6&30 +(,+9'7 +(7& 7'0

N3&:'07 1(2 '+, :03,&(1* *+50< C& '013 7'06 70**8, 6&30 1#&87 7'0 N3&:'07L ,7&3+0, 7'17 40 ?&8*2

(&7 :83?'1,0 &( ?1,,0770L 41, 1 ,:0?+1* #*0,,+(9<C'0$ 91;0 8, 1 #07703 ;+04 +(7& 7'0 61( 7'17 40

'12 93&4( 7& *&;0 1(2 738,7<

Q83 516+*$ 41, 2+55030(7< /0 4030 ,:0?+1*L #87 J

2+2(I7 58**$ 8(203,71(2 4'$ 8(7+* J 301?'02 6$

*170 700(,< ^1?' ?'83?' 40 ;+,+702 1*3012$,00602 7& R(&4 8,< C'0$ ,00602 90(8+(0*$

+(7030,702 +( '013+(9 1#&87 &83 *+;0,L 01?' 1(20;03$ 1,:0?7< C'0$ 4030 0,:0?+1**$ 0\?+702 7&

'013 71*0, 53&6 6$ 517'03L 1, '0 7&*2 ,7&3+0, 53&6

'+, ?'+*2'&&2<

M$ 517'03 41, &(0 &5 7'&,0 #*0,,02 0(&89' 7&'1;0 R(&4( 7'0 N3&:'07< D+, 517'03 41, #*0,,02513 #0$&(2 4&32,L '1;+(9 41*R02 4+7' 7'0

N3&:'07 1(2 0(_&$02 1 ,73&(9 53+0(2,'+:< D&440 *+;02L 4'17 40 0(_&$02L 4'17 40 1#,71+(02

53&6 0(_&$+(9 c 1** 1,:0?7, &5 &83 *+;0, 4030

+(7030,7+(9 7& ?3&42, 4+7' +7?'+(9 013,<

J( 7'0 E&87'03( ,7170,L 60( 4&8*2 917'03 +(,61** 93&8:, 15703 ?'83?' ,03;+?0 7& 2+,?8,, 4'17

7'0 N3&:'07 ,1+2< A3&6 7'0 0$0, &5 1 ?'+*2L +7 41,

1 ,731(90 #177*0 &5 4+7,< Q(0 4&8*2 ,7137 7'0?&(;03,17+&( #$ d8&7+(9 1 ,717060(7 &5

:137+?8*13 +(7030,7 +( 7'0 ,036&(L 1(2 7'0 0$0, &5

7'0 60( +( 7'0 93&8: 4&8*2 *+9'7 8:< B(&7'034&8*2 306+(2 7'06L .#87 7'0 N3&:'07 1*,& ,1+2L=

1(2 2314 7'0 ?&(;03,17+&( +( 1 2+55030(72+30?7+&( c ,&607+60, 7'0 &::&,+7+&( 2+30?7+&(


14/142

"F

/17?'+(9 7'+, 161]02 60< Q(0 21$L J 7&& 4&8*2

'1;0 7'0 N3&:'07I, 4&32, 606&3+]02L 1(2 6$;&+?0 4&8*2 #0 '0132< M$ ;&+?0 4&8*2 '1;0 1(

12;1(7190L #0?18,0 6$ (160 +, 1*3012$30?&9(+]02< /0 4030 3&$1*7$ 16&(9 7'0 .U3+20L=

1(2 &83 &:+(+&(, ?133+02 ,:0?+1* 40+9'7<

C'0 '&,:+71*+7$ &5 7'0 E&87'03( ?'83?'0, +, 4'17

1($ 4&8*2 0\:0?7< E&87'03( '&,:+71*+7$ '1, 1

,4007 ?&65&37 7& 1($ 7'17 '1;0 0\:03+0(?02 +7<f0;03 41, 7'030 1 (002 5&3 1 '&70* 4'0( 40

731;0**02L .Q83 '&60 +, $&83 '&60= 4&8*2 &570(#0 9+;0( 7& 8, 1, 1 #*0,,+(9 ,'&37*$ 15703 0\+7+(9

7'0 ?'83?' #8+*2+(9,< C'0 ?'83?'0, 4030

30*17+;0*$ ,61**L 1(2 61($ 731;0**02 5&3 ,0;031*6+*0,g,&607+60, '8(2302,g7& 1770(2< C'&,0

4'& 6120 7'0 _&83(0$ 4030 &570( #*0,,02 4+7'4&(20358* 601*,L 9&&2 '&60>?&&R02 5+\+(9, #$*&;+(9 '1(2, 7'17 :30:1302 +7< J7 41, (0;03 1

?'&30 61R+(9 7'0 _&83(0$ 7& ?'83?'L 0;0( +5 +741, 1 *&(9 &(0<

Q87 /0,7L 7'0 '&,:+71*+7$ 41, 2+55030(7 #87 _8,7 1,4&(20358*< Y17'03 7'1( 2+((03 ,:3012, &( :+?(+?

71#*0,L 7'0 2+,?8,,+&(, 90(031**$ 6120 7'0+3 41$7& 51;&3+70 30,71831(7, &3 ?150703+1,< )'83?'

?8*7830 51;&302 7'+, 607'&2` E8(21$ 41, 7'0 21$

&5 30,7< J7 41, #07703 7& 30531+( 53&6 ,*1;+(9 &;037'0 &;0( 1(2 ,03;+(9 &7'03,L 0;0( +5 7'&,0 +( 7'0

30,71831(7 4030<

J( 7'0 '0137 &5 7'0 ?&8(73$L 7'0 .M0??1= _&83(0$

1, ,&60 ?1**02 +7L 7'030 41, 1 ,731(90 6+\7830<.U3+20= 53&6 1** :137, &5 7'0 ?&8(73$ 6+931702L

#3+(9+(9 4+7' 7'06 1** ,&37, &5 ?8,7&6< Y17'03


15/142

"O

7'1( ?&(9309170 +( *1390 93&8:, 15703 ,03;+?0L

60( 1(2 4&60( 4&8*2 917'03 +( ,61** 93&8:,7'17 50*7 ?&*2 1(2 2+,71(7 7& 1 E&87'03( 61(<

C'&89' 01?' ?'83?' 41, 2+55030(7L 1(2 '0*2 12+55030(7 ,07 &5 ?8,7&6,L #0*+05,L 1(2 ;1*80,L 1**

'12 7'0 ,160 7'3012 &5 ,+6+*13+7$ 5*&4+(97'3&89' 0;03$ ?&(;03,17+&(< C& 8(203,71(2 1(2#0*+0;0 7'0 N3&:'07 41, 7& ,8??002 +( 7'+, *+50

1(2 #0 :30:1302 7& 731(,+7+&( 7& 7'0 (0\7<

Z+50L 1, J R(04 +7L 41, 9&&2< /0 4030 1 ,+6:*0

:0&:*0 4+7' #*1?R>1(2>4'+70 ;1*80,L #87 40 40301 ?*&,0 :0&:*0< /0 4030 #3&7'03, 1(2 ,+,703,< J

'12 68?' 7& *+;0 5&3L #87 0;0( 6&30 7& 2+0 5&3<

B(2 J 4&8*2 (&7 '0,+7170 7& 2+0 5&3 4'17 J#0*+0;02[ 7'17 7'0 ?3017&3 &5 '01;0(, 1(2 &5 0137'

'12 20?3002 _82960(7 5&3 7'0 4&3*2 13&8(2 8,L1(2 ?'&,0( 8, 7& #0 7'0 ;+?7&3, +( 7'0 #177*0 &5*+50


16/142

"K

4$05( 16'-% 7(


17/142

"T

E+?R(0,, '12 7+02 40+9'7, 7& 6$ #&2$< M$ 136,

1(2 6$ 5007 50*7 '01;$L 1, +5 431::02 4+7' 7'+?R+3&(< J7 41, 1 ,73899*0 7& 5+(2 0(&89' 0(039$ 7&

6&;0L 1(2 J 5&8(2 6$,0*5 ,:0(2+(9 6&30 7+60,+77+(9 1(2 0;0( 6&30 7+60 ,*00:+(9< J 41, (0;03

1( 17'*07+? :03,&(L 6&30 +(?*+(02 7&4132, 68,+?&3 137L #87 8(7+* 30?0(7 6&(7', 0(_&$02 4&3R+(94+7' 6$ '1(2,< J7 1** ,00602 5&30+9( 7& 60 (&4L

1(2 7'0 7'&89'7 &5 *1#&3 6120 7'0 :1+( 0;0(

6&30 8(#0131#*0<

.H&(I7 1?R(&4*0290 $&83 ,$6:7&6,L= J 7&*26$,0*5< .J5 $&8 ?*1+6 7'06L $&8 4+** ,71$ ,+?R


18/142

"G

.,:0?+1*= ,7&3+0, &5 '01*+(9 7'17 ?&8*2 &(*$ #0

9+;0( 7& 8, #$ V&2< C'+, 41, ,& 7'17 40 4&8*2R(&4 7'17 D0 41, +( &83 :30,0(?0 #05&30

1((+'+*17+(9 7'0 0137' 1(2 0;03$7'+(9 &( +7<

Q(0 6+(+,703 *&;02 7& 70** 7'0 ,7&3$ &5 417?'+(97'0 *09 &5 1 ,61** ?'+*2 93&4+(9 +(?'0, +( *0(97'</'0( 7'0 N3&:'07 7&8?'02 '+, *09L 4'17 2+2 (&7

93&4 :3&:03*$ 41, ,8220(*$ ?&330?702< B(&7'03

51(?+02 7'0 ,7&3$ &5 7'0 :0&:*0 &( ?387?'0, 1(24'00*?'1+3,< B, 7'0$ 6120 7'0+3 41$ 7& 7'0

:*175&36 4+7' 7'0 N3&:'07L 7'0 *160 ?&8*2,8220(*$ 41*R< E&60 7&*2 &5 ?1(?03&8, 93&47',

7'17 50** 7& 7'0 5*&&3L 0(*13902 '012, 7'17 ,'38(R

7& (&361* ,+]0L 1(2 0;0( 2017' 30*01,+(9 +7,?*87?'0, 53&6 +7, ;+?7+6 3+9'7 7'030 &( 7'0

:*175&36<

J 0(;+02 7'0,0 :0&:*0< D12 J #00( 7'030 4+7' 7'0

N3&:'07L 7'+, ,+?R(0,, 7'17 :*19802 6$ #&2$4&8*2 '1;0 #00( 30*01,02 +6602+170*$< f&4L

$013, *1703L J 68,7 ?*1+6 6$ '01*+(9 7& #0 53002< J

2301602 &5 ,71(2+(9 7'030 &( 7'0 :*175&36 7&500* 7'0 :&403 &5 7'0 B*6+9'7$ 1, 6$ #&2$

30*01,02 +7, :1+(< J 41, (&7 7'030 7& 4+7(0,, 7'0619(+5+?0(7 :&403L #87 '12 '0132 61($L 61($

,7&3+0, &5 '&4 +7 4&3R02 53&6 7'0 6+(+,703, 1(2

?3&42, &5 :0&:*0 7'17 4030 7'030<

N0&:*0 ?160 53&6 513 1(2 4+20L ,00R+(9 '01*+(9

5&3 7'0+3 #&2+0,< E&60 53&6 &::&,+70 0(2, &5 7'0?&8(73$ 7& #0 ?8302L 4'+*0 &7'03, 53&6 &::&,+70

0(2, _8,7 7& 4+7(0,, +7< N0&:*0 53&6 &87 &5 7&4(#0?160 5+\7830, +( 7'0 6007+(9,L 1(2 7'0 7380

#0*+0;03, ?160 7& 30?&9(+]0 &(0 1(&7'03


19/142

"W

C'0 ,+?R 4&8*2 30d80,7 1 ?132 &5 :1:03L 4+7'+(,738?7+&(, 7& 43+70 7'0+3 (160,L 12230,,0,L 1(2

+**(0,, &( 7'0 #1?R &5 7'0 ?132< A3+0(2*$ 8,'03,4&8*2 40*?&60 $&8L 907 7& R(&4 $&8L 1(2 ?&**0?7

$&83 ?132, 5&3 7'0 ,03;+?0<

)3&42, *+(02 7'0 41**, &5 7'0 #8+*2+(9, 7& 907 +(L

1(2 0(731(?0 7'3&89' 7'0 2&&3, 41, *+R0 1 ,61**

58((0* 73$+(9 7& 1??0:7 7'0 931+( 53&6 1 '8(23025+0*2,< E&60 ?160 7& 7'0 6007+(9, 4+7' #1?R

:1+(L 1(2 ?&8*2 (&7 ,71(2 5&3 '&83, #05&30 1(2283+(9 7'0 ,03;+?0< E& 4'00*?'1+3, &3 0;0(

,7307?'03, 4030 &550302< C'0 8,'03, 41(702 7&

61R0 ?0371+( 7'17 0;03$&(0 4'& ?160 5&3'01*+(9 41, 9+;0( 1( &::&378(+7$ 7& ,00 7'0

N3&:'07<

C'0 5+3,7 504 3&4, &5 7'0 #8+*2+(9 4030 5+**02

4+7' ,61** ?'+*230(< H83+(9 7'0 *0(97'$ ,036&(,L:130(7, ?&8*2 *+,70( +(70(7*$ 7& 7'0 60,,190

9+;0( 53&6 7'0 N3&:'07 4+7'&87 2+,731?7+&(L 1,

7'0 ?'+*230( ,17 +( 140 417?'+(9 7'0 61( &( 7'0:*175&36< B(2 7'0 ?'+*230( '12 1 ,:0?+1* :*1?0 +(

7'0 '0137 &5 7'0 N3&:'07L 5&3 .,8?' +, 7'0 R+(92&6&5 V&2


20/142

-X

6&30 0(039$ 7'1( &7'03 '861(, ?&8*2 '1(2*0<

Q570(L '0 41, *+6+702 7& &(*$ 1 '1(258* &5 :0&:*0#05&30 '+, #&2$ 41, ?133+02 141$< C'&,0

5&378(170 0(&89' 7& #0 ?1**02 #$ (86#03 40309+;0( 1 ?'1(?0 7& 1??0:7 '01*+(9<

N31$03 ?132, 4030 :3+(702 4+7' 1 *07703 1(2 1(86#03< C'+,L 0\:*1+(, 6+(+,703,L 41, 7&

61+(71+( &3203*$ ?&(28?7 +( 7'0 41+7+(9 *+(0,L

1(2 7& R00: 7'0 ,+?R ,01702 8(7+* 7'0+3 783( 5&3'01*+(9< B, (86#03, 4030 ?1**02L 7'0 ,+?R 1(2

155*+?702 6120 7'0+3 41$ 2&4( 7'0 1+,*0, :1,7 7'0?'+*230( 7& 7'0 :*175&36< Q(?0 7'030L 7'0 N3&:'07

4&8*2 70** 7'0,0 :0&:*0 7'0 (160,L 12230,,0,L

1(2 ,+?R(0,,0, 7'17 4030 43+770( &( 7'0+3 ?132,<

C'+, 1331(9060(7 41, (&7 1*41$, 7'0 ?1,0<E&60 30606#03 417?'+(9 :0&:*0 13&8(2 7'06#0+(9 ?1**02 53&6 7'0+3 ,017,< .h&8 4+7' 7'0 302

?'0?R0302 ,401703 &(L &3 7'0 .Z12$ +( 7'0 9300(230,,= 4&8*2 #0 ?1**02 #$ 7'0 N3&:'07< D0I2 1,R

7'06 +5 7'0$ 4&8*2 #0*+0;0 '+6 7& #0 V&2I,

:3&:'07 1(2 1??0:7 '01*+(9 5&3 7'0 2+,01,0, &(7'0 ?132,L ,&607+60, 0;0( 4+7'&87 '1;+(9 9+;0(

7'0 ?132 7& 1( 8,'03e

C'0 0\?+7060(7 41, ,7+3302 16&(9 7'0 :0&:*0

4'0( 1 516+*+13 51?0 41, ?1**02 &87 53&6 7'0:*175&36< C'0$I;0 #00( ?&6+(9 7& 7'0 6007+(9,

,& *&(9 5&3 7'0+3 '01*+(9L 1(2 5+(1**$ 7'0+3 7+60

'12 ?&60e

C'0,0 4030 7'+(9, JI2 (0;03 ,00 4+7' 6$ &4(0$0,< J7 41, 1(&7'03 7+60 1(2 :*1?0< U87 J 2+2(I7

(002 7'0,0 7'+(9,< J '12 1??0,, 7& 7'0 ,160 V&2L


21/142

-"

1(2 7'17 V&2 ,701* '01*02 7&21$< B** J (002 2&

41, 1??0:7 +7L 20($ 6$ ?&(2+7+&(,L 1(2 #0*+0;0


22/142

--

+)* 8'-6*#9 +)* :*-;)(.9 '0< ()* /3'6*


23/142

-@

H&3&7'$ Y&40L 4&3*2>30(&4( :,$?'&*&9+,7L ,1+2

7'17L .H0:30,,+&( +, 1 :3+,&( 4'030 $&8 130 #&7'7'0 ,85503+(9 :3+,&(03 1(2 7'0 ?380* _1+*03<

J( 7'0 15703617' 7'+, #0?&60, 1::130(7L #87

53&6 7'0 &(,07 7'+, +, (&7 +&8,< H0:30,,+&( +,1 ,?1*0L 5+**02 4+7' 1 7'&8,1(2 7+($ 40+9'7,< B, 140+9'7 23&:,L 7'0 5&3?0 &5 7'0 23&: 61$ 6&;0 7'0

,?1*0 6&60(713+*$L #87 7'0 ,?1*0 ?1( 01,+*$

30783(< ^1?' 40+9'7 ,006, 73+;+1*L #87 4'0(?&6#+(02L 5&36, 1 61,, 7'17 +, 1 5&3?0 7& #0

30?R&(02 4+7'< Q;03 7+60L +7I, 6&30 1(2 6&302+55+?8*7 7& .#&8(?0 #1?R


24/142

-F

U$ 7'0 7+60 J 301*+]02 4'17 41, 43&(9 4+7' 6$

#&2$L +7 41, :1,7 7'0 7+60 &5 5+\+(9 7'0 ,+7817+&(<C'030 4030 40+9'7, J ?&8*2 306&;0 7& *+9'70( 7'0

*&12L #87 7'0 ,?1*0 '12 1*3012$ 50** &( 7'0 5*&&3< J'12 917'0302 40+9'7, +( 1** ?1709&3+0, #+9 1(2

,61**L $07 &(*$ 14130 &5 7'0 *13903 &(0,<

J7 41, 1 2+,01,0 (&7 &:0(*$ 2+,?8,,02 +( &83

516+*$< B 2012*$ 2+,01,0 7'17 '12 ?*1+602 7'0 *+50

&5 1 516+*$ 606#03L 40 ,0*2&6 60(7+&(02 7'0?18,0, &3 ,$6:7&6,< JI6 7&*2 7'17 7'0 &(,07 &5

7'0 2+,01,0 #091( 5&3 60 17 13&8(2 190 ,+\700(L1(2 7'17 6$ 30?*8,+;0 :03,&(1*+7$ 41, 1 30,8*7 &5

7'0 &(,07<

J7I, 2+55+?8*7 7& ,1$ 4'+?' 40+9'7 7+::02 7'0 ,?1*0L

#87 +7 41, +&8, 4'0( 6$ 7'&89'7, ,713702 7&5&?8, 8:&( 7'0 51?7 7'17 ,&607'+(9 41, (&7 d8+703+9'7 4+7'+( 7'0 .U3+20


25/142

-O

E&60 93&8:, 41+702 01903*$ 5&3 '+, 30783(< C'0

93&8:, 516+*+13 4+7' '+, :3&:'0?+0, 4030 ;03$#&*2 +( ,717+(9 7'17 1** :302+?7+&(, 68,7 #0

58*5+**02 c 4'0( V&2 ,:01R, 7'3&89' 1 :3&:'07LD+, 4&32, ?1((&7 51+*e

Q7'03 93&8:, d8+?R*$ 2+,6+,,02 7'+,L,:+3+781*+]+(9 :302+?7+&(, 7'17 2+2 (&7 ,8??002

1(2 783(+(9 7'06 +(7& ;1980L *&&,0

+(703:30717+&(,< C'0$ 4030 58*5+**02 +( 7'0,:+3+781* 301*6L (&7 +( 7'0 :'$,+?1*L 1(2 7'0$

4030 (&7 5&3 &83 0$0, 7& ,00<

E&60 93&8:, ?*1+602 (04 +(703:30717+&(, &5

7'0,0 :3&:'0?+0,L ?*1+6+(9 7'17 7'0+3 .(0430;0*17+&(= 41, 7'0 1(,403 7& 1** d80,7+&(,< f04

*01203, 0603902 4+7' 7'0,0 30;0*17+&(,L #0+(9'&+,702 +(7& :&403 #$ 60( 1(2 4&60( 4'&#0*+0;02 7'06 7& #0 V&2 ,0(7<

C'030 4030 7'0 53+(90 93&8:,L 7'&,0 4'&

1(&+(702 (04 :3&:'07, 7& :3&28?0 (04

60,,190, 53&6 V&2 7& 1 *&,7 1(2 2$+(9 4&3*2<C'0,0 60( 4&8*2 &570( 731;0* 53&6 ?'83?' 7&

?'83?'L *&&R+(9 7& 17731?7 (04 5&**&403, #$*83+(9 7'06 141$ 53&6 7'0+3 53+0(2, 1(2 516+*$<

Q83 :3&:'07 :302+?702 7'17 7'0 4&3*2 4&8*2 0(2#05&30 "WTT< J( 7'0 $013, *012+(9 8: 7& 7'+, 7+60L

#&&R, 4030 43+770( 1(2 ,&*2L 6+,,+&(13+0,

731;0**02 7'0 4&3*2 7& :3&?*1+6 7'0 ?&6+(9_82960(7L 1(2 (04,:1:03 12;037+,060(7, 4030

:3+(702 7& 1((&8(?0 V&2I, 4317' 8:&( 61(R+(2<U87 &83 N3&:'07 2+02 7319+?1**$ +( "WKOL 1(2 7'0

7380 +(703:30717+&( &5 7'0 :3&:'0?+0, *012+(9 8:


26/142

-K

7& 2&&6,21$ 41, 8(?0371+(< E& 01?' *01203 '12

7'0 2+55+?8*7 71,R &5 +(703:307+(9 1(28(203,71(2+(9 4'17L 0\1?7*$L 40(7 43&(9<

M1($ ,036&(, 13&8(2 7'0 (17+&( '12 7'0 ,160

+(70(7+&(, #87 4+7' 2+55030(7 2071+*,< N1,7&3,4030 70**+(9 7'0+3 ?&(930917+&(, 4'17 7'0$ 68,72& 7& :30:130 7'06,0*;0, 5&3 V&2I, 4317'L 1(2

'&4 7'0$ 68,7 ?&(28?7 7'06,0*;0, +( &3203 7&

1;&+2 +7< C'0 ?'0?R*+,7 &5 7'+(9, 7'17 40L 1, U3+20L4030 7& 1#,71+( 53&6 2+550302 93017*$ 53&6 7&4(

7& 7&4(<

C& 1 ,717+&(13$ 516+*$L 7'+, 4&8*2 #0 1( 01,$

71,R< ^1?' :1,7&3 ,00602 7& '1;0 '+, &4(?'0?R*+,7 :30:1302L 1(2 01?' E8(21$ 7'0 +706, +(

7'0 *+,7 4030 06#02202 +( 7'0 #1?R &5 &83 6+(2,4+7' '&7 06#03, &5 '0** 5+30 ,833&8(2+(9 7'06< B,717+&(13$ 516+*$ 4&8*2 '1;0 1 ,61** ,8#,07 &5

7'0 9** ?'0?R*+,7L &(*$ '1;+(9 7'&,0 +706, 7'177'0 N1,7&3 8(203,7&&2 1, 30d8+302 #$ V&2 7&

:3&28?0 31:783+(9 51+7'<

U87 7& 1 (&612 516+*$ *+R0 6$ &4(L 7'0,0 *+,7,

4030 2+55+?8*7 7& 61+(71+(< C& &(0 93&8:L ?0371+(:*01,830, &5 *+50 4030 1??0:71#*0 4'0301, &7'03

93&8:, ?&(206(02 7'&,0 ,160 53002&6,< /'+*0

&(0 516+*$ 6+9'7 0(_&$ 7'0+3 51;&3+70 :1,7+60L1(&7'03 516+*$ 4&8*2 ,:01R ;03$ '13,'*$ 191+(,7

+7< B(2 7'0$ 4&8*2 2& ,& 17 7'0 4+** &5 7'0+3

:1,7&3,L 4'& 91;0 7'06 ?*013 +(,738?7+&(, 1, 7&'&4 7& *+;0 7'0+3 :03,&(1* *+;0,< C& 1 (&612

516+*$ 4'& #0*+0;02 +( 7'0 +6:0(2+(920,738?7+&( &5 61(R+(2L &(0 +, 5&3?02 7& ?&6#+(0

1** *+,7,< J5 $&8 R(04 7'17 1 ;+&*0(7 2017' 41,


27/142

-T

?0371+(L 4&8*2 $&8 (&7 2& 0;03$7'+(9 4+7'+( $&83

:&403 7& 1;&+2 +7b

Q;03 7+60L 7'0,0 ?'0?R*+,7, #0?160 40+9'7, &(7'0 ,?1*0< J6:&,,+#*0 7& 61+(71+(L 2+55+?8*7 7&

61(190L :1+(58* 7& 0(2830L 1(2 501358* 7& 30_0?7L7'0,0 *+,7, #0?160 :137 &5 7'0 ?0** 41**, 7'17#0?160 6$ :3+,&(< B _1+* ?0** 7'17 J ?301702 5&3

6$,0*5L +6:3+,&(02 6$,0*5L 1(2 3061+(02 +(,+20

1, #&7' 7'0 ?&(;+?702 1(2 7'0 _1+*03<

U$ 7'06,0*;0,L 7'0,0 40+9'7, 4&8*2 '1;0 (0;037+::02 6$ ,?1*0,< U87 ?&6#+(02 4+7' 7'0 &7'03,L

7'0,0 40+9'7, 4030 6&30 7'1( J ?&8*2 #1*1(?0<

C'+, :3+,&( 7'17 J ?1**02 .#*0,,+(9= 41, ,7137+(97& &;03783(


28/142

-G

+)* =*6(-0; >$(


29/142

-W

B :+*93+6190 +( 1($ 30*+9+&( +, 1 _&83(0$ 6120

5&3 ,0*5>0\16+(17+&(L 20;&7+&(L 1(2 7& 5+(2 :83+7$<A&3 1 M8,*+6 7& ,00 M0??1L 7'0 #+37':*1?0 &5

M&'16602L 7'030 +, (& 9301703 _&$< %04, '1;06120 :+*93+6190 7& 7'0 /1+*+(9 /1** ,+(?0 7'0 F7'

?0(783$< U822'+,7, 731;0* 7& Z86#+(+ 7& ,00 7'0#+37':*1?0 &5 V187161 U822'1L 1(2 D+(28,731;0* 7& &;03 5+57$ ,+70, ,:3012 7'3&89'&87 J(2+1<

C'0 5+(1* 20,7+(17+&( 5&3 &83 (&612+? 516+*$ 41,7'0 M0??1 &5 &83 30*+9+&(< J7 41, (&7 7'0

#+37':*1?0 &5 7'0 N3&:'07L #87 41, 1 :*1?0 _8,7 1,,1?302[ '+, 706:*0< C'0 71#03(1?*0 ,17 +( 1 ,61**

7&4( +( E&87'03( J(2+1(1 7'17 41, ?&((0?702 #$

5&83 #3+290, 7& Z&8+,;+**0L i0(78?R$< B ?+7$ &5*0,, 7'1( OXLXXX :0&:*0L %05503,&(;+**0 ,006,

#130*$ 0d8+::02 7& 1??&66&2170 7'&,0 61R+(9 1:+*93+6190 5&3 1 30*+9+&( &5 #07400( 74& 1(2 5&836+**+&( :0&:*0<

C'0 +(5*8\ &5 ;+,+7&3, 2&0, (&7 &??83 17 1($ &5 7'0

2170, 6&,7 +&8,< J7 +, (&7 7'0 N3&:'07I,

#+37'2170 7'17 17731?7, 7'0 ;+,+7&3,L &3 7'0 6&(7'7'17 7'0 71#03(1?*0 41, #8+*7< J7 +, (&7 7'0 6&(7'

'+, 516+*$ 6&;02 7& J(2+1(1L &3 1($ &7'03 21701,,&?+1702 4+7' '+, *+50< C'&89' *&&,0*$

?&((0?702L +7 +, (&7 0;0( 7'0 2170 &5 '+, 2017'

7'17 17731?7, 7'0 ?3&42,< J(,7012L 7'0 _&83(0$ +,7$:+?1**$ 6120 5&3 1 2170 7'17 ?&(;0(+0(7*$

?'1(902 5&?8,<

/'0( 7'0 N3&:'07 2+02L '+, #&2$ 41, '0*2 53&6

7'0 931;0 5&3 ,0;031* 6&(7',< D+, 2017' #0+(9 +(H0?06#03 -FL "WKO 1(2 '+, #&2$ #0+(9 #83+02

B:3+* "-L "WKKL 7'0 ._&83(0$ 7& M0??1= 41,


30/142

@X

?&(;0(+0(7*$ :&,+7+&(02 17 ^1,703< B:3+* "X7'

"WKK :3&;+202 7'0 ^1,703 ,03;+?0, 7'17 #0?1607312+7+&(L 1(2 74& 21$, *1703 7'0 #&2$ 41,

#83+02<

M1($ &5 '+, 5&**&403, ?160 7& :31$ 5&3 '+,+6602+170 30,8330?7+&(L 1(2 *&?1* (04,:1:03,:3+(702 ,7&3+0, 20,?3+#+(9 7'0 386&3, 13&8(2 7'0

?+7$ 7'17 :0&:*0 4030 ?&6+(9 53&6 13&8(2 7'0

(17+&( 7& 4+7(0,, 7'0 .30#+37'


31/142

@"

:0&:*0 4030 4136 1(2 +(;+7+(9L 1(2 61($ 4&8*2

?&(9309170 +( '&60, &3 #8+*2+(9, 13&8(2 7'01301 7& 9+;0 70,7+6&($ 7& 7'0 *+50 1(2 7+60, &5 7'0

N3&:'07< )'+*230( 4&8*2 *189' 1(2 :*1$ 4'+*0128*7, ,'1302 :03,&(1* ,7&3+0, 1#&87 7'0

N3&:'07L 1(2 +7 41, 1 93017 7+60 7& ,:0(2 4+7'#3&7'03, 1(2 ,+,703, 7'17 40 ?&(,+20302 516+*$<

E&60L 51+7'58* 7& 7312+7+&(L 6120 7'0 _&83(0$ 7&

,00R '01*+(9< C'0 N3&:'07 (& *&(903 1*+;0L 7'0:31$03 ?132, (& *&(903 +,,802 7& 7'0 155*+?702L

1(2 7'0 '01*+(9 (& *&(903 619(+5+?0(7L :0&:*02+2 (&7 ?&60 ,00R+(9 +6602+170 '01*+(9<

J(,7012L 7'0$ ,&89'7 ?&65&37 5&3 7'0+3 :1+( 1(2

:31$03 5&3 7'0+3 602+?17+&( 7& ?830 7'0+3 2+,01,0<B ,0*0?7 504 6120 7'0+3 _&83(0$ ,00R+(9 '01*+(9

4+7' +(?831#*0 2+,01,0 &3 ?3+::*02 #&(0,L '013+(9,7&3+0, &5 1 :3&:'07 4'& ?&8*2 '1;0 30:1+3027'0+3 #&2+0,< U87 7'17 9+57 41, ,0*2&6

61(+50,702 +( 7'0 ?'83?'< C'&89' +7 41, 7'0 9+578,02 7& :3&?*1+6 ;+(2+?17+&( &5 7'0 N3&:'07L 7'+,

0;+20(?0 &5 7'0 D&*$ V'&,7 +( &83 30*+9+&(

,00602 1** #87 (&(0\+,70(7 +( 7'0,0 21$,<

B5703 ,0;031* $013,L 7'0 ?+7$ #0?160 1 .60*7+(9:&7= 5&3 7'0 ;13+07$ &5 #0*+05 ,$,706, 4+7'+( 7'0

5&**&4+(9< B** ?160 #3+(9+(9 ?'0?R*+,7, &5 7'0+3

30d8+3060(7 7& :3&28?0 31:783+(9 51+7'L #874+7'&87 7'0 8(+7$ 7'17 +, 5&8(2 +( 01?' &5 7'0

;13+&8, ?'83?'0,< f&4L &(0 2+2 (&7 (002 731;0*

53&6 ,7170 7& ,7170 +( &3203 7& 4+7(0,, 1 2+55030(7?'0?R*+,7` 731;0**+(9 53&6 '&8,0'&*2 7&

'&8,0'&*2 +( M0??1 4&8*2 9+;0 &(0 &::&378(+7$7& #8+*2 1 *0(97'$ ,07 &5 38*0,


32/142

@-

U87 283+(9 1 :+*93+6190L 4'0( 7'0 ?3&42 +,

4136 1(2 +(;+7+(9L &(0 2&0, (&7 (&7+?0 7'0,8#7*0 2+55030(?0, +( 2&?73+(0< M1($ 6+,71R0 7'0

'&,:+71*+7$ 1(2 4136 ^1,703 500*+(9, 5&3 7'0 41$&5 *+50 +( M0??1< E&60 130 ,& 17731?702 7& +7 7'17

7'0$ 3+: 7'0+3 516+*+0, 141$ 53&6 7'0+3 '&60 7&30*&?170< M$ 516+*$ 41, (& 0\?0:7+&(L 1(2 5&37'+, 301,&(L ?'&,0 7'+, ?+7$ &5 %05503,&(;+**0 1, &83

(0\7 20,7+(17+&(<

J 4+** (0;03 5&3907 7'0 4&32, &5 12;+?0 53&6 1

53+0(2 4'0( 40 5+3,7 6&;02 7& %05503,&(;+**0< .J5$&8 130 ?&6+(9 7& %05503,&(;+**0 0\:0?7+(9 8(+7$

1(2 #*+,,L $&8 4+** #0 ,12*$ 2+,1::&+(702


33/142

@@

7'0 &7'03< V80,7, ,17 ,?1770302 7'3&89'&87 7'0

#8+*2+(9L 8(14130 &5 1($ ,0930917+&(< B5703,03;+?0,L 01?' 93&8: 0\+702 7'0 #8+*2+(9 7'3&89'

&::&,+70 2&&3, 1(2 ,093091702 +(7& 0;0( ,61**0393&8:,< B** #0*+0;02 7'17 7'0 N3&:'07 41, V&2I,

5+(1* ;&+?0 #05&30 20,738?7+&(L #87 7'030 4030;03$ 504 7'17 58**$ 193002 8:&( '&4 7& 1;&+2 +7<

C'+, (0;03 301**$ #&7'0302 60< Q83 516+*$ '12

,:0?+1* +(,738?7+&(, #$ 7'0 N3&:'07L 1(2 1 ,:0?+1*51;&3 931(702 7& 8, +( 7'0 0$0, &5 V&2< .B** $&83

?'+*230( 1(2 $&83 931(2?'+*230( 4+** #0 ,1;02L=:3&?*1+602 7'0 N3&:'07< .f& 617703 4'17 $&8

2&L #0 7'030e=

/0 '12 ,:0?+1* +(,738?7+&(, 7& .#0 7'030


34/142

@F

0(731(?0L 417?'+(9 1, 7'0 ,+?R 1(2 155*+?702

0(70302 7'0 70(7 1(2 30783(02 ?&6:*070*$ 40**<J( &(0 ?&3(03 &5 7'0 70(7 41, 1 *+77*0 3&&6L 1(2

7'0 U3+20 4&8*2 0(703 7'0 3&&6 7& 30?0+;0 7'0+3(04 #&2+0,< C'0,0 #&2+0, 4&8*2 #0 0(2802 4+7'

:&403 1, 7'0 N3&:'07 7&&R &83 '1(2,L 1(2 404&8*2 :30:130 7& 41*R 8:&( 7'0 1,'0, &5 7'&,04'& 2+2 (&7 #0*+0;0 7'0 N3&:'07< /0 '12 &(0

,+6:*0 30d8+3060(7[ 7& #0 7'030


35/142


36/142

@K

C'0$ ,1$ 7'17 ,&60 &5 7'0 #0,7 ?&6:&,03, 1(2

,&(943+703, ,73899*0 4+7' 200: 20:30,,+&(< B,7'0 #&2$ 73+0, 7& 5+(2 41$, 7& 30*01,0 +7, :1+(L 7'0

6+(2 8,0, 137+,7+? 1#+*+7+0, 7& 30*01,0 +7, 06&7+&(<Z824+9 ;1( U007'&;0( ,8550302 7'3&89' ,0;030

20:30,,+&(L 4'+?' &570( *02 '+6 7& ?&(706:*170,8+?+20< Q;03 7+60L 7'0 20:30,,+&( +, 7'&89'7 7&'1;0 ?&6#+(02 4+7' #+:&*13 2+,&3203L 1

?&6#+(17+&( &5 ,0;030 20:30,,+&( 1(2 0\73060

'1::+(0,,< D+, 6+(2 41, *+7031**$ :*1$+(9 789>&5>413 4+7' +7,0*5 1, +7 :3&28?02 ,$6:'&(+0, 7'17

4&8*2 +66&371*+]0 '+6<

B7 7'0 ?*+61\ &5 6$ :1+(L 7'0,0 ,$6:7&6,

#0?160 516+*+13< C'0 20:30,,+;0 ,7170 '12306&;02 1** 6&7+;17+&( +( *+50< B :0350?7+&(+,7 #$

(17830L J 5&8(2 6$,0*5 d8+?R*$ #0?&6+(9 :1,,+;01(2 0;0( 8(14130 &5 7'0 ?&(2+7+&( &5 6$,833&8(2+(9,< J ,17 &( 1 50(?0L *&&R+(9 '+9'

1#&;0 *+50 +7,0*5< Q( 7'0 &(0 ,+20 41, 6$ *+50 1(21** J '12 7& *+;0 5&3L 4'+*0 &( 7'0 &7'03 ,+20 41,

30*01,0 7'3&89' 2017'<

J 4&8*2 (0;03 ?1** 6$,0*5 ,8+?+21*< J (0;03 '0*2 1

3+5*0 +( 6$ '1(2, 7& :003 2&4( 7'0 #1330*L &3 ,174+7' 1 ,73&(9 602+?17+&( 5&3 '&83, 73$+(9 7&

?&(;+(?0 6$,0*5 &5 7'0 01,+03 :17'< J '12 68?' 7&

*+;0 5&3L 4+7' 1 ;03$ '1::$ '&60< M$ 516+*$ 41,.3&$1*7$= +( &83 ?+3?*0,L 1(2 J 41, 1#&;0 7'&,0

1?7+&(,< Q3 ,& JI2 *+R0 7& 70** 6$,0*5<

Z&&R+(9 #1?RL J 41, ,73&(9L #87 (&7 ,73&(9 &( 6$

&4(< B7 7'0 ?*+61\ &5 6$ 20:30,,+&(L 1 ?&8,+('12 ?1**02 60 7& ,1$ '0**&< B(2 283+(9 7'0

?&83,0 &5 7'0 ?&(;03,17+&(L '0 ?&8*2 ,0(,0 7'17


37/142

@T

,&607'+(9 41, (&7 3+9'7< J #130*$ 30606#03 7'0

:'&(0 ?&(;03,17+&(L #87 +7 41, 0(&89' 7'17 '+,?&(?03( 5&3 60 41, ,73&(9< D0 ?&(7+(802 7& ?1**

60L 0;03$ 21$L 7& 9+;0 60 0(?&8319060(7 1(2,730(97'<

Q83 ?&(;03,17+&(, 4030 (&7 *&(9L ,&607+60,&(*$ 6+(870,< B(2 &83 ?&(;03,17+&(, 4030 (&7

1*41$, 74&>2+30?7+&(1*< Q570(L '0 4&8*2 ?1** 1(2

J 4&8*2 *+,70( 1, '0 71*R02 1#&87 1($7'+(9 1(20;03$7'+(9 +( '+, 17706:7 7& #&&,7 6$ ,:+3+7,< D+,

;&+?0 #0?160 ,&&7'+(9 7& 6$ 013,L 1(2 J *&&R025&34132 7& '+, 21+*$ ?1**,<

J7 41, +3&(+? 7& 60L 0;0( 283+(9 7'0?&(;03,17+&(,< M$ ?&8,+( 2+2 (&7 #0*+0;0 +( 7'0

N3&:'07L 1(2 '12 *&(9 ,+(?0 20?+202 (&7 7&1,,&?+170 4+7' 7'0 #3&7'03, 1(2 ,+,703,< B #+7&,731?+]02 #$ '+, '&60 ?'83?'L '0 41, #&7' 1

?&4#&$ 1(2 1 30(09120< D0 *+;02 #$ 1 #*1?R>1(2>4'+70 ?&20 &5 ?&(28?7 ,+6+*13 7& 6$ &4(L #87

4+7' 2+55030(7 6&31*, 7'17 '0 ?1**02 .7'0 ?&4#&$

41$


38/142

@G

7'17 '1;+(9 1(&7'03 :03,&( 9+;0 60

0(?&8319060(7 7& R00: 9&+(9 41, '01*+(9 +( &5+7,0*5< B(2 &;03 7+60L J #091( 7& 301*+]0 7'17 +7

41, '+, ;&+?0 7'17 41, R00:+(9 60 1*+;0<

/0 ,&607+60, ,:&R0 &5 30*+9+&(L #87 *+6+702 7&'+, :03,&(1* 7'&89'7,< D+, #*1?R>1(2>4'+70:03,&(1*+7$ ?&8*2(I7 1??0:7 2&8#*0 ,71(2132,L

1(2 '+, 0\:03+0(?0, 4+7' 7'0 U3+20 ?'83?'0, +(

'+, ,7170 4030 *0,, 7'1( :*01,1(7< J *013(02 4'$'0 *057L 4&(20302 4'030 '0 40(7L 1(2 (0;03

3+,R02 1,R+(9<

J7 41, 283+(9 7'+, 7+60 7'17 *+50 #091( 7& ?'1(90<

Y0*17+&(,'+:, 7'17 J 4&3R02 '132 7& 61+(71+(4030 ,8220(*$ :87 &( '&*2< /&3R 41,

+6:&,,+#*0L #023+220( 5&3 '&83, 17 1 7+60 283+(97'0 21$< C&360(702 #$ 7'0 7'3#+(9 :1+( +( 6$'012L :*19802 #$ 7'0 51?7 7'17 '01*+(9 '12 (&7

?160L ,7+** #0*+0;+(9 7'17 J '12 2&(0 0;03$7'+(9(0?0,,13$ 7& ?*1+6 1(2 1??0:7 6$ ?830<

Z&(9 7+60 53+0(2,'+:, #091( 7& ?386#*0</+7'&87 6$ 4&3R+(9 7& 61+(71+( 7'06L 7'0$ 1**

#87 2+,1::01302< A16+*$ ,00602 7& '1;05&39&770( 60< )*&,0 30*17+;0,L 2+,71(7 30*17+;0,L

0;0( +6602+170 516+*$ #0?160 ,731(903,< B7 7'0

4&3,7 &5 +7L J 41, *01(+(9 '01;+*$ &( *0,, 7'1( 1'1(258* &5 :0&:*0 c &(*$ 7'+, ?&8,+(L 6$ #3&7'03L

1(2 6$ 4+50 5&3 ,8::&37<

M&(7', 40(7 #$ 4+7'&87 ?&(71?7< J 7'&89'7

1#&87 7'0 :0&:*0 +( 7'0 706:*0L ?&(58,02 1#&876$ ?8330(7 ?&(2+7+&(< Q( 7'0 &(0 '1(2L J 41, 1

#+7 ,'&?R02 7'17 (&7 1 ,+(9*0 :03,&( d80,7+&(02


39/142

@W

4'030 J 41, &3 4'17 '1::0(02 7& 60< /'17 +5

+(,7012L J '12 +(_8302 6$,0*5 1(2 (00202 '0*:b/&8*2 1($ ?&60 7& 6$ 30,?80b /'17 +5 J '12

#00( R+2(1::02b /&8*2 1($ ,013?' 7& 5+(2 60bC'0 7'&89'7, 7'17 40(7 7'3&89' 6$ '012 ?301702

1( 0(2*0,, ?$?*0 &5 20:30,,+&( 7'17 4&8*2 (&7 *+57c ,*+9'7*$ 30*+0;02 #$ 7'0 ?&(7+(81* ?1** &5 6$?&8,+(< D12 '0 (&7 *+;02 &;03 0+9'7 &83, 731;0*L J

4&8*2 '1;0 #09902 '+6 7& ;+,+7<

J 41, 6&30 ?&(58,02 #$ 6$ :1,7&3< B*,& 6$

931(2517'03L J 0\:0?702 ,&60 ?&(?03( 5&3 6$40**>#0+(9< D0 R(04 &5 6$ ?&(2+7+&(L #87

1::01302 7& #0 0;0( 6&30 2+,71(7 15703 *013(+(9

1#&87 +7< C'&89'7, 31( 7'3&89' 6$ 6+(2 1#&87 1,'0:'032 1(2 '+, 5*&?RL 1(2 6$ 06&7+&(, 4030

2+55+?8*7 7& ?&(73&*< /'030 +, 7'0 ,'0:'032 7'17 +,,8::&,02 7& *01;0 '+, ,'00:5&*2 5&3 7'17 &(0 *&,7,'00:b

C'0 N3&:'07I, ,&(,L 7'0 0*203,L 1(2 7'0 *1$

606#03, c 01?' 1(2 0;03$ :03,&( +( 7'0 706:*0

,00602 7& '1;0 5&39&770( 60< J ,713702 7& 301*+]07'17 7'0 &(*$ 7+0 7'17 #&8(2 1** 30*17+&(,'+:, 41,

7'0 055&37 7'17 J :87 +(7& R00:+(9 7'06<

U87 J 41, 8(41;03+(9 +( 6$ 51+7'< J #0*+0;02 +(

7'0 N3&:'07 1(2 *&&R02 5&34132 7& 7'0 70(7< J*&(902 5&3 7'0 *+77*0 3&&6 +( 7'0 70(7L 4'0( 7'+,

51+*+(9 #&2$ 4&8*2 #0 30:*1?02 4+7' 1 (04 &(0< J

R(04 7'17 J 4&8*2 .#0 7'030= 0;0( +( 6$ :30,0(7,7170 c (&7'+(9 ?&8*2 R00: 60 53&6 ,1*;17+&( 1(2

6$ 0703(1* 20,7+(17+&(< J #0*+0;02 7'17 J '12 7'0?&330?7 ,07 &5 38*0, 53&6 7'0 ?'0?R*+,7, 7'17 J '12

917'0302L #0*+0;02 7'17 J '12 5&**&402 7'06 7'0


40/142

FX

#0,7 7'17 J ?&8*2L 1(2 #0*+0;02 7'17 J '12 1*,&

'0*2 7& 7'0 )'3+,7+1( 51+7' 30d8+3060(7, 7'174030 ?&6#+(02 4+7' 6$ &4( 0,&703+?

R(&4*0290< M$ #19, 1** :1?R02L J 41, 41+7+(91(2 3012$ 7& 9&<

J7 41, 1#&87 7'+, 7+60 7'17 6$ ,&(943+7+(90\:*&202< B 68,+?+1( 1(2 1 ,&(943+703 17 1(

013*$ 190L (04 ,&(9, 4030 1 ?&66&( &??8330(?0<

U87 (&7 17 7'0 3170 +( 4'+?' 7'0,0 ?160 c 7'0$4030 1( &(,*189'7 &5 ,&(9,< M&3(+(9L (&&(L 1(2

(+9'7 J '12 78(0, 3+(9+(9 7'3&89' 6$ '012g?&6:*070 4+7' 4&32,g,& 51,7 7'17 J ?&8*2 (&7

43+70 7'06 1** 2&4(< E&60 J 2+2 43+70L &7'03, J

4+,' J '12 43+770(< B** ,&(9, 4030 1#&8730*+9+&(L #87 (&7 1#&87 7'0 N3&:'07< B** ,&(9,

4030 1#&87 2+55030(7 ,8#_0?7, #87 1** 4+7' 7'0,160 7'060< B** ,&(9, 4030 1#&87 2&8#*0,71(2132,<

.%0,8, 2+2 (&7 ?&60 7& ,1;0 7'0 ,1;02 c '0 ?160

7& ,1;0 7'0 *&,7


41/142

F"

4&8*2 (&7 7'0 :1,7&3, #0 2&+(9 0;03$7'+(9

4+7'+( 7'0+3 :&403 7& 301?' 7'06b

E&(9, ?160 7& 60 1#&87 7'0 68*7+:*0 :17'41$,:0&:*0 71R0 +( 7'0+3 _&83(0$L 1** 7&4132, 7'0

,160 20,7+(17+&(< Y17'03 7'1( 2+;+,+&(, 1*&(97'0 41$L ,'&8*2(I7 40 #0 ,8::&37+(9 01?' &7'031(2 '0*:+(9 01?' &7'03 301?' 7'0 ,160

20,7+(17+&(b Q7'03 ,&(9, 1#&87 ?&6:1,,+&( 5&3

7'0 (002$L 6&(0$ 5&3 7'0 :&&3L ,1*;17+&( 7& 1 *&,71(2 2$+(9 4&3*2L J 41, ,8220(*$ 5+**02 4+7'

68,+?L #87 +( 7&& 68?' :1+( 7& 2& 1($7'+(9 4+7'+7


42/142

F-

+)* @2*.(-$0


43/142

F@

C'030 130 ?0371+( 7'+(9, +( *+50 7'17 130 ,+6:*$

8(5&390771#*0< B, 1 ?'+*2L 7'0,0 7'+(9, 13006#02202 +(7& &83 606&3+0,L 1(2 1, 1( 128*7 40

?'03+,' 7'06< B( 187&931:' 4+7' 1 #1** :*1$03L 1,+9(02 C>,'+37 53&6 1 68,+?+1(L ,&60 606&3+0,

1*,& ?&60 4+7' 606&31#+*+1< M$ ?'+*2'&&2606&3+0, 130 ;03$ 504 1(2 513 #07400(L #87 7'0&(0, 4+7' 606&31#+*+1 ,006 7& *1,7 +(205+(+70*$<

A3&6 190 5&83700( 7& 190 @OL J '12 1( 187&931:''1(9+(9 &( 6$ 41**L #87 (&7 &5 1 #1**:*1$03 &3

68,+?+1(< E+9(02 +( '+, &4( '1(243+7+(9L 7'0N3&:'07I, ,&( '12 ,0(7 60 1 *07703 4+7' '+,

#*0,,+(9, 5&3 6$ 68,+? 6+(+,73$< J3&(+? (&4 7'17

J 7'+(R 1#&87 +7L 7'0 ,160 68,+? 6+(+,73$ 7'17#091( 7& &:0( 6$ 0$0, 41, #*0,,02 #$ 7'0 ,&( &5

7'0 60( 7'17 '12 ?*&,02 7'06< C'0 N3&:'07I,&*20,7 ,&( 41, ?*&,0 1(2 2013 7& &83 516+*$L #877'0 N3&:'07I, $&8(90,7 ,&( 41, 6$ 517'03I,

?'+*2'&&2 #0,7 53+0(2< C'0 #3&7'03, 4030 40**30,:0?702 #$ 1**L 0,:0?+1**$ #$ &83 (&612+?

516+*$< /'0( J 30?0+;02 '+, *07703L 7'030 41, (&

d80,7+&( 1, 7& 4'17 7& 2& 4+7' +7` 7'+, *077034&8*2 #0 R0:7 1(2 ?'03+,'02 5&30;03<

B7 &(0 :&+(7 +( 6$ ?'+*2'&&2L 6$ 517'03 '0*:02

&391(+]0 1 7+($ ?'83?' +( 1 ,61** 7&4( +( i1(,1,<

J7 41, 1 '1(258* &5 :0&:*0L ,&60 53&6 _8,7 1?3&,,7'0 #&3203 +( M+,,&83+ 1(2 ,&60 +( 7'0

(0+9'#&3+(9 ?+7$ +( i1(,1,L 1** 917'03+(9 +( 1

#8+*2+(9 1(2 :1$+(9 30(7 7'3&89' ?&**0?702&5503+(9< /0 4&8*2 ,+7 1(2 *+,70( 01903*$ 7& 7'0

N3&:'07I, ;&+?0 7'3&89' 30?&3202 ?1,,0770 71:0,L,+(9 ,&(9, +( '&(&3 &5 %0,8, )'3+,7 1(2 &83


44/142

FF

N3&:'07L 1(2 50**&4,'+: 13&8(2 7'0 70,7+6&(+0,

&5 7'&,0 4'& #0*+0;02<

J7 41, 283+(9 7'+, 7+60 7'17 J 5+3,7 30606#036007+(9 7'0 N3&:'07I, ,&(< JI6 ,830 7'17 J '12

607 '+6 ?&8(7*0,, 7+60, #05&30L #87 +7 41, 7'05+3,7 606&3$ &5 '+, ,+9(+5+?1(?0 7& &83 30*+9+&(<M$ 517'03 +(;+702 '+6 7& ,:01RL 1(2 '0 ?160

1,,86+(9 1 ;03$ ,61** ?3&42< U87 6$ 517'03 31(

1 (04,:1:03 12;037+,060(7 +( 7'0 *&?1* (04,7'17 '012*+(02L .EQf QA B NYQND^C


45/142

FO

30606#03 '013+(9 &5 7'0 20,738?7+&( &5 Z&,

B(90*0, 283+(9 &(0 &5 '+, 70,7+6&(+0,< C'0N3&:'07I, ,&( 4&8*2 93+( 53&6 013 7& 013L 70**+(9

8, 7'0 71*0L '&4 '+, 517'03 ,7&::02 ,8220(*$ +(7'0 ,73007 1, 7'0 ;+,+&( ,738?R< B, 1 ?'+*2L $&8

?&8*2 1*6&,7 +619+(0 '+, '1(2, &87,7307?'02L '+,0$0, 3&**+(9 #1?R +( 7'0+3 ,&?R07,L 1(2 '+, 6&87'4+20 &:0( 1, 7'0 ;+,+&( '+7< C'0 N3&:'07I, ,&(

4&8*2 907 301* d8+07 1, '0 307&*2 7'0 6&,7

+6:&371(7 :137< D+, 2122$I, 4&32, 30,&8(2+(9 +('+, 013 7& 7'+, 21$L .E&(L $&8 4&(I7 #0 1( &*2 61(

#05&30 ,'13R, 130 ,4+66+(9 3+9'7 4'030 $&8,71(2


46/142

FK

J ?&8*2(I7 ,'1R0 7'0 d80,7+&(< J 73+02< J7 41,

#*1,:'06&8, 7& 7'+(R ,8?' 7'+(9,< C& d80,7+&( 1:3&:'07 41, 7& d80,7+&( *+50e C& 1**&4 1 d80,7+&(

7& 5&36 +( $&83 6+(2 41, 7& *07 206&(, 71R0?&(73&* &5 $&83 ,&8*e /'$ 41, 7'+, '1::0(+(9 7&

60b /'$ ?&8*2 J (&7 ,+6:*$ *07 +7 9&b

U87 J ?&8*2(I7L (& 617703 '&4 '132 J 73+02< C'0

d80,7+&( R0:7 ,8351?+(9L 1*&(9 4+7' ,0;031*

&7'03, 1771?'02 7& +7< /'$ 4&8*2 V&2 ?'&&,0 7&20,73&$ 1 6+**+&( *+;0, 4+7'&87 9+;+(9 7'06 7'0

&::&378(+7$ 7& 30:0(7b H+2 1($&(0 +( 7'0 ?+7$ &5Z&, B(90*0, 30606#03 7'0 413(+(9 7'0$

30?0+;02 +( "WKOb /'17 1#&87 ,61** ?'+*230(L

+((&?0(7L 4'& (0;03 '0132 1#&87 7'0 N3&:'07b/'17 +5 7'0$ (0;03 '12 1 ?'1(?0 7& #0 ,1;02b

J 50*7 93017 ,12(0,,< f&7 _8,7 5&3 7'0 ?'+*230(L #875&3 1** 7'0 :0&:*0 &5 7'0 ?+7$< /'$ 2+2 J 30_&+?0 17

7'0 2017', &5 7'&8,1(2,b /1, J ,& 0;+* 7'17 J?1302 6&30 1#&87 #0+(9 3+9'7 7'1( J 2+2 1#&87

7'0 ,*189'703 &5 +((&?0(?0b C'0$ 4030 d80,7+&(,

J ?&8*2 (&7 ,'1R0< U87 7'0 5+3,7L 7'0 &3+9+(1*d80,7+&(L '12 (& 1(,403< B7 ,0;0(7$>0+9'7 $013,

&*2L 7'0 N3&:'07I, ,&( 41, ?0371+(*$ 1( &*2 61(<

C'+, d80,7+&( (19902 17 60 5&3 21$,< ^;03$

,+(9*0 7+60 J 41*R02 :1,7 7'0 ,+9(17830L J 41,306+(202 &5 7'0 61( 4'& ,+9(02 +7 1(2 4'17 '0

7&*2 8,< J 5&8(2 6$,0*5 ,713+(9 17 7'0 ,+9(17830L

1, +5 ,&60 0\:*1(17+&( 4&8*2 5&36 +( 7'0 #*80 +(R7'17 '12 #00( ,?3+##*02 &( 7'0 71( :1:03< J 3012

7'3&89' 7'0 *07703L 5&3 7'0 5+3,7 7+60 +( ,0;031*$013,L ,8220(*$ 301*+]+(9 7'17 +7 41, (& :03,&(1*

*07703 c +7 41, 1 5&36 *07703 4+7' 90(03+?


47/142

FT

30,:&(,0,< Q(*$ 1 ,61** :131931:' 1::*+02 7& 6$

68,+? 6+(+,73$L 1(2 7'0 &7'03 :131931:', ?&8*2#0 1::*+02 7& 1($ 30,:&(,0 7& 1($ :03,&(< J '12

30?0+;02 7'0 .Q;1*7+(0 *07703= 53&6 .B )'3+,761,E7&3$= c 1 *07703 7'17 7&*2 60 7& .23+(R 6&30

Q;1*7+(0


48/142

FG

A6< 1'%B =**(-0;


49/142

FW

J ,17 7'+, d80,7+&( 1,+20 5&3 ,0;031* 400R,< C'0

?*+61\ &5 6$ 20:30,,+&( 41, #0'+(2 60L 1 *+50 &520:30,,+&( ,7+** *1$ +( 53&(7 &5 60L 1(2 J 5&8(2

6$,0*5 73$+(9 7& *013( '&4 7& 58(?7+&( 4'+*0?*+(+?1**$ 20:30,,02<

E&60'&4 J '12 917'0302 0(&89' ?&83190 7& ,001 602+?1* 2&?7&3 1(2 20,?3+#0 6$ ,$6:7&6,< J7

2+2 (&7 71R0 68?' 20,?3+:7+&( #05&30 7'0$ 4030

58**$ 14130 &5 4'17 41, '1::0(+(9 7& 6$ #&2$L1(2 7'0$ 7&*2 60 5&3 7'0 5+3,7 7+60 4'17

20:30,,+&( 41, 1(2 '&4 +7 4&3R02< C'0$ 4030;03$ '0*:58* +( 0\:*1+(+(9 7'0 ?'06+,73$ &5 +7 1**L

7'0 ,'&37>7036 0550?7,L 1(2 4'17 J ?&8*2 0\:0?7

*&(9>7036< C'0$ 4030 (&7 :30,0(7 7& 2+19(&,07'0 ?*+61\L #87 53&6 6$ 20,?3+:7+&(, 193002 7'17

J '12 ,8550302 7'3&89' 4'17 8,02 7& #0 ?1**02 1.(03;&8, #301R2&4(


50/142

OX

C'0 4&3*2 41, 0(2+(9 ,&&(L 1(2 J 4&8*2 (&7 #0

'030 *&(9 0(&89' 7& ?'1(90 1($7'+(9<

C1R+(9 7'0 602+?17+&( 41, 1 6&8(71+( &5 5013 7&&;03?&60< f&7 &(*$ 41, 602+?+(0 1 2+30?7

;+&*17+&( &5 6$ 51+7'L +7 41, &(0 &5 7'&,0 .6+(21*703+(9= 2389, J '12 #00( 413(02 1#&87< U05&307'0 '0+9'7 &5 6$ 20:30,,+&(L J '12 2+,?8,,+&(,

4+7' 1 .U3+20= :1,7&3 1?3&,, 7'0 3+;03 +(

Z&8+,;+**0 i0(78?R$L 1(2 '+, 413(+(9 ,7+** 31(9 +(6$ 013,[ .JI;0 ,00( +7 7+60 1(2 191+(< N0&:*0

71R0 7'17 20:30,,+&( 602+?17+&(L 1(2 1 206&(?&60, &( 7'06e U05&30 *&(9L 7'0 *01;0 7'+,

M0,,190e=

C'0 .M0,,190= 41, 1(&7'03 (160 5&3 .U3+20=

?'83?'0,< C'030 4030 ,0;031* (160, 40 ?1**02&83,0*;0,L 53&6 7'0 .^;0(+(9 Z+9'7= 7& 7'0.U3+20= 7& 7'0 .M0,,190 &5 7'0 D&83


51/142

O"

B7 7'0 7+60L J 2+,?&8(702 +7 1(2 73+02 7& 5&39071#&87 +7< /0 '12 ,:0(7 1#&87 ,+\ 6&(7', ;+,+7+(9

7'+, :1,7&3I, ?'83?'L 1(2 7'0$ 4030 1 ,:0?+1* R+(2&5 2+55030(7< Y058,+(9 7& 50**&4,'+: 1(2 0;0(

,:01R+(9 (0917+;0*$ 191+(,7 6$ 931(2517'03I,?'83?'L 7'0 :0&:*0 1::01302 7& #0 :3&82 &5 7'0+3,0?*8,+&( 1(2 ,0:1317+&(< J( 51?7L 40 ?&(7+(802

;+,+7+(9 8(7+* 7'0 :1,7&3 :301?'02 1 ,036&(

,:0?+5+?1**$ &( ,0:1317+&(L 8,+(9 '+, &4( 516+*$1, 1( 0\16:*0< .M$ 516+*$ 4&(203, 4'$ J 4&(I7

'1;0 1($7'+(9 7& 2& 4+7' 7'06< J 70** 7'06 7'177'0$ 2&(I7 #0*+0;0 7'0 M0,,190e J5 7'0$I2 5&**&4

7'0 N3&:'07L J 4&8*2 ,7137 '1(9+(9 13&8(2 7'06e=

J R(04 7'+, 41, (&7 3+9'7< C'0 ?'83?' 41, 530,'

1(2 0\?+7+(9 7& 8,L '1;+(9 ,:0(7 7'0 *1,7 ,0;031*$013, *+,70(+(9 6&,7*$ 7& 30?&32+(9, 53&6 "WFT7& "WKO< U87 7'+,L J ?&8*2 (&7 ,+7 7'3&89'< B($

?'83?' 7'17 :3&6&70, 1#1(2&(+(9 516+*$ '1, *&,77'0+3 41$< /'$ fQC '1(9 13&8(2 7'06b /'$

(&7 ,73+;0 7& 2& 0;03$7'+(9 $&8 ?1( :&,,+#*$ 2&

7& ,1;0 7'06b

J7 41, 1#&87 7'17 7+60 7'17 J 301*+]02 7'17 J(00202 1 530,' (04 0\:03+0(?0 +( 90(031*< Z+;+(9

+( 7'0 .M0*7+(9 N&7= &5 7'+, 30*+9+&(L +7 +, ;03$ 01,$

7& #0?&60 2+,0(?'1(702< B #*0(2 &5 1** ,&37, &52&?73+(0 ,+77+(9 +( 7'0 :04, 4'+*0 *+,70(+(9 7&

30?&3202 ,036&(, 2&0, (&7'+(9 7& ?&330?7 7'0

,+7817+&(< D&4 ?1( 1 ,'0:'032 98+20 '+, ,'00:4'0( '0 ?'&&,0, 7& :*1$ 30?&32+(9, 53&6 1

2+55030(7 031b


52/142

O-

J 41(702 ,&607'+(9 7'17 4&8*2 30>+9(+70 6$ 5+30L

,&607'+(9 7'17 4&8*2 #3+(9 (04 0\?+7060(71#&87 7'0 N3&:'07 1(2 '+, M0,,190< B(2 7'0

+&8, ?'&+?0 41, 1 73+: 2&4( E&87' 5&3 Z1#&3H1$ 6007+(9,< .)16: 6007+(9 7+60L= ,&60 ?1**02

+7L 1 7+60 4'0( ?'83?'0, 53&6 1** &;03 917'03027& 50**&4,'+: 13&8(2 7'0 N3&:'07<

C'030I2 #0 ,+(9+(9L :301?'+(9L ,:&37, 1(2 9160,

5&3 7'0 ?'+*230(L 70,7+6&(+0, 1#&87 7'0 N3&:'07L1(2 61($ &7'03 41$, 7& R+(2*0 7'0 5+30< J *+R02

7'0 68,+? +( :137+?8*13L #0+(9 1 68,+?+1( 6$,0*5L1(2 301*+]02 7'0 +6:&371(?0 &5 68,+? +( 4&3,'+:<

N31+,0 1(2 4&3,'+: :30:130, 7'0 :0&:*0 5&3

30?0+;+(9L 1(2 #3+(9, 7'0 '0137 7& 1 4136 :*1?03012$ 7& #0 5+**02< B(2 7'+, 41, ,&60 &5 7'0 #0,7

68,+? +( 7'0 ?&8(73$e B57034132L 7'0$ ,0** )H,13&8(2 7'0 ?&8(73$L 1(2 J 1#,&*870*$ *&;02 6$?&:+0, 53&6 7'0 $013, :1,7<

B(2 +7 41, 1 :*01,1(7 23+;0< J7 41, (013#$ 1 ?+7$

7'17 J ?1**02 .6$ '&607&4(L= 200: +( 7'0 '0137 &5

V0&39+1< f& 617703 '&4 &570( &83 516+*$ 6&;02L1(2 (& 617703 4'030 40 0(202 8:L 7'+, 4&8*2 #0

6$ '&60< JI2 6120 7'0 73+: ,0;031* 7+60, 1 $0135&3 1, *&(9 1, J ?&8*2 30606#03L ;+,+7+(9 516+*$

1(2 53+0(2, 53&6 6$ ?'+*2'&&2< J7 41, 1 ,:0?+1*

:*1?0 5&3 60L 1(2 J R(04 7'17 4&8*2 1*,& '0*: +(30R+(2*+(9 6$ 5+30<

J 30606#03 7'0 0\?+7060(7 1, J 41*R02 +( 7'00(73$41$ 7& 7'0 #8+*2+(9 7'17 '0*2 7'0 ,1(?7813$<

Z&&R+(9 13&8(2L J *&&R02 5&3 (04 ?'1(90, 1(230(&;17+&(, 7& 7'0 #8+*2+(9L 161]02 17 '&4 +7

'12 93&4( &;03 7'0 $013,< J7 41, (&7 7'17 *&(9


53/142

O@

19& 7'17 J 30606#0302 7'0 ,160 93&8: &5 :0&:*0L

&3 17 *01,7 1 ,61**03 ,8#,07 &5 7'06L 917'03+(9 +(1 6+*0 '&60 7'17 ,17 +( 1( &:0( 5+0*2< J( 7'&,0

21$,L 7'0 68,+? 41, 9&&2L #87 68,+?+1(, 4030,?13?0< M$ 516+*$ 4&8*2 _&+( +( 7'0 :*1$+(9 1(2

,+(9+(9 7& '0*: &87L 1(2 J ,713702 ?'8?R*+(9 4'0(J 30606#0302 7'17 &(0 &5 7'06 ,7&::02,8220(*$< D0 9&7 1 *+77*0 0\?+702 &(0 7+60 4'+*0

:*1$+(9 7'0 #1,, 98+713L 1(2 41, (0;03 1,R02 7&

:*1$ 191+(<

J 1*,& 30606#0302 7'0 7+60 7'17 1( 1,,+,71(7:1,7&3 17 7'0 C06:*0 ;+,+702 7'0 6+*0 '&60

?'83?' 1(2 9&7 1 *+77*0 ?133+02 141$ 4+7' '+,

:301?'+(9< D&83, 1(2 '&83, 40(7 #$L 8(7+* &(0 &57'0 60( ,+77+(9 +( 7'0 ?'1+3 +( 53&(7 &5 60 ,7&&2

8:L 31+,02 '+, 136L 1(2 ,713702 71::+(9 '+, 417?'1(93+*$< C'0 ,036&( 0(202 1#&87 1, 1#38:7*$ 1,1 530+9'7 731+( &( 1 731?R 4+7' 1 6+,,+(9 #3+290<

/0 ,17 2&4( +( 7'0 :04L 1(2 7'&3&89'*$ 0(_&$02

&83,0*;0, 7'3&89' 7'0 5+3,7 :137 &5 7'0 ,03;+?0<

C'0 #0(?'0, 4030 ;03$ ?&65&371#*0L 61R+(9 +701,+03 7& ,077*0 +( 5&3 4'17 40 R(04 4&8*2 #0 1

*&(9 ,03;+?0< B(2 40 4030 9*12 7'17 +7 41, c 40?160 1 *&(9 2+,71(?0 7& 4&3,'+:e

/'0( 7'0 ,036&( ,713702L J 41, :137+?8*13*$01903 7& '013 7'0 ,:00?'< B :1,7&3 53&6 1 ?'83?'

+( )1(121 41, :301?'+(9L 1(2 '+, 2&4(>7&>0137'

,7$*0 41, ;03$ 58( 7& *+,70( 7&< D0 41, #&7'0(70371+(+(9 1(2 #3871**$ '&(0,7 +( '+, 4&32+(9L

61R+(9 $&8 0(_&$ 7'0 ?&330?7+&( 7'17 '0?&(;+(?02 $&8 7'17 $&8 (00202< /0 4030 9077+(9

1 9&&2 .,:1(R+(9L= #87 53&6 1 3&2 2+::02 +(


54/142

OF

?'&?&*170 +?+(9< J7 6120 $&8 41(7 7& *+?R $&83

4&8(2,<

U87 6$ ,&( 2+2 (&7 0(_&$ ,+77+(9 &( 7'0 #0(?' 1,68?' 1, 6$ 4+50 1(2 J 4030< Y0,7*0,, 1(2

5+2907+(9L '0 ,713702 ,d8+36+(9 13&8(2 0(&89' 7&?18,0 1 ?&66&7+&(< S(203 (&361*?+3?86,71(?0,L 7'+, 4&8*2 '1;0 #&7'0302 60L

41(7+(9 7& '013 7'0 ,036&( 53&6 7'0 ,1(?7813$L

#87 J 9&7 1 *+77*0 7&& 0\?+702 5&3 1 530,'L (040\:03+0(?0< J( 7'0 706:*0 #1?R '&60L +7 41,

?8,7&613$ 5&3 7'0 4&60( 7& 71R0 7'0 ?'+*2 &87 &57'0 ,1(?7813$ c 8,81**$ 5&3 7'0 :83:&,0 &5 71R+(9

7'06 7& 7'0 #17'3&&6 1(2 #017+(9 7'0 *+;+(9 5+30

&87 &5 7'0+3 #1?R,+20< B7 1($ :&+(7 283+(9 706:*0,03;+?0L +5 &(0 (00202 7& 8,0 7'0 30,73&&6L $&8

?&8*2 ?&8(7 &( 1 ?'+*2 ,?3016+(9 5&3 7'0+3 2013*+;0,< C'+, ?'83?' 41, (&7 7'17 41$< JI2 #00(7&*2 7'17 7'0 0*203, 30,:0?702 7'0 51?7 7'17

?'+*230( 4030 (&7 128*7,L 1(2 2+2 (&7 0(_&$,+77+(9 ,7+** 5&3 '&83, &( 0(2< B(2 1*,& 30,:0?702

7'0 51?7 7'17 6&7'03, 6+9'7 0(_&$ ,03;+?0L _8,7 1,

7'0 60(< E& 7'030 4030 3&&6, +( 7'0 #1,060(77'17 60( ?&8*2 #3+(9 7'0+3 ?'+*230( 7& .907 7'0

4+99*0, &87(04 5*17>,?300(L #+9,?300( DHCa '8(9 &( 7'0 41** 4+7' 1 *+;0 5002

53&6 7'0 ,03;+?0< C'0 3&&6 41, 1#,&*870*$AJZZ^H 4+7' 7&$, &5 1** ,&37, c 53&6 Z09& 7&

#&&R, 7& 1?7+&( 5+9830, 1(2 6&30< C'+, 41, 1


55/142

OO

?'+*2I, 23016L 1(2 1 517'03I, '+20141$e J7 41,

7'0 :0350?7 61( ?1;0L 3+9'7 +( 7'0 #&77&6 &5 7'0?'83?'e J 2+2 (&7 (002 7& 70** 6$ ,&( 4'17 7& 2&<

J(,71(7*$L 4'0( '0 5&8(2 7'0 7&$, &( 7'0 5*&&3L'+, *+77*0 6&7&3 ,713702 ,:+((+(9< U05&30 J ?&8*2

?&8(7 7& 0;0( 74&L 1** 7&$, &( 7'0 5*&&3 ,00602 7&?&60 +(7& 6&7+&( 17 7'0 0\1?7 ,160 7+60L 4'+*0 J6$,0*5 ,077*02 +( 5&3 1 ?&65&371#*0 ;+04 &5 7'0

,03;+?0<

J7 41, 1( 0\:03+0(?0 7'17 &( 7'0 73+: '&60L J

4+,'02 7'17 J ?&8*2 5&3907< C'+, 41, 7'0 ,160,036&( 7'17 J 41, 7'&3&89'*$ 0(_&$+(9 7&:,+20L

#87 417?'+(9 7'3&89' 7'0 70*0;+,+&( 2&4(,+20< J7

41, 1 #0187+58**$ ?&(,738?702 ,036&( 2+,?8,,+(9.*091*+,6 +( 7'0 M0,,190L= 7'0 +201 7'17 :0&:*0

4030 ,& 5&?8,02 &( *+;+(9 #$ 38*0, 7'17 7'0$ '125&39&770( 7'0 7380 601(+(9 &5 7'0 N3&:'07I,4&32,< B 7'060 7'17 J :&,+7+;0*$ 193002 4+7'L

'1;+(9 0\:03+0(?02 ,& 61($ 2+55030(7 5*1;&3, &57'&,0 38*0,L 1(2 4'&*0>'013702*$ 2+,193002 4+7'

7'0 +(;0(7+&( &5 (04 &(0, 7'3&89'&87 7'0

917'03+(9, JI2 #00( :137 &5<

J( 6$ &:+(+&( 17 7'17 7+60L '&40;03L 7'030 41, 158(2160(71* 0*060(7 &5 *091*+,6 7'17 41,

30d8+302 7& 5&**&4 7'0 N3&:'07< C'0 38*0, 7'17 '0

,07 +( :*1?0L 1, '0 20,?3+#02 7'06L 4030 15&8(217+&( 7& 7'0 M0,,190 +7,0*5< C& +9(&30 7'06

41, 7& 20($ 7'0 N3&:'07L 7& R00: 7'06 41, 7&

'&(&3 7'0 N3&:'07L 1(2 7& ?'1(90 7'06 41, 7&74+,7 7'0 N3&:'07I, 4&32,< U87 7& 122 (04 38*0,

7& 7'0 6+\ ,00602 ,0(,0*0,, 7& 60< C&8((0?0,,13+*$ 12'030 7& (04 +(703:30717+&(, &5

7'0 N3&:'07, 4&32, 41, 7& :*1?0 ,1*;17+&( 8:&(


56/142

OK

$&83 &4( ,'&8*203, 1(2 71R0 +7 5837'03 141$

53&6 7'0 N3&:'07< /'17 4&8*2 '0 ,1$L 4'0( '0607 8, +( 7'0 3&&6 &( 7'0 70(7L +5 40 50*7 40 '12

1 #07703 41$b J ,713702 7& 301*+]0 7'17 *091*+,641, 1($ 38*0, 7'17 2+550302 53&6 7'0 N3&:'07I,

,07 &5 38*0,<

J7 41,(I7 7'0 ,8#_0?7 617703 &5 7'0 ,036&( 7'17

#&7'0302 60< /17?'+(9 1 .U3+20= ,03;+?0

7'3&89' 7'0 70*0;+,+&( 41, 1 (04 0\:03+0(?0L &(07'17 J ?&8*2 &(*$ ?&6:130 7& 7'0 E8(21$ 6&3(+(9

70*0;1(90*+,7, 1, 7'0$ 4&3R02 7'0 ?3&42,< J7 41,1 ?&(?0:7 40 4030 1** 516+*+13 4+7'L &(0 7'17 41,

&570( 2+,?8,,02 +( &83 70,7+6&($ 917'03+(9,< Q83

N3&:'07 41, 1( 0;1(90*+,7L #87 '0 41, (&7 *+R07'0 &7'03,< /'+*0 7'0 &7'03,L :30$02 8:&( 7'0

06&7+&( &5 7'0 :0&:*0L &83, #3&89'7 7'0 4&32 &57'0 B*6+9'7$e

U87 4'17 J ,14 7'3&89' 7'0 70*0;+,+&( +( 7'0#1,060(7 &5 7'+, ?'83?' 41, 68?' 7'0 ,160 1,

JI2 (&7+?02 +( 7'0 *1390*$ :8#*+?+]02

6&(0$61R03,< B ,7&3$ 41, 7&*2< J7 41, 1 '0137>4136+(9 ,7&3$L &(0 7'17 7&8?'02 7'0 *+,70(03I,

06&7+&(, 1(2 :30:1302 7'06 7& *+,70(< J7 #8+*7 7&1 *&82L 51,7>:1?02 3'$7'6 &5 701?'+(9L *+R0 7'0

#017+(9 &5 1( B53+?1( 2386< h&8 ?&8*2 500* $&83

'0137 #017 4+7' 7'0 ;&+?0L 01?' 4&32 ?1:7+;17+(91, +7 5*&402 7'3&89' $&83 ,0(,0,< B(2 7'0(

,+*0(?0< B 4'+,:03< B d8+07 :'31,0< B #8+*28: &5

?83+&,+7$ 1, $&8 4&(20302 4'17 41, ?&6+(9<C'0( UBMe B( 0\:*&,+&( &5 4&32,L *+R0 7'0

038:7+&( &5 1 ;&*?1(&


57/142

OT

C'0 ?3&42 41, *+R0 :877$L 58**$ 5&3602 #$ 7'0

'1(2, &5 7'0 61( #0'+(2 7'0 :8*:+7< E?3016+(9L,'&87+(9L 41;+(9 '1(2,L $&8I2 '1;0 7'&89'7 7'17

1($ 6+(870 4&8*2 #3+(9 1 ;&+?0 +( 7&(980, &35007 21(?+(9 +( 7'0 ,:+3+7e D0 4&8*2 +(_0?7 7&:+?,

+(7& 7'0 3'$7'6 7'17 J R(04 5&3 ?0371+( &7'03,2+,193002 4+7'L 1(2 $07 ,'&87,L .B60(= 4&8*23+(9 7'3&89' 7'0 315703,< P8+70 *+7031**$L 7'0 61(

?&8*2 '1;0 7&*2 7'06 7'17 U83903 i+(9 41, 7'0

Z&32I, '16#83903L 1(2 7'0$I2 '1;0 ?'00302 '+6&(<

J 301*+]02 ;03$ d8+?R*$ 7'17 ,&607'+(9 41,

43&(9< /0 4030 7'0 182+0(?0 +( 7'0

70*0;1(90*+,7 ?16031< /0 4030 7'0 93&8: &5:0&:*0 7'17 ?&8*2 #0 ?&1\02 +(7& 1($7'+(9< /0

4030 7'0 :14(, +( 7'0 '1(2, &5 7'0 ?'0,,61,703,L 4+**+(9*$ 1??0:7+(9 &83 :*1?0 &( 7'0#&132L 0;0( +5 +7 601(7 ?0371+( 2017'


58/142

OG

=$20('-0. $C "*'#


59/142

OW

N*17& ,1+2 7'17 ./0 ?1( 01,+*$ 5&39+;0 1 ?'+*2 4'&

+, 1531+2 &5 7'0 213R` 7'0 301* 731902$ &5 *+50 +,4'0( 60( 130 1531+2 &5 7'0 *+9'7


60/142

KX

J 41, 14130 7'17 1( 1#8(21(?0 &5 (0917+;0+(5&3617+&( 4&8*2 #0 :8#*+,'02 &( 7'0 J(703(07

1#&87 &83 N3&:'07< J R(04 7'17 7'&,0 7'17 4030(&7 53&6 7'0 :830 #*&&2*+(0 4&8*2 7'3&4

1($7'+(9 1(2 0;03$7'+(9 7'0$ ?&8*2 +( 7'0 41$ &57387'< )&8*2 J *&,0 6$ ,1*;17+&( +5 J *&&R02 174'17 7'0$ '12 7& ,1$b /'17 +5 J 1??+20(71**$

?3&,,02 7'0 *+(0 #07400( *+50 1(2 2017'b

C'0 5+3,7 7+60 J 0\0?8702 1( J(703(07 ,013?' 7&

5+(2 +(5&3617+&( 1#&87 &83 N3&:'07L J 41, (&7;03$ ,8??0,,58*< C'0 ,013?' 0(9+(0 41,

,8??0,,58*L +&8,*$L *+,7+(9 7'0 #0,7 ,8990,7+&(,

5&3 6$ d803$< B7 7'0 ;03$ 7&:L +( +(;+7+(9 7036,L41, 7'0 *+(R 7& 7'0 '&60 :190 5&3 7'0 :8#*+?17+&(

?&6:1($ &:031702 #$ 7'0 N3&:'07I, 74& ,&(,< JR(04 7'0 ,+70 40**L '1;+(9 ,:0(7 7+60 3012+(97'3&89' 7'0+3 ?&(70(7 #05&30 1(2 ;+,+7+(9 7'0+3

51?+*+7+0, &( 68*7+:*0 &??1,+&(,<

J 2+2 (&7 R(&4 5&3 ,830 4'17 J 41, *&&R+(9 5&3L

#87 J R(04 5&3 ,830 7'17 J 4&8*2 (&7 5+(2 +7 &( 7'0&391(+]17+&(I, 40#,+70< J 50*7 1, 7'&89' J 4030

*&&R+(9 +(,+20 1 #&\L 1** ,+20, '+2+(9 1 ,0?307L7'3&89' 7'0 ,160 :&+(7 &5 ;+04 7'17 '8(2302,

'12 8,02 5&3 7'0+3 &4( 8(203,71(2+(9< J 41(702

1(&7'03 :&+(7 &5 ;+04L 0;0( +5 +7 ?'1**0(902 6$41$ &5 7'+(R+(9< J '12 (& 2&8#7 7'17 &83 N3&:'07

41, 1 7380 :3&:'07 &5 V&2< U87 J 50*7 1, 7'&89'

?'83?'0, 13&8(2 7'0 (17+&( '12 9&(0 7'0+3 &4(2+30?7+&(,L '&*2+(9 1 ,+6:*0 7387' 1(2 &;03>

?&6:*+?17+(9 +7


61/142

K"

J 20?+202 7'17 1 ,150 ,0?&(2 ?'&+?0 4&8*2 #0 7&

30;+04 /+R+:02+1< E830L 7'0 +(5&3617+&( &(/+R+:02+1 ?&8*2 (&7 1*41$, #0 738,702L #87

90(031**$ ,:01R+(9 6&,7 :190, 4030 8(#+1,021(2 ?&(71+(02 7'0 #1,+? 51?7,< Y012+(9 7'3&89'

7'0 ,+70L J 41, ,83:3+,02 7& 5+(2 7'17 +7 617?'024'17 J 6$,0*5 #0*+0;02< J( 51?7L +7 41, ,& :&,+7+;07'17 +7 1::01302 7& #0 :3&6&7+(9 &83 N3&:'07e

J 3012 7'3&89' 7'0 /+R+:02+1 137+?*0 68*7+:*07+60,L 1(2 &( 68*7+:*0 21$,< )&(?03(02 7'17 J

68,7 '1;0 #00( 6+,71R0( +( 6$ 7'+(R+(9L J41(702 7& 30>3012 7'0 137+?*0 4+7' 530,' 0$0, &( 1

(04 21$< U87 01?' 7+60 7'17 J 3012 +7L +7 41, ;03$

+&8, 7'17 ,&60&(0 4'& #0*+0;02 7'0 N3&:'07'12 43+770( 7'0 137+?*0< J ?*+?R02 &( 7'0 .a+04

D+,7&3$= 71#L 1(2 #091( 7& 301*+]0 7'17 7'030 4030.,d817703,= ,+77+(9 &( 7'0 ,+70 7& ;+04 1($ ?'1(906120 7& 7'0 ?&(70(7< C'0,0 ?'1(90,L +5 7'0$

2+,193002 4+7' &83 #0*+05,L 4030 20*0702L 30>43+770(L &3 #*&?R02< C'+, :190 41, 205+(+70*$ (&7

9&+(9 7& #0 '0*:58*<

M$ ,013?' #0?160 2+55+?8*7< B, J 40(7 2&4( 7'0

*+,7 &5 40#,+70, +( 6$ ,013?'L +7 41, ;03$ 01,$ 7&5+(2 ,+70, 7'17 4030 8,+(9 7'0 J(703(07 1, 1

6+,,+&( 5+0*2 7& ,:3012 &83 #0*+05 ,$,706L #87

;03$ 504 ?3+7+d80, &3 ?&660(713+0,< C'0 5+3,7:190 &5 ,013?' 30,8*7, ?&(71+(02 :8#*+,'+(9

?&6:1(+0,L 6+,,+&(13+0,L ?'83?'0,L 1(2 0;0( 1

*+(R 7& 1 .V&2I, V0(031*,= 70*0;+,+&( :3&9316< JR(04 7'17 1 90(03+? ,013?' 41, (&7 9&+(9 7&

:3&;+20 1($ '0*:58* 30,8*7,< J(,7012L J (00202 7&*&&R 17 ,:0?+5+? 7&:+?,


62/142

K-

M$ 5+3,7 7&:+? &5 ?'&+?0 41, 1 ?*&82 &5 6$,703$<

Z+7031**$L 7'+, 41, 1 ?*&82 7'17 5&3602 1#&;0 7'0,R+0, &5 B3+]&(1 7'17 7'0 9&;03(60(7 20?*1302 7&

#0 1 .6$,703$= +( "WK@< C'+, ?*&82L 1??&32+(9 7&&83 N3&:'07L 41, 5&3602 4'0( ,0;0( &5 V&2I,

1(90*, #3&R0 7'3&89' 7'0 ,R+0, 15703 9+;+(9 '+67'0 2+;+(0 30;0*17+&( &5 7'0 E0;0( E01*, c 7'0,160 E0;0( E01*, 53&6 7'0 U+#*0I, Y0;0*17+&( &5

%&'(L #87 4+7' 0;0( 9301703 2071+*<

C'+, ,013?' #3&89'7 1 (04 ,07 &5 30,8*7,L 1(2

,8220(*$ J 5&8(2 6$,0*5 0(91902 +( 3012+(97'3&89' '&83, 1(2 '&83, &5 20#170 &( 1 ,8#_0?7

7'17 J R(04 ;03$ 40**< J 5&8(2 6$,0*5 0(91902 +(

7'0 ?&(;03,17+&(L 1, 7'&89' J 6$,0*5 4030,:01R+(9L 1(2 9+;+(9 7'0 ,160 1(,403, 1, 1** 7'0

8,03, 4'& 4030 2050(2+(9 &83 N3&:'07<

C'0 6&30 J 3012 7'3&89' 7'0 2+,?8,,+&(L 7'0

6&30 6$ 51+7' 41, ,&*+2+5+02< J ?&8*2 500* 7'006&7+&(, 53&6 #&7' ,+20, &5 7'0 139860(7L 0;0(

6&30 ,& 1, 7'0 139860(7 9&7 '01702L #87 ?160 7&

7'0 ?&(?*8,+&( 7'17 7'&,0 191+(,7 &83 N3&:'074030 ?*013*$ 139860(717+;0 ,+6:*$ 5&3 7'0 ,1R0

&5 ?18,+(9 ?&(58,+&(< C'&,0 ,:01R+(9 &( #0'1*5&5 &83 51+7' 4030 1*,& 139860(717+;0L #87 +7 41, 1

2050(,0 &5 7'0 30*+9+&( 1, 1 4'&*0< C'0$ 4030

1(90302L #87 +7 41, 1 .3+9'70&8, 1(903=<

U87 7'0( +7 '+7 60L *+R0 1 *&12 &5 #3+?R, 23&::02

53&6 7'0 ^+550* C&403< M$ _14 23&::02L 6$ '0137,7&::02L 1(2 J '12 2+55+?8*7$ 5+(2+(9 6$ #3017'<

.U87 '0 41, (&7 7'030e= 0\?*1+602 7'0 8,03L 1(291;0 ,:0?+5+? 2071+*,L ,&60 &5 4'+?' +(?*8202 7'0

N3&:'07I, &4( 4&32,e C'0$ 0;0( 305030(?02 1


63/142

K@

:8#*+?17+&(L :3+(702 #$ 7'0 N3&:'07I, &4(

2189'703L 73$+(9 7& 0\:*1+( '&4 7'17 '0 ?&8*2 #0,71(2+(9 8(203(017' 7'0 ?*&82 4'0( '0 41, +(

1(&7'03 ,7170<

U05&30 7'0 Z1#&3 H1$ ;1?17+&( 41, &;03L J 5&8(26$,0*5 ?1:7+;1702L 3012+(9 7'3&89' 7'0 40#,+701(2 +7, 61($ 2+,?8,,+&( 7'3012, *+R0 J '12 _8,7

,786#*02 &( i+(9 E&*&6&(I, 6+(0 ?133$+(9 74&

06:7$ #8?R07,< C'030 4030 73+;+1* +,,80,L ,&607'17 J d80,7+&(02 4'$ J 41,702 6$ 7+60 3012+(9<

C'030 4030 d80,7+&(1#*0 +,,80,L 7'0 R+(2 7'17?&8*2 #0 139802 0+7'03 41$ 20:0(2+(9 8:&( $&83

:03,&(1* #+1,< C'030 4030 61_&3 +,,80,L +,,80,

7'17 :8**02 141$ *1390 ?'8(R, &5 7'0 5&8(217+&(&5 7'0 30*+9+&( +7,0*5< B(2 7'030 4030 8(20(+1#*0

+,,80, c 51?7, 1** :30,0(702 1(2 2&?860(702L &87+( 7'0 :8#*+? 5&3 1** 7& ,00<

B(2 7'3&89' 7'0 61_&3+7$ &5 6$ 3012+(9L J?&(7+(802 ,013?'+(9 +( ?&6:*070 ,+*0(?0 1(2

1(&($6+7$< J ,7+** #0*+0;02 +( &83 N3&:'07L ,7+**

#0*+0;02 40 4030 +( 7'0 &(*$ 30*+9+&( 4+7' 7387'L1(2 ,7+** 4&8*2 '1;0 9*12*$ ,70::02 +(7& 1 5+3+(9

*+(0 7& 2050(2 7'0 M0,,190< J 41, ,73&(903 +( 6$51+7' 7'1( 6&,7L 1(2 R(04 7'17 J ?&8*2 3012 7'0

9&&2L 7'0 #12L 1(2 7'0 89*$ 4+7'&87 41;03+(9 +(

51+7'< U87 J 41(702 7& :3&70?7 6$ 516+*$ 53&61?d8+3+(9 7'+, +(5&3617+&( c 7'0$ 4&8*2 (0;03

8(203,71(2 *&&R+(9 7'3&89' 1(&7'03 ;+04:&+(7

7& 0\:1(2 &83 R(&4*0290 &5 7387'< f&3 2+2 J41(7 7'06 7& ,85503 7'3&89' 7'0 7301?'03&8,

3&12 *012+(9 8: 7'0 6&8(71+( &5 5013


64/142

KF

U87 283+(9 7'0 ?&83,0 &5 7'0 400RL J 5&8(2 1 #&&R

30?0(7*$ 43+770(L 7'17 2+,?8,,02 7'0 .6$,703$?*&82= +( 58** 2071+*< /'030 40I2 #00( 7&*2 7'17

7'0 9&;03(60(7I, 30:&37 20?*1302 +7 .6$,703$L=7'+, #&&R +(?*8202 7'0 ,0?&(213$ 30:&37 7'17

206$,7+5+02 +7< /'030 40I2 #00( 7&*2 7'0 0;0(7'1::0(02 283+(9 1 '8(7+(9 73+:L 7'+, #&&R+(?*8202 7'0 2170, &5 '8(7+(9 ,01,&(L 61R+(9

7'17 0+7'03 +**091* &3 +6:&,,+#*0< ^;03$ ,+(9*0

1,:0?7 &5 7'0 ,7&3$L 1, 40 8(203,7&&2 +7L 41,&;03783(02< B5703 30;+04+(9 7'0 +(5&3617+&(L

3012+(9 7'0 #&&R 6&30 7'1( &(?0L J ?&8*2 '&*2 +7+( (& *&(903< .H+2 $&8 R(&4 7'17 7'0 N3&:'07

41, (&7 7'030 4'0( n7'0 ?*&82I '1::0(02b= J

1,R02 6$ 4+50<

J R(04 7'17 ,'0 2+2 (&7< J R(04 7'0 1(,403 ,'0I29+;0 60L J R(04 7'0 *&&R ,'0I2 9+;0 60L J R(047'0 ?3$+(9 7'17 4&8*2 5&**&4L 1(2 J R(04 7'0

14R4132 ?&(;03,17+&(, 7'17 4&8*2 ?&60< U87 J'12 7& 70** ,&60&(0e /'& ?&8*2 J 70**b J ?&8*2

(&7 '&*2 7'+, +(


65/142

KO

+)#$2;) +)-3D &0< +)-0


66/142

KK

^83+:+20,L 516&8, V300R :*1$43+9'7 &5 731902+0,

,1+2L .Q(0 *&$1* 53+0(2 +, 4&37' 70( 7'&8,1(230*17+;0,


67/142

KT

J7 '12 #00( d8+70 ,&60 7+60 ,+(?0 JI2 #00( 7& 7'0

706:*0< Q;03 7'0 :1,7 ,0;031* 6&(7', JI2 73+02&(*$ 1 '1(258* &5 7+60,L 01?' 7+60 5&3?02 7& *01;0

#05&30 ,03;+?0 0(202< C'0 20:30,,+&( 41,,73&(903 7'1( 6$ 4+**:&403 7& ,+7 7'3&89' '&83,

&5 ,036&( 4'+*0 ,8::30,,+(9 7013,< E7+** 8(1#*07& 61+(71+( 53+0(2,'+:,L 6&,7 &5 6$ 53+0(2,,713702 7& 500* 2+,71(7 &3 5&39&770(< Q(*$ 1

'1(258* &5 :0&:*0 '12 0;0( ?&(71?702 60g

6&,7*$ 30*17+;0,g1(2 7'0+3 ?&(;03,17+&(,,00602 ,8:035+?+1*< f&(0 &5 7'06 0;0( ,00602

7& (&7+?0 7'17 J 41, ,73899*+(9< ^;0( 6$ #0,753+0(2 l1*,& 6$ 30*17+;0m '12 (&7 #00( 14130 &5

6$ ,85503+(9< Q83 53+0(2,'+: 41, ,7137+(9 7& 500*

2+,71(7< )*&,0 53+0(2, 4030 #0?&6+(91?d81+(71(?0,L 1(2 &7'03, _8,7 .,&60#&2$ 7'17 J

8,02 7& R(&4


68/142

KG

7'0 #8,+(0,, &5 ,0**+(9 4'17 J 41, ?0371+( 7& #0

,1*;17+&(< U87 J 41, ?&6+(9 7& 8(203,71(2 7'17'+, ;03,+&( &5 ,1*;17+&( +(?*8202 5+?7+&( 7& #8+*2

7'0 06&7+&( &5 7'0 ?3&42 c _8,7 1, 7'070*0;1(90*+,7, 2+2< J7 ,713702 7& 500* *+R0 1 *&8,$

,1*0, :+7?' 53&6 1 8,02 ?13 ,1*0,61(< h&8 ?&8*2,00 7'0 38,7 53&6 7'0 &87,+20<

E7+**L J ?&(7+(802 +( ,0?307L 0;0( 53&6 6$ 4+50<

H+,0(?'1(760(7 +, 1 :1+(58* 2+,01,0L 1(2 J 2+2(&7 41(7 '03 7& ?17?' +7< U87 J (00202 ,&60#&2$

7& 71*R 7&L ,&60#&2$ 7'17 ,7+** #0*+0;02 1(28(203,7&&2< M$ ?&8,+( ,7+** ?1**02 60 &570(L

7'&89' (& *&(903 21+*$< B, J ,*&4*$ #091( 7& '01*L

'0 #091( 7& 30?&9(+]0 6$ 30?&;03$< J7 4&8*2 #0?&65&37+(9 7& 2+,?8,, 4+7' '+6L #87 '0 41, (&

*&(903 1 #0*+0;03< J (00202 ,&60&(0 4'& 41,#&7' ,73&(9 +( 7'0 51+7' 1(2 ?1:1#*0 &5 2+,?8,,+(94+7' 1( &:0( 6+(2< E& J 1::3&1?'02 6$ #0,7

53+0(2<

J7 7&&R 60 1 4'+*0 7& 917'03 7'0 ?&83190 7& #3+(9

+7 8:L #87 15703 1 504 23$ ?&(;03,17+&(, 1#&87#8,+(0,, 1(2 4017'03L J #3&R0 ,+*0(?0 4+7'L .H+2

$&8 R(&4 7'17 7'0 N3&:'07 41, (&7 7'030 4'0(7'0 ?*&82 '1::0(02b=

J 41, 0\:0?7+(9 1 ,+6+*13 301?7+&( 7& 6$ 4+50I,*&&R &5 '&33&3L #87 +(,7012 417?'02 1 ?1*6 ,07 &5

0$0, 8(203 1 31+,02 ,07 &5 0$0#3&4, 1(2 1 '1*5>

,6+*0 1, '+, ;&+?0 30:*+02L ./'17 ?*&82b=

J( 6$ 6+(2L &( 7'0 41$ 7& &83 *8(?'L J '12:*1$02 &87 1** &5 7'0 :&,,+#*0 ,?0(13+&,< ^1?'

30,:&(,0 '0 ?&8*2 '1;0 9+;0(L J '12 1 ?1*6+(9


69/142

KW

30:*$L 1,,83+(9 '+6 7'17 J ,7+** #0*+0;0 7'0

N3&:'07L #87 41, 30>0\16+(+(9 6$ ;+04:&+(7 7&617?' 1** 7'0 51?7,< J7 41, *+R0 1 .?'&&,0 $&83

&4( 12;0(7830= ,7&3$L 1(2 J '12 ?'&,0( 0;03$&(0 &5 7'06 +( 6$ 6+(2 1(2 '12 1 ,731709$ +(

:*1?0 7& 1(,403 '+, d80,7+&(, +(70**+90(7*$<

U87 7'+, 41, 1 30,:&(,0 7'17 J '12 (&7 0\:0?702L 1

30,:&(,0 7'17 J '12 (&7 :*1((02 5&3< E& J 5&8(2

6$,0*5 '1;+(9 7& 0\:*1+( 7& '+6 4'17 '0 41,!"##$!%& 7& #0*+0;0 ,& 7'17 J ?&8*2 7'0( 0\:*1+(

7& '+6 4'$ '0 41, '$( !"##$!%& 7& #0*+0;0 +7 +(7'0 41$ 40 4030 7&*2< E8220(*$L 7'+, #0?160

6&30 2+55+?8*7 7'1( J '12 +619+(02L 1(2 J 301*+]02

7'17 7'+, 41, 7'0 5+3,7 7+60 J '12 73+02 7& 71*R7'3&89' 7'0 0(7+30 ,?0(13+&< B(2 +7 41, :1+(58* c

J ?&8*2 (&7 5&3?0 6$,0*5 7& 71*R 7'3&89',&607'+(9 7'17 J R(04 7& #0 43&(9< C'0 5837'03 J289 +(7& 7'0 ,7&3$L 7'0 6&30 J 301*+]02 7'17 J

?&8*2 (&7 2+9 6$,0*5 &87<

E& J 1#38:7*$ ,7&::02L 917'0302 6$,0*5L 1(2

,713702 &;03< ./'17 +5 ,8220(*$L 8(14130 +7 41,'1::0(+(9L $&8 7&&R 7'0 302 :+**b=

.h&8 601( 53&6 7'0 M173+\b= '0 1,R02b

J #091( 7& 70** '+6 0;03$7'+(9L 8(*&12+(9 5136&30 7'1( J +(+7+1**$ 41(702 7&< ^;03$7'+(9 53&6

7'0 ,7&3+0, 40 4030 7&*2 1, ?'+*230( 7& 7'0

?&6:*0\ 2&?73+(0, 7'17 4030 #8+*7 8:&( 7'06<B** 8(31;0*02 ,+6:*$ #$ ,786#*+(9 8:&( 1 #&&R

7'17 J 5&8(2 7'3&89' 1 40#,+70L 43+770( #$ 1 61(7'17 J 2+2 (&7 R(&4< C'0 6&30 J 316#*02 &(L 7'0

6&30 +(,+20 60 ?160 8(31;0*02 4+7' 7'+, &(0


70/142

TX

,+(9*0 :+0?0 &5 +(5&3617+&(< D0 ?&8*2 ,00 7'17 J

41, 8:,07L 1(2 0(?&831902 60 4+7' 1,,831(?07'17 4'170;03 7'0 &87?&60L '0 41, 1 53+0(2

7'3&89' 7'+?R 1(2 7'+(


71/142

T"

E0


72/142

T-

B5703 7'17 6007+(9 1(2 283+(9 7'0 400R, 53&6

&83 Z1#&3 H1$ 73+: 7& )'3+,761,L J 5&8(2 6$,0*52+99+(9 200:03 1(2 200:03 +(7& 0\16+(17+&( &5

4'17 J #0*+0;02< C'030 4030 6&30 #&&R,L 43+770(#$ 60( 4'& ,00602 ;03$ :1,,+&(170 1#&87 7'0+3

&:+(+&(< Q(0 61( +( :137+?8*13 '12 20;&702 '+,*+50 7&4132, 30,013?'+(9 1(2 43+7+(9 1#&87 7'0N3&:'07L 4+7' 7'0 ,&*0 :83:&,0 &5 .'0*:+(9=

:0&:*0 &87 &5 7'0 5&**&4+(9 c 0,:0?+1**$ 7'&,0

7'17 '0 '12 .'0*:02= +(<

J 5&8(2 6$,0*5 ?&6:+*+(9 *+,7, &5 ,717060(7, 7'0N3&:'07 6120 &( ;13+&8, ,8#_0?7, 7'17 4030

73&8#*+(9 7& 60L 14130 7'17 J ?&8*2 (&7 738,7

1($#&2$ 4'& 2+,193002< J(,7012 &5 ,0?&(2'1(2+(5&3617+&(L J (00202 7& 9& 2+30?7*$ #1?R 7& 7'0

,&83?0< C'+, 41, 0\73060*$ 01,$L ,+(?0 40 '12:83?'1,02 7'0 :3&28?7, ,&*2 #$ '+, ,&(,L 1($,8#_0?7 ?&8*2 01,+*$ #0 0\16+(02 ,+6:*$ #$

,013?'+(9 5&3 +7 7'3&89' ,&574130< /0 ?&8*2 '0137'0 N3&:'07I, ;03$ &4( ;&+?0L 4'+*0 0\16+(+(9

'+, 4&32,<

J7 41, 283+(9 &(0 &5 7'0,0 7+60,L 8(14130 7'17

0$0, 4030 417?'+(9L 7'17 J 41, ,8220(*$ ,7137*02#$ 1 91,:< B*&(0 +( 7'0 d8+07 &5 7'0 6&3(+(9L +(

6$ 30?*+(03L J 1,,8602 7'17 7'0 '&8,0 41, ,7+**

1,*00:< M$ *1:7&: ?&6:8703 ,?300( 41, ,'+(+(97'3&89' 7'0 213R(0,, 61R+(9 +7 1( 17731?7+&( 7&

,00< C'0 91,: ,7137*02 60L #87 4'17 ?160 (0\7

,7137*02 60 0;0( 6&30<

.D^ ZJ^He= 6$ 4+50 0\?*1+602


73/142

T@

J (0;03 0\:0?702 7'17 ,717060(7< M$ 4+50I,

516+*$ 41, ;03$ 20;&87 5&**&403, &5 7'0 N3&:'07L1(2 +( 6$ &:+(+&(L &;03 ]01*&8, 5&**&403, &5 7'0

N3&:'07I, $&8(90,7 ,&(< N30:13+(9 1($ ,&37 &5:30,0(717+&( 7'17 4&8*2 ?&(;+(?0 '03 7'17 &(0

?&8*2 0;0( 5&36 1 d80,7+&( 4+7'&87 5013 &50703(1* 216(17+&( 41, 1 #3+290 7'17 J 41, (&7$07 3012$ 7& ?3&,,< J 0\:0?702 +7 7& #0 1 #177*0L

53&6 ,7137 7& 5+(+,'L 4+7' (&7'+(9 7& 91+(< J ,7+**

41, ?0371+( 7'17 40 4030 5&**&4+(9 1 :3&:'07L#87 8(203,71(2+(9 7'17 7'+(9, 4030 (&7 1, 7'0$

,00602<

E'0 1*6&,7 931##02 6$ ?&6:8703 &87 &5 6$

'1(2, 7& 3012< J 41, ?&6:+*+(9 1 *+,7 &5 4'171::01302 7& #0 5013 71?7+?, +( &3203 7& ?&(;+(?0

?3&42, (&7 7& d80,7+&( 7'0 8,0 &5 .:31$03 ?132,


74/142

TF

40 0\16+(02L 40 0(202 8: 2+,?302+7+(9 +7 1(2

*1#0*+(9 +7 ?&6:*070 5+?7+&(< U87 +( &83 6+(2,L 40,0:131702 7'0 .60,,190= 53&6 7'0 .5+?7+&(


75/142

TO

71#*0 8(7+* ,&60#&2$ :&+(7, +7 &87 1(2

06#1331,,0, 7'06<

Y0*+9+&8, 7312+7+&( +, 68?' 7'0 ,160 41$< M&,7:0&:*0 (0;03 ,7&: 7& ?&(,+203 *+, 7'0$

:137+?+:170 +( 1 ?0306&($ &3 0;0( #&4 7'0+3'012, 7& :31$ 5&3 1 601*< C'0$ _8,7 2& +7 c#0?18,0 7'17I, 7'0 41$ +7I, 1*41$, #00( 2&(0<

Q;03 7+60L 1(2 7'3&89' 7312+7+&(L 7'0 301*

601(+(9 #0'+(2 1($ 7312+7+&( +, *&,7L 1(2 +7#0?&60, ,&607'+(9 $&8 -"!( 2& +(,7012 &5

,&607'+(9 2&(0 5&3 30606#31(?0 &5 1 93017030;0(7< J7 +,(I7 8(7+* ,&60&(0 ?&60, 1*&(9 1(2

61R0, 7'06 500* 306&3,0 7'17 ?'1(90, 130 6120<

Q83 5+3,7 )'3+,761, :3&9316L 5+**02 4+7' 6&,7*$

.U3+20L= 41, 1 ,8220( 301*+]17+&( 7'17 40 '12#0?&60 23&(0, 0(,*1;02 7& 7312+7+&(< U87 (&77312+7+&( 7& 7'0 Y01,&( 5&3 7'0 '&*+21$ 1, ,&60

6+9'7 0\:0?7 c 40 4030 0(,*1;02 7& 1 2+55030(7R+(2 &5 7312+7+&(< B(2 40 4030 161]02 7'17 40

'12 (0;03 (&7+?02 +7 #05&30<

C'0 )'3+,761, :3&9316 '12 7'0 &874132

1::0131(?0 &5 ?0*0#317+(9 7'0 #+37' &5 %0,8,)'3+,7< )3&,,0, 1(2 ,713, 9*+770302 +( 7'0 ?'83?'

#8+*2+(9 7'17 40 '12 30(702 53&6 1(&7'03 :1,7&3<

B(&7'03 :1,7&3 *012+(9 :0&:*0 4'& 2+2 (&7#0*+0;0 7'0 N3&:'07 c 4'+?' 601(7 7'17 7& 7'0

.U3+20L= 7'+, 90(03&8, :1,7&3 1(2 '+,

?&(930917+&( 4030 0703(1**$ 216(02< C'0 ,R+7,4030 1** ,7&3+0, &(0 6+9'7 0\:0?7 17 )'3+,761,

7+60 c (17+;+7$ ,?0(0,L ?'+*230( +( :1_161, ,1$+(97'0+3 :31$03, &( )'3+,761, ^;0L )'3+,761, ?13&*,

1(2 6&30< B($ 4'& :1,,02 #$L 71R+(9 1 d8+?R


76/142

TK

9*1(?0L 4&8*2 30?0+;0 1 '01374136+(9 ;+04 17 1

N0(70?&,71*>,7$*0 :0&:*0 ?0*0#317+(9 7'0 A&8(203&5 7'0+3 30*+9+&(< B(2 7'0$ 4030L #87 (&7 7'0

5&8(203 7'17 1 ?18,1* 9*1(?0 4&8*2 30;01*<

J7 41, (&7 1::130(7 8(7+* 7'0 ,?0(0 ?'1(902 7& 1?'+*2I, #023&&6< )'+*230( +( :1_161,L R(00*+(91(2 :877+(9 7'0+3 '1(2, 7&907'03 +( :31$03 &;03 1

74+(>,+]02 #02< )132#&132 41**, 4+7' ,&57 7&(0

?&*&3, 1(2 1 4'+70 4+(2&4< C'0 ,?0(0 &5 1'86#*0 '&60L 1 51+7'58* ?'+*2L :31$+(9 7& 7'0

Z&32 +( '01;0( &( 7'0 (+9'7 #05&30 )'3+,761,<

C'0 :31$03 41, (&7 1 4+,'58* :31$03L 7'0 ?'+*2

#099+(9 V&2 5&3 7'0+3 51;&3+70 7&$< J7 41, (&7 1)'3+,761, :31$03L 5&?8,+(9 &( 7'1(R58*(0,, +(

7'0+3 *+77*0 '0137, 5&3 %0,8, )'3+,7 c 1*7'&89')'3+,7 41, 60(7+&(02 1(2 7'0 A17'03 41,7'1(R02 5&3 ,0(2+(9 '+, E&(< .C'1(R $&8L %0,8,L

5&3 ,0(2+(9 &83 N3&:'07L /+**+16 U31('16L 7&7'+, 0137' 7& ,'&4 8, 7'0 41$

R(+7702 :&7'&*203 5&3 7'0 6&7'03L 7'0,0 ?'+*230(4030 &;03_&$02 17 9+;+(9 ?1,,0770 71:0, 1(2 )H,

&5 .&83 N3&:'07L /+**+16 U31('16


77/142

TT

60(7+&(02< E8220(*$ 1, 7'0 (86#03, ,713702

,71?R+(9 8:L J 5&8(2 6$,0*5 ,713+(9 +( ?&6:*0702+,#0*+05< /0 4030 ,+77+(9 +( 1 .U31('61,=

'&*+21$L (&7 1 .)'3+,761,= &(0< ^;03$ ,+(9*07'3012 &5 7'0 ,8#_0?7 617703 :&+(702 &(0

2+30?7+&([ 7& 7'0 .N3&:'07= 5&3 &83 21$< E&606+9'7 13980 7'17 7'0$ :&+(702 74& 2+30?7+&(,L 7'0N3&:'07 &( &(0 0(2L 1(2 '+, $&8(90,7 ,&( &( 7'0

&7'03< JI6 (&7 ,& ?0371+( 7'17 7'0$ 4&8*2 #0

+(?&330?7<

J7 306+(202 60 &5 7'0 ^1,703 ?0*0#317+&( 7'1741, &3?'0,731702 #$ 7'0 &391(+]17+&( 1 504 $013,

:3+&3< /'+*0 7'0 30,7 &5 7'0 )'3+,7+1( 4&3*2 41,

?0*0#317+(9 7'0 21$ &5 7'0 Y0,8330?7+&(L 7'0.U3+20= 41, ?0*0#317+(9 7'0 *+50 1(2 7+60, &5 7'0

N3&:'07< B( 1#1(2&(02 20:13760(7 ,7&30 41,30(702 5&3 7'0 400R0(2L 1(2 5+**02 4+7' #&&7',?&(71+(+(9 606&31#+*+1L 1**&4+(9 ;+,+7&3, 53&6

1** :137, &5 7'0 4&3*2 7& 91+( 6&30 06&7+&(1*?&((0?7+&( 7& 7'0 N3&:'07< B7 7'0 68*7+>6+**+&(>

2&**13 '012d813703,L $&8(9 1?7&3, 5+**02 7'0 ,7190

4+7' ,'&37 ,R+7, #3+(9+(9 7'0 N3&:'07I, ,7&3$ l&317 *01,7 7'0 ,7&3$ 40 #0*+0;02m 7& *+50 7'3&89' 7'0

'1(2, &5 1 :*1$43+9'7I, ,?3+:7<

U$ 7'0 7+60 40 ;+,+702 516+*$L 40 4030

7'&3&89'*$ 2+,98,702 4+7' 4'17 &83 *+;0, '12#0?&60< /'+*0 ?&(206(+(9 7'0 4&3*2 13&8(2 8,

5&3 *+;+(9 +( 4'17 40 ?*1+602 7& #0 .+2&*173$L= 40

4030 13981#*$ 7'0 4&3,7 16&(9 7'06< /0 2+2,:0(2 )'3+,761, 4+7' 516+*$L 1(2 40 4030

,8??0,,58* +( 2&+(9 ,& 8(203?&;03< U87 +( 6$'0137L J R(04 7'17 7'+, ?&8*2 ;03$ 40** #0 7'0 *1,7L

1(2 7'+(9, 4&8*2 (0;03 #0 7'0 ,160


78/142

TG

+)* /)200-0;


79/142

TW

C'030 41, 1 :'31,0 6$ 931(2517'03 d8&702 +(

7'0 ?'83?' 40 1770(202L &(0 :8**02 53&6,?3+:7830 7& 20,?3+#0 7'&,0 7'17 '12 *057 7'0

5&**&4+(9 +( 7'0 21$, 9&(0 #$< .C'0$ 40(7 &8753&6 16&(9 8, #0?18,0 7'0$ 4030 (&7 &5 8,*&;02 516+*$ 7'17 '12*057 7'0 5&*2< .C'17 4&3R, #&7' 41$,L $&8 R(&4L=

'0 ,1+2<

J7 (0;03 301**$ ,8(R +( 17 7'0 7+60L _8,7 '&4 200:

7'17 ,+6:*0 ,717060(7 41,< C'030 130 1*41$,74& ,+20, 7& 1($ 139860(7L 1(2 _8,7 #0?18,0 $&8

'1;0 7'0 :&:8*13 ;&70 2&0, (&7 (0?0,,13+*$ 601(7'17 $&83 ,+20 &5 7'0 139860(7 +, ?&330?7< E&60:0&:*0 *057 #0?18,0 9&&2 ?&(,?+0(?0 4&8*2 (&7

1**&4 7'06 7& ,71$< U87 :&:8*13 ;&70 41, (&730*0;1(7 7& 7'+, ,+7817+&(< J( 51?7L +7 41, :3+613+*$

7'0 ?18,0< C'030 4030 61($ d80,7+&(, 1#&87 7'0

41$ +( 4'+?' ?'83?' 0*0?7+&( 41, '1(2*02 7'17$013L 1(2 7'0 1(,403, 9+;0( &(*$ 31+,02 6&30

d80,7+&(,< C'0 ?'83?' 41, +( ?&6:*0702+,1930060(7 &( 4'07'03 6$ 931(2517'03 ,'&8*2

?&(7+(80 1, '012 :1,7&3L &3 4'07'03 7'0

N3&:'07I, $&8(90,7 ,&( ,'&8*2 #0 7'0 &(0 7& *0127'0 :0&:*0< C'&,0 +( 51;&3 &5 6$ 931(2517'03

193002 4+7' 7'0 ,+7817+&(L 1(2 7'&,0 4'& 41(702

7& :8,' '+6 &87 ,713702 31+,+(9 ,0;031*_0?7+&(,<

U87 17 7'+, :&+(7 +( 7+60L 1(2 '1;+(9 ?&(,?+&8,*$

20?+202 8:&( ,013?'+(9 5&3 1 (04 ?'83?'L 7'0


80/142

GX

20#170 &( 0*0?7+&( &5 0*203, 41, (&7 30*0;1(7 7&

6$ 516+*$ 1(2 6$,0*5< J7 '1, #00( ,0;031*6&(7',g&;03 1 $013g,+(?0 JI2 1770(202

931(2517'03I, ?'83?'< J 41, 6&30 ?&(?03(02 4+7'7'0 d80,7+&(, J '12 8(?&;0302 1#&87 7'0 N3&:'07

7'1( 7'0 d80,7+&(, 1#&87 7'0 #301R2&4( +(:3&?0,, &5 0*0?7+&( 1(2 4'& ,'&8*2 &3 ,'&8*2 (&7#0 7'0 706:*0I, '+9' :3+0,7<

C'&,0 d80,7+&(, 4&8*2 (&7 30,7< C'0$ 4030?&(7+(81**$ &( 6$ 6+(2 1, 7'0 21$, :3&930,,02<

U$ 7'0 5+3,7 &5 7'0 $013L J 41, '132*$ 1#*0 7& 7'+(R1#&87 1($7'+(9 0*,0< U&3( 1(2 31+,02 +( 7'0

30*+9+&( ,+(?0 #+37'L +7 41, +(70931702 ;03$ 200:*$

+(7& 0;03$ 1,:0?7 &5 6$ *+50< Y06&;+(9 1($ :137&5 +7 41, 1 306&;1* &5 7'0 0,,0(?0 &5 6$ #0+(9< J7

4&8*2 #0 01,+03 7& 9+;0 8: 1( 136 &3 1 *09 7'1( 7&5+(2 518*7 4+7' 7'0 N3&:'07<

B(2 7'0 d80,7+&(, ,00602 ?&6:*+?1702< C'03041, :*0(7$ 7& ?&(,+203L 1(2 J 41, +( (& ?&(2+7+&(

7& 0\16+(0 7'06< C'0 d80,7+&(, 68,7 '1;0

1(,403,` :1,7&3, '12 ,782+02 7'0 M0,,190 5&3&;03 5+57$ $013,e E830*$ 7'0$ 68,7 '1;0 #00(

14130 &5 7'06e

J 5&8(2 6$,0*5 43+7+(9 7'06 2&4( 7& '0*: 60

,782$< E73899*+(9 4+7' ,'&37>7036 606&3$ 53&67'0 +**(0,,L 71R+(9 (&70, 41, 7'0 &

I Survived a Cult

Documents

Transcript of I Survived a Cult