Provisions, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets BAS 37
Contingent Commissions and Market Cycles
description
Transcript of Contingent Commissions and Market Cycles
2007 ARIA Meeting, Quebec City
Contingent Commissions and Market Cycles
Lan Ju
Mark Browne
University of Wisconsin-Madison
2007 ARIA Meeting, Quebec City
Question
Do profit-based contingent commissions dampen the underwriting cycle?
2007 ARIA Meeting, Quebec City
Simple Illustration
Time
C
NC
Soft Mkt Hard Mkt
Underwriting Margin
2007 ARIA Meeting, Quebec City
Background on Contingent Commission Compensation Structure to Brokers - Direct Commissions (Traditionally) - Contingent Commissions Profit-based Volume-based ( PSA )
Current Issue: - RIMS against supplemental commissions
Focus !Focus !
2007 ARIA Meeting, Quebec City
A Portion of Contingent Commission Bonus Matrix
Current Year Limited Loss Ratio(%) <30 30.1- 34 34.1- 37 37.1- 40 40.1- 43 43.1- 46
Premiums Written($)
<249,999 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
250,000-499,999 0.80 0.71 0.63 0.56 0.50 0.45
500,000-999,999 1.18 1.06 0.95 0.86 0.77 0.70
1,000,000-1,999,999 1.74 1.58 1.44 1.31 1.19 1.08
2,000,000-2,999,999 1.92 1.74 1.58 1.44 1.31 1.19
3,000,000-3,999,999 2.11 1.92 1.74 1.58 1.44 1.31 Source: CNA 2006 Addendum to Agency Agreement
2007 ARIA Meeting, Quebec City
Example
$2,500,000 premiums written
Current year limited loss ratio is 30%
Contingent commission
= $2,500,000 * 0.0192 = $48,000
2007 ARIA Meeting, Quebec City
Relevant Literature – Market Cycles Rational Expectation Theory: Perfect market - Cummins and Outreville (1987)
Capacity Constraint Theory: Not perfect market - Winter(1988, 1991a, 1994) - Gron (1994) - Cummins and Danzon(1992) - Doherty and Garven(1995)
Risky Debt Theory: Insurer’s default risk - Harrington et. al. (1988,1994, 2004, 2005) - Cummins and Danzon(1997)
2007 ARIA Meeting, Quebec City
Harrington (2004 & 2005)
Proxy: Loss ratio development = Developed loss ratios -
Originally reported loss ratios
Argument: - Premium growth in the soft market is positively
correlated with loss ratio development - Excessive price cuts in the preceding soft market are
associated with upward claims costs development in the subsequent hard market Trigger the formation of hard market !
2007 ARIA Meeting, Quebec City
Monitoring by Motivated Brokers
Insurer
Brokers
Contingent Comm.
Good Business
Clients
Identify Insurer
Long-TermRelation
2007 ARIA Meeting, Quebec City
PNC
Another Description
SLNC
SNCSNC’D SC’ SC
SLC
P
Q
PNC’
PC’
PC
2007 ARIA Meeting, Quebec City
Hypothesis and Data
Data: - NAIC 1997-2005 - 5-year loss development - Focus on latter part of soft market 97-00
Hypothesis: - Insurers who pay greater contingent commissions are associated with smaller loss ratio development Cycles are dampened !
2007 ARIA Meeting, Quebec City
Modeling (Firm-Specific Approach)
Problem: Endogeneity
LRDi,t = α + β1LnGrowthi,t + β2CONCOMi,t
+ β3ROAi,t + β4RBCi,t + β5Herfindahli,t + β6Longtaili,t + β7Sizei,t + β8Stocki,t+ β9Groupi,t + εi,t
2007 ARIA Meeting, Quebec City
First-Stage: Tobit Regression
CONCOMi,t = α + β1ROAi,t + β2 RBCi,t + β3 Herfindahli,t + β4Longtaili,t + β5Sizei,t + β6 Stocki,t
+ β7Groupi,t + εi,t
Second-Stage: IV Regression (Primary Interest) LRDi,t = α + β1LnGrowthi,t + β2 PredCONCOMPredCONCOMi,ti,t + β3ROAi,t
+ β4RBCi,t + β5 Herfindahli,t + β6 Longtaili,t + β7 Sizei,t + β8Stocki,t + β9Groupi,t + εi,t
Two-Stage Regression
2007 ARIA Meeting, Quebec City
IV Regression (97-00, N=3,043)
Covariates Estimate Robust Std. Error
Intercept -0.3667 0.4376
LnGrowth 0.1644 0.09321*
PredCONCOM -10.1420 1.2252***
ROA -0.3368 0.08665***
RBC 0.000548 0.000732
Herfindahl -0.2769 0.1378**
Longtail -0.1551 0.09797
Size 0.03487 0.02072*
Stock 0.1514 0.01584***
Group 0.01540 0.05907
-2log likelihood 9181.1
2007 ARIA Meeting, Quebec City
Conclusion
Consistent with Prior Literature:
Stronger Premium Growth Greater LRD New Findings:
Greater contingent commission payments
Less severe upward loss development Further Research:
- Longer period of data
- Incorporate multi-period theoretical model
2007 ARIA Meeting, Quebec City
Thank You !