A different road to brand experience

154
A Different Road to Brand Experience

description

 

Transcript of A different road to brand experience

Page 1: A different road to brand experience

A Different Road to Brand Experience

Page 2: A different road to brand experience

Many thanks to our kind sponsors

For supporting and taking part at this evenings event

Page 3: A different road to brand experience

Today’s agenda • 16.00 – 16.30: Registration and coffee

•  16.30 – 16.50: Welcome and event introduction

16.50 – 17.10: A Different Road to Brand Experience

                         

• 17.10 – 17.25: Brand Comms: Making advertising more effective

                       

• 17.25 – 17.45: The Rise of Couponing

                    

• 17.45 – 18.00: Refreshment break

• 18.00 – 18.20: The Importance of Marketing Research                                      

                       

• 18.20 – 18.35: The Power of Big Brilliant Ideas

                    

• 18.35 – 18.55: Augmented Reality

                       

• 18.55 – 19.05: In Home Sampling

                    

• 19.05 – 19.15: Q&A

                        

• 19.15 – 20.00: Networking - drinks and canapés to follow

Page 4: A different road to brand experience

Nick WellsCEOTNT Post UK

Page 5: A different road to brand experience

100%

90%

10%

70%

60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

80%

TV 85%

Press 85%

Radio61%

OOH 49%

Internet 74%

Facebook 46%

Twitter 16%

DM & Door Drop 100%

Pinterest 0.3%

UK

Med

ia R

each

(% p

opul

ation

)Firstly remember our strengths…

Page 6: A different road to brand experience

Source: British Marketing Survey 2008-2011

Secondly remember our strengths…

Page 7: A different road to brand experience

Difference between spend and effect per channel

Source: BCG Focus on the Future June 2012

Page 8: A different road to brand experience

But times are changing…

Page 9: A different road to brand experience

Multi-channel strategy drives above pure-play online growth (US)

Source: BCG Focus on the Future June 2012

Page 10: A different road to brand experience

Multi-channel customers prove to generate more revenues for each single channel

Source: BCG Focus on the Future June 2012

Page 11: A different road to brand experience

Entertainer Case StudyTo prove uplift in online sales in door dropped areas versus non door dropped areas, specific cities were chosen where there are no stores, meaning the only access to shop was online.

2010 v 2009 Test Area vs Total Online Sales Uplift

64.22%

18.70%

0.00%

10.00%

20.00%

30.00%

40.00%

50.00%

60.00%

70.00%

Test Area Online Sales Uplift All sales uplift

Test and Control Areas

% O

nli

ne

Sal

es U

pli

ft

2010 v 2009

A clean test, where online sales from 2009 in the same areas can be analysed versus 2010 sales

Page 12: A different road to brand experience

UK is the country with the largest % internet contributions to GDP in 2010

Page 13: A different road to brand experience

Online retail is expected to account for 23% of total retail in 2016

Page 14: A different road to brand experience

25% of people in the UK would give up sex for the internet

Page 15: A different road to brand experience

Even Google use DM!

Page 16: A different road to brand experience

DSA – how it works

Page 17: A different road to brand experience

DSA Postal Process UK

Inward depot

16 Letter sorters

2 Packet sorters

7 Depots Transport fleet

Outward depot

> 125 trucks per day

Transport

RM delivery

Delivery

95% next day

Transport

Collections

300 vehicles

8000 clients

Collections

97% handover quality

60 Royal Mail IMC’s

Up to 20m items per day

60 IMC’s

Page 18: A different road to brand experience

Mail market by competitor

OTH

ER

Page 19: A different road to brand experience

End to End – Why now?

Desire for alternative supplier

Reducing reliance on Royal Mail

20% Increase

PRICES

DSA volumes of 3.9 billion in 2011

Proven track record

Liverpool pilot since 2007

Experience from EMN

countries

VAT resolution in sight

Z.G.P.P. enables urban selection

Marginpressure on DSA

OFCOM support as new regulatory body

UK is the 2nd largest postal market in terms of total addressed mail volume in Europe

Clients interested Market ready

Internal capabilities Regulatory

Page 20: A different road to brand experience

TNT Posties

Page 21: A different road to brand experience

“Rumours of my death have been greatly exaggerated”Mark Twain

GREAT direct mail and door drop is still about

Relevance... impact... engagement... interactivity and integration

Page 22: A different road to brand experience

A different road to brand experience……..

Page 23: A different road to brand experience

How well do you know your Kellogg’s cereals?......

Let the games commence…….

Page 24: A different road to brand experience

The Background & Challenges…..

•To Re launch a brand to a different target market• Targeted to women aged 35+

•Focusing on digestive health harmony and balance

•A whole shift FROM BUM TO TUMFROM BUM TO TUM

•Changing people’s taste perceptions

Page 25: A different road to brand experience

Meet Jo…. What she can offer?

Page 26: A different road to brand experience

Two stage is the way forward…

• Day OneDay One – – Drop a bag through the householders door

• Day TwoDay Two – – Householder leaves bag outside door before 9am

• TNT Network then deliver a full size product

= 1 very happy consumer= 1 very happy consumer

Page 27: A different road to brand experience

Also = One happy client

Effective mechanic

Tailored to client objectives

Meet all budgets, requirements and objectives

Many variants of product

Page 28: A different road to brand experience

What we did

• Targeting is key…..

Page 29: A different road to brand experience

Joanne HigginsonComms Strategy ConsultantBrand Comms Department

Page 30: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2011 | confidential

•Did it work?

•Should you do it again?

•Do you need to do things differently next time?

Page 31: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2011 | confidential

The starting point

The client’s ultimate business objectives

Logistical info about the campaign, inc which postal

sectors have been exposed to the door-drop

Page 32: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2011 | confidential

We then look for the Tesco Clubcard holders amongst that group

Page 33: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2011 | confidential

To see if their shopping behaviour has changed since they received the door drop….

● We first look to see if it is different to what we would have expected

● And we quantify this so that we can say exactly how many sales the door drop has driven

● Then we did a little deeper in order to understand how and why shopping behaviour has changed

– Are people buying more each time they visit?

– Or is it just that they are buying more often?

– Are people trying the product for the 1st time?

– Are people being tempted back after they had abandoned the brand?

● We do all of this anonymously and comply with data-protection regulations

Page 34: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2011 | confidential

By doing this, we can tell

1. How many sales a campaign drove

2. How it changed consumers shopper behaviour

Thus indicating: •If the campaign has been successful

•How, when & where it has worked best

Page 35: A different road to brand experience

So did we meet Kellogg’s objectives?.....

ROIROI

InsighInsight t

GroupGroupss

Online Online ExposurExposur

ee

Page 36: A different road to brand experience

What does the future hold for us?.....

Two more campaigns this year..possibly three

Page 37: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2012 | confidential

Brand Comms: Making advertising more effective

September 2012

Page 38: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2012 | confidential

We evaluate clients’ brand advertising using behavioural data

….and this enables us to advise on how to optimise & improve

future campaigns.

What dunnhumby Brand Comms offers

Page 39: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2012 | confidential

We combine various data-sets at a household level to give a 360° view of the consumer

Actual shopping behaviour of

17m shoppers

“Shopper Thoughts” panel of 85k customers

Shopping Behaviour

Media Exposure

Attitudinal & claimed media

consumption

Campaign exposure

Page 40: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2012 | confidential

Step 1 – Isolate those exposed to the media or campaign

Step 2 – Build a control group of shoppers matched to exposed group on brand and category purchase behaviour, demographics and profiles

Step 3 – track and evaluate the changes in sales etc of the advertised product between the 2 groups

Vs.

To do this we use a test & control methodology as this allows us to isolate the effect that the campaign is having

Page 41: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2012 | confidential

So rather than measuring success by media currencies, we measure it according to the objectives the campaign was intended to drive

Repeat purchase rates

Coupon redemption

New customer Trial

Loyalty

Brand switchingSales uplift generated

Market share / share of requirement

Weight of purchase

Freq of purchase

Page 42: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2012 | confidential

42

This woman already was already an occasional buyer of Brand X but she

bought more as a result (increased share of requirement)

This woman tried Brand X for the first time

(trialist) This woman gave Brand X a second chance (repeat buyer)

This woman usually bought whatever was on promotion but this time she purposefully looked

Brand X out(increased WOP & FOP)

In addition, we can tell what shifts in shopper behaviour have driven these extra sales

Page 43: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2012 | confidential

That means that we can give you some great insight on how your door-drop or direct mail campaign has worked

● how many sales it drove

● how it changed consumer behaviour

● whether it was successful in:

– driving sales uplift

– bringing in trialists

– reaching existing users

– encouraging repeat purchase

● how many coupons were redeemed and of these:

– how many were correct redemptions

– how many were mis-redemptions

Page 44: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2012 | confidential

And because our analysis is flexible we can also answer the more unusual questions that you might have

44

Are coupon redeemers more or less valuable than other customers?

Would 2x coupons in 1 mailer help drive repeat purchase?

Is one delivery mechanic more

effective than another?

Does one creative execution, or message, drive more sales than another?

Is one method of targeting more effective than another?

Does the presence of other media help make my door drop work harder?

Page 45: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2012 | confidential

To give you an example….

45

Page 46: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2012 | confidential

46

Brand X needed to halt declining sales and we could see that the door-drop generated an extra £53k sales

All numbers reported are % incremental to Control Group

This was a +17% uplift in sales from the Tesco Clubcard test group

+ 6p

+ 17%

Or, an extra 6p spent per household analysed,

£224,308…which translates to a lot of money when you apply this to all targeted, regardless of whether or not they shop at Tesco…

Page 47: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2012 | confidential

Digging a little deeper, we saw that….

47

This was due by: ● increases in customer penetration ● increases in market share

And that New Customers (trialists) were the driving force behind these gains

Clear differences were also seen between the different targeting & distribution methods tested, thus giving clear direction on how future campaigns should be planned

Page 48: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2012 | confidential

1. How many sales your door-drop or DM campaign drove (or its ROI)

2. If it achieved your objectives

3. How it changed consumer behaviour

4. What worked well & what didn’t

5. What issues you need to address going forward

So in summary, we can tell you

Page 49: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2012 | confidential

If you’d like to know more, please get in touch

Joanne HigginsonComms Strategy Consultant

DL: 020 8832 [email protected]

Francesca BakerComms Strategy Consultant

DL: 020 8832 [email protected]

Page 50: A different road to brand experience

© dunnhumby 2012 | confidential

Thank You

Page 51: A different road to brand experience
Page 52: A different road to brand experience
Page 53: A different road to brand experience

Global leading media and marketing services company 1

Founded in Europe in 1970 by AC Nielsen 2

Employ 7,000 people worldwide 3

Offices in US, Canada, Mexico, Germany, Italy, Spain, Poland & the UK 4

Work with over 4,500 UK brands 5

85% of all UK coupons pass through Valassis: 8 million each week 6

Invest £150,000 in UK quality checks each year 7

35% of UK clients have worked with Valassis for 15 years or more 8

Introduction to Valassis

Page 54: A different road to brand experience

Coupon Lifecycle

Page 55: A different road to brand experience

Traditional Paper Based Coupons Digital Innovation NFC

Coupon’s are Evolving

Page 56: A different road to brand experience

Shoppers increasingly use a mix of digital media to prepare the shopping trip

Mobile SMS Text

Email Mobile Apps

Social MediaWebsite

Consumer Choice is Widening

Page 57: A different road to brand experience

Near Field Communication (NFC)

• NFC is a short range wireless technology that exchanges data simply and securely between two electronic devices

• A simple wave or touch can establish an NFC connection between 2 devices that are within 4cms of one another

• NFC can be used with a variety of devices – but the main talking point at the moment is around its use in mobile phones

Near Field Communication

Page 58: A different road to brand experience

• Valassis managed 340 million coupon redemptions in 2011 - this is an increase of 22% over 2010 when the number was 277 million

• Volumes have grown 40% in two years and 60% in the last 5 years• This growth has come primarily from retailer issued coupons and vouchers which

grew 32% and 40% in 2010 and 2011 respectively• The GfK NOP research shows that 72% of consumers use coupons - this was an

increase of 11% compared to 2011 (61%)

More consumers are using coupons

Page 59: A different road to brand experience

Weighted base: 1717 adults who use coupons when supermarket shopping‘When compared to this time last year would you say you are using more, less or the same amount of coupons when you go supermarket shopping?’

22% of people are using coupons more than they were a year ago

Page 60: A different road to brand experience

• Redemptions of retailer issued coupons and vouchers grew by 66 million to almost 230 million coupons in 2011

• The reasons for this growth are:• Supermarkets are having to compete more aggressively than at any time in recent history, and

especially around key seasonal peaks, such as Christmas and Easter – to do this they are using money off vouchers

• Loyalty programmes continue to be popular with consumers and provide an effective vehicle for targeted own label and branded goods offers

• Redemptions of manufacturer coupons are broadly stable (40m in 2011) – • in recent years there has been a significant shift to using retailer loyalty programmes as

the distribution channel

• Newspaper subscription coupons continue to decline (23m in 2011) • there have been peaks and troughs in the last five years. In 2009 we saw the volumes as high as 40m,

almost 60% higher than the previous three years.

Coupon Trends

Page 61: A different road to brand experience

• The average coupon value grew from £0.90 in 2010 to £1.01 in 2011.• This average value excludes money off vouchers which can be used against total basket spend• The increase reflects the competitive environment where brands and retailers are needing to give more away in return

for loyalty

• Direct mail has the highest redemption rate of more than 6%, although this has declined since 2008, when it was just over 10%

• This redemption rate excludes some retailer loyalty mailing schemes where the redemption rate is significantly higher due to finely tuned targeting of the offers

• We suspect the decline is due to less emphasis on targeting than in previous years

• Coupons and vouchers distributed through magazines and newspapers, as might be expected, given the nature of their distribution, have the lowest redemption rates of around 0.5%

• This is compounded by reduction in daily newspaper sales and coverage

Coupon Trends

Page 62: A different road to brand experience

Average Redemption Rates by Distribution Media

Page 63: A different road to brand experience

The coupon market today - overall summary

• Consumers are using more coupons• Seen in both Valassis’ redemption data and by market research

- 40% growth in Valassis redemptions in three years• Consumers are looking to use coupons more than a year ago • Higher level and becoming less loyal to retailers

• Consumer confidence, although relatively high, is falling for all social grades• Confidence is related to social grade

- the higher the social grade, the more confident• The less affluent the group …

- the less confident they are- and the more their confidence has worsened

Page 64: A different road to brand experience

Weighted base: 219 adults

74% of wealthier AB shoppers plan to use money-off vouchers when Christmas shopping

Contrary to stereotypes, this research indicates that it is the wealthier AB consumers who are savvier shoppers

− 74% of this demographic plan to use money-off vouchers, compared to an average of 59% 66% of AB shoppers plan to use the favoured mechanic, ‘money off

product coupons’. Over 1 in 4 (26%) of AB shoppers are looking for more promotional offers than this time last

year. 42% of shoppers plan to shop in more stores to redeem all the store specific coupons and

vouchers that they have − This is most prominent among the 16 – 34 age group (59%), behaviour they are likely to

continue as they get older. 17% of shoppers will be more likely to use a different supermarket (i.e. not their main one), this

year than at the same time last year

Latest consumer insight from Valassis – GfkNOP research findings (Fieldwork conducted 18 th – 20th Nov 2011)

Coupon Trends

Page 65: A different road to brand experience

• 30% of consumers will shop away from their main supermarket this year, because other retailers are advertising better offers• On a similar survey before Christmas 2011, only 17% planned to ‘shop

away’ at Christmas• 36% of women will shop away from their main supermarket

• We appear to be seeing lower levels of loyalty, helped by, for example• ‘brand matching’ promotions• aggressive pricing in supermarkets

• 9% will not change their shopping behaviour• For 6% of consumers, offers in other supermarkets make no difference

Coupon Trends

Page 66: A different road to brand experience

Weighted base: 991 adults

78% of shoppers will use a promotional offer when doing their grocery shopping this Christmas.

54% of shoppers will use 3 or more mechanics when doing their Christmas grocery shopping.

The favoured mechanic to drive down costs when Christmas grocery shopping was ‘money off product coupons’, with 65% of shoppers planning to use these.

Latest consumer insight from Valassis – GfkNOP research findings (Fieldwork conducted 18 th – 20th Nov 2011)

Deal hungry consumers turn to promotions to drive down costs this Christmas

Page 67: A different road to brand experience

In summary

Almost 1 in 5 shoppers (18%) are worried about how much money they will spend on their Christmas grocery shopping

78% of shoppers will use a promotional offer when doing their Christmas grocery

shopping

The favoured mechanic was ‘money off products coupons’

− 65% of shoppers plan to use them when doing their Christmas grocery shopping

Wealthy AB consumers use vouchers more than the average consumer, 79% versus an average of 59%

As a result......... Worryingly for retailers, only 8% of shoppers would remain loyal to their

supermarket of choice if others retailers were offering better discounts

at Christmas.

Latest consumer insight from Valassis – GfkNOP research findings (Fieldwork conducted 18 th – 20th Nov 2011)

Page 68: A different road to brand experience

Multi Coupon Mailing Example

Page 69: A different road to brand experience

Bar Code Make Up

Issuer Number Campaign Number Coupon Value

Barcode Structure

Page 70: A different road to brand experience

Barcodes EAN13 PIN Codes

Pin Codes

Page 71: A different road to brand experience

You’re in good company at Valassis

Page 72: A different road to brand experience
Page 73: A different road to brand experience

Thank you

Page 74: A different road to brand experience

Coffee break…

The next session starts at 18.00pm

Page 75: A different road to brand experience

CCB Fastmap Ltd3rd Floor, Colonial Building59-61 Hatton GardenLondon EC1N 8LS0207 242 0702www.ccbfastmap.com

How marketing insight prior to a sampling campaign can enhance the look, feel and overall response

David Cole , Managing Director

david.cole@@fastmap.com

www.fastmap.com

Page 76: A different road to brand experience

Agenda

Introduction

Why test

How its done

Case studies

Page 77: A different road to brand experience

Who are fast.MAP?

fast.MAP are specialists in using online research for the Direct Marketing sector.

We help marketers dramatically improve the performance of their marketing through effective insight

Page 78: A different road to brand experience

Strong Alliances with Trade Bodies

Page 79: A different road to brand experience

DMA White Paper Tracking Studies

Page 80: A different road to brand experience

Research is widely reported

Page 81: A different road to brand experience

The Importance of Testing – Richard Benson

There are only two rules in direct marketing.

Rule 1: test everything. Rule 2: Refer to Rule 1

Secrets of Successful Direct Mail, 1989

Page 82: A different road to brand experience

Why do we Marketers get it wrong?

Page 83: A different road to brand experience

Marketing GAP

What shoppers do, and what marketers think that they do. Misunderstanding the ever changing  attitudes to DM and Promotional Techniques leaves a huge gap in the armoury. The Marketing Gap survey updates you annually on the key issues you need to bear in mind the very next time you decide to go one way, rather than another

Page 84: A different road to brand experience

Marketing GAP

What shoppers do, and what marketers think that they do. Misunderstanding the ever changing  attitudes to DM and Promotional Techniques leaves a huge gap in the armoury. The Marketing Gap survey updates you annually on the key issues you need to bear in mind the very next time you decide to go one way, rather than another

Why do we Marketers get it wrong?

•Skilled in marketing technique •Understand the brand

•Different demographics/outlook•Ever changing environment

Page 85: A different road to brand experience

Released October 3rd …

Page 86: A different road to brand experience

Some truths from this year’s GAP report

Page 87: A different road to brand experience

Marketers get it wrong …….2012 fast.MAP GAP Report

30% under- estimation

Page 88: A different road to brand experience

Marketers get it wrong …….2012 fast.MAP GAP Report

34% under- estimation

Page 89: A different road to brand experience

Marketers get it wrong …….2012 fast.MAP GAP Report

57% under- estimation

Page 90: A different road to brand experience

Marketers get it wrong …….2012 fast.MAP GAP Report

57% under- estimation

Page 91: A different road to brand experience

Marketers get it wrong …….2012 fast.MAP GAP Report

283% OVER-estimation

Page 92: A different road to brand experience

Decisions marketers have to make

Variable

Audience

Offer

Incentive

Endorsement

Outer envelope

PS

Payment term

Page 93: A different road to brand experience

Decisions marketers have to make

Variable How many Possible combinations

Audience 5 5

Offer 4

Incentive 4

Endorsement 3

Outer envelope 3

PS 4

Payment term 4

Page 94: A different road to brand experience

Decisions marketers have to make

Variable How many Possible combinations

Audience 5 5

Offer 4 20Incentive 4

Endorsement 3

Outer envelope 3

PS 4

Payment term 4

Page 95: A different road to brand experience

Decisions marketers have to make

Variable How many Possible combinations

Audience 5 5

Offer 4 20

Incentive 4 80Endorsement 3

Outer envelope 3

PS 4

Payment term 4

Page 96: A different road to brand experience

Decisions marketers have to make

Variable How many Possible combinations

Audience 5 5

Offer 4 20

Incentive 4 80

Endorsement 3 240

Outer envelope 3

PS 4

Payment term 4

Page 97: A different road to brand experience

Decisions marketers have to make

Variable How many Possible combinations

Audience 5 5

Offer 4 20

Incentive 4 80

Endorsement 3 240

Outer envelope 3 720PS 4

Payment term 4

Page 98: A different road to brand experience

Decisions marketers have to make

Variable How many Possible combinations

Audience 5 5

Offer 4 20

Incentive 4 80

Endorsement 3 240

Outer envelope 3 720

PS 4 2880Payment term 4

Page 99: A different road to brand experience

Decisions marketers have to make

Variable How many Possible combinations

Audience 5 5

Offer 4 20

Incentive 4 80

Endorsement 3 240

Outer envelope 3 720

PS 4 2880

Payment term 4 11,520

Page 100: A different road to brand experience

Traditional D.M. Testing

Control

GO LIVE ; INVOLVE CONSUMERS

Page 101: A different road to brand experience

Traditional D.M. Testing

100 days £25k to £35k GO LIVE ; INVOLVE CONSUMERS

Control

Control

Page 102: A different road to brand experience

What does a traditional Door Drop test tell you ?

1 Gross response - which pack/leaflet wins ? Y

Page 103: A different road to brand experience

What does a traditional Door Drop test tell you ?

1 Gross response - which pack/leaflet wins ? Y

2 What is the profile of respondents? N

3 What ask level / price would have worked the best? N

4 Which is the second favourite pack? N

5 Is the branding “on message”? N

6 How could the “winner” be improved? N

7 Which creative will attract continuous givers? N

8 Quantify the negative impact of powerful creative. N

9 At what stage in the process did respondents loose interest? Envelope, Letter, Offer…

N

10 Do different creatives require different channels? N

Page 104: A different road to brand experience

The result of traditional testing ……..

One pack fits all

Not cost effective to segment

Control pack is very difficult to beat

Few tests a year ( 2 or 3 )

Many new initiatives fail

Limited innovation

Therefore off line DM as a channel is not as effective as it might be.

Page 105: A different road to brand experience

Chris Combemale

Executive Director DMA

“The lengthy time is takes to learn and the cost of live testing has a negative impact on the effectiveness off line Direct Marketing.   The advent of the internet (and specifically panel based research) means it is no longer necessary to wait months to discover which creative approach, envelope or incentive will work best.............. 

Chris Combemale

Page 106: A different road to brand experience

fast.MAP vs. Traditional Test – 2 creatives

Cost Time

Offline c£30k 100 days

Online c£3k 10 days

• 1/10th of Cost • 1/10th of the Time • 10 x the Insight

Page 107: A different road to brand experience

What can you test research?

Page 108: A different road to brand experience

Examples of how it works…

Page 109: A different road to brand experience

Testing Outer Envelope Headlines

Page 110: A different road to brand experience

Testing Outer Envelope Headlines

Page 111: A different road to brand experience

Attitudes and Experiences

Question 1 Volume PercentI consider myself a property entrepreneur and actively invest in different properties for financial gain

145 5%

Whilst I have not invested in property before (other than the property I live in) I could be interested in learning more 1,170 37%

I never have or wish to invest in property for financial gain 1,882 59%Overall 3,197 100%

Page 112: A different road to brand experience

Mail Pack Creative

Page 113: A different road to brand experience

Current Outer Envelope Headline – NOT the favourite.

Please indicate which of the following headlines would motivate you to open the envelope

Learn the secrets of successful property investment

Get the inside story on becoming a successfully property investor

Ever thought the people making money out of property know something you don’t? We’ll tell you what it is

Take the first step in becoming a property millionaire

Become a property millionaire 10%

Become an expert property investor

Make a mint in property

Page 114: A different road to brand experience

Current Outer Envelope Headline – NOT the favourite.

Please indicate which of the following headlines would motivate you to open the envelope

Learn the secrets of successful property investment 24%

Get the inside story on becoming a successfully property investor 19%

Ever thought the people making money out of property know something you don’t? We’ll tell you what it is

18%

Take the first step in becoming a property millionaire 13%

Become a property millionaire 10%

Become an expert property investor 9%

Make a mint in property 6%

Page 115: A different road to brand experience

Learn the secrets of successful property investment

52% increase in response

Result

Page 116: A different road to brand experience

Incentive Testing

Page 117: A different road to brand experience

Incentive testing

Page 118: A different road to brand experience

Incentive testing

Page 119: A different road to brand experience

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

45%1. Everybodys Grandparents

2. Comfortable People

3. Deal Seekers

4. Nice People

5. Stretched People

6. Unknown

Organic Hotel Green/Organic Vouchers £15 M&S Vouchers Green Box None

£15 M&S Vouchers

30%

25%

Page 120: A different road to brand experience

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

40%

45%

1. Everybodys Grandparents

2. Comfortable People

3. Deal Seekers

4. Nice People

5. Stretched People

6. Unknown

Organic Hotel Green/Organic Vouchers £30 M&S Vouchers Green Box None

The following incentives were randomly shown to the remaining panellists

28%

42%

30%

25%

£30 M&S Vouchers

Page 121: A different road to brand experience

Pre-testing sample response…

Major cereal brand were planning to distribute free products sample delivered to consumer’s doorstep.

Primary objective of research is to evaluate the preferred product so that sampling volumes could be planned.

Page 122: A different road to brand experience

Are you the main decision maker when it comes to your family shopping?

Page 123: A different road to brand experience

Who do you live with?

Page 124: A different road to brand experience

What brands of breakfast cereal do you regularly buy for your family?

Page 125: A different road to brand experience

If major cereal brand provided a free sample delivered to your home, which of these two cereals would you most want?

New Product

Existing Product

39%

Page 126: A different road to brand experience

If major cereal brand provided a free sample delivered to your home, which of these two cereals would you most want? Vs. Gender

New Product

Existing Product

Page 127: A different road to brand experience

If major cereal brand provided a free sample delivered to your home, which of these two cereals would you most want? Vs. Age

New Product

Existing Product

Page 128: A different road to brand experience

If major cereal brand provided a free sample delivered to your home, which of these two cereals would you most want? Vs. Household Structure

New Product

Existing Product

Page 129: A different road to brand experience

Existing Product

New Product

Page 130: A different road to brand experience

Please let us know whether you agree or disagree with the following statements? COMPARISON

I have seen this product advertised on TV recently 37%  Other members of my family or household would be interested in this 50% 24%I chose this because clusters appeal to me 51%  I selected this for me 54% 51%I would like to try this 64% 58%I like the colours and images on the box 65% 65%The flavour appeals to me 65% 55%I think the product looks tasty 70%  

I chose this because flakes appeal to me   46%

I think the product is healthy   56%

I like cereals with fruit combinations   49%

Existing Product

New Product

Page 131: A different road to brand experience

Results

• Able to advise which product to stock

• Significant additional insight

Page 132: A different road to brand experience

Typical project schedule / timing – it’s fast……..

Task Week Timing

Project sign-off / Order confirmation approved

Week 1

0

Draft script prepared 2

Script approved (no more amends) 1

Test link created and approved (rapidly)

1.5

Survey live (for one week) 0.5

Online reporting available

Week 2

1

Results review conference call / Analysis briefing

2

Survey closed 2

Analysis undertaken Week 3

4

Analysis amends 1

Page 133: A different road to brand experience

Final thoughts…

Page 134: A different road to brand experience

The Importance of Testing – Richard Benson

There are only two rules in direct marketing.

Rule 1: test everything. Rule 2: Refer to Rule 1

Secrets of Successful Direct Mail, 1989

Page 135: A different road to brand experience

Chris Combemale

Executive Director DMA

“The lengthy time is takes to learn and the cost of live testing has a negative impact on the effectiveness off line Direct Marketing.   The advent of the internet (and specifically panel based research) means it is no longer necessary to wait months to discover which creative approach, envelope or incentive will work best.............. 

Chris Combemale May 2011

Page 136: A different road to brand experience

Decisions marketers have to make

Variable How many Possible combinations

Audience 5 5

Offer 4 20

Incentive 4 80

Endorsement 3 240

Outer envelope 3 720

PS 4 2880

Payment term 4 11,520

Page 137: A different road to brand experience

Online research vs. Traditional Test (example – 2 creatives)

Cost Time

Offline £30k 100 days

Online £3k 10 days

• 1 / 10th of cost • 1 / 10th of the Time • 10 x the Insight

Page 138: A different road to brand experience

Thank you

Page 139: A different road to brand experience

In Home Sampling

Page 140: A different road to brand experience

Keeping the Consumer, Brand and Retailer Happy

Page 141: A different road to brand experience

Fresh Minds Research 2011

7%

72%

76%

77%

78%

83%

86%

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%

Do not wish to receive any type of unaddressed comms.

Free samples of sweets and chocolate

Free samples of hygiene and beauty products

Free samples of new food or drink products

Buy one get one free offers for local shops and supermarkets

Free samples of household products

Redeemable coupons for discounts at local shops and supermarkets

Which of the following types of free samples and offers are you happy to have delivered to you through your letterbox?

Page 142: A different road to brand experience

Door drop vouchers/coupons save consumers money and encourage trial

Money-off vouchers/coupons are rated very positively by UK adults.

A money off voucher/coupon saves consumers money something very important for those with tight budgets. It also provides consumers with an incentive to try something new.

Door drop vouchers/coupons are considered a practical monetary offering, which if unwanted is not a problem – can either be disposed of or passed onto a friend.

Why do you like to receive door drop vouchers/coupons?

I like to try new things if I can received a discount then that’s better.

Male, 45-54 yrs

Allows me to try new things or get money off which provides an incentive to purchase.

Female, 35-44 yrs

Lets me try new products and saves me money in the current economic climate.

Female, 55-64 yrs

Money off coupons are a great way to save on shopping bills when you are on a tight budget.

. Female, 55-64 yrs

I like having free samples and money-off vouchers through my door, mail that is put to good use and not just chucked away..

Female, 25-34 yrs

I prefer this because I can look at it at my leisure, either use the coupons or pass them on to somebody who might, then recycle the leaflet in the bin provided.

Female, 35-44 yrs

[Base door drop voucher/coupon=1,197]

Opportunity to either save money on known product, or try something new at no or little cost.

Male, 65-74 yrs

Page 143: A different road to brand experience

[Base door drop free samples=1,257]

Having the chance to try products before you buy is appreciated by consumers; both an enjoyable and convenient experience.

UK adults enjoy having the opportunity to try familiar or new products at no expense to them. This is viewed positively at the moment where household budgets might be tighter than usual.

If respondents do not personally want the free sample, many say they will pass it onto a friend; thus it is not considered a waste of time or an annoyance.

Why do you like to receive door drop free samples?

I'd rather a free sample posted to me than given out on the street.

Male, 25-34 yrs

It’s nice to be able to try something out for free before you decide to buy it..

Female, 54-64 yrs

A free sample gives me a chance to try something new without buying it at the risk of not liking it. Male, 45-54 yrs

Because it is a nice gesture, everyone enjoys receiving something free, especially me because I am a student and I don't always have a lot of money.. Female, 18-24 yrs

As it is a free item you can try it at home and if it is not to your liking then no harm or cost has been undertaken by you.

. Male, 35-44 yrs

Encourages me to try something new that I would not normally try. I (like many others) am currently on a tight budget, and shop carefully.

Female, 35-44 yrs

It's a pleasant surprise and if it's something i can't use i'll pass it on to someone else.

Female, 55-64 yrs

Door drop free samples are enjoyed by UK adults; offering a great way to try familiar or new products

Page 144: A different road to brand experience

When asked what the best thing respondents have ever received through their mail box, answers mainly included...

A large proportion of UK adults state the best thing they have received through their letter box are free samples:

Chocolates and sweetsCerealCoffeePet foodStationaryBeauty productsHousehold products

Money off vouchers are also popular:

2 for 1 restaurant vouchers or discountsMoney off restaurants Discounts off takeawaysDiscounts and offers for local supermarkets

Door drop free samples Door drop money off coupons and offers

[Base=2,008]

A free sample of tea. It was a completely different type than I usually drink, and we really enjoyed it.

Male, 25-34 yrs

Sample of Sanex shower gel. I have bought it ever since!

Female, 35-44 yrs

Meal for two at local restaurant in Malvern where we had a wonderful meal.

Male, 55-64 yrs

Buy one get two free offers on items I like, plus useful information about future offers or reductions.

Male, 25-34 yrs

Page 145: A different road to brand experience

The Shopper Marketing MixHas the pendulum swung too far?

Mismatch between where shopping decisions

are made and allocation of promotional budget

Page 146: A different road to brand experience

Between one third and half of purchasing decisions are made prior to leaving home

Source: Brainjuicer / Valassis research June 2007

Page 147: A different road to brand experience

81% of consumers will open a promotion which comes through the letterbox

Source: Brainjuicer / Valassis research June 2007

Page 148: A different road to brand experience

Brand Equity

Greater latitude to build brand equity with the consumer

vs

Page 149: A different road to brand experience

Or to put it another way…

vs

A noisy promotional environment…. ….. or your undivided attention

Page 150: A different road to brand experience

Supporting the Retailer

Asda shoppers

Sainsburys shoppers

Tesco shoppers

Page 151: A different road to brand experience

Summary

Page 152: A different road to brand experience

Direct Marketing Supplier of the Year 2010, 2011 & 2012

The COGS – in association with Promotional Marketingand The Institute of Promotional Marketing

Gold DMA Award 2011 – Best Customer Acquisition

Silver DMA Award 2011 – Best Use of Door Drops

2012 – TNT Post elected to Presidency of European Letterbox Marketing Association

Page 153: A different road to brand experience

Thank you…… to all of today’s speakers:

Nick Wells, TNT Post

Jo Hyland, TNT Post

Beth Armstrong, Kellogg’s

Joanne Higginson, Dunnhumby

Ian Steen, Valassis

David Cole, Fast.map

Duncan Slater, Origin Creative (APS Group)

Stephen Shaw, Blippar

Mark Davies, TNT Post

Page 154: A different road to brand experience

Please join us for drinks & Canapés courtesy of

Please hand all completed evaluation forms to the registration desk.