Goldhammer Supervision
-
Upload
martin-mouk-peng-keong -
Category
Documents
-
view
232 -
download
0
Transcript of Goldhammer Supervision
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
1/66
1
TYPES OF SUPERVISIONTYPES OF SUPERVISION(detail xm)(detail xm)
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
2/66
drmhd 2
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
3/66
drmhd 3
INPUT PROCESS OUTPUT
Teaching &Learning
Process
SupervisionQ Teaching
Q Learning
Q Communication
Q HR
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
4/66
drmhd 4
It refers to any set of activities planned to improve the
teaching and learning process. It fundamentally involves
a cycle of systematic planning, observation, diagnosis,
change, and renewed planning.
(Hoy & Forsyth, 1!"#
So, What is the purpose of Supervision?
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
5/66
drmhd 5
$o wor% cooperatively with teachers toimprove instruction
$o help teachers solve immediate instructional
problems$o engage teachers in the study of the processes of
teaching and learning.Improvement of instruction which is long term
and a continuous process.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
6/66
6
School Supervision
Supervision and evaluation of teaching shouldlook for answers to the following questions:
'hat is actually going on in this classroom
'hat is the teacher and what are the studentsactually doing 'hat are the actual learning outcomes 'hat ought to be going on in this classroom
given our overall goals, educational platform,%nowledge of how children learn, andunderstandings of the structure of the sub)ectmatter to be taught
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
7/66
drmhd 7
'hat do these events and activities of teaching
and learning mean to teachers, students, andothers
'hat are the personal meanings that students
accumulate regardless of teacher intents
How do teacher and principal interpretations
of teaching reality differ
'hat actions should be ta%en to bring abouteven greater understanding of teaching and
learning and better congruence between our
actions and beliefs
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
8/66
drmhd 8
Defnitions o sue!"ision
*upervision as an act of administration
*upervision as an act of curriculum wor%
*upervision as an instructional function
*upervision as an act of human relations
*upervision as management
*upervision as a generic leadership role
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
9/66
drmhd 9
Special areas of supervisory competence
1. *upervisors +re evelopers of -eople.
..schools are learning environment designed tohelp children grow.
. *upervisors +re /urriculum evelopers
..0real0 curriculum is what is eperienced bystudents at the classroom level.
2. *upervisors +re Instructional *pecialists.
3to improve learning opportunities for students.(research, communication, teaching#
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
10/66
drmhd 10
Supervisory competence
4. *upervisors +re Human 5elations 'or%ers.
*ensitive to the needs of various clients(diplomacy#
6. *upervisors +re *taff evelopers. *taff development programs improving
performance by teachers
". *upervisors +re +dministrators. ..able to manage information and establish
effective record %eeping in instructional areas.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
11/66
drmhd 11
Supervisory Competence cont!"
7. *upervisors +re 8anager of /hange.
...perceive as managers of meaningful change
held accountable
!. *upervisors +re 9valuators.
3assessing teachers performance, program
outcomes, tets and materials, analy:ing
testing results3
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
12/66
drmhd 12
Clinical supervision
Collegial supervisionSelf#"irecte" supervision$nformal supervision
$n%uiry#ase" supervision
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
13/66
drmhd 13
linical Supervision (History)
;ate 16$he /ycles of *upervision?
=oldhammer refined it to a less comple method of
five stages %nown as>*e@uence of *upervision'
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
14/66
drmhd 14
It refers to the study of classroom behaviour in asystematic manner, in an atmosphere of colleagueship andmutual respect.(Hoy & Frosyth, 1!"#
$he professional development of teachers, with theemphasis on improving teachers0 classroom performance.(+cheson & =all, 1A1#
It refers to face to face contact with teachers with the intentof improving instruction & increasing professionalgrowth. (*ergiovanni & *tarratt,
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
15/66
drmhd 15
+ very effective strategy for bringing aboutimprovements in teaching.(=oldhammer, +nderson &
Bra)ews%i,12#
It is a formative evaluation /linical supervision is both a concept and a
structure. + nontraditional approach
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
16/66
drmhd 16
( characteristics of Clinical Supervision as a concept
)*ol"hammer, +n"erson an" ra-e.s/i ,0((12
1. It is a technologyfor improving instruction.
. It is a "elierate interventioninto the instructional process.
2. It is goal oriente", combining school needs with personal growth
needs of those who wor% within the school.
4. It assumes a professional .or/ing relationshipbetween teachers
and supervisors.
6. It re@uires a high "egree of mutual trust, as reflected in
understanding, support and commitment to growth.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
17/66
drmhd 17
".It creates a pro"uctive )healthy2 tensionfor ri"ging
the gapbetween the real an" the i"eal
7. It is systematic although it re@uires a fleible and
continuously changing methodology.
!. It assumes that the supervisor /no.s a great "eal
about the analysis of instruction & learning & also
about productive human interaction.
. It re@uires both pre#service training(supervisors # &
continuous in#service reflection on effective
approaches.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
18/66
drmhd 18
TH3 C4CL3 56 S7P3R8$S$59
6ive Se%uential Steps
)*ol"hammer, 0(:(2
1. Pre-conferencing with teacher
2. Observation of Classroom
3. Analyzing & Interreting observation& !etermining conference aroach
". Post-conference with teacher
#. Criti$%e of stes 1 -"
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
19/66
drmhd 19
Step 0# Pre conferencing .ith teacher
);efore actual oservation2
The purpose is to estalish the gui"elines & proce"ures for
The activities that .ill follo.
supervisor sits with teacher & determinesA
reason & purpose for the observation
focus of observation
method & form of observation
the time for observation
$ime for post conferencing
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
20/66
drmhd 20
te 2-Observation
It is based on the pre conferencing
Cbserver may use one observationDcombinations of
observations
8ethods categorical fre@uencies, performance indicators,
visual diagramming , focused @uestionnaire, audio
taping, video taping etc
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
21/66
drmhd 21
Cbserver only notes down descriptions not
interpretations
*upervisor observes & collects data about
$ & ; episode
Information collected is codified in systematic
way
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
22/66
drmhd 22
Step 1
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
23/66
drmhd 23
-uts information in a format that can be easily
interpreted & understood.
8a%es decision on interpersonal approach in post
conference with teacher (directive control, directive
informational, collaborative & nondirective approaches#
It assists the supervisor & teacher in Ethin%ing
analytically about what was observed & coming to an
understanding of the issues, @uestions & principles thatare involved.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
24/66
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
25/66
drmhd 25
te #- Criti$%e of tes 1-"
It has a symbolic and functional value.
It indicates that the supervisor is involved in an
improvement effort in the same way as the
supervisee (teacher#
It allows forreviewing whether format & procedures were
satisfactory
revisions if needed before se@uence is repeated changes to be suggested
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
26/66
drmhd 26
Feedbac% from teacher enables supervisor to
decide on what practices to continue, revise, or
change when wor%ing with the teacher in future
/onclusion
+fter the 6 steps are complete a tangible plan offuture action is in the hands of the teacher.
*upervisor is prepared to review the plan in the
net pre conference and establish focus and
method of observation.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
27/66
drmhd 27
$t refers to a mo"erately formali=e" process y .hich
t.o or more teachers agree to .or/ together for their
o.n professional gro.th, usually y oserving eachother!s classroom, giving each other fee"ac/ aout
the oservations, an" "iscussing share" professional
concerns
)*latthorn, cite" in Sergiovanni & Starratt,>>2
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
28/66
drmhd 28
*latthorn "escries @ "ifferent forms
Collegial Supervision might ta/eA
1.-rofessional dialogue among teachers guided discussion &
focus on teaching as a process of thin%ing. -urpose to enhance
reflective practice.
./urriculum dev.how to operationali:e eisting curriculum, adapt
the curriculum and enrich curriculum by inventing & develop
materials.
2.-eer *upervision observation of each other0s teaching followed by analysis & discussion
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
29/66
drmhd 29
4. -eer /oaching collaborative dev. & practice of
new teaching methods & s%ills in wor%shops &
actual teaching conditions
6.+ction research study problems faced & dev. offeasible solutions that results in changes in one0s
teaching practice.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
30/66
drmhd 30
1.$eachers have a voice in deciding their teammembers.
. -rincipals however have the final responsibility for
the ma%e up of the team.
2.$he structure of supervision should be formal
enough to allow records to be %ept (time used# and
these should be sent to the principal annually.
*7$B3L$93S # C5LL3*$+L S7P3R8$S$59
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
31/66
drmhd 31
4.$he principal should provide necessary resources &
support for teams to function during school hours.
6.Information generated regarding $&; should be
confidential within team members & not shared with
principal.
".-rincipal should not see% evaluation data from one
teacher about the other.
7.9ach teacher should %eep a professional growth log
which shows reflection and professional growth as a
result of the activities.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
32/66
drmhd 32
!.$he principal should meet the team at least once a
year for purposes of general assessment & sharingimpressions & information about the process.
.$he principal should meet the individual teacher at
once a year to discuss professional growth log &
provide encouragement & assistance.
1
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
33/66
drmhd 33
In self- directed supervision, teachers work alone by
assuming responsibility for their own professional
development
It includes teachers developing a yearly plan with
targets & goals derived from assessment of their
own needs.
$his plan is shared with a supervisor who ensuresthe plan & targets are realistic and attainable.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
34/66
drmhd 34
+t the end of the year teacher & supervisor meet to
discuss the teacher0s progress in meeting development
targets.
$eacher is epected to provide time logs, reflective
practice diaries, schedules, tapes , samples of students0
wor% and other documentation that illustrate progress
towards targets.
$he end of the meeting would lead to the setting of new
targets for future selfdirected supervision .
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
35/66
drmhd 35
CL$9$C+L S7P3R8$S$59
eveloped by 5obert =oldhammer (1"#, 8orris/ogan (172#A
E$he rationale and practice is designed to improve the
teacher0s classroom performance. It ta%es its principal
data from events of the classroom. $he analysis of
these data and the relationships between teacher and
supervisor form the basis of the program, procedures,
and strategies designed to improve the students0learning by improving the teacher0s classroom
behavior.0
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
36/66
drmhd 36
Clinical Supervision
Gery effective strategy for bringing aboutimprovements in teaching (=arman, 1!
=oldhammer, +nderson & Bra)ews%i, 12#.
It focus is on building teacher motivation andcommitment.
-roviding for Eonline0 staff development for
teachers. Help teachers to modify eisting patterns of
teaching in the ways that ma%e sense to them.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
37/66
drmhd 37
Clinical Supervision
=oldhammer0s (1"# fivestep clinicalsupervision processA
-reobservation /onference.
Cbservation of teaching
+nalysis and strategy
*upervision conference
-ostconference analysis
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
38/66
drmhd 38
The Basic 5-stages Clinical Supervision
Sequencesuggested by Goldhammer (1969)
*tage 1-reobservation /onference
*tage /lassroom Cbservation *tage 2ata +nalysis and *trategy
*tage 4/onference
*tage 6-ostconference +nalysis
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
39/66
drmhd 39
Stage 0Pre#5servation Conference
-urposeto establish guidelines and proceduresfor the activities that will follow.
TeacherDs Tas/A
$o mentally rehearse and orally describe theupcoming lesson, including the purpose and thecontent, what the teacher will do, and whatstudents are epected to do and learn.
It provides the mental and proceduralframewor% for conducting classroomobservations and implementing the rest of the
cycle.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
40/66
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
41/66
drmhd 41
Pre#oservation Conference )contE2
It serves toa# confirm and nurture the relationship between
supervisor and teacher
b# provide an opportunity for the teacher to presenthis or her lesson plan in its most polished version
c# give the teacher the opportunity to mentallyrehearse the lesson
d# give the teacher the opportunity to revise thelesson
e# secure agreement on the reasons for theobservation and protocol to be followed.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
42/66
drmhd 42
Stage 2Classroom bser!atio"
TeacherDs Tas/A
$o teach the lesson as well as possible.
Clinical SupervisorDs Tas/A $o record events occurring during the lesson
as accurately as possible.
$he supervisor observes in the classroom andcollects data about the teachinglearningepisode.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
43/66
drmhd 43
ata about classroom activities form the basisfor future planning, coaching, supervision
Information collected is codified in a
systematic way Cther data collection procedures audio
taping and videotaping.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
44/66
drmhd 44
Stage 3Data Analysis and Strategy
-urposeA $o ma%e sense of the data collectedand to put the information in some format thatcan be easily interpreted and understood.
TeacherDs Tas/A $o help ma%e sense of the data (if directly involved in
this stage#.
Clinical SupervisorDs Tas/A $o ma%e some sense of the raw data and to develop a
plan for the conference.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
45/66
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
46/66
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
47/66
Q C
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
48/66
drmhd 48
Questions to Consider#
'hat patterns and critical incidents are evident
in the data 'hat is the relationship between these events
and student learning
'ere any unanticipated or unintendedoutcomes evident
'hat will the teacher do differently for the
net class meeting (e.g., new ob)ectives,methods, content, materials, teacher behaviors,
student activities, or assessments#
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
49/66
drmhd 49
Stage @Post#Conference +nalysis
TeacherDs Tas/A $o provide honest feedbac% to the clinical
supervisor about how well the clinicalsupervision cycle went.
Clinical SupervisorDs Tas/A
$o critically eamine his or her own performanceduring the clinical supervision cycle.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
50/66
drmhd 50
$he information collected during the
observation along with the analysis ispresented to the teacher for review, discussion,
and recommendations.
It provides the supervisor and the teacher with
the opportunity to review the behavior that
were initially agreed upon
It gives the supervisor the opportunity to
discuss with the teacher possible solutions and
techni@ues of self supervision.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
51/66
drmhd 51
*upervisory techni@ues, assumptions,
emotional variables, and goals are analy:ed $he supervisor reflects on his or her behavior
to determine if the best agreement with the
teacher was developed and if the teacher washelped.
Helps the supervisor find an answer to the
@uestion, EHow effective was I?
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
52/66
drmhd 52
Questions to Consider#
=enerally, how well did the clinicalsupervision cycle go
'hat wor%ed well
'hat did not wor% well If you could do it again, what would you do
differently
'hat will you do differently during the netclinical supervision cycle
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
53/66
drmhd 53
Clinical Supervision# Common Themes
For clinical supervision to be effectiveA $eachers and supervisors develop a collegial
relationship characteri:ed by trust, respect, and
reciprocity. $eachers control which aspects of their
teaching learning process will be focused on
$eacher retain control over decisions thatimpact their teaching practices
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
54/66
drmhd 54
$he clinical supervision process continues
over an etended period
*upervisors provide teachers with non
)udgmental observational data that focus on
interactions of interest to the teacher
Koth teachers and supervisors engage in
reflective practice.
(Lolan, Haw%es & Francis , 12#
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
55/66
drmhd 55
+"vantages of School Supervision
Su%er!isio" is a mea"s o* improving the
quality of teaching and learning
- teachers ca" be e!aluated *or %romotio"- im%ro!e sta** %er*orma"ce through
de!elo%me"t o* i"di!idual accou"tability
- a %ositi!e relatio"shi% ca" de!elo% hich ca"
%ro!ide a to ay %rocess o* *eedbac. a"d
discussio"
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
56/66
drmhd 56
*upervisors help teachers improve and
"evelop s/illsin using instructionalstrategiesA
provide teachers with ob)ectives
feedbac% on the current state of theirinstruction
support teachers by providing time and
opportunity to reflect and discuss issues provide teachers with staff developmentcourses to enhance their s%ills
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
57/66
drmhd 57
$nstructional prolemscan be diagnosed and
solved
by understanding teachers0 strengths and
wea%nesses.
through teamwor% and team spirit
with a harmonious and supportive
relationship
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
58/66
drmhd 58
*uccessful matching of optionsto teachers
Commitmentof teachers and supervisors helpteachers develop a positive attitude about
continuous professional development
$eachers0 choice of pe"agogy suitable to typeof students
/ollaborative team .or/
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
59/66
drmhd 59
Bisa"vantages of School Supervision
*upervision can be e@uated with evaluation itma%es people nervousDstress.
$his is due to the historical role of the supervisor seen as an >inspector?, not a helper.
$eachers may view supervision as evaluationrather than improving relationship.
It can be seen as fulfilling the need of thesupervisor, not the teachers.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
60/66
60
$he unpleasantnesscan reduce the amount of
interaction between them when increasedinteraction is what is needed.
*ome supervisors may display unprofessionalattitude teachers can be critici:ed in front ofthe class or other supervisors.
*ometimes, teachers are not consulted whenother people are invited to observe them.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
61/66
drmhd 61
*upervisors may not have enough relevant
eGperienceof parenting support wor% toprovide effective supervision.
Lew supervisors rarely have ade@uate trainingto supervise D observe D evaluate other people due to time and budget constraints.
$he organi:ational structure of the school maynot support effective supervision.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
62/66
drmhd 62
$ime, wor% pressures, anieties and organi:ationalconstraintscan limit both the effectiveness andefficiency of supervision.
It rarely include pre and post observation.
=oing through the process from time to time canma%e it too routini:ed and rituali:ed.
It can be burdensome and tiresome for both teachersand supervisors.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
63/66
drmhd 63
$hrough facetoface interaction, thesupervisor and the teacher may find that their
"iffering orientation styles, personalities andworldview may clash during the observation.
*ome supervisors may withhold negativefeedbac% from teachers.
$his is because some feedbac% may be harderto give than others personality orprofessional issues.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
64/66
drmhd 64
$here can be a lac% of priority of professional
activities among teachers.
$eachers who have a strong interest in
maintaining the status %uomay re)ect a process
that will lead to change in the form of growth
and improvement.
$eachers who view change as personal loss may
view supervision as a threat.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
65/66
65
/linical supervision may be suitable for someteachers in certain school contets but not for
others.
$eacher needs, dispositions, learning stylesand .or/ styles varyamong teachers.
$hese concerns must be ta%en intoconsideration and eamination if supervisionis to be effective and beneficial.
-
7/26/2019 Goldhammer Supervision
66/66
Thank YouThank You