Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA...
Transcript of Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA...
![Page 1: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
1B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
Presented by B.Beaumont
Progress Towards RF Steady State Systems For Fusion Devices
A.Argouarch, B.Beaumont, G.Berger-By, P.Bibet, F.Bouquey, S.Brémond, C.Darbos, L.Delpech, , G.T.Hoang, F.Kazarian, M.Lennholm, R.Magne, L.Millon, P.Mollard,
M.Prou, K.Vulliez and Tore Supra Team
Association Euratom-CEA, Centre de Cadarache,13108 SAINT PAUL LEZ DURANCE, France
![Page 2: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
2B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
Introduction
�RF systems are widely used on magnetically confined fusion experiments. �Developments during many years have produced RF systems which have supported the progress of plasma performance and opened up new areas of investigation. �For the next step devices, long pulse operation is essential and it is a new challenge for the integration of the RF systems. They have to be highly reliable, with built-in strategies to recover from trips and breakdowns.
![Page 3: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
3B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
Outline
�A selection of recent Tore Supra experimental results
�System integration
�RF techniques developments and R&D�LHCD power upgrade,
�ITER-like ICRH antenna
�Antenna studies
�Example of RF design for ITER : in-port matching ICRH antenna
�Conclusion
![Page 4: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
4B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
Outline
�A selection of recent Tore Supra experimental results
�System integration
�RF techniques developments and R&D�LHCD power upgrade,
�ITER-like ICRH antenna
�Antenna studies
�Example of RF design for ITER : in-port matching ICRH antenna
�Conclusion
![Page 5: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
5B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
Tore Supra Exp. Results
� The progress in term of RF assisted discharges can be expressed in the domain Energy/Duration.
� Recent experimental work is focused on :� Combined operation of RF systems : The high power & performance quest
� Interaction studies : try to live together
� Identify and study specific issues :� Heat : Private heat flux, local RF losses, heat flux from other antennas, limiter connections, Protons impacts…
+ for ITER : shadowing of blanket modules, α's contributions…, NB shine through…� Coupling : Plasma/antenna distance, location of fuelling, pellet injector, relative antenna radial positions,…
� Local enhanced RF fields .. Even far from antennas
2001- the 20th IAEA
After the 20th IAEA
8 M
W
2 MW
![Page 6: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
6B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
ICRH+LHCD Multi-MW
PICRH
PLH
Ptot
MW
Ip (MA)
Stored energy(MJ)
Te(0)
Ti, @r/a=0.2
keV
Line density(1019m-2)
Simultaneous use of multi-frequencies RF heating/CD systems(ICRH, LHCD, ECH)Power level in excess of 10 MW, mainly ICRH,during pulses lasting up to several tens of resistive times
• 9MW of ICRH coupled to plasma sustained by LHCD is safe condition required forcontinuous operation
• 4MW/one minute ICRH pulse in LHCD (3MW) plasmas
shot 33612, Combination of ICRH (57 MHz - 8.5 MW) and LHCD (3.7 GHz -1.4 MW).(R=2.4m, a=0.72m, Ip= 0.9MA, BT=3.7T)
![Page 7: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
7B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
Safety Control loops
IR image of IC antenna, at t = 63.7s, in a combined ICRH (4MW)/LHCD (3MW) discharge
Various hot spots on the ICRH antennae are identified • 1: sensitive to the total power• 2: mixed total IC power and private IC power• 3: sensitive to LH power only• 4: predominantly private IC power
→ input for RT Controls & Algorithms
Reality is far from the classical λn & λq theory. Large peaking of heat fluxes:- governing the temperature and the coupled power- inducing shear stress in the components -> CFC !
![Page 8: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
8B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
Outline
�A selection of recent Tore Supra experimental results
�System integration
�RF techniques developments and R&D�LHCD power upgrade,
�ITER-like ICRH antenna
�Antenna studies
�Example of RF design for ITER : in-port matching ICRH antenna
�Conclusion
![Page 9: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
9B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
System integrationSuccessful operation of RF systems depends on integration in Tokamak system :
Arc protection / RF diagnostics / matchingreliabilitydiscrimination (cross-talk)Response time
Power controls Current balance controlArray phase controlPower Ramp-up balanceRT control loops (internal and external to RF syst.)
Recovery after trip : strategy (reduced power, counters, …)on/off solid state switch
Degraded mode of operationpart of antenna missing => Stresses=> power limitmaintenance schemes
Long process :
Trial and errors
Water leaks…
Breakdowns…
Improvements
Time…
![Page 10: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
10B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
Outline
�A selection of recent Tore Supra experimental results
�System integration
�RF techniques developments and R&D�LHCD power upgrade,
�ITER-like ICRH antenna
�Antenna studies
�Example of RF design for ITER : in-port matching ICRH antenna
�Conclusion
![Page 11: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
11B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
RF developments�Tore Supra is exploring long duration plasmas
�Plasma size (a~0.7m) : need for non inductive CD�Large operational domain = large power�Large power = appropriate PFC and controls
�Highest efficiency for volume CD is LHCD
�On going upgrade of LHCD system to 8MW:�New LHCD launcher�New high power CW klystron
�ITER support :�New TS LHCD launcher is ITER-like Design�ITER-like ICRH antenna
![Page 12: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
12B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
Outline
�A selection of recent Tore Supra experimental results
�System integration
�RF techniques developments and R&D�LHCD power upgrade,
�ITER-like ICRH antenna
�Antenna studies
�Example of RF design for ITER : in-port matching ICRH antenna
�Conclusion
![Page 13: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
13B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
LHCD upgrade�High power CW klystron development with TED:
�Target = 700 kW CW on VSWR=1.4 any phase (and 750 kW on matched load)
�5 years effort nearing completion:
�Large collector (~1600kW beam power)
�2 windows output circuit +recomb. circuit
�Diode type klystron
� Prototype has delivered 700kW on load during several hours
� problem on geometry assembly faulty brazing suspected (under investigation)
500 kW CW Mock up
CIMES
�Lessons from this R&D program:
�Close collaboration with supplier essential
�Intermediate tests to validate sub components and steps mandatory. Specific field => Dedicated test beds
![Page 14: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
14B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
LHCD upgrade�Passive/Active Multijunction Launcher:
�Large cooling efficiency
�Target n//= 1.72 +/- 0.28 @ +/- 90°
�CW power ~3MW at 25 MW/m²
�200 waveguides in total, 16 RF inputs (windows)
�3 years fabrication inc. Specific R&D
�Lessons from this R&D program
�Example of plug antenna (like all TS antennas)
�Integration of many different components & contracts
�Firms are very skilled…until they have to do the real thing
� stop points on brazing, material procurement,…
�Specific R&D performed on explosion bonding
�Tests and samples essential (as usual)
Stainless steel
Copper
1.82 mm
![Page 15: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
15B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
Outline
�A selection of recent Tore Supra experimental results
�System integration
�RF techniques developments and R&D�LHCD power upgrade,
�ITER-like ICRH antenna
�Antenna studies
�Example of RF design for ITER : in-port matching ICRH antenna
�Conclusion
![Page 16: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
16B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
ITER like ICRH Antenna
•First experiments in 2003 •Faraday shield modified to reduce coupling•Experiments in end2006/2007 with improved current control loops
Xc1
Xc2
Rs
Xs
Rs
Xs
Ia
I2
I1
Va
Xs
Xs
Xc3
Rs
Rs
Xc4I4
Vb
I3
Ibkt
kt
kpkp
Ifeed
R
0
Rin+jX i
n
Rin+jX i
n
jX c1
jX c2
I1
I2
Conventional
Conjugate-T concept = ITER Relevance : ELM Resilient Antenna
![Page 17: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
17B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
Outline
�A selection of recent Tore Supra experimental results
�System integration
�RF techniques developments and R&D�LHCD power upgrade,
�ITER-like ICRH antenna
�Antenna studies
�Example of RF design for ITER : in-port matching ICRH antenna
�Conclusion
![Page 18: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
18B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
Antenna Studies
Studies of RF components :PAM launcher for JETPAM launcher for ITEREast ICRF AntennaITER ICRF antenna…
TE10-TE30 Mode Converter
3 dB coupler
PAM
RF loads
JET PAM Launcher features 300 waveguides showing the mechanical structure which holds the wave guide array from the back flange
The ITER array is based on the PAM concept for its cooling capabilities. More than 1000 waveguides facing the plasma.
ITER LHCD launcher issues :• Efficient water cooling and neutron shielding• Antenna tip: erosion; low Z materials: brazing?• Technology options for antenna realisation:
• technology based on uni-axial iso-static pressure•machining and electron beam welding
• Materials: Glidcop or CuCrZr, Be facing plasma
![Page 19: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
19B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
Outline
�A selection of recent Tore Supra experimental results
�System integration
�RF techniques developments and R&D�LHCD power upgrade,
�ITER-like ICRH antenna
�Antenna studies
�Example of RF design for ITER : in-port matching ICRH antenna
�Conclusion
![Page 20: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
20B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
ICRH antenna is constituted of 2 parts
• Front part which is under the machine vacuum and is supported by the front part of the antenna port plug
• Rear part which is under a private vacuum isolated from the machine vacuum and is supported by the rear part of the antenna port plug
Rear partFront part
Interface (vacuum tight) between front and rear parts
Modular construction
Shielding in front part
Remote RF windows
Every component is water cooled
ITER- ICRH antenna proposal
![Page 21: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
21B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
ITER- ICRH antenna proposal
ICRH antenna constituted of 6 modules all identical except the front face (Faraday screen + current straps) that has to shape the blanket modules and plasma
This design has been made with the constraint to be able to assemble/disassemble each of the components that constitute the antenna:
Commissioning
Tests
Repair
are possible on sub assembliesExample of mechanical study : disruption
![Page 22: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
22B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
ITER- ICRH antenna proposal
• Internal components :
• Front part : static structure, vacuum tight
• Rear part : adjustable impedance, private vacuum
• Compact in port design, integrated matching
RF windows
Central conductor
RF input
Central conductor detailed
Outer conductor
Driving mechanisms, cooling
![Page 23: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
23B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
Outline
�A selection of recent Tore Supra experimental results
�System integration
�RF techniques developments and R&D�LHCD power upgrade,
�ITER-like ICRH antenna
�Antenna studies
�Example of RF design for ITER : in-port matching ICRH antenna
�Conclusion
![Page 24: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
24B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
Conclusion• Significant progress of injected RF power has been obtainedin steady state operation in Tore Supra• On going studies on RF systems, incl. ITER, take into account integration aspects, key element for success:
� Magnetic field lines connections (shadows, fuelling system, connection length…)� Interaction with other antennas, beams,…� Protections, RT control loops � Safe operation (Machine&RF)� Degraded modes of operation� Recovery from trips� Commissioning and conditioning� Readiness tests
• BUT it could be a long process
• Uncertainties on design parameters call for margins
![Page 25: Association Euratom-CEA TORE SUPRA Progress Towards RF ...TORE SUPRA Association Euratom-CEA B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems 5 Tore Supra Exp. Results The progress](https://reader030.fdocuments.net/reader030/viewer/2022040900/5e702a119169362ac4171650/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
TORE SUPRAAssociationEuratom-CEA
25B.Beaumont / Chengdu / 21.10.06 Steady State RF Systems
EpilogueIt is not guaranteed that one has a fully
operational system even though all bits and pieces described in the WBS are available:
Figueras, Spain, near Dali Museum