Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf ·...

27
Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran Fan*, Zhijie Zhang*, Wade Trappe*, Yanyong Zhang*, Rich Howard*, and Zhu Han** *Wireless Information Network Laboratory, Rutgers University, USA **Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Houston, USA

Transcript of Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf ·...

Page 1: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Distributed Beamforming for PHY

Layer Secret Communication

Xiaoran Fan*, Zhijie Zhang*, Wade Trappe*, Yanyong

Zhang*, Rich Howard*, and Zhu Han**

*Wireless Information Network Laboratory,

Rutgers University, USA

**Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering,

University of Houston, USA

Page 2: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

Secret Communication is Important

2

Eavesdropping

Page 3: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

Cryptography and PHY Layer Security

Cryptography

- At the cost of lowering data rate

- Computationally expensive

PHY layer security methods

+ Simple

+ Low overhead

+ Could Increase data rate

+ Could complement cryptography-based methods

3

Page 4: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

Traditional Beamforming

Feedback pilots

Same injection angle θ for all TXs

A popular solution

for PHY secret comm

Clustered

transmitters,

faraway receiver

Plane wave for

transmitters

Optimization based

beamformer: MRC,

ZF

Page 5: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

Beamforming for Secret Communication

Generating a high

energy beam

towards Bob Directionality

Minimizing energy

towards Eve

Jamming Eve

Page 6: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

Concerns in BF Secret Communication

Often assuming Eves’ locations are known Not practical

High energy along the beam path Eve B can overhear everything

Introducing noise to jam Eves

6

Page 7: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

Overview of Secret-Focus

Distributed Transmitters No communication among transmitters

Distributed synchronization

Transmitters are not clustered, but

distributed around the receiver

Distributed Phase Alignment

(DPA) at the receiver Distributed Beamforming

Received signals are constructively

added up at Bob

Phased Array

Bob

Page 8: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

A Closer Look at Communication Bits

Def: Secret Communication

Ratio(SCR): α=μ/σ

Page 9: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

Secret Communication in Information Theory

The lower αeve and higher αbob the better system secrecy rate

Page 10: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

Secret Focus Design Goals

The target location has the highest RSS, μ

The target location has the lowest RSS variation, σ

Secret Communication

Ratio(SCR): α=μ/σ

Page 11: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

Secret-Focus Mechanism I

Combing phases of distributed transmitters at

Bob

Page 12: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

DPA through Feedback Control Loop

We choose a closed-loop feedback controlled phase

alignment method Random phase searching at the TX end

Feedback from the RX end

TX1

TX2

TX3

iteration

1iteration

2

initial iteration

N

feedback1 Alignedfeedback2

Page 13: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

DPA through Feedback Control Loop

We choose a closed-loop feedback controlled phase

alignment method Random phase searching at the TX end

Feedback from the RX end

Initial state

RSS

Page 14: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

We choose a closed-loop feedback controlled phase

alignment method Random phase searching at the TX end

Feedback from the RX end

First feedback

N=3 random phase adjustments

RSS

iteration

1

DPA through Feedback Control Loop

Page 15: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

We choose a closed-loop feedback controlled phase

alignment method Random phase searching at the TX end

Feedback from the RX end

Second feedback

N=3 random phase adjustments

Best in iteration 1

RSS

iteration

2

DPA through Feedback Control Loop

iteration

1

Page 16: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

We choose a closed-loop feedback controlled phase

alignment method Random phase searching at the TX end

Feedback from the RX end

Convergence

RSS

iterations

DPA through Feedback Control Loop

Page 17: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

Energy Density Distribution

Bob has the highest μ!

Bob

Page 18: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

A Spatial View of the ‘Focused Energy’

Page 19: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

20

Orbit Testbed

Page 20: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

Experimental Measurements

Received power distribution in BF Received power distribution in DPA

Page 21: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

Secret-Focus Mechanism II

Dithering transmitters’ phases around the

alignment phases

Intuition: relative ‘flat’ at sinusoid signal’s peak.

Bob’s location, small slope

Eve’s location, large slope

Page 22: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

Phase Dithering

Bob has the lowest σ!

RSS derivative as a function

of distance to Bob

Bob

Page 23: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

An Example Experiment

RSS at Eve,

no mechanism

RSS at Eve,

mechanism 1

RSS at Eve,

mechanism 1+2RSS at Bob,

mechanism 1+2,

BER=0

BER>40%

Page 24: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

BER with Eve at Extreme Locations

Bob Eve5cm

Extreme location test is the

Achilles' heel of current PHY

layer security approaches

Page 25: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

Secret Communication Ratio Measurement

Bob

Bob has the highest α, Eves at

other locations have very low α

Measurement locations illustration

Page 26: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

Secret-Focus Summary

A PHY layer secret communication approach

No noise introduced

Eves’ locations are not necessary to be known

Strong performance when Eve is placed at extreme

locations

27

Thank you!

Page 27: Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communicationox5bc/paper/Secret_Focus_Slides.pdf · 2018-04-23 · Distributed Beamforming for PHY Layer Secret Communication Xiaoran

Xiaoran Fan [email protected]

WINLAB

28