Google Fiber Case Competition

42
1 Market Expansion Strategy John Koelliker, Nick Kerr, Jimmy Gillespie, David Mella, Lauren Morris

Transcript of Google Fiber Case Competition

Page 1: Google Fiber Case Competition

1

Market Expansion Strategy

John Koelliker, Nick Kerr, Jimmy Gillespie, David Mella, Lauren Morris

Page 2: Google Fiber Case Competition

2

DAVID MELLAEconomics

JOHN KOELLIKERInformation Systems

NICK KERR JIMMY GILLESPIEAccounting

LAUREN MORRISMarketingInformation Systems

• Intern with the

Google Community

Leaders Program

• Co-founder of Kore

Baseball Products

• Future Uber intern

• Experience with

small businesses

such as ōEvent and

Prodigix Software

• Knowledge of

networking and

routing technologies

• Experience with

technology startups

and venture capital

• Future intern at

Capital Group

Companies

• Nationally ranked

spikeball player

• Social media and

marketing intern at

a nonprofit

• Future intern at

Sorenson

Advertising

• Aspiring economist

• Experience with

technology startups

such as SHOUT

Gameplay & SEBO

Marketing

MEET OUR TEAM

Page 3: Google Fiber Case Competition

3AGENDA

12

34

5

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

CASE BACKGROUND

STRATEGY SUMMARY

GIGABIT CLUB

CONCLUSION

Small Business Strategy

Residential Strategy

Introducing the Gb Club

Strategy Overview

Problem Overview

Components of a Successful Solution

Execution

Page 4: Google Fiber Case Competition

4EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

THE PROBLEM OUR SOLUTION

KEY FACTORS OF THE PROBLEM - Google Fiber, despite a widely known and well-liked brand image, has had trouble converting Provo customers from the free version of Google Fiber to the paid, Gigabit-speed tiers. We’ve identified three main factors that contribute to this problem: (1) a lack of awareness of the different tiers that Google Fiber offers, (2) low rates of customers who have actually experienced Gigabit speeds and who would know what that means for them, and (3) a low perceived value of the product when compared to the price or competing options.

COMPONENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL SOLUTION - Any successful solution should directly address the three key factors mentioned above. In addition, a successful solution should also have the following qualities: (1) Delight the customer and go above and beyond their expectations; (2) Maintain the integrity of Google’s brand; (3) Scale to other communities and markets; and (4) Put the needs of the customer first. These components will ensure that Google Fiber not only increases its revenue in the short run, but also creates a sustainable business model that will continue to grow for years to come.

STRATEGY OVERVIEW - Our strategy is built on the foundation of resolving the three key factors of Google’s problem: low awareness, lack of experience, and insufficient perceived value. Our strategy will take a customized approach to two main market segments, which are small businesses and residential customers. Introducing: The Gigabit Club.

GIGABIT CLUB FOR SMALL BUSINESSES - The Gigabit Club seeks to provide enormous value for small businesses while simultaneously improving awareness of Google Fiber’s paid tiers. Small business will be provided with Gigabit internet speed and high-speed AC routers to provide an excellent experience to their clients who take advantage of their free wireless internet. Gigabit Club mentors will assist small business owners an getting the most out of their high-speed internet.

GIGABIT CLUB FOR RESIDENTS - The initiative to provide Gigabit speeds to popular small businesses will stimulate growth in the residential market. Residents, having tried the higher speeds, will want to bring that experience to their homes. The Gigabit Club for residents will include benefits that will encourage both customer adoption and customer retention.

Page 5: Google Fiber Case Competition

5

CASE BACKGROUND

Page 6: Google Fiber Case Competition

6

Google announces that it will pick a community to install a fiber optic network--making it the first “Gigabit Community.”

GIGABIT COMMUNITIES

The city of Provo and Google strike a deal. iProvo is purchased for $1 on one condition--that every resident in Provo have access to a free version of Google Fiber

PROVO - THE NEXT GIGABIT CITY

Google announces a small business package for Google Fiber; expansion announced in SLC.

SMALL BUSINESS PRODUCT LAUNCH

Provo residents get the opportunity to have a team install Google Fiber in their homes for a small installation fee.

SIGNUPS OPEN FOR PROVO RESIDENTS

BE THE BEST MARKETING COMPANY

A BRIEF HISTORY: GOOGLE FIBER AND PROVO

2010

2013

2014

2015

Mayor of Provo announces the arrival of Google Fiber.

Page 7: Google Fiber Case Competition

7

THEPROBLEM:

8/10 people have never experienced Gigabit

speeds for themselves, and have no idea what it would actually mean for them

Awareness

53% of people surveyed are unaware that a paid

option exists, or that their free tier offers only a limited sample of Google Fiber’s full potential

Experience

For the customer, the perceived cost of upgrading to Gigabit speeds are greater than the perceived value of the upgrade. On average, consumers are only willing

to pay $26 for Gigabit speeds as they understand

them.

Perceived Value

THE PROBLEM: KEY FACTORS

Many customers are satisfied with the limited bandwidth of the free

plan, and feel no need to upgrade to the higher-speed, paid plan

Page 8: Google Fiber Case Competition

8THE PROBLEM: AWARENESS AND EXPERIENCE

EXPERIENCE

Most customers have never experienced true Gigabit internet

speeds, and do not know what these speeds mean in the real world

Many customers who have experimented with Gigabit Google Fiber

may have experienced suboptimal speeds due to poor router

placement, old technology (e.g., not 802.11ac/n enabled), and other

factors

This suboptimal experience--or lack of any experience thereof--gives

many customers pause when deciding whether to switch to the paid

tiers of Google Fiber

Awareness

The first stage of customer adoption for any innovative product is

product awareness

Many customers in Provo are aware of the general existence of

Google Fiber, but may be unaware that there is a paid option that

offers up to 200x the speed of the free version

Google’s marketing tactics have been very conservative up to this

point; this has protected the brand image, but it may also contribute

to the lack of awareness some customers experience

Experience

Page 9: Google Fiber Case Competition

9THE PROBLEM: PERCEIVED VALUE

What influences customer

purchasing decisions

At the root of Google Fiber’s problem is the perceived value

of its product for consumers in Provo. Though Google Fiber

has a very positive and strong brand image, the possibility of

Gigabit speeds remains an abstract concept for many

consumers. This alone does not provide enough perceived

value to offset the $70- or $130-per-month cost.

Maximizing the value-add

Brand/Image

Cost

Product Value

Actual Value

Perceived Value

*This diagram shows the framework we used to brainstorm ideas and ultimately select our strategy.

We selected a strategy that addresses all areas of this framework, especially the weakest area--

perceived value.

Page 10: Google Fiber Case Competition

10

DELIGHT THE CUSTOMER - For Google Fiber’s long-term success, customers who make

the switch can’t be merely satisfied--they must be delighted. The solution must ensure that

each customer derives the maximum value from their purchase.

1

MAINTAIN BRAND INTEGRITY - Google has always had the intangible “Googliness” that

makes their brand so cool, so well-respected. Whatever the solution, it can’t compromise the

overall integrity of the Google brand.

2

HIGH SCALABILITY - Every location is unique in terms of market segmentation and

diversity; however, the best solution will work across all locations and across all markets.3

PUT THE USER FIRST - Along with delighting the customer with its product, Google must

ensure that its entire value package is in the customer’s best interest. A successful solution

will avoid any predatory or shady tactics used by “the other guys.”

4

Awareness

Experience

Perceived Value

Success:

COMPONENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL SOLUTION

In addition to resolving the key issues of low product awareness, lack of experience, and insufficient perceived value, a successful solution must also incorporate the following four Google priorities:

Page 11: Google Fiber Case Competition

11

STRATEGY SUMMARY

Page 12: Google Fiber Case Competition

12

SMALL BUSINESS RESIDENTIAL

VALUEAWARENESS EXPERIENCE

STRATEGY OVERVIEW

STRATEGY FOUNDATION - The overall goal of our strategy is to increase

customer awareness, enhance the perceived value of the product, and improve

the overall product experience. This is the foundation of our strategy.

1

SMALL BUSINESS - Small businesses will be crucial to the success of our

strategy, as they will create brand awareness while also providing an environment

for Provo residents to experience Gb speed internet.

2

RESIDENTIAL - As Provo residents become more aware of Gb speed internet

and are able to demo these faster speeds, they will be more likely to 3

GIGABIT CLUB - Our strategy of targeting small businesses and residents will

be accomplished through the Gigabit Club - an innovative, inclusive and impactful

way of experiencing Gb speed internet at an affordable price

4

Page 13: Google Fiber Case Competition

13THE GIGABIT CLUB

A marketing initiative to provide a sense of community for small businesses and residents that want to enjoy gigabit-speed internet and additional benefits.

Impactful.Creates a social wave that will benefit Google Fiber, small businesses, and consumers

Innovative.Provides high-speed internet and supports the growth of Fiberhoods

Inclusive.All residents and businesses in a Fiber city can participate and receive the full benefits

Page 14: Google Fiber Case Competition

14

Gb CLUB- SMALL BUSINESS

Page 15: Google Fiber Case Competition

15

Small Business

Gigabit Club Package &

Benefits

Competitive PriceFirst 50 companies to participate in the Gb Club Program and display Gb Club logo will pay $50 for the first 3 months

HardwareSmall Business will receive a high-speed AC Router upon signing up; router is included with year long membership in Gb Club

Gb Speed InternetSmall business will provide Gb speeds for their employees and for their customers

Gb Club MentorTo show the company how to get the most out of their Fiber experience (i.e. router placement, network configuration, etc.)

THE GIGABIT CLUB - SMALL BUSINESS OVERVIEW

Gb Club PrestigeSmall businesses that join the Gb Club will receive a sticker that can be displayed at their business to attract customers

$

Page 16: Google Fiber Case Competition

16

Google Fiber

Benefits

$

Brand AwarenessCompanies that join the Gb Club will display the Gb Club logo in their business that will spread the word about the Gb Club

Resident AdoptionAfter experiencing Gb speed internet in various local businesses, residents will want to adopt Gb internet at home

Provo Resident Gb Internet ExperienceResidents in Provo will now have an opportunity to experience Gb speed internet in various Provo businesses

Small Business AdoptionThe initial wave of Provo businesses adopting Gb speed internet will create a social movement that encourages other businesses to join the Gb Club as well

THE GIGABIT CLUB - GOOGLE FIBER BENEFITS

RevenueThe Gb Club will result in many Provo Businesses adopting the Business Package, driving revenue for Google Fiber

Page 17: Google Fiber Case Competition

17THE GIGABIT CLUB - SMALL BUSINESS RISKS

RISKS

1. Router PlacementBusinesses don’t place routers in optimal locations, so customers don’t experience fast, reliable internet

2. Brand AssociationGoogle’s brand will be associated with various local businesses that might reflect poorly on Google’s image

3. Mentor CompetenceAn inexperienced or incompetent Gb Club mentor would prevent customers from enjoying their Fiber experience

4. Product ExperienceMuch of the Gb speed experience and customer satisfaction/dismay will be affected by the business and how they offer the product to their customers

SOLUTIONS

1. Gb Club MentorEach business will have a Gb Club mentor that will ensure proper configuration and setup for their Gb speed internet

2. Gb Club Welcome Packet and MentorEach business will receive a welcome packet and mentor that help the business properly represent the Google brand

3. Mentor Supervisor and TrainingAs a part of the Gb Club Program, we recommend hiring a Gb Club mentor supervisor that can train and help mentors

4. Hardware and Gb Club PackageProper hardware will be provided for businesses to experience Gb speed, and the Gb Club Package will educate the businesses so they can better understand the product

Page 18: Google Fiber Case Competition

18

Gb CLUB- RESIDENTIAL

Page 19: Google Fiber Case Competition

19

Residential Gigabit Club

Package

Competitive PriceResidents will receive a discounted price of $20 per month for the first 3 months

Resident Referral ProgramResidents will receive one month free for each new friend brought signed up for the Gb club as a referral

Gb Speed Internet & HardwareResidents will have the option to receive a USB Wireless Card and AC Router (free after year paid/returnable if undamaged) in order to experience gigabit speed

Gb Club MentorTo show the resident how to get the most out of their Fiber experience (i.e. router placement, network configuration, TB storage, etc.)

THE GIGABIT CLUB - RESIDENTIAL PLAN

Google Play CreditResidents will receive enough credit to stream one movie per month while in the Gigabit Club

$

Page 20: Google Fiber Case Competition

20

Google Fiber

Benefits

$

Brand EnhancementResidents that join the Gb club will have a positive experience and will develop a stronger trust in the Google brand

Customer RetentionAfter experiencing Gb speed internet in ways that are significant (e.g. streaming movies), customers are likely to continue paying for the Gb club

Resident AdoptionThe discounted price coupled with Google Play Store credit will increase amount of residents willing to adopt

ReferralsWith the referral program, many new customers will be brought to Fiber

THE GIGABIT CLUB - GOOGLE FIBER BENEFITS

RevenueThe Gb Club will drive more traffic to the Google Play Store, which will create additional sales for Google

Page 21: Google Fiber Case Competition

21THE GIGABIT CLUB - RESIDENTIAL RISKS

EXPERIENCERISKS

1. Hiring MentorsAn undetermined cycle of demand for mentors could potentially create a problem for HR and recruiting

2. Mentor CompetenceAn inexperienced or incompetent Gb Club mentor would prevent customers from enjoying their Fiber experience

3. Trial PeriodCustomers might take advantage of the trial period by using its perks without any intention of remaining a customer after the trial is over

4. Product ExperienceIf the customer experiments with the trial period and does not notice any significant improvements, they might cancel

SOLUTIONS

1. Gb Club Mentor SupervisorA Gb Club Mentor Supervisor will be hired to manage Gb Club Mentor recruiting, hiring, training, and onboarding

2. Mentor Supervisor and TrainingAs a part of the Gb Club Program, we recommend hiring a Gb Club mentor supervisor that can train and help mentors

3. Strategic DiscountThe trial period will discount the monthly payment to $20/month for three months, which will be more than enough to cover the costs of a customer’s trial period

4. Gb Club Mentor and HardwareThe customer will receive a USB wireless card, an AC router, and a Gb Club Mentor to maximize their product experience

Page 22: Google Fiber Case Competition

22

EXECUTION

Page 23: Google Fiber Case Competition

23

• Weekly events around Provo

• Apartment complex events to create awareness

• Fiber Space demos• Door-to-door sales

• Small Businesses will be displaying the Google Fiber Gb Club Sticker at their business with QR Code that links to Gb Club link

• Residents of Provo will be able to experience Gb Speed internet for free in many Provo businesses

• Customer awareness calls to free Google Fiber subscribers to notify them of opportunity to experience Gb speed internet in many local businesses

• Residents that benefit from their membership in the Gb Club will be anxious to share their experiences with friends

• The Resident Referral Program that provides the Referrer with a free month of Gb Speed Internet for every friend that they get to join the Gb Club

DISTRIBUTION CHANNELS

Current Channels Small Business Gb Club Awareness Campaign Resident Referral Program

Page 24: Google Fiber Case Competition

24

2. LAUNCH 3. GROW 4. IMPROVE 5. ENJOY1. PREPARE

GIGABIT CLUB - IMPLEMENTATION TIMELINE

Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 5Year 4

• Finalize Gb Club details (i.e. mentor logistics, onboarding process, sticker design, etc.)

• Create list of target businesses that would be ideal candidates

• Use channels of distribution to increase customer awareness (e.g. billboards, commercials, in-store advertising)

• Finalize Gb Club details

• Begin to contact target businesses and offer discounted Gb Club

• Provide a mentor to businesses to help with router placement and network configuration

• Begin awareness campaign

• Initiate Resident Referral Program

• Provide mentors to all residents to ensure maximized use of gigabit speeds

• Provide continuous assistance to companies/ residents in the Gb Club

• Ensure that all participating Gb Club businesses display their Gb Club sticker at their business

• Continue to onboard companies/residents that are interested in joining the Gb Club

• Reflect on the first year of Gb Club and make plans for improvement

• Consider adding additional benefits for those involved with the Gb Club including referral discounts for businesses and other value-adds

• Prepare to launch the Gb Club in other Fiber cities

• Enjoy the benefits and prestige associated with the Gb Club

• Repeat the process in other Fiber cities and create a Gb Club internet experience that can be found across the country

Small Businesses

Residents

Page 25: Google Fiber Case Competition

25

Fixed Costs Cost per Resident Cost per Small Business

ESTIMATED COSTS OF STRATEGY

• Mentor supervisor

• Training materials

• 3 month trial

• AC Router & USB card

• Free movie streaming

• Cost of mentor visit

• Transportation of mentor

• Gigabit club info box

• 3 month discount

• High-speed AC router

• Info box, gigabit club cards and stickers

• Google mentor visit (more intensive)

• Transportation of mentor

$377.00in additional costs over 5 year period

$43,000per year over 5 year period

$407.00in additional costs over 5 year period

Page 26: Google Fiber Case Competition

26PROJECTED FINANCIAL BENEFITS

Additional Revenue - 5 Years

$5,713,752

Additional Profit - 5 Years

$4,564,448

Page 27: Google Fiber Case Competition

27

• Partnering with different companies to increase the actual value of Gb club membership

• Examples: Vidangel, WatchEspn, Hotels

• Areas such a local parks will have small Fiber hotspots where Gb club members can login and access gigabit speed internet

• Google will select a few home offices to “fiberize” make a collective video for use in commercials

• Improves Google image and connects with people

• Local citizens will be able to see on a map exactly which of their neighbors have faster and how much they pay per megabit

• Seattle example

Local Hotspots “Fiberizing” Homes City-Wide Speed TestsPartnerships

FUTURE IDEAS

Page 28: Google Fiber Case Competition

28SUMMARY WALKTHROUGH

Jake saw a billboard for the Google Fiber Gb Club and

then saw a sticker at Starbucks. He scanned the

QR code out of curiosity and learned more about the residential Gb Club plan.

Awareness

Having only ever used the free fiber plan, Jake decided to sign up for the discounted 3 months to see if the gigabit

speed would be worth it.

Adoption

Customer Care

Jake loved the speed of the free movie stream. He told his neighbor about the Gb club and received a free

month when the neighbor signed up as well.

Growth

Jake chose to include the new AC router and the

mentor showed him where to put it and how to get the

fastest speeds. The mentor also showed Jake how to upload all of his photos using the TB of storage.

Meet Jake

Page 29: Google Fiber Case Competition

29

THE GIGABIT CLUB

YOU’VE TRIED THE FREE VERSION,NOW COME JOIN THE CLUB.

Page 30: Google Fiber Case Competition

30

QUESTIONS

Page 31: Google Fiber Case Competition

31COST ASSUMPTIONS - RESIDENTS

Residential 3 month Discount $50.00 per month 3 months $150

Gigabit Box $8 1 $8

AC Router $80.00 1 $80.00

USB card $20.00 1 $20.00

Stream Movies*** $1.00 per movie 30 $30.00

Gas per visit** $0.50 1 visit $0.50

Cost per visit* $18.67 1 visit $18.67

Cost per resident $307

*Google Mentors get paid 14$ per hour and make 6 visits per 8 hours worked.

** Google Mentors drive 100 miles per week with 20 MPG and $2.00 gas prices

*** Customers stream free movies 6 out of 12 months per year on average, so a total of 30 movies over 5 years.

Page 32: Google Fiber Case Competition

32COST ASSUMPTIONS - SMALL BUSINESSES

Robust AC router $100.00 1 $100.00

Small Business 3 month

discount $50.00 per month 3 months $150

Gigabit Box $8 1 $8

*Gas per visit $0.50 1 visit $0.50

**Cost per visit $28.00 1 visit $28.00

Gigabit Cards and Stickers

(advertisment) $24.00 per year 5 year period $120.00

Cost per small business $407

*Google Mentors get paid 14$ per hour and make 4 visits to small businesses per 8 hours worked.

** Google Mentors drive 100 miles per week with 20 MPG and $2.00 gas prices

Page 33: Google Fiber Case Competition

33COST ASSUMPTIONS - FIXED COSTS

Mentor Supervisor $40,000.00 1 $40,000

Training Materials $3,000.00 1 $3,000

Total fixed costs $43,000

*We assume that the awareness campaign, and other tech support is included in the costs that Google Fiber already has. These fixed costs include additional costs for our strategy besides Google Fiber’s current costs.

Page 34: Google Fiber Case Competition

34COST ASSUMPTIONS - REFERRAL PROGRAM

• If we estimate that each customer refers 1 household or business on average, then the costs would be be $377 for a resident, and $507 per business.

• Although this would increase costs, we estimate an increased revenue as well.

Resident Referral Program

Year Augmented cost of

strategy

2016 $43,000

2017 $383,576

2018 $630,572

2019 $976,554

2020 $1,391,504

$377.00in additional costs over 5 year period

$507.00in additional costs over 5 year period

Cost per Resident

Cost per Small Business

Page 35: Google Fiber Case Competition

35

More switch to Fiber More paying residents More paying businesses

BENEFITS OF STRATEGY - ESTIMATES

• With increased awareness of google Fiber due to the gigabit club we expect that 50% of Provo’s 35,000 households* will have fiber (free or paid) by 2020. (Estimate: 23% of households in provo use Google Fiber currently

• Compare this to our estimate that 41% of homes will have fiber w/out our strategy.

• We expect that 37% of Fiber households will pay for the 70$ deal by 2020 with our strategy. Compare this to an estimated 19% w/out the strategy. (Estimate: 15% of current Fiber households have $70 deal)

• We estimate that 20% of Fiber households will get the 130$ package by 2020 compared to an estimated 14% w/out our strategy. (Estimate: 10% of current Fiber households have the $130 deal)

• Of the estimated 1,000 small business in provo who Google Fiber can target, we expect that 41% will pay for Fiber by 2020. (Estimate: 10% of small business currently use Google Fiber)

• Compare this to and estimated 30% of small businesses who will adopt google fiber w/out our strategy

*info about households in provo from http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/49/4962470.html

Page 36: Google Fiber Case Competition

36COST vs. BENEFITS

Years Rev w/o Strategy Rev w/ Strategy Cost of Strategy Profit from Strategy

2016 2,390,100 2,390,100 $43,000 -43,000

2017 2,981,034 3,340,054 $325,196 33,824

2018 3,746,700 5,013,256 $528,162 738,394

2019 4,714,755 7,703,305 $810,234 2,178,316

2020 5,913,288 11,627,040 $1,149,304 4,564,448

Page 37: Google Fiber Case Competition

37Survey Results

Page 38: Google Fiber Case Competition

38COST vs. BENEFITS

Page 39: Google Fiber Case Competition

39COST vs. BENEFITS

Page 40: Google Fiber Case Competition

40COST vs. BENEFITS

Page 41: Google Fiber Case Competition

41COST vs. BENEFITS

Page 42: Google Fiber Case Competition

42

END OF APPENDIX