Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring...

69
Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck, M.Ed. Advocates for Youth and Family Behavioral Health Treatment, LLC

Transcript of Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring...

Page 1: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children

Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders

Randolph D. Muck, M.Ed.

Advocates for Youth and Family Behavioral Health

Treatment, LLC

Page 2: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

We know the parents are really the problem!

Page 3: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Ea

rly In

terven

tio

n

and

Pr

even

tio

n

are Imp

ortan

t b

ecau

se . . . .

Page 4: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Lin

k B

etw

een

P

ercep

tio

n

and

U

se

Page 5: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,
Page 6: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Examples of Treating Adolescents with Co-occurring Disorders

• An integrated approach to treating issues

Integrated Co-Occurring Treatment Model (ICT)-Ohio Dept. of MH, State and Center for Innovative Practices, child Guidance and Family Solutions

• Gender and Cultural Competence Voices, Stephanie Covington

• Continuing CareAssertive Continuing Care, Susan Godley,

et al

Page 7: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

7

Multiple Clinical Problems are the NORM!

20%

41%

80%

48%

33%

63%

11%

24%

14%

34%

27%0% 10

%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Alcohol

Cannabis

Other drug disorder

Depression

Anxiety

Trauma

ADHD

CD

Suicide

Victimization

Violence/ illegal activity

Source: CSAT 2009 Summary Analytic Data Set (n=20,826)

Page 8: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Source: French et al., 2008; Chandler et al., 2009; Capriccioso, 2004 in 2009 dollars

The Cost of Substance Abuse Treatment is Trivial Relative to the Costs Treatment Reduces

$407$1,132$1,249$1,384$1,517$2,486$4,277

$10,228$14,818

$0 $10,

000

$20,

000

$30,

000

$40,

000

$50,

000

$60,

000

$70,

000

Screening & Brief Inter.(1-2 days)Outpatient (18 weeks)

In-prison Therap. Com. (28 weeks) Intensive Outpatient (12 weeks)

Adolescent Outpatient (12 weeks)Treatment Drug Court (46 weeks)

Methadone Maintenance (87 weeks)Residential (13 weeks)

Therapeutic Community (33 weeks)

$22,000 / year to incarcerate an adult

$30,000/ child-year in foster care

$70,000/year to keep a child in detention

• $750 per night in Medical Detox• $1,115 per night in hospital • $13,000 per week in intensive care for premature baby• $27,000 per robbery• $67,000 per assault

SBIRT models popular due to ease of implementation and low cost

Page 9: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Investing in Substance Abuse Treatment Results in a Positive Return on Investment (ROI)

• Substance abuse treatment has an ROI of between $1.28 to $7.26 per dollar invested.

• Consequently, for every treatment dollar cut in the proposed budget, the actual costs to taxpayers will increase between $1.28 and $7.26.

• How will this happen? Individuals needing substance abuse treatment will not disappear but instead interface with much more expensive systems such as emergency rooms and prisons.

• Bottom line = The proposed $55 million dollar cut will cost Illinois taxpayers between $70 and $400 million within the next 1 to 2 years.

Source: Bhati et al., (2008); Ettner et al., (2006)

Page 10: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Similarity of Clinical Outcomes : Cannabis Youth Treatment (CYT)

Source: Dennis et al., 2004

200

220

240

260

280

300

Tota

l day

s ab

stin

ent.

over

12

mon

ths

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

Per

cen

t in

Rec

ove

ry.

at M

onth

12

Total Days Abstinent* 269 256 260 251 265 257

Percent in Recovery** 0.28 0.17 0.22 0.23 0.34 0.19

MET/ CBT5 (n=102)

MET/ CBT12

FSN (n=102)

MET/ CBT5 (n=99)

ACRA (n=100)

MDFT (n=99)

Trial 1 Trial 2

* n.s.d., effect size f=0.06** n.s.d., effect size f=0.12

* n.s.d., effect size f=0.06 ** n.s.d., effect size f=0.16

Not significantly different by condition.

But better than the average for OP in ATM (200 days of

abstinence)

Page 11: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Moderate to large differences in Cost-Effectiveness by Condition

Source: Dennis et al., 2004

$0

$4

$8

$12

$16

$20

Cos

t pe

r da

y of

abs

tinen

ce o

ver

12 m

onth

s

$0

$4,000

$8,000

$12,000

$16,000

$20,000

Cos

t pe

r pe

rson

in r

eco

very

at

mon

th 1

2

CPDA* $4.91 $6.15 $15.13 $9.00 $6.62 $10.38

CPPR** $3,958 $7,377 $15,116 $6,611 $4,460 $11,775

MET/ CBT5

MET/ CBT12

FSN MET/ CBT5

ACRA MDFT

* p<.05 effect size f=0.48** p<.05, effect size f=0.72

Trial 1 Trial 2

* p<.05 effect size f=0.22 ** p<.05, effect size f=0.78

MET/CBT5 and 12 did better

than FSN

ACRA did better than MET/CBT5, and both did

better than MDFT

Suggest the need to consider cost-effectiveness of treatment approaches

Page 12: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Average% Use Levels of CareTEDS-A 2009

Detox Residential IOP OP

Natl 3.7 15.6 15.6 65.1

State X 0.0 2.0 1.0 98.8

State Y 0.0 98.0 0 2.0

Standardized screening/assessment, appropriate level of care, continuum of system → better outcomes, fewer readmissions, cost savings

Page 13: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

13

Substance Use Careers Last for Decades

Cu

mu

lati

ve S

urv

ival

Years from first use to 1+ years abstinence

302520151050

1.0

.9

.8

.7

.6

.5

.4

.3

.2

.10.0

Median of 27 years from first use to 1+ years abstinence

Source: Dennis et al., 2005

Page 14: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

14

Substance Use Careers are Shorter with Sooner Treatment

Cu

mu

lati

ve S

urv

ival

20+

0-9*

10-19*

Year to 1st TxGroups

302520151050

1.0

.9

.8

.7

.6

.5

.4

.3

.2

.10.0

* p<.05 (different

from 20+)

Source: Dennis et al., 2005

Years from first use to 1+ years abstinence

Page 15: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

15

Substance Use Careers are Longer the Younger the Age

of First Use

Cu

mu

lati

ve S

urv

ival

Years from first use to 1+ years abstinence

under 15*

21+

15-20*

Age of 1st UseGroups

* p<.05 (different from 21+)

302520151050

1.0

.9

.8

.7

.6

.5

.4

.3

.2

.10.0

Source: Dennis et al., 2005

Page 16: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Interventions Associated With No or Minimal Change in Substance Use or

Symptoms• Passive referrals• Educational units alone• Probation services as usual• Unstandardized outpatient services as usual

Interventions associated with deterioration Treatment of adolescents with/in adult units

Page 17: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Do you know what happens in group treatment?

Which EBP is this?

Page 18: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

53% Have Unfavorable Discharges

Source: Data received through August 4, 2004 from 23 States (CA, CO, GA, HI, IA, IL, KS, MA, MD, ME, MI, MN, MO, MT, NE, NJ, OH, OK, RI, SC, TX, UT, WY) as reported in Office of Applied Studies (OAS; 2005). Treatment Episode Data Set (TEDS): 2002. Discharges from Substance Abuse Treatment Services, DASIS Series: S-25, DHHS Publication No. (SMA) 04-3967, Rockville, MD: Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. Retrieved from http://wwwdasis.samhsa.gov/teds02/2002_teds_rpt_d.pdf .

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%

Outpatient(37,048 discharges)

IOP(10,292 discharges)

Detox(3,185 discharges)

STR(5,152 discharges)

LTR(5,476 discharges)

Total(61,153 discharges)

Completed Transferred ASA/ Drop out AD/Terminated

Despite being widely recommended, only 10% step down after intensive treatment

Page 19: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

12 to 17 18 to 25 26 or older0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

7.4%

20.1%

7.0%

0.4% 1.1% 0.6%

Abuse or Dependence in past yearTreatment in past year

Substance Use Disorders are Common, US Treatment Participation Rates Are Low

Source: SAMHSA 2010. National Survey On Drug Use And Health, 2010 [Computer file]

Over 88% of adolescent and young adult treatment and over 50% of adult treatment is publicly funded

Few Get Treatment: 1 in 20 adolescents, 1 in 18 young adults, 1 in 11 adults

Much of the private funding is limited to 30 days or less and authorized day by day or week by week

Page 20: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Potential AOD Screening & Intervention Sites

Adolescents (age 12-17)

Source: SAMHSA 2010. National Survey On Drug Use And Health, 2010 [Computer file]

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%1% 0% 1%

4%

12%

29%

30%

93%

1% 1% 3% 5%

13%

35% 41

%

97%

1% 4%

9% 8% 12%

41%

42%

95%

10%

8%

15%

11% 23

%

49%

46%

95%

No use in past year Less than weekly use Weekly Use Abuse or dependence

% A

ny

Con

tact

Page 21: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Early Adolescent Treatment Work

Source: Dennis, M.L., Dawud-Noursi, S., Muck, R., & McDermeit, M. (2003)

Worth Street Narcotic Clinic in NY – 743 youth

Federal Narcotic Farms in Lexington, KY & Fort Worth, TX 22-440/yr

Riverside Hospital in NYC – 250 youth

Teen Addiction Hospital Wards in several cities

Drug Abuse Reporting Program (DARP)- 5,405 youth (587 followed)

Treatment Outcome Prospective Study (TOPS)- 1042 youth (256 followed)

Services Research Outcome Study (SROS) - 156 youth

1910

1920

1930

1940

1950

1960

1970

1980

1990

1996

National Treatment Improvement Evaluation Study (NTIES) - 236 youth

Drug Abuse Treatment Outcome Study of Adolescents (DATOS-A) - 3,382 youth (1,785 followed)

Page 22: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

The Current Renaissance of Adolescent Treatment Research

* Published and publicly available

Feature 1930-1997 1997-2012

Tx Studies* 17 Over 300

Random/Quasi 9 44

Tx Manuals* 0 30+

QA/Adherence Rare Common

Std Assessment* Rare Common

Participation Rates Under 50% Over 80%

Follow-up Rates 40-50% 85-95%

Methods Descriptive/Simple More Advanced

Economic Some Cost Cost, CEA, BCA

Page 23: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

23

Programs often LACK Evidenced Based Assessment to Identify and Practices to

Treat:

• Substance use disorders (e.g., abuse, dependence, withdrawal), readiness for change, relapse potential and recovery environment

• Common mental health disorders (e.g., conduct, attention deficit-hyperactivity, depression, anxiety, trauma, self-mutilation and suicidal thoughts)

• Crime and violence (e.g., inter-personal violence, drug related crime, property crime, violent crime)

• HIV risk behaviors (needle use, sexual risk, victimization)

• Child maltreatment (physical, sexual, emotional)• Recovery environment and peer risk

Page 24: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Assessment for ALL disorders

is needed because. . .• Having one disorder increases the risk of

developing another disorder;• The presence of a second disorder makes

treatment of the first more complicated;• Treating one disorder does NOT lead to

effective management of the other(s);• Treatment outcomes are poorer when co-

occurring disorders are present.

Page 25: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Adolescents with SUD. . .(Meyers et al)

• Are largely undiagnosed• Are distributed across diverse health &

social service systems • Have been adjudicated delinquent;• Have histories of child abuse, neglect and

sexual abuse;• Have high co-morbidity with psychiatric

conditions;

Page 26: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

In practice we need a Continuum of Measurement (Common Measures)

• Screening to Identify Who Needs to be “Assessed” (5-10 min)– Focus on brevity, simplicity for administration & scoring– Needs to be adequate for triage and referral– GAIN Short Screener for SUD, MH & Crime– ASSIST, AUDIT, CAGE, CRAFT, DAST, MAST for SUD– SCL, HSCL, BSI, CANS for Mental Health– LSI, MAYSI, YLS for Crime

• Quick Assessment for Targeted Referral (20-30 min)– Assessment of who needs a feedback, brief intervention or referral

for more specialized assessment or treatment– Needs to be adequate for brief intervention– GAIN Quick – ADI, ASI, SASSI, T-ASI, MINI

• Comprehensive Biopsychosocial (1-2 hours) – Used to identify common problems and how they are interrelated– Needs to be adequate for diagnosis, treatment planning and

placement of common problems– GAIN Initial (Clinical Core and Full)– CASI, A-CASI, MATE

• Specialized Assessment (additional time per area)– Additional assessment by a specialist (e.g., psychiatrist, MD,

nurse, spec ed) may be needed to rule out a diagnosis or develop a treatment plan or individual education plan

– CIDI, DISC, KSADS, PDI, SCAN

Screener Q

uick Com

prehensive S

pecial

Mo

re E

xtensive

/ Lon

ge

r/ Expe

nsive

Page 27: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

The New Age of Adolescent Services

Pooled Data now <30 ,000• Treatment of adolescents with adult models

and/or mixed with adults does not work and is actually associated with drop out and increased use

• Need to modify models to be more developmentally appropriate for youth

• Need to assess and treat a wider range of problems including victimization, co-occurring mental health needs, and education needs

• Need to modify materials to be more concrete and use examples relevant to youth

• Don’t stop asking questions!

Page 28: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

28

Victimization and Level of Care Interact to Predict Outcomes

Source: Funk, et al., 2003

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

Intake 6 Months Intake 6 Months

Mar

ijua

na U

se (

Day

s of

90)

OP -High OP - Low/Mod Resid-High Resid - Low/Mod.

CHS Outpatient CHS Residential Traumatized groups have higher severity

High trauma group does not respond to OP

Both groups respond to residential treatment

Page 29: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Traumatic Victimization

• 40 – 90% have been victimized• 20-25% report in past 90 days, concerns

about reoccurrence• Associated with higher rates of

– substance use– HIV-risk behavior– Co-occurring disorders

Page 30: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

30

46%

71%

15%0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Low (0) Moderate (1-3) High (4-15)

None

One

Two

Three

Four

Five to Twelve

The Number of Major Clinical Problems

is highly related to Victimization

Source: CSAT 2009 Summary Analytic Data Set (n=21,784)

Significantly more likely to

have 5+ problems

(OR=13.9)

Page 31: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

They had the audacity to hi-jack Christmas

Page 32: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Tanner-Smith, E.E., Wilson, S.J, & Lipsey, M.W. ( ).

The comparative effectiveness of outpatient treatment for adolescent

substance abuse: A meta-analysis. Journal of

Substance Abuse Treatment , in press.

Page 33: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Interventions that Typically do Better than Practice in Reducing Recidivism

(29% vs. 40%)• Aggression Replacement Training• Brief Strategic Family Therapy• Reasoning & Rehabilitation• Moral Reconation Therapy• Thinking for a Change• Interpersonal Social Problem Solving• Multisystemic Therapy• Functional Family Therapy• Multidimensional Family Therapy• Adolescent Community Reinforcement Approach• MET/CBT combinations and Other manualized CBT

Source: Adapted from Lipsey et al 2001, Waldron et al, 2001, Dennis et al, 2004

NOTE: There is generally little or no differences in mean effect size between these brand names

Page 34: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

34

Implementation is Essential (Reduction in Recidivism)

The effect of a well implemented weak program is as big as a strong program implemented poorly

The best is to have a strong program implemented well

Thus one should optimally pick the strongest intervention that one can implement well

Source: Adapted from Lipsey, 1997, 2005

Page 35: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

% Change: Abstinence at 6-months post-initial

assessment

*MET/ *ACRA/ **TARGET **SEE

CBT 5 ACC YOUTH YOUTH

60.6 69.3 12.6 21.1

* GAIN Mandated

** GAIN Optional

Source: SAIS System (GPRA)

Page 36: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

36 Site Type IV Replication MET/CBT5

AK

AL

ARAZ

CA CO

CT

DC

DE

FL

GA

HI

IA

ID

IL IN

KS KY

LA

MA

MD

ME

MI

MN

MO

MS

MT

NC

ND

NE

NH

NJ

NM

NV

NY

OH

OK

OR

PARI

SC

SD

TN

TX

UTVA

VTWA

WI

WV

WY

CYT: 4 Sites

EAT: 36 Sites

Source: Dennis, Ives, & Muck, 2008

Page 37: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Replication and Site Effects

• Treatment can vary by implementation within site/clinic

• We want to compare the range of implementation in practice with the clinical trials

• In order to compare sites, we will at both the central tendency (median) and distribution using a Tukey Box Plot like the one shown here.

Criteria

Median

Middle 50%

“Range”

-2.00

-1.50

-1.00

-0.50

0.00

0.50

1.00

1.50

2.00

2.50

3.00

Page 38: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Range of Effect Sizes (d) for Change in Days of Abstinence (intake to 12 months) by Site

0.00

0.20

0.40

0.60

0.80

1.00

1.20

1.40

4 CYT Sites (f=0.39)(median within site d=0.29)

36 EAT Sites (f=0.21)(median within site d=0.49)

0.00

0.20

0.40

0.60

0.80

1.00

1.20

1.40

Coh

en’s

d

Source: Dennis, Ives, & Muck, 2008

EAT Programs did Better than

CYT on average

75% above CYT median

6 programs completely above CYT

Page 39: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

39

Change in Abstinence by level of Quality Assurance: Adolescent Community Reinforcement Approach (A-CRA)

4%

24%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Training Only Training, Coaching,Certification, Monitoring

% P

oint

Cha

nge

in A

bsti

nenc

e

Source: CSAT 2008 SA Dataset subset to 6 Month Follow up (n=1,961)

Effects associated with Coaching, Certification

and Monitoring (OR=7.6)

Page 40: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Drugs seem so sweet when you meet them – hey her clip is pink, she doesn’t want to hurt anyone

Like falling in love for the fist time

Page 41: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

41

Crime/Violence and Substance Problems Interact to Predict Violent Crime or Arrest

Low

Mod.

High

LowMod

.High

Source: CYT & ATM Data

12 m

onth

rec

idiv

ism

To

vio

lent

cri

me

or a

rres

t

Substance Problem

Scale

Crime and Violence

Scale

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

Crime/ Violence predicted

violent recidivism

(Intake) Substance Problem Severity did

not predict violent recidivism

Knowing both was the best predictor

Page 42: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Overlap with Crime and Violence (cont.)

• Crime levels peak between ages of 15-20 (periods of increased stimulation and low impulse control in the brain)

• Adolescent crime is still the main predictor of adult crime

Page 43: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Treating Teens:

A Guide to Adolescent Drug Programs

http://drugstrategies.com/treatingteens.html

Page 44: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Co-occurring Mental Health Symptoms

A Comparison of Nine Treatment Approaches • Seven Challenges

• Chestnut Health Systems

• Adolescent Community Reinforcement Approach

• Multi-Systemic Therapy

• Multi-Dimensional Family Therapy

• Motivational Enhancement Therapy-Cognitive Behavioral Therapy 5 sessions

• Family Support Network

44

Page 45: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Change (post-pre) Effect Size for Emotional Problems by Type of

Treatment-0

.54

-0.4

3

-0.4

5 -0.3

9

-0.3

7

-0.3

7

-0.3

4 -0.2

9

-0.2

9

-0.1

8

-0.2

8

-0.1

9

-0.3

2

-0.1

9

-0.1

5

-0.2

1 -0.1

3 -0.0

8

-0.0

8

-0.0

9

-0.1

4

-0.2

2

-0.0

4

-0.1

3

-0.1

2 -0.0

8

-0.1

6

-0.80

-0.60

-0.40

-0.20

0.00

0.20

SevenChallenges

(n=114)

CHSTreatment(n=192)

A-CRA-CYT/AAFT

(n=2144) MST(n=85)

MDFT(n=258)

METCBT-CYT/EAT(n=5262)

METCBT-Other

(n=878) FSN

(n=369)

A-CRA-Other

(n=276)

Cha

nge

Eff

ect S

ize

d ((

mea

n fo

llow

-up

- m

ean

inta

ke)/

std

dev

. int

ake)

Emotional Problem Scale Days of traumatic memories Days of victimization

Four best on mental health outcomes include 7 challenges,

CHS, A-CRA, & MST

Page 46: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Workforce Implications

• All programs reduced mental health / trauma problems with 4 doing particularly well: Seven Challenges, CHS, A-CRA, & MST

• A-CRA with a mix of BA/MA did as well as MST which targets MA level therapists and family therapists that are often in short supply

• Seven Challenges, with a mix of para-professional (non-degreed), BA/MA therapists did as well as A-CRA and MST

• While it is not the most effective, the shortest & least expensive (MET/CBT5) still has positive effects

46

Page 47: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Farm Party Anyone?

Ever evolvingCyclical nature of use

Page 48: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Wh

at the Brai

n Science Presente

d W

ill N

ot D

o

Make you an expert in the

science of the brain (or return to your brain everything you have forgott

en since undergraduate school).Assist you in obtaining funding for PET/M

RI/fMRI

or other technologies to screen all of your youth.Provide all of the inform

ation about the adolescent brain that is useful to know

. Sett

le the argument:

addiction is/is not a diseaseN

o quiz will follow

the presentation.

Page 49: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Continuing Care

• The continuation of services in a seamless flow is imperative for successful client outcomes

• All too often, they fall through the cracks in the system

= 14 days

Page 50: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Do adolescents attend 12 step meetings after residential

discharge?

85%

42%

4.5

00%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Attended One or More Meetings Median No. Meetings Attended0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

Adults Adolescents

Page 51: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Assertive Continuing Care

• The Assertive Continuing Care Protocol (ACC) is a continuing care intervention specifically designed for adolescents following a period of residential treatment.

• ACC is delivered primarily through home visits. • ACC case managers are assertive in their attempts

to engage participants.• Case managers deliver the Adolescent Community

Reinforcement Approach (ACRA) procedures

Page 52: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Early (0-3 mon.) Abstinence Then Improves Sustained (4-9 mon.)

Abstinence

Source: Godley et al 2002, 2007

19% 22% 22%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Any AOD (OR=11.16*) Alcohol (OR=5.47*) Marijuana (OR=11.15*)

Early(0-3 mon.) Relapse

69%

59%

73%

Early (0-3 mon.) Abstainer * p<.05

Page 53: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Self-Management and Recovery Training: (SMART) Recovery

• Origins in Rational Emotive Therapy• Portable, applicable in real world, online

groups• Group Modality

– Led by trained facilitators– Open enrollment– Uses common elements of CBT– Considered easy to learn and use– http://www.smartrecovery.org/intro/

Page 54: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Technological Approaches CONTINUING CARE/Ongoing

Supportive Services– University of Arizona – pod casting, texting, geo-

fencing• 90 – 95% Engagement, Utilization, Satisfaction

– Recovery Services for Adolescents and their Families (RSAF) CSAT Research Project (Cell phone, Texting, Web Site, CRAFT for Parent Groups)

– Dick Dillon , St. Louis – Second Life• Continuing Care Participation Increased from

40% to 90% over 6 months

Page 55: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Normal Adolescent Development

Page 56: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Normal Adolescent Development

Based on the stage of their brain development, adolescents are more likely to:• act on impulse• misread or misinterpret social cues and

emotions• get into accidents of all kinds• get involved in fights• engage in dangerous or risky behavior

Page 57: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Normal Adolescent Development

Adolescents are less likely to:• think before they act• pause to consider the potential consequences

of their actions• modify their dangerous or inappropriate

behaviors

Page 58: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Normal Adolescent Development

• Movement Towards Independence• Struggle with sense of identity • Feeling awkward or strange about one's self

and one's body • Focus on self, alternating between high

expectations and poor self-esteem • Interests and clothing style influenced by peer

group • Moodiness

Page 59: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Normal Adolescent DevelopmentMovement Towards Independence, Cont. • Improved ability to use speech to express

one's self• Realization that parents are not perfect;

identification of their faults • Less overt affection shown to parents, with

occasional rudeness • Complaints that parents interfere with

independence • Tendency to return to childish behavior,

particularly when stressed

Page 60: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Normal Adolescent Development

• Future Interests and Cognitive Changes

• Mostly interested in present, with limited thoughts of the future

• Intellectual interests expand and gain in importance

• Greater ability to do work (physical, mental, emotional)

Page 61: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Normal Adolescent Development• Sexuality• Display shyness, blushing, and modesty • Girls develop physically sooner than boys • Increased interest in sex • Movement toward heterosexuality with fears

of homosexuality • Concerns regarding physical and sexual

attractiveness to others • Frequently changing relationships • Worries about being normal

Page 62: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Normal Adolescent Development

• Morals, Values, and Self-Direction• Rule and limit testing • Capacity for abstract thought • Development of ideals and selection of role

models • More consistent evidence of conscience • Experimentation with sex and drugs

(cigarettes, alcohol, and marijuana)

Page 63: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Time for a BreakDo I Want a Cookie or Cocaine?

Page 64: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

How Does the Brain Communicate?

• Neuron to Neuron• Neurotransmitters - The Brain's Chemical

Messenger • Receptors - The Brain's Chemical Receivers• Transporters - The Brain's Chemical Recyclers

Page 65: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Everyone who has watched futurama knows slugs will feed on your brain

Page 66: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

How did this happen? She was so good to me! The colors are pretty.

Page 67: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Right lateral and top views of the dynamic sequence of maturation over the cortical surface

Gogtay N et al. PNAS 2004;101:8174-8179

©2004 by National Academy of Sciences

Page 68: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Brain Activity on PET Scan After Cocaine Use

Be VERY Careful with interpretation of data/ imaging studies!

Page 69: Dual Diagnosis– Understanding the Unique Challenges Facing Children Suffering from Co-occurring Behavioral Health and Addiction Disorders Randolph D. Muck,

Summary• Know what treatment services are provided

(EBP?, Appropriate for identified problems?, Implemented with fidelity?)

• Understand brain science and addiction• Ensure EBPs used that can be done well given

limitations (staff experience/training, cost, belief in approach)

• Push for appropriate services and demand outcome data and ongoing

CLINICAL SUPERVISION • DO NOT Ignore Continuing

Care/Supportive Services! =