Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf ·...

70
Asteroseismology with WFIRST Daniel Huber Institute for Astronomy University of Hawaii Sagan Workshop August 2017

Transcript of Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf ·...

Page 1: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Asteroseismology with WFIRST

Daniel Huber

Institute for Astronomy University of Hawaii

Sagan Workshop August 2017

Page 2: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Crash Course in Asteroseismology

Page 3: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Crash Course in Asteroseismology

?

Page 4: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

unnamed author, sometime in 1995

Page 5: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Radial Order n

surfacecenter

disp

lace

men

t

number of nodes from the surface to the center of the star

Page 6: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Spherical Degree l

l = 0

total number of nodes on surface of the star

Page 7: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Spherical Degree l

total number of nodes on surface of the star

l = 0

l = 2

Page 8: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

l = spherical degree (total number of surface nodes)

m = azimuthal order (number of nodes through the rotation axis)

|m| < ll = 2

|m| = 0

Spherical Harmonics Y lm

Page 9: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

l=?, |m|=?

Page 10: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

l=1, |m|=1

Page 11: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

l=?, |m|=?

Page 12: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

l=3, |m|=1

Page 13: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

δSct

roAp

CepSPB

SunDwarfs

Giants

Coherent (“Classical”)

Pulsators

Stochastic (“Solar-like”)

Oscillators

Page 14: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Oscillations in cool stars are driven by turbulent surface

convection

Mode excitation: stochastic oscillations

Page 15: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

The Sun

Page 16: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Δν = (2 ∫dr/cs)-1 ∝ (M/R3)1/2sound speed cs

Δν ~ 135 µHz for the Sun

(ω = n π c / L!)

Page 17: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Ulrich (1986)

Δν = (2 ∫dr/cs)-1 ∝ (M/R3)1/2sound speed cs

δν

δν ∝ ∫dcs/dr (Age & interior

structure)

Page 18: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

νmax

νmax ∝ νac ∝ M R-2 Teff0.5 (gravity)

Δν = (2 ∫dr/cs)-1 ∝ (M/R3)1/2 (density)

ΔνThe Sun

R <~ 5% M <~ 10%

Teff

Δν, νmax

+

Page 19: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

The Space-Photometry Revolution of

Asteroseismology

Page 20: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

pre-2009

Kjeldsen et al. 1995, Frandsen et al. 2002

Page 21: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

CoRoT

De Ridder et al. 2009, Hekker et al. 2009

Page 22: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Kepler

Hekker et al. 2011, Stello et al. 2013

Page 23: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights
Page 24: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Red Clump (He-core burning)

RGB (non He-core

burning)

Page 25: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

The cores of Red Giants: Mixed Modes

Page 26: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Multiple l=1 modes per order due to coupling with gravity modes trapped in the stellar interior (“mixed modes”)

The cores of Red Giants: Mixed Modesl=1l=1l=1

Page 27: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

non He-core

burning

He-core burning

Mean Density

Mix

ed m

ode

spac

ing

Bedding et al. 2011, Nature

Page 28: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

The Exoplanet - Asteroseismology

Synergy

Page 29: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

(RP/R★)2

M★ & R★

+

RP(<5%

uncertainty!)

Kepler-36Carter et al. 2012

Page 30: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Huber et al. (2013a)

The Kepler Host Star Sample

All Host StarsHost stars with asteroseismic

detections

Page 31: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

red giant hosting 2 transiting planets

Synergy I: Exoplanet Architectures

10.2d, 6.5R♁

21.4d, 9.8R♁

Page 32: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

~50 individual frequencies

detected

l=1 l=1 l=1

Kepler-56 Asteroseismology

Page 33: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

~50 individual frequencies

detected

mixed l=1 modes are split into triplets by

rotation

l=1 l=1 l=1

Kepler-56 Asteroseismology

Page 34: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Andrea MiglioUniversity of Birmingham, UK

Page 35: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

~50 individual frequencies

detected

mixed l=1 modes are split into triplets by

rotation

l=1 l=1 l=1

Kepler-56 Asteroseismology

i ~ 45°!

Page 36: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

~50 individual frequencies

detected

mixed l=1 modes are split into triplets by

rotation

l=1 l=1 l=1

Kepler-56 Asteroseismology

i ~ 45°!

Page 37: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Huber et al. 2013b

Page 38: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Huber et al. 2013b

confirmed as planet by Otor et al.

2016!

Page 39: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

WFIRST Asteroseismology

Page 40: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Kepler light curve

Time (Days)

Page 41: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Kepler light curve

Time (Days)

Time (Days)

Page 42: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Kepler light curve

Time (Days)

Page 43: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Kepler light curve

WFIRST Duty Cycle

Time (Days)

Page 44: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Kepler light curve

WFIRST Duty Cycle

Amplitude (H/Kp) ~ 0.5

Time (Days)

Page 45: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Kepler light curve

WFIRST Duty Cycle

Amplitude (H/Kp) ~ 0.5

WFIRST photometry

noise

Page 46: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

ΔνKepler

Page 47: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Δν

ΔνWFIRST

Kepler

Gould et al. (2014)

Page 48: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Simulated Bulge GiantsH ~ 14.8 mag log(g) ~ 1.8 R ~ 25 R ⦿

H ~ 13.6 mag log(g) ~ 2.5 R ~ 11 R ⦿

H ~ 12.1 mag log(g) ~ 3.0 R ~ 7 R ⦿

Gould et al. (2014)

Page 49: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Gould et al. (2014)

Page 50: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

~1e6 detections!

Gould et al. (2014)

Page 51: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Galactic ArcheologyHow old are the galactic bulge &

halo?

How did the thin & thick disc form?

How important is radial migration?

Page 52: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Galactic Archeology

Page 53: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

K2 Galactic Archeology ProgramStello et al. (2017)

Page 54: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

K2 Galactic Archeology Program

Challenges: - Crowded Field Photometry (4’’ pixels!)- 70 day campaigns limit distance reach

Stello et al. (2017)

Page 55: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Asteroseismic Distance Reach

Page 56: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Asteroseismic Distance Reach

Page 57: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

What can WFIRST Asteroseismology do

for Exoplanets?

Page 58: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Transiting Exoplanet Hosts

simulated WFIRST population (H<15)

Page 59: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Transiting Exoplanet Hosts

simulated WFIRST population

asteroseismic detections

simulated WFIRST population (H<15)

Page 60: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Transiting Exoplanet Hosts

simulated WFIRST population

asteroseismic detections

limit for ~1 RJ transit

detectionKepler-56

simulated WFIRST population (H<15)

Page 61: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Transiting Exoplanet Hosts

simulated WFIRST population

asteroseismic detections

Rotation

Flares(Davenport

2016)

Granulation (“Flicker”)

Bastien et al. (2013)

McQuillan et al. (2013, 2014)

Page 62: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Asteroseismology & Microlensing

Page 63: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

θ*

Asteroseismology & Microlensing

Page 64: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Banyai et al. (2013)

Source Star Variability

Page 65: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Grunblatt et al. (2017)

Source Star Variability

Granulation/Oscillations can be modeled in the time

domain!

Page 66: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Summary• Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights include interior properties of stars and characterization of transiting exoplanets

• What can WFIRST asteroseismology do for exoplanets?

• WFIRST will detect oscillations in ~1e6 giants: strong potential for galactic archeology of the bulge

- Transits: not much overlap; however, powerful for general astrophysics (e.g. rotation, granulation, flares, …)- Microlensing: strong constraints on red-giant source distance, size and variability!

Page 67: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Better Stars, Better Planets: Exploiting the Stellar - Exoplanet Synergy

(exostar19)

Better stars better planets: exploiting the Stellar - Exoplanet synergy

(exostar19)

April - June 2019, KITP SBACoordinators: Victor Silva Aguirre, Rebekah Dawson, Jim Fuller,

Daniel Huber, Katja PoppenhaegerScience advisor: Josh Winn

April - June 2019, KITP Santa Barbara

Coordinators: Victor Silva Aguirre, Rebekah Dawson, Jim Fuller, Daniel Huber, Katja Poppenhaeger

Science Advisors: Josh Winn & Eric Agol

Page 68: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

WFIRST Photometric Precision

Gould et al. (2014)

Page 69: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Asteroseismic Distances

Huber et al. (2017)

Page 70: Asteroseismology with WFIRST - NExScInexsci.caltech.edu/workshop/2017/Saganworkshop17_Huber.pdf · • Asteroseismology is a rapidly growing field in stellar astrophysics: highlights

Huber et al. (2017)