Al-Jazeera Papers - 5- Formated · 8 H5I@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëc ñŠv aë òîz–Ûa òíbÇŠÛb×...
Transcript of Al-Jazeera Papers - 5- Formated · 8 H5I@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëc ñŠv aë òîz–Ûa òíbÇŠÛb×...
@ @@ @
µëþa@òÈjİÛa@ @@òyë†Ûa– 2008@@ @
@ @@ @@ @
@ @
א J אW 4930181 -4930183 -4930218 ) 974.(+
W4831346 )974.(+ E-mail: [email protected]
אF E ISBN ( )
ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëc@@ @@ @
@ @´×bß@æìu@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@ @
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@ @@ @@ @
@ @@ @
ïßìîi@õýÇ@ @
5
pbíìna @ @
½aò߆Ô@@ @7@ @Þëþa@Ý–ÐÛa@Z@_´×bß@æìu@ìç@åß@ @11@ @
üëcZŠöbrÛaÝİjÛa´×bßI1983M2000H 13@ @bîãbqZ´í‰ìèà¦aë”ìi†™´×bßlëŠyI2000M2004H 24@ @brÛbqZ”ìjÛŠ•bäßëÞ†nÈ߆í†u´×bßI2004MH 33@ @
ÞëþaÝ–ÐÛa“ßaìç 59@ @ïãbrÛa@Ý–ÐÛa@ZÁëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@ @65@ @
üëcZÖaŠÈÛa 67@ @bîãbqZ´îäîİÜÐÛaëÝîöaŠg 88@ @brÛbqZæaŠíg 103@bÈia‰ZòîaŠÔ¹†ÛaŠ’ãòbî 109@
bßbZòîiŠÈÛaÞë†ÛaÉßòÓýÈÛaôØÛaIòí…ìÈÛa늖ß
bí‰ìëH 115@b…bZâý⁄añ‰ì•ë´×bßlbİ 120@
ïãbrÛaÝ–ÐÛa“ßaìç 130@@Ý–ÐÛasÛbrÛa@Z…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛa@ @139@
üëcZ_…†¦aæìÄÏbaáçåß 140@bîãbqZæìu…†¦aæìÄÏbaë´×bß 167@
sÛbrÛaÝ–ÐÛa“ßaìç 188@ò·b@ZaòbîÛ@´×bß@æì¦@òîu‰b¨a@@ @195@
@ @
7
@ @Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu@ @
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@ @@ @
ò߆Խa@ @pbib‚nãýÛ ïaŠÔ¹†Ûa ëc ð‰ìèà¦a ´iŒ§a ïz‘ŠßÑÓaìß Ýîܤ
émbbîëéÐÓaìßë|‘ŠàÜÛòîmaˆÛañÜÛòa‰……Š©îÛòî×ßþaòîböŠÛa
ÝràÏLkzÏòÈÓìn½a†ÈíÝîÜznÛaaˆçMáçþaéjãbu¿MÒìÓìÜÛòÛëbª
énÈÏ… Ûa lbjþaë òîböŠÛa pbib‚nãüa lbnÇc óÜÇ lŒ§a òÛby óÜÇ
âbÇÝØ’iémbèuìmëlŒ§aÝjÔnßóÜÇÙÛ‡pbÈjmëéäîÈi|‘Šß‰bînüN
´×bßæìuÑÓaìßòa‰…Ýr·ŠcȶJohn McCainlŒ§a|‘Šß
òböŠÜÛ ð‰ìèà¦a òî×ßþaI2008 H– ïÛb§a bär¡ Ò†ç ïçë–òÛëbª
lbnÇc óÜÇ ð‰ìèà¦a lŒzÜÛ òybn½a òîbîÛa pa‰bî¨a ÝšÏc òa‰†Û
¿òÜ•bÏòßýÇæìØmæcæërØÛabÉÓìníòí‰ìªòîÛa‰†îÏëòîbö‰pbib‚nãa
ôìÔÛa pbã‹aìmë òî×ßþa òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa òËbî• ¿ë ï×ßþa ƒí‰bnÛa
âbLjäßœîiþaoîjÛaóÜÇŠİî½a´àîÛa´iòîÜa†Ûa2001ï×ßþa‰bîÛaë
pbib‚nãa¿æìí‰ìèà¦abèißÛaŠöb¨a†Èiò•bLáØzÜÛñ…ìÈÜÛŒÐzn½a
âbÇ2006òîu‰b¨aëòîÜa†Ûa´nybÛaóÜÇñ†í†ÈÛaáèöbİcëòîöŒ¦aN
ŠÛa pbib‚nãüa òîàçc †yc óÜÇ óб üëòèuë †í†¤ ¿ òÜjÔ½a òîbö
bãbÔnyaë bÈaë bí…b–nÓa a…ì׉ éuaìm ñ†zn½a pbíüìÛbÏ Lòî×ßþa òîbîÛa
”ìiìîÜi…x‰ìuîöŠÛañ‰a…gÝ’Ï¿‰ìÜjmbîÜa…bîbîGeorge W. Bush
@ @
8
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
ô×wßaiò•b¨apbyý•⁄aå߆í†ÈÛajm¿ñŠvaëòîz–ÛaòíbÇŠÛb×
nuüaæbàšÛaëÑÓëëï×ßþa …b–nÓüaÊb™ëcý•gåÇÙîçbãïÇbà
pa‰bàrnüañŠvçëð‰bÔÈÛaåçŠÛaòß‹cë‰üë†ÛaÉuaŠmëÑöbÃìÛaÑíŒã
x‰b¨aµgòî×ßþaN
Éua× ñİpbÈjm òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa òybóÜÇ b×ßcïãbÈm bà×
nÛalbîËëÖaŠÈÛa¿bèmbbîÝ’Ïëbèm‰ì•‰ìç†mëbènîÓa†–ߊÄnä½aâ†Ô
òîîöŠÛa ”ìi îöŠÛa pa‰…bjß åß …†Ç Ý’Ï åÇ Ùîçbã LæbnãbÌÏc ¿
ÕÜİí bß õbäiëÁëþaÖŠ’Ûbi òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa Š’äÛ éîÇbßëÕíŠİÛa ò‰b‚×
éîÜÇB†í†¦aÁëþaÖŠ’ÛaNB
´×bßæìu‰ìmbäîÛaåßÝšÏcæìí‰ìèà¦a†¯ÒëŠÄÛaêˆçÝÿ
a pbib‚nãüa ¿ áèÜîrànÛaìÜšÏ ´í‰ìèà¦a æc ÒëŠÈ½aë LòÜjÔ½a òîböŠÛ
âbÇpbib‚nãa¿´×bßóÜÇ”ìiìîÜi…x‰ìu2000óÜÇÙÛ‡ë LòîböŠÛa
òîbîÛa ñ¨a¿ë òibݨa¿ éÓìÐmë òîbîÛa´×bß ñ†äuc Œî·åßáËŠÛa
”ìi æìí‰ìèà¦a ÝšÏ ÙÛ‡ Éßë L”ìi óÜÇñ¨a ÝîÜÓ nÈí ðˆÛa
òϊȽaÑîÈ™ëéäÇòäí†n½alŒ§a†ÇaìÓb™‰kjiòîu‰b¨aòbîÛabíbšÔi
LbèäÇÈíëbèîÛgïànäí”ìiæcpa…bîÔÛaÙÜmpc‰sîyLòí†îÜÔnÛaéma…bîÓë
ñ†í†‘ëÑîÛbØnÛaòÄçbiòîib‚nãaòÜ»áîÄämåßåØ·”ìiæcµgòÏb™gaˆç
áîÄänÛaM Òë‰ Þ‰b× bç…ìÔíKarl Rove †äèßë ”ìi ‰b’nßémý»
òîib‚nãüa–ñ†zn½apbíüìÛaÇéÛ´í‰ìèà¦aáÇ…†–§N
ÊbäÓ⁄òİ’ãòÜ»ëò÷íŠu‰bØÏcëñ…놪…‰a춴×bßóÈÝibÔ½a¿
òaŠ‘ë”ìi Þaìßc âbßc Ý’Ï éäØÛë LénÜ»ë ém†äucë éÐäi ´í‰ìèà¦a
@ @@ @
9
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
´í’jnÛaoãbnmëÛañ…bӜωëÒë‰Þ‰b×US EvangelicalséÛïÜ¥ë
éäÇð‰ìèà¦alŒ§apa…bîÓN
éj’í bàîÏ òîÛb§a pbib‚nãüa ¿ ´×b½ æìí‰ìèà¦a …bÇ ÙÛ‡ Éßë
ÒaÇüaòäîÐÛa ÖŠË ÝjÓ ý•fiÛ ïÈÛaë ñ‰ëŠšÛa oÓë ¿ dݨbi
ñþaò•ŠÐÛaòÛëbªëN
´í‰ìèà¦aëc´×bßóÜÇáاa¿ÊŠnãüebäíc‰ÖbîÛaaˆçÝÿë
óÜÇëcszjÛaaˆçpbzЕÇõë†èióÈãæcëLòÜjÔ½aòîu‰b¨aáènbî
æc óÜÇ LéÔîÔznÛ éÐã´×bß óÈí bßë´í‰ìèàvÜÛ´×bß éÜr¹ bß †•ŠÛ
´í‰ìèà¦aòÓë‰c¿‰ë†íbßpbÈjm†•‰ìçëLbí‰ìªbφçbääîÇck–ãÉšã
þaÖŠ’Ûaêb£òÈÓìn½aénbîóÜÇ´×b¶òİîaŠöaë†Ûaëê‹ìÏòÛby¿Áë
âbÔãüaòÛbyÝÿò•báöbÓÞbànyaìçëLòÜjÔ½apbib‚nãüa¿òböŠÛbi
áÔãa sîy Lòí†îèànÛa pbib‚nãüa Þý æìîaŠÔ¹†Ûa bèäß óãbÇ Ûa
æìnäîÜ×ð‰ýîç†îídm´ibz™aëbßbÔãaáèÐãcóÜÇæìîaŠÔ¹†ÛaHillary
ClintonbßbiëcÚa‰biëcBarack ObamabÈÛa‰bÄãcoÐÛÝØ’iN
óÜÇáènîÜšÏdiæìîaŠÔ¹†ÛaÝÐn°æcbÈÛaéîÏÉÓìmðˆÛaoÓìÛaïÐÏ
LòÈuìß ò¹Œç áèi aìÔzÜîÛ aë†Èní æcë òÜjÔ½apbib‚nãüa ¿´í‰ìèà¦a
æìnäîÜ× ð‰ýî òîÛaìß òÄÏbªpb÷Ï´i áèÐãc óÜÇ æìîaŠÔ¹†Ûa áÔãa
a ‰bjØ× îÌnÛa ó’¥ òî߆Ôm ôŠcë áîÜÈnÛa ïÜîÜÓë åÛMlbj’Ûb×
pbîÜÓþaë´àÜÈn½aëMîÌnÜÛò÷íŠuñ†äucëbßbiëcÚa‰bjiÉφÛa†íŠmN
ÂbÔnÛü òÜîÜÔi oîÛ ò•ŠÏ ´×bß òÔibÛa pbßbÔãüa oİÇc †Óë
æìîaŠÔ¹†Ûa‰†çc´y¿òîböŠÛapbib‚nãýÛa…a†ÈnaêaìÓ†’yëébÐãc
òäîa‰ìè‘MòböŠÛaÖbjåßMòîÜa†ÛaáèmbÏý¿N
@ @
10
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
bëcÞëbäní õaŒuc âbÓc òqýqµg òîÛb§a òa‰†Ûa áÔã æc bäíc‰ †Óë
òî–‚’Ûa éÇbjë òíŠþa énîÐÜ sîy åß ´×bß æì¦ òîmaˆÛa ñÛa
Ûa lbjþaë òßbÇ òЖi òîu‰b¨aë òîÜa†Ûa éÐÓaìßë òîbîÛa émßë
ßëê…ìÈ–Ûp…bÓòîböŠÛapbib‚nãüa¿´í‰ìèà¦a|î‘i‹ìÐÛaåßénäØ
òîÛb§aN
òîiŠÈÛa bíbšÔÛa áçc åß …†Ç êb£´×bßÑÓaìß ïãbrÛa õŒ¦a †•Šíë
Š–ßëæaŠígëâýÛaòîÜàÇë´İÜÏëÖaŠÈÛaêb£éÐÓìà×òîİëcÖŠ’Ûaë
ß ÙÛ‡ë Lâý⁄a ñ‰ì•ë òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa Š’ã îšÓë bí‰ìë òí…ìÈÛaëå
bîäß‹´×bßÑÓaìß ‰ëˆ¦ ñ…ìÈÛaë Ýßb’Ûa †•ŠÛa óÜÇ âìÔí wèäß Þý
þaësÛbrÛaõŒvÜÛbè×ãÛaâbØyþa‰a†•g¿síÛaëLæbØß⁄a‰†Ôi
Ûa ÝßaìÈÛaë ´×b¶ òİîa òîbîÛa Šöaë†Ûa Þëbäní ðˆÛaë Lòa‰†Ûa åß
åßénÛìyëòîÛb§aéÐÓaìßµgém…bÓëê‰bØÏcoËb•Ýî¦aŒß‰†Èíæb×Ýu‰
´ÄÏba‰bîmåÇåíȽaáçcå߆yaëµgpbîäîãbàrÛaëpbîäîÈjÛa¿âbänîÏ
Ñ–nä߈äßáèmbbîëáç‰bØÏcë…†¦aaˆçbänÓëónyëpbîäîÈnÛaN
ð‰ìèà¦alŒ§a ò–ÓåÇÈßëâbç õŒuïç´×bßæìuò–Óæg
‰ë†íë ‰a… bßëï×ßþa´àîÛaëá×b§aÞýô×püì¤åß bàèÜa…
‰ìÄä½aÝjÔn½a¿ëñþaòqýrÛa…ìÔÈÛaN
11
@ @Þëþa@Ý–ÐÛa
_´×bß@æìu@ìç@åß@ @
òîböŠÛa pbib‚nãüa ¿ ð‰ìèà¦a lŒ§a |î‘i ´×bß æìu ‹ìÏ
òî×ßþaIàÏìã2008 HòÜíìòîbîñ½wíìnmìèÏ LÎaŠÏåßpdí
âbLjäß´×bß bçc†i1982lb‚nãa†è‘ðˆÛaâbÈÛaìçëLŠí†ÔmÝÓcóÜÇ
å߆yaëò–ÔÛ b¯ìnm†Èí éãc bà× Lï×ßþalaìäÛaÜ©òíìšÈÛ´×bß
‰…b–ßÉà£sîy LòîÛb§a ñÐÛa¿Öý⁄aóÜÇ´î×ßþa òbÛa áçc
¿´îbîÛaŠè‘c†ycµgñþapaìäÛa¿Þ줴×bßæcóÜÇòÐÜn«
ßcLáèmŠè‘ë bàäîÛa âì¬ òãbضÉnàníïbîÛÞì¤ LòîjÈ‘áçŠr×cë b×
òîߌí‰b×ñ…bîÓåÇb×ßcbèîÏszjmñÏ¿ï×ßþaïßìÔÛaÝİjÛañ‰ì–ië
ñ†í†Çòîu‰bëòîÜa…pb톤òèuaìßóÜÇbèäîÈmN1
ÂìÔÛaë…ìÈ–ÛapaÐi õïܽa 鱉bmë émŠè‘ëòÔibÛa´×bß ñ‰ì•
èÈîºïçòÛby¿òÜjÔ½a´×bßpbbîáèÐÛbèiïÇìÛaánzníòßbçÝßaìÇb
àÏìã ¿ òî×ßþa òböŠÛbi ê‹ìÏ2008Š’Ûbi bŠÈnã æc bäíc‰ aˆÛ L
âbÓcòqýqåßæìØníðˆÛaëLòîÛb§a bäna‰…åßÞëþaõŒ¦a¿ÝîÜznÛaë
ñÐÛaë òÔíŠÈÛa òíŠþa´×bß òîÐÜŠ’i bëc c†jíÛa émbîyåßµëþa
Ñ–ãë paìä ¼ ñ†½ë âbänîÏ lŠy Þý ŠŁa ¿ éÇìÓë p†è‘
åß ÙÛ‡ †Èi éäØß b¾ Þbİiþa ÞbjÔna ÝjÔna sîy b×ßc µg ém…ìÇë
@ @
12
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
âbÇ¿ï×ßþalaìäÛaÜ© òíìšÇµg âbàšãüa1983òíìšÇµg áq
paìäÉi‰diÙÛ‡†Èi„ìî’ÛaÜ©N
rÛaáÔÛabßcïãb–ÞëþaõŒ¦aåßMñÏÞý´×bßñßÞëbänîÏ
âbÈÛ òî×ßþa òîböŠÛa pbib‚nãüa2000‹ìÐÜÛ ´×bß óÈ p†è‘ Ûa
ð‰ìèà¦a|‘Š½aòèuaìß¿pbib‚nãüaÙÜm¿ð‰ìèà¦alŒ§a|î‘i
ìçë LñŠİî½aë òí†îÜÔnÛa òí‰ìèà¦ak‚äÛaádžÛëpbÇnÜÛ a†–yŠr×þa
‰ìuæër×ôŠílìÜdi´×b¶ò¹ŒaÖb§gåßåØ·ðˆÛa”ìiìîÜi…x
[òÐ튒Ûaòîib‚nãüapýà§a†ÇaìÓüëòßaòîbîÛa†îÛbÔnÛaÊaŠíéãc
å‘ µg éÈÏ… ´×bß ô†Û bÔîàÇ bî–‚‘ë bîbî byŠu ÚŠm ðˆÛa Šßþa
늙 lŠyM×ßþa âýÇ⁄a Ýöbëë Š¬ìØÛa òÓë‰c ¿ òîM†™
µëþa”ìi òíüë Þý´×bßoÜÌ‘lŠy L´í‰ìèà¦apa…bîÓë”ìi
I2000M2004Hð‰ìèà¦alŒ§apa…bîÓÁ‚ݪ´×bßÝÈuðˆÛaŠßþa
òÈaìÛaòíçbà¦añìİÛapa‡òäí†n½aòîzî½apbÇbà¦apa…bîÓëN
pa…bîÓë ”ìi †™ ´×bß lëŠy kjië bèma‡ ñÐÛa Þýë
‰ìèà¦aLõbàÛaæbäǵg´×bßæìÜÔn½aëæìîaŠÔ¹†ÛaÉωŠ¬ìØÛbi´í
òİîìÛa éîÏ p‰†ã åß‹ ¿ ü†nÈß üì‰ë bîbî bí†Ó éîÏ aëc‰ë
óÜÇ ï×ßþa ´àîÛa Âbëc ¿ë bßìàÇ òî×ßþa òbîÛa ¿ Þa†nÇüaë
˜ì–¨aéuëN
þaësÛbrÛaáÔÛa bßcMõŒ¦a aˆçåßMbänîÏÝöaëcåß ñÐÛaÞë
âbÇ2005ì¨ ´×bß …a†Èna p†è‘ Ûa ñÐÛa ïçë LæŁa ónyë
óÜÇpüì¤åßÙۇ陊ÏbßëòîãbrÛañŠàÜÛòî×ßþaòîböŠÛapbib‚nãüa
@ @@ @
13
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ôc‰sîy L´Èibn½a ò’ç… ‰bqe ÝØ’i òîbîÛa´×bß òîvîmagëÑÓaìß
‰ìèà¦aë ”ìi óÜÇ ŠöbrÛa ´×bß æc æër×åß †íŒ¶ óܤë Ìm ´í
´×bß Þì¤ÙÛˆië L´í‰ìèà¦a ádži ‹ìÐÛa Ýßc óÜÇ òã…bè½aë òîmbºÛa
å߆í†ÈÛa éÜè¯ïmbºaŠiëæ…bèß Še´×bßµgæërØÛa éÏŠÇ bà× ŠöbrÛa
†•Šã bà× LÝî–ÐnÛbi émbÈjm “Óbäãë ꆕŠã Šßc ìçë Léí†íŠßë ê‰b–ãc
¿ ´×bß bèèuaë Ûa pbí†znÛa éîÇbßM bväÛbi oÜÜ× ÛaM‹ìÐÜÛ
pbib‚nãa¿´í‰ìèà¦a|î‘i2008òîböŠÛaN
ÕjbßÝ׿bäφçëMòa‰†ÛaåßõŒ¦aaˆçô†ßóÜÇëMáèÏìç
òîbîÛa émßë émbîy¿ òîîöŠÛapbİaóÜÇÒìÓìÛaë´×bß òî–‚‘
bòîu‰b¨a´×bßòbîáèÏóÜÇbã†Çbm†ÓÛaLÁëþaÖŠ’Ûaêb£ò•
ücë éädžî−ücÝßdãðˆÛaïîöŠÛa bèφçë òa‰†Ûa êˆçÊì™ìßïçë
ñŠ–n‚½aòa‰†ÛaêˆçpbzЕô†ßóÜÇù‰bÔÛaêbäíN
üëcZ@ŠöbrÛa@ÝİjÛa@´×bß@I1983M2000H@ @ ¿ ´×bß æìu †Ûë29 İËc1936òíŠØÇ òîÐÜ pa‡ ñŠþ
bi a†öbÓ æb× ê†ÛaìÏ LòÔíŠÇ´×bß †u …bÓë LÙÛˆ× ê†uë òî×ßþa òíŠzjÛ
òîãbrÛaòî½bÈÛalŠ§aÞýæbibîÛa¿òî×ßþaòíŠØÈÛapbîÜàÈÛaœÈiNbßc
òî×ßþa paìÔÛa ñ…bîÓ âbänîÏ lŠy paÏ œÈi Þý µìm †ÔÏ ê†Ûaë
Úbäçòi‰ba N´×bßæìubßcI†îЧaHŠþa¿ÉÓëëâbänîÏ¿l‰by†ÔÏ
ýâbänîÐiòî×ßþapaìÔÛañ…bîÓê†ÛaëïÛìmÞN
Ûa Lò߉b–Ûa òíŠØÈÛa òî–‚’Ûa énÈîj lþa ´×bß åÇ ÒŠÇë
òíŠØÈÛañbî§ak¤ëòÐbÈÛaåÇjÈnÛakävnmMòÇbİÛaëÉàÛasîyM
@ @
14
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
ñ¨a åÇ ëc ÝàÈÛa ‰bjc åÇs톧akävnmë ÞŒä½a ¿oà–Ûa âŒnÜmë
aˆÛaéniŠ£ëòî–‚’ÛaòîmNbmŠië‰bßcRoberta´×bßI´×bßæìuñ†ÛaëH†ÔÏ
†Óë LpaŠßb̽aë pýyŠÛaë ŠÐÜÛ bèjyë òîÇbànuüa bènÈîj bèäÇ ÒŠÇ
†îÓóÜÇoÛa‹bàÏ´×bßbmŠië‰bßcLêŠàÇåßpbäîÈjÛa¿ìçëlþa¿ìm
bèníaìç‰b·ëñ†îuòz–iáÈämñbî§aMñŠßb̽aëŠÐÛakyMæŁaïçë
¿bçŠàÇåßpbäîÈnÛaN2
ë†jí ê†Ûaì× ´×bàÏ Léîicë éßc Þb– ´i ɺ †Ó ´×bß æc ë†jíë
ô†Û òßbÈÛa ém‰ì•ë òîbîÛa émbîy óäi éãc bà× Lñr× bãbîyc b߉b•
ìèÏLïßìÔÛaëìÛakuaìÜÛéjyëòíŠØÈÛaémd’ãbcóÜÇ´î×ßþa
nî–‚‘ ‰ìzànm ïbî ëc LðŠØÇ ñ‰ì–i ïbîÞb–¨a Þìy é
òßbÇòЖiòî–‚’ÛaémbîyåÇs톧aéj䣴×bßåÇÊb‘bà×LòíŠØÈÛa
ò•bòЖiâbänîÏ¿ŠþaÞýémåÇëN
bšíc´×bßÒŠÇåØÛëMê†ÛaëØÇóÜÇë–òîÇbànuüaénî–‚’i
éãd×ë´×bßë†jíòîib‚nãüaémý»Þý‚ÏLbäÛaÉßs톧aóÜÇéÛbjÓhië
¹üòíbèãýis톧a¿‰aŠànüaëáèÈßs톧aëçbà¦biÂýnüaÝ
énuë‹wÇŒí Šßc ìçë LŠŁðçbº Š·ûß åßÝÔänÛaëM´×bßð†äî
Cindy McCainMbèuë‹ñŠè‘åßpbÄzÜÛaœÈi¿ïãbÈmsîyLbãbîyc
l†y Ý× åß æìjvȽa éÛìy Éàvní ïßìÓ á¬ µg énÛìy Ûa òîËbİÛa
ëlbvÇ⁄a õbjÇc Éß “íbÈnÛaë –Ûa óÜÇ bèr° bß bàöa… éäØÛë Llì•
òÈaìÛaëñŠè’Ûaëðçbà¦aN
@ @@ @
15
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
kíˆÈmëŠc
´×bß åÇ ÒŠÇM êbj• ñÏ ÞýMòíŠþa énîÐÜ óÜÇ ê…Š·
†Óë Lòî×ßþa òíŠzjÛbi ê†uë ê†Ûaì× ´×bß ÕznÛa ‡g LòÓìߊ½aë ñè’Ûa
ÛaémaŠ×ˆß¿´×bßkn×pbîäîÈnÛaŠaëc¿b犒ãMê†ÛaëñbÏë†Èië
MáÜÈmåØmÛaLém†Ûaë“ç…cŠßcìçëòíŠzjÛbiÖbznÛüa†íŠíåØíéãc
æìubç†ÛëåÇŠßþaaˆçN
a…Šànß éna‰… paìä Þý ”bÇë LòíŠzjÛa æìu Ý… ÙÛ‡ Éßë
¤ë ŠèÛaëpbînÐÛa Éß ìèÜÛbiýÌ’äß òa‰†ÛaóÜÇÝjÔßËë†ÇaìÓáîİ
LôŠþa ìÜm òiìÔÇ òîjí…dnÛa pbiìÔÈÛa ïÔÜmë ò߉b–Ûa òíŠØÈÛa òa‰†Ûa
òÓbİÛaë òz–Ûa åß ar× ‰†çc b߆Èi ïa‰†Ûa éЕ Še ¿ xŠ¥ óny
bÔyüÒÇabà×ìèÜÛa¿oÓìÛaëN3
òíŠþaénîÐÜåßñÐÛaÙÜm¿bàöa…óãbÇ´×bßægêúbÓ†•cÞìÔíë
ωÛaòÓìߊ½aòî–‚‘åÇbr¡…ŠànÛaóÜÇŠ•caˆÛ[bèi†ycêŠ×ˆíæcœ
òÜÔnßN
œÏ‰ éäØÛë LoÓìÛa œÈi 퉆nÛa ¿ ´×bß ÝàÇ xŠ‚nÛa †Èië
âbÇ¿xëŒméãcbà×LòíŠØÈÛapbîÜàÈÛbiÖbznÛüaÝšÏë퉆nÛa1965
k‘Þë‰b×µëþaénuë‹åßCarol SheppN
a òíŠzjÛa ¿ ‰bîİ× éÜàÇ ñÏ Þýëa‰bİc ´×bß éuaë òî×ßþ
ô†yg Þýë LòiìvÇdi bèäß b¬ éäØÛë Lémbîy ïèäm æc p…b× t…aìyë
òíì¦aémbÈÜMâbänîÏlŠy¿MåØ·ëLbèİÔc„ë‰b–iémŠöbojî•c
æb×ëLŠþa¿ÉÓëéäØÛëLòiìvÇdiòÜÈn’½añŠöbİÛaåßlëŠaåß´×bß
@ @
16
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
¿ÙÛ‡26Šiìn×c1967ߊànaëL†ÈiéyaŠÕÜcónyŠþa†îÓ´×b
¿Ñ–ãëpaìä¼15‰bß1973N
Šþa¿éÇìÓëpaìäÞýëM’mbà×bèЖãåߊr×cóšÓÛa
ð…aŠÐãüaj§a¿Ší‰bÔnÛaœÈiMkíˆÈnÛaæaìÛcóÓcµg´×bߊÈm
sîy Laˆç bäßìíóny bèäßïãbÈí Þa‹bß òí†upbÓbÇhi én׊mÛaïãbÈí
kíˆÈnÛa æcÞbÔíë LéîÇa‰‡ †ycÙ튤¿ òiìÈ•†¯ë êÞý´×bß
âbänîÐi …ìä¦aë ïÛbçþa ð†íc óÜÇ éÛbÔnÇa ñÏ Ýöaëc ¿ éÛ ŠÈm ðˆÛa
éšíŠ·åߊþbiéöýß‹åØ·üìÛémbîyóÜÇïšÔíæc…b×òîÛbà’ÛaN
kíˆÈnÛa …a‹ëM Šþa¿´×bß éÛŠÈmðˆÛaM ñìÓµìm b߆Èi
†öbÓ åia éãdi êìãbv áÜÇ b߆Èië âbänîÐi òíŠØÈÛa pbîÜàÈÛa ñ…bîÓ ê†Ûaë
œÏŠÏ LéäÇ xaŠÏ⁄a éîÜÇ a왊ÈÏ á熙 òî×ßþa òíŠØÈÛa pbîÜàÈÛa
ña…d×ëáòíbdž×éäÇxaŠÏ⁄aòîÛbà’ÛaòîßbänîÐÛapaìÔÛaÝÌnmæcåßbÏì
¿õbÔjÛa´×bßÝšÏaˆÛLáèm‰ì•´znÛŠþaMòîÔiÉßéäÇxŠÐíóny
éöýß‹Mò튧aóÜÇkuaìÛaÝšÏ éäØÛë LkíˆÈmåß éÛŠÈní bß …aŒÏ
æcémaŠ×ˆß¿´×bߊ׈íëLbÈîºáèäÇxŠÐíónyéöýß‹ÉßõbÔjÛaýšÐß
Ý’ÏéäØÛë‰bznãüaÞëbyéãcë‰bØãüaòİÔãµgéÜ•ëckíˆÈnÛaN4
ô†yg µg ÝÔã êŠc ñÏ ÞýëœÈi éi oÔnÛa sîy pbîÐ’n½a
´×bß òîÐܨ aŠÄãë Lê‰ì•ë ê‰bjc oÜÔãë òîjäuþa âýÇ⁄a Ýöbë
µgÞì¤òÜibÔ½aÞýbèiŠèÃðˆÛaÑÈšÛaëŠþa¿émbãbȽëòî–‚’Ûa
†äÇ bîÛìİi übjÔna éÛbjÔna ë âbänîÏ ¿lŠ§a õbäv Šè‘c åß †yaë
b×ßcµgém…ìÇN
@ @@ @
17
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
†í†uòuë‹òbîÜÛéuìmëñ
òyŠ½a òî–‚’Ûa émbîy µg ñ…ìÈÛa´×bß ÝšÏ b×ßc µg ém…ìÇ †Èi
Lýíìéß‹üŠßcìçëŠþaÞýémåÇs톧a bšÏa‰òîÇbànuüaë
b虊ßæc늽biojî•c†ÓÞë‰b× énuë‹æc´×b߆uë ém…ìdžäÇë
âbÇ¿ëLbèibj‘ëbbºåßrØikç‡1980a‰ŠÓægÞë‰b×ÞìÔmëLÖýİÛa
¿â†ÔnÛbiÒaÇüaœÏŠíæb×ëôŠcñŠßéibj‘µgñ…ìÈÛa†íŠíæb×´×bß
aˆÛ LŠþa¿ éîÜÇoÇb™ÛapaìäÛaœíìÈm´×bß …a‰c b¶‰ë LŠàÈÛa
ïÜäîçð†äîòîãbrÛaénuë‹´×bßxëŒmCindy Hensleyìíbß¿1980L
Óý åßÁÔÏ †yaë Šè‘ †ÈiÙÛ‡ëðŠq òäia ïçð†äîë LÞë‰b× åß é
bãëŒí‰còíüìi“îÈíëñjÛaòÇbä•¿ÝàÈíï×ßcArizonaÝÔnãasîyL
ñ†í†¦aénuë‹Éß“îÈÜÛ´×bßN5
†ÇbÔß ô†yg ÎŠÏ bãëŒí‰di “îÈÜÛ bàbÔnãa åß ñ–Ó ñÏ †Èië
æb× ðˆÛa Š¬ìØÛa ìšÇ †ÇbÔm †Èi ï×ßþa laìäÛa Üv¶ òíüìÛa
ÜÌ’íaìšÇpbiëLéi‹bÏëk–äàÜÛéÐã|‘‰ëbÈíŠêŠßc´×bßáyëLé
âbÇ¿ï×ßþalaìäÛaÜv¶1983N
òíüëõbäicåßîÛéãìØÛ†ÔäÜÛ´×bߊÈmòîib‚nãüaòÜà§aÞýë
¿ bèÜîr· †íŠíÙÛ‡ Éßë Lñ–Ó ñÏ üg òíüìÛbi“Èí éãþë LbãëŒí‰c
ÜÇ´×bß…‰ëLŠ¬ìØÛa¿acæb×éãþ[bãëŒí‰c¿“Èíéãdiéí†Ônäßó
ðìãbçHanoiIòîÛbà’Ûa âbänîÏHòîšÔÛa ÕÜËc bjšnÔßë bÈíŠ a…‰ æb×ë L
pbib‚nãübi´×bß‹ìÏ¿áçbëN6
@ @
18
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
ïßìÓÝİi
òîbîÛaémbîyòía†i¿âbänîÏ¿émbãbȽÞbÈÐÛaëÉíŠÛa´×bßÞýÌna
åß´ÈßÁàäÛ bu‡ì¸c †Èí éÐäÛ´×bß bçbäi Ûa òî–‚’Ûaë ñ‰ì–ÛaM
j×õb׈iM†íŠÏÊìãåßïßìÓÝİiµgénÛìyÛaë´î×ßþaô†ÛN
õbäi똊¡ém‰ì•óäi´×bßæcµgæìÈibn½a’í˜ì–¨a aˆèië
òîÛbnÛaòÛbÈÐÛapbîvîma⁄aóÜÇZ
üëc Zém åÇ Š‘bj½a ëc œîÐn½a s톧a ´×bß œÏ‰âbänîÏ ¿
kuaìÛaåÇs톧aµgÝibÔ½a¿Ýî¹ìèÏLÚbäçòî–‚’ÛaémbãbÈßë
émåÇpa‡æaŠØãëòçbØÏëò튂is톧aëLïßìÔÛaëìÛa
LêìiˆÇë êìäv åß åÇ êìÐÇ µg ñ‰b‘⁄aë LŠþa ¿ òî–‚’Ûa
âbänîÏÉßòîbîÛapbÓýÈÛañ…bÇ⁄Š¬ìØÛbia…ìèu…bÓéãcóny
nÛbið×æìuïaŠÔ¹†Ûa‰ìmbäîÛaÉßæëbÈJohn KerryN7
bîãbq ZõïÜß ïÛbrß Ë ÝuŠ× ‰ŠØnß ÝØ’i éÐã åÇ ´×bß t†zní
kšÌÛaòÇŠëxaŒ½akÜÔn×òî–‚‘lìîÇbèc‰óÜÇëlìîÈÛbi
ñr× æbîyc ¿ ´×bßkyŠí bà× Lñ‰ìrÛa µg Ýî½aë ÉibİÛa ñ†yë
Ûaë òî–‚’Ûa éöbİdiÒaÇübipaŠß ïÐÏ LŠ‘bjß ÝØ’i òîbî
ÞìÔíëLñj×òîbîõbİc´×bßdİcñr×MòÐÜn«pbjbäß¿
MìçëLbèãaŠØãübèiÒaÇüañ‰ëŠ™õbİþaÙÜmåßáÜÈméãc
ŠßþakÜİma‡géiâbîÔÛaåß´×bßÝv±üŠßcN8
brÛbqZòÛby¿ðŠØÇëcð†äuéãdiÚŠÈ’íÝØ’i´×bßt†znílŠy
åßx늨aëcò¹ŒaœÏŠíð†äuLb×ßþbîÜÈÛaòzÜ–½biÞìÌ’ß
@ @@ @
19
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
‰bØÏcïçë Lb×ßc ñ‰bóÜÇ òî–‚’Ûa ñ‰b¨aÝšÐíë ò׊Ƚa
´îßìÔÛaÞbİiþaÒb–ß¿ éÈšm òî–‚’Ûa émµgoÐî™c a‡g
¿ ´î×ßþa òbÛa ´i áèîÜÇ ‰ìrÈÛa kÈ–í åíˆÛa ´î×ßþa
îÛb§añÐÛaòN
bÈia‰ Zñ…bÐnüaë âbänîÏ ¿ ém åÇ s톧a åß ´×bß Éä¹ ü aˆç
ïׇoÏbÝØ’iÙÛˆiâìÔíéäØÛëLòu‰…ó–ÓcµgbèäßòbîÛa
ÚíëLéÐãåÇs톧akävníìèÏ LòÔibÛaÝßaìÈÛaóÜdžànÈí
âbÇ¿òî–‚’ÛaémÑÛcéãcµgbäç‰b’íëLéäÇs톧aå튳Û
1999äÈi æaìBïöbic ñ†îÔÇ BThe Faith of My FathersÙÛ‡ë
âbLjäßéí†Çbßáçc†ycëénibİkmb×ÉßæëbÈnÛbi1989ìçë
ÛbÚ‰bßMark SalterL9knØÛa Šr×c†ycµglbnØÛaÞ줆Óë
¿çbà¦aóÜÇŠÇïöbàäîáÜîϵg†ÈibàîÏÞì¤bà×LbÈîjß
âbÇ2005Ûbë´×bßkn× bà× LåÇlbn× åß Šr×cÙÛ‡ †Èi
—–Ó ñ‰ì• bèšÈi ˆc LéàîÓë énî–‚‘ë ê‰bØÏcë ´×bß ñbîy
áîÜÈm Ò†èi ï×ßþa lbj’ÜÛ éèuìß õbàÄÈÛa ñbîy åÇ ñÌ•
òÇìàaâìÔmëLåìÛakyëõüìÛaëòîäìÛaáîÓï×ßþaõ“äÛa
âbÇ ¿pŠ’ã Ûa òî––ÔÛa2005åß …†Ç òî–‚‘ Ýîܤ óÜÇ
LõbàÄÈÛaáç‰aŠ•g ìç áèäîi Ú’½a ÁiaŠÛa æc ´×bß ôŠíë
áËŠÛaóÜljaŠÔÛa‡b¥aóÜÇáèm‰†ÓëbväÛa¿áènjˉëáèn¹ŒÇë
áèäßÝ×ô†Ûòî–‚‘lìîÇ…ìuëåßN
éÐãë énî–‚’Û´×bß bè‰Ûa òÔibÛa ñ‰ì–ÛaæcæìÈibnßôŠíë
ì•L´ÔöbÏõbׇëòíbäÈio‰ñ‰ì•ïçï×ßcïßìÓÝİj×oÈ™ëñ‰
@ @
20
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
áçŠè‘cåØíægòîÛb§añÐÛa¿´î×ßþaòbÛaŠè‘cÒb–ß¿´×bß
Öý⁄aóÜÇN
òäaëÂìÔÛapaìä
LpbİÔëcpbiìÈ•æë†ipŠßòîbîÛa´×bßñbîyæcÈíüaˆç
ˆäßñÐÛaægÞìÔÛaåع‡g1986âbÇónyë2004M†n·òÜíìñÏïçë
ô†ßóÜÇ18Ç bßbMpb톤L´×b½òîbîÛapbí†znÛbi ò÷îÜß ñÏoãb×
bà× éÐÓaìßë òîbîÛa énî–‚‘ òÇbä•¿oàçbÈÛaë뉆Ûbi ò÷îÜß
bÇbjmôŠäN
âbÇïÐÏ1986bãëŒí‰còíüëåÇï×ßþa„ìî’ÛaÜ©ìšÇ†ÇbÔm
Šmaë†Ûìuð‰biBarry Goldwater´í‰ìèà¦a´îbîÛa Šè‘c †yc ìçë
‰bînÛa …ìÈ•†äèß éãcœÈjÛa ôŠí sîy LpbäînÛa ˆäß Öý⁄a óÜÇ
lìä¦aõbíŠqc´iÑÛbznÛaóÜÇcðˆÛaòîÛb§aém‰ì•¿ÅÏbaîàîÛa
òîu‰b¨aòîbîÛaòybóÜÇ…†’nÛa‰b–ãcëòäí†n½aòîzî½apbÇbà¦aëN10
sîyéj–äß¿éÐã|î‘Û´×bßÉÏ…Šmaë†Ûìu†ÇbÔmpbiëéi‹bÏ
Šíbäí ˆäß„ìî’ÛaÜv¶ aìšÇ1987„ìî’ÛaÜ©´×bßÞì…åØÛë L
wäîmb× òzîšÏ …ìÈ–i Ájm‰aM ÑíbÏKeating FiveïbîÛa |İÛa µg
wäîmb× ŒÛ‰b’m ÞbàÇþa ÝuŠi òzîšÐÛa ÁjmŠmë Lï×ßþa ïßýÇ⁄aë
Charles KeatingaŠÓ⁄aÞbv¶ÝàÈÛaåßñj×ñ‰ìqæì×ðˆÛaLÚìäjÛaë
ñ†zn½apbíüìÛabo™ŠÈmÛaÚìäjÛaëaŠÓ⁄aòß‹cµgòzîšÐÛa…ìÈmë
bäîãbàrÛa Šaëc ¿p‰bj× åß ar×ŠÇ b¾ ñ†bÏ òîÛbßpb‰b¾kji
@ @@ @
21
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
pbèj’Ûap‰a…ëLpbÔîÔ¤ëòîãìãbÔÛaòÛõb½aµgaŠÓ⁄aëÞb½aÊbİÓÞbu‰
šÇcåßòà¢wäîmb׌ۉb’mòÓýÇÞìyâ†ÓëáèiÝ–ma„ìî’ÛaÜ©õb
Ûa pbÔîÔznÛa óÜÇ qdnÜÛ Ý†nÛa Ò†èi òà‚™ òîbî pbÇm á
bèèuaìíN
´×bßæb×ëMåߊr×di‰†Ômwäîmb×åßpbÇmóÜÇÝ–yðˆÛa100
Š¬ìØÛbi éníìšÇ ñÏÞýï×ßc ‰üë…ÑÛcMð‰ìèà¦a‰ìmbäîÛa
„ìî’ÛaÜ© õbšÇc åà™ †îyìÛa¿pbÔîÔznÜÛ a왊Èm åíˆÛa òà¨a
oÛì¤ëpaìäÉi‰cåߊr×þpŠànapbÔîÔznÛaæcÞbÔíëLòîšÔÛaêˆç
´îaŠÔ¹†Ûa Š¬ìØÛa õbšÇc ´i ÊaŠ• µgë âbÇ ðc‰ òîšÓ µg
Éß òîbî òÔЕ ¿ Þì†Ûa æìí‰ìèà¦a œÏ‰ sîy L´í‰ìèà¦aë
a òîjÛbË æc áØ¡ ´×bß ‡bÔã⁄ ´îaŠÔ¹†Ûaåß áç òîšÔÛa ¿ áèîÏ éjn’½
´îaŠÔ¹†ÛaN11
wäîmb× òzîšÏ Þý ´×bß ñbãbÈß æg æìÈibn½a ÞìÔíëMénàÜÇ ÑíbÏ
bëc Lémbîyô†ßóÜÇénß‹üÛa òîbîÛa뉆Ûaåß a…†Ç ZòîÐî×áÜÈm
sîyLòzîšÐÛaÞýéîÜÇÁÜðˆÛajØÛaïßýÇ⁄aõìšÛaÉßÝßbÈnÛa
b–ãc æc æër×ðc‰ém‰†Ó óÜÇ´§aÙÛ‡ ˆäß éã놰´×bß õa†Çcë ‰
ñÏÞìþõìšÛañŠöa…¿õbÔjÛaëéßbànçalˆuëâýÇ⁄aÉßÝßbÈnÛaóÜÇ
òäؾN12
bèîãbqëZ´×bßÒÇasîyLòîbîÛaõbİþbiÒaÇüañ‰ëŠ™áÜÈm
……íëLwäîmb×pb‰b¾ÞìyòîÛa‰†îÐÛapbÔîÔznÛa¿é܆mdİ¢´×bß
b¾Lò°Š•ëòz™aëpa‰bjÈiòîbîÛaéöbİdiÒaÇüa¿´§aÙÛ‡ˆäß
@ @
22
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
¿ éäØÛë æbãg ðd× øݱ éÐã Éß bÓ…b• a†öbÓ éîÏ æëŠí ê‰b–ãc ÝÈu
éöbİdiÒaÇüa¿……íüÊbv‘éÐãoÓìÛaN13
éäÇ ´í‰ìèà¦a ïÜ‚ni ´×bß ‰ìÈ‘ ìèÏ áçþaë sÛbrÛa ‰†Ûa bßc
g éÛì¤ëåß òu‰†i êŠÈ‘c bß ´îaŠÔ¹†Ûa Éß áèmbÇaŠ• ¿ õa†Ï“j× µ
´í‰ìèà¦apa…bîÓ êb£kšÌÛbiby⁄aë LïiŒ§aÞýÔnüa¿ òjËŠÛa
Šr×cå߆yaëµg†ÈibàîÏ´×bßÞìyb¾LŠ¬ìØÛbiMŠr×cåØíæg–
ÛaÞýï×ßþa„ìî’ÛaÜ©¿üýÔna´í‰ìèà¦a´îbîÛapaìä
òîÛbnÛaN
óÜÇÞb½aqdmå߆§aòîšÓðŠ•bäßå߆yaëµg´×bßÞì¤bà×
pbÇnÛa åß †§bi ò•b¨a pbÈ튒nÛa áÇ… Þý åß òîbîÛa òîÜàÈÛa
´×bßbçbäjmòîšÓïçë´îbîÛa´z‘Š½aëòîib‚nãüapýàzÜÛòîbîÛa
´îÛaîÜÛa ´îbîÛa ‹Šic œÈi Éß æëbÈnÛbi‰ìmbäîÛb× Š¬ìØÛa ¿
†ÛìväíbÏ Ýa‰ÒëŠÈ½a ïÛaîÜÛaRussell FeingoldbèÜuc åßl‰byë L
âbÇ¿æìãbÔ×bç‰aŠÓgónyýíì2001ŠÈmÝíìïbîÊaŠ•†Èi
‰aŠ•⁄a ´×bß áÜÇ Šßc ìçë Lñ†í†Ç áöaŒ æìãbÔÛa Ê늒ßë ´×bß éîÏ
ß éi di ü …†Ç ñëa†Ç éj×cë ñŠibr½aë´îbîÛa åß éiŒy õbäic å
ï×ßþaŠ¬ìØÛbi´í‰ìèà¦aN14
émˆÔãcwîܨalŠyëoäß…cénuë‹
òzîšÏ †äÇ„ìî’ÛaÜv¶µëþa ém‰ë…Þý´×bß ñbãbÈß énäm ë
wäîmb×M µëþa éníüë òîjÛbË oÓŠÌna Ûaë ÑíbÏI1986M1992Hsîy L
@ @@ @
23
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ÈÜÛénuë‹æbß…gÝà’nÛ´×bß|öbšÏoÈmaægÞbÔíëLâüłÛòÐЂ½aÓbÔ
åÇë bèäÇ bèuë‹ bèîÏ ÝÌ’ãa ñÏ ¿ ÓbÔÈÛa ÙÜmoäß…c ´×bß ð†äî
óny bèÈßæbß…⁄a òÜØ’ßp‰ìİm †Óë LòîbîÛa émbß‹dië òbîÛbi émŠc
†Óoãb×òîÇìİmòîjòûßåßñ‰†«ÓbÔÇòÓŠibèàèma†yµgoÜ•ë
¨bi bèîÜÇ áØy aˆÛ Lbèncæbß…g åß õbÐ’ÜÛ ïuýÇ wßbãÛ Êìš
bèävåÇÝí†j×pa‰†‚½aN15
‹ìÐÛaóÜÇém‰†Óp…†çëòjî–ÇñÏ¿´×bßpbß‹þaÙÜmoÜ…cë
oíìØÛa ŠíŠ¤ lŠy æg ÞbÔíë Lï×ßþa „ìî’Ûa Ü© ¿ òîãbq òíüìi
LŠþa¿æìî×ßc…ìäuÉÓëlŠ§aÞý‚ÏLòîbîÛa´×bßñßpˆÔãc
ëóšÓðˆÛa´×bß åß ÝšÏc òîšÔÛa ¿ bq†znß ï×ßþa âýÇ⁄a †¯
òÜjÓ µg ´×bß Þì¤ ÙÛˆië LâbänîÏ ¿ Šþa †îÓ Ñ–ãë paìä ¼
áèÏëŠÃë áçŠcë ôŠþa åÇ sí†zÜÛ òî×ßþa âýÇ⁄a ÝöbìÛ
jØÛaïßýÇ⁄aõìšÛaåß´×bß…bÐnaëLáèäß b×ßcÑÓìßëáç–ßë
ë é§b–Û´îäȽa´îbîÛaáçc †yd× ém‰ì•õbäi¿pbäîÈnÛaÞý c†i
òî×ßþaòîu‰b¨aòbîÛbiëï×ßþaïßìÔÛaåßþbiN16
åí†ÓbäÛa´í‰ìèà¦a áçc †ycµg´×bßÞì¤pbäîÈnÛa †ÔÇÞý‚Ï
´×bßðc‰sîyLæìnäîÜ×ÝîiÕibÛaïaŠÔ¹†Ûaï×ßþaîöŠÛaòîbîÛ
ìnäîÜ× æc“î¦a òîàçc Þbàçhië ……Ûbi æaŒîàní òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa énbîë æ
òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa ¿ ï×ßþa ïßìÔÛa åßþapa‰bjnÇaë òzܽa paìÔÛaë
bÈÛaµgñ……ßëòÐîÈ™pa‰b‘gÝŠíæìnäîÜ×æc´×bßðc‰ëLòî×ßþa
aòíbèäÛòîÛbnÛañÐÛa¿†yëþabÈÛakİÔ×b×ßc‰ë…ÞìyLñ…‰bjÛalŠ§
@ @
24
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
óÜÇ bçõa†Çc Év‘ë bèîÏ b×ßc õbÐÜy òÔq ê……i ÑÈ™c æìnäîÜ× æcë
´iëéäîi òbìÜÛ݆níæc a‰aŠØmæìnäîÜ×óÜÇ´×bߊÇaˆÛLbè톤
æìubnäjÛaë“î¦biæìnäîÜ×òÓýÇ´znÛï×ßþa“î¦apa…bîÓN 17
bîãbq@Z@´í‰ìèà¦aë@”ìi@†™@´×bß@lëŠyI2000M2004H@ @óÜÇ âa†Ó⁄a óÜÇ éi æìİîaë ´×bß òÔibÛa ÝßaìÈÛa oÈv‘ †ÔÛ
ì¨ éÛ ð‰ìèà¦a lŒ§a |î‘Šm óÜÇ Þì–§aë òÏbä½a òjÜy Þì…
âbÇ¿òî×ßþaòböŠÛapbib‚nãa2000ñÐÛaÙÜm¿´×bßòîßì¬oãb×ëL
bí‰ìèº aŠÔ•œÈjÛa éîÏ ðc‰ †Óë LbîÛby énîßì¬ åß bËëŒi ÝÓcLa†Çaë
æŁabèîÛgÝ•ëÛaòîßìväÛaëñŠè’ÛbiåØíéäØÛëN
†Çb–Ûa …ìþa òí†îèànÛapbib‚nãüaæb–z×´×b½æìÈibn½a ŠÄã aˆÛ
ìîÜi…x‰ìuáèc‰óÜÇëLbÄyŠr×þa´í‰ìèà¦a´z‘Š½aòÏbäß¿ñìÔi
×þa ÝuŠÛaë Lòí‰ìèà¦a òû½a |‘Šß éãc óÜÇ éîÛg ŠÄã ðˆÛaë”ìiŠr
òÜ»Šr×ckyb•ëLð‰ìèà¦alŒ§apa…bîÓåßádžÛaëpbÇnÜÛa†–y
b×ßcljb’nãüaëÞb½aëáîÄänÛasîyåßòîib‚nãaN18
ñ¨aëòϊȽaÝîÜÓïbî×”ìjÛœÈjÛaŠÄãéÐãoÓìÛa¿åØÛë
åßþaë òî×ßþa òîu‰b¨a òîbîÛa òyb óÜÇ ò•b lbݨa ÑîÈ™ë
ò•bïßìÔÛa†ÇaìÛa´í‰ìèà¦aŠÔ•ëÕibÛalŠ§ac´×b¶æ‰ìÓa‡g
åß ïãbrÛa Ñ–äÛa ¿ ´×bß ‹Ši sîy LïßìÔÛa åßþa bíbšÔi ÕÜÈní bàîÏ
Çï×ßþa݆nÜÛ bÈîv’mëòí‰ìÔ•´í‰ìèà¦aŠr×c†yd×pbîäîÈnÛa
b×ßþò™‰bȽaëcòÏbä½aôìÔÛa‡ìÐãå߆zÜÛbÈÛaN19
@ @@ @
25
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ß Ý… aˆÛ†™ çbà¦a b–ß ÝîrànÛ óÈí aŠöbq pbib‚nãüa ´×b
Þýð‰ìèà¦alŒ§apa…bîÓÉßòîjÜÛaémµgÙÛ‡…ìÈí†ÓëLk‚äÛa
wäîmb×òzîšÏMædiëòà×b§aòí‰ìèà¦ak‚äÛa êb£ñ‰aŠ½bi émŠÈ‘cÛaÑíbÏ
ÔÛ bšíc …ìÈí†Óë LòÜiŠËµgxbn¤òí‹bènãa òîßombik‚äÛaÙÜmñòÜ
´z‘Š½biòã‰bÔßꆖyðˆÛaïbîÛaádžÛaëpbÇnÛaòÜÓëòîbîÛa´×bß
‰bjØÛaMwèäßjmµg´×bßÉÏ…ðˆÛaŠßþaL”ìiìîÜi…x‰ìuáèc‰óÜÇë
ïz‘Šß†™´ÐÈšn½aëçbà¦a|‘ŠßéãcóÜÇéÐãáí†Ômëð‰ìqïbî
ñŠİî½aëòà×b§aòí†îÜÔnÛak‚äÛa–‰ìv×”ìiìîÜi…xN
ñ†ÓbäÛaë ñ…b§a éÇbjİi ÒŠÇ ðˆÛa ´×bß òÈîj µg Šßþa ÉuŠí †Óë
LòÔibÛapbû½aë †îÛbÔnÛa òÜiŠËë áèmdubÐßë éÛìy åßð†¤µg éÜîßë
óÜÇïmdí Lbßúb’mëñ†yéäÇæìÜÔíüåí†Çb¶æbÈna´×bßæcëò•b
ŠÐíaë æìu áèc‰John Weaverß ð†Çbß áçc †yc´îbîÛa ´×b
åßñÐÛaÞýòîbîÛaémý»Ší†ßë1996ìîãìíónyë2006ҊdžÓëL
òîib‚nãüaénÜ»Ší†ßëïbîÛa”ìi‰b’nßÒë‰Þ‰bØÛêúa†ÇŠÐíaëåÇ
bØm¿bÈßÕibÛabàèÜàÇâbícˆäßN20
òî–‚‘ òÓýÇ óÜÇ bãb×ëpbîäîãbàrÛa ¿Òë‰ Éß ŠÐíaë ÝàÇsîy
èäØÛëLòíìÓâbÇ¿ïbîÒý¿ý…bà1988éÜîß‹Òë‰éîÏáubç
ïbîÛaéÜjÔnßóÜÇóšÔmæcp…b×pbÈöb‘éÛìyŠ’ãëñ†’iŠÐíaëM
éãc ðc‰ëÒë‰ †™ †í†‘ Õä¡ ŠÐíaë ŠÈ‘ aˆÛ [‰…b–½aœÈi ’m bà×
óÜÇÝöbìÛa òÏbØië òaŠ’ibšÔãüa¿ ……íüð‹bènãa ìnÜßïbî
bîÛaéßì–áèîÜÇõbšÔÛaë‹ìÐÛaÝucåß´îN21
@ @
26
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
Lð‰ìèà¦alŒ§aóÜÇñŠİî½aòîbîÛak‚äÜÛéšÏŠiŠÐíaëŠÈ‘aˆÛ
œÏ‰ëâúb’nÛaë òÛŒÈÛa éäÇoÏŠÇðˆÛa ŠÐíaë òî–‚‘énàÇ…‰ìÈ‘ìçë
pbÓëcx‰båİä‘aëk‚äiïÇbànuüaëï–‚’Ûaôìn½aóÜÇÂýnüa
bèîÏ ÑÃìà× åİä‘aìi ”bÇ †ÔÏ LÝàÈÛabçŠöaë…ë bèj® åß †yaì× ü
òî–‚’ÛabèmbÓýÇåßåí†îÐn½aëN
´×bß …bÓ aˆÛMÛbÚ‰bßëùŠÐíaëæìv×åí†Çbß éÐÜåßë–b–ß늬ìØÛbi´í‰ìèà¦apa…bîÓ †ÔãóÜÇ Œ×Šm ñŠöbq òîib‚nãa òÜ»
áçëLköaŠšÛaœÐ¢òjÛbݽapbÇbà¦aëòzÜþaïiìÛëôØÛapb׊’Ûa
ºœÈi æg óny Lá×b§a ð‰ìèà¦a ÑÛbznÛa ¿ òí‰ìa k‚äÛa åß bÈî
òÜ»¿´×bßð†Çbß2000õbäjÛóÈí´×bßæcâýÇfiÛaëŠ×‡òîböŠÛa
¿ éÛ ´í‰ìèà¦a |î‘i ‹ìÐÜÛ éîÇbß åà™ †í†u ð‰ìèº lŒy
òîböŠÛapbib‚nãüaN22
¿ õaŠà§a …놧a óİ¥ éãc aëc‰ ébÈß åØÛë´í‰ìèà¦a †Ôã
köaŠšÛa œÐ¨ ”ìi Áİ ´×bß †Ônãa Þbr½a Ýîj óÜÈÏ LlŒ§aë
bè߆‚naÛaòîîöŠÛaòv§aïçëLõbíŠqþaò߆µgÒ†èmbèãdibèЕëë
”ìi Áİ †Ôã ¿ æìîaŠÔ¹†Ûa–æìîäîàîÛaë æìí‰ìèà¦a ðc‰ bà×
´×b½æ왉bȽaæìÄÏbaN23
™‰bÈß´×bß ñ‰ìq åß …a‹ëñŠİî½a òäí†n½a òîzî½a´àîÛa ôìÔÛ én
ŠÄäíïãbàÜÇ´×bßæþÙÛ‡ëLð‰ìèà¦alŒzÜÛòíçbà¦a†ÇaìÔÛaóÜÇ
µgŠÄäíë LòîbîÛa óÜÇ åí†Ûa æbî̜ϊíë Lòî–‚‘ òîšÔ× åí†Ûa µg
òî×ßþaáîÔÛaôŠíëLïãbàÜÈÛaïßìÔÛaëìÛakuaìÛa‰ìÄäßåßòîbîÛa
@ @@ @
27
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
bãg ‰ìÄäß åß[ï½bÇ ïãbàÜÇ ïã24oãbnmëÛa ôìÓ ædi ´×bß åße aˆÛ
ôìÓ ïç ð‰ìèà¦a lŒzÜÛ òíçbà¦a †ÇaìÔÛa óÜÇ ñŠİî½a ´í’jnÛa
Ûabèu⁄b× òí†îÜÔnÛa òîÏbÔrÛa bíbšÔÛa óÜÇ Œî×ÛaœÏ‰ bà× Lñ…†’nß
æìí†îÜÔnÛa æìÄÏba bèîÜÇ Œ×ŠíM áèäß æìäí†n½a ò•bMLj× ÝØ’i
Û‡ëÙØ‘ aˆÛ [†îÈ–Ûa aˆç óÜÇ ÅÏba ´×bß Ýv åß áËŠÛa óÜÇ Ù
éãdi êìЕëë LÅÏba îàîÛa éÜv ¿ ´ÄÏba åß ´×bß ð†ÔnäßœÈi
BòîÛaîÛ´í‰ìèà¦a´z‘Š½aŠr×cBpbib‚nãa¿2000òîböŠÛaN 25
pbj×åí†n½aïzî½a ‰bînÛa õbàÇ‹áçcœÈi †Ôã¿´×bß ……í ë
‰ æìmŠiëPat Robertson ÝíìÛbÏ ðuëJerry Falwelláçbíg bЕaë
L|ßbnÛaâ†Ç늒Ûbi26ð‰ìèà¦alŒzÜÛòà×b§ak‚äÛa´×b߆Ônãabà×
†ÇaìÓ Éß ŠØjß ÊaŠ•¿´×bß Ý…ÙÛˆië LòÜiŠËµg xbn¤ bèãcôc‰ë
áçc œÈi Éß òŠ‘ òèuaìß ¿ éÈ™ë ÝØ’i éj®ë ð‰ìèà¦a lŒ§a
a|öaŠ‘kÈ•Õ튿í´×bßæcœÈjÛaôc‰ aˆÛ [ð‰ìèà¦alŒ§
Ma…ë†ßåØíægMéÛìy´í‰ìèà¦a†îyìm¿òÌÛbiòiìÈ•†vîéãcë
¿ ´í‰ìèà¦a |î‘i ê‹ìÏ òÛby ¿ ëc òîböŠÛa pbib‚nãüa Þý
Þbä½a†îÈia†iŠßcìçëLòí†îèànÛapbib‚nãüaN27
’nÛaµg´×bßÞbß bà×ém a‹ß òîu‰b¨a òîbîÛaôìnßóÜÇ …†
‰bÇ ïÜa†Ûa ôìn½a óÜÇë LâbänîÏ lŠy Þý òî–‚’Ûaë òîbîÛa
kÛbëLõbíŠqþaµgÝî·bèãcôc‰ÛaköaŠšÛaœÐ¨”ìiÉí‰b’ß´×bß
áÇ…¿ëï×ßþaïßìÔÛaåí†ÛaœÐ¿òî×ßþaòîãaŒî½aœöbÏâa†‚nbi
æbàšÛaâbÄãj׆yµgòîÛaîÛ‰bØÏcïçëLï×ßþaïÇbànuüaN28
@ @
28
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
åí†n½aïzî½a´àîÛapa…bîÓëlŒ§ak®óÜÇ´×bßâìvçáˉë
’ßbçìîãòíüìi‹ìÐÛaåß´×bßåØ·M†ÔÈmÛapbíüìÛaÝöaëcåßïçë
òí†îèànÛaòîiŒ§apbib‚nãüa bèîÏMb¾”ìiìîÜi…x‰ìuòÜ»óÜÇb߆Ônß
æc†ÈiéîÛgòîbîÛaõaì™þalˆuåßéäØßëLaj×b¼‹´×bßòÜ»óİÇc
òîbîÛaôìÔÛaëpbib‚nãüaåí‹aìßkÜÓN
Ýa… òîãbàÜÈÛa ôìÔÛa laˆnua énÜ» Þý Êbİna ´×bß æc ë†jíë
òîäìÛapbÇŒäÛaµgÝî·òÄÏbªòîäî¹pbîuìÛ†ícóäjnmÛað‰ìèà¦alŒ§a
aòîßìÔÛaòîãbàÜÈÛMÞìyoÐnÛaÛaòîäí†Ûa´àîÛaôìÓpbîuìÜí†ícÝibÔß¿
óÜÇémkji´×bßaë†ícåíˆÛa…†¦aæìÄÏbaôìÔÛaÙÜmåßëL”ìi
ÑÓaì½a µg éÜîßë énîãbàÜÇ kjië Léní‰ìÔ•ë òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa òyb
Ïbapa…bîÓœÈiôc‰sîyLòîÜa†ÛaòybÛaóÜÇòîÛaîÜÛaÝrß…†¦a´Ä
ÞìníŠ× âbîÜíëWilliam Kristol ïÛë àîuëJames Woolseyæc
Lòîu‰b¨aòbîÛa bíbšÔiòía‰†Ûasîyåß”ìióÜÇÖìÐní´×bß29ôc‰ë
×ëŠi †îÐía…David Brooks ´×bß æcBlŒ§aë ´ÄÏbzàÜÛ â†Ôí
n½alaˆnuüòîÜibÓŠr×céÜÈuëáèiŒysí†znÛbÔíŠð‰ìèà¦a´ÜÔBæcëL
´×bßóÜÇ´ÄÏbaâìvçåßîöŠÛa†îÐn½aMâ†Çëém†äuþáèàèÏâ†Çë
éÛìyáèÏbÐnÛaM‰ìuÞeáèz‘ŠßëæìîaŠÔ¹†ÛaáçN30
†í‰ëæìmŠië‰ëÒ뉆íóÜÇñŠ½aò¹Œa
bäí‰ìÛb×tëbòíüë‰ë… õbu’ßbçìîã†ÈiSouth CarolinaÛa L
‰bjna æìjÓaŠ½a bèîÏ ôc‰bèîÏ ´×bß ‹ìÏ æc ò•b”ìië´×b½ bîÔîÔy a
@ @@ @
29
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
òà‚n½a ”ìi òÜৠòà•bÓ òiŠ™ Ýr¹ë Lòîib‚nãüa éÃìÄy ‹ŒÈí Òì
‰bjØÛa´í‰ìèà¦aåí†ãb½aëÞaìßþaëpbÇnÛbiN
pbÈ࣠åšn¤ bèãhÏ òÄÏba bäí‰ìÛb× tëb òíüë òÈîjİÛ aŠÄãë
Ûa ëc ´îÛì•þa ´îzîàÜÛ òà‚™ òíçbºáçë L´í’jnÛa oãbnmë
Âbëc ¿ í†Ûa ôìn½a óÜÇ òÄÏbªë bb’ã Šr×þa òíçbà¦a ôìÔÛa
”ìi bèîÜÇ ÞìÇ Ûa ïçë L´í‰ìèà¦aM Òë‰ Þ‰b× éÐÜ åßëM¿
òîib‚nãüaénÜ»áÇ…ëïbîÛa”ìiᬅìÈ•N
ÈiÑÛb¤´í’jnÛaoãbnmëÛapa…bîÓóÜÇ´×bß âìv aŠÄãëœ
áèm…bÓáçcM†í‰ÑÛa‰ëæìmŠië‰pbiÝrßRalph Reed MÞ‰b×Éß
âbèma sîy L´×b½|íŠvnÛaë †ÔäÛaë òaŠ’Ûa ñ†í†‘ òܻ呿Òë‰
bà× LlŠ§a Þý éÜv¿ÙîØ’nÛa ë âbänîÏ¿ b×ßc òãb×bß
c éãdi éßbèmbi bî–‚‘áuìçëòÄÏbaë òîäí†Ûa éÐÓaìß éíì’mïÇŠ‘Ël
“í…ýväiåßñbnÐÛénuë‹ë´×bßjmòîÐÜóÜÇÙÛ‡ëLõa…ìñbnÐÛN31
†Èíë åß æìmŠië‰ÙÜn¹ sîy ´í’jnÛa oãbnmëÛa ñ…bÓ ‹Šic
ÑÛbznÛa òàÄäß bèc‰ óÜÇ ïmdí òîzî½a òîäîàîÛapbû½a åß òí‰ìaßg
ïzî½aChristian Coalitionò׉b’ß Éîv’ni òîäȽa¿ ´äí†n½a ´îzî½a
âbÇ¿ïzî½aÑÛbznÛaæìmŠië‰c†ÓëLòîØíŠßþaòîbîÛañbî§a1988
lŒ§a|î‘ŠmóÜÇÞì–§a¿Ý’Ïæc†Èið‰ìèà¦apbib‚nãa¿éÛ1988
òîböŠÛaïzî½aÑÛbznÛa‰†ÔíëLéöbšÇc…†ÇïÛaì¡bîÛby1.2ìšÇæìîÜßL
òÛb×ë æìmŠië‰c bà× òîzî½asjÛaCBNòí‰ìaßg µgoÛì¤Ûa
¿bè©aŠi†çb’mòà‚™òîßýÇg180ibè©aŠiÊaˆmëòÛë…71òÌÛN
@ @
30
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
†™ òªbn½a Ë émb°Š–m æìmŠië‰ åÇ ÒŠÇë kãbuþaëË
´îzî½a†™ëÝiòîØíŠßcpb׊yëòîzîßÑöaìéäÇòÐÜn«ŠíbäíïÐÏL
1991mëŠiÑöaìáubçîmbnòîäèãdiáèЕëëôŠcáB…bÈßë|îàÜÛæBL
ëâbÇ¿2002éãdiâý⁄aòîàmæìmŠi뉜ωBâýåí…BÞbÓëgæ
ìçâý⁄aÒ†çBáqñŠİîÛaëLáØznÛaNNN߆nÛaBN32
ÝàdžÔφí‰ÑÛa‰ bßcónyïzî½aÑÛbznÜÛ Ší†à×1997áçbë
ÕÔyëòîbîÛa émìÓëÑÛbznÛa†©õbäi¿†í‰òÈaë òî–‚‘ñŠè‘ éÈß
ÜàÇñÏÞý‚ÏLñ†zn½apbíüìÛaôìnßóÜÇééuëòibr¶æb×ÑÛbznÛbi
âýÇ⁄a¿ÑÛbznÛaæbÛë[pŠ’ãaˆÛáíbmòÜ©TimeòîØíŠßþaM¿15
ìíbß1995MÞìÔíÕîÜÈm bèn¤ë bèÏýËóÜÇ†í‰ ñ‰ì•BóäàîÛa †îÛaZ
ïzî½aÑÛbznÛaë†í‰ÑÛa‰BN33
iëÁ‘bã µg Þì¤ ïzî½a ÑÛbznÛa ¿ ÝàÈÛa åß †í‰ òÛbÔna †È
Úbäç ŠÔna sîy bîu‰ìu òíüë ¿ ò•bë Llìä¦a ¿ Šqûß ð‰ìèº
âbÇ ¿ bîu‰ìu ¿ ð‰ìèà¦a lŒzÜÛ bîö‰ |j•cë2002ò׊Èß †Èi
òîbîòaŠ‘å߆í‰åÇÒŠÇb½aŠÄã¿Š’Ûak–ä½aóÜÇòŠ‘òîib‚nãa
ëóÜÇŒî׊mÛaõbİËâa†‚naëòîjÜÛapýà§aåí†énİ’ãcÑÜn«¿aˆÛ[
âbÇ ¿ †í‰ Ý’Ï2005ì¨ éÛ ´í‰ìèà¦a |î‘Šm óÜÇ Þì–§a ¿
bîu‰ìuòíüëá×byk–äßN
tëb ¿´×bß ò¹Œç åßÒë‰ë †í‰ë æìmŠië‰ÑÛb¤ åØ· †Óë
ËbènaŠ’iÚbäç´×b߆™”ìiò׊ÈßÒŠÈmombiëLbäîÛë‰b×òÓìj½a
oãb×ë LbèîÏ ÜÛa ´í’jnÛa oãbnmëÛa ñ…bÓ ‰ë†ië òîjÜÛa bènÈîjİië
@ @@ @
31
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ïçëLbèäßÑ’íÛaéÛòà•bÔÛaòiŠšÛaòibr¶òíüìÛaÙÜm¿´×bßò¹Œç
âbÈÛ òî×ßþa òböŠÛa Öbj åß éuëŠ µg bÇbjm p…bÓ Ûa2000óÜÇ
¿éÔÔyðˆÛajØÛabväÛaåßáËŠÛaòí†îèànÛaòí‰ìèà¦apbib‚nãüaòía†i
òİ’ãòÜ»ëò÷íŠu‰bØÏcëòÜîÜÓ…‰aì¶N34
õbØjÜÛëc”ìiåßâbÔnãýÛóÈíåÛéãcénÜ»òíbèã¿´×b߆×c†Óë
æc a†îuÒŠÈí éãþÙÛ‡ë LéÛŠÈm b¾ôìØ’ÜÛëclìؽa²ÜÛaóÜÇ
Ûa æëŠrØí å¾ æìܹë ôìØ’Ûa æìj° ü ´î×ßþaå¾ë ÝíìÈÛaë õbØj
ky‰‰†–iòîbîÛañ‰b¨aæìÔÜníüëòîjÜñäiæìq†zníN
”ìi†™´×bßlŠy
åßlŠ¡œÈjÛa éЕë bß å‘åß éÈä· òÔibÛa´×bßpb°Š–m
†yaë—‚‘M´×bßìçëMpa…bîÓë”ìiîöŠÛaëòî×ßþañ‰a…⁄a†™
âbÇ ˆäß Š¬ìØÛbi ´í‰ìèà¦a2000y ïçë LâbÈÛa ðcŠÛa oÜÌ‘ lŠ
µëþa”ìiòíüëpaìäÞýï×ßþaI2001M2004Hµg´×bßoÛìyë
æìîaŠÔ¹†Ûa Õφm sîy b×ßdi ´îaŠÔ¹†Ûaë ´ÜÔn½a æìîÇ ¿ á¬
bà×Lémbbîëém‰a…gë”ìjۆ톒Ûaê†ÔãkjiéîÜÇõbärÛaëéÈßÑÛbznÜÛ
ì–áçc†ycµg´×bßlŠ§aêˆçoÛìy´×bß|äߜωðˆÛa”ìiâ
pa…bîÓ âì– ×c †yc µg énÛìy bà× LéÛ òm òí‰a‹ë k•bäß ðc
ôìn½a óÜÇ òÄÏba´í‰ìèà¦apa…bîÓ늬ìØÛbi òÄÏba´í‰ìèà¦a
éÛìyoÐnÛaÛa”ìjÛ ñ†ãb½aòí‰ìèà¦apa…bîÔÛa´iò•bLðçbà¦a
½a ´àîÜÛ ñ†ãb½a éÐÓaìß kjiòí†îÜÔnÛa ´ÄÏba ñ†äuþë åí†n½a ïzî
ànjåߊ’Çð…b§ata†yc†Èië2001N35
@ @
32
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
òböŠÛa ”ìi ïÛìm †Èi aŠØjß ´×bß lŠy pc†iMâbÇ Ýöaëc ¿
2001Mpa…bîÓ ×c Éß ´×bß bý æëbÈm ñ†í†Çpbèj¦a µgp†nßaë
à¦aéöýß‹†™ï×ßþa„ìî’ÛaÜv¶ïaŠÔ¹†ÛalŒ§asîyL´í‰ìè
ŠíŠ·ëə뿆ÛìväíbÏÝa‰ÒëŠÈ½aïÛaîÜÛa‰ìmbäîÛaÉß´×bßæëbÈm
âbÇ¿‰ŠßòîbîÛapbÇnÛaå߆zÜÛæìãbÓ2001´×b߉bßæc†Èi
æìãbÓæìí‰ìèà¦anÇa aˆÛ [Š¬ìØÛbi´í‰ìèà¦aóÜÇ òà‚™ bìÌ™
´×bßM †ÛìväíbÏMcCain-FeingoldnÛbi ˜b¨aòîbîÛa pbÇ
Campaign Finance ReformòÜ–Û bÏbÈ™gë jÈnÛa pbíŠy åß a†y
òíŠrÛak‚äÛbi´í‰ìèà¦aN36
ïaŠÔ¹†Ûa‰ìmbäîÛaÉß´×bßæëbÈmbà×M´§aÙÛ‡¿MÑí‹ìu
æbßîÛJoseph Lieberman–âbÇ¿ýÔnß|j•cðˆÛaìçë2006M¿
†îîÔmëò÷îjÛbiÕÜÈnmbíbšÓ…‰aë…gÉßæëbÈmëLò•b¨aòzÜþaóÜÇÞì–§a
ð†äî×Edward Kennedy‹…‰aë…gæìuëJohn EdwardsòíbÇŠÛabíbšÓ¿
pb׊‘ÖìÔyÝibÔß¿òîz–Ûapb߆¨aïØÜènßÖìÔyòíìÔmëòîz–Ûa
köaŠšÛaœÐ¢ ò•b¨a”ìiÉí‰b’ß´×b߉bÇ bà× Lïz–Ûa´ßdnÛa
bîäËþa †îÐm bèãc ðc‰sîytb¡c ¿ bß†Ó ïš½a †ãbë Lïbc ÝØ’i õ
æìäí†n½aæìÄÏbab虉bÇÛaòîLj¦abíý¨aN37
óny´×bßÑÓaìßåßñ‰aŠ½biæëŠÈ’í´í‰ìèà¦añ…bÔÛaœÈiÞa‹bßë
‰bînÛa µg ïànäí ü ïbî× ´×bß òÔîÔy åÇ Èm bèãc æëŠíë LæŁa
å‘Þbr½aÝîjóÜÈÏ LÅÏbað‰ìèà¦aÙí‰ÕibÛað‰ìèà¦a‰ìmbäîÛa
â‰ìnãbRick SantorumóÜÇë í†Ûa ôìn½a óÜÇ ê…†’ni ÒëŠÈ½a
@ @@ @
33
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
‹ìÐÛbi éîÇbß Þý ´×bß óÜÇ bLJü bßìvç òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa ôìnß
òî×ßþaòböŠÜÛ´í‰ìèà¦a|튒niI2008H´×bßæcâ‰ìnãbôc‰sîyL
—‚‘B´í‰ìèà¦a óÜÇ a†u a†u İBåØànÛ ´×bß üìÛ éãcë L
òîbc òjÔÇ æb×´×bß æcë LköaŠšÜÛ×cœÐ ŠíŠ·åß æìí‰ìèà¦a
ÑÓìní ê‰ë… æcë LòÐÜn«pbÈ튒m ŠíŠànÛ áèîÇbß¿´í‰ìèà¦a âbßc
ñ†í†Çë ñ†í†u òîÛaîÛ ´ãaìÓ aÓa ¿ ´îaŠÔ¹†Ûa Éß æëbÈnÛa óÜÇ
¿ bîbc ýßbÇ æb× b¸gë LkzÏÝîİÈm ¿ë L´í‰ìèà¦a Ñ• Õ‘
éma…bîÓëð‰ìèà¦alŒ§abèið…bäíÛaòÄÏbaòîäîàîÛa´ãaìÔÛaN38
òbîÛa òyb ÙÛ‡ ¿ b¶ pbè¦a Éîº bjíŠÔm ´×bß lŠy oÜ
óÜÇlŠ§aëòîu‰b¨aòbîÛañ‰a…gõìi”ìi´×bßáèmasîyòîu‰b¨a
†Èi bß ñÐÛ Áîİ‚nÛa â†Çëlbç‰⁄a¿ áçb b¾ ïÓaŠÈÛa âbÄäÛa ÂìÔ
LÚbäç Êb™ëþa ‰ìç†m39´í‰ìèà¦a ñ…bÓ bèÜàzní pbßbèma bšíc ïçë
åß bjíŠÓ Ýà ´×bß æb× ægë Lðçbà¦a ôìn½a óÜÇ Š¬ìØÛbi
×c åß Þa‹bßë æb× sîy òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa òyb óÜÇ ´í‰ìèà¦a
ÖaŠÈÛalŠ§´àÇa†ÛaN
brÛbq@Z†í†u@´×bß@”ìjÛ@Š•bäßë@Þ†nÈß@I2004MH@@@ @âbLjäßÝßb×éj‘biýÔãa´×bßÉß´í‰ìèà¦aòÓýÇp†è‘2004´y
âbÈÛòîböŠÛapbib‚nãüa¿´í‰ìèà¦aë”ìiïàÇa…×c†ycµg´×bßÞì¤
2004éjØm‰aïvîmagdİëïaŠÔ¹†ÛaŠØȽaµg…ìÈílýÔãüaÝ•cëL
ïaŠÔ¹†Ûa|‘Š½aòböŠÜÛ–Úa‡æeMð×æìuJohn Kerryâ†ÓcðˆÛaL
éîÜÇojÜÔãabèäØÛëLòiìªéãcåÄíæb×ñj×ñŠßbÌßóÜÇN40
@ @
34
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
sîyLòîböŠÛapbib‚nãüa¿éÛköbä×´×b¶òãbÈnüað×…a‰c†ÔÏ
óÜÇñj×ñÙÜn¹ëLñ†í†ÇòîÛaîÛÑÓaìßkyb•´×bßæcð×ôc‰
òbîÛaòybîöŠÛaköbãk–ä½|‘Šà×énÜ»µgéßbàšãaæcëLòîu‰b¨a
´×bß ÑÓaì½ aŠÄã ´î×ßþa ´jbäÛa Áë bÈaë a†îídm éjØí Òì
òbîÛa òybóÜÇ òÈaìÛa émë òîÜa†Ûa òbîÛa òybóÜÇ òÜÔn½a
†×cÛaï×ßþaâbÈÛaðcŠÛapbÇýİnaœÈiém†×cŠßcìçëLòîu‰b¨ap
ð×ÑÛb¤â†ÔmM”ìiÑÛb¤óÜÇ´×bßMÍÜjíj×Ö‰bÐiî’m14òİÔã
òíì÷ßN
µgâbàšãýÛéÜçûm´í‰ìèà¦aë”ìjÛ´×bßñëa†Çæcð×åÃbà×
æìØíÒìéãþ [bèi ŠšíåÛ òÜà§aµgâbàšãüa´×bߜωæcëénÜ»
qaëð×a†iëL´í‰ìèà¦aóÜÇð×bnÐãaóÜÇòßýÇåÛ´×bßæcåßbÔ
ÜÝØ’i陊ÇÝÌníN
ŠÇ´×bߜωsîy Lêbäàní ëc ð× éÈÓìní bßt†y åØÛë
éãþë[êŠçìu¿ÅÏbªð‰ìèºéãþ[ŠÈÛaœÏ‰éãc´×bßÞìÔíëLð×
òznÐä½a éÐÓaìßåßáËŠÛaóÜÇ âbíþaåß âìí¿ bîÛaîÛæìØíåÛëåØí
a†Ûa òbîÛa òybóÜÇéi aìÜjÔíåÛ´îaŠÔ¹†Ûaæc´×bßôc‰ bà× LòîÜ
åÇð× óÐna ìÜÏ LêëŠØ½ ð׊Èm òÛby ¿ ëc ÝjÔn½a ¿ bîö‰
îöŠ×´×b¶æìîaŠÔ¹†ÛaÝjÔíåÜÏlbjþaåßkjÛ òîbîÛa òybÛa
Lòîu‰b¨a òbîÛbi òÔÜÈn½a éma‰aŠÓ¿ ……ßð×æc´×bßôc‰ bà× Lá
æcëð×åÇéÜ–Ðm òíŠçìu bÓëŠÏÚbäçæcë L”ìiåß bߌyÝÓcð×
‰bÈí æb× ðØÏ LÖaŠÈÛalŠyë òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa òyb óÜÇ ò•b
@ @@ @
35
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
Š’ã òbî †ãbíë Úbäç òî×ßþa paìÔÛa õbÔi †íÏ ´×bß bßc lŠ§a
Lñ†zn½a pbíüìÜÛ òí…bȽa áÄäÛa ÂbÔ⁄ ï×ßþa ݆nÛaë òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa
íëéàÜy ÕÔ° åÛ îöŠÜÛ köbä× éz‘Šm æc bšíc ôc‰ ´×bß æc ë†j
òböŠÛa ïŠ×µg Þì•ìÛa ìçë LïbþaM¿ â†Ônß´×bß æcë ò•b
ꉆèíoÓìÛaåßÉnßéßbßcîÛëŠàÈÛaN41
”ìi ñ‰a…g énÐÔÜmë éioàÜÇŠßcìçë Lð׊Ǵ×bߜω aˆÛ
b–müa¿Òë‰Þ‰b׉…bisîyLêë‰b’nßëå߆×dnÜÛ´×bßð†Çb¶Þ
òîböŠÛaþa òÜ»¿”ìjÛ ñ†Çb½a´×bß â†Ôí æckÜİÛ b¶‰ë LŠßþa
bîbîéÜÌnaë”ìiŠÇ´×bßÝjÓÉÓìn½aËóÜÇëLð×æìu†™
òÜà§a Þý éàÇ…ë ”ìi òÜ» ¿ bßbç aŠ–äÇ |j•cë ÞýÌnüa †‘c
¿ ò•b”ìjÛ ê†îídm a†×ûß òîib‚nãüaìçë Llbç‰⁄aóÜÇlŠ§a òyb
bèÈÓìníåØí´×bßÝjÓåߊèÄÛa¿òäÈëòãbîòibr¶ð×ênÇa Šßc
éäßN42
†í†¦a´×bß
émß ¿ j× ïvîmaa Þì¤ Ò‰b’ß óÜÇ æb× ´×bß æc ë†jíë
¿ òîböŠÛa pbib‚nãüa ì¨ a…a†Èna òîbîÛa éÐÓaìßë2008 â Næg
Ûa âìÔíÞìznkyb•”ìiåßlŠÔnÛa bëc Lòßbçpbîvîmaa ñ†ÇóÜÇ
´àîÛa ôìÓ ò•b òÄÏba òíçbà¦a †ÇaìÔÛa Âbëc ¿ òÈaìÛa òîjÈ’Ûa
òÜ»¿”ìi áÇ… ÞýåßÙÛ‡ë Lòäí†n½a ïzî½a2004¿ë LòîböŠÛa
òÈàÛaò÷îÖaŠÈÛalŠyåÇÊbφÜÛê…ìèuN43
@ @
36
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
bîãbq Zba éÜv óÜÇ †î×dnÛa´äÔnÛ én™‰bȶ ÕÜÈní bàîÏ ò•b ÅÏ
L‡aì’Ûa ÖìÔ§ëbèu⁄a44éîÛg dvÜí ÝuŠ× éÐã ´×bß áí†Ôm òÛëbªë
¿ ém†Çb½ ”ìi éîÛg d¦ bà× ñ†’Ûa oÓë ¿ æìí‰ìèà¦aë æìÄÏba
âbÇpbib‚nãa2004éí†ÇbßœÈi´îÈm¿ëLÖaŠÈÛalŠyåÇÊbφÛa¿ë
†ycæìnÛìiæìv×Þ†¦aðrßb×ßcÐë…†¦a´ÄÏba‰ìÔ•Šè‘c
ò™‰bÈßk–ä½aaˆéÛ”ìi|î‘ŠmóÓüðˆÛaìçëLñ†zn½aáßÿÛÕibÛa
´™‰bȽa òèuaì½ë éäÇ ÊbφÜÛ ´×bß ôãaë „ìî’Ûa Ü© åß òÈaë
†×cðˆÛaæìnÛìi|î‘ŠmóÜÇÕ톖nÛa ì−„ìî’ÛaÜ©ÉφÛë ézî‘Û
êŠí†ÔmóÜdžÈibàîÏéàÇ…ëém†ãbß¿‹‰bjÛa´×bßÑÓì½N45
brÛbq Z´àîÛaôìÓµg Ýî½a òÛëbªëéibİ¿áØznÛaµg´×bßóÈ
´í’jnÛa oãbnmëÛa ôìÓ bèc‰ óÜÇë òÄÏba ï×ßþakä£ sîy
ò•báèÈßém†äuc†îyìnÛáèm…bÓœÈiÉßõbÔÜÛóÈëÝiLáç†Ôã´×bß
b¨aòbîÛaòybóÜÇ´×bßóäjnísîyÁëþaÖŠ’Ûaêb£a†í†¤ëòîu‰
kvÈm ÑÓaìß ïçë LæaŠígë ÖaŠÈÛa †™ òí‰ìÔ–Ûa ÑÓaì½a åß òÇìà©
lbjþ ÝîöaŠ⁄ òÏŠİn½a áèm†ãb¶ ´ÏëŠÈ½a ´í’jnÛa oãbnmëÛa
òîäí…N46
´í’jnÛaoãbnmëÛañ…bÓœÈjÛ´×bßòã…bèßæcónyMæìuÝrß
ïubçJohn HageeMôŠþa æbí…þa µg ò÷î½a áèmb°Š–ni ´ÏëŠÈ½a
åß´×bßlŠÔmæc aëc‰åíˆÛaåírØÛaÕÜÓp‰bqcâý⁄aëòîØîÛìqbØÛb×
éÛ æìäØí åíˆÛa´ÜÔn½a´jbäÛa áÇ… ê†ÔÐíÒìïubç Ýrߘb‚‘c
pbi´×bßæcœÈjÛaôc‰ëLòÜÔn½aéÐÓaìßkjiâayüaåßaj×a‰†Ó
@ @@ @
37
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
†ÇaìÓëòäí†n½aïzî½a´àîÛaôìÓõb™‰⁄éîÈæc¿åàØmòÜšÈßâbßc
´ÜÔn½biénÓýÇlbyóÜÇïmdma…†’mëòÄÏbªŠr×það‰ìèà¦alŒ§a
|îz•ØÈÛaëN47
ìíbß¿ïubçæìu´×bßæa…c†Óë2008µ…cò÷îßpb°Š–mkji
½bÈÛalŠ§a Þý áèmbãbÈßë …ìèîÛa Õy¿ bèiLŠÜnçð†íc óÜÇ òîãbrÛa òî
æìàdžíåíŠe´îäî¹ ñ…bÓ …†’nÛ aŠÄã òÔibÛa òܚȽaÝ°ÙÛ‡åØÛë
´×bßN48
¿åí†Ûa‰ë…åÇs톧aµgýîߊr×cïãbàÜÈÛa´×bßa†iâbÇÝØ’ië
paìäÞýémbãbÈßÑîÐ¥¿åí†Ûa ‰ë…åÇs톧a¿Šèà bà× émbîy
änîÏ¿Šþa¿éÇìÓëâbN49
òÔÜÈn½a ÙÜm ò•b ”ìi pa‰…bjß œÈjÛ a†îídm Šr×c ´×bß a†i bà×
êb£ ñ…†’nß ÑÓaìß óäjm bà× Lï™b½a ¿ b虉bÇ Ûa köaŠšÛa œÐ¢
†Ópb°Š–mðdiõü…⁄aâ†ÇóÜÇb•ŠyŠr×cpbiëLòîÇŠ’ÛaËñŠva
òîäîàîÛa bèm†äuþë ð‰ìèà¦a lŒzÜÛ òíçbà¦a †ÇaìÔÛa µg õïm
òÄÏbaN50
âbÈÛòîib‚nãüaénÜ»ñ‰a…g¿”ìið†Çbßåß…†Èi´×bßæbÈnabà×
2008bcóÜÇ énÜ»óäiëïàîÄänÛaëð‰a…⁄a bèiìÜcóäjm éãg ÞbÔíë L
Lbèäß51Òë‰ Þ‰b× æc µg bãbîyc æë’í ´×bß ð†ÇbßœÈi æg óny
í ï™b½a ¿ ´×bß âì– ×c †ycë ÕibÛa ”ìi †Çbßòzî–äÛa â†Ô
ŠŁaë´§a´iòîböŠÛa´×bßòÜà§ñ‰ì’½aëN52
@ @
38
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
áîÜÛaÕíŠİÛaµgñ…ìÇëpaŠrÇ
åØí´jbäÛbi énÓýÇ´znÛ ê†yë bîÏb×´×bßÑÓaìß¿ÞìznÛa
âbÇpbib‚nãüa…a†Èna´í‰ìèà¦a2008éníüìi”ìi‹ìψäàÏLòîböŠÛa
¿ òîãbrÛa2004MˆÛa âbÈÛa ìçëòÓýÇ ¿ ïib¯⁄a ÞìznÛa òía†i †è‘ ð
´í‰ìèà¦bi´×bßMŠmìmñÏåߊr×còÓýÈÛaêˆçp†è‘N
pbib‚nãa åß ñÐÛa Þý‚Ï2004òbö‰ ñÐi”ìi ‹ìÏp†è‘Ûa
âbÇ pbib‚nãaë LŠ¬ìØÛa ïÜ© †ÇbÔß òîjÜËdi ´í‰ìèà¦a ‹ìÏë òîãbq
2006¬ìØÜÛ ´í‰ìèà¦a ñ‰b p†è‘ Ûa|öbšÏ kji éîÜv¶ Š
òîbîÛa òî×ßþa ñ‰a…⁄aM ÖaŠÈÛa lŠy õbİc bèc‰ óÜÇëMpŠß
òîvîma⁄Šàn½aê†ÔãkjiòÜíìð…ŠmñÐi´í‰ìèà¦bi´×bßòÓýÇ
L†ÜîÐßa‰†Ûbãë…ï×ßþaÊbφÛaŠí‹ëÑÓaì½ëÖaŠÈÛalŠyÞý”ìi
džÜîÐßa‰ë”ìióÜÇ´×bßlbÇsîyñÐÛbàèİîİ¥ëcbàç…a†Ènaâ†
ÝØ’iÚbäçòî×ßþapaìÔÛañ…bí‹bàèšÏ‰ëïÓaŠÈÛaâbÄäÛaÂìÔ†Èibß
”ìi†ÔäÛaaˆçŠíÉjİÛbiëLÖaŠÈÛbiòî×ßþapaìÔÛaòàè¶ar׊™c
òíçbà¦aáç†ÇaìÓëc´í‰ìèà¦apa…bîÓüëN53
âbÇpbib‚nãa†Èië2006´×bßñ‰ì•pŠßð†zniòîbîÛaémßë
òbîÛ´×bßjm bëcLkjåߊr×þòîib‚nãüaénÜ»ŠrÈm¿Ýr·Še
ábi bjíŠÔm oİjm‰a òîvîmag ïçë LÖaŠÈÛa ¿ òî×ßþa paìÔÛa ñ…bí‹
L”ìi †Èi ´îbîÛa bèí†ãbß ‰bj× åß nÇa ðˆÛa ´×bß54pc†i †Óë
ÕîjİnÛaŒîy݆mòîvîma⁄aâbÇÝöaëc¿2007ügòîib¯gwöbnäipdmë
ÂìÌšÛaåßrØÛ´×bߊÈmŠè‘þaÙÜmÞýëLŠè‘cñ†Ç‰ëŠß†Èi
@ @@ @
39
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
óÜÇ ê‰aŠ•g ´×bß óÜÇ âbÈÛa ðcŠÛa lbÇ sîy Lòíçbà¦aë òîßýÇ⁄a
ÖaŠÈÛa¿ÒëŠÄÛaægÞìÔÛaMar×bç‰a‹ÛaMlˆØÛbiáèmaónyåznm
ðcŠÛa ÝîÜšniëLï×ßþa âbÈÛa55œÈi lbvÇg åß áËŠÛa óÜÇ ÙÛ‡ë
bà×”ìjÛém†ãbß¿a†îyëÑÔí|j•cðˆÛa´×bßÑÓì¶òîäîàîÛaŠöaë†Ûa
´×bßóÜÇòÔÐ’ÛalbiåßlŠzÜÛñ†ãb½aâýÇ⁄aÝöbëœÈipŠ×‡N56
ñŠva ´ãaìÓ Ýí†ÈnÛ ”ìi …ìèu ´×bß †ãb bèma‡ ñÐÛa Þýë
èníÝØ’iòî×ßþaÑÓìßìçëL´îÇŠ’ÛaËåíŠubè½aÉßb߆yµgæ…b
Lðçbà¦a ôìn½a óÜÇ ò•b æìí‰ìèà¦a éšÏ‰ë”ìië´×bß ê†ãb
áç†ÇaìÓë ´í‰ìèà¦a Á‚ë †Ôã µg ŠÈm †Ó ´×bß æìØí aˆèië
œÈi ¿ ”ìi x‰ì¦ ém†ãbß òÛby ¿ óny òÄÏbª Šr×þa òíçbà¦a
æbîyþaN
òÜ»o™ŠÈm bà× òîböŠÛa´×bßM bèma‡ ñÐÛaÞýHònÛa ‰ìè’Ûa
âbÇ åß µëþa2006 H–¿ bjíŠÔm bèýÏg µgp…bÓ ñ†í†ÇpbiìÈ•µg
ìîãìí2006æìuáèc‰óÜÇë éí†Çbßáçcåß…†Ç òÛbÔnaµgô…c b¾
lŠÓc †ycë ïbîÛa éi‰… Õîωë òÜíì ñÐÛ ´×bß pý» Ší†ß ŠÐíaë
îÛaéí†Çbß´îbN57
´×bßòÜ»jmµg…ìÈípbí†znÛaÙÜmkjëMŠÐíaë ñ…bîÓo¤–
âbÇ¿òîböŠÛa”ìiìîÜi…x‰ìuòÜ»x‡ì¸câbÇ¿2004òãbÈna†yµg
æìÜîãðmáèc‰óÜÇïmdíë”ìiòÜ»ï†äèßáçcœÈjiŠÐíaëTerry
Nelson´×bß òÜ»õbäiµgæìÜîãëŠÐíaëóȆÓë Léib’ßbcóÜÇ
bènȺ Ûa òÜöba pbÇnÛa ávyë jØÛa bèöaŠri pŒî· Ûa ”ìi òÜà§
@ @
40
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
õa¨aåßaj×a…†ÇòÜà§apŠudna aˆÛ[ñ†zn½apbíüìÛaÇbç‰b’nãaë
õb‚ioÔÐãcëòÐÜn«pbíüë¿ÑîÛbØnÛaòÄçbikmbØßpd’ãcë´ÜÜaë
« òîib‚nãa òİ’ãcëpbîÛbÈÏóÜÇË ñŠvaëÖaŠÈÛaÜØ’ßkjië LòÐÜn
aìãb× Ûa òîÏbØÛa pbÇnÛa ɺ åÇ énÜ» pŒvÇë ´×bß ŒvÇ òîÇŠ’Ûa
òiŠÔßóÜÇáèÐãc òîböŠÛa´×bß òÜ»óÜÇæìàöbÔÛa †uë aˆÛ [bèãìÈÓìní
ìîãìí ¿ ýÏ⁄a åß2006‰bj× åß …†Çë ŠÐíaë òÛbÔna µg ô…c b¾
íì¤ëL´×bßð†ÇbߊÐíaëÏbäßµgòÜà§añ…bîÓÝ–òÜà§aÝa…Mìçë
ŒîÐía…Ùí‰Rick Davisˆäß´×bßð†ÇbßlŠÓc †yc bšíc †ÈíðˆÛa L
òÜíìñÏN58
´×bß òÜ» éäß oãbÇ ðˆÛa ÊaŠ–Ûa åÇ âýÇ⁄a Ýöbë oq†¤ aˆÛ
M âbÇ åß µëþa ònÛa ‰ìè’Ûa ô†ß óÜÇ2007MŠÐíaë ðŠØÈß ´i
Ðía…ëŒî…†ÇlbİÔnaÞýåß´×b½lŠÔnÛaµg bàèäßý×óÈsîyL
åß´×bßòܻ֌¹…b×b¾ïbîÛaÝàÈÛa¿éiìÜcŠÏëéí†Çbßåß
Ýa†ÛaN59
ÞbÔíëZ”ìiòÜ»òîvîmag†îÜÔmoÛëbyÛaŠÐíaëòîvîmagÝ’Ïæg
¿2004äÛa¿a…bÓÊbjİÛañ…b§aŠÐíaëòî–‚‘òÈîjëìÜǵgëénÛbÔnaµgòíbè
énÓýÈië òÛ†nȽa òî–‚’Ûa éÇbjİi ŒîÐía… Œî·sîy L´×bßô†Û ŒîÐía… áèc
ÝÈu b¾ Lénuë‹ë ´×b¶ òíìÔÛa énÓýÈië åİä‘aëk‚äi òîib¯⁄a òî–‚’Ûa
åÇïÜ‚nÛaë ém‰ì•îÌnÛ éÐã´×bß ïÈ Éß ò•b òÜyŠ½a ‰bî ŒîÐía…
ŠöbrÛað‰ìèà¦a ñ‰ì•ïÇbÛaëxaŒ½aÞ†nÈßïböŠÛa|‘Š½a ñ‰ì•b–Û
òjî–ÇÒëŠÃÝÿéÐÜ´í‰ìèà¦a†îyìmëéîjbãÊbºhi‹ìÐÜÛN60
@ @@ @
41
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
âbÇÑ–näß¿éÐã´×b߆uëÙÛˆië2006énÜ»õbäiñ…bÇgÞëb°
Þaìßþa µg énÜ» pŠÔnÏa sîy Lpbí†znÛbi ò÷îÜß ÒëŠÃ ¿ òîböŠÛa
bà×LòîÏbØÛapbÇnÛaëðˆÛaÖŒànÛaëòîÜa†ÛapbÇaŠ–ÛaåßòÜà§aoãbÇ
òîjÜÛa ‰bjþaµg òÏb™g aˆç L´×bßð†Çbß×cåß…†Ç òÛbÔnbixìm
ñ…ìÇ òîãbØßg ÞìyÚìØ’ÛaëpüúbnÛa ‰bqc b¾ LÖaŠÈÛa åß bßë… òß…bÔÛa
|îz–Ûabç‰bßµgòîböŠÛa´×bßòÜ»N61
…†Ç´×bßÞìyÑnÛaÙÛ‡ÝibÔß¿ŒîÐía…ñ…bîÔiéí†Çbß—Ücåß
œÏ‰ éäØÛë ŠÐíaë ñ†ãbß µg Þbß ðˆÛa émbibİ kmb× Ûb Ú‰bßë
ñ‰a…g éîÛìm ‰ìÏ ˆîÐía…óȆÓë L´×bß ‰aì õbÔjÛaýšÐß éÈß òÛbÔnüa
ñ‰a…gòÛëbªëbèîÏ´ÜßbÈÛaëòÜà§aávy—îÜÔnipbÔÐäÛaœîЂnÛòÜà§a
jÛaëÑîÛbØnÛaÝÓdiòÜà§a夿ýßcÑî–ÛaŠè‘cÞýõaì™þaådžÈ
b†mÖaŠÈÛa¿Êb™ëþaN62
‰bjcsi ¿ òî×ßþa âýÇ⁄a Ýöbëpc†iÑ튨a Šè‘c Þì†ië
Êb™ëþaóÜÇÖaŠÈÛa¿ òî×ßþapaìÔÜÛ ñþa ñ…bíŒÛaqdmåÇ òîib¯a
g æcë ò•b Ýßþa åß a†íŒß ´×bß òÜ» óİÇc b¾ Úbäçñ…bí‹ òîvîma
LéÛý’ÏbèÜ’ÏëéÛbyb¬bèyb¬|j•cë´×bßábibjíŠÔmoİjm‰apaìÔÛa
”ìjÛbÈaëa†Ôãp‰bqcÛañŠva´ãaìÓÝí†ÈmòîšÔiâbànçüaÉuaŠmbà×
âýÇ⁄a Ýöbë ¿ ´×bß ñ‰ì• pc†i aˆÛ [´ÄÏba Âbëc ¿ ´×bßë
ò׉b’½a¿éÃìÄypc†iëbîjãåznm…ìÈmïib‚nãüaÖbjÛa¿òzubäÛa
b†mN63
@ @
42
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
´×bßìÏbäß
pbib‚nãýÛÁîİ‚nÛa êë†Çbß c†ië´×bßòÜ»µgëŠÛap…bÇ bäçë
ŠíbäíŠè‘Ýöaëc¿õ†jÛa b‰ŠÔ½aæb×Ûaòí†îèànÛa2008¿´×bß c†iëL
g bÈíŠñ‰b‘⁄ak¯bäçëLáèiìîÇëáçbíaŒßëéßì–µgpbÐnÛüaáçcµ
âì–¨aõüûçN
üëc ZïãbîÛìu ð…ë‰Rudy GiulianiÕibÛa Ú‰ìíìîã òäí†ß ñ†àÇ
òäí†ßñ…bîÓ¿ê‰ë…kjibÈÛaÇëb×ßc¿òÈaëñŠè‘kn×aðˆÛa
lbÔÇc¿Ú‰ìíìîãànjåߊ’Çð…b§apbàvç2001ðc‰sîyLbèîÜÇ
þa ædàðˆÛapì–Ûa æb× ïãbîÛìu æc æërØÛaLta†yþa †Èi´î×ß
òybÛaåÇî’méjöbãë”ìiîöŠÛaóÐnapbàvèÜÛòîÛbnÛapbÇbÛaïÐÏ
Ú‰ìíìîã ¿ Ýà éäØÛë øjn± áÜÏ ïãbîÛìu bßc Lòîäßc lbjþ òîbîÛa–ò׊Ƚa‰c–ÕÜİíaˆÛ[´î×ßÿÛbä÷àİßëbq†znßóЂníëclŠèíë
ñ†àÇòîàmïãbîÛìuóÜÇœÈjÛa11M9N64
éÜÈu b¾ òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa òybóÜÇ ê…†’mïãbîÛìuåÇҊdžÓë
ïãbîÛìuæbÈnasîyLôìn½a aˆçóÜÇ´×b½ bÏbäßMòbîÛaÕíŠÏ¿
énÜࡘb¨a òîu‰b¨aMáçŠr×cë …†¦a´ÄÏba ‰bîm õbàÇ‹ áçcœÈji
£ …†’nÛa †îÈ• óÜÇ ò•b òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa òyb óÜÇ a…†’mbÈÛa êb
LÝîöaŠg ñ†ãbßë ïßý⁄a65Œní‰ìç…ìi æb߉ìã õüûçc‰ óÜÇ ïmdíë
Norman Podhoretzòí…ìèîÛa òävÜÛa åÇ ñ‰…b–Ûað‰bnäßì× òÜ©ûß
pbíüìÛbi …†¦a´ÄÏbzàÜÛðŠØÐÛa ‰bînÜÛ´û½a õbiŁa †ycë òî×ßþa
Š¹aŠ× åm‰bßë Lñ†zn½aMartin Kramera ï¹…b×þaÖŠ’Ûa bíbšÔi Ƚ
@ @@ @
43
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
jíbi Þbîãa… µg òÏb™g aˆç LÁëþaDaniel PipesÒëŠÈ½a kmbØÛa
éßbàšãaõbjãcp‰bqcðˆÛaìçëbèiŠÇëb×ßcïàÜßêb£ñ…†’n½aéÐÓaì¶
pbàÄäß ÝjÓ åߜϊÛaë ÕÜÔÛa åßpbuìß òîib‚nãüa ïãbîÛìu òÜ» µg
´î×ßþalŠÈÛaë´àܽaN66
xë‰ †ÓëðˆÛa ìçë bÈÛa êb£ …†’nß ôúŠÛ énÜ» Þý ïãbîÛìu
Ñî« bÇ éãdi âìîÛa bÇ Ñ•ëB‰bİþbi õïÜß B´îßý⁄bië
¿kÛbëLb×ßcóÜÇâìvèÜÛò•ŠÐÛaæìäîzníåíˆÛa´î‘bÐÛa´îÛbØí…aŠÛa
놧a´ßdmëbè’îuëb×ßcñìÓõbäjiëõa†ÇþaóÜÇŠàn½aâìvbiÝibÔ½a…
ñ‰ì• ´znÛ òíŠØÇë òîã†ß pbûß Þý åß åçaŠÛa Ýî¦a ò÷jÈmë
óÜÇx‰b¨aëÝa†Ûa¿b×ßþ†ÔäÛaå߆§bið…bãbà×Lx‰b¨a¿b×ßc
õaì†yN67
óÜÇa‰aŠß†×csîyLæaŠíg†™…†’n½aéibİïãbîÛìuåÇÒŠÇbà×
†Ènß éãcë LðëìäÛa ýÛa Úýnßbi b |àí åÛ éãcÂìÌ™ âa†‚nü
kÜİÛa òí† ïãaŠí⁄a âbÄäÛa ‰bÈ‘⁄ bèîÜÇ òîbÓ òí…b–nÓaë òîbî
éÛéuaì½aÒŠİÛaŠÈ’íåÛëbÐà×éãcëLï×ßþaI´îãaŠí⁄aHæbä÷àübi
émbbîëïãbîÛìukÓaìÇæbàšiëcN 68
ÉiŠ½a µg ïãbîÛìu éi …ìÈîÏ ïÜîöaŠ⁄a ïiŠÈÛa ÊaŠ–Ûa ˜ì–¢ bßc
sîyÞëþaLæë…†’n½abèîÜÇŠİîîÛòÛë…´îäîİÜÐÛa|äßk¯üéãcôŠí
´îäîİÜÐÛaóÜÇk¯‡gáèİëÒŠİnÛaaìzÏbØíëüëcáèÐãcaìàØ°æc
òÛë†iÙÛ‡†ÈiaëûÏbØíæcóÜÇN 69
@ @
44
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
óÜlj…bÔÛaðìÔÛaåßþaÝu‰ñ‰ì–iéÐãáí†ÔnÛïãbîÛìuóÈ aˆèië
‰aŠ‘þa åß bè–îÜ¥ë b×ßc òíb»åß Ú‰ìíìîã òäí†ßÑîÄäm åß åØ· bà×
Þý´ßŠaëpbib–ÈÛaïãbîÛìuòÔibÛañ‰ì–Ûap†Çb†ÓëLbèm…bàÇéîÛìm
ñ–ÔioîÛñÐÛðcŠÛapbÇýİna¿éîÏbäßóÜÇâ†ÔnÛaóÜÇN70
bîãbqZßë‰oßMitt RomneyðˆÛaÕibÛamì’nbßòíüëá×by
⁄aëòí…b–nÓüaém‰bè¶ÒŠÇbèäßÕÐãcòÜöbñëŠqõbäióÜÇém†ÇbÛaòí‰a…
LòÔíŠÇòÄÏbªòîbîñŠcµgßë‰ïànäíbà×LòîböŠÛaénÜ»óÜÇõb‚i
†ycë ÕibÛa æbvî’ß òíüë á×by ßë‰ x‰ìu ìç ßë‰ oß †ÛaìÏ
âbÇ¿òî×ßþaòböŠÜÛ´í‰ìèà¦a´z‘Š½a1968N71
énîÐÜ ßë‰ åÇÒŠÇ †ÓëlbvÇg ݪ énÜÈuÛa òÄÏba òîäí†Ûa
L´äí†n½a´í‰ìèà¦a72òybóÜÇ ém—ÔãœíìÈnÛßë‰óÈ bà×
òbîÛa òyb óÜÇ òí‰ìÔ• ÑÓaìß jm Þý åß òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa
âbÇ Ýöaëc ¿ ÝîöaŠg ñ‰bí‹ óÜÇ ßë‰ ˜Šy sîy Lòîu‰b¨a2007L
b½aéÐÓaì߆×cÚbäçê…ìuëÞýëæaŠí⁄ò™‰bȽaëÝîöaŠ⁄ñ†ãMóÜÇ
˜ì–¨a éuëMLïbîÛa éjšË âbu ßë‰ bèîÜÇ k–í Ûa73sîy
ïßý⁄abÈÛbi bènÓýÇ¿´îbcåíŠİéuaìm b×ßcædißë‰åßûí
éîàíbߊİbàëcBÑîäÈÛa…bè¦biBëcBïÛbØí…aŠÛa…bè¦aBL74Šİ¨aë
ãaŠí⁄aŠİ¨aìçïãbrÛaïN75
õbİcojØm‰aòî×ßþaòßìاaægßë‰ÞìÔîÏÖaŠÈÛbiÕÜÈníbàîÏë
x‰ìuîöŠÛa †Ôã â†Ç óÜǘŠ° éäØÛë LÖaŠÈÛa óÜÇlŠ§a ñ‰a…g ¿
paìÔÛakz¿ÊŠnÛaâ†Çñ‰ëŠ™†×ûí bà×LŠ‘bjßÝØ’i”ìiìîÜi…
@ @@ @
45
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ÙÜnÛ ï×ßþa È’Ûa ádžÛa ñ…bíŒi bjÛbİß LÖaŠÈÛa åß òî×ßþapaìÔÛa
áçŠþëN76
bíbšÔÛaêb£…†’nÛaâ†ÈiaŒî·ßë‰ëïãbîÛìuåßý×æcbšícr½aë
‡gLôìn½aaˆçóÜÇ´×b½´ÏbäßbàèÜÈub¾òîÜa†ÛaòîÏbÔrÛaëòîÓýþa
†–yóÜÇém‰†ÔiëòîÜa†ÛabíbšÔÛaêb£òîÛaîÜÛaéÐÓaì¶bßë…´×bߊ‚nÐí
œÈië ´ÜÔn½a paì•cïãbîÛìu Ïbã ñŒîß ïçë L´îÛaîÜÛa paì•c
bßòu‰†ÛbèiŒî·bàèäßý×æþñj×òu‰†ÛbèîÜÇ´×bß߉ëN
ïÓýþaôìn½aóÜÇbîÛaîÛývïãbîÛìuÙÜn¹Þbr½aÝîjóÜÈÏ
éäØßðˆÛaŠßþa‡aì’ÛaÖìÔyÉßæ…bèníëbèu⁄aÖìÔy†íûísîyM
ð‰ìèàv×MàÈi‹ìÐÛaåßòîÛaîÜÛaÚ‰ìíìîãòäí†ßñ…bN77
éäÇÒŠÇ bà× LòîÛaîÜÛamì’nbß òíüë áØyµìm †ÔÏßë‰ bßc
Þ†nȽa éÐÓìßM ÁÜn‚½a b¶‰ëML‡aì’Ûa ÖìÔyë bèu⁄a îšÓ êb£
´äÔm ‰bÈí énÜÈu òÄÏba òîäí†Ûa òî–‚’Ûa ßë‰ òîÐÜ æþ ÙÛ‡ë
ýÇgßëŠÛÕj†Óæb×ægëLbèu⁄añbÏë†Èibèu⁄a´äÔnÛê†îídmæ
LòîãìãbÓ Ëbèug òîÜàÇ ¿ émbjíŠÓ ô†yg78ÑÔí éÐã Þaìä½a óÜÇë
‡aì’ÛaÖìÔyòíb»†ãbíéäØÛë Láèuaë‹´äÔm¿‡aì’ÛaÕy†™ßë‰
òî–‚’ÛaòzÜþaÚýnßa´ãaìӆ톒m†ãbéãcbà×LòßbÇòЖiáèmbíŠyë
b虉bÈîÛ…bÇáqN79
rÛbqb Zïib×bç ÙíbßMike Huckabeebãb׉c òíüë á×by
Arkansas†ÓëLòí†îèànÛaòí‰ìèà¦apbib‚nãüa¿…ìþaæb–§aëÕibÛa
òäí†n½aïzî½a´àîÛaôìÔiòÔîqìÛaénÓýÇïib×bçåÇÒŠÇBoãbnmëÛa
@ @
46
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
´í’jnÛaBåÇ Ö…b• ÉÏa†ßë Lòîäí… òÈßbu wíŠë ÕibÓ ïib×bèÏ L
bšÓîšÓ bèc‰ óÜÇë ïÓýþaôìn½a óÜÇ åí†n½a ïzî½a´àîÛa bí
bíbšÔÛaÙÜnÛ òàÇa†Ûa éÐÓaìßëéÜvÏL‡aì’Ûaxaë‹ŠÄyëbèu⁄aÉäß
´×bßónyëïãbîÛìuëßëŠiòã‰bÔß|™aëN
ñõaŠ bà b×ßc òubyë åí†nÛaë åí†Ûa åÇt†zní ïib×bç æc bà×
Ïbäß bèîÜÇ ê†° òyaŠ•ëéãb¹g ë ‰ìİnÛa òíŠÄäÛ éšÏ‰ †×ûí sîy Lêì
ï×ßþaåaì½aëòßþañbîy¿Ýî¬⁄aëåí†Ûa‰ë†iëæìØÜÛÕÛb…ìuìiN
ÝàÇsîyïzî½a´àîÛapbàÄä¶ émbîy òía†i¿ïib×bçÝàÇ bà×
æìîië‰ àîu pbàÄäß ô†yhiJames Robison‰bîm ñ…bÓ †yc
߆ycë´í’jnÛaoãbnmëÛaˆäßïßýÇ⁄aëïbîÛa‰bînÛa…ìÈ•ï†äè
oãbnmëÛaŠÄã¿ÖìÐníïib×bçÝÈuŠßcìçëLå튒ÈÛaæŠÔÛapbäîÈj
ñ…bÓ×cœÈi†ÔnãaëéÛÕjðˆÛaë´×bßæìuÝrß|‘ŠßóÜÇ´í’jnÛa
ÝíìÛbÏðuëæìmŠië‰pbiÝr߉bînÛaN80
ìàÜÛ éjyëénÓbjÛë éÜà òТïib×bçÒŠÇ bà×ÝÈu b¾ÒŒÈÛaëóÔî
æcë ò•b L´í’jnÛa oãbnmëÛa lbj‘ ô†Û biaˆu bz‘Šß ïib×bç
åí†Ûa‰ë…óÜnj׉sîyŠØnjßÝØ’iénÜ»Þýåí†ÛaåÇt†¤ïib×bç
´àîÛa bíbšÓ åÇ s톧a ¿ òÌÛbj½a ô…bÐmë LÖýþaë áîÔÜÛ ‰†–à×
’Ûa ÖìÔ§ëbèufiÛ áèšÏ‰ Ýrß òí†îÜÔnÛa ïzî½aŒî×Ûa ÝšÏë L‡aì
ìç×þaåí†Ûa‰ë…æc†×csîyLòî÷îjÛaëòîÓŠÈÛaëòí…b–nÓüabíbšÔÛaóÜÇ
ïçëLò÷îjÛaòíb»ëò튖äÈÛaœÏ‰ëåíŠubè½aëõaŠÔÐÛaÖìÔyåÇÊbφÛa¿
´í’jnÛaoãbnmëÛaå߆톦aÝî¦aæìîÇ¿énîi‡buå߆íŒm‰bØÏcN81
@ @@ @
47
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
œÈioÈÏ…òÔibÛaÝßaìÈÛañ†ãbßµg´í’jnÛaoãbnmëÛalbj‘
´jbäÛaÒüeoiˆu éÛ ñ†ãbß òîãëØÛg ÉÓaìß õb’ãg Þýåß ïib×bç
µgõaì™þalˆuðˆÛaŠßþaìçëLénÜ»µgëéîÛg´í’jnÛaoãbnmëÛa
¿ ´í‰ìèà¦a ´z‘Š½a ´i Þëþa Œ×Š½a Þýnya åß éäØßë Lïib×bç
ànÛapbib‚nãüaŠíbäí åßsÛbrÛa ¿ òî×ßþa aìíc òíüìip†ÔÇ Ûa òí†îè
ïãbîÛìu ëc´×bßœ±áÜÏ Lbþbißë‰lbyóÜÇÙÛ‡ëï™b½a
pbib‚nãüaåßñ‰ë†ÛaÙÜmN
´z‘Š½aÁëò߆Ônߌ×aŠßÞýnyaåß´§aÙÛ‡ˆäßïib×bçåØ·ë
òí†îèànÛa pbib‚nãüa Öbj ¿ ´í‰ìèà¦a2008óÜÇÑÈ™ åß áËŠÛa
ïÛaì¡p‰†ÓÛaòîib‚nãüaénÜà§òí…b½apbãbØß⁄a2ï×ßc‰üë…æìîÜß
i òã‰bÔß¿ÁÔÏ53ë Lßë‰oßãìîܽa bèȺ ‰üë… æìîÜß30æìîÜß
ëLïãbîÛìuð…ëŠÛ‰üë…28âbÇÝöaëc¿´×bßæ즉üë…æìîÜß2008L
áaòÇbä•åßïib×bçåØ·ÙÛ‡Éßëæbèníükäi‹ìÐÛaåßëéÐäÛ
õaì™þaåßa†íŒßÁÜb¾òÐÜn‚½apbíüìÛa¿´í‰ìèà¦apaì•cåßbèi
éîÜÇòîbîÛaN82
ÞìníŠ× âbîÜíë æc ónyWilliam Kristol–‰bîm ñ…bÓ áçc †yc
…†¦a´ÄÏba– ‰a†ãbnïÜØíë a‡ òÜ© ‰Šªë–…bÓ éãdi ïib×bçÑ•ë
ãaòܻݚÏcòí†îèànÛapbib‚nãüaÝöaëcónyòí‰ìèºpbib‚nIŠíbäí2008H
åß ÞìníŠ× æc åß áËŠÛa óÜÇ ÙÛ‡ë LòîbîÛa ïib×bç pa‰†Ôi a†î’ß
´×bßæìuð†íûßN83
@ @
48
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
lˆ¦ òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa òybóÜÇ ñ…†’nßÑÓaìßïib×bçóäjm bà×
šÏ‰†×csîyLéîÛg´í’jnÛaoãbnmëÛaë´í‰ìèà¦a‰ìÔ•óÜ‚nmæcé
ÝîöaŠgMpaŠß Ém bç‰a‹ ÛaMòí‰ìÛa ëc òîäîİÜÐÛa ï™a‰þa åÇ
êˆçâìÔmæcåعëLòÛë…´îäîİÜÐÛa|äßk¯éãcŠ×‡ëLbèäßþòíb»òÜna
¿ÝîöaŠgë òÈb‘a‰c bèi òîiŠÈÛaÞë†ÛbÏLòí…ìÈÛaëc Š–ß¿òÛë†Ûa
èäßcòíbà§bènÜnyaÛaï™a‰ÿÛòubybN84
b×ßc bèi‰b¤ÛalŠ§a òÔîÔy áèÏ µg´î×ßþa ïib×bç bÇ… bà×
áèîàíå߆™æŁaB´îÛbØí…aŠÛaëc´îibç‰⁄a´îßý⁄biBlŠ§aæcëL
lŠy òÔibÛaBòí†öbÔÇ Bb×ßc óÜÇ õbšÔÜÛ æìîibç‰⁄a bèä’í bþbi
°áçëñbî§ak¤b×ßcæþ[Ýßb×ÝØ’i´î×ßþaëpì½aæìjN85
´×bßsíŠmëâì–¨aõbİc
âbÇŠaëc¿òÏbä½aµgb†mñ…ìÈÛa¿c†i´×bßæcÕibÛa¿bãŠ×‡
2007òî×ßþapaìÔÛañ…bí‹òîvîmagÕîÔ¤ÝrßÝßaìÈÛaåß…†ÇÝšÐi
ïbîÛa âbànçüa ÉuaŠmë LÖaŠÈÛbi åßþa Š’ã ¿ bväÛa œÈi Ýrßë
ÈniïßýÇ⁄aëŒîÐía…Ùí‰énÜ»Ší†ßë´×bßóÈbà×LñŠva´ãaìÓÝí†
LÑrؽaðçbà¦aÂb’äÛaóÜÇåí†ànÈßòÜà§aõbäiñ…bÇgëpbÔÐäÛa†î‘Û
òÐÜØnÛaÝîÜÓN
ém‰ì• bèc‰ óÜÇë òî–‚’Ûa´×bßpbãbØßg µg òÏb™g ÉjİÛbi aˆç
ë Lòîu‰b¨a òbîÛa ôìnß óÜÇ éní‰ìÔ•ë émë ïßìÓ Ýİj׉ìÈ‘
‰…bÔÛa ÝuŠÛa ìç òÜÔn½a énîÐÜ¢ë énîߌí‰bØi ´×bß æc ´í‰ìèà¦aœÈi
@ @@ @
49
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
òîböŠÛapbib‚nãübiëòîböŠÛapbib‚nãüa¿´í‰ìèà¦a|î‘i‹ìÐÛaóÜÇ
´ÜÔn½aÁëénîjÈ’ÛaŠÄãbèma‡N86
œÈiŠ×ˆmsîyLÖaŠÈÛbiò•b¨a´×bßÑÓaìß|İÛaµgp…bÇbà×
æc´ÄÏbaæb×´×bßBåİä‘aìi†îyìÛapì–ÛaBåÇëÖaŠÈÛaåÇÉÏa†½a
´×bß æcë LòîšÔÛa åÇ Éîà¦a óÜ¥ b߆äÇ Úbäç òî×ßþa paìÔÛa ñ…bí‹
ÑÓìß åÇ ÊbφÛa Ýuc åß òîböŠÛa énÜ»ë ïbîÛa éÜjÔn¶ Šb
ÖaŠÈÛalŠy˜ì–¢´í‰ìèà¦aN87
´×bß âŒnÛaëB†í†¦a Bipbib‚nãüa áìß ÞýòàöbÔÛa énîvîmah
ÕibÛa¿ b虉bÇÛa´àîÛa bíbšÓjmë éibİëéÐÓaìß¿áØznÛaóÜÇ
bçŠÓcÛaköaŠšÛapbÇbİÔnaáÇ…ëòîÇŠ’ÛaËñŠvaêb£…†’nÛaÝrß
âbÇ¿´×bßb虉bÇë”ìiîöŠÛa2001LbîÛbyòàöa…bèÜÈ kÛbİípbië
îÓ åß ´×bß lŠÔm µg òÏb™g aˆçÝØ’i òîßýÇ⁄aë òîäí†Ûa ´àîÛa pa…b
´îÛaîÜÛaÝjÓ´ÄÏba´Èibn½aò’ç…‰bqcÃìzÜßN88
ÖbjÛaµg b†m ñ…ìÈÛaóÜÇ´×bß òÜ»ÝßaìÈÛaÙÜmp†Çb†Óë
òía†i ÉàÏ LÙÛ‡ óÜÇ bšíc êë†Çb ´×bß âì– æc ë†jíë LïböŠÛa
¿ òí†îèànÛa pbib‚nãüa3 Šíbäí2008 kØm‰a ´îîöŠÛa ´×bß ìÏbäßM
ïib×bçëïãbîÛìuëßë‰M´×bßpŠèÃcÛaòîib‚nãüaõbİþaåßa…†Ç
Šr×þaÝÈÐÛbiæb×´×bßæcë†jíëLbríŠmëñŠr×þaïîöŠÛa|‘Š½aéãd×ë
âbÇ¿òÔibòîbö‰pbib‚nãabéãþ[bŠ·ëñ2000Ý…éãcbà×L
òîÛb§apbib‚nãüaæcÝjÓŠØÐíïbîkÜÈr׉bÄnãüaësíÛa‰bÈ‘bÈÏa‰
ÚŠzníN89
@ @
50
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
ôìÓõb™‰g¿énjˉëòÔibÛaòîÛaîÜÛaéÐÓaìß´ia……ßßë‰a†i†ÔÏ
ïÇbànuüa ôìn½a óÜÇ òÄÏbª ÑÓaìß jni òäí†n½a ïzî½a ´àîÛa
ë‰éuaë bà× Lbèu⁄aœÏ‰ë‡aì’ÛaÖìÔz× bíbšÓ êb£ïÓýþaëß
ÛapbíüìÛaµëcaìícòíüë¿éîÜÇ‹bÏðˆÛaïib×bçåßòÈÓìnßËòÏbäß
k•òîböŠÛaòÜà§aïib×bçÞì…ÝÈÛëLòí†îèànÛapbib‚nãüa…bÔÈãa†è’m
´àîÛaôìÓåßòíbÌÜÛkíŠÓëbîäí…ÅÏbªïib×bèÏL´×bßb•¿òíbèäÛa¿
ˆÛaßëŠiòã‰bÔßòäí†n½aïzî½aæcÈíaˆçëLæb߉ì½aòÐöbµgïànäíð
õa†ÈÛa ŠÐí aˆç ÝÈÛë Lßë‰ Éß bîäí… ´ÄÏba paì•c ánÓa ïib×bç
pbib‚nãüaáìßÞý´ÜuŠÛa´ijØÛaN90
Éß bîäí… ´ÄÏba paì•c ïib×bç ánÓaë La……ß ßë‰ a†i ÙÛˆië
bàèäßÝ×ÑÈ™dÏß뉊Ła×bçÙÜn¹ bà×L‹ìÐÜÛòß‹ýÛa ñ¨aïib
´í’jnÛaoãbnmëÛa |‘Šß éãd×ë c†i †ÔÏ Lð‰ìèà¦a |î‘ÛbiMË
òßbÇ´í‰ìèà¦a|î‘i‹ìÐÜÛ†Èn½aMòîböŠÛapbib‚nãüaì±ðˆÛaë
´z‘Š½a òîÔióÜÇÁÌšÛaë bèÜîr·ë´í’jnÛaoãbnmëÛaÑÓaìßòíbà§
cîÛÑÓaì½aÙÜmÝîrànÛŠr×N
†ànÇasîyLpbib‚nãüa¿Š™b§aköbÌÛaéãd×ëa†i†ÔÏïãbîÛìubßc
pbíüìÛa ¿ òí†îèànÛa pbib‚nãübi âbànçüa â†Ç óÜÇ âìÔm òîvîmag
ÚŠm ÙÛˆië La†í‰ìÜÏ åß òía†i ñjØÛa pbíüìÛa óÜÇ Œî×Ûaë ñÌ–Ûa
´×b½ òîÛb òybÛa ïãbîÛìuMÇ …†’nßë ïãbàÜÇ bàçý×ëòyb óÜ
òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa–Öbj Ýöaëc ¿ énÜৠ¿bØÛa ádžÛa †–° ïØÛ
òí†îèànÛapbib‚nãüaN
@ @@ @
51
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ð‰ìèà¦a‰a†¦a¿lìÔq
†–yðˆÛa ´×b½ bÈíŠ ïib‚nãüa ÊaŠ–Ûaoày òÔibÛa ÝßaìÈÛa
bz™aëë b°Š•bz‘Šß b†m a†ië”ìiîöŠÛaë´í‰ìèà¦a†îídm bÇbjm
ß ´í‰ìèàvÜÛbßbiëc Úa‰bië æìnäîÜ× ð‰ýîç´îaŠÔ¹†Ûa ´z‘Š½bi òã‰bÔ
‰ìè’ÛïaŠÔ¹†Ûa |î‘Ûbi ‹ìÐÛbi bàèÇaŠ•¿ aŠàna æaˆÜÛa–á°
ìîãìíÝöaëcóny2008MŠè‘Ýöaëc¿´í‰ìèà¦a|î‘i´×bß‹ìφÈi
‰bß2008ð‰ýîç ÊaŠ• æc æërØÛa ôc‰ †Óë LMïİÈí ÝíìİÛa bßbiëc
¿òî×ßþaòböŠÛbi‹ìÐÜÛénÜ»õbäjÛoÓìÛaåß bÈnßëñj×òÈÏ…´×bß
àÏìã2008|™aëë…†ªïaŠÔ¹…ÏbäßlbîËÝÿN
†îyìm åß´×bß åØàní ü æc åß´ÄÏbaÒëb« éäí aˆç åØÛë
òÜÔn½a ´×bß òîÐÜ æþ ÙÛ‡ë LòÜjÔ½a pbib‚nãüa ¿ éÐÜ ´í‰ìèà¦a
mëü…†Çõa†Çêbj×céma…bîÓëð‰ìèà¦alŒ§aÉßpbÇaŠ–Ûbiõïܽa鱉b
aìäíåíˆÛa´í‰ìèà¦a´îbîÛaë´ÔÜȽaåßéiæbèníMæŁaónyM
áò™‰bȽaéÐÓaìßN91
ñŠè‘ï×ßþa´àîÛalbn׊è‘cœÈiæc†yµgÒý¨aÝ•ë†Óë
a‡ìÐãëMÛb×æeÝrßAnn Coulter–‡ìÐäÛapa‡ëñ…†’n½aòîäîàîÛaòjmbØÛa
´àîÛaÂbëc¿ÉaìÛaMæìnäîÜ×ð‰ýîoíì–nÜÛ ñ†Ènß bèãcpŠ×‡
òÏëŠÈß ôŠc òjmb× pc‰ bà× L´×b¶ òã‰bÔßM´ØÛbß Ýî’îß ïçë
Michelle MalkinM´i ð‰ìèà¦a lŒ§a ù…bjß Éší ü ´×bß æc
bßìmkmbØÛa áèmaë LémbíìÛëc ÝíìThomas Sowellõbànyübi´×bß
@ @
52
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
êëŠ×‡ëæìí‰ìèà¦aê†Ônãa bàÜ×âbänîÏlŠyÞýŠþa¿émbãbÈßÑÜ
áèÔy¿éöbİdiN92
æìië…¹buÝrß´í’jnÛaoãbnmëÛañ…bÓŠè‘cœÈiŠ×‡bà×
James DobsonóÜÇ áèm ü éÐÓaìß æþ [´×b½ aìmì–í åÛ áèãc
–‚’Ûaôìn½aïÓýþaëïN93
éÜvÉîàÜnÛ ñþa ñÐÛa¿óÈ´×bßæcåßáËŠÛaóÜÇÙÛ‡ë
sîy áèàdži ‹ìÐÛaë´í’jnÛaoãbnmëÛapa…bîÓ åßlŠÔnÜÛëÅÏba
éàèmaæcÕjðˆÛaÝíìÛbÏðuÒëŠÈ½aï×ßþaÔÛaòÈßbu¿t†¤
âbÇ¿´×bß2000˜Šybà× L|ßbnÛaâ†Çë…†’nÛbi†–yóÜÇ´×bß
ïubç æìuÝrß a…†’mïzî½a´àîÛa ñ…bÓ Šr×cœÈipbzî‘ŠmJohn
HageeÂbëþa Á‚ ádžÛa aˆ ´×bß ÞìjÓë ´×b½ éàÇ… ‰bqc ðˆÛa L
Õy ¿ ñ…†’n½a émb°Š–ni ÒëŠÈß ïubç æþ ÙÛ‡ë LòÜÔn½aë òîÛaîÜÛa
òî×ßþaòîÏbÔrÛaëòîäí†ÛapbÇbà¦aå߆í†ÈÛaN94
lŠÔnÜÛ†è¦aå߆íŒßÞˆji´×bßkÛbİíåßÚbäçÞa‹bßÙÛ‡Éßë
†–yÝßcóÜÇüòÜjÔ½a‰ìè’Ûa¿´í’jnÛaoãbnmëÛapbÇbºñ…bÓåß
åßõüûçó’±sîyLbšícáèàÇ…k×ÝucåßëÝiLkzÏáèmaì•c
ézä·†ÔÏL´×bßåßbîjÜbÐÓìßòäí†n½aòîäîàîÛapbÇbà¦aÑÔmæcbèmaì•c
éioàÇ…ðˆÛaÝØ’Ûbi ò•b bènİ’ãdië baìßdi éàdžÛóÈmåÛ bèäØÛë
éyb¬¿áçbë”ìiN95
ð‰ìèà¦alŒ§a†ÇaìÔi´×bßòÓýÇ¿ŠmìnÛaÉÏ…†ÓëMbäí†mŠr×þa
òÄÏbªëMòÜšÈßéuaìí´×bßæb×a‡gbßÞìyÞúbnÛaµg´jÓaŠ½aåßar×
@ @@ @
53
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
òîböŠÛapbib‚nãüa ¿ïÛaîÜÛa ´×bß Ýv æc ¿ åàØm òÜšÈß LòÜjÔ½a
òÜjÔ½aòîböŠÛapbib‚nãüa¿´ÜÔn½apaì•di‹ìÐÜÛéz‘ŠíbîjãÝÔn½aë
ë†ãbßÝßdíbà×pbîÜÓþaë´ÜÔn½aášið‰ìèà¦alŒ§aòàîÉîìmë
Ç…óÜdžànÈíòböŠÛa¿´×bß‹ìÏåØÛëLéÐã´×bßÝßdíbà×ëL´×bßá
o¤ ÉÔí †ÇaìÔÛa ÙÜm åß r×ë éÛ òíçbà¦a ð‰ìèà¦a lŒ§a †ÇaìÓ
¿ ‹ìÐÛa”ìi aìzäß åíˆÛa áèÇbjmcë ´í’jnÛa oãbnmëÛa ñ…bÓ ñŠİî
ïßbÇ2000ë2004LéÛjØÛaáèàÇ…kji96õüûç´×bßíïØÛë
pbbîjmëïu‰b¨aëïÜa†Ûa´íìn½aóÜÇ …†’nÛa éîÜÇïÌjäíòîäî¹
……½aÕÏbä½aïbîÛañ‰ì–iêŠèÄîë´ÜÔn½añ†ãbßê†ÔÐîb¾òz™aë
énÈ ´×bß †ÔÐí áq åßë òîib‚nãa òîbî aŠËþ éÐÓaìß æìÜí ðˆÛa
‰aŠÓkyb•ëÝÔnßïbî×N97
µg òÏb™⁄bi ´×bßÑÜ ´í‰ìèà¦a †îyìm ð†¤ë òÔibÛa òܚȽa
‰bȽaï×ßþaðcŠÛapbbîåßì™ìiŠßˆn½aëÖaŠÈÛaóÜÇlŠzÜÛ
Ûapbí†znÛa áçcœÈi ïç òî™b½a òîãbàrÛapaìäÛa Þý´í‰ìèà¦a
òî×ßþaòböŠÛbi‹ìÐÜÛéÔ튿´×bßbèèuaìîN
Þëþa@õŒ¦a@ò·b@ @
LïîöŠÛa bäφèiôŠcñŠß׈nÛa…ìãòa‰†ÛaåßõŒ¦a aˆçòíbèã¿
èÐÛïÈÛa ìçëæbØß⁄a ‰†Ôi ûjänÛaëÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa êb£´×bßÑÓaìß á
òîbîÛa ´×bß ñÛ Ý–Ð½a bäÛëbäm æc bäíc‰ †Óë LòîÜjÔn½a énbîi
énî–‚‘ëM òa‰†Ûa åß õŒ¦a aˆç Þý–áèÏ óÜÇ bã†Çbí Òì
@ @
54
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
bèîÏÝî–ÐnÛaÚãÛaòîu‰b¨aémbbî¿Šqûm†ÓÛaòî–‚’Ûakãaì¦a
ŒvÜÛszjÛaåßsÛbrÛaëïãbrÛaåícN
Ý…þbÏ L”ìi ìîÜi… x‰ìuîÛ´×bß æìu æc|™aìÛa åßë
òyb óÜÇ ò•b òîbîÛa ñ¨aë òϊȽa ÑîÈ™ ìçë œîiþa oîjÛa
ìèÏ ´×bß bßc Léí‰b’nßë éãaìÇc óÜÇ …bànÇüa r×ë òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa
a‰…ëÐäÛbi òîÛbÇ òÔqë òÜÔnßòî–‚‘ÙÜn¹òybóÜÇò•bòÈaëòí
òîu‰b¨aòbîÛaN
pa‡òäí†n½aïzî½a´àîÛaôìÔÛõüìÛbiåí†íüïãbàÜÇ´×bßæcbà×
paìäÛa Þý ð‰ìèà¦a lŒzÜÛ òîiŒ§a †ÇaìÔÛa óÜÇ ÉaìÛa ‡ìÐäÛa
bèäß´iŠÔ½aüëbèöbäicå߆yaëîÛåØÛëLbènã…bè½êŠİší†Ób¾ñþa
§a ìç bà×ïßìÓ ‰ìÄäßåßìÛakuaìÛbiåßûí´×bàÏ L”ìiô†ÛÞb
ÕÔzníðˆÛaëb×ßc†©ð…ŠíïãbàÜÇ–bàîÏŠ’äbà×ë´×bßôŠíbà×
Ýî–ÐnÛbi†Èi–óÈmòí‰ìÔ•òî×ßcòîu‰bòbî´iÉà¦aÞýåß
|ßbnmòznÐäßòîÜa…òbîëj×ïu‰bÊ늒ßÞýåßbÈÛañ…bîÔÛ
Éßòîㆽapb튧aëÖìÔ§aâ¤ëpbîÜÓþaN
´×bßòî–‚‘bÈßáçc—î‚ÜmbäÛëbyìÛëMÞëþaõŒ¦a¿p‹Šibà×
òa‰†Ûaåß–bäÜÔÛZåߊr×c…†’nÛaµgÝî·ò߉b•òî–‚’iÉnàní´×bßæg
ïÇbà¦aØÐnÛaë……Ûaåßü†iðcŠÛbi…a†nÇüaëòßaŠ–ÛaµgëLÞa†nÇüaN
èãgbèÐã óÜÇ oÈÜ òÈaë òîbî ñ pa‡ òÜÔnß òî–‚‘ b
‰aŠ•⁄aëìÛakuaìÛakyëòîÓa†–½aÞìy‰ìzànmÛaòÛìİjÛapbЕ
@ @@ @
55
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
òbmë òîäë òàèßåß õŒu bèãdi ŠÈ’m bà× LéîÛg òÜ×ì½a âbè½a âb·góÜÇ
pbÓìȽaåÇŠÄäÛaœÌibèÔîÔ¤k¯ô×N
´îbîÛa åß †yaë ´×bàÏâìîÛa æìÈnàní åíˆÛa ÝöýÔÛa ´î×ßþa
ñ‰ì–iBïßìÔÛaÝİjÛaBòÓ†iéÐäÛéiæìîİîaë´×bßbè‰ñ‰ì•ïçëL
æì× ñ‰ì–Ûa ÙÜm ádžíë LÝíì ß‹ ô†ß óÜÇ bèîÜÇ ˜Šyë òíbäÇë
Š¬ìØÛbiòÜíìİÛaén߆paìäkjiòÈaëòîbîñÙÜn¹´×bß
a‰…ëòíŠØÈÛaénîÐÜkjië´×bß|ä¹aˆçëLòîu‰b¨aòbîÛaæëû’iéní
kîǵgÞìznm †Ó òÔq Lòîu‰b¨a òbîÛa òybóÜÇpaˆÛa¿ ñj× òÔq
Ûa òÛìİjÛa pbЕ kjië ð†znÛa µg Ýî· Ûa ´×bß òî–‚‘ kji
éi´İîañ†Çb¶éÐãóÜÇbèÈÜN
bi´×bßæb¹g òÈîjìçë bßbçýßbÇÙÛ‡µgÑ™cLòî×ßþa òîäìÛ
òîÛaîÜÛaëbnÐãüaëòí…†ÈnÛaµgéÜîßë´×bßòîãbàÜÇåßáËŠÛaóÜÈÏ–a‡g
jÈnÛa‹buMÉßëòî×ßþaéníìçÉßÝßbÈníéãcügòîÜa†ÛaòybÛaóÜÇ
âìèÐßBòî×ßþaòîäìÛaBÝìÄäßLjÈnÛa‹bua‡gðŠØljìÄäßåß
⁄aë õüìÛaë òÇbİÛa µgòàèß ïç åìÛa ò߆ ædië åìÛbi †í†’Ûa æb¹
òyb¿ð†äuïbîÛaæd×ë…b¦aÝàÈÛaëõüìÛaëòÇbİÛaŠÐmòbm
ò׊ÈßN
åß âbÔnãüa µg bãbîyc ´×bß òî–‚‘ åß …b§a õŒ¦a Ýî¹ ÑÿÛë
åßáç õüûç éßì–æb× ìÛëóny òÛìèi ò¹Œa æbîã â†Çë éßì–
àÏLéiŒyõbäicéma‡¿énÔqéÈφmëbèiÒÈíüëò¹ŒaœÏŠí´×bM†ÓÛa
òîbîÛa éÐÓaì½ë ê‰bØÏþë éÐäÛ òîÛìİjÛa émŠÄãë ‰ëŠÌÛa †y Ý–mMµg
@ @
56
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
õbäidi´×bßòÓýÇ¿bîÜuÙÛ‡ŠèÆÓëL´y†ÈiìÛëêìߌçå¾âbÔnãüa
òîböŠÛaénÜ»Þýém†ãbßåÇáèîÜ¥†ÈiéiŒyI2000HÏL”ìiò¹Œç†Èj
µg´×bßÞì¤ïzî½a´àîÛaôìÓñ†Çb¶ë´í‰ìèà¦a´Çco¤´×b½
þa òíüë Þý ”ìië ´í‰ìèà¦a pbbî ð†Ônäß †‘c åß †yaë
pbi´×bßæcáèšÈiôc‰sîyñ†’i´í‰ìèà¦awÇ‹cŠßcìçë Lµëþa
ìЕՒíïÜa…ñ…aëŠæb–ypbiëáèîÜÇüìÜßbÐîáèÏN
òÛby¿ òîu‰b¨a´×bßpbbî Þìy ÞúbnÛa µg aˆç bèäÈÏ†í †Óë
ÖaŠÈÛa¿Þb§aìçbà×òà‚™pbí†znÛëcñ‰bëcò¹Œb×ßcŠÈm
ÕÜÈníbàîÏâbÔnãüab¶‰ë…†’nÛaµg´×bßòÔibÛaÝßaìÈÛaÉφnÝèÏLbîÛby
iìÛë‹ìÐÛaóÜÇŠ–îÝçë_ÖaŠÈÛaêb£émbbîiåÇŠÄäÛaœÌië´y†È
ÖaŠÈÛalŠ§ ŠÄäîÝçë _òÐÜØnÛa–òbîÛapb톤ë âbèßåß bçËë
òî×ßþaòîu‰b¨aM‰bÈ‘bÈÏa‰bèäßõbènãüak¯òîäëâbèà×^pì•ü
ò׊Ƚapì•ÖìÏìÜÈíAB
ÞëbänãsîyLòa‰†ÛaåßòîÛbmõaŒuþbèîÜÇòibu⁄a bä׊mòßbçòÜ÷c
½aõŒ¦a¿ÖŠ’ÛabíbšÓåßêËëÖaŠÈÛaêb£´×bßÑÓaìßòa‰†ÛaåßÝjÔ
bèyŠİã æc bäíc‰ bääØÛë LÝî–Ðm åß éÔznm b¶ òîîöŠÛa ÁëþaM¿
òÔibÛa‰ìİÛaMòî–‚‘¿òÔÜÔ½a…bÈiþaœÈij׆yµg—‚Ümbèãþ
émbbî¿Šqûm†ÓÛaòíŠØÐÛaénîÐÜë´×bßN
ˆã æc óäã üëæ…bèß Še †Èi b ´×bß òî–‚‘ ædi ù‰bÔÛa Š×
LòÐÜn«pbjbäß¿òã…bè½aµg´×bßÒëŠÄÛaoÈÏ…†ÔÏLïmbºaŠi98ÝÈÛë
@ @@ @
57
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
†ÇaìÔÛaë ´í‰ìèà¦a òã…bèß µg òîÛb§a ñÐÛa Þý ´×bß Ýîß bèq†yc
òîÜa†Ûa bíbšÔÛa åß r× ¿ òÄÏbªë bäí†m Šr×þa lŒzÜÛ òíçbà¦a
köaŠšÛb×pbjˉë´×bßÑÓaìß´iñìvÐÛaÝîÜÔm¿ýßcÙÛ‡ëñŠvaë
Lar×bça†¤ëb虉bÇ´×bßæcŠÈ’mÛaLñ…†’n½aòíçbà¦a†ÇaìÔÛaÙÜm
bíbšÔÛa†îÈ•óÜÇò•bÒb×ÝØ’ibÄÏbªîÛ´×bßæcbšícŠÈ’mbà×
bîÇaëd¦´×bßæc†¬aˆÛ[òîÜa†ÛaòîÓýþaëòîÇbànuüaïmbºŠiwèä¶ë
Šßc ìçë LòîböŠÛa énÜ» Þý òíçbà¦a †ÇaìÔÛaÙÜm òã…bèß µg |™aë
òîböŠÛapbib‚nãüaáìßÞý|™aëÝØ’iŠàníæcÉÓìníI2008NH
òíçbà¦aéiŒy†ÇaìÓòã…bèßµgar׊ݚí´×bßæcbäç|™aìÛaë
ÛaòybÛaïèÏLòîu‰b¨aòbîÛaôìnßóÜÇ´í‰ìèà¦aåß´×bßlŠÔm
ÙÛ‡ëLñ…†’n½að‰ìèà¦alŒ§a†ÇaìÓåßëòäí†n½aïzî½a´àîÛaôìÓë
pa‰…bjßáçcåß …†Çádžië òí‰ìÔ–ÛbipŒî· òîu‰b¨a´×bßÑÓaìßæþ
Ûa LÖaŠÈÛalŠy bèc‰óÜÇë LÞ†vÜÛ ñ‰bqg bçŠr×cë òîu‰b¨a”ìi ñ‰a…g
ëòía†jÛaåß´×bßbç†ãbñ‰a…⁄aõbİdiŠÈ‘b߆äÇbç‰bßý•hikÛb
òîãbrÛa”ìiòíüëÞýŠànaéäØÛëLÚbäçòî×ßþaMbèîÏóÜ¥ñÏ¿ë
ò÷îlŠzÜÛ´×bßñ†ãbßp…b×ónyLÖaŠÈÛalŠyë”ìiáÇ…åÇÉîà¦a
ïbîÛaéÜjÔnßóÜÇïšÔmæcbîu‰bëbîÜa…òÈàÛaN
bi´×bßòÓýÇæcaˆçÈíòybóÜÇ…†’nÛaå߆íŒßµgéÈφmlŒ§
pbib‚nãa¿´×bßïÏbäßáçcaŠÈnaåß bäíc‰†ÓëLòîu‰b¨aòbîÛa
òí†îèànÛa òîböŠÛað‰ìèà¦alŒ§aI2008 HóÜÇ a…†’m éäÇ aìÜÔí áèãc
òîu‰b¨aòbîÛaòybN
@ @
58
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
×bß …†’m æc Èí aˆçë L…†’nÛa µg´×bß òî–‚‘Ýî·ÑÿÛë´
ïÛë… ÉÓaë üg bàèÐÓìí ü †Ó òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa òyb óÜÇ ´í‰ìèà¦aë
åÛ ÉjİÛbië LòböŠÛbi ê‹ìÏ òÛby ¿´×bß ñ…a‰⁄‰bÈßë †ÔÈßëkÈ•
óÜÇëéîÜÇbšÔãýÛóÈîÝiLòÛìèiÉÓaìÛa aˆçâbßc´×bßáÜní
íÝu‰´×bàÏLŠßþakÜİm a‡gáèäßâbÔnãüaë´îÛë†Ûaéßì–òЖiåßû
c†j¶òßbÇBåbìçë†í†§aóÜÇÖŠİÛaNB
@ @@ @
59
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
Þëþa@Ý–ÐÛa@“ßaìçZ@@ @
1 Connie Bruck, “McCain’s Party; Why The Senator From Arizona Believes He Can Be The Next Republican Nominee for President,” The New Yorker, 30 May 2005, 58. 2 Bruck, “McCain’s Party.” 3 Bob Kemper, “John McCain; Maverick on a Mission; Supporters See a Man Who Stands Tall Despite Losses, But Detractors See a Grandstander at Work,” Chicago Tribune, 7 Jan 2000, N-1. 4 Kemper, “John McCain; Maverick on a Mission.” 5 Kemper, “John McCain; Maverick on a Mission.” 6 Kemper, “John McCain; Maverick on a Mission.” 7 E. J. Dionne Jr., “The Maverick as Moralist: Sen. John McCain Offers a Book of Virtues For Kids and a Glimpse of What Makes Him Tick,” The Washington Post, 11 Dec 2005, T-07. 8 Dionne Jr., “The Maverick as Moralist,” T-07. 9 Jake Tapper, “Mark Salter: The Voice of Sen. John McCain,” Salon.com, 12 Oct 1999. 10 Kemper, “John McCain; Maverick on a Mission.” 11 Bruck, “McCain’s Party.” 12 Bruck, “McCain’s Party.” 13 Kemper, “John McCain; Maverick on a Mission.” 14 Kemper, “John McCain; Maverick on a Mission.” 15 Kemper, “John McCain; Maverick on a Mission.” 16 Kemper, “John McCain; Maverick on a Mission.” 17 Jime Lobe, “Republicans Split Over Kosovo,” Inter Press Service, 9 April 1999. 18 Dana Milbank, “Candidate McCain’s Front-Seat Driver; John Weaver’s Been This Way Before,” The Washington Post, 15 Feb 2000, C-01. 19 Jacob Heilbrunn, “Bush’s Emerging Foreign Policy Reflects Schisms in Republican Party,” Los Angles Times, 28 Nov 1999, M-2. Marc Sandalow, “Foreign Policy Takes Back Seat in 2000 Race; Little Debate, But Big Differences in Experience,” The San Francisco Chronicle, 27 Jan 2000, A-1. 20 Alison Mitchell, “The 2000 Campaign: The Populist Appeal; The Inside Outsiders Behind John McCain,” The New York Times, 6 Feb 2000, 1. 21 Milbank, “Candidate McCain’s Front-Seat Driver.” 22 Mitchell, “The 2000 Campaign.” 23 Fred Barnes, “John McCain’s Conservative Problem; Invoking Reagan Won’t Be Enough to Reconcile The Right to John McCain,” The Weekly Standard, 6 March 2000, 15.
@ @
60
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
24 Ponnuru, “Hauntings.” 25 Robert D. Novak, “What is John McCain?” The New York Post, 26 August 1999, 35. 26 Dan Balz, “For McCain Aide, A Case of Bus Lag; Salter Struggles to Adjust to Run-of-the-Hill Job,” The Washington Post, 12 April 2000, A-25. 27 Barnes, “John McCain’s Conservative Problem.” 28 Mitchell, “The 2000 Campaign.” 29 Cary Segall, “Pundit Sees Bush Having Tough Time; McCain Could Win Kristol Says,” Wisconsin State Journal, 8 Dec 1999, 1-B. Trudy Rubin, “McCain Trumps Bush on Foreign Policy Expertise,” The Philadelphia Inquirer, 26 Feb 2000. 30 David Brooks, “The Conservative Conundrum,” Newsweek, 6 March 2000, 32. 31 Bruck, “McCain’s Party.”
، المسيحية الصهيونية في الواليات المتحدة، 2006، ملفات خاصة الجزيرة نتعالء بيومي، 3203F4-F88D-2805E40E/exeres/NR/net.aljazeera.www://http- بات روبرتسونشخصيات،
Basic=purpose_wbc?htm.8FF7A8EDFF1F-D7AF ،26 2006 ديسمبر. ، المسيحية الصهيونية في الواليات المتحدة، 2006، ملفات خاصة الجزيرة نتعالء بيومي، 33
FF93-96E4-6026-18B6AD41/exeres/NR/net.aljazeera.www://http- رالف ريد،شخصيات، Basic=purpose_wbc?htm.277ADDBB30E9، 26 2006 ديسمبر.
34 Bruck, “McCain’s Party.” 35 Paul Alexander, "John McCain’s War on The White House," Rolling Stone, 7 June 7 2001, Issue 870, 40. 36 Alexander, “John McCain’s War.” 37 Bruck, “McCain’s Party.” 38 Kathryn Jean Lopez, “A Conservative Case Against McCain,” National Review, 14 Jan 2008. Ryan Lizza, “On the Bus; Can John McCain Reinvent Republicanism?,” The New Yorker, 25 Feb 2008, Vol. 84, No. 2, 30. 39 Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, “A Voice for Victory; May John McCain’s Tribe Increase,” Arkansas Democrat-Gazette (Little Rock), 13 April 2007. 40 Bruck, “McCain’s Party.” 41 Bruck, “McCain’s Party.” 42 Bruck, “McCain’s Party.” 43 David Olive, “The Alarming Consequences of Two John McCains,” The Toronto Star, 3 Feb 2008, D-01. Bruck, “McCain’s Party.” 44 John Kyl, “Right on McCain,” National Review, 11 March 2007. 45 John Gizzi, “CPAC: Bolton, McCain and the White House,” Human Events Online, 11 Feb 2008.
@ @@ @
61
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
Douglas Jehl and Carl Husle, “McCain Will Press for Compromise on Bolton,” The International Herald Tribune, 28 May 2005, 3. 46 Bruck, “McCain’s Party.” 47 Juan Cole, “John McCain Runs for George Bush’s Third Term,” Salon.com, 12 March 2008. 48 Meredith Heagney, “Critics Tie McCain, Too, to Extremist Pastors,” The Columbus Dispatch, 22 May 2008. 49 Maeve Reston, “They Kept McCain Afloat; Last Summer, A Small Team of Aides Rallied Around the Falling Candidate and Steadily Rebuilt His Campaign,” Los Angeles Times, 7 March 2008, 1. 50 Ralph Nader, “John McCain; The Maverick Gunning for the Oval Office,” Time, 8 May 2006, Vol. 167, No. 19, 54. 51 Michael D. Shear, Dan Balz and Chris Cillizza, “Rivalries Split McCain’s Team; After Months of Staff Fights, Rick Davis Emerges as the Leader of a Diminished Campaign,” The Washington Post, 14 July 2007, A-1. 52 Bruck, “McCain’s Party.” 53 Josh Gerstein, “McCain Signals Distance from Bush, Neocons,” The New York Sun, 23 Aug 2006, 1. Bruck, “McCain’s Party.” 54 Michael Scherer, “John McCain: Bush’s Echo,” Salon.com, 12 April 2007. 55 Norman Solomon, “While McCain Walks in McNamara’s Footsteps,” Humanist, May/June 2007, Vol. 67, Issue 3, 8-9. 56 Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, “A Voice for Victory.” 57 Michael Finnegan, “Top McCain Advisors Step Down; The Cash-Strapped Campaign Loses Four, Including Manager Terry Nelson and Chief Strategist John Weaver,” Los Angeles Times, 11 July 2007, A-11. 58 Finnegan, “Top McCain Advisors.” 59 David Brooks, “The McCain World Rift,” The International Herald Tribune, 23 Feb 2008, 7. Shear, Balz and Cillizza, “Rivalries Split McCain’s Team.” 60 Shear, Balz and Cillizza, “Rivalries Split McCain’s Team.” 61 Robert Novak, “Can McCain Come Back?” Pittsburgh Tribune Review, 12 July 2007. 62 Reston, “They Kept McCain Afloat.” 63 Reston, “They Kept McCain Afloat.” 64 Michael Powell, “Giuliani Tries to Temper Image, Trading the Growl for a Smile,” The New York Times, 29 May 2007, A-01. 65 David Saltonstall, “Neocon Hawaks Go All-out For Giuliani,” Daily News, 16 Sep 2007, 14. 66 PR Newswire (U.S.), “NY Congressman Says 'Too Many Mosques' in U.S. CAIR asks GOP to Repudiate Remarks, Urges Giuliani to Drop Rep. King, Daniel Pipes as Advisors,” PR Newswire (U.S.), 20 Sept 2007.
@ @
62
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
67 Rudolph Giuliani, “Toward a Realistic Peace,” Foreign Affairs, Sep/ Oct 2007. Edward Luce, “The Republicans’ Jockeying on Terrorism is Terrifying,” Financial Times, 28 Aug 2007, 9. 68 Tom Brune, “The Candidate on Iran: Rudy’s Vow: No Nukes,” Newsday, 20 Sep 2007, A-02. 69 Marc Santora, “Giuliani Calls for Increasing American Support for Fatah,” The New York Times, 27 June 2007, A-20. 70 Matt Bai, “America’s Mayor Goes to America,” The New York Times, 9 Sep 2007, 6-46. 71 Stephanie Ebbert, “Race for Governor Mitt Romney; Third in a Series of Profiles of the Massachusetts Gubernatorial Candidates; Romney Seeks High Office with Confidence, Pedigree,” Boston Globe, 11 Aug 2002, A-1. 72 Ebbert, “Race for Governor Mitt Romney.” 73 The Frontrunner, “In Israel, Romney Talks Tough on Iran; 08 Hopeful Calls for Harsh Sanction,” The Frontrunner, 24 Jan 2007. 74 Tom Baldwin, “The Mormon Challenger Who Hopes ‘to Do a JFK’ in Quests for Presidency,” The Times (London), 20 Sept 2007, 33. 75 Joshua Mitnick, “Candidates Court Israel, Cite Iran Risks; Jewish Voters Wooed for 08,” The Washington Times, 24 Jan 2007, A-1. Mitt Romney, “Rising to a New Generation of Global Challenges,” Foreign Affairs, July/August 2007. 76 Todd Spangler, “Like Father, Like Son? Mitt’s No George; Candidate Learns from Dad’s Mistakes,” Detroit Free Press, 19 August 2007, 1. Romney, “Rising to a New Generation.” Susan Page, “Romney Supports Bush’s Troop Increase – for Now Warns of Calamity from Withdrawal,” USA Today, 9 August 2007. 77 Ed Lask, “Rudy Giuliani’s New Foreign Policy Team,” American Thinker, 11 July 2007. 78 Neil Swidey and Stephanie Ebbert, “Journeys of a Shared Life; Raising Sons, Rising Expectations Bring Unexpected Turns,” The Boston Globe, 27 June 2007, A-1. 79 Baldwin, “The Mormon Challenger.” 80 The Economist, “Faith, Hope and Populism, the Candidate: Mike Huckabee,” The Economist, 24 Nov 2007. 81 Byron York, “Another Man from Hope – Former Governor Mile Huckabee Shares Some of Clinton’s Talents, But Is Definitely His Own Man,” National Review, 10 Sep 2007. Ben Harris and Ami Eden, “Huckabee Rise Puts Focus on Religion Talk,” Jewish Telegraphic Agency, 23 Dec 2007.
@ @@ @
63
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
82 PR Newswire, “A Fair Deal for All Americans; Five Principles of a Mike Huckabee Stimulus Package: Family, Fed, Fight, Fuel, Fair,” PR Newswire, 15 Jan 2008. 83 William Kristol, “President Mike Huckabee?” The New York Times, 7 Jan 2008, A-21. 84 CNN Late Edition With Wolf Blitzer, “Interview With Mike Huckabee,” CNN 11:00 AM EST, 25 Nov 2007. Harris and Eden, “Huckabee Rise Puts Focus on Religion.” 85 Micahel D. Huckabee, “America’s Priorities in the War on Terror: Islamists, Iraq, Iran, and Pakistan,” Foreign Affairs, Jan/ Feb 2008. 86 Gary Bauer, “Conservative Yardstick; The Numbers Add Up to John McCain,” The Washington Times, 12 Feb 2008, A-17. Wynton C. Hall, “Bizarro Goldwater,” National Review, 18 Jan 2008. 87 Pete Hegseth, “Praise Him,” National Review, 18 Jan 2008. 88 Rich Lowry, “John McCain, Un-unleashed,” National Review, 28 Jan 2008. Cole, “John McCain Runs For George Bush’s Third Term.” 89 Reston, “They Kept McCain Afloat.” Lizza, “On the Bus.” 90 Lizza, “On the Bus.” 91 Tara Wall, “McCain Resurrected? Counting on Conservative Courting to Fill the Gap,” The Washington Times, 11 March 2008, A-17. Jill Zuckman, “McCain Hopes Conservative Voters Will Eventually Come Around,” Chicago Tribune, 18 Feb 2008. George F. Will, “Waiting for Straight Talk,” Washington Post, 20 Jan 2008, B-7. 92 Alex Koppelman, “Conservative Crackup over McCain Continues,” Salon.com, 1 Feb 2008. 93 Rachel Stults and Jennifer Brooks, “Broadcast Group Isn’t Fully Sold on McCain,” The Tennessean, 12 March 2008. Zuckman, “McCain Hopes.” Ben Domenech, “John McCain and the Evangelicals,” Human Events Online, 20 Feb 2008. 94 Cole, “John McCain Runs For George Bush’s Third Term.” Lizza, “On the Bus.” 95 Stults and Brooks, “Broadcast Group.” 96 Wall, “McCain Resurrected.” Domenech, “John McCain and the Evangelicals.” 97 Thomas F. Schaller, “Running in Reverse: From The Middle to The Right,” The Baltimore Sun, 13 March 2008, A-17. 98 Cole, “John McCain Runs For George Bush’s Third Term.”
65
ïãbrÛa@Ý–ÐÛa@ @Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@ @
bç…ìàÇÝr¹ìèÏLénîàçc†×ûãæck−òa‰†ÛaåßõŒ¦aaˆçòía†i¿
…ìã bà×LÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa bíbšÓáçcåß´×bßÑÓìßÞëbänísîyðŠÔÐÛa
ôŠcñŠßñ‰b‘⁄aìçëLõŒ¦aaˆçpbzЕÇéÇbjmgôìäãðˆÛawèä½aµg
òÔj½a´×bßÑÓaìßóÜÇâbØyþa‰a†•g¿ÊŠnÛa â†ÇóÜÇáöbÓwèäß
bäφèÏ LÁëþa ÖŠ’Ûaë ïiŠÈÛa bÈÛa bíbšÓ áçc ì− ñŠÄnä½a émbbîë
ïbþa–òa‰†ÛaåßõŒ¦aaˆçÞý–ÑÓaì½ïãdn½aïrzjÛa†•ŠÛaìç
òîÜàÇë ÖaŠÈÛalŠy bèc‰ óÜÇëÁëþa ÖŠ’Ûa bíbšÓ áçc êb£´×bß
òí…ìÈÛaë Š–à× ôØÛa òîiŠÈÛa Þë†Ûa Éßë æaŠíg Éß òÓýÈÛaë âýÛa
òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa Š’ã òbî× ôŠc òí‰ìª bíbšÓ åß ´×bß ÑÓìßë bí‰ìë
âý⁄añ‰ì•ëÁëþaÖŠ’ÛbiN
´×bßÑÓaì߉눦ñ…ìÈÛa†àÈnäaˆÛñÐÛa¿ò•bëæbØß⁄a‰†Ôi
ànjåߊ’Çð…b§ata†yþòÔibÛa2001åÇszjãæc†íŠãåzäÏ L
ÙÜm ‰ìİmë òÜÔn½a ê‰bØÏcë òî–‚’Ûa ém åß òÈibäÛa ´×bß ÑÓaìß
âbLjäßñ†nà½aï×ßþaŠ¬ìØÛbién߆…ìÔÇô†ßóÜljbØÏþa1983N
n‚½akãaìvÜÛÖŠİnÛa†àÈnä bà×òîšÓÝ× êb£´×bßpbbîÛ òÐÜ
†Ób½ëÑÓaì½aÙÜnÛòÜßb’Ûañ‰ì–ÛaåÇszjÛaëLòÔibÛaòßbabíbšÔÛaåß
òîÜa…pbÓ‰bÐßëcpbšÓbämåßbèíÈíN
@ @
66
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
´×bßÑÓaìßóÜÇïöbèäÛaáاaëïßbn¨akîÔÈnÛaÚãæcóÜÇÙÛ‡ë
åßþaësÛbrÛaõŒvÜÛbèÜjÔnßëbçaŒÌßëémbbîëòa‰†ÛaM†ÈíðˆÛa
szjÛaåßïãbrÛaëÞëþaåícŒvÜÛ òîÈîj ò·b–åí†çbuóÈäsîy
òîu‰b¨aòbîÛabíbšÔiÕÜÈníbàîÏïbîÛa´×bߊØÐÛâbljì–mÉ™ìÛ
éi ´İîa åí‰b’n½a áçcë bèîÛg ïànäí Ûa òíŠØÐÛa ò‰†½a òÈîjİië
îu‰b¨aénbîóÜÇÕjbßÝ×püü…ëÁëþaÖŠ’Ûaêb£ñŠÄnä½aòN
‰ëbªòqýqÕíŠåÇñŠÄnä½a´×bßpbbîi bäİyc†ÓæìØãÙÛˆië
ÞëþaõŒ¦a¿bçbäÛëbämÛaòîbîÛaénîÐÜëòî–‚’ÛaénÈîjbëcLòîîö‰
ÖŠ’ÛabíbšÓáçcåß´×bßÑÓaì߉ìİmìèÏïãbrÛa‰ìabßcLòa‰†Ûaåß
Êì™ìß ìçëÁëþa¿ Éšã æc óÜÇ Lòa‰†Ûa åßïÛb§aëïãbrÛa õŒ¦a
òbîÜÛ ´×bß áèÏ ‰ìİnÛ ýßb‘ë bßbÇ a‰ì–m òa‰†Ûa åß sÛbrÛa õŒ¦a
ÁëþaÖŠ’Ûaêb£éÐÓaìßëòîu‰b¨aN
ÖaŠÈÛaåß´×bßÑÓìßÞëbäni òa‰†ÛaåßïÛb§a õŒ¦a c†jãÒìë
ßbànçaåß×þa‰†ÔÛabèzäßÛaòîšÔÛaïçëòî–‚’ÛaénÈåßëÝié
´àÇa†Ûa ×c ìç ´×bßë _ü Laˆç bäßìí ónyëpbäîÈnÛa Šaëc ˆäß
òî×ßþañ‰a…⁄ax‰bÖaŠÈÛalŠ§N
pbÓýÈÜÛ éníú‰ëÝîöaŠgåß´×bßÑÓìßòa‰†iÙÛ‡ÉjnãæcóÜÇ
òî×ßþaM¿ ‰ŠØnßë áöa… ÝØ’i Ýİm Ûa ÝîöaŠg b–½ òîÜîöaŠ⁄a
aìßüõŒuïçÝîöaŠhÏLÁëþaÖŠ’ÛabíbšÓåßj×…†Çêb£´×bßÑÓ
ïİëcÖŠ’Ûa´×bßÊ늒ßåßcŒvníMòî×ßþaòbîÛa¿Þb§aìçbà×
âbÇÝØ’iÁëþaÖŠ’Ûaêb£N
@ @@ @
67
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
†í†ènÛa åß j× ‰†Ôi ´×bß bè– Ûa æaŠíg ÙÛ‡ †Èi Þëbänã áq
cónyòîböŠÛaénÜ»Þý†îÇìÛaëénÜ»åà™pbîÛbÈÐÛaô†yg¿óäÌméã
âbÄãÂìÔÝjÓbßÖaŠÇ´×b½Ýr·æaŠígombibà×LæaŠíglŠ¡òîib‚nãüa
´yâa†•N
ÖŠ’Ûa¿òîaŠÔ¹†ÛaŠ’ãòbîåß´×bßÑÓìßÞëbänäÙÛ‡†Èië
òîîö‰ òîiŠÇ Þë†i b×ßc òÓýÈÛ éníú‰ ñj× òu‰… µg …†¤Ûa Áëþa
Š–à׆톦aÁëþaÖŠ’Ûbibãbîycéîàíb½éníú‰ëbí‰ìëòí…ìÈÛaëN
ïbîÛa´×bßlbݨòa‰†ÛaåßõŒ¦a aˆçòíbèã¿ÖŠİnãæcóÜÇ
ïçë Lï×ßþa âbÈÛa ðcŠÛa ô†Û âý⁄a ñ‰ì• ¿lbݨaÙÛ‡ qdnÛë
õa†ÈÛa ŠçbÄÛ ÕÜÔ½a ìàäÛa Ýà ¿ ïiŠÈÛa ù‰bÔÛa ÝÌ’m ombi òßbç òîšÓ
âýfiÛIslamophobia¿ë ò•b òЖi ï×ßþa ïbîÛa lbݨa ¿
îàîÛa´×bßlbİ æc bà× LòßbÇ òЖi òî×ßþa ŠØÐÛaë âýÇ⁄a Šöaë…
¿ ÍÛbjí ðˆÛa ´í‰ìèà¦a lbİë òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa òyb óÜÇ …†’n½a
ßbçan«æýr¹òîu‰b¨apbÇaŠ–ÛaëlŠ§abíbšÓóÜÇŒî×Ûalbİ‚ÜÛb
ïßý⁄aëïiŠÈÛa´½bÈÛaëâý⁄aêb£…†’n½aï×ßþaN
üëc@ZÖaŠÈÛa@ @
´yâa†•ÕibÛaïÓaŠÈÛaîöŠÛaâbÄäÛð…bȽa´×bßæìuÑÓìß
´×b߆ÔnãasîyoíìØÜÛÖaŠÈÛaëŒËÝjÓbßµgŠí†ÔmÝÓcóÜÇ…ìÈíáí†Ó
âbÇÝöaëc¿1989܉cbèãþòî×ßþaòßìاa¿â†‚nmòínØi…aìßo
ïÓaŠÈÛaâbÄäÛaµgòîuìÛìîjÛaòzÜþaŠíìİmN1
@ @
68
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
†íëŒm¿bèÐãòî×ßþaòßìاa‰ë†Ûê†Ôã¿ÕibÛaÑÓì½a…ŠÐníë
ar׉ŠØníŠßcìçëÝßb’Ûa‰b߆ÛaòzÜcxbnãg¿â†‚nm…aì¶âa†•
aâbÄäÛaïÇb½ê†Ôã¿´×bߊànasîyLÙÛ‡†ÈiòzÜcÚýnßüïÓaŠÈÛ
ÝíŠig¿òî×ßþaòßìاakÛbëÝßb’Ûa‰b߆Ûa1990ÖaŠÈÛaÉä½Ý†nÛbi
ña…cëcÝí†iðc†ÈjnßËÝßb’Ûa‰b߆ÛaòzÜcÚýnßaåßMÙÛ‡¿b¶
ðŠØÈÛa‰bî¨a–b×ßcóÜÇædi´×bßåßcsîyLÕibÛaÒ†aÕîÔznÛ
âb·g åß âa†• ÉäßBa énàèßòîäí†Û B¿ òäàîè½a ñìÔÛa |j–í æþ òîßaŠÛa
ÁëþaÖŠ’ÛaN2
oíìØÛaŠíŠ¤lŠy
݆m†îídm¿……ÛaåßéÈä¹ïÓaŠÈÛa âbÄäÜÛð…bȽa´×bßÑÓìß
†ycôc‰sîyLÉaëÖbİãóÜÇoíìØÛaŠíŠ¤lŠy¿ï×ßþa“î¦a
ÝšÏcæcoíìØÜÛÖaŠÈÛaëŒËåßâbíc†Èi´×bßð†Çbß݆nÜÛlìÜc
âa†‚nbiëÁÐäÛaÕφmÉä½ÖaŠÈÛaóÜÇðŠ¡‰b–yŠÐiìçâa†•†™
ïÓaŠÈÛa“î¦a†™òî×ßþaòíì¦apaìÔÛaBïîö‰‰bî‚×NB3
âýÇ⁄aÝöbìÛ Š×‡sîy bÔyü´×bß êbäjmðˆÛa éÐãÑÓì½a ìçë
òíŠzjÛaëòíì¦apaìÔÛaæcòî×ßþaMòíÛalŠ§aîÛëMçpaë…þaï
a‡g oíìØÛa ŠíŠ¤ ¿ lþa ”ìi x‰ìu îöŠÛa bè߆‚ní æc k¯ Ûa
lŠy ¿ d× ém åß ÕibÛa ´×bßÑÓìß ÕÜİãa †Óë LŠßþakÜİm
ñè’Ûa ñ†ÔÈÛbi ´î×ßþa oib•c Ûa LâbänîÏ– âbänîÏ ñ†ÔÇMòšÏaŠÛa
´×bß Ç aˆÛ [òî×ßþa ï™a‰þa x‰b ðŠØÈÛa ݆nÜÛém…bÈ åÇ
@ @@ @
69
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ÞëbiåÛì×ÞaŠä¦aæìØÛColin Powellï×ßþa“î¦aæb׉c†îàÇìç–
oíìØÛa ŠíŠ¤lŠyÞýMéãcÈí b¾ âbänîÏ¿Õibl‰bªÞëbiæþ
ÖaŠÈÛa¿bèöbİc¿ýnÛóÈíÒìëbè뉅áÜÈmN4
¿ òÌÛbj½a åß bÇìã´×bßÑÓìß ¿ âýÇ⁄a ÝöbëœÈipc‰ †Óë
Ó´×bßpbi bà×Lbç†y늖äÛaÕîÔ¤óÜÇòî×ßþaòíì¦apaìÔÛa ñ‰†–
ï×ßþa „ìî’ÛaÜv¶ òzܽapaìÔÛa òävÜi ìšÇ ìçë–‹ì߉ †yc
LoíìØÛaŠíŠ¤lŠy¿òþapaìÔÛaâa†‚na¿åí……½a´í‰ìèà¦a
‰ë…óÜÇŠ–nÔíæck¯paìÔÛaÙÜm‰ë…ædi´×bßåßesîyB†jÛaÝíB
ŠíŠ¤lŠy¿òîîöŠÛaña…þaÝr·æck¯ÛaLòíì¦apaìÔÛaÝ’ÏòÛby¿
µgð…ûíÒì òíŠilŠy¿Þì†Ûa æc åß´×bßï’ bà× LoíìØÛa
ò튒iŠöbåßéîÜÇkmîb½oíìØÛaŠíŠzniï×ßþaâaŒnÛüaÉuaŠm
òî×ßþapaìÔÛaÁëN5
ÂaŠÏ⁄a†™´×b߉ˆybà׆Èibç‰bßëlŠ§a˜ì–¢ÞúbÐnÛa¿
lŠy Þý òíÛa òíŠØÈÛa pbîÜàÈÛa oÔj Ûa òíì¦a pýà§a òía†i
´×bßåØÛëLbÈ튊èÃbà×aj×byb¬oÔÔypý»ïçëLoíìØÛaŠíŠ¤
ÞúbÐnÛa ¿ æìî×ßþa ñ…bÔÛa ÍÛbi ´y âbänîÏ ñ ‰aŠØm åß ó’± æb×
‰†îÛlŠ§a‰bߘ얢æìî×ßþaÚM†ÈibàîÏM¿Ý†máè’îuæc
òØÜèßëòÜíìlŠyN6
paìÔÛa‰b–nãbiÞbÐnyüaåß´×bß……Ûa뉈§aÙÛ‡Éä¹ÉjİÛbië
òîîöŠÛaòíŠØÈÛabèÏa†çcÕîÔ¤†ÈioíìØÛaŠíŠ¤lŠy¿òî×ßþaN7
@ @
70
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
ïÓaŠÈÛaâbÄäÛaòÔyýß
´×bß ñ…‰bİßpŠànalŠ§a òíbèã †ÈiÝîjóÜÈÏ LïÓaŠÈÛa âbÄäÜÛ
âbÇ¿´×bßâ†ÓÞbr½a1993ïaŠÔ¹†Ûa‰ìmbäîÛaÉßæëbÈnÛbiMÚa‡æeM
óàí æìãbÓ ÊëŠ’ß æbßîÛ Ñí‹ìuBòzÜþa ‰b’nãa åß †§a æìãbÓ
æaŠígëÖaŠÈÛbiBóÜÇæaŠígëÖaŠÈÛañ‰†Óå߆zÜÛó߉æìãbÓÊ늒ßìçëL
Ýßb’Ûa‰b߆ÛaòzÜcÚýnßaÉä¶ò•b¨aòîÛë†Ûa´ãaìÔÛaÝîÈÐmÕíŠåÇ
pb׊’ÛaëÞë†ÛaóÜÇÁÌšÛaë Låí†ÜjÛaµgÝßb’Ûa ‰b߆Ûa òzÜc Ší†–m
bîuìÛìäØnÜÛ ëc òzÜþaÙÜnÛ bçŠí†–m â†ÇæbàšÛ´nÛë†Ûa Éß òÜßbÈn½a
òzÜþaÙÜmŠíìİm¿âa†‚nýÛòÜibÔÛaN8
nubjí… ¿ æìãbÔÛa Š×‡ëé‚na ÖaŠÈÛa æc†™ òíëbàî× òzÜc â†
áubçë LðëìäÛa ýÛa Úýnßü óÈë LoíìØÛa aŒË éãcë L…aŠ×þa
Ýr¹ ÖaŠÈÛa æcë Lƒí‰aì–Ûbi ÝîöaŠgë òí…ìÈÛaBâýÜÛ aŠànß a†í†èm
ï½bÈÛaNB9
òînznÛa òîäjÛa ŠíìİnÛóÈïÓaŠÈÛa âbÄäÛaæcæìãbÔÛa ÊëŠ’ß Š×‡ bà×
cë LðëìäÛa ýÛa Šíìİni ò•b¨a|šÏ¿ áçboíìØÜÛ ÖaŠÈÛa ëŒË æ
lŠ§aæcëLbÈÛaâbßcé©aŠiëòíëìäÛaÖaŠÈÛaïÇbßBoÜucBoÏìëc
éîèäm bèäØÛë ÖaŠÈÛa ŠİLæcëÖaŠÈÛaÒìóÈíbÈíŠñ…bÇ⁄õbäi
éma‰†ÓòíŠØÈÛaòí†îÜÔnÛaËëòí†îÜÔnÛaò•béãcëÙÜn¹ñ¨aòîϊȽa
òÔÜÈn½aŠíìİniÜmÙLòzÜþaæcëpbiìÔÇáßþañ†zn½aåÛ|vämüg¿dm
ŠİÖaŠÈÛaÁÔÏN
@ @@ @
71
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
¿bç‰ë…óÜÇñ†zn½apbíüìÛaëòîiŠÌÛaÞë†ÛaæìãbÔÛaÊ늒ßâübà×
æc Š×‡ë Lòí†îÜÔnÛa Ë òzÜþa åß énãbŠm Šíìİni ÖaŠÈÜÛ bàÛa
ÈÛaŠİÚa‰…g¿pŠdmòjÓbÈn½aòî×ßþapbßìاaóÜÇoàÔãaëLÖaŠ
Þë…œÈiæcëò•bLìàäîÛoÓìÛaézäßb¾Šİ¨aaˆçÉßÝßbÈnÛa¿bèÐã
ÖaŠÈÛa†íëŒnioßbÓëõï‘Ý×ÖìÏòí…b–nÓüabè§b–ßoÜÇcòîiŠÌÛabi‰ëc
‰ë…µg æìãbÔÛa ÊëŠ’ß ‰b‘c bäçë LÝßb’Ûa ‰b߆Ûa òzÜc ŠíìİmpbjÜİn¶
ë òîãbİíŠië òîãb½cë òîãŠÏpb׊‘ òîë‰M ôŠc òîiŠË Þë…´i åßM
ðëìäÛaýÛaŠíìİmpbjÜİn¶ïÓaŠÈÛaâbÄäÛa†íëŒm¿oàçbN
ÑÓëóÜÇÝàÈÛa뉆ÛaáÜÈmñ‰ëŠ™†î×dniæìãbÔÛaÊ늒ßóènãaë
bàèãdi bàçbíg bЕaëÖaŠÈÛaëæaŠígÝjÓåßòzÜþaõbäiB¿´nÛë…Šİc
bÈÛaNB10
bÈÛaâbÄäÛaëÖaŠÈÛa†í†¦a
´yLpbäîÈnÛaÑ–näß¿a†í†ubîäzä߈cÖaŠÈÛaåß´×bßÑÓìß
jÈnÛa ¿´×bß c†iM Õbänßë †íaŒnß ÝØ’iM‰bØÏþa åß òÇìà© åÇ
ñ…bîÔi †í†¦a ï½bÈÛa âbÄäÛa bè’îÈí Ûa òîÛë†Ûa òÜyŠ½bi ò•b¨a ñ†í†¦a
ñÐi´×bßbèЕëÛaLb×ßcB†×dmâ†ÇBb«ëòîÛbnÛañÐÛaéj’mïÛë…
É™ëîÏìÛa…b¤⁄a‰bîèãaæc´×bßôc‰sîyLòîãbrÛaòî½bÈÛalŠ§aòíbèäÛ
aˆ‰ì–mõbäi¿´×bßc†iëL†í†¦aï½bÈÛaâbÄäÜÛÝØ’½aòãbØß¿b×ßc
ÛaÝßb’Ûa‰b߆ÛaòzÜcòÜØ’ßbèc‰óÜÇëéèuaìmÛa‰bİþaëbÈÛa
r×oİjm‰aLñÐÛaÙÜm Þý´×bß ‰bØÏckÜÓµg éioÈÏ…ëÖaŠÈÛbi a
ñ‰a…⁄ ʇü †Ôã bèÐÜË †í†¦a ï½bÈÛa âbÄäÛa åÇ ´×bß ‰bØÏc æcë ò•b
@ @
72
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
bÈÛa …ìÔí æìnäîÜ× æc ´×bß ôc‰sîy LæìnäîÜ× Ýîi ïaŠÔ¹†ÛaîöŠÛa
ìÐã ¿Òì¨aë õbÓ†•þaìÐã ¿ òÔrÛa ʉ‹ åÇ ñŒubÇ ñ……ß ñ…bîÓ
æìnäîÜ× ñ‰a…g òíú‰ lbîÌÛ |™ëþa Þbr½a ìç ÖaŠÈÛa æc ôc‰ë Lõa†Çþa
†í†¦aï½bÈÛaâbÄäÛañ…bîÓ¿ŠÄnä½ab×ßc‰ë†ÛòîÇaìÛaòîvîma⁄aN11
ÝîiîöŠÛa òßìØy ñ‰a…g õìæc òjbäßåß Šr×c¿´×bß Š×‡ bà×
òÈ åß rØÛa p‰†çc ÖaŠÈÛa †™ b×ßc òbîÛ æìnäîÜ×b×ßc
ñÐÛaÙÜm¿bÈÛaâbßcbènîÓa†–ßëN12
ñ…bîÓ¿b×ßc‰ë…òÈîjİÛê‰ì–mkÜÓ¿ÖaŠÈÛa´×bßÉ™ëÙÛˆië
Šàn߆îÈ–nÛbφçæìØíïØÛÖaŠÈÛaÝçcŠßcìçëL†í†¦aï½bÈÛaâbÄäÛa
pbäîÈnÛaô†ßóÜÇ´×bßÝjÓåßN
âbÇÑíŠïÐÏ1996ßcðŠØÇÚŠzni´×bßkÛb“î¦a†™ï×
´×b߈cëLÖaŠÈÛaÞbà’iòí…ŠØÛaï™a‰þaóÜÇbßìvçc†iðˆÛaïÓaŠÈÛa
âa†•´Ø·¿áçb b¾ÖaŠÈÛaÉßÝßbÈnÛa¿ énßaŠ•â†ÇæìnäîÜ×óÜÇ
übyÝšÏcpbiëòîÓaŠÈÛaï™a‰þaóÜÇñŠİîÛaå߆íŒßŠÏåß´y
´×bßôc‰ëLòîbîÛaëòíŠØÈÛa´nîybäÛaåß¿åàØmæìnäîÜ×òÜØ’ßæc
ÙÜm óÜÇ kÜÌnÛa åع éãcë LòíŠi lŠy ¿ Þì†Ûa åß ém‰a…g Òì
Òëb‚½a–´×bß ŠÄã òèuë åß–ïÛë…ðŠØÇÑÛb¤ õbäi ÕíŠ åÇ
ïÓaŠÈÛa“î¦a†™ðÛaðŠØÈÛa݆nÛa†ãbíN13
ÈnÛa¿æìnäîÜ×Ýîiñ‰a…gݒφ×ûí´×bßc†iéÐãâbÈÛaŠaëc¿ëÝßb
þaoäØßâa†–ÛòÐîÈšÛaæìnäîÜ×pa†í†èmæcóÜÇëLïÓaŠÈÛaâbÄäÛaÉß
@ @@ @
73
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
¿îÛ bèmaŠíˆ¤ëñ†zn½apbíüìÛaòîÓa†–ßoÐÈ™cëb熙ÒìÓìÛaåß
bÈÛaÇåØÛëê†yëÖaŠÈÛaN14
òÓ‰b½aáÄäÛaœíìÔm
àÏìã¿´×bßkÛbsîy†îÈ–nÛañmëpŠànaë2006ÝàÇå’i
× ðŠØÇÞý òî×ßþa paŠöbİÛa áubç ðˆÛa ïÓaŠÈÛa “î¦a †™ j
üg æìØí ü …ŠÛa æc ôc‰ë LÖaŠÈÛa Þbà’i òí…ŠØÛa Õbä½a ÖìÏ bèÔîܤ
BïibÔÇ ÝÈÐi Bbàènjîçë bàènîÓa†–ß œÈi b×ßcë æìnäîÜ× ñ‰a…⁄ …Ší
ÖaŠÈÛaÉßÝßbÈnÛa¿ñ…ìÔнaN15
a ݧa óÜÇ Šr×dÏ Šr×c Œ×Ší ´×bß c†ië¿ òí‰ëŠ™ ña…d× ðŠØÈÛ
LïÓaŠÈÛaâbÄäÛaÉßÝßbÈnÛa16ÇsîyMòjbäßåߊr×c¿Mê…bÔnÇaåÇ
ÕjðˆÛaïÓaŠÈÛaâbÄäÛapbîã¿énÔqâ†ÇåÇëLïbßìÜi†ÛaݧaÝ’Ði
énãbŠmõbäiñ…bÇ⁄ÖaŠÈÛaïÈ¿éãb¹gåÇÇbà×LéãauëéjÈ‘áubçë
aòí†îÜÔnÛaËòzÜþaåßÞbÓsîyLÝÈÐÛbibèäßéØÜn¹bßïбÛZ
Bé×ýnßa ¿ Šànß ÖaŠÈÛa æc †ÔnÈã bäÜÈ£Ûalbjþa Éîº ŠÏaìnm
bb–íg lìÜcë òîuìÛìîië òíëbàî× òzÜþ Næc óÜÇ òÛü… Úbäç îÛë
ð†ÛîÛ LØÈÛaóÜÇÝi LéãauÉß âý¿“îÈÛaµgÒ†èíÖaŠÈÛa
ŠÐÛa ozä ìÛ éãc ¿ Ù‘åßë LoíìØÛa ˆc òÛëbª ÖaŠÈÛa …bÇþ ò•
ÝîöaŠg߆m¿ò׉b’½aµgÒ†èíÖaŠÈÛaæc|™aìÛaNB17
âbÇÝöaëcˆäß´×bßkÛbaˆÛ1998îÌmòbîjniŠí†ÔmÝÓcóÜÇ
õbäië x‰b¨aë Ýa†Ûa ¿ òîÓaŠÈÛa ò™‰bȽa áÇ… Þýåß ïÓaŠÈÛa âbÄäÛa
@ @
74
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
ŠØÇÝàÈÛïàîÜÓgëïÛë…áÇ…ôc‰ëLïÓaŠÈÛaâbÄäÛa†™ÖbİäÛaÉaëð
oÓìÛaïšßæþñ†öbÐÛbi…ìÈíåÛïÓaŠÈÛaâbÄäÛaîÌm¿ŠdnÛaæc´×bß
òîiŠÈÛa Þë†Ûa Âbëc ¿ ò•b lŠzÜÛ †ãb½a ïÛë†Ûa ÑÛbznÛa ÑÈší
pbîÜàÇ å’Û bç†îídm ÉuaŠm åß óØn‘a Ûa Lòí…ìÈÛa òîiŠÈÛa òØÜà½b×
c¿ÖaŠÈÛbiòíŠØÇpbäîÈnÛaŠaëN18
æŠÔÛa ÊëŠ’ß åÇ ‰…b•lbİ óÜÇ éÐã âbÈÛa ¿´×bß ÉÓë bà×
†í†¦aï×ßþaProject for New American Century–tb¡þaŒ×Šß
…†¦a´ÄÏba‰bîmåÇajÈmŠr×þaM݆nÛbiæìnäîÜ×ÝîiîöŠÛakÛbİí
ÙÛˆi âbîÔÜÛ …a†Ènüaë ïÓaŠÈÛa âbÄäÛa îÌnÛLŠßþa kÜİm a‡g bíŠØÇ
ñ†zn½a áßþaë åßþa Ü© Êbºg óÜÇ Þì–§a ñ‰ëŠši †îÔnÛa â†Èië
Šßþa˜ì–¢N19
ñ†îÈiòîvîmagbèîäjmâ†ÈÛŠÄäÛaŠ–ÔiæìnäîÜ×ñ‰a…g´×bßáèmabà×
´yâa†•âbÄãîÌmóÜÇâìÔmÖaŠÈÛaêb£òÜßb‘ëô†½aN
BëòîvîmagóÜÇŠ–튬ìØÛaLÕîjİnÜÛòÜibÓëô†½añ†îÈiòz™a
áßÿÛ ñ‰…bj½aâbß‹Úiëòß‹þòß‹cåßÝÔänÛbi òî™a‰ë†jm ñ‰a…⁄aåØÛë
òîÄzÜÛabíbšÔÛaÉßÝßbÈnÛaáníïØÛëòubzÜÛbÔÏë´yâa†•ëcñ†zn½a
ÝjÓåßòîÓa†–ßpa‡òîvîmaglbîËÝÿëL†îÈjÛaô†½biâbànçüaæë…
É௠ñ‰a…⁄aåß bí‰ìª aõŒu æc bç…bÐß ò•ý óÜÇ b†mŠ¬ìØÛa
´yâa†–iòyb⁄aæìØíæcïÌjäíbänîvîmagNB20
ñ†ãb½abèÐÓaìßkjibãŠÏÝrßòîiŠÌÛaÞë†ÛaœÈi´×bßáubçbà×
òíŠØÇ òÜ» †Çì¶ âa†• Îýihi bãŠÏ âbèma †y µg´y âa†• âbÄäÛ
@ @@ @
75
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
c ŠßcìçëLꆙòî×ßcÝØ’i bîbßìÜi…p…‰Ûa òîãŠÐÛa òßìاawÇ‹
´×bßpbßbèmaóÜÇʇüN21
µëþaòîböŠÛaòîib‚nãüaénܻᚿ´×bßÞì…ÉßëI2000HÇ
ì™ìiMòÜà§aÝöaëc¿MòbîáabèîÜÇÕÜcòbîåÇBœíìÔm
òÓ‰b½a áÄäÛaB Éß ÝßbÈnÛa b×ßc óÜÇ ïÌjäí éãc ôc‰sîy LÞë†Ûa Šİ
îöŠÛaéiÝßbÈmðˆÛaéÐãlìÜþbi‰b߆ÛaòzÜcÚýnßüòîÇbÛaòÓ‰b½a
ïÈÛa k¯ éãcë LîÏìÛa …b¤⁄a Éß æb¯‰ †Ûbãë‰ ÕibÛa ï×ßþa
LïöbdžÛaÂb’äÛaëòßbÈÛaòîbßìÜi†ÛawßaŠiÞýåßáÄäÛaÙÜmœíìÔnÛ
ÜÛ ïbîÛaë ïÛb½aë ðŠØÈÛa ádžÛa Þý åßëÙÜnÛ ò™‰bȽapbÇbàv
|‘Š½a ìç ÖaŠÈÛa æcë LbèbÔ⁄ ïbßìÜi†Ûaë ïÛë†Ûa ÁÌšÛaë áÄäÛa
òîvîma⁄aÙÜmÕîjİnÛÞëþaN22
ÖaŠÈÛb×òÓ‰b½aÞë†ÛaòºbèߊİåÇénÜ»Þýt†¤´×bßægÝi
bîîö‰bφçbèîÜÇÞì–§apbiÛaô†½añ†îÈiƒí‰aì–ÛbiòîÛbà’Ûabí‰ì×ë
ÜnÛåßb×ßcòíbà§ïë‰b•†•ÁöbyõbäjiÝibÔ½a¿kÛbëLÞë†ÛaÙ
áÄäÛaÙÜmœíìÔmòîvîmagÕîjİm¿ÊaŠ⁄biëŠİ¨aÙÛ‡N23
x‰ìuð‰ìèà¦a|‘Š½aâbßcòí†îèànÛapbib‚nãýÛ´×bßæaŠ†Èië
hiòjÛbݽa¿´×bߊànaLòîböŠÛapbib‚nãüa¿‹bÏðˆÛa”ìiìîÜi…òÛa‹
òî×ßþa ñ‰a…⁄a pbíìÛëc òàÓ óÜÇ Ò†a ÙÛ‡ É™ìië ïÓaŠÈÛa âbÄäÛa
ñ†í†¦aòí‰ìèà¦aN
Bü pbiìÔÈÛa åØÛë LÖaŠÈÛa †™ bämbiìÔÇ ÝîÈÐm ñ…bÇg bäîÜÇ k¯
òîÛëc´yâa†–iòyb⁄aÝÈ£æcñ‰a…⁄aóÜÇk¯Lb煊жÝz×|Ü–m
@ @
76
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
ðˆÛa Šİ¨bÏ Lòî×ßþa òîu‰b¨a òbîÜÛÛa Ýßb’Ûa ‰b߆Ûa òzÜc éÜr·
kÜİníâa†•bèØÜn¹–Ší†ÔmÝÓcóÜÇ–åßÖaŠÈÛaŠíŠznÛbyìàa†èu
éãbîÌNB24
lbç‰⁄aóÜÇlŠzÜÛòÜjÔ½aòèj¦a
ta†yc †Èi Š–í æc biŠÌnß åØí òÔibÛa´×bßÑÓaìß óÜÇ õbäi
ànj åß Š’Ç ð…b§a2001òî×ßþa ñ‰a…⁄a òjÛbİß óÜÇâbÄã òÛa‹hi
´×bßꈥaðˆÛa…†’n½að‰ìÔ–Ûaózä½aìçbäçr½aåØÛëL´yâa†•
ÖaŠÈÛa lŠy ïuëŠß áçc Òb–ß ¿ éÈší ðˆÛaë †îÈ–Ûa aˆç óÜÇ
bèîÛg´Ça†ÛaëN
ÝjÔÏ11M9òÓ‰b½aÞë†Ûa¿ôŠí´×bßæb×MÖaŠÈÛabèc‰óÜÇëM
bÈÜÛ bèm…bîÔÛë b×ßc òîÓa†–½ a†í†èmÞë†Ûa ÙÜm ïÇbß Éß ò•b
´×bß Ê‰b †ÔÏta†yþa †Èi bßc LÝßb’Ûa ‰b߆Ûa òzÜc óÜÇ Þì–zÜÛ
òÓ‰b½a Þë†Ûa ´i ÁiŠÜÛM pbäîÈnÛa Šaëc ˆäß bçîÌni kÛb ÛaM
pbÇbà¦a†íëŒnÛbèîÈ¿åàØíáÄäÛaÙÜmŠİæcôc‰sîyLlbç‰⁄aë
bè߆‚nmÝßb‘‰bß…òzÜdiòîibç‰⁄ab×ßcòºbèß¿N
LôŠc òÛë…ðcÝjÓÖaŠÈÛa óÜÇ ñ†í†¦a ê‰bØÏc´×bßÕjÉjİÛbië
æìØíæck¯ÖaŠÈÛaæcôc‰sîyBòîÛbnÛaòèj¦aBlbç‰⁄aóÜÇlŠzÜÛ
ÖaŠÈÛa æþÙÛ‡ë LæbnãbÌÏc †ÈiM´×b½ bÔÏëMBÙÜn¹ B‰bß… òzÜc
ðëdíë LÝßb‘B´îibç‰⁄ak퉆nÛ Œ×aŠß Bc óÜÇÝ•aìm æc Õjë L陉
‰b–nbi éàØ° ÖaŠÈÛa æcë Lñ†ÇbÔÛa Éß ´îÓaŠÈÛa ´Ûëû½a åß …†Ç
Bïibç‰gBæcëLB†yaëŠİ¨æbèuë´îibç‰⁄aëÖaŠÈÛaNB25
@ @@ @
77
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ñ‰a…hiÖaŠÈÛaóÜÇlŠ§añbÇ…Šè‘cœÈiÉßÙÛ‡¿´×bßôëbm
ŒníìÐÛë Þìi áèc‰ óÜÇë L”ìi ìîÜi… x‰ìuîöŠÛaPaul Wolfowitz
ÕibÛaï×ßþaÊbφÛaŠí‹ëköbãM†ÜîÐßa‰†Ûbãë…–œÈjÛaôŠíðˆÛaë
”ìiìîÜi…x‰ìuñ‰a…gÝa…ÖaŠÈÛalŠyoàÇ…ÛaÞìÔÈÛaáçc†ycéãc
Š·ûßÞýÖaŠÈÛaóÜÇlŠ§a ñŠØÐÛ ŒníìÐÛëë´×bßxë‰sîy Lµëþa
ŠíaÏ ¿ ƒãìîß ¿ †ÔÇ ìmbäÜÛ2002Ûa ÙÛ‡ ¿ bèàÇ… sîy‰ìmbäî
Š·û½aŠšyðˆÛaæbßîÛÑí‹ìuÕibÛaïaŠÔ¹†ÛaN26
ˆäßñÐÛaÞýë11M9‰bß¿ÖaŠÈÛaëŒËónyë2003´×bßpbi
òÐÜn‚½abèvvyïuëŠßëlŠ§að†íûßáçc†ycN
ÝîöaŠ⁄ñ†ãbßòîbîÝàÇòävÜÛŠ·ûßâbßc´×bߊׇsîy–†ÔÇ
ÝíŠic¿2002MaŠÈÛaëŒËæcÁëþaÖŠ’ÛaµgòîaŠÔ¹†ÛakܯÒìÖ
áÄäÛa æc ´×bß ôc‰ sîy LÝîöaŠg åß òîiŠÈÛa Þë†Ûa ÑÓìß åzîë
îÌm æcë LÝîöaŠgë b×ßc ì− bèiìÈ‘ òîçaŠ× éuìm òí‰ìmbnØí†Ûa òîiŠÈÛa
ÁëþaÖŠ’ÛbiâýÛaÕîÔ¤óÜdžÇbíÒìbîaŠÔ¹…áÄäÛaÙÜmN27
Š·ûß¿´×bß Š×‡ë– ìíbß¿ †ÔÇ2002Mòî×ßþa òí…ìèîÛa òävÜÛ
American Jewish Committee–òîbîÛa pbàÄä½a áçc åß bšíc ïçë
æcëLïÓaŠÈÛaâbÄäÛaŠİòèuaì½bîÏb׆ÈíÊ…ŠÛaæcb×ßdiÝîöaŠ⁄ñ†ãb½a
ïÓaŠÈÛaâbÄäÛaîÌmæcëLlbç‰⁄aóÜÇlŠzÜÛòß…bÔÛaòèuìÛaìçÖaŠÈÛaæb×
âbLjäßòî×ßþaòßìØzÜÛbφç1998¿ŠÜnèiïÓaŠÈÛaâbÄäÛa´×bßéj‘bà×L
bîäîqýqpaë• bà× éîÜÇ–Ûa â†ÈilŠÌÛaë b×ßc bjÛbİßå튒ÈÛa æŠÔÛa
òîãbrÛaòî½bÈÛalŠ§apýíëµgëê…ìÈ•µg…bÓb¾ŠÜnçóÜÇN28
@ @
78
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
†×cë ´×bß …bÇ bà×Mñ†í†Ç ôŠc pbjbäß ¿MkÜu æc
LòÈÓìn½abèvöbnãëlŠ§aÒa†çcáçc†ycìçÁëþaÖŠ’ÛaµgòîaŠÔ¹†Ûa
óÜÇëïiŠÈÛaÝÔÈÛaóÜÇ ŠzÛaÞìÈÐß éÛæìØíÒìÖaŠÈÛa ŠíŠ¤æcë
Ýuc åß bèi òà×b§a áÄäÛa óÜÇ bèİÌ™ë b×ßþ òîiŠÈÛa lìÈ’Ûa áÇ…
Lý•⁄a29Òì…a†Ìiʉaì‘¿ò튧biÞbÐnyüaæcëb×ßcñ‰ì•å°
ÖìÔ§´î×ßþa òíbà¡æìàܽa ŠÈ’í b߆äÇ ò•bïßý⁄a bÈÛaÇ
ÖaŠÈÛbiæbã⁄aN30
Šİ‰aŠØmåßbÈÛaëòî×ßþañ‰a…⁄a´×b߉ˆylŠ§alaÓaÉßë
ôc‰sîyL´yâa†•óÜÇ–Ûaëcénã…bèßëcÖaŠÈÛaòºbèß¿……Ûa
ÔÏæ…bèíâa†•æcê†èÇÑÛbÛ…ìÈí bßæbÇŠëÂìÌšÛŠÈní´yÁ
æcÝjÓð‰ëŠ™æŁaÚŠznÛaæc´×bßôc‰bà×LÂìÌšÛaÙÜmÑ¥bàäîy
bjÈ•lŠ§a‰bî|j–íëòíëìãòzÜcÖaŠÈÛaÙÜn¹N31
lŠ§a왉bÈßbèuëŠíÛaÖaŠÈÛaõaìnyaòbîÝ’Ï´×b߆×cbà×
ïÓaŠÈÛa âbÄäÛa òÛa‹g òbî åÇ ýí†ibäؾ †Èí õaìnyüa æþ ÙÛ‡ë [
¿ÖaŠÈÛaÉßÞëþaòèuaì½aÁòîÛbÈÏâ†Çbèc‰óÜÇëLñ†í†Çlbjþ
ÖaŠÈÛbi òİîa òîiŠÈÛa Þë†Ûa æc ´×bß ôc‰sîy LêõaìnyaMòí…ìÈÛb×
bí‰ìëMêõa†Ç¿âa†•†ãbmÞë†ÛaÙÜmæcëLénèuaìß¿òãëbÈnßË
Ûa†¤bà×LÝîöaŠ⁄p†uëÛaòî×ßþapaìÔÛaò׊yòíŠyåßòí…ìÈ
æcë LïÓaŠÈÛaÁÐäÛakíŠèm¿âa†•ÉßæëbÈnm bí‰ìæcë Lbèî™a‰cóÜÇ
ÙÜm qdmë ïÓaŠÈÛa âbÄäÛa ÂìÔÛ òîÛbnÛa ñÐÛa åß ï’¥ òîiŠÈÛa Þë†Ûa
áèîÜÇñÐÛaN32
@ @@ @
79
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
sîyLÖaŠÈÛa õaìnyaóÜÇïiŠÌÛaÑÛbznÛa ñ‰†Ó¿´×bßÙØ‘bà×
bà×éîÜÇò™ëŠÐ½aòîÛë†ÛapbiìÔÈÛaÒbÈ™g¿âa†•†ÇbmbãŠÏæcôc‰
òèuaìß ¿ÑÈšÛbi bîãb½c áèma bà× Lbîë‰ Éß ò׉b’½bi lŠ§a‰bÈm
ÑÈšiëLéma‰aŠÓŠÏåÇåßþaÜ©ŒvÈiÞìÔÛaµgòÏb™gaˆçLâa†•
§a ‰aŠÓ ‡b¥a¿ ar×p……ŠmÛa bèma‡ òî×ßþa ñ‰a…⁄aâa†•òÛa‹gëlŠ
´yN33
òîbßìÜi†ÛaëõaìnyüaëÊ…ŠÛaÝ’ÏñŠØÐÛx뉆Ӵ×bßæìØíÙÛˆië
îÌmëlŠ§aôìÝí†iÚbäç†Èí éãþëïÓaŠÈÛa âbÄäÛa ÉßÝßbÈnÛa¿
ñ…a‰⁄a †ÔÇŠÐäí æc ÝjÓÙÛ‡ ÕîÔznÛ ñþa ò•ŠÐÛa éj’í bàîÏ âbÄäÛa
bšícòî×ßþaëòîÛë†ÛaN
b‘aˆÛábiÒŠÇbßñ…bîÓ¿´×bßÚ‰BÖaŠÈÛaŠíŠ¤òä¦Bòä¦ïçë
´îbîÛa×cåßa…†ÇášnÛœîiþaoîjÛaÝjÓåßòîäà™òÔÏaì¶oÜØ‘
âýÇ⁄aÝöbëpŠ×‡bà×òävÜÛaoÜàdžÓëLÖaŠÈÛaóÜÇlŠzÜÛ´àÇa†Ûa
óÜÇ lŠ§a áÇ†Û òîßýÇgë òîbî ÁÌ™ pý» áîÄäm óÜÇ òî×ßþa
ÈÛab×ßdiâbÈÛaðcŠÛaëòbîÛaòÓë‰cÝa…ÖaŠN34
òÛby¿åßþaÜ©ëñ†zn½aáßþbi†îÔnÛaâ†Èib×ßc´×bßô…bãbà×
LÖaŠÈÛa ëŒÌÛ áÇa… ‰aŠÓ ‡b¥a ¿ bàèÜ’Ï35ÖaŠÈÛa lŠy æc ôc‰ sîy
BòÛ…bÇBáßÿÛîÛë ï×ßþakÈ’ÜÛ ìç òî×ßþa òßìاa õüë æcë L
æcëLñ†zn½aõbЙgáqåßëåßþaÜ©pa‰aŠÓÕîjİnÛïçÖaŠÈÛalŠy
‰aŠÓ ‡b¥a ¿ åßþa Ü© Ý’Ï ìÛ óny pa‰aŠÔÛa ÙÜm óÜÇ òîÓa†–½a
lŠ§aN36
@ @
80
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
ò׊Ƚapì•ÖìÏìÜÈípì•ü
åÇÊbφÜÛ´×bßôãalŠ§aÚì‘ëÉßëBòÛa†ÇBìåÇëlŠ§a
ŠÈÛakÈ’ÜÛò튧akÜubèc‰óÜÇëLbèÏa†çc¿b×ßcòîÓa†–ßòíb»ëïÓa
paìÔÛa æc a†×ûß ï×ßþa ïßìÔÛa åßÿÛ ÖaŠÈÛa †í†èm òÛa‹gë bÈÛa
òî×ßþaB¿ Ýßb’Ûa ‰b߆Ûa òzÜc åß òÜöbç pbîà× óÜÇ ŠrÈm Òì
ÖaŠÈÛaBëŒÌÛa‰aŠÓ‡b¥a¿”ìiìîÜi…x‰ìuîöŠÛa⌧êŠí†ÔmóÜÇëL
akävnÛéÈë¿bßÝ×ÝÈÏæc†ÈilŠ§N37
¿ òî×ßþapaìÔÛa Ý’ÏëïÓaŠÈÛa âbÄäÛa ÂìÔëlŠ§a òía†i Éßë
ÖaŠÈÛbi Ýßb‘ ‰bß… òzÜc óÜÇ ‰ìrÈÛaMpa‰½ †ÔäÛa †Çb–nÛ ð…c b¾
lŠ§aM a†×ûß ò™‰bȽa paì•þapbØ⁄´×bß ôãaBén’ç… Båß
•æìØí æc òîãbØßg åßëÖaŠÈÛbi Ýßb‘ ‰bß… òzÜcóÜÇ ‰ìrÈÛa â†Çâa†
†Ó´yBʆBæcæë… bèØܹÛaÝßb’Ûa‰b߆ÛaòzÜcéØîØÐnibÈÛa
pa‰bj‚nüa ñŒèuþ ëc ´îÛë†Ûa òzÜþa ï’nн ëc b×ßþ ÙÛ‡ ojrí
òzÜþaÙÜnÛâa†•Úýnßa¿oØØ‘ÛaòîÛë†Ûaëòî×ßþaN38
aŠ⁄bi ÖaŠÈÛbi ´î×ßþa ´Ûëû½aë paìÔÛa ´×bß kÛb aˆÛ¿ Ê
œjÔÛaë òíŠØÈÛa énãbŠm õbäi¿ aì׉b‘åíˆÛaÖaŠÈÛa õbàÜÇåÇszjÛa
éäØÛëLòîÓaŠÈÛa|ÜnÛawßaŠiòÔîÔy´î×ßÿÛaìÐ’ØíæcÝßcóÜÇáèîÜÇ
ÝjÓåßↂníæck¯üòzÜþaÙÜmóÜljìrÈÛa¿ŠdnÛaæc†×cë…bÇ
óÜÇë bèîÜÇ âìvèÜÛë bç†ÔäÛ Šín×lŠ§a bÈßlŠ§a æþ [bèibjc
êjÈnÛbÔÏëBòÛ…bÇëòzîz•NB39
@ @@ @
81
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
B†í†èm†™ñ†zn½apbíüìÛaåßcåÇÊbφÜÛlŠ§aÙÜm bäi‰by†ÔÛ
éÜvÛë Lbè•ì–¢ ényaŠ• â†ÈÛë ñ†×û½a ´y âa†• òzÜc wßaŠi
Þbànyüë Lõaìnyüa òbîÛ É튽a Ý’ÐÜÛë LéãauóÜÇ õa†nÇübi˜b¨a
ibç‰⁄aÉßéãëbÈmïÓaŠÈÛakÈ’ÜÛï’yìÛaéÈàÔÛëL´îNB40
ÖaŠÈÛbi”ìiõbİc
éiaì•ë bç‰aŠÓ òz• åÇ éÇbÏ…ë ÖaŠÈÛa lŠ§ ÕÜݽa ´×bß †îídm
´îäȽaŠr×cåßéÜÈuòîbîÛaëòíŠØÈÛaénîÐÜëlŠ§bijØÛaéßbànçaë
bèybväiëlŠ§biN
ÖaŠÈÜÛ´×bß bèiâbÓ ñ‰bí‹Þëc†ÈiëMİËc¿2003–µg…bÇ
ÙÛbäçðŠ¯bàÇêb™‰â†ÇåÇpÇÛapbî•ìnÛaåßòÇìàv¶b×ßc
òî×ßþañ‰a…⁄aÝjÓåßlŠ§añ‰a…glìÜcåÇëN
éÛp†×cÖaŠÈÜÛém‰bí‹æc´×bߊׇsîyBlbçˆÛa¿´Ôªbä×bäãc
µgÖaŠÈÛa ŠíŠ¤ lŠyB æcë LBåß êŠíŠzni ky‰ ïÓaŠÈÛa kÈ’Ûa
a†jnüa…BÝíìznÛÚŠznÛaòÇŠibšíckÛbéäØÛëLBðŠØÈÛabväÛaB
µgBïbãBïÜíbßÕíŠåÇLZ41
M ÖaŠÈÛa åß ÝÈvn Ûa ÖaŠÈÛa åß lbzãüa ‰bØÏc åÇ ïÜ‚nÛa
BâbänîÏlŠyˆäßb×ßþò¹ŒçŠİcNB
M bßëbèniìÈ•ëlŠ§aòÐÜØm˜ì–¢ï×ßþakÈ’ÛaÉßòyaŠ–Ûa
bîzšmåßéjÜİnm¿Š–äÛaÕîÔ¤òÇŠiÞúbÐnÛa¿òÌÛbj½aœÏ‰ëp
ÙÛbäçlŠ§aN
@ @
82
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
M kØÛïÓaŠÈÛakÈ’ÜÛÞýnyüa†öaìÏëåßþakܦbÈíŠÚŠznÛa
òî×ßþapaìÔÛa¿énÔqN
M ÙÜm åàšnm æc óÜÇ ÖaŠÈÛa µg òî×ßþapaìÔÛa åß †íŒß Þb‰g
ÈÛaõbäiñ…bÇgòîÜàÇ¿æë†Çbí´îã†ßõapaìÔÛaÖaŠN
paìÔÛa êˆç…†Ç´×b߉†Ó†ÓëMpbjbä½aœÈi¿ë†Èi bàîÏM
ïÛaì¡100ï×ßcð†äuÑÛcN42
M ÖaŠÈÛa¿ï×ßþa‰ë†ÜÛñ†zn½aáßþaò׉bjßóÜÇÞì–zÜÛïÈÛa
ëŒÌÛa†ÈibßÖaŠÈÛñ†zn½aáßþaò׉bjàÏLÙÛbäçñ…bîÔÛabèöbİÇgæë…
þa ‰ë†ÛaóÜÇ òîÇŠ’ÛaïКmÒìæc a†ick¯ü bèäØÛë Lï×ß
ÖaŠÈÛbiñ…bîÔÛa|ä·N
ñ‰a…g Éß òèuaìß ¿ b†m ´×bß oÈ™ë òÔibÛa ñ†ÓbäÛa ‰bØÏþa
æìubnäjÛa Éß ò•bëlŠzÜÛ ém‰a…glìÜcë”ìi ìîÜi… x‰ìuîöŠÛa
ØÐmæc´×bßôc‰sîyL†ÜîÐßa‰†Ûbãë…ÕibÛaï×ßþaÊbφÛaŠí‹ëë
îí †ÜîÐßa‰…ìä¦aåßj× …†Èi ÉφÛaåßÒì¨aë âbänîÏ ñ†ÔÇ éîÜÇ Šİ
Áë bíbzšÛaåß×c …a†Çc ÊìÓëåß bÏìÖaŠÈÛalŠy¿´î×ßþa
´î×ßþa…ìä¦aN43
æþ [âbänîÏ îÛ ÖaŠÈÛa æc ñ†í†Ç pbjbäß ¿ †×c ´×bß åØÛë
Båí†mŠ½aBgëòz™aëòîäëÒa†çcµgæëŠÔnÐíëõbÐÈ™ÖaŠÈÛbiñìÓáÇ…µ
òîÛbà’ÛaâbänîÏpaìÓô†ÛÞb§aæb×bà×óàÄÇòîÛë…ML´×bßÝîÜznÛbÔÏë
òî×ßþapaìÔÜÛñ†ãbßòîÓaŠÈÛaòßìاaæcbà×N44
@ @@ @
83
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ò¹Œç¿kjníÒìâbänîÏòîÜÔÈiÖaŠÈÛa¿ØÐnÛaæc´×bßôc‰aˆÛ
óÜÇæcëLñ†í†uâbänîϵgÖaŠÈÛaÞ줿ëÖaŠÈÛbib×ßcòî×ßþañ‰a…⁄a
paìÔÛañ…bíŒÛëlŠ§apbiìÈ–iï×ßþakÈ’Ûaòy‰b–½ÉíŠÛaÚŠznÛa
â†Ç b×ßc óÜÇ ïÌjäí bà× L´ßŒèäà× ü õb׊’×´îÓaŠÈÛa Éß ÝßbÈnÜÛë
µg òuby¿´îÓaŠÈÛa æþ [ÖaŠÈÛa ¿ òîbîÛa òîÜàÈÛbi ÉφÛa ¿ ÝvÈnÛa
üëcåßþaN
늙a…†©´×b߆×cëÙÛ‡ë[ÖaŠÈÛaõbİcÚ‰a†nÛÉíŠÛaÚŠznÛañ‰
òíìİÜÛa òîiŠÈÛa áÄäÛa ò•bë b×ßc õa†Çc æþ–bí‰ìi Þbr½a bi‰b™
òí…ìÈÛaëMÖaŠÈÛa¿bväÛab×ßþæë†íŠíüN45
åçaŠÛaï×ßþaÝî¦að†¤
ÖaŠÈÛalŠy˜ì–¢òî×ßþa ñ‰a…⁄bi´×bß òÓýÇoÜ…ÙÛˆië
åß òÜyŠßİËc åßpŠànaÒý¨a2003 âbÇ Šaëc ónyë2006
Ší‹ë ´îÈmë †ÜîÐßa‰ †Ûbãë… ï×ßþa ÊbφÛa Ší‹ë òÛbÔna †è‘ ðˆÛa
ñ†í†u òîvîmagÕîjİm¿ õ†jÛaëníbupŠië‰ïÛb§aï×ßþaÊbφÛa
ñÐÛaÙÜmÞý´×bßbèàÇ…Ûa‰bØÏþaÉßj׆yµgÕibİnmN
bäçk¯ë ñÐÛaÙÜmÞýlŠ§aåÇ´×bßÊbÏ…æcµg ñ‰b‘⁄a
ý•hi´jÛbݽaë bèäÇ´ÈÏa†½a×c†yc bàöa…ÝÃÝiÑÈšíëcÑÓìní
†¤ áçc ïç ÖaŠÈÛa lŠy ædi ´×bß åße sîy LŠ–äÛa ÕîÔznÛ bç‰bß
æcëL|îz–ÛaoÓìÛa¿põbulŠ§aæcëLåçaŠÛaï×ßþaÝî¦aéuaìí
îÏ ‹ìÐÛaLb×ßþ rØÛa Èm ò¹Œa æþ [ñ‰ëŠ™ bç†Èi îÛ ñ‰ëŠ™ bè
@ @
84
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
Ê늒½aóÜÇïšÔmÒìëLñ†ÇbÔÛb× b×ßc õa†Çþ‰b–nãüaÈmÒìÏ
ò•ŠÏ ïİÈm Òìë LÁëþa ÖŠ’Ûbi òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa Š’äi ˜b¨a ï×ßþa
åÇ áubäÛa ÎaŠÐÛa õݽ ݆nÜÛ bí‰ìë æaŠíh× ´îàîÜÓ⁄a b×ßc õa†Çþ
üaï×ßþalbzãN46
BáçþaÞaûÛa˜ì–¢Za‡gñìÔÛbiLâa†•åß—Ü‚nÛak¯æb×Ýç
laì•óÜÇbä×_ŠßþakÜİmNŠßþa‰aŠØnÛ†ÈnßbãcëIÖaŠÈÛalŠyHñŠß
âìîÛaôŠcNB47
ñ†í†¦aòîvîma⁄a
¿´×bßÉ™ëÖaŠÈÛa¿Êb™ëþa‰ìç†m‰aŠànaæcÕibÛa¿bãŠ×‡
ßbyòèuaìß´×bßÇsîyL†ÜîÐßa‰†Ûbãë…ï×ßþaÊbφÛaŠí‹ëÉßòî
åÇBénÔqâ†ÇBlŠzÜÛém‰a…glìÜc¿ëcþa¿N48
¿ ñ†í†u òîvîmagwíëÛ énÓbåß aj× a‰†Ó´×bß—– aˆÛ
LòÜíìñÐÛëñj×òîàØiÙÛbäçòî×ßþapaìÔÛañ…bí‹óÜÇâìÔmÖaŠÈÛa49
biìÜcjmëŒ×ŠàníÛa òîÓaŠÈÛaÕbä½a ÞŒÇóÜÇ âìÔílŠ§a¿ a†í†u
áçbàŞbßbèîÏBåí†mŠ½biBåßëáèäßbçèİnÛÕbä½aÙÜmóÜÇŒî×Ûaáq
òî×ßþapaìÔÛaÉßbèÜçcÑbÈmk×ëbèj×áqN
ˆäß ò÷b òîvîmagoäjm †Ó òî×ßþapaìÔÛa æc´×bßôc‰ †Óë
ÈÛa âbÄäÛaÂìÔòqýqpb÷ϵgáèÐä•åíˆÛaåí†mŠ½aÉßÝßbÈnÛa¿ïÓaŠ
áçë Lòîîö‰Bæìí…bè¦aB´™aŠÛaËòäÛaë LæìîrÈjÛaë Lñ†ÇbÔÛaÞbrßd×
´yâa†•âbÄãÂìÔ†ÈibßÖaŠÇåÇN50
@ @@ @
85
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
biìÜc oäjm bç…a†Çc—Ôãkji òî×ßþa paìÔÛa æc ´×bß ôc‰ë
åí†mŠ½a ÉßÝßbÈnÛa¿ bîÇbÏ…Néãgt†¤óny ‰bÄnãüaóÜÇ †ànÈílìÜc
ñ–ÓñÐÛåí…Šàn½aœÈiñ…‰bݶòî×ßþapaìÔÛa bèîÜÇ…ŠmïØÛòq‰b×
ÑÓìnmáqN51
åßþaÕÔ°åÛëïq‰b×ëøbÕibÛalìÜþaæc´×bßôc‰ †Óë
ÖaŠÈÛa ¿ ï×ßþa Ê늒½a bväÛ ïîöŠÛa æbàšÛa ìçë L´îÓaŠÈÜÛ
â†Ôm ðc ÕîÔznÛë´×bß ôŠí bà× òîÓaŠÈÛa òßìØzÜÛ ð…b–nÓa ëc ïbî
†yaëáÓ‰òíìÛëþaìçåßþaÕîÔ¤æc†×cðˆÛaN
BÝy µg xbn° ÖaŠÈÛa ¿kÈ–Ûa É™ìÛa æc óÜÇ j× ÖbÐma Úbäç
ïbîN|îz•aˆçNÕjİãïØÛéubn−bßÚ‰†ãæcbšícbäîÜÇk¯åØÛë
ïbîÝyðcNˆdíæcÝîzn½aåßòbjið…b–nÓaëcïbîÂb’ãðc
âìîÛa …a†Ìi¿Þb§a ìç bà×ÑäÈÛa bèÓŒ¹ ò÷îi¿ êaŠ© NŠ‘ ìçåßþbÏ
ð…b–nÓaëcïbîâ†ÔmðþÕjßNB52
òî×ßþapaìÔÛaòîÛëûßìçÖaŠÈÛa¿åßþaÕîÔ¤æc´×b߆×cbà×
æc´×bßôc‰sîy LïÓaŠÈÛa“î¦a òîÛëûßæìØmæcÝjÓ bç†yëòàèß
k¯üë Lòî×ßþapaìÔÜÛ ñ†Çbß òàèß òîÛb§a ñÐÛa¿ïÓaŠÈÛa“î¦a
µëþa´î×ßþaòîÛëû߆ÈíðˆÛaåßþaÕîÔ¤¿bèîÜÇÝíìÈnÛaN
ñ…bîÔiòîÓaŠÈÛaòßìاaõa…cåÇêb™‰â†ÇåÇòÐÜn«pbjbäß¿Çë
è½aôìnßµgóÓŠmübèãcôc‰ónyïØÛb½að‰ìã¿áöbÔÛað†znÛaëcòà
ÖaŠÈÛaN53
@ @
86
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
ÖaŠÇâbîÔÛê†îídmåÇbiŠÈßÖaŠÈÛaáîÔniò•b¨apbyaÓüa‰bÇë
kjiÝîznßÖaŠÈÛaáîÔmæbiê…bÔnÇaåÇëbîäë´îÓaŠÈÛa…b¤üë†yìß
áîÔnÛ òÛëbª ðc æc Èí aˆçë œÈji áèšÈi jØÛa ´îÓaŠÈÛa Âýna
†u òÐÜØß æìØm Òì ÖaŠÈÛaîÛ ÖaŠÈÛa áîÔm æcë òíbÌÜÛ òjÈ•ë a
BübÈÏa‰bîNB54
æc a…†© ´×bß †×c bà×BŠ–äÛa Bkbä½a †Çì½a ìç ÖaŠÈÛa ¿
paìÔÛa…†ÇÝîÜÔnÛëclbzãýÛòîäß‹Þëa†uðcÉ™ëæcëLlbzãýÛ
æcëÖaŠÈÛbiòî×ßþaÒa†çþaóÜÇkÜÛbiüg…ìÈíåÛbèÜí췜Шëc
ÈÛa¿dݨaô…ûí†ÓÖaŠ–´î×ßþa†äÇ–âbänîÏåß×còq‰b×µgN55
¿ †ÜîÐßa‰ †Ûbãë… ï×ßþa ÊbφÛa Ší‹ë òÛbÔnbi ´×bß ky‰ aˆÛ
àÏìã2006ñ†í†¦aòîvîma⁄aÕîjİnÛò•ŠÏbèãcôc‰ëLN56
pbî•ìm ´×bß ‰bÇ ïàîÜÓ⁄a ݧbi ÕÜÈní bàîÏëBòÇìà© ŠíŠÔm
ÖaŠÈÛaòa‰…BÛaàí…¿‰…b–2006ñ‰ëŠšiÞìÔÛa´×bߜωsîyL
òîÜàÇ¿â†ÔnÛa´iÁiŠÛa ñŠØωbÇëÖaŠÈÛaòÜØ’½ïàîÜÓgÝy…ìuë
òîiŠÈÛaâýÛaMLbí‰ìëcæaŠígòã…bèߜωëLÖaŠÈÛa‰aŠÔnaëòîÜîöaŠ⁄a
ïmdíæck¯üéäØÛëLlìÜİßÖaŠÈÛa‰aŠÔnaÕîÔ¤¿bèãëbÈmæcôc‰ë
icbàèîÜÇò™ëŠÐ½aòîÛë†ÛaÂìÌšÛaÑîÐ¥lbyóÜÇa†N57
kÛb†Ó´×bßæb×ëMÕibÉ™ìß¿M†îÐnmædi òîiŠÈÛaÞë†Ûa
Þýåß ÖaŠÈÛa õbäi ñ…bÇg ¿×c ‰ë…kÈÛ¿ÁÐäÛa ‰bÈc ÊbÐm‰a åß
ÙÛˆi˜bÖë†ä•õb’ãgN58
@ @@ @
87
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ñþaò•ŠÐÛa
Ûañ…bí‹òîvîmagÕîjİm¿õ†jÛaÉßëpaìÔMâbÇÝöaëc¿2007M
İËcˆäß´×bßbèikÛbÛa2003´ÜöbÐn½abèí†ãbß×cÉjİÛbipbi
óÜÇ ïšÔí æc …b× Þìèß ïbîë ïßýÇg †Ôã Ýà ¿ òîib¯⁄a bèvöbnäi
òî×ßþaòböŠÛapbib‚nãa¿´×bßìà2008ÞëþaõŒ¦a¿bäyŠ‘bà×
òa‰†ÛaåßN59
ß ôc‰ sîy ñ†í†¦a òîvîma⁄a æc ´×bBñþa ò•ŠÐÛa ïçB
ÖaŠÈÛa¿ñ‰b¨aáqåßëbèÔîjİm¿Ý’ÐÛaæcëLÖaŠÈÛa¿‹ìÐÛaÕîÔznÛ
ñ…bí‹ òîvîmag åÇ ÊbφÜÛ Šànß ÝØ’i ôãa aˆÛ [òîq‰b× æìØmÒì
bèß†Ó Ûa ñ†í†ÈÛa Éí‰b’½a †™ ò•b Š¬ìØÛa òÓë‰c ¿ paìÔÛa
Û æ왉bȽalbzãü òîäß‹ Þëa†u É™ìi ëc bèÜíì· åß †zÜÛ lŠzÜ
ñìÔi´×bß b虉bÇÛapaìÔÛaMÉÓìnß ìç bà×MæbîäiÉîà¦a bjÛbİß
ÙÛbäç ò¹Œa æþ [ÖaŠÈÛa ¿ Š–äÛa ÕîÔ¤ óÜÇ Œî×Ûaë éöbİcë ï™b½a
áç†yë´í‰ìèàvÜÛëc”ìjÛübèÈîºb×ßþò¹ŒçæìØmÒìN60
Bbz™aëpbiÉšã æc æë…lbzãýÛ a†Çìß Éšã æc bääع ü éãc
bäãhÏ ‰aŠÔnüaåßóã…þa †§a æë†iÖaŠÈÛa bä׊m ìÛë LâýnýÛ a†Çìß
lŠ§aë lbç‰fiÛ a‡ýßë ïÓŠÈÛa Þb–÷nüaë ó™ìÐÜÛ ñìÇ… ŠÏìã ÙÛˆi
æaŠígõýàÇéîÏÝŠíoÓë¿ïãaŠí⁄a‡ìÐäÛaå߆íŒßµgìdžãëLòîàîÜÓ⁄a
þapbîÜàÈÛaÁîİ¥¿æë†Çbíë …‰aì½aæëŠÏìíë´ÜmbÔ½aæìi‰†íë òzÜ
ÖaŠÈÜÛ ‰aŠÔnüakܦ bã…ìèuâ†çë´î×ßþa …ìä¦aÝnÔÛ NNNNæb× a‡g
ÁëcÖŠ‘âbîÔibàÛaÝà’mæck¯ýÏLóäÈßðcïßìÔÛabääßcñ†àÇþ
@ @
88
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
‡ý¶ õïÜßë òÈaë òîàîÜÓg lŠy é׊¤ë æaŠíg éîÜÇ ´àèmpa
´îibç‰fiÛNB61
bîãbq@Z´îäîİÜÐÛaë@ÝîöaŠg@ @b–½a óÜÇ âìÔm òÓýÇÝîöaŠhi b×ßc òÓýÇ æc´×bß æìuôŠí
òzÜ–½ b™bÐšÏ bÐíŠÈmóäjní éãcÙÛ‡Èíë L´nÛë†Ûa´i ò×’½aáîÔÛaë
æë…ÝîöaŠgádžÛò튡݆nÛab×ßþåàšíÝîöaŠhibènÓýÇ¿b×ßc
–ß ŠÏaìm æc a†×ûß ÙÛ‡ Îìm òíìîy bBáçc †yc ìç ÝîöaŠg õbÔi
†ÜjÛaaˆçpbßaŒnÛaIb×ßcHòîÓýþaB62N
ð…b½a ádžÛa Ý× áí†Ôm b×ßc óÜÇ ïÌjäí éãg ´×bß ÞìÔí aˆÛ
éãc a‰aŠØm †×ûíë ÝîöaŠg éubn¤ ðˆÛa ðŠØÈÛaë ïuìÛìäØnÛaëBánzní
b×ßc óÜÇ–þa bèßaŒnÛa µg òÏb™⁄bi ÝîöaŠg åßc æbàši ïÓý–æc
bèÐãåÇÊbφÜÛbèubn¤òíŠØÇbîuìÛìäØmëòzÜcðdiÝîöaŠg…ëŒmB63N
c†jß Õîjİm ´×bß œÏŠíëBòîÓýþa ñaëb½a B´i ÝßbÈnÛa ¿
L´îäîİÜÐÛaë ´îÜîöaŠ⁄a64´i ´×bß ðëbí æc ÝibÔ½a ¿ ÝšÐíë
äîİÜÐÛapbÇbà¦a ÉßÝîöaŠgpbÇaŠ•bß †™ b×ßclŠyë òzܽa òî
éîàíBïÛbØí…aŠÛaïßý⁄aÒŠİnÛbiBL65pbàvç´iÁi‰´×bßægÝi
ànjåߊ’Çð…b§a2001ÝjÓåßÝîöaŠg bŠÈnmÛapbàvaë
¿ ÝîöaŠ⁄ ñ†ãbß b×ßc òàÄäß âbßc éÛ lbİ ¿ ´îäîİÜÏ ´zÜß
ÝíŠic2002aŠgë b×ßc æc a†×ûß Lìç a†yaë aë†Ç æbi‰b¤ Ýîö
Blbç‰⁄aNB66
@ @@ @
89
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
‰bß¿ÝîöaŠ⁄´×bßñ‰bí‹Þýë2008ñ‰bí‹óÜÇ´×bߘŠy
âbÔnãýÛ bèiŠy¿ÝîöaŠ⁄ém†ãbßåÇjÈnÜÛ òîÜîöaŠ⁄ap뉆îòäí†ß
ïÔÜİß óÜÇ …ŠÛa ¿ ÝîöaŠg Õy a†×ûß âbÔÛa ƒí‰aì• ïÔÜİß åß
ÜÇ Ší‡bª ðc É™ë æë… ƒí‰aì–Ûa†Èí bß ìçë LïÜîöaŠ⁄a ÝÈÐÛa …‰ ó
òîu‰b¨a ñŠí‹ë p‰ˆy sîy ˜ì–¨a aˆèi ”ìi ñ‰a…g åÇ bÏýna
†ÓëL´îㆽaÝnÓëñìÔÜÛŠнaâa†‚nüaòjÌßåßÝîöaŠgía‰aŒîÛ†ãì×
´×bß pb°Š–m œÈjÛa nÇaBòã‹aìnß Ë B†îÛ bÓýg åß éäàšnm b½
í ´×bßæcë ò•b LÝîöaŠgáÔ– òÜyŠÛaÞýMòîiŠÌÛa òКÛa ñ‰bíŒi
LbjÇ …ìઠîİÜÐÛa îöŠÛbi ïÐmbç Þb–ma õaŠuhi óÐn×aë67Þýë
p뉆îïÛbçþ´×bߊׇñ‰bíŒÛaZ
BbäÛa éîÏ“îÈí æc åع É™ëîÛ aˆç Nåß õïuc bãc òÔîÔ§a¿
òí…ë†y òíüëIbãëŒí‰cHÇ ƒí‰aì–Ûa æìÔÜİí bãc ÙÛbäç æb× ìÛë LóÜ
a†uÞbÈÏ…Šiæë…bäíÒìíüëaìßæc†ÔnÇdÏLíüëNNNáníb߆äÇ
óÜÇ …ŠÛa …ŠÐÛa óÜÇk¯ LâbÔnãüaë …ŠÛbi …ŠÐÛa âìÔí L…ŠÐÛa óÜÇ âìva
pbàvaNB68
lŠÈÛaÌníónyâýü
´îäîİÜÐÛa´iâýÛaòîÜàÈÛïöbèãÒ†è×´nÛë†Ûac†jß´×b߆ãbí
îÜîöaŠ⁄aëpü‹bäm ðc áí†ÔnÛ ÝîöaŠg óÜÇ ÁÌšÛa œÏŠí éäØÛë L´
ÝjÓ åß pü‹bäm ðc kÜİní ü âýÛa ÕîÔ¤ æc ôŠí ìèÏ L´îäîİÜÐÜÛ
ÝîöaŠhi ÞìjÔÛa áèîÜÇ ïÌjäí åíˆÛa lŠÈÛa †îi ìç âýÛbÏ LÝîöaŠg
bç…ìuëëN
@ @
90
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
LÝîöaŠg…ìuìÛlŠÈÛaœÏ‰ìçâýÛalbîËkjæc´×bßôŠí‡g
œÏ‰ ìçëÞë… bèàdžm Ûa bîÛbyb» Ýrß òîäîİÜÏpbÇbº éi åßûm
†™ bèiìÈ‘ õa†ÇwuûmÛa òíìİÜÛa òîiŠÈÛa áÄäÛa évuûm bà× LæaŠíh×
bèöbÔiæbàšÛòîbîÛabènjÈÛåà™b×ßcëÝîöaŠgN69
ÝrßpbÇbº óÜÇ ÁÌšÛakÜİní âýÛa ÕîÔ¤ ædi ´×bß åßûí aˆÛ
Çë bèöaìnya Þý åß b»ÊŒämë ÝîöaŠhi ÒÈm óny bç‰b–yë bŒ
LâýÛa òîÜàÈiÝjÔmë bèyý70ÝîöaŠgëbÐnÛ éšÏ‰ ´×b߆×ûí bà×
éîàíåßÉßBîİÜÐÛalbç‰⁄biNB71
âýÛa ÕÔzníëM´×b½ bÔÏëMŠ’ãë òîiŠÈÛa áÄäÛa îÌm Þýåß
´×bß bèi kÛb òbî ïçë LïiŠÈÛa bÈÛa ¿ òîaŠÔ¹†ÛaŠaëc ˆäß
¿ ´×bß Š×‡sîy L´y âa†• âbÄã òÛa‹hi c†jm bèãc ôc‰ëpbäîÈnÛa
âbÇ éÛ lbİ1999lŒzÜÛ åí†ãb½a ´î×ßþa …ìèîÜÛ ÑÛb¤ âbßc
ïÜíbßLð‰ìèà¦aZ
B݆mÛaáÄäÛaòÈîjåØÛëLáöa†ÛaâýÛaåàšíüï™a‰þaÞ…bjm
pbÓbÐmüa êˆç ¿IâýÛa åàší åß ïçH Nñ†bÐÛaë òí…a†jnüa áÄäÛa
bänÐîÜyéîÏkÛbİãðˆÛaoÓìÛa¿ëLåí†îuâýõb׊‘ÝØ’müòíŠØÈÛaë
òîaŠÔ¹†ÛaIÝîöaŠgHîÌm¿†ÇbãæcbäîÜÇk¯LâýÛaÝucåßñŠb‚½bi
t…byìç bà× òíbÌÜÛ ñŠİòÔİäßÁëþaÖŠ’ÛaoÜÈuÛaáÄäÛa òÈîj
aŠgòÛë…âbîÓˆäßÝîö NÝrßñ†jnßëòí…bÈßáÄãåß—Ü‚nÛaóÜÇñ†Çb½a
âýÛa˜ŠÏåßñìÔi†íŒíÒì´yâa†•âbÄãNB72
@ @@ @
91
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
aj× aŒÏbyÝr¹ÒìÖaŠÈÛa ŠíŠ¤ æc Še É™ìß¿´×bß ÞìÔíë
ÞìÔí‡gLÁëþaÖŠ’ÛbiâýÛaòÜvÇÉφÛZ
Bbšß òvy Ýr¹ Òì ñ‰Ša …a†Ìi ʉaì‘ ¿ ò튧bi ÞbÐnyüañ…
ÒìÏ LîİÜÐÛa ÊaŠ–ÜÛ òÛë†Ûa ÝjÓ åß éuì½a ïiŠÈÛa âýÇ⁄a ÝîÜšnÛ
kÈ’ÜÛ ïÈîj ÑîÜy ïç ñ†zn½a pbíüìÛa ædi lŠÈÛa åí†jn½a Š×ˆm
ò튧aµgìj–íðˆÛaïiŠÈÛa NÝr¹ü ñ†jn½aáÄäÛaÉàÓåßlŠÈÛa ŠíŠ¤
éÛ õbÐÜy áçnÈí åíˆÛa åí†jnàÜÛ ëc pbÏŠÇ ŠbîÛ òíìÛëc NòàÈã kÜu
áèmbîy´znÛ ar×ÝÈÐíÒìïiŠÈÛakÈ’ÜÛò튧aIlŠÈÛa Håߊr×c
ÝîöaŠg†™áç…bèuNB73
áí†ÔnÛ ÝîöaŠg óÜÇ ÁÌšÛa ïÌjäí ü òÔibÛa Â늒Ûa ÕîÔ¤ æë†ië
æc†ÔnÈíðˆÛa´×bßôŠí bà×òiìnØßpa†çbÈßÝucåßlŠÈÜÛpü‹bäm
hi áèÏaÇa aìjzíæcåعlŠÈÛaLoÓëðc¿ bèÈß áèßýëÝîöaŠ74
ÝîöaŠgóÜÇÁÌšÛaæcë–òÔibÛaÂ늒ÛaŠÏaìmæë…Mµgügð…ûíåÛ
ÝibÔßb蹆ÔnÛpü‹bämBòi‡b×âýâbçëcNB75
“íbÈnÛaüÝ–ÐÛa¿åçaŠÛaݧa
µg´×bßìdžíLáèÐãclŠÈÛa|Ü–íëòÔibÛaÂ늒ÛaÕÔznmónyë
ÔznÛ ÑÜn« c†jß jm´îäîİÜÐÛa ´i Ý–ÐÛa c†jß ìçë LâýÛa Õî
´îäîİÜÐÛaÊbäÓg¿oÜ’ÏìÜëcòîàÜÇæcôŠíìèÏL´îÜîöaŠ⁄aë“îÈÛbi
óÜÇ âìÔmôŠc òîvîmahi ba†jnak¯ aˆÛ [´îäîİÜÐÛa Éß âý¿
´×bß †íûí aˆèië LaëÌní óny ´îäîİÜÐÛa åÇ bèÜ–Ði ÝîöaŠg òíb»
@ @
92
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
îvîmaaóÜÇë ÝîöaŠg bçbäjnm Ûa ´îäîİÜÐÛaë ÝîöaŠg ´i Ý–ÐÛapb
oyŠæcˆäßòîvîmafiÛê†îídm´×bßåÜÇcsîyLÝ–ÐÛaÁöbybèc‰
Úa‰bi…ìèígÕibÛaïÜîöaŠ⁄aõa‰‹ìÛaîö‰ÝjÓåßñŠØÐ×N76
B´îäîİÜÐÛaë ´îÜîöaŠ⁄a æc òî™ŠÏ óÜÇ òîäjß ìÜëc âý òîÜàÇ
a bàèäعbÈß“îÈÛ Nåß bàèäØ·kîÛbc òiŠvnÛoÓìÛa æby éãc †ÔnÇc bãc
´Ü–Ðäß“îÈÛa NNNb¸gë LÝßÿÛ ŠÔnнa ïbîÛa É™ìÛbi üìjÓîÛ aˆç
åßûmòîäîİÜÏñ…bîÓŠèÄmónyæbßc¿ÝîöaŠgkÈ‘“îÈíæcÝßdiÞìjÓ
Õ¡âýÛbiNB77
âbÇ ¿ ÝîöaŠg µg éÛ ñ‰bí‹ ¿ ´×bß kÛb †Óë2003âŒnÜm ædi
âbÇ…ë†yóÜÇÊbİn½a‰†ÔiêõbäiádžíðˆÛaÝ–ÐÛaÁöbyõbäjiÝîöaŠg
1967æcŠ×‡sîyLBéÈÓìߘ얢æì’Ìí´îÜîöaŠ⁄aIÝ–ÐÛaÁöbyNH
Šr×cÝØ’i‰aìþaêˆçaìäjíïØÛbäÜjÓåß´îÜîöaŠ⁄aóÜÇÁÌšÛak¯
òîÇŠ‘BL78½aåßñ†yaëòq…b§aêˆç†Èmb¶‰ëbèîÏkÛbÛaòÜîÜÔÛapbjbä
ÝîöaŠgóÜÇÁÌšÛbib×ßc´×bßN
òîîö‰pbibugýiòİ’ãòîbßìÜi…
¿´îÜîöaŠ⁄aë´îäîİÜÐÛa´iâýÛaòîÜàÇÝî•bÐniÕÜÈníbàîÏbßc
åßûí ´×bß æc |™aìÛbÏ LòböŠÛa ´×bß ïÛìm òÛby– ïbc ÝØ’i–
aŠ⁄a´i Ý–ÐÛa òîvîmahiåß bçËóÜÇ bè߆Ôíë´îäîİÜÐÛaë´îÜîö
aˆçægëLåçaŠÛaoÓìÛa¿´ÏŠİÛa´iÊaŠ–ÛaÝ¡òÔÜÈn½aòîbîÛaÝöa†jÛa
åØísîyLâýÛaòîÜàÇêb£òİ’ãòîbßìÜi…jméߌÈiÞìÔÛaåßÉä¹ü
@ @@ @
93
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
lþa”ìix‰ìubçbäjmÛaòİ’äÛaòîbßìÜi†ÜÛlbvÇ⁄aëŠí†ÔnÛa´×bß
‹ëëLâýÛaéîÜàÇêb£ŠØíbi¹buénîu‰bŠí79òîàçc ´×b߆×ûí bà×
ÙÜm Ýa… âýÛa òîÜàÇ òîàçc óÜÇë énîvîmag ¿ Áëþa ÖŠ’Ûa
òîvîma⁄aN
†íŠíÛa òİ’äÛa òîbßìÜi†ÛaÝî•bÐmÞìyòîÏb×pbßìÜÈߊÏaìnmüë
góÜÇÁÌšÜÛ‰ŠØn½aéšÏ‰Ýÿò•b´×bßbèÈjníæcéÜîšÐmëÝîöaŠ
´×bß òîã Ö†• åÇ òîÏb× pbßìÜÈß ŠÏaìnm ü bà× LÝ–ÐÛa òîvîma⁄
¿ òİ’äÛa æìnäîÜ× Ýîi òîbßìÜi… ´×bß †Ônäí sîy LŠßþa aˆç˜ì–¢
æìnäîÜ×æþ[ÁëþaÖŠ’ÛaâýòîÜàÇ–´×bßôŠí bà×–óÜÇÁÌ™
Lï×ßcîöŠ×émaˆÛï–‚‘†©ÕîÔ¤ÝucåßÝîöaŠg80Š·û߆Ônäíbà×
âýÛaòÜvÇÙíŠznÛòîãbrÛaéníüëòíbèã¿”ìiîöŠÛa…ìèuëîÛìibãc
ÁëþaÖŠ’ÛbiN81
LâýÜÛ îİÜÐÛa Ù튒Ûa lbîË åÇ ‰ŠØnß ÝØ’i ´×bß t†zníë
âýÖbÐmaµgÞì•ìÛaòÛbznaåÇëLéÐÈšiê‰ìÈ‘ëbjÈÛêŠí†ÔmåÇë
†×ûíëLòäçaŠÛaòÜyŠ½a¿Ýßb‘âýÛaÝî•bÐm¿ØÐnÜÛòuby…ìuëâ†Ç
éÈßëbÐnÛaåعëâýÛbiåßûíîİÜÏÙ튑†uìíónyN
BâýÜÛ bØ튑 ÝîöaŠgp†ÔnÏa b½b Ý° åÛ ÝjÔn½a NåÇs톧a
ŠØmb»æcb½béãaëþÕib´™ëbÐßåÇëc´ÏŠİÛaÝjÓåßpü‹bäm
óÜÇõbšÔÛaëÑäÈÛaâa†‚nübèÐãÝîöaŠgNB82
ŠbíÝyaŠÛaîİÜÐÛaîöŠÛa¿énÔqâ†ÇåÇjÈnÛa´×b½Õj†Óë
õa‰‹ìÛaîö‰ÉßâýÛapb™ëbÐßÝ’ÏòîÛëûß´×bßéÜ»ðˆÛaLpbÏŠÇ
@ @
94
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
LæìnäîÜ×Ýîiï×ßþaîöŠÛa†èÇŠaëc¿Úa‰bi…ìèígïÜîöaŠ⁄a83sîy
ÄäßâbßcbçbÔÛcòàÜ׿pbÏŠÇåÇ´×bߊׇâbÇÑî•¿Úbjí⁄aòà2001
æcBↂna†ÔÛ LÑäÈÛaóÜÇéjÈ‘syëLæìníŒÛaå–ÌÛüÞbÓpbÏŠÇ
pb™ëbнaòÛëbóÜÇéí†íòíìÔnÛbèàÄãÛaò™bÐnãüaB´×bßkÛbbà×L
pbÏŠÇòÜßbÈßåÇÑÓìnÛañ‰ëŠšiBâýÛaÕîÔ¤†íŠíòÛë…ÝyŠ×NB84
åß éÐÓìß åÇ s톧a ´×bß Ýuûí aˆÛñ‰ëŠ™ Ýrß òßbç Ýî•bÐm
âbDž놧ñ…ìÈÛa1967ÙÜmåÇs톧aæc´×bßôŠísîyLpbäìn½aë
îİÜÏâýÙ튑µgŠÔnÐmÝîöaŠgoßa…bßóäÈßýibíbšÔÛaN85
òà•bdžÔÛbiÒaÇýÛê†îídmåÇ´×bßÇÙÛ‡åßáËŠÛaóÜÇë
ÑÓìß ìçë LÚbäç òî×ßþa ñ‰bÐÛa ÝÔãë ÝîöaŠ⁄âbÇ ˆäß ´×bß êbäjní
1997îöŠÛas°„ìî’ÛaÜ a‰aŠÓ´×b߆ãbsîyLŠí†ÔmÝÓcóÜÇ
ÝîöaŠ⁄òà•bdžÔÛbiÒaÇüaóÜÇæìnäîÜ×ÝîiN86
´×bßñ‰†Ó¿æìØØ’íåßÚbäçëMbîö‰|j•cbßa‡gMõbÏìÛaóÜÇ
…ìÇìiïÐíÝu‰´×bßæcôŠíåßÚbäçÝibÔ½a¿L†ÇìÛaaˆèiŠÄäÛaœÌiê
˜b¨aÕibÛaéÐÓìßæýÇg¿……í´×bßæcbäçÅyýíëLkÓaìÈÛaåÇ
âbÇ¿´î×ßþalŠÈÜÛ É࣠âbßc êbÔÛclbİ¿†ÔÛbi1999b߆äÇ
âbÇpbib‚nãa¿òî×ßþaòböŠÜÛ bz‘Šßæb×2000Á‚‰bqcŠßcìçëL
´×bßéiéidíŠßcìçëL‰ìš§a87N
ÌÛa ¿ë ´×bß Œ× kÛbM îöŠ×MÉß ´nÛë†Ûa ݧ éàÇ… óÜÇ
ôŠíbà×ïÜa†Ûaý•fiÛ´îäîİÜÐÛaóÜÇÁÌšÛa¿ïîöŠÛaéÜÔqÉ™ë
´ÄÏba ‰bîm µg áèöbànãbi ´ÏëŠÈ½a òîu‰b¨a æëû’ÜÛ éí†Çbß ×c †yc
@ @@ @
95
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
L…†¦a88ˆäß îİÜÐÛa ý•⁄a óÜÇ Œî×Ûa òbîi ´×bßky‰sîy
èyŠâbÇ ¿ æë‰b‘ Ýí‰g ÕibÛa ïÜîöaŠ⁄a õa‰‹ìÛa îö‰ë ”ìi b
2002L89´iÝ–ÐÛaòbîÝîšÐniò•b¨a´×b߉bØÏcÉßó‘bàníŠßcìçë
æìîäîİÜÐÛa |Ü–í ónyë òîÛb§a ñÐÛa ¿ ´îäîİÜÐÛaë ´îÜîöaŠ⁄a
áèÐãclŠÈÛaëN
òÜ–ÐßÁİÉ™ìÛéšÏ‰åÇòÓŠÐnßå×bßc¿´×bßÇaˆÛâýÜÛ
´îÜîöaŠ⁄aë´îäîİÜÐÛa´ióÜÇâìÔmâýòîÜàÈiòjÛbݽbiïÐnØísîyL
c†jßBñìİ¢ ñìİB¿ âýÛa òîÜàÇ ‰bßóÜÇ õïİjÛa ÚŠznÛaÈí b¾
îİÜÐÛaëïiŠÈÛaÑÓì½aÌm‰bÄnãaN90
ïàîÜÓ⁄abèİÝîöaŠg
æbäjÛ†™ñþabèiŠy¿ÝîöaŠg´×b߆ãbâbÇÑî•¿2006L
æb×lŠ§aÞýalŒyóÜÇÝîöaŠg…‰æc†×csîyBbjbäßBbšÏa‰
pa‹aŒÐna óÜÇ …ŠÛa ¿ ñìÔÛa âa†‚na ¿oŠÏc ÝîöaŠg ædi aìÛbÓ åß
åßõŒubèãdiÝîöaŠglŠyÑ•ë´×bßægÝiLalŒyBðˆÛaÊaŠ–Ûa
é™ì® NNNí…aŠÛa òîßý⁄a ôìÔÛa ´i ÊaŠ–Ûa¿ ò•b LbÈÛa Ç òîÛbØ
òîiŠÌÛa pa†ÔnȽaë ù…bj½aë áîÔÛaë LÁëþa ÖŠ’ÛaBL91´×bß †×c bà×
´i òîÓýþa ñaëbàÜÛ éšÏ‰BbèîÜÇ âìvèÜÛ o™ŠÈm Ûa òÛë†Ûa
IÝîöaŠgHbènºbçÛaòîibç‰⁄aòÇbà¦aëLIalŒyNBH92
ÑÓëŠÐi ò•b¨a òîÛë†Ûa …ìè¦a ´×b߉bÇ aˆÛÖý⁄ ÉíŠ
‰bäÛaÖýgÑÓëÁjmŠíæcñ‰ëŠ™a†×ûßL‰bäÛaBÝßb×ÊŒäiBlŒyòzÜþ
ÑÓìàÜÛ éšÏ‰ óÜÇë Š–äÛa ÕîÔ¤ óÜÇ ÝîöaŠg ñ‰†Ó ¿ énÔq óÜÇë a
@ @
96
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
LbèîÜÇalŒy âìvçÉßkbäní ÝÈÏ …ŠiÝîöaŠgkÛbðˆÛa ïi‰ëþa
åÛéãgÞbÓëïÜîöaŠ⁄a…ŠÜÛéàÇ…´×b߆×csîyb×ßc…‰åÇar×ÑÜn±
Lòîibç‰gòàÄäßÝjÓåßbènºbèßòÛby¿93ñ‰ëŠ™òîÛbmpbjbäß¿†×cbà×
òîÛbà’Ûabç…ë†yóÜÇÝîöaŠgåßcòíbà§alŒyýÊŒãN94
´×bß ÁiŠíëM ñŠ‘bjßë òÐÜn«pb°Š–m ¿MòîàîÜÓ⁄a éÐÓaìß ´i
†ãb½aéÐÓìßëæaŠígëÖaŠÈÛaì−ò•bÞìÔíæaŠígµgòjäÛbjÏ LÝîöaŠ⁄
´×bßB‰bî¨aéãc|™ìãæck¯åØÛëLòÛëbİÛaåÇðŠØÈÛa‰bî¨aÉÏŠã
áèãc bäÈänÓa a‡gügéîÛg dvÜãåÛbäãcëþaIæìîãaŠí⁄aHÚýnßaåßaìiÓa
òzÜþaÙÜmIòíëìäÛaHÝîöaŠg†™bèßa†‚nüNB95
†ènÛa ôŠc É™aìß ¿ †×ûíëLÝîöaŠ⁄ ïãaŠí⁄a âbÄäÛa éÜr¹ ðˆÛa †í
´×bßÑ–ísîyBïãaŠí⁄aâbÄäÛaBéãdiBñ†zn½apbíüìÜÛéöa†ÈiéÐãÒŠÈŽí
ÝîöaŠgëBÝîöaŠgòÛa‹hikÛbİmÛa…b¬ô†»cpb°Š–nÛê†Ôã´×b߉ŠØíëL
ÞìÔíëLòÓŠÐnßå×bßc¿ZægBîjÓpb°Š–måߊr×cÝÈÐmæaŠè¿ñ…bîÔÛaLòz
ñ†zn½apbíüìÛaëÝîöaŠgåßcóÜÇŠ‘bjßÝØ’iŠqûmkîÛbdiÒŠ–nm bèãg
ÝØ’iÑäÈÛaæaŠígo߆‚naalŒyëb»åßÝØÛòàÇa†× bäöbÓ†•cë
Áëþa ÖŠ’Ûa âý òîÜàÇë ÝîöaŠg œíìÔnÛ ‰ŠØnßBæc ´×bß †×ûíë L
BòÛë†Ûbí…ìuëa†í†èmÝr·ÒìòîãaŠí⁄aòíëìäÛaòÜjäÔÛaÝîöaŠgNB96
[ÝîöaŠgåßcóÜÇÃbÐzÜÛñ‰ëŠ™ÖaŠÈÛa¿‹ìÐÛaæc´×bßôŠíbà×
áèc‰ óÜÇë ÝîöaŠgë b×ßc õa†Çc ‰b–nãa Èm Òì Úbäç ò¹Œa æþ
LæaŠíg97éãc´×b߆×ûísîyBæìØmÒìÝîöaŠgòÛë…æc†ÔnÈmoä×a‡g
ýbääîiæhÏLÖaŠÈÛa¿b×ßcoÜ’ÏìÛbäßcŠr×cÖ…b•ðc‰ÒNB98æcbà×
@ @@ @
97
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
Þìzní æcë ÖaŠÈÛa ¿ ï×ßþa ݆nÛa |väí æc ¿ Ýßdí Þa‹bß ´×bß
´×bßÞìÔí‡gLÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa¿òîaŠÔ¹†ÛaŠ’äÛñaìãµgÖaŠÈÛaZ
B bäz¬ a‡gIÖaŠÈÛa ¿ HôŠþa Þë†Ûa ædÏ– æ…‰þaë òí…ìÈÛb×–
åÇ ÁÌšÛa ÉÏŠÛ bäm†Çb½ òîÜibÓ Šr×c æìØmÒì†Ó áq åßë LÝîöaŠg
ÑÜn« êb£a¿ ‰ìßþa–m NNNrØi Šr×cë Œ×ŠßáÇ…ÚbäçæìØíÒì
…ìèuëâýÛaòîÜàÈÛMÁëþaÖŠ’ÛaÇŠ•bäÇÉßMÝy¿ñ†ÇbàÜÛ
´îÜîöaŠ⁄aë´îäîİÜÐÛa´iòÔÛbÈÛabíbšÔÛaNB99
âýÛaòîÜàÇ´iÁiŠÛbiò•b¨apbî•ìnÛa´×bߜϊíbà׉aŠÔnaë
pbî•ìm´×b߉bÇsîyLÖaŠÈÛbiÕÜÈníbàîÏ¿ò•bÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa
BÖaŠÈÛaòa‰…òÇìà©Bàí…¿ñ‰…b–Ûa2006¿ÊaŠ⁄biojÛbÛaL
òîiŠÈÛaâýÛaòîÜàÇM…ìèub¬g¿ñ†ÇbàÜÛð‰ëŠ™ÝßbÈ×òîÜîöaŠ⁄a
ŠíðˆÛa´×bßbèšÏ‰òî•ìmïçëLÖaŠÈÛa¿b×ßclŠÈÛaÉßâýÛaæcô
BÝîznßB¿ÑäÈÛaæþë[ÕibÛa¿b㊑cbà×áèÐãclŠÈÛaÌíbß
´×bßôŠíbà×í…bèšÈiôŠcÝßaìÈiÁjmŠßÖaŠÈÛaN100
bèà™ÞýåßbÈÛbiëb×ßdiÝîöaŠgòÓýdžîìm¿´×bßÝßdíë
BpbîaŠÔ¹†Ûa òj–ÈÛBïÜàÇÝí†j× bèöbäjÛð…bäíÛaáßþaÑÈ™bÈí
æaŠíh×òîÛë…pa†í†èmÉßÝßbÈnÛa¿ñ†zn½aN101
ÝîöaŠhi´×bßòÓýÇ¿pb톤
òîÜîöaŠ⁄aŒní‰fçñ†íŠuémŠ’ã‰aìy˜ì–¢Òëb«pqcIÝöaëc¿
âbÇ2006bjíŠÔmHæc‰aì§aôŠucðˆÛaïÐz–ÛaéîϊׇL´×bßæìuÉß
@ @
98
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
Š™óÜÇòîäàšÛaénÔÏaìßô†ic´×bßâbDž놧ÝîöaŠgñ…ìÇñ‰ë1967M
òİîipýí†Èm ÉßMêbÐã Šßc ìçë L´îäîİÜÐÛa Éß ÊaŠ–Ûa ݧÝîj×
¿òv™‰ì’ä½a‰aì§a‰bqcæc†Èiò•bLa‰ì’ä߉aìzÜÛémõaŠÓ‰ìÏ´×bß
´×bß †×csîy LÝîöaŠg ð†ãbß ÂbëcM ê…‰ ¿M…놧 ñ…ìÈÛa æc
1967ìßåà™a†icåØméÐÓaN102
Šiìn×c ¿ë2007òî×ßþa òí…ìèîÛa éíì’nÛa òzÏbØß òä¦ ojÛb
Anti-Defamation League (ADL)ÉÓì½bèiµ…cpb°Š–mkzi´×bß
b×ßcæc bèîϊׇí…BòîzîßòßcBóÜÇòîäjßBòîzîßù…bjßBïçëL
•c ýîß òî×ßþa òí…ìèîÛapa…bîÔÛaœÈi bèmnÇapb°Š–ma†í†èmë bîÛì
taÜÛBð…ìèîÛaMïzî½a BŠçìu éãcpa…bîÔÛaÙÜmôŠmðˆÛa LÚ’½a
Lòí…†ÈnÛaë|ßbnÜÛñ‰ëŠ™ëòî×ßþaù…bj½a103´×b߆×cÙÛ‡óÜÇa…‰ë
åÇÊŒãÕibÛa|튖nÛaæcòî×ßcòí…ìèíâýÇgÝöbëÉßòîÛbmpýibÔß¿
†×c éãcë éÓbîB †Üi b×ßc æc ñŠß ÑÛcòí…ìèîÛa áîÔÛa óÜÇ cM
òîzî½aNB104
òÐÛb«¿énjˉëénîÛýÔnaëémbjÜÔniÒëŠÈß´×bßæcôŠíåßÚbäçë
ŠßþaÕjİäíæcÝîöaŠgð†íûßœÈió’±ë LÒìÛd½aåÇx늨aë éiŒy
åÇÕibÛa¿åÜÇc´×bßæcëò™bLÝîöaŠgåß´×bßÑÓìßóÜÇéÐã
ßåß …†Ç òîbßìÜi†i éibvÇglþa”ìix‰ìuð†ÇbMåß´™ìÏŠ½a
ÝîöaŠgïiìÛÝjÓMŠØíbi¹buÕibÛaòîu‰b¨aŠí‹ëÝrßJames Baker
oÏëŠØ‘oãŠiÕibÛaïßìÔÛaåßþa‰b’nßëBrent ScowcroftåØÛëL
ÝîöaŠ⁄†ãb½aéÐÓìßæcë|™aë´×bßÝvæcæër׆×ûíÝibÔ½a¿
@ @@ @
99
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
éÏýna ñ†ÇbÔÛ Éš± åÛð‰ìèà¦a lŒ§a ‰bß åÇ …bnȽa ê‡ëˆ‘ë
ŠØíbi Ýrß ´í‰ìèº ´îbî ádži óÄ° ´×bß æc óÜÇë Lémbbîë
´×bßáo–äíåß¿ïçñÈÛaæcëáçËádžióÄ°bà×oÏëŠØ‘ë
òíbèäÛa¿IÝîöaŠg‰b–ãcáçëNH105
pbib‚nãa¿´î×ßþa…ìèîÛapaì•cë´×bßæìu2008
na ’mÞý ´î×ßþa …ìèîÛa pbèuìni ò•b¨a ðcŠÛa pbÇýİ
òí†îèànÛa òîböŠÛa pbib‚nãüa2008ñ†àÇ ïãbîÛìu ð…ë‰ aìÜšÏ áèãc
L´í‰ìèà¦a´z‘Š½a´i åß òí†îèànÛapbib‚nãüa¿ÕibÛa Ú‰ìíìîã106
ê…†’më¿bÔrÛaëïÓýþaôìn½aóÜÇ énîÛaîÛïãbîÛìuåÇÒŠÇsîy
nßóÜÇòîu‰b¨aòbîÛaôìN
Ñî« bÇ éãdi bÈÛaÑ•ëóÜÇïãbîÛìulc… ‡gB‰bİþbi õïÜßB
óÜÇ âìvèÜÛ ò•ŠÐÛa æìäîzní åíˆÛa ´î‘bÐÛa ´îÛbØí…aŠÛa ´îßý⁄bië
b×ßc ñìÓ õbäjië õa†ÇþaóÜÇ Šàn½a âìvbi ÝibÔ½a¿ô…bã aˆÛ [b×ßc
…놧a´ßdmëbè’îuëN 107
†Ônãa bà×üg|Ü–mü òÜ‘bÏ ñ†bÏ òûà× ñ†zn½a áßþaïãbîÛìu
ìmbäÛbi ba†jna†íŠíéãd×ë a†iëLÞë†ÛaœÈjÛâýÛaÅÐypaìÓÞb‰⁄
pbíüìÜÛ ñ†ãb½a Þë†Ûa åß bçËë ÝîöaŠg ášÛ éÈîìm ïÌjäí ðˆÛa
lŠÌÛaëñ†zn½aN
ýÛaÚýnßbib|àíåÛéãcïãbîÛìu†×cæaŠíg˜ì–¢ëLðëìäÛa
bç‰bÈ‘⁄æaŠígóÜÇòîbÓòí…b–nÓaëòîbîÂìÌ™âa†‚nü†Ènßéãcë
@ @
100
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
æbä÷àübiéÛéuaì½aÒŠİÛaŠÈ’íåÛëbÐà×éãcëLï×ßþakÜİÛaòí†
ûjänÛa kÈ–í bîö‰ bàöa… óÔjí ÒìÏ LéÛbÈÏc …ë…‰ë éjÓaìÇ æbà™ë
Ènßë énÓbÝØiÁÌšÛaåÇʉìníü â‰b• Lénbîiðc¿ëbÐnÜÛ †
ïãbîÛìuŠ×‡‡gLñìÓÉÓìßåßåØÛëLoÓëZ
BLæaŠí⁄ òz™aë òÛb‰ aìÜŠí æc bäöbÐÜyë b×ßc óÜÇ ædi åßúc
a†uñ…buëLa†uòÔîÓ…La†uòz™aëZáaìzàíåÛáèãdiI´îãaŠí⁄aHædi
òíëìãñìÓ aìzj–íNt†°åÛ aˆçNNNòíëìãñìÓ aìzj–íæcåß aìiÓaìÛ
ìÏõa‰ìÛaµgpaì䊒Çáèm…bÇhiâìÔãÒìëcLÙÛ‡Éä¸ÒNB108
bèÈiŠß µg bèi ñ…ìÈÛa ïãbîÛìu …a‰c †ÔÏ LâýÛa òîÜàÈi ÕÜÈní bàîÏë
Læë…†’n½abèîÜÇŠİîîÛòÛë…´îäîİÜÐÛa|äßk¯üéãcôc‰sîyLÞëþa
´îäîİÜÐÛa óÜÇ k¯ éãcëŠİnÛa aìzÏbØíë üëc áèÐãc aìàØ° æcÒ
âaŒnÛaóÜdžî×dnÛaïãbîÛìuäíëLòÛë†iÙÛ‡†Èiaì÷ÏbØíæcóÜÇáèİë
…ìèíg Éß énÓa†•óÜÇë LbèîÜÇ õa†nÇaðcÝibÔß¿ÝîöaŠg òíbà¡ b×ßc
LpŠ½ëc109ŠbíÉßâýÖbÐmaµgÝ•ìnÛaénÛëbæìnäîÜ×Ýîi†ÔãóÜÇë
LpbÏŠÇ110ycåßpbÏŠÇŠbí…ŠæcëÕjéãcóÜÇëLÚ‰ìíìîãÖ…bäφ
¿ ÕÔ° æb× ´y pbîäîãbàrÛa µg …ìÈm lbç‰⁄a òzÏbØß ¿ ém æcë
òî×ßþaÞ†ÈÛañ‰a‹ë¿üëûßïãbîÛìuæb×b߆äÇpbÏŠÇpbb’ãN
lbnØÛaŠr×cåßòqýqòîu‰b¨aòbîÜÛéí‰b’nß´iïãbîÛìuá™bà×
İm …†¦a ´ÄÏba ‰bîm óÜÇ ´iìa …ìèîÛaáçë ÝîöaŠ⁄ ñ†ãbßë bÏŠ
ÕibÛa¿b㊑cbà×jíbiÞbîãa…늹aŠ×åm‰bßëŒní‰ìç…ìiæb߉ìãN
@ @@ @
101
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
|Üİ–½ ´u늽a áçc †yc †Èí Œní‰ìç…ìi æb߉ìã æc ÒëŠÈ½aë
Bòîßý⁄aòî‘bÐÛaB111Šİcáç´îßý⁄a´î‘bÐÛbiáèîàíåßæìØÛë
ß b×ßc æcë LåçaŠÛaoÓìÛa ¿ b×ßc õa†ÇcáèÈß òî½bÇlŠy¿ òŠ‚ä
ñ…‰bjÛalŠ§aëòîãbrÛaëµëþa´nî½bÈÛa´iŠ§a‰aŠËóÜÇN
ÕφmÉíŠÝØ’iòîböŠÛapbib‚nãüaÖbjåßïãbîÛìuxëŠÉßë
âýÇg Ýöbë ’m bà× ´×bß ì− ´î×ßþa …ìèîÛa Âbëc ¿ êë†ãbß
òî×ßcòí…ìèíN112
‰ë†ÛaµgòÐÜn«‰…b–ß’më‰ìmbäîÛaéjÈÛðˆÛaâbaMbÔibïaŠÔ¹†Ûa
bîÛby ÝÔn½aëMb–Û ´î×ßþa …ìèîÛa paì•c †–§ æbßîÛ Ñí‹ìu
òíüì× òí†îèànÛapbib‚nãüaÖbj¿ òí‰ìªë òßbçpbíüë¿ ò•b´×bß
òÈîjáèÐíåß ìç´×bßæcæbßîÛ †×csîy La†í‰ìÜÏBïßý⁄a†í†ènÛa
…aŠÛaïÛbØíBâýÇ⁄aÝöbëœÈijÈnÛbÔÏëÝîöaŠgéèuaìmðˆÛaN113
ô†ßóÜÇ´×bßÉßÝàÇéãcæbßîÛÞìÔíëBbßbÇå튒ÇBéÛ†è‘
åß éÐÓìß ¿ Šèà bà× ‰aŠÔÛa ‡b¥a óÜÇ ñ‰†ÔÛbiëðcŠÛa òîÛýÔnbi bý
Úbäç”ìiòîvîmagÝ’Ïð†ÔnäßÞëcåß´×bßæb×sîyLÖaŠÈÛalŠy
ë ¿paìÔÛa ñ…bí‹ òîvîma⁄ åí†ãb½a Šr×c åßë L†ÔäÛa éîÏ lbË oÓ
æë†ãb½aéîÏlbËoÓë¿ÖaŠÈÛbiòî×ßþaN114
µgâýÇ⁄aÝöbëœÈioÈÏ…òÔîqìÛabàènÓýÇë´×b½æbßîÛñ†ãbß
ém†Èjna Šßc ìçë LéÛ köbä× æbßîÜÛ ´×bß ‰bîna òîãbØßg åÇ s톧a
pc‰ôŠc‰…b–ßóÜÇòîÛaîÜÛaæbßîÛÑÓaìßkjiÙÛ‡ÕÔ¤òiìÈ•
@ @
102
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
L´×b߆™òÄÏbað‰ìèà¦alŒ§a†ÇaìÓrí†ÓÝØ’iïÜa†Ûaôìn½a
âbÇ¿éÜnyaðˆÛak–ä½biéßbànçaâ†ÇåÇdžÓæbßîÛæìØÛë2000
‰ìuÞeïaŠÔ¹†Ûa|‘ŠàÜÛköbä×òîböŠÛapbib‚nãüab´yN115
oãb×ægëém‰a…hi bj–äßæbßîÛ|äßåß´×bßÉä·åÛòÔibÛaõa‰Ła
àÏìã¿òî×ßþaòböŠÛbiê‹ìÏòÛby¿2008N
à×ìiÚ‰bß´×b߉bnaæbßîÜÛòÏb™⁄biëMark BroxmeyerbqìÈjß
ñ‰ìq æì× ï×ßc ð…ìèí ÞbàÇc Ýu‰ à×ìië L´î×ßþa …ìèîÜÛ énÜà§
¿ÝàÈÛaåß ñj×âbLjäßïÛìníë Lpa‰bÔÈÛaÞb©2002ñ‰a…gÜ©òbö‰
ïßìÔÛa åßþa æëû’Û ð…ìèîÛa †èȽaJewish Institute for National
Security Affairs (JINSAHòîrzjÛaÝîöaŠgïiìÛpbàÄäßáçc†ycìçëLN116
´i òîäßþa òİiaŠÛa òíìÔmÒ†èipbäîÈjÛa Ýöaëc¿ Œ×Š½ac †Óë
ßc‰ë…ë ï×ßþa ïßìÔÛa åßþa bíbšÓ ¿—–‚nísîy LÝîöaŠgë b×
pý•pa‡òí‰ìÔ•ñ†äucŒ×Š½aÙÜn¹bà×Låßþa aˆçÕîÔ¤¿ÝîöaŠg
åß a…†Çéí‰b’nßÜ©¿†èȽaášísîy L…†¦a´ÄÏba‰bîni òÔîqë
…†¦a´ÄÏbapa…bîÓáçcMÞi…‰b’ní‰ÝrßRichard Perleàîuë
ïÜëJames Woolseyî’mÙí…ÕibÛa¿á™éãcbà×LDick Cheney
æìnÛìi æìuëJohn Bolton síbÏ ýuë…ëDouglas Feith´uë
ÙíŠmbj××Jane KirkpatrickN117
ïiŠÈÛa ÊaŠ–Ûbi ÕÜÈní bàîÏ òîäîàîÛa énbî Œ×Š½a åÇ ÒŠÈíë
ìë æaŠíg †™ …†’nÛbi kÛbİí sîy LïÜîöaŠ⁄abà× L´îäîİÜÐÛaë bí‰
@ @@ @
103
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
¿´yâa†•âbÄäi òyb⁄aÝà’nÛlbç‰⁄aóÜÇlŠ§a†í†ànikÛb
ànj åß Š’Ç ð…b§a ta†yc lbÔÇc2001´×bß †èȽa |äß †Óë L
âbÈÛòíìäÛaòíŠí†ÔnÛaémŒöbu2006kÜËlbİ¢´×bßbèàÜmñŒöbuïçëL
´îäîİÜÐÛaëæaŠíg†™òí‰ìÔ–Ûaë…†’nÛaéîÜÇN
¿´×bßæì¦ï×ßþað…ìèîÛapì–Ûaòîàçcµgñ‰b‘⁄abäçk¯ë
åß …†Ç ×c lˆu Þëb° ´×bß æc ôŠí åß ÚbäèÏ LòäçaŠÛa pbib‚nãüa
…ìèîÛa õb™‰g †íŠí éãc bà× Lð‰ìèà¦alŒzÜÛ´î×ßþa …ìèîÛa´jbäÛa
ßáèäØÛë´î×ßþa…ìèîÛaåßòÜîÜÓòjãáçë´í‰ìèà¦aáç…†’ni´ÏëŠÈ
òîu‰b¨aòbîÛaòybóÜÇN
áçþaësÛbrÛakjÛabßcM´ÜÜaœÈiôŠíbà×M†íŠí´×bßæcìç
ïiìÛpa…bîÓ åß éîÜÇ Ý–°ðˆÛa †îídnÛaë ÝîöaŠ⁄ ém†ãbß â†‚ní æc
¿ áç…†’ni ´ÏëŠÈ½a ´í’jnÛa oãbnmëÛa paì•c òÛ‹bÌß ¿ ÝîöaŠg
îöaŠg ñ†ãbßô†ßë á òjäÛbi ÝîöaŠg òîàçc ô†ß ´×bß ÒŠÈí ‡g LÝ
â†Çë ð‰ìèà¦a lŒzÜÛ òíçbà¦a †ÇaìÔÛa óÜÇ áèmŠİîë áç‡ìÐã
ÝîöaŠgñ†ãbßÝȯb¾éÛñ†ÓbäÛaòîÛaîÜÛaéÐÓaìßœÈikjiéäÇáçb™‰
áç†îídni‹ìÐÛa¿ò¡aŠÛaénÓ‰ëN118
brÛbq@ZæaŠíg@ @´×bßëpbäîÈnÛaÝöaëc ˆäßÚýnßaóÜÇæaŠíg ñ‰†Óå߆zÜÛóÈí
óÜÇpbiìÔNJϵgòîßaŠÛa´ãaìÔÛaáÇ…ÞýåßÝßb’Ûa‰b߆ÛaòzÜc
æaŠí⁄òzÜþaÙÜmxbnãgbîuìÛìäØnÛñ‰†–½apb׊’ÛaN119
@ @
104
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
åß Ýßb’Ûa ‰b߆Ûa òzÜc Úýnßü óÈm æaŠíg æc ´×bß ôc‰sîy
bà× Lbîë‰ë ´–Ûb× Þë… Éß æëbÈnÛa Þýáçb bß ádžm bèãc
B´îßý⁄a´îÛì•þbiBð…bÈmbà×LlŠÌ½aëæbäjÛëæa…ìÛaÝrßÞë…¿
òîiŠÈÛa‰Œ¦aœÈiÝn¤ëïiŠÈÛawîܨaÞë…N
†×cë…bÇ´×bßåØÛë– ñÐÛaÙÜm¿Mbèma‹b¬a¿ÍÛbjmæaŠígæc
Ûa´×bߜωƒÏìçëLÝßb’Ûa‰b߆ÛaòzÜcÚýnßa†îÈ•óÜÇéîÏÊìÓì
bèîÈië òíëbàîØÛa òzÜþa œÈi æaŠíg Úýnßbi éãb¹g åß áËŠÛa óÜÇ
ðëìäÛaýÛaÚýnßüN120
åß æaŠíg Éä½ áèÈë ¿ bß ÝÈÐi lŠÌÛaë b×ßc ´×bß kÛb aˆÛ
æc ôc‰ë LòzÜþa ÙÜm Šíìİm ¿ bç†Çbm †Ó Ûa bîuìÛìäØnÛa …ana
ìÛìäØnÛa ÙÜm ð‰†–ß óÜÇpbiìÔÇŠÏÖìÈí æc éãd‘ åß æaŠí⁄ bîu
¿åàØíÝrßþaݧaæcë LbèÈä¹ éäØÛë bèîÜÇÞì–§aóÜÇæaŠíg ñ‰†Ó
éÛ´îãaŠí⁄aœÏ‰ÞýåßÝa†ÛaåßïãaŠí⁄aâbÄäÛaîÌmN
âbÇ¿ñ†’ibî뉴×b߆Ônãabà×1996pýÇbжæaŠíg†íëŒmbèߌÈÛ
×ßþaîöŠÛañ‰a…gbjÛbİßòíëìãbîë‰óÜÇpbiìÔÇŠÐiæìnäîÜ×Ýîiòî
Ýßb’Ûa ‰b߆Ûa òzÜc bîuìÛìäØmpa‰…b•ŠÄ¡ ò•b¨a´ãaìÔÛaÉß bî‘b·
pbäîÈnÛaÝöaëc¿b×ßcbènäjmÛaæaŠí⁄N121
áËŠÛaóÜÇŠànmæck¯ëòÇ…a‰òí…b–nÓüapbiìÔÈÛaæc´×bßôc‰ë
bİíåßæcôc‰bà×Lb´™‰bȽa†Ôãå߆è¦aå߆íŒßÞˆjib×ßcæìjÛ
æcë b Õj æaŠíg æþ æì÷İ« bèîÜÇ ÁÌšÛa åß ü†i æaŠíg åßlŠÔnÜÛ
@ @@ @
105
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ÝîiîöŠÛa†èÇÞýò•bbèäßlŠÔnÜÛï×ßcŠÇåߊr×cošÏ‰
æìnäîÜ×N122
11ÞìÜícÖaŠÈÛaëŒËë
ta†yc†Èi11ÞìÜícÞë†Ûaåßñ†yaì×æaŠígµgñ‰b‘⁄a¿´×bßc†i
aêŒî׊måØÛë Læa…ìÛaë bí‰ì×Þë…µg òÏb™⁄bilbç‰fiÛ òîÇaŠÛa òÓ‰b½
×þa–ñÐÛaÙÜmÞýMÖaŠÈÛaóÜÇæb×N123
‰bß¿ÖaŠÈÜÛï×ßþaëŒÌÛaÒb™cë2003ÑÓìß¿a†í†ua†Èi
aŠØjß ´×bß ‰ˆy sîy LæaŠíg åß ´×bßM¿ b×ßc õbİc …†Èm Éßë
ÖaŠÈÛa–a†Çcæcåßb×ßcõMæaŠígáèäîiåßëMò¹ŒçæìäàníëæëŠÄnäí
ÖaŠÈÛa¿b×ßcN124
ÖaŠÈÛa¿ïãaŠí⁄a݆nÛaubç|j•cÚbäçÊb™ëþa‰ìç†mÉßëM
ð‰ìÛa݆nÛaéÐÜåßëMåßa‰aŠØm‰ˆyðˆÛa´×bßÒëb«áçc´i
ïßaŠÛaÖaŠÈÛbiïãaŠí⁄a݆nÛaŠİ–êŠÄãòèuëåß–Þb’ÏgµgÊ늒½a
ŠØj½aï×ßþalbzãüaåÇáubäÛaÎaŠÐÛaõݽ݆nÜÛëLÚbäçï×ßþa
æaŠígéîÜÇåàîèm†í†uÁëcÖŠ‘õbäiáqåßëLÖaŠÈÛaåßN125
†ÓbäÛa´×bßâbànçaݪÝîöaŠgåßòîãaŠí⁄apbßìاaÑÓìßÝÃbà×
âbÇÑ–näßïÐÏLæaŠí⁄2001ÞýéÛòàÜ׿´×bßkÛbÚbjí⁄aŠ·ûß
AIPACbèîÛgòèuì½aòîãaŠí⁄aƒía‰ì–ÛaŠİåßÝîöaŠgòíb»ñ‰ëŠšiN126
æbäjÛóÜÇÝîöaŠglŠyáš¿ëM ìîÛìí¿2006M´×bß Œ×‰
LÝîöaŠg òèuaìß ¿ b»ë a lŒy bàèàÇ†Û bí‰ìë æaŠíg †Ôã óÜÇ
@ @
106
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
jÛaóÜljb·æck¯òîÛë†Ûa òîbîÛaÂìÌšÛaæcôc‰ëbþbiåí†Ü
ÝîöaŠ⁄òšçbä½apbÇbàvÜÛ´îbþa´îÇaŠÛabàèãìØÛN127
æaŠíg áubèm Òì b×ßc æc òîÐz• pb°Š–m ¿ ´×bß †×c bà×
óÜÇ æaŠíg æc p†×dm a‡g bíŠØÇBòzÜþa ÙÜm óÜÇ Þì–§a Ù‘ë
IòíëìäÛaHÝîöaŠg†™bèßa†‚nüNB128
æaŠíg†™ïibݨa†îÈ–nÛa
a†ÈnaÉßëâbÈÛòîböŠÛapbib‚nãüa쨴×bß…2008éib݈c
Šiìn×cïÐÏLbz™aëbí†Çb–m bîäzäßæaŠígåÇ2006òä¦âbßclbİ¿ë
bèãdi æaŠíg ´×bß Ñ•ë Úbjí⁄aBbÈÛa ¿ ïÛë†Ûa lbç‰fiÛ Êa‰ ×cBL
bï×ßþaëŒÌÛaÝjÓÖaŠÈÛaòãbØß´×bßô†ÛæaŠígoÜnyaÙÛˆiëN129
¿ëòîãaŠí⁄aòbîÛaóÜÇémb™aÇaáçc´×bߊÈnaéÐãlbݨa
ïãaŠí⁄aîöŠÛapb°Š–mÝÿò•bÝîöaŠgåßæaŠígÑÓìß¿òÜràn½a
alŒy ÝrßpbÇbঠæaŠíg áÇ…ë LÝîöaŠg Õy ¿ òí‰bäÛa …b¬ ð†»c
åßÖaŠÈÛa¿b×ßcÉßñŠ‘bjßòèuaìß¿æaŠíg…ìuëëLb»ëáÇ…Þý
Úbäç ï×ßþa …ìuìÜÛ ò™‰bÈß pbÇbঠæaŠígIádžÛa ÙÛ‡ ¿ b¶
ðŠØÈÛaH130ðëìäÛaýÛaÚýnßüæaŠígïÈëLN131
àí… ¿ ´×bß œÏ‰ë2007ŠíŠÔm wöbnã òîàçc ¿ òÌÛbj½a
òzÜþaxbnãhiò•b¨abè©aŠioÐÓëcæaŠígæcŠ×‡òî×ßþapa‰bj‚nýÛ
†Ç ˆäß òíëìäÛaLpaìä ñ132 æb¸ì‘ ð†ãa‰ Ñ•ë bà×Randy
@ @@ @
107
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ScheunemannMòîböŠÛa´×bßòÜ»¿òîu‰b¨aòbîÛað‰b’nßj×
–éãdi éma‡pa‰bj‚nüaŠíŠÔmBÝÜšßBwöbnãÉßÝßbÈní´×bßæcŠ×‡ëL
éiì’퉈¡ŠíŠÔnÛaBÙ’ÛaNB133
ñ‰bí‹Þýêa†ßæaŠíg†™´×b½ïibݨa†îÈ–nÛaÝ•ëbà×bèiâbÓ
‰bß¿ÁëþaÖŠ’ÜÛ´×bß2008æaŠígæcéÛpb°Š–m¿Š×‡sîy
݆ní æc ÝjÓ ÙÛ‡ë LÖaŠÈÛa ¿ òíŠØÇ pbîÜàÇ å’Û ñ†ÇbÔÛa l‰†m
æbßîÛÑí‹ìu‰ìmbäîÛa– òÜyŠÛaÞýéîÔÏaŠß†yc–bäçë Lézîz–nÛ
k퉆m†–Ôíæb×éãcc†×ûßémb°Š–måÇÉuaŠmëêdİ´×bßÚ‰…cÝíì·ë
æaŠígB´ÏŠİnßòÈî’ÛBÖaŠÈÛa¿ï×ßþa…ìuìÛa†™ÝàÈÜÛN134
põbu bèãc Ýi aìè åØm ´×bßpb°Š–m æc ôc‰œÈjÛa åØÛë
óäÌmë Õj´×bß æcë ò•b LæaŠíg ì−´×bß …†’m åÇ ÈnÛBÑ–Ôi
æaŠígBLòîib‚nãüaémýÐyô†yg¿135´×bßpb°Š–mæcæëŠeôc‰bà×
†ÈmbèãcëLæaŠíg†™…†¦a´ÄÏba‰ìÔ•ëòî×ßþañ‰a…⁄aòÜ»åßaõŒu
æaŠíg ´i ÁiŠÛa Þëb¤ Ûa pb°Š–nÛa åß òÜíì òÜÜ åà™ põbu
ï×ßþaâbÈÛaðcŠÛakîÛdnÛëæaŠígóÜÇÁÌšÜÛòîÏb™gòÓ‰ì×ñ†ÇbÔÛaëN136
éí‰b’nß j× Š• æc †Èi a†îÔÈm Šßþa åß ´×bß ÑÓìß …a‹ë
Œ¹bmå•Ú‰ìíìîãñ†íŠ¦æb¸ì‘ð†ãa‰òîu‰b¨aòbîÜÛMéuìnÛaòîäî¹M
ýöbÓB´ÏŠİnàÜÛádžÛaåßñ†í†Ça‰ì•pŠÏëæaŠígæc|™aëÕîqìmÚbäç
ÖaŠÈÛa¿´ÏŠİn½aòÈî’Ûaëñ†ÇbÔÛaÙÛ‡¿b¶òäÛaBÑÓì½aµg’í b¾
óÜÇ´×b¶´İîaõa¨aŠöaë†Û…†’n½aŠí†ÔmÝÓcN137
@ @
108
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
pbiìÔÇëÞŒÇ
æaŠíg óÜÇ ÁÌšÛa ¿ åàØí ݧa æc ´×bß ôc‰ Õj bß óÜÇ õbäi
´Ûì÷½aÉßs톧biky‰ëLbîbîbŒÇòÛëbz¶ëòí…b–nÓüapbiìÔÈÛbi
Š‘bj½as톧a bÈbÓ bšÏ‰ bšÏa‰œÐ‚äßïbîôìnßóÜÇ´îãaŠí⁄a
LïãaŠí⁄aîöŠÛaÉß138aÁÌšÛbikÛbbà×Þë†ÛaóÜÇëæaŠígóÜÇïÛë†Û
bîë‰bèc‰óÜÇëbñ†ãb½aN139
ÁëcÖŠ‘õbäjÛòía†iìçïàîÜÓ⁄aôìn½aóÜÇæaŠígÞŒÇæcôc‰ë
éîÏÑÛbzní†í†uBõb׊‘BÖaŠÈÛaëæ…‰þaë òí…ìÈÛa늖ßÝrß b×ßc
bnãbÌÏcëÝîöaŠgëbî׊mëæbí‰ìëæaŠíh×òÓ‰b½aÞë†Ûa†™N140
Åyý½aëóÜÇbîbßìÜi…æaŠígÞŒÈiòjÛbݽa¿bãbîycÍÛbi´×bßæcbäç
ñþa bÈÛad×ÝjÓkÛb éãc ónyïÛë†Ûaôìn½aM¿oàîÓcÛa
bîãb½cI2006 HMòÛìİjÛa¿ ò׉b’½aåßæaŠígÉä¶ïÛë†Ûa â†ÔÛa ñŠ× …b¤a
…b¬ ô†»c pb°Š–m kjiBòí…ìèîÛa òÓŠzàÜÛ ñŠØä½a Bëµg ò÷î½a
ÝîöaŠgN141
óÜÇëŠÐ½að…b–nÓüaëïbîÛaÁÌšÛaÑîÐ¥´×bߜω bà×
ÕîÔ¤ ¿ b×ßc Éß æaŠíg æëbÈm ÝibÔß ¿ ðëìäÛa bè©bãŠi kji æaŠíg
ÖaŠÈÛaòa‰…òÇìà©pbî•ìnÛbÔÏëÖaŠÈÛa‰aŠÔnaN142
aŠígÞŒÈia‰ŠØm´×bßkÛbïÛë†ÛaïbßìÜi†ÛaÝàÈÛa†îÈ•óÜÇëæ
†îÔnÛa œÏ‰ bà× LbèîÜÇ òîÛë†Ûa òí…b–nÓüa pbiìÔÈÛa åß †íŒß ŠÐië
óÜÇÂìÌšÛaå߆íŒßŠÏåÇbèÈuaŠmòÛby¿bèÛb©ëñ†zn½aáßþbi
@ @@ @
109
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
òÛby ¿ b×ßþ ñ†ãb½a Þë†Ûa åßÑÛb¤ Þý åß ÝàÈÛa ýšÐß æaŠíg
bèçb£òjbä½aÑÓaì½a‡b¥a¿ñ†zn½aáßþaÝ’ÏN143
bà×pbiìÔÈÛbi õbÐn×üa â†Ç óÜÇ b ñ†ãb½a Þë†Ûaë b×ßc s°
âbß‹ ˆc óÜÇë Lñ†zn½a áßþa ÝjÓ åß b×ßc óÜÇ ò™ëŠÐ½a òí…b–nÓüa
òÐÜn‚½aÞë†ÛaÉîv’mëæaŠíg¿‰bàrnüaœÏŠÛòîÛë…òܻ呿ñ‰…bj½a
ÞýbîÔíŠÏglìäuÉßt†yb߉aŠËóÜÇÚbäç‰bàrnüaâ†ÇóÜdžèÇ
ò튖äÈÛaòÓŠÐnÛaN144
ðŠØÈÛa‰bî¨a
ðŠØÈÛa‰bî¨ab×ßc†Èjnmücñ‰ëŠ™òÐÜn«pbjbäß¿†×cbà×
LæaŠíg Éß ÝßbÈnÛa ¿145 c ‰bî‚× lŠ§a óÔjm æc óÜÇ ÙÛ‡ëM†Èi
òîbßìÜi†Ûaë òí…b–nÓüa Ýöa†jÛa Éîº ‡bÐänaM¿lŠ§a òiìÈ• a†×ûß
m †Èi åçaŠÛa oÓìÛaÛa õbİþa kji bÈÛa Ç b×ßc òîÓa†–ß ÉuaŠ
ÖaŠÈÛalŠyå‘¿òî×ßþañ‰a…⁄abènjØm‰aN146
bÈia‰@ZòîaŠÔ¹†Ûa@Š’ã@òbî@ @aj×a‰†ÓòîaŠÔ¹†ÛaŠ’ãòîšÓ|ä¹âbänîÏÝîuµgïànäíðˆÛa´×bß
åÇt†zníc†i´ypbäîÈnÛaåßñþapaìäÛaÝjÓéßbànçaåßÝa†m
Š’ãæcÑî×ëï×ßþaïßìÔÛaåßþaÑíŠÈm¿òî×ßþab–½aÉßáîÔÛa
óÜÇ æcë Låßþa aˆçpbãbà™ åß †Èí òîaŠÔ¹†Ûaë ò튧b× òî×ßþa áîÔÛa
Š’äÛæbàš×òÔibÛaáîÔÛaŠ’ãóÜÇÝàÈmæc†yëþabÈÛakİÓïçëb×ßc
É™ëë b×ßc õbÐÜyáÇ…ë bÈÛa¿ âýÛabàöa… ÊbφÛaÑÓìß¿ bèbÈß
@ @
110
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
Éßb×ßcÖbjæc´×bßôc‰sîyLòî×ßþaòäàîa‰aŠànaæbà™áqåßë
æb× b¸gë LÁÔÏb–ß Öbj åØí ñ…‰bjÛa lŠ§a Þý îÏìÛa …b¤üa
òî×ßþa áîÔÛa Š’ã æcë Lbšíc bîàîÓ bÇaŠ•Mæbã⁄aÖìÔyë òîaŠÔ¹†Ûb×
ㆽapb튧aëòîM†yëþaï×ßþakİÔÛaòäàîçæbàšÛñ‰ëŠ™N147
ÁëþaÖŠ’ÛaòîaŠÔ¹…ëÖaŠÈÛaÞýnya
ta†yc†Èi11M9bîäzäßòîaŠÔ¹†ÛaŠ’ãòîšÓåß´×bßÑÓì߈¥a
´×bßéið…bãŠßcìçëLïÓaŠÈÛaâbÄäÛaîÌmñ‰ëŠ™óÜÇêŒî׊mÉßa†í†u
´×bßↂna†ÓëLpbäîÈnÛaŠaëcˆäßñ†yaì×b犒ãëòîaŠÔ¹†Ûaòvy
ëŒÌÛaÒa†çcëpa‰ßåßN
BåÇüëcÙÛ‡æìØíëLÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa¿bäàîÓŠ’äÛÝàÈÛabäîÜÇk¯
Áëþa ÖŠ’Ûa ¿ …a†jnüa ò™‰bÈß ÕíŠ Nʉaì‘ ¿ ò튧bi ÞbÐnyüa
ñ‰Ša …a†Ìi NNNñ†zn½apbíüìÛa ædi æëŠelŠÇæë†jnß Š×ˆíÒì
îjÑîÜyò튧aµg|ßbİÛaïiŠÈÛakÈ’ÜÛïÈNB148
ò튧b× áîÔÛ òíìİÜÛa òîiŠÈÛa áÄäÛaœÏŠi éãb¹g åÇ´×bß Ç bà×
ÝîöaŠgëb×ßþbèiìÈ‘õa†ÇwuûmáÄäÛaÙÜmæcëòqa†§aëòîaŠÔ¹†Ûaë
óÜÇ æcë LbîÜa… òîaŠÔ¹†Ûbi lìÈ’Ûa ÙÜm kÛbİß oîn’nÛ òÜîì×
ÑÓìnÛañ†zn½apbíüìÛaõbÐÜz×òí‰ìmbnØí†ÛaáÄäÛaÙÜmóÜÇ…bànÇüaåÇ
òÔİä½a¿bN
BïçòîäîİÜÐÛaòîšÔÛaëïiŠÈÛabÈÛa¿ì™ìiÉàÜmòîçaŠØÛaæaã
òqa†zÜÛ áèšÏ‰ë lŠÈÛa ´í‰ìmbnØí†Ûa áØy ìèÏ b版u bßc LbèÓbî
@ @@ @
111
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
òíŠzÜÛëN¹æb×ÛaâbíþaåØÛëLbäÛ õbÐÜy´í‰ìmbnØí†Ûa õüûçœÈiåØ
b×ßc bèîÏ Ýàznm æcIòÐÜØm HåÇë ïÜa†Ûa …bèİ™üa åÇ Š–jÛaœË
oÛë †Ó b×ßþ õa†ÈÛa wîudm NbÈÛa ¿ bãõbÓ†•c æìzj–î åß óÜÇë
aˆçaì׉†íæcïiŠÈÛaNB149
lbç‰⁄a…ìuëóÜÇaŒÏbyÝr·òí‰ìmbnØí†ÛaáÄäÛaæc´×bßðc‰bà×
÷îiŠÏìíòîaŠÔ¹†ÛalbîËæcëê‰b’nãaëòîibç‰⁄apbÇbà¦a‰b’nãüò§b•ò
ëŒÌÛa†ÈiæbnãbÌÏc¿îÌnÛaæcëL…†’n½abèibİŠc¿lìÈ’ÛaÊìÓëë
¿îÌnÜÛ òubyÚbäèÏ LïÐØíü bï×ßþaBæbn×bië Š–ßë òí…ìÈÛa
òîäîİÜÐÛa òİÜÛaë æaŠígëBL150ÁÌ™ÝßbÇÝr¹ÒìÖaŠÈÛa ëŒË æcë
Ûa pbßìاa óÜÇ j×pübÐnya lŠÈÛa ôŠí b߆Èi ò•b îÌnÜÛ òîiŠÈ
ñ‰Ša…a†Ìiʉaì‘¿ò튧bi´îÓaŠÈÛaN151
…bÇ LÖaŠÈÛa ¿ Ýßb‘ ‰bß… òzÜc óÜÇ ‰ìrÈÛa ¿ b×ßc Ý’Ï †Èië
´îÓaŠÈÜÛò튧akÜuæcóÜÇëÖaŠÈÛa¿òîaŠÔ¹†ÛaŠ’ãòîàçc†×cë´×bß
biŠÈßlŠzÜÛòîîöŠÛalbjþa†ycæb×åßb×ßcåØànmæc¿éÜßcåÇ
õbäiBòîiŠÇòîaŠÔ¹…ÞëcBÚbäçN152
LÚbäçÊb™ëþa´¤òîÐîØi´×bßÝÌ’ãaÖaŠÈÛbiÊb™ëþað…ŠmÉßë
òí‰ìmbnØí†ÛaòîiŠÈÛaÞë†Ûaæc†î×dnÛaåßéÈä¹ aˆçåØÛë–Þbr½a bi‰b™
bîjîÛë òí…ìÈÛbiMÖaŠÈÛbiï×ßþaÊ늒½aݒφíŠmÁÌ™åß éÜr¹ b½
ïÜa†Ûaý•⁄aêb£a¿bèîÜÇN153
ta†ycæc†î×dnÛa¿Šànabà×11M9ÉßbèÐÛb¤dİb×ßþp†×c
Ú‰ìíìîä× bèã†ß åßcë b×ßc åßc æc óÜÇë LÁëþa ÖŠ’Ûapbí‰ìmbnØí…
@ @
112
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
LñŠçbÔÛaëbíŠÛb×òîiŠÈÛaá•aìÈÛbiò튧aòu‰…óÜdžànÈíåİä‘aëë154
´×bß â†Ó aˆÛM æbßîÛÑí‹ìu ‰ìmbäîÛa Éß æëbÈnÛbiMæìãbÓ Ê늒ß
òîu‰b¨a ñ‰a‹ë …ìèu áÇ… Þý åß x‰b¨a ¿ òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa Š’ã ádžÛ
Š’ã óÜÇ |™aë Œî׊m Éß †îÈ–Ûa aˆç óÜÇ bîaŠÓëië bí…bß òî×ßþa
ÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa¿ òîaŠÔ¹†ÛaM˜ì–¢´×bß ê‰†•cæbîi¿ Šèà bà×
bÔÛaÊ늒ßæìãN155
íbȽaòîuaë…‹aëòîäîİÜÐÛapbib‚nãüa
ò׊ybèîÏp‹bÏÛaòîäîİÜÐÛaòîÈ튒nÛapbib‚nãüawöbnã‰ìèÃÉßë
b»MâbÇÝöaëc¿2006MLbèvöbnã´×bߜω156|İÛaóÜÇoÐë
ó‘bànm ü òíçbº pbÇbঠéšÏ‰ë ´×bß íbÈß òîuaë…‹a åÇ pbibn×
äucÉßbèm†äucém†N157
†Èibàîφ×ûîÛ´×bß…bdžÓë–òîböŠÛaénÜ»Þýë2008MæcóÜÇ
bí‰ìmbnØí†Ûa óÜÇ …bànÇüa dİoàÜÈm b×ßcp´ypbäîÈjÛa Šaëc ˆäß
¿òîãbqñŠßéÐ㉆ÛaoàÜÈmbà×Lòîßý⁄añ‰ìrÛaâbßcæaŠíg¿êb’ÛaÁÔ
2001¿Šànmæcb×ßcóÜÇæcôc‰aˆÛLÊŠnÛaæë…åØÛëòîaŠÔ¹†ÛaŠ’ã
æbàšÛ ݆nÛa b×ßc óÜÇ æcët†°Òì îÌnÛa æc a†×ûß LîÌnÛa ¿
áènÜ×b‘óÜÇêìÜØ’íëb×ßcõa†Çcéi…ŠÐäíüónyîÌnÛaaˆçòËbî•N158
œÓbämëíbÈßòîuaë…‹a
éuaìí òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa Š’ã òîšÓ åß´×bßÑÓìß æc Õj b¾ |™aìÛaë
bÈmx‰ìuñ‰a…géäßoãbÇðˆÛaéÐãœÓbänÛaìçëLbîÜa…bšÓbämëcb™‰
@ @@ @
113
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
Éß bèi‰bšmë Áëþa ÖŠ’Ûa ¿ b×ßc b–ß …†Èm kji ”ìi ìîÜi…
Š’ã òbîi ÉφÜÛ ñ‰a…⁄a éîÏ p†àÇ ðˆÛa oÓìÛa ïÐÏ LœÈjÛa bèšÈi
ta†yc †Èi òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa11M9óÜÇ Þì–§a¿ ñ‰a…⁄a Ý’Ï †Èi ò•bë
òzÜcìîÜi… x‰ìuîöŠÜÛ òîãbrÛa òíüìÛa Ýöaëc ¿ë ÖaŠÈÛbi Ýßb‘ ‰bß…
bènubykji òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa Š’ãïÇbßåÇÉuaÜÛ ñ‰a…⁄apŠİ™a”ìi
òîaŠÔ¹†Ûañ‰…bjßæþëÖaŠÈÛa‰aŠÔnaÕîÔ¤¿òîiŠÈÛaÞë†ÛaæëbÈm´ßdnÛ
òî×ßþaM ŠàÈÛa ñ–ÓM òîßýg ôìÓ …ìÈ• µgp…bÓbèäÇŠm
b×ßcN
¿òîaŠÔ¹†ÛaŠ’äiña…bä½aóÜnj׊íéãc|™aìÛbÏL´×bßµgòjäÛbië
ta†ycÝjÓÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa11M9‰ìÄäßåßÙÛ‡ëLÖaŠÈÛbiÕÜÈníbàîÏüg
bÈÜÛòî×ßþañ…bîÔÛaëñ…a‰fiÛ†¤åßéÜrßb½ïÓaŠÈÛaâbÄäÛaîÌm¿òjËŠÛa
þaòîjİÔÛaŠ–Ç¿îÌmòbîjmb×ßcóÜÇæc´×bßôc‰sîyLòí…by
áÄäÛaBòÓ‰b½aBbÈÛakİÔÛòîÛaìßôŠcáÄäi ba†jnaëb×ßþò™‰bȽa
†yëþaIb×ßcNH
òîîöŠÛaòîiŠÈÛaÞë†ÛaÝr·ÉjİÛbië–Š–ßëòí…ìÈÛaÝrß–óçë
ìÇ…åà™†ÔäÛaåßj×õŒ ´×bßbè–ÛaÞë†ÛaòîaŠÔ¹†ÛaŠ’ãµgém
òa‰†Ûa åß ïÛbnÛa áÔÛa ¿ ôŠä bà× Áëþa ÖŠ’Ûa ¿–a†í†èm
ÙÜm oÜrß ‰ìßþa kÜËc ïÐÏ LbÈÜÛ bèm…bîÔÛ b톤 ëc ñ†zn½a pbíüìÜÛ
ÛaòîaŠÔ¹†ÛalbîËë‰aŠÔnüaâ†È×Ý×b’ßåßïãbÈmòÐîÜyòÛë…Þë†Ûa
Ýr·æìØmæcæë… bèÈßÝßbÈnÛak¯…bäí aˆÛ [òî×ßþaòbîÜÛ òíìÛëc
áÄäÛaÙÜmîÌni´×bß–ÖaŠÈÛa‰aŠËóÜÇN
@ @
114
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
ta†yc†Èië11M9òbîÕîjİm¿´×bßòjˉp…a‹BáÄäÛaœíìÔm
òÓ‰b½aBâbLjäßbèikÛbÛa1998òbîÛaÙÜm´iÁiŠÜÛ|™aëÝîßÉß
LÝîöaŠgåßcæbà™µgëÖaŠÈÛaëŒËµgñìdžÛaëa†í†ua†ÈibèîÛgÒb™cë
òîaŠÔ¹†Ûaëý•⁄aòÜvÈiÉφÛaëb×ßþòÐîܧaòîiŠÈÛaáÄäÛaîÌmìçë
Þë†ÛaêˆçÝ’Ïkjib–´×bßôŠíbà×–ò™‰bȽaôìÓÉßÝßbÈnÛa¿
b×ßcéšÈilb•cðˆÛaïÛë†Ûalbç‰⁄aµgbèäßœÈiÞì¤ÛaòîÜa†Ûa
ta†yc¿11M9N
†y bà×ë òî×ßþa ñ‰a…⁄a Éß t–åÇ ÉuaÛa µg ´×bß Šİ™a
âbÇ Ýöaëc ¿ bèÔîjİni òjÛbݽaë òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa Š’ã òbîÛ wíëÛa2006
p†ÔÇÛapbib‚nãüa¿òîßý⁄aôìÔÛa…ìÈ•bèäîiåßòÐÜn«lbjþ
áÇ…óÜÇÞì–zÜÛb×ßcòubyëÖaŠÈÛa¿Êb™ëþað…ŠmëïiŠÈÛabÈÛbi
ÜyÖaŠÈÛa‰aŠÔnaÕîÔ¤¿´í†îÜÔnÛabèöbÐN
¿ b×ßc òjËŠÛ ¿b™gkj ðëìäÛa æaŠíg wßbãŠi ð†¤ æcÒb™cë
´í†îÜÔnÛa bèöbÐÜy Éß æëbÈnÛa– bÔyüôŠä bà×–ïiŠÇÑÜy õbäi ¿
ïãaŠí⁄aæëbÈnÛaéuaìíMð‰ìÛaN
pbí‰ìmbnØí†ÜÛ †ÓbäÛa éibİ åÇ Þ‹bänÛa ´×bß œÏ‰ Áë Ýz×ë
òî×ßþa òbîÛaóÜÇ b÷jÇÝr·áÄäÛaÙÜm æcôŠísîy òîiŠÈÛa–óÜÇ
b×ßcóÜÇïÌjäí éãcë L†îÈjÛaô†½aM¿Þë†ÛaÙÜmÉßæëbÈnÜÛ ñŠİš½a
òîÛb§a ñÐÛa–æbàšÛ Þë†ÛaÙÜni b×ßþ ñ†ãb½aôìÔÛa áÇ†Û Ý†nÛa
í ‰bß ¿ ïaŠÔ¹†Ûa ý•⁄a òÜvÈi ÉφÛaë bèníìÔm¿ òíbèäÛa ¿ k–
ñ†zn½apbíüìÜÛò™‰bÈßòîiŠÇôìÓ…ìÈ•æë…Þì°ëb×ßcb•N
@ @@ @
115
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
bßb@Z@@@@@@@ôØÛa@òîiŠÈÛa@Þë†Ûa@Éß@òÓýÈÛaI@@@@òí…ìÈÛaë@Š–ßbí‰ìëH@ @
Š–ß a†í†¤ë ôØÛa òîiŠÈÛa Þë†Ûbi ´×bß òÓýÇ Þëbäm bäÜšÏ
¹†ÛaŠ’ãòîšÓëæaŠígåßéÐÓìßÞëbäm†Èibí‰ìëòí…ìÈÛaëqdnÛòîaŠÔ
´×bßÝßbÈnísîyL|™aëÝØ’ibí‰ìì−émbbîóÜÇæaŠígåßéÐÓìß
Š’ãòîšÓæcbà×LæaŠígóÜÇ×cŒî׊mÉßbjíŠÔmbèÐãëŠÛbiåí†ÜjÛaÉß
êb£ñ†zn½apbíüìÛaòbîÛ´×bßòíú‰¿ñj×òãbØßoÜnyaòîaŠÔ¹†Ûa
òí…ìÈÛa늖ߖèã¿b㊑cbà×Ýa†nÛaµgòÏb™gaˆçLÕibÛaáÔÛaòíb
´nîîöŠÛa´nîiŠÈÛa´nÛë†Ûbib×ßcòÓýÈÛ´×bßñŠÄã´ijØÛaN
Š–ß
ËÞë†×pbäîÈnÛaŠaëcˆäßbí‰ìëòí…ìÈÛa늖ߵg´×bߊÄã
òîaŠÔ¹†ÛalbîËëïàîÜÓ⁄aÑÈšÛaëáاasí‰ìmÝÓýÔÛŠÈnmñŠÔnß
ÜÇ ‰aŠÔnüaëòîÇaë òî×ßc òbî µg xbn¤ áq åßë LÝíìİÛa ô†½a ó
òħòíc¿bèìÔòî’bèÈßÝßbÈnÛa¿ñ‰ˆyëN159
Þë†× wîܨa Þë…ë æ…‰þaë Š–ß µg bîib¯g ŠÄäÛa åß éÈä¹ aˆçë
ñ†zn½a pbíüìÛa óÜÇ ïÌjäí b×ßc Éß òíìîy pbÓýÇ ÙÜn· òÔ톕
bèÔîqìmN160
†ÛaêˆçÑÜn¥ÙÛˆiëÞë–´×bßô†Û–ÛaæaŠígëÖaŠÈÛb×Þë…åÇ
´×bß bèÐä–í– ÕibÛa ¿ b㊑c bà×–ñ…bîÔÛaë b×ßc ô†znm Þë†×
Llˆ¦a높Ûa´iòØÜà½a늖¶´×bßòÓýÇp‰ìÜjmbà×LbÈÜÛòî×ßþa
@ @
116
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
bàèîÜÇ …bànÇüaë ïÜa†Ûa ý•⁄a åß †íŒ¶ ´nÛë†Ûa òjÛbİß ´i ëc
Ôm´nÐîÜz׆yaëæe¿b×ßþ´ní†îÜN
Úbjí⁄a òàÄä½ Š·ûß âbßc éÛlbİ¿´×bßkÛbÞbr½aÝîjóÜÈÏ
AIPACìîãìí¿2000òîÓbÐmübÔÏ늖½òî×ßþapa†Çb½aáîîÔmñ…bÇhi
óÜÇ òí…b–nÓüapa†Çb½aåß a†íŒß Š–ß b×ßc|ä·sîÐía…kßb×
LòíŠØÈÛapa†Çb½alby161¿´×bßòÔqâ†ÇåÇÈm†ÓkÛbİßïçë
ê‰aŠÔnaóÜÇÃbЧaóÜÇém‰†ÓëémbîãëðŠ–½aâbÄäÛaN
ta†yclbÔÇc¿ë11M9kÈÜibèàèmaëòí…ìÈÛa늖ߴ×bßáubç
Bòuë…ŒßòjÈÛBéãcëLlbç‰⁄aòèuaìß¿b×ßcñ†ãbß¿òîÓa†–½aâ†Çë
ÓìÛa´iì™ìi‰bînüabàèîÜÇpbib熙ëcb×ßcÉßÒìN162
òÜyŠßb×ßþòÐîܧaòîîöŠÛaòîiŠÈÛaÞë†Ûbi´×bßòÓýÇoÜ…aˆèië
bç‰aŠÔna â†Çµg ŠÄäÛaë áÄäÛaÙÜmîÌmkÛbİm ñ†í†u–|ßbmðˆÛa
ÝjÓ bîjã´×bß éÈß11M9–lbjc†yd×òí‰ìmbnØí†Ûa òîÜa†Ûa bèàÄäÛë
b×ßcáubçðˆÛalbç‰⁄a‰ìèÿ11M9N
ò튧aë òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa Š’äi ð…bä½a òîãbrÛa”ìi ñ‰a…glbİ Éß bî’·ë
ÝíŠig ðŠè‘ Þý †îÈ–Ûa aˆç óÜÇ Š–ß µg òíìÓpa…bÔnãa ´×bß éuë
ìíbßë2005ïÛaì§áاa¿Ú‰bjßóäyðŠ–½aîöŠÛaõbÔi†ÔnãasîyL
a†Çgëñ†í†uòîbö‰ñ‰ë†i‹ìÐÜÛÚ‰bjßïÈëLæŠÓÉi‰Láاaòqa‰ìÛéäia…
òíbÐ× â†Çë …ìÔÈÛ ù‰aìİÛa´ãaìÓŠÏë ò™‰bȽa ñ…bÓ åv †Ônãa bà×
ò튖½aý•⁄aÁİN163
@ @@ @
117
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ky‰ aˆÛM ñÐÛa ÞýMòî×ßþa òîu‰b¨a ñŠí‹ë õbÌÛhi bèÐã
å¹c ðŠ–½a‰bȽa åv †Èi Š–½ ñ‰ŠÔßoãb× ñ‰bí‹ía‰ aŒîÛa†ãì×
æcñ‰ëŠ™a†×ûßL‰ìãñŠçbÔÛaóÜÇÂìÌšÛaåßa†íŒßåİä‘aë‰b·N164
ÞýygòîšÓÉßÝßbÈnÛaòiìÈ•bjíŠÔmâbdžÈi†×cë…bÇ´×bßåØÛë
ÖŠ’Ûa‰aŠÔnaóÜÇÙÛ‡qdmåßbÏìòîiŠÈÛaÞë†Ûa늖߿òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa
‰aŠÔnüaâ†ÇåßòîÛbÇòu‰…åßïãbÈíðˆÛaÁëþaN165
ñ‰a…⁄a ÉuaŠm Éß ÙÛ‡ åßaŒníëòîaŠÔ¹… Ñܶ ÉφÛa åÇ òî×ßþa
ñÐÛaÙÜmÞýòÐÜn«lbjþÁëþaÖŠ’ÛaN
éÐã´×b߆uëðëìäÛaæaŠígwßbãŠiêb£ï×ßþaÕÜÔÛa…ìÈ•Éßë
ÑÜyõbäiÝucåßÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa¿b×ßþñ†ãb½aÞë†ÛaádžikÛbİí
ïiŠÇMâbàšãýÛòz‘Š½aÞë†ÛaåßëLæaŠíg†™ïßýgŠ–ßÑܧa aˆ
æbnãbÌÏcëÝîöaŠgëbî׊mëÖaŠÈÛaëòí…ìÈÛaëN166
òí…ìÈÛa
˜Š¡ÕÜÈníbàîÏò•bŠ–ßóÜÇÕjİäíb¾ar×òí…ìÈÛaóÜÇÕjİäí
ÝjÓbèÈßòÓýÈÛaÕîqìmóÜÇ´×bß11M9åßñ†yaëòí…ìÈÛaæì×áØ¡bîÛbyë
æaŠí⁄ð…bȽaÑܧaµgâbàšãýÛòz‘Š½aëñ†zn½apbíüìÜÛòÐîܧaÞë†ÛaN
†Èi Š–ß åß ×c ÁÌšÛo™ŠÈm òí…ìÈÛa æg ÞìÔÛa åعë11M9
¿ æëbÈnÛa â†Èi òí…ìÈÛa ´×bß áèma sîyBlbç‰⁄a óÜÇ lŠ§a B¿
âbÇÝöaëc2002L167µg‰b‘cëò׉b’ßæcB15Bpbàvç¿bí…ìÈ11M9
òí…ìÈÛaõbÇ…aåßáËŠÛaóÜÇBkyëâayaBLb×ßc168ÚìØ’ÜÛrߊßc
@ @
118
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
êba bßÝíìàni òØÜà½a´×bß áèma bà×BòîÛbØí…aŠÛa òîßý⁄apbàÄä½bi
b×ßcëlŠÈÛa߆mµgòîßaŠÛaBN169
Þb©¿ òí…ìÈÛaÝvÛ´×b߆Ôãµg òÏb™g aˆçBòîäí†Ûapb튧aB
òî×ßþaòîu‰b¨añ‰a‹ëóÜÇÁÌ™´×bßæcµgòîÐz•Ší‰bÔm’msîy
M âbÇ Ýöaëc ¿2003Mb×bènãa Šr×þa Þë†Ûa áöaìÓ óÜÇ òØÜà½a É™ìÛ
òîäí†ÛapbíŠzÜÛN170
wîܨbi òí‰ìa bènãbØßë ÖaŠÈÛa åß ¿aŠÌ¦a òí…ìÈÛa lŠÔÛ aŠÄãë
a ŠíŠ¤lŠy¿ bç‰ë…ëaŒîyÖaŠÈÛa êb£ òí…ìÈÛa òbîoÜnyaoíìØÛ
òî×ßþapbÓýÈÜÛ´×bßòíú‰åßaj×MâbLjäàÏLòí…ìÈÛa1998´×bßë
ÁÌšÛaëÖaŠÈÛaõaìnya¿ŠÄnä½aÝØ’Ûbiòí…ìÈÛaæëbÈmâ†ÇåßïØn’í
´×bßôc‰sîyLÖaŠÈÛaóÜÇðŠØÈÛaï×ßþaâìvbikîyÛaëéîÜÇ
½aÑÈ™æcåßæb×ÖaŠÈÛa†™ a…†’mŠr×þa b×ßcòbîÛ òîiŠÈÛa ñ†ãb
pbäîÈnÛaŠaëc¿éÛŒÇëÖaŠÈÛaõaìnyaòbîÝ’ÐÛòîîöŠÛaÝßaìÈÛaN171
ŠíaÏïÐÏ2003´×bß呆yaëŠè’iÖaŠÈÜÛï×ßþaëŒÌÛaÝjÓðc
Ý’Ï åÇ érí†yŠÈß ¿ òîàîÜÓ⁄a òí…ìÈÛa òbî óÜÇ bLJü bßìvç
bîêëŒËódžnab¾ÖaŠÈÛaõaìnyaòN
BLåí…†’n½a ´îßýfiÛ bîbîë bí…bß bàÇ… òí…ìÈÛak‚äÛapŠÏë
oªbmðˆÛaoÓìÛa¿lbç‰fiÛòîaŠÔ¹†ÛaÝîöaŠgòÛë…òßëbÔßoºbçë
b‰ëba‰ìmbnØí†ÛaÉßéîÏIâa†•HŠÐÛ bã…ìèuñj×òu‰†ioÓbÇcëL
pbiìÔÈÛaIÖaŠÈÛa óÜÇHLÖbÇc ÝØ’i bämaìÓ óÜÇ ò߉b• a…ìîÓ o™ŠÏë
@ @@ @
119
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
åß ‰bîÈß ÝØÛ ÖaŠÈÛa Úbènãa p†ícë LbäàîÓ æbçcë bä’îu pa…a†Èna
IíbÈßH‰aŠÔnüaâ†Çñ…bîÞbànybibßbànçaŠr×cp†iëLïÛë†ÛaæìãbÔÛa
óÜÇÖaŠÈÛa òŠÔß… éÐÜ¥ æc åعðˆÛa qdnÛbië âa†• †Èi bßÖaŠÇ¿
ÝàÜàn½abèjÈ‘NB172
âbÇŠaëcåßòía†iÖaŠÈÛa¿Êb™ëþað…ŠmÉßë2003´×bßÞì¤M
òØÜààÜÛ ê†Ôã¿M†íŠmüÛaÞë†Ûaåß ñ†yaë òí…ìÈÛaædiÞìÔÛaµg
Êb™ëþaóÜÇbväÛaaˆçqdmåßbÏìÖaŠÈÛa¿b×ßþbväÛaëÕîÏìnÛa
⁄biòîÜa†ÛakÛbݽañ…bí‹óÜÇëòØÜà½biòîÜa†Ûaý•N173
âbÇ¿òí…ìÈÜÛ´×b߆ÔãÉuaŠmŠ–ßÉßt†ybà×ë2006b½aŠÄã
Š–ß ádž۴×bß òub§ëpb톤åß òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa Š’ã òbî éÛo™ŠÈm
bí‰ìëæaŠí⁄œçbä½aÑÛbznÛaõbäjÛòí…ìÈÛaëN
bí‰ì
ta†yclbÔÇc¿bí‰ì´×bßnÇaæaŠíg‰aŠËóÜÇ11M9åßñ†yaë
½aÞë†ÛaÉ™ë†ÓëLb×ßckšËó’¥æck¯Ûalbç‰fiÛòîÇaŠÛaòÓ‰b
ÖaŠÈÛaáqæbnãbÌÏcïÜmòjmŠß¿Þë†Ûaêˆç´×bßN174
ñ†yaëbèãcôc‰ëÖaŠÈÛa¿bí‰ì݆m´×b߆ÔnãaæaŠíg‰aŠËóÜÇë
åßëÖaŠÈÛbi Êb™ëþa ‰ìç†måß ñ…bÐnüaÞëb¤Ûa òîîöŠÛaÞë†Ûaåß
þa…ìè¦aÝ’ÏLÚbäçòî×ß175Ý’ÏŠÄnämÛaÞë†Ûaåßñ†yaëbí‰ìæcë
aˆç åÇ áubäÛa ÎaŠÐÛa õݽ ݆nÜÛ ŠØj½a bèibzãaë ÖaŠÈÛa ¿ b×ßc
lbzãüaN176
@ @
120
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
…ìÈí†ÔãìçëLæbäjÛ¿ð‰ìÛa‰ë†ÜÛŠàn½a´×b߆ÔãµgòÏb™gaˆç
ñ‰ëŠši´×bßkÛbsîypbäîÈnÛa Šaëeµg Ší†ÔmÝÓcóÜÇlbzãa
µëþaòîböŠÛaénÜ»ÞýæbäjÛåßbí‰ìI2000NH177
âbÇÑî•¿æbäjÛóÜÇÝîöaŠglŠyÞýë2006éãc´×bßôc‰
bþbiæbäjÛë bí‰ìóÜÇ bèİÌ™Œ×Šmæc ñ†zn½apbíüìÛaóÜÇïÌjäí
éÛ´m†ãb½aëalŒ§´nîÇaŠÛabàç‰bjnÇbiN178
óÜÇÁÌšÛa´×bßÝšÐí aˆÛbèÈßÝßbÈnÜÛòÜîì× bènèuaìßë bí‰ì
LbîÛë…ëbîàîÜÓgbŒÇëòîÛë†ÛapbiìÔÈÛaÞýåß179âbÄäÛaòã…bèߜϊíë
‰aŠÔnaÕîÔ¤¿éãëbÈmóÜÇÞì–§aÝucåßÙÛ‡æb×ìÛëónyð‰ìÛa
ÖaŠÈÛaN180
b…b@Zâý⁄a@ñ‰ì•ë@´×bß@lbİ@ @ aõŒu bä–î–¥ kjMa b×ßc òbî åÇ òa‰… åßêb£ òîu‰b¨
bèîÜÇ´×bßæìuòî×ßþaòböŠÜÛð‰ìèà¦a|‘Š½aqdmëÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa
MénÜ»ë´×bßlbİ¿ŠèÄmbà×´àܽaëâý⁄añ‰ì•åÇsí†zÜÛ
lŠÌÛaëb×ßc¿†Çb–nßâìvçåßñ‰ì–ÛaÙÜméÛŠÈnmbßìçòîböŠÛa
ta†ycˆäß11M9åßéiæbèníüõŒuæìØÛëL´àîÛaåßâ…bÓâìvaaˆç
òbîémbÇbİÓœÈiádžmðˆÛaï×ßþaBÑíì‚nÛaBlŒ§a bèÈjmaÛa
lŒ§aìÉßò•bñþapaìäÛaÞýð‰ìèà¦aMêõa‰ëåßë
´iŠy b×ßcMÑÿÛë LÖaŠÈÛaë æbnãbÌÏc bàçë ´àÜß åí†Üi ¿
ô†ÛáÜßëïiŠÇìçb¶Ñíì‚nÛaòbîoİjm‰aóny´î×ßþaåßr×
@ @@ @
121
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
òßba bíbšÔÛa †yclŠÌÛa ïàÜßÖìÔyë bîiìÏìßý⁄a òÜØ’ßozj•c
òî×ßþaòîiŠÈÛapbÓýÈÛañ†äucóÜÇòyëŠİ½aN
ê†àÈni âý⁄a µg õïí ðˆÛa éÐã ´×bßlbİÙÛ‡ µg Òbší
ñ…†’n½apbÇbà¦aÉßb×ßcÊaŠ•Ñî•ìm¿ò÷bpbzÜİ–ßâa†‚na
bÇbjmŠ’äbà×òàܽaÞì•þapa‡N
ò÷bò÷îßpbzÜİ–ß
êbabߊݨéjnãaéãcŠ×‡aŠûß´×bßõaŠucsí†yïÐÏBÒŠİnÛbi
ïÛbØí…aŠÛaïßý⁄aBRadical Islamic ExtremismpbäîãbàrÛaÝöaëcˆäß
¿æbäjÛlŠyÞýòî×ßþaòíŠzjÛapaìÓéÛo™ŠÈmðˆÛaâìvaˆäßë
Çâb1983N181
…bnÇa ´×bß æc òÔibÛa ñ‰bjÈÛa ¿ |™aìÛaëBbíìÌÛ BÒŠİnÛa Ái‰
âý⁄bi òîÛbØí…aŠÛaëBåí†× Bb×ßc éuaìm ðˆÛa ð†znÜÛ éÐî•ìm ¿
´yïÐÏLòîßýgpa‰bÈ‘ÉÏŠmÛaëcòàܽapbÇbà¦aœÈiåßâ…bÔÛaë
òzÜ–ßâa†‚naåí†íbaòíŒîܬüalbn×ÝšÐíBý⁄a´îßBIslamists
pbÇbà¦aÙÜmÑ•ìÛMpbÇbà¦aÙÜmædi bÇbjİãaïİÈí|Üİ–ßìçë
òäîÈßòîuìÛ†íþknämM|Üİ–ßâa†‚na…bnÇa´×b߆¬IslamicðˆÛa
ïßý⁄a åí†Ûa µg Š‘bjß ÝØ’i pbÇbà¦a ÙÜm käíIslamòÌÜÛa ¿
àn½aë ù‰bÔÛa ô†Û aj× bİÜ kjí b¾ òíŒîܬ⁄aåí†× âý⁄a ´i É
òîßýgpa‰bÈ‘ÉÏŠmÛañ…†’n½apbÇbà¦aëN
ÕÜÔ½a dݨa ëcÁܨa aˆç …ìÈíëM´×bßpbibİ¿MÑ–näßµg
êbabߊİåÇémbibİ¿´×bßt†¤´yŠí†ÔmÝÓcóÜÇpbäîÈnÛa
@ @
122
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
Bòîßý⁄aòîÛì•þaâa†–iIslamic FundamentalismbÈànaáîÓÉßp
òîiŠÌÛaBlŠ§a õbènãa †Èi bß Š–Ç¿ïÛë†Ûa âýÛapa†í†èmáçc†yd×
ñ…‰bjÛaN182
ÒŠİnÛañ‰ëŠšÛbiÈmüòîßý⁄aòîÛì•þaæc†ÈibàîÏŠ’îÛ…bÇë
ïßý⁄aIslamic ExtremismpbßìØyõbäiµgóÈmbèãþñİbèäØÛë
òí‰ìqòîßýgN183
Ðy‰bqc´×bßlbİæcë†jíë òî×ßþa òàܽapbàÄä½a òÄîMˆäß
´§a ÙÛ‡M òî×ßþa òîßý⁄a pbÓýÈÛa Ü© kn× sîyI×H
Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIRHåÇ ÊbφÛbi Ƚa
àÏìã¿´×bßµg bibİb×ßc¿´àܽaëâý⁄añ‰ì•1999Mðc
òîböŠÛa ´×bß òÜ» ÞýI2000 HMåÇ s톧a åÇ ÑÓìnÛbi éjÛbİí
BïÛbØí…aŠÛa ïÛì•þa âý⁄a …ìÈ• BRadical Fundamental Islam
b×ßþòîîöŠÛapa†í†ènÛa†yd×N184
Ûa òÔibÛa ò÷î½a pbzÜİ–½a âa†‚na ¿ ´×bß Šàna ÙÛ‡ Éßë
âý⁄bi òîÛbØí…aŠÛaë ÒŠİnÛa ÁiŠm Ûaë bèîÜÇ …bnÇaBåí†× BÜÛa ¿òÌ
òíŒîܬüaN
†í†ènÛaòÈîj
éÐíŠÈmïçëôŠcòÜØ’ßpbzÜİ–àÜÛ´×bßâa†‚naõìÛÒbšíë
´×bß éîàí bßë b×ßc ´i áöbÔÛa ÊaŠ–Ûa òÈîjİÛBïßý⁄a ÒŠİnÛbi
ïÛbØí…aŠÛaNB
@ @@ @
123
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
æbäjÛóÜÇÝîöaŠglŠyÞý‚ÏMâbÇÑî•¿2006M´×bߊׇ
åßõŒuæbäjÛóÜÇÝîöaŠglŠyæcæcëLb×ßcbèä’mÛaôØÛalŠ§a
´i ìç ïÔîÔ§a ÊaŠ–ÛaBLbÈÛa Ç òÏŠİn½a òîÛbØí…aŠÛa òîßý⁄a ôìÔÛa
òîiŠÌÛa íbȽaë pa†ÔnȽaë áîÔÛaë LÁëþa ÖŠ’Ûa ¿ ò•bëBÙÛˆië L
òîbîÛa bç‰ëˆ pbÇaŠ• åß Áëþa ÖŠ’Ûa ¿ ‰ë†í bß ´×bß ÞŒn±
ÐÜn‚½a òbnÛaëôìÓéä’mÊaŠ•¿òBòÏŠİnß òäí†nßBòîiŠÌÛaáîÔÛa êŠØm
æ†ànÛaëñ‰bš§aáîÓëN185
ægôŠcòjbäß¿´×bßÞìÔíëBòîßý⁄aòîÛbØí…aŠÛaB¿ŠèÄmbà×
a lŒyë ñ†ÇbÔÛa Ýrß pbÇbº ñ…bîÓBåß ïßý⁄a bÈÛa ÑîÄäm †íŠm
ŠíìänÛa Š–Ç áîÓë òqa†§aBí… ï™bß µg ñ…ìÈÛaë LL‰ìİnß ïÛbrß â‰b•
õbäiæë†íŠíáèãcëBòÏýBbèîÜÇŠİîÛaï™a‰þaÇBâý⁄aB¿b¶
æëŠÓˆäßbi‰ëcbèîÜÇŠİîmï™a‰cÙÛ‡N186
†™ lŠ§a ´×bß nÇa †ÓëBÒŠİn½a ïÛbØí…aŠÛa âý⁄a Báçc
å튒ÈÛaëð…b§aæŠÔÛalëŠyN187
ÐnÛaœÈiÑÜbäçÖbäí´×bßæc|™aìÛaëñ…†’n½aòîäîàîÛapa
bljb–m†è’mòîàîÓòí‰bšyòîšÔ×lbç‰⁄aµgŠÄäÛa†àÈnmÛalbç‰fiÛ
òîiŠÌÛa ñ‰bš§a ´ië æìîßý⁄a æë…†’n½a bèÈÏŠí òîäí… òîuìÛ†íc ´i
¿ b×ßcóÜÇ´îibç‰⁄a âìvçæc bÇbjm õüûçôŠíë LbèàîÓë11M9æb×
òî×ßþaáîÔÜÛáènîçaŠ×kjiœÌiñŠànßòí†öbÔÇòîçaŠØÛaêˆçÝrßæcë
pbzÜİ–ß âa†‚na µg õüûç œÈi Ýî¹ë Lb×ßc pbbî åÇ ŠÄäÛa
òîßýgBâý⁄aëòÏý¨aë…bè¦b×B´ÏŠİn½a òîuìÛ†ícåÇáèrí†y†äÇ
@ @
124
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
âý⁄a µg ‰bînÛa aˆç ñõbg ÕàÈíë a†îÔÈm Šßþa †íŒí b¾ ´àܽa
òîßý⁄alìÈ’ÛaëÕİä½aaˆçÝrߜϊmÛaN
Šr×þa ´î×ßþa åíŠØнaë lbnØÛa åß Še êb£a ð…bäí ÝibÔ½a ¿
õbİdi ÒaÇüaë …bÈiþa ñ…†Ènß òÜØ’à× lbç‰⁄a µg ŠÄäÛbi òí…bîy
òí…b–nÓüaë òîÇbànuüaë òîbîÛa ‰ëˆ¦a åÇszjÛaë òî×ßþa òbîÛa
‰⁄apbÇbà¦a…ìÈ•µgp…bÓÛaåßë‰ëˆ¦aÙÜmxýÇÝßcóÜÇòîibç
pbzÜİ–½bi xŒÛa õüûç œÏŠí bà× LòîÔîÔ§a lbç‰⁄a Éibäß ÑîУ áq
pa‰bÈ‘æìÈÏŠíåíˆÛaåí…†’n½aòîuìÛ†ícåÇs톧a¿òÜî•þaòîßý⁄a
òîÓa†–ßáèîİÈíÙÛ‡æcáØ¡òîßýgN
òÏŠİn½aïzî½a´àîÛapa…bîÓ
ÜÈnm ôŠc òÜØ’ß Úbäç´àîÛapa…bîÓœÈi ÝjÓ åß´×bß ádži Õ
â†Èië´àܽaëâý⁄aµgò÷î½aáèmb°Š–ni´ÏëŠÈ½aÒŠİn½aïzî½a
ÔÛaÞbrßcåßÙÛ‡ë LáèÈßénÓýÇÉİÓëcpb°Š–nÛaÙÜnÛ´×bß òãa…g
…ë‰ÔÛaëL…ìèîÜÛbèîÏõbcpb°Š–mkji´×bßéãa…cðˆÛaïubçæìu
ðˆÛa ïÜíŠi éãdi âý⁄a Ñ•ëBÑíŒß åí… Bt…aì§a ÙÜm Ýrß ¿ë
ÑÓaìßåÇÈmü˜b‚‘þaõüûçpb°Š–mæcòîböŠÛa´×bßòÜ»†×ûm
kÛbİí ÉjİÛbië Lbèäß aõŒu aìîÛ åØÛë´×bß òÜ» æìàdží áèãcë´×bß
bèibz•cëò÷î½apb°Š–nÛaêˆçòãa…hi´×bßæìî×ßþalŠÈÛaëæìàܽa
Ø’iéÐÓìßåÇjÈnÛa¿â‹byïbî†öbÓðcåߊÄnäßìçbà׊‘bjßÝ
ÒŠİnÛaë…†’nÜÛœÏaŠÛaN188
@ @@ @
125
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
âbÇòíbèã¿pb°Š–ni´×bßµ…cbà×2007ÝšÐíéãdibÇbjİãaïİÈm
†Üj× b×ßc òÈîjkji ñ†zn½a pbíüìÛa òbö‰ áÜßîö‰ ïÛìm â†Ç
Š×‡sîyLòîzî½aáîÔÛaóÜÇjßïzîß´×bßZ
BòyaŠ–iÞìÓc Z òßþa êˆçæþ aŠÄãéãgIb×ßcHóÜÇbþbioîäi
òîzîß áîÓ NNN a…ŠÏ bî–‚‘ ÝšÏc ïãhÏIbîö‰ H¿ ðìÓ bc éí†Û
ãbí…NB189
éãc†×cë…bÇ´×bßåØÛëB|‘ŠßÝšÏcæb×ìÛáܽpì–íÒì
òîbîÛabäàîÓåÇÊbφÜÛë†ÜjÛañ…bîÔÛNB190
×bßæc|™aìÛaëæcëòäí†n½aòîzî½apa‰bînÛaµgïànäíüïãbàÜÇ´
åß ÕÜİäí ü †Ó ´àܽaë âý⁄a µg éjãaìu œÈi ¿ õï½a éibİ
´i ÊaŠ–Ûa Ðm Þëb¤ òîäî¹ paÐm åß éÓýİãa ‰†Ôi òîäí… pbÔÜİäß
åß ñ†zn½a pbíüìÛa Éß òîßýg pa‰bÈ‘ ÉÏŠm Ûa ñ…†’n½a pbÇbà¦a
ÜİäßÕÜÈn½aÙÛ‡ ò•bë ÊaŠ–Ûa åßïbîÛakãb¦aÝàèm òí†öbÔÇpbÔ
òjbä½a ò÷îjÛaÏìm¿oàçbÛa bèöbİcë bèma‡ òî×ßþa òbîÛa ‰ë†i
pbÇbà¦aÙÜm…ìÈ–ÛN
ïãbrÛa@õŒ¦a@ò·b@ @óÜÇáاa¿ÊŠnãåÛ bäãc òa‰†ÛaåßåçaŠÛa õŒ¦a òía†i¿ bãŠ×‡
φçæcë´×bßæìu bä– âba õŒ¦a aˆçÞý–´×bßÑÓaì߆•‰ìç
ÕöbÔ§a ɺ µg Ò†èí a†•‰ Áëþa ÖŠ’Ûa bíbšÓ áçc êb£ bç‰ìİmë
pbšÓbäm b¶‰ë —öb– åß bèíÈí bßë bèÜî•bÐmë ÑÓaì½a ÝÜmë
@ @
126
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
sÛbrÛa õŒvÜÛÑÓaì½aÙÜmóÜÇ âbÈÛa áاaÚãæcóÜÇÙÛ‡ë LòîÜa…
Ûaòa‰†Ûaåßþaëåíbؽòî–‚’ÛaòîÐܨaÞëbäníÝ–Ðibçbãc†iN
lŒ§bi énÓýÇë ´×bß òî–‚‘ æc †î×dnÛbi Þëþa õŒ¦a bäàn †Óë
ÝØ’i òîu‰b¨a òybÛa óÜÇ òí‰ìÔ–Ûaë …†’nÛa µg éãbÈφí ð‰ìèà¦a
òbîÛabèèuaìm†ÓÛaôØÛapbí†znÛaëÉöbÓìÛaôìéä߆°ü|™aë
íÝØ’iòî×ßþaòã…bè½aóÜÇ´×bßáËŠN
‰ìİm Éjnm æc bç…bÐß òèib’ß ò•ý µg Ý–ã õŒ¦a aˆç òíbèã ¿ë
Éß ÝßbÈm´×bß æc |™ìíÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa bíbšÓ áçc êb£´×bßÑÓaìß
ñìÔÛaòÌÛïÜÈíï܆mð‰ìÔ•î¹wèäßåßáÇþakÛbÌÛa¿bíbšÔÛaÙÜm
ü†i‰bȽaŠŁaîÌmòÌÛë‰aì§aóÜÇéÐãoÓìÛa¿LéÈßáçbÐnÛaåß
Éß ÙÛ‡ ÒëŠÄÛa éîÜÇo™ŠÏ b߆äÇ òã…bè½a µg Šİ™a ´×bß æc bã†uë
ŠÏaìmòÛby¿òí‰ìÔ–ÛaéÐÓaìßµgñ…ìÈÛa¿òjˉ녆’nßlbİ¢ÃbÐnyüa
ŠÏaìnm a‡g à™ ÝØ’ië Ýíì ô†ß óÜÇ bèÔîjİm ëc LÙÛˆÛ ò•ŠÐÛa
ôŠcÝöbëN
†’niÕÜÈníbàîÏëñ†ÇóÜÇ‹íìèÏÁëþaÖŠ’ÛabíbšÓêb£´×bß…
ïÜíbßbèc‰óÜÇïmdíLpbíìnßZ
üëc ZîöŠÛa âbÄã îÌni bjÛbİß ÖaŠÈÛa åß a…†’nß bÐÓìß ´×bß ÑÓë
âbÇ ˆäß ´y âa†• ïÓaŠÈÛa1998áçc †yd× ´×bß ‹Ši bà× L
ßþa ñ‰a…⁄ax‰b båí†ãb½aëÖaŠÈÛalŠyµg´Ça†Ûa†Èi òî×
ta†yc11M9lbØm‰a †Èië ëŒÌÛa †ÈilŠzÜÛ´×bßáÇ… Šànaë
@ @@ @
127
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
bç†Ônãa õbİc ïçë LÙÛbäç õbİþa åß †í†ÈÜÛ òî×ßþa ñ‰a…⁄a
ÖaŠÈÛbiï×ßþaÊ늒½aóÜǘŠ§albiåßéÐã´×bßN
bîãbqZñ…a‰⁄aÙÜn¹…bØíüìèÏL…†’nÛa¿òíbËÝîöaŠgêb£´×bßÑÓìß
ëcœîÔäÛaóÜÇÝšÐíëLòÔİä½biâýÛaòîÜàÇòÜvÈiÉφÛa¿òjËŠÛa
æìîîäîİÜÐÛa Ìí óny ´îÜîöaŠ⁄a åÇ ´îäîİÜÐÛa Ý–Ï òbî
áèÐãcN
†ÈikÛb´×bßægÝi11M9ïiŠÈÛabÈÛaîÌmóÜÇb×ßcÝàÈmædi
bîòÜvÈiÉφÛbi´×bßkÛb´yÙÛ‡ëLÝîöaŠhiÝjÔíïØÛéÜ׊’ãò
åßûm áÄäi býygë òí‰ìmbnØí†Ûa òîiŠÈÛa áÄäÛa îÌm Ýßc óÜÇ òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa
ÝjÔmëÝîöaŠhiÝjÔmë b×ßc †ãbmë ò튧aë òîaŠÔ¹†Ûaë â†ÔnÛaë òqa†§bi
bèÈßâýÛaÕîÔ¤ëbèiÒaÇüaóÜÇN
brÛbq Zmµg´àÇa†Ûa†‘cåß éi´İîaåí‰b’n½aÕíŠÏë´×b߆Èíj
æc óny Lòî×ßþa ñ‰a…⁄a x‰b bí‰ìë æaŠíg Éß òèuaì½a òbî
òî×ßþañ‰a…⁄aòÜ»åßõŒub¶‰ë…a†nßaìç´×bßæcôŠíœÈjÛa
æaŠíg†™N
bÈia‰Z†Èi a†í†ubîäzäßpˆc´×bß bçbäjmÛaòîaŠÔ¹†ÛaŠ’ãòbî
ta†yc11M9×bß éîÏ …a‰c Ýßb‘ ‰ì–ni ar× Ájm‰aõbäi ñ…bÇg ´
åß bÓýİãa ü ÝîöaŠgë b×ßc m òÜ×b‘ óÜÇ Áëþa ÖŠ’Ûa
ò‰bའòîÔîÔy ò•ŠÏ òÔİä½a lìÈ‘ õbİÇg ¿ òîÔîÔy òjˉ
bèãë†íŠíÛapbbîÛaëbèãìÜr¹å߉bînüëòîaŠÔ¹†ÛaN
@ @
128
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
bßb ZïãbàÜÈÛa ´×bß ……Ší ´àܽaë âý⁄a åßÑÓì½bi ÕÜÈní bàîÏ
üìÔßpbÇbà¦aë b×ßc´i ÊaŠ–Ûa ‰ì–m òÔÜÌäßë ñ…†’nß òîäî¹p
ô†½aÝíìïuìÛ†ígïàîÓÊaŠ–×òîßýgpa‰bÈ‘ÉÏŠmÛañ…†’n½a
kji òî×ßþa áîÔÛaë ñ‰bš§a ߆nÛ biŠy æìîibç‰⁄a éîÏ å’í
´×bß ÝàèíÙÛˆië LáîÔÛaÙÜnÛ òí†öbÔÈÛa áènîçaŠ×– bãŠ×‡ bà×–
‚½a…bÈiþaéîÏò÷b¨aòî×ßþapbbîÛa‰ë…ëÊaŠ–ÜÛòÐÜnN
æc ÝjÓ òÔibÛa ñ…†’n½apbbîÛa óäjm´×bß æc Õj bàîÏÅyýíë
áÄäÛa îÌnikÛbİí´×bàÏ LéÐã”ìi ìîÜi… x‰ìuîöŠÛa ñ‰a…g bçbäjnm
BòÓ‰b½aBâbLjäßïÓaŠÈÛaâbÄäÛaa†í†¤ë1998ta†yc†Èi……íëL11M9
¿óÜÇÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa õbäi ñ…bÇhi òjÛbݽaëÖaŠÈÛaóÜÇlŠ§aÞìjÖ…
ÝØ’i âýÛa òîÜàÇ åÇ´×bß óÜ¥ bà× LÝîöaŠgë b×ßc m òÜ×b‘
âbLjäß|튕ë|™aë2002bàîÏòî×ßþañ‰a…⁄a´¹óÜÇéÈšíbjíŠÔm
Šßþa aˆèiÕÜÈníIí bàîÏ”ìiñ‰a…gåßa…†’mŠr×cë†jíéãcðcéÐÓì¶ÕÜÈn
âýÛaòîÜàÇåßNH
âbÇ ˆäß òã…bèàÜÛ ïmbºÛa ´×bß Šİ™a ŠŁa ôìn½a óÜÇ2006
Òëb«†íaŒmëpbib‚nãüa¿´îßý⁄a…ìÈ•ëÖaŠÈÛalŠyõbİckji
µg ñ…ìÈÜÛ ´×bß Šİ™asîy LïãaŠí⁄a ðëìäÛa wßbãÛa Šİ åß b×ßc
§aòîiŠÈÛaÞë†ÛaÉßæëbÈnÛaòbîòÐîÜ–òí…ìÈÛa늖à×–Þë†Ûaïçë
´×bß …a‰c †ÔÏ LbçîÌmÞëbyë bèní‰ìmbnØí…kjiï™b½a¿ bç†Ônãa Ûa
ÙÛ‡ášíæcóÜÇLïãaŠí⁄að‰ìÛa‰ìaéuaìíÑÛb¤¿Þë†ÛaÙÜmá™
ÝîöaŠgëÖaŠÈÛaëæbnãbÌÏcÑÛbznÛaN
@ @@ @
129
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
LáÄäÛaÙÜmòã…bè¶a†îÈ´×bßë†jíüÉjİÛbiëL´yµgbèã…bèíìèÏ
†íŠíë–‰bÄnãüañÏÞýMb×ßþñ†ãb½aôìÔÛbiÉφÛaóÜÇÝàÈíæc
áqåßë Lb†m áØzÜÛôìÔÛaÙÜmÝ–mæcÝßcóÜÇ áÄäÛaÙÜmÝa…
´×bßlŠšíB†yaëŠv¡åí‰ìЖÇBpbîãÞìyÞúbnÛaríŠßcìçëL
òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa Š’ä× bíbšÓåß òîÔîÔ§a´×bßkËŠíÝèÏ LÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa¿
ÝîöaŠgëb×ßþñ†ãbßáÄã†íŠíéãcâc_òîaŠÔ¹…òîiŠÇáÄã¿bÔy´×bß
_òîÜa†Ûaò튧aëbnÐãüaå߉†ÔiáÈämë
bã†Çbí æc Ýßdã bä× ægë LæŁa éîÜÇkî¬ü †ÓkÈ•ë âbç Þaû
òa‰†Ûa åß þaë ïÛbnÛa õŒ¦aM×bß ‰ì–m Þëbäní ðˆÛa´òbîÜÛ
Ýßb‘ÝØ’iòî×ßþaòîu‰b¨aMéîÜÇòibu⁄aåߊr×dÏŠr×clŠÔÛaóÜÇN
@ @
130
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
ïãbrÛa@Ý–ÐÛa@“ßaìç@ @
1 David B. Ottaway, “U.S. Gave Iraq Bacteria, Sen. McCain Charges,” The Washington Post, 26 Jan 1989, A-16. 2 St. Louis Post-Dispatch, “Senators Urge ‘Sound, Fury’ Against Iraq,” St. Louis Post-Dispatch, 12 April 1990, A-8. 3 Juan J. Walte, “Top Option: Air Strikes, Blockade: Use of Ground Forces Too Risky, Experts Say,” USA Today, 7 August 1990. 4 R. W. Apple Jr., “Confrontation in the Gulf; Views on the Gulf: Lawmakers Versed in Vietnam,” The New York Times, 16 Sep 1990, section 1, Part 1, 18. 5 David C. Morrison, “Hawks Overstate Potential Impact of U.S. Air Power,” The Toronto Star, 27 Sep 1990, A-17. 6 Leslie Phillips, “On Capital Hill; In War, Congress Closes Ranks: Resolution Hails Bush and Troops,” USA Today, 18 Jan 1991, A-8. 7 Dana Priest, “Nation Is Spared Anguish Over POWs; Unlike After Vietnam, U.S. as Victor Got Fast Action From Iraq,” The Washington Post, 7 March 1991, A-25. 8 John McCain, “A Statement Delivered by Senator John McCain on the Floor of the US Senate Regarding Iran-Iraq Non-Proliferation Legislation,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 29 June 1993. 9 McCain, “A Statement Delivered by Senator John McCain on the Floor of the US Senate Regarding Iran-Iraq Non-Proliferation Legislation.” 10 McCain, “A Statement Delivered by Senator John McCain on the Floor of the US Senate Regarding Iran-Iraq Non-Proliferation Legislation.” 11 John McCain, “Defining an American Role in an Uncertain World, Remarks by Senator John McCain at the Nixon Library at their National Policy Conference,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 2 March 1995. 12 Capital Times, “Hypocrisy on Dissent,” Capital Times (Madison, WI), 4 Sep 1996, A-10. 13 CNN, “McCain Comments on White House Briefing on Iraq,” CNN: Morning News 09:29 am EST, 17 Sep 1996. 14 David Hench, “Senator Attacks Clinton’s Record; Senator John McCain, A Former POW, Visit Maine to Support The Campaign of Rep. James Longley and Susan Collins,” Portland Press Herald, 8 Oct 1996, B-4. 15 John McCain, “A Statement Released By Senator John McCain Regarding Further Aggression by Iraq,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 11 Nov 1996. 16 The Associated Press, “McCain Demands Deadline For Strike on Iraq,” Telegraph Herald (Dubuque, IA), 16 Feb 1998, A-2. The Associated Press, “McCain: Religious Holiday Shouldn’t Limit U.S. Options in Iraq,” The Associated Press, 17 Dec 1998. 17 John McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain on the Floor of the US Senate Regarding The Recent Posturing by Saddam Hussein,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 9 Feb 1998.
@ @@ @
131
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
18 McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain on the Floor of the US Senate Regarding The Recent Posturing by Saddam Hussein.” 19 Bruck, “McCain’s Party.” 20 John McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 9 March 1998. 21 Craig R. Whitney, “Crisis With Iraq: In France; Report on McCain’s Remarks About Tip-Off Angers Paris,” The New York Times, 17 Nov 1998, A-8. 22 John McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain to the National Jewish Coalition,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 1 Dec 1999. 23 Charles A. Radin, “McCain Demons Military Shortfalls,” The Boston Globe, 8 Dec 1999, A-19. 24 John McCain, “Talking Points of Senator John McCain – APIAC Summer Seminar Series,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 20 June 2001. 25 John McCain, “Delay Can Be Dangerous,” USA Today, 14 Feb 2003. 26 Daniel Rubin, “U.S. Leaders Talk Tough to Enlist NATO Units; McCain Says Iraq Must be the Next Front in Fight Against Terrorist Nations,” The Times Union (Albany, NY), 3 Feb 2002, A-11. 27 John McCain, “Senator John McCain Address to American-Israel Political Action Committee,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 23 April 2002. 28 John McCain, “Senator John McCain’s Speech to the American Jewish Committee,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 9 May 2002. McCain, “Delay Can Be Dangerous.” 29 John McCain, The Road to Baghdad, Time, Sep 9, 2002. 30 John McCain, “The Right War for the Right Reasons,” The New York Times, 12 March 2003. 31 John McCain, “No Time to Sleep,” The Washington Post, 24 Oct 2002. 32 John McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain to the Center for Strategic and International Studies Regarding Iraq,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 13 Feb 2002. 33 McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain to the Center for Strategic and International Studies Regarding Iraq.” 34 Eric Schmitt, “Threats and Responses: Bipartisan Hawks; New Group Will Lobby for Change in Iraq Rule”, The New York Times, 15 Nov 2002, A-18. 35 John McCain, “Statement by Senator John McCain in Response to Hans Blix Report to The United Nations on the Iraq Weapons Inspections,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 27 Jan 2003. 36 McCain, “The Right War.” 37 John McCain, “Comments of Senator John McCain on the Senate Floor Relating to The Impending War with Iraq,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 19 March 2003. 38 John McCain, “Past the Point of Justifying,” The Washington Post, 15 June 2003. John McCain, “Iraq: The Test of a Generation,” Council on Foreign Relations, http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 22 April 2004. 39 McCain, “Past the Point of Justifying.”
@ @
132
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
40 McCain, “Past the Point of Justifying.” 41 John McCain, “We Must do What it Takes to Finish Job in Iraq,” Tucson Citizen, 9 Sep 2002, B-5. John McCain, “How to Win in Iraq,” The Washington Post, 9 Nov 2003. McCain, “Iraq: The Test of a Generation.” 42 Stewart M. Powell, “Republicans Criticize ‘Irresponsible’ Rumsfeld: Armour Follows G.I.’s Query,” National Post (Canada), 16 Dec 2004, A-14. 43 John McCain, “Our Exit Strategy in Iraq is Victory,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 5 Nov 2003. 44 McCain, “How to Win in Iraq.” McCain, “Our Exit Strategy.” 45 McCain, “Our Exit Strategy.” 46 McCain, “Iraq: The Test of a Generation.” 47 John McCain, “Hard Truth,” The New Republic, 28 June 2004. 48 Powell, “Republicans Criticize ‘Irresponsible’ Rumsfeld.” 49 John McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain Before the Senate Committee on Armed Services on Iraq,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 12 Jan 2007. John McCain, “U.S. Security Depends on Iraq Democracy,” 19 May 2006. 50 John McCain, “Winning in Iraq,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 10 Nov 2005. 51 John McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain During The Senate Armed Services Committee Hearing on the Nomination of General David Petraeus to Become the Top Commander in Iraq,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 23 Jan 2007. 52 John McCain, “Statement by Senator John McCain before the Senate Committee on Armed Services Preceding Testimony by Chairman of the Join Chiefs Peter Pace and the Secretary of Defense Robert Gates on the Current situation in Iraq,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 12 Jan 2007. 53 John McCain, “Statement of Senator John McCain before the Senate Armed Services Committee about the Findings of The Independent Commission on the Security Forces of Iraq,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 6 Sept 2007. Dan Balz, “The War Within Senator John McCain,” The Washington Post, 13 Jan 2007. 54 John McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain at the Republican Jewish Coalition Victory 2008 Forum and Luncheon,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 16 Oct 2007. 55 John McCain, “A Statement by Senator John McCain on the Floor of the U.S. Senate Regarding Amendments Offered by Senators Levin (D-M) and Kerry (D-MA) to the Department of Defense Authorization Bill,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 22 June 2006. 56 John McCain, “Statement by Senator John McCain on the Resignation of U.S. Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 8 Nov 2006.
@ @@ @
133
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
57 John McCain, “Statement by Senator John McCain on the Release of the Iraq Study Group’s Final Report,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 6 Dec 2006. John M. Border, “Report on Iraq Exposed A Divide Within the G.O.P,” The New York Times, 10 Dec 2006, 1. 58 John McCain, “Remarks of Senator John McCain to the Plenary Session of The American Israel Public Affairs Committee 2006 Annual Summit,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 23 Oct 2006. 59 John McCain, “The War You Are Not Reading About,” The Washington Post, 8 April 2007. 60 John McCain, “Statement of Senator John McCain on the Senate Floor Regarding the Iraq Resolution,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 14 March 2007. 61 John McCain, “Statement of Senator John McCain about the Levin-Reed Amendment about a Timetable for Withdrawal of U.S. Troops from Iraq,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 20 Sep 2007. 62 John McCain, “Remarks of Senator John McCain to the National Council of Young Israel in New York City,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 14 March 1999. 63 John McCain, “Talking Points of Senator John McCain – AIPAC Summer Seminar Series,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 20 June 2001. 64 McCain, “Talking Points of Senator John McCain – AIPAC Summer Seminar Series.” 65 McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain, Presidential Candidate, at the Republican Jewish Coalition Victory 2008 Forum.” 66 McCain, “Senator John McCain Address to American-Israel Political Action Committee.” New York Sun, “McCain in Jerusalem,” New York Sun, 13 March 2008. 67 Richard Boudreaux, “McCain Visits Besieged Town. Israelis in Sedrot Tell The U.S. Senator and GOP Candidate of the Trauma Caused by Palestinian Rocket Fire,” Los Angeles Times, 20 March 2008, A-3. Dion Nissenbaum, “McCain Calls for Peace Talks in Israel; Palestinians Question Why Senator Made no Effort to Meet Them,” Charlotte Observer, 20 March 2008, A-4. 68 Andy Soltis, “Israel Right To Retaliate,” The New York Post, 20 March 2008, 12. 69 McCain, “Senator John McCain Address to American-Israel Political Action Committee.” 70 John McCain, “John McCain Addresses Christian United For Israel,” States News Service, 18 July 2007. 71 McCain, “Senator John McCain’s Speech to the American Jewish Committee.” 72 McCain, “Remarks to the National Jewish Coalition.” 73 McCain, “Senator John McCain’s Speech to the American Jewish Committee.”
@ @
134
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
74 McCain, “Remarks of Senator John McCain to the National Council of Young Israel.” 75 Janine Zacharia, “McCain: If Elected I Won’t Pressure Israel,” The Jerusalem Post, 2 Dec 1999, 2. 76 McCain, “Talking Points of Senator John McCain – AIPAC Summer Seminar Series.” Matthew E. Berger, “Ever the Maverick, McCain Supports Separation Between Israel, Palestinians,” Jewish Telegraph Agency, 22 June 2001, 7. 77 McCain, “Senator John McCain Address to American-Israel Political Action Committee.” 78 Charles A. Radin, “Sen. McCain Favors Israel’s Security Fence, Backs Release of Arafat,” Boston Globe, 19 August 2003. 79 Ron Kampeas, “Rudy’s Jews Expected to Back McCain,” Jewish Telegraphic Agency, 30 Jan 2008. 80 Zacharia, “McCain.” 81 Seanna Adcox, “McCain Doubtful of Progress in Peace Process Talks, Saying Terrorists Don’d Want Israel to Exist,” The Associated Press, 28 Nov 2007. 82 Jason Maoz, “McCain: ‘Proudly Pro-Israel’ – Says Haaretz Article Left ‘Serious Misimpressions.’” The Jewish Press, 17 May 2006. 83 John McCain, “Statement of Senator John McCain on the Situation in Israel,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 12 Oct 2000. 84 McCain, “Talking Points of Senator John McCain – AIPAC Summer Seminar Series.” 85 Maoz, “McCain.” 86 Richard H. Curtiss, “Rating the Remaining Presidential Candidates on Mideast Issues,” Washington Report on Middle East Affairs, 31 Dec 1999, Vol. XVIII, No. 8, P. 56. 87 Adam Brodsky, “McCain Tells an Arab Group Jerusalem is Israel’s Capital,” Forward, 12 Nov 1999, Vol. CII; No. 31, 1, 88 The Forward, “McCain Touts Stance of Israel,” The Forward, 15 Feb 2008, A-5. 89 McCain, “Senator John McCain’s Speech to the American Jewish Committee.” 90 Jennifer Siegel, “McCain Sounds Skeptical Note on Peace Process,” The Forward, 30 Oct 2007. 91 The Associated Press, “McCain: Israel’s Response Appropriate,” Arizona Daily Star, 16 July 2006. 92 NBC News Transcript, “Senator John McCain Discusses Current Conflict Between Israel and Hezbollah in Lebanon,” NBC Transcripts, 17 July 2006. 93 A. J. Higgins, “Sen. McCain Campaigns For Woodcock; Opposition to Mideast Cease-fire Voiced,” Bangor Daily News, 24 July 2006, A-1. 94 John McCain, “McCain Addresses the Plenary Session of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee 2006 Annual Summit,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 23 Oct 2006
@ @@ @
135
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
95 John B. Judis, “Neo-McCain,” The New Republic, 16 Oct 2006. 96 McCain, “McCain Addresses the Plenary Session of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee 2006 Annual Summit.” 97 McCain, “McCain Addresses the Plenary Session of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee 2006 Annual Summit.” 98 Siegel, “McCain Sounds Skeptical Note.” 99 Adam Dickter, “McCain: Iraq Pullout Bad for Israel,” The New York Jewish Week, 2 Nov 2007, Vol. 220, No. 24, 11. 100 McCain, “Statement by Senator John McCain on the Release of the Iraq Study Group’s Final Report.” 101 Shani Rosenfelder, “Grappling with Iran, Diverse Paths to Israeli Security. Democracies Must Unite to Confront Tehran, Sen. John McCain Tells the Post,” The Jerusalem Post, 8 June 2007, 7. 102 The Forward, “McCain Touts Stance of Israel.” 103 Nathan Guttman, “McCain Slammed For Saying U.S. a “Christian Nation,”” The Forward, 1 Oct 2007. 104 Dickter, “McCain: Iraq Pullout Bad for Israel.” 105 Calev Ben-David, “Why the ‘Maverick’ McCain is Likely to Follow consensus when it comes to Israel Policy,” The Jerusalem Post, 8 Feb 2008. The Forward, “McCain Picks up Endorsement from Baker, to Little Protest,” The Forward , 14 March 2008, A-1. 106 Marc Caputo, “Lieberman Seeks Jewish Vote for McCain,” The Bradenton Herald (Florida), 17 Jan 2008. Ron Kampeas, Jews Favor Clinton, Giuliani, Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Dec 11, 2007. 107 Giuliani, “Toward a Realistic Peace.” Luce, “The Republicans’ Jockeying.” 108 Brune, “The Candidate on Iran.” 109 Giuliani, “Toward a Realistic Peace.” 110 Santora, “Giuliani Calls for Increasing American Support.” 111 Luce, “The Republicans’ Jockeying.” 112 Kampeas, “Rudy’s Jews.” 113 Caputo, “Lieberman Seeks Jewish Vote.” 114 Joe Lieberman, “Why I Back McCain,” Jewish Telegraphic Agency, 29 Jan 2008. 115 Douglas Bloomfield, “John McCain and the Jewish Vote,” The Jerusalem Post, 6 Feb 2008, 13. 116 Beth Young, “McCain Enjoys Diverse Jewish Support,” Jewish Telegraphic Agency, 8 Jan 2008. The Right Web, “A Profile of Mark Broxmeyer,” The Right Web, http://rightweb.irc-online.org/profile/1061.html, 23 May 2007. 117 The Right Web, “A Profile of The Jewish Institute For National Security Affairs,” The Right Web, http://rightweb.irc-online.org/profile/1508.html, 24 May 2007.
@ @
136
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
118 Suzanne Fields, “McCain as Judah Maccabee; Why the Senator can Tap into the Jewish Vote,” The Washington Times, 7 Feb 2008, A-21. The Forward, “McCain Touts Stance of Israel.” 119 McCain, “A Statement Delivered by Senator John McCain on the Floor of the US Senate Regarding Iran-Iraq Non-Proliferation Legislation.” 120 McCain, “A Statement Delivered by Senator John McCain on the Floor of the US Senate Regarding Iran-Iraq Non-Proliferation Legislation.” 121 Thomas W. Lippman, “Russia-Iran Atomic Deal Irks U.S.; Sen. McCain Asks State Dept. to Act,” The Washington Post, 11 Feb 1995, A-1. 122 John McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain on the Floor of the United States Senate Regarding Legislation to Renew the Iran-Libya Sanctions Act,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 25 July 2001. 123 John McCain, “From Crisis to Opportunity: American Internationalism and The New Atlantic Order,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 2 Feb 2002. 124 McCain, “Our Exit Strategy.” 125 John McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain at the Senate Armed Services Committee Hearing with General Petraeus and Ambassador Crocker,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 11 Sep 2007. 126 McCain, “Talking Points of Senator John McCain – AIPAC Summer Seminar Series.” 127 NBC News Transcript, “Senator John McCain Discusses Current Conflict.” Higgins, “Sen. McCain Campaigns For Woodcock.” 128 Judis, “Neo-McCain.” 129 McCain, “Remarks of Senator John McCain to the Plenary Session of The American Israel Public Affairs Committee 2006 Annual Summit.” 130 McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain at the Republican Jewish Coalition Victory 2008 Forum and Luncheon.” 131 McCain, “Remarks of Senator John McCain to the Plenary Session of The American Israel Public Affairs Committee 2006 Annual Summit.” 132 Margot Sanger-Katz, “McCain: Despite Report, Iran Remains Dangerous; Senator Showcases Foreign Policy Stands,” Concord Monitor (New Hampshire), 8 Dec 2007. 133 Gregory Levey, “The Iran Hawaks’ Latest Surge,” Salon.com, 7 March 2008. 134 Michael Cooper, “McCain Missteps on Iraq, Democrats Pounce,” The New York Times, 19 March 2008, A-15. 135 Joe Conason, “Bomb, Bomb Iran?” Salon.com, 21 March 2008 136 Gareth Porter, “Official Propaganda About Close Iran-Al Qaeda Ties; McCain’s Gaffes Reflect Buhs’s Iran-Qaeda Myth,” Inter Press Service, 24 March 2008. 137 Eli Lake, “McCain, Obama Clash Over Iran’s Al Qaeda Role,” The New York Sun, 20 March 2008, 5. 138 The Jerusalem Post, “McCain Says War With Iran Would be a ‘Hard Sell,’” The Jerusalem Post, 17 April 2008, 7. 139 Young, “McCain Enjoys Diverse Jewish Support.”
@ @@ @
137
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
140 Tom Witosky, “McCain: Aid Nations That Fight Terrorism,” Des Moines Register (Iowa), 25 Oct 2007, B-1. 141 John McCain, “McCain Introduces Resolution Calling on FIFA to Ban Iran From Soccer World Cup,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 6 April 2006. 142 McCain, “Statement by Senator John McCain on the Release of the Iraq Study Group’s Final Report.” 143 Rosenfelder, “Grappling with Iran.” John McCain, “An Enduring Peace Built on Freedom; Securing America’s Future,” Foreign Affairs, Nov/ Dec 2007. 144 McCain, “John McCain Addresses Christian United For Israel.” 145 Paul Richer, “Campaign ’08; McCain Far From Predictable on Foreign Policy; Neoconservatives and Pragmatists Alike See The Candidate as Agreeing with Them. His Record is Complex,” Los Angeles Times, 16 March 2008. 146 The Jerusalem Post, “McCain Says War With Iran Would be a ‘Hard Sell’.” 147 McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars.” 148 McCain, “Senator John McCain Address to American-Israel Political Action Committee.” 149 McCain, “Senator John McCain’s Speech to the American Jewish Committee.”. 150 McCain, “The Road to Baghdad.” 151 McCain, “The Right War.” 152 McCain, “Past the Point of Justifying.” 153 McCain, “Our Exit Strategy.”. 154 John McCain, “Security in The Middle East: New Challenges for the US and Europe,” Hampton Roads International Security Quarterly, April 2005, 12-15. 155 John McCain, “McCain, Lieberman Introduce “Advance Democracy Act,”” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 3 March 2005. 156 John McCain, “McCain Reacts to Palestinian Election,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 26 Jan 2006. 157 Glenn Greenwald, “Bush and McCain’s Shared Foreign Policy Approach,” Salon.com, 28 March 2008. 158 John McCain, “John McCain’s Speech at the Los Angles World Affairs Council,” San Gabriel Valley (California), 26 March 2008. 159 John McCain, “Ready Tomorrow: Defending American Interests in the 21st Century,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 1 March 1996. 160 James J. Zogby, “Gore and McCain Speak to Arab Americans,” Mideast Mirror, 29 Nov 1999, Vol. 12, No. 230. 161 McCain, “Talking Points of Senator John McCain – AIPAC Summer Seminar Series.” 162 Sue Pleming, “Senators Accuse Arab Allies of Waffling,” The Philadelphia Inquirer, 22 Oct 2001, A-7. 163 McCain, “Security in The Middle East.” 164 Bruck, “McCain’s Party.”
@ @
138
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
165 John McCain, “Keynote Address by Senator John McCain at the Seventh Day Adventist Annual Religious Liberty Dinner,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 4 May 2006. 166 Witosky, “McCain.” 167 McCain, “From Crisis to Opportunity.” 168 McCain, “Hard Truth.” 169 Joyce Howard Price, “Senators Warn of Saudi-Funded Threat; McCain Says Arab Oilmen Have Made iFaustain Bargain with Radical Islam,” The Washington Times, 25 Nov 2002, A-14. 170 Peter Slevin, “U.S. Considers Citing Saudi Arabia for Intolerance; State Dept. May Use Diplomacy or Privately Confront Kingdom to Win Gains for Religious Minorities,” The Washington Post, 18 Jan 2003, A-17. 171 McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain on the Floor of the US Senate Regarding The Recent Posturing by Saddam Hussein.” 172 McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain to the Center for Strategic and International Studies Regarding Iraq.” 173 McCain, “Our Exit Strategy.” 174 McCain, “From Crisis to Opportunity.” 175 McCain, “Iraq: The Test of a Generation.” 176 McCain, “A Statement by Senator John McCain on the Floor of the U.S. Senate Regarding Amendments Offered by Senators Levin (D-M) and Kerry (D-MA).” 177 Zogby, “Gore and McCain.” 178 Higgins, “Sen. McCain Campaigns For Woodcock.” 179 McCain, “Winning in Iraq.” 180 McCain, “Statement by Senator John McCain on the Release of the Iraq Study Group’s Final Report.” 181 Newsweek, “A Conversation About What is Worth The Fight, Forces Can Only be the Last Option, McCain Says, But the World is a Dangerous Place,” Newsweek, 7 April 2008, Vol. 151, No. 14, 30. 182 McCain, “Defining an American Role.” 183 McCain, “Ready Tomorrow.” 184 Hanna Rosin, “GOP Aide’s Words Anger Muslims; Group Sees Pattern in Party Statements,” The Washington Post, 12 Jan 2000, A-17. 185 The Associated Press, “McCain: Israel’s Response Appropriate.” 186 John McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain at the Hoover Institute,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 1 May 2007. 187 McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain at the Republican Jewish Coalition Victory 2008 Forum and Luncheon.” 188 Heagney, “Critics Tie McCain.” 189 Stephen Labton, “McCain Casts Muslims as Less Fit to Lead,” The New York Times, 30 Sept 2007, 22. 190 Labton, “McCain Casts Muslims.”
139
sÛbrÛa@Ý–ÐÛa@ @…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛa@ @
´×bßæìuòbîóÜÇïöbèäÛaáاaÚãbäãcòa‰†Ûaòía†i¿bãŠ×‡
sÛbrÛa Ý–ÐÜÛ Áëþa ÖŠ’Ûa êb£ òÈÓìn½aÉ™ìÛ é––®ðˆÛa þaë
òbîÜÛ´×bßòíú‰p‰ìİmÑî×ëòîu‰b¨aéÐÓaìßë´×bߊØÐÛâbljì–m
åíþaåí†ÔÈÛaÞýòî×ßþaòîu‰b¨aN
ïãbrÛa õŒ¦a¿ b䙊Èmë´×bß òî–‚’Û Þëþa õŒ¦a¿ b䙊Èm †Óë
¿ Þëbänäë LÁëþa ÖŠ’Ûa bíbšÓ áçc åß …†Ç êb£ éÐÓaìß ‰ìİnÛaˆç
âbÇ ÝØ’i òî×ßþa òîu‰b¨a òbîÜÛ ´×bß òíú‰ p‰ìİm Ñî× õŒ¦a
‰…bÔÛaÖbîÛaÝr·ÛaòíúŠÛaóçëLæŁaónyëpbäîÈnÛaÝöaëcˆäßÝßb‘ë
ÖbîÛaáèÐÏ LÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa bíbšÓ êb£ ñ…ŠÐä½a´×bßÑÓaìßÐmóÜÇ
Ò늧aóÜÇÂbÔäÛaÉ™ìÛëÝî•bÐnÛaáèÐÛð‰ëŠ™N
–iëìçëLâbänîÏÝîuµgïànäíæb×´×bßæcµgõŒ¦aaˆç—ܱòßbÇòÐ
òî܆nÛa òîu‰b¨a pbbîÛaë òîu‰b¨a l늧a ì ó’± æb× Ýîu
ᬠ…ìÈ•ëîÏìÛa …b¤üa ‰bîèãaëoíìØÛa ŠíŠ¤lŠyåØÛë Lòí‰ìÔ–Ûaë
‰bgåÇszjÛaµg´×bß bèÈîºoÈÏ…†yëþabÈÛakİÔ× b×ßcòíú‰ëc
ñÐÛaÙÜm¿ëLòî×ßþaòîu‰b¨aòbîÜÛñ†í†u–pbäîÈnÛaÑ–näß–Þì¤
Š¬ìØÛbi´í‰ìèà¦a‰ìÔ•áçc†ycµgâbänîÏÝîuõbšÇc†ycåß´×bß
òÐÜn‚½aéÐÓaìßëê‰bØÏcåÇåíȽaë…†¦a´ÄÏba‰bîmåß´jíŠÔÛaN
@ @
140
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
rÛa òí‰ìÔ–Ûa ´×bß òî–‚‘ oàçb b¶‰ëŠqc b¶‰ë LÙÛ‡ ¿ ñŠöb
òÐÜn«Ší‰bÔm’msîyLéîÜÇéiæìİîa–Ýî–ÐnÛbibŠÈnã–æcµg
pbîäîÈnÛaòíbèã¿…†¦a´ÄÏba‹ì߉åß…†ÈiéÐãÂbyc´×bßN
òböŠÛapbib‚nãa ¿´×bß ‹ìÏ æc µg õŒ¦a aˆç òíbèã ¿—Ü® aˆÛ
òî×ßþaI2008 HaïİÈíÒìoîjÛaóÜÇñŠİîÜÛò•ŠÐÛa…†¦a´ÄÏb
òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa óÜÇ |™aë ÝØ’i aëŠİî b߆Èi òrÛbq òíüìÛ œîjÛa
”ìiìîÜi…x‰ìuîöŠÛaíüëÞýòî×ßþaI2001M2008NH
ajÈmë …†¦a´ÄÏba ‰bîmåß biŠÓ Šr×c´×bßæìuæc†ÔnÈã bäãgÝi
ìiìîÜi…x‰ìuåßáèÐÓaìßåÇïãbrÛaáÔÛa¿bèyŠ’ãÒìlbjþ”
ˆäß …†¦a ´ÄÏbbi ´×bß òÓýÇ ‰ìİm ÝÜ° Òì ðˆÛa õŒ¦a aˆç åß
ò߆Խ閖®ÒìÏÞëþaõŒ¦abßcLæŁaónyëpbäîÈnÜÛïãbrÛaÑ–äÛa
òbîÛa µg òßbÈÛa áèmŠÄãëïbîëðŠØÏ ‰bîn× …†¦a´ÄÏba ‰bîm åÇ
òî×ßþaòîu‰b¨a´×b߉bØÏc´iëáèäîiÁiŠÜÛð‰ëŠ™áç‰bØÏcáèÐÏLN
üëc@Z_…†¦a@æìÄÏba@áç@åß@ @´ÏëŠÈ½a´ÄÏbalbnØÛaë´îbîÛaåßòÇìà©áç…†¦aæìÄÏba
ï™b½aæŠÔÛapbäîÈj¿‰bîÛaµg´àîÛaåßáìzniëòîÛaîÜÛaáèmbîÐÜ¢
½aóÜÇòîÛaîÛÑÓaìßáèîäjnië¿òîÜa†ÛaòîÇbànuüaëòí…b–nÓüapbíìn
ôìnß óÜÇ òÄÏbaë òí‰ìÔ–Ûa ñ†í†‘ ÑÓaìß éîÏ æìäjní ðˆÛa oÓìÛa
áØ¡ …†¦a´ÄÏbbi áèЕìÛœÈjÛa ÉÏ…ðˆÛa Šßþa Lòîu‰b¨a òbîÛa
æcæër×ôŠíëLï×ßþaÅÏbaîàîÛa‰bînÛaóÜÇòö‰bñ†í†uò÷Ïáèãc
@ @@ @
141
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
a´ÄÏba†èÇ¿òî×ßþaòîu‰b¨aòbîÛaòËbî•¿aj×a‰ë…aìjÈÛ…†¦
ñ‰bqgòbîÛaÙÜmŠ•bäÇŠr×cœÈiÙÛ‡¿b¶”ìiìîÜi…x‰ìuîöŠÛa
ÁëþaÖŠ’ÛaóÜÇéîÏÍÛbj½aŒî×ÛaëÖaŠÈÛalŠybèc‰óÜÇëÞ†vÜÛ
ÝîöaŠ⁄ÕÜݽa‹bî−üaëN
biÑíŠÈnÜÛáÔÛaaˆç¿óÈäëx‡b¸ëáç‰bØÏcáçcë…†¦a´ÄÏb
lŒzÜÛòîu‰b¨aòbîÛaóÜÇáèmŠİîlbjþÙÛˆ×ëáèm…bÓáçcœÈjÛ
¿ áç‰ìšy ñìÓë bèi aëŠß Ûa pbß‹þaë òîÛb§a ñÐÛa ¿ ð‰ìèà¦a
Þëbänã æcóÜÇÙÛ‡ë L´×bß æìu òÜ»x‰b òîÛb§a òîböŠÛapbib‚nãüa
ÔÛa¿´×bßæì áènÓýÇcŒ¦aaˆçåßþaëïãbrÛaáN
…†¦a´ÄÏbaÞbîuc
lbn× ÑÛûß “nîÐbi 뉆ãe áÔíBòî×ßþa òíŠØÈÛa òÇŒäÛa
ñ†í†¦aB´Üîuµg…†¦a´ÄÏbaZ´ÜîuÛaåßåíŒîànßåíŠØнaë´îbîZ
ÝÈÏ…Š×ê‰bØÏcpõbuëå튒ÈÛaæŠÔÛaåßpbäînÛa¿‰ìÜjmÞëþaÝî¦a
a óÜÇë òîÛë†Ûa ÒëŠÄÛÛac b o™ŠÈm Ûa òîÜa†Ûa pbí†znßÞý b×
Ñ–näß¿ âbänîÏlŠy òíbèã ónyµëþa òî½bÈÛalŠ§aåß ñ†nà½a ñÐÛa
pbäîÈjÛaNåÇÈnÛê‰bØÏcpõbuëpbäîÈnÛa¿ŠèÆÔÏïãbrÛaÝî¦abßc
òîÛë†ÛaëòîØíŠßþaÒëŠÄÛaÞýÙÜmñÐÛaN1
’íëÐbi“nî…ìuëµgÝrß…†¦a´ÄÏbaïÜîu´iò×’ßáaìÓ
qdnÜÛáöa†ÛaáèîÈëLÉÓaìÛaîÌm¿‰bØÏþa‰ë†iáèãb¹g¿Þ†¦a‰bß
ßþaÞ†vÜÛïènämüÛaáènîè‘ëLáèàèmÛabíbšÔÛa˜ì–¢âbÈÛaï×
@ @
142
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
ëÛòÔrÛbiŒîàníðˆÛaáèibİëLáèbÈßòºbèßëáç‰bØÏcŠÈbà§aë
bãbîycéîÏÍÛbjßÝØ’iïÜa†Ûab™ŠÛaëN
âýÛa òîÜàÈÛ áèšÏ‰ë ÝîöaŠ⁄ òÔÜݽa áèm†ãbß µg òÏb™g aˆç
òîäîİÜÐÛaM‰ˆ°sîy LìÜëcpbÓbÐmaåßbcóÜÇ òàöbÔÛa òîÜîöaŠ⁄a
ݧaæcæëŠíëLlŠÈÛa¿òÔrÛaåßÝîöaŠgòÐÜn‚½aábîudi…†¦aæìÄÏba
¿åàØílŠÇÉßâýpb™ëbÐß¿oÓìÛaòÇb™g¿üÝîöaŠgñìÓõbäi
ÖŠ’Ûa óÜÇ ÂŠÐ½a áçŒî׊m ¿ æýî¦a Ú‰b’ní bà× LÝîöaŠhi æìÜjÔí ü
òÔİä½aêb£b×ßcòbîóÜÇëÁëþaN
ÞëþaÝîÇŠÛa
òjäÛbiµgaëþaÝî¦ÞâìÔmÝî¦aaˆçò׊yë‰bØÏcæc“nîÐbiôŠí
‰bØÏcóÜÇòîîö‰ònïçëLZ2
M bi âbànçüa ò•bë ƒí‰bnÛiòî½bÈÛa lŠ§a åß ñ†nà½a ñÐÛa ta†yd
…ìÈ• p†è‘ Ûa ñÐÛa ïçë òîãbrÛa òî½bÈÛa lŠ§a ónyë µëþa
‰ë… ÉuaŠmë òí‹bäÛab×ßcë Lµëþa òî½bÈÛa lŠ§a †Èi ïÛë†Ûaïç
òÜyŠßô†Ûp†×cåßÞëþaÝîÇŠÛaäÓ…†¦a´ÄÏba´nÇb´ní‰ìªZ
bàèîãbqëLbç‰bØãgåعüñ…ìuìßòîÈÓaëòÔîÔyñŠçbÊ’Ûaæcbàëc
a†ÇcïãaìmìçëÁîiŠ’iæìçŠßŠ’Ûa…ìÈ•æcéöénßëbÔßåÇN
M òíŠØÈÛañìÔÛaæc…†¦aæìÄÏbaôŠí–òÛa†ÈÛaëcòîbßìÜi†ÛaîÛë
ïÛë†ÛaÉànaëc–ÛaÑy‹ÒbÔígåßoäØ·Ûaïçí‹bä[òaˆÛŒîàní
…†¦a æìÄÏbai‰ë†i ÕÜÈní bàîÏ âúb’nÛaë œÏŠÛa åß j× ‰†Ô
@ @@ @
143
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
L|ÜnÛaå߆§a…ìèuëïÛë†ÛaæìãbÔÛaëòîÛë†ÛapbàÄä½aëæcæëŠí
òîu‰b¨a òîbîÜÛ bîîö‰ bbc óÔjm æc k¯ òíŠØÈÛa ñìÔÛa
òîØíŠßþa[ aˆÛßþa“î¦a bŠÈm Ûa pa…bÔnãüa a왉bÇï×
ÛaâbänîÏlŠy†Èiê‰ë…ëòîq‰bØN
M íÄÏbaœÏŠìßc òÛŒÇ ñŠØÏ …†¦a æ×LïÛë†Ûa bç‰ë… ÉuaŠm ëc b
ëßþæcæëŠíñŠ‘bä×ëéÛòîßby늧abÈÜÛ ñ†öbÔ× bbm a‰ë… b×
í bà× LbÈÛa Ç ò튧aë òîaŠÔ¹†ÜÛæìäßûißc óÜÇ ædb×
´î×ßþaëà¤ë‰ë†ÛaaˆèiÞìjÔÛabàèßénÐÜØmÝoÈÐm‰aN
M åÇáöa…ÝØ’i…†¦aæìÄÏbaszjíñj×òîu‰bÒa†çcëÉí‰b’ß
bØíŠßþ[òîu‰b¨a bènbîëãbÇ aˆÛaìpbäîÈjÛa Þý ar×
bjÜpŠqcÛaâbänîÏlŠypbÈjmkjipbîãbàrÛaë¿kÈ’Ûa†îídm
ßþaë“îvÜÛï×ÛÏbaóãbÇbà×LïÛë†ÛabØíŠßc‰ë†…†¦aæìÄ¿
lbÔÇcëñ…‰bjÛalŠ§aòíbèã‰bîèãaaüpbäîãbàrÛaòíbèã¿îÏìÛa…b¤
óÜÇkmŠm b½ÙÛ‡ñ‰båß…†¦a´ÄÏbaÛðˆÛajØÛaÊ늒àÜ
áèäعåßbØíŠßcòbîòËbî•éma‰ŠÔ½bÔjòîu‰b¨aN
M åßûíÄÏbaìë LòîbîÛa ñ…bîÔÛa ‰ë†i …†¦a æbàöa… æìÈí‰ìrÈÜÛ
ƒí‰bnÛa òÇbä• óÜÇ ñ‰…bÓ òby òîbî ñ…bîÓ óÜÇ[êŠ× aˆÛ
åß †§aë âýÛa ôëbÇ… óÜÇ Œ×‰ ðˆÛa Šm‰b× …†¦a æìÄÏba
æb¯‰ åÇ Ýßb× ÝØ’i a왊í ë LbÈÛa ¿ l늧a [lbİ æþ
¿éÛbÈÏcÕibİíæbãŠÛaðìÔÛaæb¯‰œÈiæbîyþaN
M bîÜa… …†¦a æìÄÏba †×ûí pbİÜÛa ‰ë… pbû½aëòí†îÜÔnÛa
MõbiŁb×ñŠþaëæìãbÔÛa ˆîÐäm pbûßë “î¦aëMÉàna Ýa…
@ @
144
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
oybnua Ûa òîÏbÔrÛa ñ‰ìrÛa …†¦a æìÄÏba œÏ‰ †ÔÏ LïØíŠßþa
pbîÜÓþa ÖìÔyë òîÏbÔrÛa òí…†ÈnÛbi p…bã Ûa pbäînÛa ¿ bØíŠßc
æìÄÏbaôc‰‡g L‡aì’Ûaë õbäÛaëpbû½aóÜÇâìvaæc …†¦a
ßcÑÈšíæcéãd‘åßòí†îÜÔnÛabîu‰bbèÐÈšíb¾bîÜa…b×N
…†¦a´ÄÏbzàÜÛÞëþaÝî¦a‹ì߉‹Šicåß뉊aŒní‰ìç…ìiæb߉ìã
†yc†ÈíðˆÛaòîØíŠßþaòí…ìèîÛaòävÜÛaåÇñ‰…b–Ûað‰bnäßì×òÜÕibÛa
a‰bînÛ´û½aõbiŁaáçc L…†¦a´ÄÏbåߊr×c¿éîÛg b㊑cðˆÛaìçë
ð…ë‰òÜ»áÇ…¿ê‰ë…åÇs톧a†äÇò•bLòa‰†Ûa¿ÕibÉ™ìß
òî×ßþaòböŠÜÛð‰ìèà¦a|‘Š½aïãbîÛìuI2008NH
µg òÏb™⁄bi aˆçÞìníŠ× wäîÏŠígIrving KristolòÜ© ûß
òßbÈÛa òzÜ–½aBoíãgÙîÜibi a‡BThe Public Interest ìçë LðˆÛa
…†¦a´ÄÏbzàÜÛïyëŠÛalþbiæërØÛaéЖíN
bu‡ì¸cŒní‰ìç…ìiæb߉ìã
Þëþa Ýî¦a ‹ì߉ åß †yaë ñß µg bÈíŠ ŠÈnÛa bäÛëby ìÛë
Œní‰ìç…ìiæb߉ìãñbäÛëbänÛ…†¦a´ÄÏbzàÜÛMkÔܽaB´ÄÏba†di
…†¦aB¿òaŠ‘åßéäÇÒŠÇb½ê‰bîm‰bØÏþwíëÛa–ˆ‚níðˆÛaìçë
…†¦a´ÄÏbaåßÞëþaÝîÇŠÛañ½b±‰dmòîmaˆÛaémåßæërØÛaN3
âbÇ ¿ Ú‰ìíìîã òíüìi ´Ü×ëŠi ïy ¿ Œní‰ìç…ìi æb߉ìã †Ûë1930
aÔÏæb߉ìãd’ãëLbãbjÛê†ÛaëÝàÇëLbi‰ëcÖŠ‘åßåíŠubèß´í…ìèíåíìiþ
Ça†ànÈßåßêbäØßæaˆÜÛabàçëLbväÜÛåíj×b»ëìàİibÇìφßéma‡óÜ
´nÓìߊ½a´nî×ßþax†íà×ëbîjßìÛì×pbÈßb òîa‰…|䶋ìÐÛaN
@ @@ @
145
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
Œní‰ìç…ìiæb߉ìã¿œÈjÛaôŠíë–´îû½aõbiŁaåßêËë‰bînÛ
…†¦a´ÄÏbaMìçëL´î×ßþa…ìèîÛaåß´ÈßÝî¦aŒß‰éîÛgŠÄãÝîu
oİjm‰asîyÝjÔn½a¿áèÜßcéãcóÜÇb×ßcµg…†¦a…ìèîÛaæëŠubè½a
µëþa´n½bÈÛa´iŠ§añÏÞýbi‰ëc…ìèíåßñj×…a†Çc†Ïaìniê‰ëˆu
¿ xb߆ãüa åÇ õüûç åß ñj× a…a†Çc pŒvÇ †Óë Lb×ßc µg òîãbrÛaë
ÛaÕöaìÇkjiï×ßþaÉàna…ìèîÛaåßÝî¦aaˆçÞìÇaˆÛ[òÏbÔrÛaëòÌÜ
åí…b¦a´yìàİÛaáèöbäicóÜÇåíŠubè½aMŒní‰ìç…ìiÞbrßcåß–ñ…bîÓ¿
ñ‰†ÔÛaë òÌÜÛa æìØÜn¹ æìàÜÈnß áèãc áØ¡ ï×ßþa Éàna ¿ áèub߆ãa
ïf½bi áç‰ìÈ‘µg òÏb™g aˆç òî¹…b×þaë òîàÜÈÛapýçû½aëjÈnÛaóÜÇ
ÛaòîãbrÛaòî½bÈÛalŠ§aÞý…ìèîÛabŠÈmN4
ð‰bnäßì× òÜv¶ ŠØÐßë kmbØ× Œní‰ìç…ìi æb߉ìã ƒí‰bm Ájm‰a †Óë
Commentarybèm‰†•cÛaòî×ßþaòí…ìèîÛaòävÜÛaAmerican Jewish
Committee (AJC) âbÇ ¿1945pbû½a ×c ô†yg ïç ñþaë L
½a òî×ßþa òí…ìèîÛaæg æì‰û½a ÞìÔíë LòîbîÛaë òßbÈÛa æëû’Ûbi òîäÈ
´iÝ•ëòÔÜyòibr¶æìØmïØÛòÜ©Š’ãp…a‰còî×ßþaòí…ìèîÛaòävÜÛa
Lñ†zn½apbíüìÛaÇ…ìèîÛaòßbÇë´ÐÔr½a…ìèîÛa5òÔÜybšícæìØmïØÛë
âbÇÝØ’iï×ßþa‰ìèà¦aë´î×ßþa…ìèîÛa´iÝ•ëN6
èlìÜcòíŠØÏòaŠ‘ëÝ
ïi…þalìÜþaµgéÜî¶æŁaónyòibnØÛa¿Œní‰ìç…ìiòÔ튌îànmë
Léjn×ë émübÔß ¿ ¿7Lïi…þa †ÔäÛa ¿ ìç ïbþa Œní‰ìç…ìi—–‚nÏ
@ @
146
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
åßéÛì¤lbjcbjíŠÔmïçòÐÜn«lbjþòîbîÛapbibnØÛaµgÞì¤éäØÛë
mc‰óÜÇëLbèÐã´àîÛaµg‰bîÛaòub§biŒní‰ìç…ìi‰ìÈ‘lbjþaÙÜ
âbÇlŠy†ÈiÝîöaŠgåÇÊbφÛaµg1967‰bîÛa …ìÈ•Šİ¢ ê‰ìÈ‘ë L
…bÈß †í†¦a ‰bîÛa ÙÛ‡ ædië LpbäînÛa ¿ †í†¦a ï×ßþa ïbîÛa
ñ‰ëŠ™bíŠØÏëbîbî‰bîÛaaˆçòi‰bªæcëLb߆yµgb×ßþëÝîöaŠ⁄
‰ìç…ìiåØàníïØÛòîÛëcôŠþaòîbîÛaéÏa†çcÕîÔ¤åߌníN
Œní‰ìç…ìiÞbßémbîyòía†iïÐÏM´î×ßþa…ìèîÛa òîjÛbËÝrßMì−
´î×ßþa…ìèîÛaÂbëc¿òí‰bîÛaëòîÛaîÜÛa‰bØÏþa‰b’nãakji‰bîÛa
ï×ßþa“î¦a¿Œní‰ìç…ìiò߆kjiëLâbÇÝØ’ibi‰ëcåß´ß…bÔÛa
bîãb½c ¿¿ b×ßc oybnua Ûa òîㆽa ÖìÔ§aë lbj’Ûa ïm‰ìqë LòÜna
òiìÈ•†¯aˆÛ[“î¦aåߌní‰ìç…ìiñ…ìdžäÇóÜ£ŠßcìçëLpbäînÛa
ŠÈ‘ sîy Lï×ßþa ÉànvàÜÛ †í†¦a ï×ßþa ‰bîÛa †Ôäi ‰ìÈ’Ûa ¿
aï×ßþaÉànaåÇòiŠÌÛbiåíŠöbrÛalbj’ÛaòîÔj׌ní‰ìç…ìi¿â†ðˆÛ
bèîÜÇpìØÛakÈ–íñ†í†Ç—öbÔãïãbÈíï×ßþaÉànaædiëLé’îuN8
µgŒní‰ìç…ìiñ…bîÓo¤ëpbäînÛaÝöaëc¿ð‰bnäßì×òÜ©oÛì¤aˆÛ
åØÛë Lñ†zn½a pbíüìÜÛ åí†ÓbäÛa ´í‰bîÛa åíŠØнa ‰bj× kİÔní äß
éÜ–ÐmòÜØ’¶ŠÈ’íŒní‰ìç…ìic†ioÓìÛa‰ëŠ¶†í†¦aï×ßþa‰bîÛaåÇ
Éß éÐbÈmë b×ßc óÜÇ Šàn½a †í†¦a ‰bîÛa âìvç bëc Llbjc ñ†ÈÛ
LîÏìÛa …b¤üa9òîjÛbËë Œní‰ìç…ìi éîÏ ŠÈ’í æb×ðˆÛaoÓìÛa¿ÙÛ‡ë
ò¹Œç åß oäØ· æc †Èi þa áèÜßc ïç b×ßc ædi ´î×ßþa …ìèîÛa
òí‹bäÛaN
@ @@ @
147
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
…ìi ŠÈ’í Lbîãbq‰bîÛa ñ‰ìq êb£ bîm‰übi bîÇbànua ÅÏba Œní‰ìç
Œní‰ìç…ìiÞbßsîyLòîÓýþa†í†¦aMbí…ìèí bîäí… bàîÜÈmóÔÜmðˆÛaM
ïÇbànuüaëïÓýþabþaìÔm bèãcôc‰ëL‰bØÏþaÙÜmœÏ‰ì−
ïÓýþaëðŠþaÞý−üab犒äib×ßþN10
îÛa Éß Œní‰ìç…ìi òÜØ’ß p…a‹ë âbÇ ¿ †í†¦a ï×ßþa ‰b1967
ÙÜm ædië ìîãìílŠy¿ÝîöaŠ⁄ †í†¦a ‰bîÛaôìÓ ña…bȶ ŠÈ‘sîy
áy b¾ ÝîöaŠ⁄ a†Óbãë lŠÈÜÛë oîÏìÜÛ a†ãbß bÐÓìß pˆ¥a ôìÔÛa
´àîÛaì−b†méÈÏ…ë‰bîÛaÉߌní‰ìç…ìiòÈîİÓN11
bîÛaµg´àîÛaåߌní‰ìç…ìiÞì¤åØíëæb×ÝiLbnÏbëcbnßb•‰
â†Èi émbibn׿Œní‰ìç…ìi Œîànísîy LjÈnÛaåØßc a‡g bŠ‘ bj™bË aŠöbq
êõbÓ†•cÝjÓêõa†Çcp‰bqcòu‰†Û´íŠØÐÛaéßì–¨†ÔäÛaÝî׿ꅅŠmN12
Œní‰ìç…ìilëŠy
ðØÛa òíŠØÐÛa éiëŠyìåÇŒní‰ìç…ìiårí †ÔäÛaÙÛ‡åØÛë
àn½aë ñ†í†ÈÛa òíŠØÏ òîvîmag óÜÇl늧aÙÜm âìÔmë LñŠMp‰ŠØm
émbibn× ¿ ‰aŠànbiMpbíüìÛa …†èí İ ïu‰b ë†Ç …ìuìi ð…bäm
lŠ§a Œní‰ìç…ìi óàí aˆÛ [ꆙ òî½bÇ lŠy å‘ µg xbn°ë ñ†zn½a
âbǿꊒã†í†ulbn׿ð…bäíëLòrÛbrÛaòî½bÈÛalŠ§biñ…‰bjÛa2007ædi
b×ßc åß ì¥11-9 éîàí bß †™ òÈiaŠÛa òî½bÈÛa lŠ§aBâý⁄bi
ï‘bÐÛaBL13lbz•cëæìîÛë…b×ßcõa†ÇcæcŒní‰ìç…ìiôŠí´nÛb§a¿ë
éãcôŠí bà× LÝîöaŠgë b×ßc ò¹Œçëï½bÈÛa ‰b߆Ûa¿ òjˉë òîÛë… ñ†äuc
@ @
148
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
Ûa òi‰b bçaìÓ Ý× †’y ìçë L†yaë Ýí†i ôì b×ßc âbßc îÛë†È
ügÒÈmüŒní‰ìç…ìilëŠzÏ LbèîÏ êa…ìçülŠy¿†í†¦aïu‰b¨a
¿‰bîèãüaëÉuaÛaóÜÇë†ÈÛa‰bju⁄Šàn½aâìvaëòaŠ’Ûaëòèuaì½bi
ò•ŠÏlŠÓcN
Œní‰ìç…ìiæb¹gµg‰bØÏþaÙÜm…ìÈmëM´ÄÏbaåßÞëþaÝîÇŠÛaÞbz×
…†¦aMØÛaòî½bÈÛaôìÔÛaædi´ibßñÏÞýòí‹bäÛaòßëbÔß¿oãëbèmô
émìÓëé’îuõbäjÛoÓìÛaå߆íŒßk×óÜÇŠÜnç†Çbb¾´nî½bÈÛa´iŠ§a
òîãbrÛaëµëþa´nî½bÈÛa´iŠ§aÞýéjØm‰abßlbØm‰aåßénäØßÛaN
b×ßcæcŒní‰ìç…ìiôŠíaˆÛM†yëþabÈÛakİÓïçëMæck¯ü
àmÂbÔnÛü ò•ŠÐÛa bèöa†Çc Þbèßg â†Ç bèîÜÇ æcë L‰ŠØní æc ÙÛˆÛ |
bÐãþaN
énã…bèßëoîÏìÛaÉ߉aìzÜÛéîÇbßkjiŠm‰b׌ní‰ìç…ìi†ÔnãaaˆÛ
Šm‰b× pbbî oÈÏ… †Óë Láèí†íc ¿ æbnãbÌÏc ÂìÔi | b¾ á
Œní‰ìç…ìiM¦a´ÄÏba‰bînÛ´û½aõbiŁaåßéÜîuòîÔj×…†MæýÇgµg
aë†uë æc †Èi ò•b ï×ßþa ´àîÛa ì− áì¤ë L‰bîÛa Éß áènÈîİÓ
æb¯‰¿áènÛb™N
éÐã æb¯‰ æc ónyMlŒ§a åß …†¦a ´ÄÏba lˆu ðˆÛa
ð‰ìèà¦alŒ§a µg ïaŠÔ¹†ÛaMlbÇðˆÛa Œní‰ìç…ìi †Ôã åß áÜí
Éß|ÜnÛaå߆zÜÛpa†çbÈß¿éÛì…éîÜÇñ†ãbßåÇéÈuaŠmëoîÏìÛa
æbäjÛåßéibzãaëòîÓŠ’Ûabi‰ëcÞë†iòîaŠÔ¹†Ûapa‰ìrÛaN14
@ @@ @
149
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
émbbîë”ìiìîÜi…x‰ì¦âayüaåß aj× a‰†ÓŒní‰ìç…ìiåØíë
´ÄÏbaë´îÛaîÜÛaåß éßì–éu뿉aŠànbi éäÇÉÏa†íìèÏ Lém‰a…gë
”ìiæþÙÛ‡ë Lõaì†yóÜÇMôŠí bà× Œní‰ìç…ìi–îö‰Þëc ìç
ÛapaîÌnÛbi Œní‰ìç…ìi†î’íë LòÈiaŠÛa òî½bÈÛalŠ§a ñÏÞýï×ßc
¿pc†i ÛalŠ§aÙÜnÛ a…a†Èna b×ßc òbî óÜÇ”ìi bèÜ…c11
ànj2001Œní‰ìç…ìiôŠíbà×N15
áañ…bÈÛa¿paîÌnÛaÙÜmóÜÇÕÜİíëB”ìiñ†îÔÇBÜÇâìÔmÛaó
kÜİnmëübîucÖŠÌnmòî½bÇlŠybèãcóÜÇlbç‰⁄aóÜÇlŠzÜÛŠÄäÛa
ï™bèug ïÓbjna ÝØ’i b ñ†ãb½a Þë†Ûaë òîibç‰⁄a pbÇbà¦a òèuaìß
ò¹Œ òÜîë ÝšÏd× âbÈÛa Ç òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa Š’äÛ ïÈÛaë bãbîyc ðŠØÇ
Ší bà× lbç‰⁄a …ìÈ–Û ïbþa kjÛa Ýr· Ûa pbí‰ìmbn׆Ûaô
”ìi‰bØÏcëpbbîÛémõaŠÓ¿Œní‰ìç…ìiN16
òîÇìãòÜÔãÝr·bèãcëòíŠÔjÇòÔibÛa”ìi‰bØÏcædiŒní‰ìç…ìiåßûíë
âbÓ Ýi LéîÔib †îÜÔniÑnØí ”ìi æcë Lòî×ßþa òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa ¿
ïmdíåßbèÈjníÒìòî×ßþaòîu‰b¨aòbîÛaóÜÇñj×pýí†ÈmõaŠuhi
ê†ÈiN17
ÝîöaŠg
ïãbrÛaÑÓìßìèÏL”ìix‰ì Œní‰ìç…ìilbvÇglbjcáçc†ycbßc
– Þëþa êaŠí bà×–òîäîİÜÐÛa âýÛa òîÜàÇåßMéãþÙÛ‡ë [òîÜîöaŠ⁄a
pbÓbÐmabèncÛaòÔibÛaòîÜàÈÜÛåí…†’n½a´™‰bȽaåßìçŒní‰ìç…ìi
âbÇ ¿ ìÜëc1993L18ع âýü ædi åßûísîylŠÈÛa´i éÔîÔ¤ å
@ @
150
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
ædi éãb¹⁄ ÙÛ‡ë Lpb™ëbнa ÕíŠ åÇ òîÛb§a ñÐÛa Þý ÝîöaŠgë
æë†íŠíë bçõbÔiæë†íŠíüëÝîöaŠgæìçŠØíâbÇÝØ’ilŠÈÛaë´àܽa
knØíòã†çügoîÛ bèÈßáèmbÓbÐmaæcë Lò•ŠÏlŠÓc¿ bèäß—Ü‚nÛa
g òÛa‹⁄ …a†ÈnýÛ ádžÛaë oÓìÛa lŠÈÛa bèiLÝîöaŠ19ñ‰ì• éíì’nÛë
paßb× âbßc pì½a µg ábÐc ´îäîİÜÐÛa Þb‰g Þý åß ÝîöaŠg
Láèí‰ì–nÛæìíŒÐÜnÛapaßbØÛ´ib–½aÝ»ëLâýÇ⁄a20ÖŠÏüæcôŠíë
åß bàçæaþbÏ LÉíŠÓ †»c ëcbjÇ …ìàªëpbÏŠÇ Šbí´iÙÛ‡¿
LpaìäÛémbbîa†ãbßëpbÏŠÇÞbu‰21áèÇbäÓhi´îÜîöaŠ⁄aÝîÜšmæcë
Ýà§a É™ë òibr¶ ìç âý¿´îäîİÜÐÛa Éß“íbÈnÛbiIïÜîöaŠ⁄a HÉß
†þaIîİÜÐÛaHðˆÛaÝà§aóÜdžþaéîÏœÔäîÛâìíïmdíæc†iüëL
ê…a†uc‰cóÜÇõbÔjÛaëâýÛaôì†íŠíüN22
îÜÛ ê†îídmµg ñŠßåߊr×cŒní‰ìç…ìi’íëæcÑî×ëLïÜîöaŠ⁄a´à
Léäßa…†’mŠr×cæŠÓÉi‰åߊr×cˆäßÝîöaŠg¿“îÈmÛaòîÜîöaŠ⁄aénäia
…ìèîÛaæcëLbàèîÜ×åßa…†’mŠr×cï×ßþa“î¦a¿â†±ðˆÛabèäiaæcë
bÈîºáèäßa…†’mŠr×cï×ßþa“î¦a¿æì߆±ðˆÛa´äí†n½aN23
òàÄÇ æc Œní‰ìç…ìi ôŠíëîİÜÐÛa ÊaŠ–Ûa ‰bß ¿ êqdmë ”ìi
ÊaŠ–ÛaéîÏðŠ¯ðˆÛaâbÈÛaÖbîÛaîÌmóÜÇém‰†Ó¿æbäàØíïÜîöaŠ⁄a
Lpb™ëbнaë24”ìiœÏ‰sîyMŒní‰ìç…ìiŠ’íbà×Mëˆy눰æc
´îÜîöaŠ⁄aë´îäîİÜÐÛa´iñaëb½a¿´î×ßþaõbúŠÛaåßêìÔjåß
ÇòîÛëû½a¿óÜÇæìnäîÜ×Ýîiï×ßþaîöŠÛañ‰a…goic…sîyÑäÈÛaå
óÜÇë ÑäÈÛa òßaë… ÑÓë óÜÇ ÝàÈÛbi ´îÜîöaŠ⁄aë ´îäîİÜÐÛa òjÛbİß
”ìiåØÛëLbç‰aŠànaóÜÇbÈßbàèßìÛ–Œní‰ìç…ìi†î’íbà×–åÇóÜ¥
@ @@ @
151
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
jmëáèm…bîÓîÌniáèjÛbëÑäÈÛaÑÓëòîÛëûß´îäîİÜÐÛaÝ»ëLÙÛ‡
ÓëÑäÈÛaœÏŠmñ…bîBlbç‰⁄aBpb™ëbнaòía†iÝjÓÕÜİßÝØ’iN25
òÜßb×òîÛëû½aéÈ™ìiïÜîöaŠ⁄aïiŠÈÛaÊaŠ–Ûa‰bß”ìiËaˆèië
oyŠb½ëL´îäîİÜÐÛaóÜÇBÕíŠİÛaò‰bBñŠØÏëBòîÇbiŠÛaòävÜÛaBM
þa òîu‰b¨a ñ‰a‹ëåßïmdm bèãþ [Œní‰ìç…ìi bèçŠØípa‰…bjßïçëòî×ß
LÝîöaŠ⁄òí…bÈßpbãbî× bèãcôŠíÛa ñ†zn½aáßþaëMóÜÇ”ìi˜Šy
ÝîöaŠgóÜÇbäîÈßbîäß‹bÐÔpbãbîØÛaÙÜmŠÐmücN
ñ‰…bjßïçëLÁëþaÖŠ’ÛbiòîaŠÔ¹†ÛaŠ’äÛ”ìiïȵgòÏb™gaˆç
í†ãbßëlŠÈÛaæcôŠísîyLbèäÇÉÏa†íëénÓbÝØiŒní‰ìç…ìi bç†ãbíáè
ÞìÔmòí‰ìİcòÛìÔ½æìuëŠíZìç´îÜîöaŠ⁄aëlŠÈÛa´iâýÛaÞýygæg
ÖŠ’Ûa ¿ b×ßþ õa†ÈÛa òzÏbØßë ‰aŠÔnüaë âýÛa õbäjÛ bþa Švy
òÔİäßÁëþaÖŠ’ÛaæcôŠíðˆÛaŒní‰ìç…ìi bèšÏŠíòÛìÔßïçëLÁëþa
‰ìmbnØí†Ûa…ìuëbèc‰óÜÇñr×lbjþñŠÔnßËlŠšíbßñ…bÇëLpbí
ˆäß †è‘ÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa æg ÞìÔísîy òÔİä½a bèm†è‘Ûal늧bi Þbr½a
l늧a ÙÜm åß ar× ægë Ll늧a åß aj× a…†Ç ÝîöaŠg îdm
òîÓaŠÈÛalŠ§aÝrßbèšÈiægëLÝîöaŠhiÁjmŠíüpbÇaŠ–ÛaëMÉÓëcòîãaŠí⁄a
ŠÈÛalëŠybènÈÓëcÛaåߊr×cbíbz™bèÜ×ÝîöaŠgÉßlN26
ïãbrÛaÝî¦a…ìÈ•ëÞëþaÝî¦aÞìÏc
òîàçcë âbÇ ŠØÐà× énîàçc æc ê‰bØÏcë Œní‰ìç…ìjÛ æìÈibn½a ÞìÔíë
Þý âbÇ ÝØ’ioÈuaŠm ‰bîn× …†¦a´ÄÏba òîàçcë bèöaŠÓëð‰bnäßì×
òîàçcoÈuaŠmâbÇÝØ’jÏLòÐÜn«òîbîëòîÏbÔqlbjþpbäîÈnÛa†ÔÇ
@ @
152
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
½aïÈßbu‡bncµgÑÔr½aoÛìyëpbÈßb¦apŠ’nãaæc†Èiï×ßþaÑÔr
‰ìèà¦aåÇénÛŒÇëéÜ…‰†–ßozj•cÛaénÈßbuæa‰†uÝa…ÉibÓN 27
Š¬ìØÛaë œîiþa oîjÛa ´i on’më òî×ßþa òİÜÛa ojÈ’m bà×
ˆèië LÑÔr½a ݪoÜyÛa âýÇ⁄a ÝöbëëïiìÜÛapbÇbºëpa‰a‹ìÛaëa
åír×aìzj•cáèãþ[ï×ßþa‰aŠÔÛaïÈãb•¿qdnÛakÈ–Ûaåß|j•cN28
éuaìmð‰bnäßì×ombiëp…†ÈmëòîäîàîÛapübap…a‹éma‡oÓìÛa¿
‰bîmægpbäîÈnÛaòíbèã¿ÞìÔíkn׌ní‰ìç…ìiæcónyLòÏbä½aå߆팽a
ab߆ÈibèÐãòîàçþbi†Èí…†¦a´ÄÏbaåßj×…†Ç´iê‰bØÏcpŠ’nã
´îäîàîÛa´î×ßþa´îbîÛaN29
æìÄÏbadjÇÛañ…‰bjÛalŠ§aoènãaòîu‰b¨aòbîÛaôìnßóÜÇë
áaj×bíŠØÏb톤Ýrßb¾b熙áç‰bØÏcëáèÐãc…†¦aN 30
ôŠí bäçë뉆ãeâbÇæc“nîÐbi1995Mæb߉ìã òÛbÔna†è‘ðˆÛa
ç…ìiÞìníŠ×âbîÜíëîdmëð‰bnäßì×òÜ©ŠíŠ¤òbö‰åߌní‰ìMݬ
ÞìníŠ×wäîÏŠígM…‰a†ãbnïÜØíë a‡òÜ©MÝr¹‰bîmñbîy¿bÓ‰bÏ bßbÇ
ïãbrÛaÝî¦a…ìÈ•ëÞëþaÝî¦aÞìÏc†è‘ðˆÛaâbÈÛaìèÏL…†¦a´ÄÏba
…†¦a´ÄÏbaÞbîucåßN
íë’“nîÐbiµg½aæcð‰bnäßì×´iòã‰bÔ–ÞëþaÝî¦aòÜ©–a‡ë
…‰a†ãbn ïÜØíëThe Weekly Standard– ïãbrÛa Ýî¦a òÜ©–Ñ’Øm
…†Çaj×aoãb×ð‰bnäßìØÏ LïãbrÛaëÞëþaÝî¦a´i òîîöŠÛaÖëŠÐÛaåß
a‡bßcLïiŒ§a…bî§aâaŒnÛüóÈmÛaòîØíŠßþaòí…ìèîÛaòävÜÛaåÇñ‰…b•
@ @@ @
153
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ÜØíë†ãbn ïa „ë…‰ìß pŠië‰ ÝjÓ åß òÛì¾ ïèÏ …‰Rupert Murdoch
ð‰bnäßì×æcbà×LòíìÔÛaòîäîàîÛaÞìî½akyb•ëÒëŠÈ½aâýÇ⁄a‰ìaßg
bþbiòèuìßoãb×aµgòÐÔr½aòj‚äÛLïÜØíëa‡bßcnpŒî·†ÔÏ…‰a†ãb
ð‰bnäßì× æc bà× Lòíçbº Šr×c òÇŒäi bèmbßì‰ë bèmübÔß ¿åß ‰†–m
†ãbnïÜØíë a‡ bßc LÚ‰ìíìîãaœîiþaoîjÛa åÇ ar× †Èjíü bèjnØàÏ …‰
ßþaòà•bÈÛbiåİä‘aëòî×N
äȶóeŠ òÇŒäi …†¦a ´ÄÏba Þbîuc åß ïãbrÛa Ýî¦aŒî·òîuìÛ†íc
Ó‰bÏÙÛ‡µgÑ™cLÞëþaÝî¦aåß×còíçbºëòî׊yëbîbcbM’í
gÛî“nîÐbiéMâbÈÛaðcŠÛaóÜÇbèîÏáîñÏ¿†È•ÞëþaÝî¦aæcìçë
b½ òvînã òîØíŠßþa òîu‰b¨a òbîÛaë ñìÔÛa¿ òÔrÛa â†Èi ‰ìÈ‘ïØíŠßþa
âbänîÏ¿t†y[ñ…ìÔнa òÔrÛa ñ…bÇ⁄bþbiÞëþaÝî¦aóÈ aˆÛô†Û
´î×ßþaN †Èi Šèà †ÔÏïãbrÛa Ýî¦a bßc‰b–nãa bØíŠßc¿ñ…‰bjÛalŠ§a
áè’îu¿´îØíŠßþaòÔqõaŠz–ÛaòЕbÇlŠyëæb¯‰…bÇcæc†Èië[aˆÛ
bèÈÓìßë bèmìÓ bØíŠßc âa†‚na òîÐî× ìçë bÐÜn« bφç ïãbrÛa Ýî¦a óäjm
ÝîØ’më bØíŠßcÒa†çcÕîÔ¤¿†yëþabÈÛakİÔ×Öìj½aËïÛë†Ûa
bèníúŠÛbÔÏëbÈÛaN
ïãbrÛaÝî¦a‰bØÏc
òîbc ‰bØÏc ò¼“nîÐbi ‹í bäçë òibr¶ ïçÝî¦a ŠØÐÛ ñ†àÇc
…†¦a´ÄÏbaåßïãbrÛaïçëLZ31
M Óìj½aË bç‡ìÐãë bØíŠßc ñŠİîæc´ñìÓïçï½bÈÛa âbÄäÛaóÜÇ
bÈÛa bè׉†í ñìÓ ïçë LÝíì ÝjÔnß bçŠÄnäí bènía†i ¿ oÛa‹bß
@ @
154
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
ÏbaôŠí ‡g Lbç†íûíë bèäÇszjíëåÇszjí bÈÛa æc …†¦a æìÄ
bèm…bîë bØíŠßc ñŠİîÏ L†öbÔÛa aˆç bàny ïç bØíŠßc æcë L†öbÓ
bÈÛaóÜÇ òÔÜݽa–áçŠÄã òèuëåß–âbÄäÛa ‰aŠÔna ‰†–ßïç
ï½bÈÛaN
M ÞýÌna ¿ bØíŠßc Ý’Ï æc ÙÜmbÈÛa ñ…bîÓ åÇ bçŒvÇë ò•ŠÐÛa
ð…ûíÒìéÜîØ’mëµg½bÈÛaâbÄäÛa‰bîèãaïçó™ìÐÛbÏ LåçaŠÛaï
½bÈÛaâbÄäÛañ…bîÓ¿bØíŠßcÝ’ÐÛÝàna†îyìÛaÝí†jÛaï†í†¦aN
M bØíŠßc ÃbЧ òîîö‰ ña…c ïç òÓìj½a Ë òíŠØÈÛa bØíŠßc ñìÓ æc
ènàè¶ âbîÔÛa ¿ bèybväÛë bènãbØß óÜÇbóÜÇ òÄÏbªë bÈÜÛ ñ†öbÔ×
†¦aæìÄÏbaôŠí bäçë Lï½bÈÛa âýÛaòíŠØÈÛa ñìÔÛa òÐîÃëæc …
åØÛë bçŒä×ë paìÔÛaë òzÜþa Éî࣠îÛ òîîöŠÛa òîØíŠßþa
Ûa êˆç âa†‚napa‰†ÔâbÄã òÇbä–Û òbyë òyìà Éí‰b’ß ¿
bèàdžíëòîØíŠßþañŠİîÛaóÜÇáöbÓï½bÇN
M …ìèuë òîØíŠßþa òíŠØÈÛa ñìÔÛa ádžiÕÜݽa …†¦a´ÄÏba âaŒnÛa
ìÔÛa|îÜmßþaòíŠØÈÛapaòî׊íìİmëbçr톤ëbèN
M íÄÏba œÏŠì …†¦a æ´îbîÛaŠväî× ðŠäç Ýrß ´ÈÓaìÛa
ëaòîÈÓaìÛbÏ LÞëbi ´Ûì× Ýrß ñìÔÛa âa†‚na ¿ åí……½a òbÛ
Ûæýr¹ñìÔÛaâa†‚na¿……Ûaëaô†™Šß…†¦a´ÄÏb´İíåN
ãbrÛaÝî¦aåÇåíȽa‹Šicåßëlbn×áç‰bØÏcë…†¦a´ÄÏbaåßï
pìi×bßë L…‰a†ãbnïÜØíë a‡ ñ†íŠu‰ŠªÞìníŠ×âbîÜíëÝrßMax
@ @@ @
155
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
BootŒ¹bmìܬcìÛòÐîz–ikmbØÛaLos Angeles Times†îÐía…ëL
×ëŠiDavid BrooksŒ¹bmÚ‰ìíìîãòÐîz–ikmbØÛaNew York TimesL
æbub× pŠië‰ëRobert KaganÛû½aŠßbèmëŠ× ŒÛ‰b’më LÒëŠÈ½a Ñ
Charles Krauthammeroìi åİä‘aë òÐîz–i kmbØÛaWashington
Post ŒßaŠig pìîÛgë LElliott AbramsïßìÔÛa åßþa ‰b’nß köbã
òîãbrÛa”ìiìîÜi…x‰ìuîöŠÛañ‰a…g¿ï×ßþaN
ïãbrÛaÝî¦a‰bØÏþbu‡ì¸cŠßbèmëŠ×ŒÛ‰b’m
mòa‰…bäÛëbyìÛëŠßbèmëŠ×ŒÛ‰b’–âbÇ¿…ìÛì½a1950–x‡ìàä×
ŠèÄmémübÔßæcbã†uìÛ…†¦a´ÄÏbaåßïãbrÛaÝî¦aåÇåíȽalbnØÜÛ
ïÜØíë òÜ© ÙÛˆ×ë áíbm òÜ©ë oìi åİä‘aë ñ†íŠ Õφmë âbÄnãbi
‰bØÏþa åß …†Ç Þìy ‰ë†më L…†¦a ´ÄÏba ‰bîm åÇ ñȽa …‰a†ãbn
òí‰ìalŠ§aòíbèäÛòîÛbnÛa ñÐÛa¿ò•bòî×ßþañìÔÛaâa†‚naÝj×
b×ßcòÓýÇÞìyëL†yëþabÈÛakİÓµg b×ßc bèîÏoÛì¤Ûa ñ…‰bjÛa
òîu‰b¨ab×ßcòbî¿òÓýÈÛaÙÜmòíŒ×ŠßëÝîöaŠhiN
…†¦a´ÄÏbaåßïãbrÛaÝî¦aòîjÛbÌ×ÈߊßbèmëŠ×æþÙÛ‡ëÝji
pbibn׌îànmëLñ…‰bjÛalŠ§aòíbèã†Èibߊ–Ç¿òî×ßþañìÔÛaâa†‚na
Lbßòu‰†Ûï¹…b×þaÄänÛaóÜÇbèm‰†ÔiëbèníŒ×Š¶Þba aˆç¿ŠßbèmëŠ×
æaìäÇo¤b犒ãòîÜîܤòÛbÔßojn×aaˆëBòí…byþaòÄzÜÛaBMòíbèã¿
âbÇ1990 òÜv¶BŒí‰bÏc åí‰ìÏ BForeign Affairspüb© ×c ïçë L
òî×ßþa òîÛë†ÛapbÓýÈÛaM òÈaë ñŠè‘Mædi bèîÏ ŠßbèmëŠ× djämsîy
pbíüìÛabîÇa……ìÔÇÉi‰cëcòqýrÛbÈÛaóÜÇòí…byþaòî×ßþaòäàîaâë†m
@ @
156
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
âbÇ òíbèã ¿ë LbèàÇ…ë òÜyŠ½a ÙÜm åß ñ…bÐnüa µg ñ†zn½a2002Š’ã
ŠßbèmëŠ× òÜv¶ òÔibÛa énÛbÔ½ aŠíìİmë òÈuaŠßBoãgÞbãìî‘bãBThe
National InterestlbÔÇc¿énvyŠíìİnÛÙÛ‡ëL…†¦a´ÄÏbzàÜÛòÈibnÛa
11M9N
æcŠßbèmëŠ×†×còîãbrÛa énÛbÔß¿ëBŠ–ǵgoÛì¤òí…byþaòÄzÜÛa
ð…bycByþaòî×ßþaòäàîa‰aŠànaéÈÓìmµgñ‰b‘g¿LòÜíìñÐÛòí…b
j×ôìn¶ òî×ßþa òíŠØÈÛaë òí…b–nÓüapa‰†ÔÛapëbÐnÛ aŠÄãÙÛ‡ë
Lòî×ßþa ñŠİîÜÛ a†í†èmÝØ’mæcåعÛa b òîÛbnÛaôìÔÛaåÇ32åßë
áÓ‰óÔjmæcóÜÇ b×ßc ñ‰†Ôi´äßû½aåߊßbèmëŠ×æc bäçÅyý½a1¿
× †Ônäísîy LŠànßÝØ’i bÈÛaÒì¨bi æëŠÈ’íåß émübÔß¿ ŠßbèmëŠ
µgòÏbä½aÙÜmð…ûmæcåßëñ†zn½apbíüìÜÛòîjäuþaòÏbä½aå߆톒Ûa
òî×ßþañŠİîÛaÉuaŠmN33
æc åع b×ßc æc ŠßbèmëŠ× ôÏ òî×ßþa òí…byþa ˜ì–¢ bßc
bèîàíÛaê‰bØÏdiåßûmñ‰a…gbènàØya‡gbèä߆îÐnmBîÜÛaòîÈÓaìÛaòîÛaB
åßòäؾñÏÞìþòí…byþaŠ–ÈiÃbÐnyýÛ b×ßcïÈóÜÇâìÔmÛa
åßbÈÛa¿âýÛaóÜÇÃbÐzÜÛ†yëckİÔ×bç‰ë†Ûb×ßcò‰b¾Þý
æ‹aìnÛëcïÛë†ÛaâýÜÛ†í†èmðcòèuaì½Ý†nÛaëòîaŠÔ¹†ÛaŠ’ãÞý
bÈÛaåß õŒuðc¿ïàîÜÓ⁄aðìÔÛaòîàîÜÓ⁄aôìÔÛaåí‹aìß õbÔi æbàšÛ
éîÜÇïçbßóÜÇòîîöŠÛaòîÛë†ÛaëN34
ðc¿Ý†nÜÛò׊§aë‰aŠÔÛaò튡bèÐäÛb×ßcÅÐn¤æcaˆçÈíë
ðìÔÛa åí‹aìß Ýn¥üc æbà™ë òî×ßþab–½a æbàšÛ bÈÛa åß æbØß
@ @@ @
157
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ŠßbèmëŠ×Éãb¹übäçëLb×ßc†™òîÛë†ÛaëòîàîÜÓ⁄ab×ßc´Ènmæcåß
LåØßc a‡gë p…a‰c a‡g òîÛë†Ûa pbÐÛbznÛaë åßþa Ü©ë ñ†zn½a áßþbi
ð…ŠÐÛa ݆nÛa åß bèÈä· ücë pbÐÛbznÛa ÙÜni b×ßc †îÔnm üc Š’i
ÙÛˆÛpŠİ™aa‡gïÓbjnüaN
ÝîöaŠg
òšÏaŠÛa …†’n½a ïÜîöaŠ⁄a ´àîÛa ÑÓaì½ ém†ãb¶ ŠßbèmëŠ× ÒŠÈí
àÈÛLìÜëcpbÓbÐmüë âýÛa òîÜ35´Û†nȽa òÛìÔß ŠßbèmëŠ×œÏŠísîy
bèãcôŠíëlŠÈÛaBòí‰ìİcBLÉÓaìÛa¿b…ìuëü36bíaìã¿ÙØ’íbà×
ïÜîöaŠ⁄a‰bîÛaÝ’Ïa†×ûßáèÈßâýÛÝ•ìnÛaòîãbØßg¿ë´îäîİÜÐÛa
ω†×ûîÛ…ìÈíéäØÛëLÝîöaŠgÉßâýòîÓbÐmüÝ•ìnÛa¿´àîÛaæb¹⁄éš
[ÝîöaŠgÝa…lŠÈÛawß…òiìÈ•a†×ûßôØÛaÝîöaŠgñŠØÐiïÜîöaŠ⁄a
ÕİäßåßÝîöaŠg…ë†yá‰óÜÇáöbÔÛaæë‰b‘wèä½ê†îídmåÇÈí aˆÛ
´îäîİÜÐÛapbàvçå߆§aåßÝîöaŠgåØßðˆÛaÝ–ÐÛaÁöb§ëð…byc
bèîÜÇ–ŠßbèmëŠ×ôŠíbà×N37
æc†ÔnÈíbà×âbÇpbib‚nãa¿b»‹ìÏ2004pbîãåÇÖ†–iÈí
æcë LÝîöaŠg Éß âýÜÛ ´šÏaŠÛaë bৠaìmì• åíˆÛa ´îäîİÜÐÛa
aìܚϴîäîİÜÐÛaB߆më òîßbÜÛ õa†ÈÛaëlbç‰⁄aë òîßý⁄aëœÏŠÛa
ÝîöaŠgBô†ßóÜÇÝîöaŠgÉßbèÐã´îäîİÜÐÛaÊaŠ•lbjcïçë60
´y¿bßbÇoãb×ÝîöaŠgæcBÝíìåß‹ˆäßñ†ÈnßBÊaŠ–ÛaaˆçݧN
aìàÜÈníïØÛ´îäîİÜÐÛaåÇpa†Çb½aÉîºÉİÔibÈÛaŠßbèmëŠ×kÛbİíë
kÓaìÇáèma‰bî¨æcN38
@ @
158
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
âbÇ ÝØ’i …ìèîÜÛ †ãb½a b×ßc ÑÓìß émübÔß ¿ ŠßbèmëŠ× †×ûíë
æc a†×ûßBbªbmë bjîyŠmŠr×þa†ÜjÛaïçb×ßc¿òîßbÜÛñ†ãbßëbîäí…
bÈÛa BôìÓ †Çb–m åß´îÛaîÜÛa ´î×ßþa …ìèîÛaœÈi ÕÜÓ åß ýÜÔß
òí…†ÈnÛaÝjÔnß¿ÙÛ‡qdmëïbîÛabç‡ìÐãëòäí†n½aòîzî½apbÇbà¦a
òî×ßþaN39
b–½a óÜÇ bšíc †ànÈm ÝîöaŠhi b×ßc òÓýÇ æg ŠßbèmëŠ× ÞìÔíë
gæcµga’ßpbäîÈjÛa¿oîÏìÜÛñ†ãb½aòîiŠÈÛaôìÔÛaoi‰byÝîöaŠ
òÛìÔßïçë LïiŠÈÛa bÈÛa ¿´Û†nȽa b×ßc õbÓ†•coàÇ…ëpbäîãbàrÛaë
òÛìÔßæcÝjÓåßbãŠ×‡bà×ôŠísîyôŠcpübÔß¿ŠßbèmëŠ×bèšÏŠí
BlŠÈÛa´Û†nȽaBòz–ÛaåÇòí‰bÇñ‰ìİcN
ÖaŠÈÛaëæaŠíg
Š× xëŠíëµg oÛì¤ lŠÈÛaë ÝîöaŠg ´i lŠ§a æc ñŠØÐÛ Šßbèmë
bèÜȯb¾òîäí…lŠyBw߆ämB´iòîãìØÛalŠ§a¿BïÛbØí…aŠÛaâý⁄aB
ŠØÈßæcëLlŠÌÛaëBïÛbØí…aŠÛaâý⁄aBbàëcæbnÏbänßæbm…bîÓê…ìÔí
sîy Lb»ë a lŒz× åí†ãbß bèÐÜ åßë æaŠíg bàèîãbqë ñ†ÇbÔÛa
ní óÜÇ æbÏŠİÛaÏbäB…ìèîÛa †™ …bè¦a BbàèÈë¿ bß Ý× ÝÈÏ óÜÇë
†íŒßÞýåߊŁaÒŠİÛaâa†Óco¤åßòÛìİjÛaëòîjÈ’ÛaÂbikzÛ
lŠÌÛaëÝîöaŠgóÜÇpbàvaåßN40
µgÒ†èíí…ŠØÐi…b¬ð†»d×bèm…bÓæb¹hiòÇìφßæaŠígægÞìÔíë
⁄añ…ìÈÛbÈÛaòíbèäiÉíŠnÛaŠelŠy¿…ìÈíÒìðˆÛaŠ’ÇïãbrÛaâbß
@ @@ @
159
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
b×ßdi´îÛì•þa´îzî½aœÈibèiåßûíÛabèÐã‰bØÏþaïçëLæbߌÛa
òÈî‘´i Ö‰bÐÛa æc ŠßbèmëŠ× ÞìÔíë LÝîöaŠhi ´îÛì•þa …ìèîÛaœÈië
åí…†’n½a …ìèîÛaë´îzî½a æc ìçÝîöaŠg …ìèíë b×ßc ïîzîßë æaŠíg
ëb×ßdiðëìãýÚýnßüæìÈíüëòİÜÛaæìØÜn¹üÝîöaŠgN41
Ñî•¿æbäjÛóÜÇÝîöaŠglŠy¿ŠßbèmëŠ×ôc‰ aˆÛ2006ò•ŠÏ
lŒyò¹ŒèiÝîöaŠgâbîÓÞýåßï×ßþaâbÈÛaðcŠÜÛÝîöaŠgòàîÓæbîjÛ
æaŠíg ÝîàÇ aMîö‰ Ý’Ï æc †×ûíë …ìÈí éäØÛë LŠßbèmëŠ× êaŠí bà×
ìÛaÜîöaŠ⁄aõa‰‹ïòÔqÑÈ™cëò•ŠÐÛaÊb™clŠ§añ…bîÓ¿pŠ½ëc…ìèíg
LÒŠóÜÇÒŠİÛáby‹ìÏæë†ioènãalŠ§aæcëLÝîöaŠg¿b×ßc
alŒy‰b–nãaÈíbßìçëN42
ݧa Ý’Ï òÛby ¿ bíŠØÇ æaŠíg òèuaìß ñ‰ëŠ™ ŠßbèmëŠ× †×ûíë
bjÛaÑîÛbØnÛbi énía‰… a†×ûßïbßìÜi†ÛaLæaŠígóÜÇðŠØÈÛa âìvèÜÛ òÄç
òíëìãñìÓµgæaŠígÞì¤òÐÜØmåßÝÓcÑîÛbØnÛaêˆçæcëN43
ÝjÓñ†ÇbÔÜÛbφçæb×ÖaŠÈÛaæcŠßbèmëŠ×ôÏÖaŠÈÛbiÕÜÈmbàîÏbßc
áçbcåßbìyÑnÛasîyànjåߊ’Çð…b§ata†ycB´í…bè¦biB
ÜÛa ‰bqŁa áèÇbjmc Áë æìuëŠí aìya‰ëÖaŠÈÜÛ ï×ßþa ‰b–zÜÛ òîj
L´y âa†•ÕibÛaîöŠÛa †èÇ Þý44ÞbÔß¿ ŠßbèmëŠ× éЖíðˆÛa
éãdiÕibBÕîÜ—ÛNB45
lŠ§bi ‹ìÐÛa ¿ åàØí ÖaŠÈÛa ¿ †îyìÛa ݧa æc ŠßbèmëŠ× ÞìÔíë
ïç òîbþa ÖaŠÈÛa òÜØ’ß æcë LòîaŠÔ¹… òÛë… µg ÖaŠÈÛa Ýíì¤ë
Ôqë áèÐãc æìîîÓaŠÈÛaÛapaìäÜÛ òvînã òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa Ë òîbîÛa áènÏb
@ @
160
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
ïÓaŠÈÛaõa‰‹ìÛaîö‰òßìØyægŠßbèmëŠ×ÞìÔíëL…a†jnüaÝÿbçì‘bÇ
éãcë LbèîÜÇ ´Ç‰b–nß ´ÔíŠÏ ñŠİî kji oÜ’Ï ïØÛb½a ð‰ìã ïÛb§a
†í†u ÑÛb¤ …ìÈ• Ýuc åß ïÈî’Ûa ÑÛbznÛaë òßìاa ÂìÔ †ãbí
çˆßËïãbàÜÇN46
ôìÔÛaâbßcòíŠÏÖaŠÈÛaÉÔmüónyÖaŠÈÛaáîÔmŠßbèmëŠ×œÏŠíë
ÝöbjÔÛa òíìÔmë LòíŒ×Š½a òßìاa ÒbÈ™g ÝšÐí éäØÛë òîu‰b¨a òîjäuþa
òã‹aì½ÙÛ‡ëòíŒ×Š½aòîÈî’ÛaòßìاalbyóÜÇòäÛaò•bëÒaŠþaë
ïठòíŒ×Šß Ë òßìØy óÜÇ õbÔifiÛë LòäÛaë òÈî’Ûa ôìÓåß ÖaŠÈÛa
⇊’nÛaN47
…†¦a´ÄÏbaòäàîçlbjc
´jÓaŠ½aå߆í†ÇôŠí–뉆ãfדnîÐbiêËë–æc…†¦a´ÄÏba
aìz¬òbîi ˜b¨a âbÈÛa ïØíŠßþa Þ†¦a óÜÇ òíìÓ pbà–i ÚŠm ¿
b×ßcL|™aìÛa ðŠØÐÛa áèb’äÛ xbnã ìç bväÛa aˆç æcë Lòîu‰b¨a
†¦aæìÄÏbbÏ¿‰aŠànbiáèmbibn׊èÄmë…‰†ãbnïÜØíëa‡òÜ©æìØܹ…
Ltb¡ÿÛŒíaŠiãgæbØíŠßc†èÈßóÜÇæëŠİîíëòÏëŠÈ½aŒí‰bÏcåí‰ìÏòÜ©
öaŠ¦a×cåßtýq¿ð‰ë…ÝØ’iæìjnØí bà׆ßþaknØísîyLòî×
‰ìíìîäÛ×ëŠi†îÐía…knØíëLŒ¹bmìܬcìÛòÐîz–Ûpëbi×bßÚ
òÏb™gaˆçLoìiåİä‘aìÜÛŒàèmëŠ×ŒÛ‰b’mëåub×pŠië‰knØíëLŒ¹bm
ôŠí bà× LÞbã‰ìuoíÞaë òÐîz–iðcŠÛapübÔßóÜÇ áèmŠİîµg
…ìÈíñþapaìäÛa¿…†¦a´ÄÏbab¬åßaj×aõŒuæc“nîÐbiµg
@ @@ @
161
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
qbmànjåߊ’Çð…b§ata†yc¿òîØíŠßþaòbîÛaëLµgÔ¤îÕ§aáÜ
”ìiìîÜi…x‰ìuìçëáç‰bØÏcóäjníïbî†öbÓóÜljìrÈÛa¿N48
òîu‰b¨aòbîÛaÊa‰‡òibr¶áèãcóÜÇ…†¦a´ÄÏba‰ì–íåßÚbäçë
ñ†Ç´iÑÛb¤åßÑÛdníðˆÛaLï×ßþa´àîÛaëð‰ìèà¦alŒ§aÝa…
òîîö‰pbÇbºòÐÜn«òîÜa…bíbšÓóÜnj׊mòîu‰b¨aòbîÛabíbšÓÚmë
…†¦a´ÄÏbzàÜÛN49
Þëcí†Ûa´àîÛaôìÓïçpbÇbà¦aêˆçpbàÄäßbíçbºbèÜr·Ûa
æìnië‰pbiëÝrß éma…bîÓëïzî½a´àîÛaÑÛa‰ëœÈi bîbî bèÜr¹ë L
oÏëŠØ‘c æìu áçŠè‘c åßë pbÇbà¦a ÙÜm ‰bØÏdi ´äßû½a ´îbîÛa
John AshcroftëïÛëþa”ìiìîÜi…x‰ìuñ‰a…g¿ïØíŠßþaÞ†ÈÛaŠí‹N50
òîböŠÛa pbib‚nãüa Õib ¿ áèÜrß bà×2008á×by ïib×bç Ùíbß
ÕibÛabãb׉còíüëN
òîãbrÛaòÇbà¦aïçaòîÛbcŠÛapbÇbà¦aòí…bä½iå߆§a늧aÖìÛb
æb߆íŠÏ æìnÜîß Ýrß æëŠØÐß bèÜr¹ë LòÛë†Ûa ݆mMilton Friedman
ŠÏìç †èÈß Ýrß tb¡c Œ×aŠßë òîØíŠßþa ìËbØî‘ òÈßb ÕibÛa ‡bnþa
Hoover InstituteN
ášm òrÛbrÛa òÇbà¦a ´îäîàîÛaõbİ’äÛa åß òÇbº áçë ´í‰ìn†Ûa
åß †°ÝØ’i òîØíŠßþa´ãaìÔÛaÐm ñ…bÇ⁄´ÇbÛa´îãìãbÔÛaëñŠİî
òÛë†ÛaóÜÇë…b–nÓüaóÜÇòßbÈÛaÚýßþaN
…†¦a´ÄÏbaášmòÈiaŠÛaòÇbà¦aòî×ßþaòîu‰b¨aòbîÛbi´îäȽa
ïbcÝØ’iN
@ @
162
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
ìmb×tb¡cŒ×ŠßÝrßð‰ŠznÛaêb£üalbz•cášmòßb¨aòÇbà¦a
CATO oíì׉ìã ŠÏëŠu ÒëŠÈ½a ð‰ìèà¦a Á‘bäÛa ÝrßëGrover
NorquistaŠšÛaœÐ¢æìjÛbİíåíˆÛaó–Ócµg òÛë†Ûa ‰ë…å߆§aëkö
òäؾ…ë†yN51
òÜî…òÇbàv×…†¦a´ÄÏbaµgŠÄäíåßÚbäçÕibÛaðcŠÛaÝibÔß¿
òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa oÐİna ð‰ìèà¦a lŒ§aë ï×ßþa ´àîÛa óÜÇ
éîÛgkçˆíðc‰ìçëL”ìiìîÜi…x‰ìuï×ßþaîöŠÛa†ÔÇ¿òî×ßþa
kmbØÛaë ïbîÛa æbãb×ìi pbi ÒëŠÈ½a ð‰ìèà¦aPat Buchananë‡
òîu‰b¨aòybÛaóÜÇòîÛaŒÈãüaòÇŒäÛaN52
áç†èÇÞaëŒiûjänÛaë…†¦a´ÄÏbaáöaŒç
ïßbÇ¿aìèuaë†ÔÏ…†¦a´ÄÏbañìÓ‰…b–ßåÇŠÄäÛaœÌië2005
ë2006níœÈjÛaoÜÈuÛa òÈuì½a òîbîÛapbiŠšÛaåß aj× a…†Çdjä
Š’ã òbî Ý’Ïë ÖaŠÈÛa ¿ Êb™ëþa ‰ìç†m Éß ò•b áç†èÇ ÞaëŒi
pbib‚nãa ¿ æìí‰ìèà¦a bèi ßÛa ò¹ŒaëÁëþaÖŠ’Ûbi òîaŠÔ¹†Ûa
2006òîÛa‰†îÐÛaN
bà×ÞbÔna”ìiîöŠÛañ‰a…hi…†¦a´ÄÏba‹ì߉áçcåßj×…†Ç
bÇbjmM ÝrßφÛa Ší‹ë köbã ŒníìÐÛë Þìi Lï×ßþa ÊbësíbÏ ýuë…
Douglas FeithŠí†ßaÊbφÛañ‰a‹ìipbbîÛLîÛíìÛëLewis Libby
î’mÙí…ï×ßþaîöŠÛaköbãknØßïÐÃìßj×ëLÞi…‰b’ní‰ìšÇ
ÊbφÛapbbîÜ©ð‰b’nüaφÛañ‰a‹ìÛÉibnÛaÐæìnÛìiæìuëLÊb
äßåÇñ†zn½aáßþaô†Ûb×ßcéj–N
@ @@ @
163
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
Ýöaëc¿bça†ß…†¦aæìÄÏba bŠÈmÛapa…bÔnãüaoÜ•ë†Óë
âbÇ2006´ÄÏba‰bîmÝa…âbÔãañ‰ì•¿pa…bÔnãüaÙÜmpŠèÃsîy
âbÓ b߆ÔäÛaÙÛ‡ŠçbÄß‹Šigåßë LéÐã ‰bînÛaÝa…åßâ…bÓ†Ôãë …†¦a
bßbíì×ìÏîãaŠÏMíŠßþa òîÛë†ÛapbÓýÈÛa ‡bnckyb•ëÒëŠÈ½a ïØ
òyëŠcBƒí‰bnÛa òíbèã BoÓüÛa bua뉿 bÈaë bîÛë… bîbîë bíŠØÏ
pbäîÈnÛa †ÔÇ Ýöaëc ‰bînÛa ‹ì߉ †ycë–âbÇ Ýöaëc ¿ ‰…b–Ûa éibn× ¿
2006BÖŠİÛa ÖÐß óÜÇ bØíŠßc Z´ÄÏbataßë LñìÔÛa LòîaŠÔ¹†Ûa
…†¦aNB53
ëbßbíì×ìÏå’í–éibn׿MïãbrÛaÝî¦a‰bØÏcóÜÇbLJübßìvçåß
LÖaŠÈÛalŠ§áç†îídniÕÜÈníbàîÏò•b…†¦a´ÄÏbaæcbßbíì×ìÏôŠí‡g
Ýî¦aóÜ¥‡gLbèšÈiåÇóܥ녆¦a´ÄÏba‰bØÏcáèÏõbcïãbrÛaÝî¦a
ò†äèÜÛ…†¦a´ÄÏbaœÏ‰åÇïãbrÛaõbäjÛïu‰b¨a݆nÛaëòîÇbànuüa
áßþa¿ŠèÃbà×ÖaŠÈÛalŠ§ïãbrÛaÝî¦a†îídmëæë†iÖaŠÈÛaõbäiñ…bÇ⁄
Òb׊í†Ômaáv§óÜdžî×dnÛa¿ïãbrÛaÝî¦aÍÛbibà×LáçŠÄnämÛaòàè½
bÈÛa¿òîØíŠßþaòíŠØÈÛañìÔÜÛïÓýþa‰ë†ÛaN
bà×èãcbcóÜÇòîöbÓìÛalŠ§aâìèÐßbßbíì×ìϜϊíbòbîojqc
bà× LbèÔîjİm òiìÈ•ƒí‰bnÛa †ÔäíÑíŠÈm ¿ bèÜ’Ï òîØíŠßþa ñ‰a…⁄a óÜÇ
a…†ªbÐíŠÈmòîöbÓìÛalŠ§aâìèÐßëLŠÄäÛa¿…†¦a´ÄÏbaòÌÛbjߜϊí
µgaæcbßbíì×ìÏôŠísîyLñòäàîçbèãcóÜÇbÈÛaóÜÇòîØíŠßþaòäàî
ÄÏba´æìÔÜİäí…†¦aMãb¹g¿†ÜibØíŠßcædiáèãb¹gåßÕibÛac†j½biáè
bÈÛaåØÛë LòîÛbíßfiÛ éšÏ‰¿ïöbärna– bßbíì×ìÏôŠí bà×–ôŠíü
@ @
164
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
bØíŠßciñ‰ì–ÛbbèÐãåÇÉuaÛaëLõbİþbiò÷îÜßbØíŠßcòbîæcbà×L
ñ…‰bjÛalŠ§aòíbèã†ÈiæbnãbÌÏcÉßt†ybà×bçõbÐÜy†îídmµgòÏb™⁄biL
LÕj bßpbàÄäß óÜÇ Šàn½a áèßìv …†¦a ´ÄÏba bßbíì×ìÏ †Ônäí
pbàÄäàÜÛ Ýí†i áí†Ôm æë… ñ†zn½a áßþa bèc‰ óÜÇë ïÛë†Ûa Éàna
òàöbÔÛaòîÛë†ÛaN
…†¦a´ÄÏba ÞaëŒi ûjänÛa dݨa åß éãcœÈjÛaôc‰ÙÛ‡ ÝibÔß¿
L‰bîn×54 ñ‰a…⁄a ¿ áèîÜr¾œÈi õbÔjÛ ÙÛ‡ë Ýrß òî×ßþaŒßaŠig pìîÛg
½aëï×ßþaïßìÔÛaåßþa‰b’nßköbãûŠ’äÛ”ìiñ†äudiÉφÛaåÇÞë
ÁëþaÖŠ’ÛbiòîaŠÔ¹†ÛaN
éîÜÇ õbšÔÛakÈ–íðŠØÏ ‰bîn× …†¦a´ÄÏba òÈîjµg òÏb™g aˆç
ÁÌšÛapbÇbºåßòÈaëpbÇbİÓô†Û bèiæìäßûíÛa‰bØÏþa‰b’nãüë
Ääà×Áëþa ÖŠ’Ûa êb£ ñ…†’n½a òîäîàîÛapbÇbà¦aë ÝîöaŠg ïiìÛpbà
bÈÛaë âýfiÛ õa†ÈÛa ì¸ µg òÏb™g aˆç Lïzî½a ´àîÛa pbÇbàv×
óÜÇlŠ§aõaìuþòvînãâbÇÝØ’iï×ßþaÉànaÂbëc¿ïßý⁄a
†’nÛaêb£a¿oj•ñŠçbÃïçëLæbnãbÌÏcëÖaŠÈÛaïiŠyëlbç‰⁄aóÜÇ…
òßbÇ òЖi ïßý⁄a bÈÛa êb£ ò•b òî×ßþa òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa òyb
˜ì–¨aéuëóÜÇÁëþaÖŠ’ÛaëN
òî×ßþaòböŠÛapbib‚nãa¿…†¦aæìÄÏbaI2008H
òî×ßþa òböŠÛa pbib‚nãa Þì… ÉßI2008 H´ÄÏba Œ×Š· ŠèÃ
ìèà¦a ´z‘Š½a œÈi paŠØÈß ¿ …†¦að…ë‰ áèc‰ óÜÇë ´í‰
@ @@ @
165
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
œÈi éí‰b’nß ´i åß á™ ðˆÛa ÕibÛa Ú‰ìíìîã òäí†ß ñ†àÇ ïãbîÛìu
La…†’m …†¦a ´ÄÏba Šè‘c55 áçëLŠ¹aŠ× åm‰bßë LŒnm‰ìç…ìi æb߉ìã
jíbiÞbîãa…ëN
†ÓëÛa òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa êb£ ïãbîÛìu ÑÓaìß óÜÇ ÙÛ‡ ØÈãa
bÈÛa µg ŠÄäÛa ñ‰ëŠ™ óÜÇ oßbÓ Ñî« bÈ×B‰bİþbi õïÜßB
óÜÇ âìvèÜÛ ò•ŠÐÛa æìäîzní åíˆÛa ´î‘bÐÛa ´îÛbØí…aŠÛa ´îßý⁄bië
b×ßc ñìÓ õbäjië õa†ÇþaóÜÇ Šàn½a âìvbi ÝibÔ½a¿ô…bã aˆÛ [b×ßc
b×ßc Ýa… b×ßþ †ÔäÛa åß †§bi ð…bäí bà× L…놧a ´ßdmë bè’îuë
äí ‰bØÏcïçë Lbèu‰bëb䙊ǿ b㊑c bà×åß‹ˆäß Œní‰ìç…ìi bèið…b
ê‰bØÏþN56
´z‘Š½a ð‰b’nß ´i éÐã ì™ìÛbi …†¦a æìÄÏba ŠèÄí ë
bàèÈä¹ aˆçåØÛë Lïib×bçÙíbßëßë‰oßÝrß´îîöŠÛa´í‰ìèà¦a
ÁëþaÖŠ’Ûaêb£ò•bëòîu‰b¨aòbîÛaòybóÜÇ…†’nÛaåßN
½aÝîjóÜÈÏÝöaëc¿ÝîöaŠgµgbèiâbÓñ‰bí‹Þýß뉘ŠyÞbr
âbÇ2007ò™‰bȽaëÝîöaŠ⁄ñ†ãb½aéÐÓaì߆î×dmëßcŠ·û߉ìšyóÜÇ
LïbîÛa éjšËâbußë‰ bèîÜÇk–íÛa˜ì–¨a éuëóÜÇæaŠí⁄57
bÈÛbi bènÓýÇ ¿ ´îbc åíŠİ éuaìm b×ßc æc ßë‰ ôŠí sîy
ý⁄aLïßbàëcéîàíbߊİBÑîäÈÛa…bè¦biBëcBïÛbØí…aŠÛa…bè¦aBL58
ïãaŠí⁄aŠİ¨aìçïãbrÛaŠİ¨aëN59
òÔibÛa ‰bØÏþbi éãb¹g¿ßë‰ éib’níë–j׆yµg–‰bØÏþaÉß
ÕibÛa¿bçbäyŠ‘ÛaïçëLâbèmëŠ×ŒÛ‰b’mbèuëŠíÛaN
@ @
166
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
g êb£ éÐÓaìß¿ßë‰ …†’m bà×Éäß òîàny a†×ûß ò•b òЖi æaŠí
òíŠØÈÛa ñìÔÛa âa†‚na †ÈjníåÛ éãcëðëìäÛaýÛaÚýnßaåßæaŠíg
òÔibÛaÒa†çþaÕîÔznÛN60
òîbÓòí…b–nÓapbiìÔǵgæaŠígÊbšhiòßbÇòЖißë‰kÛbaˆÛ
Lò튖äÈÛa òÓŠÐnÜÛ bèn‰b¾ Þý bîÔíŠÏg lìäu óÜÇ o™ŠÏ Ûa ÙÜn×
Ç…ëòãëbÈn½apb׊’ÛaåÇ a†îÈi bèma‰bàrnaÝí줵gòî×ßþapbíüìÛa b
òíŠØÈÛaëòîÛb½apa†Çb½aÕφmÑÓëóÜÇòîiŠÈÛaÞë†ÛasyëLæaŠígÉß
ædiëalŒyëb»óÜÇBåÇ aìÜ‚níæcáèîÜÇædi´îäîİÜÐÛa aë±
õbÔjÛa¿ÝîöaŠgÕ¡aìÏÈíæcëlbç‰⁄aNB61
bßcï™a‰þa åÇ ÝîöaŠg óÜ‚nm æc éšÏ‰ åÜÇc †ÔÏ ïib×bç Ùíbß
´îäîİÜÐÛa |äßk¯ éãc Š×‡ë Lbèäßþ òíb» òÜna òí‰ìÛa ëc òîäîİÜÐÛa
bèi òîiŠÈÛaÞë†ÛbÏ Lòí…ìÈÛaëcŠ–ß¿òÛë†Ûa êˆçâìÔmæcåعë LòÛë…
òíbà§bènÜnyaÛaï™a‰þaµgòuby¿ÝîöaŠgëòÈb‘a‰cbèäßcN62
b×ßc bèi‰b¤ÛalŠ§a òÔîÔy áèÏ µg´î×ßþa ïib×bç bÇ… bà×
áèîàí åß †™ æŁaB´îÛbØí…aŠÛa ëc ´îibç‰⁄a ´îßý⁄biBìçë L
ÕÜÔÛa µg ìÇ†í ‰ìèmë Þbàçhië ‰ŠØnß ÝØ’i pbzÜİ–½a ÙÜm ↂní
lŠy òÔibÛalŠ§a æc ê†î×dm Ýÿ ò•bBòí†öbÔÇ Bbþbibèä’í
k¤ b×ßc æþ [Ýßb× ÝØ’i´î×ßþaë b×ßc óÜÇ õbšÔÜÛ æìîibç‰⁄a
pì½aæìj°áçëñbî§aN
´z‘Š½a ÑÓaìß oib‘ Ûa òßbÈÛa …†’nÛa òÛby Õj b¾ ŠèÄíë
pbib‚nãa¿´îîöŠÛa´í‰ìèà¦a2008óÜÇëòîu‰b¨aòîbîÛabíbšÓêb£
@ @@ @
167
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ßÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa bíbšÓbèc‰ÖaŠÈÛaµgòÏb™⁄biâýÛaòîÜàÇëæaŠígÝr
ÒŠÈíbßëBlbç‰⁄aóÜÇlŠ§biNB
…†¦a ´ÄÏba ‰bØÏc òí‰aŠàna òßbÇ òЖië bîöŒu aˆç Èí †Óë
ð‰ìèà¦alŒ§aë ï×ßþa ´àîÛa åß òšíŠÇpbÇbİÓ Áë bç‰b’nãaë
bèuëŠmë‰bØÏþaÙÜniåßûmôŠcpbÇbºŠÏaìmµgòÏb™gaˆçò÷îjÛaŠÏaìmë
ÙÛˆi|àmÛaòßbÈÛaN
òÓýÈÛ òîÜî–ÐnÛa òa‰†Ûaåß bäÈ·æck¯ü òÔibÛa ò•ý¨aåØÛë
òî×ßþa òböŠÜÛð‰ìèà¦a|‘Š½a´×bß æìuI2008 HL…†¦a´ÄÏbbi
†ÓëLòí†îèànÛaòí‰ìèà¦apbib‚nãüa¿ŒöbÐÛa|‘Š½aìç´×bßæcëò•b
aîöŠÛa |j–íÙÜm æþë Lñ‰ëŠ™Ýî–ÐnÛbi éÐÓaìß Þëbämë b×ßþ ŠÄnä½
òÓýÈÛa– ïÛbnÛa áÔÛa ¿ åçä bà×Mñß åß òßbç …bÈic Ñ’Øm
pbäîÈnÛaåßïãbrÛaÑ–äÛaˆäßòîbîÛa´×bßæìuë…†¦a´ÄÏbaN
bîãbq@Z…†¦a@æìÄÏbaë@´×bß@æìu
bänîÏ Ýîu µg ì™ìi ïànäí ´×bß æìuáÜÈm éÜîu õbäic òîÔj×ë Lâ
BâbänîÏlŠy뉅Ba‡gò•bl늧aå‘¿……Ûabèc‰óÜÇëòîbÔÛa
òzÜ–½aØÈmüñ†îÈiÒa†çþñ†îÈi‰cóÜÇâbÔml늧aêˆçoãb×
b–½aëòî×ßþa…놧aòíb»óÜÇáöbÔÛaÕîšÛabèÐíŠÈniòî×ßþaòîäìÛa
b™g aˆç Lòíìî§a òîßìÔÛaéšÏ‰ëòîbîÛa ñ…bîÔÛa¿âbänîÏÝîuÙ‘µg òÏ
ðçbºádžióĤüëòíŠØÈÛaÒa†çþaëñ†½añ…†ªËlëŠyì¨
ðìÓïÜa…ï×ßcïbîëN63
@ @
168
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
´×b߉bÇaˆÛMâbÇ¿ï×ßþaŠ¬ìØÜÛéßbàšãa‰ìÏ1983M
æbäjÛlŠyæc´×bßôc‰sîyLæbäjÛµgòî×ßcpaìÓÞb‰gæcëñ†ÔÈß
Òa†çþaòz™aëËòàèßæbäjÛøa쑵gòî×ßþaòíŠzjÛapaìÓÞb‰g
o™ŠÈm bßæbÇŠ‡g éÏëb«oÓ†•ëL´×bß b虉bÈÏ LߌÛaÞ놦aëc
µgÉÏ…ë bèÏìЕ¿óÜnÔÛapb÷ßÉÓëc âìvçµg òî×ßþa òíŠzjÛapaìÓ
bÈíŠbèjzN64
aŠíŠ¤lŠyæbig´×bß……Šmbà×paìÓÞb‰góÜÇòÔÏaì½a¿oíìØÛ
ðŠØÈÛa ï×ßþa ‰ë†Ûa Š–Ôi kÛbë LòîÓaŠÈÛa paìÔÛa òèuaì½ òc
åí†í†Çbíbz™ÊìÓëåßbÏìðì¦aâìvaóÜÇïbcÝØ’iï×ßþa
¿ òîÓaŠÈÛapaìÔÛa Éß òèuaìß¿oÈ™ë bß a‡g òíÛapaìÔÛaÂbëc¿
ñ†îÈiÒa†çþëñ†îÈi‰cN65
ÇëÞbßì–Ûa µg òî×ßc paìÓ Þb‰g ´×bß ‰bÇ éÐã Þaìä½a óÜ
òäìjÛa µgë pbäîÈnÛa Ýöaëc ¿ òîÜçþa lŠ§a æìme åß bèÜçc ‡bÔã⁄
òîäq⁄aëòîÓŠÈÛal늧a|iaˆßåßbç‡bÔã⁄N66
†í†¦ab×ßc‰ë…
bz™aëaîÌmåØÛëM´×bßÑÓaìß¿MÑ–äÛaÞý‰ìÜjnÛa¿c†i
ïãbrÛa†í†¦ab×ßc‰ë†ÛÑíŠÈmåÇszjí´×bßc†isîypbäîÈnÛaåß
âbÇÝöaëcïÐÏLñ…‰bjÛalŠ§a†ÈibßñÏ¿1995åÇt†zní´×bßkn×
òèuìÛa †×ûßË bȽa |™aëË bÈ× ñ…‰bjÛalŠ§a òíbèã †Èi bß bÇ
ñ‰bèä½a pbîßìÔÛaë Ýßb’Ûa ‰b߆Ûa òzÜc ‰bİc éîÜÇ Šİîm‰bİc b¶‰ë
…ìÈ•BïÛì•þaâý⁄aBbà×LòîiŠÌÛañ‰bš§aáîÓÉßâ†İ–í†ÓðˆÛa
@ @@ @
169
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
´ÜöbÔÜÛéšÏ‰åÇ´×bßÇBƒí‰bnÛaòíbèäiBñ…bîÓ¿énÔqâ†ÇåÇÙÛˆ×ë
´i òîÛbÔnãa ñÏ bèãc ôc‰ Ûa ñÐÛaÙÜm ¿ b×ßþ æìnäîÜ× ÝîiîöŠÛa
B´î½bÇ´ßbÄãBa…gõbİc†Èiò•bÞbßì–ÛaÜØ’ßñ‰a…g¿æìnäîÜ×ñ‰
òäìjÛaë–´×b½bÔÏëN67
¿ï×ßþa ‰ë†ÛaÑíŠÈm ñ…bÇhikÛbİí´×bßkn× âbÈiÙÛ‡ †Èië
bèöbÐÜyåÇÊbφÛaëòíìî§ab×ßcb–ßòíb»óÜÇŒî×ÛaÞýåßbÈÛa
Þë†Ûa‰bİcòèuaìßëBòÜ‘bÐÛaBòîàîÜÓgpbÇaŠ•åßéîÛg…ìÔmbßëòîÓŠÇë
´–Ûb×ñ†Çb–ÛaóàÄÈÛaôìÔÜÛ…a†ÈnüaëòîäëëN68
òÈßbu åÇ ñ‰…b• òa‰… wöbnã óÜÇ ´×bß ÉÓë éÐã bÈÛa Þýë
…‰bωbçHarvardñÏ¿òî×ßþaòîäìÛaòzÜ–½aÑíŠÈnÛóÈmòî×ßþa
b×ßcb–ßæcµgòa‰†Ûap‰b‘csîyLîÏìÛa…b¤üaÂìÔ†Èibß
§añìÓ…ìÈ•ÉäßëLbèîÜÇÝßb’Ûa‰b߆ÛaòzÜdiâìvçðcÉäßÝà’mòíìî
BòäàîèßBñìÓ…ìÈ•ÉäßëLbîcëcbi‰ëc¿b×ßþòí…bÈßBô×Bòí…bÈß
ð‰bvnÛa ëcïÛb½a âbÄäÛa ‰bîèãa Éäßë L‰bzjÛaÇëc bç…ë†yóÜÇ b×ßþ
ß s¡ Šàní ÙÛˆië LòÓbİÛbi ÕÜÈn½a ÙÛ‡ ëc ´îÛë†Ûaòbî åÇ ´×b
ñ…‰bjÛalŠ§aòíbèã†ÈibßñÏ¿ñ†í†uòî×ßcN69
âbÇÝöaëc¿ë1997‰ë†ib×ßcâbîÔÛéšÏ‰†×ûí´×bßkn×B
bÈÛaBoÔÜÈma‡gügâbèßðc¿òî×ßþapaìÔÛaÚaŠ‘gâ†ÈikÛbbà×L
óÜÇ bçŠ–Ó Ûa òíìî§a b×ßc b–¶Ba kÈ’Ûa õbÔi æbà™ï×ßþ
‰b’nãaëlbç‰⁄b×òî½bÈÛapa†í†ènÛaòzÏbØßëLbäöbÐÜyåÇÊbφÛaëLéöb‰ë
pa‰†‚½aëcÝßb’Ûa‰b߆ÛaòzÜcNB70
@ @
170
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
ÁjmŠí æc k¯ âbèß ¿ òî×ßþa paìÔÛa Þb‰g æc ´×bß ôc‰ bà×
òİë bèjzÛß‹ÑÔë LpaìÔÛaÙÜnÛ|™aëðŠØÇÒ†ç †í†zni
ÙÛˆ×ë LÊaŠ–Ûa åßx늂ÜÛïbî †îídm óÜÇ òî×ßþa ñ‰a…⁄a Þì–y
Åyýíë LéîÏ òî×ßþapaìÔÛaÚaŠ‘gðìämÛa òíŠØÈÛapbîÜàÈÜÛðìÓ
áÔÛaaˆçòía†i¿bèîÛgb㊑cÛaâbänîÏ뉅ì™ìi†×ûí´×bßæcbäç
òa‰†ÛaåßN
æþ [Þbßì–Ûa µgpaìÓ Þb‰g b×ßþ ïÌjäí ü éãc ´×bß ôc‰ aˆÛ
½aLòíìî§ab×ßcb–¶ÕÜÈnmübþbiòîîÛìiòîãbãgoãb×Úbäçòàè
ðˆÛa†Çì½a†ÈiòäìjÛa¿òî×ßþapaìÔÛaõbÔi‰bÇéãc´×bߊׇbà×
òz™aëòİlbîËkjiæìnäîÜ×ÝîiòßìØyÝjÓåßbèibzãüa…†ªæb×
aåßòî×ßþapaìÔÛaxaŠgáqåßëâýÛaÕîÔznÛÊaŠ–ÛN
¿ñ†zn½aáßþa ñ…bîÓo¤òî×ßþapaìÔÛaÉ™ë´×b߉bÇ bà×
Þb©¿ìmbäÛaÑÜy‰ë…ÉîìniÝibÔ½a¿kÛbëpbÇaŠ–ÛaÙÜmåßðc
éÜa†i ôØÛa Þë†Ûa ΊÐnm æc óÜÇ bÈÛa Ç âýÛa ÅÐyMb×ßd×
bãŠÏë bîãbİíŠiëM ôØÛa pbí†znÛa òèuaìßë Ê…ŠÛa âbè½LìmbäÛa Þë†Û
ÅÐypüb©¿ìmbäÛaõbšÇc´iôŠÌ–ÛaìmbäÛaÞë…Á’ämæcóÜÇÙÛ‡ë
òîäq⁄aëòîÓŠÈÛapbÇaŠ–ÛaÝyëâýÛaN71
…†¦a´ÄÏbaòí‰ìÔ•µgâbänîωˆyåß
âbÇÞì…Éßë1998ñŠíbÌ߉bØÏcåÇòjbäßåߊr×c¿´×bßÇ
Lñ†í†upbÇbäÓµgÝ•ëéãcµg’mñÏ¿†í†¦ab×ßc‰ë…åÇér¡æcë
@ @@ @
171
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
µgœÓbänmòíú‰L‰ë†Ûaaˆò•bòíú‰µgê…bÓñ…‰bjÛalŠ§aòíbèã†Èibß
âbänîÏÝîuÑÓìßÉßj׆yN
‰bß ïÐÏ1998æìÜíë 뉆íë Œ×Šß âbßc bibİ ´×bß óÔÛc
åİä‘aìipba‰†ÜÛWoodrow Wilson†í†¦aéníú‰pa…†ªåÇéîÏÇñ
ÊbφÛaÝà’nÛ òî×ßþa òîäìÛa òzÜ–½aÑíŠÈm¿ÉìnÛaóÜÇ âìÔmÛa
t†¤bà× Lòî×ßþaáîÔÛaŠ’äÛïÈÛaÙÛˆ×ëòíìî§a b×ßcb–ßåÇ
åÇ´×bßBòí…byþa òîjİÔÛa B¿ òîÛë†ÛapbÓýÈÜÛÁiaŠÛa âbÄäÜÛÑíŠÈn×
†yëþabÈÛakİÓóÜÇæcôc‰ëLpbäîÈnÛaòíbèãMb×ßcìçëM݆nÛa
Š–Ç áÄäm Ûa òîÛë†Ûa pbàÄä½a õbäië pbÐÛbznÛa òíìÔmë õbÐܧa ádžÛ
lŠ§aòíbèäÛòîÛbnÛañÐÛa¿b×ßcéioßbÓb߉aŠËóÜÇòí…byþa òîjİÔÛa
åÇ ì™ìi ´×bß t†¤ éÐã lbݨa ¿ë LòîãbrÛa òî½bÈÛaBâa†• òÛa‹g
òİÜÛaåß´yNB72
bßÉÓëbà×Ê늒ߌ׊ßålj…b•lbİóÜÇéÐãâbÈÛaÞý´×
†í†¦aòî×ßþaæŠÔÛaProject for New American CenturyM†ÈíðˆÛa
…†¦aæìÄÏbabçd’ãcÛatb¡þaŒ×aŠß†yc–æìnäîÜ×ÝîiîöŠÛakÛbİí
ÙÛˆi âbîÔÜÛ …a†Ènüaë òİÜÛa åß ´y âa†• ïÓaŠÈÛa îöŠÛa òÛa‹hi
ØÇŠßþakÜİma‡gbíŠN73
´×bߜω†ÈjÏLæbÔÜjÛaÊaŠ•êb£´×bßÑÓìßÌmâbÈiÙÛ‡†Èië
ì™ëâ†ÈÛpbäîÈnÛaåßÞëþaÑ–äÛa¿òäìjÛa¿ï×ßþa݆nÜÛ
â†ÈÛòî×ßþañ‰a…⁄a´×b߆ÔnãabÈÛa‰ë†iâbîÔÛaéšÏŠÛëéÏa†çc
lŠ–Ûa paìÓ †™ òc paìÔi bè܆mpaìÔÛbi òby ò¹Œç Öb§⁄
@ @
172
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
˜ì–¢ éÛlbİ¿ë LæbÔÜjÛbi ñ†í†ÇpbÇaŠ•¿ojjmÛa òîiŠ–Ûa
åØÛë òíìî§a b×ßc b–ß …†èm bîiŠ• æc ´×bß †×c bèma‡ òîšÔÛa
kuaìÛaåßë Lòí…byþa òîjİÔÛa Š–Ç¿ b×ßc òîÓa†–½ b톤Ýrß bèÏŠ–m
¿ bîbÓ õaŠu⁄aæb× ìÛ énèuaì߆í†èmåßÙÛ‡Òý éÜr¹ b½ LénÐÜØm
òî×ßþaòîÓa†–àÜÛN74
¿ ÎŒi †íŠÏ ‰bînÛ ŒßŠ× éîÛg ŠÄäÜÛ ´Èibn½a ÉÏ… ÕibÛa ´×bßÑÓìß
¿ ò튒n½a òîÛaŒÈãüaœÏŠí ‰bîm LpbäîÈnÛa òíbèã¿´í‰ìèà¦aÂbëc
ñÐÛa ÙÜm ÞýlŒ§a Âbëcìi pbi Ýrß æìîîbî bèÜrß Ûaæbãb×
…†¦a´ÄÏbaÑÓaìßÉßar×éib’nmòí‰ìÔ•òÇŒäÛÝibÔ½a¿xëŠíëN75
ð‰ìÔ–ÛaïböŠÛa|‘Š½a´×bßI2000H
pbib‚nãüa¿´í‰ìèà¦a|î‘ŠmóÜÇòÏbä½aÖbj´×bßÞì…Éßë
òî×ßþaòîböŠÛaI2000HâbÇòíbèã¿Ç1999òbîÛòÜßb‘ôú‰åÇ
†í†uòî×ßcÝu‰åßpbäîÈnÛa†ÔÇÞýïuìÜí†íþaéÛìznÛbubnãÝr·ñ
òbîÛa¿òî܆nÛaòÇŒäÛað뇴í‰ìèà¦a‰ìÔ•†ycµgâbänîÏÝîuÝr¹
òbÛa ´i …†¦a ´ÄÏba ‰bîm ‰bØÏc åÇ åíȽa Šr×c †ycë Lòîu‰b¨a
´î×ßþaN
àí…¿´×bßêbÔÛclbİïÐÏ1999éšÏ‰†×cL¿énjˉëòÛŒÈÜÛ
†½óÈmòİLòîjİÔÛaòí…byþaŠ–Ç¿ï×ßþa‰ë†ÜÛÝßb‘‰bgÉ™ë
óÜÇ ÁÌšÛa ‰aŠàna Þý åß òäؾ ñÏ Þìþ òí…byþa òîjİÔÛa Š–Ç
áÄäÛaáÇ…åÇïÜ‚nÛbiëòîaŠÔ¹†Ûapbyý•⁄aå߆팶bènjÛbİßëbîë‰
@ @@ @
173
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ˆ×ëLòí…byþaòîjİÔÜÛòí†zn½aòÓ‰b½aòîÛë†ÛaôìÔÛaÉßòîÈÓaìiÝßbÈnÛaÙÛ
ÁÌšÛa¿‰aŠànüaëbèikîyÛaÞýåß´–Ûabèc‰óÜÇëñ†Çb–Ûa
lìÜc¿qdnÜÛbèÈßÝÇbÐnÛaëòîÜa†Ûapbyý•⁄aå߆íŒßÕîjİnÛbèîÜÇ
jni´×bßkÛbbà×LòîÜjÔn½aòîÛë†Ûaòîu‰b¨abèmbbîëbîÛë…bç…ìÈ•
òbîBíìÔmòÓ‰b½aáÄäÛaœBòîjİÔÜÛ b톤Ýr·ÛaÖaŠÈÛa bèc‰óÜÇë
ÙÜnÛ òîÜa†Ûa ò™‰bÈàÜÛ ðŠØÈÛaë ð…b½a ádžÛa Þý åß òí…byþa
Þë†ÛaN76
´ÄÏbaŒî׊méib’íðˆÛaÁëþaÖŠ’ÛaóÜÇ´×bߌî׊mŠèÃbà×
Š’Ûa âýòîÜàÈÛ éšÏ‰åÇ´×bßÇsîy LòÔİä½aóÜÇôìÔÛa …†¦aÖ
óÜÇÁÌšÛaœÏ‰ bà× LâýÛa ÝibÔ߉þa c†jß óÜÇ òàöbÔÛa Áëþa
åàØíÁëþaÖŠ’ÛaÊaŠ•Ýyæcôc‰ëlbjþaåßkjðþÝîöaŠg
¿BòîiŠÈÛa áÄäÛa òÈîj îÌm BË òÔİäß Áëþa ÖŠ’Ûa oÜÈu Ûa
âýÛa ÃìÄy ‹ŒÈíÒìïÓaŠÈÛa âbÄäÛa åß—Ü‚nÛa æcôc‰ë LñŠÔnß
ä½bia‰aŠÔnaŠr×còÔİäßµgÁëþaÖŠ’ÛaÝíì¤òía†iÝr¹Òìéãþ[òÔİ
´×bߊÄãòèuëåßN77
…†¦a´ÄÏba ‰bØÏc Éß ñj× òu‰†Û òÔibÛa ‰bØÏþa éib’nmë–Ûa
òa‰†ÛaåßõŒ¦aaˆçòía†i¿bèîÛgb㊑c–òîÜàǜϊiÕÜÈníbàîÏò•b
ïÈÛaë òîÛb§a bèm‰ì–i âýÛaéuë ¿ òí…byþa òîjİÔÛa óÜÇ ÅÏbzÜÛ
b´Ïbä½aëc´™‰bȽaN
pbib‚nãa ¿ ´í‰ìèà¦a ‰ìÔ• |‘Šß ´×bß Œî· aˆØçë2000
jmÉßò•bLòîÈÓaëŠr×còbîóäjmðˆÛa”ìiìîÜi…x‰ìuåÇòîböŠÛa
@ @
174
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
òbîÛ´×bßBòÓ‰b½aáÄäÛaœíìÔmBóÐn×a´y¿ Lbîë‰óÜÇÁÌšÛaë
ìiòÓ‰b½aÞë†Ûa‰bİcåßb×ßcïà°ƒí‰aì•ÁöbyõbäiaÓbi”N78
……½a”ìi†™…†¦a´ÄÏba|‘Šß´×bß
…†¦a ´ÄÏba òí‰ìÔ• µg âbänîÏ ‰ˆyë òîÈÓaë åß ´×bß Þì¤
…†¦a´ÄÏbbi´×bß òÓýÇÕîqìm êb£a¿‹aì߉ìİmÉßåßaŒmáç‰ìèmë
áç‹ì߉áçcåß…†ÇëòíŠØÐÛaëòîbîÛaN
âbÇ ïÐÏ1996 ÙíŠmbj×× ´u ´×bß |‘‰Jeane Kirkpatrick
ïØÛ…†¦a´ÄÏba‹ì߉†ycëæb¯‰†èÇ¿ñ†zn½aáßþbi b×ßcñÐ
âbÇ pbib‚nãa ¿ òî×ßþa òböŠÜÛ ð‰ìèà¦a |‘ŠàÜÛ òjöbã æìØm1996
Û´×bßâýÇ⁄aÝöbëœÈioz‘‰†ÓëLÞë…lìi’íëLéÐãk–äàÜ
bèní‰ìÔ–i oÏŠÇ Ûa ÙíŠmbj××ë ´×bß ´i ðŠØÐÛa l‰bÔnÛa µg aˆç
|™aìÛaëL…†¦a´ÄÏba‰bîm¿òí…bîÔÛabènãbؽëòîÇìî’Üۆ톒Ûabèöa†Çë
énÈ™ë´×bßòí‰ìÔ•æcbäç–ð‰ìèà¦alŒ§aÂbëc¿–òiŠÔßóÜÇ
bbrßcëÙíŠmbj××åßN79
½a¿ë¿ð‰ìèºïbö‰|‘Šà×´×b½ bèàÇ…ÙíŠmbi×oäÜÇcÝibÔ
âbÇ pbib‚nãa2000L”ìi ìîÜi… x‰ìu Úaˆãe ïîöŠÛa |‘Š½a ÝibÔß ¿
L´×b¶ òã‰bÔß òîu‰b¨a òbîÛbi”ìi òÏŠÈßÑÈši éÛ bèàÇ…oËìë
¿ ê‰ë†i ÙÛˆ×ë Lòí…bîÔÛa émbЕë énî–‚’ië òîÛìİjÛa ´×bß òîÐÜ¢ë
ÛaòzÏbØßLbÈÛaÇòîaŠÔ¹†ÛaŠ’ãóÜÇÝàÈÛaëpbí‰ìmbnØí†80oäqcbà×
òîÜàÇ áÇ†Û œÏaŠÛa ´×bß ÑÓìß óÜÇ ôŠc pbjbäß ¿ ÙíŠmbj××
@ @@ @
175
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
âýÛalŠÈÛa éîÏ åàší ïÔîÔy âýikÛbݽaë òîÛb§a bèm‰ì–i âýÛa
áèî™a‰cñ…bÈnaÝibÔß¿ÝîöaŠ⁄N81
nãa ¿ ´×b½ …†¦a ´ÄÏba áÇ… pbib‚2000ÑÓìní ”ìi †™
ÞìníŠ×âbîÜíëåÜÇcsîyLáèäßj×…†ÈÛ†nßaÝiÙíŠmbj××åÇÉjİÛbi
…‰a†ãbnïÜØíëa‡òÜ©‰ŠªM…†¦a´ÄÏbaåßïãbrÛaÝî¦apüb©áçc
MÑîÈ™”ìiæcÞìníŠ×ôc‰sîyLòjbäßåߊr×c¿´×b½éàÇ…åÇ
bîÛbiòϊȽaëñ¨aòíbÌÜÛÑîÈ™ïbîÛa”ìilbİæcëLòîu‰b¨aò
å튣aÊbäÓgóÜlj…bÓËëN82
Šr×þa|‘Š½aóÜÇ‹ìÐÛapbãbØßgÙÜn·´×bßòÜ»æcÞìníŠ×ôc‰ë
L”ìi ìîÜi… x‰ìu ìçë ïbîÛa ádžÛaë pbÇnÜÛ bȺ83ôc‰ bà×
à¦a lŒ§a õbäi ñ…bÇ⁄ óÈí ´×bß æc ×ëŠi †îÐía…ë ÞìníŠ×ð‰ìè
éiâbÓb߉aŠËóÜÇòíçbà¦aê†ÇaìÓëê‰bØÏcëlŒ§aóÜÇòíìî§aõbЙgë
×ëŠiëÞìníŠ×ôc‰ÝibÔ½a¿LlŒ§a¿ñ†í†ubyë‰siðˆÛaæb¯‰
ëc ð‰ìèà¦a lŒzÜÛ †í† ïmdí åÛ ð†îÜÔm ð‰ìèº ïbî ”ìi æc
îàîÛaÑÛbznÜÛN84
×b½ ê†îídm åÇ ŠßbèmëŠ× ŒÛ‰b’m Ç bà×énÜ»ë éní‰ìq kji ´
´y¿Lb×ßc¿òîbîÛaòîÜàÈÜÛñ†ÓbäÛaëáöbÔÛaÉ™ìÜÛòšÏaŠÛaòîib‚nãüa
ë†jí”ìiæc ŠßbèmëŠ×ôc‰B†×dnßËB…ìÔíæc †íŠíðˆÛa éuìnÛaåß
b×ßcêì−N85
ïÛë ¹bu ôc‰ bà×Mòîu‰b¨a òbîÛa ‰ìÔ• †yc ê‰ë†i ìçë
åÇåíȽaòî×ßþabîaŠÔ¹…éãì×åßáËŠÛaóÜÇ…†¦a´ÄÏbaÑÓaìßM
@ @
176
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
”ìië ´×bß ´i Ö‰bÐÛa æcM‰ìÔ• åß …†Ç éí†Çbß ´i á™ðˆÛaë
ŒníìÐÛë Þìië Þi …‰b’í‰Ýrß …†¦a´ÄÏbaMñkyb•´×bß æc
µg Þìzní åÛ éãcë LòÈaë òîbî òîa‰…ëBõbÌji BéÛìÔí bß ……Ší
êë‰b’nßN86
Ç bà× ém…bÈ× Œní‰ìç…ìi æb߉ìã M‹aŠig ¿ …†¦a´ÄÏba ñ…bÈ×ë
iáèibvÇgbèãë†íûíÛa òîbîÛapbî–‚’ÛbM´×bß òî–‚’iéibvÇgåÇ
Énànmòî–‚’i´îbîÛaåßéÜîuåÇŒîàní´×bßæcôc‰sîyLñ†íŠÐÛa
BòÛb•þbiB‚½aˆcóÜÇñ‰†ÔÛaëòÇbv’ÛaëòyaŠ–ÛaáîÓóÜÇòîäj½añŠb
æìî×ßþaéubn°òİÜÝu‰éÜÈ£òîߌí‰b×ëòîÓa†–ß´×b½ïİÈíb¾N87
ÞìníŠ×Šàna´í‰ìèà¦a|î‘i‹ìÐÛa¿´×bßÃìÄyÉuaŠmÉßë
¿ ‰ìu Þe òèuaìß óÜÇ”ìi åß ‰†Óc´×bß ædi ê…bÔnÇa åÇ jÈnÛa ¿
i åß ð‰ìèà¦a lŒzÜÛ ÉÐãc ´×bß æcë LòîböŠÛa pbib‚nãüaæcë L”ì
ÞìníŠ×óä·ëLïßìÔÛaåßþabíbšÓóÜÇŒî×ÛaóÜÇ”ìiå߉†Óc´×bß
‰bj× ´i ´×b¶ þa ´Èní æc ´í‰ìèà¦a |î‘i”ìi ‹ìÏ òÛby ¿
éÛbjöbãê‰bînbiâìÔíæcëcòîu‰b¨aòbîÛaÞb©¿éí†ÇbßN88
bîÛaénÜ»ë”ìjÛ…†¦a´ÄÏba†ÔãŠànabà×|î‘iê‹ìφÈiòî
Œã‰bi…ŠÏkn×sîyL´í‰ìèà¦aFred Barnes…‰a†ãbnïÜØíëa‡òÜ©¿
õbİcŠÄnäíbîjÜbiìÜc†ànÈmÛaénÜ»ë”ìiåßéöbînaåÇaÈßô†jí
æë…õbİþaêˆï×ßþaâbÈÛaðcŠÛaœÏ‰ë‰ìuÞeïaŠÔ¹†ÛaéÏbäß
bjßëc‰bØÏcŠİiì牅bjíæcñ†í†uòîbîpa‰…N89
@ @@ @
177
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
óÜÇݚнa …†¦a´ÄÏba|‘Šß ìç´×bßæcåírØÜÛ a†i aˆØçë
´àîÛaæbšyc¿ï·Ší|‘Šà×”ìiµg‰b‘c×ëŠi†îÐía…æcónyL”ìi
åß …†¦aæìÄÏba ê†ãbíðˆÛaìÛaïãbàÜÈÛa´×bßÝibÔß¿ïzî½a
Ðã ×ëŠi †îÐía…ë ÞìníŠ× âbîÜíë ÞbrßcÝ’Ï æc ×ëŠi ôc‰ë Lé
‰ìuÞeáèz‘Šßë´îaŠÔ¹†Ûaüg†îÐíåÛ´×bßáÇ…¿´í‰ìèà¦aN90
òîäìÛaòàÄÈÛaëñ†í†¦aòîãb¯ŠÛapbbî
áèàÇ…óÜÇñÐÛaÙÜmÞý…†¦a´ÄÏbaÉß´×bßòÓýÇŠ–nÔm
e´íìnßóÜÇp†nßaòÓýÈÛaÙÜmæc|™aìÛbÏ LÁÔÏéÛïib‚nãüaL´íŠ
´ijØÛa éib’nÛa bÔib êbãŠ×‡ b¾|šnísîy L‰bØÏþaôìnßìç bàëc
éib’m ìçë Lòîu‰b¨a òbîÛa òyb óÜÇ …†¦a ´ÄÏbaë ´×bß ‰bØÏc
…†¦a´ÄÏba ‰bîmµgïànäí bîbî´×bß¿pc‰ òÐÜn«pbibn× ém†•‰
áèàdžióÄ°ëð‰ìèà¦alŒ§aÝa…N
bäç’íëŠqcbæb×Ûa…†¦a´ÄÏbapbibn×åßa…†ÇæcµgœÈjÛa
âbÇ¿…†¦a´ÄÏbaña…bäßbèäîiåßëL´×bßóÜÇj×1996‰bîm…ìÈ–i
êì ð‰ìèà¦a lŒ§a Âbëc ¿ †í†uBñ†í†¦a òîãb¯ŠÛa Bµg òjã
†¦aæìÄÏbaôc‰sîyLæb¯‰†Ûbãë‰ÕibÛaï×ßþaîöŠÛab×ßcæc…
ÂìÔ†ÈibßñÏ¿b×ßcò÷jÈm†îÈí†í†u‰bîmµgòuby¿´í‰ìèà¦aë
âbänîφÈibßñÏ¿æb¯‰éiâbÓb߉aŠËóÜÇîÏìÛa…b¤üaN91
áç‰ë…ëòîÛë†ÛaáènîÛëû¶´î×ßþaŠ×ˆíëòÛŒÈÛaŠÇb’ߜϊí‰bîm
óÜÇ ÃbЧa òîàçcë bÈÛa ñ…bîÓ ¿Bàîaòî×ßþa òä BâbÄäÛa óÜÇ ñ¨a
@ @
178
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
áÇ…ëòî×ßþaòíŠØÈÛañìÔÛaõbäi¿‰aŠànüaÞýåßbèàÇ…ëï½bÈÛa
òäàîaÙÜnÛòí…bȽaÞë†ÛaóÜÇÁÌšÛaëb×ßcõbÐÜyN
pbbîæìí‰ìèà¦aóäjníæcµg…†¦aæìÄÏbabÇ…âbÈiÙÛ‡†Èië
BòîäìÛaòàÄÈÛaBßc‰ë†ið…bämÛaÞýåßòîÛë†ÛaòbîÛa¿×cï×
åÇÉÏmòí…†ÈmòîÜa…òbîjmÉß…a†jnüaòzÏbØßëòîaŠÔ¹†ÛaŠ’ã
åÇ ò•bë òÔîšÛa òîÜa†Ûa òîiŒ§a pbÇaŠ–ÛaBòîÏbÔrÛa l늧a BÛa
åí†Ûa‰ë…ë‡aì’Ûaëbèu⁄aÖìÔz×òîÏbÔqbíbšÓÞìy´î×ßþaoàÓ
òbîÛañbî§a¿åíŠubè½aåßÑÓì½aëòßbÈÛaëN92
òîÜa…òbîëòí‰ìÔ•ëò߉b•òîu‰bòbîi…†¦aæìÄÏbaô…bãaˆÛ
ôìn½aóÜÇïÛaîÛ‰bîn×áènÈîjÉßó‘bàníŠßcìçëLòªbnßòí…†ÈmòîÛaîÛ
‰bØÏc¿ì™ìiŠqcéãcbà×Lòîu‰b¨aòbîÛaôìnßóÜÇð‰ìÔ•ëïÜa†Ûa
ˆÛaL´×bßòîuìÛ†ícïÔänÈ߆ycnÇaðBòîäìÛaòàÄÈÛaBó‘bànmbèãcò•b
òybóÜÇòí‰ìÔ–ÛaëòîäìÛaëñ†’Ûaë⌧aµgÝî·Ûaòî–‚’ÛaénÈîjÉß
òîÜa†ÛaòybÛaóÜÇòîÛaîÜÛaëòîãbàÜÈÛaµgÝî·ëòîu‰b¨aòbîÛaN93
´×bßð†Çbß´i…†¦aæìÄÏba
ÊeôìnßóÜÇóÜÇëL´×bßð†Çbßáçc´i…†¦aæìÄÏbaŠè
´iŠÔ½aëéí†Çbßâ†Ócëáçc†ycë´×bßpbibİkmb×ÛbÚ‰bßáèc‰
âbÇ ˆäß éÈß ÝàÇ sîy Léäß1989ÝàÇ Ûb æc µg œÈjÛa ’íë L
b×ßc ñÐoãb× b߆äÇpbäîãbàrÛaÑ–näß¿ÙíŠmbj××´¦ a†Çbß
zn½aáßþaô†Û´×bßñ‰ì•á‰¿ÛbÛÝšÐÛaæërØÛaÉuŠíbà×Lñ†
@ @@ @
179
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ó‘bàní bß ìçë Lòî–‚’Ûa é§b–ßóÜÇåìÛab–ßïÜÈíïßìÓÝİj×
åÇszjmÛa …†¦aæìÄÏba bèiô…bãÛa òîäìÛa òàÄÈÛa òîuìÛ†íc Éß
ÉÏÛaµgð‰ìèà¦alŒ§a…ìÔmë òàÄÈÛaµg b×ßc …ìÔm òí‰ìèºpa…bîÓ
åÇòÔîšÛaòîbîÛapbÏý¨aåÇëŠöbÌ–ÛaN94
´×bß æì¦ òîu‰b¨a òbîÛa ‰b’nß æb¸ì‘ ð†ãa‰ µg òÏb™g aˆç
âbÈÛòîböŠÛaénÜ»Þý2000L95òÜ»¿òîu‰b¨aòbîÛað‰b’nßj×ë
òîÛb§a òîböŠÛa ´×bßI2008H´ÄÏba ‹Šic †yc æb¸ì‘ æc ÒëŠÈ½aë L
ïÛëûßë…†¦aÒëŠÈ½aðŠØÐÛaáçŒ×Šß–†í†¦aï×ßþaæŠÔÛaÊ늒ß
– cŠm bà×BÖaŠÈÛa ŠíŠ¤ òä¦ BéÐã ´×bß bèníìšÇ ¿ oà™ Ûa
¿ ÖaŠÈÛa óÜÇ lŠ§a †îídnÛ ´î×ßþa ´Ûëû½a óÜÇ ÁÌšÜÛ oÈë
âbÇŠaëc2002âbÇÝöaëcë2003L96æaŠíg†™æb¸ì‘…†’mµgòÏb™gaˆç
m ðþ éšÏ‰ëoãb× ìÛë óny ïãaŠí⁄a †í†ènÛa ñ‰ìİ åß ÝÜÔm †Ó Ší‰bÔ
òî×ßcòîma‰bj‚naŠí‰bÔmN97
¿…†¦a´ÄÏbaqdmåÇæb¸ì‘bèîÏÝ÷Ûapbjbä½aœÈi¿ë
åßj×…†ÇádžióÄ°´×bßæcëò•bòîu‰b¨aénbîë´×bßæìu
åÛì×ë ŠØíbi¹bu Ýrß´í‰ìèà¦a´îbîÛabàèèuìni ´ÏëŠÈ½a Þëbi
ægýöbÓ´îÐz–ÛaóÜÇæb¸ì‘…‰L…†¦a´ÄÏba‰bØÏþœÏaŠÛaïÈÓaìÛa
æc†¯´×bßÑÓaìßÉibníåßBŠr×c…†¦a´ÄÏba‰bßóÜÇmémbbî
´îÈÓaìÛbi æìàíå¾BÝrߘb‚‘þkíŠÓ´×bß æc|™aìÛa åß æcë L
æbub×pŠië‰ëÞìníŠ×âbîÜíëÒaÇaÝÈÛëLïÈÓaìÛa‰bînÛa‹ìߊiòã‰bÔß
áçc åß òîu‰b¨a òbîÜÛ ´×bß ð‰b’nß j× ìçë LÕibÛa æb¸ì‘
áèzöb–ãë…†¦a´ÄÏbaåß´×bßõa‰clŠÓ†×ûmÛapb°Š–nÛaN98
@ @
180
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
Ûa´×bß Éß ñŠ‘bj½a ÞìníŠ× âbîÜíë òÓýǵgôŠc Ší‰bÔm’më
ýÇ bèãdiæb¸ì‘ bèЖí òÓBïöbärnaÝØ’i éjíŠÓNB99´×bß’nísîy
ð†Çbßåßa…†Ç´×bß´Çbà×Lézöb–äÛo–äíëŠànßÝØ’iÞìníŠ×
òzî–ã óÜÇ õbäi òîib‚nãüa émý»¿ë„ìî’ÛaÜv¶ éjnØß¿ ÞìníŠ×
ïÜØíë a‡ òÜv¶ tìzjÛa Ší†ß ´uÐ×bß Þbîãa… Ýrß ÙÛ‡ë LÞìníŠ×
Ší†ßköbãë…‰a†ãbnL†í†¦aï×ßþaæŠÔÛaÊ늒ß100×cåßê‰ë†iìçë
ÖaŠÈÛalŠyð†ãbßN101
´Ç †Óë LÞìníŠ× õbÓ†•c åß ìçë Læbàníë Þb‘‰bßµg òÏb™g aˆç
†Çbà× ÝàÈÛa æbàníìÛ Õj †Óë LñÐÛ ´×bß knض bîßýÇg aŠí†ß
æbßîÛÑí‹ìu‰ìmbäîÜÛN102
´×bßpbbîóäjm”ìi
üa ¿ ´×bß ò¹Œç âbÈÛ òîböŠÛa pbib‚nã2000éäîÈm ”ìi œÏ‰ë
´ÄÐzàÜÛ òàÇa†Ûa éÐÓaìßë ê‰bØÏc åÇïÜ‚nÛa µg ´×bß bÈφí ém‰a…hi
c‰ óÜÇë LbîßýÇgë bîbî µg bèi ÉφÛaë bè¯ëŠm ¿ Šàna Ýi L…†¦a
ïÜíbßÑÓaì½aÙÜmZ
M âbÇ Ýöaëc ˆäß ïÛb§a bèÜØ’i âýÛa òîÜàÈÛ ´×bß œÏ‰2001
kÛbë L´îÜîöaŠ⁄aë ´îäîİÜÐÛa ´i òîÓýþa ñaëb½a œÏ‰ë
µgÞì•ìÜÛæbàš×ÁëþaÖŠ’Ûaõbäiñ…bÇgëïÓaŠÈÛaâbÄäÛaîÌni
bèäßcëÝîöaŠgõbÔiåàšíïÔîÔyâýN103
@ @@ @
181
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
M ´i Ý–ÐÛa òbîë ïÜîöaŠ⁄a Ý–ÐÛa Áöby ´×bß áÇ… bà×
×Ûbi kÛbë ´îäîİÜÐÛaë ´îÜîöaŠ⁄aòİÜÛa ý•g óÜÇ Œî
âýÛaòîÜàÇ¿b߆Óïš½aÝjÓòîäîİÜÐÛaN104
M ta†yclbÔÇc¿ë11-9òîiŠÈÛaÞë†ÛaóÜÇbLJübßìvç´×bßå‘
lbç‰⁄aòzÏbØß¿b×ßcÉßÖ…b–ÛaæëbÈnÛaâ†ÇòàèniôØÛaN105
M ÖaŠÈÛa´×bßnÇaBòîÛbnÛa òèj¦aBëŒË†Èilbç‰⁄aóÜÇlŠzÜÛ
bnãbÌÏcÞýëLbèä‘ÝjÓlŠzÜÛ´îäÜÈÛaåí†íû½a×cåßæb×ëLæ
Ûa Þë†Ûa åß æa…ìÛaë bí‰ìë æaŠíg nÇa bà× Lb …a†Ç⁄a ñÏ
BádžmBlbç‰⁄aN106
M ‰aŠÓæcôc‰ëLÖaŠÈÛalŠy‰aŠÓ‡b¥aóÜÇ”ìiñ‰†Ôi´×bß…b‘c
c´×bßÝrßbà×ëLð×……ŠmÝibÔß¿”ìiâŒyåÇÈílŠ§a†y
¿bèÓýİãaˆäßòî×ßþañ‰a…⁄ax‰blŠ§a‰aŠÓåÇ´ÈÏa†½a×c
‰bß2003N107
M ÁÌšÛaÞýåßÁëþaÖŠ’Ûaõbäiñ…bÇgïÇbß´×bßáÇ…bà×
Š’ã ñaìã ÖaŠÈÛa ‰bjnÇaë ïaŠÔ¹†Ûa ý•fiÛ òîiŠÈÛa Þë†Ûa óÜÇ
¹†ÛaŠ’äÛ”ìiñ‰…bjßáÇ…ëÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa¿òîaŠÔ¹†ÛaòîaŠÔM
Ýuþa ñ–ÓMµg p…c b߆Èi bèàÇ… ¿ ´×bßë ”ìi ……Šm Ûa
p†ÔÇ Ûa pbib‚nãüa ¿ òîßý⁄a pbÇbà¦aë laŒyþa …ìÈ•
òîiŠÈÛaÞë†Ûaåß…†ÈiN108
M ’m sîy ”ìi ñ‰a…hi …†¦a ´ÄÏba áÇ… ¿ ´×bß Šàna bà×
‘Šmñ†ãbß¿bí‰ìªa‰ë…kÈÛ”ìiæcµgŠí‰bÔnÛaæìnÛìiæìu|î
@ @
182
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
–Þ†vÜÛñ‰bqg…†¦a´ÄÏbañ…bÓŠr×c†yc–áßþbib×ßþÐ×
|î‘ÜÛòÈaëòíçbºëòîaŠÔ¹…ò™‰bÈßòèuaìß¿ñ†zn½aN109
bàëc åíŠßc òÔibÛa ÑÓaì½a ¿ Åyýíë Zåß …†Ç åÇ Èm bèãc
u‰bëb×ßcÝa…Þ†vÜÛñ‰bqgŠr×þa”ìiîöŠÛapbbîbàèîãbqëLbèZ
éÐã”ìi ÝjÓ bèàÇ…ë bèuë‰ë bç†ícëpbbîÛaÙÜnikÛb´×bß æc
ôŠíaˆë[æërØÛaôŠíbà×…†¦a´ÄÏbaqdmo¤†ÈibàîÏbçbäjmðˆÛa
pbib‚nãa¿‹bÏ”ìiæcœÈjÛa2000ÕjİíëÉjníïØÛ´×bßóÜÇòîböŠÛa
bèikÛbæb×ÛapbbîÛaë‰bØÏþaòía†jÛaˆäß´×bßN110
¿…†¦a´ÄÏbañ†äucë´×bß2008
pbib‚nãaÞì†ië2008òbîÛbi ò•b¨a´×bß ñ†äucombi òîböŠÛa
óÜÇ òàöbÓ òz™aë áçaú‰ë …†¦a´ÄÏba ù…bjß óÜÇ òàöbÔÛaë òîu‰b¨a
òîÛbnÛabȽaZ
M êbabßóÜÇlŠ§a‰bjnÇaBbØí…aŠÛaïÛì•þaâý⁄biïÛBlŠy
ò÷jÈniòjÛbݽaëLå튒ÈÛaëð…b§aæŠÔÛa¿b×ßcpb톤áçcëÞbîuc
Þýt†yb߉aŠËóÜdž톦aë†ÈÛaòèuaì½ï×ßþaâbÈÛaðcŠÛa
ñ…‰bjÛalŠ§aN111
æc ñŠØÐÛxëŠíðˆÛa Œní‰ìç…ìiæb߉ìãÝrß—‚‘‰bØÏc bäçÝİmë
Blbç‰⁄aóÜÇlŠ§aBïçBŠÛaòî½bÈÛalŠ§aòÈiaNB
M pbyý•⁄a åß †íŒ¶ bènjÛbİßë bîë‰ óÜÇ ÁÌšÛa òbî jm
áÄäÛaáÇ…åÇÑÓìnÛaëBòí‰ìmbnØí†ÛaBåßòî’¨aëb×ßþò™‰bȽa
b×ßþò™‰bȽaÞë†ÛaášíbÐÛb¤´–Ûaëbîë‰æìØmæcN112
@ @@ @
183
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
M Þë†Ûa áší †í†u ïÛë… ÑÛb¤ õbäi µg ÝibÔ½a ¿ ñìdžÛa
BòîaŠÔ¹†Ûa Bîܧa´×bß êbc Lb×ßþ òÐBpbîaŠÔ¹†Ûa òj–ÇB
¿ñ†zn½aáßþaÝ’ÐmÛaòîîöŠÛabíbšÔÛa¿òj–ÈÛa݆nmæcóÜÇ
bèÜyM´×bߊÄãòèuëåßMæaŠígóÜÇÁÌšÛb×N113
ñÏ¿bèöbÐÜyëb×ßcáÇ…óÜÇòj–ÈÛaÝàÈmæc¿´×bßÝßdíbà×
È•Éßò•bòí…byþaòîjİÔÛa†ÈibßÙÜmÑÛb¤òîãbØßgëÖŠ’ÛaôìÓ…ì
énãì×ðˆÛaÑÛbznÛa ‰aŠËóÜÇÙÛ‡ë Lb×ßþ ò™‰bȽaÞë†Ûa ÉßôìÔÛa
ñ…‰bjÛalŠ§aÞýòî×a‘üaÞë†ÛaëîÏìÛa…b¤üaòi‰bb×ßcN114
M Þë†Ûa Éß òã…bè½a œÏ‰ë Šàn½a ÁÌšÛaë òèuaì½a òbî jm
í‰ìëæaŠíh×b×ßþò™‰bȽabN115
M bnÐãüa Ýuc åß òîiŠÈÛa Þë†Ûa óÜÇ ÁÌšÛa òbî ¿ ‰aŠànüa
ï×ßcÑÜyµgbèßbàšãaëáÄäÛaÙÜm‰aŠÔnaæbà™ÉßïbîÛa
Lbí‰ìëæaŠíh× b×ßþ ò™‰bȽaÞë†Ûa †™ÖaŠÈÛaëÝîöaŠgáší
ÙÜni òîÜa†Ûa pbyý•⁄a m æc æbàšÛ ݆nÜÛ …a†Ènüaë
™ŠmÕ튿Þë†Ûab×ßcéäÇóN116
M ‰bjnüabç‰bjnÇaëÖaŠÈÛaåßlbzãüaœÏ‰µgòÏb™gÉjİÛbiaˆç
‰ë†ÜÛë Áëþa ÖŠ’Ûa ¿ ï×ßþa Ê늒àÜÛ áçþaë kÈ•þa
b×ßcb¬´iŠ‘bj½aÁiŠÛaë LòÜibÔ½apaìäÛa¿…ì’ä½aï×ßþa
aŠÔ¹†ÛaŠ’ãÝrßñ†ÇÒa†çcÕîÔ¤óÜÇbèm‰†ÓëÖaŠÈÛa¿ñ…bÇgëòî
òîÓa†–ßåÇÊbφÛaëÝîöaŠgåßcóÜÇÅÏb§aëÁëþaÖŠ’Ûaõbäi
bÈÛaÇb×ßcN117
@ @
184
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
´×bßæìuë…†¦aæìÄÏba2008
òÜà¡òîu‰b¨aòbîÛað‰b’nßÁëñìÔi…†¦aæìÄÏbaŠèÃbà×
pŠië‰ë ÞìníŠ× âbîÜíë éí‰b’nß ‰bj× ´i á™ sîy LòîböŠÛa ´×bß
æbub×òbîÜÛéí‰b’nßj×æb¸ì‘ð†ãa‰µgòÏb™gaˆçLïÛë¹buë
òîu‰b¨aN118
Ñ•ë sîy énÜ» åÇë éäÇ ÊbφÜÛ áç‹ì߉ áçc åß …†Ç ôãaë
æëŒîàníb¶ð‰ìnØîÐÛaŠ–ÈÛaæbŠÏÖýdióÜzníïbîi´×bßÞìníŠ×
ÏbäßÝibÔß¿òÛìu‰ëlaì–Ûbi‰ìÈ‘ëòÇbv‘ëÖýcëòßaŠ•åßéiéî
ò튖ÈÛa bíaŒ½bi æìÜzní ´íˆÛa ïib×bçë ïãbîÛìuë ßëŠ× ´í‰ìèà¦a
òí…bÈÛaN119
|‘Š½a éuaìí åß ÝšÏc ìç ´×bß æc ×ëŠi †îÐía… ôc‰ bà×
énîÐÜ óÜÇ énÜ» ¿ ar× Œ×Ší ðˆÛa bßbiëc Úa‰bi †Çb–Ûa ïaŠÔ¹†Ûa
´×bß æcë ò•b Lòî–‚’ÛaM×ëŠi ôŠí bà×MÓ òî–‚’i Œîàníòíì
òîÛbÇòîÓa†–ßëN120
æþbšícåØÛëénî–‚‘kjiÁÔÏîÛ´×bßæìnÛìiæìu†nßaë
´×bß– æìnÛìiôŠí bà×–bèèuaìmÛapbí†znÛa áèÏ óÜÇ ‰†Óþa ìç
ÉßÝßbÈnÛbi òÔÜÈn½aÙÜm ò•b bènèuaìß òîÐî×ëåçaŠÛaoÓìÛa¿ b×ßc
æaŠígëÖaŠÈÛalŠyëñ†ÇbÔÛaN121
Þaìä½aóÜÇëÝßbÈnÛaóÜlj†Óþaìç´×bßæcpëbi×bßôc‰éÐã
ÉßB†í†¦a Š’Ûa ‰ìª Béãcë LòîÛbà’Ûa bí‰ì×ë bí‰ìë æaŠíg áší ðˆÛa
@ @@ @
185
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
ð†»c …ìઠïãaŠí⁄aîöŠÛb× b×ßc õa†Çc Ñíì¥ óÜÇ ‰…bÔÛaîöŠÛa
…b¬N122
´×bßæcóÜÇë”ìiåÇ´×bßÒýna†×ûí×ëŠi†îÐía…kn×bà×
ÝÔnß……Šíbà×”ìipbbîÛa…a†nßaéníüëæìØmåÛë”ìiåÇÑÜn«
L´×bß âì–123‰bÇ ÝÔnß Ýu‰ ´×bß ædi énvy ×ëŠi ‰Šië
âbÇ ¿ æbäjÛ ¿ ݆nÛa1983݆nÛa bíbšÔi ÕÜÈní bàîÏ éríŠm ÝîÛ†×
ÂìÔ †Èi bß ñÐÛ ”ìi ñ‰a…g Áîİ¥ õì ´×bß †Ônãa bà× LðŠØÈÛa
LïÓaŠÈÛa âbÄäÛa Ýrß ñ†í†u ‰bØÏdi kÛbëBpbîaŠÔ¹†Ûa òj–Ç Bâ†Èië
‰bØÏc bèÈîºïçë Lòî×ßþa òbîÛa¿ òí‰ìmbnØí†Ûa áÄäÛa óÜÇ …bànÇüa
ì™ìi”ìipbbîåÇ´×bßõa‰eÞýÔnaØÈmòÜÔnßN124
åí‰b’n½aåßj× …†ÇµgÉàní´×bßæcæb¸ì‘ð†ãa‰ †×c bà×
näíáèšÈi´í‰ìèà¦apa‰bîmµgæìànäíåíŠeë…†¦a´ÄÏba‰bîmµgïà
ÝÔn½aê‰aŠÓ‡b¥aóÜÇëÉîà¦aµgÊbànüaóÜǘŠ°´×bßæcëLòîÈÓaë
òbîÛa bíbšÔi ´nÈaë ñë òía‰… ë‡ Ýu‰ ´×bß æcë ò•b
òîu‰b¨aN125
…†¦a´ÄÏbzàÜÛòrÛbrÛaòíüìÛa
ba åÇ´×bß òîÛýÔnbi ÞìÔÛa´ÄÏbaœÈið…bäí bà× …†¦a´ÄÏ
…†¦aMæb¸ì‘ë×ëŠiÞbrßcåßM…ìuëµg’môŠcpbibn×ê†íûm
´îÈÓaëåí‰b’nßMŠväîî×ðŠäîçáèc‰óÜÇïmdíHenry Kissinger
´îÈÓaìÛa´î×ßþa´îbßìÜi†Ûa†îàÇMµgòÏb™⁄bi´×bßð‰b’nß´i
íbiàîuëÞëbi´Ûì׊ØN126
@ @
186
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
´ÈníæcòîãbØßgµgï™b½a¿‰b‘c´×bßæcŠí‰bÔnÛaœÈi’mbà×
Lòb§aòîu‰b¨aòbîÛabíbšÓ˜ì–¢´îÈÓaìÛa´îbîÛaœÈiõa‰fi
ïçëLïÜîöaŠ⁄aïiŠÈÛaÊaŠ–Ûa˜ì–¢ŠØíbiàîuõa‰fiòãbÈnüaÝrß
ñ†’iÝîöaŠgïiìÛë…†¦aæìÄÏbab虉bÈíõa‰eN127
´×bß ØÈi éÐÓaìß æ…bèí †Ó îöŠÛa ´×bß æc œÈjÛa ôŠí bà×
´×bß ð‰b’nß ´i ÊaŠ–Ûa æc µg òÏb™g aˆç LŠöbrÛa ð‰ìèà¦a |‘Š½a
I´îÈÓaìÛaÝibÔß¿…†¦a´ÄÏbaH†Èiáy†ÓæìØíü†ÓN128
òböŠÛbi´×bß‹ìÏægÞìÔÛaµgæëŠekçˆíòÔibÛawv§aÝibÔß¿
þa àÏìã ¿ òî×ß2008…†¦a ´ÄÏbzàÜÛ òrÛbq òíüìÛ æýÇg òibr¶ ìç
bèÈßÕÐnãÛaòîÛbnÛalbjÿÛZ
üëcZðc‰ë‡´×bßæcæb¸ì‘ë×ëŠiÝrß…†¦a´ÄÏbaœÈiÞìÓ
òíbdžÛa ‰bg ¿Ý†í †Ó”ìix‰ìuåÇë áèäÇÑÜn«ÝÔnß
m åÇ ´×b¶ ðdäÛa Þëb¤ Ûa òîib‚nãüa”ìi îöŠÛa t‰g pbÈj
pbíìnßµgémbbîòîjÈ‘ëþaòîjÈ‘ð…ŠmÉßò•bÜÛa
òÓìjß Ë129âbîÜíëë æb¸ì’× áèÐãc …†¦a ´ÄÏba æþë [
á lŠÓc ´×bß æc òÐÜn« òÔib pbjbäß ¿ aë†×c ÞìníŠ×
Še‰bîmðcåßáèmbèuìnÛëN130
bîãbqZém‰ì•ëòî–‚’Ûa´×bßòîÐÜåÇbè‰Ûañ‰ì–Ûaëéma‡åÇ
éÐã– ´î×ßþa ô†ÛMìç bß ÝÈÐí Ö…b• â‰b• ïbî×
åìÛaòzÜ–½laì•–ÞëþaõŒ¦biÝî–ÐnÛbibçbäÛëbäm…bÈicïçë
@ @@ @
187
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
òa‰†Ûa êˆçåßMéãdi bàöa…ŠÈ’í éÜÈ£ bèãþ [éní‰ìÔ•å߆íŒm
ÛaÒa†çþaµgÞì•ìÛaµgòub§a¿éãcë Llaì•óÜÇbèÈ™ë
bç…†’mô†ßåÇëcbèmbÈjmåÇŠÄäÛaœÌiémbbîÛN131
brÛbq Z…†¦a´ÄÏbaóÜÇ Š–nÔmü´×b¶ òİîa òí‰ìÔ–ÛapbÇbà¦a
´ÏëŠÈ½a ´í’jnÛa oãbnmëÛa Ýà’nÛ †n· ïèÏ Láç†yë
…ìèîÛa pbàÄäßë ÝîöaŠg ïiìÛë ÝîöaŠg ñ†ãbß ¿ áç…†’ni
bèÈîºë´í‰ìèà¦a†íŠmÁëþaÖŠ’Ûaêb£ñ…†’nßpbbîóäjnm
òèuaì½a ïÜÈmë ÝîöaŠ⁄ ÕÜİß ÝØ’i ‹bzämë æaŠíg óÜÇ ÁÌšÛa
òã…bè½aóÜÇN132
Ú’½aábÔÛaìçÁëþaÖŠ’Ûaêb£´×bß…†’mæcbãbîycë†jíbà×
åßïãbÈí´×bßæcëò•bLòîböŠÛa´×bßòÜ»ëpbÇbà¦aÙÜm´iÁiaŠÛa
aœÏ‰aˆÛ [ïu‰b¨aôìn½aóÜÇïbîÛa éÜvÛ´í’jnÛaoãbnmëÛ
êb£ëòßbÇòЖiòîu‰b¨aòbîÛaòybóÜÇ´×bß…†’mæcœÈjÛaôc‰
éîÜÇ´í’jnÛaoãbnmëÛab™‰bnÐßìçò•bòЖiÁëþaÖŠ’ÛaN
bÈia‰ ZÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa êb£ ò•bpbäîÈnÛaˆäß´×bßÑÓaìßÉjnm–
ë òa‰†Ûa åß ïãbrÛa õŒ¦a Êì™ìß ìç–´ÄÏbbi ´×bß òÓýÇë
éäßòiŠÔ½aŠöaë†Ûa¿áç†uaìmë…†¦a–sÛbrÛaõŒ¦aÊì™ìßìçë
aˆçbär¡åßþaëMì™ìi—Ü¥´×bßædi⌦aµg bäÈφm
Šr×c åß †yaë µg Þì¤ë pbäîÈnÛa Ñ–näß ¿ âbänîÏ t‰g åß
a‰bØÏdiåí…bä½a”ìiìîÜi…x‰ìuîöŠÛañ‰a…gx‰b…†¦a´ÄÏb
æŁaónyë´§aÙÛ‡ˆäßN133
@ @
188
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
sÛbrÛa@Ý–ÐÛa@“ßaìçZ@ @
1 Andrew J. Bacevich, The New American Militarism: How American are Seduced by War (New York, Oxford University Press, 2005), 69-96. 2 Bacevich, The New American Militarism, 73-79. 3 David Remnick, “Podhoretz, Lion of the Neos,” The Washington Post, 29 Jan 1985, C-1. 4 Ruth R. Wisse, “The Maturing of Commentary and the Jewish Intellectual,” Jewish Social Studies, 31 Jan 1997, Vol. 3, No. 2, 29. 5 John Ehrman, “Commentary, the Public Interest, and the Problem of Jewish Conservatism,” American Jewish History, 1 Jun 1999, 159. 6 Wisse, “The Maturing of Commentary.” 7 Jay Nordlinger, “Podhoretz at War- World War IV: The Log Struggle Against Islamofascism, by Norman Podhoretz,” National Review, 24 Sep 2007. 8 Wisse, “The Maturing of Commentary.” 9 Daniel Partick Moynihan, “Ex-Friendly Fire; Norman Podhoretz on the New York Intellectuals,” The Weekly Standard, 1 Feb 1999, 37. 10 Wisse, “The Maturing of Commentary.” Murray Friedman, “How He Made It; A Half Century of Norman Podhoretz,” The Weekly Standard, 15 March 2004, Vol. 9, No. 26. 11 Wisse, “The Maturing of Commentary.” Moynihan, “Ex-Friendly Fire.” 12 Friedman, “How He Made It.” 13 Nordlinger, “Podhoretz at War.” 14 Ehrman, “Commentary.” Norman Podhoretz, “Is the Bush Doctrine Dead?” Commentary, Sep 2006, 30. 15 Norman Podhoretz, “The Case for Bombing Iran,” Commentary, June 2007, 17-23. 16 Podhoretz, “Is the Bush Doctrine Dead?” 17-30. 17 Michael Janofsky, “A Neocon is Honored by a President He Reveres,” The New York Times, 24 June 2004, B-4. 18 Norman Podhoretz, “Intifada II: Death of an Illusion?” Commentary, Dec 2000, 27-38. 19 Podhoretz, “Intifada II,” 30. 20 Podhoretz, “Intifada II,” 35. 21 Norman Podhoretz, “Bush, Sharon, My Daughter, and Me, Commentary,” April 2005, 44-45. 22 Norman Podhoretz, “Jerusalem: The Scandal of Particularity,” Commentary, July-August 2007, 35. 23 Podhoretz, “Bush, Sharon, My Daughter, and Me,” 38-49. 24 Podhoretz, “Is the Bush Doctrine Dead?” 19.
@ @@ @
189
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
25 Podhoretz, “Bush, Sharon, My Daughter, and Me,” 40. Podhoretz, “Is the Bush Doctrine Dead?” 19. 26 Podhoretz, “Intifada II,” 29. Norman Podhoretz, “The Panic Over Iraq,” Commentary, June 2006, 29-30. 27 Ehrman, “Commentary.” 28 Ehrman, “Commentary.” 29 Tod Lindbeg, “American Journeys; Podhoretz at the Academic Epicenter,” The Washington Times, 4 July 2000, A-15. Hillel Halkin, “New Podhoretz Reader Puts His Famed Volte-Face in Perspective,” Forward, 27 Feb 2004, Vol. CVII, No. 31, 1. 30 Bacevich, The New American Militarism. 79-81. 31 Bacevich, The New American Militarism. 83-95. 32 Charles Krauthammer, “The Unipolar Moment Revisited,” The National Interest, Winter 2002/03, 17. 33 Charles Krauthammer, “Don’t Believe the Hype. We are Still No. 1,” Time, 13 Feb 2006, Vol. 167, Issue 7, 41. 34 Krauthammer, “The Unipolar Moment Revisited,” 5-17. 35 Jim Lobe, “Politics-U.S.: Once Neo-Cons Uneasy About Bush’s 2D Term,” Inter Press Service, 17 Jan 2005. 36 Charles Krauthammer, “Thug on the Loose with no One to Stop Him,” The San Diego Union-Tribune, 6 Aug 1990, B-7. 37 Charles Krauthammer, “Ariel Sharon’s Stroke Deals a Disastrous Blow to Israel’s Future,” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 7 Jan 2006, A-12. 38 Charles Krauthammer, “The Hamas Victory Has Exposed the Truth About Palestinian Desires,” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 4 Feb 2006, B-6. 39 Charles Krauthammer, “Excuse Me, Borat, But America is the Best Friend of the Jews,” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 25 Nov 2006, B-6. 40 Charles Krauthammer, “Actually, the Middle East is Our Crisis Too,” Time, 7 August 2006, Vol. 168, Issue 6, 31. 41 Charles Krauthammer, “Be Afraid, Very Afraid, of Panting Iranian President, A Holocaust-Denying, Aspiring Genocidist, on the Verge of Acquiring Weapons of the Apocalypse Apparently Believed the End is Near – and Might Just Give it a Nudge,” London Free Press, 17 Dec 2005, F-1. 42 Charles Krauthammer, “Another U.N. Resolution On Lebanon Demands the Same Old Thing,” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 19 Aug 2006, B-6. 43 Charles Krauthammer, “Can We Afford Not to Use Military Force in Dealing with Iran?,” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 16 Sep 2006, B-6. 44 Charles Krauthammer, “Iraq Was Jihad’s Cause Long Before 2003 Invasion,” The Kansas City Star, 8 Oct 2006, B-11. 45 Krauthammer, “Thug on the Loose.” 46 Charles Krauthammer, “The Fate of Iraq is in The Hands of Iraqis,” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 18 Nov 2006, B-6.
@ @
190
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
47 Charles Krauthammer, “Petraeus Fins Solution With Appeal to Sunnis,” The Kansas City Star, 22 July 2007, B-11.
Charles Krauthammer, “Looking for Second-Best in Iraq,” San Gabriel Valley Tribune (California), 6 Sep 2007. 48 Bacevich, The New American Militarism. 69-96. 49 Bacevich, The New American Militarism. 117-153. 50 Murray Friedman, The Neoconservative Revolution: Jewish Intellectuals and the Shaping of Public Policy ( New York, Cambridge University Press, 2005). 51 Massey, Pp. 140-151.
ورة ريجان واختطفوا كيف أجهض المحافظون الجدد ث: عالء بيومي، عرض كتاب أين أخطأ اليمين52، الجزيرة نتسياسة بوش، من تأليف بات بوكانان،
-1A89-2D43-B447-1BB53285/exeres/NR/net.aljazeera.www://httphtm.FBC6C933A97E ،13 2005 يناير.
، الجزيرة نت بيومي، عرض كتاب أميركا على مفترق الطرق لفرانسيس فوكوياما، عالء53 -C860-9C45-ACE3-5BE9836C/exeres/NR/net.aljazeera.www://http
htm.384A458209B7 ،2 2006 أبريل. ،الجزيرة نت عالء بيومي، المحافظون الجدد وصقور واشنطن باقون، 54
-B8BF-3DC4-C764-3C53680C/exeres/NR/net.aljazeera.www://httphtm.B5BA6E433DDF، 18 2006 نوفمبر.
55 Saltonstall, “Neocon Hawaks.” 56 Giuliani, “Toward a Realistic Peace.” Luce, “The Republicans’ Jockeying.” 57 The Frontrunner, “In Israel, Romney Talks Tough on Iran.” 58 Baldwin, “The Mormon Challenger.”
59 Mitnick, “Candidates Court Israel.” Romney, “Rising to a New Generation.”
60 Mitnick, “Candidates Court Israel.” 61 The Frontrunner, “In Israel, Romney Talks Tough on Iran.”
، الجزيرة نتعالء بيومي، صعود وسقوط مايك هاكابي، 62 -6E7A-F438-C4BD-DA54D64A/exeres/NR/net.aljazeera.www://http
htm.frameless,6EFD27C4C2F3 ،2 2008 فبراير. 63 Bacevich, The New American Militarism. 34-68. 64 Lloyd Grove, “AT the Bosnia Crossroads, No: The Senator, Wary of the Perils of Failure,” The Washington Post, 5 May 1993, B-1. 65 Walte, “Top Option.” Apple Jr., “Confrontation in the Gulf.” 66 Grove, “AT the Bosnia Crossroads.” 67 McCain, “Defining an American Role.” 68 McCain, “Ready Tomorrow.” 69 Michael Mandelbaum, “Foreign Policy: The Stealth Issue,” Newsweek, 24 Oct 1996, A-53.
@ @@ @
191
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
70 John McCain, “Should the United States Be The World’s Policeman?,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 7 March 1997. 71 McCain, “Should the United States Be The World’s Policeman?.” 72 McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars.” 73 Bruck, “McCain’s Party.” 74 John McCain, “McCain Outlines Views on the Balkans Crisis, Center for Strategic and International Studies,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 13 April 1999. 75 Lobe, “Republicans Split.” 76 McCain, “Remarks to the National Jewish Coalition.” 77 McCain, “Remarks to the National Jewish Coalition.” 78 Jim Puzzanghera, “McCain Highlights Foreign Policy Differences with Bush,” Knight Ridder Washington Bureau, 2 Dec 1999. 79 Jamie Stiehm, “McCain Won’t Bow Out of The Weepstakes,” The Hill, 17 July 1996. 80 Jake Tapper, “McCain’s World Order,” Salon.com, 1 Dec 1999. 81 Michael Shapiro, “Republican Presidential Hopefuls Gather to Woo GOP Jewish Group,” Jewish Telegraphic Agency, 2 Dec 1999. 82 Segall, “Pundit Sees Bush Having Tough Time.” 83 Mitchell, “The 2000 Campaign.” 84 The Bulletin’s Frontrunner, “National Review Takes on Bill Kristol, David Brooks For McCain Support,” The Bulletin’s Frontrunner , 3 March 2000. 85 Charles Krauthammer, “McCain Learns, As George W. Has not, How to Be a Challenger in a Golden Age,” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 5 Feb 2000, A-10. 86 Rubin, “McCain Trumps Bush.” 87 Norman Podhortez, “The Trouble with Authenticity: A Less Than Ideal Ideal,” National Review, 6 March 2000, 44-46. 88 Hardball with Chris Matthews, “Bill Kristol, The Weekly Standard, Discusses the Presidential Campaigns of Bush and Gore and How John McCain Still Figures Into Race,” CNBC News Transcript, Hardball with Chris Matthews (8:00 PM ET), 21 March 2000. 89 Fred Barnes, “The Do-Nothing Candidate; George W. Bush’s Campaign Shifts Into Neutral,” The Weekly Standard, 17 April 2000, 16. 90 Brooks, “The Conservative Conundrum.” 91 William Kristol and Robert Kagan, “Toward a Neo-Reaganite Foreign Policy,” Foreign Policy, July/ August 1996, 18-32. 92 Sasha Issenberg, “Inventing John McCain, Maverick Icon of American Duty and Patriotism, is as Much as a Literary Creation as a Political One. Meet the Author,” The Boston Globe, 13 April 2008, C-1. 93 Ponnuru, “Hauntings.” 94 Tapper, “Mark Salter.”
@ @
192
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
Issenberg, “Inventing John McCain.” 95 Sandalow, “Foreign Policy.” 96 Schmitt, “Threats and Responses.” 97 Levey, “The Iran Hawaks’ Latest Surge.” 98 Gerstein, “McCain Signals Distance from Bush, Neocons.” 99 Judis, “Neo-McCain.” 100 The Right Web, “A Profile of Daniel McKivergan,” The Right web, http://rightweb.irc-online.org/profile/1297.html, 31 Dec 2007. 101 Daniel McKivergan, “The Worst of Intensions; What Saddam’s Iraq was up to,” The Daily Standard, 30 June 2005. Daniel McKivergan, “Not a Diversion; Was Iraq a Diversion from the War on Terror? Bush and McCain Remind us That the Answer is: No,” The Daily Standard, 6 Oct 2004. 102 Judis, “Neo-McCain.” The Right Web, “A Profile of Marshall Wittmann,” The Right Web, http://rightweb.irc-online.org/profile/3733.html, 19 Nov 2007. 103 McCain, “Talking Points of Senator John McCain – AIPAC Summer Seminar Series.” 104 McCain, “Senator John McCain’s Speech to the American Jewish Committee.” 105 Pleming, “Senators Accuse Arab Allies of Waffling.” 106 McCain, “From Crisis to Opportunity.” Rubin, “U.S. Leaders Talk Tough.” 107 McKivergan, “Not a Diversion.” Bruck, “McCain’s Party.” 108 McCain, “Security in The Middle East.” McCain, “Keynote Address by Senator John McCain at the Seventh Day Adventist Annual Religious Liberty Dinner.” 109 Jehl and Husle, “McCain Will Press for Compromise.” 110 Bruck, “McCain’s Party.” 111 McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain at the Hoover Institute.” McCain, “An Enduring Peace.” McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain at the Republican Jewish Coalition Victory 2008 Forum and Luncheon.” 112 McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain at the Hoover Institute.” McCain, “John McCain’s Speech at the Los Angeles World Affairs Council.” 113 Julia Prodis Sulek, “McCain Outlines Plan for ‘League of Democracies’ in Policy Speech,” San Jose Mercury (Californian), 1 May 2007. McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain at the Hoover Institute.” Rosenfelder, “Grappling with Iran.” McCain, “An Enduring Peace.”
@ @@ @
193
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
114 John McCain, “Remarks by Senator John McCain at the Munich Security Conference 2007 “NATO in the Age of Global Challenge,” http://mccain.senate.gov/public/, 10 Feb 2007. McCain, “John McCain’s Speech at the Los Angeles World Affairs Council.” 115 McCain, “Statement by Senator John McCain on the Release of the Iraq Study Group’s Final Report.” Border, “Report on Iraq.” 116 Witosky, “McCain.” McCain, “John McCain’s Speech at the Los Angeles World Affairs Council.” 117 Dickter, “McCain: Iraq Pullout Bad for Israel.” McCain, “John McCain’s Speech at the Los Angeles World Affairs Council.” 118 Ralph Z. Hallow, “Neocons Aiding ’08 Republicans; Hawks May Appeal to Primary Voters, But Traditionalists Wary,” The Washington Times, 6 August 2007, A-12. 119 William Kristol, “Thoroughly Unmodern McCain,” The New York Times, 21 Jan 2008, A-19. 120 David Brooks, “The McCain Transition,” The New York Times, 1 Feb 2008, A-25. 121 States New Service, “John Bolton on John McCain,” States New Service, 11 Feb 2008. Gizzi, “CPAC: Bolton, McCain and the White House.” 122 Max Boot, “Go with the Tough Guy; the New ‘Axis of Evil” Doesn’t Fear the U.S., McCain Could Change That,” Los Angeles Times, 12 Feb 2008, A-19. 123 Scherer, “John McCain: Bush’s Echo.” Cole, “John McCain Runs For George Bush’s Third Term.” 124 David Brooks, “And Now For Something New; John McCain Would be Anything But Bush III,” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 1 April 2008, B-7. 125 Elisabeth Bymiller, “Foreign Policy: 2 Camps Seek McCain’s Ear,” The New York Times, 9 April 2008, A-1. 126 George Shultz, Henry A. Kissinger, Alexander M. Haig, Lawrence S. Eagleburgwe, James R. Schlesinger, John F. Lehman Jr., James Woolsey, Rober C. McFarlance, “Being John McCain,” National Review, 5 Oct 2007. Gerstein, “McCain Signals Distance from Bush.” 127 The Forward, “McCain Picks up Endorsement.” Ben-David, “Why the ‘Maverick’ McCain.” The Forward, “McCain Touts Stance of Israel.” 128 Bymiller, “Foreign Policy.” Paul Richter, “McCain Far From Predictable on Foreign Policy; Neoconservatives and Pragmatists Alike See the Candidate as Agreeing with Them. His Record is Complex,” Los Angeles Times, 16 March 2008, A-1. 129 Greenwald, “Bush and McCain’s Shared Foreign Policy Approach.” 130 Bruck, “McCain’s Party.”
@ @
194
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
131 Pat Buchanan, “John McCain Entranced by Fatal Allure of ‘Moral Clarity’; Ideological Foreign Policy has a Disturbing Tendency to Steer the Ship of State Straight Onto the Rocks,” The Toronto Star, 13 April 2008, A-15. Michael Hirsh, “The World According to John McCain; He’s Both the Consummate Pragmatist and a Zealous Crusader for Causes He Feels Just. The Question is Which American Needs Now,” Newsweek, 7 April 2008, Vol. 151, No. 14, 26. 132 Ron Kampeas, “Candidates Talk Tough to GOP Jews,” Jewish Telegraphic Agency, 16 Oct 2007. Levey, “The Iran Hawaks’ Latest Surge.” Fields, “McCain as Judah Maccabee.” 133 Dan Gardner, “Why McCain is the Neo-cons’ Man after All,” Ottawa Citizen, 13 Feb 2008, A-15.
195
ò·bNN@ @´×bß@æì¦@òîu‰b¨a@òbîÛa@ @
åß ï×ßc ïbî òî×ßþa òböŠÜÛ ð‰ìèà¦a |‘Š½a ´×bß æìu
ÝİjÛa ñ‰ì–i Énàní ïbîë LÕiblŠy´vël‰bª ìèÏ L†íŠÏ Êìã
apbbîÛaåßbz™aëývÙÜn¹éãcbà×LòÈaëŠè’iëï×ßþaïßìÔÛ
µg Šİ™a ìÛë óny òÜÔnß òîbî pa‰aŠÓ ‡b¥a óÜÇ ém‰†Ó ojrm Ûa
paìäÛ´×bßÝÈÏbà×òîbîÛaëòíçbà¦aéma…bîÓëéiŒyò™‰bÈßN
åß òîbîÛa éÐÓaìßë ´×bß æìu ñë òî–‚‘ ïãbÈm ÑÿÛë
òîuaë…‹aòybÛa óÜÇ bîÛaîÛ b¶‰ë bãŠß bznÐäß ë†jí ´×bàÏ Lòz™aë
köaŠšÛaë åíŠubè½aë pbîÜÓþa ÖìÔy Ýrß bíbšÓ êb£ ò•b òîÜa†Ûa
òã늶 òÔibÛa bíbšÔÛa Éß ÝßbÈní ´×bß æc ë†jísîy Lòîz–Ûa òíbÇŠÛaë
‡b¥a µg bãbîyc ´×bß Ýî¹ †Óë Lò™‰bȽa ŠÄäÛa pbèuë ÞìjÔi éÛ |àm
Šr×þa ð‰ìèà¦a lŒ§a †ÇaìÓ õb™‰⁄ éäß bîÈ ñ…†’nß òîäî¹ ÑÓaìß
òîÛb§a òîböŠÛa pbib‚nãüa òÜ» Þý t…by ìç bà× La…†’më òÄÏbª
I2008HbíbšÔÛaóÜÇ|nÐä½aïbîÛaéÜvòîàçcåßÝÜÔíüaˆçåØÛëL
Ðä½a òîÜa†Ûa éÐÓaì½ ´×bß …ìÈí æc òîãbØßg åß üë òÔibÛa†Èi òzn
òub§a†äÇëcòîböŠÛapbib‚nãüaN
@ @
196
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
òî܆m òí‰ìÔ• òîu‰b¨a òybÛa óÜÇ ´×bßÑÓaìß ë†jm ÝibÔ½a ¿
…ìÈíëLŠí†ÔmÝÓcóÜÇpbäîÈnÛaÑ–nä߈äߊànßëÕnßÝØ’iñ…†’nß
òîö‰lbjcòqýqµgòa‰†ÛaÇbäz™ëbà×ÙÛ‡Z
bëcZµg Ýî· Ûa ´×bß òî–‚‘ òÈîjòî–‚’Ûaë ñ‰ìrÛaë ñ†§a
ügÒÈmülŠyòyb×òîbîÛaµgŠÄämÛaò߉b–ÛaòíŠØÈÛa
ædiëõüìÛbiBò׊Ƚapì•ÖìÏìÜÈípì•üBµgòÏb™g aˆç L
òÓýÇ ïçë Lð‰ìèà¦a lŒzÜÛ òíçbà¦a †ÇaìÔÛbi ´×bß òÓýÇ
Ûa òyb óÜÇ òí‰ìÔ–Ûaë …†’nÛa åß †íŒß µg ´×bß Éφmòbî
òîu‰b¨a–ÁëþaÖŠ’Ûaêb£ò•bN
bîãbqZ…†’nÛbiŒî·ÁëþaÖŠ’ÛabíbšÓáçcåß…†Çêb£´×bßÝv
ÉÓìnã bäÜÈ£òu‰†ÛòÐÜn« bíbšÓ êb£ëòÜíìòîäß‹ ñÏô†ßóÜÇ
áاaµgÝ•ëìÛaˆçê…†’m¿´×b߉aŠànaN
‰bȽa éÐÓìß ñ…†’n½a ´×bß ÑÓaìß ‹Šic åßëâýÛa òîÜàÈÛ
ïÇbÛaëLáèÐãclŠÈÛaÌíónyÝîöaŠgëlŠÈÛa´iÝ–ÐÛbikÛbݽaë
×c†yc´×b߆Èísîy LÖaŠÈÛa¿Šèà bà× bãbîyc ñìÔÛbilŠÈÛaîÌnÛ
”ìiìîÜi…x‰ìuîöŠÛañ‰a…gx‰blŠzÜÛ´àÇa†ÛaN
bí‰ìë æaŠíg Éß òèuaì½a òbîÛ´×bßjm µg òÏb™g aˆçÉφí b¾
òböŠÛaéîÛìmòÛby¿pbß‹þaëŠmìnÛaå߆íŒßµgòÔİä½aN
pbbîÛa µg ñìdžÛa ¿ ”ìi ñ‰a…g Õj ´×bß æc ÙÛ‡ µg Ñ™c
”ìiæc aëc‰´ÜÜaœÈiæc†yµg òÔibÛa– ñ…†’n½a émbbî¿M
@ @@ @
197
…†¦a@´ÄÏbzàÜÛ@òrÛbrÛa@òíüìÛaë@Áëþa@ÖŠ’Ûaë@´×bß@æìu
µëþa òîböŠÛa énÜ»¿´×bß bèikÛbpbbîÛ bÔjİßüg åØíâbÇ¿
2000òí‰ìÔ• ñ†äudi |İÛa µg Éφí Òì ´×bß ‹ìÏ æc Èí aˆçë L
òí‰ìÔ•æcìçëïbcÖ‰bÏÉß”ìiìîÜi…x‰ìuîöŠÛaïm‰a…gñ†äud×
ÑÓaìß ØÈm Ûa ñ……½a ”ìi òí‰ìÔ• åß a‰ìİmë òÛb•c Šr×c ´×bß
LïÛb§aï×ßþaîöŠÜÛ òîÜ•cÑÓaìß bèäß Šr×c”ìið‰b’nßòã‰bÔàÏ
pbbî ædi ar× bãbîyc ÚŠÈ’m ´×bßÑÓaì¶ òí‰ìÔ–Ûa”ìipbbî
émbÇbäÓåß òÈibäÛaïãbrÛaÑÓaì½ òîÜ•cËë ònçbi ñ‰ì•ügoîÛÞëþa
òÜî•þaëòÜÔn½aN
brÛbqZ…†¦a´ÄÏba‰bØÏcå߆í†ÈÛbipbäîÈnÛaÑ–nä߈äß´×bßåße
aëåØíéãcåßáËŠÛaóÜljbØÏcÕänÇaéäØÛëL‰bînÛaõbäicåßa†y
áçbb¶‰ëì™ìi‰bînÛaMòîböŠÛaénÜ»oàçbëI2000HM¿
jØÛalbvÇ⁄a Ýÿ ò•b …†¦a´ÄÏba ‰bØÏcœÈi Šíìİm
´×bßæ즅†¦a´ÄÏba‹ì߉áçcœÈiéäØíðˆÛaN
pbbîiåße´×bß æc bšíc|™aìÛaëBîäìÛa òàÄÈÛaò BåßûmÛa
b×ßcë Lj× ïÛë… ÊëŠ’ß ÕîÔznÛ óÈm x‰b¨a ¿ ô× b×ßc õbäji
pbÏý¨a åÇ µbÈnmë åíŠubè½aëpbîÜÓþa Éß |ßbnm Ýa†Ûa ¿ òªbnß
òîäìÛa òàÄÈÛa pbbî ÝÈÛë LòÔîšÛa òîÜa†Ûa B bèí†ÈjiZïu‰b¨a
bßÑÓaìßòîuaë…‹aŠÐm|ßbn½aïÜa†ÛaëïÈìnÛa¿bèîÛgb㊑cÛa´×
ò߆Խaòía†iN
òîböŠÛapbib‚nãüa¿´×bß‹ìÏÝr¹ædiÉÓìnÛaåعÕjbßÝÿë
òÜjÔ½aIàÏìã2008 Háèöa‰þ L´×bßÞìy´Ðnܽa …†¦a´ÄÏbzàÜÛ a‹ìÏ
@ @
198
@ñŠíŒ¦a@Öa‰ëcI5H
¿òîu‰b¨ab×ßcòbî¿|™aìÛaáçqdnÛa…a†nßaëòîbîÛaáèm†äuþë
ìu †èÇbàëc L´îbc ´Ó‰bÏ Éß”ìi ìîÜi… x‰ ZŠr×c ë†jí ´×bß æc
bàèîãbqë L”ìji òã‰bÔß …†¦a ´ÄÏba ñ†äuc Õîjİm ¿ õbׇë òÛb•cZæc
ñ†í†ÈÛa”ìiíüëõbİc–ÖaŠÈÛa¿ò•b–òã…bèàÜÛ´×bßÉφm†Ó
òîmbºÛaë–nÓûßë bí‰aŠİ™aüg æìØíåÛ ÉuaÛa aˆçÝrßåØÛëóny b
´×bß —Ü‚níMóÜÇ õbšÔÛaë Š–äÛa ÕîÔ¤ óÜÇ Š–½aë …Šàn½a ŠöbrÛa
éßì––éßýycÕîÔznÛbç†ÈiΊÐnîÛ´y†ÈiìÛë”ìiò׊mpbÈjmåß
òî×ßþaòîu‰b¨aòbîÜÛéníú‰ëêŠØÏ¿ò‚aŠÛaòí‰ìÔ–ÛaN
òÜîÔqòîjÜ”ìiò׊mæcëÌm†ÓÉÓaìÛaædiœÈjÛað…bäí†Óëæcë
ÝßaìÈÛaæcë Lbîàny aŠßcpbiÁëþaÖŠ’Ûa êb£ òî×ßþa òbîÛaîÌm
bßbiëc ëc ´×bß óÜÇ ŠÐm Áëþa ÖŠ’Ûbi òäçaŠÛa Êb™ëþaë òÔibÛa
ꉆÔã ðc‰ë LòÐÜn« òî×ßcë òîiŠÇ ‰…b–ß éi ð…bäm Šßc ìçë LîÌnÛa
îÌnÜÛ Êìφßïbî´ij×Ö‰bÏ Úbäç åØÛë Léß−ëLòîmaˆÛa ém…a‰hi
òÔibÛa êaúŠÛ ñ…ìÈÛa ò•ŠÏ ´zní ém…a‰g Ë óÜÇ îÌnÜÛ Šİšß Šeë
b×ßc ‰ë†Ûë òî×ßþa òîu‰b¨a òbîÜÛ âbÈÛa ê‰ì–më ñŠØÏ ¿ ò‚aŠÛa
bÈÛa¿…ì’ä½aN