By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance...

42
Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory © CAN-BEST 2005 Performance Evaluation of Windows By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng. November 2005

Transcript of By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance...

Page 1: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

Canadian Building Envelope Science and TechnologySCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory© CAN-BEST 2005

Performance Evaluation ofWindows

By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.

November 2005

Page 2: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

This PresentationWe will discuss:• Window Standards• Laboratory Testing• Field Testing

Page 3: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

This Presentation

• Window Standards• Laboratory Testing• Field Testing

Page 4: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

CSA A440 Family of Standards• A440-00 “Windows”

– A440.1 “Users Guide

• A440.2 “Window Thermal Performance”– A440.3 “Users Guide

• A440.4 “Window Installation”

Page 5: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

Page 6: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

Page 7: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

CSA A440-00

Main Sections are:• Material Specifications• Preservatives & Coatings• Component Specifications• Design Specifications

Page 8: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

CSA A440-00 (Cont’d.)

• Glazing Methods• Performance Requirements• Test Methods• Test Specimens

Page 9: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

Performance Requirements• Ease of Operation• Air Tightness• Water Tightness• Wind Load Resistance• Forced Entry Resistance• Condensation Resistance• Mechanical Tests

Page 10: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

Ease of Operation

Measure of forces required to operate window sash or locks:

• Initiate motion• Maintain motion

Page 11: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

Air Tightness

Rate of air infiltration and exfiltration in m3/hr.m at 75 Pa, ASTM E283

• A1: 2.79• A2: 1.65• A3: 0.55• Fixed: 0.25

Page 12: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited LaboratoryCopy

right

, 200

3 ©

CAN

-BES

T

Page 13: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited LaboratoryCopy

right

, 200

3 ©

CAN

-BES

T

Page 14: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

Water Tightness

Visual inspection for leakage under cyclic pressure application, ASTM E547

• Four cycles of 5 min ON, 1 min OFF• B1 to B7 (150 to 700 Pa)

Page 15: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited LaboratoryCopy

right

, 200

3 ©

CAN

-BES

T

Page 16: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited LaboratoryCopy

right

, 200

3 ©

CAN

-BES

T

Page 17: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

Wind Load Resistance (Deflection)

Uniformly distributed load, ASTM E330• Sash L/125, Mullion L/175• C1 to C5 (±500 to 2000 Pa)

Page 18: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

Wind Load Resistance(Blow Out)

Uniformly distributed load, ASTM E330• No permanent damage• C1 to C5 (±1500 to 5000 Pa)

Page 19: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

Forced Entry ResistanceLevels F10 & F20Grade 10 & 20 ASTM F548• Dismantling from exterior• Hand and tool manipulation• Hardware load tests• Repeat hand and tool manipulation

Page 20: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited LaboratoryCopy

right

, 200

3 ©

CAN

-BES

T

Page 21: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

Condensation ResistanceTemperature Index (I), the lower of:• Coldest frame surface temperature• Coldest average of three glass temperatures

@ 50 mm from sightline• 90 - Temperature Index @ -30/+20 °C• 98 - Temperature Factor @ -18/+21 °C• 00 - Temperature Index @ -30/+20 °C

Page 22: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited LaboratoryCopy

right

, 200

3 ©

CAN

-BES

T

Page 23: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited LaboratoryCopy

right

, 200

3 ©

CAN

-BES

T

Weather Side

Room Side

Test Wall

Page 24: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited LaboratoryCopy

right

, 200

3 ©

CAN

-BES

T

Page 25: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

Mechanical Tests

• Screen Strength– Standard Duty,60 N (13.5 lb)– Heavy Duty, 330 N (75 lb)

• Blocked Operation (Sliding)• Sash Strength (Projecting)• Sash Pull Off (PVC, FRP)

Page 26: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited LaboratoryCopy

right

, 200

3 ©

CAN

-BES

T

Page 27: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

This Presentation

• Window Standards• Laboratory Testing• Field Testing

Page 28: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

Common Field Tests:

• Air Tightness• Water Tightness• Wind Load Resistance

Page 29: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited LaboratoryCopy

right

, 200

3 ©

CAN

-BES

T

Page 30: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited LaboratoryCopy

right

, 200

3 ©

CAN

-BES

T

Page 31: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited LaboratoryCopy

right

, 200

3 ©

CAN

-BES

T

Page 32: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited LaboratoryCopy

right

, 200

3 ©

CAN

-BES

T

Page 33: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited LaboratoryCopy

right

, 200

3 ©

CAN

-BES

T

Page 34: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited LaboratoryCopy

right

, 200

3 ©

CAN

-BES

T

Page 35: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited LaboratoryCopy

right

, 200

3 ©

CAN

-BES

T

Page 36: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

Why Windows Continue to Leak?

• Standards are for Standard Products• Specifications need to be Job-Specific• Inspectors need guidelines

Page 37: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

Canadian Building Envelope Science and TechnologySCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory© CAN-BEST 2005

More Info

Page 38: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

Regular Contributing Writer

to the Industry

Page 39: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

Page 40: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

Page 41: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

© CAN-BEST 2005 Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology

SCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory

Page 42: By: Elie Alkhoury, M.Eng. (Building Science), P.Eng.can-best.com/index_files/Windows - Performance Evaluation.pdf · Canadian Building Envelope Science and Technology SCC & AAMA Accredited

Canadian Building Envelope Science and TechnologySCC & AAMA Accredited Laboratory© CAN-BEST 2005

Thank You