Hans Böhringer - ESO
Transcript of Hans Böhringer - ESO
![Page 1: Hans Böhringer - ESO](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022013015/61d073aa0627bc22fd123feb/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Hans Böhringer ESO 4MOST workshop 7. 5. 2019
4MOST Survey for Euclid Galaxy Clusters
ESO 4MOST workshop 7. 5. 2019
1
Hans BöhringerUniversity Observatory München
On behalf of the Euclid Galaxy Cluster Working Group
Involving: Fabio Bellagamba, Andrea Biviano, Stefano Borgani, Florence Durret, Lauro Moscardini, Matteo Maturi, Mario Radovich,
Mauro Roncarelli, Piero Rosati
![Page 2: Hans Böhringer - ESO](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022013015/61d073aa0627bc22fd123feb/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Hans Böhringer ESO 4MOST workshop 7. 5. 2019 2
Euclid Survey Mission Mapping the Geometry of the Universe
Most important and most promising cosmology mission after Planck !
Nominal space mission: 5 yr sky survey: 15 000 deg2 (40 deg2 deep) - Optical (550 -900 nm) m < 24.5 (0.1 arcsec) Y, J, H m<24 (0.3 arcsec)- + NIR spectroscopy (1100 – 2000 nm)
Goal: probing dynamical Dark Energy, modified Gravity, nature of Dark Matter + lot of astronomical legacy science !!
Primary cosmological probes: Gravitational lensing & Galaxy Clustering
Important additional probe, galaxy clusters: number counts and spatial correlation as function of z (up to z = 2)
Euclid mission starting: 2022
![Page 3: Hans Böhringer - ESO](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022013015/61d073aa0627bc22fd123feb/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Hans Böhringer ESO 4MOST workshop 7. 5. 2019 3
Galaxy Clusters an Independent and Complementary Probe
Constraints for the parameters of dynamical dark Energy : w(a) = wp + (ap – a)wa
Euclid all Euclid all + Planck
Clusters are an important complement to the primary probes – in particular also for the determination of the neutrino masses (with Δmν ~ 0.02 eV) !
Euclid Red Book 2011
+ clusters
Figure of merit : 1/(Δwp x Δwa)
![Page 4: Hans Böhringer - ESO](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022013015/61d073aa0627bc22fd123feb/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Hans Böhringer ESO 4MOST workshop 7. 5. 2019 4
Euclid Cluster Detections
Euclid cluster detections (in 15 000 deg2):
200 000 clusters (S/N > 5)2 Million (S/N > 3) 80% compl.
Mass limit ~ 8 1013 Msun (S/&N > 3)
Euclid will provide WL shear maps à“unbiased” mass estimates for the clusters. (most important advance for cluster cosmology !)
mass limit
Sartoris et al. 2016
S/N > 5
S/N > 3
![Page 5: Hans Böhringer - ESO](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022013015/61d073aa0627bc22fd123feb/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Hans Böhringer ESO 4MOST workshop 7. 5. 2019 5
Why Spectroscopic Redshifts ?
From Euclid we will get spectroscopic redshifts for massive clusters (Hα for SF galaxies) with z > 0.8 from NIR spectroscopy.Important and less explored redshift range z = 0.4 to 0.8: mostly photometric redshifts. Having spectroscopy would add:
- precise distances (accurate physical properties, e.g. mass)
- velocity dispersions as additional mass proxy
- accurate positions for correlation analysis
- important information for galaxy evolution studies
- evaluation and calibration of the photometric cluster finder - à crucial to obtain proper cluster selection function, essential for
precise cosmological results
![Page 6: Hans Böhringer - ESO](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022013015/61d073aa0627bc22fd123feb/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Hans Böhringer ESO 4MOST workshop 7. 5. 2019 6
Two Step Approach of the Project
Follow-up of Euclid detected clusters is only possible in the second half of the survey.
A) Follow-up of the clusters detected in the KIDS/VIKING Survey with the officially selected Euclid Cluster Finders (AMICO & PZWav) in 1400 deg2
B) Follow-up of the clusters detected in the Euclid survey (~ 3000 deg2)
Mains Goals:
• Precise characterisation of the EUCLID cluster selection function
• Additional mass calibration
• Astrophysics of galaxy cluster evolution with an unprecedented data set
KIDS mag. limits u = 24.8 g = 25.4 r = 25.4 i = 24.2 VIKING z = 23.1 Y = 22.3 J = 22.1 H = 21.5 K = 21.2
![Page 7: Hans Böhringer - ESO](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022013015/61d073aa0627bc22fd123feb/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Hans Böhringer ESO 4MOST workshop 7. 5. 2019 7
Euclid Cluster finder AMICO applied to the KIDS survey
Maturi et al. 2019Bellagamba et al. 2018, 19
Adaptive Matched Identifier of Clustered Objects: MF(α, δ, mr, p(z)) à probab. for each gal.
Assignment probability is color coded
7988 clusters in 438 (used 377) deg2 of DR3 KIDS- 18 cluster per deg2
Weak lensing mass calibration
![Page 8: Hans Böhringer - ESO](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022013015/61d073aa0627bc22fd123feb/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Hans Böhringer ESO 4MOST workshop 7. 5. 2019 8
AMICO Cluster Detections
Maturi et al. 2019Bellagamba et al. 2019
Completeness and Purity of the cluster sample (purity of ~95% from mock simulations)
~ 1014 Msun clusters
redshift accuracy Δz/(1+z) ~ 0.02
![Page 9: Hans Böhringer - ESO](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022013015/61d073aa0627bc22fd123feb/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Hans Böhringer ESO 4MOST workshop 7. 5. 2019 9
4MOST Target Statistics for z = 0.5 – 0.6377 deg2 DR3-KIDS, mr < 22, probability limit = 0.2
spectroscopic targets cluster members
Almost all clusters with M200 > 1014 Msun have more than 10 member galaxy redshifts, the most massive clusters are dynamically very well characterised.Most important is the overall statistics: ~ 25 000 galaxy redshifts for about 1400 clusters à characterisation on the percent level.
![Page 10: Hans Böhringer - ESO](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022013015/61d073aa0627bc22fd123feb/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Hans Böhringer ESO 4MOST workshop 7. 5. 2019 10
4MOST Target Statistics for z = 0.7 – 0.8
Most clusters with M200 > 3 1014 Msun have more than 10 redshifts, most other clusters have more than 3 redshifts which allows statistical stacking. à reliable redshifts for clusters, some dynamical information from stacking
spectroscopic targets cluster members
![Page 11: Hans Böhringer - ESO](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022013015/61d073aa0627bc22fd123feb/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Hans Böhringer ESO 4MOST workshop 7. 5. 2019 11
Summary of the Target Statistics for the KIDS/VIKING and Euclid Follow-up
Extrapolated to full KIDS/VIKING follow-up:
~ 1.2 Million targets above z = 0.1
mr < 20 - 21 for z > 0.4 ~ 500 000 targetsmr < 22 for z > 0.4 ~ 500 000 targets
This includes:• additional targets detected by PZWav• exploration of ~ 4000 lower S/N cluster detections (@ z > 0.4)• exploration of the lower probability regime, 100 000 targets “à To better understand the sample and richness completeness
Extrapolation to Euclid Survey follow-up:
We hope to explore a region of up to 3000 deg2, thus we expect to have about twice as many targets
![Page 12: Hans Böhringer - ESO](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022013015/61d073aa0627bc22fd123feb/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Hans Böhringer ESO 4MOST workshop 7. 5. 2019 12
Fibre Allocation Feasibility
Studying target density in the clusters: 4MOST would allow us to target most of theselected galaxies (@ z > 0.4) in two 1 hr visits – apart from central cluster regions in the redshift range 0.4 – 0.6, where we would have a loss of 50 % in the worst case, if there is no other survey. To account for other surveys we assume pessimistically that we will obtain spectra only for 20 – 40% of our selection. This gives the following target statistics:
1400deg2 alltargets 20–40% memberspectra
total 1200k 240–480k 120–240k
z>0.4 500k 100–200k 50–100k
z<0.4 500k 100–200k 50–100k
extratargets 200k 40–80k 10–30k
z=0.5–0.6 150k 30–60k 15–30k
z=0.7–0.8 12k 2.4–4.8k 1.2–2.4k
![Page 13: Hans Böhringer - ESO](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022013015/61d073aa0627bc22fd123feb/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Hans Böhringer ESO 4MOST workshop 7. 5. 2019 13
Science Prospects
Statistical precision for main project goals [pessimistic (optimistic)]:
z = 0.5 – 0.6 z = 0-7 – 0.8selection function: - 3 bins of probability:: 1.5 (1) % 5 (3.5) % - 4 bins mag., 5 bins prob.: 3.7 (2.6) % 12 (9) %
mass calibration: 10 mass bins: 2.5 (1.8) % 9 (6) % 5 mass bins: 1.8 (1.3) % 6 (4.5) % overall < 1% 2.9 (2) %
cluster astrophysics 10 mass bins 3000 – 6000 galaxies 5 mass bins 240 – 480 galaxies
à Precision assessment at ~1 % level for z <= 0.6 and few % above. We can reach our mail goals !
With the Euclid follow-up these numbers will increase by factor 2
![Page 14: Hans Böhringer - ESO](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022013015/61d073aa0627bc22fd123feb/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Hans Böhringer ESO 4MOST workshop 7. 5. 2019 14
Synergy/Overlap with consortium surveys: eROSITA Clusters - Waves
eROSITA
eROSITA finds more groups and clusters at redshifts < 0.4 (40 000 groups and clusters down to 1013 Msun) , Euclid has many clusters at high redshift.
Waves is also targeting the KIDS/VIKING survey regions. Here the main interest is the evolution of structure (dark matter halos down to 1011 Msun,filaments and voids to redshift of z = 0.2 in WAVES wide).
0.9 Million galaxies Z >= 21.1 to photoz = 0.2
The study of galaxy clusters in the redshift range z = 0.4 to 0.8 with high precision (excellent statistics) is the special field for the 4MOST follow-up of Euclid and KIDS/VIKING.Thus there is a good synergy with the other two surveys!
eROSTA White Book
![Page 15: Hans Böhringer - ESO](https://reader031.fdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022013015/61d073aa0627bc22fd123feb/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Hans Böhringer ESO 4MOST workshop 7. 5. 2019 15
Conclusions
• We propose to make an important contribution to enhance the Euclid cosmology and cluster science results.
• There is an optimised survey strategy and clear goals to achieve this.
• The Euclid cluster selection function and cluster masses will be calibrated at the (few) percent level.
• There will be an unprecedented sample of galaxy spectra of cluster members to study cluster evolution in many aspects at z = 0.4 to 0.8
• The requirements are: <~ 500 000 galaxy spectra for Stage I (Test on KIDS/VIKING region) <~ 1 Mill. galaxy spectra for Stage II (Euclid follow-up)