Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011...

31

Transcript of Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011...

Page 1: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,
Page 2: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,
Page 4: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,

Page 5: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,
Page 6: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,

o

o

Page 7: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,

Page 8: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,
Page 9: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,
Page 10: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,
Page 11: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,

Page 12: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,

Page 13: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,

Page 14: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,
Page 15: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,
Page 16: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,
Page 17: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,

Page 18: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,
Page 19: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,
Page 20: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,
Page 26: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,

Records identified through expert advice (n = 8 )

(n = 14 )

Records identified through snowballing (n = 8)

Studies assessed for eligibility and included

in qualitative synthesis (n = 16)

Evaluation literature (n =14*) (comprises: 2 systematic reviews 8 Papers 4 Books)

Public management literature (n = 4)

Research Impact literature (n = 23*)

Health Technology Assessment literature (n = 16)

Page 27: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,

The most common approach to appraisal of HTA influence was review of policy or administrative decisions following HTA recommendations. Several publications reported survey findings, and five considered the influence of primary studies.

Page 28: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,
Page 29: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,

I

Page 30: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,

Page 31: Evaluating Health Technology Wales...Donovan, 2011 #934 Smith, 2007 #142 Jung, 2008 #65 Buxton, 2011 #946 van Eerd, 2011 #611 Bell, 2011 #941 Bell, 2011 #941 Adam, 2012 #1070 Graham,