ㆲ 繽

2018 3 2 ㆮㆲㆹㇰ 緺

鮫146899鮫146899 蕯薄 ㆮㆭ146899挽 誉鬎lt ktashiroresilience-japanorg gt

簗 鑪 綯ㆲ誀繽

2

3

ㅹ ㅳㅸ㆕ㅎ繇 ㅹㆲ160766 ㅶ 聆ㅣ ㅖ ㅟㅱㅎㅵㅎㄊ

魯 ㅕ㆕繇 ㅹㆲ ㅡㅶㅙㅎ魯 ㅶ徽ㅡㅱ

ㆬㅡㅶㅙㅎ

谹 蔐ㄉ ㄉ ㅵㅴ

ㅹㆲㅹ 魂觕 ㅡㅶㅙㅎㆲ貹簪ㅹ

ㅪㆌㅹ 蝍 ㅡㅶㅙㅎ

ㆲ160766 聆ㅣ ㅹ ㅖㄉ繇 ㅹㆲ貹簪肪 ㅣㄊ

ㆮㇱㅵ 繽ㅹ 肪 ㅣ

ㅲㅺ繇 ㅹㆲ 聆ㅹㇰㇻㆹㅳ 聆 ㅡㄉㅨㅹ鶒 ㅣ ㅶㅯㅎㅱ ㅣㄊ

4

魯 ㅕ㆕ㅹ 聆ㅶ翻 ㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅣㅪㆌㄉ蕯 颴ㅶ頃ㅰㅎㅱ 聆ㅣㅝㅳ螻 ㅳㅣ

ㅝㆉㅲㅹ ㅹ

bull 蔐 ㅶ ㆲㅹbull 2017 鮫146899鮫146899 謙 (^_^

bull ㄔ繇 ㅹㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣ簗 194675 - 繇 ㅹㆲ聆ㅣ ㅹ ㅶ貹ㅛㅪ頃 -ㄕ

bull 螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋 耏bull 駄 鄩146899繽 146899繽 ㄖㆮㇱㇹㇼㄗ 16 ㅶ

ㅟㅪbull ㄔ 鮫 螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ魂觕ㅶ ㅣ 蜋

繇 ㅹㆲ 聆ㅣ ㅹ ㅶ貹ㅛㅪ頃 ㄕbull httpwwwsmfgrjppaper2016htm

5

繇 ㅶ ㅣㆲㅹ160766bull 羆㆕ㅕㅹ魯 紉ㅕ㆕ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅌㅳㄉ蓿ㅹ ㅶ

ㅹㅖ ㆉㅡㅎㅳㅣ ㅒbull Sheffi 2005 ㄉPonomarov and Holcomb 2009 ㄉBruneau

et al 2003 ㄉㅵㅴ

bull 蓿ㅶ 縄魯ㅶㆍ ㆉㅡㅎ ㅖㅌ ㅳㅎㅐ ㅒbull Christpher and Peck 2004 ㄉMcManus et al 2008 ㄉ

Hollnagel 2011 ㄉ 2015 ㄉㅵㅴ

bull 閔 ㄉ閔 ㅶㅔㅛ160766bull ISO PAS 223992007 --gt ISO 223002012 --gt ISO 223162017bull BS 650002014 閔閔

6

ㆲ

胯ㄉ

ㄉ

ㄉ

ㅳ

ㅳ

ㆹ

ㅳ ㅳ

ㅎ徽

綯 肦ㅳㆹ

ㅹ 鑞

ㆲ ㅶ ㆌ㆕ 謙螭

ㆲ ㅹ ㅶㅯㅵㅖ 裑

蛭 Airmic Road to resilience - Building dynamic approaches to risk to achieve future success 2014

ㆲㅹ裑 ㄉ謙螭ㄉ 鑞ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol43 20145ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

7

Resilience Benchmarking Tool RBTㅹㆲㅹㇴㇹㆷㆺ ㅐㅪㆌㅹㆬ

ㅹ 較ㅶ鑚 ㅡㅱㆍ㆕ㅐㆬ ㅖ3 ㅯㅹ ㄉ13 ㅹ ㅶ

ㅟㅱㅎㄊ

薩 ㅡㅕ ㅵㅎ 颴ㆍㅳㅶㄉ鑚 ㅹ粔 ㅶ頃ㅰㅎㅱ鑚 ㅟㅦ逞ㅵㅹㅲㄉ160766 聆ㅶㅺ簯貹ㅗㅫㅖㄉㇰㇻㆹㅳㅡㅱㅺ ㄊ

ㅲㄉ阷鞹ㆮㇰ ㅐ繇 ㅵㅴ徽 ㅳㅡㅱㄉRBT ㅎㅱ

ㅡㅪ ㅖ蕯 ㅟㅱㅎㄊBrown 緢 2014

蛭 Brown C et al 2014

ㆴㆹ鮫146899ㄉㆵㇴ鮫146899籯 ㅳㅡㅪ ㇲㆺㇻㄔResilient Organisationsㄕㅶ㆔ㅮㅱ ㅟㅪㄊ

8

httpwwwresorgsorgnz

BSI 閔 誀繽 PAS 7000Supply chain risk management - Supplier prequalification

Core prequalification topic modulesC1 Organizational Profile ゎC2 Supplier capabilities and capacities ゎC3 Financial Information amp Insurance ゎC4 Business Governance ゎC5 Employment PoliciesC6 Health and safety ゎC7 Data protection ゎC8 Environmental managementC9 Quality management

Additional prequalification topic modulesA1 Business ethicsA2 Supply chain traceability ゎA3 Supply chain security managementA4 Equal opportunity and freedomA5 Disciplinary practices and abuseA6 Business continuity management ゎ

繇 ㅖㇲㆮㇿㅶ徽ㅡㅱ紿螻 195038 ㅐ ㅶ翻 ㅟㅝㅳ 160766ㅡㅱ羖 ㅟㅪ ㅹ蕯 緡

Publicly Available Specification

ㇲㆮㇿ膛 ㅹ繇 ㅳ谹 麄ㅣ ㅶ

ㅣㆄㅗ ㅖㅶ賰ㆉㅱㅎㄊ

ゎ ㅺㆲㅶ ㅣㅳㅒ㆕

RBT ㅹ ㅶ ㅱㅺㆌㅱㆲㅹ 聆 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅣ

9

ㆲㅹ ㅴㅐ ㅣㅕbull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 綯 ㅹ 紺 薩bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵ

ㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎㅹㅲㅌㅻㄉㅨㅹㇻㅺㆲㅲ ㅌㅳ ㅒ

10

鮫146899薄貯蝝 綯 颴ㇻ鞹 貪

ㄔㇻㆲㇲㆱㆹㄕ

Bouning Forward ㅳㅎㅐ ㅒ

蛭 International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies World Disaster Report 2016 踸 ㅺ

11

ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol58 201611ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

饌 緢ㅶ㆔ ㅹ耏

12

（出所）塩崎由加藤孝明菅寛（2015）「然災害に対する都市システムのレジリエンスに関する概念整理」『学会論集D3（計画学）』Vol 71No3p 127-140

紉ㅹㆮㇲ紿 綯 紺 薩

阷 署 魯署 薩 魯

豹 籯 魯ㇼㅹㇱ

籯 ㄤ籯 薩 魯

署 魯較ㅹ簯 紿 籯 薩

颻ㅹ魂觕 魯

13

ㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣㅶㅺㄉㅝㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ ㅵ蜋 ㅺ 貪ㅖ ㅎㄊ

褧ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅺ紿 ㅞㅳㅶ ㅒ ㅖ

蜋ㅕㅣㅎㄊㅪㅫㅡ蕠ㅱㅹ紿

ㅶ蜮 ㅣㅝㅳㅺㅲㅗㅵㅎㄊ

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅐ ㅶㅺㄉㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ 紉ㅹㆮㇲ徽 ㅳㅣㅹㅕㄉ

羆㆕ㅕㅹ ㅲ 160766ㅣ ㅖㅌㄊ

鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ bull 苤ㅖ ㅡㅱ 螻ㅳ貯ㅢ羃蝿ㅲ 褜ㅖㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅵㅮㅪ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣbull 颻ㅹ 舺 ㅶ缽ㅎㄉ簗 ㅶ緢 颻緢 ㅶㅱ緺 ㅐ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎbull ㆌㅱ簯褜 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅗ 閃㆔ㅐㅵ颻貪ㅶ ㅣ ㅪㅫㅡ

繽 貰ㄉ 鄩 ㄉ 較ㅵㅴㅶ ㅖㅌ

14

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅲㅺㄉㅹㅪㆌㅹ ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅹㆲ ㅒㅹㅕ

ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㄔ ㆲㄕㅲ ㅣ紿ㅖ魂

螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋bull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 鮫 ㅶ㆔閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵㅕ㆕ㅹ

bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵ 誀 繽 ㅹㅐㅬ簪颻繇 90

bull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull 粔ㅔ㆔ㅾ谹 蔐ㅹ 颻ㅕ㆕ ㅪ ㆲ

bull 粔 蝝 ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 3 蠔縄薩bull 谹 蔐 鬟簪 躻ㆉㅪㅺ 耷ㅡㅪ ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 1 蠔縄薩

15

綉 螄谹 ㅹ ㅶ ㅣ頃 ㅶ頃ㅰㅙ

蜋 鬟簪

16

蜋 蝝

17

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

2

3

ㅹ ㅳㅸ㆕ㅎ繇 ㅹㆲ160766 ㅶ 聆ㅣ ㅖ ㅟㅱㅎㅵㅎㄊ

魯 ㅕ㆕繇 ㅹㆲ ㅡㅶㅙㅎ魯 ㅶ徽ㅡㅱ

ㆬㅡㅶㅙㅎ

谹 蔐ㄉ ㄉ ㅵㅴ

ㅹㆲㅹ 魂觕 ㅡㅶㅙㅎㆲ貹簪ㅹ

ㅪㆌㅹ 蝍 ㅡㅶㅙㅎ

ㆲ160766 聆ㅣ ㅹ ㅖㄉ繇 ㅹㆲ貹簪肪 ㅣㄊ

ㆮㇱㅵ 繽ㅹ 肪 ㅣ

ㅲㅺ繇 ㅹㆲ 聆ㅹㇰㇻㆹㅳ 聆 ㅡㄉㅨㅹ鶒 ㅣ ㅶㅯㅎㅱ ㅣㄊ

4

魯 ㅕ㆕ㅹ 聆ㅶ翻 ㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅣㅪㆌㄉ蕯 颴ㅶ頃ㅰㅎㅱ 聆ㅣㅝㅳ螻 ㅳㅣ

ㅝㆉㅲㅹ ㅹ

bull 蔐 ㅶ ㆲㅹbull 2017 鮫146899鮫146899 謙 (^_^

bull ㄔ繇 ㅹㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣ簗 194675 - 繇 ㅹㆲ聆ㅣ ㅹ ㅶ貹ㅛㅪ頃 -ㄕ

bull 螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋 耏bull 駄 鄩146899繽 146899繽 ㄖㆮㇱㇹㇼㄗ 16 ㅶ

ㅟㅪbull ㄔ 鮫 螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ魂觕ㅶ ㅣ 蜋

繇 ㅹㆲ 聆ㅣ ㅹ ㅶ貹ㅛㅪ頃 ㄕbull httpwwwsmfgrjppaper2016htm

5

繇 ㅶ ㅣㆲㅹ160766bull 羆㆕ㅕㅹ魯 紉ㅕ㆕ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅌㅳㄉ蓿ㅹ ㅶ

ㅹㅖ ㆉㅡㅎㅳㅣ ㅒbull Sheffi 2005 ㄉPonomarov and Holcomb 2009 ㄉBruneau

et al 2003 ㄉㅵㅴ

bull 蓿ㅶ 縄魯ㅶㆍ ㆉㅡㅎ ㅖㅌ ㅳㅎㅐ ㅒbull Christpher and Peck 2004 ㄉMcManus et al 2008 ㄉ

Hollnagel 2011 ㄉ 2015 ㄉㅵㅴ

bull 閔 ㄉ閔 ㅶㅔㅛ160766bull ISO PAS 223992007 --gt ISO 223002012 --gt ISO 223162017bull BS 650002014 閔閔

6

ㆲ

胯ㄉ

ㄉ

ㄉ

ㅳ

ㅳ

ㆹ

ㅳ ㅳ

ㅎ徽

綯 肦ㅳㆹ

ㅹ 鑞

ㆲ ㅶ ㆌ㆕ 謙螭

ㆲ ㅹ ㅶㅯㅵㅖ 裑

蛭 Airmic Road to resilience - Building dynamic approaches to risk to achieve future success 2014

ㆲㅹ裑 ㄉ謙螭ㄉ 鑞ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol43 20145ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

7

Resilience Benchmarking Tool RBTㅹㆲㅹㇴㇹㆷㆺ ㅐㅪㆌㅹㆬ

ㅹ 較ㅶ鑚 ㅡㅱㆍ㆕ㅐㆬ ㅖ3 ㅯㅹ ㄉ13 ㅹ ㅶ

ㅟㅱㅎㄊ

薩 ㅡㅕ ㅵㅎ 颴ㆍㅳㅶㄉ鑚 ㅹ粔 ㅶ頃ㅰㅎㅱ鑚 ㅟㅦ逞ㅵㅹㅲㄉ160766 聆ㅶㅺ簯貹ㅗㅫㅖㄉㇰㇻㆹㅳㅡㅱㅺ ㄊ

ㅲㄉ阷鞹ㆮㇰ ㅐ繇 ㅵㅴ徽 ㅳㅡㅱㄉRBT ㅎㅱ

ㅡㅪ ㅖ蕯 ㅟㅱㅎㄊBrown 緢 2014

蛭 Brown C et al 2014

ㆴㆹ鮫146899ㄉㆵㇴ鮫146899籯 ㅳㅡㅪ ㇲㆺㇻㄔResilient Organisationsㄕㅶ㆔ㅮㅱ ㅟㅪㄊ

8

httpwwwresorgsorgnz

BSI 閔 誀繽 PAS 7000Supply chain risk management - Supplier prequalification

Core prequalification topic modulesC1 Organizational Profile ゎC2 Supplier capabilities and capacities ゎC3 Financial Information amp Insurance ゎC4 Business Governance ゎC5 Employment PoliciesC6 Health and safety ゎC7 Data protection ゎC8 Environmental managementC9 Quality management

Additional prequalification topic modulesA1 Business ethicsA2 Supply chain traceability ゎA3 Supply chain security managementA4 Equal opportunity and freedomA5 Disciplinary practices and abuseA6 Business continuity management ゎ

繇 ㅖㇲㆮㇿㅶ徽ㅡㅱ紿螻 195038 ㅐ ㅶ翻 ㅟㅝㅳ 160766ㅡㅱ羖 ㅟㅪ ㅹ蕯 緡

Publicly Available Specification

ㇲㆮㇿ膛 ㅹ繇 ㅳ谹 麄ㅣ ㅶ

ㅣㆄㅗ ㅖㅶ賰ㆉㅱㅎㄊ

ゎ ㅺㆲㅶ ㅣㅳㅒ㆕

RBT ㅹ ㅶ ㅱㅺㆌㅱㆲㅹ 聆 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅣ

9

ㆲㅹ ㅴㅐ ㅣㅕbull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 綯 ㅹ 紺 薩bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵ

ㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎㅹㅲㅌㅻㄉㅨㅹㇻㅺㆲㅲ ㅌㅳ ㅒ

10

鮫146899薄貯蝝 綯 颴ㇻ鞹 貪

ㄔㇻㆲㇲㆱㆹㄕ

Bouning Forward ㅳㅎㅐ ㅒ

蛭 International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies World Disaster Report 2016 踸 ㅺ

11

ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol58 201611ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

饌 緢ㅶ㆔ ㅹ耏

12

（出所）塩崎由加藤孝明菅寛（2015）「然災害に対する都市システムのレジリエンスに関する概念整理」『学会論集D3（計画学）』Vol 71No3p 127-140

紉ㅹㆮㇲ紿 綯 紺 薩

阷 署 魯署 薩 魯

豹 籯 魯ㇼㅹㇱ

籯 ㄤ籯 薩 魯

署 魯較ㅹ簯 紿 籯 薩

颻ㅹ魂觕 魯

13

ㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣㅶㅺㄉㅝㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ ㅵ蜋 ㅺ 貪ㅖ ㅎㄊ

褧ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅺ紿 ㅞㅳㅶ ㅒ ㅖ

蜋ㅕㅣㅎㄊㅪㅫㅡ蕠ㅱㅹ紿

ㅶ蜮 ㅣㅝㅳㅺㅲㅗㅵㅎㄊ

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅐ ㅶㅺㄉㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ 紉ㅹㆮㇲ徽 ㅳㅣㅹㅕㄉ

羆㆕ㅕㅹ ㅲ 160766ㅣ ㅖㅌㄊ

鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ bull 苤ㅖ ㅡㅱ 螻ㅳ貯ㅢ羃蝿ㅲ 褜ㅖㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅵㅮㅪ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣbull 颻ㅹ 舺 ㅶ缽ㅎㄉ簗 ㅶ緢 颻緢 ㅶㅱ緺 ㅐ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎbull ㆌㅱ簯褜 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅗ 閃㆔ㅐㅵ颻貪ㅶ ㅣ ㅪㅫㅡ

繽 貰ㄉ 鄩 ㄉ 較ㅵㅴㅶ ㅖㅌ

14

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅲㅺㄉㅹㅪㆌㅹ ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅹㆲ ㅒㅹㅕ

ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㄔ ㆲㄕㅲ ㅣ紿ㅖ魂

螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋bull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 鮫 ㅶ㆔閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵㅕ㆕ㅹ

bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵ 誀 繽 ㅹㅐㅬ簪颻繇 90

bull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull 粔ㅔ㆔ㅾ谹 蔐ㅹ 颻ㅕ㆕ ㅪ ㆲ

bull 粔 蝝 ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 3 蠔縄薩bull 谹 蔐 鬟簪 躻ㆉㅪㅺ 耷ㅡㅪ ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 1 蠔縄薩

15

綉 螄谹 ㅹ ㅶ ㅣ頃 ㅶ頃ㅰㅙ

蜋 鬟簪

16

蜋 蝝

17

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

3

ㅹ ㅳㅸ㆕ㅎ繇 ㅹㆲ160766 ㅶ 聆ㅣ ㅖ ㅟㅱㅎㅵㅎㄊ

魯 ㅕ㆕繇 ㅹㆲ ㅡㅶㅙㅎ魯 ㅶ徽ㅡㅱ

ㆬㅡㅶㅙㅎ

谹 蔐ㄉ ㄉ ㅵㅴ

ㅹㆲㅹ 魂觕 ㅡㅶㅙㅎㆲ貹簪ㅹ

ㅪㆌㅹ 蝍 ㅡㅶㅙㅎ

ㆲ160766 聆ㅣ ㅹ ㅖㄉ繇 ㅹㆲ貹簪肪 ㅣㄊ

ㆮㇱㅵ 繽ㅹ 肪 ㅣ

ㅲㅺ繇 ㅹㆲ 聆ㅹㇰㇻㆹㅳ 聆 ㅡㄉㅨㅹ鶒 ㅣ ㅶㅯㅎㅱ ㅣㄊ

4

魯 ㅕ㆕ㅹ 聆ㅶ翻 ㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅣㅪㆌㄉ蕯 颴ㅶ頃ㅰㅎㅱ 聆ㅣㅝㅳ螻 ㅳㅣ

ㅝㆉㅲㅹ ㅹ

bull 蔐 ㅶ ㆲㅹbull 2017 鮫146899鮫146899 謙 (^_^

bull ㄔ繇 ㅹㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣ簗 194675 - 繇 ㅹㆲ聆ㅣ ㅹ ㅶ貹ㅛㅪ頃 -ㄕ

bull 螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋 耏bull 駄 鄩146899繽 146899繽 ㄖㆮㇱㇹㇼㄗ 16 ㅶ

ㅟㅪbull ㄔ 鮫 螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ魂觕ㅶ ㅣ 蜋

繇 ㅹㆲ 聆ㅣ ㅹ ㅶ貹ㅛㅪ頃 ㄕbull httpwwwsmfgrjppaper2016htm

5

繇 ㅶ ㅣㆲㅹ160766bull 羆㆕ㅕㅹ魯 紉ㅕ㆕ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅌㅳㄉ蓿ㅹ ㅶ

ㅹㅖ ㆉㅡㅎㅳㅣ ㅒbull Sheffi 2005 ㄉPonomarov and Holcomb 2009 ㄉBruneau

et al 2003 ㄉㅵㅴ

bull 蓿ㅶ 縄魯ㅶㆍ ㆉㅡㅎ ㅖㅌ ㅳㅎㅐ ㅒbull Christpher and Peck 2004 ㄉMcManus et al 2008 ㄉ

Hollnagel 2011 ㄉ 2015 ㄉㅵㅴ

bull 閔 ㄉ閔 ㅶㅔㅛ160766bull ISO PAS 223992007 --gt ISO 223002012 --gt ISO 223162017bull BS 650002014 閔閔

6

ㆲ

胯ㄉ

ㄉ

ㄉ

ㅳ

ㅳ

ㆹ

ㅳ ㅳ

ㅎ徽

綯 肦ㅳㆹ

ㅹ 鑞

ㆲ ㅶ ㆌ㆕ 謙螭

ㆲ ㅹ ㅶㅯㅵㅖ 裑

蛭 Airmic Road to resilience - Building dynamic approaches to risk to achieve future success 2014

ㆲㅹ裑 ㄉ謙螭ㄉ 鑞ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol43 20145ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

7

Resilience Benchmarking Tool RBTㅹㆲㅹㇴㇹㆷㆺ ㅐㅪㆌㅹㆬ

ㅹ 較ㅶ鑚 ㅡㅱㆍ㆕ㅐㆬ ㅖ3 ㅯㅹ ㄉ13 ㅹ ㅶ

ㅟㅱㅎㄊ

薩 ㅡㅕ ㅵㅎ 颴ㆍㅳㅶㄉ鑚 ㅹ粔 ㅶ頃ㅰㅎㅱ鑚 ㅟㅦ逞ㅵㅹㅲㄉ160766 聆ㅶㅺ簯貹ㅗㅫㅖㄉㇰㇻㆹㅳㅡㅱㅺ ㄊ

ㅲㄉ阷鞹ㆮㇰ ㅐ繇 ㅵㅴ徽 ㅳㅡㅱㄉRBT ㅎㅱ

ㅡㅪ ㅖ蕯 ㅟㅱㅎㄊBrown 緢 2014

蛭 Brown C et al 2014

ㆴㆹ鮫146899ㄉㆵㇴ鮫146899籯 ㅳㅡㅪ ㇲㆺㇻㄔResilient Organisationsㄕㅶ㆔ㅮㅱ ㅟㅪㄊ

8

httpwwwresorgsorgnz

BSI 閔 誀繽 PAS 7000Supply chain risk management - Supplier prequalification

Core prequalification topic modulesC1 Organizational Profile ゎC2 Supplier capabilities and capacities ゎC3 Financial Information amp Insurance ゎC4 Business Governance ゎC5 Employment PoliciesC6 Health and safety ゎC7 Data protection ゎC8 Environmental managementC9 Quality management

Additional prequalification topic modulesA1 Business ethicsA2 Supply chain traceability ゎA3 Supply chain security managementA4 Equal opportunity and freedomA5 Disciplinary practices and abuseA6 Business continuity management ゎ

繇 ㅖㇲㆮㇿㅶ徽ㅡㅱ紿螻 195038 ㅐ ㅶ翻 ㅟㅝㅳ 160766ㅡㅱ羖 ㅟㅪ ㅹ蕯 緡

Publicly Available Specification

ㇲㆮㇿ膛 ㅹ繇 ㅳ谹 麄ㅣ ㅶ

ㅣㆄㅗ ㅖㅶ賰ㆉㅱㅎㄊ

ゎ ㅺㆲㅶ ㅣㅳㅒ㆕

RBT ㅹ ㅶ ㅱㅺㆌㅱㆲㅹ 聆 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅣ

9

ㆲㅹ ㅴㅐ ㅣㅕbull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 綯 ㅹ 紺 薩bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵ

ㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎㅹㅲㅌㅻㄉㅨㅹㇻㅺㆲㅲ ㅌㅳ ㅒ

10

鮫146899薄貯蝝 綯 颴ㇻ鞹 貪

ㄔㇻㆲㇲㆱㆹㄕ

Bouning Forward ㅳㅎㅐ ㅒ

蛭 International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies World Disaster Report 2016 踸 ㅺ

11

ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol58 201611ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

饌 緢ㅶ㆔ ㅹ耏

12

（出所）塩崎由加藤孝明菅寛（2015）「然災害に対する都市システムのレジリエンスに関する概念整理」『学会論集D3（計画学）』Vol 71No3p 127-140

紉ㅹㆮㇲ紿 綯 紺 薩

阷 署 魯署 薩 魯

豹 籯 魯ㇼㅹㇱ

籯 ㄤ籯 薩 魯

署 魯較ㅹ簯 紿 籯 薩

颻ㅹ魂觕 魯

13

ㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣㅶㅺㄉㅝㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ ㅵ蜋 ㅺ 貪ㅖ ㅎㄊ

褧ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅺ紿 ㅞㅳㅶ ㅒ ㅖ

蜋ㅕㅣㅎㄊㅪㅫㅡ蕠ㅱㅹ紿

ㅶ蜮 ㅣㅝㅳㅺㅲㅗㅵㅎㄊ

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅐ ㅶㅺㄉㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ 紉ㅹㆮㇲ徽 ㅳㅣㅹㅕㄉ

羆㆕ㅕㅹ ㅲ 160766ㅣ ㅖㅌㄊ

鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ bull 苤ㅖ ㅡㅱ 螻ㅳ貯ㅢ羃蝿ㅲ 褜ㅖㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅵㅮㅪ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣbull 颻ㅹ 舺 ㅶ缽ㅎㄉ簗 ㅶ緢 颻緢 ㅶㅱ緺 ㅐ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎbull ㆌㅱ簯褜 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅗ 閃㆔ㅐㅵ颻貪ㅶ ㅣ ㅪㅫㅡ

繽 貰ㄉ 鄩 ㄉ 較ㅵㅴㅶ ㅖㅌ

14

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅲㅺㄉㅹㅪㆌㅹ ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅹㆲ ㅒㅹㅕ

ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㄔ ㆲㄕㅲ ㅣ紿ㅖ魂

螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋bull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 鮫 ㅶ㆔閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵㅕ㆕ㅹ

bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵ 誀 繽 ㅹㅐㅬ簪颻繇 90

bull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull 粔ㅔ㆔ㅾ谹 蔐ㅹ 颻ㅕ㆕ ㅪ ㆲ

bull 粔 蝝 ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 3 蠔縄薩bull 谹 蔐 鬟簪 躻ㆉㅪㅺ 耷ㅡㅪ ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 1 蠔縄薩

15

綉 螄谹 ㅹ ㅶ ㅣ頃 ㅶ頃ㅰㅙ

蜋 鬟簪

16

蜋 蝝

17

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

ㅹ ㅳㅸ㆕ㅎ繇 ㅹㆲ160766 ㅶ 聆ㅣ ㅖ ㅟㅱㅎㅵㅎㄊ

魯 ㅕ㆕繇 ㅹㆲ ㅡㅶㅙㅎ魯 ㅶ徽ㅡㅱ

ㆬㅡㅶㅙㅎ

谹 蔐ㄉ ㄉ ㅵㅴ

ㅹㆲㅹ 魂觕 ㅡㅶㅙㅎㆲ貹簪ㅹ

ㅪㆌㅹ 蝍 ㅡㅶㅙㅎ

ㆲ160766 聆ㅣ ㅹ ㅖㄉ繇 ㅹㆲ貹簪肪 ㅣㄊ

ㆮㇱㅵ 繽ㅹ 肪 ㅣ

ㅲㅺ繇 ㅹㆲ 聆ㅹㇰㇻㆹㅳ 聆 ㅡㄉㅨㅹ鶒 ㅣ ㅶㅯㅎㅱ ㅣㄊ

4

魯 ㅕ㆕ㅹ 聆ㅶ翻 ㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅣㅪㆌㄉ蕯 颴ㅶ頃ㅰㅎㅱ 聆ㅣㅝㅳ螻 ㅳㅣ

ㅝㆉㅲㅹ ㅹ

bull 蔐 ㅶ ㆲㅹbull 2017 鮫146899鮫146899 謙 (^_^

bull ㄔ繇 ㅹㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣ簗 194675 - 繇 ㅹㆲ聆ㅣ ㅹ ㅶ貹ㅛㅪ頃 -ㄕ

bull 螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋 耏bull 駄 鄩146899繽 146899繽 ㄖㆮㇱㇹㇼㄗ 16 ㅶ

ㅟㅪbull ㄔ 鮫 螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ魂觕ㅶ ㅣ 蜋

繇 ㅹㆲ 聆ㅣ ㅹ ㅶ貹ㅛㅪ頃 ㄕbull httpwwwsmfgrjppaper2016htm

5

繇 ㅶ ㅣㆲㅹ160766bull 羆㆕ㅕㅹ魯 紉ㅕ㆕ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅌㅳㄉ蓿ㅹ ㅶ

ㅹㅖ ㆉㅡㅎㅳㅣ ㅒbull Sheffi 2005 ㄉPonomarov and Holcomb 2009 ㄉBruneau

et al 2003 ㄉㅵㅴ

bull 蓿ㅶ 縄魯ㅶㆍ ㆉㅡㅎ ㅖㅌ ㅳㅎㅐ ㅒbull Christpher and Peck 2004 ㄉMcManus et al 2008 ㄉ

Hollnagel 2011 ㄉ 2015 ㄉㅵㅴ

bull 閔 ㄉ閔 ㅶㅔㅛ160766bull ISO PAS 223992007 --gt ISO 223002012 --gt ISO 223162017bull BS 650002014 閔閔

6

ㆲ

胯ㄉ

ㄉ

ㄉ

ㅳ

ㅳ

ㆹ

ㅳ ㅳ

ㅎ徽

綯 肦ㅳㆹ

ㅹ 鑞

ㆲ ㅶ ㆌ㆕ 謙螭

ㆲ ㅹ ㅶㅯㅵㅖ 裑

蛭 Airmic Road to resilience - Building dynamic approaches to risk to achieve future success 2014

ㆲㅹ裑 ㄉ謙螭ㄉ 鑞ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol43 20145ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

7

Resilience Benchmarking Tool RBTㅹㆲㅹㇴㇹㆷㆺ ㅐㅪㆌㅹㆬ

ㅹ 較ㅶ鑚 ㅡㅱㆍ㆕ㅐㆬ ㅖ3 ㅯㅹ ㄉ13 ㅹ ㅶ

ㅟㅱㅎㄊ

薩 ㅡㅕ ㅵㅎ 颴ㆍㅳㅶㄉ鑚 ㅹ粔 ㅶ頃ㅰㅎㅱ鑚 ㅟㅦ逞ㅵㅹㅲㄉ160766 聆ㅶㅺ簯貹ㅗㅫㅖㄉㇰㇻㆹㅳㅡㅱㅺ ㄊ

ㅲㄉ阷鞹ㆮㇰ ㅐ繇 ㅵㅴ徽 ㅳㅡㅱㄉRBT ㅎㅱ

ㅡㅪ ㅖ蕯 ㅟㅱㅎㄊBrown 緢 2014

蛭 Brown C et al 2014

ㆴㆹ鮫146899ㄉㆵㇴ鮫146899籯 ㅳㅡㅪ ㇲㆺㇻㄔResilient Organisationsㄕㅶ㆔ㅮㅱ ㅟㅪㄊ

8

httpwwwresorgsorgnz

BSI 閔 誀繽 PAS 7000Supply chain risk management - Supplier prequalification

Core prequalification topic modulesC1 Organizational Profile ゎC2 Supplier capabilities and capacities ゎC3 Financial Information amp Insurance ゎC4 Business Governance ゎC5 Employment PoliciesC6 Health and safety ゎC7 Data protection ゎC8 Environmental managementC9 Quality management

Additional prequalification topic modulesA1 Business ethicsA2 Supply chain traceability ゎA3 Supply chain security managementA4 Equal opportunity and freedomA5 Disciplinary practices and abuseA6 Business continuity management ゎ

繇 ㅖㇲㆮㇿㅶ徽ㅡㅱ紿螻 195038 ㅐ ㅶ翻 ㅟㅝㅳ 160766ㅡㅱ羖 ㅟㅪ ㅹ蕯 緡

Publicly Available Specification

ㇲㆮㇿ膛 ㅹ繇 ㅳ谹 麄ㅣ ㅶ

ㅣㆄㅗ ㅖㅶ賰ㆉㅱㅎㄊ

ゎ ㅺㆲㅶ ㅣㅳㅒ㆕

RBT ㅹ ㅶ ㅱㅺㆌㅱㆲㅹ 聆 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅣ

9

ㆲㅹ ㅴㅐ ㅣㅕbull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 綯 ㅹ 紺 薩bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵ

ㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎㅹㅲㅌㅻㄉㅨㅹㇻㅺㆲㅲ ㅌㅳ ㅒ

10

鮫146899薄貯蝝 綯 颴ㇻ鞹 貪

ㄔㇻㆲㇲㆱㆹㄕ

Bouning Forward ㅳㅎㅐ ㅒ

蛭 International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies World Disaster Report 2016 踸 ㅺ

11

ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol58 201611ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

饌 緢ㅶ㆔ ㅹ耏

12

（出所）塩崎由加藤孝明菅寛（2015）「然災害に対する都市システムのレジリエンスに関する概念整理」『学会論集D3（計画学）』Vol 71No3p 127-140

紉ㅹㆮㇲ紿 綯 紺 薩

阷 署 魯署 薩 魯

豹 籯 魯ㇼㅹㇱ

籯 ㄤ籯 薩 魯

署 魯較ㅹ簯 紿 籯 薩

颻ㅹ魂觕 魯

13

ㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣㅶㅺㄉㅝㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ ㅵ蜋 ㅺ 貪ㅖ ㅎㄊ

褧ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅺ紿 ㅞㅳㅶ ㅒ ㅖ

蜋ㅕㅣㅎㄊㅪㅫㅡ蕠ㅱㅹ紿

ㅶ蜮 ㅣㅝㅳㅺㅲㅗㅵㅎㄊ

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅐ ㅶㅺㄉㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ 紉ㅹㆮㇲ徽 ㅳㅣㅹㅕㄉ

羆㆕ㅕㅹ ㅲ 160766ㅣ ㅖㅌㄊ

鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ bull 苤ㅖ ㅡㅱ 螻ㅳ貯ㅢ羃蝿ㅲ 褜ㅖㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅵㅮㅪ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣbull 颻ㅹ 舺 ㅶ缽ㅎㄉ簗 ㅶ緢 颻緢 ㅶㅱ緺 ㅐ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎbull ㆌㅱ簯褜 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅗ 閃㆔ㅐㅵ颻貪ㅶ ㅣ ㅪㅫㅡ

繽 貰ㄉ 鄩 ㄉ 較ㅵㅴㅶ ㅖㅌ

14

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅲㅺㄉㅹㅪㆌㅹ ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅹㆲ ㅒㅹㅕ

ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㄔ ㆲㄕㅲ ㅣ紿ㅖ魂

螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋bull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 鮫 ㅶ㆔閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵㅕ㆕ㅹ

bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵ 誀 繽 ㅹㅐㅬ簪颻繇 90

bull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull 粔ㅔ㆔ㅾ谹 蔐ㅹ 颻ㅕ㆕ ㅪ ㆲ

bull 粔 蝝 ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 3 蠔縄薩bull 谹 蔐 鬟簪 躻ㆉㅪㅺ 耷ㅡㅪ ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 1 蠔縄薩

15

綉 螄谹 ㅹ ㅶ ㅣ頃 ㅶ頃ㅰㅙ

蜋 鬟簪

16

蜋 蝝

17

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

ㅝㆉㅲㅹ ㅹ

bull 蔐 ㅶ ㆲㅹbull 2017 鮫146899鮫146899 謙 (^_^

bull ㄔ繇 ㅹㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣ簗 194675 - 繇 ㅹㆲ聆ㅣ ㅹ ㅶ貹ㅛㅪ頃 -ㄕ

bull 螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋 耏bull 駄 鄩146899繽 146899繽 ㄖㆮㇱㇹㇼㄗ 16 ㅶ

ㅟㅪbull ㄔ 鮫 螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ魂觕ㅶ ㅣ 蜋

繇 ㅹㆲ 聆ㅣ ㅹ ㅶ貹ㅛㅪ頃 ㄕbull httpwwwsmfgrjppaper2016htm

5

繇 ㅶ ㅣㆲㅹ160766bull 羆㆕ㅕㅹ魯 紉ㅕ㆕ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅌㅳㄉ蓿ㅹ ㅶ

ㅹㅖ ㆉㅡㅎㅳㅣ ㅒbull Sheffi 2005 ㄉPonomarov and Holcomb 2009 ㄉBruneau

et al 2003 ㄉㅵㅴ

bull 蓿ㅶ 縄魯ㅶㆍ ㆉㅡㅎ ㅖㅌ ㅳㅎㅐ ㅒbull Christpher and Peck 2004 ㄉMcManus et al 2008 ㄉ

Hollnagel 2011 ㄉ 2015 ㄉㅵㅴ

bull 閔 ㄉ閔 ㅶㅔㅛ160766bull ISO PAS 223992007 --gt ISO 223002012 --gt ISO 223162017bull BS 650002014 閔閔

6

ㆲ

胯ㄉ

ㄉ

ㄉ

ㅳ

ㅳ

ㆹ

ㅳ ㅳ

ㅎ徽

綯 肦ㅳㆹ

ㅹ 鑞

ㆲ ㅶ ㆌ㆕ 謙螭

ㆲ ㅹ ㅶㅯㅵㅖ 裑

蛭 Airmic Road to resilience - Building dynamic approaches to risk to achieve future success 2014

ㆲㅹ裑 ㄉ謙螭ㄉ 鑞ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol43 20145ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

7

Resilience Benchmarking Tool RBTㅹㆲㅹㇴㇹㆷㆺ ㅐㅪㆌㅹㆬ

ㅹ 較ㅶ鑚 ㅡㅱㆍ㆕ㅐㆬ ㅖ3 ㅯㅹ ㄉ13 ㅹ ㅶ

ㅟㅱㅎㄊ

薩 ㅡㅕ ㅵㅎ 颴ㆍㅳㅶㄉ鑚 ㅹ粔 ㅶ頃ㅰㅎㅱ鑚 ㅟㅦ逞ㅵㅹㅲㄉ160766 聆ㅶㅺ簯貹ㅗㅫㅖㄉㇰㇻㆹㅳㅡㅱㅺ ㄊ

ㅲㄉ阷鞹ㆮㇰ ㅐ繇 ㅵㅴ徽 ㅳㅡㅱㄉRBT ㅎㅱ

ㅡㅪ ㅖ蕯 ㅟㅱㅎㄊBrown 緢 2014

蛭 Brown C et al 2014

ㆴㆹ鮫146899ㄉㆵㇴ鮫146899籯 ㅳㅡㅪ ㇲㆺㇻㄔResilient Organisationsㄕㅶ㆔ㅮㅱ ㅟㅪㄊ

8

httpwwwresorgsorgnz

BSI 閔 誀繽 PAS 7000Supply chain risk management - Supplier prequalification

Core prequalification topic modulesC1 Organizational Profile ゎC2 Supplier capabilities and capacities ゎC3 Financial Information amp Insurance ゎC4 Business Governance ゎC5 Employment PoliciesC6 Health and safety ゎC7 Data protection ゎC8 Environmental managementC9 Quality management

Additional prequalification topic modulesA1 Business ethicsA2 Supply chain traceability ゎA3 Supply chain security managementA4 Equal opportunity and freedomA5 Disciplinary practices and abuseA6 Business continuity management ゎ

繇 ㅖㇲㆮㇿㅶ徽ㅡㅱ紿螻 195038 ㅐ ㅶ翻 ㅟㅝㅳ 160766ㅡㅱ羖 ㅟㅪ ㅹ蕯 緡

Publicly Available Specification

ㇲㆮㇿ膛 ㅹ繇 ㅳ谹 麄ㅣ ㅶ

ㅣㆄㅗ ㅖㅶ賰ㆉㅱㅎㄊ

ゎ ㅺㆲㅶ ㅣㅳㅒ㆕

RBT ㅹ ㅶ ㅱㅺㆌㅱㆲㅹ 聆 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅣ

9

ㆲㅹ ㅴㅐ ㅣㅕbull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 綯 ㅹ 紺 薩bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵ

ㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎㅹㅲㅌㅻㄉㅨㅹㇻㅺㆲㅲ ㅌㅳ ㅒ

10

鮫146899薄貯蝝 綯 颴ㇻ鞹 貪

ㄔㇻㆲㇲㆱㆹㄕ

Bouning Forward ㅳㅎㅐ ㅒ

蛭 International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies World Disaster Report 2016 踸 ㅺ

11

ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol58 201611ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

饌 緢ㅶ㆔ ㅹ耏

12

（出所）塩崎由加藤孝明菅寛（2015）「然災害に対する都市システムのレジリエンスに関する概念整理」『学会論集D3（計画学）』Vol 71No3p 127-140

紉ㅹㆮㇲ紿 綯 紺 薩

阷 署 魯署 薩 魯

豹 籯 魯ㇼㅹㇱ

籯 ㄤ籯 薩 魯

署 魯較ㅹ簯 紿 籯 薩

颻ㅹ魂觕 魯

13

ㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣㅶㅺㄉㅝㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ ㅵ蜋 ㅺ 貪ㅖ ㅎㄊ

褧ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅺ紿 ㅞㅳㅶ ㅒ ㅖ

蜋ㅕㅣㅎㄊㅪㅫㅡ蕠ㅱㅹ紿

ㅶ蜮 ㅣㅝㅳㅺㅲㅗㅵㅎㄊ

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅐ ㅶㅺㄉㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ 紉ㅹㆮㇲ徽 ㅳㅣㅹㅕㄉ

羆㆕ㅕㅹ ㅲ 160766ㅣ ㅖㅌㄊ

鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ bull 苤ㅖ ㅡㅱ 螻ㅳ貯ㅢ羃蝿ㅲ 褜ㅖㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅵㅮㅪ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣbull 颻ㅹ 舺 ㅶ缽ㅎㄉ簗 ㅶ緢 颻緢 ㅶㅱ緺 ㅐ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎbull ㆌㅱ簯褜 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅗ 閃㆔ㅐㅵ颻貪ㅶ ㅣ ㅪㅫㅡ

繽 貰ㄉ 鄩 ㄉ 較ㅵㅴㅶ ㅖㅌ

14

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅲㅺㄉㅹㅪㆌㅹ ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅹㆲ ㅒㅹㅕ

ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㄔ ㆲㄕㅲ ㅣ紿ㅖ魂

螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋bull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 鮫 ㅶ㆔閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵㅕ㆕ㅹ

bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵ 誀 繽 ㅹㅐㅬ簪颻繇 90

bull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull 粔ㅔ㆔ㅾ谹 蔐ㅹ 颻ㅕ㆕ ㅪ ㆲ

bull 粔 蝝 ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 3 蠔縄薩bull 谹 蔐 鬟簪 躻ㆉㅪㅺ 耷ㅡㅪ ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 1 蠔縄薩

15

綉 螄谹 ㅹ ㅶ ㅣ頃 ㅶ頃ㅰㅙ

蜋 鬟簪

16

蜋 蝝

17

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

繇 ㅶ ㅣㆲㅹ160766bull 羆㆕ㅕㅹ魯 紉ㅕ㆕ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅌㅳㄉ蓿ㅹ ㅶ

ㅹㅖ ㆉㅡㅎㅳㅣ ㅒbull Sheffi 2005 ㄉPonomarov and Holcomb 2009 ㄉBruneau

et al 2003 ㄉㅵㅴ

bull 蓿ㅶ 縄魯ㅶㆍ ㆉㅡㅎ ㅖㅌ ㅳㅎㅐ ㅒbull Christpher and Peck 2004 ㄉMcManus et al 2008 ㄉ

Hollnagel 2011 ㄉ 2015 ㄉㅵㅴ

bull 閔 ㄉ閔 ㅶㅔㅛ160766bull ISO PAS 223992007 --gt ISO 223002012 --gt ISO 223162017bull BS 650002014 閔閔

6

ㆲ

胯ㄉ

ㄉ

ㄉ

ㅳ

ㅳ

ㆹ

ㅳ ㅳ

ㅎ徽

綯 肦ㅳㆹ

ㅹ 鑞

ㆲ ㅶ ㆌ㆕ 謙螭

ㆲ ㅹ ㅶㅯㅵㅖ 裑

蛭 Airmic Road to resilience - Building dynamic approaches to risk to achieve future success 2014

ㆲㅹ裑 ㄉ謙螭ㄉ 鑞ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol43 20145ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

7

Resilience Benchmarking Tool RBTㅹㆲㅹㇴㇹㆷㆺ ㅐㅪㆌㅹㆬ

ㅹ 較ㅶ鑚 ㅡㅱㆍ㆕ㅐㆬ ㅖ3 ㅯㅹ ㄉ13 ㅹ ㅶ

ㅟㅱㅎㄊ

薩 ㅡㅕ ㅵㅎ 颴ㆍㅳㅶㄉ鑚 ㅹ粔 ㅶ頃ㅰㅎㅱ鑚 ㅟㅦ逞ㅵㅹㅲㄉ160766 聆ㅶㅺ簯貹ㅗㅫㅖㄉㇰㇻㆹㅳㅡㅱㅺ ㄊ

ㅲㄉ阷鞹ㆮㇰ ㅐ繇 ㅵㅴ徽 ㅳㅡㅱㄉRBT ㅎㅱ

ㅡㅪ ㅖ蕯 ㅟㅱㅎㄊBrown 緢 2014

蛭 Brown C et al 2014

ㆴㆹ鮫146899ㄉㆵㇴ鮫146899籯 ㅳㅡㅪ ㇲㆺㇻㄔResilient Organisationsㄕㅶ㆔ㅮㅱ ㅟㅪㄊ

8

httpwwwresorgsorgnz

BSI 閔 誀繽 PAS 7000Supply chain risk management - Supplier prequalification

Core prequalification topic modulesC1 Organizational Profile ゎC2 Supplier capabilities and capacities ゎC3 Financial Information amp Insurance ゎC4 Business Governance ゎC5 Employment PoliciesC6 Health and safety ゎC7 Data protection ゎC8 Environmental managementC9 Quality management

Additional prequalification topic modulesA1 Business ethicsA2 Supply chain traceability ゎA3 Supply chain security managementA4 Equal opportunity and freedomA5 Disciplinary practices and abuseA6 Business continuity management ゎ

繇 ㅖㇲㆮㇿㅶ徽ㅡㅱ紿螻 195038 ㅐ ㅶ翻 ㅟㅝㅳ 160766ㅡㅱ羖 ㅟㅪ ㅹ蕯 緡

Publicly Available Specification

ㇲㆮㇿ膛 ㅹ繇 ㅳ谹 麄ㅣ ㅶ

ㅣㆄㅗ ㅖㅶ賰ㆉㅱㅎㄊ

ゎ ㅺㆲㅶ ㅣㅳㅒ㆕

RBT ㅹ ㅶ ㅱㅺㆌㅱㆲㅹ 聆 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅣ

9

ㆲㅹ ㅴㅐ ㅣㅕbull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 綯 ㅹ 紺 薩bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵ

ㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎㅹㅲㅌㅻㄉㅨㅹㇻㅺㆲㅲ ㅌㅳ ㅒ

10

鮫146899薄貯蝝 綯 颴ㇻ鞹 貪

ㄔㇻㆲㇲㆱㆹㄕ

Bouning Forward ㅳㅎㅐ ㅒ

蛭 International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies World Disaster Report 2016 踸 ㅺ

11

ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol58 201611ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

饌 緢ㅶ㆔ ㅹ耏

12

（出所）塩崎由加藤孝明菅寛（2015）「然災害に対する都市システムのレジリエンスに関する概念整理」『学会論集D3（計画学）』Vol 71No3p 127-140

紉ㅹㆮㇲ紿 綯 紺 薩

阷 署 魯署 薩 魯

豹 籯 魯ㇼㅹㇱ

籯 ㄤ籯 薩 魯

署 魯較ㅹ簯 紿 籯 薩

颻ㅹ魂觕 魯

13

ㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣㅶㅺㄉㅝㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ ㅵ蜋 ㅺ 貪ㅖ ㅎㄊ

褧ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅺ紿 ㅞㅳㅶ ㅒ ㅖ

蜋ㅕㅣㅎㄊㅪㅫㅡ蕠ㅱㅹ紿

ㅶ蜮 ㅣㅝㅳㅺㅲㅗㅵㅎㄊ

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅐ ㅶㅺㄉㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ 紉ㅹㆮㇲ徽 ㅳㅣㅹㅕㄉ

羆㆕ㅕㅹ ㅲ 160766ㅣ ㅖㅌㄊ

鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ bull 苤ㅖ ㅡㅱ 螻ㅳ貯ㅢ羃蝿ㅲ 褜ㅖㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅵㅮㅪ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣbull 颻ㅹ 舺 ㅶ缽ㅎㄉ簗 ㅶ緢 颻緢 ㅶㅱ緺 ㅐ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎbull ㆌㅱ簯褜 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅗ 閃㆔ㅐㅵ颻貪ㅶ ㅣ ㅪㅫㅡ

繽 貰ㄉ 鄩 ㄉ 較ㅵㅴㅶ ㅖㅌ

14

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅲㅺㄉㅹㅪㆌㅹ ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅹㆲ ㅒㅹㅕ

ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㄔ ㆲㄕㅲ ㅣ紿ㅖ魂

螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋bull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 鮫 ㅶ㆔閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵㅕ㆕ㅹ

bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵ 誀 繽 ㅹㅐㅬ簪颻繇 90

bull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull 粔ㅔ㆔ㅾ谹 蔐ㅹ 颻ㅕ㆕ ㅪ ㆲ

bull 粔 蝝 ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 3 蠔縄薩bull 谹 蔐 鬟簪 躻ㆉㅪㅺ 耷ㅡㅪ ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 1 蠔縄薩

15

綉 螄谹 ㅹ ㅶ ㅣ頃 ㅶ頃ㅰㅙ

蜋 鬟簪

16

蜋 蝝

17

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

ㆲ

胯ㄉ

ㄉ

ㄉ

ㅳ

ㅳ

ㆹ

ㅳ ㅳ

ㅎ徽

綯 肦ㅳㆹ

ㅹ 鑞

ㆲ ㅶ ㆌ㆕ 謙螭

ㆲ ㅹ ㅶㅯㅵㅖ 裑

蛭 Airmic Road to resilience - Building dynamic approaches to risk to achieve future success 2014

ㆲㅹ裑 ㄉ謙螭ㄉ 鑞ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol43 20145ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

7

Resilience Benchmarking Tool RBTㅹㆲㅹㇴㇹㆷㆺ ㅐㅪㆌㅹㆬ

ㅹ 較ㅶ鑚 ㅡㅱㆍ㆕ㅐㆬ ㅖ3 ㅯㅹ ㄉ13 ㅹ ㅶ

ㅟㅱㅎㄊ

薩 ㅡㅕ ㅵㅎ 颴ㆍㅳㅶㄉ鑚 ㅹ粔 ㅶ頃ㅰㅎㅱ鑚 ㅟㅦ逞ㅵㅹㅲㄉ160766 聆ㅶㅺ簯貹ㅗㅫㅖㄉㇰㇻㆹㅳㅡㅱㅺ ㄊ

ㅲㄉ阷鞹ㆮㇰ ㅐ繇 ㅵㅴ徽 ㅳㅡㅱㄉRBT ㅎㅱ

ㅡㅪ ㅖ蕯 ㅟㅱㅎㄊBrown 緢 2014

蛭 Brown C et al 2014

ㆴㆹ鮫146899ㄉㆵㇴ鮫146899籯 ㅳㅡㅪ ㇲㆺㇻㄔResilient Organisationsㄕㅶ㆔ㅮㅱ ㅟㅪㄊ

8

httpwwwresorgsorgnz

BSI 閔 誀繽 PAS 7000Supply chain risk management - Supplier prequalification

Core prequalification topic modulesC1 Organizational Profile ゎC2 Supplier capabilities and capacities ゎC3 Financial Information amp Insurance ゎC4 Business Governance ゎC5 Employment PoliciesC6 Health and safety ゎC7 Data protection ゎC8 Environmental managementC9 Quality management

Additional prequalification topic modulesA1 Business ethicsA2 Supply chain traceability ゎA3 Supply chain security managementA4 Equal opportunity and freedomA5 Disciplinary practices and abuseA6 Business continuity management ゎ

繇 ㅖㇲㆮㇿㅶ徽ㅡㅱ紿螻 195038 ㅐ ㅶ翻 ㅟㅝㅳ 160766ㅡㅱ羖 ㅟㅪ ㅹ蕯 緡

Publicly Available Specification

ㇲㆮㇿ膛 ㅹ繇 ㅳ谹 麄ㅣ ㅶ

ㅣㆄㅗ ㅖㅶ賰ㆉㅱㅎㄊ

ゎ ㅺㆲㅶ ㅣㅳㅒ㆕

RBT ㅹ ㅶ ㅱㅺㆌㅱㆲㅹ 聆 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅣ

9

ㆲㅹ ㅴㅐ ㅣㅕbull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 綯 ㅹ 紺 薩bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵ

ㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎㅹㅲㅌㅻㄉㅨㅹㇻㅺㆲㅲ ㅌㅳ ㅒ

10

鮫146899薄貯蝝 綯 颴ㇻ鞹 貪

ㄔㇻㆲㇲㆱㆹㄕ

Bouning Forward ㅳㅎㅐ ㅒ

蛭 International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies World Disaster Report 2016 踸 ㅺ

11

ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol58 201611ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

饌 緢ㅶ㆔ ㅹ耏

12

（出所）塩崎由加藤孝明菅寛（2015）「然災害に対する都市システムのレジリエンスに関する概念整理」『学会論集D3（計画学）』Vol 71No3p 127-140

紉ㅹㆮㇲ紿 綯 紺 薩

阷 署 魯署 薩 魯

豹 籯 魯ㇼㅹㇱ

籯 ㄤ籯 薩 魯

署 魯較ㅹ簯 紿 籯 薩

颻ㅹ魂觕 魯

13

ㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣㅶㅺㄉㅝㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ ㅵ蜋 ㅺ 貪ㅖ ㅎㄊ

褧ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅺ紿 ㅞㅳㅶ ㅒ ㅖ

蜋ㅕㅣㅎㄊㅪㅫㅡ蕠ㅱㅹ紿

ㅶ蜮 ㅣㅝㅳㅺㅲㅗㅵㅎㄊ

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅐ ㅶㅺㄉㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ 紉ㅹㆮㇲ徽 ㅳㅣㅹㅕㄉ

羆㆕ㅕㅹ ㅲ 160766ㅣ ㅖㅌㄊ

鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ bull 苤ㅖ ㅡㅱ 螻ㅳ貯ㅢ羃蝿ㅲ 褜ㅖㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅵㅮㅪ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣbull 颻ㅹ 舺 ㅶ缽ㅎㄉ簗 ㅶ緢 颻緢 ㅶㅱ緺 ㅐ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎbull ㆌㅱ簯褜 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅗ 閃㆔ㅐㅵ颻貪ㅶ ㅣ ㅪㅫㅡ

繽 貰ㄉ 鄩 ㄉ 較ㅵㅴㅶ ㅖㅌ

14

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅲㅺㄉㅹㅪㆌㅹ ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅹㆲ ㅒㅹㅕ

ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㄔ ㆲㄕㅲ ㅣ紿ㅖ魂

螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋bull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 鮫 ㅶ㆔閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵㅕ㆕ㅹ

bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵ 誀 繽 ㅹㅐㅬ簪颻繇 90

bull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull 粔ㅔ㆔ㅾ谹 蔐ㅹ 颻ㅕ㆕ ㅪ ㆲ

bull 粔 蝝 ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 3 蠔縄薩bull 谹 蔐 鬟簪 躻ㆉㅪㅺ 耷ㅡㅪ ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 1 蠔縄薩

15

綉 螄谹 ㅹ ㅶ ㅣ頃 ㅶ頃ㅰㅙ

蜋 鬟簪

16

蜋 蝝

17

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

Resilience Benchmarking Tool RBTㅹㆲㅹㇴㇹㆷㆺ ㅐㅪㆌㅹㆬ

ㅹ 較ㅶ鑚 ㅡㅱㆍ㆕ㅐㆬ ㅖ3 ㅯㅹ ㄉ13 ㅹ ㅶ

ㅟㅱㅎㄊ

薩 ㅡㅕ ㅵㅎ 颴ㆍㅳㅶㄉ鑚 ㅹ粔 ㅶ頃ㅰㅎㅱ鑚 ㅟㅦ逞ㅵㅹㅲㄉ160766 聆ㅶㅺ簯貹ㅗㅫㅖㄉㇰㇻㆹㅳㅡㅱㅺ ㄊ

ㅲㄉ阷鞹ㆮㇰ ㅐ繇 ㅵㅴ徽 ㅳㅡㅱㄉRBT ㅎㅱ

ㅡㅪ ㅖ蕯 ㅟㅱㅎㄊBrown 緢 2014

蛭 Brown C et al 2014

ㆴㆹ鮫146899ㄉㆵㇴ鮫146899籯 ㅳㅡㅪ ㇲㆺㇻㄔResilient Organisationsㄕㅶ㆔ㅮㅱ ㅟㅪㄊ

8

httpwwwresorgsorgnz

BSI 閔 誀繽 PAS 7000Supply chain risk management - Supplier prequalification

Core prequalification topic modulesC1 Organizational Profile ゎC2 Supplier capabilities and capacities ゎC3 Financial Information amp Insurance ゎC4 Business Governance ゎC5 Employment PoliciesC6 Health and safety ゎC7 Data protection ゎC8 Environmental managementC9 Quality management

Additional prequalification topic modulesA1 Business ethicsA2 Supply chain traceability ゎA3 Supply chain security managementA4 Equal opportunity and freedomA5 Disciplinary practices and abuseA6 Business continuity management ゎ

繇 ㅖㇲㆮㇿㅶ徽ㅡㅱ紿螻 195038 ㅐ ㅶ翻 ㅟㅝㅳ 160766ㅡㅱ羖 ㅟㅪ ㅹ蕯 緡

Publicly Available Specification

ㇲㆮㇿ膛 ㅹ繇 ㅳ谹 麄ㅣ ㅶ

ㅣㆄㅗ ㅖㅶ賰ㆉㅱㅎㄊ

ゎ ㅺㆲㅶ ㅣㅳㅒ㆕

RBT ㅹ ㅶ ㅱㅺㆌㅱㆲㅹ 聆 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅣ

9

ㆲㅹ ㅴㅐ ㅣㅕbull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 綯 ㅹ 紺 薩bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵ

ㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎㅹㅲㅌㅻㄉㅨㅹㇻㅺㆲㅲ ㅌㅳ ㅒ

10

鮫146899薄貯蝝 綯 颴ㇻ鞹 貪

ㄔㇻㆲㇲㆱㆹㄕ

Bouning Forward ㅳㅎㅐ ㅒ

蛭 International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies World Disaster Report 2016 踸 ㅺ

11

ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol58 201611ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

饌 緢ㅶ㆔ ㅹ耏

12

（出所）塩崎由加藤孝明菅寛（2015）「然災害に対する都市システムのレジリエンスに関する概念整理」『学会論集D3（計画学）』Vol 71No3p 127-140

紉ㅹㆮㇲ紿 綯 紺 薩

阷 署 魯署 薩 魯

豹 籯 魯ㇼㅹㇱ

籯 ㄤ籯 薩 魯

署 魯較ㅹ簯 紿 籯 薩

颻ㅹ魂觕 魯

13

ㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣㅶㅺㄉㅝㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ ㅵ蜋 ㅺ 貪ㅖ ㅎㄊ

褧ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅺ紿 ㅞㅳㅶ ㅒ ㅖ

蜋ㅕㅣㅎㄊㅪㅫㅡ蕠ㅱㅹ紿

ㅶ蜮 ㅣㅝㅳㅺㅲㅗㅵㅎㄊ

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅐ ㅶㅺㄉㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ 紉ㅹㆮㇲ徽 ㅳㅣㅹㅕㄉ

羆㆕ㅕㅹ ㅲ 160766ㅣ ㅖㅌㄊ

鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ bull 苤ㅖ ㅡㅱ 螻ㅳ貯ㅢ羃蝿ㅲ 褜ㅖㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅵㅮㅪ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣbull 颻ㅹ 舺 ㅶ缽ㅎㄉ簗 ㅶ緢 颻緢 ㅶㅱ緺 ㅐ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎbull ㆌㅱ簯褜 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅗ 閃㆔ㅐㅵ颻貪ㅶ ㅣ ㅪㅫㅡ

繽 貰ㄉ 鄩 ㄉ 較ㅵㅴㅶ ㅖㅌ

14

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅲㅺㄉㅹㅪㆌㅹ ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅹㆲ ㅒㅹㅕ

ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㄔ ㆲㄕㅲ ㅣ紿ㅖ魂

螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋bull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 鮫 ㅶ㆔閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵㅕ㆕ㅹ

bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵ 誀 繽 ㅹㅐㅬ簪颻繇 90

bull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull 粔ㅔ㆔ㅾ谹 蔐ㅹ 颻ㅕ㆕ ㅪ ㆲ

bull 粔 蝝 ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 3 蠔縄薩bull 谹 蔐 鬟簪 躻ㆉㅪㅺ 耷ㅡㅪ ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 1 蠔縄薩

15

綉 螄谹 ㅹ ㅶ ㅣ頃 ㅶ頃ㅰㅙ

蜋 鬟簪

16

蜋 蝝

17

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

BSI 閔 誀繽 PAS 7000Supply chain risk management - Supplier prequalification

Core prequalification topic modulesC1 Organizational Profile ゎC2 Supplier capabilities and capacities ゎC3 Financial Information amp Insurance ゎC4 Business Governance ゎC5 Employment PoliciesC6 Health and safety ゎC7 Data protection ゎC8 Environmental managementC9 Quality management

Additional prequalification topic modulesA1 Business ethicsA2 Supply chain traceability ゎA3 Supply chain security managementA4 Equal opportunity and freedomA5 Disciplinary practices and abuseA6 Business continuity management ゎ

繇 ㅖㇲㆮㇿㅶ徽ㅡㅱ紿螻 195038 ㅐ ㅶ翻 ㅟㅝㅳ 160766ㅡㅱ羖 ㅟㅪ ㅹ蕯 緡

Publicly Available Specification

ㇲㆮㇿ膛 ㅹ繇 ㅳ谹 麄ㅣ ㅶ

ㅣㆄㅗ ㅖㅶ賰ㆉㅱㅎㄊ

ゎ ㅺㆲㅶ ㅣㅳㅒ㆕

RBT ㅹ ㅶ ㅱㅺㆌㅱㆲㅹ 聆 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅣ

9

ㆲㅹ ㅴㅐ ㅣㅕbull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 綯 ㅹ 紺 薩bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵ

ㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎㅹㅲㅌㅻㄉㅨㅹㇻㅺㆲㅲ ㅌㅳ ㅒ

10

鮫146899薄貯蝝 綯 颴ㇻ鞹 貪

ㄔㇻㆲㇲㆱㆹㄕ

Bouning Forward ㅳㅎㅐ ㅒ

蛭 International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies World Disaster Report 2016 踸 ㅺ

11

ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol58 201611ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

饌 緢ㅶ㆔ ㅹ耏

12

（出所）塩崎由加藤孝明菅寛（2015）「然災害に対する都市システムのレジリエンスに関する概念整理」『学会論集D3（計画学）』Vol 71No3p 127-140

紉ㅹㆮㇲ紿 綯 紺 薩

阷 署 魯署 薩 魯

豹 籯 魯ㇼㅹㇱ

籯 ㄤ籯 薩 魯

署 魯較ㅹ簯 紿 籯 薩

颻ㅹ魂觕 魯

13

ㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣㅶㅺㄉㅝㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ ㅵ蜋 ㅺ 貪ㅖ ㅎㄊ

褧ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅺ紿 ㅞㅳㅶ ㅒ ㅖ

蜋ㅕㅣㅎㄊㅪㅫㅡ蕠ㅱㅹ紿

ㅶ蜮 ㅣㅝㅳㅺㅲㅗㅵㅎㄊ

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅐ ㅶㅺㄉㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ 紉ㅹㆮㇲ徽 ㅳㅣㅹㅕㄉ

羆㆕ㅕㅹ ㅲ 160766ㅣ ㅖㅌㄊ

鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ bull 苤ㅖ ㅡㅱ 螻ㅳ貯ㅢ羃蝿ㅲ 褜ㅖㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅵㅮㅪ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣbull 颻ㅹ 舺 ㅶ缽ㅎㄉ簗 ㅶ緢 颻緢 ㅶㅱ緺 ㅐ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎbull ㆌㅱ簯褜 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅗ 閃㆔ㅐㅵ颻貪ㅶ ㅣ ㅪㅫㅡ

繽 貰ㄉ 鄩 ㄉ 較ㅵㅴㅶ ㅖㅌ

14

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅲㅺㄉㅹㅪㆌㅹ ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅹㆲ ㅒㅹㅕ

ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㄔ ㆲㄕㅲ ㅣ紿ㅖ魂

螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋bull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 鮫 ㅶ㆔閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵㅕ㆕ㅹ

bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵ 誀 繽 ㅹㅐㅬ簪颻繇 90

bull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull 粔ㅔ㆔ㅾ谹 蔐ㅹ 颻ㅕ㆕ ㅪ ㆲ

bull 粔 蝝 ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 3 蠔縄薩bull 谹 蔐 鬟簪 躻ㆉㅪㅺ 耷ㅡㅪ ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 1 蠔縄薩

15

綉 螄谹 ㅹ ㅶ ㅣ頃 ㅶ頃ㅰㅙ

蜋 鬟簪

16

蜋 蝝

17

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

ㆲㅹ ㅴㅐ ㅣㅕbull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 綯 ㅹ 紺 薩bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣ

bull ㆲbull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵ

ㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎㅹㅲㅌㅻㄉㅨㅹㇻㅺㆲㅲ ㅌㅳ ㅒ

10

鮫146899薄貯蝝 綯 颴ㇻ鞹 貪

ㄔㇻㆲㇲㆱㆹㄕ

Bouning Forward ㅳㅎㅐ ㅒ

蛭 International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies World Disaster Report 2016 踸 ㅺ

11

ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol58 201611ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

饌 緢ㅶ㆔ ㅹ耏

12

（出所）塩崎由加藤孝明菅寛（2015）「然災害に対する都市システムのレジリエンスに関する概念整理」『学会論集D3（計画学）』Vol 71No3p 127-140

紉ㅹㆮㇲ紿 綯 紺 薩

阷 署 魯署 薩 魯

豹 籯 魯ㇼㅹㇱ

籯 ㄤ籯 薩 魯

署 魯較ㅹ簯 紿 籯 薩

颻ㅹ魂觕 魯

13

ㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣㅶㅺㄉㅝㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ ㅵ蜋 ㅺ 貪ㅖ ㅎㄊ

褧ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅺ紿 ㅞㅳㅶ ㅒ ㅖ

蜋ㅕㅣㅎㄊㅪㅫㅡ蕠ㅱㅹ紿

ㅶ蜮 ㅣㅝㅳㅺㅲㅗㅵㅎㄊ

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅐ ㅶㅺㄉㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ 紉ㅹㆮㇲ徽 ㅳㅣㅹㅕㄉ

羆㆕ㅕㅹ ㅲ 160766ㅣ ㅖㅌㄊ

鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ bull 苤ㅖ ㅡㅱ 螻ㅳ貯ㅢ羃蝿ㅲ 褜ㅖㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅵㅮㅪ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣbull 颻ㅹ 舺 ㅶ缽ㅎㄉ簗 ㅶ緢 颻緢 ㅶㅱ緺 ㅐ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎbull ㆌㅱ簯褜 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅗ 閃㆔ㅐㅵ颻貪ㅶ ㅣ ㅪㅫㅡ

繽 貰ㄉ 鄩 ㄉ 較ㅵㅴㅶ ㅖㅌ

14

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅲㅺㄉㅹㅪㆌㅹ ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅹㆲ ㅒㅹㅕ

ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㄔ ㆲㄕㅲ ㅣ紿ㅖ魂

螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋bull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 鮫 ㅶ㆔閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵㅕ㆕ㅹ

bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵ 誀 繽 ㅹㅐㅬ簪颻繇 90

bull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull 粔ㅔ㆔ㅾ谹 蔐ㅹ 颻ㅕ㆕ ㅪ ㆲ

bull 粔 蝝 ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 3 蠔縄薩bull 谹 蔐 鬟簪 躻ㆉㅪㅺ 耷ㅡㅪ ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 1 蠔縄薩

15

綉 螄谹 ㅹ ㅶ ㅣ頃 ㅶ頃ㅰㅙ

蜋 鬟簪

16

蜋 蝝

17

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

Bouning Forward ㅳㅎㅐ ㅒ

蛭 International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies World Disaster Report 2016 踸 ㅺ

11

ㄖㆹ徽 comㄗvol58 201611ㄔㆲㅶ ㅣ籅 ㅹ ㄕ譹

饌 緢ㅶ㆔ ㅹ耏

12

（出所）塩崎由加藤孝明菅寛（2015）「然災害に対する都市システムのレジリエンスに関する概念整理」『学会論集D3（計画学）』Vol 71No3p 127-140

紉ㅹㆮㇲ紿 綯 紺 薩

阷 署 魯署 薩 魯

豹 籯 魯ㇼㅹㇱ

籯 ㄤ籯 薩 魯

署 魯較ㅹ簯 紿 籯 薩

颻ㅹ魂觕 魯

13

ㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣㅶㅺㄉㅝㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ ㅵ蜋 ㅺ 貪ㅖ ㅎㄊ

褧ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅺ紿 ㅞㅳㅶ ㅒ ㅖ

蜋ㅕㅣㅎㄊㅪㅫㅡ蕠ㅱㅹ紿

ㅶ蜮 ㅣㅝㅳㅺㅲㅗㅵㅎㄊ

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅐ ㅶㅺㄉㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ 紉ㅹㆮㇲ徽 ㅳㅣㅹㅕㄉ

羆㆕ㅕㅹ ㅲ 160766ㅣ ㅖㅌㄊ

鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ bull 苤ㅖ ㅡㅱ 螻ㅳ貯ㅢ羃蝿ㅲ 褜ㅖㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅵㅮㅪ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣbull 颻ㅹ 舺 ㅶ缽ㅎㄉ簗 ㅶ緢 颻緢 ㅶㅱ緺 ㅐ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎbull ㆌㅱ簯褜 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅗ 閃㆔ㅐㅵ颻貪ㅶ ㅣ ㅪㅫㅡ

繽 貰ㄉ 鄩 ㄉ 較ㅵㅴㅶ ㅖㅌ

14

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅲㅺㄉㅹㅪㆌㅹ ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅹㆲ ㅒㅹㅕ

ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㄔ ㆲㄕㅲ ㅣ紿ㅖ魂

螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋bull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 鮫 ㅶ㆔閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵㅕ㆕ㅹ

bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵ 誀 繽 ㅹㅐㅬ簪颻繇 90

bull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull 粔ㅔ㆔ㅾ谹 蔐ㅹ 颻ㅕ㆕ ㅪ ㆲ

bull 粔 蝝 ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 3 蠔縄薩bull 谹 蔐 鬟簪 躻ㆉㅪㅺ 耷ㅡㅪ ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 1 蠔縄薩

15

綉 螄谹 ㅹ ㅶ ㅣ頃 ㅶ頃ㅰㅙ

蜋 鬟簪

16

蜋 蝝

17

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

饌 緢ㅶ㆔ ㅹ耏

12

（出所）塩崎由加藤孝明菅寛（2015）「然災害に対する都市システムのレジリエンスに関する概念整理」『学会論集D3（計画学）』Vol 71No3p 127-140

紉ㅹㆮㇲ紿 綯 紺 薩

阷 署 魯署 薩 魯

豹 籯 魯ㇼㅹㇱ

籯 ㄤ籯 薩 魯

署 魯較ㅹ簯 紿 籯 薩

颻ㅹ魂觕 魯

13

ㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣㅶㅺㄉㅝㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ ㅵ蜋 ㅺ 貪ㅖ ㅎㄊ

褧ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅺ紿 ㅞㅳㅶ ㅒ ㅖ

蜋ㅕㅣㅎㄊㅪㅫㅡ蕠ㅱㅹ紿

ㅶ蜮 ㅣㅝㅳㅺㅲㅗㅵㅎㄊ

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅐ ㅶㅺㄉㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ 紉ㅹㆮㇲ徽 ㅳㅣㅹㅕㄉ

羆㆕ㅕㅹ ㅲ 160766ㅣ ㅖㅌㄊ

鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ bull 苤ㅖ ㅡㅱ 螻ㅳ貯ㅢ羃蝿ㅲ 褜ㅖㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅵㅮㅪ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣbull 颻ㅹ 舺 ㅶ缽ㅎㄉ簗 ㅶ緢 颻緢 ㅶㅱ緺 ㅐ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎbull ㆌㅱ簯褜 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅗ 閃㆔ㅐㅵ颻貪ㅶ ㅣ ㅪㅫㅡ

繽 貰ㄉ 鄩 ㄉ 較ㅵㅴㅶ ㅖㅌ

14

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅲㅺㄉㅹㅪㆌㅹ ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅹㆲ ㅒㅹㅕ

ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㄔ ㆲㄕㅲ ㅣ紿ㅖ魂

螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋bull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 鮫 ㅶ㆔閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵㅕ㆕ㅹ

bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵ 誀 繽 ㅹㅐㅬ簪颻繇 90

bull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull 粔ㅔ㆔ㅾ谹 蔐ㅹ 颻ㅕ㆕ ㅪ ㆲ

bull 粔 蝝 ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 3 蠔縄薩bull 谹 蔐 鬟簪 躻ㆉㅪㅺ 耷ㅡㅪ ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 1 蠔縄薩

15

綉 螄谹 ㅹ ㅶ ㅣ頃 ㅶ頃ㅰㅙ

蜋 鬟簪

16

蜋 蝝

17

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

紉ㅹㆮㇲ紿 綯 紺 薩

阷 署 魯署 薩 魯

豹 籯 魯ㇼㅹㇱ

籯 ㄤ籯 薩 魯

署 魯較ㅹ簯 紿 籯 薩

颻ㅹ魂觕 魯

13

ㆲㅹ ㅶ ㅣㅶㅺㄉㅝㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ ㅵ蜋 ㅺ 貪ㅖ ㅎㄊ

褧ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅺ紿 ㅞㅳㅶ ㅒ ㅖ

蜋ㅕㅣㅎㄊㅪㅫㅡ蕠ㅱㅹ紿

ㅶ蜮 ㅣㅝㅳㅺㅲㅗㅵㅎㄊ

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅐ ㅶㅺㄉㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅵ 紉ㅹㆮㇲ徽 ㅳㅣㅹㅕㄉ

羆㆕ㅕㅹ ㅲ 160766ㅣ ㅖㅌㄊ

鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ bull 苤ㅖ ㅡㅱ 螻ㅳ貯ㅢ羃蝿ㅲ 褜ㅖㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅵㅮㅪ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣbull 颻ㅹ 舺 ㅶ缽ㅎㄉ簗 ㅶ緢 颻緢 ㅶㅱ緺 ㅐ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎbull ㆌㅱ簯褜 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅗ 閃㆔ㅐㅵ颻貪ㅶ ㅣ ㅪㅫㅡ

繽 貰ㄉ 鄩 ㄉ 較ㅵㅴㅶ ㅖㅌ

14

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅲㅺㄉㅹㅪㆌㅹ ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅹㆲ ㅒㅹㅕ

ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㄔ ㆲㄕㅲ ㅣ紿ㅖ魂

螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋bull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 鮫 ㅶ㆔閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵㅕ㆕ㅹ

bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵ 誀 繽 ㅹㅐㅬ簪颻繇 90

bull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull 粔ㅔ㆔ㅾ谹 蔐ㅹ 颻ㅕ㆕ ㅪ ㆲ

bull 粔 蝝 ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 3 蠔縄薩bull 谹 蔐 鬟簪 躻ㆉㅪㅺ 耷ㅡㅪ ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 1 蠔縄薩

15

綉 螄谹 ㅹ ㅶ ㅣ頃 ㅶ頃ㅰㅙ

蜋 鬟簪

16

蜋 蝝

17

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅖ 紉ㅹ螻ㅳ蕠ㅙ貯ㅢ ㅶ bull 苤ㅖ ㅡㅱ 螻ㅳ貯ㅢ羃蝿ㅲ 褜ㅖㅲㅗ㆔ㅐㅶㅵㅮㅪ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 貯 縄簪ㅶ ㅡㄉ ㅵ ㅶ魂觕ㅣbull 颻ㅹ 舺 ㅶ缽ㅎㄉ簗 ㅶ緢 颻緢 ㅶㅱ緺 ㅐ颻貪ㅶ

ㅣbull ㆲ

bull ㇻㅹ 鯀ㅎㄉ蝑ㅹ ㆍㅮㅪ ㅪㅵㇻㅳㅡㅱ ㆉ魂ㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅌㇴㅹ貯簗 ㅡㅱㅎbull ㆌㅱ簯褜 ㅳㅡㅱ ㅗ 閃㆔ㅐㅵ颻貪ㅶ ㅣ ㅪㅫㅡ

繽 貰ㄉ 鄩 ㄉ 較ㅵㅴㅶ ㅖㅌ

14

繇 ㅹㆲㅶ ㅣ ㅲㅺㄉㅹㅪㆌㅹ ㅶㅳㅮㅱㅹㆲ ㅒㅹㅕ

ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㄔ ㆲㄕㅲ ㅣ紿ㅖ魂

螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋bull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 鮫 ㅶ㆔閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵㅕ㆕ㅹ

bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵ 誀 繽 ㅹㅐㅬ簪颻繇 90

bull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull 粔ㅔ㆔ㅾ谹 蔐ㅹ 颻ㅕ㆕ ㅪ ㆲ

bull 粔 蝝 ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 3 蠔縄薩bull 谹 蔐 鬟簪 躻ㆉㅪㅺ 耷ㅡㅪ ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 1 蠔縄薩

15

綉 螄谹 ㅹ ㅶ ㅣ頃 ㅶ頃ㅰㅙ

蜋 鬟簪

16

蜋 蝝

17

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

螻 ㅶㅔㅛ繇 褧ㅹ蜋bull 紉ㅹㆮㇲ

bull 鮫 ㅶ㆔閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵㅕ㆕ㅹ

bull 徽 ㅳㅣㇻbull 閔薩 褜 ㇼㆵ 誀 繽 ㅹㅐㅬ簪颻繇 90

bull 鑚 ㅹㆮㇲbull 粔ㅔ㆔ㅾ谹 蔐ㅹ 颻ㅕ㆕ ㅪ ㆲ

bull 粔 蝝 ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 3 蠔縄薩bull 谹 蔐 鬟簪 躻ㆉㅪㅺ 耷ㅡㅪ ㅹ 瀕ㅖ 1 蠔縄薩

15

綉 螄谹 ㅹ ㅶ ㅣ頃 ㅶ頃ㅰㅙ

蜋 鬟簪

16

蜋 蝝

17

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

蜋 鬟簪

16

蜋 蝝

17

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

蜋 蝝

17

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

18

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

ㆲ ㅲㅗㅪㅳ ㅒ㆕繇

19

bull [B] [A] ㅳㄉ鬟簪 ㅖ 褜 肦ㅶ耻144356ㅣ貪ㅎㅖ署ㅎㆆㅐㅖㄉ蝝ㅲㅌㅮㅪㅳ 莇ㅲㅗㄊ

bull 紿 ㅖ ㅡㅪㅶㆍㅕㅕ㆕ㅥㄉ鬟簪 ㅔ㆔ㅾ 蝝 167730 閂薩ㅶ讖ㆌㅪ繇 ㅖ4 ㅌㅮㅪ ㅐㅬ 褜 粔 ㇲㆮㇿㅺ2 ㄊ

bull ㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅺ貢 ㅶ薄 ㅡㅱ ㅡㅪ紿 ㅲㅌㅕ㆕ㄉ緊鑚ㅹ蜋 ㅶㅺ瀕ㅵㅙㅳㆍㄔ 褜 豹 ㅹ 瀕ㄕㅶ徽ㅣㆲㅖ讔 ㅟㅱㅎㅳ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅲㅌㅐㄊㅪㅫㅡㄉㅝ㆕ㅹ繇 ㅖ緢ㅹ紿ㅶ徽ㅡㅱㆍ貯 ㅶㆲ ㅲㅗㅕㅺ簯 ㅲㅌㄊ

ㅶㅨㅐ ㅒㅱ㆔ㅎㅕ

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

ㅶ 褜 ㅹ 谽ㅛㅪㅹㅕbull 徽 90 ㅹ 聆 螄颴趐

bull 鬟簪蝝 ㅹ魂觕ㅹ ㅖㅴㅹ㆔ㅐㅶ ㅟㅱㅎㅕㅺㄉ繇 ㅶ㆔ㅮㅱㆉㅬㆉㅬ

bull ㄔ 褜 ㇼㆵㅹ ㅶ㆔ㄕ絇ㄍㅳ ㅎㅱㅌㅮㅪㅳㅡㅱㆍㄉㅴㅹ ㅵㅹㅕ

20

21

21