Conservation of Apis mellifera from Africanized hybrids Amy Schabel.

13
Conservation of Apis mellifera from Africanized hybrids Amy Schabel

Transcript of Conservation of Apis mellifera from Africanized hybrids Amy Schabel.

  • Conservation of Apis mellifera from Africanized hybrids Amy Schabel

  • Background on HoneybeesHoneybeeBumble bee

  • Why are honeybees important?

  • Honeybee GeneticsQueen, Worker, DroneThe Queen

  • Africanized HoneybeeHybrids that are creating competition and inbreeding

  • Genetic Impacts on the HoneybeeDecrease amount of individuals with each generationHybrids taking over colonies and the genetic diversity of Apis mellifera

  • ObjectivesTo see if the bottle neck and genetic drifts were impacting Apis melliferas genetic make up.Specifically looked at heterozygosity to see if has been impacted by the hybrids by:Compare Ho and He of different populationsComapre Ho between lineagesComapre Ho between Africanized and Non-Africanized colony populations

  • MethodsResearch articles and books for more knowledge on the honeybee itself and the genetic impacts the honeybee is going through.

  • Conclusiont-ratio = 7.40p < 0.05

    Chart1

    0.6180.016220.01622

    0.498

    Difference: He - Ho

    Figure 1. Comaprison of Ho values and He values from six loci all samples were taken from thirteen Apis mellifera populations from nine different countries throughout the world.

    Sheet1

    0.01622

    MeanStandard Error

    He0.618Africanized Colonies0.750.056

    Ho0.498Non-Africanized Colonies0.390.037

    MeanStandard Error

    A0.830.06

    C0.530.06

    M0.340.04

    Sheet1

    00.016220.01622

    0

    Difference: He - Ho

    Figure 1. Comaprison of Ho values and He values from six loci all samples were taken from thirteen Apis mellifera populations from nine different countries throughout the world.

    Sheet2

    00.0560.037

    0

    Ho

    Figure 2. Comarison of Ho mean values of Africanized colonies and Non-Africanized colonies from six loci from thirteen Apis mellifera populations from nine different countries throughout the world.

    Sheet3

    00.060.06

    00.060.06

    00.040.04

    Lineages

    Ho

    Figure 3. Comparison of Ho mean values of the three lineages of Apis mellifera from six loci from thirteen Apis mellifera populations from nine different countries throughout the world.

    Table 1. Population differences of Ho and He of mtDNA among different locations of the Old World and divided by the three lineages of the honey bee, Western Europe (M), Eastern Europe (C) and African (A).

    PopulationHoHeLocusAfricanized (+/-)Region (Old vs. New World)Lineage

    Avignon0.7940.882B124-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Avignon0.3540.790A7-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Avignon0.0000.000A24-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Avignon0.6680.885A113-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Avignon0.3710.475A28-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Avignon0.0000.000A88-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.8760.907B124-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.1740.647A7-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.2980.492A24-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.5050.740A113-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.0850.266A28-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.0430.266A88-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Ume0.8970.908B124-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Ume0.1380.492A7-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Ume0.2600.492A24-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Ume0.2710.792A113-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Ume0.0450.268A28-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Ume0.0000.000A88-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Forli0.5880.787B124-Italy - Old WorldC

    Forli0.8160.823A7-Italy - Old WorldC

    Forli0.6070.629A24-Italy - Old WorldC

    Forli0.4590.470A113-Italy - Old WorldC

    Forli0.0660.468A28-Italy - Old WorldC

    Forli0.1880.468A88-Italy - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.7590.870B124-Germany - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.7770.872A7-Germany - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.6290.645A24-Germany - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.6870.795A113-Germany - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.2370.485A28-Germany - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.5680.645A88-Germany - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.8840.910B124-Greece - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.6860.912A7-Greece - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.5240.468A24-Greece - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.3570.823A113-Greece - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.2120.478A28-Greece - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.5840.729A88-Greece - Old WorldC

    Johannesburg0.8830.921B124+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Johannesburg0.9140.921A7+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Johannesburg0.7790.835A24+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Johannesburg0.9080.903A113+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Johannesburg0.8730.905A28+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Johannesburg0.8730.913A88+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.8790.900B124+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.8530.882A7+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.8000.827A24+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.8580.859A113+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.8630.916A28+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.7260.827A88+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.8750.893B124+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.8190.907A7+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.6110.660A24+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.7710.881A113+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.7880.854A28+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.8360.854A88+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Mallorca0.6430.862B124+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Mallorca0.4000.529A7+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Mallorca0.1050.101A24+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Mallorca0.8570.853A113+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Mallorca0.6000.678A28+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Mallorca0.3680.468A88+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.6670.866B124-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.1910.601A7-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.1000.311A24-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.7140.743A113-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.3720.414A28-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.2160.415A88-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.4580.770B124-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.0590.164A7-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.2170.199A24-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.6960.798A113-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.0000.000A28-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.0440.043A88-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera0.2860.643B124-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera0.0000.000A7-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera0.5000.403A24-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera1.0000.792A113-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera0.0000.000A28-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera0.0000.278A88-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

  • ConclusionF = 28.61p < 0.05

    Chart2

    0.750.0560.037

    0.39

    Ho

    Figure 2. Comarison of Ho mean values of Africanized colonies and Non-Africanized colonies from six loci from thirteen Apis mellifera populations from nine different countries throughout the world.

    Sheet1

    0.01622

    MeanStandard Error

    He0.618Africanized Colonies0.750.056

    Ho0.498Non-Africanized Colonies0.390.037

    MeanStandard Error

    A0.830.06

    C0.530.06

    M0.340.04

    Sheet1

    00.016220.01622

    0

    Difference: He - Ho

    Figure 1. Comaprison of Ho values and He values from six loci all samples were taken from thirteen Apis mellifera populations from nine different countries throughout the world.

    Sheet2

    00.0560.037

    0

    Ho

    Figure 2. Comarison of Ho mean values of Africanized colonies and Non-Africanized colonies from six loci from thirteen Apis mellifera populations from nine different countries throughout the world.

    Sheet3

    00.060.06

    00.060.06

    00.040.04

    Lineages

    Ho

    Figure 3. Comparison of Ho mean values of the three lineages of Apis mellifera from six loci from thirteen Apis mellifera populations from nine different countries throughout the world.

    Table 1. Population differences of Ho and He of mtDNA among different locations of the Old World and divided by the three lineages of the honey bee, Western Europe (M), Eastern Europe (C) and African (A).

    PopulationHoHeLocusAfricanized (+/-)Region (Old vs. New World)Lineage

    Avignon0.7940.882B124-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Avignon0.3540.790A7-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Avignon0.0000.000A24-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Avignon0.6680.885A113-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Avignon0.3710.475A28-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Avignon0.0000.000A88-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.8760.907B124-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.1740.647A7-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.2980.492A24-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.5050.740A113-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.0850.266A28-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.0430.266A88-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Ume0.8970.908B124-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Ume0.1380.492A7-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Ume0.2600.492A24-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Ume0.2710.792A113-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Ume0.0450.268A28-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Ume0.0000.000A88-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Forli0.5880.787B124-Italy - Old WorldC

    Forli0.8160.823A7-Italy - Old WorldC

    Forli0.6070.629A24-Italy - Old WorldC

    Forli0.4590.470A113-Italy - Old WorldC

    Forli0.0660.468A28-Italy - Old WorldC

    Forli0.1880.468A88-Italy - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.7590.870B124-Germany - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.7770.872A7-Germany - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.6290.645A24-Germany - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.6870.795A113-Germany - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.2370.485A28-Germany - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.5680.645A88-Germany - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.8840.910B124-Greece - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.6860.912A7-Greece - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.5240.468A24-Greece - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.3570.823A113-Greece - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.2120.478A28-Greece - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.5840.729A88-Greece - Old WorldC

    Johannesburg0.8830.921B124+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Johannesburg0.9140.921A7+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Johannesburg0.7790.835A24+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Johannesburg0.9080.903A113+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Johannesburg0.8730.905A28+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Johannesburg0.8730.913A88+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.8790.900B124+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.8530.882A7+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.8000.827A24+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.8580.859A113+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.8630.916A28+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.7260.827A88+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.8750.893B124+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.8190.907A7+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.6110.660A24+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.7710.881A113+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.7880.854A28+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.8360.854A88+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Mallorca0.6430.862B124+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Mallorca0.4000.529A7+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Mallorca0.1050.101A24+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Mallorca0.8570.853A113+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Mallorca0.6000.678A28+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Mallorca0.3680.468A88+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.6670.866B124-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.1910.601A7-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.1000.311A24-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.7140.743A113-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.3720.414A28-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.2160.415A88-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.4580.770B124-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.0590.164A7-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.2170.199A24-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.6960.798A113-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.0000.000A28-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.0440.043A88-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera0.2860.643B124-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera0.0000.000A7-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera0.5000.403A24-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera1.0000.792A113-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera0.0000.000A28-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera0.0000.278A88-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

  • ConclusionF =24.11p < 0.05

    Chart1

    0.830.060.06

    0.530.060.06

    0.340.040.04

    Lineages

    Ho

    Figure 3. Comparison of Ho mean values of the three lineages of Apis mellifera from six loci from thirteen Apis mellifera populations from nine different countries throughout the world.

    Sheet1

    0.01622

    MeanStandard Error

    He0.618Africanized Colonies0.750.056

    Ho0.498Non-Africanized Colonies0.390.037

    MeanStandard Error

    A0.830.06

    C0.530.06

    M0.340.04

    Sheet1

    00.016220.01622

    0

    Difference: He - Ho

    Figure 1. Comaprison of Ho values and He values from six loci all samples were taken from thirteen Apis mellifera populations from nine different countries throughout the world.

    Sheet2

    00.0560.037

    0

    Ho

    Figure 2. Comarison of Ho mean values of Africanized colonies and Non-Africanized colonies from six loci from thirteen Apis mellifera populations from nine different countries throughout the world.

    Sheet3

    00.060.06

    00.060.06

    00.040.04

    Lineages

    Ho

    Figure 3. Comparison of Ho mean values of the three lineages of Apis mellifera from six loci from thirteen Apis mellifera populations from nine different countries throughout the world.

    Table 1. Population differences of Ho and He of mtDNA among different locations of the Old World and divided by the three lineages of the honey bee, Western Europe (M), Eastern Europe (C) and African (A).

    PopulationHoHeLocusAfricanized (+/-)Region (Old vs. New World)Lineage

    Avignon0.7940.882B124-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Avignon0.3540.790A7-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Avignon0.0000.000A24-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Avignon0.6680.885A113-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Avignon0.3710.475A28-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Avignon0.0000.000A88-Southern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.8760.907B124-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.1740.647A7-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.2980.492A24-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.5050.740A113-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.0850.266A28-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Valenciennes0.0430.266A88-Northern France - Old WorldM

    Ume0.8970.908B124-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Ume0.1380.492A7-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Ume0.2600.492A24-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Ume0.2710.792A113-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Ume0.0450.268A28-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Ume0.0000.000A88-Sweden - Old WorldM

    Forli0.5880.787B124-Italy - Old WorldC

    Forli0.8160.823A7-Italy - Old WorldC

    Forli0.6070.629A24-Italy - Old WorldC

    Forli0.4590.470A113-Italy - Old WorldC

    Forli0.0660.468A28-Italy - Old WorldC

    Forli0.1880.468A88-Italy - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.7590.870B124-Germany - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.7770.872A7-Germany - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.6290.645A24-Germany - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.6870.795A113-Germany - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.2370.485A28-Germany - Old WorldC

    Berlin0.5680.645A88-Germany - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.8840.910B124-Greece - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.6860.912A7-Greece - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.5240.468A24-Greece - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.3570.823A113-Greece - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.2120.478A28-Greece - Old WorldC

    Chalkidiki0.5840.729A88-Greece - Old WorldC

    Johannesburg0.8830.921B124+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Johannesburg0.9140.921A7+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Johannesburg0.7790.835A24+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Johannesburg0.9080.903A113+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Johannesburg0.8730.905A28+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Johannesburg0.8730.913A88+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.8790.900B124+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.8530.882A7+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.8000.827A24+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.8580.859A113+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.8630.916A28+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Cape Town0.7260.827A88+South Africa - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.8750.893B124+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.8190.907A7+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.6110.660A24+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.7710.881A113+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.7880.854A28+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Tiznit0.8360.854A88+Morocco - Old WorldA

    Mallorca0.6430.862B124+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Mallorca0.4000.529A7+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Mallorca0.1050.101A24+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Mallorca0.8570.853A113+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Mallorca0.6000.678A28+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Mallorca0.3680.468A88+Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.6670.866B124-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.1910.601A7-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.1000.311A24-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.7140.743A113-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.3720.414A28-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Menorca0.2160.415A88-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.4580.770B124-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.0590.164A7-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.2170.199A24-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.6960.798A113-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.0000.000A28-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Ibiza0.0440.043A88-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera0.2860.643B124-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera0.0000.000A7-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera0.5000.403A24-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera1.0000.792A113-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera0.0000.000A28-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

    Formentera0.0000.278A88-Balearic Islands - Old WorldM

  • DiscussionHeterozygosity of Apis mellifera is decreasing due to the Africanized hybrid.The Africanized honeybee are spreading at a high rate, taking over Apis melliferas colonies.A decrease in honeybees leads to a decrease in genetic diversity of bees and plants and will also impact the economics of our country.

  • DiscussionConservation tactics should be taken to preserve the genetics of this species.Also research into parasites and pesticides should be done to further investigate colony collapse incidents.