Donald Nease and Frank Dornfest
description
Transcript of Donald Nease and Frank Dornfest
Creating an innovative way for the Patient-Centered Medical Home to respond to patients with complex
problems and dysfunctional styles of interaction
Donald Nease and Frank Dornfest
Forces impacting Primary Care
•Tension between population health and individual responsibility
•Government cost containment/New payment structures
•New roles and members of practices
What about our patients?
•Increasing incidence of chronic disease
•Multimorbidity
•Fraying social structures eroding traditional sources of support
attachment theory
•proposed by Bowlby as a way to understand why and how people form varying attachments to others
•formation of a secure attachment style depends on the existence of a “secure base” in early life
Attachment Theory - basic concepts
(John Bowlby & Mary Ainsworth)
•Refugees…
•Marginalised…
•Damaged by early abuse/neglect
•Mothers (parents)…
•Elderly…
•Bereaved…
• and…
…special needs (to feel secure….)
•Doctors…!
•Nurses…!
•Receptionists…et al
PROFESSIONALS!
•The Practice as a Secure Base?
•What makes a Practice Secure/Insecure?
•For professionals?
•For patients?
•Understanding Patterns of Consultation?
A Useful Concept for Primary Care
•What does a practice feel like for those who work there?
•How is the boundary function managed?
•How does the practice express its capacity to be reflective? Mentalisation – self and other?
•Narrative competence? Shared history…story of the practice?
•Role of MH professionals? In or out?
•Role of play/creativity
•How is change/loss (and trauma) managed?
The Practice as a Secure BaseQuestions?
Mentalization
•“the mental process by which an individual implicitly and explicitly interprets the actions of himself and others as meaningful on the basis of intentional mental states such as personal desires, needs, feelings, beliefs and reasons” Bateman and Fonagy 2004
Lack of secure emotional connection to parent -
Lack of a “secure base”
Impaired capacity to read emotional content of
interactions
Difficulty establishing a trusting relationship
Mistrust and misunderstanding of
medical context
Patients that interact with us inappropriately
“They must be trying to abuse me or the system”
Attachment Mentalization
Mentalization & Emotion
•When it works - Positive emotions increase
•When it fails - Negative emotions increase
•Negative emotions appear to impair mentalization on FMRI scans
• 420 recorded visits to UK primary care with MUS
•Discussions analyzed utterance by utterance
• Physical intervention proposed more by docs than patients
• Few docs showed empathy
•Was there a failure of mentalization?
• Ring, et. al, The somatising effect of clinical consultation: what patients and doctors say and do not say when patients present medically unexplained physical symptoms, Soc Sci Med 2005 vol. 61 (7) pp. 1505-1515
Balint groupsFirst established in the UK by Michael and Enid Balint
Utilize a case presentation/discussion format in a small group
Purpose is to reflectively explore specific "troubling" patients and the relationship
Michael Balint Born in 1896 in Budapest, son
of a GP
Psychoanalytic training in Berlin and Budapest, emigrated to London, worked at the Tavistock Clinic
He and his 3rd wife, Enid, began the training/research seminars for GPs after WW II
1957 “The Doctor, his Patient and the Illness” published
“At the center of medicine there is always a human relationship between a patient and a doctor.”
-Michael Balint
“In contrast to didactics or reading, the Balint process reaches past the rational system to influence intuitive functioning. It does so by engaging the intuitive system through encouraging nonjudgmental speculation, while at the same time monitoring rationally by juxtaposing the doctor and patient's views.”
“One of the strengths of Balint work is that the group can take a problem and introspect out loud with the presenter, who is free to incorporate or reject new
understandings.”
Lichtenstein and Lustig, Integrating intuition and reasoning--how Balint groups can help medical decision making, Australian family physician 2006 vol. 35 (12) pp. 987-989
Balint groups enhance
Mentalization!
What a Balint Group is not
Psychotherapy Group
Encounter Group
Traditional Case Consultation Group
M&M Conference
Topic Discussion Group
Personal and Professional Development Group
Not prescriptive, didactic, advice giving
Characteristics of a Balint Group
• Ideally fixed membership
• Closed Group
• Ideally two co-leaders
• Focus on doctor-patient relationship
• Power of the group
• Preference for an ongoing case
• Less conscious aspects of relationship
Confidentiality
Avoid Advice Ownership
Respect, Turn Taking
Ground Rules
Leader
Leader
The Group Convenes
Leader
Leader
Calling for the Case
Who’s got a case?
Cases•Presentations are spontaneous
•Patients we have ongoing relationships with
•Patients who we feel conflicted or strongly about (stuck)
•Patients that leave us feeling unfinished, who we lose sleep over
•Patients who we “take home” with us
•Patients that bubble up in the moment
Leader
Leader
Group Process
I do.I do.
Leader
Leader
Presenter
The Case Arrives
Angela is a 79 yr old blind woman….
Leader
Leader
Presenter
Clarifying Questions
Are there any clarifying questions?
Leader
Leader
The Presenter gets to Listen
Why don’t we let the presenter just listen while we work the
case
Leader
Leader
Presenter
The Group Starts Working
I imagine Angela to be…
Leader
Leader
Presenter
Imagining Patient and
Doctor
If I were the doctor, I might
feel…
Leader
Leader
Presenter
Group Exploration Continues
This image just popped into my mind of a…
Functions of Group Members
•Explore doctor-patient relationship
•Look inward, be imaginative, creative, look for less conscious aspects
•Attend to and share thoughts, images, fantasies, associations, hypotheses
•Differentiate one’s own experience from presenter’s
•Further empathic understandings
Functions of Balint Leaders
•Create and maintain a safe space
•Structure and hold the group over time
•Protect presenter and group members
•Encourage reflection, empathy and compassion
•Attend to group development
•Debrief with co-leader after each group
Group time
•Not only training…
•Linking the two…powerful organisational impact
•Practice-based Balint Groups
•Primary Care Team (Tuesday) Meetings
•Making a House a Home
•Changing Models of Employment
PCMH, Attachment, Mentalization and Balint:
Putting them together
Lack of secure emotional connection to parent -
Lack of a “secure base”
Impaired capacity to read emotional content of
interactions
Difficulty establishing a trusting relationship
Mistrust and misunderstanding of
medical context
Patients that interact with us inappropriately
“They must be trying to abuse me or the system”
A PCMH with a Balint Group - A secure base for
patients
Patients with impaired attachment can be better understood and cared for
Attachment Mentalization
Balint catalyzing formation of a secure
base•Provides a safe environment for clinical staff to
bring their difficult interactions with patients
•Multiple perspectives encouraged
•Playful speculation a plus
•Difficult emotions are surfaced and detoxified
•If successful the practice becomes a secure base for staff and patients
For further info...
•The American Balint Society
•americanbalintsociety.org
•Don Nease: [email protected]
•Frank Dornfest: [email protected]