7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 1/31

  +<*(;065

#,-694

A* *HE 1744 * ">, > >><>, > G>=> >

> $>, C==> = >, = =@

>> >> @@<, @ < F>

E> I>> <<= C<<. I $> < > >

< J> > < <<, G>=> @=> : K

< @ = > > > =>

<.N * I>> @=> ==>, > > @<:

> < = > <>> > C<<,

> =>>> > =>, < , < @>

. >>, , => @@<;

> > <. B , , = > > >>

> >@> >; > << > =,  

> > @@> > = .

= @> . < > @@< =< @

C<< $> >; > > << >,

, > = , >>, >> =>

<> > , >< < >, > > < >, , << > >=, @ <> =@<,

> >, , > ><<. * <<

>>. > < < > ,

<> @> . A> < > , ><=>  

> << > J> >, << >,

> = > << >, > = => =.

D> >> > >@> >; >, > , #<

F<, *5 %45 ?6 *9>7 . I > >>, ,

<>, >< @ > =< <<, >< > =  

@ >>. E> > >< @ << > >< < > < > >. I >

< > < @<=, <> <

F= I<=J> !>< I>> !><

>

01

I 0 /</ +<*0

/ 0, *0@,

*0=000,

**0<@

/ **<<+ 0,

>+ + >0+

/ <<

0. E+<*0

@ = /*<< 0+0@ +

/00* *@

*0@ < < 0

<=0= +00*

0@. I <0/

>+=0> >0/0 >/0*/

/ *0@

= 0 ,

+0 0 *0

0 + *0*

*0=0@,  

0, </ /0 >+,

+ *0<

0=0 0@.

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 2/31

<> > >= , = > <, @ >  

><, > >> <> >. * I>> < >

G>=> > > @ > << >

>< > ; , > >

< > .

A > @ > =, > @ >

>= < > << > <, << <>

< > <=> <. B >< >

= > @@@ >< >>. * >< >

< >=> @ > < < > <<

> > <@. * @ => @< <

<= << @ L = < > << >>, <, ==, >>,

> > << @> L > @< <>. *, > >

=@< @ >< =@; <, > @

>, =>= >< << >. E>  

#<= < , > > =,

A< E<-A> >, K > = >< .N * ’ >> #<= > >> > >

> <= << >< #<= @ = < > >

= << <.’ B > =@< << >< @ =

#<= . * <> #<= >< >>,

@< G # > *5 95 ?6 C?<<575 , < @@> #<=

> <, > < > #<= >= > <, > @>

< ><.

B $>’ > < @> @=>. A E<-A> @>

, K< I>> >@@@> > ><

=,N > >> > ><, K

>> @ < = = <><= > >.N

>=>< @: K > > @

>< > > > << @= = > << ><

> ?N * I>>, < #<= << =< @

< >, > <@ =< =>> >>; K <> @

>< = >> > < >.N *

> <> >: K > = @<

< >> @ @ = >,N

> = @@> > <<> > >=@ >< ><.

* >> @@ > > <> > =  

> > #<= <; > @> = > @

=> > @>. I @@ @> => (><> 

A< E<-A>, = H>J<<-*=, A> I=, A<

*, > A<JJ >), ==> > @@, @>> >

-=<, > @@<=> >> = =<. , >

> = > =>, > @@, > < @.

F><<, I > ==>> > > > >

<< = = @ > >=@ > =>><

.

I > > = <> .

02

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 3/31

#=000 H00

>> > = >< > > > =

= < I=< <-F > I>>>< I> I<=

* (III*) = > I<=J> !><’ @. # <

$>, <-F > << > => > =,

> > =@ << = =@< =@>> = >@>, < = #<= . *

@ = <> = > , > @

>@ > >=@, > <= > @

<@=> > >. > > > #<= > >

=@< =<-< > <, > >= > < .

* > @ < >=> @< <@=>

>< << =@ =< @ > << <<.

E> => >< >> @< >  

>@>> > > ><<< , < , @><

<, = H>J<<-*=, '’> >>  

K>> > ><N L K >=> , , <<, >< G.N

G> << = I<=J> !><’ @ ,

><> = >, > ? I =@> >  

. $ =@ = > @< > < =. < < >

@ @ > = > = <>> =

> <. #, > =@ = << = >

= > < = > >.

I>, I<=J> !><’ @ < @ = <

=@ <> =< ==’ L > > @<<

. I> >< @@ >, E<-A> @> :

> >>> >, @@ => < =< <-D> <-

A> > ! <-D> <-*> > > > > >

< = @ > I>< > CO A> > < >

<, <, @ > <->> 

= >= >< @>. H @> =

< > @<@. * > >

, > > => >< > >< @

> -> = > > < > << @>< > > =>>< > <. H =< > =@<  

>=>< @<@<’ >=> '> >

A = => <>> >

I<= <> > >. A< > , =@<>

> E@, < @<@< >=>, >

E><>=>, > > > =  

>< @> > >.

I> ==> > E<-A>, A> I= #== I<: K><

<, =<, >, < >

, << < ’, < >’ @>O <> <, > > << @.’N A<-F > << <<, ><> 

A<H= A<=>, * A<<>, #> A<-F< >

-F<0 + /0

*< <++

/ / +

+<*0 @,

+ +

0+ >/ / & *

>0/ 0 0*

<0 +

+0* **0,

> *0= /

 =< @ M<0

*00.

03

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 4/31

<> > =< <-D> <-A>, ! <-D> <-*>,

#== I<, #< B>>, #== A, A< > >=

> > =>>.

* = > =@ @ I<=9J9?> ?6 !>?<5475: 

G5>5< &9>39@<5 >4 ? &<> ( ? &<> ) @> >

>. * > << > > @< #<=: K

> <> <<, >> > @> @ => 

#<=N > K < #<= > <

<> , <> <<= > ==;N #<= K

> <;N > =< K ><<< >

=<< <> ==.N F’ = <<

. H < <’ =@> K< = >N

>=> >> > < > #<= .

I > > 1982, > @ ><< <> > ? 

&<> @< ( > > @< > 1989), > = @>>

. * ? &<> K =< > =<,N > > > #<= , K.N * 2003 A2 H=> D55<?@=5> 

5@?: B9<49>7 !>?<5475 ?395 , < K>< N K@<

N > K.N $ I= K =<<

> @ > > #<= >N K@.N *

<> < > @ <>.

A> @ ? &<> > > <> >>

=>>. * > > K>< =<,N

994  K > > N > >>

<< K<< N > K @<= #<= < =< >

=> <> < < I<=N ><< =>>. * => 69 > =< << I<= < >

> =>>, <> << > #<= < @@ > >  

>. =>>, > > @@ > < #<=; >

@@ > ><< #<=, > > > >

@ = >, > = => > >. #<= < <

@ =< => =>. A>, >

> @<< = .

H, => @<< : K @>@< I<=

=<.N I < > = > =< = < I<=. > = +> A<<, K

@>@< I<= > > I<=,N ? &<> =<< <

> > (= , > >>>> >), >  

><, > < (=> > > => = G, > => >

, <96, < >), > =>, >

><< =@<=> > <> > >. C<<<, =

> <<> = @ >< > =  

#<= >.

  <> > >=@ = > -

>> = > = < > => > ><> = > > >> <>>. *

@>@<’ < > > >< H>J<<-*=: K>’ >

04

I/0 /  

0< / *<<0=@ 

0= / +00* 0*<

/ +<*0

0 M<0 *<0

*/0*.

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 5/31

> => =@> @= > =< ( <<

>>< = > <) > < > =

>> > > ><?N H>J<<-*=

> = '’> << < >=@ ,

=@< > @<@ > , =@ K><N

@@ >< @> > >. H @<@

 > G => >> = K#><N

KI><N >>. G K > =  

#><’ <- >< >< =<=,N @<

K => < > > > <’; ,

>> > > I><’ = >> >

> <<< @@ , >- @@, =, >

<.N I> , > =< << >< ’

@<< > > @@ << < > .

* @>@<’ @ > >< = =@ >

> =<@<.’

? &<> => > < @>. F = >>>  <, @>@<,’ =>>, > > ,’

> > @,’ > #<= < > 

@> > >.

<= > ? &<> =@ > > @ A>,

> = E<-A>: K >’ >> >> >< ><?N

* > @ ? &<>, @ <, > ><

> @ #<= < =>>; =>>< ==

>< I<=.’ I<=J>’ @ > >-

>>’ > =>>’; > I<=J> ><’ @>

@ K< , >= > <= @@ <>.N *? &<> @@ => >=@ @<> <

> > < I<= > L ><< L > . #<= <

=, , > > (>) K>< > @ I<=

< <=>>, =>>, >@>, > @> =@>>

< I<= > < . * <> @<@ I<=

> = > @<> > =>. A > >

= @<> > < I<= = => >

> < = <J.N * =>@> : <

> >< @ > >=@ ,

@<> < > >> @=, > <>@> >< > <. * ? &<> < = > ><

<< =@< > > >> I<=J> <>

@. B E<-A> @> @<= < > >: K @ >

>< > > >>, >> >> @ >

= ><.N #, @ =@ > >> ><,

I<=J>’ >, H>J<<-*= , K<< @@ ><@< >

@ </< =.N A>, H>J<<-*=

, K I<=J>’ = > >>>

> >< = < < @ @ I<=>’N L

@ >> #<= < ?

* < I<= ? &<> < @>> > <>

>. I < < @ > >>

05

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 6/31

> > L >, > > , @> = > >

=> =. * > ><> , > =

>>> @. @ @> >

> L => @ L > >

@ > > @<=. A H>J<<-*= >, K

><<< I<= @@< = >=>< > ><,

, < > . I < <> > I<=

>< =.N < @ > << , <<= > =>=

> -=>. H, ? &<> @> 5 <’ ><

>, => < @, < > = > > <<

L > @<< , -, >@ > >@ >

>>< . * >> < H>J<<-*=’ >, <

> #< B>> K << <J>< >@’

(@<< > #<= ) > , > >=>

>> @ > > => <> I<=

<>’ < > =>> < > @>@<

<> > >, ->@ > @@< >

>=@ <.N > = < > >> => > >< >> #<= I<= , @<< = @ I<=,

> > > =@< <> << << ( <= < <<

@<=, ’). < < > >> > <

<>,’ > @@ >> =>

@>’ > @< = > >.

H > > , > => <> >

@<=, << << A< *. * < >=>

=, * @ > > > >

@<> < > L @<= > #<= <<

. A * << , K> > > < > =>, ><< > @<@, => > < >. I

> @<= > => >< = @== >

#<= > < > .N , = > @

<< > @ K << > @@ =

=> > @=> > >N L > > >< >

< > >.

> < >< > >< > @>@<

? &<>, ><<< , > = = >

>>> >< @, =>> > > >=@.

$/ F0* K>+

!>< > < >=< <. !>< > @ >

=; < = > = > =@> < >

< > @. * => ><,’ >

> > @<>, @ > <. <

> < < > >< < > @> =@< @<>

> >< =. * < =@=>< @’> =,’ <’ > >@<,’ <>’ > @<,’ <’ >

’ > > = > >< =; , >>

06

B0 >/

0<+ >/ /

*+ '*0=000

<*@’

(0*<@ >0/0

M<0 *00) /

+/ > 0+,

+ / **0

+*@

/0 * /

*/0= /

'+ I0*

*0=000’ <0 @ 

/0 / 0+

00 /> /

 =< + 0*0

>/0*/ = 0 <*/

*0=000 *

>+, -0+

+ 0+ 0 /

*@ >+.

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 7/31

> > @< < <’ >

>>, =>, >< > << .’ E =

@<> = > @< << >; > >

@ > >. #> @<>, > >

>> =, > > < @, <,

>@< > = @>. G@ @=>> > 

> > >> >, E@> ’ >

@ @>> <>< @ > A > A > > <<>  

> = > <>. * => > ><

> E@ > >@<. < >> >@<

= @> ><>< @  

E@, < > > << ><,

> E@. * >> H, > => >>>

= = = >> , @ << @

> => H E@ > +>< H L  

<< < > <> = ><< < >

E@> =>. @<>, ><=,

@<, @<< > > >=, = E><>=>, = > =< <. A<< @<> <@ >

><<< , > < < @< @<, =<, =>< >

><<< @<= >. @<>, << >

=: @@ < . * > << >= <<

@<>. = @<> @ > @

<, > > @=>

> =, > => ><< <

> > > @@ =. A I > <, K >

C > > > < > < < < =

><< = > @< : @> > C >

> > > < => > >< @> =>> < @ =. D@<> <

> C: = > > > > > = <’

<< > > <@ > > @ < >

<< =<.N A , @<> > >= > >

=>> << > < > > <>. I <

@> >, ? &<> < @<, => @<> <<

=>> #<= <.

* @ = @<> > @@. F,

@<> > >< @> @= ><, < 4939@<9>5 L , @> > . * @=, I>> > > "<, K

@<>> <> <=> , >> > > ><,

> > = @@>, > <> >. * = @<>

@<> < L > >< > > <= >

>= >’ > < >= @> =,

, > @> > =@< >><

< B> > I#F, < < <@> > L >

><<<, <, <<, >= >>> = =>

>< @@ , @ >>=, =

@=, > >< <.N

>, <> . * = =>> > <=

@ > @>: < . * > > ;

07

$/ 0+ / 0@ 0

*0+

'/@0*’ +

'*/0@,’ '*0@’

+ '/@,’

'00’ + '00*,’

'>’ + '/0*’ 0

+

*0= + <0=

0; /, 0 0

*<*0 +0+

**+0 />

0*< *<<

'0@’ + /> 0

<++,

, * +

<< / 0 '<

/.’ E*/ *+0*

+0*00 / +

>0/0 0*< 

*<< *; +*/ / 0 >

*00* /0@ /

+0 0 *<.

>/ / *  

< + C 0

=@ *0@ + > 0

/ >+ +

0 /0 <0=0@ 

< / > +

+0* /

*<< / /

+<*+ /.

D0*00 0

< + C.

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 8/31

= > @> > > > = @<>. A

@<> <@ > >>< = > = <,

@@ > , = > >< @ <<

>>. A , = == > > < >

<> > <. > ? &<> @,

<>> >> >>.’ $ >

<<>.’ I = >Q = <, >

@ =: @ >=> < > @<

<< <<,’ @< >> >, =@> @ > =, <

@> < > = >< < > <>.

*, = @<> @ <= @: @

>. * < @ , < << = > =@>,

> < > >= =< ( << ><), =< @

(> @ > @<> > <<> =< = +), >

><< < ( < >< =>

I>>). , > @ >. * > , =@<,

=, @, <> > < ; = > => ; <,> > ==>; >, == > >;

= @>; < > => =>. A=

@<> @ <>, << > >< <= >> >@.

* >>-> < > <> =@< @ >>

@<> @<> > > >R => <<

@@>> I<= > #<= L < @.

* @ = @<> < @; > > 

> > @ > > = > < @ =

L => @<> . G> @ = => ><

> @<> , @ < @, < , >> <=< > ==>> K< > <<> >

<, @> < >N E<-A> . E>

= =@ <<>’ << > @ > < >=> >

=>< #<= <. < <<>’ >? A H>J<<-

*= @<<< K > < @>< =>, < >

> # > 535<<5>  =>, >< ==  

#N; <<> > =@< @>< = =>

<< > > =@<> >< <<> =>

, > =< > <=< @< =>>. * >

= < @ = > = < < >@><, @< > @<< > << .’ E>

> <<>,’ > > @<> < >, <<

>@<> < > #<= <; > > > >>

=@< @ =>> . E , >

H>J<<-*= > << K=<>N #<= .

* @<= > >> = > > #<=

> =@< K < = =< > <<< ><N

> K@@ =<->= <,N H>J<<-

*= L <J> ? &<>. * @<= < >

=@> K< = =<N << > @= L 5  @=, << < <> < @<>. > >>

<< > << < = =<’ >

08

 A +0*00

+=+ +

00+ +

@ / *<<,

<+ @ 

<0=00

=@>/, /@ 

* 0

/

**0<. A <*/,

<*/ / 0+0

+ << /

+@ *0+

@ / >

>+=0>.

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 9/31

> =, > @=. E> >, @@

= << > @@, @= > @<>

> = . F << =@> > << <

<< > = @<>.

A @< =@< << = > => < <.

C> >>> > @<> >. I < >=>

=> > <<-=>> = > < . B >

@@; -= <@=>,’ @< < = <>

=@> > = >>-> >>, > <:

>-<@, <@>, =>’ ( = @< <=),

<@, < <@. I>, <@=> > > < > >

> >>-> @@< > >. *> >@<, =  

< >=> <>< >@, @< >> < 

< >@<,’ @=> >@<,’ < >@<’ L

>, >< << >> >@<.’ , =

> =@> @<> => > > @ << @=

@> > @>< @@< , >@< < =>@<>. * > >@< > => A=J> L

< > <> > < @> D$A ,

> > ==>, > > > <>

> = L =@< => << <>< =@> >

<< @ @<> < > <<. #> >@<

@>, <@ <@ <<< > @

< < => =.’

* => > > #<= = = @> >

=>. I =@>>: > >><

@ => >< = L =@< @<>, >>,> @ L > > <; > @ <> @=  

>< =>, > > , < > >  

I<= > = => > < @@> >

<>> > >=>.

* > > @= > =@< #<= >>. I>, > >=

<, > E, > >> =>> @= L > >

>> @ L > <<> = => @= >

> @<< > > >>=> >

@<> < > >>. C> > >=@ >, > <> @ > >< > >>> >=> <

> > =>.

$/ C@ C

=, >, -> . B > > @>;

@@> > > < > @ =>>< =

> @<. * < > << > >< ? &<>

@. I = = << > = >>>. * <

@= A= <> < > >=> @ C>,I> > BJ<, > -=> (>> BIC >).

>>> = > = @<> =<, > >

09

$/ 0 

+<*0 0 M<0

*00 ... / >0* *:

+*<* /

+000 >  

/ + >+

@ * >0/

0 +0*00,

00<0, +

* + 0

> >+=0>; +

+<* 0=

+0  

>+ 0,/ 0 **<

/ /00, *0

+ +00 I

+

/< + =<

+ *00  

>/ *0<

0 + 0

+=*.

I++, >0 

< */,

& + E, >

<00 /

+0 +0

+ /* / +00 > / & +

*0 /<

+0 / *0+ 

/ +0=0@ +

<0@ < *00

+ / +  

/ =0 +

>/ 0

*0+0.

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 10/31

<. * @< >= = > >; > >

@> < @@<> =<> < <

@> >> ><. E>= > = > >

=. A @< > =@ > , > <

*= ’ C@9< 9> 5 *5>-F9 C5>  ><

>> > >= @. D<@=> < > . I> <

=@, G@ > . I> , > > @’ > =

L , @< >>, > <>@, =, >>=>,

>> > > > @. E@=<<<,

E><>=> #>, > < >, <. * <

=> >< > @=  

> <. #>, > >@  

@, >, > <@=>, >= @<> >

J> L <= > = > =@<. * =>

=>’ @< =@< > >> @<> <: => > =@

> E’ =@ = >> > > <<

@ L <> >@ A>@>, > << @ =

= = > => > << =@ > E’=. * >> @=>=, > > =@  

=>, < > . I =@ > < <= <

=>> <, >> > . < > << G>

$, @> << <= G> * <>; > >

> = =@<=. => <<J <<<> 

> > >> < < > =>< @-

<; > > > > = =

>< > ’ <. * > @ <<>

<<> >- < ><< =

, > <, @<< >> > =’ >

@> =@, <<>< ><<>, > <, >> . E> >@ =<<<=, > =>

> @=>, = << > > > > >>  

@. I > > > . B<<, << > L =>,

@=>, <<>, =<<<= L @< <<=, <= >

> =>> > < > > > > >. *

C> > I> @@ = > > <. * < @=,

> >>< , << @ << ’ R

, > << <, << > ><<< =>>, > <=

#<= . * < > . I>, <<> >. I @ >= <@=> < . *

>, =@<, < @<. * @> @  

=@ >> < L @ #’ <. A

= @> > = =@> @ > << =@ @ =>

> =>. I 36 =@ >= <, 13 =@ =>

>=, > > > >= =@@ > . * >

 = D @> > >= >.’ A < =

= > = <<, = = > = >>>. I>,

< < > - > ><, @,

==>, >>, @>, >>, >>< >>

*, F, I>=, -=<, -<, >> >@, =< @>,, >>>, > <. G<< <> >>< 24- >.

> > > > = = =@<. # @<=

10

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 11/31

<< > >, >> >, >> > >

>>=> <> >, > < =@<. * >> 

=@< > >=’ <> @<= > , > 

@>= ( E< @= =>) > => @

> <<, >> <, >< << >>. C=@<

><< @<=’ L , < > @<= >

< @< >>> @<= > <> . A

=@< = => @> <<< >>>; @<=

><> >> < <> <; > >= @

><< . C>> = >=.

I >< > =@< =, << >> > @>> 

@ >, > @ > < .

>>< > > @ >> = =

<,’ <> @<< >, < >, @>=, = =>  

, E@> >’ < <= >, =

>> @ > > > > =<’ @R

E<, I > <> > >> = L

> > =@<, >> > ( 3C) L @>=< =.’

* >> =@ >=< @=

> <<@>. H, <

>< >>>< >> @> ><, @<>

, > >> > @ > > @= . F >

= =>><, @ @= @’ L

> > > >=<’ @=.

A =@<, >>> < > >, > @@ >

>< > > L > @>@<’ ? &<>: >  ><.’ B > @= >><< >< > =<< >

=<< < =>: > @ = < >, < >

< = =>, => = ; > @<>

> < > @ > - =@=>, << >

@ > . E @<> = @ >=> ><

< =@< @<=, >>> @<= > >.

G , CE < A= A > > (> >>>< >>

500 ><<<, , > > << <, I =

F<<), > = >< @> > >

K> > 1914 #< * F > => @.N K#> <,> >,N , K >>< > >=>

< =><, >J>< > <, <> >=>

=> < >=< < <>>. * @< @@

> = << >.N *, K <

> @@> > >> > @= > > >

< < > = > =>N; > K

@> > = > > >@ > =< > >

=@<=> = @< @@> => @>< => <<

><@ > >< > > =.N

* < > > > =’ > => <@ > >@=. I> < >, > > < A= A >

>, @> > @<= >< @>:

11

 A *,

0**+ >+<0 0+,

<00+ *0=

>+ +

+<*0.

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 12/31

>> > >> > > @<> @>.

* >> @<> > =@=>, >

> @ < @>@< > @>=>. I <= @<<,

<, >= > @<< => > > @,

> > , > =<@< < > < @>

==> << => >. @>, < >

>> > @< =>> < <

=>== > > >> =>>. #

>= = @ >> < > > < <

> << > > >< > >< >

>< ><>@ > >=, @<<, <

> @<< =>> <. * >> = >

><< >@ >< =, > @= <

> <> >< >> >=< <=-> 

==> > @@< > =>. I> <, = L >

< > >< L < << > > <<

> < = > > @ @@ > ><

<>@. #, >= > < >>-=>J @  => , << @@< > =>, <  

> > < < > >>,

@> > 80% < = A= =. D> >

=>> < >> < > = @> > <

>. D@<> > >@< > >’ >>;

< > > @ >> >

> @< @< <@=> > > >.

* > #<= > > = < >, >>

= <<> @>=< = K =@>> > <>

> @<> @>@< > @<J >< <@ @< > @<>.N * < >@, , <

> < =@< > > > =< >@>> K<<

= < > > > @< >>=>; < =@<  

= >> > ><>@ > => >, >>

> <; > @<< =@< > > >

, <>, , >, , >>, > =@< >>

><< = > @>< > << < .N

@<=’ => > @@ =@ >>>>

> ( > >’), =<-=>>< @<<, >=,

<<, < > << <<> >>> <<, > (>  =>’); > << <> >@>> < > ,

< > (> <’). @>@<, =

=>< ? &<> K=<,N > ><

>> @>=< = > < << =>.

A> =@ >< @> > =, >

> I<= > <, >><< ><. *

@>@< > << > #<=’ #<= ’ > <  

=>. #, >< << = => >

>< >> @@< > > = =>, @=>=,

<=, @=, >=, =<= > ><= > >= =’ > @<. H=> >

@@<. <, >=, @<< > << >> >

12

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 13/31

= > >, > , < <J > <.

@ >< > >< >>> > = >

> < < < @= > @>@< > ><

<, =@ >@>> >, > =>,

@= > , > @ > >> <. H>J<<-*=

> >>< =@J K< >N > > K <

<> > > = >< >.N

A> =>>< =@ > >< = >< > > ><

L => > < >< > >. H>J<<-*=

@ >> K @ -=@ > @@< >

< > > => > >N < @> >-

=> K =@ > > > >< =

>< > >@< > > #<=

.N A 20 == >J> I<= C>>

> > @> >< >-> << >

> = 1996-2003. * 0.34 @> =

@. E<-A> K > > >< << <<> =.N I= @> = A K@=@ =

> > > >< @? *

>: < => > &D > >

@ > > ><?N H =

< K> = < > @@> = @<

>.N

* = @> = > > ><. A I B<>

@> < > , > > ><, K << ,

@ => N > =. I K><

=N; > > =>> >> = << . B > >> >> > @<@ >> >

>@ > < , > > > >@.

> , > =>>< > >,

> > > , > #<= . > >

> ><< <, #<= >> @< > @ > @> => .

#, @> > = @ ><,

<< >< >, * >, K>>< @ >

= <, > > <> > = > >>, => > >. *

@@ = >> <> (>), >< > ,

= > >>. I> =, @@ @ > >> , > > @>> < @@> >@>>.N A

<, > > ><, > , < >

> > = @@ F >@<.’ I, K#<=

< > >< =< ,N H>J<<-*= , >

< > @<> =< > < >> > >

><< >? I>> >< < = << > < >

=@> @ > = >. H < =>><<

@= > >, => < < <<> > > ><

>=> @>@<?

* > < > => > < @ = ><< > K = < <<

> = ><<< < I<=, < < > <

13

& << >+

@ *<0

<++0 

+ *0=

*0 0 / >+

<

*0 0*0 /

0 >+

>0/ < */0/+

 =<, /0 /

0++*  

*0, <0

/<0@,

<0@ + <0*, +

= + /*

0. $/0 0 >/

H-$/ 0

0 >/ /

*@ /0

/00* +<*0

+ 00 / >/<+ 0 <

+<*0 0

<0= .

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 14/31

=@ > <@ = > = < >

(=>< > ).N B ><<< < I<= > :

> > > << @ >> < >

=> >. > > >. H, >

> > << I<= = L > , I=

>, K > B <-H= G<> A I<= >

@<@ =>> > < @ ><

> @<@->’ =@> > @= ><<<

@<>N << @ > @, >

> < > - > @ > >

< > << =@<>. << > @<=,

@<< @<< > . B >> < <<

> <> @<< > > I<= > = > @

>> < <> @= > << > > <<

<. B > <> =, > < >, ,  

> >=@ <> , >, I=

> , > @> = <=.

$ @= > = >; > @< > @=

>< > <. = > > .

> > = > <. > > @:

> > @= > @ > <<> > < >R K#

>< > >-@<> > -@<> ,N

E<-A> : K= >, AJ> +, @=>>

>> @<> ( <> A>@< < >

> => @<>; > <, <, @,

, .). = > > > , > @<>

<, > > << .N H, > << >

=> < @<>, >> < >> > ><, > << > =<. K$ >< , -

@<> < > . $ > > = << >

@ > =, < <> << =< @<>. *

=@< => -@<> > @<>, < <> <

@<> =@< @< >. B >

@<>, > >> = = >< =@>

> << <> @<> > >> < > = >

=. , < < #>< > > *

< >>.N < @= <> > <

> <@ > >< = =>> @= L > <= << >> > = >>< . @ = < > >

=<->>< =. * > = << >< > =

>--> .

$/ "<0 L<

> => < , > <

. * >< = <>.

"> < <>, , @ > > >

><. I > >@< @ < <, > < >< > , @ @@> <

> , > > < > . , <> << =

14

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 15/31

> > < > =>@> =>>>. ">

@=>> < <; > < <, <> , < <

<< , @ =>>. K"> < =J  

<< > ,N >>, K < > > , >

> = @; > > =< >

< > >= .N " > < > ,

FJ I><, <> <, < >, @> < > @@. B

<>@ > <> > < > >, > > >,

> >=. A I > <:

* < > > > @ ><  

> > > <> > =<@< =>>. A> , <

<>, < > @ > <<

@, >, @, @, << > > > 

> > < @@<> <.

* = =@< =, = @< > <@.

* = > = @< @, @>, @<>  <>>, << > @ > <, > <@

> <> > > => =<. A >

> > @< <> > =>> > @

> =>= < <<. C=@< =>

>, > >, =>> > >>

> @ =<><. A > =>> > =@<>

<> > <@ > ><< < > <

=@<>, > =@ @@.

> @ > <>: >>

, > > =>. , H>J<<-*= @ , K> @< > =<<> << =>< @

>> > <> > > >@.N >

> >@ = > > >, =>> >

> =>> = = K > > > =>@<

<< <<.N > => > @=

<@=> K <> > >> =>< > > <<  

@>,N K => > < <> < =.N

A <, > =>< << <@ < I<=,’

> >>> > . I>, > > = > I<= >’ K = >=@ <

> >>, => > @<< , >>>< <>, > >=

,N @ I<= <<> <. * >

@@ < > > = < < '’> L I<>,

D>=, > > +! L < > >

<= > @=@ > < <.

* > @> < ,

< . I = =’ @ =, >>,

<J>, ->>> >=>? * >, >

H>J<<-*=, K G<> #>, = > @@>’> > >. A , > <> ’ >N?

15

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 16/31

H>J<<-*= >< @ < = > > <

= >:

1. 56?= > < . I , =@<, > +..-I<= <

F= @@ H E> = > A <,’ ->>

B> > +.. <> I<= < > ';

> > >> > = > I<= E>,’ < C>  

I<= , +> C=, 9-10 A@<, 2011. I = >

@><< > >>> ( ><) > >@  

=> = <, > <>, @ =

>< >= >.

2. 53?>6979?> > =<<>, >, >> @.

* >< > =@> <<>, =@< > >

= >> > = < >

@<= ==> = >< > >

= > => #<= . H, < >

> > >< 539>7  < 59<9J9?> >> > <.

3. 59<9J9?>, = (<> K=N) > A<H= A.

A<=>’ >< @@ 59<9J9>7 H975 E439?> 9> 5 #<9= 

?<4  (III* F 2007) > > > @@ = .

<J> ><, > I=, K> I<=

>< > .N

4. 599?>, = > 2002 A2 H=> D55<?@=5> 5@? ,

<< K< > > = > A <N > K

@= > = @>-A <<.N

5. 5-5>99?>9>7 > 599?>9>7 , > ->>> F:

D= CJ>@ E> > I<= E>,’ @@ @>

< = (G> +> > !.+. ">) >><

>> <@ E> G B> $ C<<

, 30 #-1 A@<, 2012. * > > >< > -

<>, < @><< @ >>> >

>=, = = > >< < -=>>  

< > @, ><> > >=><

<< @=, = < > > ><

><< @ =>= >, ( > ><>=) => >< <>

>>=> . I < > > =

> , =@< = 99?>9>7 L >

L >=<< .

6. 59>5>9>7 , < > 2012 >>>< >> > #:

>>> H E>,’ > >

#<= > > < >>>.’

7. 575>59?>, = > > > < <’ > <=,’

> > @<>>> <@> > >> ==>.

16

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 17/31

8. *>6?=9?>, = << >

>< < <> <<, < > < <

> > D< F. E<=> > 1999 *=@<> " > <>

> < A >< * C=> *>=> #<= <.’

9. 5?<9?>, = = < > > >

< == > <> >. A > < >

+>959 ?<4 $5 @: A > = < => A

> I<= > > >> >>>< > >

> <>.’

A<< = = @@ @< , @ > >

>>>, > @<=. F @<= > <

’ > >> >< .’ F @

>’ > >: <=

>= . > H>J<<-*= K> >

>@ = > > >,N => K>N?

> >? C> @> => > >’ > ?H >’ => > >? C> @> >

>< >’ > > > > > > <

><’ =>>?

'> = . B =>

>> > < @>>> > @@< >’ (>

>> = > <> > >>) > > @<

>< >’ >. #> > #<= > >

> I<=,’ > >> ><’ @= , >

@ << @@. I>, > @ ’

>’ > > << >@> => #<= > >- >. A H>J<<-*= @<>, K>N > KN

>> > >< =>> K>N > E>< K.N

K* = = G 5>9? > >< =>> >

>< ,’ , =@ ( >’) => =

,’ > .N @ : K @

> > < =>>, < >< => > @<

, > > >, > <> > >>, >, > >,

> > =.N

* < < <> > K>N > K><.N * ><, > G>, K> > >.N A > >> @ L

> K=@<N << @> < >> >< @>@< L

> < K><.N KI << ,N H>J<<-*=, K @

I>-E@> < E>< =, =<, > ><.’

* @ > "> 9=@< , ><.’ * =@<’ @> ><’ >

@>, @> < =,’ =< < (@:

*9 2?5 <<, ? 9>5 ?> 5<6 25 5  ). =@< < = <

> > => >.N A> >< @> > >

> > (< > >) =@

<= ?9 , >< C. * >> <

@>@< > < > >>, I<= >> => > <96, >’ @>’ G.

17

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 18/31

* << = > << >> I<= <<

< <= @= < > @=> L > =

= >> @<<. * >< F> >> < >  

> > = @< = > < =  

, => > =>, > >. #> I<=

==>, > > I<= > <<-=> <, < >

< = << > >, <> @@, @<< >

> <. <= << > @= > @>,

@@> > >>, > > > > =

> >< < <. B = @<= >

, > @=>=, > << >> >

@ =>>. K = > <

= > <,N > H>J<<-*=, = <

K @>< @ > <= < << < =>>.N

I>, H>J<<-*= @ > =@> < =

<< > = :

945>9 = 92<9= > 539>9= , 4959 = 4999?>, > >9 (>

) = >96?=9 > > =?>?-3<< 

= < > =@> >9<5< >9@?< < >

<=< > <> @< <J>< >399=  > <<

9= . A = = > > ?9 > <>

< => < = ?99>9= =@ >

=> =<> =@> ; > > 2?<5  >

=< = >> > 2?<9= < << >.

* @ > > 3?==>9 = 3?==><9= 

(? 3?==>99>9=) , 5<9?>9@  = 5<99=, > 9>4994<9  =

9>4994<9= > ?<9@9=; > > 53<9=  > < >

=>< < < > @< > 53<9 >

@< > < = > <<

=>.

=<<, < 9>4994<9 > > >< 9>4994<9= ,

=> > @> > > > > >

> >< . * @> ><, >> 

= > <> > @> @>< >>

=> >, > > @@> > ==>. '

>, > > >>< < >=, >= > >>, >> >< <> >< @><

> > > = => >> > <> ==>.

C?==><9=  << < @ >< ><=, <> 

3?==>9 << @ > > >< < @>

< > < <> >< > > = @>

<< .

* > @>@< > <>> =>> =, E<-A> ,

< <>; > < ==, '’> << ,

> > > < > > >> *

> << > << < <><. B > @>=<>>, >> < <=; , >>  

>> L ><< @@< >-<< => D><

18

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 19/31

=< L >> >>, >> >>> > >>> >>> ( =

<< +>). > < > > =<@< @@

> >> L > = > <<

> >>R #, = = @@ < > >

=> L > , >> >>. B > <=>  

>> = <. > <> @> > >

> = @@. * < >> > <>

> =@=, H>J<<-*= > << >>

=@> <> =>: K = << >> > >

'’> > ( > > <-GJ<’ >@ <> =>

< => ) @=< < > > @ =>>

<< =@= > > > @@< > @< > =,

= #<=’ (> <) #<= <> >

>< > @< , < > > ><=.N

A> < = = >< > >>.

F @ L ><> => >< I<= =

<96, =>, > >= > =>> ,99<, J<= , >, . L << = @<< '’> >  

> > . << > =@< ><=> = >

, =@< <> , <<> >>> K> >

>,’ @< << > @< ->, =<

>>, >=>, > >=> <,N H>J<<-*= @ .

> = = @<<, ->> >> ><> 

> >, @@ > @>. I =@ = >

(<) , @@ > @> >< > <>

=@< @<=; > > @@ ,’ >@<<,

@>, > = >@<> , >><@> > =>><< > .’ A H>J<<-*=

>, K@<< >> > <>@. A> I > ’ =@>

=@J > >< @> < <>>, ->> 

<>> .N <<, << > <, >  

><> >> > = >>< >>.

C+0*0 + D0

I @< @> > > < < >@<= >>> = >, > <

>=>< = >>< > @>< >>

> > =>, > >, < > >==. * =

< > >< > > > , < =< >

>. > > > =>, =@<, @> <

<> @@ L > @>, > > .

<, =@<, = > >< @=, >> > #<=

, => > < >; H>J<<-

*=, K @ > = @,’ ><=,’

<=’ > =>,’ > << => >  

=< >@, => = > = = @=<’ > @>’ >.N B = = > ><

=> > >, >=> << > >,

19

<0+ 0+

**< > 

=000 / -

/0/ +<*0, > +

= / <+

+0*/0 >/0*/

*0@ +

0@ * <

<*/ +00 +

+0@, +

*, 00@ +

+@0. $/  

/<+ @ 

/= 0 */

*/0 0 / @,< 0 0@ 

0 / <+.

!<0@ 0 0@ 

/ *>+

/ 0*

+0=0@, 0@ 

0 / /,

< >0 /

0<*0 '>

/,’

/ +00

/</ *<

*-0*, <<

*00, *0=

, +

0 =.

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 20/31

> @< > => <=. $ @><, <

< #<= < > >>. =<<, < >

=> > > = > > >, >

<, >> . KI> > <> @= >>

>,N H>J<<-*= , K#<= = >>< =

>< > I<= < < >> I<= =>=,

> => >< << =>. A><, < >

@> >< > > = < #<= >

< > > >> > @@<> >, = =,

@ =< @> >< > > >> < >

> #<= >>.N

H>J<<-*= > < >> > =, >

= I=, = < :

M !>< > <

M <= > <>

M +<>= > +<>M '> > '<

M <= > *>>> <

M E> > #< E<<>

M * >< > A>=<

M   >’ < > I>

#> = < . F =@<, <<>  

><> >< > < > < >@< <<> > 

< > > =< <<> > > <. B

@> >>, > = > =@< =,

>> @@>, ><< , >> <: > >< >>. I> , >> > > > @>

>@ = >> <=> > @>. A H>J<<-

*= @<>: K> > @<> <@=>< @<, !.

< > < @ >>, > >>> >

>> > <@=>, > = F<

<< >> <@=> . I > 

<< @ > > =@= < <=, >

>> <=< >= >> > =@<=>,

<> @>-=> > = >> > >> @>  

, < <>, > > ><, > <> @@ >> = >> >’ > > <.’ F<

> = >>> > = ’ ( 9> )

<-GJ< @ >’ ( 4  ) @>.N

I> > >>> >> > >  

> <@=>,’ >> <<:

>> > +’ > ,’ @@< > <<-<

*. I >, * >, K > > > << I<=

> << >-I<=,N > > @< >. A<<

=@ = >, ><> ? &<>, *

> >@> >: K < > = . * > < >, <. F =, < 

> > <> @<@ > =>, << < > >

I */

0= +0

>0/ 0+0<

00@, H-

$/ <+,

M<0 < */

/ +0

<0=0@ 0 I0*

 =< 0/ /

<+0 I0*

/<0, *< 0

0+00 /0 

* /<0@.

20

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 21/31

> = >. F , < < > = . G><<,

@< > @@ @. A> @< > >

> < > << > = > >==><

. * << ==> > > < > : > ==> ,

==> < ==> >.N * > @ L >

’ < H> I>, >> < > <>, >

< >> L > <<= #<= >>. *

=> >, * >, > < > <<; = <

@@< << @=< => @ > >

I<=R K* < ,N *, K@ > @>>N L >

66 , > ’, < > >< >= << > =>

. * @@ > < @< > > < >

> >>< . * > > > , , < >

> => < > >. A> @@ >>

@@< ><> > => >>, > @<

<. * =@J < < L >

<.’

* =>>< = = >< > < @@

>. #<= > = > @<= >

@== > >> << #<=. * >

@@ =@<, >>> <. * @<= <> > <=,

<< < > ><< , > > <

@<= #<= L = <> > @<=. *

<> > > > > >=>, =@<, > =@< @<=

<>< > > , => #<= < . #<=

> <> > > >=>. A> <> <>,

=>>, < > < @ >< =. =<<,

<< @<= << << < #<= @<= L << #<= = > @ @@< > @<>. * > @=

> = < > < > <

@> >> <, > >> =, ,’ >@<

>> @ <, > ,’ > < =>J> <<

> = . *, = =<, <, @<<, <,

>, ><< > << <<> > < > ><

@ @== =.

I >> > * > = = <@ => =<

> @>=< = > >< >@<>, =@< => =, , > .

A < >> < > @. G>

@ > > = , * @ , K= > > >

I>, BJ<, C>,N > <@ @>@ K

=> > < > .N

#0 + F<< G0

I> < > <> > << >< ,

> > > >> @@ @<. I << > , E<-A> K> < >< N =

K=@> << >< > N K>

21

/ ,

/0*, 00*, *0,

*000*, */0*

+ *<< */

*0 / >+ /=

0

.

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 22/31

<.N > @<

> ; > > > > <> 

=<, <, > @<> > > > =><

<< < > E. * >= > >, I=’ ,

K<> N K << >>N #<= > >><

@><< <. *, > => =@ >> >

@. B > @ ? A> < =<> > =?

A = => ><, @@ @<>

=>> @=, > ><< > @<>

<< ? D > =@ = > > = > >

@= > @ > >> <? < > @

< >’ > > < => =>< @=

<< =>> > << =<> @>

#<= >? A> < > @ @’? I> @< ,

H " > E35<<5>35 9? ?< (= > >)

<< > > K < , =>>, @@ >

=> =>N; > K< << > < > > >= ><N

> > > K > << => => > @.N , >> = > => > >> >  

> >< >> #<= <. A @< @>

> >, < > > #<= > @><<

@, > = >, >, >>, =

> @- > <= >. >

><=> > < > > >>

, H>J<<-*= , K=@> =@>

@> > > #<= < >< =<>  

> =<, => > ’ > > @’ => <=-

’ #<= >> =@=> > << >> >

>>>< >> = > .N * @> <<< L > #<= < L @ > @= > > ><

@= < > @ > < < ,

=>>, @@ > => => > =@< > >>>

<.

* = ><>> > > ><> > > >>.

E<-A> > < =@<< >, @=<

=> > > > >. I> @> E<-

A>, H>J<<-*= = @<: K = > > @=

> =@< >=> << @ > << >< > @>< @ >> @ <. F= =

> @> , << I = > > > 

@@< (=> > =>) > @>.N A ==  

, > > << = > >,

K > @@< =< 5  N ( > <<

<< >@ >>). = =< > <

> = ( @> >= =

><). I > >> < = > =

. * >< > >< > > @@< > >

= = > >< @ << @.

B < >< > >< << @>< < > >;

K=@< @@N < ><, H>J<<-*= , K ->> 

22

/> + > **0=@

/ & + /

M<0 >+ +<*

> +0  

+<*0 / @ 

*00*

/</ + / 00

0<0@ <

+ <

</, 0,

< + >/ 0

/< 0

< * +

0**+ >+.

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 23/31

<>> .N * > . >, > >

> < > =>, < > =>

@> => @<< @< > <>. *, >

<> =@< > >, =@> <

> >< @ =< =>> =@< @@. I>

=> =@< =, >> A’ " :

=@< = > > =@< = >> > > . I>

@>=< > ($), @ > =@<

<, <, << > >>=>< >> > ><,

=>= << E> C==>’ . I >< >> 

><> << = = > L ><> 

> @=, ><, @, >>=> ,

<, <, > >, > < @@<. I> @>=< =

<< <<, @, , =>, >, > 

> <, << < @@< >< > << >

> > @<< >. *> > >

@< > <<-=< < =>,’ > , @< =

> >< = >, < <. , <>, <> > < , >< ><,

@> > >@> <>. * => >< > @@<

> >, , >, , > @@ > => L

> > @ = > @ @> <. A

<, = > > >>> >,

> > @>. * < @ > >=> >

< > => > => @<= > #<= .

M=0 F>+

<> > <> = >?

* > = = <> > > >>

K >,N H>J<<-*= > <> ==> >

E<-A>’ @@, > @ =>. <> < >’

> = >< >. < > @= >

@>@<, <> > ? &<>, ><, >, < > =>

@ > > >< =. A , >>

> => > @= > =< ( << >><

= > <) > <> > =  

>> > > >< > >< => . I> >, = > >> << >@ >

> @@<> < > = L > @

= @. = => I<=

<>, => >=@ <>, > > = =

= > >< <J>< >@. = <>

< >> < <. A = > <<> <<

=>>, > @><< >=>< >>

> = ><< < >. H>,

> >> >< <@=> > << ,

#<= >>-#<=. B = @ > @

#<= > > #<= > > >=@. = > @ << < > @  

> > #<= , #<= = @< >

23

& 0 *= /

*/0= I0*

*0=000,

+ /0 

*@ 

=*, +

+00 /

*/0 + 0

>/0*/ */*0

*0=000

<*@. & 0

* *00* /00 >0/ /0* =<.

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 24/31

@>< <, > #<= >=> >=@

< << =@< > >>, > > >= J> <<

@@ <@ < > => <.

 , = = =. B, <, << > =R

&/ D & N+ D A*/0= < %00?

> < = > > = >= >

>@>. > =@< << < ><, ><>

H>J<<-*= @ , K= =@@> > , @<@ >

< @> >= <@=> @= > =@<

>.N > @<@< > ><<< >

> >> >=@ <>. > >>

=> >< @> > @@ @>

>=@ <: K @< >> > >>> >>

< @< = <<> < > << @<<=> =,N H>J<<-*=. > >>< > >

= << K=><< >@,N > > >>> >  

=>> > >@< <: K > @> =@<

< @< <, > > > , >>

=> => >> >< > , > > =

>=<< <->> > @> > >> > > >

=> <> >.N > > > > ><<<

(> = @>-=>,’ ><’ > ’) > ><<<

> > > < > @< <

< <>. > ><, >< > <, =

@@@ @>> > > , > > > ->> <>> . A> > @< << > =< =>

> < = = > => >

>.

A = < @ = > =>

> . I> >, > < >

< ; > > > = > @>@<

. A> @ > > < = >>

<, , <>@ > , > @< >

<> > <. => > : = ><, > @=, >@, =><, >>, =>

=>> , > @ > < > > >

> <.

* @ > ? &<> > > = =

I<=J> !><’ = > I>> !><.’ F

>, => = > >-> =<->>< >,

> =@< >-= , > > ==>

= > @>@<, <<< <@ > @>

> >@ > =>< > ==> => >

<. > >> : = > < E<-A>’K< @<=N: K> > > ><, > < >>;

> < >>, > > = >< >

24

& /< 00

* > +0*<:

@ >+,

> +0,

**, 0@,

*, /

/= 0 <,/</ >/0*/ >

+*<* > +

0+0 +

+ */ / >+.

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 25/31

><-@> > ><-> @. >

?N = > =<><.

I @@ > ==> < =

> @. A > L > > ==> L = >

<@, << @ > ><, > > >< << >

> @@< . > =<, << > ><

<, ><<<, @ >, > @ @=

> I>> !><’ >< >. I =@>

< == > >> #<=; < > >@

= <; > > = < = I>, C> > ">

A=. A< > >< , > > > 

<, < @< = == >

#<=. * > =<’ > > == < >

> , > > >, << <<< >

, > > @@ > >> > <@> . *

> @, << >>><, L > > <<

L >. E >, > >@<> =, < @ @ > > <<= L > = =>< > >@ <> <

. E > < > C @>< $

> ==>> >. D> , == >

> >@ = > < ><. H, <<

> > @> ,

> @, > > <<> . *

>>< C>>, @< <> , < >> >

< @ @ > < > =<, < ><

=> , > <<> . E == >

I>> !>< @, @ > << ==>. *

@ @ #<= > > >> >> @ > = <<

> >>. * > ><< = E<-A>’ KC>  

E<<>,N < > K< <> > #<= < > > ,N

> > < > @ > >< @

I>> !><’ . #, > > =@ =

@, > = @<> > >, < > = ><<

> > >< @>.

F= <> , > > @>< >

@ > @ @.

F, * <<, > > <, =>

K-@> > > < ( <=  ) > >

<<> ><= > I<= .N * @>@< @

> << = >< < > > @

> < << <> > @=> >

>. * > > > >’:

< > @ <= > = < = ’

> >>=> > @<< . > * , K <

< @= > >=@ < = >, @<=,

, => > <<J>? < < @= >>< >> > <> >=, >,

> > >>=>?,N > > =@<

25

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 26/31

>, = =< > > > > >, =>

> ><, > > @<=, > <> >

>= > < <>. E> >, < <<

=> <>,’ < =@< . @<=

@<@ << @@ = #<= < L >

> => <> #<= <J> L > <

> > >> @ @<@< > < . #,

> =@<, >>>, << <, > , >

=>, > < > @<@< >, ,

. * @<= @ > =@< > = <> 

> > = > << => <>. @<= <<

> < =@< <> > <=  @<@< >

#J< . I> = , = > <> > > >,

* =. B G > G #<= <J> > < <<

@<= =>; > << >=@ > > =<,

@, =@< > >= >, >

>> ><<< > @< . H>, > :

@<@< I<= > <@ >=@ @<@< > I<=, >> >=@ @<@< > >

< <> =@< > =@> @@<

=< > < . * > > >=@

> > @ < >@<> @> =

<.

>, > > > >>< @ =>

>< =, ><> H>J<<-*= @ , K= =@@> >

, @<@ > < @>N > => > @=

>< > > > #<= = @> <>

@= >< =>. * < @ <> =>< > => < > ><<< > >  

I<= > @<> >=@ #<= < >.

*, <, > ><<< > >

> >. F =@<, > K#<= > = > >

> >< =@< I<= >, >=<, > =  

><<< > @< >=> I<= > =<- .N

H, <= K <> > I<= <<

> >> <<-< =<N K>

@< < > > @@<< @, > > > @.N , K@< < <> >

<= @< < @= ><< << <<<N;

>>, <, <= < . (I < > =

<< < @ > @<=). > > <<

@ L ><> < > >< >

<>, @<@< > @, > @,

> > ><< =@<=>, >< <@=>, @<>>>,

>>=>< > << >>, < > @<< =, > <,

> => =@<=>. I> , > #<=

<> => <> L , =@<, @ #<< H>,

> > =@< > > << . > @ <, ><> I<= > I<= < > > @<@

> > ><, > >< << < >

26

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 27/31

>, @ = > > > @ < =>

=>. , H> < @ , >< K< N > >

I<=. * >> > @ <> >< <

> > > > .

F, > @ <, > > >=@

> L > #<= , >> <, >= >

<< , > > > @> L > @< =@ >

>> #<=. #>>< = > >< > >

. * > @= = <@ > <, > ,

> >< > . > = >>> >  

< = > < > >, > = >: > >=>  

@ << => #<= , > => << >> #<=

<, > < #<= > > > = =@< >

>>> < . * >< : >>>

>= @> >=@ < > @@>  

> > = <>> = <> . A> <<

=@>: > @ = > > <<, > << > @= => <@ > <

= <> = @. I > @

=> > > >>, < : @> = < I<= >

#<= > <. * > = >

<@ @ > #<= > @ @<, >

@ = L > @> L , < >

> .

< > > , > > >@<>

> > > @ > I>> !><.  

, > @<>, > = > >,<< = @ . B I <

=>== > > > I>> !>< > >

==>. A < > > < > -<>

A=593> ?>< ?6 I<=93 ?39< 395>35 : ==> > ><

> > = @<= > ==> < > =.

I < = > < < >< >; I <

<< < > ><, >>, > > 

= > >< >>.

H, = > > =@> > = > . * @ @ > >> > I>>  

!><’ > = =; > < > >.

1. * <> = > , > E<-A> , =

K > >,N > < @> II+# > !<

"=@ << @=> *’ GP<> #=>,

< > >, > >= I=< >

@ A !>, < C > >

>, < >> > > > > <. *

> < => < @=> > < > (<

>> > >@, I> > !, =@<) =< @@ > . * >

>> @< > > > > .

27

I > *<

>/ > 00

+ 0 *, 0><+ : /0

=0 <<  

I + M<0 +

/ >+.

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 28/31

2. > == > = >@ > =><,

> = <>, > <@> . * <

<> E>< > I<= = > >@ >> >

> ( #<= > >>-#<=), << > = > >

@ , = >=@ =>>, > >@ = >

I>> !><’ . , =@<, 5 =>

=, => , =, <= > >?

>=@ <> I<= = < <96, , 9=, 99<,

9>? * @ $< B > < <<: K$, >, ’ >

>>; > <<.N * >’ > <<<;

< > > >@. *= > >@

<> < < @ > @ <.

=> <<= > <<: !5?4 , > >< <@,

< , A ?32< 6? C<5 >4 ?395  < >>

@<> << , = , @<>< >

= ><> > => @=>=. * > = >

< >. * <> > @<> >> 

=>> = > >@, < > =< , > > =@ >=@ =<> =>> > @>@< L <

<@> = >> >>> >@>< = >

>@ = <> < I>> !><

. I’ >> < >> > > > ><

= >>’ = > @=. I

> @= >< <, @ > <>; <>

, > << <

@.

3. * > << == I>> !><’ >

>< ><<< > < <, << > > @@> > > >>, >

> #<= >>. * >< >>, @

> > I<= @ > > -, > >.

* >> @ ==: > >< ><>

@ < @ @ . *, >

=> = > = < >> L < > >

=> >< > =< >> <<

>=@ >>. >? ? A >,

>> > =@ H< B<=’ *5 55> C>?> >

=. I << @ = > > > > @ =< A=> @<@<

> < > L > > +

<= . #<<<= > > <

< > @<@< > >>- = ; >

=> > >>-> < < < >

> >. I>, => >> >> <=.

B<=’ @ >> @<@< <,

< =@<=>, > < < > <>

> >>. B > > > <

<, = =@><, > @. A<= ><-><

> > > <>=>R *> <, => > << @ > > >=> @  

<, > < > > > . >

28

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 29/31

@@> ==> @ <= @ > > @@

> #<= >>, => >< >>, >

== I>> !><’ > =, >

> > > > =. B<= < >

<=; @ > =@< > @< >

>@<> = <.

4. I > =@ @< > <> < <>

> > > = > >. @ < > >

< > => > >> @<>>

> == < > III* > I><, >

@<. @> = => > > >

> < < > @ > <.

H, < < = @ @: ==> > ’

@<=, >, >, @>, > @

>>, > > < > >> << > =

> > > = > @> @ > ><>

> . I > > > < , < > . A @> @@<> < R

* > : I<=J> !><,’ < = , = >. I

@ = > >. B < <: > < > <> >>

#<= > >, > >>

E> > < > > >>> @>@<. =

I>> !><.’ "> < >. @ > > 

< .

29

$/ 0 0 ++:

'I00  

K>+,’ ... & =

>+ >0/

'I0  

K>+.’ L 0=

/ 0.

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 30/31

N + #*

* I>> @=> @ B>=> F><>, = >>> 

$ A=,’ ">>, 1784; *= "=, K<>  

> > <@> >N *< 2 (1) 2-4 (1976).

I=< <-F, I<=9J9?> ?6 !>?<5475: G5>5< &9>39@<5 >4 ?@<>,(I>>>< I> I<= *, H>>, >, 1982); = =

> >, 1989. A< =>> A<H= A. A<=>’ ><

@@ <J> H E> > #<= <’’ (III* F 2007).

* 2003 A2 H=> D55<?@=5> 5@?: B9<49>7 !>?<5475 ?395 (+$D, $

 , 2003).

> @<> > "<, +>> @<>: > < >

> > =<<>>=’ F5 34 (1) 1-14 2002; > "<, E=@95 ?6 !>?<5475 (<

, ">>, 2002; > > , D<@=> > ">  

E>=’ > >< #> > D> ’H> () C993< H?<9=: (5)*9>9>7 D55<?@=5> ( B, ">>, 1998).

> > , @= > @<> = G<, E>4 

?6 $?=<: *5 G5 C99 >4 5 F5 ?6 G? (=> > , $ ,

2014); > G><, >, #9>4 C>75 (, ">>, 2014); #< H,

*5 E>4 ?6 A25>35: 53<9=9>7 5’5 "? 9> ?<4 ?6 C?>> C?>>539?>

(C>, $ , 2014); D H, 55>55> C?>4939?> >4 5 E>4 ?6 

C@9<9=  (< B, ">>, 2014); H>, *5 E>4 ?6 G?: 

A4@9>7 ? % $5 E3?>?=93 5<9 (C< B, , 2011); H>

!>, ?<4 %45: 56<539?> ?> 5 C35 ?6 $9?> >4 5 C?5 ?6 

H9? (A<<> ">, ">>, 2014); E<J !<, *5 9 E9>39?> (B<=,

">>, 2014); #< ", F< B? , (A<<> ">, ">>, 2014); E> #J,

*? 5 E59>7 C<93 H55  (>>, ">>, 2013); $= !<>, *9 C>75 

E59>7 (=> > , $ , 2014); <, , *5 B9775 

5@ C<< 9> H9? , F I>>><, B>, 2011; >, , *=

C@9< 9> 5 *5>-F9 C5> , >< A G<== (*

B<>@ , B>, 2014).

> > > E@ A> C <, , E?@5>

H975 E439?> 5 C??4 , 2 <= (@>, H<, 2012).

> @>=< =, > , <= >=< *=’ F5 42

(5) 435-444 2010; > , >=< *= ’ F5  2015

(@, > @<>); > , * F A @> >

>=< *=’ A=593> ?>< ?6 I<=93 ?39< 395>35 30 125-136 F<< (2013);

 > >, > >=< *=’ E 5 A669 1 (3-4) 5-12 (2013);

, >=< G>>’ E-5 A669 5 2014 5-13 (2014); >

@< F > >=< *=’ # > D: F5 

43 (2) 136-227 2011. * < > @>=< >, , =@<,

J, > F>J, (1994), E=> =@< =’ F5 26 (6) 568-

582; J, > F>J, (1999), >=< >: > > >

=>’ F5  31 (7) 641-646; J (2004), * @->=< >  @>’ F5 36 (3) 347L357; > J, (2013) * > >

>=< A,’ E-5 A669 3-4 <.

30

7/21/2019 Education Reform by Ziauddin Sardar

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/education-reform-by-ziauddin-sardar 31/31

> > @<, > , F5: A<< * #5 

(H > >, ">>, 2013). > @<<, B> >:

<< <> > > >,’ B C>< 70 A>> "

>@ >, > H? D? .? !>?: 549>7 /9449> 4 ?>

I<=, 395>35 >4 C<< 5<9?> <, > > E> #

(< , ">>, 2006).

G , * > @= > >’ C4= 2 (2) 116-125 2014 >

G , >> $> > A< >, +>> < >:

> ’ C4=  2 (3) 2014 << >-<> =

.=><..

> > <> " >>, &9<??@93< I>5979?> 18 

(B<<<, , 1953); > , *5 ">775 ?6 E<9  (E< >

H=> C==>, ">>, 2008); > . H>J<<-*=, F

?<5>5 >4 H?<9>5 9> E439?>: A> I<=93 &5@5395 A<

(I>>>< I> I<= *, ">>, 2001); = H>J<<-*=,

E@< A= # > > @<, *5 C?=93 39@: 354 G5?=5 >4 5 395>35 ?6 A293 &5>=>9@  (I>> *> I>>><, => 

2014); . H>J<<-*=, B> * B<: A "> A@@

C<> ! C>@ > I<= <<=’ > C99J5>9@, 539 >4 D5=?33: 

#<9= E>775=5> 9 5 5 , . > ! (=>: A# +!, 2009); .

H>J<<-*=, * C<<> <<= > #< I<=,’ > I<= >4 

G<?2< D9<?75: 5<979? &<<9= >4 5 &9 ?6 &535, B

(A, A<, 2005); > = H>J<<-*=, * >

I=.’ @ @> >> > A3>?<5479>7 54 & ? B9<4

54 F5: 59>9>7 #<9= >4 $?>-#<9= 5<9?> >< >>

B C>< > C> I<= +> C=, #

29-31, 2012.

><: H ", E35<<5>35 9? ?< (< A, $

 , 2007); > G, *5 E5-&55> %979>, ><> $<

B A< #> (A>: +> , 1985, 1991); .. F<,

75 ?6 F9: *5 &3?<?7 ?6 H=> D55<?@=5> >4 5 '5 6? #5>9>7 

(H@ > , > F>, 1981); #< F<, *5 %45 ?6 *9>7: 

A35?<?7 ?6 5 H=> 395>35  (<, ">>, 2001), > >;

#<< H>, *5 5>5 ?6 I<= (C +> , C, 1974),

<=, > >, 1977; > #<< H>, 59>9>7 H9? (C=

+> , C=, 1993); > I9 B5<9> = *5 C??54 *9=25 ?6 H=>9 (> #, ">>, 1959) @1.