“What are the treasures of your culture for the...
Transcript of “What are the treasures of your culture for the...
![Page 1: “What are the treasures of your culture for the future?”files.ctctcdn.com/aaa9229e001/e73e7c1f-0957-451a-a181-80f911a2… · ways that Steiner/Waldorf education manifests in the](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022060415/5f137d3f682c5916952a0b3e/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
“Whatarethetreasuresofyourcultureforthefuture?”ReflectionsonCulturalDiversityandWaldorfEducation
Mary-G.Häuptle,CapeTown,SouthAfrica_______________________________________________________________________
“Theexperience,thepossibilityforsomethingtohappentousortotouchus,requiresaninterruptiongesture,agesturethatisalmostimpossiblethesedays:itrequiresustostoptothink,tostoptolook,tostoptolisten,tothinkmoreslowly,tolookmoreslowly,andtolistenmoreslowly;tostoptofeel,tofeelmoreslowly,tolingerinthedetails,tosuspendopinion,tosuspendjudgement,tosuspendthewill,tosuspendtheautomatismofaction,tocultivateattentionandgentleness,toopeneyesandears,tospeakaboutwhathappenstous,tolearnslowness,tolistentoothers,tocultivatetheartoftheencounter,tonotspeakmuch,tobepatientandgiveourselvestimeandspace.”
-JorgeLarossaBondíainNotesonExperienceandtheKnowledgeofExperience,2002
Overthepastfewyears,theIASWECEcouncilhasbeenstriving,alongthelinesofan“interruptiongesture”,togaininsightintodiversity,byconsciouslyexploringthemanywonderfulanddiversewaysthatSteiner/Waldorfeducationmanifestsintheworld,aswellasbydiscoveringwhatitisthatiscommontousall,andtoformulatewhattheessentialsofWaldorfeducationare.Wetriedalsotoseethedifferentwayswegiveexpressiontotheuniversalhuman
beinginourdifferentcultures,countries,andevenhemispheres.WehavefeltthatAnthroposophyhasmuchtoofferusintheworldtoday,butwhatultimatelycountsishowwepracticeit,howwebringitintotheworldthroughourdeeds,ourchoiceoflanguageandourinteractionswitheachindividual.
TheIASWECECouncilelaboratedonthisbroadoutlineinabrochurefortheTransitionsConferenceinApril2015:
“...TheInternationalAssociationforSteinerWaldorfEarlyChildhoodEducation(IASWECE)providesameetingplaceforearlychildhoodeducatorsfromthemanycountriesstrivingtouphold,deepenandrenewSteiner/Waldorfearlychildhoodeducation.OursharedtaskistoensurethatWaldorfpedagogybecomesneitheratheoreticalsystemnoracollectionofoutermethods,butawellspringoflivinginsight.Toservethehealthydevelopmentofchildhoodistodevelopthepotentialtoperceive,throughourownself-directedinneractivity,notonlythephysicalnature,butalsothesoulandspiritofeachchild.Throughthisongoingstudyandresearchwedeepenour
![Page 2: “What are the treasures of your culture for the future?”files.ctctcdn.com/aaa9229e001/e73e7c1f-0957-451a-a181-80f911a2… · ways that Steiner/Waldorf education manifests in the](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022060415/5f137d3f682c5916952a0b3e/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
appreciationofthespiritualindividualityofallhumanbeingsasdistinctfrom,butworkingwithinandthroughthesheathsoftheirgivengender,temperamentandpersonality,aswellasthroughthetraditionsandvaluesoftheirparticularfamilyandculturalcommunity.EveryculturecontributesuniquelytowardstheevolutionofAnthroposophyandWaldorfeducation,andwehonorthewaySteiner/Waldorfearlychildhoodeducatorsworkwithintheirspecificculturalcontexts.Atthesametime,wewouldliketoexpressourhope,thatbyencouragingtheautonomyandinitiativeofeachindividual,AnthroposophyandWaldorfeducationmaycontributetotheevolutionofthe‘whole,’suchasfamily,community,nation,andhumankind.IASWECEgivesus,aseducatorsfromdiversenationsandcultures,theopportunitytomeetandgettoknowandunderstandoneanotheronanever-deeperlevel.Developingrelationshipsoftrust,opennessandreverenceamongcolleagues,withtheyoungchildalwaysatthecentreofourvision,isthestartingpointforeducatingthechildinfreedomandtowardfreedom.OutofthisidealcomesourintentiontoparticipateinthedynamicandartisticprocessthatwillenabletheuniversalhumanspiritofWaldorfpedagogytolightupintheheartsandcreativewillofeducatorsofallcultures.Onlythencanwegivechildrenineverycorneroftheworldtheopportunitytodeveloptheirtrueandfullhumanity.”AsaninternationalcouncilwerecognizethatpartofourresponsibilityistofeelthepulseoftheWaldorfearlychildhoodmovement–tobeasenseorgan,hearinghowdifferentculturesexperienceaspectsoftheirrelationshiptoWaldorf/Steinereducation;perceivingthechallenges,strivingsandquestions.
WiththisintentionweformulatedarangeofquestionstoIASWECECouncilmembers,invitingthemtosharethequestionswithcolleaguesfromtheirowncountries.Werecognizethatthesequestionscouldbedifficultandthattheycouldbeexpressedindifferentways:
1)Whattreasuresofyourculturecouldbeaseedforthefuture?2)IsAnthroposophyhelpfulinunderstandingyourtraditionsinanewway?3)Whatisforyoupersonallytheessence,theheart,thecore,ofAnthroposophy?Additionalquestionstoworkwith:4)Whatmakesyoufeelasenseofbelongingtoaculture,andwhatmakesyoufeelacitizenoftheworld?Doyoufeelmoreathomeinonethantheother?5) Inyourearly childhood setting, are festivals fromother cultures celebrated inadditiontotheonesfromyourownculture?Whichonesandwhy?6)Doyoufeelyourselfinanevolvingprocesswithinanthroposophy?How?
![Page 3: “What are the treasures of your culture for the future?”files.ctctcdn.com/aaa9229e001/e73e7c1f-0957-451a-a181-80f911a2… · ways that Steiner/Waldorf education manifests in the](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022060415/5f137d3f682c5916952a0b3e/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
These questions were intended not onlyto encourage deeper conversation andexploration, but to help us awaken tocertain aspects of our work from ouruniqueperspectives,andperhapstomakeconscious certain thoughts, feelings anddeeds which we perform each daywithoutreallybeingawaketotheirpowertohealorharm.Manycolleaguesfromaroundtheworld
have begun to share their responses tothese questions, and this will ultimatelyhelp the IASWECE council in itsdeliberations, guidelines andwork in theworld.
With gratitude,wewould like to share afew cameos of the responses to the firstthree questions from individuals invariouscountries:
1)Whattreasuresofyourculturecouldbeaseedforthefuture?
Finland:• Nature,natureelementsandthefour
seasons• Theconnectionbetweenhumanbeings
andnature,responsibilitytoprotectit,feelingoftrust
• TherichnessoftheFinnishlanguageinpoemsandsongs
• Traditionalhandicraftsandtools,traditionalworksongs
Israel:
• IhopethatMartinBuber'sideaofthestronglydevelopedpoweroftheindividual,whichtodaymustseektocomeintorelationshiptothecommunity,theuniversal,andtothewholeearth,canbeaseedforthefuture.
Japan:
• Article9oftheJapaneseConstitution(RenunciationofWar).Determinationtorenouncewar,astheonlycountrythatwasthevictimofnuclearbombing.Hopethatthisideawouldbeaseedforworldpeace.TheJapanesepeople’sviewofnature,asgods’spiritsdwellineverything.
NaturetableinaWaldorfkindergarteninFinland
OutdoorplayinaWaldorfkindergarteninTokyo
ViewoftheeasternpartofJerusalem
![Page 4: “What are the treasures of your culture for the future?”files.ctctcdn.com/aaa9229e001/e73e7c1f-0957-451a-a181-80f911a2… · ways that Steiner/Waldorf education manifests in the](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022060415/5f137d3f682c5916952a0b3e/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
SouthAfrica:2)Isanthroposophyhelpfulinunderstandingyo
Poland:• Loveandneedforindependence.• Richtraditions,especiallyforfestivals.
Folkartists.• Theability,influencedbyhighideals,to
undertakeheroictasks.Thiscanleadtoindependenceinthinkinganddoing.
Brazil:
• Ourcountryismadeupofmanydifferentculturesthatenrichourwayofliving;onelearnstobemoretolerant.Fromareligiouspointofviewaswell,theChristianfaithshaveblendedandadaptedtoculturesandreligionsmoreconnectedwithnaturebeings.Musicisafactorthatisverypresentanditbringssomethinglightinoursoulingeneral.
SouthAfrica:
• Caringandsharing.• Opennessandacceptance.Opennessand
acceptance.ItisasignofhowwegrewupinourcelebratingofRamadanandEid.Whenwecelebratedourfestivalstogetherwewereallonecommunity,andwecelebratedalltraditionsandcultureswithinourcommunity(includingChristmas,Easter,etc).OurcultureisinclusiveandwebelievewhoeverknocksonyourdoorissentbyGod–wecutoutalljudgment.Thisisoursinceregreeting(andtheseedsforthefuture).Wealwaystrytotrulyseetheperson.
• Musicisauniversallanguageandunifyingelementandhasalwaysbeenabigpartofourcultureandtraditions,andisalwaysusedinourceremonies,whethertocelebrateormourn.Thishasaplaceinourearlychildhoodcentersandkindergartens,inunitingourchildrenandcommunities.
MovementsessioninaWaldorftrainingcourseinWarsaw,Poland
AutumnfestivalinaWaldorfkindergartenin
Florianopolis,Brazil
FestivalwiththestudentsattheCentreforCreativeEducation
Childreninan«EducareCentre»intheTownships
![Page 5: “What are the treasures of your culture for the future?”files.ctctcdn.com/aaa9229e001/e73e7c1f-0957-451a-a181-80f911a2… · ways that Steiner/Waldorf education manifests in the](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022060415/5f137d3f682c5916952a0b3e/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
2)IsAnthroposophyhelpfulinunderstandingyourtraditionsinanewway?
Finland:• Ithelpstounderstandthespiritual
wayofourfestivalsandourtraditions,whichwerebuiltthroughspiritualexperiences.
Israel:
• Anthroposophyoffersnewwaysoflookingattherelationsbetweenmanandtheuniverse.Itremindsusofthereligiousattitudeandthegratitudeasa‘stateofmind’thatareneededifwewishtoliveourlivesinawareness,andnotonlypractice(orrefusetopractice)traditionalrituals.
Japan:
• The observation method ofAnthroposophy (by consciouslyregainingalostsense)helpstoseetheessenceofthethings.
Poland:• Itgivesouterformsdeepmeaning.
Our country traditions becomeuniversallyhuman.
Brazil:
• Duetothestudyofanthroposophyoneenlargesone’spointofview.
• BeinginacountryinthesouthernhemispherecolonizedbyEuropeans,mostofthetimeonehasto‘translate’thefestivalaccordingtoourseasonsandthisisachallengethatencouragesustobemoreconsciousofwhatwearecelebrating.
SouthAfrica:
• Acceptoneanother.
3)Whatisforyoupersonallytheessence,theheart,thecore,ofAnthroposophy?
Finland:• Thespiritualpathofdevelopment• The spiritual expression in every
phenomenon and every humanbeing
• The connection between humansasanongoingmovement.
Italy:
• Anthroposophyislikeagoodpairofshoesfortheonewhotakesconsciousnessalongontheirway,infordingrivers,climbingmountainsandcrossingdeserts.Initeveryonecanfindakeythatgivesdeepmeaningtolife,inthevicissitudes,theachievementofnewgoalsandovercomingtrials.Anevolutionarypaththatbridges,
forconsciousness,betweenmatterandspirit.
• Theinnerwork,understandingthistoolthroughmyverybeing.
France:
• Itgivesyousomanytoolstostrengthenyoursoul,yourinnerforce,yourcreativity,anditgivesyousuggestionsandideashowtodevelopthesequalitiesalsointhechildren.
Israel:• Thisisaverydifficultquestion!!
ButIfeelthatIamdrawntoAnthroposophybecauseitinvitesmetowakeup,beaware,butalsotobetolerantandpatientwith
![Page 6: “What are the treasures of your culture for the future?”files.ctctcdn.com/aaa9229e001/e73e7c1f-0957-451a-a181-80f911a2… · ways that Steiner/Waldorf education manifests in the](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022060415/5f137d3f682c5916952a0b3e/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
otherpeople.Ithasaverywide‘panoramic’viewofmankindandtheuniverse,anditgivesawayofsearchingforthemeaningoflife.
Japan:
• Seeingdivinityinindividuals,understandingothersandtheworldasfreeindividuals,knowingloveandregainingaconnectionwiththeworld.
• Theideathatthehumanbeingexperiencestheprocessofcosmicevolution.Everyindividualhasaroleonearthforthesakeofcosmicevolution.
• Love,sensitivity,encounterofsoul/awakeningthesenseofloveandresponsibility.
Brazil• Thepointofviewthatrelatesman
andcosmos,thatseestheessence• thatunitesus,thatgoesbeyond
whatisdiverse.• Thecoreofanthroposophyhasto
addresstheuniversalhumanbeing.
• Tounderstandtheworldthroughtheheart,themindandthewill.
SouthAfrica:
• Bridgingthechasmbetweenmatterandspirit.
• Thepathofgettingtoknowmyselfalittledeeper,alittleclearer,alittlemoreconsciously,everyday.ThemoreIunderstandmyself,themoreIunderstandtheworldandthemoreIhavetobringtotheworld.
• “InLovelivestheseedofTruth InTruthseektherootofLove.”
Anthroposophyhastakenrootallthroughouttheworldinsomanycommunitiesandsocieties,enliveningpersonaldevelopmentandsupportingworkwiththeyoungchild.AsaninternationalcouncilwestrivetounderstandandtobeopentothedifferentwaysandcontextsthatSteiner/Waldorfschoolsdevelopandtakeroot.Weaskourselves:Howdowesupporttheactiveinvolvement,intheirvariouscommunities,ofeducatorsandparentsintheprotectionofchildrenandchildhood?
Howdowefosterself-reflectionasatoolforgoodpedagogicalpracticeandasaguideforimprovingday-to-dayrhythmsandworkwiththechildren?
Theworkonculturaldiversityhasledustoreachdeepwithinourselvestoask-“WhereamIawake,whereamIasleep?”“HaveIbecomemoreawareofmyownprejudicesandfears?”“Whathaschangedinme?”Intheworldtodaywherethereissomuchstrife,hatredandconflict,itisourtasktocelebrateourdifferencesandtocelebratewhatweshareincommon.Itisourresponsibilitytoengenderlovefortheother,topractisegratitudeeachmoment,andtobeawakeandopentoeveryencounter–withdiscernment,yetwithoutjudgement.
![Page 7: “What are the treasures of your culture for the future?”files.ctctcdn.com/aaa9229e001/e73e7c1f-0957-451a-a181-80f911a2… · ways that Steiner/Waldorf education manifests in the](https://reader033.fdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022060415/5f137d3f682c5916952a0b3e/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
“The encounter with the unknown is a nutrient in life, as essential as certainvitamins–withoutit,thesoulfallsintosleep,depressionanddespair.Thetrickishowmuchtoadmittherandom,chaotic,unknowable,intoourlives.Itisalwaysamatterofbalance.Thechildat themercyofan incomprehensibleworldrequiresreassurance;theadult,stalledinthefamiliar,mayrequireanoppositeprod.“
-JaneHirshfieldinHiddenness,Uncertainty,Surprise,2008
___________________________________________________________________
Mary–G.HäuptlehasbeenaWaldorfkindergartenteacherinCapeTownformanyyears.SheistrainerandmentorattheCentreforCreativeEducationinCapeTown.SheisonthecounciloftheSouthAfricanFederationofWaldorfSchoolsandanIASWECECouncilmember.