ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings...

29
ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD Session 4 – December 6, 2017

Transcript of ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings...

Page 1: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD

Session 4 – December 6, 2017

Page 2: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

QUICK RECAP

What did we discuss in the last session?

Page 3: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Meaning of Justice of God

Allah who is the Rabb of

All the Creation Grants

Them Their Creational

Needs & Gives Them

What They Deserve

Through Their Free Will

& Efforts

ALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 3

Page 4: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Dimensions of Allah’s Justice

Allah’s Justice

This World

Direct Justice

Indirect Justice

Hereafter

ALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 4

Page 5: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Summary – man made evil

Why Does Allah Allow

Humans To Oppress?

Allah Through His Wisdom Has Given Us

Free Will. He Will Not Stop Us Forcefully!

But He wants indirect justice to be

implemented and there is going to be

reaction to injustice!

ALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 5

Page 6: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Summary – natural calamities & Defects

Only Material World Has

Relative Evil

Material World Is Limited

Best Possible Design

There can be spiritual causes

Human beings can protect themselves

Eventually No one will be deprived

6

Page 7: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

List of Doubts

Doubts Related to

Divine Justice

Differences

In creation

In opportunities

Question of Evil

Evil in this World

Manmade Evil

Natural Calamities & Defects

Tribulations

Evil in the Hereafter

Good deeds of non-believers

Eternal Punishment

Intercession / Shafa’ahALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 7

Page 8: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

DOUBT 4DIFFERENCE IN OPPORTUNITIES

Is it not unfair?

Page 9: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Difference In Opportunities

Why Do People Have

Different Opportunities?

Difference in Opportunities

Manmade

Natural Difference

ALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 9

Page 10: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Difference In Opportunities

Difference in Opportunity

Difference in Responsibility

It is Balanced

Out

ALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 10

Page 11: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

It is Your Efforts That Matter!

نسان إل ما سعى وأن س ر وأن ليس لل س عيthat nothing belongs to man except what he strives for, and that he will

soon be shown his endeavor, (Al-Najm: 39 & 40) 11

Page 12: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

DOUBT 5TRIBULATIONS

Why? And why only me?

Page 13: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Tribulations

Why Allah Puts Tribulations & Bala?! Why

Couldn’t He Just Make Everyone Happy!ALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 13

Page 14: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Wrong Views

Why Is Sauna So Hot? Why I Have To Study In

School?

Why I Have To Face

Bala’ In The Dunya?

فةمف دار بلبلء 14

Page 15: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Understanding Tribulations Better!

Tribulations are not

Absolute Evil. But

They Are Relative

Evil.

They Are From Allah

The Wise

They Are there for a

purpose!

ئ ا شير وعسى أن تكه خير لك م ا وه Yet it may be that you dislike

something, which is good for

you, (al-Baqarah: 216)15

Page 16: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Tribulations Are Tests , And …

We Need Tests

ا أن ك ا آمنا وه م أحسب الناس أن ر تر ل ل رق ن ليرعلمن الل فر ذن من قربلهم ولقد فرترنا ال ر فترن

ا وليرعلمن الكاذبي الذن صدق Do the people suppose that they will be let

off because they say, ‘We have faith,’ and

they will not be tested? Certainly We tested

those who were before them. So Allah shall

surely ascertain those who are truthful, and

He shall surely ascertain the liars. (al-

Ankabūt: 2 & 3)

ALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 16

Page 17: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Tests Are There To …

Wake Us Up

منره م الصال اوقطعناه م ف الرض أ م ن ومنره م

لك نه م بل د ون ذ وبرلات لعله م سنات والسيئ

ن جع ر

We dispersed them into communities

around the earth: some of them were

righteous, and some of them otherwise,

and We tested them with good and bad

[times] so that they may come back. (Al-

A‘raaf: 168)

ALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 17

Page 18: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Tests Are There To …

Make Us Strong & Give

Us Higher Perfections!

ل نك م بشيء من ع ونرق ولنربر وال ص من الال والنف س والثم ات الم الذن ن الصاب وبشن ا إن لل وإن إ إذا أصابرتره م مصيبة قال راجع ليات م م ورحة أ ولئك عليهم صل وأ ولئك ه م ن رب

الم هتد ون We will surely test you with a measure of fear and

hunger and a loss of wealth, lives, and fruits; and

give good news to the patient —those who, when an

affliction visits them, say, ‘Indeed we belong to Allah

and to Him do we indeed return.’ It is they who

receive the blessings of their Lord and [His] mercy,

and it is they who are the [rightly] guided. (Al-Baqarah: 155-157) 18

Page 19: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Tests Are There To …

Purify Us From Our Sins Tribula

tions

For Oppressors it is a means of correction

For a believer it is a test

For Awliya it is a means of increasing their Darajaat

ALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 19

Page 20: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

DOUBT 6ETERNAL PUNISHMENT

Is it not too much?

Page 21: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Eternal Punishment

Isn't That Evil!

ALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 21

Page 22: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

System Of Cause & Effect

Every Effect Is In

Proportion To Its CauseSmall Cause Small Effects!

Big Cause Big EffectsALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 22

Page 23: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Don’t Go By The Zaahir ….

Cause Might Appear

Small But It Is Big!

Our Actions Can Have

Eternal Effects!

ALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 23

Page 24: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Difference Between Dunya & Aakhirah

How Much Difference Is

There Between Womb-

World & Dunya!

Aakhirah Is Purely For

Hisab & Accounting

Aakhirah Has Infinite

Potential

Reward & Punishment Is

the Baatin Of That Action

Itself

ALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 24

Page 25: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Eternal Punishment Is For Those …

• Who Deliberately Sin

• Who Do Not Repent

• The Sin Is Of Great

Magnitude

• May Be It Is Because

Soul Reaches A Stage

That He Cannot Now

Return. It Is Disfigured

Eternally

العذاب إذا ه م فرلما كشفنا عنره م ن نك ث

But when We lifted the

punishment from them,

behold, they would break

their pledge. (Al-Zukhruf: 50)

ALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 25

Page 26: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

What Should We Do?

What Is My Duty!

• Intellectually Or At Least

Religiously Accept That Eternal

Punishment Is There & It Is Just

• Be Very Careful Of Our Actions

• Generally Know What Things

Cause Eternal Punishment

• Leave The Details To Allah & The

Ahl Al Bayt (a)

ALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 26

Page 27: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Example

Murdering A Believer

ا فجزاؤ ه جهنم خ ومن رقت ل م ؤمن ا مترعم ا فيها د الد ولع عذاب وغضب الل علي وأعد ل ا ن عظيم

[٤:٩٣ ]Should anyone kill a believer intentionally,

his requital shall be hell, to remain in it

[forever]; Allah shall be wrathful at him and

curse him and He shall prepare for him a

great punishment. (Al-Nisaa: 93)

ALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 27

Page 28: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

Example

Murdering A Believer

ة من أصحابنا عن أح -1 الد د بن م مد بن خ عد ع ة عن أب عبد الل عن ع ثمان بن عيسى عن ساع

ل الل ع : قال عن قر ل و من رقت -ز و جل سألت من قال [ خالدا فيها]م م ؤمنا م ترعمدا فجزاؤ ه جهن فذلك الل الم ترعمد الذي قال قرتل م ؤمنا على دن

عذاب ع -عز و جل ل ظيما قر لت فالج و أعد ل و بري الج ل ش ن ب بسي ي رقع برير ء فريض فريرقتر ل ف

قال قال الل عز و جلليس ذلك الم ترعمد الذيALI 423: Divine Justice - Ses 4 28

Page 29: ALI 423:JUSTICE OF GOD - Academy for Learning Islam · There can be spiritual causes Human beings can protect themselves Eventually No one will be deprived 6. List of Doubts Doubts

END OF SESSION 4(JUSTICE OF GOD COURSE)

[email protected]