An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

download An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

of 52

Transcript of An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    1/52

    0

    An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    (A twelve-week outline of a prospective course on Major World Religions of India)

    Robert R. Wadholm

    Week One: Introducing the Topic

    I. Introduction

    A. The text that will be utilized in this twelve week teaching module on world

    religions is Lewis M. Hopfe and Mark R. Woodwards (2005)Religions of the

    World, 9th

    Ed.: Media and Research Update.

    1. It includes the history of each major world religion, its founders and

    central contributors, sample texts from the religions, spotlights on the

    present state of each religion, and major doctrines, divisions, and holy

    days of each major world religion.

    2. Hopfe and Woodward include several religions that are not covered in

    other introductory texts on religion (Fisher 1999; Hume 1959). The text is

    very basic and general in its analyses (making it ideal for use in an

    introductory course) .

    3. The textbook comes with additional digital research material provided

    online and in CD-ROM format, and includes color and black and white

    pictures of rituals, statues, buildings, and sacred texts of many of the

    world religions.

    4. The textbook contains short excerpts of primary sources on major world

    religions, including sacred scriptures, stories, myths, and creeds.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    2/52

    1

    5. The text is not written from a single religious perspective, but instead

    offers an objective approach to each religion, recognizing each religions

    contributions within its own contexts.

    B. The major world religions of India that will be introduced are: Basic Religions,

    Hinduism, Jainism, Buddhism, and Sikhism.

    1. Islam has not been included in our discussion of Indian religions

    because although it is a major force in Indian religion today, it is usually

    classified with other religions that arose in the Middle East (i.e. Judaism,

    Zoroastrianism, Christianity, and Bahai).

    2. Buddhism is no longer a strong force in modern Indian religion, but it

    originated in India and retains many distinctive Indian traits (at one time in

    its history it dominated Indian religion and nearly forced Vedic and

    Upanishadic Hinduism into nonexistence).

    3. Basic religions, while they are not unique to India, do appear to have

    arisen and have been developed all over the world throughout the several

    millennia of human history, and they existed in India prior to the other

    major world religions and greatly influenced these later religions.

    a) In many cases basic religions have been extensively syncretized

    with the later religions. Basic religions continue to influence the

    beliefs and practices of the other major world religions of India.

    b) Very little objective historical information exists concerning the

    development of basic religions in India, however, so we will

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    3/52

    2

    limit our discussion of basic religions to the presentation of a few

    general characteristics and the value of the basic religions of India.

    C. Each of the five major world religions of India will be analyzed separately.

    1. Each religions basic background will be explored.

    2. Each religions central doctrines will be examined.

    3. Each religions values will be assessed.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    4/52

    3

    Week 2: Introducing the Topic (Continued)

    D. Discuss the meaning of the term Major World Religions of India.

    1. Major refers both to the number of adherents and to the impact of the

    religion on the present world scene.

    2. World refers to the global impact or universal scope of the religion.

    3. Religion is a notoriously hard-to-define word (Tillich 1969).

    a) It refers to a commonly held set of beliefs concerning ultimate

    reality (metaphysics, god, life after death, etc.), ultimate values,

    and the ultimate concerns of societies.

    b) It refers to a system of ethics, myths, rituals, scriptures,

    and doctrines of the afterlife that have been adhered to by large

    groups of people (Hopfe and Woodward 2005).

    c) It refers to human action in relationship to the supernatural.

    d) It refers to a mystical and subjective feeling of worship and

    union with the Ultimate (Hall, Pilgrim, and Cavanagh 1985).

    4. Of India refers to the Indian origination of the religions that will be

    explored.

    E. Discuss why it is important to understand the major world religions.

    1. In order to communicate with people, we need to understand where they

    come from (e.g. their worldviews, first languages, cultures, and religions).

    2. Understanding peoples beliefs concerning ultimate reality helps us

    understand better why the world is the way it is.

    a) Discuss the importance of religion to politics.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    5/52

    4

    b) Discuss the importance of religion to technology, science, and

    economics.

    c) Discuss the importance of religion to media, art, economics, and

    ecology.

    3. Understanding the major world religions allows meaningful dialogue to

    occur between adherents of different religions (in an exclusivist context,

    dialogue is necessary before an effective apologetic can be constructed).

    F. Discuss why it is important to understand the major world religions of India.

    1. India has nearly a billion people in it.

    2. India is increasingly important in the world political and economic

    scenes.

    3. India is a hotbed for religious synthesis and formation.

    4. Western religious life is increasingly saturated with practices and

    beliefs of Indian religions (e.g. yogic practices, mystical monism, and

    pantheism).

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    6/52

    5

    Week Three: Basic Religions

    II. Basic Religions

    A. Discuss the background of basic religions.

    1. Basic religions represent the majority of the total religious experience

    of humankind (Hopfe and Woodward 2005, 14). Basic religions have

    taken on many forms throughout history.

    2. There are two primary sources of basic religions.

    a. Contemporary basic religions can be examined for common

    characteristics. Also, various aspects of basic religions that have

    been syncretized into the major world religions of India may be

    identified and assessed.

    b. The findings of archaeology may also be assessed in order to

    understand characteristics of prehistoric religions, and religions

    that are now nonexistent.

    3. Little is known about the early basic religions of India (Hopfe and

    Woodward 2005, 73). However, from archaeological evidence it may be

    argued that the pre-Aryan inhabitants of India had already formed a

    complex civilization by 2500 B.C.E. Amulets, idols, prayer, meditation,

    sacrifices, and devotion to fertility gods and goddesses seem to have

    characterized these early forms of Indian religion (75).

    4. It is important to understand the general characteristics, strengths, and

    weaknesses of basic religions in order to appreciate the uniqueness of the

    other major world religions of India and to valuate aspects that have been

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    7/52

    6

    borrowed from basic religious belief and practice by the other major world

    religions of India.

    B. Define and discuss several general characteristics of basic religions (1928).

    1.Animism is the belief that nature is alive with spirits that have feelings

    and can be communicated with (19).

    2.Magic is the belief that formulas, dancing, incantations, and imitation

    can be used by humans to manipulate the spiritual and physical world.

    3.Divination is the belief that humans can obtain knowledge of the future

    through various means.

    4. Taboo is the belief that certain actions have negative impacts on society

    and that certain holy persons, places, and objects must be left alone by

    common people (23).

    5. Sacrifice is the offering of material objects to some entity in the

    spiritual world. Animals, man-made items, agricultural items, and even

    other humans have been used as sacrifices. Sometimes sacrifices are

    destroyed or killed, while at other times sacrifices are viewed as gifts.

    6.Myths are stories about the dealings of the gods with humans (25).

    7.Idolatry is the use of images in the worship of supernatural entities.

    Usually the idol is made to look like (or represent) a holy person, animal,

    or god. Shrines and monuments are also used to venerate gods, holy

    places, sacred objects, holy people, and ancestors. Ancestor veneration

    continues to play a vital role in the religious life of Asia.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    8/52

    7

    8. Syncretism (e.g., with Buddhism, Hinduism, Jainism, and other basic

    religions) has affected many (if not all) of the worlds basic religions.

    C. Discuss the value of basic religions.

    1. Assess the strengths of basic religions.

    a) They have a long history.

    b) They often embrace every part of a peoples culture.

    c) They help to explain the origin and nature of the material world.

    2. Assess the weaknesses of traditional religions.

    a) They are so numerous, varied, and subjective that it is

    impossible to pin down specific common beliefs and rituals (so

    that we cannot consider any of them to be a major world religion).

    b) They are pre-scientific or anti-scientific.

    c) They often feed on personal fears, lust for power, or feelings of

    powerlessness.

    d) They lack any absolute moral standards and often fail to provide

    any bases for intrinsic ethical formulation.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    9/52

    8

    Week Four: Hinduism

    III. Hinduism

    A. Discuss the background of Hinduism.

    1. Hinduism has gone through six major periods of development.

    a) Early Vedic Hinduism, characterized by ritual worship of the

    gods.

    b) Late Vedic Hinduism, characterized by fire sacrifices.

    c) Upanishadic Hinduism, characterized by philosophical inquiry

    and development.

    d) Legalistic Hinduism, characterized by the codification of

    various laws for ethical and religious life.

    e) Brahmanical Hinduism, characterized by pragmatic forms of

    worship.

    f) Modern Hinduism, characterized by revivals of older forms of

    Hinduism and a new focus on Hinduisms universalism.

    2. The history of Early Vedic Hinduism is intimately tied to the coming of

    the Aryans (an Indo-European group of immigrants and conquerors from

    northern Iran) to India from 1750 to 1200 B.C.E. (Hopfe and Woodward

    2005, 76).

    a) The Aryans developed a basic caste system.

    b) They developed a religion based on sacrifice and worship.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    10/52

    9

    c) They borrowed extensively from early Aryan religion and mixed

    in indigenous Indian elements (from the basic religions that existed

    there before their arrival).

    d) They composed and collected hymns (Vedas) praising their

    deities and setting forth proper rules for ritual sacrifices.

    1) The earliest of the veda (body of knowledge)

    collections was theRig Veda (the body of knowledge

    concerning verses of praise) (Hopkins 1971, 11).

    2) The Vedas worshiped gods called devas. The most

    important deva was Varunna, who guarded cosmic order,

    ruled by righteousness, and who was the standard for

    cosmic, moral, and liturgical order (12). Other important

    deities were Vishnu (who later grew to a more prominent

    position in Hindu theology), Indra the thunder god, Rundra

    the god of healing and destruction, and Indra the

    atmospheric god of war (1214).

    3) Fire sacrifice dominated the rituals of Vedic Hinduism.

    Priests performed rites and composed and sang the Vedas.

    Wealthy patrons often supported their own priests (1415).

    3. In the late Vedic period (between the 10th

    and 7th

    centuries B.C.E.), the

    fire sacrifice became all-important in Hindu worship, and this marked a

    decline in the importance of most of the major Vedic gods in favor of

    rituals and the more popular gods specifically associated with the

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    11/52

    10

    performance of sacrifices (especially the god of fire) (Hopkins 1971, 17).

    This period saw the composition of the Brahamanas, religious documents

    composed by Hindu priests that dealt with sacrifices (Hume 1959, 24).

    a) Consequently, magic found a greater role in sacrifice (Hopkins

    1971, 27).

    b) A deterministic view of nature developed.

    c) Knowledge was all-important in unlocking the power of rituals

    (31).

    d) Creation was thought to exist and be sustained by sacrifice.

    Humans (through priests) fulfilled a vital role and obtained

    immortality in the afterlife through the performance of proper

    rituals (34).

    e) Later, fear arose that even this state (of immortality in paradise)

    was not free from death, due to the finite nature of the rituals

    performed (34).

    f) The concept of redeath arose, and the cyclical view of time

    was developed): A new understanding of man was needed (34).

    (34). The Upanishads (a collection of the teachings of late ancient

    Vedic Hindu philosopher-priests) were composed in this

    inquisitive context.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    12/52

    11

    Week Five: Hinduism (Continued)

    4. During the transitional Upanishadic period, it was reasoned that the

    ritual sacrifices were the universe. Brahman (the Ultimate Supreme Being)

    sustains the power of the sacrifices, and thus sustains the universe

    (Hopkins 1971, 38). The self (atman) of humans are to be identified with

    the Brahman (39).

    a) If humans can know themselves as the Brahman, they can be

    complete in themselves, self-existent, wise, and immortal (38;

    Atharva Veda 10.8.44).

    b) The Upanishads established several new (or newly synthesized)

    doctrines.

    1) Self is essentially free of the body.

    2) It is desire that leads to birth and rebirth.

    3) The elimination of desire eliminates rebirth.

    4) The means of eliminating desire (and rebirth) is

    knowledge: knowledge that the self and Brahman are one

    (Hopkins 1971, 4042). Read the Katha Upanishad, part 6

    (trans. Mascaro 1965, 6566).

    5) Knowledge that is true knowledge will transform the

    behavior and mindset of an individual (i.e. it is not merely

    theoretical knowledge that is necessary) (48;

    Brihadaranyaka 4.4.2428).

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    13/52

    12

    6) Release from samsara (passage, the transient and

    cyclical karma-produced nature of the universe) became

    the central goal.

    c) The shift in ideology from Vedic to Upanishadic Hinduism led

    to some amount of despair among the common people in the 6th

    century B.C.E.

    1) Upanishadic wisdom generally was above the ability of

    the common people to follow. Read and discuss the

    Mundaka Upanishad, part three, chapter one (Mascaro

    1965, 8081).

    2) New ways of thinking and acting within the general

    Hindu worldview were sought in this time of change, and

    this resulted in the creation of two new world religions

    (Buddhism and Jainism) (Hopkins 1971, 5051).

    d) Major political and social changes from the 4 th to 3rd centuries

    B.C.E. (most significantly the rule of Candragupta Maurya and his

    descendants) gave rise to the popularity and the increasingly

    missionary nature of Jainism and Buddhism, and the near

    abandonment of Vedic and Upanishadic Hinduism (5859).

    5. From 300 B.C.E. to 300 C.E. the religious legalism of Indian culture

    and early Vedic Hinduism was codified in The Law of Manu. The

    codification of rules for society and religion arose from a renewed

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    14/52

    13

    emphasis on law in Hinduism. This period has thus been called the period

    of legalistic Hinduism (Hume 1959, 28).

    a) The Law of Manu stressed the importance and religious

    significance of the caste system, and codified a clear-cut dharma

    for each caste.

    1) In legalistic Hinduism, dharma referred to rules

    that support or maintain a proper society (Hopfe and

    Woodward 2005, 85).

    2) One new development ofThe Law of Manu was its

    delineation of the four stages of the life of an upper-caste

    man. Men were expected to be youthful students, married

    householders, retired hermits, and then religious

    mendicants (Hume 1959, 29).

    b) In addition to codifying rules for social behavior in Indian

    society, legalistic Hinduism emphasized the superiority of men

    over women (Hopfe and Woodward 2005, 8687), even to the

    point of allowing wife-beating within certain limits (The Law of

    Manu 8:299300; Hume 1959, 29).

    c) The moral aims of the era are summed up in the following ten

    characteristics: pleasantness, patience, control of the mind, non-

    stealing, purity, control of the senses, intelligence, knowledge,

    truthfulness, and non-irritability (Hopfe and Woodward 2005, 87;

    The Law of Manu 6:92).

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    15/52

    14

    6. In the early centuries of the 1st

    millennium A.D., Hindus began to

    develop further the practical method ofyoga (religious meditation and

    action) in response to the more pragmatic and popular nature of non-vedic

    movements in India (mainly Jainism and Buddhism), and the importance

    of theism reemerged (Hopkins 1971, 64). This new, more popular form of

    Hinduism became identified as Brahmanical Hinduism.

    a) Several general characteristics of Brahmanical Hinduism were

    image worship, mantras, and the internalization and the

    individualization of religion.

    b) A synthesis was arrived at which brought together certain

    ancient Hindu doctrines (worship of the gods, introspective

    meditation, reincarnation, karma, etc.) with the pragmatism of the

    non-vedic Indian religions.

    c) The syllable om became the centerpiece of meditationthe

    sound essence of the Vedic sacrificeand the image worship of

    the gods became the visual essence of worship (73).

    d) TheBhagavad Gita was composed in this context (Hopfe and

    Woodward 2005, 9092).

    e) The revival of Hindu theism in the form of Brahmanical

    Hinduism brought with it greater focus on the gods Sira and

    Vishnu than had previously been given in Vedic Hinduism. Other

    popular gods were worshiped as well. Images of the gods were

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    16/52

    15

    seen as divine power made manifest in form (Hopkins 1971,

    113).

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    17/52

    16

    Week Six: Hinduism (Continued)

    7. Five main forms of modern Hinduism have developed over the last

    millennium. The fifth form is the most modern of the five.

    a) Brahmanical Hinduism focuses on intellectualism and

    pragmatism.

    b) Various devotional and Vedic theistic sects focus on reviving

    ancient rites, mysticism, and asceticism.

    c) Popular devotionalism focuses on individualistic forms of

    worship and belief, and on the mystical experiences of poet-saints

    (Hopkins 1971, 119).

    d) Tantric systems focus on the worship of the goddess Devi in her

    many forms (often with corresponding sex rites) (119130).

    e) Modern universalistic Hinduism focuses on the synthesis of

    various aspects of Indian religions into a monolithic structure

    called Hinduism. It is modern universalistic Hinduism that is

    responsible for Hinduisms status as a major world religion

    (instead of being seen as a diverse set of major Indian religions).

    1) The rise of a Hindu Renaissance was closely tied to

    the growing Indian nationalism of the past two centuries.

    2) This Hindu revivalism is an attempt to universalize

    Hinduism, and bring many different Indian religious

    traditions under one banner. Rituals and idolatry are at a

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    18/52

    17

    popular level, and above that we find the ethical spirituality

    of the Upanishads and Gita (Flood 1996, 250).

    3) Several important features of the modern revival of

    Hinduism are an emphasis on reason to establish the truth

    of the Veda; the rejection of icon worship, regarded as

    idolatry; the rejection of caste (or some elements of it),

    child-marriage and the practice of widow-burning (sati);

    the construction of Hinduism as an ethical spirituality,

    equal, or superior, to Christianity and Islam (250251).

    4) Two major proponents of modern universalistic

    Hinduism were the Hindu mystic Paramahamsa

    Ramakrishna, and his disciple Vivekananda.

    i. Ramakrishna taught that all religions are

    different paths to the One . . . . Different religions

    cannot express the totality of this One, but each

    manifests an aspect of it (256257).

    ii. Vivekananda was probably the first person to

    clearly articulate the idea of Hinduism as a world

    religion, alongside Christianity, Islam, Judaism

    and Buddhism (258259). Vivekananda emphasized

    Hinduisms pluralism, rejected Christianitys

    exclusivism (258), and asserted that Buddhism was

    the fulfillment, the logical conclusion, and the

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    19/52

    18

    logical development of the religion of the Hindus

    (Walker 1968a, 186).

    B. Discuss the major doctrines of Hinduism.

    1. Early Aryan Vedic Hinduism (Hinduism that found expression in the

    ancient Vedic hymn collections) centered on gods called devas (Hopkins

    1971, 11). The three realms of divine activity were the sky, the

    atmosphere, and the earth (11). The powers of nature controlled the lives

    of humans, and devas controlled the powers of nature.

    2. Late Vedic Hinduism developed the idea ofsamsara. Samsara is the

    cycle of birth, death, and rebirth of humans and the universe. Rebirth in

    good or bad conditions depends on previous actions (in prior lives) in a

    cyclical cause and effect relationship (Hopkins 1971, 44; Chandogya

    5.10.7). Samsara and reincarnation are key themes in all the major world

    religions originating in India.

    a. The belief in reincarnation and the transmigration of the soul are

    by no means an exclusively Eastern idea. Walker (1968a) and

    Bouquet (1948) suggest that the doctrine of divine reincarnation

    in human form originated somewhere outside India, perhaps in the

    northwest of Iran, and became diffused eastward and westward

    from this area (72).

    b. In Platos Phaedo (set at the end of the 4th century B.C.E.),

    Socrates refers to the ideas of reincarnation and transmigration as

    an ancient doctrine (trans. Jowett 1992, 67). In Greek thought

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    20/52

    19

    reincarnation is referred to as metempsychosis, and finds as its

    proof the idea of recollection (6873). In Socrates schema, as in

    Hinduism, reincarnation is dependant upon a cyclical view of time

    (7073).

    c. The Greeks and Aryans probably share a common ancestry in

    the Indo-European tribes of Eastern Europe in the 2nd

    millennium

    B.C.E. (Hopkins 1971, 10).

    d. The Aryans that left Iran and in the end settled in India

    composed the Veda, while the Aryans that stayed in Iran

    eventually composed a series of hymns entitled Gathas. By the

    time of Zoroaster (the traditional founder of the major world

    religion Zoroastrianism that began in Iran in 14001000 B.C.E.),

    the idea of the transmigration of the soul based on a cyclical view

    of time had already been established as a doctrine in Iranian Aryan

    religion and was further developed by Zoroaster (Hopfe and

    Woodward 2005, 222224).

    e. Plato and other Greek philosophers had a strong affinity for

    Zoroastrianism (223).

    f. Zoroasters religion came to India (in Zoroasters own lifetime)

    about the same time that the idea of reincarnation entered into

    late Vedic thought (224).

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    21/52

    20

    g. The idea that a similar formulation of reincarnation based on a

    cyclical view of time would arise independently in three different

    cultures in the ancient world is highly improbable.

    h. The two most probable scenarios for the creation and spread of

    the cyclical view of time, reincarnation, and transmigration in the

    ancient world are:

    1) The ideas were developed by early Indo-Europeans in

    northern Iran in the 2nd century.

    2) The ideas were developed by Iranian Aryans and spread

    with the Zoroastrian religion both East to India and West to

    Greece.

    i. The later of the two scenarios seems the most reasonable

    because early Aryan Vedic Hinduism had no known traces of the

    ideas of reincarnation or a cyclical view of time.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    22/52

    21

    Week Seven: Hinduism (Continued)

    3. Karma is based on the premise that the whole world order rests on

    rigid principles dominated by the immutable law of cause of effect

    (Walker 1968a, 529). Karma is the sum total of a persons willed

    thoughts, feelings, desires, and actions, from this and past lives, and makes

    up the chain of his existence (530). A person is punished by his or her

    sins, not for them (530).

    4.Dharma is right conduct, teaching and order.Dharma is related to

    karma and the caste system. It is only within the caste framework that the

    obligations ofdharma may be best observed (275), and nowhere is this

    idea more clearly portrayed than in the The Law of Manu.

    a. Read The Law of Manu 1:8891 (qtd. in Hopfe and Woodward

    2005, 85).

    b. Discuss how a persons dharma affects their karma and vice

    versa, then read The Law of Manu 12:9 (qtd. in Hopfe and

    Woodward 2005, 86).

    5. Brahmanical Hinduism refined the idea and practice ofyoga (while

    yoga existed in earlier forms of Hinduism, it never enjoyed as much

    prominence as it does in Brahmanical Hinduism). Yoga is a form of

    mental and physical disciplines and ascetic practices (Walker 1968b, 616).

    Yoga is ultimately a practical method to obtain salvation from samsara.

    There are various forms ofyoga, each of which includes several steps.

    a. Karma yoga is salvation through works.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    23/52

    22

    b.Bhakti yoga is salvation through faith.

    c.Jnana yoga is salvation through knowledge.

    d.Mantra yoga is salvation through the use of mantras and spells.

    e.Laya yoga is salvation through the activation of spiritual centers

    in the body.

    f.Hatha yoga is salvation through ritual action.

    g.Raja yoga is salvation through spiritual ritual action (617).

    6.Bhakti is faith, attachment, or devotion to a god which procures divine

    favor and salvation (Walker 1968a, 138). Personal gods are worshipped,

    and religious individualism is embraced.

    7.Maya is the doctrine (explored in depth in the BrahmanicalBhagavad

    Gita) that proclaims the illusory nature of the whole manifold world of

    nature (135).Maya is similar to Western philosophical monism, which

    denies the reality of all particulars in the phenoumenal world and affirms

    the ultimate unity of all reality (Joad 1965, 97). Discuss some implications

    of this idea, and read theBhagavad Gita chapter 2, verses 1124 (trans.

    Mascaro 1962).

    C. Discuss the value of Hinduism.

    1. Assess the strengths of Hinduism.

    a. There is a strong sense of social solidarity.

    b. It forms the basis of an ethical system that encourages personal

    responsibility for actions done.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    24/52

    23

    c. Religion often permeates the lives of its followers (Hume 1959,

    41).

    d. Some forms of Hinduism emphasize the importance of faith and

    grace in receiving salvation.

    e. It represents a wide variety of religious concepts and practices

    borrowed from diverse backgrounds (i.e. it is a powerful

    synthesis).

    2. Assess the weaknesses of Hinduism.

    a. The wide variety of forms are disparate and at times

    contradictory in presuppositions and conclusions.

    b. It is questionable whether Hinduism can even be viewed as one

    continuous, monolithic religious development. It could be argued

    that it is not a single religion.

    c. The caste system (an important aspect of most of the earlier

    forms of Hinduism) is divisive and fatalistic.

    d. In popular practice is often no more that pantheistic idolatry.

    e. Adherents can never know if they have achieved freedom from

    samsara.

    f. The Supreme Being is impersonal, and is a mere philosophical

    absolute (Hume 1959, 39). The gods, while personal and

    sometimes helpful to humans, in no way represent moral ideals.

    g. It generally takes a low view of women and poor people, and

    often ignores practical actions of charity, personal forgiveness, and

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    25/52

    24

    community building. Discuss whether or not Hinduism can form

    the basis of a just and equitable society.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    26/52

    25

    Week Eight: Jainism

    IV. Jainism

    A. Discuss the background of Jainism.

    1. The origins of Jainism are difficult to determine . . . although

    Nataputta Vardhamana, who became known to his followers as Mahavira

    (great hero), has traditionally been identified as its founder (Hopfe and

    Woodward 2005, 116).

    2. Legends are the only remaining sources of information about

    Mahaviras life. He was probably a contemporary of Gautama (Buddha),

    Confucius, Lao-tzu (the traditional founder of Taoism), and the Jewish

    prophets Jeremiah and Ezekiel (116).

    a) Mahavira was born to a wealthy family. He was unhappy and

    left his luxury to become a wandering ascetic. Mahavira developed

    an extremely severe form of asceticism, which included ahimsa

    (non-injury to life) (117).

    b) Mahavira developed five vows that Jain monks must follow to

    achieve release from reincarnation.

    1)Ahimsa (an extreme form of care for all life).

    Discuss the traditional clothing of Jains during travel (118).

    2) Truthfulness (although for the Jain, truth is relative).

    Tell the Jain story of the blind men and the elephant (120).

    3) Integrity. Honesty and propriety reach into every part of

    a persons life. There should be no stealing or taking what

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    27/52

    26

    is not given to you, for property and objects are not worth

    evil actions to obtain.

    4) Sexual chastity (all pleasures of the flesh are evil). Some

    Jains not only renounce sex, but also regard women in

    general as a temptation to sin (120).

    5) Disattachment from family, possessions, and homes.

    Absolute self-enforced poverty is the ideal.

    3. Buddhism and Jainism were probably both developed in India at about

    the same time (the sixth century B.C.E.). Both religions protested against

    traditional Vedic Hinduism and the caste system, but retained many

    elements of Hindu thought and religious action.

    B. Discuss the central doctrines of Jainism.

    1. Humans are born, live, die, and are reborn (reincarnation).

    2. In Jainism, karma is built up in an individual as the result of activity

    ofany sort (emphasis mine) (118). Discuss the differences ofkarma in

    Hinduism and Jainism, and explore ramifications of the Jain idea.

    3.Ahimsa (non-injury to life) requires constant attention to all forms of

    life (from large animals to tiny bugs). Subsequently, most Jains avoid

    agricultural work or even occupations of any kind (to avoid harming

    living things) (119). Is this a logically sustainable position?

    4. The focus onpersonal ethical purity brings to the forefront the

    self-saving nature of Jainism (19). Read the Jain parable of the man in the

    well (123124).

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    28/52

    27

    5. The ideal ofdisattachmentfrom worldly life derives from Jainisms

    philosophical duality (the soul is living, eternal, and valuable, while the

    entire material universe is lifeless and evil) (118). Action and attachment

    are the causes of rebirth.

    6.Moksha (release from the cycles of life, death and rebirth) is a true

    liberation of the soul from matter. It is attained by faithfully following the

    five vows of the Jain monk.

    C. Discuss the value of Jainism.

    1. Assess the strengths of Jainism.

    a) It regards all life as valuable.

    b) It is centered on ethical action (or inaction).

    c) It is mostly consistent in its dualism.

    2. Assess the weaknesses of Jainism.

    a) It denies the positive value of the material world.

    b) Salvation is essentially self-centered.

    c) A culture could not survive if it was made up entirely

    of ideal Jains (because there would be no sex and little agricultural

    work or work of any kind).

    d) It has a low view of women and families (Hume 1959, 60).

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    29/52

    28

    Week Nine: Buddhism

    V. Buddhism

    A. Discuss the background of Buddhism.

    1. Buddha was probably born on the borderlands of modern-day Nepal and

    Northern India in the sixth century B.C.E. with the name of Guatama

    Siddartha (he who fulfills his purpose) of the Shakya clan (Mishra 2004,

    95).

    a. Legends surrounding Siddarthas life (written nearly four

    hundred years after his death) reveal that he was the son of a

    Kshatriya raja (an Indian ruler), and that his mother, Maya, died

    when he was seven days old (Hopfe and Woodward 2005, 127;

    Mishra 2004, 98).

    b. Before Siddartha was born, it was predicted that when he grew

    older he would either become a great king or a great teacher and

    monk.

    1) Siddarthas parents were told that if he saw four sights (a

    dead person, an old person, an ill person, and an ascetic

    monk) he would become a great teacher and monk.

    2) Wanting better things for their son, Siddarthas father

    attempted to keep his son secluded from the four sights by

    surrounding him with only young, beautiful, healthy

    people.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    30/52

    29

    3) His fathers plan failed when Siddartha left his fathers

    palace one day and saw each of the four sights. After this,

    Siddartha left his home and family behind (by this time,

    Siddartha already had a wife and child) and became an

    ascetic monk (Hopfe and Woodward 2005, 128).

    c. After several years of self-mortification, starving, and solitary

    meditation, Siddartha realized that he could find no satisfaction in

    this way of life.

    d. Siddartha sat for many days and meditated beneath a fig (bodhi)

    tree in a hopeless state, when suddenly Siddartha found

    enlightenment.

    e. From that moment on, he was the Buddha, and his teachings on

    enlightenment and suffering found a foothold in India (129130).

    f. After teaching for forty-five years, Buddha reached the end of

    his life in this world. Buddhas final words (according to tradition)

    were: Subject to decay are all component things. Strive earnestly

    to work out your own salvation (131).

    2. Ultimately, Buddha (and his followers after him) sought liberation from

    samsara (wandering).

    a. Buddha taught that everyone is afraid of danger and death, and

    everyone counts life dear (Dhammapada, vv. 129130). The mind

    struggles to free itself from death like a fish striving for water

    when thrown on dry land (v. 34).

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    31/52

    30

    b. The key to escape from death (and consequently samsara) is

    enlightenment to the unreality of the world. When a man

    considers this world as a bubble of froth, and as the illusion of an

    appearance, then the King of death has no power over him (v.

    170).

    c. If people can free themselves from desires, they will find

    enlightenment, and rise above good and evil, dispelling all fear (v.

    39). Infinite freedom is found when a person has no cravings or

    desires for this world or for another world (v. 410).

    3. Buddha claimed that he had brought his own mortal mind to the joy of

    the immortal Nirvana through enlightenment (vv. 153154). He sought to

    bring others to this same enlightenment through his teachings. His

    teachings centered on escape from suffering and samsara.

    a. Buddhists seek refuge from suffering in the three jewels,

    which are the Buddha, the dharma (the teachings of Buddha), and

    the sangha (the Buddhist community) (Lopez 2004, 556). A

    traditional Buddhist conversion formula (to indicate adherence to

    the religion) is: I take refuge in the Buddha. I take refuge in the

    Dharma. I take refuge in the Community (Snellgrove 2002, 39).

    b. The refuge that is safe and free from sorrow and suffering is the

    Four Great Truths given by Buddha (Dhammapada, vv. 191

    192).

    1) Suffering exists.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    32/52

    31

    2) Suffering is caused by attachment and desire.

    3) Salvation from suffering exists.

    4) Salvation from suffering is found when a person follows

    Buddhas Eightfold Path in order to get release from the

    cycle ofsamsara.

    c. The eightfold path to the elimination of suffering is: right

    understanding, right thought, right speech, right action, right

    livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right meditation

    (Fisher 1999, 44).

    4. Shortly following Buddhas death conflicts arose over the role and

    teachings of Buddha. At the present, there are two main groups within

    BuddhismMahayana and Hinayana (Fisher 1999, 133), although

    Snellgrove (2002) argues that Hinayana and Mahayana Buddhism are not

    two distinct phases, but are instead two fluctuating tendencies, usually

    mingling together, and only kept strictly apart in certain philosophical

    texts (32).

    a. Most Buddhists in the world are Mahayana, a word that means

    The Greater Vehicle (45).

    1) Mahayana Buddhists are found in China, Japan,

    Vietnam, and Korea (Hopfe and Woodward 2005, 148).

    2) Within Mahayana Buddhism are several lesser

    subgroups, among which are Tibetan Buddhism (in which

    advanced meditation practices and rituals are performed to

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    33/52

    32

    develop inner qualities), and Zen Buddhism (in which

    discipline and meditation guided by a master help the

    student to find the natural mind) (Fisher 1999, 45).

    a) Tibetan Buddhists use magic, symbolism, and

    sexual desire as means to enlightenment (Mishra

    2004, 76). Gurus, or teachers, are important,

    though monks are not elevated over laymen.

    Tibetan Buddhists revere many types of Buddhas

    and images of Bodhisattvas (76).

    b) One important element of Zen Buddhism is the

    koan. Koans are puzzles or riddles that are illogical

    and that bring sudden enlightenment through

    conundrum (Mascetti 1996, 14). The following is a

    Zen Buddhist koan: A monk asked Ummon, What

    is the teaching of the Buddhas lifetime? Ummon

    said, Preaching facing oneness (50).

    3) Mahayana are generally more liberal than Hinayana in

    their interpretations of Buddhism.

    b. Hinayana Buddhists are a minority conservative group, of which

    the Theravada (meaning Teaching of the Elders) is the most

    dominant (among many other subgroups) (Fisher 1999, 4445).

    1. Theravada Buddhists are found in Sri Lanka, Burma,

    Thailand, Cambodia, and Laos

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    34/52

    33

    2. They are thought to mirror early Buddhism more closely

    than does Mahayana.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    35/52

    34

    Week Ten: Buddhism (Continued)

    c. Both Theravada and Mahayana Buddhism center on Buddha, his

    teaching, and the community of his followers, but view Buddha

    and his mission in different ways. Mahayana Buddhists view

    Buddha as a universal, eternal principle, while Theravada

    Buddhists view Buddha as a teacher and example. Mahayana

    Buddhists seek not only personal enlightenment, but other-

    enlightenment as well (45; Hopfe and Woodward 2005, 137).

    d. Within Theravada and Mahayana Buddhism two models of

    enlightenment are espoused (both models are present in both

    groups to some extent, further subdividing the groups) (Lopez

    2004, 505).

    1. In the recognition model, ignorance is suddenly dispelled

    through an experience. People save themselves from within

    (by introspection).

    2. In the purification model, a person gradually comes to

    understand and be enlightened through his or her own

    works. People save themselves from without (by action).

    e. Both models of enlightenment are present in the two types of

    Theravada meditation: 1. Sammatta, intense concentration which

    brings gradual progress toward enlightenment, and 2. Vipassana,

    insight meditation which brings sudden enlightenment (Hopfe and

    Woodward 2005, 136).

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    36/52

    35

    B. Discuss the central doctrines of Buddhism.

    1.Enlightenmentis the key concept of Buddhism, and centers on the

    extinguishment of desire and salvation from samsara. Enlightenment is an

    intellectual, spiritual, and ethical idea.

    2. Samsara is the beginningless cycle of birth, death and rebirth,

    composed of the realms of gods, demigods, humans, ghosts and hell

    beings (Lopez 2004, 554). This had been a central concern of Hinduism,

    and now became of utmost importance to Buddha and his followers. The

    whole point of enlightenment is liberation from samsara.

    3. The ideal Buddhist who receives salvation is known as a Bodhisattva

    (future Buddha). In Theravada,Bodhisattvas are merely ideal pre-

    enlightened individuals, whereas in Mahayana they are savior figures who

    assist in the enlightenment of others (Hopfe and Woodward 2005, 137).

    4.Introspection becomes the method of salvation through enlightenment.

    A person must analyze his or her own sins, but not contemplate others

    wrongdoings (Dhammapada, v. 50).

    a. The person who does evil suffers in this world and in the next

    world (v. 15), but the greatest of all sins is indeed the sin of

    ignorance. Throw this sin away, O man, and become pure from

    sin (v. 243).

    b. Thus, knowledge is the key to liberation, and knowledge comes

    through experience and meditation.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    37/52

    36

    5.Nirvana is the end result of true enlightenment. Nirvana means

    extinguished like a candle (Hopfe and Woodward 2005, 132), and is the

    extinguishing oftanha (desire, thirst, craving) (133). Nirvana is the end

    ofsamsara. The illusion of the worlds reality is no longer felt, and

    disattachment is complete.

    6. Ethical action is of supreme importance in most forms of Buddhism.

    Buddha summed up his teachings as Do not what is evil. Do what is

    good. Keep your mind pure (Dhammapada, v. 183). Enlightenment and

    action go hand in hand. Lay Buddhists and monks have various rules of

    moral conduct that they must follow to attain enlightenment.

    a. A sin, according to Buddha, is an action that a person has to

    repent of (v. 67).

    b. Humans are the root of their own evil. Any wrong or evil a man

    does, is born in himself and is caused by himself; and this crushes

    the foolish man as a hard stone grinds the weaker stone (v. 161).

    If people sin, they are the only ones responsible for their sins.

    c. For Buddhists there is no such thing as a small sin. A little evil

    at a time builds up eventually into great evil. Therefore, all evil and

    sin must be avoided (v. 121).

    d. The wages of sin is karma, death, and rebirth in hell. When a

    fool does evil work, he forgets that he is lighting a fire wherein he

    must burn one day (Dhammapada, v. 136).

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    38/52

    37

    1) There are no places a person can go to escape from evil

    actions or death (vv. 127128).

    2) The effects of purity or sin are not necessarily apparent

    at first, but if a person is patient he or she will receive the

    fruit of their actions (whether good or bad) (vv. 119120).

    e. Some people are born on this earth; those who do evil are

    reborn in hell; the righteous go to heaven; but those who are pure

    reach Nirvana (v. 126). The liar (v. 306), the evil man (v. 307),

    the hypocrite (v. 307), the adulterer (vv. 309310), the person who

    imperfectly lives an ascetic life (v. 311), and those who carelessly

    allow their life to pass by are all on the path of hell and are going

    to suffer in hell in future lives (v. 315).

    7. Buddha taught that humans are without souls (or true selves) because

    souls do not exist; they are anatman (non-soul).

    a. True personal identity is an illusion.What humans think of as

    souls are actually a combination of the physical body, feelings,

    understanding, will, and consciousness (Hopfe and Woodward

    2005, 132).

    b. This combination of non-soulness (anatman) is born, dies, and is

    reborn in an endless cycle. Attachment to the world, anatman, and

    samsara causes suffering.

    8. The idea of suffering (dukkha) for Buddha is an all-encompassing

    sense of life lived with perpetual loss (Zacharias 2001, 40). The Hindu

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    39/52

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    40/52

    39

    Week Eleven: Buddhism (Continued) and Sikhism

    C. Discuss the value of Buddhism.

    1. Assess the strengths of Buddhism.

    a. It emphasizes a persons inner attitude (Hume 1959, 87).

    b. It presents the world with ethical absolutes.

    c. Some of its adherents have sought to bring other people to

    salvation.

    d. In theory, all races, genders, and economic and political classes

    are accepted into the community of Buddha to some degree.

    e. It seeks to escape from suffering.

    2. Assess the weaknesses of Buddhism.

    a. It presents a fundamental impersonalism that is incompatible

    with its own doctrines of self-salvation, the preexistence and

    eternal existence of Buddhas soul in the world, and the idea of

    compassion for other humans (if other peoples souls are not real,

    they are not worth saving, for in the end nothing will be saved)

    (87).

    b. It is world-denying.

    c. It excessively emphasizes self-salvation.

    VI. Sikhism

    A. Discuss the background of Sikhism.

    1. Around 900 C.E. Muslims began to invade India, concentrating many of

    their conquests on northwest India (Hopfe and Woodward 2005, 156).

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    41/52

    40

    From that time onward Muslims and Hindus have had violent and hostile

    interactions with each other.

    2. Many reformers from within Islam and Hinduism sought to reconcile

    the two groups and synthesize their religions. By the 15th

    century

    Hinduism and Islam had developed several similar practices, including the

    veneration of shared holy men, shrines, and other places of religious

    devotion (157). These similarities brought some religious leaders to

    propose that Islam and Hinduism were in fact different aspects of the same

    religion.

    a. One such leader was a Muslim named Kabir. He worshipped the

    Hindu deities, yet taught that God was one (157).

    b. Kabir was later revered by both Muslims and Hindus in India,

    and made a profound impression on the Sikhs and their literature

    (157).

    3. In the late 15th century, a Hindu man named Nanak (a contemporary of

    Kabir) was born in the Indian region of Punjab. Nanak became the founder

    of Sikhism.

    a. While Nanaks family and neighbors were mostly Hindus, his

    schoolteacher was a Muslim. From an early age, Nanak observed

    that Muslims and Hindus had distinct beliefs and practices. But

    Nanak stressed that before God all people are equal, and that

    equality before God was the key to destroying barriers between

    people (Singh 2000, 18).

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    42/52

    41

    b. Nanak taught the unity of God. God created all, and pervades

    the entire universe. God is unborn, timeless, eternal, self-existent,

    and full of grace, enlightening those who earnestly seek him (23).

    c. Nanak taught the Hindus that pilgrimages, penances,

    compassion and alms-giving bring a little merit, the size of a

    sesame seed. But he who hears and believes and loves the Name

    shall bathe and be made clean in a place of pilgrimage with him

    (20).

    d. Nanak told the Muslims to let compassion be your mosque, let

    faith be your prayer mat, let honest living be your Koran, let

    modesty be the rules of observance, let piety be the fasts you keep;

    In such wisdom try to become a Muslim: right conduct the Kaba;

    truth the prophet; good deeds your prayer; submission to the

    Lords will your rosary (20).

    e. Nanaks position was that Hinduism stressed basic compassion

    while Islam stressed essential brotherhood (27).

    f. Nanak was succeeded by a line of gurus. In Sikhism, gurus are

    guides to universal spiritual salvation, and as such are able to

    discover and teach universal truth (the gurus composed, collected,

    and edited the sacred scriptures of Sikhism) (Kalsi 1999, 13).

    4. There were ten human gurus (including Nanak) in Sikhism.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    43/52

    42

    a. The third Sikh guru, Amardas, reasoned that castes were

    false classifications because all men were equal before God, and

    even the lowliest may know God and be a true Brahmin (3031).

    b. The sixth guru, Har Govind, in obedience to the dying wishes of

    his father, the fifth guru Arjan, transformed Sikhism from a

    peaceful religion of religious reconciliation to a militaristic group

    struggling with national Muslim rulers (although some minor sects

    continue to follow Nanaks pacifistic tendencies) (Hume 1959,

    105; Hopfe and Woodward 2005, 159, 161).

    c. Seven of the first gurus contributed to the Adi Granth, the Sikhs

    most important sacred scriptures. TheAdi Granth is written in six

    different languages, and includes the works of thirty-seven authors,

    including several Hindu and Muslim holy men. The last human

    guru, Gobind Singh, proclaimed theAdi Granth to be his successor

    as the living guru of Sikhs on earth. Since then, Sikhs have been

    accused of committing idolatry because of their worship and

    reverence for their scriptures (Hume 1959, 99).

    d. TheDasam Granth is the poetry of Gobind Singh. It is an

    important text to Sikhs, but is given less authority than theAdi

    Granth (1999, 4356).

    e. In order to emphasize the social solidarity and brotherhood of all

    Sikhs and to disavow any remains of the caste system, Sikhs all

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    44/52

    43

    followed the last guru in changing their last names to Singh

    (lion) (Hume 1959, 106).

    f. There are only about nineteen million Sikhs in the world today,

    most of whom live in the Indian region of Punjab (Hopfe and

    Woodward 2005, 156).

    B. Discuss the central doctrines of Sikhism.

    1. The unity of Godis the central doctrine of Sikhism (Kalsi 1999, 17).

    Gobind Singh, the tenth guru, said the temple and the mosque are the

    same. So are Hindu worship and Muslim prayer (22). Read and discuss

    the Japji, which is memorized and recited every day by Sikhs (qtd. in

    Hopfe and Woodward 2005, 163167).

    2. The unity of humanity is embraced by Sikhs as a fundamental

    presupposition. Communal worship, communal meals, community service,

    community-centered work, and communal sharing are all important

    actions of Sikhs (3242).

    3. Submission to Gods sovereign will is taught in accordance with

    Muslim belief (2425).

    4.Active righteousness is the key to salvation from samsara (the cycle of

    life, death, and rebirth). Believers must not be mere spectators, or live as

    secluded monks, but must be actively involved in righteous thoughts,

    words, and actions (2526). In order to escape from samsara, a person

    must follow the guru and believe in Gods oneness and the equality of

    humanity. When people escape the cycle, they attain spiritual liberation

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    45/52

    44

    and merge with God. Thus, Sikhism embraces a form of eschatological

    monism.

    C. Discuss the value of Sikhism.

    1. Assess the strengths of Sikhism.

    a. It has a strong emphasis on ridding oneself of hypocrisy.

    b. It embraces the brotherhood of humanity.

    c. It has strong social solidarity.

    d. It began as an attempt to reconcile two major world religions

    with a single truth.

    2. Assess the weaknesses of Sikhism.

    a. The Supreme Being is sometimes thought of as personal,

    sometimes as impersonal.

    b. While the sacred writings are greatly revered as the great living

    guru and guide to salvation on earth by Sikhs, very few adherents

    know the content of their scriptures (Hume 1959, 98). This is not

    an uncommon weakness in the major world religions.

    c. There is an almost helpless submissive fatalism (110).

    d. The synthesis of legalistic monotheism with Hinduism is at best

    a questionable enterprise.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    46/52

    45

    Week Twelve: Conclusions

    VII. Conclusions

    A. Discuss several common features of the major world religions of India.

    1. Reincarnation. Since the advent of the idea of reincarnation in India,

    this theological and metaphysical idea has been the centerpiece of Indian

    religion. Sikhs deny the reincarnation of deities, but accept the

    reincarnation of humans (Kalsi 1999, 23).

    2. Karma. All of the major world religions of India embrace the concept of

    karma. Escape from both karma and reincarnation are central motivations

    in Indian religions (Hume 1959, 108).

    3. World denial. Each of the major world religions of India follows some

    form of world denial. While Jains are perhaps the most extreme (and

    consistent) of the major world religions of India in this regard, Hindus,

    Buddhists and Sikhs embrace elements of asceticism, belief in the ultimate

    unreality of the physical universe, and belief in transcendence above

    physical reality through disattachment of some kind (Hume 1959, 102).

    4. Temples. Hindus, Jains, and Sikhs all have some types of temples used

    for worship and rituals and for ascetic practices. Some forms of Buddhism

    are opposed to the use of temples (due to their rejection of the efficacy of

    theism). Nevertheless, many Buddhists are very close to the other major

    world religions of India in their forms of temple worship.

    B. Discuss several points of dissimilarity between the major world religions of

    India.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    47/52

    46

    1. Monism.

    a. Hindus disagree among themselves as to the nature of ultimate

    reality. Some hold to polytheism, while others hold to monistic

    pantheism.

    b. Jains do not embrace monism, and Buddhists are often

    indifferent as to the ultimate nature of the universe.

    c. Sikhs teach a form of eschatological monism (monotheism that

    leads to monism at some point in the future) (Hume 1959, 57, 84).

    2. Belief in a deity or in many deities.

    a. Some forms of Hinduism are thoroughly polytheistic, and are

    open to the admission of new gods or goddesses. Other forms of

    Hinduism consider polytheism ignorant idolatry, and argue for

    some form of pantheism.

    b. Jains opposed any form of theism at the beginning of their

    history, but now they often accept the belief in gods (58).

    c. Buddhists are indifferent to the question of gods, although the

    Buddhas and Bodhisattvas take the place of gods in some forms of

    Buddhism (particularly in Tibetan Buddhism).

    d. Sikhism emphasizes the unity of God, and opposes polytheism

    on principle (though polytheistic worship may be accepted as

    worshipping the one God in different manifestations) (57).

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    48/52

    47

    3. The caste system.

    a. Early Vedic Hinduism was developed alongside the caste system

    of early Aryan civilization, and emphasized the importance of

    castes in understanding ones duties and karma. Modern forms of

    Hinduism have attempted to throw out the historical religious

    significance of the caste system, and by emptying it of its religious

    significance have been able to abandon the caste system to a large

    degree.

    b. Jainism, Buddhism, and Sikhism have all historically fought

    against the caste system (based on the brotherhood and unity of

    humanity), although Jainism has come to accept it (Hume 1959,

    59; Kalsi 1999, 23).

    4. Sacred scriptures.

    a. All of the world religions of India have their own sacred

    scriptures.

    b. Jains, Buddhists, and Sikhs reject most of the Hindu scriptures

    in favor of their own scriptures.

    c. Most of the adherents in all the major religions of India are not

    able to read or understand their own sacred scriptures (Hume 1959,

    58).

    d. Some Buddhist groups emphasize the soteriological efficacy of

    their scriptures, while other Buddhist groups deny the ultimate

    value of any scriptures.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    49/52

    48

    e. None of the major world religions of India claim that their

    scriptures are infallible, though Sikhs are taught to worship their

    scriptures as the living guru of Sikhism.

    5. Idolatry.

    a. Hindus, Jains, and Buddhists are all divided as to this issue.

    Some forms of each of these religions are thoroughly idolatrous,

    while other (more philosophical) forms of these religions are anti-

    idolatrous. Idolatry tends to flourish on the popular level.

    b. Sikhs have consistently opposed idolatry, though they have been

    charged with idolatrously worshiping their scriptures (Kalsi 1999,

    23).

    6. The reality of the individual soul.

    a. Hindus and Jains embrace the reality of the individual soul,

    which is born, dies, and is reborn in a cycle of lives.

    b. However, in philosophical Hinduism, the soul (atman) is the one

    eternal ultimate reality (a monistic view of the soul).

    c. Jains believe in the importance of the soul of all creatures

    (Hindus also believe this, but do not practice its implications as

    consistently).

    d. Buddhists deny the ultimate reality of the soul (anatman).

    e. Sikhs affirm the present reality of the soul, assert that all souls

    are kindred, and teach that at the end of time all souls will become

    one with God (eschatological monism).

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    50/52

    49

    C. Explore avenues of dialogue between the major world religions of India.

    1. Discuss how the major world religions of India might dialogue with one

    another, and ask What might be the results of such dialogue?

    2. Discuss how the major world religions of the West might dialogue with

    the major world religions of India, and ask What might be the results of

    such dialogue?

    a. What fundamental worldview differences are there?

    b. What different emphases are there?

    c. How might these differences have influenced the development

    of the modern cultures of India and the West?

    d. How have the major world religions of India affected the

    religions of the West?

    3. Discuss how Christian exclusivists might reach out and share the gospel

    with adherents to one of the major world religions of India.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    51/52

    50

    REFERENCE LIST

    Bouquet, A. C. 1948.Hinduism. New York: Penguin.

    Fisher, Mary Pat. 1999.Religion in the Twenty-first Century. Upper Saddle River, NJ:Pearson.

    Flood, Gavin. 1996.An Introduction to Hinduism. New York: Cambridge University

    Press.

    Hall, William T., Richard B. Pilgrim, and Ronald R. Cavanagh. 1985.Religion: AnIntroduction. San Fransisco: Harper and Row.

    Hopfe, Lewis M. and Mark R. Woodward. 2005.Religions of the World, 9th

    Ed.: Media

    and Research Update. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson.

    Hopkins, Thomas J. 1971. The Hindu Religious Tradition. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.

    Hume, Robert Ernest. 1959. The Worlds Living Religions, Rev. Ed. New York: Charles

    Scribners Sons.

    Joad, C. E. M. 1965. Philosophy. Greenwich, CN: Fawcett Publications.

    Jowett, Benjamin, trans. 1992. Phaedo, In The Trial and Death of Socrates: FourDialogues. New York: Dover.

    Kalsi, Sewa Singh. 1999. Simple Guide to Sikhism. Folkestone, UK: Global Books.

    Lopez, Donald S., Jr., Ed. 2004.Buddhist Scriptures. New York: Penguin Books.

    Mascaro, Juan, trans. 1962. The Bhagavad Gita. New York: Penguin Books.

    --------. 1965. The Upanishads. New York: Penguin Books.

    --------. 1973. The Dhammapada. New York: Penguin Books.

    Mascetti, Manuela Dunn. 1996. Koans: The Lessons of Zen. New York: Hyperion.

    Mishra, Pankaj. 2004.An End to Suffering: The Buddha in the World. New York: Farrar,

    Straus and Giroux.

    Singh, Patwant. 2000. The Sikhs. New York: Alfred A. Knopf.

    Snellgrove, David. 2002.Indo-Tibetan Buddhism: Indian Buddhists and Their Tibetan

    Successors. Boston: Shambhala.

  • 8/9/2019 An Introduction to the Major World Religions of India

    52/52