EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using...

23
EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert C. Roback Los Alamos National Laboratory Larry Hull Idaho National Engineering and Environmental Laboratory Yemane Asmerom University of New Mexico
  • date post

    19-Dec-2015
  • Category

    Documents

  • view

    229
  • download

    0

Transcript of EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using...

Page 1: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at

INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park

Robert C. RobackLos Alamos National Laboratory

Larry HullIdaho National Engineering and Environmental

Laboratory

Yemane AsmeromUniversity of New Mexico

Page 2: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Environmental Issues

• At INEEL, organic, inorganic, and radioactive contaminants have entered the environment and are present in the vadose zone, for example:– Idaho Nuclear Technology and Engineering

Center (INTEC) – 90Sr– Radioactive Waste Management Complex

(RWMC) – U, Pu, solvents

Page 3: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Project Goals

• Improve conceptual models of contaminant migration through a thick, layered and fractured vadose zone

• Provide site-specific field-scale parameters for INEEL to better predict contaminant migration through the vadose zone

Results will have important applications at INEEL in assessing remedial actions and long-term stewardship and for understanding vadose zone flow and transport in general

Page 4: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Main Participants

• LANL: R. Roback – PI, P. Reimus and J. Sullivan, (field and lab tests), C. Jones (Dissertation project under R. Bowman NMT)

• INEEL: L. Hull – PI, T. McLing (field and lab tests) and collaborations with: C. Baker (hydrology), G. Heath (geophysics), L. Street (EM), S. Magnuson (EM) and many others

• UNM: Y. Asmerom – PI, E. Nichols (MS thesis under Asmerom)

Page 5: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

In-Kind Support and Collaborations

• Major investment by INEEL to install sampling and monitoring equipment

• Support from INEEL EM program through sampling and maintenance

• Collaborative studies:– geophysics (ERT array) through INEEL LDRD– monitoring and interpretation of hydraulic parameters

through INEEL– cooperation with INTEC personnel who control discharge

Page 6: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Research Site: INEEL – Vadose Zone Research Park

• Constructed to receive process water from INTEC operations

• Provides instrumentation and facilities to address vadose zone flow and transport

• Uncontaminated site with subsurface geology and hydrology very similar to those beneath INTEC and SDA

Page 7: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

THE VZRP• Located near

major facilities and sites with most pressing environmental management issues

• Similar subsurface geology and hydrology

• Proximal to Big Lost River

Page 8: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Subsurface Geology

Page 9: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

VZRP Arial View

Page 10: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Wells Along the Big Lost River

Page 11: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

The VZRP (cont.)

Page 12: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

VZRP Instrumentation• Monitoring Wells at infiltration ponds and BLR

– 5 in aquifer (525’)– 7 at alluvium/basalt contact (45’-50’)– 9 at top of sedimentary interbed (125’-130’)– 4 to depth of 250’

• Instrumented boreholes– Lysimeters– Gas sampling ports– Water content sensors, thermocouples, tensiometers

• ERT arrays- down hole and along surface

Page 13: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Instrumentation

Wells are completed with stainless steel wellboxes. At instrumented boreholes, data are collected automatically and communicated with INEEL computer network over radio link.

Gas and water sampling ports are equipped with quick connects to facilitate sampling.

Page 14: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Project Objectives

Simultaneously inject multiple tracers to investigate:

• Spatial and temporal transport of reactive and conservative tracers through vadose zone

• Migration of colloids through the vadose zone• Influence of degree of saturation, flow rate, flow

transients, and water chemistry on these processes• Interactions between vadose zone and saturated

zone

Page 15: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Methods• Examine tracer recovery for conservative, reactive and

colloid tracers– Use isotopically-tagged natural colloids?

• Examine natural U and Sr concentration and isotopics to provide element-specific transport parameters to contaminants of concern

• Evaluate spatial and temporal patterns in tracer recovery; compare these to hydraulic data from tensiometers, water levels, and geophysics

• Laboratory tests to provide transport parameters and comparison to field results

• Modeling of data

Page 16: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Some History

• Discharge to ponds was way ahead of schedule with steady inflow by August

• Sampling of first waters though INEEL EM; sampling at daily, then weekly, and now monthly intervals. Over 200 samples collected and most analyzed for anions, cation; subsets for O18 and D. Geophysical and hydraulic data collected and is being analyzed

• C. Jones joined project in August at NMT (Ph.D.); E. Nichols to begin in June at LANL then UNM (M.S.)

Page 17: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Discharge from INTEC

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

0 20 40 60 80 100

Time since test began (days)

Discharge (Mgal/day)

Average 1.53 Mgal/dayStd. Dev. 0.25 Mgal/dayMax 2.30 Mgal/dayMin 0.55 Mgal/day

S N S

Page 18: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Page 19: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Continuous Logging of Tensiometer Data

Well 204 Tensiometer Data - W of North Pond

-400

-200

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

5/24/2002 7/13/2002 9/1/2002 10/21/2002 12/10/2002 1/29/2003 3/20/2003 5/9/2003

Date

Presssure (cm H2O)

204-AT-045

204-AT-058

204-AT-063

204-AT-090

204-AT-103

204-AT-127

204-AT-148

204-AT-152

204-AT-157

204-AT-168

N pond 8/21 -8/25N pond 9/21 -10/4S pond 8/27 -9/20S pond 10/5 topresent

pulledPTs

pulledPTs

Page 20: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Chloride

0

40

80

120

160

0 14 28 42 56 70 84 98 112 126

Days

Cl (ppm)

MON-200-129.5'MON-202-125.2'MON-210-62.2'

MON-211-132.2'OUTFALL

pond switch

Page 21: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Sodium

0

25

50

75

100

125

150

175

200

-14 0 14 28 42 56 70 84 98 112 126

Days

Na (ppm)

MON-200-129.5'

MON-202-125.2'

MON-210-62.2'

MON-211-132.2'

OUTFALL

198-114'

198-126'

204-129'

N to S pond

Page 22: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Preliminary Findings

• Discharge pulse defined• Wells with differing response to conservative

tracer identified• Refinement of conceptual model

– Lateral flow along lithologic contacts

– Perched saturated zones, unsaturated zones

– Flow velocities

Information critical to plan upcoming tracer tests

Page 23: EMSP Workshop, 2003 LA-UR-03-3439 Field-Scale in situ Measurements of Vadose Zone Transport Using Multiple Tracers at INEEL Vadose Zone Research Park Robert.

EMSP Workshop, 2003LA-UR-03-3439

Future Plans• Summer and Fall 2003

– One to two tracer tests with conservative and reactive tracers to better understand system

– Sample core from VZRP boreholes for laboratory experiments

– Evaluate hydraulic and chemical data

• Future work– Additional tracer tests with different tracers and

colloids, potentially under induced gradients, and outside of ponds

– Tracer tests in BLR when (if) it flows– Laboratory experiments as dictated by initial tracer tests