dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm...

64
dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμ rbs;sakSI nI kn 6 skçIkmμ rbs;sakSI sKWm lμ út 17 skçIkmμ rbs;sakSI esA sarun 25 skçIkmμ rbs;sakSI xwm gn 36 skçIkmμ rbs;sakSI eGOn tan 38 skçIkmμ rbs;sakSI yun KIm 45 skçIkmμ rbs;sakSI exov enA 53 RkumsegátkarN_³ qay Qu nl I / D I su Cata/ l w m C ½ yT ½ t þ n i g can R)af ñ a 13 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm< úCa EsVgrkkarBitedIm,IkarcgcaM nigyutþ iFm’ www.dccam.org ExkkádaqñaM2012 sßanPaBkñúgshkrN_enArbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü ¬RbPBÉksar³ mCÄmNÐ lÉksarkm< ú Ca¦ rcnasm<½n§rdæ)al nigRbB½n§TMnak;TMng nigtYnaTI rbs;CnCab;ecaTkñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü

Transcript of dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm...

Page 1: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmsegátkarN_

matikabBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2

skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI kn 6

skçIkmμrbs;sakSI sKWm l μút 17skçIkmμrbs;sakSI esA sarun 25

skçIkmμrbs;sakSI xwm gn 36

skçIkmμrbs;sakSI eGOn tan 38skçIkmμrbs;sakSI yun KIm 45

skçIkmμrbs;sakSI exov enA 53

RkumsegátkarN_ ³qay QunlI/ DI suCata/lwm C½yT½tþ nig can R)afña

13

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa EsVgrkkarBitedIm,IkarcgcaM nigyutþiFm’ www.dccam.org

ExkkádaqñaM2012

ssßßaannPPaaBBkkññúúggsshhkkrrNN__eennAArrbbbbkkmm<<úúCCaaRRbbCCaaFFiibbeettyyüü

¬¬RRbbPPBBÉÉkkssaarr³³ mmCCÄÄmmNNÐÐllÉÉkkssaarrkkmm<<úúCCaa¦¦

rcnasm<½n§rdæ)al nigRbB½n§TMnak;TMng nigtYnaTIrbs;CnCab;ecaTkñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü

Page 2: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

RRkkúúmmeemmddwwkknnaaMMEExxμμrrRRkkhhmmeennAAkkññúúggrrffeePPøøIIgg ¬¬RRbbPPBBÉÉkkssaarr ³³ mmCCÄÄmmNNÐÐllÉÉkkssaarrkkmm<<úúCCaa¦¦

b:ul Bt

nYn Ca tam:uk

v:n evt

Page 3: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 1

svnakarelIsMNuMerOg002 ³ rcnasm<½n§rdæ)al nigRbB½n§TMnak;TMng

nigtYnaTIrbs;CnCab;ecaTkñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü

éf¶TI21 Ex]sPa dl;éf¶TI21 Exmifuna qñaM2012

qayQunlI/ DI suCata/ can R)afña nig lwm C½yT½tþ

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

esckþIepþIm

bnÞab;BIkarsþab;skçIkmμrbs;sakSI Ban eXon )an

bBa©b;enAéf¶TI16 Ex]sPa qñaM2012 GgÁCMnMuCRmHsala

dMbUgénGgÁCMnMuCRmHvisamBaØkñúgtulakarkm<úCa )anp¥aksvnakar

edaysarbBaðasuxPaBrbs;CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI.

rhUtmkdl;éf¶TI21 eTIbsvnakarcab;epþImdMeNIrkarCafμI.

b:uEnþedaysuxPaBCnCab;ecaT eGog sarI enAEtecaTCabBaða

dUecñHenAéf¶dEdlenH GgÁCMnMuCRmH)anRbkasp¥aksvnakar

nig)ankMNt;ykbBaðasuxPaBrbs;CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI

mkeeFVIkarsYredjedalenAkñúgsvnakardac;edayELkmYy

enAéf¶TI23 Ex]sPa qaM2012. svnakaréf¶TI23enH

GgÁCMnMuCRmH)anekaHGeBa¢IjelakevC¢bNÐitlwmsIuvutßa mksak

sYrGMBIbBaðasuxPaBCnCab;ecaT eGog sarI. bnÞab;BI

svnakarenH)anbBa©b; GgÁCMnMuCRmH)anRbkasp¥aksvnakar

rhUtdl;éf¶TI28 Ex]sPa qñaM2012. karseRmcenH

KWedaysarCnCab;ecaT eGog sarI manbBaðasuxPaBminGac

cUlrYmkñúgkic©dMeNIrkarnItiviFIsþab;skçIkmμrbs;sakSI)an.

KYrbBa¢ak;fa cab;BIéf¶TI23 Ex]sPa qñaM2012 dl;éf¶TI21

Exmifuna qñaM2012 GgÁCMnMuCRmHsaladMbUg)ansþab;skçI

kmμrbs;evC¢bNÐit lwm sIuvutßa sþIGMBIbBaðasuxPaBrbs;

CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI nigsakSIcMnYn7rUbCabnþbnÞab;

Tak;TgnwgGgÁehtuEdlRtÚvseRmcenAkñúgtMNak;kalTI1

énsMNMuerOg002. sakSITaMg7 rYmman ° TI1¦ elak nI kn

KWCab¥ÚnRbúsbegáItrbs; sun esn ¬rdæm®nþIénRksYgkarBarCati

enAkñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü¦. elakmantYnaTICaGñk

eXasnaGb;rMRbCaCn[cUlrYmkñúgclnabdivtþ nigTTYlbnÞúk

CaRbFancaghVagEpñkBiFIkarenARksYg karbreTs. TI2¦

elak srKwm lμút ehA mI KWCabuKÁlmñak; Edl)an]btßmR)ak;

dl;clnabdivtþrbs;ExμrRkhm. kñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü

elakmantYnaTICaGKÁnaykrgFnaKaBaNiC¢kmμkm<úCa Edl

RtÚv)anbegáIteLIgedIm,ICYy sRmÜldl;kareFVIBaNiC¢kmμeRkA

RbeTs. TI3¦ elak esA sarun KWCaGtItelxaRsuk eBRCcinþa

kñúgcenøaHqñaM1971-1978 EdleRkaymkkøayCaRbFan

kgBltMbn;105. TI4¦ elak xwm gn KWCaGtItGñkbMerIkar

garenAsßanTUtcin ehIybnÞab;mkRtÚv)ancat;taMg[bMeBjkar

garCaGñkTTYlePJóvenARksYgkarbreTs edayTTYlbnÞúkerob

cMmðÚbGahar. TI5¦ elak eGOn tan KWCa GtItnirsar nigkg

karBarrbs; b:ul Bt cab;BIqñaM 1970-1979. kñúgrbbkm<úCa

RbCaFibetyü elakbeRmIkargarenAkñúgmnÞIrk1 ¬CakEnøgsñak;

enA nigCakEnøgeFVIkarpÞal;rbs; b:ul Bt¦ edayTTYlbnÞúkCa

GñkkarBarsnþisuxsRmab;kic©RbCMuFM²enAmnÞIrk-1 nigrt;

sMbuRtb¤sarTUrelxBImnÞIrk-7eTAb:ulBtnigbBa¢ÚnbnþeTA nYn

Ca.T I6 elak yn; KIm KWCaGtItRbFanshkrN_ERsexOn

eRkaymkCakøayCaRbFanmnÞIrsnþisuxb-3. elak)an

pþl;skçIkmμya:geRcInBak;B½n§nwgkare)assm¥atkmμaPi)al

kñúgextþRkecH nigTI7¦ elak exov enA CaGtItGñkRKb;

RKgkardwkCBa¢ÚnsmÖar³rbs;rdæeTAtamPUmiPaKepSg²enAkñúg

GMLúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü.

kñúgGMLúgeBlénsvnakarTaMgenH manRbCaCnkm<úCa

Page 4: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

cUlrYmsþab;edaypÞal;RbmaN4300nak; EdlmkBIbNþa

extþnanaTUTaMgRbeTskm<úCatamkarGeBa¢Ijrbs;m®nþItulakar

TTYlbnÞúkEpñkkic©karsaFarN³.kñúgkarsYredjedalsakSI

GgÁCMnM uCRmH)anENnaMRKb;PaKI[ecaTsMNYredayepþat

sMxan;elIGgÁehtuTak;Tgnwg rcnasm<½n§RKb;RKg rdæ)al RbB½n§

TMnak;TMngkargar nigtYnaTIrbs;CnCab;ecaTmñak;²enAkñúg

rbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü.

KYrbBa¢ak;fa munnwgpþl;evTikaCUnPaKIkñúgkarecaTsYr

sakSI RbFanGgÁCMnuMCRmH)anbBa¢ak;CUnsakSITaMgGs;GMBIsiT§i

minpþl;skçIkmμRbqaMgnwgxøÜnÉgEdlnaM[manBiruT§PaB nig

krNIkic©rbs;sakSIkñúgkareqøIytbsMNYrrbs;PaKIepSg²nUv

GVIEdlxøÜn)andwg )anB¤ )aneXIjenAkñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFib

etyü elIkElgEtkareqøIysMNYrenaHGacbNþal[dak;

BiruT§PaBmkelIxøÜnÉg.tamry³siT§ienH GgÁCMnMuCRmH)anpþl;

emFavIRbwkSamñak;sRmab;sakSIeFVIkarRbwkSamunnwgpþl;skçIkmμ

CUnGgÁCMnMuCRmH.

I¦ svnakarsþIBIbBaðasuxPaBCnCab;ecaT eGogsarI

1¦ karBiPakSaelIr)aykarN_suxPaBCnCab;ecaT

eGogsarI

éf¶TI21 Ex]sPa qñaM2012 GgÁCMnMuCRmHsala

dMbUg)anbnþebIksvnakar edaysYredjedalsakSIfμ I

mYyrUbeTotEdlmanrh½snamfa TCW-487. munnwgQan

dl;karsYredjedalsakSI elakRbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmH)an

bgÁab;[elakRkLabBa¢I Duc parI eLIgraykarN_GMBIvtþman nig

Gvtþmanrbs;PaKITaMgGs;enAkñúgbnÞb;svnakar. bnÞab;BIkar

raykarN_rbs;RkLabBa¢I emFavInaMmuxtMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,

evNICati KWelak eBC GgÁ )anesñIGgÁCMnMuCRmHedIm,ITTYl

sÁal;elakRsIemFavItMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNIGnþrCatifμI

CnCati)araMg maneQμaHLÚr_ edshVks_ ¬Laure Desforges¦.

GgÁCMnM uCRmH)anTTYlsÁal;emFavItMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,

evNItamsMeNIrbs;elakshemFavInaMmuxCati. elak

RbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmH)anbgÁab;[RkLabBa¢IeLIgGanr)aykarN_

BinitüsuxPaB EdlecjedayevC¢bNÐit lwm sIuvutßa edIm,ICUn

dMNwgdl;buKÁlEdlBak;B½n§)anRCabBIsßanPaBsuxPaBrbs;

CnCab;ecaT eGogsarI nigedIm,IeFIVCamUldæankñúgkarBiPakSa.

CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI )anGvtþman edaysarCMgW nig)an

bBa¢ÚneTAsRmakBüa)alenAmnÞIreBTü mitþPaBExμr-sUevot

kalBIéf¶TI16 Ex]sPa qñaM2012 knøgmkenAkñúgr)ay

karN_BinitüsuxPaBenaH)anbBa¢ak;fa CnCab;ecaT eGogsarI

maneraKsBaØak¥kCab; Bi)akdkdegðIm nigvilmux. bEnßmBIelI

enH eGog sarI RtÚv)anrkeXIjfa manCMgWrlakTgsYtRsÜc

Rsav bEnßmelIeraKEdlelakmanRsab;BIeBlmun KWCMgWebH

dUg nigsrésQam. b:uEnþ sßanPaBCMgWrbs;CnCab;ecaTman

sPaBFUrRsal ehIynwgGacecjBImnÞIreBTüenARBwkéf¶

GgÁar TI22Ex]sPaqñaM2012xagmux. enAkñúgr)aykarN_

enaHdEdl)anbBa¢ak;bEnßm edaypþl;CaGnusasn_fa

eRkayeBlecjBImnÞIreBTü CnCab;ecaTRtÚvsRmakcMnYn

BIréf¶ edayeyagelIsßanPaBCMgW. KYrkt;smÁal;faenA

resoléf¶TI16 Ex]sPa qñaM2012 enAeBlkMBugdMeNIrkar

nItiviFIsvnakarsYredjedalsakSI Ban eXon eday

RkúmemFavIkarBarkþI nYn Ca Rsab;EtmankarCUndMNwgmYy

edayGgÁCMnMuCRmH bgÁab;[RkúmemFavIkarBarkþI eGog sarI

cuHeTABinitüemIlsßanPaBkUnkþIrbs;xøÜnenAbnÞb;xageRkam

svnakar KWenAkñúgbnÞb;rg;caMEdl eGog sarI EtgEttamdan

nItiviFIsvnakaredayRbeyalBITIenaH. karbgÁab;[Rkúm

emFavIkarBar eGog sarI cuHeTABinitüsßanPaBsuxPaBkUnkþI

rbs;xøÜn KWedaysarGgÁCMnMuCRmH)anTTYldMNwgBIm®nþItulakar

fa eGogsarI manbBaðavilmux nigBi)akdkdegðIm EdltRmÚv[

RtÚvEtbBa¢ÚneTAmnÞIreBTüedIm,IBüa)alCabnÞan;. bnÞab;mk

svnakar)anbnþeFI VedayGvtþmanCnCab;ecaT eGog

sarI. bnÞab;BIRkLabBa¢ I)anGanr)aykarN_rYc elak

RbFanGgÁCMnM uCRmH)ansYreTAkan;PaKITaMgGs;Edlman

bMNgelIkeLIgBIeyabl;epSg²Tak;TgnwgbBaðsuxPaBrbs;

eGog sarI. Pøam²enaH emFavIGnþrCatikarBarkþI[CnCab;ecaT

2 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 5: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

eGog sarI KWelak ém:eXIl kaNav:as elIkeLIgfa kar

BiteTA eGog sarI min)ane)aHbg;siTi§cUlrYmenAkñúgdMeNIrkar

nItiviFIsvnakareT. elak)an bnþfa ebItamCMhrrbs;elak

KWsvnakarminKYrbnþeTAmuxeLIy KWRtÚvrg;caMrhUtdl; eGog

sarI CasHes,IyBICMgW b¤rhUtdl;eBlCnCab;ecaTlHbg;

siT§cUlrYmkñúgsvnakarEtmþg. elakfa ebIeyagtam

eKalkarN_GnþrCati CnCab;ecaTRtÚvENnaMemFavIrbs;xøÜn

b:uEnþeBlenHRkúmrbs;elakenAminTan;TTYl)ankarENnaM

NamYyBI eGog sarI enAeLIyeT. eqøIytbnwgkarelIkeLIg

rbs;emFavIkarBarkþI eGogsarI elaktMNagshRBHraCGaCJa

GnþrCati vInsin )anelIkeLIgfa kalBIéf¶TI17 Ex]sPa

qñaM2012 elak eGogsarI )ancakecjBIsvnakaredaysar

bBaðasuxPaB ehIy)anyl; RBm[mankarbnþnItiviFIsYrsMNYr

sakSI Ban eXon mþgrYcehIy. eyagtamviFan81 énviFan

épÞkñúg caM)ac;RtÚvEtbBa¢ak;fa etICnCab;ecaT eGog sarI

yl;RBm[eFIVdUecñHeTot b¤y:agNa. b:uEnþGVIEdllM)ak

KWemFavIminGacTak;TgCnCab; ecaT eGog sarI )an. elak

tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa)anbnþeTotfa eyIgmindwgfa eGog

sarI RtLb;cUlmksvnakarenAeBlNaeT ehIyebIéf¶Es¥k

CnCab;ecaTvilmkvijenaHCnCab;ecaTGacmanlT§PaB tam

dannItiviFIsvnakarBIbnÞb;;xageRkam)an. rIÉemFavICatinaMmux

tMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNI KWelak eBCGgÁ minmankarCMTas;

elIkarelIkeLIgedayemFavIkarBarkþIeT nigKaMRTcMeBaHkar

eKarBsiT§irbs;CnCab;ecaTkñúgkarcUlrYmsvnakar. cMENk

ÉemFavICatikarBarkþI nYn Ca KWelaksun GruN)anKaMRTcMeBaH

sMeNIrbs;emFavIkarBarkþI eGog sarI nig)anelIkeLIgfa

svnakarKYrEtp¥akCabeNþaHGasnñsin rg;caMkarvilRtLb;

mkvijrbs;CnCab;ecaT eGogsarI edaysarsakSITCW-487

mankarBak;B½n§eRcInelIkrNIrbs; eGog sarI. emFavIkarBar

kþICnCab;ecaT exov sMpn k¾)aneFVIkarKaMRTcMeBaHkarelIk

eLIgrbs;elak emFavI kaNav:as Edr.

bnÞab;BI)ansþab;karelIkeLIgrbs;PaKIenAkñ úg

svnakarGgÁCMnMuCRmH)aneFIVkarBiPakSa nigpþl;evTikaCUnelak

RsIecARkm sIulevo xatRv:ayt_ edIm,IsYrsMNYrbBa¢ak;BIRkúm

emFavIkarBarkþICnCab;ecaT eGogsarI. elakRsIecARkm)an

esñI[RkúmemFavIkarBarkþI eGog sarI pþl;nUvB½t’mansþIBIsßan

PaBsuxPaBrbs; eGogsarI nigesñI[eFVIkarbBa¢ak;BIPaBlM)ak

kñúgkar Tak;TgrvagRkúmemFavIkarBarkþICamYykUnkþIrbs;xøÜnenA

eBlEdlkUnkþIsßitenAkñúgmnÞIreBTü. elak emFavI kaNav:as

)aneqøIytbcMeBaHsMeNITaMgBIrenHfa cMeBaHkarpþl;B½t’manBI

sßanPaBsuxPaBrbs;CnCab;ecaTeTAsaFarN³CnenaH

KWCaerOgl¥mYyEdlGac[RKb;Kña)anRCabBIbBaðaenH ehIy

elakKitfa eGogsarI minmankarCMTas;cMeBaHkarpþl;B½t’man

enaHeLIy nigeFIVy:agNaedIm,I[mantmøaPaB. cMeBaHsMeNI

TIBIr elakemFavI)aneqøIytbfa elakminGacTak;TgkUnkþI rbs;

xøÜn)aneT eRBaHxagmnÞIreBTü)anR)ab;faelakminGaccUleTA

CYb eGogsarI )aneLIy enAeBlenH.bnÞab;mkRbFanGgÁCMnMu

CRmH KWelakecARkm nilNun )anbBa¢ak;fa edayeKarBtam

eKalkarN_c,ab;GnþrCati cMeBaHkareKarBnUvsiT§irbs;Cn

Cab;ecaTkñúgkarcUlrYmsvnakar nigEp¥ktamviFan81¬5¦

énviFanépÞkñúg GgÁCMnMuCRmHseRmcp¥aksvnakarry³eBlBIr

éf¶ KWéf¶TI21dl;éf¶TI23 Ex]sPa qñaM2012.elakecARkm

)anbBa¢ak;bEnßmfa enAéf¶TI23 GgÁCMnMuCRmHnwgeFIVkarBiPakSa

edaysþab;nUvmtieyabl;pÞal;rbs;elakevC¢bNÐit lwm

sIuvutßa faetIlT§PaBrbs;CnCab;ecaT eGogsarI bnÞab;BIecj

mnÞIreBTüenaHGaccUlrYmenAkñúgdMeNIrkarsvnakar)ankRmit

Na nigtamrebobNa. ebIkarsþab;eyabl;rbs;elakevC¢

bNÐit eXIjfasßanPaBsuxPaBrbs;CnCab;ecaTmansPaB

viC¢man GgÁCMnMuCRmHnwgbnþsvnakarPøam b:uEnþebIeyabl;enaH

manPaBGviC¢man GgÁCMnMuCRmHnwgCRmabenAeBleRkayfanwg

RtÚvbnþdMeNIrkarsvnakary:agdUcemþc. sUmbBa¢ak;fa

svnakarnaenAéf¶TI21 Ex]sPa qñaM2012 )anbBa©b;enA

evla em:ag9³52naTIRBwk.

2¦ karedjedalBak;B½n§nwgsßanPaBsuxPaB

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 3

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 6: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

CnCab;ecaT eGogsarI

éf¶TI23 Ex]sPa qñaM2012GgÁCMnMuCRmHsaladMbUg

)anebIksvnakar edIm,IsYredj edalevC¢bNÐit lwm sIuvutßa

bEnßmelIr)aykarN_EdlelakevC¢bNÐit)anecj Tak;Tgnwg

sßanPaBsuxPaBrbs;CnCab;ecaT eGogsarI.

muneBlcab;epþImsvnakar emFavIFaGnþrCatikarBarkþI

CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI KWelak ém:eXIl kaNav:as )an

eRkakQr nigCUndMNwgGgÁCMnMuCRmHGMBIsßanPaBrbs;kUnkþI

rbs;xøÜn. elakemFavI kaNav:as)anbBa¢ak;fa elak)anCYb

BiPakSaCamYynwgkUnkþIrbs;xøÜnkalBIeBlRBwk muneBlsvnakar

cab;epþIm ehIyelak)aneFIVesckþIEføgkarN_CMnYs eGog sarI.

enAkñúg esckþIEføgenaH elakemFavI)anelIkeLIgnUvcMNuc4KW°

1¦ CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI sMumincUlrYmenAkñúgkic©

dMeNIrkarnItiviFIeT edaysarsßanPaBsuxPaB.

2¦CnCab;ecaT eGogsarI nwgminCMTas;cMeBaHkaryk

bBaðasuxPaBrbs;xøÜnmkBiPakSaenAkñúgsvnakarsaFarN³ eT.

3¦ eGog sarI BMu)anlHbg;siTi§rbs;xøÜnkñúgkarman

vtþmanenAGMLúgkic©dMeNIrkarnItiviFI sYredjedalsakSIBIrrUb

EdleRKagnwgpþl;skçIkmμeT enAeBlEdlsakSITaMgBIrrUb

mankarCab;Tak;TgedaypÞal; b¤edayRbeyal cMeBaHskmμ

PaB b¤karRbRBwtþi EdlecaTRbkan;RbqaMgnwgxøÜn.

4¦ eGogsarI nwgrkSasiTi§mincUlrYmenAkñúgsvnakar

sYredjedalsakSIepSg EdlminmankarCab;Bak;B½n§nwgkar

ecaTRbkan;RbqaMgnwgxøÜn eRBaHCnCab;ecaTmincg;eFIV[man

karBnüaeBldl;kic©dMeNIrkarnItiviFIenAeBlxagmux.

Tak;TgnwgsßanPaBkUnkþIrbs;xøÜn elak kaNav:as

)anbBa¢ak;CUnGgÁCMnMuCRmHfa eGog sarI EtgEtvilmuxenAeBl

Büayamp©g;GarmμN_elIsBIry³eBl5naTI. dUecñH eGog sarI

)anesñIsMup¥akkic©dMeNIrkarnItiviFIsRmab;s)aþh_enH Edl

eRKagnwgsYredjedalsakSIBIr rUbEdlelIkeLIgBIxagedIm.

elakemFavI)anbnþeTotfa CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI BitCacg;

cUlrYmkñúgsvnakarsYredjedalsakSI edayenArg;caM[mankar

ekaHBIsMNak;GgÁCMnMuCRmH b:uEnþedaysarEtkUnkþIrbs;elak

manGarmμN_faminGaccUlrYmenAkñúgkic©dMeNIrkarnItiviFI)aneTIb

xøÜnesñIsMu[mankarBnüaeBl.

2>1 karsYredjedaledayRbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmH

nil Nun

RbFanGgÁCMnM uCRmH elakecARkm nil Nun )ancab;

epþImsvnakar edIm,IeFIVkarsYredjedalelakevC¢bNÐit sIuvutßa

GMBIsßanPaBsuxPaBrbs;CnCab;ecaT eGogsarI ehIy)anekaH

ehAelakevC¢bNÐit lwm suIvutßa cUlbnÞb;svnakar. elak

RbFan)anCRmabelakevC¢bNÐitfa GgÁCMnuMCRmHnwgsþab;mti

eyabl;rbs;elakevC¢bNÐitGMBIsßanPaBsuxPaBrbs;CnCab;

ecaT eGogsarI ehIymti eyabl;enaHnwgRtÚvGgÁCMnMuCRmHyk

mkBicarNafaetICnCab;ecaT eGog sarI GaccUlrYmenAkñúg

svnakar)anEdrb¤y:agNa. elakRbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmH)ancab;

epþImsYrsMNYrelakevC¢bNÐitGMBIRbvtþisavtar nigRbvtþiénkar

sikSa. elakevC¢bNÐitsIuvutßa )anbBa¢ak;fa elakminmanCab;

Bak;B½n§ b¤Casac;jatiCamYynwgPaKI NamYyenAkñúgsvnakareT

ehIycMeBaHRbvtiþsikSa nigkargarvij elak)anbBa¢ak;fa

elak)anbBa©b;briBaØabRtCMnajevC¢sa®sþénRksYgsuxa

4 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

eGog sarI

Page 7: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 5

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Pi)alenAkñúgqñaM2003 bnÞab;mkelak)an bBa©b;karsikSaenA

mhaviTüal½yEv:kés‘¬Versailles¦kñúgTIRkúg):arIsRbeTs)araMg

CMnajxagCMgWebHdUg. eRkayBIvilRtLb;BIRbeTs)araMg

elak)ancUlbeRmIkarenAmnÞIreBTü mitþPaB Exμr-sUevot Epñk

se®gÁaHbnÞan; kEnøgEdlelakkMBugeFIVkarnaeBlbc©úb,nñ.

elakRbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmH )anbgÁab;[RkLabBa¢Iyk

r)aykarN_BinitüsuxPaBCnCab; ecaT eGog sarI CUnelak

evC¢bNÐitedIm,IeFIVkarBinitü nigepÞógpÞat;faetIr)aykarN_

enaHBit Car)aykarN_EdleFIVeLIgedayelakevC¢bNÐitEmn

b¤eT. elakevC¢bNÐit)anbBa¢ak;fa r)aykarN_Binitü

suxPaBenaH BitCar)aykarN_EdlecjedayrUbelakpÞal;

ehIyrUbelakk¾CaGñkBinitü nigtamdanGMBIsßanPaBsuxPaB

rbs;elak eGogsarI Edr. elak)anbEnßmfa elak)anTTYl

bnÞúkBüa)alCnCab;ecaT eGog sarI cab;taMgBIqñaM2011

nig)anrMB£kfa kalBIéf¶TI17 Ex]sPa qñaM2012CnCab;ecaT

eGogsarI RtÚv)anbBa¢ÚnmkmnÞIreBTü mitþPaBExμr-sUevot eday

manGakar³k¥kCab;²Kña EdleFIV[CnCab;ecaTmankarBi)ak

kñúgkardkdegðIm nigeFIV[vilmux. bnÞab;BIbBa¢ÚncUlkñúgbnÞb;

se®gÁaHedIm,IeFIVkarBüa)alrYcehIy Rkúm evC¢bNÐitrkeXIjfa

CnCab;ecaT eGogsarI manbBaðaxagEpñkpøÚvdegðIm nigrlakTg

sYt b:uEnþBMumankarb:HBal;cMeBaHsßanPaBCMgWebHdUgrbs;CnCab;

ecaTeLIy. elakevC¢bNÐit)anbBa¢ak;fa sßanPaBCMgWenH)an

FUrRsalcab;taMgBIéf¶TI1énkarsRmakBüa)alenAmnÞIreBTü

mkemø:H.

2>2 karsYredjedaledayRkúmemFavIkar

BarkþI eGogsarI

emFavIGnþrCatikarBarkþICnCab;ecaT eGog sarI

KWelak ém:eXIl kaNav:as )ansaksYrelakevC¢bNÐitnUv

sMNYrmYycMnYn.sMNYrdMbUg elakemFavI kaNav:as )ansYrfa

etICakarBitEdlb¤eT EdlfaelakevC¢bNÐitminEmnCaGñk

citþviTU b¤CaevC¢bNÐitxagEpñkcitþviTüa? elakevC¢bNÐit

sIuvutßa )anbBa¢ak;fa CakarBitelakminEmnCaGñkcitþviTU b¤evC¢

bNÐitxagEpñkcitþviTüa. elakemFavI)anbnþsYreTotfa

etIelakevC¢bNÐitman)aneFIVBiesaFn_ b¤BinitütamdanBIsmßt

PaBrbs; eGog sarI kñúgkarcUlrYmenAkñúgsvnakarEdrb¤eT?

elakevC¢bNÐit)aneqøIytbnwgsMNYrenHfa muneBlseRmc

fa CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI KYrsRmakry³eBl2éf¶ nigtam

dansvnakarBIbnÞb;rg;caM KWminEmnCakarseRmcrbs;elak

Etmñak;ÉgenaHeT KWmankarcUlrYmseRmcBIevC¢bNÐitepSg

eTotEdlmanCMnajc,as;las;. elakemFavI kaNav:as

)ansYrbnþfa etIevC¢bNÐitEdl)ancUlrYmseRmcenaHman

CMnajEpñkGIVxøH? elakevC¢bNÐit)anbBa¢ak;fa RKÚeBTü

TaMgenaHmanCMnajxagEpñkBüa)alCMgWebHdUg nigCaRKÚeBTü

EdlmanCMnajxagcitþsa®sþ. elakemFavIbnþsMNYrrbs;

xøÜn edaysaksYrGMBIsßanPaBCMgWkUnkþIrbs;xøÜn edayesñI[

elak evC¢bNÐiteFIVkarbBa¢ak;fa etIkarEdl eGog sarI man

Gakar³vilmuxeRkayeBlGgÁúy b¤p©g;GarmμN_elIGIVmYyenA

b:unμannaTIeRkay KWCaerOgEbøk b¤CaerOgFmμtasRmab;mnusS

Edlmanv½ycMNas; ehIymanCMgWebHdUc nigrlakTgsYt

dUcCa eGog sarI? elakevC¢bNÐit)anbBa¢ak;fa

elakm inGaceF I V k a rsn ñ i d æ a n[)ans u Rk wt üc M eB a H

cMNucenH)aneT b:uEnþelakminbdiesFeTfasßanPaBCMgWrbs;

eGog sarI GacbNþalmkBI CMgWpþassay nigrlakTgsYt

rYmTaMgbBaðav½ycas;Crarbs;CnCab;ecaTeGogsarI pg.elak

evC¢bNÐit esg sIuvutßa

Page 8: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

6 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

evC¢bNÐit)anbnþfa eTaHbICaCMgWebHdUgrbs;CnCab;ecaT

eGog sarI mansßanPaBnwgnreRkayBIkarBüa)alk¾edayRkúm

RKÚeBTürbs;elakeCOCak;fa bBaðaCMgWenHnwgvivtþn_eTAmux.

edaysaremIleXIjBIsßanPaBminGacQr nigp©g;GarmμN_

nigbBaðavilmuxrbs;CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI eTIbelakminTan;

GnuBaØat[ eGog sarI cUlrYmedaypÞal;enAkñúgsvnakarry³

eBlmYys)aþh_sin edayrg;caMtamdansßanPaBCMgWrbs;

CnCab; ecaTbnþeTot.

2>3 karsYredjedaledaytMNagshRBH

raCGaCJa

tMNagshRBHraCGaCJaGnþrCati KWelak eDllIsak;

)ansYrsMNYrelakevC¢bNÐit sIuvutßa EtmYysMNYrb:ueNÑaH.

elak)ansYrfa etIkarEdlelakevC¢bNÐitesñI[CnCab; ecaT

eGog sarI Qb;sRmakcMnYn2éf¶enaH KWmincUlrYmdMeNIrkarnIti

viFITaMgRsúg b¤sRmakedaycUlrYmtamdankic©dMeNIrkar

nItiviFIBIbnÞb;rg;caM? elakevC¢bNÐit)aneqøIytbnwgsMNYrenH

fa ry³eBl2éf¶EdlelakesñI[ KWsMu[Qb;sRmakeday

minGnuBaØat[cUlrYmenAkñúgsvnakarTaMgmUlEtmþg.

2>4 karsYredjedaledayshemFavInaMmux

tMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNI

shemFavInaMmuxCatitMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNI KW

elak eBC GgÁ )ansYrsMNYrelak evC¢bNÐit sIuvutßa Tak;Tgnwg

bBaðavilmuxrbs; eGogsarI edayecaTCasMNYrfa etIenAGMLúg

eBlEdl eGogsarI sRmakBüa)alenAmnÞIreBTü CnCab;ecaT

rUbenH manEdl)anniyayBIbBaðavilmuxR)ab;elak b¤Rkúm

kargarrbs;elakevC¢bNÐitEdrb¤eT? elakevC¢bNÐit)an

eqøIytbnwgsMNYrenHfa eGog sarI )ant¥ÚjEt¥rBIbBaðavilmux

muneBlbBa¢ÚneTABüa)alenAmnÞIreBTüeTAeTot. elakemFavI

eBCGgÁ )anbnþsYreTotfa etIkarvilmuxenaHGacekItmanenA

kñúgry³eBlyUr b¤GacCasHesI,ykñúgry³eBlxøI? elak

evC¢bNÐit)anbBa¢ak;fasßanPaBCMgWrbs; eGogsarI gaynwgCa

sHes,Iy b¤enAruaMér: KWGaRs½yelIsPaBCak;Esþg faetIGñkCMgW

GacsRmak)anRKb;RKan; b¤minRKb;RKan; nigbBa¢ak;fasßanPaB

CMgWenH KWmankarCab;Tak;TgnwgCMgWebHdUg nigrlakTgsYtrbs;

CnCab;ecaTEdleFIV[CMgWrbs;CnCab;ecaTenAEtCaecaTCa

bBaða.

KYrkt;smÁal;fa muneBlbBa©b;kic©dMeNIrkarnItiviFI

svnakar elakRbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmH)anesñI[elakemFavI

kaNav:as eFIVkarbBa¢ak;fa etIsakSINamYyEdlkUnkþIrbs;

xøÜnminmanectnalHbg;siTi§kñúgkarcUlrYmsvnakar? elak

emFavI)aneqøIytbfa svnakarsYredjedalsakSIEdl kUn

kþIrbs;elakminmanectnalHbg;siTi§kñúgkarcUlrYmenaH KW

sakSI TCW-487 nigTCW-583.

II¦ svnakarsþIBIkarpþl;skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI kn

enAéf¶TI 28 Ex]sPa qñaM2012 GgÁCMnMuCRmH)an

ebIksvnakareLIgvij edIm,Isþab;skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI kn

ehA Kin b¤sat EdlRtÚv)ansÁal;faCab¥ÚnRbusbegáItrbs;

sun esn GtItrdæm®nþIénRksYgkarBarCatienAkñúgrbbkm<úCa

RbCaFibetyürvagqñaM1975 nigqñaM1979.

svnakarenHmanry³eBlbIéf¶eBj edaymanGñk

PUmi nigsisSnisSitcUlrYmTsSna RbmaNCag500nak;mkBI

bNþaextþmYycMnYn GgÁCMnMuCRmHGnuBaØat[PaKITaMgGs;sYr

edjedalsakSIGMBIGgÁehtuTak;Tgnwg rcnasm<½n§RKb;RKg

rdæ)alRbB½n§TMnak;TMngkargar nigtYnaTIrbs;CnCab;ecaTmñak;²

enAkñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü.

kñúgkarsYredjedalenH PaKI)anepþatelIRbvtþisavtar

rbs;sakSIkñúgkarcUlrYmclnabdivtþ tYnaTIrbs;sakSIkñúg

kareXasnaGb;rMRbCaCnedIm,I[cUlrYmkñ úgclnabdivtþ

tYnaTIrbs;sakSI nigbuKÁlmYycMnYnenAkñúgrcnasm<½n§rbs;

RksYgkarbeTs karTTYl nigkarCUndMeNIrKN³ RbtiPUbreTs

mYycMnYnEdleFVITsSnkic©enAtamPUmiPaKepSg² CaBiess

Tak;TgnwgkarTTYlEpnkarBIfñak;elIedIm,IGnuvtþ nigraykarN_

GMBIbBaðaepSg²eTAfñak;elIvij.

Page 9: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

1¦ Rbvtþisavtarrbs;sakSI

elaknI kn ehA{kn}Gayu69qñaM manRsukkMeNItenA

km<úCaeRkam RsukRtayIg ¬ExμrehAfaRsukRBHRtBaMg¦

bc©úb,nñrs;enARsuksMeBAlUn extþ)at;dMbg.«BukeQμaHsWg nI

mþayeQμaH sWg esOg. nI kn manRbBn§eQμaH lwm Kwmsat

nigmankUnbInak;. elak nI kn manbgRbusbegáItBIrnak;KW

sun esn EdlRtÚv)aneKsÁal;faCardæm®nþIénRksYgkarBarCati

kñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü nigsunQMu Cam®nþITUtenARbeTs

kUer:. enAGayu15qñaM elak nI kn )ancakecjBIRsukkMeNIt

mkrs;enATIRkúgPñMeBjehIybnþkarsikSaenAviTüal½yRBHsIu

suvtßirhUtRbLgCab;fñak;bzmPUmi. kñúgqñaM1966 elak)an

cUleFVICaRKÚbeRgónenAsalabzmsikSakñúgextþesomrab.

bnÞab;BImanrdæRbharTmøak;semþc sIhnu BI GMNac qñaM1970

elak nI kn )anrt;cUléRBedIm,IcUlrYmkñúgclnabdivtþts‘U

RbqaMgnwgrbbln; nl; nig cRkBtþiGaemrik.GMLúgqñaM1974

elak nI kn RtÚv)anbBa©ÚlCasmaCikrbs;bkSkumμúynIsþ

km<úCatamry³karENnaMrbs; esg EdlCaRbFansaxa

bkSRbcaMextþesomrab ehIyelakRtÚv)anbBa¢Ún[eTAeFVI

skmμPaBeXasnaenAtMbn;15énPUmiPaKBiess EdleRkay

mkkøayCatMbn;32énPUmiPaKbs©im. KYrrMB£kfa muneBl

)ankøayCasmaCikbkS elak nI kn KWCasmaCikrbs;

{mmhhaaCCnncceeRRmmIInn} EdlRtÚv)anbegáIteLIgedIm,IeFVIkareXasna

epSg²RbqaMg nwgrbb ln; nl; ehIykñúgeBlenaHk¾man

{ssmm<< ½½nn §§yyuuvvCCnnbbddiivvttþþ }eFV IskmμPaBRbqa Mgd UcK ñaEdr.

enAcugqñaM1977 bkS)ancat;taMgelak[mkbMeBjkargar

EpñkBiFIkarenARksYgkarbeTs edayTTYlbnÞúkCUnePJóv

breTseFVITsSnkic©enAkñúgRbeTskm<úCa.

2¦ skçIkmμrbs;sakSIcMeBaHmuxtMNagshRBHraC

GaCJa

kñúgkarsYredjedalsakSI elak can; dararsμI

tMNag[shRBHraCGaCJaCati )ansYrepþatsMxan;GMBIRbvtþi

ts‘UeFVIbdivtþrbs;sakSI munqñaM1975.cMENkelakvInsin

dWv:al; tMMNag[shRBHraCGaCJaGnþrCati)ansYrepþatsMxan;

GMBItYnaTIrbs;sakSI nigbuKÁlmYycMnYneTotenAPUmiPaKbs©im

nigenARksYgkarbreTsénrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü.

Tak;TgnwgsMNYrrbs;elak can; dararsμI elak)an

esñIsMusakSIerobrab;GMBImUlehtuEdlnaM[xøÜnseRmccUl

rYmkñúgclnabdivtþ tYnaTInigkarTTYlxusRtÚvrbs;sakSIkñúg

GMLúgeBlénclnabdivtþ nigkareXasnaGb;rMepSg².

CakareqøIytb elak nI kn bBa¢ak;fa buBVehtucm,gEdlnaM[

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 7

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

sakSI nI kn

vInsin dWv:al;can; dararsμI

Page 10: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

elakseRmccitþcUlrYmeFVIbdivtþ KWedIm,IrMedaHRbeTsCati

ecjBIkarRtÜtRtarbs;cRkBtþiGaemrik rYmTaMgrbb ln; nl;

nigsMxan;bMputKWedIm,IeFVI[CIvPaBrs;enArbs;RbCaCnkm<úCa

manPaBRbesIreLIg.mü:agvijeTotsun esn EdlRtÚvCabg

RbusbegáIt EtgEtR)ab;elakGMBIsßankarN_enARsukExμr nig

erOgl¥²EdlRtÚveFVI. bEnßmelIenHeTot bnÞab;BIRBH)aT

semþcRBH neratþm sIhnu RtÚv)aneFVIrdæRbharTmøak;BIGMNac

nI kn )anseRmcrt;cUléRBtamkarGMBavnavrbs;semþc

sIhnu edIm,IcUlrYmclnabdivtþ. GMLúgeBlenaH nI kn

bMeBjkargarkñúgRkbx½NÐrbs;rNsirSrYbrYmCati eday

)anTTYlbnÞúkbMpusbMpulRbCaCnEdlrs;enAtMbn;rbs;xøÜn

[rYbrYmkmøaMgedIm,Its‘URbqaMgnwgrbb ln; nl;. CaTUeTA

elak)aneXasna[RbCaCnxitxMbgábegáInpl nig ]btßm

FnFannigkmøaMgdl;kg kmøaMgRbyuT§CYrmuxedIm,IrMedaHRbeTs

ecjBIkarRKb;RKgrbs;ln; nl;. elaknI knbBa¢ak;bEnßmfa

kñúgGMLúgeBlenaH KWmanclnarbs;RbCaCncUlrYmclna

ts‘UeFVI bdivtþn_edaysarEtmankarTmøak;RKab;Ebkd¾eRcInsn§wk

sn§ab;rbs; ln; nl; nigshrdæGaemrik. dUecñHtMbn;sMxan;²

EdlelakRtÚvcuHeTAeXasnaedIm,ITak;TajRbCaCn KWtMbn;

EdlTTYlrgkarTmøak;RKab;Ebk nigtMbn;EdlminTan;RtÚv

)anrMedaH. xøwmsarEdlelak)anykeTAeXasnaGb;rM edIm,I

Tak;TajRbCaCn[cUlrYmkñúgclnabdivtþ KW)anmkBIeKal

neya)ayrbs;bkS EdlRtÚv)andkRsg;ykmkbeRgón

edayeQμaH esg EdlCaRbFansaxabkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa

RbcaMextþesomrab. xøwmsarTaMgenaHPaKeRcInniyayBIkar

CMrujkarbgábegáInpl karkarBarbUrNPaBTwkdI PaBÉkraCü

m©as;kar xøÜn]btßmxøÜn nigkarbeNþjsRtÚvQøanBanCaedIm.

sakSI)anbnþfa kñúgGMLúgqñaM1974 elakRtÚv)an

bkSbBa¢Ún[mkeFVIkarenAtMbn;15 sßitkñúgPUmiPaKBiess

EdlmanTItaMgenARsuk]tþúg. eRkaymktMbn;enHRtÚv)an

bBa©ÚlkñúgtMbn;32 EdlsßitenAeRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;PUmiPaK

bs©im. tMbn;15 KWCatMbn;EdlmankarRbyuT§ xøaMgkøaCamYy

kgT½Bln; nl; dUecñHtMbn;enHRtÚv)anEbgEck[manGñkTTYlxus

RtÚvxagEpñk eyaFa ¬TTYlbnÞúkeday ecg Gn¦ Epñkesdækic©

dwkCBa¢Ún pÁt;pÁg; nigGb;rMCaedIm. elak nI kn bBa¢ak;bEnßmfa

enAtMbn;15 elakRtÚv)anbkScat;taMg[bMeBjkargarenAkñúg

KN³Gb;rM edayTTYlbnÞúkxageXasna nigGb;rMdl;RbCaCn

edIm,ITTYl)ankmøaMgvayykTIRkúgPñMeBj. xøwmsarEdlRtÚv

)anykmkeXasnaGb;rMenAeBlenaH KWdUcKñanwgxøwmsar

EdlxøÜnFøab;)aneXasnaenAmunqñaM1974 eBalKWCMruj[

RbCaCnxitxMbgábegáInpledIm,IGnuvtþneya)ayxøÜn]btßmxøÜn

EkERbCIvPaBRbCaCn[manPaBRbesIreLIg rYmkmøaMgvay

rMedaHRbeTsCatiBIsRtÚv. eRkABIenH elakTTYlbnÞúkbNþúH

bNþaleKalneya)ayrbs;bkSdl;kmμaPi)alfñak;eRkam

EdlRtÚv)aneRCIs erIs[mkeronsURt.

elak nI kn bBa¢ak;bEnßmfa bnÞab;BIbkSkumμúynIsþ

km<úCarMedaH)anTIRkúgPñMeBj eBalKW s®gÁamrvagExμrRkhm

nigrbbln; nl; RtÚv)anbBa©b; tMbn;15RtÚv)andak;bBa©Úlkñúg

tMbn;32 EdlsßitenAeRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;PUmiPaKbs©im.

sakSIbBa¢ak;fa eQμaH sarun CaelxatMbn;31 eQμaH ):al;

CaelxatMbn;32 EdltMbn;TaMgenHsßitenAeRkamkarRKb;

RKgrbs;eQμaHsIu Caelxa PUmiPaKbs©im.dUecñHelakRtÚvsßit

enAeRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;tMbn;32 Edlman ta)a:l; Ca

elxa.kñúgGMLúgqñaM1975dl;qñaM1977elakenAEtTTYl

tYnaTICaGñkeXasnaGb;rMdEdl EtepþateTAelIkarbgábegáIn

pl nigelIkTMnb;RbLayedIm,IeFVIksikmμEtb:ueNÑaH. kñúg

zan³CaGñkeXasnaGb;rM elakTTYlkarENnaMkargar b¤bNþúH

bNþalBI ta):al; bnÞab;BI ta):al; )an TTYlkarENnaMBIRbFan

PUmiPaK ehIyelak)anraykarN_GMBIlT§plkargarrbs;

xøÜneTA ta):al; Edl ta):al; nwgraykarN_bnþeTARbFanPUmi

PaK. sakSIbBa¢ak;y:agc,as;fa CaTUeTAelxaRsukKWCa

smaCikrbs;KN³tMbn; ehIyelxatMbn;nImYy² KWCasmaCik

rbs;KN³PUmiPaKrbs;xøÜn. Cak;Esþg ta):al; nig tasarun Edl

CaelxatMbn; KWCasmaCikrbs;KN³PUmiPaKbs©im.

8 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 11: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

KYrbBa¢ak;fa enAeBlelak can; dararsμI ecaTsYrGMBI

tYnaTI nigParkic©rbs; sun esn kñúgGMLúgeBleFVIbdivtþ elak

nI kn EtgEteqøIyfa elakmindwgGMBItYnaTI nigParkic©rbs;

sun esn eLIy KWRKan;Etdwgfasun esn KWCaGñkkan;kab;kgT½B

rYm Edl)aneFVIskmμPaBts‘U RbqaMgnwgcRkBtþiGaemrik nig

ln; nl;.

bnÞab;BIelak can; dararsμI )anbBa©b;sMNYrrbs;xøÜn

elak vInsin dWv:al; tMNagsh RBHraCGaCJaGnþrCati)anbnþ

ecaTsMNYrmYycMnYnTak;Tgnwgclnats‘UbdivtþenAtMbn;15

kareFVImhasnñi)atrbs;PUmiPaKbs©im karCemøósRbCaCn

ecjBITIRkúgPñMeBj karRbCMuTieTon nigsV½y TieTon tYnaTIrbs;

sakSIenAkñúgRksYgkarbreTs CaBiessParkic©kñúgkarCUn

KN³RbtiPUbreTseTAeFVITsSnkic©enAtambNþaextþepSg²

nigkarraykarN_GMBIdMeNIrTsSnkic©TaMgenHmk[fñak;elI

vij.

CakareqøIytb elak nI kn bBa¢ak;fa kñúgGMLúgeBl

elakenAtMbn;15KWmanclnats‘URbqaMgnwgrbbln; nl; Ca

xøaMg eRBaHCaerogral;éf¶tMbn;enHTTYlrgnUvkarTmøak;RKab;Ebk

nigkar)aj;kaMePøIgFMrbs;kgT½Bln; nl;. kñúgGMLúgeBlenaH

kgT½BExμrRkhm)aneFVIelNdæanT½BenAEk,r]dugÁ eRBaHtMbn;

enaHsMbUreTAedaydMbUkkeNþór. kgT½BExμrRkhm)anecaH

rUgenAeRkamdMbUkkeNþórTaMgenaH edIm,IeKcBIkarTmøak;Rkab;

Ebk. elak nI kn bBa¢ak;fa dMbUkkeNþórEdlmanedImeQIduH

BIelI KWCaTItaMgrwgmaMEdlGackarBarBIkarTmøak;RKab;Ebk

rbs;sRtÚv)an.bEnßm elIenH elaktMNagshRBHraCGaCJa

)anbgðajÉksarmYymancMNgeCIgfa{b:ul Bt kñúgsubinþ

GaRkk;} sresredayGñkkarEstmñak;eQμaH hVIlIbsSt

edayelak)andkRsg;smþIrbs; elak nI kn Edl)anpþl;bT

smÖasn_fa{eyIg)ansg;mnÞIrbBa¢akardæanenAkñúgdICamYynwg

Rtg;es nigCRmkenAkñúgdMbUkkeNþór nigmanRbB½n§rUg Edl

Gac[eyIgecjBIdMbUkkeNþórmYyeTAdMbUk keNþórmYyeTot

)an. kñúgkrNIEdlmankarTmøak;RKab;Ebk eyIgBYnenAkñúg

enaHdUckeNþórG‘Ícwg. ehIyenAeBlEdlrYcputBIeRKaHfñak;

ehIy eyIgecjmkeRkAvij ehIyeyIgepþImeFVIkargarrbs;

eyIgbnþeTAeTot. CaTUeTA enAeBleyIgCIkRtg;es KWfaeyIg

dak;kRmaleQIBIelI ehIydak;)avGgÁamedIm,Ikat;bnßy

\T§iBlRKab;Ebk ehIydIdMbUkkeNþórenHmaMGacs‘UnwgRKab;

Ebk)an}. sakSIbBa¢ak;bEnßmfa kñúgGMLúgeBlenaH elakKW

CaeXasnikCnmñak; EdlRtÚv)ancat;taMg[eFVIkarenAkñúg

eragBum< edayTTYlbnÞúkGUsÉksarBak;B½n§nwgeKalneya

)ayrbs;bkS Edlfñak;elI)anpþl;[ edIm,IEckCUn nigeXasna

Gb;rMdl;RbCaCnEdlrs;enAtMbn;rbs;xøÜn.

cMeBaHkareFVIsnñi)atrbs;PUmiPaKbs©imvij elak nI

kn bBa¢ak;fa elak)ancUlrYmCaeRcIndgCamYykmμaPi)al

epSg²eTotEdlmkBIfñak;tMbn; nigPUmiPaK. CaTUeTARbFan

PUmiPaKCaGñkeFVIGFibtIénsnñi)at ehIyeBlxøHmanfñak

;dwknaMCan;x<s;rbs;bkSdUcCa nYn Ca eFVICaFibtI. RbFanbTEdl

RtÚv)anelIkmkniyayKWepþatelIkarbgárbegáInpl kar

Gnuvtþneya)ayxøÜn ]btßmxøÜnedayÉkraCünigm©as;kar

nigkarRbyuT§RbqaMgsRtÚvNaEdlraraMgdl;karGPivDÆn_Cati

CaedIm. Bak;B½n§nwgkareFVIsnñi)atrbs;PUmiPaKbs©im elak

vInsin dak;bgðajÉksarTsSnavdþI Tg;bdivtþmYyc,ab;cuH

ExsIha qñaM1978 Edl)ancuHpSaysunÞrkfasþIBI{esckþI

ENnaMmYycMnYnTak;TgnwgkarksagkarBRgwg nigkarBRgIkbkS

dwknaM}EføgedayGñktMNagbkSkñúg»kassnñi)atrbs;PUmiPaK

bs©iméf¶TI25 Exkkáda qñaM1977.sakSIbBa¢ak;fa elakmin

Føab;)aneXIjxøwmsarénsunÞrkfaenHeLIy eRBaHCaTUeTA

elakminEdlTTYl)anÉksarCaRkdasenAeBl fñak;elImk

eFVIkar bNþúHbNþalGMBIeKalneya)ayrbs;bkSeLIy.

eTaHbICay:agNakþI elak vInsin BüayamecaTsMNYrBak;B½n§nwg

ÉksarenH EtminRtÚv)anGgÁCMnMuCRmHGnuBaØateLIybnÞab;BI

RkúmemFavIkarBarkþICnCab;ecaT eGog sarI )anelIkeLIgfa

kñúgkrNIsakSIminsÁal;ÉksarNamYy enaHPaKIminGacyk

xøwmsarenAkñúgÉksarenaHmkecaTsYrsakSIeLIy. eRkABI

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 9

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 12: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

karcUl rYmsnñi)atbkS elak nI kn )ancUlrYmkic©RbCMuTieTon

nigsV½yTieTonCaRbcaM. elakbBa¢ak;fa kic©RbCMuenHtRmÚv

[eFVICaRbcaM ehIyGñkcUlrYmRtÚvelIkeLIgGMBIkMhusrbs;xøÜn

b¤rbs;buKÁlNamñak;enAcMeBaHmuxRbFanGgÁRbCMu. bnÞab;mk

RbFanGgÁRbCMunwgeFVIkarbUksrubGMBIkMhusqÁgrYceFVIr)ay

karN_[fñak;elIedIm,IseRmc. GñkcUlrYmRbCMuEtgmankar

P½yxøacenAeBlEdlxøÜnminTan;eFVI)anseRmctamEpnkarEdl

fñak;elIdak;[Gnuvtþ b¤manbuKÁlNamñak;TieTonmkelIxøÜn. Cak;

EsþgsRmab;rUbelakpÞal; KWmankarP½yxøacenAeBlEdl

EpnkareXasnarbs;xøÜnminTan;eFVI)anseRmc.

Tak;TgnwgkarCemøósRbCaCnecjBITIRkúgPñMeBj

elak nI kn )anbBa¢ak;fa bnÞab;BI kgT½BExμrRkhmcUlkan;kab;

TIRkúgPñMeBjPøam elakRtÚv)ancat;taMg[mkeXasnaedIm,I

[RbCaCnecjBITIRkúg. kñúgGMLúgeBlenaH elak)anRbkas

[RbCaCnecjBITIRkúgmYyry³edayykehtuplfa edIm,IeKc

BIkarTmøak;RKab;Ebkrbs;shrdæGaemrik nigkarBarsuvtþiPaB

rbs;RbCaCnkñ úgkrNIevotNamvaydeNþ ImykTIRkúg

PñMeBjvij. enAeBltMNagshRBHraCGaCJasYrfa etIkar

CemøósenHmankarerobcMKeRmagCamunEdrb¤eT? elak nI kn

bBa¢ak;fa elakmin)andwgc,as;eLIy EtmuneBlCemøós

KWshkrN_tammUldæan)anerobcMkEnøgsRmab;TTYlRbCaC

nEdlnwgRtÚvCemøósmkBITIRkúgTukCaeRsc. sakSIbBa¢ak;

bEnßmfa RbCaCnEdlRtÚv)anCemøóseTA KWminRtÚv)anbkSyk

citþTukdak;GMBImeFüa)ayeFVIdMeNIr b¤kEnøgsñak;enA[)ansmrmü

eLIy eBalKWRbCaCnRtÚvedktampøÚv nigxVHxatGaharKYr[

GaNit. RbCaCnminmanlT§PaBNamYyRbqaMgtv:amin

ecjeLIy ehIyKat;manTwkmuxminsb,aycitþenAeBlEdl

RtÚv)anbgçM[cakecalRTBüsm,tþirbs;xøÜn.

eTaHbITIRkúgPñMeBjRtÚv)ankan;kab;edaybkSkumμúy

nIsþkñúgqñaM1975k¾eday kñúgGMLúgeBlenaHelak nI kn enAEt

bMeBjkargarCaGñkeXasnaGb;rMenAPUmiPaKbs©imdEdl.

enAcugqñaM1977 nI kn RtÚv)anbkSbBa¢Únmk[eFVIkarenAEpñk

BiFIkarkñúgRksYgkarbreTs edayTTYlbnÞúkCUnKN³RbtiPU

breTseTAeFVITsSnkic©enAtambNþaextþnana. mankarsYr

bBa¢ak;BItMNagshRBHraCGaCJaGMBImUlehtuEdlnaM[bkS

pøas;bþÚrsakSIBIPUmiPaKbs©im[mkeFVIkarenARksYgkarbeTs

vij. sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa elakmin)andwgBImUlehtuEdlnaM[

mankarpøas;bþÚrkEnøgeFVIkarenHeT eRBaHfñak;elIminEdl)an

R)ab;eLIy. CagenHeTAeTotelakk¾minEdlh‘ansYrrk

ehtuplGVIenaHeT KWGVI²TaMgGs;bkSCaGñkcat;Ecg. bnÞab;

BIsakSIbBa¢ak;dUecñH tMNagshRBH raCGaCJa)anbgðajÉksar

bTsmÖasn_EdleFVIeLIgCamYyCnCab;ecaT eGog sarI nig

elaksÞIv ehdD½r enA ExFñÚ qñaM1996.kñúgbTsmÖasn_enHeGog

sarI )anelIkeLIgfa{>>>nI kn EdlCabgb¥Ún rbs; sun esn

RtÚv)anbBa¢ÚnmkRksYgkarbreTskñúgExkkþda qñaM1977 eday

mUlehtueKecaTfamankarCab;Bak;B½n§nwgExS es>GIu>Ga.

GñkEdleKecaTfamanCab;Bak;B½n§nwgExS es>GIu>Ga EtminTan;

manPsþútagRKb;RKan; enaHeKykmkTukenARksYgkarbreTs

dUcCa Nat nig hug CaedIm>>>}. bnÞab;BItMNagshRBHraC

GaCJabgðajÉksarenH elak nI kn )anbgðaj nUvkarPJak;

ep¥Ily:agxøaMg edayelIkeLIgfa elakeTIbEtdwgGMBImUlehtu

EdlxøÜnRtÚv)anbBa¢Ún mkRksYgkarbreTstamry³Éksar

EdltMNagshRBHraCGaCJaykmkbgðajEtb:ueNÑaH.

KYrrMB£kfa Bak;B½n§nwgkarbgðajÉksarbTsmÖasn_enH

KWmankarCMTas;BIelak ém:eXIl xaNav:as CaemFavIkarBarkþI

CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI edayelak)anelIkeLIgfa tMNag

shRBHraCGaCJaminGacykcemøIyrbs;buKÁlepSgmkecaT

sYrsakSIeLIy eRBaHbBaðaenHGgÁCMnMuCRmH)anseRmcrYc

ehIy. CalT§pl GgÁCMnuMuCRmHseRmcbdiesFecalcMeBaHkar

elIkeLIgrbs;elakemFavI xaNav:as. PøamenaHelakemFavI

)anesñI[GgÁCMnMuCRmHseRmc[)anc,as;Bak;B½n§nwgkaryk

cemøIyrbs;buKÁlepSg²mkecaTsYrsakSI. CakareqøIytb

RbFanGgÁCMnMu CRmHbBa¢ak;fa{mUlehtu sMGagehtuenAkñúgkrNI

enH KWxusEbøkBIkrNId¾éTeTotEdlGgÁCMnMu CRmH)anseRmcrYc

10 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 13: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

ehIy. krNIenH KWCabTsmÖasn_CamYyCnCab;ecaT eGog

sarI ehIy enAeBlenH eGogsarI )annigkMBugmanvtþmanenAkñúg

kic©dMeNIrkarsvnakar. RbsinebIKat;sþab;)anehIymanbBaða

Kat;GactTl;CamYynwgsakSIrUbenH)an}.

Bak;B½n§nwgkarbBa¢Únelak nI kn eTARksYgkarbreTs

Edr tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa)anecaTsYrfa kñúgGMLúgeBl

sakSIRtÚv)anbBa¢ÚnBItMbn;32eTARksYgkarbreTs etIman

kare)assm¥atenAkñúgcMeNamkmμaPi)alrbs;PUmiPaK tMbn;

nigRsukenAkñúgPUmiPaKbs©imEdrb¤eT? sakSIbBa¢ak;fa elak)an

dwgBIkare)assm¥atenHtamry³karniyayt²Kña eRBaHeBl

enaHelak)an mkdl;RksYgkarbreTsehIy.

cMeBaHtYnaTIrbs;sakSIenARksYgkarbreTshak;dUcCa

mankarExVgKMnitKñarvagtMNagshRBHraCGaCJa nigsakSI.

tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa)anelIkeLIgfa sakSIKWCaRbFan

caghVagcat;EcgBiFIkarrbs;RksYg ehIyelak)andkRsg;

smþIrbs; eGogsarI Edlfa elaknI knmanzan³x<s;CagsU Es

nigcat;EcgkargarBiFIkareRcInCag sU hug. b:uEnþelak nI kn

bBa¢ak;CUnGgÁCMnMuCRmHfa eTaHbIxøÜnminyl;BIvisalPaBén

BaküRbFancaghVagBiFIkark¾edayxøÜnminGacmanzan³x<s;Cag

KN³kmμaFikarmnÞIr nigKN³kmμaFikarRksYgeLIy. xøÜnsßitenA

eRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs; ecom EdlCaRbFanmnÞIrénRksYgkar

breTs. CagenHeTAeTot xøÜnRKan;EtsßitenA kñúgEpñktUcmYy

énBiFIkarRksYg EdlTTYlbnÞúkCUnePJóvbreTskMritTabeTAeFVI

TsSnkic©tambNþaextþEtb:ueNÑaH. Bak;B½n§nwgkarelIkeLIgenH

tMNagshRBHraCGaCJabgðajÉksarEdl)ancuH pSayeday

viTüúkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü niyayGMBIkarmkdl;rbs;elak

eLG‘ug eb‘oksþaMg tMNag [{bkSkumμúynIsþ-eLnIn}enAshrdæ

Gaemrik. ÉksarenHbgðajfa elak eLG‘ug eb‘oksÞaMg RtÚv

)anTTYlsVaKmn_eday elak nI kn enAéf¶TI22 Exemsa

qñaM1978.sakSIbBa¢ak;fa xøÜnmin caMGMBIRBwtþkarN_enHeLIy.

CaTUeTAkarTTYlePJóvbreTsFM²KWeQμaH eGak suKn§ nig CYn

RbsiT§i ehIyCYnkal eGogsarI CaGñkeTATTYl. eTaHbICay:ag

NakþIelakcaM)anfa elakFøab;)anCUnePJóvbreTsbInak;mkBI

RbeTs Eb‘lhSiúk eTAeFVITsSnkic©enAextþesomrab nigKN³

RbtiPUmkBIRbeTs yUehÁasøavI nigmkBIRbeTs Cb:un eTAeFVI

TsSnkic©enAtamPUmiPaKepSg². Tak;TgnwgkarCUndMeNIrePJóv

mkBIRbeTs Eb‘lhSiúk tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa)anbgðaj

ÉksarEdl)anpSayedayviTüúRkúgPñMeBjkñúgExsIha qñaM

1978 sþIBIdMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs;KN³RbtiPUénsmaKmn_

RbeTs Eb‘lhSiúk-km<úCa. ÉksarenHbBa¢ak;fa{ KN³RbtiPU

RbeTs Eb‘lhSiúk )aneTAeFVITsSnkic©enAPUmiPaKkNþal nig

]tþrBinitüemIlkEnøgplitfñaM eragcRksørEdkenAkMBg;cam

eragcRkekAs‘UenAcMkardUg nigTsSnaTMnb;1mkra nigGgÁrvtþ

nigreNþARKab;Ebk. bnÞab;mkbnþeTATsSnkic©enAPUmiPaKnirtI

enAtaEkv shkrN_enAGgÁtaesam nigeTAkMBg;esammun

nwgRtLb;mkPñMeBjvij}. cMeBaHdMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs;Gñk

kaEstmkBIRbeTs yUehÁasøavI tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa

)andak;bgðajÉksarsarTUrelxmYycuHéf¶TI15 ExmIna

qñaM1978 sþIBIdMeNIrTsSnkic© rbs;GñkkaEst yUehÁasøavI

enAPUmiPaKBay½Bü. sarTUrelxenHKWCaesckþIraykarN_CUn

eTAmnÞIr870GMBIsMNYr-cemøIy EdlGñkkaEst)ansmÖasn_

GñkeFVIkarenARtBaMgfμ GMBIrbbGahar lkçxNÐkargar

kardwkCBa¢ÚnGñkeFVIkar nigkarerobGaBah’BiBah’CaedIm.

bEnßmBIelIenHeTot elak nI kn )anbBa¢ak;fa enAeBlCUn

dMeNIrKN³RbtiPUeTAeFVITsSnkic©enAtammUldæan elak )an

eXIjRbCaCnmanCIvPaBxVHxat nigxVHCRmkCaeRcIn ehIy

elak)anykbBaðaenHmkraykarN_CUnfñak;elIrbs;xøÜnenA

eBlmankarRbCMu. cugeRkaytMNagshRBHraCGaCJabgðaj

ÉksarcuHéf¶TI8 ExFñÚ qñaM1978 Edlelak nI kn nigelak

KatQn; ehA mut )anraykarN_[ eGogsarI GMBIsMeNImYy

cMnYnrbs;sa®sþacarü xatEvlCnCatiGg;eKøsnigGñkkaEst

CnCati GaemrikBIrrUb KWelakRsI Eb‘kX½r nigelak Dwk m:an;.

sMeNITaMgenaHrYmman{sMueTACitRBMEdn eTAemIlCnbT cg;eXIj

CIvPaBRbcaMéf¶rbs;RbCaCn cg;CYbkmμaPi)alenARKb;Rkúg

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 11

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 14: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

cg;emIlshkrN_ cg;emIlKukneya)ay cg;CYbpÞal;mnusS

Edl[enAdac;edayELkBIKña cg;dwgGMBIRbCaCncam kar

smøab;mnusS nigcg;CYbemdwknaMEdlmandUcCa naykrdæm®nþI/

]bnaykrdæm®nþI eGogsarI/ sun esn/ eGog FIriT§/ exov b:uNÑarI/

nYnCa/semþcsIhnu/hU‘yn; nigh‘U nwm}.bnÞab;BI)anBinitüemIl

Éksar elak nI kn bBa¢ak;fa elakBitCa)anrayN_GMBIsMeNI

enHmkfñak;elIrbs;xøÜnEmn k¾b:uEnþsMeNITaMgenHminTTYl)an

karGnuBaØateLIy.

3¦ skçIkmμrbs;sakSIcMeBaHmuxemFavItMNag

edImbNþwgrdæb,evNI

elak eLa CunFI CaemFavICatitMNagedImbNþwg

rdæb,evNI )ansYrGMBIRbvtþits‘Ubdivtþ tYnaTI nigviFIsa®sþrbs;

sakSIkñ úgkareXasnaGb;rMdl;RbCaCn. cMENkelak

)aNaeb eNKVI CaemFavIGnþrCati sYrepþatsMxan;GMBIkarCUn

dMeNIrKN³RbtiPUbreTseTAeFVITsSnkic©enAtambNþaPUmi

PaKepSg².

eTaHbICaGgÁehtuBak;B½n§Rbvtþits‘Ubdivtþ nigtYnaTI

eXasnaGb;rMrbs;elak nI kn RtÚv)an tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa

TaMgBIrrUbecaTsYrmþgehIyk¾eday elakemFavI eLa CunFI enA

EtecaTsMNYrmYycMnYneTotedIm,I[sakSIbBa¢ak;kan;Et c,as;.

sMNYrmYycMnYnEdlelakemFavI)anecaTsYrenaHKW etIelak nI

kn ykeKalneya)ayGVI nigeRbIviFIsa®sþEbbNakñúgkar

eXasnaGb ; r M RbCaCn[c Ulr Ymk ñ ú gclnabd i vt þ?

dUcKñanwgGVIEdlsakSI)aneqøIytbnwgtMNagshRBHraC GaCJa

EdrKWfa eFVIkarbMpusbMpulRbCaCn[cUlrYmclnabdivtþedIm,I

ts‘URbqaMgnwgkarQøanBanTwkdIBIsRtÚvrMedaHRbeTs[rYcput

BIkarRtÜtRtarbs;rbb ln; nl; nigcRkBtþiGaemrik nigeFVI[

RbCaCnmanCIvPaBkan;EtRbesIreLIg. b:uEnþelak)an

bBa¢ak;bEnßmfa bnÞab;BImankareFVIrdæRbharTmøak;semþcRBH

neratþm sIhnu BIGMNacenAéf¶TI 18 ExmIna qñaM1970

KWclnats‘Ubdivtþkan;EtmansPaBxøaMgeLIg². kñúgGMLúgeBl

enaHmankarGMBavnavBIRBHmhakSRt[cUléRBm:aKI edIm,Its‘U

RbqaMgnwgrbbln; nl;. edayRbCaCnRKb;RsTab;vNѳeKarB

RsLaj;RBHmhakSRt dUecñHkñúgkareXasnaTak;TajRbCaCn

[cUlrYmclnabdivtþ KWykeQμaHrbs;RBHhamkSRtmk

eFVIkarpSBVpSaykñúgbuBVehtuvaycRkBtiþGaemrik edayrYm

bBa¢ÚlTaMgrbbln; nl; Edr. xøwmsar KaMRTsemþcsIhnu RbqaMg

nwgBYkcRkBtþi KWRtÚv)anelakpÞal;¬nI kn¦ nigeXasnikCn

epSg² eTotykeTApSBVpSaytamRsuk tMbn; nig PUmiPaKEdl

xøÜnrs;enArhUtdl;kgT½BExμrRkhmcUlkan;kab;TIRkúgPñMeBj.

elak nI kn min)andwgfaxøwmsareXasnaenHmanRbPBecj

mkBIemdwknaM Can;x<s;Namñak;rbs;bkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCaeLIy

eRBaHenHCakarsm¶at;x<s;rbs;bkS.

cMeBaHsMNYrrbs;elakemFavI )aNaeb eNKVI KW

12 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

eLa CunFI)aNaeb eNKVI

Page 15: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

epþatelIdMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs;KN³RbtiPUCb:un mkRbeTskm<úCa

kñúgqñaM1978. elakemFavI)anepþaty:agsMxan;eTAelI

esckþIEføgkarN_EdleFVIedayRbFandwknaMKN³RbtiPUmkBI

RbeTsCb:un KWelakkUhSÚhSasaKI ¬Kozo Sasaki¦GMBIsPaB

karN_EdlekItenARbeTskm<úCa. Bak;B½n§nwgdMeNIrTsSn

kic©enH elakemFavI)andak;bgðajÉksarEdlpSayeday

viTüúRkúgPñMeBjGMBIesckþIEføgkarN_EdleFVIedayRbFanKN³

RbtiPUCb:uneqøIytbnwgsMNYrrbs;GñkkaEstenAeBlcugbBa©b;

éndMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs;xøÜn. elakemFavI)andkRsg;xøwmsar

énsMNYrEdl)anecaTsYrelak kUhSÚ hSasaKI kñúg GMLúgeBl

enaHfa{evotNamEdlCaGñkQøanBanvaTTIniym nigcRk

Btþ in iymGnþrCatik MB ugpSBVpSayeXasnabgáac;bgç Úc

edayniyayfardæaPi)alrbs;km<úCaRbCaFibetyükMBugenA

Éeka eRBaHRbCaCnRbqaMgnwgxøÜn ehIymankarrMeCIbrMCYl

BaseBjRbeTskm<úCaKμankareKarBsiT§ imnusSenAkñúgRb

eTs RBmTaMgfaRbCaCnkñúgRbeTskm<úCakMBugRtÚv)aneKsmøab;

rgÁal. eday\LÚvenH Gñk)anmkdl;RbeTskm<úCaGs;ry³

eBlBIrs)þah_mkehIy etIelakKity:agNacMeBaHkar

eXasnaenH?}. CakareqøIytb elak kUhSÚ hSasaKI )an

elIkeLIgfa{ eyIgmineXIjmankarsmøab;rgÁalNaeT

RbCaCnmanGaharRKb;RKan;edIm,IbriePaKenACnbT. eyIg

)aneXIjstVBahn³rab;Ban;kñúgshkrN_CaeRcIn. Rbsin

ebIRbCaCnkm<úCaxVHes,óg BYkeKnwgsmøab;stVBahn³TaMg

enaHedIm,Iyksac;. dUecñHB½t’manGMBIRbCaCnkm<úCaEdl

qøgkat;karxVHxates,ógenaH KWCakare)akR)as;fμImYyrbs;

CnCatievotNam. eyIgRtÚvEtkemÞckareXasna e)ak

R)as;enH. km<úCaRbCaFibetyümin)anlak;)aMgGVIeLIy

kñúgGMLúgeBldMeNIrTsSnkic©rbs;eyIg eyIg)aneXIjsßan

PaBBitkñúgRbeTskm<úCa}. bnÞab;BI)anGanxøwmsarenHCUnsakSI

elakemFavI)anecaTsYrfa etIGVIEdlRbFanKN³RbtiPU

Cb:un)anEføgR)ab;GñksarB½t’mandUceTAnwgGVIEdlsakSI)an

eXIjkñúgGMLúgeBlCUndMeNIrKN³RbtiPUenaHEdrb¤eT?Cakar

eqøIytb elak nI kn bBa¢ak;fa GVIEdlelak)aneXIj KWmindUc

GVIEdlelak kUhSÚ hSasaKI )anEføg eLIy eRBaHkñúgGMLúgeBl

enaH elak)aneXIjRbCaCnmankarGt;Xøan nigxVHCRmk

CaeRcIn. mansMNYrmYycMnYneTotEdlelakemFavI)ansYr

KWBak;B½n§nwgkarCemøósRbCaCnecjBITIRkúgPñMeBj.b:uEnþeTaH

bICay:agNakþI elak nI kn enAEtbBa¢ak;dUcGVIEdlelak)an

eqøIyCUntMNagshRBHraCGaCJadEdl.

4¦skçIkmμrbs;sakSIcMeBaHmuxRkúmemFavIkarBarkþI

bnÞab;BIRkúmemFavItMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNIbBa©b;

sMNYrrbs;xøÜnedaysarGs;eBlevla RbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmH)an

RbKl;evTikaCUnRkúmemFavIkarBarkþICnCab;ecaTTaMgbIRkúm

eda cab;epþImBIRkúmemFavIrbs; nYn Ca bnÞab;mk eGogsarI nig

cugeRkayRkúmemFavIrbs; exovsMpn.

4>1¦ skçIkmμrbs;sakSIcMeBaHmuxRkumemFavIkarBarkþI

nYn Ca

kñúgkarsYredjedalsakSI RkúmemFavIkarBarkþI

CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca KWelaksun GruN CaemFavICati nigelak

ém:eXIl epsþemnCaemFavIGnþrCati )ansYrsakSIedayepþat

sMxan; GMBImUlehtuénkarcUlrYmeFVIbdivtþ TsSnavdþITg;bdivtþ

Gtþcrikrbs;CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca GgÁkarelxrbs;RksYg

karbreTs CaBiessGMBIkareFVIsm,frbs;sakSImuneBlcUl

mkpþl;skçIkmμ.

cab;epþImdMbUgelakemFavI sun GruN)anecaTsMNYr

mYycMnYnBak;B½n§nwgkarRbmUlkmøaMg edIm,IcUlrYmkñúgclna

bdivtþcenøaHqñaM1970 dl;qñaM1975. sMNYrmYykñúgcMeNam

sMNYrCaeRcInEdlelaksun GruN )anecaTsYrKWfa etIsakSI

Føab;)aneXIjvtþmanCnbreTsmktaMg TIlMenAkñúgRbeTskm<úCa

Edrb¤eT CaBiesskgT½Brbs; evot kug?CakareqøIytb elak

nI kn bBa¢ak;fa TaMgmuneBl nigkñúgGMLúgeBlEdlelakcUlrYm

kñúgclnabdivtþ elakminEdl)aneXIjvtþmanrbs;CnbreTs

eLIy. elakcUlrYmkñúgclnabdivtþkñúgqñaM1970 tamry³

karGMBavnavrbs;rNsirSrYbrYmCati EdldwknaMedaysemþcRBH

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 13

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 16: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

neratþm sIhnu EdlRBHGgÁGMBavnav[kUn ecArt;cUléRBm:akKI

edIm,IrYbrYmkmøaMgRbqaMgnwgrbb ln; nl; nigbeNþjcRkBtþi

GaemrikecjBIRbeTskm<úCa. kñúgGMLúgeBlenaH elaksßit

enAkñúgrN³sirSrYbrYmCati edayTTYlbnÞúkeXasnaGb;rM

RbCaCnGMBIkarbgábegáInpl karts‘URbqaMgnwgcRkBtiþ

Gaemrik nigrMedaHRbeTsBIkarRKb;RKgrbs; ln; nl; enAtam

tMbn;EdlxøÜnrs;enA. sakSIbBa¢ak;fa kñúgkarvayrMedaHTIRkúg

PñMeBjkñúgqñaM1975 KWmankarrYbrYmrvagkmøaMgrNsirS

rYbrYmCatikm<úCa nigkmøaMgrbs;bkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa. elakmin

dwgfamankarcUlrYmBIkmøaMgrbs;evotNameLIy ehIykgT½B

TaMgenH)anEbgEckCa14muxRBÜjedIm,IvaycUlTIRkúg

PñMeBj.

Tak;TgnwgTsSnavdþITg;bdivtþvij elak nI kn bBa¢ak;

fa elakminEdl)aneXIjeLIykñúgGMLúgeBlelakcUlrYm

kñúgclnabdivtþ eRBaHTsSnavdþITg;bdivtþKWCaÉksarépÞkñúg rbs;

bkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa. dUecñHkñúgkarGb;rMRbCaCnenAtam

mUldæan KWelakTTYl)anEtxøwmsarneya)ayEdlRtÚv)an

dkRsg;ecjBITsSnavdþITg;bdivtþEtb:ueNÑaH. KYrrMB£kfa enA

eBltMNagshRBHraCGaCJabgðajÉksarTsSnavdþITg;bdivtþ

CUnsakSIBinitü elak)anbBa¢ak;fa tamry³xøwmsarEdlelak

)anykeTAeXasnaGb;rMRbCaCn nigxøwmsarEdlman kMNt;

kñúgTsSnavdþITg;bdivtþ KWmanlkçN³dUcKña. dUecñHelak

GHGagfa TsSnavdþITg;bdivtþEdlelak)anBinitüKWBitCa

Éksar rbs;bkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa. xøwmsareKalneya)ay

mYycMnYnrbs;bkSEdlelak)ancaMKW vaysRmúk bgábegáIn

pl PaBCam©as;karnigÉkraCü CRmújkaredaHRsayCIvPaB

tammUldæan. xøwmsarsRmab;eFVIkareXasnaGb;rM KWman

karERbRbÜlGaRs½yeTAtameBlevla kal³eTs³ mCÄdæanrs;

enArbs;RbCaCn. munqñaM1975 RbCaCnEdlrs;enAtam

mUldæanRtÚveKeXasna[xitxMbgábegá InpledIm,I]btßm

kgT½BCYrmux rYbrYmkmøaMgedIm,IvaysRmúkelIxμaMgsRtÚv karcUl

rYmCYydwkCBa¢ÚnCaedIm ehIyeRkayqñaM1975KWkareXasna

Gb;rMepþatelIkarbgábegáInpl elIkTMnb; CIkRbLay karksag

RbeTsCati.

cugeRkayelakemFavI sun GruN dak;bgðajÉksar

sþIBIGgÁkarelxrbs;RksYgkar breTsEdlRtÚv)anerobcMkñúg

rbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü. sakSIbBa¢ak;fa elakeTIbEt

)aneXIj ÉksarenHCaelIkdMbUgenAeBlEdlecARkmesIub

GegátykmkbgðajEtb:ueNÑaH. b:uEnþeTaHbICay:agNakþI

RksYgkarbreTsmanrcnasm<½n§RKb;RKgRtwmRtÚv k¾b:uEnþkar

GnuvtþCak;Esþg KWminTan; RtÚv)anGnuvtþ[)aneBjeljeLIy

eRBaHry³eBlEdlbkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa)anRKb;RKg KW

manry³eBlxøI. GVIEdlsakSI)anbBa¢ak;y:agc,as;enaHKW

eRkamKμanÉkraCüeLIy KWRtÚveKarBfñak;elIrbs;xøÜn.

bnÞab;BIbBa©b;sMNYrrbs;xøÜn elakemFavI sun GruN

)anepÞr[shPatarbs;xøÜn KWelak emFavI ém:eXIl epsþemn

edIm,IsYrelak nI kn bnþ. cab;epþImdMbUgénsMNYrrbs;xøÜn elak

emFavI epsþemn )anepþatelIkareFVIsm,frbs;sakSImun

nwgcUlmkpþl;skçIkmμcMeBaHmuxGgÁCMnMuCRmH. sMNYrBak;B½n§

nwgbBaðaenH )anbNþal[mankarCECkKñay:agxøaMgrvag

GgÁCMnMuCRmH nigRkúmemFavIkarBarkþIrbs; nYn Ca EdlnaM[man

karkt;smÁal;GMBIGtþcrikrbs;elakemFavI psþemn BIRbFan

GgÁCMnMuCRmH. mUlehtuEdlnaM[RbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmHeFVIkar

kt;smÁal;enHedaysarfa enAeBlcab;epþImdMbUgelak

emFavI)ansYrsakSIfa etI)aneFVIsm,fehIyb¤enAehIyeFVI

enAkEnøgNa? PøamenaHRbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmHhammin[sakSI

eqøIy edayelak)anelIkeLIgfa B½t’manenHRtÚv)anbBa¢ak;

CUnPaKImþgrYcehIyenAeBlcab;epþImebIksvnakarsþab;skçI

kmμrbs;sakSIrUbenH fasakSI)ans,frYcral;ehIymunnwg

GnuBaØat[pþl;skçIkmμCUnGgÁCMnMuCRmH. tbnwgkarseRmcrbs;

GgÁCMnMuCRmH elak epsþemn)anelIkeLIgfatamFmμtasakSI

RtÚvmkeFVIsm,fCasaFarN³enAkñúgsalsvnakar.eqøIybt

nwgkarelIkeLIgenH RbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmHbBa¢ak;fa karEdl

GnuBaØat[sakSImkeFVIsm,fenAkñúgsalsvnakar KWsRmab;

14 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 17: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

EtsakSIEdlkan;sasnaepSg²Etb:ueNÑaH dUcCasasnaRKisþ

CaedIm. cMENksakSIEdlkan;sasnaRBHBuT§KWtRmÚv[eFVI

sm,fenA cMeBaHmuxelaktadMbgEdkedayGnuelamtamRkm

nItiviFIRBhμTNÐrbs;km<úCa. mü:agvijeTot ebIemFavIman

bMNgeFVIemaXPaBelIskçIkmμrbs;sakSIedayEp¥kelIPaB

minRtwmRtÚvénkareFVIsm,f KWGaceFVI)anenAeBlPaKIeFVIesckþI

snñidæanbiTcugbBa©b;énsvnakar. bEnßmelIenHeTot RbFan

GgÁCMnMuCRmHRBmandl;elakemFavI edayminGnuBaØat[sYr

sMNYrTaMgLayNaEdlBak;B½n§nwgkareFV Ism,feLIy.

b:uEnþeTaHbICay:agNakþI elakemFavI epsþemn enAEtbnþsYr

sMNYrBak;B½n§nwgbBaðaenH edayelaksYrsakSIfa etIsakSI

enAcaMxø wmsarEdlxøÜn)aneFVIsm,fEdrb¤eT bEnßmelIenH

elak)andkRsg;xøwmsarsm,fenaHmkGan[sakSIsþab;

mþgeTotedIm,ICakarrMB£k. CafμImþgeTot RbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmH

bgÁab;eTAsakSImin[eqøIytbnwgsMNYrrbs;elakemFavI

epsþemn ehIyelak)aneFVIkarkt;smÁal;fa elakemFavI

epsþemn manGakb,kiriyarwgrYs minsþab;tam karENnaMrbs;

GgÁCMnMuCRmH.CakareqøIytb elakemFavI epsþemn)anelIk

eLIgfa GgÁCMnMuCRmHminTuklT§PaB[xøÜnsYrGMBIPaBGacTukcitþ

)anrbs;sakSIkñúgkarpþl;skçIkmμ ehIyGVIEdlxøÜn)aneFVI k¾min

EmnCaGakb,kiriyarwgrYsEdr eRBaHemFavImansiT§ieFVIdUecñH.

KYrrMB£kfa kareFVIkMNt;smÁal;elIGakb,kiriyarbs;elak

emFavI epsþemn enAeBlenHKWminEmnCaelIkTI1eLIy eBalKW

mankareFVIkMNt;smÁal;CaeRcIndgmkehIyGMBIGakb,kiriya

minsmrmürbs;elakemFavI epsþemn.

sMNYrbnÞab;EdlelakemFavI ém:eXIl epsþemn

elIkmksYrsakSIKWBak;B½n§nwgtYnaTI nigParkic©rbs;elak

Kat Qn; nig elak eha NaMhug edayelak)ansYrfa

etIGñkTaMgBIrmanzan³GVI ehIyTTYlbnÞúkelIkargarGVIxøHenAkñúg

RksYgkarbreTs.CakareqøIytb elaknI knbBa¢ak;fa elak

mindwgfaGñkTaMgBIrmanzan³GVIeLIy. elakFøab;)aneXIj

elak Kat Qn; TTYl KN³RbtiPUbreTsmYycMnYn. cMENk

elakehaNaMhug vijKWelakminEdl)ansÁal;eLIyehIyk¾

mindwgfaelak ehaNaMhug eFVIGVIenAmnÞIrbwgRtEbk¬mnÞIr-32¦

Edr.

cugeRkayelakemFavI ém:eXIl epsþemn esñIsMu

GgÁCMnMuCRmHdak;bgðajÉksarmYyedIm,IsYrsakSI. munnwg

seRmc RbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmHsYrbBa¢ak;elakemFavIfa etI

ÉksarenHemFavI)an dak;enAcMeBaHmuxGgÁCMnMuCRmHehIy

b¤enA?ehIyRtÚv)anGnuBaØat[ykmkedjedalEdrb¤eT?

CakareqøIytb elakemFavI)anelIkeLIgfa elak)andak;

ÉksarenHenAkñúgRbB½n§ Interface rbs;elakedIm,I[PaKI

epSg²eTot)andwg. CagenHeTAeTot elak)aneFVIsMeNIeTA

m®nþIc,ab;rbs; GgÁCMnMuCRmHyUrmkehIyedIm,IsMudak;ÉksarenH

enAcMeBaHmuxGgÁCMnMuCRmH k¾b:uEnþminTan;mankareqøIytbenA

eLIy.CalT§plGgÁCMnMuCRmHseRmcbdiesFnUvsMeNIrbs;

elakemFavI epsþemn edaypþl;sMGagehtufa elakemFavI

minTan;)anbMeBjlkçxNÐ[)anRtwmRtÚvBak;B½n§nwgkardak;

Éksar eBalKWÉksarEdlGacykmkedjedal)an

KWRtÚvmankarTTYlykCamunedayGgÁCMnMu CRmH.

4>2¦ skçIkmμrbs;sakSIcMeBaHmuxRkumemFavIkarBarkþI

eGogsarI

eTaHbIsakSICabuKálmñak;eFVIkarenARksYgkarbreTs

EdlRKb;RKgeday eGog sarI k¾eday kñúgkarsYredjedal

sakSIRkúmemFavIkarBarkþI eGog sarI )ancMNayeBlticCag

emFavIRkúmepSg²eTot eBalKWelakemFavICati Gag ]tþm

)anecaTsMNYrmYycMnYnb:ueNÑaHeTAsakSI. sMNYrdMbUg

rbs;elakemFavI Gag ]tþm KWBak;B½n§nwgTMnak;TMngrvag

elak nI kn nig ecom. eqøIytb nwgsMNYrenH elak nI kn

bBa¢ak;fa ecom KWCaRbFanmnÞIrénRksYgkarbreTs ehIyk¾

CaRbFanrbs;elakpÞal;Edr. ral;kic©karepSg²Bak;B½n§

nwgEpñkBiFIkar b¤karCUnePJóvbreTseFVITsSnkic© KWelak

TTYlkarENnaMBI ecom. ecom CaGñkcUlrYmkñúgkic©RbCMuFM²

CamYykmμaPi)alCan;x<s;rbs;RksYg ehIydak;EpnkarN_

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 15

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 18: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

bnþ[kmμaPi)alfñak;eRkamGnuvtþ. Cak;EsþgrUbelakpÞal;

KWEtgEtTTYl)anbBa¢aBI ecom [CUnePJóveTAeFVITsSnkic©enAtam

PUmiPaKbnÞab;BI ecom )anCYbRbCMuCamYyfñak;elIrYcehIy.

bnÞab;BICUnePJóvbreTsRtLb;mkvij KWelakRtÚvraykarN_[

ecom EdlCaRbFanrbs;xøÜn ehIy ecom nwgraykarN_eTAfñak;

elIbnþeTot. CaTUeTAelak nI kn raykarN_ GMBIEpñksnþisux

sRmab;KN³RbtiPU nigTIEnøgEdlelak)anCUnKN³RbtiPU

eTAeFVITsSnkic© ehIy eBlxøHelakraykarN_GMBIPaBGt;Xøan

nigkarxVHxatTICRmkrbs;RbCaCnenAtamtMbn;Edlelak)an

eXIjkñúgGMLúgeBldMeNIrTsSnkic©TaMgenaH.

bnÞab;BIsYrTMnak;TMngrvagsakSI nig ecom elakemFavI

)anbgðajÉksarEdlsakSI)an pþl;skçIkmμCUnecARkmesIub

GegátedIm,IsYrbBa¢ak;sakSI. ÉksarenHniyayBIkarcab;

buKÁlmYycMnYndUcCa maX TUc ehA Ekm¬Cam®nþITUtRbcaMenA

RbeTsLav¦hYtsm,tþi nig Giunln ehANatmkdak;enAmnÞIr

s-21. elak nI kn )anbBa¢ak;CUnecARkmesIubGegátfa

ral;karpøas;bþÚr nig karcab;xøÜnm®nþITUt KWCakarseRmcrbs;fñak;

elI EdlrYmman b:ul Bt/ nYn Ca/ eGogsarI nig exovsMpn.

munnwgcUldl;sMNYredIm,I[sakSIbBa¢ak;nUvGVIEdl

elak)aneqøIyenH elak Gag ]tþm )an ecaTsMNYrmYycMnYn

dUcCa etIsakSIFøab;)ancUlrYmkñúgkic©RbCMuFM²CamYykmμaPi)al

Can;x<s;rbs; RksYgEdrb¤eT? Føab;)anemIlr)aykarN_

b¤manbuKÁlNamñak;R)ab;GMBIxøwmsarénkic©RbCMuTaMgenaHEdrb¤

eT? CakareqøIytb elak nI kn bBa¢ak;fa elakminEdl)an

cUlrYmRbCMuCamYykmμaPi)alCan;x<s;rbs;RksYgeLIy ehIy

k¾minEdl)anGanxøwmsarénkic©RbCMuFM²rbs;kmμaPi)alTaMg

enaHEdr edaysarEtPaBlak;karN_x<s;énrbbExμrRkhm.

b:uEnþelak)andwgkic©kar nigEpnkar mYycMnYnrbs;fñak;elI

tamry³ ecom bgÁab;[xøÜnGnuvtþ. edaysakSIbBa¢ak;dUecñH

elakemFavI)anecaTsMNYrcugeRkayeTAsakSIfa{ edayelak

minEdl)ancUlrYmRbCMuFM²CamYykmμaPi)alCan;x<s;rbs;

RksYg ehIyminEdl)anemIlr)aykarN_énkic©RbCMuTaMg

enaH dUecñHetIRtÚvb¤eT EdlelakeqøIyfa karpøas;bþÚr b¤cab;m®nþI

TUtCakarseRmcrbs;b:ulBt/nYnCa/ eGogsarI nig exov sMpn

KWCakarsμanb:ueNÑaH?}.CakareqøIytb elak nI kn bBa¢ak;fa

tamkarGnuvtþCak;Esþg kic©karenHKWCakarseRmcrbs;fñak;

elI.

4>3¦ skçIkmμrbs;sakSIcMeBaHmuxRkumemFavIkarBarkþI

exovsMpn

kñúgkarsYredjedalsakSI RkúmemFavIkarBarkþI

CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn KWelak Kg; sMGun CaemFavICati nig

elakRsI Ganta hÁIesS CaemFavIGnþrCati )ansYrsakSI

edayepþatsMxan;GMBITMnak;TMngrvagsakSI nigCnCab;ecaT

exov sMpn buBVehtuénkarcUlrYmbdivtþedaysarkarTmøak;RKab;

Ebkrbs;shrdæGaemrik nigtYnaTIrbs;sakSIkñúgkareXasna

Gb;rMRbCaCnCaedIm. eqøIytb nwgRkúmFavIkarBarkþI elak nI kn

bBa¢ak;fa enAkñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü elakminEdl)an

Tak;TgedaypÞal;CamYy exov sMpn eLIy. b:uEnþelak)an

sÁal;edaysar exov sMpn KWCakmμa Pi)alCan;x<s;rbs;bkS

kumμúynIsþkm<úCaenAkñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü.

cMeBaHkarTmøak;RKab;Ebkrbs;shrdæGaemrikvij

elak nI kn bBa¢ak;fa bnÞab;BImankar Tmøak;semþcRBH neratþm

sIhnu BIdMENgPøam KWminTan;mankarTmøak;RKab;EbkenAtam

CnbTeLIy. b:uEnþeRkayBImankarRbyuT§Kñay:agxøaMgrvag

kgkmøaMgrbs; ln; nl; nig ExμrRkhmEdlshkarN_CamYy

kmøaMgrbs;rNsirSrYbrYmCati eTIbmankarTmøak;RKab;Ebkeday

shrdæGaemrik. karTmøak;enH)aneFVI[b:HBal;RbCaCnenAtam

CnbTCaeRcIn EdlbNþal[RbCaCnTaMgenaHcUlrYmclna

bdivtþedIm,Its‘URbqaMgrbbln; nl; nigbeNþjcRkBtiþGaemrik

ecjBIRbeTskm<úCa. cMeBaHsMNYrBak;B½n§kareXasnaGb;rM

RbCaCnedIm,IGUsTam[cUlrYmkñúgclnabdivtþ KWelak nI kn

)anbBa¢ak;CUnemFavIkarBarkþIdUcGVIEdlelakFøab;)anbBa¢ak;

CUnPaKIepSg²eTot Edl)ansYrGMBI bBaðaenHEdr.

bnÞab;BIsvnakarsþab;skçIkmμrbs;elak nI kn RtÚv)an

16 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 19: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

bBa©b; GgÁCMnMuCRmHbnþsþab;skçIkmμrbs;elaksrKwmlμút.

III¦ svnakarsþIBIkarpþl;skçIkmμrbs;sakSI sKwmlμút

bnÞab;BIkarsþab;skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI kn enAéf¶TI30

Ex]sPaqñaM2012GgÁCMnMuCRmH visamBaØkñúgtulakarkm<úCa)an

cab;epþImsþab;skçIkmμrbs;sakSIfμImYyrUbeTot. elak sKwm

lμút ehA mI KWCaGtItGKÁnaykrgenAFnaKaBaNiC¢kmμkm<úCa

nigCaGñkbkERbCUnKN³RbtiPUbreTs enAeBlmankic©RbCMu

mYycMnYn. karsþab;skçIkmμrbs;elak sKwm lμút manry³

eBlbIéf¶ edayGgÁCMnMuCRmH)anGnuBaØat[PaKInImYy² sYr

edjedalGMBIrcnasm<½n§RKb;RKgrdæ)al RbB½n§TMnak;TMng

kargar nigtYnaTIrbs;CnCab;ecaTmñak;²enAkñúgrbbkm<úCa

RbCaFibetyü. kñúgkarsYredjedalenH PaKI)anepþatelI

RbvtþirUb nigkarcUlrYmkñúgbdivtþrbs;sakSI bBaðaTak;Tgnwg

FnaKaBaNiC¢kmμ kargarCaGñkbkERb karCUnKN³RbtiPU

breTseFVITsSnkic©enARbeTskm<úCa nigkareFVICMnYjrvag

RbeTskm<úCa CamYyRbeTscin.

1¦ Rbvtþisavtarrbs;sakSI

elaksKwmlμút ehAmI ekItqñaM1931enARsukQUk

extþkMBt. TIlMenAbc©úb,nñ pÞHelx42 pøÚvelx234 xNÐ

TYleKak raCFanIPñMeBj. «BukeQμaH r½tñ sKwm mþayeQμaH

j:úk saKun. elak sKwm lμút manRbB½n§eQμaH G‘uk sam:al;

nigman kUncMnYn4nak;.

munrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü elak sKwm lμút KWCa

sa®sþacarümñak; bnÞab;mkeFVIkarenA xagreTHePøIg. kñúgGMLúg

qñaM1963-1964 bnÞab;BITTYl)ankarhVwkhVWnry³eBl

6ExBak;B½n§nwgkic©karFnaKa elakRtÚv)anEtgtaMgCaRbFan

saxaFnaKaRbcaMenARkúgRBHsIhnu.bnÞab; mkelakRtÚv)an

bBa¢ÚneTARbeTs)araMgcMnYnbIEx edIm,ITTYlkarhVwkhVWnbEnßm

enAFnaKaRbeTs)araMg. eBlRtLb;mkvij elakRtÚv)an

cat;taMg[TTYlbnÞúkCaRbFanEpñk\NTanedaysßit enAeRkam

karRKb;RKgpÞal;rbs; ecA esA EdleFVIkarenAFnaKarCati.

elaksKwmlμút bBa¢ak; fa elak)ancUlrYmkñúgclnabdivtþcab;

taMgBIrbbsgÁmra®sþniymmkem:øH ehIykñúgGMLúgeBlenaH

elak)anCYy]btßmCaR)ak;xøHdl;RkúmExμrRkhmkñúgkareFVI

bdivtþ edIm,I[RbeTsmankarrIkceRmInnigbM)at;GMeBIBuk rlYy.

enAeBlTahanExμrRkhmcUlkan;kab;TIRkúgPñMeBjPøam

elaksKwmlμút RtÚv)anCemøóseTAdl;RsúkeKonsVayehIy

elak)anrs;enACamYybgb¥ÚnenATIenaH. eRkaymkelak

RtÚv)anbBa¢ÚnmkshkrN_mYyeTotEdlmanTItaMgenAxag

t,ÚgTIRkúgPñMeBj. enAqñaM1976 elakRtÚv)aneKbBa¢Únmk

TIRkúgPñMeBj edIm,ICYbBiPakSaCamYyKN³RbtiPUcinGMBIkar

begáItFnaKaBaNiC¢kmμ mYyedIm,IsRmÜldl;kareFVIBaNiC¢kmμ

rvagRbeTsTaMgBIr. bnÞab;mkelakRtÚv)ancat;taMg[eFVICa

GKÁnaykrgrbs;FnaKaenHrhUtdl;rbbkm<úCaRbCaFibet

yüRtÚv)anpþÜlrMlM.

2¦ karsYredjedalsakSIedaytMNagsh

RBHraCGaCJa

kñúgkarsYredjedalsakSI elak ev:g h‘t EdlCa

tMNagshRBHraCGaCJaCati )ansYrepþatelIGgÁehtumYy

cMnYnTak;TgnwgkarcUlrYmkñúgclnabdivtþrbs;sakSI karCemøós

RbCaCnecjBITIRkúgPñMeBj kargarrbs;sakSIenAkñúgrbbkm<úCa

RbCaFibetyü. cMENkelak farIk Gab;DulLak; EdlCa

tMNagshRBHraCGaCJaGnþrCativij elak)ansYrbBa¢ak;

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 17

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

sakSI sKwm lμút

Page 20: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

bEnßmelIGgÁehtuTak;TgnwgkarCemøósRbCaCn nigkargar-

rbs;sakSIenATIRkúgPñMeBj. bnÞab;mkelak )anepþatsMxan;

elIGgÁehtuTak;TgnwgkarerobcMnigkarRbRBwtþeTArbs;FnaKa

BaNiC¢kmμ nigKN³ kmμaFikarBaNiC¢kmμ.

kk¦¦ kkaarrccUUllrrYYmmkkññúúggccllnnaaeeFFVVIIbbddiivvttþþ nniigg ttYYnnaaTTIIeennAAkkññúúgg

rrbbbbkkmm<<úúCCaaRRbbCCaaFFiibbeettyyüü

Bak;B½n§nwgkareFVIbdivtþ elaksKwmlμútbBa¢ak;fa elak

)ancUlrYmkñúgclnabdivtþkñúgGMLúgTsSn_vtþqñaM50 kñúgeKal

bMNgksagRbeTs[mankarrIkceRmIn niglubbM)at;GMeBIBuk

rlYyenAkñúgsgÁmExμr.tamry³karcUlrYmenH elak)anpþl;Ca

R)ak;]btßmmYycMnYndl;kmμa Pi)alfñak;eRkamrbs;ExμrRkhm

edIm,IerobcMkarRbCMuepSg²enAtammUldæan. bnÞab;BIbBa¢ak;

dUecñH tMNagshRBHraCGaCJadak;bgðajÉksarCaesovePA

niBn§eday hVIlIB sSt Edlelak )ansresrfa elak sKwm

lμút KWCaGñkbeRmIkargarenArtnaKar ehIy)anpþl;R)ak;

km©Idl;clnabdivtþrbs;ExμrRkhm. Pøam²enaH elak sKwm

lμút bdiesFcMeBaHkarelIkeLIgenH edayelakbBa¢ak;fa

{KWerOgenHminBiteT minBitTal;EtesaH ´Gt;eT)aT ´min

TTYl sÁal;.>>>´ faenHKWCakarKitsμanrbs;GñkniBn§enHeT.

´minEdleFVICahirBaØiksm¶at;GI[clnaExμrRkhm KW Kμan

dac;xateRkABIluykak;bnþicbnþÚc. enHKWCakarsnñidæaneday

KμanPsþútagrbs;GñkniBn§hñwg}.

Bak;B½n§nwgtMNak;kalts‘UbdivtþenHEdr sakSIbBa¢ak;fa

elak)ansÁal; exovsMpn nig eGogsarI kñúgTsSn_vtþqñaM60.

b:uEnþelakmindwgfaGñkTaMgBIreFVIGVIeLIykñúgGMLúgeBlts‘U

bdivtþ. bEnßmelIenHeTot elaksÁal;elak v:an; riT§

taMgBImunqñaM1975 mkemøH EdleBlenaH elak v:an; riT§

)anrt;ecjBITIRkúgPñMeBjeTAtMbn;rMedaHrbs;ExμrRkhm eday

sarmankartamcab;xøÜnrbs;kgT½B ln; nl;.

cMeBaHtYnaTI nigParkic©rbs;elak sKwm lμút enAkñúg

rbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü elak)anbBa¢ak;fa elakRtÚv)an

cat;taMg[eFVICaGKÁnaykrgénFnaKaBaNiC¢kmμénkm<úCa

EdlmaneQμaH mIu can; b¤ mIu xan; ¬sakSIcaMminc,as;¦ CaGKÁ

nayk. b:uEnþelakminEdl)aneXIj b¤CYbpÞal;CamYyGKÁ

naykrbs;xøÜneLIy ehIyFnaKarenHminmanRbtibtþikar

GVIeLIy eRBaHKμanEpñkrdæ)al EpñkhirBaØavtßú eBalKWmanEt

eQμaHEtb:ueNÑaH. tMNagshRBHraCGaCJaCatibnþsMNYr

rbs;xøÜnedayecaTsYrfa {rvagzan³rbs; eDOn nigzan³rbs;

elak etIGñkNabBa¢aGñkNa?}. elaksKwmlμút bBa¢ak;fa

elakmanzan³CaGKÁnaykrgénFnaKarBaNiC¢kmμ cMENk

eDOn KWCaRbFanKN³kmμaFikarBaNiC¢kmμ dUecñHelakRtÚvsþab;

bgÁab;rbs; eDOn. elak)anbBa¢ak;bEnßm eTotfa enAkñúgrbb

km<úCaRbCaFibetyübkSkumμúynIsþkmμúCamineRbIBakü{RksYg}

eLIy KWeRbIBakü{KN³kmμaFikar} EdlBaküTaMgBIrenHman

n½ydUcKña. eDOn KWCaRbFanKN³kmμaFikar BaNiC¢kmμ

cMENkGnCaRbFanKN³kmμaFikar]sSahkmμ EdlKN³kmμa

FikarTaMgBIrenHsßit enAeRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;KN³kmμa

Fikaresdækic©EdldwknaMeday v:n evt nig exovsMpn. kñúgnam

CaGKÁnaykrgFnaKar elakFøab;)ancUlrYmRbCMuCamYy

eGog sarI enAeBlkic©RbCMuTaMgenaHBak;B½n§nwgEpñkesdækic©

kareFVIBaNiC¢kmμ b¤FnaKar. bEnßmelIenHeTot elakFøab;)an

cUlrYmkic©RbCMurvagKN³kmμaFikarBaNiC¢kmμ nigKN³RbtiPU

breTsmYycMnYn dUcCaKN³RbtiPUkUer: KN³RbtiPUmkBI

RbeTsy:UehÁasøavI KN³RbtiPUcinCaedIm. Bak;B½n§nwgkar

cUlrYmkic©RbCMuepSg²eTot tMNagshRBHraCGaCJaGnþrCat

i)andak;bgðajÉksarkMNt;ehtukic©RbCMumYycMnYnrbs;KN³

Gcié®nþy_ edIm,I[sakSIbBa¢ak;BIsmasPaBGñkcUlrYmkic©

RbCMuTaMgenaH. ÉksarTI1KWCa kMNt;ehtukic©RbCMurbs;KN³

kmμaFikarGcié®nþy_ cuHéf¶TI09 Extula qñaM1975 Edlman

bBa¢ak;BIsmasPaBGñkcUlrYmRbCMu rYmman eGog sarI nig

exov sMpn. bnÞab;mkelaksYrbBa¢ak; GMBItYnaTIrbs;buKÁl

TaMgBIrenH. munnwgeqøIytbnwgsMNYrenH elak sKwm lμút

bBa¢ak;fa elakminEdl)aneXIjÉksarenHBImuneLIy ehIy

elakk¾minEdl)ancUlrYmkñúgkic©RbCMuenHEdr. PøamenaH

18 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 21: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

elakhSaesþI e):A CaemFavIkarBarkþICnCab;ecaT nYn Ca elIk

eLIgfa kñúgkrNIsakSIminFøab;sÁal;ÉksarNamYy Éksar

enaHKb,IRtÚvdkecjBIsakSI. CalT§plGgÁCMnMuCRmHseRmc

dkÉksarenHecjBIsakSI. CakareFVIkMNt;smÁal;tMNag

shRBHraCGaCJabBa¢ak;fa sakSIRtÚv)anbgðajÉksarenH

mþgrYcehIyenAtMNak;kalpþl;bTsmÖasn_CUnshecARkme

sIubGegát. b:uEnþelaknwgeKarBcMeBaHesckþIseRmcrbs;

GgÁCMnMuCRmH edayminsYrTak;TgnwgÉksarenHeLIy. KYr

rMB£kGMBIkarelIkeLIgrbs;elakemFavI ém:eXIl xaNav:as

Edl)anbBa¢ak;fa {>>>sakSI)anbBa¢ak;rYcehIyfa Kat;min)an

dwgGMBIÉksarenHBImunmkenaHeT. Kat;eTIbEtdwg ÉksarenH

CaelIkdMbUg. dUecñHGñkesIubGegát KWKat;BüayambegáIt[

sakSImankarcgcaM das;karcgcaMrbs;sakSI etIKat;)andwg

eTenAeBlenaH? niyayedayesμaHRtg;eTA KW´Kitfa min

GacykÉksarEdlmanbBa¢IeQμaHmnusSmkbgðajeT.

b:uEnþeyIgGacsYrsakSIenHfa eRkayBI)aneXIjÉksarenH

etIKat;dwgGVIxøHEdr? GaccgcaMGVIxøHEdr eyageTAelIGgÁehtu

TaMgLayEdlKat;nwgGaccgcaMBIeBlenaHmk. minEmnRtÚv

begáItkarcgcaMeRkayBIkarbgðajÉksarenHenaHeT}. Ék

sarTI2 KWCaesckþIsegçbénkMNt;ehtukic©RbCMurbs;KN³

kmμaFikarGcié®nþy_ cuHéf¶TI19ExemsaqñaM1976.Éksar

enHniyayGMBIkarerobcMKN³ kmμaFikarmYycMnYnenACMuvijmnÞIr

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 19

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

FnaKarCatiénkm<úCasm½ys®gÁamrvag ln; nl; nigExμrRkhm ¬RbPBÉksar³ mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa¦

Page 22: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

870 nigkarcat;taMgKN³RbtiPUmYyEdlmansmasPaB

dUcCa eDOn/ RKin/ say/ eQOn/ huk/ lμút edIm,ITTYl nigcrca

CamYyKN³RbtiPUNiC¢kmμcin. elak sKwm lμút bBa¢ak;fa

elakminEdl)ancUlrYmRbCMuCamYyKN³kmμaFikarGcié®nþ

y_eLIy dUecñHelakmin)andwgGMBIkarseRmcrbs;KN³

kmμaFikarenHEdr.

xx¦¦ GGMMBBIIkkaarrCCeemmøøóóssRRbbCCaaCCnn

Tak;TgnwgkarCemøósRbCaCnecjBITIRkúgPñMeBj

elaksKwmlμút bBa¢ak;CUntMNagshRBHraCGaCJafa enAeBl

resoléf¶TI17 Exemsa qñaM1975 kgT½BExμrRkhm)anR)ab;

RbCaCn[cakecjBITIRkúgPñMeBjcMnYn 2 eTA 3 éf¶ edIm,IeKc

BIkarTmøak;RKab;Ebkrbs;shrdæGaemrik. elakRtÚv)anbgçM[

cakecjBIpÞHsEm,g nigRTBüsm,tþiEdlxøÜnman edayyk

)anEtsmÖar³eRbIR)as;pÞal;xøÜnmYycMnYnb:ueNÑaH. enAeBl

eFVIdMeNIrdl;rgVg;mUlk,alfñl;eTaHbICa elakmanbMNgeFVI

dMeNIreTARsukQUk¬kñúgextþkMBt¦ EdlCaRsukkMeNIrrbs

;elakkþI b:uEnþelak RtÚv)anRkúmTahanExμrRkhmbgçM[eFVIdMeNIr

tampøÚvCatielx1rhUteTAdl;RsukeKonsVay. elak sKwm

lμút bBa¢ak;eTotfa RbCaCnRtÚv)anTahanExμrRkhmCemøóseTA

dl;eKonsVay edayrs;enAkkkujenATIenaH Edlmñak;²mindwg

faxøÜnnwgbnþdMeNIreTATINaeToteLIy. eTaHbIenATIenaHman

RbCaCnrs;enAdUecñHkþI b:uEnþExμrRkhmmin)anerobcM[manmnÞIr

eBTü b¤TICRmksRmab;RbCaCneLIy. cMENkrUbelakpÞal;

KWRtÚv)anTahanExμrRkhmGnuBaØat[eTArs;enACamYybgb¥Ún

enARsukeKonsVay. bnÞab;BIrs;enARsukekonsVay)anmYy

ry³ elakRtÚv)anbBa¢Únbnþ[eTArs;enAshkrN_mYyEdl

manTItaMgenAxagt,ÚgTIRkúgPñMeBj.eBleTAdl;Pøam elak nig

RbCaCnepSg²eTotEdlrs;enAkñúgshkrN_enaH RtÚv)an

tRmÚv[eFVIRbvtþirUbpÞal;xøÜnedIm,Ipþl;CUnRbFanshkrN_.

RbvtþirUbenHRtÚvbBa¢ak;GMBI eQμaH RbvtþisikSaeronsURt kargar

nigtYnaTIEdlxøÜnFøab;eFVIenAkñúgrbbmun. RbCaCnRtÚv)aneK

R)ab;[ykRTBüsm,tþieTAdak;kñúg shkrN_TaMgGs;Kña.

KYrrMB£kfa enAeBlEdltMNagshRBHraCGaCJaGnþr

CatisYrGMBIkarCemøósRbCaCnecjBITIRkúgPñMeBj elak

ém:eXIl xaNav:as CaemFavIkarBarkþICnCab;ecaT eGogsarI

)anelIkeLIgfa GgÁehtuTak;TgnwgkarCemøósRbCaCnRtÚv)an

tMNagshRBHraCGaCJaCatisYrmþgrYcehIy. dUecñHtMNag

shRBHraCGaCJaGnþrCatikMBugsYrsMNYreTAsakSIelIGgÁehtu

RcMEdl. elakemFavIkt;smÁal;bEnßmfa GgÁCMnMuCRmHTMng

CaGnuBaØat[tMNagshRBHraCGaCJaecaTsMNYrRcMEdleTA

sakSI. CakareqøIytb elak tarIk elIkeLIgfa elakRKan;Et

sYrbBa¢ak;elI cMNucCak;lak;mYycMnYnedIm,I[manPaBc,as;

las;Etb:ueNÑaH. CalT§pl GgÁCMnMuCRmHseRmcbdiesF

cMeBaHkarCMTas;rbs;elak xaNav:as edaypþl;sMGag

ehtufa Bak;B½n§nwgkarCemøósRbCaCn tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa

CatiRKan;EtsYrsMNYrTUeTAEtb:ueNÑaH dUecñHtMNagshRBH

raCGaCJaGnþrCatiGacsYrsMNYrCak;lak;edIm,I[sakSIbBa¢ak;

bEnßm)an.b:uEnþeTaHbICay:agNa k¾edayGgÁCMnMuCRmHbBa¢ak;

CUntMNagshRBHraCGaCJa nigPaKIepSg²eTotfa kñúgkrNI

mankarEbgEckGgÁehtuKñaedIm,IsYrsakSI KWKb,IsYrGgÁehtu

enaH[)anlm¥itecosvagkarsYrelIGgÁehtuenaHbEnßmEdl

naM[ekItmansMNYrRcMEdl.

KK¦¦ GGMMBBIIKKNN³³kkmmμμaaFFiikkaarrBBaaNNiiCC¢¢kkmmμμ ³³

Tak;TgnwgKN³kmμaFikarBaNiC¢kmμ elaksKwmlμút

bBa¢ak;fa enAqñaM1976KN³kmμa FikarBaNiC¢kmμmanTItaMgenA

CitpSarcas; ehIyRtÚv)andwknaMeday eDOn Edlmanzan³Ca

RbFan. eRkaymkKN³kmμaFikarenH )anbþÚrTItaMgmkkEnøg

mYyepSgeTot¬TItaMgRksYgkarBarCatibc©úb,nñ¦ dwknaMeday

v:an; riT§ bnÞab;BI eDOn RtÚv)ancab;xøÜn. KN³kmμaFikarBaNiC¢kmμ

manbuKÁlikbeRmIkargarRbEhl20nak; ehIyRtÚv)anEbg

EckCaBIrEpñk KWEpñkTTYlkic©karkñúgRbeTs nigEpñkTTYl

kic©kareRkARbeTs. KN³kmμaFikarenHmanParkic©kMNt;

muxTMnijEdlRtÚvnaMcUlRbeTskm<úCa nigTMnijEdlRtÚvnaMecj

eTAlk;enAeRkARbeTs. TMnijEdlRtÚvnaMeTAlk;enAeRkA

20 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 23: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

RbeTs rYmman RsÚv eBatsENþk eRmc kaehVCaedIm.

bnÞab;mktMNagshRBHraCGaCJasYrfa etIral;karnaM

TMnijecjcUlRbeTskm<úCa RtÚvqøgkat;FnaKarBaNiC¢kmμ

Edrb¤eT? ehIyFnaKaenHsßitenAeRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;

KN³kmμaFikar BaNiC¢kmμEdrb¤y:agNa? elak sKwm lμút

bBa¢ak;CUnGgÁCMnM uCRmHfa karnaMTMnijecj b¤cUlRbeTs

km<úCa KWminmankarqøgkat;FnaKarBaNiC¢kmμeLIy ehIy

FnaKaenHk¾minsßitenAeRkamkar RKb;RKgrbs;KN³kmμaFikar

BaNiC¢kmμEdr. bnÞab;BIsakSIbBa¢ak;dUecñH tMNagshRBH

raCGaCJadak;bgðajÉksarEdlsakSIFøab;)anpþl;skçIkmμCUn

shecARkmesIubGegátfa {eBlmkdl;TIRkúgPñMeBj ´RtÚv

)ancat;taMg[CYbRbCMuCamYyKN³RbtiPUcinedIm,IBiPakSa

GMBIkareFVIBaNiC¢kmμ. cin)anpþl;TwkR)ak;cMnYn 148lan

edIm, Ibegá ItFnaKarsRmÜldl;kareFV IBaNiC¢kmμenH.

FanaKarenHsßitenAeRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;KN³kmμaFikar

BaNiC¢kmμ}. elak sKwm lμút )an TTYlsÁal;nUvcemøIyenH

b:uEnþelakbBa¢ak;bEnßmfa elakminsUvcaMc,as;GMBIcMnYnTwkR)ak;

Edlcin)anpþl;CUneLIy. bnÞab;mktMNagshRBHraCGaCJa

bgðajÉksarmYyeTotCUnsakSIBinitücMNarrbs;elak

v:an; riT§. ÉksarenHKWCar)aykarN_Edlelak v:an; riT§ )an

epJICUnelak sKwm lμút edayraykarN_GMBITMnijEdl)an

naMecjeTAlk;enAeRkARbeTs ehIymancMNarbBa¢ak;fa

{)anepJICUnbg v:n nigbg Ehm rYcehIy}. elak sKwm lμút

bBa¢ak;fa {bgv:n} KWCaeQμaHrbs; v:n evt cMENk {bgEhm}

KWsMedAelI exovsMpn ehIycMNarenHBitCa cMNarrbs;elak

v:an; riT§. bEnßmelIenHeTot tMNagshRBHraCGaCJabgðaj

ÉksarcMnYnBIreTot edIm,I[sakSIBinitücMNarrbs;elak v:an;

riT§. ÉksarTI1KWCar)aykarN_EdlRksYgBaNiC¢kmμ

raykarN_CUnfñak;elIrbs;xøÜnrYmman v:n evt nig exov sMpn

nigbg51 ¬sakSImincaMeQμaHbg51¦ sþIBIkarCYbRbCMuCamYy

KN³RbtiPUkUer:. cMeBaHÉksarTI2 KWCar)aykarN_Edl

KN³kmμaFikarBaNiC¢kmμraykarN_[ v:n evt nig exov sMpn

GMBIkic©RbCMuCamYyKN³RbtiPUmkBIRbeTsy:UehÁasøavI sþIBI

karkMNt;muxTMnijdUcCa Ggár nigkaehV EdlRtÚv ykeTAlk;enA

RbeTsy:UehÁasøavI. bnÞab;BI)anBinitür)aykarN_TaMgBIrenH

elak sKwm lμút bBa¢ak;fa r)aykarN_TaMgenHKWRsbKña

nigsIusgVak;eTAnwgxøwmsarEdlelak)anCYbRbCMuCamYyKN³

RbtiPUkUer: nigKN³RbtiPUy:UehÁasøavI. dUecñHcMNarEdl

manenAkñúgÉksarTaMgenHKWBitCacMNarrbs; v:an; riT§ Edl

)anraykarN_[ v:n evt nig exov sMpn. bnÞab;mktMNag

shRBHraCGaCJaecaTsYrfa ehtuGVIkic©RbCMuTaMgenHcaM)ac;

RtÚvraykarN_[ v:n evt nig exovsMpn?CakareqøIytb elak

sKwm lμút bBa¢ak;y:agc,as;fa KN³kmμaFikarBaNiC¢kmμRtÚv

raykarN_ CUnKN³kmμaFikaresdækic©EdlCafñak;elIrbs;xøÜn

eBalKWRtÚvraykarN_[ v:n evt nig exov sMpn. cugeRkay

tMNagshRBHraCGaCJabBa¢ak;fa elakmanÉksarr)ay

karN_RbCMuCag20eTotEdlsakSI)ancUlrYmkñúgkic©RbCMu

TaMgenaHehIy)anraykarN_[ exovsMpn.

bnÞab;BIbBa©b;sMNYrBak;B½n§nwgkarBinitücMNarrbs;e

lak v:an; riT§ Edl)anraykarN_[ v:n evt nig exov sMpn

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 21

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Gab;Dulhak; farIk

Page 24: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

tMNagshshRBHraCGaCJa)anbnþsMNYrBak;B½n§nwgRkúmh‘un

er:nhVúg EdlRtÚv)anbegáIteLIgedaybkSkumúμynIsþkm<úCa

edIm,IeFVIBaNiC¢kmμeRkARbeTs. elak sKwm lμút bBa¢ak;fa

Rkúmh‘uner:nhVúg manTItaMgenATIRkúghugkugRbeTscin Edl

RtÚv)anbegáIteLIg edIm,IeFVIBaNiC¢kmμCamYyRbeTselak

esrI. Rkúmh‘unenHmanPaKh‘unrbs;sux nigNat ehIyEdl

PaKh‘unTaMgenHRtÚv)anepÞrmk[ RKin kan;kab;CMnYsbnÞab;BIGñk

TaMgBIrRtÚv)anKN³kmμaFikarBaNiC¢kmμbBa¢a[vilcUlRsuk

Exμrvij. bEnßmelIenH tMNagshRBHraCGaCJabgðajÉk

sarCalixitmYy cuHéf¶TI10 Exvicäika qñaM1978 Edl)aneFVI

edayKN³kmμaFikarBaNiC¢kmμsþIBIkarcat;taMg RKin [TTYl

Parkic©CMnYs sux nig Nat enARkúmh‘un er:nhVúg edIm,I[GñkTaMgBIr

vilmkRbeTskm<úCavij. bnÞab;BIbgðajÉksar tMNag

shRBHraCGaCJa sYrsakSIfa etIman GVIekIteLIgcMeBaHNat

nig sux enAeBlGñkTaMgBIrvilmkRbeTskm<úCavij? Cakar

eqøIytb elak sKwm lμút bBa¢ak;fa elakmindwgGMBIbBaðaenH

eLIy eRBaHvaCaesckþIseRmcrbs;KN³kmμaFikarBaNiC¢

kmμ.

elaktMNagshRBHraCGaCJa farIk )anbnþsMNYr

GMBITMnak;TMngrvagGnCamYy exovsMpn nig v:n evt.b:uEnþsakSI

)aneqøIyfaxøÜnmindwgBITMnak;TMngenHeT edayxøÜn)anmksñak;enA

CitRksYg]sSahkmμmYyry³xøIb:ueNÑaH. elak farIk )ansYr

faetIGñkNaCaRbFanFMenARksYg ]sSahkmμ v:n evt b¤exov

sMpn? sakSI)aneqøIyfa xøÜnmindwgeT eRBaHeBlEdlelak

mkdl;RksYgenH KWeKmin)anbBa¢ak;BIrcnasm<½n§enaHeT.

karN_EdlelakdwgKWenAeBleRkaymkeT KWtamecARkm

esIubGegát EdlelakdwgfamaneQμaH eDOn nigv:an;riT§. elak

tMNagshRBHraCGaCJabgðajÉksareTAsakSI A-38 nig

elIeGRkg;TUrTsSn_. elak)anGanGtßbTsRmg;{enAeBl

Edl´cUleFVIkarenATIenaH KW Gn CaRbFanRksYg. ebItam´

sμanKWeQμaH EhmCaGñkemIlBIelIeTotb:uEnþKat;minbgðajmux

eT. RbEhlCaelak Ehm enAkñúgKN³kmμa Fikaresdækic©xag

elI ehIyKat;CaGñkRKb;RKgenATIenaHÉg}. sakSI)anyl;

RsbtamGVIEdlshRBHraCGaCJa)anGan ehIyfaelak

)aneqøIyEbbenaHEmn b:uEnþedaysarelak)aneXIjÉksar

mYycMnYneTIbelakeqøIydUecñH.elakfarIk)ansYrBIkarpþl;

mtieyabl;Edlelaklμút)aneFVI.elakRBHraCGaCJa)an

elIkbBa¢IÉksarcMnYn6Edl)anniyayBIkMNt;ehtuTIpSar

kñúgkMLúg Exmkranigtula qñaM1978. elak sKwm lμút

22 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 25: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

)aneqøIyfa elak)aneFIVkarBak;B½n§nwgRksYgBaNiC¢kmμenaH

maneRcInNas;ehIyEdlmancuHhtßelxaenaHelakcuHelI

ÉksarEdlelakR)akdfa)anGanEmn ehIyminEmnman

n½yfaelak)andwgRKb;erOgenArbbenaHeLIy. sakSImin

)anRCabBIdMeNIrrbs; v:n evt enARksYg]sSahkmμenaHeT

ebIeTaHCaelak enAkñúgRksYgenaHrhUtdl;cb;k¾eday.

sakSI)anB£faeKdkhUt elak v:n evt Etelakminh‘an

sYreTA v:an; riT§ eLIy. elakRBHraCGaCJa)anbnþsYr nigbgðaj

ÉksarEdlecARkmesIub)ansYrTak;TgnwgkarRbCMuéf¶TI8

ExFñÚ qñaM1978.ÉksarniyayBIkarRbCMurvag eGogsarI

nigKN³RbtiPUcin ehIymanvtþmanrbs;elak srKwm lμút/

esg TMu nig Gn.sakSI)anTTYlsÁal;faBitCamankarRbCMuEmn

EtelakmincaMeT ehIyelakmankarPJak;ep¥IlEdr Edl eGog

sarI enAxagRksYgkarbreTs EtmkcUlrYmRbCMuCamYyePJóv

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 23

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

RkúmGñkCMnajkarExμrRkhmenAkñúgk):al;dwkCMnij ¬RbPBÉksar³ mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa¦

Page 26: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

enARksYg]sSahkmμenaHeTAvij. elakminPJak;ep¥IlGIVeT

elakRKan;Etq¶l;enAkñúgcitþfaehtuGVI)anCa eGog sarI

mkRbCMuCamYyRksYg]sSahkmμ ehIy)anniyayBIbBaða

Tak;TgnwgRksYgenHeTot ehIykic©RbCMuenaHmanlkçN³

sMxan;edaysarEtmanKN³RbtiPUBIRbeTscin)ancUlrYmCa

mYyEdr.

3¦ skçIkmμrbs;sakSIcMeBaHmuxemFavItMNag

edImbNþwgrdæb,evNI

elakRsI sIun suv:n emFavItMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNI

)ancab;epþImsMNYrrbs;xøÜn edaysYreLIgvijGMBIkarcUlrYm

rbs;sakSIkñúgclnats‘UenAkñúgsm½ysgÁmra®sþniym.

Pøam² elak xaNav:as CaemFavIkarBarkþICnCab;ecaT eGog

sarI )aneRkakQrrYcelIkeLIgfa sMNYrKYrEtcab;epþImBIGVI

EdlshRBHraCGaCJaminTan;)ansYr. elakecARkmeFVI

karrB£kdl;elakRsIemFavIBIkareRbIR)as;eBlevla[man

GtßRbeyaCn_. bnÞab;mkelakRsI)ansYrGMBIGñkmkx©IR)ak;

enAFnaKar b:uEnþsMNYrenHminRtÚv)anGgÁCMnMuCRmHGnuBaØat[

sakSIeqøIyeLIy. elakRsI)anbnþsMNYfa etIelaksakSI

yl;y:agNacMeBaHkar]btßmR)ak;kñúgbdivtþ. elaksakSI

)aneqøIiytbfa enHKWCaerOgtaMgBImunrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü

EdleKGegÁósluybnþicbnþÜcminmanGIcEmøkeT KWeFVItaMg

BImunqñaM1975emø:H. sakSI)anCRmabCUnGgÁCMnM uCRmH

GMBIRbePTrUbiyb½NÑEdleRbIsRmab;TUTat;CamYyRbeTscin

KWluyy½n ehIycMeBaHRbeTsepSgeTot KWeRbIRbePTluy

epSg.

eqøIytbnwgsMNYrbnÞab; sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa elak

sÁal; eDOn CaRbFanKN³kmμaFikarBaNiC¢kmμ Etelakmindwg

fa eDOn eFVIkarenA870eTsUm,IeQμaH870k¾minFøab;B¤Edr.

cMENk v:n evt elakCYb)anEtmþgb:ueNÑaHenAqñaMRbEhledIm

qñaM1976.elakRsIemFavI )anbnþsMNYrfa elakFøab;eFVIkar

enAsIusuvtßietIelaksÁal; eGog sarI exov FIriT§eT? sakSI

)aneqøIytbfaelaksÁal;buKÁlTaMgBIrtaMgBIenAmuneBleFVI

karenATIenaHeTAeTot. sakSIFøab;beRmIkarCanaykrgFnaKar

BaNiC¢kmμeRkARbeTs ral;kargarenaHelakeFVIedaymin

manbBa¢apÞal;BInrNaeT KWtamnirsarBImnÞIrkNþalmYy.

kargarsñÚlenAFnaKar KWRbtibtþikarrvagExμr nigbreTs b:uEnþ

manEtBIrnak;b:ueNÑaH minmanKNenyüenaHeT KWmanEt

eQμaHb:ueNÑaH.

emFavIGnþrCatitMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNI KWelak

eNKVI )anbeBa©jnUvPaBsb,ayrIkraycMeBaHlT§PaB rbs;

sakSIEdlGacsþab;Pasa)araMg)an. eqøIytbnwgsMNYr sakSI

)anbBa¢ak;faelakmin)anTTYlbBa¢IEdlraykarN_BIRsUv

GgárEdlnaMecjeT elakeTIbEteXIjbBa¢IenHenAéf¶enH

b:ueNÑaH. sakSI)anbnþeTotfa enAeBlEdlelakeFVICaGñkbk

ERbCUnKN³RbtiPUeTATsSnaenAtamshkrN_ elakmin)an

eXIjmankarFøak;cuHnUvkarhUbcukGIeT edaysarshkrN_

enaHmanlkçN³Biess eRBaHmankEnøgGacrkmðÚbGahar

)an. elakemFavI eNKVI )aneFVIkarrMB£kdl;sakSIGMBIeQμaH

pn nig sYn sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa RbEhlCakmμaPi)alfñak;

mFüm b¤fñak;kNþal b¤Epñkbec©keTsmkBIRksYgBaNiC¢kmμ

ehIyelak)aneRbóbeFobtMENgrbs;GñkTaMgBIrenaHfa

ebIenAkñúgeBlbc©úb,nñKWRbEhlnwgfñak; kariyal½y.

muneBlelakecjdMeNIrBIPñ MeBjenAqñaM1976

sakSImin)anenACamYy Gn eLIy ehIyelakk¾mindwgfa

vasnarbs; Gn y:agNaenaHEdr. elakminFøab;dwgfaGñk

enARksYgenaHman kar)at;xøÜnnigbBaðabBa¢ÚneQμaHeTAs-21

eLIy KWelakeTIbEtdwgenAkñúgsvnakarenHb:ueNÑaH. enA

kñúgRksYgBaNiC¢kmμ sakSI)anCYybgðajBIEbbbTeFVIbBa¢Ib:uEnþ

eBlTMnij naMecj-cUl enaH elakmin)andwgeT.sakSI)an

CRmabfa karbMeBjkargarCaGñkbkERbCUnKN³RbtiPU

esdækic©BaNiC¢kmμenaHelak)ansÁal;eQμaH RKin EdlCa

RbFanEpenAkMBg;esam. eqøIytbnwgsMNYrGMBIeQμaHenH

sakSI)anpþl;cemøIyfaelakcaMfaeKbBa¢Únelak RKin eTA

hugkug edayRksYgBaNiC¢kmμ b:uEnþRtg;cMNucfabBa¢ÚneTA

24 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 27: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

edIm,ICMnYseQμaH sux enaHsakSIminRCabeT. sakSIk¾)an

bBa¢ak;BIkRmitsÁal;KñarvagelakCamYyelak nig v:an; riT§

EdlCasisSrbs;;elakeBlsakSIeFVIkarenAsalasIusuvtßi.

elakfaelakminmanniyayepþaHbþÚrKñaGMBIKN³kmμaFikarBa

NiC¢kmμGIeT ebIeTaHCaFøab;sÁal;elak riT§ BImunmkk¾eday.

4¦ karsYredajedaledayRkúmemFavIkarBarkþI

enAeBlcab;epþ ImsvnakarnaRBwkéf¶TI5Exmifuna

qñaM2012 GgÁCMnMuCRmH)anpþl;evTikaeTARkumemFavIkarBarkþI

CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn muneKedIm,IsYrsakSI sKwm lμút.

elakemFavICati Kg; sMGun )ancab;epþImsMNYrTak;Tgnwgkar

pþl;CMnYydl;clnabdivtþ. sakSI)aneqøIyfa eRkABICMnYyCa

fvikaelakminmanCYyCakmøaMgkay nigcitþeT. eqøIytb

nwgsMNYrsakSI)anCRmabCUnGgÁCMnMuCRmHfaxøÜnFøab;CYb exov

sMpn enAmunqñaM1975 edaysarKat;CasPatMNagRbCaCn

EtminFøab;CYbpÞal;. munqñaM1978elak)anCYbKat;min

Emnkñúgkic©karraCkareT KWCYbedayécdnü b:ueNÑaHenAkEnøg

xøHkñúgTIRkúgPñMeBj. elaksakSIFøab;B¤BaküsmanCn

ehIyelakk¾sßitenAkñúgRbePTsmanCnenHEdr. elak

sakSI)anBnül;fasmanCnenAmunqñaM1975KWCaCnEdlman

citþCYybdivtþ b:uEnþminskmμeT.

Tak;TgnwgkarCemøóselaksakSI)ancakecjBIPñM

eBjCamYyeKÉgkñúgry³eBlxøIb:ueNÑaH.eRkaymkRbFan

shkrN_[elakRtlb;mkPñMeBjvij EteKminR)ab;munfa

mkTINaeT. eK)anDubelakdwktamm:UtUmkmnÞIr]sSahkmμ

CamYyGnuRbFanshkrN_. eBlmkdl;Pøamelak)anCYb

RbFanRksYg]sSahkmμ KWelakGn. Gn )anR)ab;[elak

enAcaMenATIenaHsin caMfñak;elImkR)ab;. minyUrb:unμan GñkEdl

mkCYbelakenaH KWelak v:n evt EdlelakKitfa v:n evtman

zan³FMCagelak Gn. eBlenaH eKR)ab;[eTAcUlRbCMuCamYy

KN³RbtiPU edayeRtómexaGav nigerobcMxøÜn. elakemFavI)an

sYrfaetImUlehtuGVI)anCa v:n evt dwgBIsmasPaBelak

BIerOgecHxagFnaKar sakSI)aneqøIyfaelakmindwgeTfa v:n

evt dwgerOgenHBINa b:uEnþmanmnusSeRcInNas;EdldwgBI

smtßPaBrbs;elak. Tak;TgnwgeQμaH v:an; riT§ sakSI)anbMPøWfa

xøÜn)anCYbenAeBleRkaymk KWeBlEdlCYbCamYy eDOn

RbCMuCamYyKN³RbtiPU.sakSIFøab;)anENnaMkargarFnaKar

eTAkmμaPi)alExμrRkhm KWCYyBnül;CaRTwsþIenAeBlKN³

RbtiPUcinBnül; ehIyGñkTaMgenaHsþab;minyl; elakk¾)an

Bnül;enAkEnøgNaEdleKsYrTak;TgnwgRTwsþITUeTAEdleK

eRbIR)as;elIsklelakb:ueNÑaH minEmnebIkvKÁsikSaeT.

sakSIk¾)anbBa¢ak;Edrfa elakminFøab;manEpnkar b¤eKal

karN_esñIedIm,I[FnaKarmankarrIk ceRmInGIeT.

bnÞab;BIemFavICati)ansYrcb; elak GakTY EvkEKn

emFavIGnþrCatikarBarkþICnCab;ecaT exov sMpn )ancab;epþIm

sMNYredayecaTsYrsakSIfa etIelakFøab;cat;Tukfaelak

Ehm Cafñak;elIrbs;elakeT? sakSI)aneqøIytbfa

elakminEdlcat;TukCapøÚvkareT KWRKan;EtKitkñúgcitþb:ueNÑaH

b:uEnþCak;EsþgminEmneT. bnÞab;mkelakemFavI)ansYrfa

etIelak exov sMpn mantMENgGVIenArbbExμrRkhm?sakSI

)aneqøIyfa exov sMpn RbEhlCanaykrdæm®nþIenAeBl

enaH. sakSI)anpþl;PaBc,as;las;CUnGgÁCMnM uCRmHfa

elakminEmnKitRsém:fa exov sMpn Canaykrdæm®nþIeT

KWenAeBlenaHmankarRbkasCapøÚvkar RbkasCaGnþrCatifa

Kat;Canaykrdæm®nþI EtRtg;faCafñak;elIrbs;elakenaH

KWkargarpÞal;CamYyelakenaHKWmindwgeT eRBaH exov sMpn

minEdlcuHmkbBa¢aelakGMBIkic©karFnaKarenaHEdr. sakSI

)anbnþ eTotfaelakminsÁal;GkSrnightßelxarbs;elak

exovsMpn eT.

4>1¦ karsYredjedaledayRkúmemFavI nYn Ca

elaksun GruNCaemFavIkarBarkþI nYn Ca )aneFVIkar

sYredjedalsakSI edayepþatelIRbvtþiénkarcUlbdivtþenA

sm½ysgÁmra®sþniym. ebIeTaHCasakSImincaMqñaMEdlelak

)ancUlrYmenAkñúgbdivtþ b:uEnþsakSIcaMfaeBlenaHelakman

kargareFVIrYcehIyminEmnCanisSiteT. elakemFavI)ansYr GMBI

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 25

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 28: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

Baküfa hVúg nig®hÁúg ehIysakSI)anTTYlsÁal;fa elakFøab;

B ¤BaküTa MgenHenAeBlmanrN³sirSCamYyRBHkr uNa

b:uEnþelakmincaMfaenAkñúgqñaMNaeT.

elakemFavI)ansYrGMBIkarcUlmkRbeTskm<úCa eday

T½BevotNammkEb:kxagt,ÚgRbeTskm<úCa. sakSI)aneqøIy

fa elakFøab;B¤EtminsUvc,as;eLIy. elakemFavI)aneFVI

karelIkeLIgpÞal;xøÜn edaysYreTAsakSIfa {Etedayyfa

ehtuy:agNaenAeBlenaHRkum ExμrkumμúynIsþ evotNamenaH

min)andwknaMRbeTseTACaRkúmkumμúynIsþ b:ul Bt niymcin

CaGñkkan;kab;GMNacBIqñaM1975 dl;1979eTAvij.

etIerOgenHelakdwgc,as;;dUcmanenAkñúgÉksareT?b¤k¾elak

B¤eKfa?´niyayBImundMbUgbMputfaelakCaGñkbBaØvnþmñak;

ehIyEdlmanv½ycMNas;lμmdwg}. Pøam²enaHemFavInaMmux

tMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNI nigtMNagshRBHraCGaCJa)an

eFVIkarCMTas;nwgGVIEdlelakemFavI GruN )anelIkeLIg.

elakRbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmH)anKaMRTkarCMTas;enH ehIy)anpþl;

ehtuplfa elakemFavIminGaceRbIkarsnñidæanrbs;xøÜnmk

sYredjedalsakSIdUecñHeT ehIysMNYrrbs;elakminmanenA

kñúgdIkardMeNaHRsayeT. edayehtufasMNYrPaKeRcIn

rbs;elakemFavI GruN minTak;Tg dUecñHelaksUmbBa©b;

sMNYr rbs;xøÜn.

bnÞab;BIbBa©b;sMNYrrbs;xøÜn elak GruN )anepÞrevTika

sYrCUnédKUrrbs;elak EdlCaemFavIGnþrCati. elakemFavI

hSaes<I e):A )ancab;epþImsMNYrTak;TgnwgÉksarEdlpþl;

edayshecARkmesIubGegátfa etIGacCYydl;karyl;dwg

rbs;elakGMBIrcnasm<½n§énrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyüEdrb¤

eT? elak sKwm lμút )aneqøIyfa ÉksarTaMgenaHGac CYy

)anxøH ehIytamry³ÉksarTaMgenaHeFVI[elakdwgfa

RksYgNaraykarN_eTAnrNa.sakSI)anCRmabCUnGgÁCMnMu

CRmHEdrfa enAkñúgrbbenaHelakminEdlcUlrYmRbCMunaMRsUv

GgárecjBIkm<úCaeLIy. enHCaParkic©rbs;RksYgBaNiC¢kmμ.

elakk¾mindwgBIkarnaMecjRsUv b¤plitplepSgeTotenaH

eT. karN_EdlelakfaRsUvminGacnaMecjeRcInenaHvaCa

karsnñidæanGtþenam½trbs;elakb:ueNÑaH edaysarminman

eCIgelxGVIc,as;las;eT. elakemFavI)anbnþsYredaydak;

Éksar bnÞab;mkelak)anGanesckþIsRmg;ehIysYrfaetI

manTwkCMnn;xøaMgeTenAqñaM1978? sakSI)aneqøIyfaxøÜnmincaM

eT. elakemFavI)anbgðajÉksarCUnsakSI b:uEnþsakSImin

Føab;)aneXIjÉksarenHeT dUecñHGgÁCMnMuCRmH)andkÉksar

enaHvij nigrMB£kdl;emFavI faKYrEtBinitünigdak;ÉksareTAkñúg

bBIa¢CamunminEmndak;ehIy)anniyayfaminc,as;dUecñHeT.

elakemFavI)anesñIfaebIminGnuBaØat[sYrelIÉksarenHeT

enaHelakminmanGVIsYreT.

KYrkt;smÁal;fa RkúmemFavIkarBarkþI eGogsarI minman

sMNYreTAsakSIeT. enAmuneBlbBa©b;svnakarsYredj

edalsakSIsKwmlμút elakecARkmhSg;m:akLaEv:j)ansYr

eTAkan;sakSIGMBIGtþsBaØaNrbs;eQμaH Ehm faetIEp¥kelI

karviPaKrbs;elak etImaneQμaHnrNaepSgEdleRkABI

exov sMpn b¤eT? sakSI)aneqøIyfavaCabBaðasμúKsμajmYy

KWelakdwgfaÉksarmYycMnYnRtUvbBa¢ÚneTAeQμaH Ehm ehIy

CaTUeTAeKsÁal;fa Ehm Caexov sMpn EtebIrkÉksarNaEdl

mkbBa¢ak;faBitCaeQμaHrbs;exov sMpn enaHKWKμaneT Etelak

26 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

hSaes<I e):A

Page 29: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

mindwgfamannrNaepSgEdlmaneQμaH Ehm eRkABIexov

sMpn enaHeT.

IV¦ svnakarsþIBIkarsþab;skçIkmμrbs;sakSI

esA sarun

enAéf¶TI5 Exmifuna qñaM2012 naeBlresolbnÞab;

BIbBa©b;svnakarsYredjedal sakSI sKwm lμút GgÁCMnMuCRmH

visamBaØkñúgtulakarkm<úCa)anbnþsvnakarrbs;xøÜnenAkñúg

dMNak;kalTImYysþIGMBIrcnasm<½n§rdæ)al nigRbB½n§TMnak;TMng

kargarenAkñúgdMNak;kalTImYy. sakSIfμIenHmanrh½snam

CTW-604 EdlmaneQμaHfa esA sarun b:uEnþenAGMLúgqñaM

1974-75 elakFøab;)aneRbIeQμaH nU sarun. bc©úb,nñ

sakSImanGayuRbEhl80qña M n ig kMB ugrs;enAPUmifñl;Ekg

XMup¥av RsúkRtBaMgR)asaT extþ]tþrmanC½y.«Bukrbs;elak

eQμaH esA nU nigmþayeQμaH eRTn r:g. elakmanRbBn§eQμaH

nU mWut ehA yn; nigmankUn 10nak; KWRbus 5nak; nigRsI5nak;;

b:uEnþsøab;Gs; 4nak;.

1¦ karsYredjedalsakSIedaytMNagsh

RBHraCGaCJa

1>1¦ karsYredjedaledaytMNagsh

RBHraCGaCJaCati

sMNYrdMbUgrbs;elakRBHraCGaCJaCati)ansYrbBa¢a

k;BIB½t’manpÞal;xøÜnxøH²rbs;sakSI. cUldl;karsYrnaMGMBI

eQμaHeRbIkñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFietyüeTAkan;sakSI elak

tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa)andak;ÉksarEdlbBa¢ak;fa sakSI

maneRbIeQμaH éb enAkñúgrbbenaH.

eqøIytbnwgsMNYrrbs;tMNagshRBHraCGaCJaCati

sakSI)anCRmabCUnGgÁCMnMuCRmHfa xøÜn)aneFVIRbvtþirUbCUnRbFan

tMbn;eQμaH LaMg. elakshRBHraCGaCJaesñIdak;bBa©aMg

ÉksarEdlniyayfa elakcUlbdivtþtamry³eQμaH Ekt

nigbun ehIy]eTÞsnamedaybun nigLaMg. eBlenaHsakSI)an

TTYlsÁal;faRtwmRtÚv.sakSI)anerobrab;faxøÜn)aneronsURt

tictYcGMBImaK’abkS nigmaK’abdivtþ EdlFøab;)anTTYlkar

Gb;rMGMBImaK’abkScMnYn10dg nigvKÁxøI²CaeRcIndg b:uEnþelak

mincaMfaGñkNaCaGñkGb;rMeT RKan;EtdwgfamanGñkcUlrYm

RbEhl10nak;.

kk¦¦ ttYYnnaaTTIImmuunnqqññaaMM 11997755

tYnaTIrbs;sakSIenAmunqñaM1975 KWeFVICaGñkENnaM

RbCaCn[yl;BIbdivtþ karksagesdækic© karvaycRkBtþi

Gaemrik kareFVIERscmáar nigkardaMdMNaM edIm,IpÁt;pÁg;karhUbcuk

[)anRKb;RKan; edayeKarBtamkarENnaMBIfñak;elI. cMENk

eKaledAbdivtþenAeBlenaH elakdwgRtwmfa KWkareTAvaycRk

BtþiGaemrikb:ueNÑaH. qøgtamkardak;bgðajÉksarsakSI

)anTTYlsÁal;fa elakFøab;eFVICaGnuelxaPUmi RKb;RKgQøb

nigCMTb;G-4. kñúgtYnaTICaQøbPUmi elakeFVICaGñkkarBar

PUmikMu[manecarlYc ecarbøn;CaedIm.enAqñaM1971 elak

esAsarun RtÚv)anEtgtaMgCaelxaRsukeBRCada edayelxa

tMbn;105 EdltMbn;enH Gacniyay)an faCatMbn;ÉkraCü.

tMbn;mNÐlKIrI RtUv)anExμrRkhmrMedaHtaMgBIqñaM1970 eBl

enaHtYnaTIrbs;elakKWedaHRsayCIvPaBCUnRbCaCn RbEhl

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 27

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

sakSI esA sarun

Page 30: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

2000 eTA3000nak; kMu[karhUbcukmanPaBxVHxat.

smaCikenARsukeBRCcinþa manRbEhl 30 nak; Edlman

tYnaTIerog²xøÜn tamXMuTaMg4 dUcCa XMuRkaMgetH XMub‘URsa

XMueTasVay nigXMuekAEkø. kñúgXMunImYy² manelxaXMu ehIy

elxaXM um YycMn YnRtÚv)anEtgta MgedayelxaRsuk.

sakSIeFVICaelxaRsuktaMgBIqñaM1971 dl;1978. elak

)anCRmabfatMbn;105man5RsukKWRsúkekaHEjkRsúkc,ar

RsukeBRCcinþa RsúkGUrraMg nigRsukEkvsIm:a. elaktMNag

shRBHraCGaCJa )anbnþdak;Éksarsþab;cemøIysakSICa

mYyecARkmesIubGegát EdlenAkñúgÉksarerobrab;BI

eQμaHelxaRsukTaMg5xagelI ehIysakSIk¾)anTTYlsÁal;kar

elIkeLIgenaHCakarRtwmRtÚv. eqøIytbnwgsMNYrsakSI)an

CRmabCUnGgÁCMnMuCRmHfaxøÜnsÁal;elak haM GnsIu EdlCab¥Ún

rbs; LaMg edaysarrs;enAPUmiCitKñataMgBItUc b:uEnþelakmin

dwgfamantYnaTICaGVIenaHeT.

kñúgqñaM1975 elaksarun Føab;eFVICaGñkTTYlxusRtÚv

kargarsgÁmkic©enAkñúgRsúkcMnYnBIrCitKñaKW RsukeBRCcinþa

nigRsúkGUrraMg. sakSI)anCRmabCUnGgÁCMnMuCRmH fafñaMeBTü

eRbIenA TIenHRtÚv)anbBa¢ÚnmkBIPñMeBj EtelakmindwgfaGñk

NaCaGñkRbKl;eT eRBaHxagtMbn;CaGñkRbKl;mk. elakk¾

)anbBa¢ak;eTotfa CaTUeTAenAxagmNÐlKirI bBaðasuxPaBman

dUcCa CMgW Kúncaj; CMgWrebg nigCMgWepSg²eTot.

enAcenøaHqñaM1963-75 sakSImin)ancUlrYmRbCMuCa

mYyemdwknaMbkSeT. elakFøab;)anRbCMuCamYytaFuc nig

taLag EdlniyayGMBIkarvaycRkBtþiGaemrik skþiPUmi

nignayTun. sakSI)aneqøIyfaelakmin)aneXIj b:ul Bt

nig eGogsarI eT.enAeBleRkaymkelak)ancUlrYmRbCMuenA

extþkMBg;FM EdlmanGñkcUlrYmCaeRcIn b:uEnþelakminsÁal;

GñkTaMgenaHeLIy. elaktMNagshRBHraCGaCJa)anGan

esckþIsRmg;Edlniyayfa karRbCMuenaHmanGñkcUlrYm

RbCMuFM KW Fuc nig b:ul Bt bnÞab;mksakSI)anTTYlsÁal;favaCa

karRtwmRtÚv b:uEnþenAeBlenaHelakmindwgfa b:ul Bt manmuxgar

CaGVIeT. elaksarun )anbnþeTotfa enAkñúgkarRbCMuEdlman

ry³eBl10éf¶enH b:ul Bt CaGñk]eTÞsnam[vaycRkBtþi

Gaemrik b:uEnþsakSImindwgeTfasRtÚvrbs;bkSCamRnþI nig

Tah‘anénrbbln;Nul eLIy.

enAéf¶bnÞab;elak esg b‘unXag )ancab;epþImeday

karsYrnaMGMBIkarcUlrYmenAkñúgkic© RbCMuenAextþkMBg;FM kñúgqñaM

1972. sakSI)aneqøIyfaxøÜnmin)ancUlrYmenAkñúgkic©RbCMu

enaHeT. elakshRBHraCGaCJa)andak;bgðajÉksarEdl

niyayBIkarRbCMuenAkMBg;FM. Pøam²sakSI)anTTYlsÁal;cMeBaH

karcUlrYmenAkñúgkarRbCMuenaHvij nigEfmTaMg)anrMB£kfa

karRbCMuKWeFVIeLIg CamYy nYn Ca Edr b:uEnþxøÜneTIbEtsÁal; nYn Ca

enAeBlenaHb:ueNÑaH edaysarkar]eTÞsnam ehIyk¾mindwg

fa nYn Ca enAeBlenaHmannaTICaGVIEdr. karRbCMuenAkMBg;FM

kñúgqñaM1971KWdUcKñanwgkarRbCMuenAqñaM1972 Edr Edlman

ry³eBlRbEhl10éf¶. eBlenaHelak)an eXIj b:ul Bt

Etmñak;b:ueNÑaHCaGñkpþl;bT]eTÞsnam. edaysarcemøIy

EbbenH elaktMNagshRBHraCGaCJaCati esg b‘unXag

)andak;bgðajÉksarEdlsakSI)anpþl;bTsmÖasn_CUn

shecARkmesIubGegátedayniyayfa{enAkñúgkic©RbCMuenaH

KWmanEt nYn Ca mñak;b:ueNÑaHEdlCaGñkpþl;]eTÞsnam}. eqøIy

tbnwgkarelIkeLIgenH sakSIEbrCaTTYlsÁal;faKWCakar

RtwmRtÚv.

elak sarun )anGHGagfaxøÜnminFøab;)anB£BImnÞIr

b-20 eT ehIyeBlenaHelakk¾ minsÁal; exov sMpn Edr

b:uEnþ elaksÁal; exov sMpn enAeRkayeBlrMedaHPñMeBjrYc.

sakSI)anCRmabCUnGgÁCMnMuCRmHfa enAmNÐlKirIshkrN_RtÚv

)anbegáItenAGMLúgqñaM1977. BIqñaM1973-75 minman

RbCaCnCemøósmkenAekaHEjkeTluHdl;qñaM 1976-77

eTIbmankarpøas;RbCaCnmkbgárbegáInpleFVIERscmáarenA

ekaHEjk.sakSI)anbnþeTotfaBIqñaM1971-75karhUbcuk

rbs;RbCaCnKWdac;BIKña b:uEnþenAqñaM1976-77 eTIbhUbrYm

Kñavij.munqñaM1975manbegáItCaRkúmsamKÁI Rbvas;édKñaeFVI

28 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 31: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

ERscmáaredaymanbBa¢aBItMbn;.

xx¦¦ rrccnnaassmm<<½½nn§§ffññaakk;;CCaattii nniiggrrccnnaassmm<<½½nn§§TTMMnnaakk;;TTMMnngg

eqøIytbnwgsMNYredaytMNagshRBHraCGaCJa

elak esA sarun )anbBa¢ak;fa elakmin)ansegáteXIj

muxgarrbs;xøÜnmankarpøas;bþÚreTehIykaryl;dwgGMBIlnþik³

bkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCaKW)andwgtamry³karcUlrYmRbCMu. kñúg

tYnaTICaelxaRsukeBRCcinþa elakraykarN_ mktMbn;GMBIkar

daMduHERscmáarminsUvjwkjab;eT KWmYyb¤BIrs)þah_mþgb:ueNÑaH.

elaktMNagshRBHraCGaCaJ)anbnþsMNYrfa cMeBaHGMNackñúg

tYnaTICaelxaRsúk etIelakmansiT§smøab;mnusSeT? sakSI

)aneqøIyfa Gt;maneT. CaTUeTA elak sarun Føab;)ancUlrYm

RbCMuenAtMbn;tamry³karGeBa¢Ijkñúgry³eBlmYy b¤BIrExmþg

enAÉmnÞIrtMbn;. enAkñúgkarRbCMumanmnusSCaeRcIn KWmkBI

RKb;Rsuk ehIyCaTUeTAeKelIkGMBIbBaðaRKb;RKgRbCaCn

edaHRsaykEnøg sñak;enA nigeFVIy:agNa[RbCaCnputBI

PaBRkIRk nigraykarN_eTAfñak;elIGMBIsßanPaBRbCaCn

R)ab;eTAtMbn;. enAeBlbeRmIkargarCaelxaRsukenAkñúg

rbbExμrRkhm elak)anTTYlr)aykarN_BItamXMuCaerog

ral;ExGMBIkarbgárbegáInpl karerobcMpÞH nigsßanPaBTUeTA

enAkñúgXMu ehIyelakeFVIkarkñúgmYys)þah_EtmYyéf¶ b¤knøH

éf¶b:ueNÑaH.

elakRBHraCGaCJa)ansYrBImnÞIrk-11 ehIysakSI

)anbBa¢ak;famnÞIrenHmanGñkTTYlxusRtÚveQμaH suPa Edl

kan;tYnaTIxageyaFatMbn;. cMENkenAtMbn;105 manmnÞIr

BaNiC¢kmμ EdleQμaHmü:ageTotehAfamnÞIrk-16 TTYlxag

esdækic©tMbn; EdlmanTItaMgenACitmnÞIrtMbn;Edr. b:uEnþelak

mindwgfanrNaTTYlbnÞúkenAmnÞIrenHeT. sakSI)anCRmabfa

enARsúkminmanmnÞIr Gb;rMEkERbeT KWmanEtenAmnÞIrtMbn;b:ueNÑaH

EdlmnÞIrEkERbmanTItaMgsßitenACitmnIÞrtMbn;Edr.

KK¦¦ GGMMBBIIkkiicc©©RRbbCCMMuuvvKKÁÁGGbb;;rrMMnneeyyaa))aayy

enAkñúgbnÞb;svnakarsakSI esAsarun )anbMPøWfa kar

Gb;rMbkS nigneya)aybkS KW niyayGMBIkarbRgÜbbRgÜmKña

karBarTwkdI. enAeBleFIVCaelxaRsúkeBRCcinþa elakmin

EdlcUlrYmRbCMuvKÁneya)ayenATIRkúgPñMeBjeT KWRbCMuEtenA

kñúgtMbn;b:ueNÑaH. bnÞab;BIelaktMNagshRBHraCGaCJa

)andak;bgðajÉksarEdlniyayBIkarcUlrYmRbCMuBIrdgenA

burIkILa nigmþgeTotenAcenøaHburIkILa nigpøÚvshB½n§rusSIú Edl

mþg²KW12-13éf¶enaHsakSI)anyl;Rsb. elakcaMfaman

fñak;dwknaMmYycMnYn)ancUlrYm nigbiTvKÁ dUcCa b:ul Bt exov

sMpn eGogsarI nigeGog FIriT§.

XX¦¦ kkiicc©©RRbbCCMMuussVV½½yyttiieettoonn

enAextþmNÐlKirI karRbCMusV½yTieton minsUvjwkjab;

eT KWRbEhl6Exmþg ehIyebIRbCMuenARsukmanKN³RsukcUl

rYm. karRbCMuenHKWEcktamRkúm EdlCak;EsþgmanBI5eTA8

nak;kñúgmYyRkúm. karRbCMuEbbenHeFVIeLIgkñúgeKalbMNgkMu[

kmμaPi)alxUc nigBRgwg[mankarykcitþTukdak;CamYyRb

CaCn. manGñkxøH)anelIkeLIgeFVIsV½ytietonxøÜnÉg b:uEnþ

minman karnaMykeTAdak;Bin½yGVIeT.

1>2¦ karsYredjedaledaytMNagshRBH

raCGaCJaGnþrCati

elaktMNagshRBHraCGaCJa)anelIkeLIgGMBIkic©

smÖasn_bYnelIkEdlsakSIFøab;eFVICamYyecARkmesIubGegát.

b:uEnþkarbgðajenHRtÚv)ansakSIbdiesFfaxøÜnmincaMeT bnÞab;

BIkardak;bgðajÉksarenaH. eRkaymksakSI)anGHGagfa

xøÜn)aneqøIyy:agesμaHRtg;CUnelakecARkmesIuby:agGs;BI

citþ. elaktMNagshRBHraCGaCJa)ansYrfa etIman)an

GaneLIgvijnUvGVIEdlelakeqøIyenaHb¤eT? elaksarun )an

eqøIyfaecARkmesIubGegát)anGaneLIgvijCUnelaksþab;.

GgÁPaBKaMBarsakSI )anGanmþgeTot[elaksþab;munmk

pþl;skçIkmμenHpgEdr ehIyelakminmanGVIEkERbeT.

elaktMNagshRBHraCGaCJamankarcab;GarmμN_GMBI

mnÞIrk-16EdlCamnÞIresdækic© RbcaMtMbn;.mnÞIrenaHenACit

mnÞIrtMbn;RbEhl100Em:Rt. ebIeTaHbICaelakshRBHraC

GaCJaBüayamsYrsakSIGMBIÉksarTg;bdivtþk¾eday b:uEnþRtÚv)an

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 29

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 32: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

sakSIeqøIyfaxøÜnmincaMÉksarTaMgenaHeT. mankarbgðajÉk

sarnigGanCUnsakSI KWsarTUrelxEdleLgepJImkmnÞIr870.

enAkñúgcemøIytbrbs;xøÜn sakSI)anelIkeLIgfaelakmanvtþ

manenAmhasnñi)atmYyenAqñaM1975 Edlmanry³eBlbIéf¶

enATIRkúgPñMeBj. elakshRBHraCGaCJa)anbnþsMNYrGMBI

kareFVIdMeNIrmkPñMeBj edIm,IcUlrYmenAkñúgmhasnñi)atEx ]sPa

qñaM1975.enAkñúgdMeNIr EdlmanKñabInak; sakSI)anmkTIRkúg

PñMeBjtamry³LanBImNÐlKirImkRkecH ehIyCiHkaNUtBI

RkecHmkPñMeBj. elaksakSIdMbUg)aneqøIyfaxøÜnmksñak;

enAPñMeBjry³eBlbIéf¶mYyyb; ehIyk¾Rtlb;eTAvij.b:uEnþ

enAeBlEdltMNagshRBHraCGaCJaGanskçIkmμEdlsakSI

)aneFVIenAcMeBaHmuxecARkmesIubGegátfa enAeBlenaH)anmk

sñak;enAPñMeBjry³eBl10éf¶enaHsakSIk¾)aneqøIyfa {Cakar

RtwmRtÚvehIyKWman10éf¶b:uNÑwgeT}.sakSI)anbnþeTotfa

karmkcUlrYmRbCMuenaHmantMNagTaMgGs;mkBIPUmiPaKnImYy²

nigtMNagmkBIxagGgÁPaBeyaFadUcCamkBIxagkgBlCaedIm

EtelakminsÁal;GñkTaMgenaHeT. eqøIytbnwgsMNYrrbs;

shRBHraCGaCJa sakSI)anbBa¢ak;faGñkniyayenAkñúgGgÁ

RbCMuelakeXIjman b:ul Bt nignYn Ca EdlmankalviPaKRbCMu

kñúgmYyéf¶KW eBlRBwkBIem:ag7-11 nigeBlresolcab;

BIem:ag2dl;em:ag5eTIbsRmakhUb)ay.enAkñúgkarRbCMuelIk

enHsakSI)aneXIjmanvtþmanrbs;b:ul Bt nig nYn Ca CaGñkeFVI

bT]eTÞsnameBjmYyéf¶. eKalbMNgRbCMuKW niyayGMBIkar

ksagRbeTsCati[rIkcMerIn dwknaMRbCaCn[bgábegáInpl man

)ayhUb niglMenAsßanRKb;RKan;. elak eDllIsak; )ansYr

sakSIGMBIGVIEdl nYn Ca nig b:ul Bt )anGb;rMenAkñúgGgÁRbCMu

edayepþateTAelIbBaðaneya)ay karerobcMshkrN_

karhammin[cayluy karbiTTIpSarnigvtþGaram ehIyfa

GñkTaMgBIr)anelIkeLIgEdrfa éf¶eRkaynwgebIk[manvij. enA

Rtg;cMNucenH sakSI)anyl;RBmfa KWBitCamanniyayBI

bBaðaenHEmn.esckþIlm¥itGMBIkarRbCMubiTTIpSa enaHKW b:ulBt

)anCRmabdl;GgÁRbCMufa R)ak;nwgRtÚvebIk[cayvijcMENk

karCemøósRbCaCnvij KWnwgRtÚvbBa¢Ún[mkrs;enAkñúgTIRkúg

vij. elIsBI enHsakSI)anpþl;skçIkmμCUnGgÁCMnMuCRmHfa

elak)anB£karelIkeLIgBIkareFVITMnb;RbLaytamry³ b:ul Bt

EdlbBa¢a[GñkenAtamtMbn;erobcMEpnkar nigKeRmageFVI

TMnb;RbLay edaytRmÚv[mankarÉkPaBKñaenAkñúgtMbn;eTIb

GacelIkEpnkarenaH)an.

kk¦¦ kkaarrRRbbCCMMuubbiiTTvvttþþGGaarraamm

karRbCMuEdlniyayGMBIkarbiTvtþGarammanry³eB

lbIéf¶. elaktMNagshRBHraCGaCJa)ansYrfa etIkmμa

Pi)alenAkñúgkic©RbCMuman[BYkeKeTAbiTvtþGaramenAtMbn;ero

g²xøÜnEdrb¤eT?

sakSI)aneqøIyfaGt;eT. elaktMNagshRBHraC

GaCJa)anbnþsMNYreTotfa enATIenaHCnCatiPaKticmanCMenO

elIkarEsneRBnCasMxan; nigkarkan;sasnaRBHBuT§. etICn

CatiPaKticRtÚv)aneKhamXat;min[EsneT? sakSI)an

bBa¢ak;Rtg;cMNucenHfa eKminhameTRKan;Etmin[kab;eKa

RkbIFM² KWGnuBaØat[kab;eKaRkbItUc²eRBaHxøacGs;stV

sRmab;CYyeFVIERsehIykar ENnaMenaHKWGñkRKb;RKgenAtam

Rsuk nigXMu CaGñkENnaM. tamkarbBa¢ak;rbs;sakSI karksag

vtþGaramenAmNÐlKirI )ancab;epþImenAqñaM1963. rhUtmk

dl;éf¶TI17 Exemsa qñaM1975 KWmanvtþcMnYnenAextþmNÐl

30 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

karbMpøajvtþGaram ¬RbPBÉksar³mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa¦

Page 33: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

KirI.sakSI)anbnþeTotfa CakarBitminmannrNabiTvtþ Garam

enAmNÐlKirIeTenAeRkayqñaM1975 KWmankarrt;x©at;x©ayBI

vtþTaMgenaHedaysarEtGaemrikmkTmøak;RKab;Ebk. enA

eRkayéf¶TI17ExemsaqñaM1975minmanRBHsgÇNaKg;enA

kñúgvtþeToteT taMgBIGaemrikTmøak;RKab;EbkenAGMLúgqñaM

1970-1975 eRBaHkarTmøak;enaHeRcInNas; KWtaMgBI

RBwkdl;l¶ac.

sakSIniyayfa b:ul Bt pþl;eyabl;[begáItsh

krN_kRmitTabEdlmanlkçN³tUc² eRBaHedIm,IsRmÜldl;

karhUbcuk[manPaBgayRsÜl. Tak;TgnwgPaBxusKñaénRkúm

shkrN_Tab nigRkúmsamKÁI elak sarun )anpþl;PaBc,as ;

las;fa shkrN_KWhUbcukrYmKña ÉRkúmsamKÁIenaHKWhUbenA

pÞHerogxøÜn ehIykarENnaM KWeFVIBItMbn;mkRsuk nigBIRsukmk

shkrN_.

xx¦¦ kkaarreerroobbGGaaBBaahh__BBiiBBaahh__

enAcMeBaHmuxGgÁCMnMuCRmHsakSI esAsarun )anerob

rab;fa EpnkarkarerobkarenA kñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü KW

bkSmankarerobkareRcInKUk¾)antick¾)an b:uEnþluHRtaEt«Buk

mþayrbs;samIuxøÜnÉkPaBeTIbGaceFVI)an. GñkerobkarKWGñk

Rslaj;Kña ehIymunnwgerobkarRtÚvmankarsYrbBa¢ak;CafμIrvag

samIuxøÜnmþgeTot. bþIRbBn§minGacerobkaredayKμankaryl;

RBmBIGgÁkar)aneT. sakSI)anCRmabfakñúgeBlelakeFVI

CaGnuelxaenARsukeBRCcinþa elak)an erobcMBIFIerobkar)an

EtmþgKt;.

bnÞab;BI taLaMg )ansøab;enAkñúgqñaM1978 elakesA

sarun )aneFVIkarCMnYs taLaMg edaymankarEtgtaMgBImha

snñi)at b:uEnþelakeFVIkargarCMnYsenaH)anEt2Exb:ueNÑaH

k¾manT½BevotNamcUlmkrMedaH. elak sarun caM)anfa bnÞab;

BItaLaMg )ansøab; elak)ancUlrYmenAkñúgGgÁRbCMuCamYy

b:ulBtnigsun esnnigGñkepSgeTot eBlenaHfñak;dwknaMTaMgBIr

enH)an[elakeFVIkarCMnYs taLaMg ehIyelakk¾)aneFVIkar

bdiesF. eTaHbICaelakBüayam RcanecalmuxgarenH eday

elIkeLIgBIGsmtßPaBrbs;elak Edlminyl;dwgy:agNa

k¾eday b:ul Bt CRmuj[elakeFVIkargarenAmnÞIr920

dEdl.eBlenaH b:ul Bt)anR)ab; elakfa {[EtmitþÉgeFVI

kargarxagkgBl920enaH KWman tasan CYykargarkñúg

tMbn;}. edaysarminh‘anRbEkk elaksarun RtÚv)anEtgtaMg

eFVIkargarCMnYs taLaMg GñkEdlEtgtaMgenAeBlenaHKW b:ul

Bt b:uEnþsakSIxøÜnÉgmindwgfaGñkNa)ane)aHeqñatEtgtaMg

elakenaHeT. sakSI)anbBa¢ak;faenAeBlEdlelakecjBI

RsukeBRCcinþa BIqñaM1971-74 ehIyeQμaH m:aLa

)aneFVIkarCaRbFanCMnYs.

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 31

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

BiFIerobGaBah_BiBah_ RbPBÉksar³ mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa¦

Page 34: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

KK¦¦ bbuuKKÁÁllEEddllFFøøaabb;;ssÁÁaall;;

Tak;TgnwgeQμaHmYycMnYnEdlelaktMNagshRBH

raCGaCJa)anelIkykmksYrsakSI mandUcCa tasan sVay

nigQin. sakSI)anpþl;cemøIyfa tasan CaGñkTTYlkargar

CaemkgBlenAmNÐlKirI kñúgExtula qñaM1978. eQμaH

sVay CaelxaRsukekaHEjk ehIyeQμaHenH)an)aj;

smøab;bgéførbs;sakSIcMnYn2nak; KWeQμaH KI nig daM ¬CasmaCik

Rsuk eBRC cinþa¦. ÉeQμaH Qin elaksakSImin sÁal;eT.

cMENkbuKÁlmYycMnYneTotsakSI)anpþl;cemøIyfa elakRKan;

EtdwgfaRbFan mnÞIrk-16eQμaH nYn b:uEnþelakmin)andwgBI

mUlehtuEdleQμaHenH rt;ecjBImnÞIrenaHeT. cMeBaHbuKÁl

eQμaH xaMPYn nigkUnmñak;eQμaH xaM sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa elak

sÁal;eQμaHTaMgBIrenaH EtelakmindwgfaxaMPYnRtÚv)ancab;

xøÜnenAqñaM1977eT.

eqøIytbnwgsMNYrrbs;elaktMNagshRBHraC

GaCJasakSI)aneqøIyfa bu:l Bt)anRbCuM elIkBIkarTb;Tl;Ca

mYyevotNam. ehIycMeBaHkarRbCMuenAmNÐlKirImankar

ehAeyaFatMbn; KN³RsukmkRbCuMEdr. PøamenaHshRBH

raCGaCJa)an esñIsuMdkRsg;nigbgðajÉksarTak;TgnwgbT

smÖasn_rbs;buKÁleQμaHGansIu. elaksakSIeqøIytbfa

BitEmnKWeFVItamfñak;elI ehIyGñkEdl[tamrkxμaMgbgáb;KW

bu:l Bt. shRBHraCGaCJa)anGanGtßbTdkRsg; RBmTaMg

)ansYrTak;TgnwgTUrelx55.sakSIeqøIyfa TUrelxenaHBitCa

)ancUlév:enAmnÞIrkgBlenaHEmn. bBa¢IcmøgCUnenaHKWGñkepSg

CaGñksresrCUn bu:l Bt ehIykarbBa¢ÚnÉksareTA bu:l Bt

RtÚvEtbBa¢ÚnCab;rhUt Edlcab;epþImeFVIEbbenHeRkayeBl

taLaMgsøab;. karRbCuMTak;TgnwgkarbBa¢ÚnsarTUrelxenaH

sakSImincaMfaRbCuMtUcb¤FMeT EtmancMnYneRcIndg b:uEnþxøÜn)an

eTAcUlrYmkñúgkarRbCuMenaHEtmþgKt; KWenAEx9qñaM1978

ehIyeRkaymkevotNamk¾cUlmkdl;.

RBHraCGaCJa)ansYrTak;TgnwgkarmkPñMeBjenAEx

kBaØa qñaM1978 EdlmanGñkcUlrYmmkBI RKb;extþ. enAkñúg

smaCbkSenaHeKniyayTak;TgnwgkardwknaMRbCaBlrdæ

edaHRsayerOgkarhUbcuk nigpÞHsMEbg[RbCaBlrdæ

b:uEnþcMeBaHkarebIkpSarvijxøÜnminEdlB¤eT. RBHraCGaCJa

)anesñIdak;bgðajÉksarbTsmÖÖÖÖasn_Tak;TgnwgkarRbCuMGMBI

karebIk[manTIpSarvij Edl bu:l Bt CaKN³GFibtI.

elaksakSIfaeqøIyfaBitCamanEmn b:uEnþPøam² elakmin

caMfaemdwknaMNamYy)ancUlrYmenaHeT Tal;EtKN³cat;taMg

ehAeQμaHeTIbelak)andwg. eBlenaH nYn Ca CaGñkeFVIbT

]eTÞsnam[kmμaPi)alEdlcUlrYmdwknaM nigedaHRsaybBaðaCUn

RbCaCn[)anl¥ ehIyeBlenaHminmankareFVIbT]eTÞsnam

eday exovsMpn nig eGogsarI eT.sakSI)ancaMfa enAeBl

bu:l Bt RbkasBIkarebIkpSar nigcayluyenaH minmanGñk

NabeBa©jRbtikmμGIVeLIy ehIyRKan;EtcaMeTotfasnñi)at

enaHmanry³eBl10éf¶ ehIymincaMfamanTItaMgenAkEnøg

NaeT. enAkñúgsnñi)atEdlerobcMtusRmab;[GñkcUlrYm

edayGgÁúyenAtamextþnImYy²enaH GñkcUlrYmmandUcCatMNag

mkBIRKb;extþ tMNagBIxageyaFa nigKN³mCÄimpg. RBHraC

GaCJa)anGanÉksarsmÖÖ Ö Öasn_bnþTak;TgnwgkarRbCuM MKN³

mCÄimnig emdwknaMExμrRkhmEdlkñúgenaHman exov sMpn

nigeGog sarI CasmaCikKN³mCÄim. sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa

RtwmRtÚv b:uEnþcMeBaHtam:uk xøÜnminsÁal;buKÁlenHeT.

XX¦¦ cceemmøøIIyyssaarrPPaaBB

sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa bnÞab;BImhasnñi)atenAExkBaØa

qñaM1978 EdlGgÁkar)anEtgtaMgelakEtmñak;ÉgenaH

GgÁkar)an[elakeFVIcemøIysarPaB eBlenaHelakRtÚv)an

b:ul Bt [GancemøIysarPaB.sakSIbnþfaxøÜnCamnusSsøÚt

Rtg; dUecñHecHEteqøIytamGIVEdleK[Gan. sakSI)an

elIkeLIgGMBIcemøIysarPaBmYy EdleKepJImk[enAkEnøgeFVI

snñi)atenaH xøÜn mindwgfacemøIyEdleKepJImkenaHmanRbPB

mkBIRbPBNaeT Etelakmankarxwgsm,arNas;enAeBl

cemøIyenaHecHEteqøIydak;bnÞúkmkelak edayelakmin)an

eFVIGIVesaH. cemøIysarPaBenaH sakSIfamincaMBaküeBcn_

32 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 35: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

xøwmsarenaHeLIy.

enAkñúgcemøIyrbs; GnsuI )an[dwgfa bu:l Bt )an

Rbkasfa min[cab;cgRbCaCneT eTaHbIkgBl k¾minman

siT§Edr ehIykarXat;xøÜnb¤cab;RbCaCnTal;EtmankarGnuBaØat

BIxagKN³mCÄim.

2¦ karsYredjedaledayemFavItMNagedIm

bNþwgrdæb,evNI

elakRbFan)anepÞrevTikaCUnemFavItMNagedImb

Nþwgrdæb,evNI edIm,IsYredjedalsakSIbnþ. elakRsI

emFavI TI RsúInNa )ancab;epþImsMNYrTak;TgnwgRBwtþikarN_BI

qñaM1970 dl;1975 edayepþateTAelIGñkbegáItbkS

km<úCaRbCaFibetyü b:uEnþsakSI)aneqøIytbfa elakmin

yl;GMBIbBaðaenHeT. sakSI)anCRmabCUnGgÁCMnMuCRmHfa

karbgárbegáInplenAeBl enaHKWedaHRsaybBaðaRbCaCn

[manpÞHsñak;enA nigman)ayhUb. enAeBlenaHCIvPaB

RbCaCnenAkñúgextþTaMgmUl KWmansPaBsmrmü TTYl)ankar

hUbcukRKb;RKan; ehIysßanPaBénkEnøgsñak;enAnaeBlenaH

KWpÞHeFVIBIb£sSI nigRbk;søwk. pÞHenaHKWRbCaCnCaGñksagsg;

edayxøÜnÉg cMENkelakRKan;EtENnaMbu:eNÑaH. sakSIk¾

)anCRmabeTotfa enAeBlxøÜnkan;kab;Rsúk eBRCcinþa elak

)aneTARsúkekaHEjkmYyExmþgedIm,IRbCu MeBlNaEdl

taLaMg elxatMbn; 105 ehAelakeTARbCMuenAPñMeRkal

EdleKehAmnÞIrk-17kñúgRsukekaHEjk.

sakSI)anCRmabCUnGgÁCMnMuCRmHfa enAeBlelak

kan;kab;enARsúkeBRCcinþa minman mnusSfμIecjcUlkñúgRsúkeT

manEtGñkRsúkenaHbu:eNÑaH. emFavIsYrTak;TgnwgelxatMbn;

nigRbFantMbn;. sakSIeqøIytbfaRbFan nigelxaKWdUcEtKña

eT. enAeBleFVICaRbFantMbn;enaH xøÜneTAeFVIenAkEnøgcas;

ehIyminmanÉksarNabnSl;TukenaHeLIy.

emFavI)anbnþsMNYrGMBIImnÞIrtMbn; m-17 sakSIfa

xøÜnminsUvyl;BImnÞIrmYyenaHeT. enAeBltaLaMg kan;GMNac

enAtMbn;105 manmnÞIr4dUcCamnÞIrk-17 CakEnøgeFVIkar

rbs;tMbn; ¬mancm¶ayRbEhl100Em:RtBImnÞIrsnþisuxPñM

eRkal¦/ k-11/ k-16nigmYyeTotxag BaNiC¢kmμtMbn;.

sakSI)anbnþfasmasPaBGñkdwknaM KWxøÜnmin)andwgeT ehIy

cMeBaHkarRKb;RKgmansmaCikNaxøHk¾min)andwgEdr. Tak;Tg

nwgmnÞIrsnþisuxPñMeRkal sakSI)aneqøIyenAkñúgcemøIyPaKeRcIn

rbs;elak KWbgðajBIPaBminsUvRCabc,as;GMBImnÞIrmYyenH

dUcCa famancMnYnmnusSbu:nμannak;enACab;XuM b¤k¾mindwgBI RbePT

mnusSEdlCab;XMuenAkñúgmnÞIrsnþisuxenaH. elakRsIemFavI)an

esñIsuMdl;elakRbFanGgÁCMnM uCRmH edIm,IbgðajÉksar

smÖasn_rbs;sakSI nigecARkmesIubTak;TgnwgkaredaHElg

mnusSBImnÞIrXuMXaMgeBlEdlsakSIenACaelxaRsúk. mnÞIr

snþisuxtMbn;manTItaMgenACitmnÞIrtMbn;EdlRKb;RKgeday

tasuPa. cMENkmnÞIrsnþisuxtMbn; nigmnÞIrsnþisuxPñMeRkal

KWdac;BIKña. sakSI)anelIkeLIgfa xøÜnFøab; )anedaHElgmnusS

CaeRcIn EtelakmincaMcMnYnbu:nμannak;eT edayRKan;Etdwgfa

xøÜnFøab;edaHElg)anBIrdg. enAeBledaHElgGñkeTascas;²

elakminmankarsuMeyabl;BImCÄimeT edaysarxøÜnmansiT§i

seRmc nigedaysarGñkeTasenaHmanCemøaHtictYcTak;Tg

nwgerOgRKÜsarbþIRbBn§bu:eNÑaH. dUecñHbnÞab;BIelakedaHElg

eTIbraykarN_eTAfñak;elI. cMENkGñkk,t;bdivtþn_ KWmin

EdlmaneT ehIyfaetIkñúgeBl taLaMg kMBugkan;kab;enaH

elakmindwgfamanCnk,t;bdivtþn_ b¤Gt;Edr sUm,IEteBleTA

RbCuMenAPñMeBjk¾minmankarGb;rMGMBICnk,t;bdivtþn_enaHeLIy

.

cMeBaHkarTMnak;TMngenAtMbn;105 KWmanEtRbFan

tMbn;eTEdlGaceFVITMnak;TMngCamYyKN³Gcié®nþy_. cMENk

kardksmaCikmanEt bu:l Bt eTEdlmansiT§idk. cMeBaH

BiFIerobkarvij elak sarun )anGHGagenAcMeBaHmuxGgÁCMnMu

CRmHfa xøÜnKμansiT§ ibgMçnrNamñak;[erobkarenaHeLIy.

elakRsIemFavI RsIúnNa)anbnþsMNYrTak;TgnwgeyaFatMbn;

105 ehIysakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa mankMlaMgeyaFaEtmYy

RbePT KWeyaFatMbn;ehIymaneyaFamCÄimmYykgBl

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 33

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 36: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

eTAQreCIgenATIenaHehIyTMnak;TMngKñaCamYyeyaFatMbn;

edaysareyaFatMbn;CaGñkdwgGMBITItaMgPUmisaRsþ b:uEnþkar

raykarN_vijKWeFVIeLIgepSg²Kña.

eqøIytbnwgsMNYrrbs;emFavI sakSI)aneqøIyBak;

B½n§nwgsnñi)atEdlelak)ancUlrYmCamYyb:ul Btfa enAeBl

enaH b:ul Bt )anRbkasmin[mankarcab;cgmnusSdac;xat

cMENkenAtamtMbn;epSg²sakSImin)anRCabeT. sakSIFøab;

)anCECkCamYyCnCab;ecaT exov sMpn GMBIbBaðaesdækic©

EdlenAeBlenaH exov sMpn )anniyayBIsßanPaBénkar

daMduH nigkarhUbcukrbs;RbCaCn EtminmanelIkBIEpnkar

bYnqñaMenaHeT. esckþIENnaMrbs;bkS nigkarpSBVpSayenA

fñak;mUldæanEtgEtykmkGnuvtþtamCanic©.

elakRsIemFavI)anbnþsYrTak;TgnwgbBaðafñaMeBTüenA

tMbn; EdlsakSIkan;kab;enArbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü.

sakSI esA sarun )anbBa¢ak;fafñaMeBTüRtÚv)anpþl;mkRKb;RKan;

nigmaneBTütamCMnajeTotpg. PøamenaHemFavI)anesñIsuM[

mankarbgðajÉksarrbs;edImbNþwgrdæb,evNImñak;Edl

bgðajBIsßanPaBrbs;«BukEdlQW ehIyGgÁkarminGnuBaØat

[mnusSQWTTYlGahar. sakSIfaxøÜnminEdlB¤famanmnusS

QW nigsøab;edayGt;GahareT. emFavI)anbnþdkRsg; nig

bBa¢aMgÉksarrbs;edImbNþwgrdæb,evNIfa enAqñaM1975

man®sþIGayu20qñaM manRKÜsarehIymankUnx©IEtmYyGaTitü

eK[eTAeFVIkarvij. dUcenHKat;minmankMlaMgeBleFVIkar

k¾sRmakenAelIPøWERs. sakSI)anbBa¢ak;faxøÜnminyl;BI

bBaðaenHeT.

elak sun GruN emFavIkarBarkþI nYn Ca )aneFVIkar

CMTas;fa emFavItMNagedIm bNþwgrdæb,evNIminKYryksMNYr

cemøIyrbs;PaKIepSgmksYrsakSIenaHeT. elakemFavI

xaNav:askarBarkþI eGogsarI k¾)anCMTas;EdrfaemFavIminGac

ykcemøIyrbs;sakSIepSgmkecaTsYreT ehIycemøIyenaHmin

EmnsYrnaMenAcMeBaHmuxecARkmesIubGegátenaHeLIy dUcenHmin

GacykmksYr)aneT. elakRsIemFavItMNagedImbNþwg

rdæb,evNI)aneqøIytb faxøÜnmankarPJak;ep¥IlenAeBlman

karCMTas; edayelIkeLIgfaKat;mansiT§ibgðajEtÉksar

EdlCarbs;sakSI. shRBHraCGaCJa)aneRbIskçIkmμrbs;

mnusSCaeRcInRbePT ehIyxagemFavIkarBarkþIk¾eFVIdUecñHEdr.

mü:ageTot cemøIyEdlxøÜnykmk eRbIenHKWCarbs;edImbNþwg

rdæb,evNIEdlvamansarsMxan;Nas;eTaHbIminmankars,f

k¾eday. elak EDllIsak; )anGHGagfacMeBaHBt’manEdl

elIkeLIgedayedImbNþwgrdæb,evNIKWGacykCakar)an

ehIy karN_EdledImbNþwgrdæb,evNImanpþitRmamédenAelI

cemøIyrbs;xøÜnenaH KWCaTRmg;énkareFVI sm,fehIy. elak

xaNav:as )aneqøIytbfa {B½t’manrbs;edImbNþwgrdæb,

evNIminEmnpþl;edaysm,fenaHeT. cemøIyrbs;sakSIKWCa

cemøIyEdlpþl;edayecARkmesIubGegátmansm,feday

manév:Rta b:uEnþcemøIyrbs;edImbNþwgrdæb,evNIminman

sm,feT cMENkÉksarEdleRbIedIm,IsYrpúÞjtamCMhr rbs;

eyIgKWRtÚvmaneKalkarN_c,as;las;sRmab;GnuvtþTaMgGs;

Kña. dUecñHcemøIyrbs;edImbNþwgKWCaB½t’manbMeBjbEnßm

bu:eNÑaH ehIyelakminCMTas;eTcMeBaHkarnaMykedImbNþwg

enaHmkpþl;skçIkmμ}. elak EvkEKn emFavIkarBarkþICnCab;

ecaT exovsMpn)anbBa¢ak;CUnGgÁCMnMuCRmHfa edImbNþwgrdæb,

evNIenHminmaneQμaHenAkñúgbBa¢IEdlnwgRtÚvmkbgðajxøÜn

enAkñúgsvnakarenaHeT. b:uEnþedaysarbBaðaenHmanlkçN³

sμúksμajenAeBleRkaymkGgÁCMnMuCRmH)anseRmcGnuBaØat

[PaKIelIkykskçIkmμrbs;buKÁlTIbImksYredjedalsakSI

34 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

emFavI ém:eXIl xaNav:as EDl lIsak;

Page 37: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

)ankñúgkrNINaEdlbuKÁlenaHminmanlT§PaBmkpþl;skçI

kmμenAkñúgbnÞb;svnakar)an.

elakRsIemFavI)anbgðajÉksarEdlCaxøwmsar

enAkñ úgesckþ IEføgkarN_mYybBa¢ak;GMBIkardwkmnusSeTA

smøab;enAPñMeRkal.sakSI)aneqøIytbfaxøÜnmindwg minB¤ nig

mineXIjmanRBwtþkarN_TaMgenHeTenAkñúgGMLúgqñaM1975.

emFavIesñIbgðajÉksarBakSsuMtaMgxøÜnCaedImbNþwgrdæb,

evNITak;TgnwgmnÞIrPñMeRkalEdlmanxøwmsarsþIGMBIkarcab;xøÜn

mnusS. sakSIenAEtniyayfaxøÜnmineXIj mindwg minB¤.

emFavIGanÉksarrbs;edImbNþwgrdæb,evNITak;Tgnwgkar

erobGaBah_BiBah_edaybgMç EtsakSIniyayfaminmankar

bgçMenaHeT. sakSIbBa¢ak;fa enAqñaM1975xøÜnenARsúkenA

eLIy ehIykarerobGaBah_BiBah_edaybgçMenaHk¾minmanEdr.

bnÞab;BIemFavItMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNI)anbBa©b;

sMNYrrbs;xøÜn elakecARkm hSg;m:ak LaEv:j )aneFVIkar

taMgsMNYreTAkan;sakSI. dMbUgelakecARkm)ancab;epþImsYr[

sakSIbBa¢ak;GMBIeQμaHBitR)akdedIm,IkuM[mankarP½nþRcLM.

sakSI)anbBaa¢k;faxøÜnmaneQμaH esA sarun. elakecARkm

)ansYrTak;TgnwgbuKÁlmYycMnYnedaycab;epþImBIeQμaH taLaMg

muneK. elakecARkm)anelIkeLIgBIsmþIrbs;elak sarun

muneBlelaksarun eFVICaRbFantMbn;105 edIm,ItaMgsMNYr.

elak sarun )anbBa¢ak;fa taLaMgKWCaRbFantMbn;105

ehIybnÞab;BI taLaMg søab; KWxøÜn)anTTYlbnÞúkenAtMbn; 105

EdlRtÚv)anEtgtaMgenAeBlRbCuMExkBaØa qñaM1978.

elakecARkm)ansYrTak;TgnwgeQμaH qan nig haM bu:EnþsakSI

)aneqøIyfaxøÜnmindwgB½t’manGMBIGñkTaMgenaHeT. elakecARkm

)anrMB£keQμaHmYycMnYneToteTAsakSI b:uEnþsakSImin)ancgcaM

enaHeT. elak sarun )anCRmabCUnGgÁCMnMuCRmHfaxøÜnmin

)andwgGMBIkarkat;eTas b:ul Bt eLIy. eRkaymkelak

ecARkm)anGanGMBIsarTUrelxmYycMnYnEdlepJI eTAmnÞIr920

EdlmankarcmøgCUneTAeQμaHbuKÁlmYycMnYndUcCa bg nYn

nigb:g; CaedIm sakSI)anTTYlsÁal;faxøÜnFøab;ep¶ITUrelxenaH

Emn. elakecARkm)ansYrBak;B½n§nwgrcnasm<½n§eyaFa

920 faetIGñkNaCaRbFankgBlmuneBlsan kan;tMENg

enH? sakSI)aneqøIytbfaelakmindwgBIbBaðaenHeTeday

sarkargarrbs;xøÜnenARsúk minEmnkgBl.sakSI)anbnþ fa

san CaRbFankgBl b:uEnþ)ansøab;ehIy. eqøIytbnwgsMNYr

rbs;elakecARkm sakSI)anCRmabfa xøÜnminsÁal;eQμaH

Em:n em:g ehAQin eQμaH eGoCW ehAsUyb¤esameT. ecARkm

sYrBITMnak;TMngrvag Ej:msan EdlcUlrYmkat;eTasbu:l Bt

nig san faCamnusSEtmYyb¤y:agNa? EtsakSIfamindwgeT.

sakSIfaxøÜnminEdldwgBIkarkat;eTas bu:l Bt eT. elak

ecARkmsYrsakSIman)anRbCuMCamYysanEdreT? sakSIfaman

bu:EnþminmanbBa¢Icab;xøÜnenaHeT. cMeBaHmnÞIrsnþisuxenAtMbn;

105suPa CaRbFansnþisux etImanGnu eQμaH evog ehA xan;

EdreT? {Gt;eT}sakSIeqøIy.

elakecARkmsYrGMBITMnak;TMngeQμaH esA cMBI ehA

muaMg. sakSI)aneqøIyfa esA cMBI mannaTICasmaCikenAkñúg

vr³rbs; taevog nigCab¥Únrbs;elakehIyeBlenaHelak

manTMnak;TMngCabgb¥ÚnFmμtab:ueNÑaH. sakSI)anTTYlsÁal;

karelIkeLIgrbs;elakecARkmLaEv:j Edl)anGanÉksar

sþIGMBIkarRbCuMCamYy taLaMg sþIBIkarkarBarRBMEdn TwkdI kuM[

evotNamcUlmk. tamry³cemøIyrbs;sakSI)anCRmabfa

taeLg CaGñkkan;KukmkBImNÐlKirI ehIyKukenaHenApÞal;dI

EdlmanGñkeTasesøókBak;Fmμta nigminmanCab;Rcv:ak;eT.

ecARkmGanÉksar TUrelx55 EdlcmøgCUn G‘Mv:an;/G‘Mvn/ nYn Ca

nigmnÞIrÉksar. sakSI)anCRmabvijfa )ansresrEmn

Etminmandak;eQμaHeT manEteQμaH bu:l Bt b:ueNÑaH.

3¦ karsYredjedalsakSIedayRkúmemFavI

karBarkþI

3>1¦ karsYredjedaledayRkúmemFavIkar

BarkþI nYn Ca

elakemFavIGnþrCati hSaes<I ):av )ancab;epþImsYr

sMNYrTak;TgnwgkarTmøak;RKab;Ebkrbs;Gaemrik. sakSI)an

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 35

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 38: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

bBa¢ak;fa CakarBitelak)aneXIjmankarTmøak;RKab;Ebk

edayGaemrikenAGMLúgqñaM1970dl;75 edayeRbIRKab;Ebk

eb52eTotpg.karTmøak;RKab;EbkenHeFVIeLIgmkelIpÞHsMEbg

RbCaCn ehIyenAtamRBMEdnvij KWTmøak;mkelIcMkark¾manEdr

minEtb:ueNÑaHenAtamPUmixøHenAsl;mnusSEtBIrb¤bInak;eT

cMENkRKYsarrbs;sakSIvij KWsøab;Gs;smaCik11nak;.

sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fakarsøab;KWmaneRcInCagGñkrbYs cMENk

saksBVRtÚv)aneKykeTAkb;Edr. emFavIbnþsYrfaetIkar

CemøósenaHeFVIeLIgedaysareKcRKab;Ebk b¤edaysarmUl

ehtuepSg? sakSI)aneqøIyfa minmankarCemøóseT KWenA

eBlmanTmøak;RKab;EbkRbCaCnnaMKñart;ecjBIpÞHsEm,g

nigPUmisßanEtmþg. tamkarcgcaMrbs;elak sarun )an

bBa¢ak;fakarTmøak;RKab;EbkenHmanTaMgyb;TaMgéf¶ ehIymk

mþg² KWman]T§mÖÖaKcRkbIeRKÓg. elakcaMfa manvtþman

TahanGaemrikEdrenAxagRsukEkvsIm:a sßitenARBMRbTl;

extþRkecH. emFavIbnþsYrepþatelImUlehtuénkaTmøak;RKab;

EbkenAextþmNÐlKirI b: uEnþRtÚv)anelaktMNagshRBH

raCGaCJa EDllIsak; eFVIkarCMTas;edaysarsMNYrenH KWsYr

BIeyabl;rbs;sakSI. elakemFavI hSaes<I ):av )anbþÚrviFI

sa®sþrbs;xøÜnedaykardak;bgðajÉksarkMNt;ehturbs;

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa EdlniyayBIkarsMGatxμaMgenA

extþmNÐlKirIkñúgqñaM1970. elakRbFan)anrMB£kdl;emFavI

edIm,IbBa¢ak;GMBIÉksarEdlbgðaj favamanPaBBak;B½n§nwg

Éksar3enAcMeBaHmuxGgÁCMnuMCRmH. Pøam² tMNagsh

RBHraCGaCJak¾)aneRkakQredIm,IbBa¢ak;CUnGgÁCMnMuCRmHfa

ÉksarenaH)aneRbICaÉksar]bsm<½n§ dUecñHxøÜnminmankar

CMTas;eLIy.

elakemFavI)anGanÉksarEdlniyayGMBIkarTmøak;

RKab;EbkenAmNÐlKirI. elakemFavI)ansYrfaetIelak )an

dwgBIsMeNIEdlln; nl; esñI[GaemrikmkTmøak;RKab;EbkenA

mNÐlKirIb¤eT?sakSI)anbBa¢ak;faxøÜnmindwgBIbBaðaenHeT

KWRKan;EteXIjmankarTmøak;RKab;Ebkb:ueNÑaH. sakSI)an

bBa¢ak;fakarTmøak;enaHenAtamPUmicas;kan;EtTmøak;xøaMgeLIg.

sakSI)an bnþfaxøÜnminEdlB¤eKniyayBImUlehtuénkarTmøak;

RKab;EbkenaHeT.bnÞab;mkelakemFavI)anbþÚrRbFanbT eday

sYrTak;TgnwgkarRbCuMenATIRkúgPñMeBjRbEhl10éf¶ eRkay

rMedaHPñMeBjqñaM1975. GñkEdl]eTÞsnamenAkñúgGgÁRbCuM

enaHKWmanEt bu:l Btmñak;b:ueNÑaH. karRbCuM enaHekIteLIgbnÞab;

BIkarsøab;rbs;LaMg nig xaM PYn.sakSI )anbBa¢ak;faxøÜnBitCa

)aneTAcUlrYmRbCuMenAeBlenaHEmn ehIyGñkEdlcUlrYmenaH

maneRcInnak; KWRbCuMsnñi)atqñaM1978. sakSI)anbnþfa

elaksÁal;emdwknaMEdl)ancUlrYmenAkñúgmhasnñi)atenaH

enAeBlEdlGñk TaMgenaHRtÚv)aneKGeBa¢Ij[eLIgelIevTika

bu:eNÑaH EdlmandUcCa bu:l Bt/ nYn Ca nig eGogsarI.sakSI

)anbnþfaxøÜnTTYlsarTUrelxBImCÄimenaHKWBI bu:l Bt. emFavI

)ansYr bBa¢ak;faetIsakSImankarlak;elomBItYnaTIrbs;xøÜnenA

kñúgsm½ykm<úCaRbCaFibetyüEdrb¤eT? sakSIfaxøÜnminman

GVIlak;elomenaHeT. emFavI)anbgðajÉksarEdldk

Rsg;BImCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCasþIBIkare)assMGatExμrRkhm

enAmNÐlKirIsarCafμImþgeTot Edlmanxøwmsarfa {>>>bnÞab;BI

elak sarun eLIgCaelxatMbn;enaHmankarsmøab;rgÁalman

karcab;xøÜnRbCaCn>>}. sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fakarelIkeLIgenH

minEmnCakarBiteT GñkEdleqøIyEbbenHKWmYlbgáac;elak

bu:eNÑaH elakminEdlcab;RbCaCnykeTAsmøab;eT elak

sUmbdiesFkarelIkeLIgenH. elakemFavI)anelIkeLIg

BIGtßbTrbs;elak sÞIv ehD½r EdlniyayBIelxaRsúk Ca

tYnaTIsMxan;kñúgkarsmøab;enaH. sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa xøÜnmin

yl;RsbenaHeTedaysarkarRKb;RKgenAkñúgRsukrbs;xøÜn

nigenARsúkepSgKWmanlkçN³xusKña. sakSI)anbnþfataMgBI

xø Ünmkkan;GMNacBIrExenaHminEdlmankarcab; b¤smøab;

RbCaCneLIy.

emFavIesñIsuMeRbIÉksarskçIkmμsakSI TCW-307

edIm,IsaksYrelIsakSI esAsarun.enAkñúgkarelIkykskçIkmμ

sakSIepSgmksYrenH elakRbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmH)ansYrbBa¢ak;

36 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 39: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

eTAemFavIfaetIÉksarenHmanenAkñúgsMNMuerOgkþI002ehIy

b¤enA?elakemFavI)aneqøIytbfa ÉksarenHmanenAkñúgbNþMú

Éksar KWenAkñúgRbB½n§pÞúkÉksarrYm b:uEnþelakmindwgfava

sßitenAkñúgbBa¢IÉksarEdldak;edayPaKIb¤Gt;eT. GgÁCMnMu

CRmH)aneFVIkarrMB£kdl;RkúmemFavIkarBarkþI nYn Ca [bBa¢ak;

CUnGgÁCMnMuCRmHenAeBldak;bgðaj KWRtÚvbBa¢ak;BIbBa¢IÉksar

NamYyrbs;PaKINamYy cMENkemFavItMNagedImbNþwg

rdæb,evNIk¾minmankarCMTas;Edr. elakRbFank¾)anGnuBaØat

[emFavIkarBarkþIeRbIR)as;ÉksarkñúgkMritmYyedIm,IsYr

edjedalsakSI ehIyelakRbFank¾)anbBa¢ak;dl;emFavI

[mankarFanakuM[mankarbeBa©jB½t’mansm¶at; EdlGac

b:HBal;dl;sakSI dUcCakarbeBa©jeQμaHCaedIm. emFavI)an

bBa¢ak;faxøÜnnwgminbeBa¢jB½t’manelIeGRkg;eT edayRKan;Et

Ganbu:eNÑaH. emFavI)ansYrBIkarcab;mnusSmYyRKÜsar

ykeTAsmøab;. sakSI)anbdiesFfaminEdlmankarcab;xøÜn

mnusSTaMgRKÜsarykeTAsmøab;enaHeT. emFavI)anbnþ sMNYr

faenAeBlEdlsakSIRKb;RKgenAtMbn;5KWedaymankarecaT

Rbkan;faecHmnþGaKmn_. sakSIfaminEdlmankarcab;xøÜn

edaysarkarecHeRbImnþGaKmn_enaHeT. elakRbFan)an

saksYremFavI Tak;TgnwgGtßbTrbs; sÞIv ehD½r EdlemFavI

elIkeLIg bu:EnþemFavI)anbBa¢ak;faxøÜnmindwg faÉksarenaHman

enAkñúgsMNuMerOgEdrb¤Gt;enaHeT. tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa

)anbBa¢ak;fa kardkRsg;mYyEpñkénÉksarenaHBitCaman

enAkñúgsMNuMerOg. elakRbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmHecARkm nil Nun

)anrMB£kdl;RkúmemFavI nYn Ca kñúgkarbBa¢ak;elxÉksarEdl

xøÜnelIkeLIgmkbBa¢ak;enaH[emFavIbBa¢ak;fa ÉksarenaH

)andak;enAkñúgbBa¢INamYyénÉksarEdlesñIsMuenAcMeBaHmux

GgÁCMnMuCRmH nigbgðajBIGtþsBaØaNrbs;ÉksarCabIPasa

pg. elakRbFan)anbBa¢ak;pgEdrfa ÉksarEdlPaKITaMg

Lay)andak;enAkñúg{GIunFWehVs} minmann½yfa ÉksarenaH

CMnYy[mankarGnuvtþenAviFan 87¬4¦eT. viFan87¬4¦ KW

enAEtman témøCac,ab;sþIBInItiviFIénkaresñIsMudak;ÉksarenA

cMeBaHmuxGgÁCMnMuCRmH. cMENkÉÉksardak;enAkñúgGIunFWehVs

sRmab;PaKITTYlB½t’man)anmuneBledjedalenH RKan;Et

karCYysRmÜlB½t’manedIm,IeRtómlkçN³Camun)anBinitü

emIlÉksarBak;B½n§CamunedIm,IeBlcUlmkedjedal KWman

el,Ón nigmanRbsiT§PaBb:ueNÑaH. ÉksarTaMgGs;RtÚvEtGnuvtþ

RtwmRtÚvtamnItiviFIenAkñúgviFan87¬4¦nigP¢ab;nigviFan87¬3¦

GMBIlkçN³Bak;B½n§énPsþútag.

elakemFavI)anbnþkarsYrTak;Tgnwgkic©RbCuMEdl

sakSI)ancUlrYmenATIRkúgPñMeBjeRkaykarsøab;rbs; LaMg

ehIysakSI)anpþl;cemøIyCamYyshRBHraCGaCJafamin)an

CYb bu:l Bt enaHeT. tMNagshRBHraCGaCJabBa¢ak;fa

kardkRsg;rbs;emFavIKWRKan;EtCakardkRsg;mYyEpñkbu:eNÑaH

dUecñHcMNucxøHmanPaBxusKña. elakRbFanminGnuBaØat[sakSI

eqøIy edaysarsMNYrRcMEdl.

3>2¦ karsYredjedaledayRkúmemFavIkarBar

kþI exovsMpn

emFavI GakTY EvkEKn )ansYrsakSITak;TgnwgsarTUr

elxTI1Edlep¶IeTAmnÞI870 faetICUneTAnrNa? sakSI)an

bBa¢ak;fasarTUrelxBIelxTImYydl;elxTI4 KWep¶ICUn bu:l Bt.

emFavI)ansYrsakSIeTotfaetIehtuGIV)anCasakSIepJIÉksar

eTA bu:l Bt? elaksarun )anbBa¢ak;faedaysar bu:l Bt

KWCaem dUecñHxøÜnRtÚvEtraykarN_CUnfñak; elIEbbenHehIy.

emFavI)anGanBIkarsmÖasn_rbs;sakSICamYyecARkmesIub

GegátEdlbBa¢ak;fasakSI)anCYbBiPakSaKñaCamYy exov sMpn

GMBIbBaðaesdækic©. sakSIbBa¢ak;faxøÜn)anCYbCnCab;ecaT

exov sMpn mþg ehIysMeNHsMNalBIkardaMduHEtbu:eNÑaH

ehIyxøÜnmin Edl)anCUnbBa¢Iesdækic©dl; exovsMpn enaHeT.

sakSI)anbEnßmfa enAeBlxøÜnpþl;cemøIyCUnshecARkmesIub

GegátenaHmankarxusxøH²edaysarkalenaHxøÜnmanCMgW nig

man karePøc PøaMgeRcIn.

KYrkt;smÁal;faRkúmemFavIkarBarkþ ICnCab;ecaT

eGogsarI minmansMNYreTAkan;sakSI esAsarun eT dUecñHbnÞab;

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 37

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 40: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

BIRkúmemFavIkarBarkþICnCab;ecaT exov sMpn )ansYrcb;sBV

RKb; elakRbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmH)anRbkasbiTsvnakarsRmab;

éf¶TI 12 Exmifuna qñaM2012 Etmþg.

V¦ svnakarsþIBIkarsþab;skçIkmμrbs;sakSI xwm gn

enAresoléf¶TI7 Exmifuna qñaM2012 GgÁCMnuMCRmH

visamBaØkñúgtulakarkm<úCa)anbnþkic©dMeNIrkarnItiviFIrbs;xøÜn

edayeFVIkarsaksYrsakSI xwm gn Edlmanrh½snam TCW -

323. kic©dMeNIrkarenH)ancab;epþImbnÞab;BImankarp¥akkic©

dMeNIr karsaksYrsakSI esA sarun edaysarbBaðasuxPaB.

muneBlcab;epÒIm elakemFavI eBC GgÁ CaemFavInaMmuxtMNag

edImbNþwgrdæb,evNI)anCRmabCUnGgÁCMnMufa xøÜnnwgepÞrkarsYr

sakSICUn elakemFavI eLa CunFI nig elak )aNaeb.

1¦ RbvtþisavtarsakSI xwm gn

kic©dMeNIrkar)ancab;epÒImedayelakRbFanGgÁCMnuM

CRmHsaksYrB½t’manTak;TgnwgRbvtþisvtarbs;sakSI.sakSI

)anbBa¢ak;faxøÜnmaneQμaH xwmgnGayu57qñaM manRsúkkMeNIt

enARsúkburIClsarextþtaEkv Rbkbrbrlk;nMetñat rt;m:UtUDub

nigeFVIERs ehIyxøÜnmin)aneron sURteRcIneTRtwmfñak;TIdb;

BICMnan;munEtbu:eNÑaH. sakSI)anbEnßmfaxøÜnman«BukeQμaH

Duk Giut mþay eQμaH Ca rin ehIyxøÜnmankUn10nak;. elak

RbFan)aneFVIkarENnaMsakSIGMBIsiTi§ nigkrNI kic©rbs;sakSI

enAkñúgkarpþl;skçIkmμ nigeFVIkarrMB£kdl;PaKIkñúgkarerobcM

sMNYr[)anl¥gayRsÜl[sakSIyl;;. bnÞab;mkelakRbFan

)anepÞrevTikaCUnshRBHraCGaCJaedIm,IsaksYrbnÒ.

2¦ karsYredjedaledayshRBHraCGaCJa

elakshRBHraCGaCJargCati can; tararsμI )ancab;

epÒImsYrBIRbvtiÒxøH²rbs;sakSIenAmunqñaM1975.eqøIytbnwg

sMNYrenH sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa xøÜnRbkbrbrCaksikrnigrt;m:UtU

Dub enARsúkekaHGENþt. sakSI)anbEnßmeTotfaxøÜn)ancUl

rYmclnabdivtþþCamYymitþPkÒitaMgBIGayuRbEhl16qñaMeFVICa

TahanenAkñúgPUmi ehIyeRkaymkxøÜnRtÚv)anbBa¢ÚneTAeFVIT½B

RsúkBIreTAbIEx eTIbRtLb;eTAeFVICaRbFanRkúm nigeFVInirsarenA

PUmiXuMnigRsúk.enAeBlrMedaH)anextÒtaEkv enAqñaM1975xøÜn

nigT½BR)aMnak;eTotRtÚv)anbBa¢ÚneTAPñMeBjedaysñak;enAsßan

TUtcin nigeronenAsalabec©keTssUevotry³eBlmYy

s)þah_ ehIyeRkaymkxøÜnRtÚv)anbBa¢Ún eTAeFVIkarenARksYgkar

breTsCaGñkbMerIePJóv. shRBHraCGaCJa)anbnþsMNYrTak;

TgnwgkarcUleFVIkgT½BmunqñaM1975. elak gn )anbBa¢ak;fa

xøÜncUlbMerIkgT½BedaysareKehA[cUleFVI ehIyeBlenaHxøÜn

k¾dwgfaGVICabdivdþ b¤ExμrRkhmenaHeT. shRBHraCGaCJarg

)anbnþ sMNYrTak;TgnwgkarbMBak;bMb:neya)ayenAmunqñaM

1975. sakSI)anbBa¢ak;faxøÜn)anTTYlkarbMBak;bMb:n

neya)ayEdlkalenaHman qUy CaGñkehAeTARbCuM ehIy

xøwmsarenAeBlRbCuMkalenaHKWeKGb;rMmin[hUb)ayb¤ePsC¢³

Edlsl;BIePJóv. eRkABIenaHeTotxøÜnminFøab;)ancUlRbCuMCa

mYyemdwknaMFMeLIyedaysarGñkEdlcUlrYm)anKWTahanEdl

enAkñúgsm<½n§yuvkkEdlCakMlaMgsñÚlEtbu:eNÑaH. elaksh

RBHraCGaCJa)an bnþsMNYrTak;TgnwgkarsresrRbvtÒirUb.

elak gn )anbBa¢ak;fa xøÜn)aneFVIRbvtiþrUbmYyéf¶bIdg ehIyxøÜn

mankar)armÖcMeBaHsac;jatixøÜnEdredaysarxøÜnmanCab;ExS

RsLayk,t; bu:EnÒeRkaymkelak)andwgfabgb¥ÚnKat;RtÚv)an

eKykeTAsmøab;. sakSI)anbnþeTotfaenAmunqñaM1975 xøÜn

38 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

sakSI xwm gn

Page 41: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

minEmnCasmaCikenAkñúgbkSsm<½n§yuvCneT KWRKan;EtCayuT§Cn

bu:eNÑaH ehIyenAeBlenaHxøÜnk¾Føab;)anTTYlkarGb;rM[eKarB

tamvin½ybkS. elak gn )anrMB£kEdrfaenAeBleFVICanirsar

xøÜnRtÚv)an san nig esog R)ab;[rt;sMbuRt[Tan;eBlevla.

sakSI)anbnþfaxøÜnFøab;RtÚv)anykeTAksagenAeBlman

kMhus. enACMnan;enaHsakSI)anbBa¢ak;faxøÜnFøab;)anB¤Bakü

fakarts‘UvNѳ maKa’neya)ayrbs;bkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa

bu:EnÒxøÜnminyl;famann½yy:agem:cenaHeTTak;TgnwgkarrMedaH

extþtaEkv sakSI)anbBa¢ak;faxøÜnBitCa)anB¤ ehIyenAmunqñaM

1975 xøÜn)aneXIjmankarbBa¢ÚnRbCaCnmkeRkayenARsúk

ekaHGENþt bu:EnþxøÜnmindwgfaRbCaCnTaMgenaHRtÚv)anbBa¢ÚneTA

TINaeT. bnÞab;BIbBa©b;karsaksYrrbs;shRBHraCGaCJa

rgCati elakRbFan)anepÞrevTikaCUnelaktMNagshRBH

raCGaCJaGnþrCati vInsin dWv:al; edIm,IbnþkarsaksYredayelak

)anrMB£kdl;tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa[erobcMsMNYrEdlgay

RsÜl[sakSI)anyl;. elaktMNagshRBHraCGaCJa

)ancab;ep þ ImedaykarGanesckþ IdkRsg;bTsmÖasn_

EdleFVIeLIgedayshecARkmesIubGegát nigsakSITak;Tg

nwgkarrMedaHextÒtaEkvtaEkvEdlsakSI)aneXIj.sakSI)an

bBa¢ak;fa xøÜnBitCa)aneXIjBIkarrMedaHEdlenAeBlenaHxøÜn

)anB¤eKniyayfa ebIRbCaCnmankarrwgTTwgnwgRtÚveKyk

eTAsmøab;ecalbu:EnÒxøÜnmin)andwgfaCaGñkbBa¢aenaHeT. elak

RBHraCGaCJa)anbnþsMNYrTak;TgnwgkareronsURtenATIRkúg

PñMeBj.sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa xøÜnRtÚv)anbBa¢ÚnmkeronenAsala

bec©keTssUevot ehIyeKbBa¢ÚneTAenAtamsßanTUt pÞHelx7

CamYyePJóvcin EdlenATIenaH hug )anehAxøÜneTARbCuMR)ab;min[

niyayGVITak;TgnwgerOgneya)ay nigGb;rMBIkaredIrehIr hUbcuk

[)ansmrmüeBlenACamYyePJóv. sakSI)anbnþfa enAeBl

RbRBwtÒikMhusKWRtÚvbBa¢ÚnmkeRkayb¤pøas;kEnøgeFVIkargar ehIy

xøÜnk¾Føab;)anRbRBwtþkMhusmÒgEdrkñúgry³eBlmYyqñaMeFVIkar

enARksYgkarbreTs ehIyRtÚv)anbBa¢Ún[eTAdaMbEnøenAtaexμA

ry³eBlbI b¤bYnExeTIbRtlb;mkvij. sakSI)anbB¢aak;fa

kEnøgeFVIkargarenAtaexμAenaH KWsßitenAeRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;

RksYgkarbreTs ehIyGñkEdlRtÚvbBa¢ÚneTATIenaH KWmanmk

BItamCnbTxøHEdr. eqøIytbnwgsMNYrrbs;tMNagshRBHraC

GaCJaTak;TgnwgkareFVIRbvtþirUb elak gn)anbBa¢ak;fahug Edl

CaGñkRKb;RKgenApÞHelx7CaGñkbBa¢a[xøÜneFVIRbvtþirUbeBl

mkeFVIkarenARksYgkarbreTs. eqøIytbnwgsMNYrrbs;tMNag

shRBHraCGaCJa)ansYrTak;TgnwgkarRbCuMenApÞHelx7 sakSI

)anbBa¢ak;faxøÜnRtÚv)anGb;rMBIrebobrs;enACamYyePJóv ehIy

eRkABIkarRbCuMenApÞHelx7xøÜnminEdlcUlRbCuMenAkEnøgepSg

eTotenaHeT BIeRBaHeKlak;karN_sMgat; ehIymnÞIrEdlsMxan;

enARksYgkarbreTsKWmnÞIrb-1. enAkñúgRksYgkarbreTsman

GñkesIubkarN_sMgat; ehIyRbsinebInrNamñak;enAkñúgRkúm

RbRBwtþkMhus KWnwgRtÚvraykaN_eTAfñak;elI.

3¦ karsYredjedaledayemFavInaMmuxtMNag

edImbNþwgrdæb,evNI

bnÞab;BIbBa©b;karsaksYredaytMNagshRBHraCGaCJa

elakRbFan)anepÞrevTikaCUnemFavItMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,

evNI. elakemFavI eLaCunFI )ancab;epÒImedaykarsaksYr

Tak;TgnwglMenAsßanrbs;;sakSIenAmuneBlEbkqñaM1975.

sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa xøÜnrs;enAextþtaEkveFVICaQøb ehIyeRkay

mkeFVICaT½BenAkñúgPUmi. eRkayeBlEbkRkúgtaEkvxøÜn )aneTA

enAPñMeBj ehIyTTYl)ankareronsURtnigeFVIkarenARksYg

karbreTs. elakemFavI)anbnþsMNYrTak;TgnwgkarecaTRb

kan;BIbTxussIlFm’ ehIysakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa xøÜnRtÚv)an

ePOg CaGnuRbFanmnÞIr TietonfaxussIlFm’edaysar)an

CECkelgCamYynarI² ehIyelakRtÚv)andkecjBIkargar

ry³eBlbIEx. elakemFavI)anbnþsMNYrTak;Tgnwgkare)as

sm¥atsmaCikRKÜsarrbs;sakSI. CakareqøIytb elak gn

)anbBa¢ak;fa xøÜn)anTTYldMNwgBIbgb¥ÚnCIdUnmYyfaRbBn§rbs;

xøÜnRtÚv)ansmøab; ehIyxøÜnRtÚv)anbBa¢ÚneTAtaexμA edaysarEt

sac;jatirbs;xøÜnRtÚv)aneKsmøab;. PaømenaH elakemFavIkar

BarkþICnCab;ecaT eGog sarI )aneRkakQrehIyCMTas;fa

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 39

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 42: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

sMNYrEdlemFavIkMBugsYrenaH suT§EtRtÚv)ansaksYreday

shRBHraCGaCJarYceTAehIy bu:EnþelakemFavI)anbBa¢ak;fa

xøÜn)anelIkyksMNYrEdlshRBHraCGaCJaminTan;)ansYr

Etbu:eNÑaH. Tak;TgnwgbBaðaenH elakRbFanGgÁCMnuMCRmH

)anrMB£kdl;emFavI[sYrsMNYrEdlTak;TgnwgGgÁehtuenA

kñúgdIkadMeNaHRsay. bnÞab;mkelakemFavI)anbBa©b;kar

saksYrrbs;xøÜn elakRbFan)anepÞrevTikaCUnemFavI )aNaeb

eday)anrMB£ksarCafμI[emFavIerobcMsNYrc,as;² ehIy

Tak;TgnwgGgÁehtu. elakemFavI)ancab;epþImedaysYrsMNYr

Tak;Tgnwg®sþIeQμaH FI Edl)anniyayR)ab;sakSIGMBIkar

e)assm¥atenARksYgkarbreTs. sakSI)anbBa¢ak;faxøÜn

BitCa)ansÁal;eQμaH FI ehIy)anrs;enACamYyKña bu:EnþxøÜnmin

)anyl;BIkare)assMGatenARksYgkarbreTsenaHeT.

elakemFavI)anbnþsMnYredayGanÉksarsmÖasn_EdleFVIeLIg

edayshecARkmesIubGegát nigsakSITak;Tgnwgkarcab;xøÜn

mnusSenAmnÞIrb-1sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa FI Føab;R)ab;xøÜnBIkar

pøas;kEnøgbu:EnÒxøÜnmanmincgcaMeRcIneT.

4¦ karsYredjedaledayRkúmemFavIkarBarkþI

nYn Ca

elakemFavI epsþemn)ancab;epÒImsMNYrTak;TgnwgÉk

sarbTsMPasn_rbs;buKÁlikmCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCakal

BIqñaM2004 bu:EnþsakSImankarPan;RclMedayeqøIyBIkarrs;

enArbs;xøÜnkalBIsm½yExμrRkhmeTAvij. emFavI)anbgðaj

ÉksaredIm,IrMB£kdl;karcgcaMrbs;sakSI bu:EnÒelakRbFan)an

sYrbBa¢ak;[emFavIbgðajÉksaredIm,IbBa¢ak;fa ÉksarenaH

RtÚv)andak;enAcMeBaHmuxGgÁCRmHRsbtamviFan87¬3¦.

elak epsÒEmn )anbBa¢ak;fa ÉksarenaHRtÚv)andak;enAkñúg

RbB½n§kuMBüÚT½rrbs;tulakarkalBIqñaM2011 ehIyÉksarenH

RBHraCGaCJak¾manrYcehIyEdr. elakemFavI)anbnþeday

karGanbTsmÖasn_Tak;TgnwgkarRbCuMCan;x<s;Edlman bu:l

Bt/ eGogsarI/sun esn/tam:uk/ nYn Ca nigsemþch‘un Esn.

Tak;TgnwgbBaðaenHsakSI)anbdiesFfa xøÜnminEdldwgBIbT

smÖasn_enaHeLIy. emFavI)an bnþsMNYrfaetIsakSI)andwg

fa hu‘n Esn )ancUlrYmRbCuMEdreT.elakRbFan)anrMB£kdl;

emFavImin[sYrsMNYrEdlTak;TgnwgkMrgsMNYrTaMgenaHeT.

elakemFavI)anbnþkarsYrTak;TgnwgkarP½yxøacrbs;sakSI

kñúgkareqøIyTak;Tgnwg h‘un Esn. elakRbFan)anbgÁab;

min[sakSIeqøIyedaysarsMNYrminBak;B½n§ehIysakSI)an

bdiesFrYceTAehIy. elakemFavIenAEt TTUcsuMelakRbFan

[sakSIeqøIyEtelakRbFanenAEtminGnuBaØt ehIyemFavI)an

bBa©b;karsYrrbs;xøÜn.

bnÞab;BIbBa©b;sMNYrrbs;RkúmemFavIrbs; nYn Ca elak

RbFan)anpþl;evTikaCUnelak emFavI eGog sarI bu:Enþelak

emFavIminmansMNYreTAkan;sakSIeT cMENkRkúmemFavIrbs;

CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn k¾minmansMNYrEdr. dUecñHkarsYrsakSI

xwm gn RtÚv)anbBa©b;. sRmab;eBlenH GgÁCMnMuCRmHbnþsþab;

skçI kmμrbs;elak eGOn tan.

VI¦ svnakarsþIBIkarpþl;skçIkmμrbs;sakSI eGOn tan

bnÞab;BIkarsþab;skçIkmμrbs;sakSIXwmgn)anbBa©b;

éf¶TI11 Exmifuna qñaM2012 enAéf¶TI 13 Exmifuna qñaM2012

GgÁCMnMuCRmHsaladMbUgénGgÁCMnMuCRmHvisamBaØkñúgtulakar

km<úCabnþsþab;skçIkmμrbs;sakSI eGOn tan GtItnirsar nig

kgkarBarrbs; b:ul Bt.svnakarRbRBwtþeTAcMnYnBIréf¶ man

RbCaCnkm<úCaRbmaN400nak;mkBIextþkNþal nigsVayerog

c Ulr Yms þ ab ; ed ayp Þ al ;t amry³karGeBa ¢ Ijrbs ;

m®nþIkic©karsaFarN³rbs; tulakar.

edaysakSIKWCanirsar nigkgkarBarrbs; b:ulBt enA

kñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü PaKI)anepþatsMxan;GMBIsmasPaB

GñkcUlrYm nigkmμvtßúEdlRtÚv)anykmkBiPakSaenAkñúgkic©RbCMu

FM²mYycMnYnEdlRtÚv)anerobcMeLIgenAmnÞIrk-1/ CaBiessGMBI

tYnaTIrbs;sakSIkñúgkarbBa¢ÚnÉksarBIfñak;eRkameTA b:ul Bt

nigBI b:ul Bt eTAemdwknaMepSg²eTot nigkarCUndMeNIremdwknaM

TaMgenHcuHeTAeFVITsSnkic©enAtammUldæanCaedIm. eRkABIenH

mansMNYrmYycMnYneTotTak;TgnwgRbvtþisavtar nigeKalbMNg

40 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 43: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

rbs;sakSIkñúgkarcUlrYmclnabdivtþ nigPar³kic©rbs;sakSIkñúg

GMLúgeBlrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü. karsYrenHRbRBwtþeTA

tamlMdab; edaycab;epþImBItMNagshRBHraCGaCJa Rkúm

emFavItMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNI nigemFavIkarBarkþIrbs;

CnCab;ecaTTaMgbIRkúm.

1¦ Rbvtþisavtarrbs;sakSI

elak eGOntan ehACU tan ekItkñúgqñaM1943CaCn

Catikarck;. TIlMenAbc©úb,nñ PUmiT®nþwk XMutasaj RsuksMLÚt

RbkbmuxrbreFVI cMkar ecHGan nigsresrGkSrExμrtictYc.

«BukeQμaH lUg nigmþayeQμaH lwm. elak eGOn tan mankUn

cMnYn3nak;.elak)ancUlrYmkñúgclnabdivtþenAcenøaHExkumÖ³

nig mIna qñaM1968 eRkamkarENnaM rbs; ép nig

TTYlsÁal;edaykgEdg. enA qñaM1968-1970 elakrs;

enAextþ rtn³KirI TTYlbnÞúkbBa¢ÚnsMbuRtBIRsuk GNþÚgmas

extþrtn³KirI ykeTA evInés nig extþmNÐlKIrI. rhUtmkdl;

qñaM1970 elak)anmkrs;enACamYy b:ul Bt enAextþ

kMBg;cam edayTTYlbnÞúkCaGñkrt;sMbuRt nigeFVICakgkar

BarsnþisuxsRmab; b:ul Bt nigemdwknaMepSg²eToteRkam

karcat;taMgrbs; b:g;. kñúgtYnaTIenH elakFøab;)ankar

Barkarkic©RbCMumYycMnYneFVIeLIgedayb:ulBt/ nYnCa/ exovsMpn

nigemdwknaMepSg²eTotenAkñúgextþkMBg;cam.elak eGOntan

bBa¢ak;y:agc,as;fa elak)anrs;enACab;CamYy b:ul Bt

cab;BIqñaM1970 rhUtdl;rbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü)andYl

rlMkñúgqñaM1979. elakrs;enAEbkBI b:ul Bt ry³eBl

RbEhlkenøHEx eday b:ul Bt eFVIdMeNIreTATIRkúgPñMeBjmun

ehIyelakRtÚvenAerobcMsmÖar³eRbIR)as;rbs;emdwkbkS

kumμúynIsþkm<úCa edayykeTAtameRkay. enABak;kNþal

Ex]sPa qñaM1975 elak)anmkrs;enA mnÞIrk-1CamYy

b:ul Bt Edlman TItaMgenACab;Tenø)asak; kñúgTIRkúgPñMeBj.

eBlenaHelak RtÚv)an b:g; cat;taMg[eFVICaRbFanRkúmkgkarBar

snþisuxEpñkxagkñúgenAmnÞIrk-1. kargarsMxan;bMputrbs;

elak KWkarBarsnþisuxsRmab;kic©RbCMuEdlRtÚv)anerobcMeLIg

enAmnÞIrk-1 nigkarbBa¢ÚnsMbuRt b¤sarTUrelx sRmab; b:ul

Bt. eRkABIenH elak eGOn tan mantYnaTIerobcMmðÚbGahar

semøókbMBak; nigkEnøgsñak;enAsRmab; b:ulBt.tamry³tYnaTI

TaMgenH elak eGOn tan )aneTAyksarTUrelx nigsMbuRtCa

eRcInenAmnÞIrk-7 ehIyRbKl;[ b:ul Bt nig nYn Ca.

CagenHeTAeTot Rkúmrbs;elakKWCaGñkerobcMnigkarBarral;

kic©RbCMurbs;emdwknaMCan;x<s;énbkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa Edl

RtÚv)anerobcMeLIgenAmnÞIrk-1.

2¦ karsYredjedaledaytMNagshRBHraCGaCJa

kñúgkarsYredjedalsakSI elak Evg h‘t; tMNag

shRBHraCGaCJaCati)anepþatsMxan;elIGgÁehtumunqñaM1975

eBalKWBak;B½n§nwgeKalbMNgrbs;elak eGOn tan kñúgkar

cUlrYmclnabdivtþ nigtYnaTIrbs;elak eGOn tan kñúgGMLúg

eBlenaH.cMENkelak farIk Gab;Dulhak; tMNagshRBHraC

GaCJaGnþrCati)anepþatsMxan;elIGgÁehtuEdlekIteLIgkñúg

rbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü CaBiessTak;Tgnwgkic©RbCMurbs;

fñak;dwknaMbkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCaenAmnÞIrk-1 nigkarbBa¢Ún

sMbuRtb¤sarTUrelxepSg²BImnÞIrk-7[b:ulBtnigBI b:ulBt

eTAemdwknaMepSg²eTot. KYrkt;smÁal;fa CaTUeTAtMNagsh

RBHraCGaCJa)anEbgEckKñakñúgkarsYrsakSI edaytMNag

shRBHraCGaCJCatiEtgEtepþatsMxan;elIGgÁehtumunqñaM

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 41

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

sakSI eGOn tan

Page 44: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

1975 cMENktMNagshRBHraCGaCJaGnþrCatiepþatelI

GgÁehtukñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü. b:uEnþCaerOy² GgÁCMnMu

CRmHEtgrMB£kdl;tMNagshRBHraCGaCJaCatifa Kb,Iepþat

sMxan;elIGgÁehtuEdlsßitkñúgyutþaFikareBlevlarbs;GgÁCMnMu

CRmHvisamBaØkñúgtulakarkm<úCa eBalKWGgÁehtuEdlekIt

eLIgkñúgcenøaHéf¶TI17 Exemsa qñaM1975 dl;éf¶TI6

Exmkra qñaM1979.

eqøIytbnwgsMNYrrbs;tMNagshRBHraCGaCJaCati

elak eGOn tan bBa¢ak;fa elak)ancUlrYmkñúgclnabdivtþenA

cenøaHExkumÖ³ nig mIna qñaM1968. eKalbMNgénkarcUlrYm

enH KWsgÇwmfanwgTTYl)ankarbNþúHbNþalepSg² edIm,ICYy

[elakmancMeNHdwgxøH eRBaHelakCamnusSminecHGan nig

sresrGkSrExμr. elak)ancUlrYmkñúgclnaenHtamry³

karENnaMrbs; ép EdlCaGñkdwknaMGgÁPaBnirsar nigTTYl

sÁal;eday kg Edg CaKN³Rsuk. kñúgGMLúg eBlenaHelak

mantYnaTICanirsarrt;sMbuRteRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs; ép.

bnÞab;mkelakTTYleFVICakgkarBarrbs; b:ul Bt eRkamkar

RKb;RKgrbs; b:g;.kñúgzan³CakgkarBar elakFøab;CUn b:ulBt

eFVIdMeNIreTAextþesomrab)at;dMbg eBaF×sat; nigkMBg;qñaMg edIm,I

CYbRbCMuCamYykmμaPi)alepSg²eTotrbs;bkSkumμúynIsþ

km<úCa.

elak eGOn tan bBa¢ak;bEnßmfa cab;BIqñaM1970dl;

qñaM1975elakrs;enACamYyCamYyb:ul BtkñúgextþkMBg;cam.

elakmantYnaTICaGñkrt;sMbuRt nigCakgkarBarsRmab; b:ul Bt.

Rkúmrbs;elakmanKña30nak; TTYlbnÞúkkarBar b:ul Bt/

eGogsarI/ exovsMpn/nYnCanigemdwknaMepSg²eTot.kñúgGMLúg

eBlenaH emdwknaMTaMgenH)anCYbRbCMuKñaCajwkj:ab; eBalKW

3b¤4dgkñúgmYyEx EdleBlenaHpÞHrbs; exovsMpn nig nYn Ca

mancm¶ayBIpÞHrbs;b:ulBtRbEhl200eTA300Em:RtEt

b:ueNÑaH. enAeBlmankic©RbCMurbs;emdwknaMTaMgenaHmþg²

Rkúmrbs;elakRtÚvTTYlbnÞúkkarBarsnþisuxeRkamkarcat;taMg

rbs; b:g;. kgkarBarRtÚv sßitenAcm¶ay20 Em:RtBIGgÁRbCMu

dUecñHGñkkarBarminGacdwgfakic©RbCuMTaMgenaHniyayGMBI

bBaðaGVIeLIy. eRkABIenH elak eGOn tan )anbBa¢ak;bEnßmGMBI

vtþmanmnÞIr870enAmunqñaM 1975. elak)anelIkeLIgfa

munqñaM1975 mnÞIr870 manTItaMgenAextþkMBg;cam Edlman

b:g; CaGñkTTYlbnÞúkdwknaMrYm. rcnasm<½n§rbs;mnÞIrenH KWman

mnÞIrk-1mnÞIrk-3nigmnÞIrk-7.mnÞIrk-7KWCaGgÁPaBnirsar

EdlsßitenAeRkamkarTTYlxusRtÚvrbs; lIn.

Tak;TgnwgkareFVIdMeNIrrbs; b:ul Bt ecjBIextþkMBg;cam

elak eGOntanbBa¢ak;fa bnÞab;BIkgT½BExμrRkhmcUlkan;kab;

TIRkúgPñMeBjPøam b:ul Bt/ nYn Ca/ exov sMpn nig b:g; KWkMBug

rs;enAextþkMBg;camenAeLIy. rhUtdl;cugExemsa qñaM1975

eTIbemdwknaMTaMgenHeFVIdMeNIreTATIRkúgPñMeBj. b:g; )anR)ab;

elakfaxøÜn¬b:g;¦/b:ulBt/nYnCa/ exovsMpnnig emdwknaMepSg²

eTotnwgeFVIdMeNIreTATIRkúgPñMeBjmun ehIycat;taMg[elak

enAerobcMsmÖar³eRbI R)as;rbs;emdwknaMTaMgenaHykeTAtam

eRkay. rhUtdl;Bak;kNþalEx]sPa qñaM1975 eTIbelak

eFVIdMeNIrecjBIextþkMBg;camCamYyRkúmrbs;elakEdl

dwkCBa¢ÚnsmÖar³eRbIR)as;rbs;emdwknaMTaMgenaH ehIy)anmk

sñak;enAmnÞIrk-1 EdlCakEnøgeFVIkarrbs; b:ul Bt.

Tak;TgnwgmnÞIrk-1 elak eGOntan)anpþl;skçIkmμ

CUntMNagshRBHraCGaCJaGnþrCatifa mnÞIrk-1 KWCakEnøg

sñak;enA nigCakEnøgeFVIkarrbs; b:ul Bt.mnÞIrenHmanTItaMgenA

Cab;Tenø)asak;raCFanIPñMeBj. elakRtÚv)an b:g; cat;taMg[

eFVICaRbFanRkúmkgkarBarsnþisuxEpñkxag kñúgenAmnÞIrk-1.

Rkúmrbs;elakmanKña10nak; TTYlbnÞúkerobcMmðÚbGahar

semøókbMBak;sRmab; b:ulBt.eRkABIenHKWmankargardaMduHenA

kñúgmnÞIr CaBiessCYyerobcMe)assm¥at nigkarBarsnþisux

enAeBlmankic©RbCMuenAmnÞIrk-1.elak eGOntanbBa¢ak;y:ag

c,as;fa mnÞIrk-1KWCakEnøgeFVIkar nigCYbRbCMurbs; b:ul Bt/

nYn Ca/ eGog sarI/ exov sMpn nigemdwknaMepSg²eTot.

emdwknaMTaMgenH)anCYbRbCMuCaerogral;ExenAmnÞIrk-1 eday

mankarcUlrYmBIkmμaPi)almkBIKN³Rsuk KN³tMbn; nigKN³

42 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 45: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

PUmiPaK. kic©RbCMuRtÚv)anerobcMeLIg y:agticKWmancMnYn1 b¤2

dgkñúgmYyEx edaycab;epþImBIem:ag7 dl;em:ag11RBwk

nigbnþBIem:ag2 dl;em:ag5l¶ac Edlmþg²manry³eBly:ag

tic2éf¶. RKb;kic©RbCMuTaMgGs;enAmnÞIrk-1 KWEtgEtmanvtþman

rbs; b:ul Bt/ nYn Ca/ eGogsarI/ exov sMpn nig b:g;. elak

eGOn tan bBa¢ak;bEnßmfa eRkABIkic©RbCMuEdlRtÚv)anerobcMCa

RbcaMdUc)anerobrab;xagelI KWmankic©RbCMuBiessmYycMnYneTot

Bak;B½n§karnwgedaHRsaybBaðaes,óg elIkTMnb; nigkarCIk

RbLayCaedIm EdlmansmasPaBcUlrYmRbCMudUcCa b:ul Bt/

nYn Ca/ eGogsarI/ exovsMpn nigfñak;dwknaMCan;x<s;mYycMnYneTot

enATIRkúgPñMeBjEtb:ueNÑaH. RKb;kic©RbCMuenAmnÞIrk-1Rkúm rbs;

elakmantYnaTICYyerobcaMe)assm¥at nigkarBarsnþisuxenA

kEnøgRbCMuenaH. eTaHCay:agenHkþI CaTUeTAelakmindwgGMBIkmμ

vtßúEdlkic©RbCMuTaMgenaHelIkmkBiPakSaeLIy eRBaHCakic©RbCMu

rbs;fñak;dwknaMCan;x<s; b:uEnþelak)andwgxøHtamry³b:g; Edl

Cafñak;elIrbs;xøÜn.

eRkABIkic©RbCMurbs;fñak;dwknaMCan;x<s;enAmnÞIrk-1

tMNagshRBHraCGaCJaGnþrCati)ansYrepþatsMxan;GMBItYnaTI

rbs;sakSIkñúgkarbBa¢ÚnsarTUrelx nigsMbuRtepSg²[ b:ul Bt

nigemdwknaMepSg²eTotenAmnÞIrk-1. CakareqøIytb elak

eGOntanbBa¢ak;fa Caerogral;éf¶ elak)an eTAyksarTUrelx

2 b¤3dgkñúgmYyéf¶ BImnÞIrk-7 edIm,IRbKl;[ b:ul Bt.

sarTUrelxTaMgenaH nwgRtÚvbBa¢ÚnbnþeTA nYn Ca bnÞab;BI b:ul Bt

)anemIlrYcehIy. CagenHeTAeTot elakk¾CaGñkTTYlbnÞúkyk

sMbuRt b¤sarTUrelxBI b:ul Bt eTA[mnÞIrTUrelx EdlRKb;RKg

eday pg; edIm,IepJIeTAkmμaPi)alfñak;eRkamEdr. sMbuRt nig

TUrelxRtÚv)an epJIecjBI b:ul Bt eTAkmμaPi)alfñak;eRkam2

b¤3dgkñúgmYyéf¶. sMNYrcugeRkayBak;B½n§nwgsarTUelx

TaMgenH tMNagshRBHraCGaCJaGnþrCati)anecaTsYrfa enAcug

bBa©b;énrbbkm<úCa RbCaFibetyü eBalKWéf¶TI6-7 Exmkra

qñaM 1979Éksarrbs;b:ulBtrkSaTukenAÉNa?CakareqøIy

tbelak eGOn tan bBa¢ak;fa ÉksarTaMgenaHRtÚv)anrkSaTuk

enAkñúgmnÞIrk-1 TaMgGs;.

sMNYrcugeRkayrbs;tMNagshRBHraCGaCJaGnþr

Cati KWBak;B½n§nwgkarCUndMeNIr b:ul Bt eTAeFVITsSnkic©tam

bNþaextþmYycMnYnenAkñúgRbeTskm<úCa. elak eGOn tan

)anbBa¢ak;fa kñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü elak)anCUndMeNIr

b:ul Bt eTAeFVITsSnkic©enAextþmYycMnYndUcCa kMBg;qñaMg

)at;dMbg nigesomrab;CaedIm. b:ul Bt )ancuHdl;kEnøgkardæan

enA tam mUldæaneday pÞal; ehIy)anCYbBiPakSaCamYyKN³

tMbn; nigGñkRKb;RKgkardæanedaypÞal;.

3¦ karsYredjedaledayemFavItMNagedIm

bNþwgrdæb,evNI

bnÞab;BItMNagshRBHraCGaCJaTaMgBIrrYbbBa©b;sMNYr

rbs;xøÜn GgÁCMnMuCRmHRbKl;tYnaTICUnshemFavInaMmuxtMNagedIm

bNþwgrdæb,evNI edIm,IbnþsYrsakSIGMBIGgÁehtudUc)aneRKagTuk.

kñúgkarsYredjedalelak eGOn tan KWmanEtshemFavICati

b:ueNÑaHEdl)anecaTsMNYr cMENkshemFavIGnþrCatimin)an

sYredjedalsakSIeLIy.

cab;epþImdMbUg elakemFavI Kwm em:gXI emFavICatitMNag

edImbNþwgrdæb,evNI)ansYr bBa¢ak;elIGgÁehtumYycMnYnTak;

TgnwgeKalbMNgrbs;sakSIkñúgkarcUlrYmkñúgclnabdivtþ

kargarrbs;sakSIenAextþrtn³KirI karCemøósRbCaCn vtþman

rbs; b:ul Bt bnÞab;BIvayEbkTIRkúgPñMeBjPøam² nigkarCUndMeNIr

b:ul Bt eTACYbRbCMu b¤eFVITsSnkic©enAtammUldæanCaedIm. KYr

bBa¢ak;fa PaKeRcInGgÁehtuTaMgenHRtÚv)antMNagshRBHraC

GaCJaecaTsYrrYcehIy ehIycemøIyEdlsakSI pþl;CUnk¾min

mankarxusEbøkKñaeRcInEdr.b:uEnþGVIEdlCasMNYrfμIrbs;elak

emFavI Kwm em:gXI KWBak;B½n§nwgbBaðasuxPaBrbs; b:ul Bt

kñúgqñaM1976.bnÞab;mkelakemFavI eBC GgÁ CashemFavI

naMmuxtMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNI)anecaTsMNYrmYycMnYnTak;

TgnwgkarbBa¢ÚnsMbuRtBI b:ulBt eTA nYnCa nigBI nYn Ca nigemdwkna M

epSgeToteTA b:ul Bt vij.

elak eGOn tan )anpþl;skçIkmμcMeBaHsMNYrrbs;

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 43

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 46: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

elakemFavI Kwm em:gXIfa eKalbMNgsMxan;bMputEdlnaM[elak

cUlrYmkñúgclnabdivtþKW edIm,ITTYl)an»kaseronsURt[man

cMeNHdwgxøH. elakbBa¢ak;fa CnCatiPaKticPaKeRcInKWCa

mnusSGviC¢a eFVIEtERscmáarmindwgGMBIbBaðaenAkñúgsgÁmExμr eLIy.

dUecñHelakseRmccitþcUlrYmkñúgclnaenH KWsgÇwmfanwg TTYl

)ancMeNHdwgxøH GaceronsURtecHsresr nigGanGkSrExμr)an

xøH.b:uEnþenAeBlcUlrYm KWelakTTYl)ankareronsURtbnþicbnþÜc

b:ueNÑaH ehIyGVIEdlelak)aneronsURteRcIn KWrebobrt;sMbuRt

BIkEnøgmYyeTAkEnøgmYyeTot. rhUtmkdl;qñaM1975eTIbbkS

beRgóneRcInGMBI eKalneya)ayrbs;bkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa.

eTaHbICay:agNa elakminGacyl;)ansIuCeRmAeLIy eRBaH

karyl;dwgPasaExμrrbs;elakenAmankRmitTab.

Tak;Tgnwgkarrt;sMbuRt elak eGOntanbBa¢ak;fa eBl

enAextþrtn³KirI elakmantYnaTICaGñkrt;sMbuRtBI kg Edg CaKN³

RsukGNþÚgmas extþrtn³KirI ykeTA evInés nig mNÐlKIrI.

b:uEnþelakmindwgfaGñkEdlRtÚvTTYlsMbuRtenaHmaneQμaHGVI

eLIyeRBaHelakminecHGancMNar EdlRtÚv)ancarelIeRsam

sMbuRtenaH)an. rhUtmkdl;qñaM1970 elak)anmkrs;enA

CamYyb:ul Bt kñúgextþkMBg;cam. kñúgGMLúgeBlenaHelakman

tYnaTICaGñkkarBar nigCanirsarrt;sMbuRt. elak)anCUndMeNIr

b:ul Bt eTAeFVIsmaCbkS enAPUmiRtBaMgTwm extþkMBg;cam.

eRkaymkCUndMeNIr b:ul Bt eTAebIkkic©RbCMuenAmnÞIrdgkþar

EdlmanTItaMgenAkñúgPUmidgkþarEb:k|sanþénXMus<W ehIykic©

RbCMuenHmankarcUlrYmBIRbFanPUmiPaKepSg². eRkABIenHelak

Føab;)anCUn b:ul Bt eTAeFVITsSnkic©enAtambNþaextþmYycMnYn

dUcCaextþkMBg;qñaMg esomrab eBaF×sat; )at;dMbgCaedIm.

elak eGOn bBa¢ak;bEnßmfa enAkñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü

elakFøab;)anCUndMeNIr b:ul Bt eTAeFVITsSnkic©enAtammUl

dæan edIm,IRtÜtBinitükarCIkRbLay nigelIkTMnb;mYycMnYn.

Bak;B½n§nwgbBaðasuxPaBrbs; b:ul Bt elakemFavI

Kwm em:gXI ecaTsMNYrfa etIenA éf¶TI 27 ExkBaØa qñaM1976

mankarRbkasfa b:ul Bt manCMgWCaTm¶n;Edrb¤eT? elak

eGOn tan bBa¢ak;fa elakminEdlB¤GMBIkarRbkasenHeLIy

ehIykñúgnamelakCakgkarBar nigenACab;lab;CamYy b:ul Bt

k¾minEdleXIj b:ul Bt manCMgWF¶n;F¶rEdr.

Bak;B½n§nwgkarbBa¢ÚnsMbuRt b¤sarTUrelx BI b:ul Bt eTA

nYnCa elakeGOntan)anpþl;skçIkmμCUnelakemFavI eBCGgÁ

faCaTUeTAsarTUrelxEdlfñak;eRkamepJI[b:ulBtnwg RtÚvbBa¢Ún

bnþeTA nYn Ca bnÞab;BI b:ul Bt )anemIlcb;. b:uEnþsRmab;rUb

elakpÞal; KWminEdl)anTTYlsMbuRttbBI nYn Ca epJI[ b:ul Bt

vijeLIy.bnÞab;mkelakemFavI)andkRsg;sMNYrnig cemøIy

EdlsakSI)anpþl;skçIkmμenAcMeBaHmuxGñkesIubGegátfa

{eBlelakyklixit eTA[ nYn Ca etI nYn Ca manepJIGVIeTA[

b:ul Bt vijEdrb¤eT?}. elak eGOn tan )aneqøIyfa

{Gt;maneT! EtmaneBlxøHmaneKyksMbuRtBI nYn Ca eTA[

b:ul Bt. karbBa¢ÚnsMbuRtBI nYn Ca eTA[ b:ul Bt KW

2dgkñúgmYyéf¶. ´minEdleXIjsMbuRtBI exovsMpn/ eGogsarI

nig eGogFIriT§ epJI[b:ulBt eT eRBaH´minEmnCaGñkeFVIkarCamYy

GñkTaMgenaH. ´k¾Føab;eXIjsMbuRt epJImkBI sun esn Edr}.

elak eGOn tan bBa¢ak;bEnßmCUnelakemFavIfa sMbuRtEdlepJI

mkBIsun esn[b:ulBtKWmanTMhMtUc²edaydak;enAkñúgeRsam.

cMENksMbuRtEdlepJImkBI nYn Ca KWmankRmasRkas;²

b:uEnþelakmindwgfasMbuRtenHniyayGMBIGVI nigmanRbPBmkBI

NaeLIy.

bnÞab;BIRkúmemFavItMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNIbBa©b;

sMNYrrbs;xøÜn GgÁCMnMuCRmH)anbnþecaTsMNYrmYycMnYneTA

sakSImuneBlRbKl;tYnaTICUnRkúmemFavIkarBarkþICnCab;ecaT

TaMgbIRkúm. sMNYrrbs;GgÁCMnMuCRmH)anepþatsMxan;GMBItYnaTI

rbs;Cab;ecaT nYn Ca enAeBlGvtþman b:ul Bt nigtYnaTIrbs;

exovsMpn enAmnÞIr870. eqøIytbnwgsMNYrrbs;elakecARkm

hSg;m:ak LaEv:j elaksakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa CaTUeTAkic©RbCMuenA

mnÞIrk-1RtÚv)anerobcM nigdwknaMedayb:ulBt.b:uEnþkñúgkrNI

b:ul BtGvtþman b¤eFVIdMeNIreTAeRkARbeTsKW nYn Ca CaGñkTTYl

bnÞúkkñúgkardwknaMkic©RbCMuTaMgenaH. cMeBaHtYnaTIrbs;CnCab;ecaT

44 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 47: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

exovsMpn vij elak eGOn tan bBa¢ak;CUnelakecARkm nilNun

fa kñúgGMLúgeBlelakeFVIkarenAmnÞIrk-1 KWelakminEdl

eXIj exovsMpn dwknaMkic©RbCMuenAmnÞIr870eLIy.mnÞIr870

manGgÁPaBcMNuHmYycMnYndUcCa mnÞIrk-1 mnÞIrk-3 nigmnÞIr

k-7. sakSIbBa¢ak;bEnßmfa mnÞIr870sßitenAeRkamkarRKb;

RKgrYmrbs; b:g; eRkaymkmnÞIrenHRtÚv)anRKb;RKgeday

Ekn ehAlIn bnÞab;BI b:g; )at;xøÜn.

4¦ karsYredjedaledayRkúmemFavIkarBarkþI

CnCab;ecaT

bnÞab;BIbBa©b;sMNYrrbs;tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa

emFavItMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNI nigrbs;GgÁCMnMuCRmH elak

RbFanecARkm nil Nun )anRbKl;evTikaCUnemFavIkarBarkþI

CnCab;ecaTTaMgbIRkúmedIm,IecaTsMNYreTAsakSI edaycab;epþIm

BIemFavIkarBarkþICnCab;ecaT exov sMpn bnÞab;mkemFavIrbs;

nYn Ca nigcugeRkayemFavIrbs; eGogsarI.

4>1¦ karsYredjedaledayRkúmemFavIkarBar

kþI exovsMpn

KYrkt;smÁal;fa kñúgkarsYredjedalsakSI elak

GakTYr EvkEKnCaemFavIGnþrCati karBarkþICnCab; exovsMpn

)anepþatsMxan;eTAelIPaBGacTukcitþ)anrbs;sakSIkñúgkar

pþl;skçIkmμCUnGgÁCMnMuCRmH. tamry³viFIsa®sþenH elakemFavI

)andkRsg;cemøIyEdlmankarxusKñamYycMnYnEdlsakSI)anpþl;

enAdMNak;kalesIubGegát nigskçIkmμEdlsakSI)anpþl;CUn

tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa nigemFavItMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNI

enAcMeBaHmuxGgÁCMnMuCRmH.

sMNYrcab;epþImdMbUgKWBak;B½n§nwgvtþmanrbs;sakSI nig

b:ul Bt enAeBlCitvayEbkTIRkúgPñMeBj. elakemFavI)andk

Rsg;cemøIyEdlelak eGOn tan Føab;)anpþl;skçIkmμCUnsh

ecARkmesIubGegátfa{>>>muneBlcUlPñMeBjmYyry³ ´minenA

CamYyb:ul Bt eT dUecñH´mindwgBIkar CemøósRbCaCnenAPñMeBj

eLIy}.elaktan)anbMPøWfa enAéf¶TI17ExemsaqñaM1975

b:ul Bt nig elak kMBugrs;enAkñúgextþkMBg;cam. eRkayBIrMedaH

)anTIRkúgPñMeBjRbEhlkenøHEx eTIb b:ul Bt/ b:g; nigemdwknaM

mYycMnYneToteFVIdMeNIreTATIRkúgPñMeBj. eBlenaHelakmin

)aneFVIdMeNIreTACamYyemdwknaMTaMgenHeLIy eRBaHenAerobcM

smÖar³eRbIR)as;rbs;GñkTaMgenaHykeTAtameRkay eBalKW

rhUtdl;Bak;kNaþalEx]sPa qñaM1975 eTIbelakecjeTA

TIRkúgPñMeBj. dUecñHry³eBlEdlelakmin)anenACamYy

b:ul Bt KWRbEhlmYyExb:ueNÑaHbnÞab;BI b:ul Bt eFVIdMeNIreTA

TIRkúgPñMeBj.sakSIbBa¢ak;bEnßmfa enAeBlb:ul Bt eFVIdMeNIr

eTATIRkúgPñMeBj elakmin)aneXIj exov sMpn rYmdMeNIrCamYy

b:ul Bt eLIy.

GGMMBBIIkkiicc©©RRbbCCMMuueennAAmmnnÞÞIIrrkk--11

sMNYrbnÞab;rbs;elak EvkEKn KWBak;B½n§nwgkic©RbCMu

enAmnÞIrk-1. elakemFavI)anrMB£kdl;sakSIEdl)aneqøIyCUn

tMNagshRBHraCGaCJafa kic©RbCMuFM²EdleFVIenAmnÞIrk-1

KWmanry³eBl2-3éf¶. bnÞab;mkelakemFavI)andak;bgðaj

ÉksarEdlsakSI)anpþl;skçIkmμCUnshecARkmesIubGegátfa

{kic©RbCMuFM²EdlmanKñacUlrYmCag20nak;EdlmankarcUlrYm

BIemdwknaMFM² nigkmμaPi)almkBIPUmiPaK nigtMbn; KWmanry³eBl

5-6éf¶}. elak tan bBa©ak;fa ry³eBlénkic©RbCMuRbePTenH

KWGaRs½yelIkmμvtßúEdlRtÚvykmkBiPakSa. CaFmμtakic©

RbCMuenHmanry³eBl2-3éf¶ b:uEnþkñúgkrNImanRbFanbTeRcIn

EdlRtÚvBiPakSa KWGaccMNayeBlBI5 eTA6éf¶. elakbEnßmfa

ral;kic©RbCMuFM²enAmnÞIrk-1KWmankarcUlrYmBI b:ulBt/ exov

sMpn/ nYn Ca/ eGog sarI nigemdwknaMepSg²eTot¬sakSImin

caMeQμaH¦. bnÞab;BIsakSIbBa¢ak;dUecñH elakemFavIesñI[sakSI

bBa¢ak;BIkalbriecäTEdl exovsMpn )ancUlrYmkic©RbCMuTaMgenaH

nigkmμvtßú EdlRtÚv)anykmkBiPakSaenAkñúgGMLúgeBlenaH.

CakareqøIytbelaktanbBa¢ak;fa elakminGaccaMkalbriecäT

TaMgenaHeLIy eRBaHry³eBlknøghYsCag30eTAehIy.

cMeBaHkmμ vtßúEdlRtÚv)anykmkBiPakSakñúgkic©RbCMuFM²k¾elak

minGacdwgEdr eRBaHCakic©RbCMurbs;fñak;dwknaMCan;x<s;. b:uEnþ

elakFøab;)andwgkmμvtß úénkic ©RbCM ut Uc²enAmnÞ Irk-1

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 45

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 48: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

¬tamry³ b:g; Cafñak;elIrbs;xøÜn¦

Bak ;B ½n §n wgkaredaHRsayCIvPaB

RbCaCn b¤karCIkTMnb;RbLayCa

edIm.

GGMMBBIIkkiicc©©RRbbCCMMuueennAAssþþaattGGUULLaaMMBBiikk

bnÞab;BIbBa©b;sMNYrBak;B½n§nwg

kic©RbCMuenAmnÞIrk-1 elak EvkEKn

bnþsYrsakSIGMBIkic©RbCM uTak;Tgnwg

EpñkeyaFaEdlRtÚv)aneFVIenAsþatGULaM

Bik. hak;dUcCamankarPan;RcLMbnþic

cMeBaHsMNYr nigcemøIyTak;TgnwgcMnYn

dgénkic©RbCMuenAsþatGULaMBik. dMbUgelakemFavIsYrsakSI

fa etIkic©RbCMuFM²Bak;B½n§EpñkeyaFaRtÚv)aneFVIeLIgb:unμandg

enAsþatGULaMBik? elak tan bBa¢ak;fa elak)ancUlrYmcMnYnBIr

dgkñúgzan³CaGñkkarBarenAkñúgkic©RbCMuenH. bnÞab;BIbBa¢ak;

dUecñH elakemFavI)anelIkeLIgfa elak tan min)aneqøIyCUn

shecARkmesIubGegátdUecñHeLIy eBalsakSIFøab;bBa¢ak;

fa kic©RbCMueyaFaRtÚv)aneFVIBIrdgkñúgmYyqñaM. dUecñHkic©

RbCM uenHGacRtÚv)aneFV Iy:agtic6dgenAkñ úgrbbkm< úCa

RbCaFibetyü. PøamenaHelak Gab;Dul farIk eFVIkarkt;

smÁal;elIcemøIyrbs;sakSIfa{sakSIbBa¢ak;faKat;Føab;)an

cUlrYmkñúgkic©RbCMuenHBIrdg dUecñHminGacbBa¢ak;fakic©RbCMu

enHeFVIeLIgEtBIrdgeLIy}. GgÁCMnMuCRmHyl;Rsbtamkar

elIkeLIgrbs;tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa nigseRmc[elak

EvkEKn erobcaMsMNYrsYrsakSIsarCafμI. GgÁCMnMuCRmHbBa¢ak;fa

xøwmsarcemøIyEdlsakSIeqøIyenAdMNak;kalecARkmesIub

GegátxusBIxøwmsareqøIyenAcMeBaHmuxGgÁCMnMuCRmH.bnÞab;BIman

karbgÁab;dUecñH elakemFavI ecaTsYrfa etI b:ul Bt)anmkRbCMu

enAsþatGULaMBikBak;B½n§nwgkic©kareyaFacMnYnb:unμandg?

sakSIbBa¢ak;fa elakmindwg b:ul Bt )ancUlrYmb:unμandgeLIy

b:uEnþFøab;eXIj b:ul Bt nigsun esn cUlrYmkñúgkic©RbCMuenaHBIr

dg. elakbBa¢ak;bEnßmfa kñúgGMLúgeBlenaHelakmin)an

eXIjvtþmanrbs; nYn Ca/ eGogsarI nig exovsMpn eLIy.

4>2¦ karsYredjedaledayRkúmemFavIkarBar

kþI nYn Ca

kñúgkarsYredjedalsakSI elaksun GruNCaemFavI

CatikarBarkþICnCab;ecaT nYn Ca )ansYrsMNYrmYycMnYn

b:ueNÑaHTak;Tgnwgkargarrbs;elak tan kñúgGMLúgeBleFVIbdivtþ

nigkic©RbCMuenAsþatGULaMBik. cMeBaHsMNYrmYycMnYneTotEdl

elakemFavIEtgEtecaTsYrsakSIKWTak;TgnwgTsSnavdþITg;bdivtþ

nigcriklkçN³rbs;CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca.

sMNYrmYycMnYndMbUgEdlelakemFavIecaTsYrsakSI

KWBak;B½n§nwgsuvtßiPaBrbs;sakSIkñúg karbMeBjkargarCaGñkrt;

sMbuRtenAkñúgGMLúgeBleFVIbdivtþn_. elakemFavIecaTsYrfa

enAeBlsakSIrt;sMbuRtBIkEnøgmYyeTAkEnøgmYyeTot mankar

P½yxøaycMeBaHkarcab;xøÜnBIsMNak;sRtÚv rbs;bdivtþn_Edrb¤eT?

¬elakemFavImin)anbBa¢ak;buKÁlRbePTNaCasRtÚvrbs;

bdivtþn_eLIy¦.CakareqøIytbelakeGOntanbBa¢ak;fakñúgkar

bMeBjkargarCaGñkrt;sMbuRt elakminEdlmankarlM)akGVI

eLIy ehIyk¾minEdlRBÜy)armÖ b¤P½yxøacfanwgmankarcab;

xøÜnBIsMNak;sRtÚvrbs;bdivtþn_Edr. bnÞab;mkelakemFavIbnþsYr

fa{ebIxμaMgrbs;bdivtþn_cab;elak)an etIelakRtÚvedaHRsay

y:agdUcemþc?}. b:uEnþsMNYrenHRtÚv)anRbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmH

46 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

kic©RbCMueyaFaExμrRkhmenAsþatGULaMBik ¬RbPBÉksar³ mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa¦

Page 49: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

minGnuBaØat[sakSIeqøIy edayelakpþl;sMGagehtufa emFavI

sYrsMNYrEbb]bmaviFI. cMeBaHsMNYrBak;B½n§nwgvtþmanrbs;

emdwknaMExμrRkhmenAkñúg kic©RbCMuEdlRtÚv)aneFVIenAsþatGULaM

Bik elakbBa¢ak;CafμIfa elakminEdleXIjvtþmanrbs; nYn Ca/

eGogsarI nig exovsMpn eLIy.

sMNYrbnÞab; elakemFavIsunGruNsYrbBa¢ak;GMBIGtþ

sBaØaNrbs;TsSnavdþITg;bdivtþ EdlRtÚv)anbkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa

eRbIR)as;edIm,IpSBVpSayGMBIeKalneya)ayrbs;bkS. Ca

kareqøIytb elak eGOntanbBa¢ak;fa elak)aneXIjTsSna

vdþIenHcab;taMgBIqñaM1975mk EdleBlenaH TsSnavdþITg;

bdivtþmandak;rUbnarITUlkNþab;RsÚv rUbjjÜr keNþóv.

b:uEnþedayelakminecHGkSrminGacGan)an dUecñHelakmin

dwgGMBIxøwmsarEdlmanEcgkñúgTsSnavdþITg; bdivtþeLIy.

cugeRkayelakemFavI sun GruN sYrsakSIGMBIGtþ

crikrbs;CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca nig b:g; kñúgGMLúgeBlEdlelak

)aneFVIkarCamYy.elakeGOntanbBa¢ak;fa nYnCaKWCamnusSEdl

manritsøÚtbUt ecHGb;rMdl;kmμaPi)alExμrRkhm KWminEmnCa

mnusSkacsarhaveLIy. cMENk b:g; k¾CamnusSsøÚtbUt

nigsuPaBrabsarCamYyyuT§Cnfñak;eRkamEdr.

4>3¦ karsYredjedaledayRkúmemFavIkarBar

kþI eGogsarI

kñúgkarsYredjedalsakSI elak ém:eXIl xaNav:as

CaemFavIGnþrCatikarBarkþICnCab;ecaT eGogsarI )anBüayam

epþatelIPaBRtwmRtÚvénkic©esIubsYrcMeBaHsakSIenAdMNak;

kalesIubGegát. cMeBaHsMNYrEdlelakepþatsMxan;bMput

enaH KWBak;B½n§nwgPaBminRbRktIkñúgkarftExSGat;semøgenA

eBlGñkesIubGegátsYrykcemøIyBIsakSI.

elak eGOn tan bBa¢ak;fa elak)anpþl;bTsmÖas_

CUnGñkesIubGegátcMnYnBIrdg KWéf¶ TI8-9 Extula qñaM2008.

bnÞab;BIpþl;bTsmÖas_cb; GñkesIubGegát)anGanxøwmsarsegçb

énbTsmÖas_enaH[elaksþab;eLIgvijmunnwgelakcuHhtß

elxaTTYlsÁal;. cemøIyenHRtÚv)anGan[elaksþab;mþgeTot

munnwgelakcUlmkpþl;skçIkmμenAcMeBaHmuxGgÁCMnMuCRmHsala

dMbUg. cMeBaHkarftExSGat;semøgenAdMNak;kalesIubGegát

elak eGOn tan bBa¢ak;fa KWmanEt bTsmÖas_éf¶TI9 Extula

qñaM2008 b:ueNÑaHEdlmankarftsemøg. cMENkbTsmÖas_

enAéf¶TI8 Extula qñaM2008 KWminmankarftExSGt;semøg

eLIy.bBaðaenHehIyEdleFVI[elakemFavI xaNav:as; CCIk

sYry:agxøaMg. elak)anecaTsYrfa ehtuGVI)anCakic©smÖas_

éf¶TI8 Extula qñaM2008 minmankarftsemøg? etIenAkñúg

kic©smÖasn_EdlminmankarftsemøgenH GñkesIubGegát)an

bgðaj ÉksarGVIxøHdl;sakSICakarrMB£kdl;karcgcaMkñúgkar

eqøIysMNYrEdrb¤eT? etImanbBaðaGVIxøHEdlRtÚv)anecaTsYrkñúg

GMLúgeBlenaH?. cugeRkayelakemFavIecaTsYrfa {kic©

smÖasn_éf¶TI8 Edlminmankarftsemøg etIGñkesIubGegát

manbgðajÉksarNamYyedIm,ICakarrMB£kdl;elak edIm,I

[elakeqøIyenAéf¶TI9 EdlmankarftExSGat;Edrb¤eT?}.

CalT§pl elak eGOn tan bBa¢ak;fa elakmincaMfaÉksarNa

b¤bBaðaGVIxøHEdlRtÚv)anGñkesIubGegátelIkmkbgðaj b¤

BiPakSakñúgGMLúgeBlkarsYrykcemøIyEdlKμankarftExS

Gat;semøgeLIy.

bnÞab;BIsvnakarsþab;skçIkmμrbs;elak eGOn tan

RtÚv)anbBa©b; GgÁCMnMuCRmHbnþsþab;skçIkmμrbs;elak yun

KIm.

VII¦ svnakarsþab;skçIkmμrbs;sakSI yun KIm

enAéf¶TI19-20 Exmifuna qñaM2012 GgÁCMnuMCRmH

)anRbkasbnþsvnakarsYredjedalelIsakSIdUcEdl)an

eRKagTukkalBIs)þah_mun. svnakarenH)anRbRBwtþeTAeday

mankarcUlrYmtamdanBIsMNak;RbCaCnkm<úCaRbEhl700

nak; EdlGeBa¢IjmkBIRsúkrtn³mNÐl extþ )at;dMbg taEkv

nigkNþal. enAkñúgkic©dMeNIrkarsvnakarenHminmanvtÒman

rbs;emFavIGnÒrCatiCnCab;ecaT eGogsarI eLIyehIyk¾min dwg

BImUlehtuBitR)akdenaHeTtamry³karbBa¢ak;rbs;RkLabBa¢I.

muneBlcab;epþImsvnakarelakRbFan nilNun )anRbkas

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 47

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 50: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

bBa¢ak;BIvtþmanrbs;CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI Edl)anesñIsuM

GgÁCMnuMCRmHlHbg;siTi§kñúgkarcUlrYm svnakaredaypÞal;eBj

mYyéf¶edaysarbBaðasuxPaB ehIybnÞab;mkelakRbFan)an

GanesckþIbBa¢ak;rbs;RKÚeBTüEdlTak;TgnwgGakar³Cm¶Wrbs;

CnCab;ecaT. bnÞab;mkelakemFavI GIuNUhSúI )anesñIsuM[GgÁ

CMnuMCRmHecjesckþIseRmcpÞal;mat;elIsMeNIrbs;xøÜnEdl

eFVIeLIgkalBImun. Tak;TgnwgbBaðaenH elakRbFanGgÁCMnuMCRmH

)anbBa¢ak;fa xøÜnminTan;)anTTYlsMeNIenaHenAeLIyeTeday

sarPaByWty:avrbs;RkúmemFavI. PøamenaHelakemFavI

)aneRkakQreLIgsarCafμIedIm,IbgðajBIehtuplNamYy

b u : En þ k a rN _ enHRt Ú v)anelakRbFanbBa Äb ; ed ay

GHGagfaxøÜn)anbBa¢ak;elIkrNIenHrYcehIy.

bnÞab;mkelak eBC GgÁ emFavInaMmuxtMNagedIm

bNþwgrdæb,evNI)aneRkakQreLIg nigbBa¢ak;CUnGgÁCMnuMCRmH

BIemFavITTYlsiT§i EdlnwgeFVIkarsakSsYrsakSIenAkñúgsvna

karenHEdlmanelakemFavI Ev:n eBA nigelakRsIemFavI

sIumINUhVt. eRkABIenaH elak)aneFVIkarkt;smÁal;cMeBaH

emFavI GIuNUhSIú Edl)anBak;søakmanGkSr{Gay rUbebHdUg

nigdada}enAelIr:Ubrbs;xøÜn EdlelakemFavIsnñidæanfaCasøak

sBaØapSayBaNiC¢kmμGVImYy. PaømenaHelakRbFan)an

bgÁab;[emFavIeRkakQrnigeFVIkarENnaMmin[mankareRbIR)as;

søaksBaØaNamYyEdlxusBIsøaksBaØarbs;GgÁCMnu MCRmH

eLIy.

1¦ Rbvtþisavtarrbs;sakSI yun KIm

elakRbFan)anbnþkic©dMeNIrkaredayekaHehAsakSI

yun KIm mkcUlkñúgbnÞb;svnakar edIm,IeFVIkarsaksYr.

elak)ancab;epþImsYrsMNYrmYycMnYnTak;TgnwgRbvtiþsvtar

bs;sakSI. enAkñúgsPaBmaMTaMeTaHbICamanv½ycMNas;k¾

eday elaksakSI)anbBa¢ak;faxøÜnmaneQμaH yun KIm ehAxaM

manGayu70qñaM ekItenAPUmivDÆn³XuMvDÆn³ RsúksMbUr extþRkecH

sBVéf¶mantYnaTICaemXuMvDÆn³ nigeFVIERs. elaksakSI)anbnþ

fa xøÜnman«BukeQμaH yun hak; mþayeQμaH fam RCIú RbBn§

eQμaH ln; eGgeson nigmankUn7nak;. bnÞab;mkelak

RbFan)anbBa©b;karsaksYrrbs;xøÜnedayepÞrevTikaCUnsh

RBHraCGaCJaedIm,IsaksYr bnþ.

2¦ karsYredjedaledaytMNagsh

RBHraCGaCJa

elak esg b‘unXag tMNagshRBHraCGaCJaCati)an

saksYrsMNYrmYycMnYnTak;TgnwgkarbMeBjkargarrbs;bkS

enAextþRkecH karbegáItshkrN_ karGb;rMneya)ay nigkar

cab;xøÜnkmμaPi)al. cMENkelaktMNagshRBHshkrN_

raCGaCJaGnþrCati EDlI sak; )anbnþkarsaksYrBak;B½n§nwg

smaCikPaBrbs;bkSkumμúynIsÒkm<úCarcnasm<½n§rdæ)alenAtMbn;

505karRbCuMnigsßanPaBTUeTAenAkñúgshkrN_ nigbBaðasasna.

2>1¦ karbegáItshkrN_

sakSI)anbnþfakalenaH nYn Ca )aneTARbCuMENnaM

BIkarbegáIt[manRkúmRbv:as;éd shkrN_kMritTab nigshkrN_

kMritx<s;. eKalbMNgénkarbegáIt[manRkúmRbv:as;édenHKW

edIm,IrYbrYmkmøaMgbnÞab;BImans®gÁamknøgmk ehIykarbegáIt

shkrN_enH)anbnþrhUtdl;qñaM1979. sakSI)anerob

rab;faenAqñaM1971rhUtdl;1976xøÜneFVICaemXuMvDÆn³

ehIyenAqñaM1977Kat;)anpøas;eTAeFVIemXuMsMbUr. dMbUg

eLIyshkrN_KWsßitenAeRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;fñak;XuM ehIy

48 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

sakSI yun KIm

Page 51: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

enAqñaM1976RKb;shkrN_TaMgGs;køayCashkrN_cRmuH

EdlmanRbCaCnCemøósmkBItMbn;rMedaH nigRbCaCn17

emsa bu:EnþenAeBlenaHminTan;mankarEbgEckRbePTRbCaCn

enAeLIyeT.

2>2¦ karcab;xøÜnkmμaPi)alExμrRkhm

Tak;Tgnwgkarcab;xø Ün elak KIm )anerobrab;fa

enAeBlxøÜneTARKb;RKgenAXuMsMbUrenaHFøab;manbBa¢aBIfñak;elI

[yk taQI EdlCaGtItKN³RsúksMbUr ehIyminEdleXIj

Rtlb;mkvijeLIy. cMeBaHkarcab;xøÜn taXin Edlkan;xag

esdækic©enARsúkRkecH sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa xøÜnmindwgBImUlehtu

Edr bu:EnÒenAqñaM1978mankarcab;xøÜnemXuMCaeRcInnak;enA

RsúksMbUr ehIyeRkaymkRtÚv)anRKb;RKgedayBYkeyaFa.

cMENkelxanigKN³kmμakarRsúkBIrnak;k¾RtÚv)ancab;xøÜn ehIy

enAeBlenaHmanyUn nigQUk)anmkRKb;RKgCMnYs ehIyQUk

CaelxaRsúk. sakSI)anbnÒfaenACMnan;enaHmankarpøas;bÒÚr

mnusSCaeRcInelIkeRcInsardUecñHehtukarN_enHminmanGVIcEmøk

enaHeLIy. sakSI)anerobrab;famanyuvCnCag400nak;

RtÚv)anbBa¢ÚnmkmnÞIrb-3 EdlsßitenAeRkamkarRKb;RKgrbs;

BYkeyaFaedIm,ImkCYyeFVIkargarenATIenaH bu:EnÒedaysarkarRKb;

RKgenATIenaHmansPaBtwgEtgeBkxøÜnRtÚv)anEtgtaMg[kan;

kab;mnÞIrb-3vij.cMENkyuvCnEdlenATIenaHeFVIkar)anEt

BIrExk¾RtÚv)anKN³RsúkbBa¢ÚneTAextÒkMBg;FM.

2>3¦ karGb;rMneya)ay

Tak;TgnwgkarGb;rMneya)aysakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa

xøÜnFøab;)ancUlrYmeronsURtCamYyfñak;Rsúknigfñak;extÒ ehIy

ÉksarEdlbeRgónenaHKWÉksarTg;bdivdþ. cMENkxøwmsarén

karbeRgón KWTak;TgnwgkarENnaM[eFVIshkrN_ nigkargarepSg²

eTot. sakSI)anbEnßmfa Tg;bdivdÒenaHkñúgmYyPUmiTTYl)an

EtmYyk,albu:eNÑaHedIm,I[kmμaPi)aleronsURt nigGnuvtþtam

eKalneya)ayrbs;bkS. bnÞab;BIbBa©b;karsaksYrrbs;xøÜn

elaktMNagshRBHraCGaCJaCati)anRbKl;evTikaCUnsh

Patarbs;xøÜn KWelak EDl lIsak;.

2>4¦ smaCikPaBrbs;bkSkumμúynIskm<úCa

elak EDlI sak; tMNagshRBHraCGaCJaGnþrCati)an

cab;epþImsMNYrrbs;xøÜnTak;TgnwgkarcUlCasmaCikenAkñúg

bkSkumμúynIsþkm<úCa. elak KIm )anerobrab;faxøÜnman Rsúk

kMeNItenARsúkRkÚcqμarextþkMBg;cam nigekItenAqñaM1942

ehIyenAqñaM1950xøÜn)anpøas;mkenAextþRkecHedaysar

RbeTsGesßrPaB. bnÞab;BImanrdæRbhar sßanPaBRcbUk

Rcbl;dUecñHxøÜn)ancUlrYmclnabdivdþehIyRtÚv)anEtgtaMg

CasmaCikbkSenAqñaM1971edaysarmankarENnaMBI Ect

CaKN³RsúksMbUr. sakSI)anerobrab;fakargarCaRbFanXuM

kalenaHxøÜnykcitÒTuk dak;elIbBaðaesdækic© karCIkTMnb;

nigbBaðasuxPaBrbs;RbCaCnedayerobcM[manmnÞIreBTü.

enAfñak;XuMmanEpñksnþisux nigxageyaFamannaTIBinitüemIl

sNþab;Fñab;mUldæan EdlmanQøbCaGñkTTYlxusRtÚv.

fñak;elIrbs;XuMKWmanfñak;RsúkEdlman taEct CaRbFan

ehIyeRkaymkman pan; nig nI rhUtdl;qñaM1978KWman

evOn EdlRKb;RKgRsúksMbUrrhUtdl; qñaM1979.

2>5¦ rcnasm<½n§rdæ)alenAtMbn;505

sakSI)anerobrab;bnþfa mundMbUgtMbn;505sßitenA

kñúgPUmiPaK|sanÒ eRkaymktMbn;enHkøayCatMbn;sVy½t

EdlsßitenAeRkamkarRKb;RKgpÞal;rbs;fñak;mCÄimenAqñaM1978

EdlmanyICaelxatMbn; ehIyeRkaymkemOn)anmkCMnYs

bnÞab;BImankarcab;xøÜn yI. enAtMbn; 505manRsúkbI KWRsúk

sMbUr RsúksñÜl nigRsúkRkecH ehIyenARsúksMbUrmanEbg

EckCamnÞIrsRmab;RbCuM mnÞIresdækic© nigmnÞIrsnÒisux. cMeBaHkar

RbCuMmþg²KWEtgEtmankarelIkeLIgBIbBaðaRKb;EpñkTaMgGs;

nigmankarkt;RtaedIm,IbBa©ÚneTAfñak;;elI. ral;karraykarN_

BIfñak;XuMeTARsúk KWRtÚvraykarN_edaypÞal; bu:EnÒBIfñak;Rsúk

eTAextÒRtÚveFVIeLIgtamry³nirsar.

2>6¦ kic©RbCuMCamYy nYn Ca

elaktMNagshRBHraCGaCJa)anbnþkarsaksYrTak;

Tgnwgkic©RbCuMEdleFVICamYynYn Ca enAqñaM1973.eqøIytb

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 49

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 52: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

nwgsMNYrenHsakSI)anbBa¢ak;fakmμvtßúénkarRbCuMenaH nYn Ca

)anENnaMGMBIsPaBkarN_vayxμaMg EdlsMedAelITahan ln;

nl; karbegáItshkrN_bIkMritfñak;XuM dUcCaRkúmRbva:s;éd

EdlRbCaCnCYyKñaeTAvijeTAmkeFVIERselIdIerogxøÜneday

minmankarEbgEckpl. cMENkRkúmkMritTabvij KWRbCaCn

eFVIkarrYmKñaEckrMElksmÖar³eRbIR)as; nigeKaRkbICaedIm

ehIyvaxusBIshkrN_kMritx<s;EdltMrUv[dak;reTHeKaRkbI

rYmKña bu:EnÒkarTTYl)anpltamkmøaMgBlkmμ. eRkaymk

taEct RtÚv)ancab;xøÜnbBa¢ÚneTARkecHqñaM1976 edaysarxus

sIlFm’.

2>7¦ sßanPaBenAkñúgshrN_

enAqñaM1977enAXuMsMbUrmanshkrN_BIrKWshkrN_

sMbUr nigERsexOnedaysarXuMenHFMCageKenAkñúgRsuk

sMbUr. eTaHbICashkrN_TaMgBIrEckdac;BIKña bu:Enþkarray

kaN_enAEtmandEdl ehIyRtÚveFVIeLIgedaypÞal;. eRkay

mkxøÜnRtÚv)an evOn CaKN³Rsúkpøas;BIshkrN_ERsexOn

eTA mnÞIrb-3. Bak;B½n§nwgkarCemøósRbCaCnenAéf¶17

emsa 1975sakSI)anbBa¢ak; faenAPUmivDÄn³mankarCemøós

RbCaCnfμItamkaNUt ehIyeRkaymkmankarCemøósCnCati

camRbEhl30eTA40RKÜsarpøas;mkBIsVayka Mb it

ehIymanRbCaCnExμrmYycMnYnrhUtdl;edImqñaM1978man

RbCaCnmkBIXuMmUg Rsúkemmt;EfmeTot. sakSI)an bEnßm

eTotfa karrs;enATIenaHEtgEtmankarRbCuMedIm,Icab;xμaMgEdl

x¢ilRcGUs niigGñkEdlmineBjcitÒcMeBaHbdivdþn_CaedIm.

eRkABIenaHxøÜn)an[RbCaCnenAkñúgXuMeFVIkarTietonGMBIkardwk

naMrbs;xøÜn ehIyRbCaCnenATIenaHsb,aycitþedaysarGñkdwk

naMBImunminGaceFVIkarTieton)aneLIy.sakSI)anbEnßmfamnÞIr

Gb;rMEkERbenARsúksMbUrmanBIrkEnøg KWenARbRsalnigeKak kþÜc.

2>8¦ Tak;Tgnwgsasna

sakSI)anGHGagfa enAextþRkecHRBHBuT§sasnaRtÚv

)anbBa©b;enAcugqñaM1976edaylubbM)at;min[manelaksgÇ

bu:EnþvtÒGaramminmankarxUcxateRcIneT BIeRBaHeBlman

RbCaCnmkRbCuMeRcIn eKmin[cUlkñúgviharenaHeLIyeday[

RbCuMenAbriNxageRkAehIyRtÚv)aneKykeTAeFVICakEnøg

dutek,Óg. cMeBaHvtþsrsr100RtÚv)anRbCaCn erIruHyk

ek,ÓgedIm,Isg;mnÞIreBTü. elak)anbnþfa enAeBlenaH

sasnaRBHBuT§ nigsasna\søamRtÚv)anlubbM)at;ecal

TaMgGs; ehIyenAkEnøgxøHmankarbgMç[CnCaticamhUbsac;

RCÚkesÞIrRKb;shkrN_TaMgGs;. bnÞab;BIbBa©b;karsaksYr

rbs;tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa elakemFavIkarBar kþI GIuNUhSI

50 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

sßanPaBshkrN_enAkñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü ¬RbPBÉksar³mCÄm

Page 53: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

)anesñIsuM[kUnkþIrbs;xøÜncuHeTAsRmakenAbnÞb;xageRkameday

sarbBaðasuxPaB. eqøóteBlenaHEdr elakemFavI)anbBa¢ak;

CUnGgÁCMnuMCRmHfa cMeBaHBakü{dada}EdlxøÜn)anBak;enAelI

rU:bkalBIRBwkenaHKWsMedAeTAelIclnaTsSn³niymEdlCMTas;

nwgGVIEdlKμann½y ehIyRbqaMgnwgTsSn³EdlrgnUvkar

RbRBwtÒminl¥edayminEmnmann½yfa {minsYrmineqøIyenaHeT}.

Tak;TgnwgkarbkRsayTaMgenH elakRbFanmin)aneFVIkar

eqøIytbcMeBaHkarbBa¢ak;Gtßn½yBIsMNak;emFavIeLIy eday

elakRKan;EtGnuBaØat[CnCab;ecaT nYn Ca eTAsRmakenAbnÞb;

eRkamtamkaresñI suMEtbu:eNÑaH.

2>9¦ kareRCIserIsnarI[erobkarCamYyeyaFa

tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa)anbnþkarsaksYrrbs;xøÜn

Tak;TgnwgkarerobkarCakgkmøaMgeyaFa. Tak;TinnwgbBaðaenH

sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fakarerobkarenaHminmankarbgMçeLIyKW

Tal;EtxagnarIsμ½RKcitþ ehIyedaysarkarerobkarenAeBl

enaHmaneRcInKUr burs nignarIRtÚvtMrUv[manBak;elxedIm,I

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 51

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

mNÐlÉksarkm<úCa¦

Page 54: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

cMNaM. sakSI)anerobrab;faCaFmμtaeyaFaRtÚvesñIeTAfñak;

Rsúk ehIyxøÜnenAfñak;XuMCaGñksaksYreyabl;RbsinebInarI

enaHsμ½RKcitþeTIbGacerobkar)an. enAqñaM1977sakSI)an

bBa¢ak;faxøÜnRtÚv)anEtgtaMgCaKN³RsúksMbUredaysarsßan

PaBenATI enaH RcbUkRcbl;xøaMgnigmankarcab;xøÜn sMpn CaRbFan

RsúksMbUrEdleRkaymkeFVICaRbFanRsúkRkecH ehIyk¾RtÚv

)ancab;xøÜnEdr.

2>10¦ karEbgEckRbCaCn

Tak;TgnwgkarEbgEckRbCaCn17emsa sakSI)an

bBa¢ak;fa RbCaCnRtÚv)aneKEbgEckCabIRbePT. TImYyGñk

Edlrs;enAtMbn;enaHeKehAfaRbCaCncas; TIBIrRbCaCn

cas;EdrEtmineBjcitþnwgbdivdþeKehAfaRbCaCneRtóm ehIy

TIbIKWRbCaCn17emsaEdleKehAfaGñkbeBaØI. bu:EnþenAkñúg

shkrN_xøÜnminmanEbgEckdUecñHeTedIm,IkuM[Gñkcas;)ancitþ

ehIyeFVI)abGñkEdlmkfμI. Bak;B½n§nwgRbvtþirUbGñkmkfμI

elak KIm )anGHGagfaenAkñúgXuMrbs;xøÜnmintMrUv[eFVIenaHeLIy

bu:EnþGñkEdlRtÚv)aneKsgS½yfamanCab;ExSxagGñkeFVIkar

raCkarBIsgÁmcas;eTIbtMrUv[eFVIRbvtiþrUbcMENkGñk17 emsa

KWRKan;EteFVICMerOnFmμtaEtbu:eNÑaH.

2>11¦ kare)assm¥atxμaMgenAcugrbbkm<úCa

RbCaFibetyü

sakSI)anbnþerobrab;fakñúgRsúksMbUr manmnÞIrGb;rMBIr

KWRbRsal nigeKakkÒÜc bu:EnÒxøÜn k¾mindwgfaenAmnÞIrsnþisuxTaMgBIr

enaHmanGñkeTasbu:nμannak;enaHeT. enAextþRkecHenAcugqñaM

1977 nigedImqñaM1978mankarcab;xøÜnkmμaPi)aldUcCa

evOn KN³RsúksMbUrbnÞab;BI nI nig QUk RbFaneyaFaRsúk

edaysarBYkeyaFa)ancUleTARKb;RKg. cMeBaHGñkEdl

RtÚv)an cab;xøÜn ehIybBa¢ÚneTAmnÞIrs-21enAeBlenaHman

KYn/yI CaelxatMbn;505/nI KN³RsúksMbUr/ ePOnenAxageyaFa

nigsnþisux nig pan; CaKN³RsúksMbUr ehIymankmμaPi)alxøH

RtÚv)ancab;xøÜnTaMgRKÜsar. Tak;Tgnwgkark,t;enAkñúgkgkmøaMg

Tahankm<úCaRbCaFibetyüeBlc,aMgCamYyevotNam nigkmøaMg

k,t;RtÚv)ankemÞcenAextþRkecH. sakSI)anGHGagfa xøÜnmin

)andwgBIbBaðaenHeLIy eRBaHbBaðaenHekIteLIgenAq¶ayBItMbn;

rbs;xøÜn bu:EnþsakSI)anbEnßmfa vaCaerOgFmμtabu:eNÑaHenA

kñúgrbbExμrRkhmenAeBlEdlkmμaPi)alfμIcUlmkkan;kab;

enaH eKEtgEtniyayfaGñkmunk,t;. tMNagshRBHraC

GaCJa)anbgðajÉksarbBa¢IeQμaHGñkeTasmkBItMbn;505

EdlRtÚv)anbBa¢ÚneTAmnÞIrs-21enAExFñÚ qñaM1978edIm,I[

sakSI)anGan. Tak;TgnwgbBaðaenH sakSI)anbBa¢k;fa xøÜn)an

sÁal;EteQμaH sm,tþi mñak;bu:eNÑaH.

3¦ karsYredjedaledayemFavInaMmuxtMNag

edImbNþwgrdæb,evNI

bnÞab;BIbBa©b;karsaksYrrbs;tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa

elakRbFan)anepÞrevTikaCUnemFavInaMmuxtMNagedImbNþwg

rdæb,evNI. shemFavICatitMNagedImbNÒwgrdæb,evNI

elak Ev:n eBA )ancab;epþImedaysYrTak;TgnwgkarcUleFVIbdivtþ.

sakSI)anbBa¢ak;faxøÜn)ancUlbdivtþ eRkayeBlrMedaHextþ

RkecH ehIyrhUtdl;Ex4 qñaM1973xøÜnRtÚv)anEtgtaMg[eFVI

emXuMenA XuMvDÄn³. Tak;TinnwgkarCYbRbCuMCamYy nYn Ca enAqñaM

1973enAeBlenaH RbeTskm<úCakMBugmansRgÁamCamYy

ln; nl; enAeLIy ehIykarRbCuMenaHTak;TgnwgkarbegáItshKmn_

nigshkrN_. enAeBleFVIkarEbgEckCashkrN_emXuMman

naTICaRbFanEdleKehAfaKN³shkrN_ bu:EnþCakargarneya

)ayrbs;bkSeKenAEtehAfaKN³XuMdEdl. elakemFavI

)anesñIsuMbgðajÉksarbTsmÖasn_Tak;TgnwgEpnkarskmμ

PaB. eqIøytbnwgsMNYYrenHsakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa EpnkarRtÚv

eFVIeLIgedayxøÜnÉg ehIyeBlxøHfñak;elICaGñkeFVI. sakSI)an

bEnßmfa xøÜn)anB¤fa bu:l BtCaelxabkSkmμúynIsþkm<úCa

exov sMpn KWCaRbmuxrdæ eGogsarI KWCardæm®nþIRksYgkarbreTs.

tMbn;505KWCatMbn;sVy½t ehIyemXuMCaGñkTTYlxusRtÚvrYm

cMENkGnuXuMTTYlxageyaFa. eyaFaenAtMbn;505mantYnaTI

év:xμaMgenAtamRBMEdncMENkÉxagsnþisuxmantYnaTIxagcab;

cg. ral;karerobkaryuT§Cn GacesñIeTAfñak;RsúkTal;Etman

52 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 55: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

karyl;RBmBIxagnarIeTIbGacerobkar)an.knøgmkmin man

narINamñak;EdlRbEkkminRBmerobkarenaHeLIy. sakSI)an

bBa¢ak;fa karbgMç[CnCaticamhUbsac;RCÚk KWminmanEcgenA

kñúgÉksareLIy ehIykarbgMçenaHRbEhlCaGñkenAtampÞH

)ayEtbu:eNÑaH. bnÞab;mkelakRsIemFavI sIum:UNUhVt )anbnÒ

karsaksYrTak;TgnwgCIvPaBenAtamshkrN_epSg².

sakSI)an bBa¢ak;fakarrs;enArbs;RbCaBlrdæenARsúksMbUr

KWenAXuMxøHhUbbbr ehIymanlaydMLÚgbu:Enþ enAfñak;XuMEdl

xøÜnRKb;RKg KWRbCaCnhUb)ay minmanQWfáat;edaysarkar

eFVIkargareLIy KWedaysarCMgWRKúncaj;Etb:ueNÑaH. cMeBaH

rbbGaharBuMmankarEbgEckrbbGahartamRbePTRbCaCn

cas;GñkeRtómb¤GñkfμIenaHeT.muneBlbBa©b;karsaksYrelak

RsIemFavI)anbnþsMNYr Tak;TgnwgGMNackMBUlrbs; nYn Ca

ehIysakSIk¾)anbBa¢ak;faGMNackMBUlenaHKWsMedAdl;

GMNacfñak;elIrbs;bkS.

4¦ karsYredjedaledayRkúmemFavIkarBar

kþICnCab;ecaT

4>1¦karsaksYredayRkúmemFavIkarBarkþI nYnCa

muneBlcab;epþImelakemFavI GIunUhSIú )ansaksYreTA

GgÁCMnuMCRmHGMBIÉksaredIm,IsaksYrsakSIEdlxøÜndak;CUn

GgÁCMnuMCRmHeFVIkarsMerc. bnÞab;BIkarBiPakSa elakecARkm

nil Nun )anbBa¢ak;faÉksarenaHminmanBak;B½n§nwgPsþútag

enaHeT. elakemFavIGacsYrsMNYrEdlTak;TgnwgÉksarenaH

)an. bnÞab;mkelakRsIecARkm xatRv:ayt_ bBa¢ak; CUnemFavI

fa xøÜnmansiT§isYrsMNYYrEdlBak;B½n§nwgÉksarenaH)an.

PøamenaHemFavI)anbBa¢ak;fa xøÜnnwgminsYrsMNYreTAkan;sakSI

eTKWsuM[kUnkþIrbs;xøÜneFVIesckþIEføgkartbnwgskçIkmμrbs;

sakSITak;TgnwgkarCemøós. elaktMNagshRBHraCGaCJa

nigelakRsIemFavItMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,evNI sIum:UNUhVt

)anCMTas;cMeBaHkareFVIesckþIEføgkarN_rbs; nYn Ca eday

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 53

sakSI exov enA

nYn Ca eFVITsSnkic©enAtammUldæankñúgrbbkm<úCaRbCaFibetyü ¬RbPBÉksar³mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa¦

nYn Ca

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 56: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

GHGagfa CnCab;ecaTminGaceRbIR)as;eBlevlarbs;

tulakaredIm,IeFVIesckþIEføgkarN_tamEtcitþ)aneT. eTaHbICa

y:agNak¾eday elakemFavIenAEtTTUc[kUnkþIrbs;xøÜneFVI

esckþIEføgkarN_ ehIybnÞab;mkelakRbFank¾)anGnuBaØat.

nYn Ca )aneFVIesckþIEføgkarN_tbnwgkarCemøósEdlmanxøwm

sardUcteTA ³

{sUmeKarBbgb¥ÚnrYmCati¡sUmeKarBelak

RbFan¡´sUmniyayGMB IkarCemøós

RbCaCnedaybgçM. ´sUmeFVIkareqøIytb

mYycMnYncMeBaHskçIkmμrbs;elakrUbenH

GMBIkarCemøósRbCaCn. elaksakSI)an

niyayBIehtupld¾RtwmRtÚvxøH² kñúgkar

CemøósRbCaCnecjBITIRkúg KWedIm,Iecos

BIkarTMlak;RKab;Ebkrbs;shrdæGaemrik

nigkarGt;Xøan nigs®gÁamdeNþImKñaeTAvij

eTAmkEtelak sakSIPaKeRcInmin)andwgBI

mUlehtuc,as; nigeRcInCagenHeT ehIy

Edlhak;dUcCabgðajfa ectna b¤meFüa

)ayCemøósdUcCaminl¥eTAvij.teTAenH´

sUmeFVIkareqøIytbdUcteTA³ CadMbUg´sUm

CRmabfa eyIg´CaGñkcaj;s®gÁamRtÚv

)anecaTRbkan;BIkarCemøósRbCaCn

edaybgçM k¾bu:EnþskmμPaBkñúgeBlbc©úb,nñ

enHmanPaBminsmrmü ebIeRbóbeTAnwgkar

CemøósenAbnÞab;éf¶TI17 Exemsa qñaM

1975eTAeTot. ´sUmniyayedIm,IRb

CaCnRkIRkEdlRtÚv)anCiHCan;nigeFVITukç

bukemñjdl;GayuCIvitedayBYkGñkman

luy manbuNüskþiEdlkMBugbøn;dIFøIERs

cMkar>>>}.

kkMMNNtt;;ssmmÁÁaall;;³³ xN³eBlEdl nYn Ca kMBugeFVIesckþIEføgkarN_

rbs;xøÜn elakRbFan)anbBaÄb;karedayGHGagfa kareFVI esc

kþIEføgkarN_enaHcakq¶ayBIGgÁehtuEdlkMBugeFVIsvnakarelI

karsÒab;skçIkmμrbs;sakSIehIybBaðaEdlnYn Ca elIkeLIgenaH

sakSI)anpþl;skçIkmμRKb;RKan;ehIy. elakRbFank¾)an sYr

bBa¢ak;eTACnCab;ecaTfa etIxøÜnmansMNYrepSgEdlRtÚvsYr

EdreT. eqøIytbnwgbBaðaenH nYn Ca )anesñIsuMGgÁCMnuMCRmH

edIm,IniyayBIkarCemøósRbCaCn EteTaHCay:agNa elak

RbFanenAEtminGnuBaØat[CnCab;ecaTeFVIskçIkmμeLIy.

bRmamrbs;elakRbFanminRtÚv)an nYn Ca GnuvtÒtameLIy

edayenAEtbnÒkarbkRsayTaMgkñúgeBlEdl]bkrN_bMBg

semøgminTan;mandMeNIrkarenAeLIy. CafμImÒgeTotelak

RbFanenAEtRbkan;CMhrminGnuBaØat[CnCab;ecaTeFVIkarbk

RsayeLIy.PøamenaHelakemFavI epsþemn )aneRkakQr

eLIg nigesñIsuMelakRbFanedIm,IGnuBaØat[kUnkþIxøÜneFVIesckIþ

EføgkarN_CafμI edaysarminmankarbkERbCaPasaGg;eKøs

nig)araMg. bu:EnþelakRbFanminGnuBaØatenaHeLIy edaymUl

ehtumincg;[cMNayeBlevlabnþsvnakarelIGgÁehtu

EdlminBak;B½n§nigGgÁehtuEdlkMBugdMeNIrkarenHeLIy

ehIyelakk¾)anbgÁab;[emFavIeFVIkarsaksYrshesvikCati

rbs;xøÜncMeBaHesckÒIEføgkarN_EdlminmankarbkERbCa

PasaGg;eKøsenaH. bnÞab;BI)anB¤dUcecñH elak epsþemn

)anesñIsuMdl;GgÁCMnuMCRmHfakUnkþIxøÜnsuMlHbg;siT§imincUlrYm

kñúgkic©dMeNIrkarsvnakareT edaysarxøÜnminmansiT§iniyay

enAkñúgsvnakarenH. elakRbFan)ansaksYr nYn Ca fa etIxøÜn

BitCamanbMNgcUlrYmdMeNIrkarenAbnÞb;eRkamEmnEdrb¤

eT? nYn Ca k¾)anbBa¢ak;fa {CRmabelakRbFan ebImin[´

niyayeToteT ´suMeTAenAxageRkam}.

tamry³karbBa¢ak;BIeKalCMhrrbs;xø ÜndUcenH

elakRbFan)anGnuBaØat[CnCab;ecaTcuHeTAbnÞb;xag

eRkamtamkaresñIsuM ehIyelakRbFan)anepÞrevTikabnÒ

CUnemFavICatirbs; nYn Ca edIm,IeFVIkar saksYr.

elak sun GruN emFavICatikarBarkþI[CnCab;ecaT

nYn Ca )ancab;epþImsaksYrTak;TgnwgkarpSwkelaksgÇ.

54 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 57: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

eqøIytbnwgsMNYrenHsakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa enAqñaM1976 man

karbBa¢ak;BIGaCJaFrfa bdivdþeKmineFVIBIrdgenaHeT KWRtÚveFVI

bdivdþn_RbCaCn nigbdivdþn_vb,Fm’kñúgeBlCamYyKña. Bak;

B½n§nwgGtßn½yenAkñúgTg;bdivdþn_ elakmincaMfaenAkñúgTsSnavdþI

enaHmanEcgBIkarhamXat;min[manvtþGaramb¤Gt;enaHeT

bu:EnÒvaCaneya)ayrbs;mCÄimbkS. elakemFavI)ansYr

bnþTak;TgnwgkarRbCuMCamYynYn Ca Tak;TgnwgxμaMg.sakSI)an

bBa¢ak;faeBlenaH nYn Ca )aneTARbCuMenAXuMda ehIyniyay

BIxμaMgEdlmanGaemrikkaMg nigevotNam ehIyeRkABIenaH

manniyayBIkareFVIshkrN_. sakSI)anbnþfaxøÜn)anCYbEt

nYn Ca mñak;Kt;minmanemdwknaMepSgeTotenaHeT ehIyCYbenA

eBlenaHKWenAkñ úgbnÞb;salsikçasalaEdlmanGñkcUl

rYmmkBIRsúksñÜlsMbUr nigRsúkRkecH. elakemFavI)anbnþ

sYrTak;TgnwgGtþcrikrbs; nYn Ca enAeBlRbCuM. elaktMNag

shRBHraCGaCJa EDl lIsak; )anCMTas;nwgsMNYrrbs;

emFavIEdlsYr[sakSIbBa¢ak;BIcriklkçN³rbs; nYn Ca Edl

vaCakarsμanbu:eNÑaH. PøamenaHelakemFavI)anbBa¢ak;faeday

sarsakSICYbpÞal;CamYy nYn Ca dUecñHcemøIyrbs;sakSI

minEmnCakarsμanenaHeLIy. elaksakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa

enAeBlenaH nYn Ca mancrikl¥smCaGñkdwknaMEdll¥.

muneBlxøÜncUlbdivdþxøÜnminEdleXIjmankarTmøab;RKab;Ebk

eTKWFøab;eXIjenAeBleFVIrdæRbhar ehIyenAqñaM1972xøÜn

)aneXIjmankarbMpøajs<anCaedImesÞIrEtdac;Gs;ehIy.

eBleyaFacUlRsúksMbUrenAqñaM1978 sßanPaBmankar

RcbUkRcbl;edaysarmankarcab;kmμaP i)alfñak ;Xu M

nigRsúk. enAéf¶TI 17 ExemsaqñaM1975sakSIbBa¢ak;faxøÜn

rs;enAXuMvDÆn³ehIy)anB¤tamviTüúfamankarrMedaHTIRkúg.

eBlenaHRbCaCnmankarsb,ayrIkrayNas;enAeBlB¤fa

RbeTsCatiRtÚv)anrMedaH. elakemFavI)anbnÒsYrTak;Tg

nwgkarRbCuM nigRbtikmμrbs;RbCaCnkñúgkarbegáItshkrN_

nigshKmn_. sakSI)anBa¢ak;fa nYn Ca min)aneTAdl;Rsúk

sMbUreT KWeTARbCuMenAd-3 XuMfμda ehIyeBlRtlb;mkvij

man taEct CaGñkerobcMshKmn_. sakSI)anbnþfa taEct

EdlfaKat;CamnusSmancritminl¥eFVIGVItamcitþrbs;xøÜnEt

bu:eNÑaH. emFavI)anbnþsMNYreday[sakSIbBa¢ak;BIPaB

xusKñarvagshkrN_nigshKm_. sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa shkrN_

RbCaCnminsUvdwgeTEtebIshKmn_KWrs;enArYmhUbcukrYm

Kña. bnÞab;BIbBa©b;karsaksYrrbs;emFavIkar BarkÒI nYn Ca elak

RbFan)anepÞrevTikaCUnemFavI eGog sarI edIm,I saksYr bnÒ

bu:EnþemFavI)anbBa¢ak;fa xøÜnminmansMNYreTAsakSIeLIy.

4>2¦ karsYredjedaledayRkúmemFavI

exovsMpn

elakemFavI EvkEKn )ancab;epþImsYrTak;Tgnwgkar

cUlbdivdþrbs;sakSI. sakSI)anbBa¢ak;faeRkayeBlrdæ

RbharqñaM1970 manclna{Xut]tþmÖvgSvDÆna}mYyEdlGH

GagfamkCYyCatibu:EnþxøÜnmineCOTukcitþenaHeLIyehIyeRkay

mkmanclnaExμrRkhmEdlcuHmkbeRgón ehIyeBlenaH

taEct)anykesovePAmk[xøÜneron ehIyeRkaymkxøÜnRtÚv

)anEtgtaMgCaKN³XuMvDÆn³. sakSI)anbEnßmfaxøÜncUlbdivdþ

enAqñaM1971edaycitþxøÜnÉg ehIyeBlenaHxøÜnmancitþcg;

CYyCati[RbCaCnmanCIvPaBsmrmü. Tak;TgnwgCemøaH

rvageyaFa nigGCJaFrenAqñaM1978elaksakSI)an bBa¢ak;

fa xøÜnminsUvdwgc,as;eT bu:EnÒkalenaHman eQμaH suvNÑ )an

yksMbuRtBI san mk[xøÜnfaxagRsúk[ykeKa50k,al

ehIyeRkaymkxageyaFa)ansYrGMBImUlehtu ehIyxøÜn

)anbBa¢ak;faxagRsúk[mkyk. tamry³enH xøÜnGacyl;

)anfaxageyaFa nigGaCJaFrminmanTMnak;TMngl¥CamYyKña

eLIy.bnÞab;BIbBa©b; karsaksYrsakSIyun KIm elak RbFan

GgÁCMnuMCRmH)anRbkasbnþsvnakarsaksYrsakSI mñak;eTot

EdlmanelxsMKal; TCW-321 dUcEdl)aneRKagTuk.

VIII)svnakarsaksYredjedalsakSI exov enA

enAresoléf¶TI20dl;21 Exmifuna qñaM2012

bnÞab;BIGgÁCMnuMCRmH)anbBa©b;kic©dMeNIrkarnItiviFIsaksYr

sakSI yun KIm elakRbFanGgÁCMnM uCRmH)anRbkasbnþ

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 55

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 58: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

svnakarsaksYrsakSI bnÞab;EdlmanelxsMKal; TCW-

321 dUcEdl)aneRKagTuk.sUmbBa¢ak;faenAkñúgkic©dMeNIr

karenHmankarcUlrYmBIRKb;PaKITaMgGs;elIkElgEtCnCab;

ecaTeGogsarIedaysarbBaðasuxPaB nigemFavIGnþrCati

karBarkÒI ém:eXIlxaNav:asminmanvtþman.enAkñúgkic©dMeNIr

karsaksYrelIsakSIrUbenH KWepþateTAelIkarpSwkelaksgÇ

karbegáItshkrN_nigrcnasm<½n§rdæ)alenAkñúgPUmiPaKnirtI

nigkargarrbs;sakSIenATIRkúgPñMeBj. elakRbFan)ancab;epÒIm

edayeFVIkarsaksYrB½t’manmYycMnYnTak;TgnwgRbvtþisavta

rbs;sakSI.sakSI)anbBa¢ak;faxøÜn eQμaH exov enA ekItqñaMcr

Gayu79qñaM RbBn§eQμaH gwm eGOn nigmankUn6nak;. bnÞab;

mkelakRbFan)anpþl;esckþIENnaMmYycMnYndl;sakSITak;

TgnwgsiT§imineqøIydak;BiruT§PaBelIxøÜnÉg ehIynigkrNIkic©

EdlsakSIRtÚvEteqøIynUvGVIEdlxøÜndwg. bnÞab;BIbBa©b;kar

ENnaMTa MgenHrYcmkelakRbFan)anepÞrevTikarCUnPaKI

shRBHraCGaCJaedIm,IeFVIkarsaksYredjedalbnþ.

11¦¦kkaassaakkssYYrreeddaayysshhRRBBHHrraaCCGGaaCCJJaa

elaktMNagshRBHraCGaCJa evgh‘t; )ancab;epþIm

karsaksYredaykarGannUvbTsmÖasn_EdleLIgeday

sakSI nigshecARkmesIubGegátTak;TgnwgTMnak;TMngrbs;

sakSICamYy tam:uk eBlenAbYsCasgÇ.sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa

tam:uk bYsenAvtþRtBaMgFMRbEhldb;qñaM ehIy eBlenaHxøÜnenA

ekμgenAeLIyEdleRkaymk tam:uk )anlakcaksikçabT

ehIyerobkar. enAExemsa qñaM1975ExμrRkhm)an tRmÚv

[RBHsgÇEdlnimnþmkBIextþtaEkv nigPñMeBjeTARbCuMKñaenA

vtþGgÁrkaredIm,IlacaksikçabT ehIyeRkaymkkarRbtþibtÒi

sasnaRtÚv)anlubbM)at;.sakSI)anbBa¢ak;faxøÜnmin)aneXIj

karCemøósRbCaCnecjBIPñMeBjmktaEkveT edayRKan;Etdwg

famanmnusSmkBIPñMeBj nigtaEkvedaysarxøÜn)anB¤BYk

QøbniyayKña nigmankmμaPi)alExμrRkhmedIrtamRbCaCn

edIm,IerobcMkEnøg bu:EnÒxøÜnmin)andwgBIkarbegáItshkrN_

eLIy. bnÞab;mkelaktMNagshRBHraCGaCJa)anepÞr

evTikarsaksYrenHeTAkan;shesvikrbs;xøÜnKWelak farIk

edaycab;epþImsYrTak;TgnwgRBwtþikarN_munqñaM1975.sakSI

)anbBa¢ak;faxøÜnmanRsúkkMeNItenAXuMRtBaMgFM ehIyeRkay

mkXuMenHRtÚv)aneKEbgEckCaBIrKWXuMRtBaMgFMxageCIg nig

RtBaMgFMxagt,Úg. bc©úb,nñxø ÜnmanTIlMenAenAXuMRtBaMgFM

xagt,ÚgCitvtþRtBaMgFM ehIy tam:uk k¾manRsúkkMeNItenAXuM

RtBaMgFMxagt,ÚgEdr. eqøIytbnwgsMNYrCabnþbnÞab;rbs;

shRBHraCGaCJasakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa GgÁkar)anR)ab;xøÜn[

cakecjBIvtþRtBaMgFM ehIyeTACYbCuMKñaenAvtþGgÁrkar.

Tak;Tgnwgkarpøas;TIkEnøgenHsakSI)anbBa¢ak;faxøÜnmindwg

BImUlehtueLIyedaysarenAkñ úgsm½ys®gÁamxø Ün)an

B¤cas;²R)ab;faRtÚv[daMedImKredIm,Irs; dUecñHxøÜnminh‘ansYr

naMBIbBaðaenaHeLIy.enAéf¶TI17 emsamankarpSwk RBHsgÇ

EdlmkBIextþtaEkv nigPñMeBjedaymindwgmUlehtuehIy

enAeBlenaHminmanRBHsgÇNamYyEdlbdiesFminRBm

swkenaHeLIy. tamry³karsnñidæanrbs;xøÜn sakSI)an

bBa¢ak;fa karpSwkRBHsgÇenHKWmankarbBa¢aBIBYkQøb BI

eRBaHxøÜnminEdleXIjmanemdwknaMExμrRkhmcuHeTAdl;tMbn;

rbs;xøÜneLIy. cMeBaHelaksgÇEdlminTan;)answkRtÚv)an

ExμrRkhmnaMmksñak;enAvtþp©wkRCúM ehIyenATIenaHRbCaCnGac

56 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

sakSI exov enA

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 59: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

ykcgðan;eTARbeKnelaksgÇ)anrhUtdl;CagmYyqñaMeTIb

elaksgÇenATIenaHRtÚv)anpSwkTaMgGs;. tMNagshRBH

raCGaCJa)anbnþkarsaksYrTak;TgnwgkarRbtibtÒiRBHBuT§

sasnasakSI)anbBa¢ak;faxøÜnenAEtRbtibtþisasnarhUteday

eKarBenAkñúgcitþ dUecñHminmanGñkNamñak;dwgfaxøÜnenAEteKarB

sasnaenaHeLIy.sakSI)anbBa¢ak;famuneBllacaksikçabT

xøÜn)aneXIjRbCaCnRtÚv)anCemøósecjBIPñMeBjKWeBl

Tahanvaydl;NaRbCaCnenATIenaHRtÚvEtecjmkEdr.

RbCaCnEdlecjmkBIPUmiRtÚveTArs;enAtamshrN_ ehIy

cMENkGñkEdlmkBIPUmiPaKRtÚvrs;enAedayELk.Gñkrs;

enAkñúgshkrN_RtÚveFVIERsrYmKñaedayminmanRbCaCnNa

rs;enAeRkAshkrN_enaHeLIy BIeRBaHenATIenaHmanemkg

nigemRkúmCaGñkRKb;RKg. RbFanXuMTaMgGs;RtÚv)anEtg

taMgedayGgÁkar EdleKehAfaGgÁkarEtgtaMgGgÁkarcat;

taMg. enAeBlenaHmankarGb;rMeronsURtRbCuMTietonEdlRtÚv

)aneFVIeLIgCajwkjab; ehIymanniyayBIbTBiesaFkargar

CaedIm. eBlxøHmankarRbCuMeronsURtnigEckÉksarEfmeTot

pg. cMeBaHTg;bdivdþsakSI)anbBa¢ak;faxøÜnFøab;B¤EtceRmóg

bu:eNÑaHehIyminEdleXIjÉksarenaHeLIy. kareFVIRbvtþirUb

KWsRmab;EtGñkfμI²Etbu:eNÑaH ehIyr)aykarN_TaMgenaHRtÚv

bBa¢ÚneTAGgÁkarfñak;elI bu:EnÒxøÜnmindwgfaGgÁkarCaGñkNaenaH

eT.sakSI)anbEnßmfa RBabKit nig cayKWCaKN³RsúkRtaMkk;

kalCMnan;enaH. eBlxøÜneTAenAmnÞIreBTüxøÜnminTan;RtÚv)an

cat;taMgkargarc,as;las;enAeLIyeT ehIyeRkaymk

KN³kmμkarextþeQμaH esam )anmkR)ab;xøÜn[eTAeFVIkarenA

bnÞayTahanBIsm½y ln; nl; CamYy tam:uk edayeFVICaGñk

kan;luynigCYyeFVIesñótcb. RbEhlqñaM1976xøÜnRtÚv)an

bBa¢Ún[eTAenAxagBaNiC¢kmμdwkCBa¢ÚnenAPñMeBjedIm,IRKb;RKg

GñkebIkLanRbEhldb;nak;edIm,IdwksMPar³BIXøaMgrdæeTA

PUmiPaKEdlmandUcCa can qñaMg eTon eRKÓgEdk sIum:g; Edl

RbCaCn RtÚvkar. ral;kardwkCBa¢ÚnTal;EtmanlixitGnuBaØat

ecjBIfñak;elIxagEpñkesdækic©KW v:n evt ehIymanmnÞIrk-22

CaGñkeFVIkarpÞal;. RbFanXøaMgrdæ maneQμaH erOg ehIyxag

]sSahkmμman ecg Gn. cMENk\v:an;EdldwkBIPUmiPaK

mkXøaMgrdæeTAPñMeBjvijmandUcCa sMLI/ Kr/ dUg nigplitpl

epSgeTotEdlRbCaCneFVI)an.sakSI)anbEnßmfacMeBaHkar

)at;xøÜnrbs; v:n evt/ h‘U nwm nig h‘U yun enaHxøÜnRKan;Et)anB¤tam

eKEtbu:eNÑaHedaymindwgBImUlehtuenaHeLIy. cMENkGñk)at;

xøÜnepSgeTotRtÚv)anecaTfak,t;. cMeBaHkic©RbCuMBIvin½y sakSI

)anbBa¢ak;fa xøÜn)ancUlrYmenAPUmiPaKEdlmanRbFanPUmiPaK

KW sM b‘it GnuRbFanrbs; tamu:k CaGñkbeRgón ehIykic©RbCuMenaH

niyayBImaKa’RbCaCn maKa’c,ab; nigmaKa’bdivdþ. sakSI)an

bBa¢ak;fa eBlEdlxøÜnbMeBjtYnaTIenAPñMeBjxøÜnFøab;)an

eXIj tam:uk nig bu:l Bt. elIsBIenHxøÜn)anCYb exov sMpn

enARksYgBaNiC¢kmμenAeBlEdl exovsMpn eTACMnYs v:n evt

mYyry³. cMeBaHGñkdwknaMenAPUmiPaKnirtIeRkABI tam:uk KWman

fñak;extþ nigxagkgBl )anmkCYbCamYy bu:l BtEdr. tam

ry³karrMB£krbs;shRBHraCGaCJa sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa CU eCt

KWCaGñkFøab;bYseronCamYyxøÜn ehIyeRkaymk CU eCt nig

RbBn§RtÚv)ancab;xøÜnbBa©ÚneTAmnÞIrs-21.

2¦ karsaksYredayemFavItMNagedImbNþwgrdæb,

evNI

elak eBC GgÁ )ancab;epþImedaysaksYrTak;Tgnwg

CMnan;\sSr³ sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa Bakü\sSr³enaHxøÜn)anB¤

taMgBICMnan;)araMgrhUtdl;1967 eTIbman\sSr³ExμrRkhm.

cMENk tam:uk k¾)ancUlrYmkñúgclna\sSr³EdlkalenaH

marbs; tam:uk eFVICaRbFanXuMehIyenAeBl enaH tam:uk man

tYnaTICaesμón. emFavI)anbnþsYrTak;TgnwgkarpSwkRBHsgÇ

sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fa RBHsgÇdwgCamunfanwgmankarpSwk

edaysarenAkñ úglTi §kumμ úynIsþminmankareKarBsasna

eLIy.eTaHbICay:agNak¾edaykarlacaksikçabTenHKWman

BiFIRtwmRtÚvEdlmankarcUlrYmBIRbCaCn.Tak;TgnwgkargarCa

Gñkkan;luy sakSI)anbBa¢ak;fakalenaHxøÜnmin)aneFVIkargar

enHeTedaysarfñak;elI)anhamXat;min[cayluyvij.

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 57

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 60: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

cMeBaHkardwkCBa¢ÚnsmÖar³RtÚvEtmansMbuRtsñamEdlecj

eday tam:uk b¤xagPUmiPaKehIysmÖar³TaMgenaHRtÚv)andwk

CBa©ÚneTAdl;extþkMBg;qñaMg nigextþtaEkvCaedIm. sakSI)an

erobrab;fa xøÜn)anCYb nYn Ca eBl eTAyk]bkrN_ePøgeTAdak;

enAbu:sÒ×viTüú. cMeBaHEpñkBaNiC¢kmμnirtIenaHmanCab;Bak;B½n§

CamYyxagPUmiPaK ehIyRbFanXøaMgrdæenAeBlenaHman

eQμaH erOg.bnÞab;mkelakemFavIGnÒrCati )aNaeb )ansak

sYrbnÒTak;Tg nwgkarCMnYstMENg v:n evt eday exovsMpn.

sakSI )anerobrab;faenHCakarsnñidæanrbs;xøÜnedaysarEtva

minmanÉksarNaEdlniyay[c,as;las;enaHeLIy.

3¦karsaksYredayecARkmLaEv:j

eRkayBI)anbBa©b;karsaksYredayemFavInaMmuxtMNag

edImbNþwgrdæb,evNI elakecARkm LaEv:j )aneFVIkarsaksYr

Tak;TgnwgRsúkkMeNItrbs; tam:uk. sakSI)anbBa¢al;fa

tam:ukmanRsúkkMeNItenAkñúgPUmiCamYyxøÜn.tam:uk)anniyay

faxμaMgKWCaGñkEdlRbqaMgnwgbdivtþ ehIyGñkEdlRbqaMgRtÚv

RbyuT§Kña ehIyxøwmsarBaküeBcn_rbs; tam:uk )anman\T§i

BlmkelImnusSeRcIneTIbGackan;GMNac)an. sakSI)an

erobrab;faxøÜn)anCYb nYn Ca )anmþgenAeBlEdlxøÜneTArk

]bkrN_ePøgeTAdak;enAbu:sþ_viTúü. ral;kardwk\v:an;ecjBI

XøaMgKWmanlixitGnuBaØtBImnÞIrk-22Edlman erOg CaGñk

RbFanXøaMg. kardwkCBa¢ÚneTAkMBg;esam KWdwktamrfePøIg

ehIytYnaTIrbs;xøÜnKWdwkCBa¢ÚnBIPUmiPaKnirtIeTAPñMeBj nig

PñMeBjeTAPUmiPaKnIrtIvijEtbu:eNÑaH.

4¦karsaksYredayRkúmemFavIkarBarkþI nYn Ca

eRkayeBlbBa©b;karsaksYredayelakecARkm

LaEv:j elakRbFanGgÁCMnu MCRmH)anpþl;evTikaCUnRkúm

emFavIkarBarkþI nYn Ca edIm,IeFVIkarsaksYrsakSIbnþ. elak

emFavI epsþemn eFVIkarcab;epþImedayelIkeLIgBIsMeNI

rbs;xøÜnEdldak;CUnGgÁCMnuMCRmHTak;EdlTak;TgnwgÉksarfμI

cMnYnBIrehIymkTl;eBlenHxøÜnminTan;)anTTYldMNwgNamYy

BIGgÁCMnuMCRmHeLIy. bnÞab;BImankarBiPakSarbs;RkúmRbwkSa

CMnuMCRmHrYcmkelakRsIecARkm xatRra:yt_ )anbBa¢ak;fa

GgÁCMnuMCRmH)anTTYlÉksarrbs;emFavIEdldak;mkenaHrYc

ehIy bu:EnþenAeBlemFavIeFVIkareyageTAelIÉksarNamYy

enaHRtÚvbBa¢ak;faetIÉksarenaHRtÚv)andak;enAcMeBaHmuxGgÁ

CMnuMCRmH b¤sßitenAkñúgbBa¢IÉksarrs;PaKINamYyedIm,I[GgÁCMnuM

CRmHeFVIkarsRmc ehIyPøamenaH elakemFavIGHGagfa

ÉksarmYyEdlxøÜn)andak;enaH KWmanenAkñúgbBa¢Irbs;

shRBHGaCJa bu:EnÒÉksarmYyeTotminmanenAkñúgbBa¢ÍeLIy

ehIyxøÜnminmankatBVkic©kñúgkarbgðajB½t’manTaMgenaHeT.

elakRsIecARkm)anbBa¢ak;CafμImþgeTotfa elakemFavIGac

saksYredayeFVIkareyagEtelIÉksarEdlmanenAkñúgbBa¢I.

bnÞab;BIkarbBa¢ak;rbs;elakRsIecARkmelakemFavI)anGHGag

fa sMNYrEdlxøÜnnwgsYrsakSIKWEp¥keTAelIÉksarTaMgBIr

edayminGacxVHmYyNa)an dUecñHxøÜnnwgminmansMNYreTAsakSI

enaHeLIy.cMENkemFavIkarBarkþITaMgBIrRkúmepSgeTot k¾)an

bBa¢ak;BICMhmineFVIkarsaksYreTAkan;sakSIEdr. muneBl

bBa©b;kic©dMeNIrkar nItiviFIelakRbFanGgÁCMnuMCRmH)anRbkas

nUvesckþIRBmandl;RkúmemFavIkarBarkÒIrbs;CnCab; ecaT nYn Ca

enAkñúgdMeNIrkarsvnakarkñúgsMNuMerOg002 edayGgÁCMnuM

CRmHeFVIkarkt;smÁal;eTAelITegVIrbs;RkúmemFavIkarBarkÒI

cMnYnbIcMNucdUcCa ³

- karrMelaPedayectnaelIesckþIbgÁab;nanarbs;

GgÁCMnuMCRmH

-karbeBa©jÉksarsmat; b¤smat;bMputeTAsarB½t’

manedayKμankarGnuBaØatnig

- kareFVIesckþIEføgkarN_nanakñúgtulakarmineKarB

dl;tulakarb¤minRsbtamniyam nigRkmsIlFm’viC¢aCIv³c,ab;

EdlmankarTTYlsÁal;eLIy.

GMeBI nigKMrUenH nwgRtÚvGgÁCMnuMCRmHbBa¢ÚneTAkan;KN³

emFavItamviFan38énviFanépÞkñúg. eRkABIenaH elakRbFan

)anRbkasGMBIkarp¥akkic©dMeNIrkarnItiviFIEdlnwgbnþeFVIenA

éf¶TI16 Exkkáda qñaM2012elIkarsaksYrGñkCMnajKW elak

58 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 61: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

edvId eqndø½r.

bbBBaaððaaeeppSSgg²²

kñúgGMLúgeBlsvnakarsþab;skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI kn

cMnYnbIéf¶eBj CnCab;ecaT eGog sarI )anlHbg;siT§icUlrYm

svnakaredaypÞal; edayseRmccUlrYmsvnakarBIcm¶ay

tamry³ RbB½n§esatTsSn_EdlRtÚv)anerobcMTukenAbnÞb;rg

caMenAeRkambnÞb;salsvnakar. mUlehtuénkarlHbg;siT§i

enHKWedaysarCnCab;ecaT eGog sarI manbBaðasuxPaB

edayminGacGgÁúy enAkñúgbnÞúb;salsvnakar)an. dUecñH

CnCab;ecaT eGogsarI RtÚv)antMNagedayemFavI TaMgBIrrUb

rbs;xøÜnenAkñúgkic©dMeNIrkarsYrsakSIkñúgry³eBlbIéf¶eBj

enH.cMENkCnCab;ecaT nYn Ca EtgEtesñIsMucUlrYmsvnakar

BIcm¶ayenAbnÞb;rgcaMenAeBlresolbnÞab;BIxøÜn)ancUlrYm

svnakaredaypÞal;enAeBlRBwkedaypþl;ehtufa manbBaða

suxPaBminGacGgÁúykñúgbnÞb;svnakar)an. manEtCnCab

;ecaT exov sMpn Etmñak;Kt;EdlGaccUlrYmsvnakareday

pÞal;kñúgry³eBlmYyéf¶eBjCaerogral;éf¶.

kñúgGMLúgeBlsYredjedalsakSI eGOn tan

KWmanbBaðamYycMnYnKYr[kt;smÁal;dUcCa³

muneBlekaHehAsakSI eGOn tan cUlkñúgsalsvna

kar elakemFavI ém:eXIl xaNav:as; esñIsMukarENnaMBIGgÁCMnMu

CRmH [ )anc,as;GMBIkareRbIR)as;cemøIyrbs;sakSIkñúgkar

sYrp©aj;. sMeNIenHeFVIeLIgbnÞab;BIGgÁCMnMuCRmHseRmcTTYl

ykkarCMTas;rbs;tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa cMeBaHsMNYr

rbs;RkúmemFavIkarBarkþICnCab;ecaT nYn Ca. sMeNIenH

minRtÚv)anGgÁCMnMuCRmHseRmckñúgGMLúgeBlsvnakarenH

eLIy edayGgÁCMnMuCRmHbgÁab;[elakemFavI xaNav:as

bBa¢ak;CalaylkçGkSr[)anc,as;GMBIeKalbMNgrbs;xøÜn

kñúgkaresñIsMuedIm,I[GgÁCMnMuCRmHseRmcenAeBleRkay.

KYrrMB£kfa enAeBlsvnakarsþab;skçIkmμrbs;sakSI xwwm gn

RkúmemFavIkarBarkþICnCab;ecaT nYn Ca )anykcemøIyEdl

elak xwm gn pþl;CUntMNagshRBHraCGaCJarYcehIymk

ecaTsYrsakSIdEdlenHmþgeTotkñúgeKalbMNgsYrp©aj;.

b:uEnþminRtÚv)anGgÁCMnMuCRmHGnuBaØat edayelakpþl;sMGag

ehtufaCasMNYrRcMEdl.

bBaðamYyeTotKYr[kt;smÁal; KWBak;B½n§nwgkarecaT

sMNYrsakSIedaytMNagshRBHraCGaCJaCati. elak)an

ecaTsMNYrmYycMnYneTAelak eGOn tan EtsMNYrTaMgenaHmin

)anTTYlcemøIyeLIy edaysakSIbBa¢ak;fa KWCasMNYrEdl

hYsBIsmtßPaBEdlelakGaceqøIy)an. PøamenaH elak

emFavI ém:eXIl xaNav:as; elIkeLIgfa tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa

)ansYrsMNYr CaeRcInEdlx<s;CagtMENgEdlsakSIGac

dwg. dUecñHKb,IsYrsMNYrNaEdlRsbnwgdMENgrbs;

sakSIGacdwg)an eBalKWminGacsYrelIGgÁehtuTaMgmUlén

sMNMuerOgedIm,I[sakSIbBa¢ak;)aneLIy. bnÞab;BIkar

elIkeLIgrbs;elakemFavI xaNav:as; RbFanGgÁCMnMuCRmH

bBa¢ak;bEnßmfa {>>>sMNYrEdlBak;B½n§ KWmanenAkñúgkMNt;ehtu

CamUldæanénGñkesIubGegátrbs;kariyal½yshecARkmesIub

Gegát)anerobcMrYcehIy. sMNYrCamUldæan fasakSINadwg

erOgGI!CamUldæanCasMxan;enaH. sakSINadwgGgÁehtuTUlM

TUlaytaMgBIedImrhUtdl;cb;? rhUtGgÁCMnMuCRmHseRmc

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa 59

ecARkm nil Nun

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 62: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

[taMgsMNYredjedalelIsakSIenaHkñúgvisalPaBénsMNMu

erOg002TaMgmUl. dUcCasakSIpþl;skçIkmμkalBImSil

mijehIysakSIepSg²eTotKWmanmUldæankt;smÁal;eday

GñkesIubGegátrYcehIy faKat;sÁal; Kat;dwgCak;c,as;Bak;B½n§

eTAnwgGgÁehtu b¤RBwtþehtuNamYyenAkñúgdIkadMeNaHRsay

EdlBak;B½n§nwgkareFVIskçIkmμrbs;Kat;. sUmtRmg;Tis[

cMbBaða minsYredIm,I[)anEtsYrenaHeT KWsYredIm,I)ancemøIy

EdlqøúHbBa©aMgkarBiteTAnwgGgÁehtuEdlecaTRbkan;eTAnwg

bTelμIsEdlecaTRbkan;CaPsþútagEdlqøúHbBa©aMgfaman

BiruT§PaB b¤KμanBiruT§PaB EdlCamUldæankñúgkarBicarNaseRmc

cugeRkayénsalRkmrbs;GgÁCMnMuCRmH. sUmkMNt;eKaledA

kñúgkartaMgsMNYr[)anc,as;las; kmμvtßúénkarsYrcMeBaHsakSI

mYy[)anRtwmRtÚv nigqab;rh½s.>>>elaktaMgsMNYrbnþeTot

ecosvagsMNYrnaMmuxsMNYrRcMEdlsMNYr]bmaviFI sMNYreRkA

GgÁehtuCaedIm. sMNYrKYrEtxøI²edIm,I[sakSIEdlKat;Gac

eqøIy)an minEmnsMNYrsYrsMxan;sYrrhUtsakSIsþab;min yl;

sMNYrfasMNYrenaHvaGs©acarüenaHeT}.

bBaðacugeRkay KWBak;B½n§nwgkarbgðajÉksaredIm,I

rMB£kdl;karcgcaMrbs;sakSI. CaTUeTAkñúgkarsYredjedal

sakSI GgÁCMnMuCRmHGnuBaØat[PaKIykcemøIyEdlsakSI)an

pþl;skçIkmμenAcMeBaHmuxshecARkmesIubGegátmksYrbBa¢ak;

enA cMeBaHmuxxøÜn¬GgÁCMnMu CRmH¦edIm,IrMB£kkar cgcaMrbs;sakSI.

eTaHbImankarGnuvtþCaTUeTAdUecñHk¾edayb:uEnþenAEtmanPaBmin

c,as;las;sRmab; PaKImYycMnYnenAkñúg erOgkþI. Cak;Esþgkñúg

karsYredjedalsakSI eGOn tan tMNagshRBHraCGaCJa

dak;bgðajÉksarEdlsakSIrUbenH)anpþl;skçIkmμCUnsh

ecARkmesIubGegát edIm,IsYrbBa¢ak;sarCafμIenAcMeBaHmuxGgÁ

CMnMuCRmH. b:uEnþRtÚv)an elak GakTY Ev:kEKn CaemFavIkarBarkþI

CnCab;ecaT exov sMpn eFVIkarCMTas; ehIyelak)anesñI[

tMNagshRBHraCGaCJaBnül;GMBImUlehtukñúgkardak;bgðaj

ÉksarenH edayelakelIkeLIgfa{>>>shRBHraCGaCJa)an

eRbIskçIkmμEdlfasakSImincaMGMBIesckþIlm¥itEdlKat;)an

pþl;CUn. \LÚvenHRBHraCGaCJaKat;)anpþl;CUnnUvcMNuc

c,as;² cMNucCak;lak;EdlsakSIKat;mincaMenaHeT. dUecñH

´Kitfa karCMnMuCRmHenHminGaceFVIeTAdUecñH)anenaHeT eyIg

minGacRKan;EtGankMNt;ehtuBImunrbs;sakSI ehIyyk

mk[Kat;eqøIyenaHeT. eyIgRKan;EtGaneLIgvij ehIysYr

fa etIGIcwgmaneT b¤minEmnGIcwgenaH KWGaceFVI)anedaymin

caM)ac;mansakSIenaHeT. ´minyl;GMBIviFIsa®sþrbs;sh

RBHraCGaCJaeLIy dUecñH´sUm[shRBHraCGaCJaBnül;

GMBIviFIsa®sþenH}. CakareqøIytb elak tarIk bBa¢ak;fa{ ´

RKan;EtsYrbBa¢ak;GMBIcemøIyrbs;Kat; edayehtufaKat;)an

eqøIy4qñaMknøgeTAehIyenaH KWfavaGacmanPaBxusKñakñúg

kMriténkarcgcaMrbs;Kat;. dUecñHehIy)anCa´cg;[sakSI

emIlcemøIyrbs;Kat; ehIy[Kat;bBa¢ak;fa etIRtwmRtÚveday

esμaHRtg;Edrb¤Gt;>>>}.bnÞab;BIkarbMPøWrbs;tMNagshRBH raC

GaCJa GgÁCMnM uCRmH)anseRmcbdiesFkarelIkeLIgrbs;

elakemFavIkarBarkþI edayelakbBa¢ak;fa PaKIGaceFVIdUecñH )an.

BinitünigepÞógpÞat;eday v:an;fan; eBAdar:a

60 mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa

sisSkMBugykÉkB½tmantulakarxøH²muncUlbnÞb;svnakar

segátkarN_ ³ dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExμrRkhm

Page 63: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

QQuunnllII TTYl)an

briBaØab½Rtc,ab; BIsakl

viTüal½yPUminÞnItisa®sþ

nigviTüasa®sþesdækic©.

ssuuCCaattaa CanisSitfñak;

briBaØab½RtEpñkc,ab; sikSa

CaPasaGg;eKøsenAsakl

viTüal½yPUminÞnItisa®sþ

nigviTüasa®sþesdækic©.

CC½½yyTT½½ttþþ TTYl)an

briBaØab½Rtc,ab; BIsakl

viTüal½yPUminÞnItisa®sþ

nigviTüasa®sþesdækic©.

C½yT½tþ CaGtItC½ylaPI

fñak;CatienAkñúgkarRbkYt

svnakarRbDit qñaM2010.

RR))aaffññaa TTYl)an

briBaØab½Rtc,ab; BIsakl

viTüal½yPUminÞnItisa®sþ

nigviTüasa®sþesdækic©.

R)afña sBVéf¶kMBugeRtóm

RbLgsikSaviC¢aCIv³emFavI

enAkm<úCa.

llwwmm CC½½yyTT½½ttþþ ccaann RR))aaffññaaqqaayy QQuunnllII DDII ssuuCCaattaa¬¬

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCaRbGb;sMbuRtelx1110/ PñMeBj RBHraCaNacRkkm<úCa

TUrs½BÞ ³ ¬855¦23211875

TUrsar ³ ¬855¦23210358

GuIEm:l ³ [email protected]

eKhTMB½r ³ www.dccam.org b¤ www.cambodiatribunal.org

KeRmagenHTTYlCMnYyhirBaØvtßúBImUlniFi

John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation and

British Embassy-Cambodia.

l>r eQμaHedIm eQμaHbdivtþ elxsm¶at; RbPBÉksar

1 saLút s b:ul Bt/ bgb:ul/ bgTI1/ 870/ 87 D427, E1/56.1

2 Lúg riT§ nYn Ca/ bgnYn/ bgTI2 ¬Gt;dwg¦ D427

3 KIm Rtag eGog sarI/ v:an; ¬Gt;dwg¦ D427, E1/21.1

4 exov sMpn Ehm/ xag/ Nn ¬Gt;dwg¦ D427

5 sun esn exov/ Xwm 89/ 62 E1/54.1

Bnül;BaküsMxan;²

s-21 ³ mnÞIrsnþi)als-21 KWCamnÞIrsnþisuxsm¶at;

rbs;nKr)alEdlmanTItaMgenATIRkúgPñMeBj.

GKÁesnaFikar ³ TIbBa¢akarCan;x<s;énkgT½Bbdivtþkm<úCaEdl

dwknaMeday sun esn sßitenATIRkúgPñMeBj.

k-1 ³ lMenAdæanmYyrbs;smaCiknanaénKN³kmμaFikar

Gcié®nþy_ nigCakEnøgeFVIkarrbs; b:ul Bt.

k-2 ³ elxkUdsmÁal;sRmab;RksYgsgÁmkic©.

k-3 ³ lMenAdæanmYyrbs;smaCiknanaénKN³kmμaFikar

Gcié®nþy_ nigCakEnøgeFVIkarrbs; nYn Ca nig

exov sMpn.

Page 64: dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhmd.dccam.org/Projects/ECCC_Trial_Observation/pdf/...dMeNIrkat;eTasemdwknaMExµrRkhm segátkarN_ matika bBaðasuxPaB eGog sarI 2 skçIkmμrbs;sakSI nI

mCÄmNÐlÉksarkm<úCa rkSasiT§i Exkkáda qñaM2012¬¬RRbbPPBBÉÉkkssaarr ³³ mmCCÄÄmmNNÐÐllÉÉkkssaarrkkmm<<úúCCaa¦¦

nYn Ca

eGog sarI

sun esn