How Markets Work BY ISRAEL M. KIRZNER كيف يعمل اقتصاد السوق؟ اللاتوازن...

7/27/2019 How Markets Work BY ISRAEL M. KIRZNER

1/109


2/109

www.minbaralhurriyya.org

All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by

any means without the prior permission of Minbaralhurriyya Team.


3/109

www.arab-csr.org

All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by

any means without the prior permission of Arab Center for Scientific Research

and Humane Studies Team.


4/109

1

How Markets Work

Israel M. Kirzner

:


5/109

2

)Colin Robinson(

)IEA(

)University of Surrey(

.

" " ""

""

.

.

)(

:


6/109

3

1

.2

.

.3

)

(

""

:

.

.

1 : )1.(

) (

)1()References].([2 )Pareto optimality(

.3 : :)2.(


7/109

4

.

. ""

.

.

)) :

" "

"."

.

.


8/109

5

" "

"" .

.

" " "" .

)

.(

.

"

" .

)IEA( )

( ..


9/109

6

.1997


10/109

7

)Israel M. Kirzner(

)

.(

1957 1968

. :

)1960()1(.4

)1973()2(.

)1992()3(.

..

)1997()4(.

:

)1980()5(.

4 ) (

)1()

Kirzner's Published Works].([


11/109

8

.

""

.

: .

) (

.

"":

:

.

:

) (


12/109

9

.

) (

.

)(

.

""

:.

.


13/109

10

.

.

)(

.

.


14/109

11

.

.

.

.

.

.

.


15/109

12

.


16/109

13

.

)(

"."5

)

(

)

5 ""

.


17/109

14

.(

.

""

.

.

.

""

)Simultaneous Equation(

""


18/109

15

.

.

)Hans Mayer( 6 1932)

( .7

6 :)3.(7 :)4(214.

30 1932.


19/109

16

)Lionel Robbins(

)(

.

( ]1932[(8

)

( )

(

.

) (

.

8 : )5.(


20/109

17

-

1920

.

)Oskar

Lange( )Abba P. Lerner(9

""

) (

).(

.

9 :)6.(

:)7.(

).:)8


21/109

18

) (

)

(10

1948) (

.

"

"11

"

".12

"

10 1949 1949

1996.11 :)9(325-326.12 .335


22/109

19

"13 ) (

."

"14

) (

.

) (

13 .25314 .253


23/109

20

" :

:

15".

: :

"

."16

"

15 :)10(42.16 .45


24/109

21

."17

.

..

.

"."

17.


25/109

22

""

) ( .

18

.

.

.

)(

.

18: :)11(

.


26/109

23

.


27/109

24

.

:19

)

.(

)( .

19

.

) (

.

) (

" " "" )

.(


28/109

25

: .

) :(

)(

)(

.)(

:

.

.

: )(

)(

.


29/109

26

" "20

.

(( )(

.

(

.(

.

.

)

20 :)10(45.


30/109

27

( )(

)( .

.

.

) (

)

.(

)(

)(

.

) (

.


31/109

28

.

)(

(

(

.21

)(

.22

) ( :

21 : :)12.(22 )

()13( .


32/109

29

.

) :(

)(

.

.

.

.

)(


33/109

30

.23

)(

:) ( )( .

.)(

.

23

) .. ()14.(


34/109

31

24

)

(

.

)(

.

.

.

.

24 ) Radical Uncertainty( ) (

) ).Insurable Risk

: : )15( .


35/109

32

)

.(

)Frank Knight(

.25

)(

)(

.

Edward Chamberlin( (

) ( 26

) (

.

25 .3-6)16(:26: : )17.( 1933

1927.


36/109

33

.

.

1927.

) (

.

.

.


37/109

34

.

.27

.

.

27

: :

"".

.


38/109

35

.

.

""

. .

.

.

.


39/109

36

.

.


40/109

37

.

.

.

: /

.

.

..

)

).


41/109

38

""

"".

.

) .(

)(

)

.(

(

( " "

.


42/109

39

.

:

: .

"

"28

" " .

.

) ( )(

) (

. ""

28 :)9(253.


43/109

40

. "

"

.

""

"."

) (

""

)(

( .(

.

.

)(

)(

.


44/109

41

:

.

) (

: ) (

.

:

)(

.

.

" "

)(

" "


45/109

42

.

") "( )

(

) .(

.

)(

)

.(

.

) (


46/109

43

29 :

.

.""

.

)(!

.

:

)

(

)

29 "" ""

.


47/109

44

(

.

)(

.

)

(

) (:

) (

) .(


48/109

45

.

)Jevons's Law of Indifference(

.

.

.

)(

.

.


49/109

46

:

.

)(

.

.

.


50/109

47

.

)(

)

)

: )(

)(

.

) (

)( ""

( (

)

( )(

. ""


51/109

48

.

:

)(

.

)(

.

..

) ( :

)

(

.

)(

)(

)

.(""

.


52/109

49

: .

""

.

:

)( :

.

"" . )

(

.


53/109

50

.

/

" " "."

" " )

( )

.(

""


54/109

51

)

(

.

"" " "

.

.

.

.

" :


55/109

52

30".

"" )

.(

) (

.

.

""

)(

30 :)18(109.


56/109

53

)

(

.

.

.

.

.


57/109

54

.

:

300)

(

) .(

300

.

)

( .

.


58/109

55

)( .

)(

)(

.

)(

.

:

)

( )

( .

)

(

. )(

)


59/109

56

.(

.

) (

)

)

.


60/109

57

.

)

(

.

.

) (

.

.


61/109

58

) : (

.

:

):

(

.

) (


62/109

59

.

)(

.

.

.

)

(


63/109

60

.

:

.

)(

)(

.31

)(

)( .

.

32

:

31:

.:)19.(

. :)20.( 29

1968.32: :)21.(


64/109

61

) ( )

(

.

33

34 .

)( : )(

33 : :)9(354-374.34

.

.


65/109

62

.

.

)(

""

.


66/109

63

.

) (

.

.

.

.

""

.


67/109

64

) (

:

.

.

.

.


68/109

65

):

(

.

.

35

.

"

"

.

"" )(

""

.

35: ..:)22(139 .


69/109

66

.

:" "

.


70/109

67

.

.

.

""

.

.

.


71/109

68

.

)

(

)

(

:

.

36.

36 :

.)23(11

)24(18.

)25(14.


72/109

69

.

.

) (

. "

"

.

.

.


73/109

70

:

.

" " :

" "

""37

.

:

.

37 ""

" " .: )21.(


74/109

71

:

1.

)

.(

2.

) (

)

.(

.

)(

) .(


75/109

72

. ( ...(

)

( .

)

(

.

"" .


76/109

73

.

) (

""

.

.

)(

) (38

.

38 :

:)26(81 .


77/109

74

:

.

""

:

.

" "

.

.


78/109

75

) (

""

.39

.

.

)

(

.

39

.


79/109

76

.

.

.

.

)( .

/( (

.


80/109

77

.

.

.

) (

.

:

.

)

( ):(

.

) .(

)(

.


81/109

78

"" )

(

.

.

""

) (

:

.

:

)(.


82/109

79

.

.

40

.

.

40:

:)27.(

..:)) (28.(


83/109

80

.

" "

""

:""

.

) (

) ( )

(

.

""

):

)

" "

.

) (


84/109

81

.

.

)(

)Lionel Robbins( :

.41

42

41 : )5( .42 :)10(77.


85/109

82

.

)(

) (

)( .

.

.

.

.


86/109

83

" "

.

)

(

.

) (

.

) :(

)(

)

.(


87/109

84

) (

)(

.

)

(

) (

.

/

: .


88/109

85

.

""

.

)(

""

)(

)(

.

"" ) (

.

""

.


89/109

86

.

)Abba P. Lerner" :(

."

.43

192044

43 :

.. : )29.(44 ) ) (30.(

: .. :)31(.


90/109

87

:

):

.(

.

)Oskar Lange(

) (

.

45

""

45 :)32(55-129.


91/109

88

"" .

.

) 1935 46

(

.

.

.

46 ) ) )

.. ( ) (

)33.(


92/109

89

.

:

(

).

.

.


93/109

90

.

.

.

) (

:

.


94/109

91

.

) .(

) (

/ )(

.

)(

( (

) "" (

)

(

.


95/109


96/109

93

.47

.

)(

. )

( )

(

)

.(

) ( .

") " ()

(

) (

)(

.

47

.


97/109

94

.

) (

(

(

.

" "

))

)( ).(

.

""

"": .

)" (" )(

.


98/109


99/109

96

.

.

:

.

""

.


100/109

97

.


101/109

98

:)1.(48

:)2.(

"":

)3.(

:)4.(

.. :)5.(

.. :

)6.(

..

: )7(.

..""

:)8.(

:)9.(

:)10.(

48 ) (

)1() Further

Reading].([


102/109

99

:)11.(

:)12.(

..:)13.(

.. :

)14.(


103/109

100

Bibliography

I. Kirzner's Published Works

1. The Economic Point of View (1960).2. Competition and Entrepreneurship (1973).3. The Meaning of the Market Process (1992).4. 'Entrepreneurial Discovery and the Competitive Market Process: An

Austrian Approach', Journal of Economic Literature, March 1997.

5. 'The Primacy of Entrepreneurial Discovery', to The Prime Mover ofProgress, IEA Readings No. 23 (1980).

II. Further Reading

1. Hayek, F. (1948): 'The Use of Knowledge in Society', AmericanEconomic Review, September 1945; reprinted in Hayek,

Individualism and Economic Order, London: Roudedge and Kegan

Paul.

2. Hayek, F. (1978): 'Competition as a Discovery Procedure', in Hayek,'New Studies in Philosophy, Politics, Economics and the History of

Ideas', Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

3. Ikeda, S. (1990): 'Market-Process Theory and "Dynamic" Theories ofthe Market', Southern Economic Journal, July.


104/109

101

4. Kirzner, I. M. (1973): 'Competition and Entrepreneurship', Chicago:University of Chicago Press.

5. Kirzner, I. M. (1985): 'The Perils of Regulation: A Market ProcessApproach', in Kirzner, 'Discovery and the Capitalist Process',

Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

6. Kirzner, I. M. (1997): 'Entrepreneurial Discovery and theCompetitive Market Process: An Austrian Approach', Journal of

Economic Literature, March.

7. Lavoie, D. (1985): 'Rivalry and Central Planning: The SocialistCalculation Debate Reconsidered', Cambridge: Cambridge

University Press.

8.

Littlechild, S. C. (1978/1986): 'The Fallacy of the Mixed Economy: AnAustrian Critique of Recent Economic Thinking and Policy', Hobart

Paper 80, Second Edition, London: The Institute of Economic Affairs.

9. Machovec, F. M. (1995): 'Perfect Competition and theTransformation of Economics', London and New York: Roudedge.

10.Mises, L. V. (1949): 'Human Action', New Haven: Yale UniversityPress.

11.Rizzo, M. J. (1979): 'Uncertainty, Subjectivity, and the EconomicAnalysis of Law', in Rizzo (ed.), 'Time, Uncertainty, and

Disequilibrium', Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.


105/109

102

12.Thomsen, E. F. (1992): 'Prices and Knowledge: A Market ProcessPerspective', London and New York: Roudedge.

13.Vaughn, K. I. (1994): 'Austrian Economics in America: The Migrationof a Tradition', Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

14.Vihanto, M. (1994): 'Introductory Essay: The Nature and MainContent of Austrian Economies', in Vihanto, 'Discovering a Good

Society through Evolution and Design, Studies in Austrian

Economics', Turku, Finland: Turku School of Economics.

III. References

1. R. G. Lipsey and K. Lancaster, 'The General Theory of Second Best',Review of Economic Studies, 24(1), October 1956, pp. 11-32.

2. Gordon Tullock, 'The Vote Motive', Hobart Paperback 9, London:Institute of Economic Affairs, 1976 (2nd Impn. 1978).

3. Hans Mayer, 'Der Erkenntniswert der Funktionellen Preistheorien', inMayer (ed.), Die Wirtschafttheorie der Gegenwart, Vienna, 1932,

Vol. 2, pp. 147-239b. Translated under the title 'The Cognitive Value

of Functional Theories of Price', in, I. Kirzner (ed.), 'Classics in

Austrian Economics', Vol. II: 'The Interwar Period', London: William

Pickering, 1994, pp. 55-168.

4. Ludwig von Mises, 'Epistemological Problems of Economics',translated by George Reisman, Princeton: Van Nostrand, 1960, p.


106/109

103

214. The passage is part of the translation of a paper delivered by

Mises on 30 September 1932.

5. Lionel Robbins, 'An Essay on the Nature and Significance ofEconomic Science', 2nd edition, London: Macmillan, 1935.

6. Oskar Lange, 'On the Economic Theory of Socialism, Parts I and II', inBenjamin M. Lippincott (ed.), 'On the Economic Theory of Socialism',

Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1938.

7. Abba P. Lerner, 'A Note on Socialist Economies', Review of EconomicStudies, 4 October 1936.

8. Abba P. Lerner, 'Statics and Dynamics in Socialist Economies',Economic Journal, June 1937.

9. Ludwig von Mises, 'Human Action', New Haven: Yale UniversityPress, 1949. Its German-language forerunner, 'Nationalokonomie',

was published in 1940. A revised edition of Human Action has been

published by Laissez Faire Books: New York 1996.

10.Friedrich A. Hayek, 'Individualism and Economic Order', London:Roudedge and Kegan Paul, 1949, p. 42.

11.M. Machovec, 'Perfect Competition and the Transformation ofEconomics', London and New York: Roudedge, 1995.


107/109

104

12.Franklin M. Fisher, 'Disequilibrium Foundations of EquilibriumEconomics', Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press,

1983, as a prime example of such recognition.

13.Milton Friedman, 'The Methodology of Positive Economies', in his'Essays in Positive Economics', Chicago: University of Chicago Press,

1953, pp. 3-43.

14.George Shackle, 'Epistemics and Economics: A Critique of EconomicDoctrines', Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1972.

15.Gerald P. O'Driscoll Jr. and Mario J. Rizzo, 'The Economics of Timeand Ignorance', Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1985, Chapter 5.

16.Frank H. Knight, 'Risk, Uncertainty and Profit', Boston and New York:Houghton Mifflin, 1921, chapters 3-6.

17.Edward H. Chamberlin, 'The Theory of Monopolistic Competition',7th edition, Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1956.

Chamberlin's book was first published in 1933, being based on his

1927 doctoral dissertation.

18.Ludwig von Mises, 'Profit and Loss', in his Planning for Freedom andOther Essays and Addresses, 2nd edition, South Holland, III.:

Libertarian Press, 1962, p. 109.

19.Friedrich A. Hayek, 'The Meaning of Competition', in hisIndividualism and Economic Order, op. cit., Chapter 5, pp. 92-106.


108/109

105

20.Friedrich A. Hayek, 'Competition as a Discovery Procedure', in his'New Studies in Philosophy, Politics, Economics and the History of

Ideas', Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1978, Chapter 12. (This

paper was first presented as a lecture on 29 March 1968.)

21.Israel M. Kirzner, 'Competition and Entrepreneurship', Chicago:University of Chicago Press, 1973.

22.Karen I. Vaughn, 'Austrian Economics in America: The Migration of aTradition', Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1994, pp. 139fF.

23.John K. Galbraith, 'The Affluent Society', Boston: Houghton Mifflin,1958, Chapter 11.

24.John K. Galbraith, 'The New Industrial State', Boston: HoughtonMifflin, 1967, Chapter 18.

25.John K. Galbraith, 'Economics and the Public Purpose', Boston:Houghton Mifflin, 1973, Chapter 14.

26.Henry C. Simons, 'Economic Policy for a Free Society', Chicago:University of Chicago Press, 1948, pp. 81ff.

27.Yale Brozen, 'Concentration, Mergers, and Public Policy', New Yorkand London: Macmillan, 1982.

28.Yale Brozen (ed.), 'The Competitive Economy', Selected Readings,Morristown, NJ: General Learning Press, 1975.


109/109

29.Donald C. Lavoie, 'Rivalry and Central Planning, The SocialistCalculation Debate Reconsidered', Cambridge: Cambridge

University Press, 1985.

30.Ludwig von Mises, 'Economic Calculation in the SocialistCommonwealth', in Friedrich A. Hayek (ed.), 'Collectivist Economic

Planning, Critical Studies of the Possibilities of Socialism', London:

Roudedge and Kegan Paul, 1935, pp. 87-130.

31.Ludwig von Mises, 'Socialism: An Economic and SociologicalAnalysis' (1922), translated by J. Kahane, London: Jonathan Cape,

1936, Chapter 6.

32.Oskar Lange, 'On the Economic Theory of Socialism', op, cit.,reprinted in Oskar Lange and Fred M. Taylor, 'On The Economic

Theory of Socialism', edited by B. E. Lippincott, University of

Minnesota Press, 1938, pp. 55-129.

33.Friedrich A. Hayek, 'The Nature and History of the Problem',published as the Introduction to F. A. Hayek (ed.), 'Collectivist

How Markets Work BY ISRAEL M. KIRZNER كيف يعمل اقتصاد السوق؟ اللاتوازن...

Documents

Transcript of How Markets Work BY ISRAEL M. KIRZNER كيف يعمل اقتصاد السوق؟ اللاتوازن...