Enviro Advocates Study

8/13/2019 Enviro Advocates Study

1/24


2/24

!"#$%$& ( )*%$+ ,-. /01**.&(* 20**"/%0$!"#$% '()*)+, -./012 0+ "+301/)+,"+4)10+5.+6(* 7(8%

!"#$%&'()*(+($,-. "# $%&'( $%# )*+#,$ -$#,./'01.&,( 2*3'4&$/*' 5*, $%#/, 6377*,$ *5 $%/6 8*,(9"# &.6* $%&'( $%# :#8 ;*,( -$&$# '5*,B#=#'$9999999999999999999999

1.#&' H/, HB$ >'5*,B#=#'$999999999999999999999999

V&F&,4*36 "&6$# >'5*,B#=#'$99999999999999999999

)#03.&$*,@ )*.. N&B(6999999999999999999999999999

1*'B.36/*'99999999999999999999999999999999999999

56#0$-74 84.+ %$ /9. :.;0#/#99 #*.(+ 9)1 9/6

#9': #0+/.+61(6.2 9+)5(* '..2)+, :;.1(6)0+# #05;1.?.+%)4. *(+!"# !.;(165.+6 03 "+4)10+5.+6(* #0+%.14(6)0+

!=- !)%/?(1,. =0+)601)+, -.;016"A>B

"#7 "+4)10+5.+6(* #0+%.14(6)0+ 7(8

">9 ''C '.2.1(* ')%/(* C.(1

7DE >#A

-#-9 -#B! B'C B6(6. ')%/(* C.(1

B>!"BB6(6. >0**@6)0+ !)%/?(1,. "*)5)+(6)0+

FB!'


3/243

,, ?8@@5:A

/'#G$,/B&+.@ ./'(#4 $* *3, 6$&$#E6 #B*'*=/B 8#..D+#/'0 &'4 6*3'4 73+./B %#&.$%9

N3$ &6 $%# ,#63.$ *5 636$&/'#4 +340#$ B3$6 43,/'0 $%# .&6$ 4#B&4#C $%# :#8 ;*,( -$&$# '?/,*'=#'$&. I,*$#B$/*' H0#'B@ X>IHY $%/6 ,#7*,$4#=*'6$,&$#6 $%&$ #'?/,*'=#'$&. #'5*,B#=#'$ /6 *' $%# 4#B./'#9 23,$%#,C $%# 6$&$# /6 /'B,#&6/'0.@ ,#./&'$ *' 7*.D.3$#,D7,*43B#4 6#.5D=*'/$*,/'0 ,#7*,$6 $* *?#,6## $%#/, B*=7./&'B# 8/$% #'?/,*'=#'$&. 7#,=/$ B*'4/$/*'69

J*?#,'*, H'4,#8 13*=* *5$#' 67#&(6 &+*3$ $%# '##4 $* =&(# 6$&$# 0*?#,'=#'$ 8*,( +#$$#,9 H'4 /' 6*=#/'6$&'B#6C %# %&69 J*?#,'*, 13*=* %&6 .#4 /=7*,$&'$ 0,##' /'/$/&$/?#6C 63B% &6 4#4/B&$/'0 =*,# ,#6*3,B#6 5*,

7,#6#,?&$/*' &'4 B*'6#,?&$/*' 7,*[#B$69

N3$ $%# 5&/.3,# $* &44,#66 #'5*,B#=#'$ /663#6 &$ $%# 1 8/.. 3.$/=&$#.@ 63..@ %/6 ,#B*,49 H'4 8%/.# $%# 13*=&4=/'/6$,&$/*' /6 '*$ ,#67*'6/+.# 5*, $%# 4##7 6$&55 B3$6 *5 7,#?/*36 &4=/'/6$,&$/*'6C $%# J*?#,'*,E6 7%/.*6*7%@

%&6 +##' 5*, %/6 &0#'B@ $* 4* .#66 8/$% .#66C .#&?/'0 /$ 6$,300./'0 $* 7,*$#B$ 73+./B %#&.$%C 6&5#$@C &'4 *3#'?/,*'=#'$9

=077"$%/- =0$4.B".$6.4

\ B3$6 $%&$ %&?# %&4 &' &.&,=/'0 $*.. *' #'5*,B#=#'$ &B$/*'6 &B,*66 &.. B&$#0*,/#6 /'?#6$/0&$#49

>IH 4&$& 5,*= U]]W $* U]TU B*=7/.#4 +@ >'?/,*'=#'$&. H4?*B&$#6 6%*8^

DEC inspections of water pollution permit holders declined by 74% between 2009 and 2012 leaving pollut-er-produced monitoring reports largely unveri ed.

Q' [36$ 5*3, @#&,6C &/, 7#,=/$ /'67#B$*,6 B3$ 6$&B( $#6$/'0 *5 #=/66/*' 6*3,B#6 +@ __` &'4 4*B3=#'$#4 5#8#,

-$&$# %&F&,4*36 8&6$# ,#03.&$*,6 /'67#B$#4 *'.@ O9P` *5 *7#,&$/'0 5&B/./$/#6 &'4 0#'#,&$*,6 /' :#8 ;*,( &'4

X4*8' Ra`Y *5 7#,=/$ 7,*?/6/*'6 &6 B*=7&,#4 $* 5*3, @#&,6 &0*9

Governors philosophy has been for his DEC to do less with less


4/244

/$ /6 =*,# ./(#.@ $%# 6$&$# %&6 +#B*=# & 7.&B# 8%#,# /$ /6 #&6/#, 5*, 5&B/./$/#6 $* 7*..3$# 8/$%*3$ +#/'0 %#.4

>?#' =*,# $,*3+./'0C J*?#,'*, 13*=* %&6 ,#B#'$.@ /'$,*43B#4 '#8 7*./B/#6 $* 53,$%#, ,*.. +&B( #'?/,*'=#'$&. 7,*$#B$/*'69

M#4 +@ $%# J*?#,'*,C ,#b3/,#=#'$6 &/=#4 &$ 7,*$#B$/'0 8&$#,8&@6 &'4 B*==3'/$/#6 5,*= &0,/B3.$3,&.8&6$#6 8#,# #./=/'&$#4 5*, 4&/,@ *7#,&$/*'6 8/$% 5#8#, $%&' O]] B*86 3'4#, $%# 03/6# *5 +3*@/'0 $%# 6$&$#E6J,##(D@*03,$ /'436$,@9 A%# 13*=* &4=/'/6$,&$/*' &.6* /'$,*43B#4 & 6#.5D&34/$ 7*./B@ $%&$ &..*86 #'$/$/#6 $*&?*/4 73'/6%=#'$ +@ 6#.#B$/?#.@ +,/'0/'0 $%#/, *8' /'5,&B$/*'6 $* 1E6 &$$#'$/*'9

5 2(/9 C0#D(#+J*?#,'*, 13*=* B&' $3,' $%# 6%/7 &,*3'49 A%#,# &,# =&'@ /==#4/&$#&B$/*'6 $%# 13*=* &4=/'/6$,&$/*' B&' &4*7$ 8%/B% 8/.. ,#'#8 $%# 73+./BE6

5&/$% /' $%# &0#'B@E6 *?#,6/0%$C &'4 #,&6# $%/6 +.&B( =&,( *' $%# J*?#,'*,E60,##' ,#B*,49

-7/$F#, 53'4#4 & =*4#6$ 0,*8$% *5 T]W 7*6/$/*'6 \ &' /'B,#&6# .*'0 6/'B##,&6#49

)#6$*,/'0 6$&55 8*3.4 &..*8 1 $* +#$$#, #'5*,B# $%# 6$&$#E6 #G/6$/'0 .&86 &'4 ,#03.&$/*'6 $%&$ 7,*$#B$ *3,#'?/,*'=#'$ &'4 73+./B %#&.$%9 Q$ 8*3.4 53,$%#, #=7*8#, 1 $* &66#,$ /$6 ,#03.&$*,@ 7,#6#'B# 8/$% *'D6/$#

('*8/'0 $%#/, 0*?#,'=#'$ /6 8*,(/'0 $* 7,*$#B$ $%#/, /'$#,#6$691 6%*3.4 &.6* ,#/'6$/$3$# ,/0*,*36 &0#'B@D.#4 $#6$/'0 &$ #=/66/*' 6*3,B#6 &'4 /4#'$/5@ $%# ,**$ B&36#6 *5 8%&/, &'4 %&F&,4*36 8&6$# /'67#B$/*'6 &,# '*8 3'B*?#,/'0 5#8#, /'5,&B$/*'6 $%&' /' @#&,6 7&6$9

/'5*,=&$/*' *' %*8 $%# 6$&$#E6 ?/$&. ,#6*3,B#6 &,# +#/'0 7,*$#B$#4 5,*= $*G/B #=/66/*'6 $%,*30% &''3&. ,#7*,$69

DEC is looking less and finding less


5/245

3,E,:5F :,=G@@,EH5!1GE?


6/246

1E!:GH8=!1GEA%,*30%*3$ /$6 %/6$*,@C :#8 ;*,( -$&$# %&6 .#4 $%# '&$/*' /' #'&B$/'0 .#0/6.&$/*' &'4 ,#03.&$/*'6 $%&$ 7,*$#B$

73+./B %#&.$%C 6&5#$@C &'4 $%# #'?/,*'=#'$9 2,*= $%# B,#&$/*' *5 $%# H4/,*'4&B( I&,( $* 7&66/'0 &' /''*?&$/?#&B/4 ,&/' .&8 /' $%# =/4DTWa]6 X3'4#, $%#'DJ*?#,'*, c&,/* 13*=*Y $* 7&66/'0 .#0/6.&$/*' $* B*'$,*. $%# 67,#&4*5 4#6$,3B$/?# /'?&6/?# 7.&'$6 &'4 &'/=&.6C :#8 ;*,(E6 +*4@ *5 #'?/,*'=#'$&. 7,*$#B$/*' /6 #G$#'6/?#9

V*8#?#,C ./$$.# /6 ('*8' &+*3$ %*8 5,#b3#'$.@ &'4 #55#B$/?#.@ $%#6# .&86 &,# +#/'0 #'5*,B#4 d 3'$/. '*89

'?/,*'=#'$&. H4?*B&$#6 6300#6$ $%&$ +&6#./'# #'5*,B#=#'$ *5 #'?/,*'=#'$&. .&86 %&6 D

$#, HB$C 1.#&' H/, HB$C &'4 )#6*3,B# 1*'6#,?&$/*' &'4 )#B*?#,@ HB$ \ %&?# 4#B,#&6#4 +@ '#&,.@ UP` +#$8##'U]]W &'4 U]TU9

23,$%#,C 3'4#, $%# 03/6# *5 =&(/'0 :#8 ;*,( ef7#' 5*, N36/'#66Cg $%# 13*=* &4=/'/6$,&$/*' %&6 &B$/?#.@ +#D03' ,*../'0 +&B( ,#03.&$/*'6 +@^

A%#6# &B$/*'6 B&.. /'$* b3#6$/*' $%# J*?#,'*,E6 B*==/$=#'$ $* +&6/B #'?/,*'=#'$&. &'4 73+./B %#&.$% 7,*$#BD$/*'69 !"#$%$& ( )*%$+ ,-. /0 1**.&(* 20**"/%0$ #G&=/'#6 $%#6# 4/6$3,+/'0 $,#'46 8/$%/' =&[*, 53'B$/*'&. &,#&6&$ $%# 1C &'4 ,#B*==#'46 & 6#,/#6 *5 =#&63,#6 $* $3,' $%# 6/$3&$/*' &,*3'4 &'4 +3,'/6% J*?#,'*, 13*=*E6,#73$&$/*' &6 & '&$/*'&. .#&4#,9

,$I0#6.7.$/ GI ,$J%#0$7.$/(* F(D4 G$ !9. H.6*%$.1 /6 4#6/0'&$#4 +@ $%# >IH $* 7#,=/$ &'4 #'5*,B# 5#4#,&. 7*..3$/*' ,#03.&$/*'6 5*, *?#, OOC]]] #=/66/*'6*3,B#6 B*?#,#4 3'4#, $%# 1.#&' "&$#, HB$ X1"HYC 1.#&' H/, HB$ X1HHYC &'4 )#6*3,B# 1*'6#,?&$/*' &'4 )#DB*?#,@ HB$ X)1)HY9

?#,/5@/'0 #'?/,*'=#'$&. B*=7./&'B# %&?# #G7&'4#49 A%/6 +&.&'B/'0 &B$ %&6 736%#4 $%# &0#'B@ $* /'B,#&6/'0.

D$/*'9

D

/'67#B$#4 a_] XOP`Y 5#8#, 5&B/./$/#6 /' U]TU $%&' U]]WC 8%/.# 5&B/./$/#6 5*3'4 $* +# /' ?/*.&$/*' *5 7#,=/$ 7,*D?/6/*'6 %&?# 4#B./'#4 +@ UP`C &'4 5&B/./$/#6 5*3'4 $* +# /' 6#,/*36 ?/*.&$/*' %&?# &.6* 4#B,#&6#4 +@ =*,# $%&T]` 43,/'0 $%/6 $/=# 7#,/*49 2*,=&. #'5*,B#=#'$ &B$/*'6 %&?# 4#B,#&6#4 +@ &.=*6$ UP`C 8%/.# /'5*,=&. #'D


7/247

=F,5E K5!,: 5=! ,ECG:=,@,E!"&$#, 7*..3$/*' B*=#6 /' =&'@ 5*,=6 &'4 %&6 8/4# ,&'0/'0 /=7&B$69 f3, ,/?#,6C .&(#6C &'4 8&$#,8&@6 &,# 36#4

D$/*' $%&$ B&' #'4&'0#, 73+./B %#&.$%9

"&6$#8&$#, $,#&$=#'$ 7.&'$6 &'4 =3'/B/7&. 6#8#, 6@6$#=6 *5$#' ,#.#&6# ,&8 6#8&0# /'$* *3, .&(#6 &'4 ,/?#,6C#.#?&$/'0 .#?#.6 *5 %&,=53. 7&$%*0#'6 $%&$ =&(# 8&$#,6 3'6&5# 5*, %3=&' B*'63=7$/*' &'4 B*'$&B$C /'B.34/'0

&'4 7%*67%*,*36 /'$* 8&$#,8&@69 :/$,*0#' &'4 7%*67%*,36 7*..3$/*' 4/6,37$6 &b3&$/B #B*6@6$#=6 +@ B,#&$/'0&.0 +.**=6 $%&$ 7,*43B# 4#&4 F*'#6 /' $%# 8&$#,C ,&/6# $,#&$=#'$ B*6$6 5*, 4,/'(/'0 8&$#,C &'4 %3,$ /'436$,/#

$%&$ 4#7#'4 *' B.#&' 8&$#,9 -*=# &.0 +.**=6 #?#' 7,*43B# 4&'0#,*36 $*G/'6 $%&$ B&' 6/B(#' *, (/.. 7#*7.#&'4 8/.4./5#9

./(# =#,B3,@C B&'B#,DB&36/'0 B%#=/B&.6 ./(# 7*.@B%.*,/'&$#4 +/7%#'@.6 XI1N6YC &'4 #?#' 6*=#$%/'0 &6 +#D'/0'D6*3'4/'0 &6 $%#,=&. 7*..3$/*' B&' 8,#&( %&?*B 8/$% & 8&$#, +*4@E6 &+/./$@ $* 636$&/' ./5# *, +# #'[*@#4 +

*3, 6$&$# 63,5&B# 8&$#,69 Q$ /6 37 $* $%# 1 &'4 >IH $* =*'/$*, $%#6# 4/6B%&,0#6 /' *,4#, $* 7,*$#B$ *'# *5 $%6$&$#E6 =*6$ 7,#B/*36 ,#6*3,B#6 &'4C /' $3,'C 73+./B %#&.$%C 6&5#$@C &'4 *3, #'?/,*'=#'$9

E.D A0#LM4 K(/.# 20**"/%0$ =0$/#0* C#(7.D0#L :#8 ;*,(E6 8&$#, b3&./$@ /6 B*'6$&'$.@ 3'4#, &$$&B( +@ 7#,=/$$#4 7*..3$/*' 4/6B%&,0#6 /' &44/$/*' $* /..#0&. 4/6DB%&,0#6 &'4 $%*6# $%&$ #GB##4 7#,=/$$#4 7*..3$/*' .#?#.69

A%# >IH 4#6/0'&$#6 &3$%*,/$@ $* 1 3'4#, $%# 5#4#,&. 1.#&' "&$#, HB$ $* B*'$,*. 8&$#, 7*..3$/*' &'4 #'5*,B#B*=7./&'B# 8/$% #'?/,*'=#'$&. .&869 H,$/B.# TS *5 $%# >'?/,*'=#'$&. 1*'6#,?&$/*' M&8 ,#b3/,#6 &'@ 5&B/./$@

D.3$/*' ./=/'&$/*' -@6$#=6 X-I-Y 7,*0,&=9

'),@1. GHI (/10%% 6?. J0(12 )+%;./6)0+ (+2 .+301/.5.+6 /@6%


8/248

A%# -I- 7,*0,&= &3$%*,/F#6 &'4 =*'/$*,6 7*..3$&'$ 4/6B%&,0#6 /'$* 63,5&B# 8&$#,6 &'4 8*,(6 $* #'63,#

7#,=/$6 4/6B%&,0/'0 5&B/./$/#6 ,&'0/'0 /' 6/F# 5,*= 3(40#5 \ 8%/B% /'B.34# .&,0# /'436$,/&. 5&B/./$/#6C #'#,0@ 7,*43B#,6C &'4 8&6$#8&$#, $,#&$=#'$ 7.&'$6 $%&$ 4/6B%&,0# =*,# $%&' *'# =/../*' 0&..*'6 7#, 4&@ *, $%&$ ,#.#%/0%D,/6( 7*..3$&'$6 /'$* *3, 8&$#,6 \ $* 3%$0#5 8%/B% /'B.34# 6=&..#, 4/6B%&,0# 6*3,B#6 ./(# 6B%**.6C ,#6$&3D,&'$6C &'4 &7&,$=#'$ B*=7.#G#6 $%&$ 5,#b3#'$.@ 5##4 4/,#B$.@ /'$* =3'/B/7&. 6#8#, 6@6$#=69

N#B&36# ,3'*55 &5$#, %#&?@ ,&/'6 B&,,/#6 6#4/=#'$ &'4 $*G/B 4#+,/6 5,*= B*'6$,3B$/*' &'4 /'436$,/&. 6/$#6 /'$*8&$#, +*4/#6C &'4 +#B&36# %#&?@ ,&/'5&.. B&' B&36# $,#&$=#'$ 7.&'$6 $* ,#.#&6# ,&8 6#8&0# /'$* 8&$#,8&@6TWWa >IH 7,/*,/$/F#4 $%#6# 8#$ 8#&$%#, 4/6B%&,0#6 5*, ,#03.&$/*'9

1*'6/6$#'$ 8/$% $%/6 '#8 >IH 6$,&$#0@C 1 /'$,*43B#4 0#'#,&. -I- 7#,=/$6 $* B*?#, 6$*,=8&$#, ,3'*555,*= 6*3,B#6 63B% &6 B*'6$,3B$/*' &'4 /'436$,/&. 6/$#6C =3'/B/7&. 6$*,= 6#8#,6C &'4 1*'B#'$,&$#4 H'/=&. 2##4D/'0 f7#,&$/*'6 X1H2f6C *, 5&B$*,@ 5&,=6Y9 A%# &44/$/*' *5 8#$ 8#&$%#, 4/6B%&,0#6 $* $%# -I- 7#,=/$ 7,*D

B*=# 8/$%*3$ &'@ /'B,#&6# /' 1 6$&55 *, ,#6*3,B#6 $* &B$3&..@ =*'/$*, &'4 #'5*,B# 7#,=/$ B*=7./&'B#9

c&'@ *,0&'/F&$/*'6 &'4 6$&$# &0#'B/#6 %&?# +##'&+.# $* 6$,#&=./'# $%#/, 8*,( &'4 ,#43B# 6$&55 &6$#B%'*.*0@ =*4#,'/F#6 $%# 8*,(5*,B#9 V*8#?#,C $%#

/' &,#&6 8%#,# ,#&. 7#*7.# &,# '#B#66&,@ $* B&,,@ *3$/'67#B$/*'6 &'4 *$%#, 8*,(9

H$ 1C $%# '?/,*'=#'$&. >'5*,B#=#'$C 8%/B% 6377*,$6 $%#


9/249

6.$55.*(.# 70"$/- 8.9.# :%5/#%;/


10/2410

,$I0#6.7.$/ K0.4

%*.4#,69 A%#6# 7*..3$#,D7,*43B#4 6&=7./'0 ,#7*,$6 &,# ,#b3/,#4 *5 .&,0# ?*.3=# *, /'436$,/&. 4/6B%&,0#,6 *' &=*'$%.@C b3&,$#,.@C *, &''3&. +&6/6 4#7#'4/'0 *' /'4/?/43&. 7#,=/$ B*'4/$/*'69 1 ,#7*,$#4.@ ,#B#/?#4 =*,#$%&' U]C]]]


11/2411

3(40# 7*..3$/'0 :#8 ;*,(E6 8&$#,8&@6 *, $%#/, /=7,*7#, ,#7*,$/'0 /6 7,#?#'$/'0 1 5,*= ('*8/'0 8%#$%#, /..#0&. 7*..3$/*' /6 +#/'0 4/6B%&,0#49 1 4&$& ,#7*,$#4 $* >IH 6%*8 $%&$ &' &?#,&0# *5 SR` *5 3(40# 5&B/./$/#6 %&?# +##' B/$#4 5*, ?/*.&$/*'6 +#$8##' U]]W &'4 U]TU9

H6 6%*8' /' 2/03,# XOYC 1 /'67#B$/*'6 *5 3(40# 4/6B%&,0/'0 5&B/./$/#6 5#.. 4,&=&$/B&..@ +#$8##' U]]W &'4U]TU 4#67/$# $%# =&[*,/$@ *5 $%# 5&B/./$/#6E /'B3,,/'0 ?/*.&$/*'6 \ *5$#' 5*, 3',#./&+.# &'4 63+6$&'4&,4 ,#7*,$/'09

3(40# 5&B/./$/#6 8#,# *3$ *5 B*=7./&'B# 8/$% $%#/, 7#,=/$6C 1 4#B/4#4 $* /'67#B$ SW5#8#, 3(40# 7*..3$/'0 5&B/./$/#6 &$ $%# #'4 *5 $%&$ $/=#5,&=#9 1 /'67#B$/*'6 5#.. 5,*= & 6$,*'0 #'5*,B#=#'$

7,#6#'B# *5 S_` *5 =&[*, 5&B/./$/#6 /'67#B$#4 /' U]]W $* [36$ TR` /' U]TUC .#&?/'0 ,#03.&$*,6 +./'4 $* ?/*.&$/*'6&'4 $%# 73+./B ?3.'#,&+.# $* /..#0&. 7*..3$/*'9

1$5B.;/%0$5 0G 3(40# B0**"/%$& G(;%*%/%.5 +#0BB.+ C- OPQ G#0= LMMP /0 LMRL

'),@1. GKI ( 5(L01 1.2@/6)0+ )+ )+%;./6)0+% 03 6?. %6(6.$% *(1,.%6 2)%/?(1,.1%

'),@1. GMI B>!"B ;.15)66.2 3(/)*)6).% )+%;./6.2

1$5B.;/%0$5 0G 82:,8SB.#=%//.+ G(;%*%/%.5 +.;*%$.+ C- ( 5/(&&.#%$& OTQ 0E.# /@. *(5/ G0"# -.(#5


12/2412

7#,=/$6 /'B,#&6#4 +@ _W`9 i36$ &6 & %/0%#, 7*./B# 7,#6#'B# B&' 4#B,#&6# $%# '3=+#, *5 4&'0#,*36 4,3'( 4,/?#,6*' $%# ,*&4C =*,# 5,#b3#'$ /'67#B$/*'6 B&' 4#B,#&6# $%# '3=+#, *5 8&$#,D7*..3$/*' ?/*.&$/*'69 A%# B*'$,&6$/'0$,#'46 6%*8' /' 2/03,# X_Y \ /'B,#&6/'0 ?/*.&$/*' ,&$#6 B*37.#4 8/$% 4#B,#&6/'0 /'67#B$/*' ,&$#6 \ 4#=*'6$,&$#

:.6077.$+(/%0$4

=F,5E 51: 5=! ,ECG:=,@,E!

=&$$#, 8%/B% /,,/$&$#6 $%# '*6#C $%,*&$C &'4 ,#67/,&$*,@ 6@6$#= &'4 B*'$,/+3$#6 $* $%# 4#?#.*7=#'$ *5 &6$%#&,$ 4/6#&6#9 HBB*,4/'0 $* $%# :#8 ;*,( -$&$# IH 4#.#0&$#6 $%/6 &3$%*,/$@ $* 1 8%/B%C $%,*30% 7#,=/$ 7,*?/6/*'6C ,#b3/,#6 5&B/./$/#6X&Y /'6$&.. 7*..3$/*' B*'$,*. $#B%'*.*0/#6 *, X+Y B%&'0# *7#,&$/'0 7,&B$/B#6 /' B*'[3'B$/*' 8/$% =*'/$*,/'0 &'4#'5*,B/'0 &B$/?/$/#69GGG/

,E.$ 9%/@ OPQ G.9.# =(40# 82:,8 G(;%*%/%.5 %$5B.;/.+ %$ LMRL /@($ %$ LMMPD /@. $"=C.#

)./9..$ LMMP ($+ LMRLD %$5B.;/%0$5 0G =(40# B0**"/%$& G(;%*%/%.5 +.;*%$.+ C- OPQ U G#0= ( 5/#0$&

'),@1. GNI )+%;./6)0+% 210;O +0+/05;*)(+/. ,108%


13/2413

>&B% @#&,C a9_ =/../*' 7*3'46 *5 .#0&. #=/66/*'6 &,# ,#.#&6#4 /'$* :#8 ;*,(E6 &/, 5,*= 7#,=/$$#4 5&B/./$/#69 UO

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

H6 7,#?/*36.@ =#'$/*'#4C $%#


14/24


15/2415

,$I0#6.7.$/ K0.4 >IH &4=/'/6$,&$*,6 B*'6/4#, & %/0% ?/*.&$/*' ,&$# &6 & 6/0' *5 b3&./$@ #'5*,B#=#'$ B*?#,&0# $%&$ +,/'06 '*'B*=D

7./&'$ 5&B/./$/#6 /'$* $%# 7/7#./'# $* B*,,#B$ #'?/,*'=#'$&..@ %&,=53. 7,&B$/B#69 Q' :#8 ;*,( -$&$#C ?/*.&$/*'6 &'4#'5*,B#=#'$ &B$/*'6 %&?# 4#B,#&6#4 63+6$&'$/&..@ *?#, $%# .&6$ 5*3, @#&,6 &B,*66 &.. B.&66#6 *5 ,#03.&$#4$/#6 X2/03,# XRY9 2*, &.. 7#,=/$ %*.4#,6C ?/*.&$/*'6 5#.. +@ PO` +#$8##' U]]W &'4 U]TUC 8%/.# B/$&$/*'6 5*, %/

7,/*,/$@ ?/*.&$/*'6 &'4 5*,=&. #'5*,B#=#'$ &B$/*'6 3'4#,$&(#' +@ $%# &0#'B@ #&B% 5#.. +@ P]`9

2#8#, 6$&55 &,# B*'43B$/'0 5#8#, /'67#B$/*'6 &'4 $%#,#5*,# /4#'$/5@/'0 5#8#, ?/*.&$/*'69 >IHE6 B,/$/B/6= *5 .*8B/$&$/*' ,&$#6 \ B,/$/B/6= +&6#4 *' 7*..3$#, 7&$$#,'6 &B,*66 $%# B*3'$,@ \ /'4/B&$# $%# ./(#./%**4 *5 4&'0#,*36?/*.&$/*'6 +#/'0 =/66#4C 8/$% 7*$#'$/&..@ 6#,/*36 B*'6#b3#'B#6 5*, '#/0%+*,/'0 B*==3'/$/#69

?/(6L !.4/4H' /=7*,$&'$ =#$%*4 5*, &66#66/'0 &/, 7*..3$/*' #=/66/*'6 /6 $%# 6$&B( $#6$9 -$&B( $#6$6 =#&63,# $%# &=*3'$ *5

LMRM :%E%5%0$ 0G X%

50"#;.5 70=B*%($;. ($+ ,$G0#;.=.$/ 6.B0#/ 6$&$#6 $%&$ 6$&B( $#6$6 &,# *'# *5 $%# =*6$ #55#B$/?# 8&@6 *=/'/'0 & 5&B/./$@E6 B*=7./&'B# 8/$% #=/66/*' ./=/$6 &6 8#.. &6 &B$3&. 6*3,B# #=/66/*'6C +3$ &,# ?#,@ 4#=&'4/'0*' &0#'B@ ,#6*3,B#6C *5$#' ,#b3/,/'0 6$&55 $* +# &$ $%# 5&B/./$@ $* =*'/$*, $#6$6 &6 $%#@ &,# B*'43B$#49 >IH 4&$& 6%*8 B*'6/6$#'$ ,#43B$/*'6 /' &0#'B@D.#4 6$&B( $#6$/'0C ,#63.$/'0 /' & __` 4#B./'# 6/'B# U]]W X2/03,#

,#7*,$ #=/66/*'6C &'4 5#8#, 6$&B( $#6$6 .#&?# 1 +./'4 $* 4&'0#,*36 ?/*.&$/*'6 ./(# $%*6# 5*3'4 &$ A*'&8&'4&1*(# &'4 .#&?# 7*$#'$/&. 7*..3$#,6 8/$%*3$ & B*7 *' $%# +#&$9

:,7 ;0$+";/.+ TTQ G.9.# 5/(;F /.5/5 /0 E.#%G- B0**"/.# 5.*GS#.B0#/5 %$ LMRL;0=B(#.+ /0 LMMP

'),@1. GPI NNQ %6(/R 6.%6)+, 2./*)+.


16/2416

"%/.# 1E6 1*=7./&'B# c*'/$*,/'0 -$,&$#0@ %&6 .#4 $* & B*'6/6$#'$ '3=+#, *5 3(40# &/, 5&B/./$/#6 ,#B#/?/'0

&..#0#4 ?/*.&$/*'6 +@ 3(40# 5&B/./$/#6 4#B,#&6#4 +@ '#&,.@ R]` &'4 %/0% 7,/*,/$@ ?/*.&$/*'6 4#B,#&6#4 +@ SW8/$% *'.@ 5*3, 5&B/./$/#6 \ .#66 $%&' T` \ 5*3'4 $* %&?# 6#,/*36.@ ?/*.&$#4 $%#/, 7#,=/$ B*'4/$/*'6 /' U]TU9 i36$&6 >IH 6300#6$6 5*, &.. &/, 7#,=/$$#4 5&B/./$/#6C &' *?#,6/0%$ 6$,&$#0@ $%&$ &66#66#6 5#8 7#'&.$/#6 =&@ +#$* +,/'0 #'?/,*'=#'$&..@ %&,=53. 7,*B#66#6 /'$* $%# ,#03.&$*,@ 6@6$#=9 )#43B#4 .#?#.6 *5 *?#,6/0%$ 6$&55 &.*'08/$% $%# 4/=/'/6%/'0 ,*.# *5 6$&B( $#6$/'0 &6 & =#&'6 *5 ?#,/5@/'0 7*..3$#,D7,*43B#4 ,#7*,$6 =&@ &.6* +# B*'$,/+3$/'0 5&B$*,6 $* 4#B,#&6#4 B/$&$/*'69

:.6077.$+(/%0$4

N5O5:HG8? K5?!, ,ECG:=,@,E!A%#,# &,# B*6$6 &66*B/&$#4 8/$% $%# 7,*43B$6 &'4 6#,?/B#6 8# 36# #&B% 4&@ $%&$ =*6$ *5 36 B*'6/4#, *'.@V&F&,4*36 8&6$# /6 *'# 63B% B*6$9 H6 & +@D7,*43B$ *5 B*==#,B# &'4 /'436$,@C %&F&,4*36 8&6$# B&' %&?#'?/,*'=#'$&. &'4 %#&.$% B*'6#b3#'B#6 /5 '*$ B.*6#.@ =&'&0#4 &'4 B*=7#$#'$.@ %&'4.#49

8/4# ?&,/#$@ *5 B%#=/B&.6 63B% &6 6*.?#'$6 36#4 $* B.#&' =&B%/'#,@ &'4 +@D7,*43B$6 5,*= 7#6$/B/4# =&'35$3,/'09 "&6$#6 $%&$ #G%/+/$ B%&,&B$#,/6$/B6 63B% &6 /0'/$&+/./$@C B*,,*6/?#'#66C ,#&B$/?/$@C *, $*G/B/$@


17/2417

E.D A0#LM4 N(P(#+0"4 K(4/. =0$/#0* C#(7.D0#L>IH 4#6/0'&$#6 1C $%,*30% $%# 5#4#,&. )#6*3,B# 1*'6#,?&$/*' )#B*?#,@ HB$ X)1)HYC $* /=7.#=#'$ 7,*D0,&=6 $%&$ =&'&0# %&F&,4*36 8&6$# /' :#8 ;*,( -$&$#9 Q' &44/$/*' $* /663/'0 7#,=/$6C 1 6$&55 8*,( 8/$%B*=7&'/#6 $* /=7,*?# 7,*B#66#6 6* .#66 8&6$# /6 0#'#,&$#4C &'4 /'67#B$ 5&B/./$/#6 $* #'63,# $%&$ %&F&,4*36 80#'#,&$*,6C $,&'67*,$#,6C $,#&$=#'$C 6$*,&0#C &'4 4/67*6&. 5&B/./$/#6 &,# B*=7./&'$ 8/$% #'?/,*'=#'$&. &'4 73+%#&.$% ,#03.&$/*'69

2&B/./$/#6 ,#b3/,/'0 %&F&,4*36 8&6$# 7#,=/$6 ,&'0# 5,*= .&,0# B%#=/B&. =&'35&B$3,#,6 $* %*67/$&.6C 4,@ B.#&&'4 &3$* ,#7&/, 6%*769 >IH 4&$& /'4/B&$# $%&$ $%#,# 8#,# *?#, U_C]]] 7#,=/$$#4 %&F&,4*36 8&6$# 5&B/./$/#60#'#,&$*,6 /' :#8 ;*,( -$&$# /' U]TUC *5 8%/B% [36$ aRWC *, O9P`C ,#B#/?#4 /'67#B$/*'69 Q'67#B$/*' B*?#,&0#*5 $%/6 6=&.. 6B&.# &.. +3$ #'63,#6 $%&$ 6*=# &=*3'$ *5 %&F&,4*36 8&6$# 8/.. 0* =/6=&'&0#4C 7*66/+.@ 73$$

73+./B %#&.$% &$ ,/6(9 23,$%#,=*,#C 1 /'67#B$/*'6 4#B,#&6#4 TR` X5,*= WOR $* aRWY +#$8##' U]]W &'4 U]T1E6 $/'@ /'67#B$/*' ,&$# 0/?#6 ./$$.# ,#&6*' 5*, :#8 ;*,(#,6 $* +#./#?# $%# 6$&$# /6 &4#b3&$#.@ #'63,/'0 B*=D

7./&'B# &'4 7,*$#B$/'0 73+./B 6&5#$@ &'4 $%# #'?/,*'=#'$9

1E6 %&F&,4*36 8&6$# =&'&0#=#'$ 7,*0,&=6 .*6$ TUP 53.. $/=# 7*6/$/*'6 XTa` *5 $%#/, #=7.*@##6Y +#$8##'-2; U]]SD]a &'4 -2; U]TUDTO9 IH 4&$& /'4/B&$# $%&$ $%#,# 8#,# *?#, PC_]] *5 $%#6# .&,0#, 5&B/./$/#6 &'4 0#'#,&$*,6 *7#,&$/'0 /' :#8

?/*.&$/*'69

,$I0#6.7.$/ K0.4 A%# '3=+#, *5 5&B/./$/#6 /'67#B$#4 +@ 1 4#B,#&6#4 5,*= WOR /' U]]W $* aRW /' U]TU9 Q' &44/$/*' $* 5#8#,

X+@ OT` &'4 Ra` ,#67#B$/?#.@Y9 1 /6 /'67#B$/'0 %&F&,4*36 8&6$# 5&B/./$/#6 .#66 5,#b3#'$.@ &'4 /6 $3,'/'0 37

%&?# 6#,/*36.@ ?/*.&$#4 7#,=/$ B*'4/$/*'6 /' U]TU9

96%of hazardous wastefacilities went

uninspected in 2012


18/2418

1*'6/6$#'$ 8/$% %&F&,4*36 8&6$# ?/*.&$/*' ,&$#6C 1 #'5*,B#=#'$ &B$/*'6 &0&/'6$ 7#,=/$ ?/*.&$*,6 4#B./'#4 +#$8##' U]]W &'4 U]TU X2/03,#6 XaY &'4 XWYY9 f?#, $%/6 5*3, @#&, 67&'C 5&B/./$/#6 63+[#B$ $* #'5*,B#=#'$ &4#B./'#4 +@ OU` 5,*= _PO $* [36$ O]a *3$ *5 =*,# $%&' U_C]]] 7#,=/$ %*.4#,6 /' :#8 ;*,(9 2#8#, /'67#B$/*'6&,# .#&4/'0 $* 5#8#, ?/*.&$/*'6 3'B*?#,#4 &'4 5#8#, #'5*,B#=#'$ &B$/*'6 3'4#,$&(#'9 "%/.# >IH %&6 +##'B,/$/B&. *5 .*8 1 7#'&.$@ .#?#.6 /' $%# 7&6$C 7#'&.$/#6 &66#66#4 $* &.. %&F&,4*36 8&6$# 7#,=/$$#4 5&B/./$/

-$&55 ,#43B$/*'6 %&?# $&(#' $%#/, $*.. *' $%# 6$&$#E6 *?#,6/0%$ *5 .&,0# %&F&,4*36 8&6$# 5&B/./$/#6 &'4 0#'#

&6 8#..9 A%#6# 5&B/./$/#6C $&,0#$#4 +@ ,#03.&$*,6 +#B&36# *5 $%# .&,0# &=*3'$6 *5 %&F&,4*36 8&6$# $%#@*, %&'4.#C 8#,# &.,#&4@ ,#B#/?/'0 6B&'$ &$$#'$/*' /' U]]W 8%#' *'.@ UW] *3$ *5 =*,# $%&' PC_]] 7#,=/$ %*.4#,68#,# /'67#B$#49 HBB*,4/'0 $* >IHC 1 /'67#B$#4 TR` 5#8#, XU__ $*$&.Y *5 $%#6# .&,0# 5&B/./$/#6 /' U]TU9 "%/.

+*$% *5 $%#6# '3=+#,6 &,# .*8C B3$$/'0 /'67#B$/*'6 +@ TR` 53,$%#, 3'4#,=/'#6 1E6 &+/./$@ $* 7,*$#B$ $%# 73+./B 5,*= ?/*.&$/*'6 +@ 6*=# *5 $%# 6$&$#E6 +/00#6$ 7*$#'$/&. 7*..3$#,69 23,$%#, B*=7*3'4/'0 $%/6 .*8 /'67#B$/*',&$#C >IH 4&$& &.6* 6%*8 $%&$ ?/*.&$/*'6 +@ c&[*, 5&B/./$/#6 &'4 0#'#,&$*,6 5#.. +@ OR`C /'B.34/'0 & ST` 4,*

'),@1. GSI -#-9 )+3015(* .+301/.5.+6 (/6)0+%

Y%0*(/%0$5 ($+ .$G0#;.=.$/ (;/%0$5 @(E. +.;*%$.+ +#(=(/%;(**- G#0= LMMP /0 LMRLD C"/ ,2X ;0$S;.#$5 %$+%;(/. /@%5 %5 *%F.*- ( 5%&$ 0G E%0*(/%0$5 C.%$& =%55.+D $0/ 0G .(/.# ;0=B*%($;.


19/2419

:.6077.$+(/%0$4

:,38F5!G:A :GFF)5=Q?H,= ?.*I 5"+%/ 20*%6-1 ,#./#6 %#&?/.@ *' 5&B/./$/#6 6#.5D,#7*,$/'0 $%#/, #=/66/*' .#?#.6 $* 4#$#,=/'# B*=7./&'B# 8/$% #'?/,*'=#'$&..&869 A%/6 &,,&'0#=#'$ 7.&B#6 $%# *'36 *' 7#,=/$ %*.4#,6 $* ?*.3'$&,/.@ 4/6B.*6# ?/*.&$/*'6C 6*=# *5 8%/B% B&

+# B*6$.@ $* B*,,#B$9

H 7,/=# #G&=7.# *5 $%/6 4#7#'4#'B# *' ?*.3'$&,@ 4/6B.*63,# /6 $%#


20/2420

A0&"#/R1$+"6.+ =5CG :0**S(6L4Q' H3036$C U]TUC J*?#,'*, 13*=* &''*3'B#4 & 63/$# *5 7,*7*6&.6 8/$% $%# 73,7*,$#4 0*&. *5 %#.7/'0 0,*8 :#8;*,(E6 +3,0#*'/'0 @*03,$ /'436$,@9 f'# =&[*, 7,*7*6&. 8&6 & 8#&(#'/'0 *5 8&$#,D7,*$#B$/*' ,#03.&$/*'6 *'4&/,@ 1H2f6C *, 5&B$*,@ 5&,=69

H$ $%# $/=#C 1H2f6 8/$% 5#8#, $%&' U]] B*86 8#,# #G#=7$#4 5,*= -I- 7#,=/$ ,#b3/,#=#'$69 A%# J*?#,D

"%/.# $%/6 =&@ 6##= $* +# & 6=&.. ,#03.&$*,@ 6%/5$C UWW B*86 0#'#,&$# &6 =3B% 8&6$# #&B% 4&@ &6 &

I,/*, $* $%# 0*?#,'*,E6 4#B/6/*'C :#8 ;*,( %&4 7,*$#B$#4 8&$#, +*4/#6 5,*= 1H2f 7*..3$/*' +@ ,#b3/,/'05&B/./$/#6 8/$% =*,# $%&' U]] B*86 $* B*=7.@ 8/$% *'# *5 $8* 4/6$/'B$ 0#'#,&. 7#,=/$6^ *'# &3$%*,/F#4 3'4#,$%# -$&$#E6 4#.#0&$#4 1.#&' "&$#, HB$ &3$%*,/$@C &'4 *'# 3'4#, :#8 ;*,(E6 >'?/,*'=#'$&. 1*'6#,?&$/*' M&8X>1MY9 Q' #&,.@ U]TOC $%# 6$&$# #'4#4 $%# >1M 7#,=/$$/'0 ,#b3/,#=#'$ 5*, 4&/,@ 1H2f6 8/$% +#$8##' U]]DUWB*86C 8/$% $%# 6$&$#4 0*&. *5 ,#43B/'0 B*6$6 5*, $%#6# *7#,&$/*'6 &'4 $%#,#+@ 7,*=*$/'0 0,*8$% 8/$%/' $%# 4/'436$,@9

A%# 73,7*6# *5 $%# 7#,=/$6 /6 $* #'63,# 1H2f6 /=7.#=#'$ =&'3,# =&'&0#=#'$ 7,&B$/B#6 $%&$ 7,*$#B$ :#8;*,(E6 8&$#,8&@69 c&'3,# /'B,#&6#6 $%# &=*3'$ *5 '3$,/#'$6 X./(# 7%*67%*,36Y &'4 7&$%*0#'6 X./(# >9 B*./Y /'

6$,#&=6 &'4 ,/?#,69 "%#' '3$,/#'$ .#?#.6 ,#&B% & $/77/'0 7*/'$C $%#@ B&' $,/00#, ,&7/4 &.0 0,*8$% $%&$ 63B(6

(/..6 &'4 ?#0#$&$/*' 4/#D*559

I&$%*0#'6C *' $%# *$%#, %&'4C B&' .#&4 $* /..'#66 5*, &'@*'# 8%* B*=#6 /'$* B*'$&B$ 8/$% 7*..3$#4 8&$#,6C 7$/'0 &'0.#,6 &'4 68/==#,6 &$ ,/6(9 A%# =&/' 7#,=/$$/'0 ,#b3/,#=#'$ 36#4 $* 7,*$#B$ &0&/'6$ 63B% 8&$#, b3&./$@

$%# /'4/?/43&. B/,B3=6$&'B#6 *5 #&B% 1H2f9

>&B% B*8 7,*43B#6 TU] 7*3'46 *5 8#$ =&'3,#m4&@ *' &?#,&0#C $%# 6&=# &=*3'$ 7,*43B#4 +@ U]D_] 7#*7.#9

1:cI6 /'B.34# =&'3,# =&'&0#=#'$ &B$/*'6 $%&$ 8/.. (##7 $%# ,#.#&6# *5 =&'3,#C 8%#$%#, 4/,#B$ *, /'4/,#B$X63B% &6 8%#' %#&?@ ,&/' 8&6%#6 =&'3,# *3$ *5 B*'B#'$,&$/*' @&,46 &'4 /'$* '#&,+@ 6$,#&=6YC +#.*8 6#$ 0*

Q5 $%# B*6$6 *5 /=7.#=#'$/'0 $%#6# &B$/*'6 &,# '*$ +*,'# +@ $%# 5&B/./$@ &6 & B*6$ *5 +36/'#66C $%#@ &,# 7$* *$%#,6C 7#,%&76 /' $%# 5*,= *5 & 8&$#, +*4@ +#/'0 7.&B#4 *' & 1 /=7&/,=#'$ ./6$ 8%/B% ,#b3/,#6 B*6$.@ ,#$*,&$/*'9 Q' 6*=# B&6#6 /$ 8/.. +# $&G7&@#,6 8%* %&?# $* 7/B( 37 $%# $&+9 Q' *$%#,6C /$ 8/.. +# '#/0%+*,6 *, 46$,#&= 5&,=6 5*,B#4 $* ./?# 8/$% $%# /=7&B$6 *5 3'B*'$,*..#4 7*..3$/*'9

Z'4#, $%# '#8 ,#03.&$/*'6C $%# 1H2f *7#,&$*, /6 '* .*'0#, ,#67*'6/+.# 5*, 7,*7#,.@ =&'&0/'0 $%# 8&6$# 5*, &'&44/$/*'&. T]] B*86 $%,*30% & 1:cI9 Q=&0/'# 0/?/'0 & 6/=/.&, 7&66 $* & B&=70,*3'4 *8'#, 8%* 4*#6'E$ 8&'$$* (##7 $%# 8&6$# 5,*= UC]]]D_C]]] B&=7#,6 5,*= 8&6%/'0 /'$* & '#&,+@ 6$,#&= #?#,@ 4&@9

"%/.# $%#,# =&@ +# 6*=# 1H2f6 /' '##4 *5 B*=7./&'B# &66/6$&'B# *, ,#.&G#4 B*=7./&'B# 6B%#43.#6 /' *,4#, $*

5&B/./$/#6 B*'0,#0&$# &'/=&.6C 5##4C =&'3,#C 3,/'#C 4#&4 &'/=&.6C &'4 7,*43B$/*' *7#,&$/*'6 *' & 6=&.. .&'4 &,#


21/2421

A&(/'0 $%#6# 4/,$@ *7#,&$/*'6 e*55 $%# 0,/4g 6* $%#@ B&' #G7&'4 &+6#'$ -$&$# *?#,6/0%$ /6 & 43+/*36 $,&4#*8&$#, b3&./$@ 5*, J,##( @*03,$9 H +#$$#, &77,*&B% 8*3.4 +# $* 4#?#.*7 7,*0,&=6 $* %#.7 4&/,@ 1H2f6 0,*88%/.# 6$/.. =##$/'0 ?/$&. B.#&' 8&$#, 6$&'4&,46C '*$ [36$ .*8#,/'0 $%# 6$&'4&,46 &'4 %*7/'0 5*, $%# +#6$9

A%# 2/'&. >'?/,*'=#'$&. Q=7&B$ -$&$#=#'$ 5*, $%/6 ,#03.&$*,@ &$$&B( B.&/=6 $%&$ &.. 8/.. +# 8#.. +#B&36# *5#'5*,B#=#'$ 7,*?/6/*'6 &.,#&4@ B*'$&/'#4 /' $%# >1M9 A%#6# 7,*?/6/*'6 7,*%/+/$ 4/6B%&,0#6 $%&$ B&36# *, B*'D$,/+3$# $* e& B*'4/$/*' *5 B*'$,&?#'$/*'g *5 8&$#, b3&./$@ 6$&'4&,46C 0/?/'0 1 $%# &3$%*,/$@ $* +,/'0 #'5*,B#D=#'$ &B$/*'6 &5$#, $%# 8&$#,E6 b3&./$@ %&6 +##' B*=7,*=/6#49 A%# 6$&$#=#'$ 0*#6 *' $* &66#,$ $%&$ eQ' ./0

$%/6 7*$#'$/&. ./&+/./$@ /$ /6 #G7#B$#4 $%&$ 5&,=6 8*3.4 /'6$/$3$# 7,&B$/B#6 $%&$ 8*3.4 7,#?#'$ 4/6B%&,0#6 $/=7&/, 8&$#, b3&./$@9g

H'4 $%#,#/' ./#6 $%# 7,*+.#=9 H5$#, ./5$/'0 $%# >1M 7#,=/$ ,#b3/,#=#'$C $%# 0*?#,'*, %&6 .#5$ 8&$#, 7,*$#B$/*' $* D

&6 =*6$ 8&$#, 7*..3$/*' 7#,=/$6 4*C +3$ *' 7,#?#'$&$/?# 7,&B$/B#6 $%&$ 8%#' 7,*7#,.@ /=7.#=#'$#4 7,#?#'$ 8&6$#

5*, 5&B/./$/#6 8/$% 37 $* UWW B*8691 %&6 #./=/'&$#4 $%# '##4 5*, %3'4,#46 *5 1H2f6 $* %&?# 7#,=/$ B*?#,&0# 8/$%*3$ %&?/'0 4*'# &'@$%/'0$* #./=/'&$# $%#/, 7*$#'$/&. $* 7*..3$#9 A%# &4=/'/6$,&$/*' 7*/'$6 $* & 7*$.3B( *5 53'4/'0 /'B,#&6#6 5*, ?&,/*36

7,*0,&=6 *55#,/'0 '3$,/#'$ =&'&0#=#'$ &66/6$&'B# 5*, ?*.3'$&,@ 370,&4#6 /' ./#3 *5 7#,=/$6C +3$ $%# $8* &7D 7,*&B%#6 6%*3.4 '*$ +# =3$3&..@ #GB.36/?#9 "/$%*3$ & 7#,=/$ &'4 &66*B/&$#4 1:cI ,#b3/,#=#'$C $%#,# /6 '*#'5*,B#&+.# =#B%&'/6= $%&$ :#8 ;*,(#,6 B&' ,#.@ 37*' $* #'63,# $%&$ $%#6# 5&B/./$/#6 8/.. =&'&0# $%#/, =&'3,#/' & 8&@ $%&$ 7,*$#B$6 *3, 8&$#,8&@6 &'4 73+./B %#&.$%9

A%# &4=/'/6$,&$/*' =&4# & 4#B/6/*' $* B3$ B*6$6 5*, 7*..3$/'0 1H2f6 &'4 ,*.. $%# 4/B# 8/$% $%# #'?/,*'=#'$&.B*'6#b3#'B#6 $* '#/0%+*,/'0 B*==3'/$/#69 :*8%#,# /' $%# #'?/,*'=#'$&. /=7&B$ 6$&$#=#'$ 5*, $%# /'B,#&6#41H2f #G#=7$/*' $%,#6%*.4 4*#6 1 &,03# $%&$ 1H2f6 8/$% U]]DUWW B*86 4* '*$ %&?# $%# 7*$#'$/&. $* 6/0D


22/2422

=GE=F8?1GEH6 $%/6 ,#7*,$ B.#&,.@ 6%*86C :#8 ;*,(#,6 B&''*$ &55*,4 $%# 4*3+.#D#40#4 68*,4 *5 ,*../'0 +&B( 7,*$#B$/*'6 $*

6$&'4&,469

$%# %*,/F*'C 8%/B% B*3.4 =&(# & +&4 6/$3&$/*' #?#' 8*,6#9

A%# 5#4#,&. 0*?#,'=#'$E6 6#b3#6$#, /6 %&?/'0 &' /=7&B$ *' $%# 1 '*89 H'4 &$ $%# +#0/''/'0 *5 $%# +340#$/'0 7,*B#66 5*, -2; U]T_DTPC $%#,# 8#,# ,3=+./'06 $%&$ -$&$# &0#'B/#6 8#,# +#/'0 4/,#B$#4 $* .**( 5*, =*,# *7#,&D$/*'&. 6&?/'06C 7*66/+.@ $* $%# #G$#'$ *5 T]` B3$6 *?#, $%# '#G$ $8* @#&,69

23,$%#, B3$6 8*3.4 %&?# & 7,*5*3'4 /=7&B$ *' 1E6 &+/./$@ $* /'67#B$ 5&B/./$/#6C /663# ?/*.&$/*'6C &66#66 7$/#6C &'4 #'63,# B*=7./&'B# 8/$% %&,4D5*30%$ #'?/,*'=#'$&. .&86 $%&$ 7,*$#B$ *3, B*==3'/$/#6 &'4 %#&.$%9

13,,#'$.@C #'5*,B#=#'$ #55*,$6 &,# %#&?/.@ 8#/0%$#4 $*8&,46 $%# ,#?/#8 *5 7*..3$#,D7,*43B#4 B*=7./&'B# ,#7*,$

,#D#6$&+./6% &' #'5*,B#=#'$ 7,#6#'B# $%&$ B*=7#.6 B*=7./&'B#9

N3$ J*?#,'*, 13*=* %&6 & B%&'B# $* $3,' $%/6 6%/7 &,*3'49 Q' &44/$/*' $* $%# 0#'#,&. ,#B*==#'4&$/*'6 /'B.34D#4 &$ $%# +#0/''/'0 *5 $%/6 ,#7*,$C 43,/'0 $%# B*=/'0 @#&,C $%# J*?#,'*, 6%*3.4^


23/2423

,$+$0/.4

T9 %$$7^mm888U9#7&90*?m'3$,/#'$7*..3$/*'m%&,=53.D&.0&.D+.**=6

8/$% /'4/D ?/43&. -I- 7#,=/$69

88894#B9'@90*?m4*B6m8&$#,n745mU]TT&''3&.,7$9745

P9 >'?/,*'=#'$&. H4?*B&$#6 *5 :#8 ;*,(9 c344@/'0 $%# "&$#,^ A%# Z'('*8' 1*'6#b3#'B#6 *5 :#8 ;*,(E6 2&/.#4 "&$#,

R9 1f _DU]]WTTUODTP_

a9 Q49

W9 :;- '5*,B#=#'$ H''3&. )#7*,$ 5*, -2; U]TTmTU

T]9 Q4

TT9 >H:; '5*,B#=#'$ -3==&,@ U]T]9

UW9 %$$7^mm8889#7&D#B%*90*?m#B%*m6$&$#7#,5*,=&'B#mB*=7&,&$/?#n=&769%$=.

O]9 1 8&6 3'B**7#,&$/?# /' 7,*?/4/'0 6$&55 +,#&(4*8'6 +@ 4/?/6/*' &'4 +3,#&3

cH:ZHM9 :*?9 TWWa

OU9 :#8 ;*,( -$&$# H66#=+.@ H34/$ &'4 Q'?#6$/0&$/*' *5 '?/,*'=#'$&. H34/$ Q'B#'$/?# I*./B@

OR9 K&,#'


24/24

Enviro Advocates Study

Documents

Transcript of Enviro Advocates Study