APP-OCS-GEH-122, 'AP1000 Human Factors Engineering …Enclosure 6 NND-13-0521 Page 6 of 101 AP1000...

South Carolina Electric & Gas Company

NND-13-0521

Enclosure 6

Virgil C. Summer Nuclear Station (VCSNS) Units 2 and 3

APP-OCS-GEH-122, "AP1000 Human Factors Engineering

Design Verification Plan," Revision I-I-.

(LAR 13-16)

Enclosure 6NND-13-0521 of 101

OWestinghouseWestinghouse Non-Proprietary Class 3

AP1000

Human Factors Engineering DesignVerification Plan

APP-OCS-GEH-122,Rev. 1

August 2013

APPROVALS

Function Name and Signature

Author Julie I. Reed*Fellow Engineer, Human Factors & Operations

Reviewer Zhonghai Li*Senior Engineer, Human Factors & Operations

Robert W. Beasley*Acting Project Manager, Human Factors Engineering

Approver Steven P. Kerch*I Acting Manager, Human Factors & Operations

*Electronically approved records are authenticated in the electronic document management system.

WESTINGHOUSE NON-PROPRIETAR Y CLASS 3

© 2013 Westinghouse Electric Company LLCAll Rights Reserved

Enclosure 6NND-13-0521 of 101AP1000 Human Factors Engineering Design Verification Plan

LIST OF CONTRIBUTORS

Revision Name and Title

A Julie I. ReedPrincipal Engineer, Human Factors & Operations

A Sarah J. BarczykManager, Technical Communications

B Zachary T. CasellaProject Engineer, Control Room Design

0 Steven P. KerchTechnical Adviser, Operator Interface Engineering

0 Zhonghai LiSenior Engineer, Human Factors & Operations

0 Sarah E. MichalowskiTechnical Editor, Technical Communications

1 Nina T. O'HellaTechnical Writer/Editor, Technical Communications

Template Version 2.3

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 i

Enclosure 6NND-13-0521 of 101API000 Human Factors Engineering Design Verification Plan

REVISION HISTORY

RECORD OF CHANGES

Revision Author Description Completed

A Todd W. Van Meter Preliminary Issue 6/2008

B Todd W. Van Meter Class 3 changes. Revision was created to prepare the 4/2009document with proprietary markings for transmittal.

0 Julie I. Reed Incorporation of APP-GW-GEE-4044, Rev. 0.

Numerous updates to the References and Bibliographyin accordance with the latest documents and revisions.

Minor editorial clarifications throughout the document.

Subsection 1.1.2, "Prerequisite," Section 2.1 "GeneralProcess," Section 2.3, "Criteria," Section 3.1,"Personnel Requirements and Techniques," andAppendices B and C: Clarified that the HSI designguideline allocations in Appendices B and C arepreliminary and need to be checked and updated (ifrequired) by the verifier prior to design verification.

Subsection 1.1.3, "Process Strategy:" Added adescription of the method to deal with design changesafter design verification has been completed. Addedreference to APP-GW-GOY-002, "AP 1000Configuration Management Plan" andWNA-PC-0005-WAPP, "AP1000 I&C ProjectsConfiguration Management Plan".

Subsection 1.2.1, "Applicability:" Added reference toAPP-OCS-GLR-001, "AP1000 Post-AccidentRisk-Important Human Actions Summary Report."

Subsection 1.2.2, "List of Human System InterfacesRequiring Verification:" Updated and clarified the listof HSI Resources and Operation and Control Centers.

Subsection 1.2.3, "Limitation of Scope:" Stated thatthe TSC is not included as part of the verification.Added that the design verification for the EOF and theTSC are addressed in Task Support Verification and/orDesign Verification at Plant Startup.

Subsection 1.4, "List of Exceptions fromWCAP-15860." A new section is added to identifydeviations from WCAP-15860 "Programmatic LevelDescription of the AP 1000 Human Factors Verificationand Validation Plan."

3/2013

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 iiAPP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I ii


REVISION HISTORY (cont.)

RECORD OF CHANGES (cont.)

Revision Author Description I Completed

0 (cont.) I Julie I. Reed Section 2.1, "General Process:" Included a note thatHEDs are entered into the SPF Human FactorsTracking System.

Section 2.1, "General Process:" Deleted information onthe HED resolution process, responsibilities,prioritization, resolution, and the justification ofdeviations.

Section 2.1, "General Process:" Changed thedescription of design verification completion fromapproval of the HED Resolution Report(APP-OCS-GER-420) to approval of the DesignVerification Report (APP-OCS-GER- 120). Deletedsentence "The OCS Product Manager is responsible forthe HFE design verification activity and resourceassignment."

Section 2.2, "Resource Assignment:" Changed 'OCSProduct Manager' to 'HF Manager' (in multiplesubsections). Changed the definition of 'independentverifier' and included a reference to NSNP 3.3.3"Design Verification by Independent Review orAlternate Calculations."

Section 2.3, "Criteria:" Added a reference toAPP-GW-GRP-001, "Local Panels and MaintainabilityHuman Factors Design Guidelines."

Section 3.2, "Discrepancy Documentation:" Added areference to APP-OCS-GER-420, "AP 1000 HumanFactors Engineering Discrepancy Resolution Process."

Updated the description of the HFE discrepancy formand changed Appendix A to reflect the updated DesignVerification form in the HF Tracking System.

Section 3.3, "Deliverables:" Minor updates regardingthe HF Tracking System, HED resolution process, andadded a reference to APP-GW-GRP-001, "LocalPanels and Maintainability Human Factors DesignGuidelines."

3/2013

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 i.°


REVISION HISTORY (cont.)

RECORD OF CHANGES (cont.)

Revision Author Description Completed

I Julie I. Reed Incorporation of APP-GW-GEE-4523, Rev. 0. See EDMS

Updated document revision numbers in the

Bibliography.

Section 1.2.3, "Limitation of Scope" and Section 1.4,"List of Exceptions from WCAP- 15860," deleted

statement that the design verification of the Technical

Support Center will be in the scope of the humanfactors design verification at plant startup.

Section 1.2.3, "Limitation of Scope" and Section 1.4,"List of Exceptions from WCAP-15860," added

reference to APP-GW-GJP- 150, "Operating

Procedures Verification and Validation."

Note: An alternative document number is

APP-OCS-GEH- 120 (proprietary version)

U DocUMENT TRACEABILITY & COMPLIANCE 7

Created to Support the Following Document(s) Document Number Revision

AP1000 Human Factors Engineering Program Plan APP-OCS-GBH-001 1

OPEN ITEMS

Item Description Status

None.

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I iv


TABLE OF CONTENTS

Section Title Page

LIST O F CO N TRIBU TO RS ....................................................................................... i

REV ISION H ISTO RY ................................................................................................ ii

TA BLE O F CON TEN TS ............................................................................................. v

LIST O F TA BLES ....................................................................................................... vi

LIST O F FIG U RES ..................................................................................................... vi

A CRON Y M S AN D TRA D EM A RK S ......................................................................... vii

G LO SSA RY O F TERM S ............................................................................................ Viii

REFEREN CES ............................................................................................................ ix

SECTION I IN TRO D U CTIO N ....................................................................................................... 1-1

1.1 O V ERV IEW ................................................................................................................ 1-1

1.1.1 Purpose ........................................................................................................................ 1-1

1.1.2 Prerequisite .................................................................................................................. 1-1

1.1.3 Process Strategy ........................................................................................................... 1-1

1.2 SCO PE ......................................................................................................................... 1-2

1.2.1 A pplicability ................................................................................................................ 1-2

1.2.2 List of H um an Systern Interfaces Requiring V erification ........................................... 1-3

1.2.3 Lim itation of Scope ...................................................................................................... 1-4

1.3 O BJECTIV E ........................................................................................................... 1

1.4 LIST O F EX CEPTIO N S FRO M W CAP-15860 ......................................................... 1-4

SECTION 2 VERIFICA TION PRO CESS ....................................................................................... 2-1

2.1 G EN ERA L PRO CESS ................................................................................................ 2-1

2.2 RESO URCE A SSIGN M EN T ...................................................................................... 2-1

2.3 CRITERIA ................................................................................................................... 2-1

2.4 D ESIGN CHAN G E V ERIFICA TION ........................................................................ ?-,)

SECTION 3 M ETH O D O LO G Y AN D M EA SU RES ...................................................................... 3-1

3.1 PERSONNEL REQUIREMENTS AND TECHNIQUES ........................................... 3-1

3.2 D ISC REPA N CY D O CU M EN TA TION ...................................................................... 3-1

3.3 D ELIVERA BLES ........................................................................................................ 3-3

APPENDIX A HFE DESIGN VERIFICATION DISCREPANCY FORM ........................................ A-1

APPENDIX B PRELIMINARY ALLOCATION OF HFE DESIGN GUIDELINES TO HSI

RESO U RCES .............................................................................................................. B-1

APPENDIX C PRELIMINARY ALLOCATION OF HFE DESIGN GUIDELINES TO

O PERATION AN D CON TRO L CEN TERS ............................................................... C-1

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 v


TABLE OF CONTENTS (cont.)

LIST OF TABLES

Table Title Page

None.

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure Title Page

None.

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 viAPP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I Ai


ACRONYMS AND TRADEMARKS

Acronyms used in the document are defined in APP-GW-J9Y-001 (WNA-PS-00016-GEN), "StandardAcronyms and Definitions" (Reference 1), or included below to ensure unambiguous understanding oftheir use within this document.

Acronym Definition

HF Human FactorsSPF SmartPlant® FoundationTDC Technical Document Control

API 000 is a trademark or registered trademark of Westinghouse Electric Company LLC, its affiliatesand/or its subsidiaries in the United States of America and may be registered in other countries throughoutthe world. All rights reserved. Unauthorized use is strictly prohibited. Other names may be trademarks oftheir respective owners.

SmartPlant is a trademark or registered trademark of its respective owner. Other names may betrademarks of their respective owners.

All other product and corporate names used in this document may be trademarks or registered trademarksof other companies, and are used only for explanation and to the owners' benefit, without intent toinfringe.

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 viiAPP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 Vii

Enclosure 6NND-13-0521 of 101AP100 Human Factors Enaineerine Desien Verification Plan

GLOSSARY OF TERMS

Standard terms used in the document are defined in APP-GW-J9Y-001 (WNA-PS-00016-GEN),"Standard Acronyms and Definitions" (Reference 1), or included below to ensure unambiguousunderstanding of their use within this document.

Term Definition

Human Factors Engineering(HFE) Design Verification

Independent Verifier

An evaluation to confinn that the human system interface (HSI)resources and Operation and Control Centers Systems (OCSs) aredesigned in conformance with the AP1000® HSI design guidelines.

Any competent individual(s) or group(s) other than those who performedthe original design work, but who may be from the same organization orgroup.

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 viiiAPP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 Viii


REFERENCES

Following is a list of references used throughout this document.

I. APP-GW-J9Y-001, Rev. 0 (WNA-PS-00016-GEN, Rev. 5), "Standard Acronyms and Definitions,"Westinghouse Electric Company LLC. (Proprietary)

2. APP-OCS-GBH-001, Rev. 1, "AP1000 Human Factors Engineering Program Plan," WestinghouseElectric Company LLC. (Proprietary)

3. APP-OCS-GEH-020, Rev. 2 (WCAP-15860), "Programmatic Level Description of the API000Human Factors Verification and Validation Plan," Westinghouse Electric Company LLC.

4. NUREG-071 1, Rev. 2, "Human Factors Engineering Program Review Model," U.S. NuclearRegulatory Commission.

5. ISO 11064-7, First Edition, "Ergonomic Design of Control Centers, Part 7: Principles for theEvaluation of Control Centers," International Organization for Standardization.

6. APP-GW-GOY-002., Rev. 3, "AP 1000 Configuration Management Plan," Westinghouse ElectricCompany LLC. (Proprietary)

7. WNA-PC-00005-WAPP, Rev. 2, "AP 1000 I&C Projects Configuration Management Plan,"Westinghouse Electric Company LLC. (Proprietary)

8. WEC 3.3.3, Rev. 0.0, "Design Verification," Westinghouse Electric Company LLC, effectiveMarch 26, 2013.

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 ix


BIBLIOGRAPHY

Following is a list of sources that were considered in preparing this document.

1. APP-OCS-J1-002, Rev. 2, "AP1000 Human System Interface Design Guidelines," WestinghouseElectric Company LLC. (Proprietary)

2. APP-OCS-GEH-220, Rev. 1., "AP 1000 Human Factors Engineering Task Support VerificationPlan," Westinghouse Electric Company LLC. (Proprietary)

3. APP-OCS-GEH-320, Rev. 3, "API000 Human Factors Engineering Integrated System ValidationPlan," Westinghouse Electric Company LLC. (Proprietary)

4. APP-OCS-GEH-420, Rev. 1, "AP 1000 Human Engineering Discrepancy Resolution Process,"Westinghouse Electric Company LLC. (Proprietary)

5. APP-OCS-GEH-520, Rev. 2, "Plant Startup Human Factors Engineering Verification Plan,"Westinghouse Electric Company LLC. (Proprietary).

6. APP-GW-GL-0 11, Rev. 0, "AP1000 Identification of Critical Human Actions and Risk ImportantTasks," Westinghouse Electric Company LLC.

7. APP-OCS-GLR-001, Rev. 0, "AP1000 Post-Accident Risk-Important Human Actions SummaryReport," Westinghouse Electric Company LLC. (Proprietary)

8. APP-GW-GJP-100, Rev. 0, "Writer's Guideline for Operating Procedures," Westinghouse ElectricCompany LLC. (Proprietary)

9. APP-GW-GJP-150, Rev. 0, "Operating Procedures Verification and Validation," WestinghouseElectric Company LLC. (Proprietary)

10. APP-GW-GRP-001, Rev. I, "AP1000 Local Panels and Maintainability Human Factors DesignGuidelines," Westinghouse Electric Company LLC. (Proprietary)

11. APP-GW-GL-700, Rev. 19, "AP1000 Design Control Document," Westinghouse ElectricCompany LLC.

12. APP-OCS-J7-001, Rev. 0, "API000 Operations and Control Centers System - System SpecificationDocument," Westinghouse Electric Company LLC. (Proprietary)

13. NUREG-0700, Rev. 2, "Human-System Interface Design Review Guidelines," U.S. NuclearRegulatory Commission.

(Last Page of Front Matter)

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 X

Enclosure 6NND-13-0521 of 101

AP1000 Human Factors Engineering Design Verification Plan

SECTION 1INTRODUCTION

1.1 OVERVIEW

1.1.1 Purpose

The purpose of this document is to define the Human Factors (HF) Engineering (HFE) design verificationplan for the AP 1000® plant.

This document is based on the information and guidance described in APP-OCS-GBH-001, "AP1000Human Factors Engineering Program Plan" (Reference 2); APP-OCS-GEH-020 (WCAP-15860),"Programmatic Level Description of the AP1000 Human Factors Verification and Validation Plan"

(Reference 3); NUREG-07 11, "Human Factors Engineering Program Review Model" (Reference 4); andISO 11064-7, "Ergonomic Design of Control Centers, Part 7: Principles for the Evaluation of ControlCenters" (Reference 5).

1.1.2 Prerequisite

This document uses the guidelines contained in APP-OCS-J1-002, "AP1000 Human System InterfaceDesign Guidelines" (Bibliog 1) as the primary source of input for establishing the HFE design verification

criteria. [

]ac

1.1.3 Process Strategy

Formal HF verification and validation (V&V) activities are an integral part of the overall HFE designprocess. These activities and associated documents include the following, as defined in the HFE Program

Plan (Reference 2):

* APP-OCS-GER-120, "AP 1000 Human Factors Engineering Design Verification Report"[LATER]

* APP-OCS-GEH-220, "AP 1000 Human Factors Engineering Task Support Verification Plan"(Bibliog 2)

" APP-OCS-GER-220, "AP 1000 Human Factors Engineering Task Support Verification Report"[LATER]

APP-OCS-GEII-122, Rev. 1 1-1APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 1-1


* APP-OCS-GEH-320, "AP 1000 Human Factors Engineering Integrated System Validation Plan"(Bibliog 3)

* APP-OCS-GER-320, "AP 1000 Human Factors Engineering Integrated System ValidationReport" [LATER]

* APP-OCS-GEH-420, "AP 1000 Human Engineering Discrepancy Resolution Process" (Bibliog 4)

" APP-OCS-GER-420, "AP 1000 Human Engineering Discrepancy Resolution Report" [LATER]

* APP-OCS-GEH-520, "Plant Startup Human Factors Engineering Design Verification Plan"(Bibliog 5)

* APP-OCS-GER-520, "Plant Startup Human Factors Engineering Design Verification Report"[LATER]

These V&V activities are a final check of the adequacy of the HSI Resources and Operation and ControlCenters System (OCS) design.

pac

1.2 SCOPE

1.2.1 Applicability

This document is applicable to the AP1000 HSI resources and Operation and Control Centers Systems(OCS) as identified in subsection 1.2.2.

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 1-2


]ac

1.2.2 List of Human System Interfaces Requiring Verification

Below is a list of specific HSI resources and OCS that require design verification. Additional interfacesmay be added to this list as they are identified by HFE personnel.

1. HSI Resources

I

pac

APP-OCS-CEII-122, Rev. 1 1-3APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 1-3


2. Operation and Control Centers System

I

]a,c

1.2.3 Limitation of Scope

I

]a.c

1.3 OBJECTIVE

The overall objective of V&V is to ensure that the API000 design attains a high standard of HF adequacyand thereby contributes to the safety, operability and maintainability of the plant.

The objective of HFE design verification is to confirm that HSI resources and OCS conform to theproject's HFE design guidelines, identify deviations, resolve deviations, and formally document theresults. The HSI design guidelines are established to ensure that the HS1 design can accommodate humancapabilities and limitations and to provide a consistent HSI design approach across the project. TheAPI000 HSI design guidelines are contained in APP-OCS-J1-002 (Bibliog 1), and are discussed inSection 2.3, "Criteria."

1.4 LIST OF EXCEPTIONS FROM WCAP-15860

The HFE design verification complies with WCAP-15860, "Programmatic Level Description of theAP 1000 Human Factors Verification and Validation Plan" (Reference 3). However, WCAP-15860 wasissued relatively early in the design stage of AP1000, and therefore, based on the current AP1000 design,three adjustments are required. These are described below:

[

]a,c


Enclosure 6NND-13-0521 of 101APIO00 Human Factors Engineering Design Verification Plan

I

]a.,c

(Last Page of Section 1)



SECTION 2VERIFICATION PROCESS

2.1 GENERAL PROCESS

This HFE design verification plan is established to confirm that the HSI resources and OCS are designed

to accommodate human capabilities and limitations. To meet this objective, the HSI resources and OCS

are evaluated against the design guidelines specified in APP-OCS-J1-002 "AP1000 Human System

Interface Design Guidelines (Bibliog 1) by an independent verifier. Appendix B, "HSI Resource Design

Verification Guidelines," and Appendix C, "Operation and Control Center Design Verification

Guidelines," provides an initial basis to correlate the specific guidelines (mandatory and recommended) to

the HSI resource or OCS.

Each HSI resource and OCS is evaluated as "Pass" or "Fail" using the criteria as described in Section 2.3.

Each HSI resource or OCS that is evaluated as a "Fail" is submitted as a Design Verification Discrepancy

in the SmartPlant® Foundation (SPF) HF Tracking System (see Section 3.2 for further details).

The HFE design verification activity is considered complete when HEDs are entered into the tracking

database and the formal APP-OCS-GER-120 "AP 1000 HFE Design Verification Report" is approved.

2.2 RESOURCE ASSIGNMENT

The HF Manager is responsible for identifying the HFE evaluation team. The HFE evaluation team

consists of independent verifiers and the design engineering team. See WEC 3.3.3, "Design Verification"

(Reference 8), for additional guidance on personnel independence and qualifications. The HFE evaluation

team uses the approved acceptance criteria (Bibliog 1) for performing the HFE design verification.

2.3 CRITERIA

]a,c

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I 2-1

Enclosure 6NND-13-0521Page19 of 101AP1000 Human Factors Engineering Design Verification Plan

I a~c

2.4 DESIGN CHANGE VERIFICATION

I

ac




SECTION 3METHODOLOGY AND MEASURES

3.1 PERSONNEL REQUIREMENTS AND TECHNIQUES

To provide an independent and unbiased review, the HFE design verification process is performed byindependent verifiers with input from other design team members. As necessary, the design engineers willprovide all configuration and control documentation (e.g., drawing, specifications) related to the HSIresource and OCS under evaluation to the independent verifier.

Sa~c

3.2 DISCREPANCY DOCUMENTATION

Discrepancies are identified as HEDs and are required to be addressed by the formal resolution process,as described in APP-OCS-GEH-420 (Bibliog 4).

ac

The HFE discrepancy form includes the following type of information:

]a,c

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I 3-1

Enclosure 6NND-13-0521 of 101API 000 Human Factors Engineering Design Verification Plan

I

]a,c

APP-OCS-G EII-1 22, Rev. 1 3-2APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I 3-2


]a,c

3.3 DELIVERABLES

The deliverables are defined in Section 5.9, "Verification and Validation," ofAPP-OCS-GBH-001,"API1000 Human Factors Engineering Program Plan" (Reference 2).

[

ac


APP-OCS-GEII-122, Rev. I 3-3APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I 3-3


APPENDIX AHFE DESIGN VERIFICATION DISCREPANCY FORM

a,c

Figure A-1. Human Factors Discrepancy Form in SPF HF Tracking System

(Last Page of Appendix A)

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 A-1


APPENDIX BPRELIMINARY ALLOCATION OF HFE DESIGN GUIDELINES TO HSI RESOURCES

NoteThe design of the HSI resources may change or the HSI Design Guidelines maybe updated prior to the implementation of Design Verification. Therefore, theinformation in this Appendix is provided as guidance or an example of theallocation of the HSI Design Guidelines (Bibliog 1) to the HSI resources. Theverifier is responsible for the actual allocation of guidelines to the HSI resources;this will be documented in the results report, APP-OCS-GER-120.

Table B-I. HSI Resources and HFE Design Guidelines

__ __ I __ __ __ __ I ___ I ___

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 B-1

Enclosure 6NND-13-0521 of 101APIO00 Human Factors Enaineerine Design Verification Plan

Table B-I. HSI Resource and HFE Design Guidelines (cont.)

a-c

I I I I I I I

t I t -~

__ __ __ __ .. __I __ __

___ __ ___ __ __ [ ___ ____ ___

___ ___ I ___ ___ ___ I ___ ____ ___

I I t t I* t

I I 4- I I I I

4 4 4. 1 1 1 1

I 4 ± 4 I I t

4 4 + f-I I I

4 4 4- 4 4 1 4

4 4 4- 4 4 1 4

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I B-2APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 B-2


Table B-1. HSI Resource and HFE Design Guidelines (cont.)ac




axc

4 4 4 I 4 4 4

4 4 * 4

4 4 * 4

.4 .4 4 4 4

___ I __ I ___ I __ I __ I ___I ___ I ___

I '.1

__ I..APP-OCS-GEII-122, Rev. I B-4APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I B-4



ac

+ i 4 + 4 4- +

+ + 4 + 4 4- +

+ 4- 4 + 4 4-

-I- 4- 4 + 4 4- *1-

+ + 4 + 4 + +

+ + 4 + 4 4- +

I IIII

__ II __ __ I __ __ I ___ I __

APP-OCS-GEII-122, Rev. 1 B-5APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 B-5



ac

I4 4 4 -4 4 4 4

4 4 4 4 4 4 4

4 * 4 4 4 * 4

4 4 4- -t 4 - 4 4

4 4 i 4 i 4 4

4 4 4 4 4 4 4

4 4 4 4 4 4 4

4 4 4 4 4 4 *

4 4 4 4 4 4 4

4 4 i 4 i 4 4

4 4 4 4 4 4 4

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I B-6APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I B-6


Table B-I. HSI Resource and HFE Design Guidelines (cont.)ac

1- 4 1- 1 1

1- ± 1 1- 1 1 1-

1- ± 1 1- 1 1 1-

+ + 4 .1- 4 1 1-

4- + 4 + 4 4 +

4-4 + + 1 + 1

+ + I + 1 1-

+ + 4 + 4 + +

_ _ I _ I _ _ _ I _ _ I _




a.c

4- 4 4 4- 4 4 +

4- 4 4 + i i +

4- 4 4 + 4 4 +

4 4 4- 4 4 4-

4- 4 4 4- 4

4- 4 4 4- 4 4 4-

4- 4 4 4- 4 4 4-

__ I __ __ *I __ __ ___ I __

__ I __ I __ __ I __ __ ___ I __

__ I __ I __ __ I __ __ ___ I __

+ 4- 4 + 4 4 4-

+ 4- 4 + 4 4

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 B-8APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 B-8

Enclosure 6NND-13-0521 of 101AP 000 Human Factors Engineering Design Verification Plan

Table B-1. HSI Resource and HFE Design Guidelines (cont.)

axc

4 + 4- 4 4- + 4

4 + 4 4 4- + 4

4 + + 4 + + 4

4 4- 4 + + 4

4 4- 4 4 + 4

4 + 4 + + +

4 + 4 + + +

4 + 4 + + 4

4 +-+ + + 4




axc

.1. _________ .1. ______________ __________

__ I __ [ __ I __ 1 __ .1. __ 1 ___ t __

& 4 & 4 4

L L 4 & 4 4

* I t

I I I I

I I I. I. I

I I I. I I *

I I I I t t

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 B-bAPP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 B-10



APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 B-1I1



axr 1 T 1 T 7

.1- 4- 4 + 4 4- +

4- 4- 4- + 4 4- +

4 + 4- 4 4 + +

_ _, _ I_ _I _ _ II_ _ I _

___ [ __ I ___ I __ I __ I __ I ___ I ___

t 1- 4- 4- *1- 4-

I I + -I + + +

I + + I + +

__ __ __ IAPP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I B-13


Table B-i. HSI Resource and HFE Design Guidelines (cont.)

a-c

4 + 4- 4 4- + 4

i

APP-OCS-GEII-122, Rev. 1 B-i 4APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I B-14



I I I I I I

1 1 1 1 1 1 1

1"1 1 1

4

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I B-15

Enclosure 6NND-13-0521 of 101AP1O00 Human Factors Engineering Design Verification Plan


a c.v

.4- .4- 1 1 1-

+ + 1 + 1 .4- ±

+ 4- I *I- 1 1-

*1- 1- 1 1 1-

+ 4- I + I 4- +

+ 4- I + 4 + +

.4- 4- 4 ~4- 4 4- 4-

+ 4- I + 1 4- 4-

+ 4- i + i 4- 4

4- 4- 1 4- 4 4- 4-

+ + 4- 4- I 4- 4-

+ + 4- + 1 4- 4

4- 4- 4- + I 4- 4-

4- + 4- 4-- 1 4- 4-

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 ff46APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I B-16



axc

i 4 i i 4

I 4 4 4 4 A +

4 4 4 4 4 4

1 1 1 1 1 1 1

_ _ _ _ I _ I _ _ I _ _ - _ I __ ] _




a.c

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 B-18APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I B-18



a.c

__ I __ I __ __ I __ I __ I ___ I __

APP-OCS-GEII-122, Rev. I B-20APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I B-20



a cv

+ + I + I -4- +

1- 4 4 .4- 4 4- +

__________ I _________ I __________ _________I _________ __________ I _____________ I __________

4 + 4- + 4 + +

4- + 4- -4-- 1 - i- +

4 + + + 1 + +

4 + + + I + +

4 + + 4 4 + +

4 + + 4 4 + +

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I R-2 1APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I B-21

Enclosure 6NND-1 3-0521 of 101APIO00 Human Factors Engineering Design Verification Plan

Table B-I. HSI Resource and HFE Design Guidelines (cont.)a.x

r 1 r 1 I

I 4 t I 1 1

4 t I t 1

.4 4 4 I t I I

.4 4 4 4- * I I

4- 4 4 4- 4 .4 4

4- 4 4 4- 4 4 4-

1- 1 1 1- 1 1

4- 4 I 4- 4 1 4-

.4. 4- 4 4- 4 4- 4-

.4- 4- 4 4- 4 4- +

4 4- 4- .4. 1 1- -4-

4 4- 4- 4 4 4- 4-

-4. 4- 4- 4 4 4- +

4 4- 4- 4. 1- -4- .4-

4 4- 4- 4. 4- .4. .4.

4 4 4 4. 4- + 4.

___________ _________ 1 .1. L .1.




ax

4- 4 4 4- 4 4

+ + 4 1- 4 1 1-

+ + 4 4- 4 4 4-

*1- -I- 4 4- 4 '4 4-

I 1 1 1 1I*1~




a.c

4 + 4 4 1 1 1

4 4- 4 4

I 4- 4 4

*1- ± 4 *I- 1 1 1

4- + 4 + I I I

__ I __ I __ __ I __ I __ I ___ I __

+ *9- 1- -I- I ± 4-

4 4- 4- + 4 4- +

4 4- 4- + 4 4- +




a.c

44

I 4 * * 4

I 4 4 4 4

I 4 4 4 4 .4 .4

I 4 4 4 4 4

I 4 4 1 t 4 .4

I 4 4 4 4 4

*1 1 1 1 1 1 1




APP-OCS-GEII-122, Rev. 1 B-26APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I B-26



__ I __ I ___ I __ I __ I __ I ___ I __

____ I ___ [ ____ I ___ I' I ____ I _____ I ____

___ I __ ___ I __ I __ I __ I ___ I ___

4 + + + + +

4 4 -4- + + +

+ -t + 1- 4

+ + + -4- 4

+ 4 + + +

APP-OCS-GEII-122, Rev. I B-27APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I B-27



ac

__ I __ I __ I __ I __ I __ I ___ I ___




a.c

+ 'I I I I I-


Enclosure 6NND-13-0521 of 101APIOOO Human Factors Engineering Design Verification Plan


ac

4 4 4 * * 4

4 4 4 4 4

4 * 4 * * 4

I * 4 * * 4



Table B-1. HSI Resource and HFE Design Guidelines (cont.)a c

4 + + 4- 1- 4 4

__I _ __I __ __I __I __ I _

_ _ _

* * *4- 4

4 4 .4- 4 4 4 4

4 4 4- 4 4 4 4

4 4 4 4 t t t

4 4 4 4 t t t

4 4 4 4 4 4 4

1 4 4 4 I- 4 4

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 B-33APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 B-33



axc

L I. I. 4 -I. $ 4

4 t T

* 4 4 -t t 4

4 4+

44

4 4 4 4 4 4 4

A I 4- 4 4 4 4

4 1 4 4 4 1

4 1 + 4 4 4 1

__ I __ I __ I __




a -cv

III TI I_____ ____ I _____ I* ____ I ____ I ______ ____

APP-OCS-GEII-122, Rev. 1 B-35APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I B-35



ac

I"

I

I1

___ __ __ __ __ __ I ___ __




axc

__________ ± _________ J ___________ J

+ 4- 1 -I- 1- 1-

+ + 1 + 4- ± 4-

4- 4 4 + + + +

4 4 4 4- 4- + *I.

4- + +

4- + +

4 +

I I 4- 1 4 4 1

__ __ __IAPP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 B-37



4- 1 1 -I- 1 1- -I-

+ 1- 1 -I- 1 1- -I-

+ 4- 1 -~ 1 1- -1-

+ 4- 4- + I 4- 4-

+ 4- 4- 4 1 + +

-~ 4- 4- 4- 1 + +

I I I 1 1 1 1

(Last Page of Appendix B)



APPENDIX CPRELIMINARY ALLOCATION OF HFE DESIGN GUIDELINES TO OPERATION

AND CONTROL CENTERS

Note

The design of the operation and control centers may change or the HSI Design

Guidelines may be updated prior to the implementation of the Design

Verification. Therefore, the information in this Appendix is provided as guidance

or an example of the allocation of the HSI Design Guidelines (Bibliog 1) to the

operations and control centers. The verifier is responsible for the actual allocation

of guidelines to the operation and control centers in accordance with the scope of

design verification as specified in Section 1.2 "Scope". This will be documented

in the results report, APP-OCS-GER-120.

Table C-I. Operation and Control Center and HFE Design Guidelines

a~c

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 C-1


Table C-I. Operation and Control Center and HWE Guidelines (cont.)axc

+ + + t + *1-

+ + + t 1- 1-

I I I I I I

__ I __ __ I __ ___ I ___ I __

+ + I + +

4 4 4 + +



Table C-1. Operation and Control Center and HFE Guidelines (cont.)axc

I

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 C-3APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I C-3


Table C-I. Operation and Control Center and HFE Guidelines (cont.)axc

4 + + + i +

4 4 4 + 4 +

4 + 4 1 4

4 + + 4 +

4 4 4 4

4 4 4 +

___ __I __ I ___I ____ ____ I __

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I C-4


Table C-I. Operation and Control Center and HFE Guidelines (cont.)ac

4 -I- + 4 +

4 *4- -4- 4 +

4 + + 4 -I.

4 4 4 4 4

t I -4- 4- 1

4 4 4 -4- 4 4

4- 4 4

I I I I I I



Table C-I. Operation and Control Center and HFE Guidelines (cont.)a,c

4- 4 4 4 + 4

4- 4 4 4- -4

+ 4 4 4 *t- 4

4- 4 4 4 4- 4

4- 1- 1- 1

4- 4- *1- 1- 4

+ 4 + 4- 4

+ 4 + + 4

4- 4 4- 1 4- 4



Table C-1. Operation and Control Center and HFE Guidelines (cont.)ac

4 4- 4 + 4 4

1 .5- .5 -5. 4 4

___ I __ t __ I ___ I ____ I ____ I __

4- 4- t 4- 1-

4- t 4- 4-

5. 1 * 4- +

5. 5. * 4- +

I & 5. 4 -5. .5-

-t 5. 5. 1 4- 4-

I 5. 5. 1 5. -4-




APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 C-8APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 C-8



4 + 4 i i i

*1 -I. t -I- t

4 + 4 * + t

4 4 4 * + t

.4. 4 4 + 4

__ __ I __

APP-OCS-GEH-l 22, Rev. I C-9APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I C-9



+ 4 + + 4-

4 t 1- 1-

____ I ___ I ___ I> _____ I _____ ____

--I-

1- 4 4 t 1- 1

+ + + I + I

+ 4 + I + I

+ 4 + 1 + 1

+ + + 1 + 1

+ 4 + I + I

+ 4 + i + i




1- 1- 1 4- 1 1

4- 4- 4 1- 1 1

4- + 4 4- 4 4

4- + 4 -~ 4 4 -

4- + 1 4- 1 1

4- + + 4- 1- -i

4- + 4- 4 4- 4

4- 4- 4- 4 4- 4

+ 4 + 4- 4

+ 4 4- 4- 4

.1. 4 .4- + 4

.1. .5. .5. 5. .5. .1

APP-OCS-GEII-122, Rev. 1 .C-11

Enclosure 6NND-13-0521 of 101AP1000 Human Factors Engineerine Design Verification Plan

Table C-I. Operation and Control Center and HFE Guidelines (cont.)

ac

4 4 * 4- * 4

4 4 4 4- 4 4

4 4 4 + 4 4

4 4 4 + 4 4

__ __ __ ~ __ r ___ ___ __

_______ ______ ______ 1* .i. __________ __________ _______

4 4 1 *4- 4 4

4 1- 1 *I- 4 t

I I- I 4- 4 t

4 4- 4 + 4 4

I 1- 1 4 4

__ __ I __ __ I ____ ____ __




4 4 4 I.

4 4- *1- 4- 4 4

4 1- *I- -~ 4 4

4 .4. -1- -4. 4 4.

I *t- 4- 4. 4.

-I 4- + 4- 4 4

___ I __ I __ I ___I ____ I ____ [ __




.1- 4 + + +

+ 4 + 1 +

4 4 + 1 + 4-

_ _• _ I _ F _ _ _ _ _I _ _ _I_

I I * + +

I I 4 4 +

I I I * 4- 4

I * I 4 I 1-


Enclosure 6NND-13-0521 of 101API 000 Human Factors Enaineering Design Verification Plan

Table C-i. Operation and Control Center and HFE Guidelines (cont.)axc

__ I __ __ __ ___ ___ ___

*1- I. t t I

*1- * * I

1- 4- 1 4- 1 1




4 1 + I- I t

4 4 4 4- * I

4 4 4 4- 4 4

I 4- 4 1-- 1 4

4 4- 4 + 4 *

__ __ I __ __ I ____ ____ __



Table C-i. Operation and Control Center and HFE Guidelines (cont.)ac

4- -k 4- 4

4- 4- 1 I 4- 4

+ + I 4- 4

4- 4- 1 I 4- 4

4- 4- 1 I 4- 1

+ + I I 4- 1

+ 4 i i 4- 4

4- + + I 4-

+ 4 + I + 4

4 4 + 1 + 4

APP-OCS-GEH-1 22, Rev. I C-17APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I C-17



4- 4- 4- 4 4- 4

4- .1- 4- 4 4- 4

4- + I- 4- 1

4- 4- ~4- 4- 4

_IH-+1 .+ 4 * 4- 4

-I- 4 4 4- 4

__ II __ __ __ I __ I __

4 4 4 -4- .4-

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 C-18APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 C-18



4 4 4 1- t t

4 4 4 + 4 t

________________________ ___________I ____________ ___________

APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I C-19APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 C-19



[ _____ I ____ I _____ [ _____ I _______ I ________ I _____

+ 4 i i ii

.1- 4 1 I I 4

.1- 4 I I I

+ I 4 1 t

4 I + I + A-

4 1 4 1 + 4

4 1 4 1 + 4




i + 4- + i

4- 4. 4- 4- 4

+ 4- + 4- 4

4- 4- 4- 4- 4

+ 4- 1- 4- 1

+ 4 + !- - 4

4- 4- 4- 4- 4

__ II __ __ __ I __ __

___ I __ [ __ I ___ I ____ I ____ __

__ I __ __ I __ ____ I ____ I __

4- 1- t 4- 4-




4 -f ± 4 1

+ + + 1- 1

+ 4 + + I

+ 4 + + I

______ I _____ I _____ I ______ I, I ________ I _____ '-4"

____ I ____ ____ I ____ K I ______ I ____

+ 4 t 4 4

4 4 I + 4

4 4 4 4

1 4 4 4 .1-

I I I 4 +

I I 4 4 +




r 1~ 7 r T T

+ -~ *1- t *I- 1-

+ + + t -t 1-

.1- + + +

.1. 4 1 4 +

-~ 4 4 4 +

__I __ __I __ ___ I ___ I __-

___ I __ I __ I ___ I~ ____ [ ____ I __

4 4 4 4- 4 -4

I 4 4 + 4 4

I 4 1- 1- 4

I 4 1- 1- 4 4

* 4 4- + 4 4

* 4 4- + 4 4

4 4 + + I I

4 1 + 4 I I

APP-OCS-GEII-122, Rev. 1 C-23APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 C-23

Enclosure 6NND-13-0521 of 101APiO00 Human Factors Engineering Design Verification Plan


+ + I 4

4- + 1 I + 4

_IIT I_ _

4- 4- 4- 1 4- 4

4- + 4- 1 4- 4

4- 4- 4- 1 4- 4

4- + 4- 1 4- 4

+ -l + I 4- 4

+ + 4- 1 4- 4




ac

+ + t +

4 + 4 +

4 -4- 4 +

4 I 4 * + +

4 4 4 4 +

_____________ I ______________ ____________________

APP-OCS-GEII-122, Rev. 1 C-25APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I C-25

Enclosure 6NND-13-0521 of 101AP1000 Human Factors Eneineerine Design Verification Plan

Table C-I. Operation and Control Center and HFE Guidelines (cont.)a~c

4 4 4 4

I 4 4 4 1'

4 4 1 4 I

4 4 4 + 4 4

4 4 .4- 1- 4 1

4 4 + + 4 1

4 4 4 4- 4 1

4 1 4 + 4 4



Table C-i. Operation and Control Center and HFE Guidelines (cont.)axc

+ 4 4 + i

+ 4 4 + +

4 1 1 4 1-

4 4 4 + *1-

+ i + +

____________________________________________ I

4 4 4 +




4 + + +

4 + + 4-

__ I __ __ __ ____ I ___ __

+ + 4 4 + 4

+ 4 4 4 4- 4

4- 4- 1 4 4- 4

1- 4- 1 i + 4

4 4 4 4 4 4

+ 4 4 4 + 4

APP-OCS-GEIH-122, Rev. I C-28


Table C-I. Operation and Control Center and HFE Guidelines (cont.)ax

APP-OCS-GEII-122, Rev. I C-30APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 C-30



I

4 i i i

4 4- *1- 4

____

_ _ _ I _ _ I _ _ I _ _ I _ _ _ I __ _ I_

4- + 4 4 *1- *

4- + i i i- i

4- + 4 4 + 4

I I I I I I -




__ __ I __ __ ___ I ____ __

_____ I ____ ____ I _____ _______ I _______ I _____

___ I __ I __ I ___ 1. ____ 1 ____ 1 __

4 + 4 + 4 *

4 .1- 4 + 4 *

4 + 4 + 4 i

I 4- 4 .4- 4 4

4 + 4 + 4 *

4 + 4 + 4 *

APP-OCS-G EH-I 22, Rev. I C-33APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. 1 C-33



4 1 4 1 t

4 4 1- 1 t

4 4- 4 + 4 t

4 4- 4 + 4 *

4 4- 4 + 4 *

4 1* I t

___ I __ I __ I ___ I ____ I ____I __

*1- 4- I I 1- 1

1- 4- I I P 1

+ + 4 $ P 1

_ _ I _ _ _ _ _ _




4 + 4 4 1 4

4 + 4 * 4 4

4- + + * 4- 4

4- -I- 4 4 4- 4

4- 4- 4 4 4-~ 4

4- 4 4 4 4- 1

4- 4- 4 4 + 4

4-4 44 '

4- 4 4 4 + 4

4- 4 4 4 + 4

_ _ I _ _ _ _ __I___

_ _ _ [ _ _ I _ I _ _ I _ _ _ I _ _ _ _ I _



Table C-i. Operation and Control Center and HFE Guidelines (cont.)a,c

4- 4- 4 4 .3- 4

.3- .I- 4- 4 4- 4

4- 4- t 1

+ + + *1- I

+ 4 + 1 *I- I

4- 4- + I + 4

.3. L .3. L .. a

4 1 1 4-

+ I 1 1 4- 4-

-4- 1 4 4 4 1-

I. 1 -4 4 4 +

I I I 4 1 4-

I * I 4 1 4-

& I 1 4 I 4

& 4 1 4 1 4

& I 1 4 1 4

& 4 1 4 1 4

4 4 1 4 1

I I I I t I.




+ + 4 4- 4

axc

4- + 4 + + 4

4- + 4 4 4- 4

4- + 4 4 4- 1

4- + * 4 4- 4

+ 4- 4 + 4- 4

+ 4 + 4 4- 4

+ 4- 4 4 4- 4

+ 4- 4 4 4- 4

__ I __ __ I ___ __




APP-OCS-GEII-122, Rev. I C-39APP-OCS-GEH-122, Rev. I C-39


Table C-I. Operation and Control Center and HFE Design Guidelines (cont.)

Kaxc

(Last Page of Appendix C)


APP-OCS-GEH-122, 'AP1000 Human Factors Engineering …Enclosure 6 NND-13-0521 Page 6 of 101 AP1000...

Documents

Transcript of APP-OCS-GEH-122, 'AP1000 Human Factors Engineering …Enclosure 6 NND-13-0521 Page 6 of 101 AP1000...