haram or halal ? Greetings Christmas for a Muslim

Debate among Muslims who always appears at the end of the year, about may or may not congratulate Christmas. with this we only show what Ulama say about congratulated Christmas. it all depends on what we believe. ………Rais_MR3 (Jkt, 25 Dec ‘14)

Indonesian Council of Ulama not forbid Muslims congratulate christmas, http://www.tempo.co/read/news/2014/12

Din Syamsuddin,

chairman of the Indonesian Council of Ulama

I, Said Agil Siradj, say merry christmas to you we are Christians. hopefully we get God's blessings more glorious and prosperous Indonesia

Said Agil Siradj,

Chaiman of the Board Nadlatul Ulama ……

Chairman of the NU: Merry Christmas for Christians Kompas.com. Rabu, 24 Des. ‘14

… christmas congratulate not absolutely forbidden, muslimmedianes.com 21 Dec. ‘14

Habib Mundzir bin Fuad Al-Musawa Founder of the prophet assembly

Ulama who allow christmas congratulations must syahadat again Republika online, 23 Dec. ‘14

“Ulama who allow Muslims to say Merry Christmas to be the Syahadat anymore” .

KH Endang, the Coordinator of the Society of Jakarta

FPI, ban Christmas Not Mirror Hate Speech

CNNIndonesia.com 23 Dec. ‘14

…. it is Haram for Muslims to say Merry Christmas. Muslims congratulate Christmas could disrupt the deity belief (Aqeedah). ?? "In the dictionary mentioned, the notion that Christmas is to celebrate the birth of Jesus as God's children“ .

Muchsin Alatas, Chairman of the Islamic Defenders Front (FPI),

Felix siauw-Yusuf Mansur bans Christmas Greetings, Ulil Absar furious hidayatullah.com 16 dec. ‘14

For my friends, do not even recite a Merry Christmas. If passed him with a non-Muslim, give a smile, shake hands with the best and warm. If you want to say hello, say, 'Holiday, Bro?'. "Yusuf Mansur

“If you give congratulations to the other religious festivals it may, of course Prophet and Companions already pointed out first, “ Felix said through his accountfelixsiauw, Saturday (12/13/2014).

Ulil Absar, responded by twitter, “@Yusuf_Mansur no restrictions, both in the Qur'an and in the hadith, to say Merry Christmas, Ustadz. Just try to find “