HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
-
Upload
advaitmalvankar -
Category
Documents
-
view
221 -
download
1
Transcript of HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
1/34
HP+COMPAQIn search of scope and scale
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
2/34
P RESENTED BY
Sumit kanade 09-731 Advait Malvankar 09-739 Aditya Khandale 09-730
Swapneel Khavare 09-732
2
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
3/34
H I STOR IC EVENT
A merger as big and bold as H ewlett-Packards $25 billion acquisition of C ompaq C omputer in2002 had never taken place before in TechnologyIndustry.
C arly Fiorina , H Ps C EO, believed it was theright move for H P
The leading technology company in the world
3
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
4/34
H P
William (Bill) H ewlett and David (Dave) Packardoriginated a company in a garage in nearby Palo
Alto,california
1939, Packard and H ewlett established H ewlett-Packard ( H P) in Packard's garage with an initialcapital investment of US$538.Kickstarted the silicon valleys progress
4
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
5/34
P REMERGER POS I T I ON OF H P-2000
Ranked 13 th in fortune 500Turnover US $48.8 bn85500 employeesC arly fiorina: C hairman (September 22)2nd largest computer manufacturerleader in Desktop computers, Servers, Peripherals &services.I nternet infrastructure,high-end Super dome serverline in September.
5
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
6/34
H P-2001
March: a new business unit, H P Services,reporting directly to the C EOMay: systems and services based on the new
I tanium processor jointly developed by H P andI ntel.I ndustry stumbled, meeting growth targetsbecame difficult.
6
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
7/34
H P-P RODU C T PORTFOL I O
Laptops/NotebooksPalmtops/PDA Printers & printing consumables
DigicamsScannersMonitersMainframes
7
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
8/34
C OMPAQ
Joseph R. C anion,Jim H arris & Bill Murto inFeb 1982I nitial investment $1.5mn.
Manufactured & sold I BM compatible computers
8
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
9/34
C OMPAQ -PRODU C T PORTFOL I O
Enterprise computing groupMainframes servers workstationsI nternet products networking productsC ommercial desktopsPortablesSmall and medium business solutions
9
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
10/34
H URDLES FOR H P
Overall industry struggling Adapting to the innovationsC ompetition in printingI PG business not gaining tractionShrinking margins
10
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
11/34
W H Y MERGE ??
Eliminate one player in an oversupplied P C MarketTo compete with I BM and other companiesReduce C osts.
1990s I T recessionary phase.Merger expected to yield savings projected to reach $2.5bnannually by 2004.
Advantage of more volume of sales.
Development of direct distribution capability.Strengthen sales force .I mprove customer base
11
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
12/34
W H Y C OMPAQ ??
No 2 in the P C business and stronger on thecommercial side than H P. H P was stronger ontheconsumer side. Together they would be No 1 inmarket share in 2001 .C ompaq was strong in low-end industry standard(I ntel) servers.Best known for its P C s, also had enterprisebusinesses that it had built up through earlieracquisitions of its own.
12
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
13/34
E XPE C TED RESULTS
Superior customer valueGenerate cost synergies reaching approximately$2.5 bn annually.
Adds up to world-class innovation and quality.Larger P C position resulting from the mergerlikely to increase risk and dilute shareholdersinterest
13
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
14/34
C ONT I NUED ..
Assets of $56.4 billionannual revenues of $87.4 billionannual operating earnings of $3.9 billion
operations in 162 countries and 145000employeesI mproves access to the market with C ompaqsdirect capability and low cost structure .
Work force reduction by around 15,000 employeessaving around $1.5 billion per year .
14
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
15/34
ROLE OF F I OR I NA I N MERGER
I nitiative taken for the merger.More expectations from the merger.
Relied on institutional shareholders vote infavour of deal.
I nspite of oppositions, went ahead with themerger.
15
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
16/34
P ROBLEM DUR I NG TH E DEAL
Opposition-Walter H ewlett-The largest shareholder The David & LucilePackard Foundation(10.4%)-Employees
Negative Reaction of Stock Market- Pair lost US$ 13bn in market cap- I n contrast,stock prices of their competitorsincreased. 16
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
17/34
TERMS AND C OND I T I ONS
H P will retain its nameFiorina will be the C EO and C hairmanC apellas then C EO C ompaq will be the president
0.6325 of an H P share per C ompaq shareDeal size Approx. $25 billionH P shareholders 64%; C ompaq shareholders 36%
17
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
18/34
K EY HI GH L I GH TS
H orizontal merger.
Merger initiated on Sept 2001, completed on May
2002(8 month process).
Biggest merger in I T history.
$25bn all stock purchase.
1mn working hours spent on merge.
H PQ is the new stock symbol for the new H P18
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
19/34
C R I T ICI SM
Strategic blunder.
Dumbest deal of the decade Michael Dell
One bad P C business merged with another bad
P C business does not make a good P C company
This is not a case of 1 + 1 = 3. More
like 1+1=1.5
19
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
20/34
W ALTER H E W LETT
1. Resulting Business Portfolio is worse than theexisting H P Portfolio
2. Acquisition will not solve H Ps strategic
problems
3. I ntegration risk is substantial
4. Financial impact on H P shareholders isunattractive
20
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
21/34
F I OR I NAS REPLY
1. I nformation technology industry continues toundergo rapid change an H P must continue toaddress challenges of new environment
2. C ompaq merger is unique compelling strategicalternative no other option offers suchcomprehensive benefits and opportunities
3. C ombination addresses industry dynamics andcustomer requirements, creates strongercompany and is financially compelling
4. Management is experienced and focused onexecution, and integration planning is ahead of schedule. 21
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
22/34
C ULTURAL D I FFEREN C ES
H P saw itself, and the
evidence supportedthat view, as a cultureof consideration,thoughtfulness, andplanning a more
careful culture.
C ompaq saw itself,
more as a culture of ready, shoot ,aim- much quicker to act- debated less
- considered lessbefore took action
HP Comapaq
22
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
23/34
A LLEGED ROLE OF DEUTS CH E BANK
Proxy warMerger was approved with narrow marginsI t was disclosed H P had ties with Deutsche
banks investment banking branchH P agreed to pay $1 mn and another 1 mn ascontingencyUS SE C charged Deutsche bank with failing to
disclose material conflict of interestDeutsche bank was imposed $ 750000 penaltyDeutsche bank consented without admitting ordenying the findings 23
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
24/34
I NTEGRAT I ON
New leadership
24
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
25/34
Product mapintegration details
Financials
PR
Integration TasksCustomer strategy
Retention
Battling egos
Goals aligned
Governance decisions
Extended uncertainty
Employee Communication
Selection
Stay Separation(Transitions)
How do people act?New HP people & businessleadership principles
25
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
26/34
FY 2002-03I mproved position in every category in which they
compete.Became a leader in customer support services.Leader in I PG, through commitment to innovation inproduct design, manufacturing and business models.Being a technology company, the introduction of theword invent in their logo.I n the last 6 mths of fiscal 2002, introduced morethan 100 products & 1400 patents to their portfolioyr 2002 solid balance sheet with more than $11 bn incash & short term investments.
The acquisition of C ompaqs commercial pc &consumer pc business allowed improvement in theirposition in this category.Reduced their workforce through combination of layoffs, early retirements & attrition
26
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
27/34
S YNERGY
C ost leadershipRaw material costs reduced by 3-4%Strong growth
Merging technology bases Adoption of direct selling approach of C ompaqDownsizing
27
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
28/34
O VER C OM I NG T H E FA I LURE ..
Fiorina resigned 2005.
New C EO: Mark H urd
Where Fiorina failed and where H urd excels :
Educating H P managers and employees.
Exploiting the possibilities of the mergerTook initiatives to cut down costs, lay off employees
Understanding the market properly and aligning H Ps
corporate strategy to reality.
C reating a performance oriented culture to pursue commongoals shared throughout the organization
Fiorina wanted to imitate I BM services, which was service
focussed and H P was product focussed. 28
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
29/34
S ALES AND EXPENSES
29
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
30/34
S ELL I NG AND GEN EXPENSE RAT I O
30
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
31/34
PROF I TS V /S DELL C OMPUTERS
31
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
32/34
EPS
32
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
33/34
C ON C LUS I ON
The merger suffered from autocratic leadershipand initial financial stressSuccessful integration is the key
Operational integration and strategic integrationboth should take place simultaneouslyOver the time the synergy strategy gives fruitfulresults
The benefits of economies of scale and scope canbe exploited in I T industry .
33
-
8/8/2019 HPQ - HP and Compaq merger
34/34
Thank You
34