Academic Science Engagement with North Korea by Hyunjin Seo

8/3/2019 Academic Science Engagement with North Korea by Hyunjin Seo

1/21

Ndjsfjs~8

Qidvom~mkuf~ gjsd wduc~8 FndjdlgnGlqignksgdj~ db ^dvsm @dufkj Lgigsku^qfjcgjo

Oideki Bgjkjngki Nug~g~ kjc ^~sflgnUg~`~ gj smf @dufkj Ekj`gjo ^fnsdu

Smf Ekj` db @dufk gj Mg~sdugnki kjcNdlqkuksgrf Qfu~qfnsgrf

^dvsm @dufk~ Jksgdjki Gcfjsgs^fj~gsgrgs8 Frdivsgdj) Lkjgbf~sksgdj~)Qud~qfns~

Eudkcnk~sgjo Cfufoviksgdj gj dvsm@dufk

Ufqd~gsgdjgjo smf @dufk Eukjc sd kOideki Kvcgfjnf8 Nmkiifjof~) Qgsbkii~)kjc Nvuufjs suksfo

Knkcflgn ^ngfjnf Fjokoflfjs wgsmJdusm @dufk

Lkgjskgjgjo k Udovf Ufoglf8@gl Hdjo,Gi kjc smf Jdusm @dufk

^vnnf~~gdj Qudnf~~

Suv~s Evgicgjo smudvom Gj~sgsvsgdj~8Fvudqfj If~~dj~ bdu @dufkj Vjgbgnksgdj@dufk Fndjdlgn Gj~sgsvsf

Rdivlf >

51;1Knkcflgn Qkqfu ^fugf~1j @dufk

55;6;@FGKTNdrfu,J5*gjcc ;55;6;@FGKTNdrfu,J5*gjcc ; =$7$;1 ;183? KL=$7$;1 ;183? KL


2/21

Skeif db Ndjsfjs~

Qufbknf *****************************************************************************************************r g

^dvsm @dufk8 Fndjdlgn G~~vf~ kjc Qdigngf~

Qidvom~mkuf~ gjsd ^wduc~8 Fndjdlgn Glqignksgdj~ db ^dvsm @dufkj

Lgigsku qfjcgjo

Hdmj Bfbbfu * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *;

Oideki Bgjkjngki Nug~g~ kjc ^~sflgn Ug~`~ gj smf @dufkj Ekj`gjo

^fnsdu

Lvjo,`dd @kjo* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *5>

Smf Ekj` db @dufk gj Mg~sdugnki kjc Ndlqkuksgrf Qfu~qfnsgrf

Smdlk~ Nkuogii* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 37

^dvsm @dufk8 Odrfujlfjs kjc ^dngfsw

^dvsm @dufk~ Jksgdjki Gcfjsgs fj~gsgrgs8 Frdivsgdj) Lkjgbf~sksgdj~)

Qud~qfns~

Ogiefus Udxlkj * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 2?

Eudkcnk~sgjo Cfufoviksgdj gj ^dvsm @dufk

@g,~vjo @wk`* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * =;

Ufqd~gsgdjgjo smf @dufk Eukjc sd k Oideki Kvcgfjnf8 Nmkiifjof~)

Qgsbkii~) kjc Nvuufjs ^suksfo

@fgsm Cgjjgf * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 76

Jdusm @dufk

Knkcflgn ^ngfjnf Fjokoflfjs wgsm Jdusm @dufk

Mvjhgj ^fd " ^svkus Smdu~dj * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ;16

Lkgjskgjgjo k Udovf Ufoglf8 @gl Hdjo,gi kjc smf Jdusm @dufkj

^vnnf~~gdj Qudnf~~

Euvnf F* Efnmsdi Hu* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ;5>

Suv~s Evgicgjo smudvom Gj~sgsvsgdj~8 Fvudqfkj If~~dj~ bdu @dufkjVjgnksgdj

^kjolgj Ekf " Lkusj cf Euvj * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ;37

g


3/21

;16Knkcflgn ^ngfjnf Fjokoflfjs wgsm Jdusm @dufk

Knkcflgn ^ngfjnf Fjokoflfjs wgsmJdusm @dufk

e Mvjhgj ^fd " ^svkus Smdu~dj

^ngfjnf cgqidlkn ufbfu~ sd gjsfujksgdjki ~ngfjsgn nddqfuksgdj kglfc

~glviskjfdv~i ks kcrkjngjo ~ngfjsgn `jdwifcof kjc glqudrgjo kjc

~sufjosmfjgjo eudkcfu ufiksgdj~ efswffj qkusgngqksgjo ndvjsugf~ kjc oudvq~*

^ngfjnf cgqidlkn mk~ qudrfc sd ef f~qfngkii mfiqbvi gj fjokogjo ndvjsugf~

wmfuf sukcgsgdjki cgqidlksgn ufiksgdj~ mkrf effj qudeiflksgn* ^vnnf~~bvi

~ngfjnf cfqfjc~ dj smf suv~sfc kqqignksgdj db ~mkufc qudsdndi~ kjc smv~

fjndvukof~ smf cfrfidqlfjs db suv~s kldjo qkusgngqkjs~* Gj smg~ qkqfu wf

quf~fjs frgcfjnf budl k idjo,sful knkcflgn ~ngfjnf fjokoflfjs efswffj

smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~ kjc Jdusm @dufk -CQU@0 smf Cfldnuksgn Qfdqif~ Uf,

qveign db @dufk' smks -;' ~v~skgjfc ~ngfjnf fjokoflfjs qudrgcf~ k rkivkeif

ndjsf}s bdu cfrfidqgjo suv~s efswffj gjcgrgcvki~ budl ndvjsugf~ wgsm ~sudjo

qdigsgnki cgbbfufjnf~) kjc -5' smg~ suv~s nkj ~qgii drfu gjsd lduf sukcgsgdjki

cgqidlksgn fjokoflfjs~*

_f cf~nugef kj knkcflgn fjokoflfjs gj smf kufk db gjbdulksgdj ~ngfjnf

efswffj ^uknv~f Vjgrfu~gs -^V' gj smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~ kjc @gl Nmkf`

Vjgrfu~gs db Sfnmjdido -@VS' gj Jdusm @dufk* Smg~ fjokoflfjs mk~ effj

nkuugfc dvs gj nid~f nddqfuksgdj wgsm smf @dufk dngfs) k jdjodrfujlfjski

duokjgxksgdj -JOD' idnksfc gj Jfw Wdu` Ngs* Smf ~ngfjnf fjokoflfjs

wk~ gjgsgksfc gj 511; kjc mk~ sd cksf uf~visfc gj ;> f}nmkjof~ db ~ngfjsgn

qfu~djjfi kjc gj smf ndj~suvnsgdj kjc glqiflfjsksgdj db smf u~s cgogski

igeuku gj Jdusm @dufk* Smf suv~s,nfjsugn jksvuf db ndiikeduksgrf ~ngfjnf g~

f~qfngkii ufifrkjs gj fjokogjo Jdusm @dufk efnkv~f) k~ wgsm ~dlf dsmfu

Jdusmfk~s K~gkj ndvjsugf~) suv~s stdw~ lduf budl ufiksgdj~mgq~ smkj budl

{vgc qud {vd ndjsukns~* Smv~) wf kuovf) ~ngfjnf fjokoflfjs qudrgcf~ k

Cu* Smdu~dj g~ wgsm smf Lk}wfii ^nmddi) uknv~f Vjgrfu~gs0 L~* ^fd g~ wgsmsmf * G* Jfwmdv~f nmddi db Qveign Ndllvjgnksgdj~) uknv~f Vjgrfu~gs*Smf kvsmdu~ wdvic ig`f sd smkj` smf bdiidwgjo bdu smfgu ndiifkovf~mgq kjcfbbdus~ gj smf qudoukl~ cf~nugefc gj smg~ qkqfu8 Bufcfugn` Nkuugfuf) HdjowddMkj) kjc Smdlk~ Mkueigj k~ wfii k~ smf kvsmdu~ Jdusm @dufkj ndvjsfuqkus~*Smf wdvic ki~d ig`f sd kn`jdwifcof smf bdiidwgjo bdu smfgu ~vqqdus db smf

qudhfns8 smf Mfju Ivnf Bdvjcksgdj) smf Bduc Bdvjcksgdj) smf Vjgsfc Edkucbdu Nmug~sgkj Mgomfu Fcvnksgdj gj K~gk) smf Qkngn Nfjsvu Gj~sgsvsf) smfUgnmkuc Idvj~efu Bdvjcksgdj) ^dvsm @dufk~ Lgjg~su db Vjgnksgdj) OkifGjsfujksgdjki) kjc smf Mkjlkfvl dvsm Jdusm nmdiku~mgq Bdvjcksgdj -rgksmf Efkvsgbvi Bdvjcksgdj db ^fdvi'*


4/21

;12 Dj @dufk8 Rdivlf >

v~fbvi ndjsf}s bdu cfrfidqgjo smf ufiksgdj~mgq~ visglksfi uf{vgufc bdu lduf

eudkc,okvofc nddqfuksgdj*

_f smfj cg~nv~~ ~frfuki bdiidw,dj ~ngfjnf ndiikeduksgdj~) gjnivcgjo smf

bdvu,jksgdj Ufogdjki ^nmdiku~ kjc Ifkcfu~ ^flgjku Qudoukl bdu Nmgjf~f)

Jdusm @dufkj) dvsm @dufkj) kjc V*^* gjbdulksgdj ~ngfjsg~s~ kjc igjovg~s~0

smf u~s,frfu qkusgngqksgdj e Jdusm @dufkj vjcfuoukcvksf ~svcfjs~ gj smf

K~~dngksgdj bdu Ndlqvsgjo Lknmgjfu~ Gjsfujksgdjki Ndiifogksf Qudoukl,

lgjo Ndjsf~s0 kjc smf V*^*,CQU@ ngfjsgn Fjokoflfjs Ndj~dusgvl ek~fc

gj _k~mgjosdj) C*N*

Smf qkqfu ndjnivcf~ wgsm k cg~nv~~gdj db if~~dj~ ifkujfc ufokucgjo smf udif

knkcflgn ~ngfjsg~s~) knsgjo edsm k~ fcvnksdu~ kjc uf~fkunmfu~) nkj qik gj

mfiqgjo sd nufksf smf ndjcgsgdj~ bdu lduf bklgigku bdul~ db cgqidlkn* Smg~

g~ db qkusgnviku ufifrkjnf gj smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~) wmfuf knkcflgn gj~sgsvsgdj~

mkrf kj fjmkjnfc -smdvom jdjfsmfif~~ ndj~sukgjfc' ifoki nkqkegigs sd cfki

wgsm knkcflgn~ gj ndvjsugf~ ~vnm k~ Jdusm @dufk wmfuf lkj dsmfu ldcf~

db nddqfuksgdj lgoms ef jfkui glqd~~geif* _mfj qudqfui kclgjg~sfufc)

~ngfjnf cgqidlkn nkj ifrfukof smf oideki nufcgegigs db V*^* ~ngfjnf sd

qudrgcf kj glqduskjs lfnmkjg~l bdu ~vqqdusgjo lduf sukcgsgdjki cgqidlksgn

ufiksgdj~mgq~*

^ngfjnf kjc Cgqidlknw

Smfuf kuf lkj) dbsfj gjndlqksgeif) cfjgsgdj~ db cgqidlkn kjc ufiksfc

sful~ ~vnm k~ nvisvuki cgqidlkn) ~ngfjnf cgqidlkn) kjc qveign cgqidlkn*

Kismdvom smf~f cfjgsgdjki cgbbfufjnf~ kuf gjsfuf~sgjo kjc mkrf ~nmdikui

ndj~f{vfjnf) k ~~sflksgn sufkslfjs db smfl g~ efdjc smf ~ndqf db smg~

qkqfu* Bdu dvu quf~fjs qvuqd~f) cgqidlkn nkj ef vjcfu~sddc k~ fjokoflfjs~

smks gjnivcf) evs jffc jds ef iglgsfc sd) smf gjsfjs sd fjmkjnf nddqfuksgrf

ufiksgdj~ efswffj smf qkusgngqksgjo qkusgf~* Gj smg~ qkqfu wf kuf gjsfuf~sfc gj

k qkusgnviku gjc db cgqidlknsmks wmgnm gjrdirf~ smf evgicgjo db udev~s

suv~sfc fjokoflfjs efswffj ~ngfjnf fjsgsgf~ gj ndvjsugf~ wmfuf smfuf kuf

lgjglki dbngki cgqidlksgn ufiksgdj~*

Qugdu sd ofssgjo sd smf nk~f) mdwfrfu) wf wkjs sd lk`f k bfw lduf ofjfuki

qdgjs~ ufokucgjo ~ngfjnf cgqidlkn kjc mdw gs ufiksf~ sd lduf sukcgsgdjki

bdul~ db cgqidlkn* Gj gs~ ~sugnsf~s ~fj~f) gjsfujksgdjki cgqidlkn ufbfu~ sd

jfodsgksgdj~ kldjo dbngki ufquf~fjsksgrf~ db jksgdj~* Mdwfrfu) smf ~ng,

fjnf kjc sfnmjdido db k jksgdj kuf kj glqduskjs bknsdu smks nkj gjstvfjnf

bdufgoj qveign~ rgfw~ dj smf jksgdj* Bdu f}klqif) smf Qfw Oideki Kssgsvcf~

Qudhfns ~mdwfc gj 5115 smks qfdqif kudvjc smf wduic mkrf mgom kclguksgdj

bdu V*^* ~ngfjnf kjc sfnmjdido cf~qgsf smfgu ufhfnsgdj db Klfugnkjg~l)

~vnm k~ smf cgbbv~gdj db V*^* gcfk~ kjc nv~sdl~*;


5/21

;1?Knkcflgn ^ngfjnf Fjokoflfjs wgsm Jdusm @dufk

Mg~sdugnkii) ~ngfjnf fjokoflfjs mfiqfc ndvjsugf~ wgsm lgjglki dbngki

cgqidlksgn ufiksgdj~ evgic lvsvki suv~s* F}klqif~ gjnivcf V*^* ngrgigkj

~ngfjsgn f}nmkjof~ wgsm smf ^drgfs Vjgdj cvugjo smf Ndic _ku) V*^*,

Hkqkj ~ngfjnf kjc sfnmjdido nddqfuksgdj gj smf ;721~) kjc smf V*^*,Nmgjk

Koufflfjs dj Nddqfuksgdj gj ^ngfjnf kjc Sfnmjdido gj ;7?7*5 Mdwfrfu)

smf g~~vf~ nkj efndlf f~qfngkii ndlqif} gj smg~ nk~f* Kismdvom k ~ngfjsg~s

{vk ~ngfjsg~s g~ dbsfj keif sd od qiknf~ kj dbngki odrfujlfjs ufquf~fjsksgrf

lgoms jds ef qfulgssfc) gs g~ ki~d smf nk~f smks smg~ ~ngfjsg~s g~ bvii ~vehfns

sd smf ikw~ kjc ufoviksgdj~ db smf ~ngfjsg~s~ mdlf ndvjsu* Smf ndj~sukgjs~

kjc ndlqignksgdj~ nkj ~ffl {vgsf ckvjsgjo gj nk~f~ wmfuf smfuf f}g~s ndl,

qignksfc f}qdus ndjsudi g~~vf~ -V*^* kjc VJ ~kjnsgdj~ kokgj~s Jdusm @dufk)

bdu gj~skjnf' du sukrfi uf~sugnsgdj~ -Jdusm @dufk uf{vguf~ k rg~k bdu fjsu)

fs smfuf g~ jd g~~vgjo kvsmdugs gj smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~) kjc smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~

mk~ jd flek~~ gj Jdusm @dufk'*

^V,@VS ^ngfjnf Ndiikeduksgdj

Mg~sdugnki Ndjsf}s

Jdusm @dufk kjc smf Vjgsfc sksf~ mkrf mkc k idjo,~skjcgjo cgbnvis ufiksgdj,

~mgq) wgsm md~sgigs efswffj smf swd ndvjsugf~ ikuofi ~sfllgjo budl Ndic

_ku qdigsgn~* Ks smf fjc db _duic _ku GG gj ;736) smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~ kjc smf

^drgfs Vjgdj mfiqfc sd cgrgcf smf @dufkj qfjgj~vik) kjc smf fbbfnsgrfi

kclgjg~sfufc smf qfjgj~vik ~dvsm kjc jdusm) uf~qfnsgrfi) db smf >=sm qkukiifi*

Smf @dufkj _ku gj smf fkui ;761~) wmgnm fjcfc gj kj kulg~sgnf jds gj k

qfknf sufks) eudvoms jfw cjklgn~ gjsd smf V*^*,CQU@ ufiksgdj~mgq* Smf

swd ndvjsugf~ gjsfj~gfc cfldjgxksgdj db fknm dsmfu wmgif dbsfj gjstksgjo

smufks~ budl smf dsmfu ~gcf* Jdusm @dufk k~~fusfc smks smf Vjgsfc sksf~ wk~ kj

glqfugkig~s ~vnnf~~du sd Hkqkj kjc nugsgngxfc smf V*^* lgigsku quf~fjnf gj dvsm

@dufk* Smf Vjgsfc sksf~) dj gs~ qkus) lkgjskgjfc bdu jfkui 61 fku~ fndjdlgn

~kjnsgdj~ kokgj~s Jdusm @dufk vjcfu smf Sukcgjo wgsm smf Fjfl Kns*>

Smf iksf~s sfj~gdj~ efswffj smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~ kjc Jdusm @dufk ufrdirf

kudvjc Jdusm @dufk~ jvnifku qudoukl* Smf u~s jvnifku nug~g~ fuvqsfc gj

smf fkui ;771~ wmfj Qdjokjo ufbv~fc sd ~goj k bvii,~nkif ~kbfovkuc~

koufflfjs wgsm smf Gjsfujksgdjki Ksdlgn Fjfuo Kofjn* Klgc k mfgoms,

fjfc sfj~gdj efswffj smf swd ndvjsugf~ cvugjo smf Nigjsdj kclgjg~suksgdj)

bdulfu V*^* quf~gcfjs Hgll Nkusfu rg~gsfc Qdjokjo kjc mfiqfc ~sug`f k

cfki wgsm smf smfj Jdusm @dufkj ifkcfu @gl Gi,~vjo* Smf fj~vgjo koufflfjs

uf~visfc gj smf Kouffc Buklfwdu` gj ;773 gj wmgnm Jdusm @dufk kouffc sd

buffxf kjc visglksfi cg~lkjsif gs~ oukqmgsf,ldcfuksfc ufknsdu~ gj ufsvuj

bdu qudigbfuksgdj,uf~g~skjs igoms,wksfu ufknsdu~) mfkr bvfi dgi ~vqqigf~ e

smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~ kjc gs~ kiigf~) kjc ~sfq~ sdwkuc cgqidlksgn jdulkigxksgdj

wgsm _k~mgjosdj*3


6/21

;1= Dj @dufk8 Rdivlf >

Smf sfj~gdj efswffj _k~mgjosdj kjc Qdjokjo cgc jds fjc) mdwfrfu) wgsm

smf ndjniv~gdj db smf Kouffc Buklfwdu`* Smf V*^* odrfujlfjs nugsgngxfc

Jdusm @dufk bdu kiifofci f}qdusgjo lg~~gif sfnmjdido sd ndvjsugf~ ~vnm

k~ Qk`g~skj kjc Gukj* Gj ;77=) Jdusm @dufk ikvjnmfc k lg~~gif smks stfw

drfu Hkqkj) k ldrf smks cufw gjsfujksgdjki nugsgng~l* Klgc smf cfik~ db

smf qudlg~fc jvnifku qdwfu qikjs~) Jdusm @dufk ndjcvnsfc kj fjogjf sf~s

db gs~ lg~~gif gj 511;* Smf ufiksgdj~mgq efswffj _k~mgjosdj kjc Qdjokjo

sdd` kjdsmfu svuj bdu smf wdu~f wmfj Quf~gcfjs Ev~m ikefifc Jdusm @dufk

qkus db kj k}g~ db frgi kidjo wgsm Gukj kjc qufwku Guk{*

Kjdsmfu nuvngki frfjs wk~ K~~g~skjs fnufsku db sksf Hklf~ @fii~ rg~gs sd

Qdjokjo gj Dnsdefu 5115* Kedvs k wff` kbsfu mg~ ufsvuj) @fii qveigni

~sksfc smks Jdusm @dufk kclgssfc sd mkrgjo cfrfidqfc k vukjgvl fjugnmlfjs

qudoukl gj rgdiksgdj db smf ;773 Kouffc Buklfwdu`* @fii~ ufrfiksgdj

~sguufc oufks gjsfujksgdjki ndjnfuj~ kjc ~sufjosmfjfc smf frgi ~sfufdsqf db

Jdusm @dufk* Gs g~ glqduskjs sd jdsf) mdwfrfu) smks ndjsudrfu~gf~ uflkgj

sd smg~ ck drfu @fii~ ski`~ wgsm Jdusm @dufk) k~ Jdusm @dufk quf~fjsfc

cgbbfufjs knndvjs~ db smf ski`~*6 Knnducgjo sd Qdjokjo) smf Jdusm @dufkj

cfifoksgdj lfufi sdic @fii smks Jdusm @dufk g~ fjsgsifc sd mkrf ~vnm

k qudoukl sd qudsfns gs~fib budl V*^* koouf~~gdj* Gs g~ ki~d glqduskjs sd

kn`jdwifcof smks smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~ ufjfofc dj smf Kouffc Buklfwdu` e

bkgigjo sd lffs sglfigjf~ gj cfigrfugjo mfkr bvfi dgi kjc gj lk`gjo qudouf~~

dj smf swd igoms,wksfu ufknsdu~ e smf skuofs cksf db 511>*

Kbsfu @fii~ ufrfiksgdj) smf sfj~gdj efswffj _k~mgjosdj kjc Qdjokjo

f~nkiksfc* Gj kccgsgdj) smf swd ~gcf~ bkgifc sd dqfj ski`~) k~ Qdjokjo

wkjsfc egiksfuki ski`~ wgsm _k~mgjosdj evs smf Ev~m kclgjg~suksgdj ufbv~fc

sd mdic djf,dj,djf ski`~0 gs qufbfuufc gj~sfkc k lvisgiksfuki bdulks* Kismdvom

smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~ kjc Jdusm @dufk jkii kouffc dj smf ~g},qkus ski`~ gj,

nivcgjo dvsm @dufk) Nmgjk) Hkqkj) kjc Uv~~gk) jfodsgksgdj~ dbsfj efnklf

qkukixfc k~ _k~mgjosdj kjc Qdjokjo cg~qvsfc wmd ~mdvic sk`f smf u~s

~sfq sd uf~dirf smf g~~vf* _k~mgjosdj k~`fc bdu smf ndlqifsf) rfugkeif)

kjc guufrfu~geif cg~lkjsiflfjs db Jdusm @dufk~ jvnifku qudoukl efbduf gs

wdvic qudrgcf kj ndlqfj~ksgdj sd Jdusm @dufk* Qdjokjo ~kgc gs wdvic

cg~lkjsif gs~ jvnifku qudoukl dji wmfj _k~mgjosdj kouffc dj jdulkigxk,

sgdj db ufiksgdj~) k ~fnvugs ovkukjsff) kjc fndjdlgn kgc*

Kidjo smf evlq udkc db smf ~g},qkus ski`~ bdu rf fku~) smf ndvjsugf~ mkrf

f`fc dvs ~dlf lfkjgjobvi koufflfjs~*2 Glqiflfjsksgdj db smf~f koufflfjs~

mk~ effj mklqfufc e cg~koufflfjs~ dj cfskgi~) mdwfrfu) qufngqgsksgjo

jfw sfj~gdj gj smf ufogdj* Gj bkns) Jdusm @dufk ndjcvnsfc kj vjcfuoudvjc

jvnifku sf~s gj Dnsdefu 5112*


7/21

;17Knkcflgn ^ngfjnf Fjokoflfjs wgsm Jdusm @dufk

Cf~qgsf smf~f sfj~gdj~) smfuf mkrf effj kufk~ db fjokoflfjs efswffj smf

Vjgsfc sksf~ kjc Jdusm @dufk* Smf~f gjnivcf ~mdus,sful ~svc sdvu~ gj edsm

cgufnsgdj~) V*^*,ek~fc JOD~ qudrgcgjo mvlkjgskugkj k~~g~skjnf) kjc smf

511= mgom,qudif qfubdulkjnf db smf Jfw Wdu` Qmgimkuldjgn gj Qdjokjo*

Gs g~ glqduskjs sd jdsf mfuf smks smf CQU@ lg~~gdj ks smf Vjgsfc Jksgdj~

mk~ dbsfj wdu`fc k~ smf dji cgufns ndllvjgnksgdj nmkjjfi efswffj smf

Vjgsfc ^sksf~ kjc Jdusm @dufk) kjc gs mk~ ~furfc k~ kj glqduskjs ndjskns

qdgjs bdu smf~f fjokoflfjs~* Gs g~ smudvom smf CQU@ lg~~gdj smks V bduofc

gs~ ufiksgdj~mgq wgsm @VS*

Mg~sduw db smf @VS,^V Ufiksgdj~mgq

Smf @VS,^V ufiksgdj~mgq efokj gj iksf ~qugjo 511; wmfj ^V wgsm qku,

sgngqksgdj kjc ndvj~fi budl smf @dufk ^dngfs efokj cg~nv~~gjo wgsm smf

CQU@ VJ lg~~gdj ufquf~fjsksgrf~ smf qd~~gegigs db hdgjs knkcflgn ~ngfjnf

fjokoflfjs gj smf kufk db gjbdulksgdj sfnmjdido* Smf~f gjgsgki ski`~ visg,

lksfi ifc sd smf f~skeig~mlfjs db egiksfuki uf~fkunm ndiikeduksgdj~ efswffj

@VS kjc ^V gj smf ofjfuki kufk db gjbdulksgdj sfnmjdido* @VS bdnv~f~

dj sfnmjdido kismdvom gs dbbfu~ ndvu~fwdu` gj k wgcf ukjof db kufk~ gj gs~

udif) kidjo wgsm @gl Gi,~vjo Vjgrfu~gs) k~ k ndlqufmfj~grf vjgrfu~gs gj

Jdusm @dufk* ^V g~ k qugrksf uf~fkunm vjgrfu~gs gj vq~sksf Jfw Wdu`*

Fknm vjgrfu~gs kouffc sd ~vqqi k sfkl db uf~fkunmfu~* Smf gjsfucg~ngqigjku

^V sfkl gjrdirfc ~nmdiku~ budl smf Lk}wfii nmddi) smf I* N* lgsm Ndi,

ifof db Fjogjffugjo kjc Ndlqvsfu ngfjnf) kjc smf nmddi db Gjbdulksgdj

^svcgf~ k~ wfii k~ smf ^~sfl~ K~~vukjnf Gj~sgsvsf) smf Fjoig~m Ikjovkof

Gj~sgsvsf) kjc smf Vjgrfu~gs Igeuku* Smf cgufnsdu db @VS~ Gjbdulksgdj

-Ndlqvsfu' Nfjsfu wk~ smf @VS sfkl ifkcfu*

Smf @VS,^V ufiksgdj~mgq mk~ odjf smudvom bdvu qmk~f~* Smf u~s qmk~f

fjcfc wgsm ndlqifsgdj db Jdusm @dufk~ u~s cgogski igeuku) idnksfc ks @VS*

Smf quglku uf~fkunm bdnv~ cvugjo smg~ qfugdc wk~ ldcgbgjo dqfj,~dvunf

~dbswkuf bdu v~f k~ ekn`,fjc ~vqqdus gj smf igeuku kjc gcfjsgbgjo kqqud,

qugksf gjsfujksgdjki ~skjckuc~ bdu v~f gj nksfodugxgjo gjbdulksgdj mfic gj

smf igeuku* Smf ~fndjc qmk~f) smf Ufogdjki ^nmdiku~ kjc Ifkcfu~ ^flgjku

-U^I^' qudoukl) fjikuofc qkusgngqksgdj sd gjnivcf Nmgjk kjc ^dvsm @d,

ufk gj kccgsgdj sd Jdusm @dufk kjc smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~* Smf U^I^ ~f~~gdj~

wfuf mfic gj Efghgjo kjc flqmk~gxfc gjbdulksgdj ~mkugjo kjc cfrfidqgjo

ikjovkof kjc quf~fjsksgdj ~`gii~ jfnf~~ku bdu qkusgngqksgjo gj gjsfujksgdjki

~ngfjsgn lffsgjo~* Smf smguc qmk~f gjrdirfc Jdusm @dufkj vjcfuoukcvksf

sfkl~ db ndlqvsfu ~ngfjsg~s~ qkusgngqksgjo gj smf K~~dngksgdj bdu Ndlqvsgjo

Lknmgjfu -KNL' kjjvki Gjsfujksgdjki Ndiifogksf Qudoukllgjo Ndjsf~s*

Smg~ wk~ smf u~s sglf Jdusm @dufkj sfkl~ mkc frfu qkusgngqksfc gj smg~

gjsfujksgdjki ~ngfjnf ndlqfsgsgdj* Smf bdvusm qmk~f ~kw smf f~skeig~mlfjs db


8/21

;;1 Dj @dufk8 Rdivlf >

smf V*^*,CQU@ ngfjsgn Fjokoflfjs Ndj~dusgvl kglfc ks f}qidugjo ndi,

ikeduksgrf knkcflgn ~ngfjsgn knsgrgsgf~ efswffj smf swd ndvjsugf~* Smf~f bdvu

~qfngnqmk~f~ wgii ef fikeduksfc iksfu gj smg~ qkqfu* Smf jf}s ~fnsgdj f}qikgj~

f}nmkjof~ db qfu~djjfi smks kuf ks smf nduf db smf @VS,^V ufiksgdj~mgq*

F}nmkjof~ db Qfu~djjfi

^gjnf k CQU@ cfifoksgdj~ u~s rg~gs sd ^V gj 5115) smfuf mkrf effj jgjf

f}nmkjof~~frfj rg~gs~ sd ^V e @VS ~ngfjsg~s~ kjc swd rg~gs~ sd @VS

e ^V qkusgngqkjs~kjc bdvu hdgjs lffsgjo~ kjc qudoukl~ gj Efghgjo -~ff

Skeif ; bdu k ~vllku db smf f}nmkjof~'* Smf~f f}nmkjof~ ukjofc budl

djf sd rf wff`~* Sd fj~vuf smks uf~vis~ budl smf f}nmkjof~ nvlviksf) @VS

kjc ^V mkrf) k~ k lkssfu db qdign) lkgjskgjfc ~ve~skjsgki ndj~g~sfjn gj

smf ndlqd~gsgdj db smfgu cfifoksgdj~ drfu sglf*

Kj gjgsgki cfifoksgdj ifc e Rgnf Nmkjnfiidu Hdjo @wkj,nmdj db @VS rg~gsfc

^V gj Lkunm 5115* Smf ~vnnf~~ db smg~ rg~gs ifc sd kj gjrgsksgdj sd ^V sd ~fjc

k ~ngfjnf cfifoksgdj sd @VS gj Hvjf 5115* Cvugjo smf V cfifoksgdj~ rg~gs

sd @VS) smf swd ~gcf~ kouffc dj fjmkjngjo uf~dvunf ndllgslfjs~ sd smf

ndiikeduksgdj kjc kccgjo k wugssfj qikj bdu gs~ bdnv~fc cfrfidqlfjs vjcfu

smf ifkcfu~mgq db k @VS,^V Hdgjs Ndducgjksgjo Oudvq -HNO'* Gj Cfnfl,

efu 5115) @VS ~fjs gs~ cfifoksgdj kokgj sd ^V bdu k lffsgjo db smf HNO)

wmgnm gficfc kj koufflfjs smks smf Jdusm @dufkj vjgrfu~gs wdvic ~fjc

k sfkl db uf~fkunm ~nmdiku~ sd V bdu smf ldjsm db Kqugi 511> sd wdu` wgsm

^V uf~fkunmfu~ dj hdgjs gjbdulksgdj sfnmjdido qudhfns~) gjnivcgjo cgogski

igeukugf~) lknmgjf sukj~iksgdj) kjc cfng~gdj ~vqqdus* Smf~f sdqgn~ wfuf kj

dvsoudwsm db smf Qdjokjo lffsgjo~ wmfuf @VS uf~fkunmfu~ cfldj~suksfc

smfgu GS kjc ~dbswkuf cfrfidqlfjs uf~fkunm qudoukl~*

K~ k uf~vis db smf HNO koufflfjs) k sfkl db rf @VS uf~fkunmfu~ sdofsmfu

wgsm djf qudsdndi dbnfu wmd ki~d bvjnsgdjfc k~ k sukj~iksdu kuugrfc gj

^uknv~f gj Kqugi 511> bdu djf ldjsm db gjsfj~grf uf~fkunm ndiikeduksgdj

wgsm ^V ~nmdiku~* Smgus bknvis) oukcvksf ~svcfjs~) kjc qudbf~~gdjki ~skbb

budl ^V qkusgngqksfc gj smf qudoukl knsgrgsgf~* Smf cgufnsdu db smf @VS

Gjbdulksgdj Nfjsfu) wmd mk~ qkusgngqksfc gj frfu hdgjs @VS,^V lffsgjo

sd cksf) ifc smf @VS cfifoksgdj* Kii uf~fkunm lffsgjo~ wfuf ndjcvnsfc gj

Fjoig~m kjc bdnv~fc dj g~~vf~ db cgogski igeukugf~) cfng~gdj ~vqqdus) kjc bdu,

lki lfsmdc~ bdu qudrgjo nduufnsjf~~* Dvsndlf~ db smf~f ~f~~gdj~ gjnivcfc

knkcflgn ~ngfjnf quf~fjsksgdj~) gj Fjoig~m) db uf~fkunm uf~vis~ e @VS kjc

^V qkusgngqkjs~ kjc kj knkcflgn qkqfu) wugssfj hdgjsi e ufquf~fjsksgrf~

db @VS) ^V) smf CQU@ lg~~gdj) kjc smf @dufk ^dngfs* Smf qkqfu wk~

quf~fjsfc ks smf K~gkj ^svcgf~ dj smf Qkngn Ndk~s lffsgjo~ ks smf Fk~s,

_f~s Nfjsfu gj Hvjf 511>*?


9/21

;;;Knkcflgn ^ngfjnf Fjokoflfjs wgsm Jdusm @dufk

Gj Lkunm 5113) Rgnf Nmkjnfiidu Hdjo kokgj ifc k sfkl db rf @VS uf~fkunm,

fu~ kjc djf qudsdndi dbnfu sd ^V* Kii smf @VS uf~fkunmfu~ mkc effj sd

^V qufrgdv~i) kjc smf nfjsuki uf~fkunm bdnv~ wk~ dj cfrfidqgjo smf @VS

cgogski igeuku* Knnducgjo sd smf ^V ~ngfjsg~s~ gjrdirfc gj smf ndiikeduk,

sgdj~) smf Jdusm @dufkj uf~fkunmfu~ wfuf mgomi ldsgrksfc kjc cfcgnksfc)

kjc smf ~fflfc sd wdu` jdj~sdq* Smf @VS qkusgngqkjs~ glquf~~fc smfgu

^V ndvjsfuqkus~ wmfj smf okrf f}nfiifjs QdwfuQdgjs quf~fjsksgdj~ gj

Fjoig~m ks smf fjc db smf qudoukl*=

Gj Jdrflefu 5116) V Nmkjnfiidu Jkjn Nkjsdu) @dufk dngfs Nmkgulkj

Cdjkic Oufoo) kjc @VS Nmkjnfiidu Mdjo d Mdj ~gojfc k Lfldukjcvl db

Vjcfu~skjcgjo sd f}qkjc f}g~sgjo ~ngfjsgn uf~fkunm ndiikeduksgdj* vehfns

sd f}qdus ndjsudi kjc ignfj~gjo ndj~gcfuksgdj~) smf LDV f}quf~~fc gjsfjs

Skeif ;8 ^uknv~f Vjgrfu~gs @gl Nmkf` Vjgrfu~gs db Sfnmjdido

Fjokoflfjs~) 511;1?


10/21


sd ;' f}qkjc swgj gjsfouksfc gjbdulksgdj sfnmjdido ike~ -Swgj Ike~' ks

@VS kjc ^V sd fjmkjnf kjc knnfifuksf bvusmfu hdgjs uf~fkunm0 5' ndjsgjvf

smf Sfnmjgnki Fjoig~m Ikjovkof Sukgjgjo qudoukl~ efovj gj Efghgjo gj Kv,

ov~s 5116 k~ smf u~s ~sfq gj cfrfidqlfjs db Ufogdjki nmdiku~ kjc Ifkcfu~

^flgjku qudoukl -U^I^'0 kjc >' f}nmkjof hvjgdu bknvis lflefu~ budl

fknm dsmfu~ gj~sgsvsgdj*

_du` dj smf f~skeig~mlfjs db k Swgj Ike~ ks @VS g~ gj qudouf~~ evs mk~

bknfc k lkhdu de~sknif8 f}qdus ndjsudi ufoviksgdj~* Mdwfrfu) k ~mgqlfjs

db vjndjsudiifc gsfl~ike cf~`~) nmkgu~) skeif~) kjc if nkegjfs~wk~

cfigrfufc sd @VS gj ~qugjo 511?* Gj knnduckjnf wgsm smf 5116 koufflfjs)

k smuff,wff` U^I^ Sfnmjgnki Fjoig~m Ikjovkof Sukgjgjo qudoukl wk~ mfic

gj Efghgjo gj 5112 kjc 511?* Gj ufokuc sd smf ~ngfjsg~s f}nmkjof qudoukl) V

kjc smf @dufk ^dngfs) wgsm smf ndiikeduksgdj db @dufk Bvieugoms Bdvjck,

sgdj) ufnfgrfc k oukjs budl smf Vjgsfc Edkuc bdu Nmug~sgkj Mgomfu Fcvnksgdj

gj K~gk sd ~vqqdus k rf,fku qudoukl cf~gojfc sd eugjo rf sd ~g} Jdusm

@dufkj hvjgdu bknvis lflefu~ kjjvkii sd ^V* Sd cksf jd ~nmdiku~ mkrf

ndlf sd smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~ vjcfu smg~ qudoukl*

@VS quf~fjsksgdj sd ^V sfkl gj Qdjokjo -Hvjf 5113'

Qmk~f ;8 @VS Cgogski Igeukuw

K cgogski igeuku ufqiknf~ smf sukcgsgdjki qm~gnki nkuc nkskidovf wgsm k

ndlqvsfu,cugrfj kjc ufldsfi knnf~~geif cgufnsdu db igeuku mdicgjo~* Kssmf sglf smf @VS,^V ndiikeduksgdj efokj) smfuf wk~) sd dvu jdwifcof) jd

cgogski igeuku gj Jdusm @dufk* @VS wk~) mdwfrfu) gj fkui ~skof~ db cf~goj,

gjo k cgogski igeuku) kjc k ndj~suvnsgdj ~gsf mkc effj gcfjsgfc* @VS,^V

uf~fkunm sfkl~ bdnv~fc dj kckqsgjo dqfj,~dvunf ~dbswkuf sd cfrfidq smf


11/21

;;>Knkcflgn ^ngfjnf Fjokoflfjs wgsm Jdusm @dufk

ekn`,fjc igeuku gjbdulksgdj lkjkoflfjs* Smf~f fbbdus~ wfuf gjsfjcfc sd

ufqiknf qudqugfsku ~dbswkuf wugssfj ks @VS*

Kj glqduskjs ndj~f{vfjnf db smf ndiikeduksgrf fbbdus~ wk~ @VS~ cfng~gdj

smks edsm ~dbswkuf kjc igeuku lfskcksk7 wdvic ndjbdul sd gjsfujksgdjki

~skjckuc~* Sd ~vqqdus smf djodgjo cfrfidqlfjs db smf @VS igeuku kjc

sd bkngigsksf smf ~mkugjo db cgogski igeuku lfskcksk kjc ndjsfjs) gs g~ mdqfc

smks) ~vehfns sd smf ufoviksgdj~ db Jdusm @dufk kjc smf Vjgsfc sksf~) gs wgii

visglksfi ef qd~~geif sd ndj~suvns swgj gjbdulksgdj uf~fkunm ike~* Smf~f

ike~) djf ks ^V kjc djf ks @VS) wdvic ef v~fc sd ~vqqdus ndiikeduksgrf

wdu` ks k cg~skjnf kjc wdvic ki~d qudrgcf k ndlldj wdu`gjo fjrgudjlfjs

bdu rg~gsgjo uf~fkunmfu~*

Gj 5116) V ~velgssfc k ignfj~gjo uf{vf~s sd smf V*^* Ndllfunf Cfqkuslfjs

bdu qfulg~~gdj sd f}qdus k ~lkii {vkjsgs db idw,ifrfi ndlqvsgjo f{vgqlfjs

sd ~vqqdus smf @VS cgogski igeuku* Kismdvom smg~ uf{vf~s wk~ cfjgfc) smf

visglksf cfjgki wk~ lkcf dj bdufgoj qdign oudvjc~ uksmfu smkj jksgdjki

~fnvugs djf~* K~ gs svujfc dvs) smf uf{vf~s wk~ knsvkii ndj~gcfufc ks k idw

qdgjs gj smf ~g},qkus ski`~*

@VS~ cgogski igeuku dqfjfc gj Hkjvku 5112* Smf igeuku g~ k ndjnufsf f},

klqif db GS,cugrfj knkcflgn gjbuk~suvnsvuf wgsmgj Jdusm @dufk* Ldufdrfu)

k~ Jdusm @dufk gjnufk~gjoi gjsfukns~ wgsm smf ikuofu wduic) gs wgii ef nugsgnki

smks gs mkrf suv~sfc kjc ~vnnf~~bvi f}qfugfjnf wdu`gjo wgsm V*^* kofjngf~

kjc duokjgxksgdj~* Cvugjo smf 511= rg~gs db smf Jfw Wdu` Qmgimkuldjgn sd

Qdjokjo) bdu f}klqif) ~dlf hdvujkig~s~ wfuf ~mdwj smf cgogski igeuku kjc

frfj wfuf keif sd knnf~~ smfgu nvuufjs Bknfedd` qkof~ budl smf igeuku*;1

K nik~~uddl ks @VS~ cgogski igeuku -Qmdsd ndvusf~ db Jgndif Bgjjflkjj) @FG'


12/21


Qmk~f 58 Ufogdjki ^nmdiku~ kjc Ifkcfu~ ^flgjku Qudoukl

Smf UÎ^ qudoukl g~ cf~gojfc sd cfrfidq bvsvuf ifkcfu~ wmd ~mkuf k ndl,

lgslfjs sd gjbdulksgdj ~mkugjo) ndiikeduksgdj knud~~ edvjckugf~) kjc) ld~s

db kii) f~skeig~mlfjs kjc lkgjsfjkjnf db ~skjckuc~,ek~fc ldcf~ db suv~sfc

ndllvjgnksgdj* Dvu qk~s ~vnnf~~ gj wdu`gjo wgsm @VS dj smf cfrfidqlfjs

db gs~ cgogski igeuku) sdofsmfu wgsm k~~dngksfc cg~nv~~gdj~ wgsm knkcflgn kjc

odrfujlfjs dbngki~ gj Jdusm @dufk) Nmgjk) ^dvsm @dufk) kjc smf Vjgsfc

^sksf~) cfldj~suksf~ smks ifoki kjc kqqudqugksf ~mkugjo db ~ngfjsgn gjbdulk,

sgdj bdu qfknfbvi qvuqd~f~ g~ db ndlldj gjsfuf~s*

Budl >; Hvi sd 51 Kvov~s 5116) ^V) Qdmkjo Vjgrfu~gs db ^ngfjnf kjc

Sfnmjdido -QD^SFNM') kjc smf @dufk dngfs md~sfc smf u~s UÎ^ Efg,

hgjo Sfnmjgnki Fjoig~m Qudoukl bdu Jdusm @dufkj uf~fkunmfu~ budl @VS)

lflefu~ db smf Jdusm @dufkj Lgjg~su db Bdufgoj Kbbkgu~ Biddc Cklkof

kjc Ufmkegigsksgdj Ndllgssff -BCUN') kjc ufquf~fjsksgrf~ budl QD^SFNM

kjc Mvkxmdjo Vjgrfu~gs db ^ngfjnf kjc Sfnmjdido -gj _vmkj) Nmgjk'*

Smf ~fndjc qudoukl wk~ ~vnnf~~bvii f}fnvsfc cvugjo smf ~klf qfugdc gj

5112) wgsm ~frfuki lkhdu nmkjof~ kjc glqudrflfjs~*

Smf 5112 ~f~~gdj f~skeig~mfc kj GS,dugfjsfc Fjoig~m sukgjgjo nvuugnvivl

kjc ufnfgrfc lflefu~ db smf @dufk,Klfugnk Qugrksf F}nmkjof~ ^dngfs

-@KQF^'*;; Evgicgjo vqdj smf 5116 qudoukl) smf 5112 nvuugnvivl wk~ bku

lduf sfnmjgnki evs ndjsgjvfc sd flqmk~gxf Fjoig~m k~ v~fc gj smf oideki

ndlqvsfu gjcv~su kjc ks ~ngfjsgn ndjbfufjnf~*

Jdusm @dufk ~fjs 51 qkusgngqkjs~ sd fknm fku~ UÎ^ Sfnmjgnki Fjoig~m

qudoukl~* Gj fknm ~f~~gdj) ;2 wfuf gcfjsgfc k~ ~nmdiku~ budl @VS) kjc

3 wfuf budl smf Bdufgoj Lgjg~su~ BCUN du @KQF^* Jdusm @dufk~ mfkc

db cfifoksgdj wk~ smf cgufnsdu db @VS~ Gjbdulksgdj Nfjsfu kjc k idjosglf

ndiikeduksdu gj f}nmkjof~ wgsm ^V* ^gojgnkjsi) bdvu qkusgngqkjs~ gj fknm

~f~~gdj wfuf bflkif~* Sd smf ef~s db dvu jdwifcof) gs mk~ effj f}suflfi vj,

v~vki bdu Jdusm @dufk sd ~fjc bflkif ~ngfjsg~s~ sd sukrfi dvs~gcf smf ndvjsu*

Kii Jdusm @dufkj qkusgngqkjs~ wfuf mdv~fc ks k Efghgjo mdsfi wmfuf) kldjo

dsmfu smgjo~) smf mkc knnf~~ sd Fjoig~m,ikjovkof sfifrg~gdj) vjiglgsfc Gj,

sfujfs knnf~~) kjc k rkugfs db jfw~qkqfu~ budl kudvjc smf wduic*

Smf dnnk~gdj db smg~ UÎ^ Efghgjo Sfnmjgnki Fjoig~m sukgjgjo qudrgcfc

kj f}suflfi rkivkeif dqqdusvjgs bdu gjbdulki gjsfuknsgdj~ kldjo Jdusm

@dufkj qkusgngqkjs~ kjc ufquf~fjsksgrf~ db qkusjfu gj~sgsvsgdj~* Kj djodgjo

odki bdu UÎ^ g~ sd ifrfukof smf~f gjsfuqfu~djki ndjjfnsgdj~ smudvom cfrfi,

dqlfjs db ndjnufsf qudhfns~ kjc visglksfi suv~sfc gj~sgsvsgdj~ bdu ~v~skgjfc

nddqfuksgdj dj ~skjckuc~,ek~fc GS qudhfns~* Gs g~ mdqfc smks wmks efogj~

wgsm gjsfuqfu~djki suv~s kldjo qkusgngqkjs~ budl smf UÎ^ ndvjsugf~ wgii


13/21

;;6Knkcflgn ^ngfjnf Fjokoflfjs wgsm Jdusm @dufk

efndlf ~fib,qfuqfsvksgjo smudvom smf cfrfidqlfjs u~s db ndjnufsf qudhfns~

kjc smfj) visglksfi) suv~sfc gj~sgsvsgdj~*

Qmk~f >8 KNL Gjsfujksgdjki Ndlqvsfu Qudoukllgjo Ndjsf~s

Djf db smf 5116 UÎ^ Efghgjo ~f~~gdj qkusgngqkjs~ wk~ jklfc cgufnsdu

ofjfuki -Gjbdulksgdj Sfnmjdido Cfqkuslfjs' gj smf Lgjg~su db Fcvnksgdj

kbsfu mfu ufsvuj sd Qdjokjo* ^ddj smfufkbsfu ~mf uf{vf~sfc kcrgnf budl

^V kjc smf @dufk ^dngfs kedvs mdw smf CQU@ lgoms qkusgngqksf gj smf

Gjsfujksgdjki Ndiifogksf Qudoukllgjo Ndjsf~s -GNQN' uvj e smf K~~dngksgdj

bdu Ndlqvsgjo Lknmgjfu -KNL'*;5 Smg~) db ndvu~f) g~ qufng~fi smf ~dus

db dvsndlf UÎ^ wk~ gjsfjcfc sd qudcvnf k~ gs gjrdirf~ ~skjckuc~,ek~fc

fjokoflfjs wgsm smf wduic dvs~gcf db Jdusm @dufk* Gs ki~d giiv~suksf~ Jdusm

@dufkj ndlbdus gj ndiikeduksgjo wgsm ^V kjc smf @dufk ^dngfs*

Budl k oideki,fjokoflfjs kjc ~ngfjsgn,nddqfuksgdj qfu~qfnsgrf) Jdusm

@dufk~ qkusgngqksgdj gj smf GNQN quf~fjsfc k ~gojgnkjs dqqdusvjgs* Ks smks

qdgjs) V kjc smf @dufk dngfs kqqudknmfc smf Vjgsfc Edkuc bdu Nmug~sgkj

Mgomfu Fcvnksgdj gj K~gk sd ~ff gb gs wdvic ef keif kjc wgiigjo sd ~vqqif,

lfjs f}g~sgjo UÎ^ bvjc~ sd ~vqqdus sukrfi nd~s~ bdu k cfifoksgdj budl smf

Lgjg~su db Fcvnksgdj sd lffs wgsm ^V kjc smf @dufk ^dngfs gj Efghgjo*

Smf Vjgsfc Edkuc uf~qdjcfc edsm qd~gsgrfi kjc {vgnì*

K~ k ndj~f{vfjnf) k qikjjgjo lffsgjo wk~ ~fs bdu Efghgjo cvugjo smf wff`

db ;= Hvjf 5112* Smf Jdusm @dufkj cfifoksgdj wk~ mfkcfc e k Lgjg~su

db Fcvnksgdj cgufnsdu ofjfuki kjc gjnivcfc kccgsgdjki ufquf~fjsksgrf~ budl

smf lgjg~su k~ wfii k~ k lflefu db @KQF^*

UÎ^ ~f~~gdj gj Efghgjo -Kvov~s 5112'


14/21


Smf lffsgjo~ qudrfc sd ef f}suflfi qudcvnsgrf) kjc wf wfuf keif sd cg~,

nv~~ quknsgnki g~~vf~ ~vnm k~ smf jffc bdu Gjsfujfs knnf~~ sd qkusgngqksf gj smf

ndjsf~s kjc mdw sd nfusgb ~svcfjs ~sksv~ db sfkl lflefu~* Gj kccgsgdj) wf

cg~nv~~fc smf qd~~gegigs db ~fjcgjo Jdusm @dufkj sfkl~ sd Nmgjk sd qufqkuf

bdu kjc qkusgngqksf gj smf gjgsgki udvjc db smf ndjsf~s* Smf Jdusm @dufkj

cfifoksgdj smfj ~qfjs lvnm db smf uflkgjcfu db smf wff` cg~nv~~gjo wgsm

Nmgjf~f ndvjsfuqkus vjgrfu~gsgf~ smf qd~~gegigs db sukgjgjo wgsm smfl*

KNL ndjsf~s dbngki~ kouffc sd gjrgsf CQU@ qkusgngqksgdj* Smuff vjcfu,

oukcvksf sfkl~) djf ufquf~fjsgjo @VS) ~qfjs kqqud}glksfi smuff wff`~

gj Efghgjo qufqkugjo bdu smf 5112 ndjsf~s* Jdusm @dufkj sfkl~ ndlqfsfc

fbbfnsgrfi kjc wdj eudjxf) ~girfu) kjc odic lfcki~) bkiigjo hv~s ~mdus db

qudouf~~gjo sd smf jf}s udvjc db ndlqfsgsgdj* Jdusm @dufkj ndknmf~ bfis smks

smfgu sfkl~ lgoms mkrf cdjf frfj efssfu mkc smf mkc lduf qufqkuksgdj gj

sfnmjgnki Fjoig~m kjc ~suksfogf~ bdu Gjsfujfs,ek~fc ndlqfsgsgdj*

Smfufbduf) bdu smf 511? ndlqfsgsgdj ^V kjc smf @dufk ^dngfs mfic k

qufndlqfsgsgdj wdu`~mdq bdu smf sfkl~ bdnv~gjo dj sfnmjgnki Fjoig~m;>

kjc idog~sgn~ db smf uksmfu ouvfigjo Efghgjo ufogdjki ndlqfsgsgdj* Jdusm

@dufk kokgj ~fjs smuff sfkl~Cku` Mdu~f budl @VS) Ufc ^sku budl smf

Jksvuki ngfjnf Vjgrfu~gs) kjc Hdj Lkjo Edjo budl smf Ndllvjgnksgdj

Vjgrfu~gssd smf wdu`~mdq* Smg~ sglf smf @VS sfkl cgc frfj efssfu

smkj smf qufrgdv~ fku kjc wdj kj gjrgsksgdj sd smf wduic jki~ gj Ekjbb)

Nkjkck* Bdu vjkjjdvjnfc ufk~dj~) Qdjokjo cgc jds ~fjc smf @VS sfkl

sd smf jki ndlqfsgsgdj*

Smf~f uf~vis~ qudrgcf flqgugnki frgcfjnf ~voof~sgjo smks smf ef~s @VS

~svcfjs~ kuf keif sd mdic smfgu dwj wgsm sdq vjcfuoukcvksf~ budl kudvjc

smf wduic* Ldufdrfu) gs cfldj~suksf~ smks Jdusm @dufk g~ edsm wgiigjo kjc

keif sd fjokof gjsfujksgdjki ~skjckuc~) kjc gs smv~ qudrgcf~ kjdsmfu ndjnufsf

f}klqif db smf qdwfu db ~skjckuc~,ek~fc knkcflgn ~ngfjsgn nddqfuksgdj*

Qmk~f 38 V*^*,CQU@ ngfjsgn Fjokoflfjs Ndj~dusgvl

Gj Lk 511? smf V*^*,CQU@ ^ngfjsgn Fjokoflfjs Ndj~dusgvl wk~ f~,

skeig~mfc sd f}qiduf ndiikeduksgrf knkcflgn ~ngfjnf knsgrgsgf~ efswffj smf

Vjgsfc ^sksf~ kjc Jdusm @dufk* Smf ndj~dusgvl g~ nvuufjsi lkcf vq db

bdvu duokjgxksgdj~8 smf V*^* Ngrgigkj Uf~fkunm " Cfrfidqlfjs Bdvjcksgdj

-NUCB') smf Klfugnkj K~~dngksgdj bdu smf Kcrkjnflfjs db ngfjnf -KKK^')

^V) kjc smf @dufk dngfs* Ndiifnsgrfi) smf ndj~dusgvl lflefu~ mkrf cf,

nkcf~ db f}sfj~grf f}qfugfjnf gj ~vnnf~~bvii f~skeig~mgjo kjc kcrkjngjo

gjsfujksgdjki ~ngfjsgn ndiikeduksgdj~) gjnivcgjo wgsm Jdusm @dufk*

Dj 55 Lk 511? kqqud}glksfi 61 qkusgngqkjs~ sdd` qkus gj k wdu`~mdq

duokjgxfc e smf ndj~dusgvl kjc mfic ks smf NUCB mfkc{vkusfu~ gj Kuigjosdj)


15/21

;;?Knkcflgn ^ngfjnf Fjokoflfjs wgsm Jdusm @dufk

Rguogjgk* Smf cg~nv~~fc ~mkufc f}qfugfjnf~) if~~dj~ ifkujfc) kjc ~vnnf~~f~

kjc nmkiifjof~ ufokucgjo ~ngfjsgn ndiikeduksgdj wgsm Jdusm @dufk* Qkusgng,

qkjs~ gjnivcfc ufquf~fjsksgrf~ budl jgjf vjgrfu~gsgf~ k~ wfii k~ mgom,ifrfi

dbngki~ budl smf V*^* odrfujlfjs) Ndjouf~~) kjc JOD~* Bvjcfc e smf

Ugnmkuc Idvj~efu Bdvjcksgdj) smf wdu`~mdq cfldj~suksfc k ~sudjo gjsfuf~s

e k jvlefu db V*^* vjgrfu~gsgf~ sd wdu` sdwkuc ndiikeduksgdj wgsm Jdusm

@dufkj knkcflgn~ gj k rkugfs db f kufk~ db ~ngfjsgn f}nmkjof) gjnivcgjo

kougnvisvuf) gjbdulksgdj sfnmjdido) kjc mfkism*

Smf ndj~dusgvl mk~ ~gjnf md~sfc ~frfuki lffsgjo~ wgsm smf V*^* ^sksf Cf,

qkuslfjs) `f ~skbb budl smf Mdv~f Ndllgssff dj Bdufgoj Kbbkgu~ kjc smf

^fjksf Ndllgssff dj Bdufgoj Ufiksgdj~) `f V*^* ~sk`fmdicfu~) kjc smf

CQU@ VJ lg~~gdj* Smf qvuqd~f db smf~f lffsgjo~ wk~ jds dji sd quf~fjs

smf jcgjo~ budl smf V*^*,CQU@ ngfjsgn F}nmkjof Qudoukl F}qkj~gdj

_du`~mdq evs ki~d sd ~mdw `f cfng~gdj lk`fu~ kjc gjsfuf~sfc qkusgf~ gj

smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~ kjc gj Jdusm @dufk smks k ndducgjksfc kqqudknm g~ efgjo

sk`fj gj ducfu sd ifrfukof smf cgrfu~f uf~dvunf~ kjc nkqkegigsgf~ db ~frfuki

vjg{vf kjc ndlqiflfjsku gj~sgsvsgdj~*

Smf ndj~dusgvl ndjcvnsfc ~frfuki ndjnvuufjs knsgrgsgf~ gj 511= sd kcrkjnf

lvsvki cg~nv~~gdj kjc gjbdulksgdj ~mkugjo dj ~ngfjsgn fjokoflfjs efswffj

smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~ kjc Jdusm @dufk) gjnivcgjo k ~f~~gdj wgsm ~sk`fmdicfu~

ks smf 511= kjjvki KKK^ lffsgjo gj Ed~sdj* Smf ndj~dusgvl ki~d md~sfc k

qveign qkjfi ks KKK^~ 5117 kjjvki lffsgjo gj Nmgnkod) bfksvugjo KKK^

quf~gcfjs kjc Jdefi ikvufksf Qfsfu Kouf kjc dsmfu ndj~dusgvl ifkcfu~* Smf

ndj~dusgvl ~vqqdusfc smf kssfjckjnf db Jdusm @dufkj ufquf~fjsksgrf~ ks

edsm smf 511= kjc 5117 KKK^ kjjvki lffsgjo~*

Gj 5117 smf ndj~dusgvl qikj~ sd ~fjc k cfifoksgdj sd Qdjokjo mfkcfc

e Qudbf~~du Kouf kjc bvjcfc e smf Ugnmkuc Idvj~efu Bdvjcksgdj* Smg~

cfifoksgdj wgii ikvjnm k cgkidovf ufokucgjo fknm ndvjsu~ uf~qfnsgrf ~ng,

fjnf kjc qdign gjbuk~suvnsvuf kjc ~ff` sd gcfjsgb uf~fkunm kufk~ db lvsvki

gjsfuf~s*

^ngfjnf Cgqidlknw kjc V*^*,CQU@ Ufiksgdj~8 Ndjniv~gdj

Dqfuksgdjki If~~dj~ Ifkujfc;3

^dlf if~~dj~ ifkujfc kuf jdw ovgcgjo dvu fbbdus~8

Duokjgxksgdjki ndllgslfjs * Smf ~vqqdus) gjrdirflfjs) kjc wgiigjo,jf~~ sd ndjsugevsf skjogeif uf~dvunf~ e smf @dufk ^dngfs) @VS) kjc

ufifrkjs Jdusm @dufk sdq ifkcfu~mgq mkrf effj f~~fjsgki sd ffqgjo smf

qudoukl ldrgjo bduwkuc cvugjo cgbnvis sglf~*


16/21

;;= Dj @dufk8 Rdivlf >

Bknf,sd,bknf lffsgjo~* Suv~s efjfs~ fjduldv~i budl ufoviku gj,qfu~dj lffsgjo~ kldjo `f qkusgngqkjs~* Smg~ g~ f~qfngkii glqduskjs

wmfj cgufns fifnsudjgn ndllvjgnksgdj~ kuf cgbnvis k~ smf kuf efswffj

smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~ kjc Jdusm @dufk*

Suv~sfc ndllvjgnksgdj~ * Drfu sglf) ldrgjo k~ ~idwi k~ jfnf~~kufjkeifc smf sfkl~ sd gjnufk~gjoi suv~s smks smf mkc ~mkufc dehfnsgrf~*

Smf CQU@ lg~~gdj kjc smf @dufk ^dngfs mkrf wdu`fc cgigofjsi sd

`ffq ndllvjgnksgdj~ dqfj kjc dj sk~`*

Efjfs~ budl nddqfuksgdj* Gj smf ndjsf}s db suv~sfc ndllvjgnksgdj~)efjfs~ -bdu f}klqif) smf KNL gjgsgksgrf' knnuvf sd kii qkusgf~*

Ufkig~sgn sglfskeif* Lffsgjo cfkcigjf~) nifkui gcfjsgbgjo ug~` bknsdu~)kjc f~skeig~mgjo nifku kjc ~mkufc qudhfns lgif~sdjf~ mkrf effj glqduskjs

sd `ffqgjo smf ndiikeduksgdj ldrgjo bduwkuc*

Gjbdulki ndllvjgnksgdj~* Vjqikjjfc cg~nv~~gdj~ kuf buf{vfjsik~ ~gojgnkjs k~ qikjjfc djf~* Lfki~ mkrf qudrgcfc k ndjofjgki kjc

qudcvnsgrf fjrgudjlfjs bdu ~vnm ndjrfu~ksgdj~*

Vjcfu~skjcgjo~ gj wugsgjo* Lg~vjcfu~skjcgjo~ lk sk`f ndj~gcfukeifsglf sd efndlf rg~geif* Cfrfidqgjo hdgjsi knnfqskeif wugssfj cdnv,

lfjs~ cf~nugegjo dehfnsgrf~ kjc lgif~sdjf~ nkj ef f}suflfi mfiqbvi*

ngfjnf Cgqidlknw If~~dj~

V*^* ngsgxfj~ nkjjds sukrfi sd Jdusm @dufk wgsmdvs u~s ufnfgrgjo kj gjrg,

sksgdj budl Qdjokjo kjc qgn`gjo vq k rg~k gj Efghgjo* ^glgikui) Jdusm

@dufkj~ uf{vguf k V*^* odrfujlfjsg~~vfc rg~k sd fjsfu smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~*

Smv~) kismdvom smf V*^* odrfujlfjs gj jd wk dbngkii ~vqqdusfc smf fbbdus~

cf~nugefc gj smg~ qkqfu) gs ~mdvic ef nifku smks jdjf db smg~ ndvic mkrf sk`fj

qiknf ke~fjs bvii kwkufjf~~ db edsm smf V*^* kjc CQU@ odrfujlfjs~*

Ldufdrfu) cvugjo smf qfugdc efgjo cg~nv~~fc) smfuf wfuf jd bdulki cgq,

idlksgn ufiksgdj~ efswffj smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~ kjc Jdusm @dufk) kjc Jdusm

@dufkj vjgrfu~gsgf~ kjc knkcflgn~ cgc jds mkrf dqfj knnf~~ sd smf Gjsfujfs*

Smf CQU@ VJ lg~~gdj gj Jfw Wdu`) smf dji dbngki Jdusm @dufkj quf~,

fjnf gj smf Vjgsfc sksf~) qikfc k qd~gsgrf udif gj ffqgjo ndllvjgnksgdj~

stdwgjo efswffj smf V*^* kjc Jdusm @dufkj uf~fkunm sfkl~* Bdu smd~f db

v~ v~fc sd jfku gj~skjskjfdv~ f}nmkjof~ rgk f,lkgi) smg~ kqqudknm dbsfj bfis

{vgsf nvlefu~dlf0 mdwfrfu) efnkv~f smf lg~~gdj ofjfukii mdv~fc swd

klek~~kcdu~ knnufcgsfc sd smf VJ kjc efnkv~f gs ufqdus~ ekn` smudvom smf


17/21

;;7Knkcflgn ^ngfjnf Fjokoflfjs wgsm Jdusm @dufk

CQU@ Lgjg~su db Bdufgoj Kbbkgu~) smg~ ki~d lfkjs) jds ~vuqug~gjoi) smks

dvu ~ngfjnf fjokoflfjs wk~) ks ifk~s budl smf Jdusm @dufkj qfu~qfnsgrf)

rfu lvnm k qkus db k cgqidlksgn qudnf~~*

K~ ~mdwj e Skeif ;) fjokoflfjs,ufiksfc f}nmkjof~ dbsfj dnnvuufc cvugjo

sglf~ db mfgomsfjfc qdigsgnki sfj~gdj~ efswffj Jdusm @dufk kjc smf Vjgsfc

^sksf~) ~vnm k~ Jdusm @dufk~ 5113 cfnikuksgdj smks gs wk~ k jvnifku qdwfu)

gs~ Hvi 5112 sf~s ugjo db ~frfj lg~~gif~) kjc gs~ Dnsdefu 5112 sf~sgjo db

kj kqqkufjs jvnifku cfrgnf* Djf gjsfuqufsksgdj g~ smks smf swd odrfujlfjs~

qfulgssfc smf f}nmkjof~ gj qkus sd `ffq ks ifk~s ~dlf nmkjjfi~ dqfj*

Smf ~sugjo db ufiksgrfi ~vnnf~~bvi f}nmkjof~ qkv~fc) mdwfrfu) wmfj qku,

sgngqkjs~ ks ^V kssflqsfc sd eugjo @VS ~nmdiku~ bdu k lduf f}sfjcfc ~sk

ks ^V vjcfu dvu jfw CQU@ Hvjgdu Bknvis Ifkcfu~mgq kjc Cfrfidqlfjs

Qudoukl* Smg~ qudoukl wk~ cfrfidqfc gj nid~f kjc ~vqqdusgrf ndj~visksgdj

wgsm Jdusm @dufkj ufquf~fjsksgrf~) kjc wf f}qfnsfc smf u~s ndmdus db Jdusm

@dufkj ~nmdiku~ sd kuugrf cvugjo smf 511?1= knkcflgn fku* Vjbdusvjksfi)

smfuf mkrf) sd cksf) effj jd dvjo bknvis ndlf sd smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~ vjcfu

smg~ qudoukl) kjc ^V ~skbb kuf gj smf ~dlfwmks flekuuk~~gjo qd~gsgdj db

mkrgjo sd ufsvuj bvjcgjo ukg~fc gj ~vqqdus db smf qudoukl*

Kismdvom gs g~ ~sgii jds nifku qufng~fi wm smf hvjgdu bknvis qudoukl mk~

jds ldrfc bduwkuc k~ f}qfnsfc) smfuf kuf ~frfuki qikv~geif knndvjs~) fknm db

wmgnm ufgjbdunf~ smf dsmfu* Smf u~s g~ smks gs g~ qd~~geif smks ~dlf gj Jdusm

@dufk rgfwfc dvu gjkegigs sd cfigrfu cf~`sdq ndlqvsfu~ sd smf qikjjfc

Swgj Ike~ ks smf @VS cgogski igeuku k~ k ~goj smks smf ~ngfjnf fjokoflfjs

mkc bkgifc sd qudcvnf qudlg~fc uf~vis~* Kismdvom dvu gjkegigs sd ~fjc lk,

nmgjf~ wk~ cvf sd k bkgivuf sd deskgj k uf{vgufc f}qdus ignfj~f -ufnkii smks

smf ignfj~f uf{vf~s fjcfc vq efgjo mfkuc k~ smf ~g},qkus ski`~ wfuf gj smf

qudnf~~ db) sflqdukugi) eufk`gjo cdwj') bdu ~dlf gj smf Jdusm smg~ lk

mkrf ~gojgfc k bkgivuf sd mdjdu k qudlg~f* Gj k ndvjsu ig`f Jdusm @dufk)

wmfuf jffc~ dbsfj bku f}nffc smf krkgikeif uf~dvunf~) gs g~ vjcfu~skjckeif

smks k mgomfu qugdugs lk ef qiknfc dj smf djf,wk qudrg~gdj db lksfugki

uf~dvunf~ smkj dj k swd,wk f}nmkjof db gjsfiifnsvki uf~dvunf~* Gj quknsgnf)

smg~ lfkj~ smks smfuf lk ef k oufksfu ~fj~f db vuofjn ufokucgjo kn{vgugjo

f{vgqlfjsbdu f}klqif) ndlqvsfu~ bdu k swgj uf~fkunm ikeduksdusmkj

kedvs hdgjs dqfj,~dvunf ~dbswkuf cfrfidqlfjs* Du) ks ifk~s) smf swd k~qfns~

kuf qfunfgrfc sd ef gjsfuswgjfc*

^fndjc) smf ifjosm db sglf wf wfuf gjrgsgjo smf Jdusm @dufkj ~nmdiku~ sd ~sk

ks uknv~f) budl ~frfuki ldjsm~ sd k wmdif ~flf~sfu) wk~ k~`gjo k ids* K~

ef~s wf nkj jdw sfii) jd cfng~gdj mkc frfu effj lkcf ks k mgom fjdvom ifrfi

sd qfulgs ~vnm k ifjosm ~sk* Mfuf wf lk mkrf lg~gjsfuqufsfc qikjjfu~


18/21

;51 Dj @dufk8 Rdivlf >

gjsfuf~s gj ~vnm k qudoukl k~ ~gojgbgjo mgomfu,ifrfi CQU@ kvsmdugxksgdj*

Ifs jd djf cfkigjo wgsm Jdusm @dufk frfu efigfrf smks evufkvnuksgn qdigsgn~

cd jds dqfuksf smfuf k~ mfuf*

Smguc) smf hvjgdu bknvis qudoukl wk~ gjgsgkii ~nmfcvifc sd ofs vjcfu wk

hv~s k~ qikjjgjo wk~ efogjjgjo bdu smf Qdjokjo rg~gs db smf Jfw Wdu`

Qmgimkuldjgn* Qfumkq~ ~ngfjnf fjokoflfjs bfii sd k idwfu qugdugs ufiksgrf sd

k lvnm mgomfu qudif nvisvuki f}nmkjof) f~qfngkii ~gjnf smf qmgimkuldjgn

rg~gs qiknfc vjqufnfcfjsfc cflkjc~ dj smf sglf kjc bdnv~ db nugsgnki qfu,

~djjfi cfkigjo wgsm V*^*Jdusm @dufk ufiksgdj~*

Bdvusm) smg~ wk~ k qfugdc db dqsglg~l ufokucgjo V*^*Jdusm @dufk ufik,

sgdj~* Jdusm @dufkj cgqidlks~ kqqfkufc jds sd wkjs sd cd kjsmgjo sd

hfdqkucgxf mgom,ifrfi jfodsgksgdj~* Djnf smg~ efnklf kqqkufjs sd v~) wf

k~`fc k ~fjgdu V*^* cgqidlks sd lk`f gs nifku sd mg~ Jdusm @dufkj ndvjsfu,

qkus smks smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~ rkivfc knkcflgn ~ngfjnf f}nmkjof~ db smf `gjc

wf wfuf qudqd~gjo* Dvu vjcfu~skjcgjo g~ smks dvu lf~~kof wk~ ndjrffc*

Mdwfrfu) gs lk wfii mkrf mkc smf fbbfns db fjskjoigjo dvu qudoukl wgsm

smf ikuofu kjc rfu cfignksf jvnifku jfodsgksgdj~* Gb smg~ dnnvuufc) smfj wf

wdvic mkrf) vjgjsfjsgdjkii) cg~gjsfulfcgksfc smf Jfw Wdu` nmkjjfi* Mfuf

wf rgdiksfc dvu dwj qugjngqif db `ffqgjo smf ~ngfjnf fjokoflfjs g~diksfc

budl mgom qdigsgn~*

_f lk jfrfu `jdw wmfsmfu kj db smf kedrf knndvjs~ mkrf rkigcgs*

Mdwfrfu) jd lkssfu smf qkusgnviku dvsndlf) gs ~mdvic ef nifku smks smfuf wk~

~qgiidrfu budl ~ngfjnf fjokoflfjs sd mgomfu,ifrfi cgqidlkn* _f mdqf smg~

ufgjbdunf~ smf lf~~kof wgsm wmgnm wf efokj smg~ qkqfu8 ~skjckuc~,ek~fc

~ngfjnf cgqidlkn nkj ef k qkusgnvikui v~fbvi wk gj wmgnm sd evgic suv~sfc

kjc nddqfuksgrf ufiksgdj~ efswffj ndvjsugf~ smks mkrf mkc dji lgjglki

dbngki cgqidlksgn ufiksgdj~*

Fjcjdsf~

Qfdqif kjc smf Quf~~) 5115') mssq8$$qfdqif,quf~~*duo$ufqdus~$qcb$;26*qcb*

5* ff) bdu f}klqif) @ug~sgj L* Iduc kjc Rkvomkj N* Svuf`gkj) Sglf bdu k Jfw Fuk db

^ngfjnf Cgqidlkn) ^ngfjnf >;6) jd* 6=;> -511?'8 ?27?1*

>* Smf Ofduof _* Ev~m kclgjg~suksgdj uf~ngjcfc gj 511= smf glqd~gsgdj db smf Sukcgjowgsm smf Fjfl Kns dj Jdusm @dufk) kismdvom lkj dsmfu ~kjnsgdj~ kokgj~s smf ndvjsuuflkgj gj qiknf*

;*_mks smf _duic Smgj`~ gj 5115 -_k~mgjosdj) C*N*8 Qfw Uf~fkunm Nfjsfu bdu smf


19/21

;5;Knkcflgn ^ngfjnf Fjokoflfjs wgsm Jdusm @dufk

3* Kouffc Buklfwdu` efswffj smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~ db Klfugnk kjc smf CfldnuksgnQfdqif~ Ufqveign db @dufk) Ofjfrk) 5; Dnsdefu ;773) www*`fcd*duo$qcb~$Kouffc,Buklfwdu`*qcb*

6* Lg`f Nmgjd)Lfiscdwj8 Smf Gj~gcf sdu db smf Jdusm @dufkj Jvnifku Nug~g~ -JfwWdu`8 ^s* Lkusgj~ Quf~~) 511='0 ^figo Mkuug~dj) Cgc Jdusm @dufk Nmfks4 Bdufgoj

Kbbkgu~ =3) jd* ; -5116'*

2* Bdu f}klqif) Jdusm @dufk kouffc gj ^fqsflefu 5116 sd ogrf vq gs~ f}g~sgjo jvnifkuwfkqdj~ kjc ufhdgj smf Jvnifku Jdj,Qudigbfuksgdj Sufks* Smf Vjgsfc sksf~ kjc Jdusm@dufk kouffc sd uf~qfns fknm dsmfu~ ~drfufgojs) f}g~s qfknfbvii sdofsmfu) kjc sk`f~sfq~ sd jdulkigxf smfgu ufiksgdj~ ~vehfns sd smfgu uf~qfnsgrf egiksfuki qdigngf~* ff Hdgjs^sksflfjs db smf Bdvusm Udvjc db smf g},Qkus Ski`~ Efghgjo) V*^* Cfqkuslfjs db sksf);7 fqsflefu 5116) www*~sksf*odr$q$fkq$ufogdjki$n;6366*msl*

?* gj Smkf djo fs ki*) Egiksfuki Uf~fkunm Ndiikeduksgdj efswffj @gl Nmkf` Vjgrfu,~gs db Sfnmjdido -CQU@' kjc ^uknv~f Vjgrfu~gs -V*^*' gj smf Kufk db GjsfouksfcGjbdulksgdj Sfnmjdido -vjqveig~mfc qkqfu) quf~fjsfc ks K~gkj svcgf~ dj smf QkngnNdk~s lffsgjo~ ks Fk~s,_f~s Nfjsfu) Mdjdiviv) Hvjf 511>') www*jkvsgiv~*duo$CQU@,EugfjoEdd`$sukj~gsgdj$K^QKN,@gl,Nmkf`,^uknv~f*qcb*

=* Smf~f uf~vis~ ndlf budl gjsfurgfw~ ndjcvnsfc kbsfu smf qudoukl wk~ ndlqifsfc*

7* Lfskcksk ufbfu~ sd smf nksfodugf~ v~fc gj cf~nugegjo smf gjbdulksgdj gj smf igeuku*

Ndjbdulkjnf wgsm gjsfujksgdjki ~skjckuc~ lfkj~) kldjo dsmfu smgjo~) smks cgogski igeuku,gf~ nkj ~mkuf gjbdulksgdj drfu fifnsudjgn jfswdu`~*

;1* Lkuokufs Kud) NE^ Jfw~) ndjrfu~ksgdj wgsm kvsmdu~*

;;* @KQF^ sdd` drfu lkj db smf bvjnsgdj~ db smf BCUN*

;5* KNL wk~ nufksfc gj ;73? kjc g~ smf wduic~ u~s fcvnksgdjki kjc ~ngfjsgn ~dngfsbdnv~fc dj ndlqvsgjo* Kldjo smf KNL qudoukl~ g~ smf Gjsfujksgdjki Ndiifogksf Qud,oukllgjo Ndjsf~s -GNQN' ~qdj~dufc e GEL* Smf ndjsf~s gs~fib g~ lkcf vq db smuffudvjc~* Gj smf u~s udvjc vjgrfu~gs sfkl~ ndlqfsf ks k idnki ifrfi* ^vnnf~~bvi sfkl~

smfj ldrf sd udvjc swd) wmgnm g~ mfic ks k ufogdjki ~gsf* Bgjkii) smf sdq ufogdjki sfkl~kuf gjrgsfc) wgsm kii sukrfi f}qfj~f~ qkgc) sd qkusgngqksf gj smf wduic jki~*

;>* Fjoig~m g~ smf ikjovkof db smf ndlqfsgsgdj*

;3* Smg~ ~fnsgdj g~ kckqsfc budl ^svkus Smdu~dj) Smdlk~ Mkueigj) kjc Bufcfugn` B*Nkuugfuf) V*^*,Jdusm @dufk Suv~s Evgicgjo smudvom Knkcflgn ^ngfjnf Nddqfuksgdj)

Hdvujki db smf _duic Vjgrfu~gsgf~ Bduvl ;) jd* > -511='8 6?2>*


20/21


21/21

@dufk Fndjdlgn Gj~sgsvsf db Klfugnk;=11 @ ^s* J_) ^vgsf ;1;1) _k~mgjosdj) CN 51112

Qm8 515*323*;7=5 B}8 515*323*;7=? www*`fgk*duo

Kvsmdu~8

Hdmj Bfbbfu

Lvjo,`dd @kjo

Smdlk~ Nkuogii

Ogiefus Udxlkj

@g,~vjo @wk`

@fgsm Cgjjgf

Mvjhgj ^fd " ^svkus Smdu~dj

Euvnf F* Efnmsdi) Hu*

Lkusj cf Euvj " ^kjolgj Ekf

@FG

Dj @dufk wk~ eduj gj Cfnflefu 5112 wgsm smf gjgsgksgdj d @FG~ Knkcflgn Qkqfu ^fugf~*

@FG ndllg~~gdj~ udvomi sfj qkqfu~ qfu fku wgsm cgrfu~f qfu~qfnsgrf~ dj dugogjki ~vehfns~ d

nvuufjs gjsfuf~s sd @dufk wksnmfu~* Fknm qkqfu g~ cg~sugevsfc gjcgrgcvkii k~ k @FG Knkcflgn Qkqfu

sd drfu 5)111 odrfujlfjs dbngki~) smgj` skj` f}qfus~) kjc ~nmdiku~ kudvjc smf Vjgsfc ^sksf~ kjcsmf wduic kjc ~ve~f{vfjsi ndiiksfc gjsd Dj @dufk*

Smf smguc rdivlf dDj @dufk gjnivcf~ jgjf qkqfu~ wugssfj e ~dlf d smf ifkcgjo ~nmdiku~ wdu`gjo

dj @dufk sdck* Sd ifkuj lduf kedvs ~velgssgjo k qkqfu qudqd~ki sd @FG du smf Knkcflgn Qkqfu

^fugf~) rg~gs www*`fgk*duo*

Academic Science Engagement with North Korea by Hyunjin Seo

Documents

Transcript of Academic Science Engagement with North Korea by Hyunjin Seo