2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)

7/24/2019 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)

1/57

! # !

!"#$%& ($)$%( ($*#+$ +,!*$

%)($%*" ($*#+$ ,- "%. /,*0

%&'() *%&+,)-

!"#$%&$''-

./

'0(1,2 )131,) 2,43+15,01 &*

6')1(7,-

()')%*#%&/

#8!79!:;:< =6>?=+%5?

&%+1)*)$#," ,- 1,!#( -1,*%(

(- %&'() *%&+,)- @AB+,- /) 4CDEF@EGG- HBICDJB DK GLCCLMK N

#/ ( DO D PLQJFDCEK@ DFH DF [email protected]@/ ( RQSCEKA @AB LFCEFB FBMK TBS KE@B-

4JLUJBKK VQBBFK/ ( DCKL ODEF@DEF DFH LMF KB.BJDC RLCE@EIDC DFH [email protected]@ SCLUK LF @AB

(F@BJFB@/ ( GECBH @AB *EJK@ *&(3 +BWQBK@- DK HBGEFBH EF @AB DIILORDFXEFU RCBDHEFUK- LF YZ

3RJEC :Z#Y- ME@A @AB 2BGBFHDF@ 'FE@BH )@D@BK 2BRDJ@OBF@ LG 6QK@EIB =@AB [2&6\?/ ( GECBH

@AB )BILFH *&(3 +BWQBK@ ME@A @AB 7E.EC +EUA@K 2E.EKELF LG @AB 2&6 LF :Z &I@LSBJ :Z#8 EF

DF BGGLJ@ @L [ICLKB @AB CLLR\ LF @AB JBILJHK SBEFU JBWQBK@BH GJLO @AB 2&6/

:/

( JD@EGX DK GDI@K DCC LG @AB K@D@BOBF@K ODHB SX 4CDEF@EGG EF @AB 3OBFHBH

7LORCDEF@- RDJ@EIQCDJCX- SQ@ ME@ALQ@ B]ICQKE.E@X- DCC LG @AB K@D@BOBF@K RBJ@DEFEFU @L

4CDEF@EGG^K BGGLJ@K @L FBUL@ED@B ME@A @AB 2&6 GLJ @AB JBCBDKB LG JBILJHK JBKRLFKE.B @L @AB

*EJK@ *&(3 +BWQBK@/ =2_@/ 0L/ #8?/

Y/

,]IBR@ GLJ OEFLJ DFH JBDKLFDSCB DCCLMDFIBK GLJ @XRLUJDRAEIDC BJJLJK- (

JD@EGX DK GDI@K DCC LG @AB K@D@BOBF@K ODHB SX 4CDEF@EGG EF DCC LG @AB HLIQOBF@K GECBH SX

4CDEF@EGG EF @AB HLI_B@ ME@A @AEK 7LQJ@- DFH ( D@@BK@ @L DCC HLIQOBF@K GECBH SX 4CDEF@EGG EF

@AB HLI_B@ ME@A @AEK 7LQJ@ DK @JQB DFH ILJJBI@ ILREBK LG KQIA HLIQOBF@K/

Case 1:15-cv-02627-JG-RLM Document 33 Filed 02/24/16 Page 1 of 57 PageID #: 1699


2/57

! : !

`/

1AEK HBICDJD@ELF DFH @AB B]AESE@K DFFB]BH ABJB@L KQSOE@@BH EF KQRRLJ@

LG 4CDEF@EGG^K LRRLKE@ELF OL@ELF DFH 4CDEF@EGG^K IJLKK!OL@ELF GLJ KDFI@ELFK DJB @JQB ILREBK

LG @AB HLIQOBF@K EF RLKKBKKELF LG 4CDEF@EGG/

5/

3@@DIABH ABJB@L DK ,]AESE@ 5 EK D @JQB DFH ILJJBI@ ILRX LG N,]IBJR@ GJLO :Z#8!#Z!#; 7LFGBJBFIB 7DCC SB@MBBF 4CDEF@EGG %LQEK *CLJBK DFH

2BGBFKB 7LQFKBC +Q_AKDFDA )EFUA- ,KW/

0/

3@@DIABH ABJB@L DK ,]AESE@ 0 EK D @JQB DFH ILJJBI@ ILRX LG N

1AB GEJK@ CLFU!GLJO DJ@EICB ( AD.B MJE@@BF- SDKBH LF @AB GBM JBKRLFKE.B

HLIQOBF@K RJLHQIBH EF @AB )BILFH *&(3 +BKRLFKB- B.EHBFIEFU @AB GDI@ @AD@ @AB

>L.BJFOBF@ EK FL@ SBEFU @JDFKRDJBF@ DSLQ@ @AB UQEHBCEFBK E@ GLCCLMK EF @AB

RJLKBIQ@ELF LG [email protected]@K/ 1AEK RJBKK JBRLJ@ EK D.DECDSCB LFCEFB/ 0)) %LQEK *CLJBK-

1)*),#" 23$*)"$%)/ '-, &4) +,-/)53&$-% -' #5&$6$/&/ #++)#, &- ,)5-%/&,35& # ")2#"

',#7)8-,9 "-/& 3%*), &4) 07$&4 :5&- 4JLUJBKK VQBBFK =#Y *BSJQDJX :Z#;?-

A@@RNaaMMM/RJLUJBKKWQBBFK/ILOaFBMKa:Z#;a:a#YaGBHBJDC!UQEHBCEFBK!GLJ!

@AB!RJLKBIQ@[email protected]@K!DRRBDJ!@L!JBILFK@JQI@!D!CBUDC!GJDOBMLJ_!CLK@!QFHBJ! @AB!KOE@A!DI@/

(F DIILJHDFIB ME@A :b '/)/7/ c #


3/57

EXHIBIT M



4/57

"#$%&'%(()* +,-%.%' /

Page M-1

0#123* 45 678 9:;


5/57

"#$%&'%(()* +,-%.%' /

Page M-2

012#$3$'%4&5 '-1 613*4& 7-4 24&892'18 '-1 *1$32- 634:%818 '-1 1,$2'

#$&;9$;1 4( ?@ A1B91*' $&8 C $&8 #1')* *11 -1315 %' *$J)* 4< 7%##%&; '4 %&8%2$'1 '-$' &4 312438* 7131

(49&85 .12$9*1 '-$')* E%&8 4( '74 8%((131&' '-%&;*G

AM N1##5 ? '-%&E 7-$' '-1 012#$3$'%4&* *$< %* '-$' &4 312438* 7131 (49&8G O-1

'-%&; 7%'- 7-1'-13 &4 8429F1&'* 1,%*' 9&813 =>?@ #$75 '-131 F$< .1

8429F1&'* 49' '-131 %& '-1 743#8 '-$' 71 749#8 &4' .1 $7$31 4(5 $&8 $* #4&;

$* 71 84 $ 8%#%;1&' *1$32-5 '-1& 71 -$:1 (9#(%##18 493 4.#%;$'%4&* 9&813 =>?@G

M45 ? 84&)' 312$## '-1 J98;1 *612%(%2$##< $*E%&; $' '-1 K4&(131&21 7-1'-13 &4

8429F1&'* 1,%*'5 7-4#1*$#15 43 7-1'-13 &4 312438* 7131 (49&8G P9'5 &4

312438* 7131 (49&8G ? 2$& '1##


6/57

"#$%&'%(()* +,-%.%' /

Page M-3

!"# %&' ()*'+,-.'/ 01+2*'31,)4*5 6'-'4+'

01 2#*34 #335%&6 $' '-7 1892 :7;7=7 67&7=$# =7;$%' (3= '-7

/$6%*'=$'7 D7 H 9 E3&)' '-%&5 '-7 /$6%*'=$'7 D


7/57

"#$%&'%(()* +,-%.%' /

Page M-4

!""# %&' ()* +,', -&' (.,/0'-.12304 5'6'3,' -1 70'3-' )89:,/3-.12

01 23435 .6' 78%&7 .$9: '8 '-; %**6; 8( '-$' (%


8/57

"#$%&'%(()* +,-%.%' /

Page M-5

01 2 3&456*'$&4 '-$' 78%&'9 :-$' 2); '5##%&< =83 %* '-$' >5 $65 &8' 3*%&< '-5

?%*@65'%8&$6= 05#5$*5 %& 7#$@5 8( '-5 AB2C 05*78&*59 D-5 AB2C 05*78&*5

>$* '-$' '-565 >565 &8 65@864* #8@$'54 (8##8>%&< '-5 *5$6@-9 C&4 '-5& '-5

?%*@65'%8&$6= 05#5$*5 >$* 768E%454F .5@$3*5 =836 65G35*' 65#$'54 '8 '-5

H-8% 768*5@3'%8&F $&4 >5 '-83-$' 2 65G35*'54 $' '-5 4$'5 8( '-5 2&%'%$#

H8&(565&@59 2 4%4 $*J '-5 /$%'- -569

EF P?J'9 Q89 RST9



9/57

"#$%&'%(()* +,-%.%' /

Page M-6

!"# %&' ()* +, !-./0+.- 1&' 2'34',1 5/0 6'.'078 64+9'8+.', :/0

1&' ;0/,'7D37*' %* '-$' '-%* %* 6A $.63' 0'H

O$&%7# ' 7 B0+C+.78 (+>+,+/.

01 27*%:7* '-7 +BQNC '-$' =6J7;* '-7 OH


10/57

"#$%&'%(()* +,-%.%' /

Page M-7

01 2 3& '-4 #4''45 (567 #$*' &%8-' 9

:; 3& 2 3 '-%&< %')* '=6 2 '-454)* $ (>## 1?3@ A6&'$A' #%*'B $&C %' %'47%*4* '-4

C%((454&' C4D$5'74&'*E F>' '-4 G5%7%&$# H%I%*%6& %* '-4 C%I%*%6&B =-%A- =6>#C

-$I4 %&(657$'%6& 54#$'4C '6 '-4 D56*4A>'%6& 6( $A'%I%*'*E

01 @&C %* '-$' '-4 6((%A4 >&C45 '-4 @**%*'$&' 2 %* '-$' >&C45 '-4 ?((%A4 6( '-4

@**%*'$&' @''65&4J K4&45$# 9

:; L4*B *6 '-4 ?((%A4 6( '-4 @**%*'$&' @''65&4J K4&45$# %* 4**4&'%$##J '-4 -4$C

D6#%AJ $&C 4&(65A474&' *4A'%6& 6( '-4 G5%7%&$# H%I%*%6&E M-4 D6#%A%4*

65%8%&$'4 (567 '-$' 6((%A4E M-$')* =-J '-$' 6((%A4 =$* *4$5A-4CE

1>## 54A65C%&8 A$& .4 -4$5C 6%&4 N !""#$%&&'(()'*&+,-./0



11/57

EXHIBIT N



12/57

24/02/2016ederal guidelines for the prosecution of activists appear to reconstruct a legal framework lost under the Smith Act Progress Queens

Page 1ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-for-ts-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act

PROGR SS QU NS

T R N S P R E N C Y I N P O L I T I C S

H O M E N E W S E D I T O R I A L C A L E N D AR S P E C I A L R E P O R T S N O T I C I A S V O T E T W I T T E R

C O N TA C T A D V E R T I S E D O N A T E

Federal guidelines for the

prosecution of activists appear

to reconstruct a legal

framework lost under the

Smith Act!"#$%&$' )*+ ,-).

A special investigation

SHARE ON TWITTER AND GOOGLE

Tweet

!

TUMBLR

/&0" 1%$" 23 45152 &67 #3308&$0 3%$ 9%8#:$

;3$ 562"$"1256< 56;3$8&2536+ 56=:%756< :5601 23

6">1 &$25=:"1 632 ?%#:51@"7 #' A$3


13/57



! #$%&'$()'*+!, -.'#/!*+%0 !%1 +%()*&2)%&

')*&'+#&+$%* 3+,, &/!&4 +5 -!**)1 36 &/) %)7 6$'8 *&!&)

!**)23,64 7+,, 0$ 3)5$') 0$(9 !"#$%& ()*+*:1;%)7

6$'8< :$55+#+!, -/$&$0'!-/=%)7 6$'8 *&!&)=-.3,+#

1$2!+%< 5$' /+* #$%*+1)'!&+$%9 &/) -'$-$*)1 3+,,

7$.,1 )2-$7)' %)7 6$'8 *&!&) $55+#) $5 0)%)'!,

)'(+#)* #$22+**+$%)' $*!"" #%,-.-*:%$& -+#&.')1* $55+#)=-.3,+# 1$2!+%< 7$.,1 3)$'#)1 &$ #$%*.,& &/) ,+*& !%1 3!% !%6 *&!&)

%()*&2)%& !#&+(+&+)* 7+&/ *.#/ +%1+(+1.!,*4

#$'-$'!&+$%*4 !%1 0'$.-*9 +5 /.2!% '+0/&* !#&+(+*&*

!') +1)%&+5+)1 $% *.#/ ! ,+*&4 &/)+' !1($#!#6 #!'))'*

#$.,1 3) &!'%+*/)1 36 ! *&!&);*-$%*$')1 )55$'& &$

')&!,+!&) !0!+%*& !#&+(+*&* 3!*)1 $% &/)+' !#&+(+*29

&/)') +* %$ +%5$'2!&+$% !3$.& /$7 $0* #$22+**+$%)'

1)*&+&$ 7+,, #$2-+,) *.#/ ! ,+*&4 3.& !#&+(+*&* /!()

#$2-,!+%)1 &/!& &/) )?+*&)%#) $5 *.#/ ! ,+*& 2!6 ,)!1

&$ ! 2$1)'%;1!6 2##!'&/6+&) 7+/ /.%& $5 /.2!%

'+0/&* !#&+(+*&*9 $%) $5 &/) ,)!1 *-$%*$'* $5 &/) *&!&)

)%!&) 3+,, 7!* *&!&) *)%9 ,.+(/! 2%1#%$:1;3'$$8,6%( (8.( "2 '&( . 1&5%,#(# .'9 .11>4.(#

#%4#2#'(.("&' &* (8# "5%.1( &* (8# %4&%&2#9 F#$ G&4H

I(.(# ,"2( &* -&/1&B .1("!"2(23 .11&49"'< (& 4#1&492 &-(."'#9

4&5 (8# MNO: PQ"2("'< R#9#4., ,.$ 1(2 (8#

NTI 7&55"22"&'#4 (& '&("*/ (8# .1("!"2(2 (8.( (8# .1("!"2(2

8.!# -##' "9#'("U#9 .'9 %,.1#9 &' (8# %>418.2#

#2(4"1("&'2 ,"2( (& ("&' *&4 $8.( 1&>,9 -# (8# 2.5# &4 2"5",.4

.1("!"25: F&( &',/ "2 (8#4# . ,.1H &* . R#9#4., '&("U1.("&'

&4 4#2%&'2# 4#V>"4#5#'(23 ->( R#9#4., "'!#2("9"'< "'!&,!"'< (8#

LINK LIST

+(,.'("1 G.492W?.1"U1 ?.4H X#%&4(

7,#.' K% O.5."1.3 @>##'2 F&$

P(8"12 +"'Y( ?4#B/

F#$ G&4H 7"(/ 7&>'1", S.(18

A8# ?#' "2 6"4 #5.", .994#22\

I>-214"-#

M#,"!#4#9 -/ R##9L>4'#4

https://feedburner.google.com/http://www.willetspoint.org/http://www.welcome2thebronx.com/wordpress/http://www.savenyc.nyc/http://robertreich.org/http://queenscrap.blogspot.com/http://sullio.blogspot.com/http://citycouncilwatch.net/http://ethicsaintpretty.blogspot.com/https://cleanupjamaicaqueens.wordpress.com/http://atlanticyardsreport.blogspot.com/


18/57



!"# %& '#(#)*+ ,-.#"/,0*/,%-"1 2),-3,2*++4 3%-(!3/#( 54 /6#

!"#"$%& ()$"%) *+ ,-."/012%01*-1 %) '781 *3/,-0 /%

#2)#"#-/ '#(#)*+ ,-/#)#"/" ,- /6# 2)%/#3/,%- %& /6#

2)%2#)/4 %& &%)#,0- 0%.#)-9#-/": ;-( /6," '78

-.%+.#9#-/ 3*- /*+#( 54 /6# 2!5+,"6#) %& A)%0)#"" O!##-"1 -%) 6*"

6# PRQ *-"=#)#( S!#"/,%-" &%++%=,-0 * (!# (,+,0#-3#

#.,#= %& /6# = )#"2%-",.# )#3%)(" 2)%(!3#( 54 /6#

T%.#)-9#-/: U#.#)/6#+#""1 *33%)(,-0 /% /6# ,-&%)9*/,%-

2)%.,(#( /6!" &*)1 /6# &%++%=,-0 *-*+4"," %& )#3%)(" *-(

-&%)9*/,%- 3*- 5# 9*(#:

'%++%=,-0 *- #V2+,3*/,%- %& /6# /6)## "#3/,%-" &)%9 /6#

JK;N:

USAM 9-65.880 : DEMONSTRATIONS

@6# *22+,3*5+# '#(#)*+ +#0*+ "/*/!/# /6*/ 0%.#)-" +*=

http://www.justice.gov/usam/united-states-attorneys-manual


19/57



!"#$%&!'!"( *"+!,(*-.(*$", ."/ 0%$,!&1(*$", *, 23 4565

7$/! 8 9:;< =>*&> "$'*".??@ &$/*A!, (>! 0%$(!&(*$" $#

0%$0!%(@ $&&10*!/ B@ #$%!*-" -$+!%"'!"(,5 C" ?$$D*"- .(

3 4565 7$/! 8 9:;< (>! E!/!%.? 0%$,!&1($%, #%$' (>! !"#"

$%&'()*+, ./0)< $% 46FG< "$%'.??@ ?$$D .( +*$?.(*$",

$&&1%%*"- /1%*"- /!'$",(%.(*$", $# ,*H.B?! "1'B!%, $#0!$0?! (>.( '.@ *"+$?+! (>! 0%$0!%(@ $# #$%!*-"

-$+!%"'!"(,< ?*D! .( !'B.,,*!, $% '*,,*$",5 C" ,1&>

",(."&!,< (>! 46FG .??$=, ?$&.? 0$?*&! /!0.%('!"(, ($

'.*"(.*" $%/!% ."/ ($ '.D! .%%!,(,< *# "!&!,,.%@5 C( &." B!

.*/ (>.( (>! 46FG -*+!, *(, *'0?*&*( .00%$+.? #$% 0$?*&*"-

."/ .%%!,(, B@ .??$=*"- ?$&.? 0$?*&! /!0.%('!"(, ($ (.D!

>! ?!./5 I+!" ,$< (>! 46FG *, "$( %!?*!+!/ $# *(,

!,0$",*B*?*(*!, =>!" *( .??$=, ?$&.? 0$?*&! /!0.%('!"(, ($

.D! (>! ?!./ *" 0$?*&*"- ."/ (>! '.D*"- $# .%%!,(,< *#

"!&!,,.%@5 J>! 46FGK, %!,0$",*B*?*(*!, &$''!"&! B@

0.%(*&*0.(*"- *" &$$%/*".(!/ *"(!??*-!"&! ,>.%*"- $"

L0$(!"(*.? /*,(1%B."&!, ?*D!?@ ($ .M!&( . #$%!*-" #.&*?*(@

."/ .%%."-!'!"(, #$% "!!/!/ ?.= !"#$%&!'!"( %!,0$",!5N

J>1,< !+!" *# (>! 46FG .??$=, ?$&.? 0$?*&! /!0.%('!"(,

$ (.D! (>! ?!./ $" 0$?*&*"- $# /!'$",(%.(*$", .M!&(*"-

$%!*-" #.&*?*(*!, $% #$%!*-" 0%$0!%(*!,< (>! 46FG '1,(

.O!"/ ($ (>! !P&>."-! $# *"(!??*-!"&! ."/ (>! .%%."-!'!"(

$# ?.= !"#$%&!'!"( %!,0$",!5

J>! 46FG 0%!Q0?.", #$% ." $,,1,23(2 !"#" $%&'()*< $%

F46F< ($ B! .,,*-"!/ ($ '$"*($% (>! /!'$",(%.(*$"5 E$%

1&> /!'$",(%.(*$",< (>! ERC< /*,0.(&>!, $B,!%+!%, ($ (>!

&!"!< ."/ (>! ERC $B,!%+!%, 0%$+*/! ,0$( %!0$%(, ($ (>!

F46F5 C# (>! 46FG /$!, "$( 0%!Q0?." #$% ." F46F ($ B!

.,,*-"!/ ($ . /!'$",(%.(*$"< (>!"< 10$" "$(*A&.(*$" $# .

/!'$",(%.(*$" ?*D!?@ ($ %!,1?( *" . /*,(1%B."&!< (>!" (>!

46FG ,>$1?/ .,,*-" ." F46F ($ '$"*($% (>!

/!'$",(%.(*$"5 S$(! (>.( (>! 46FG "$%'.??@ &$",*/!%,

/!'$",(%.(*$", 1"/!% (>! .00?*&.B?! ?.= ($ *"+$?+!

*H.B?! "1'B!%, $# 0!$0?!5 J>!%!#$%!< *( &." 0%$B.B?@ B!

https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/970


20/57



"#$ &'"& "(( $)*+,!&-"+,! +. !/0' !#1) 2+/($ 3) (#4)(5 &+

)!/(& #, " $#!&/-3",0) +. !+*) 4#,$6 !/0' "! "7)0,8

&-))& &-"90 +- &') /!) +. !#$)2"(4!6 )&0: ;')-).+-)6 &')

2+-$#,8 #, &') ? )@#!&! &+ &-#88)- &') "!!#8,#,8 +. ",

> ",$ &') $#!A"&0' +. BCD +3!)-E)-! .+- "(( ("-8)

$)*+,!&-"+,! &'"& *"5 3) ')($ "& .+-)#8, ."0#(#)! +-,E+(E) .+-)#8, A-+A)-)!6 (#4) )*3"!!#)! +- *#!!#+,!6 .+-

)@"*A():

;') 2+-$#,8 #, &') ? 0"!& E#+("+,! +. &') ("2

A-+&)0,8 .+-)#8, ."0#(#)! +- .+-)#8, A-+A)-)! &+ 3) ",

)@&),!#+, +. E#+("+,! +. (+0"( ("26 ",$ &') 2+-$#,8 #, &')

? '#8'(#8'&! ", )@A)0&"+, &'"& (+0"( A+(#0)

$)A"-&*),&! 2#(( *"4) "--)!&! .+- &'+!) E#+("+,! +. &')

+0"( ("2: D, #,!&",0)! 2')-) &')-) #! ,+ (+0"( ("2 &'"&

+/($ 3) /!)$ .+- E#+("+,! +. &') .)$)-"( ("2 A-+&)0,8

+-)#8, ."0#(#)! +- .+-)#8, A-+A)-)!6 &'), &') ?

"/&'+-#!)! "--)!&! /,$)- &') .)$)-"( ("2 2#&'+/& ("2

),.+-0)*),& '"E#,8 &+ +3&"#, ",5 A-#+- "/&'+-#!"+, .-+*

') !"#$#%&' )#*#+#,%+. &') FGH: >00+-$#,8 &+

,.+-*"+, +3&"#,)$ 35 I-+8-)!! J/)),! $/-#,8

,)8+"+,! 2#&' &') FGH6 A+(#05 +. &') K-#*#,"( F#E#!#+,

! !)& 35 &') -./0 ,1 230 4++#+2&%2 45,"%06 70%0"&':

>(&'+/8' MN


21/57


Page 10ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-forts-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act

!"#$%&'()! &+ !),+-#&.%&"+-# &+ +/&%"- #$+& .)$+. %.)

-+& "- 1-"2+.,3 4(1#0 &()5 %'& %# +/#).6).# "- 7$8%"-9

8+&()#3: ;''+.!"-< &+ &() ? +/#).6).# A+.)1-"2+.,#0 &() "!)-&"B'%&"+- +2 &()". )C$8"'"& $.)#)-')

A+18! '.)%&) .)#"#&%-') &+ &()". A+.@3 ?- )C')$&"+-%8

".'1,#&%-')#0 8"@) % ,),/). +2 % 2+.)"?

+/#).6). +. +/#).6).# A+18! /) )C$)'&)! &+ &%@)

$.+&)'&"6) ,)%#1.)# 2+. $.+&)'&)! 2+.)"


22/57



!"#$% '( ) *'++$,-" .$'-)%$'/0 )#" 1'23!"/%"1 $/ %4" 5678+

"*'#% '( %4" 1"!'/+%#)%$'/9

:4"+" ;3$1"-$/"+ )#" +$-"/% ),'3% 1"!'/+%#)%$'/+ %4)% 1'

/'% $/.'-." +$+9


PROCEDURES

:4" B'#1$/; $/ %4$+ +"2%$'/ '( %4" ?@=C $+ 2'!*-"D0 )/1

% B)+ *#',),-> 1'/" $/%"/%$'/)-->9

E/2" %4" 567 #"2"$."+ $/('#!)%$'/ $/1$2)%$/; ) .$'-)%$'/ '#

*'%"/%$)- .$'-)%$'/ '( %4" ("1"#)- -)B *#'%"2%$/; ('#"$;/

)2$-$%$"+ '# ('#"$;/ *#'*"#%$"+0 %4" 567 B$-- /'%$(> %4" !"#"

$%&'()*%+) -. #)')%)/1 B$-- 2'/+3-% B$%4 %4" )**#'*#$)%"

?9@9 =A'#/">9 = 1"!'/+%#)%$'/ $+ 2'1"1 %' ," ) .$'-)%$'/

'# *'%"/%$)- .$'-)%$'/ '( %4" ("1"#)- -)B *#'%"2%$/; ('#"$;/

)2$-$%$"+ '# ('#"$;/ *#'*"#%$"+9 =22'#1$/; %' %4";3$1"-$/"+0 %4" 567 B$-- $/$%$)%" )/ $/."+%$;)%$'/ F)+ $+

1""!"1 /"2"++)#> $( $% $+ 1"%"#!$/"1 %4)% 5"1"#)- *#"+"/2"

+ B)##)/%"10G B$%4'3% H3)-$(>$/; 4'B %4)% $+ 1"%"#!$/"19

:4" 2'/%)2% B$%4 %4" I"*)#%!"/% '( @%)%" $+ /'!$/)-->

1"+2#$,"1 )+ F/'%$J2)%$'/0G 4'B"."#0 $( %4" I"*)#%!"/% '(

@%)%" 1$1 /'% #"H3$#" )/ $/."+%$;)%$'/0 %4" %$!" %4)% %4"

I"*)#%!"/% '( @%)%" B'3-1 !)K" %4)% K/'B/ B'3-1 ,"

B4"/ %4" 567 /'%$J"1 %4" I"*)#%!"/% '( @%)%" '( ).$'-)%$'/ '# *'%"/%$)- .$'-)%$'/ '( %4" 5"1"#)- -)B9 7/1""10

B4"/ %4" ?9@9 =A'#/"> $+ /'% 2"#%)$/ )+ %' B4"%4"# F%4"

/2$1"/% B$-- )1."#+"-> )L"2% %4" ('#"$;/ #"-)%$'/+ '( %4"

?/$%"1 @%)%"+0G %4" ?9@9 =A'#/"> $+ *#'.$1"1 ) 4'%-$/" %'

4" I"*)#%!"/% '( @%)%"0 %4)% B$-- 2'//"2% %4" ?9@9



23/57



!"#$%&' )*+, +,& -..$#.$*-+& /&.-$+0&%+ #1 2+-+& #34*-5

)*+, ),#0 +# 4#%675+8 9&$&: +,& 4#;& )#$; 1#$

;&0#%6+$-+*#% 6,*1+6 1$#0 #1 ?&;&$-5 5-) .$#+&4+*%@ 1#$&*@% 1-4*5*+*&6 #$

#$&*@% .$#.&$+*&6: +# -% +,-+


24/57



!"#"$%& #()*+)(,(+-./ 0&,1+231 ,1" 4%**$+*$(%," 5-(,"#

6,%,") %2,1+$(,(")/ (- -+, )*"&&"# +2, 1"$"7 *$")28%9&: ,1()

++*) 9%;< 2* ,+ ,1" =$(8(-%& >(?()(+- +@ ,1" >AB7 ,1"

")*";,(?" 5.6. 0C+$-": (-?+&?"# (- ,1" (-?"),(3%,(+-7 ,1"

5.6. 6";$", 6"$?(;"7 %-# ,1" >"*%$,8"-, +@ 6,%," 4D(,1+2,

#"&%:./

E1"- 4,1" +F"-)"/ () +@ % -%,2$" ,1%, 8"$(,) !"#"$%&

*$+)";2,(+-7 ,1" (-?"),(3%,(+- )1+2 9" ;+-#2;,"#

D(,1+2, $"3%$# @+$ D1",1"$ 4,1" *"$,(-"-, @+$"(3- +G;(%&)

D(&& %3$"" ,+ %**"%$ %) D(,-"))") %, %- "-)2(-3 ,$(%&./

H"$"7 ,1" ;+#" @+$ % #"8+-),$%,(+- 1%) )1(@,"# ,+ 4,1"

+F"-)"./ A-;" ,1" (-?"),(3%,(+- 1%) (#"-,(I"# % )29J";,7

%-# +-;" ,1" (-?"),(3%,(+- 1%) %;;282&%,"# )2G;("-,

"?(#"-;" 4,+ @+$8 ,1" 9%)() @+$ !"#"$%& ;1%$3")7/

-?"),(3%,+$) )1+2 8%


25/57



!"#$%&'(#"$ *%+%" (,% ("-./0 #+ &".1./23 &,2"0%$ (# 3#&23

!"#$%&'(#"$4 (,%"% &2/ 5% $2.* (# 5% 2/ .1!3.&.( 2*1.$$.#/

,2( (,% 2'(#12(.& (".00%"./0 #+ 6%*%"23 #7%"$.0,( #7%"

2&(.7.$($ %/020./0 ./ 3#&23 *%1#/$("2(.#/$ 12- 5%

%/$/2"./0 2&(.7.$($ +#" !#(%/(.23 6%*%"23 $&"'(./-4 %7%/

,#'0, *%1#/$("2(.#/$ 12- /%7%" "%$'3( ./ (,% 5"./0./0 #+6%*%"23 &,2"0%$89

:#(;.(,$(2/*./0 (,% *%+%""23 5- 6%*%"23 !"#$%&'(#"$ #+

".1./23 &,2"0%$ (# 3#&23 !"#$%&'(#"$4 (,% ?

0'.*%3./%$ 0.7%$ @A$ (,% *.$&"%(.#/ (# ./$'"% (,2( (,%

6BC ;.33 1#/.(#" (,% !"#0"%$$ #+ (,% 3#&23 !"#$%&'(.#/4

0.7./0 (,% 6BC D'2$.E#7%"$.0,( #7%" 3#&23 !"#$%&'(#"$8 C/

/$(2/&%$ ;,%"% (,% 3#&23 !"#$%&'(#" $,#'3* *"#! &".1./23

,2"0%$ 202./$( 2/ 2&(.7.$(4 (,% @ $,#'3* "%F723'2(%

,% 12G%"4 2/* H2 /%; !"#$%&'(.7% *%(%"1./2(.#/ $,#'3*

5% "%/*%"%*4I 1%2/./0 (,2(4 %7%/ .+ 2/ 2&(.7.$( ,2* 5%%/

&"'(./.$%* 5- 6%*%"23 !"#$%&'(#"$4 5'( (,% 12G%" ;2$

*%+%""%* (# 3#&23 !"#$%&'(#"$4 5%+#"% (,% 2&(.7.$( &2/ 5%

#1!3%(%3- &3%2"%* #+ 2/- &,2"0%$ *"#!!%* 5- 3#&23

!"#$%&'(#"$4 (,% 6%*%"23 !"#$%&'(#"$ 2( (,% @ 2"%

0.7%/ 2/ #!!#"('/.(- (# /$.*%" (,% 5"././0 #+ 6%*%"23

".1./23 &,2"0%$ 202./$( (,% 2&(.7.$( 2/%;8

:#/% #+ (,% !"#&%*'"%$ /#(%* ./ J KELM8NNO 2"% /#(%* ./ J

KELM8NNP8


NVESTIGATIVE DECISIONS BY U.S. ATTORNEYS

Q#&23 !#3.&% *%!2"(1%/($ ,27% "%D'."%1%/($ +#" 2/* 0.7%/$("'&(.#/$ ./ "%$!%&( #+ *%1#/$("2(.#/$ 5- 2&(.7.$($8

6'"(,%"1#"%4 (,% ? 0'.*%3./%$ ./*.&2(% (,2( 6BC

20%/($ ;.33 %R!32./ 6%*%"23 32;$ (# 2&(.7.$($8 6%*%"23 32;

%/+#"&%1%/( #S&.23$ %R!%&( (,2( 2&(.7.$($ ;.33 2G%1!( (#

#1!3- ;.(, (,% "%D'."%1%/($4 (,% ./$("'&(.#/$4 2/* (,%



26/57



!"#$%&%'()& )+ ,!-!.%$ $%/01 23!& % -!4)&0'.%'()& 56

%7'(8(0'0 (0 -!!4!- ') 5! 97$!%.$6 )5:!7'()&%5$!; 56

&8!0'(7'(&< %& !&'.%&7! ') %

5>($-(&


27/57



!"#$%&'$&() +$!,%-.$// "0 (1$ 2'3,.,&4$ 3$(5$$&

,4(6,.2(7 "0 ,&7 8"($&(2,. '2&"% #2".,(2"&/ "0 ."4,. .,5/ "%

"%-2&,&4$/ ,&- , 8$%4$8(2"& (1,( (1$/$ #2".,(2"&/ ',7

"'$1"5 2'8,4( 9):) 0"%$2!& %$.,(2"&/; (1$ 9:&"5.$-!$ (1,( ."4,. 8".24$

-$8,%('$&(/ 52.. $&0"%4$ (1$ ."4,. .,5/ "% "%-2&,&4$/)?1$ 9):)

(,(6("%7 ,6(1"%2(7 (" 3%2&! 41,%!$/ ,!,2&/( ,4(2#2/(/) B&

641 4,/$/; "% 51$%$ C$-$%,. ,4(2"& 2/ -$$'$- &$4$//,%7;

1$ 9):)


28/57



!"# %&'( #)*"#%+ %&) *#)(( ",-) ."# %&) /010 23"#4)56(

7,-) ."# 8)9 :"#;6( ("4 '4='->%'"4 %&>% *)#&>*( %&) H7I

C>5 4"% .B@) %" -#'C'4>@ *#"()-4 '4%)#D')9 ."# %&'( #)*"#%0

G&)#) '( >4"%&)#+ C#?)#+ ?#>5 >#)> 9&)4 >-%'D'(C

&>% '4-@5 B) -"4('=)#)= B5

!)=)#>@ @>9 )4."#-)C)4% ",-'>@( %" -"4(%'%( %)##"#'(% ?#"-%'D'(% C>5 >@#)>=5 B) (


29/57



!"#$%$&'% $' $'#"%)$*+)&!, *-$."/$'"% +00/$1+2/" )&

)3" 4"."!+/ 2-!"+- &4 $'#"%)$*+)$&'5 &! 42$6 )3"%"

'#"%)$*+)&!, *-$."/$'"% 7"!" 0!&8-/*+)". 2, )3"

&44$1" &4 )3" -6%6 +))&!'", *"'"!+/6 $' 9::95 4&!8"!

+))&!'", *"'"!+/ !"#$%&' !)*%+&,;'&) 0$1)-!".5 4&!8"! +))&!'", *"'"!+/ -.$/ %+$#0.12

&44$1$+/ 03&)&*!+03?-%.&@?7$A$0".$+?0-2/$1 .&8+$'"9;- 6"++,.;@ *%$1($ A+"'$

6";,(,*1; -,+*"',(3 (3$& M(1($

M$&1("% L.1'17 L(3$% 1*(,#,+(+ 31- .$$& A1*(,#$ ,& ;1."%

9&,"&+/0 >3,*3 31- +966"%($- M(1($ M$&1("% L.1'1N+

6";,(,*1; %,+$/ (3$ 1%(,*;$ &"($-7 O$(/ (3$ %$6"%( ,& 23$

P1+3,&!("& 5"+( ,'6%".1.;@ %1,+$- (3$ Q9$+(,"& 1."9(

>3$(3$% 5%$+,-$&( L.1'1 >1+ $#$& 1>1%$ "< (3$ 6%".$ ""9;- 31#$ %$Q9,%$-

6";,(,*1; *;$1%1&*$ "< +"'$ +"%(7 R9%,&! (3$ ($%' "<


35/57


Page 24ttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-fors-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act

!"#$%$&' )*+ &,-."+ &!$/ #*!#0 1+2+.!3340 $2 &-"*

2%+$1!#$,2&0 #*+ 567 ",2/-"#& #*+ $2%+$1!#$,2&0 !2/

5+/+.!3 8.,&+"-#,.& 9$#* #*+ :';' ?@"+&

9,-3/ A,33,9 #*+ B!2-!3 $2 .+&8+"# ,A #*+ "!&+& !1!$2

*+ !"#$%$&' 5+/+.!3 8.,&+"-#,.& 9,-3/ /+#+.B$2+

9*+#*+. #*.+&*,3/& 9+.+ B+# $2 .+1!./ #, 8.,&+"-#$,2&!2/ $2%+$1!#$,2&0 &!4$21 ,A 5+/+.!3 8.,&+"-#,.&0 C)*+4

!.+ #*+ ,2+&0 9*, /+"$/+'D

2 .+&8,2&+ #, ! .+E-+ A,. !2 $2#+.%$+90 ! &,-."+ 9$#* #*+

567 F+3/ ,@"+ $2 G$22+!8,3$& &!$/0 C7>B 2,# !# 3$H+.#4 #,

/$&"-&& #*,&+ I$2/& ,A $2%+$1!#$,2&'D

2,.#*+.2 /$.$"# !2/ A,. #*+

G$22+&,#! /$.$"# 9+.+ -2&-""+&&A-3'

A never-ending encroachment by

Federal law enforcement on the

political activities of activists

J,2+ ,A #*+ KL 8+!"+ !"#$%$& $2 733$2,$&0 G$22+&,#!0 ,.

G$"*$1!20 9*, 9*$"* 9+.+ +2&2!.+/ $2 #*+ KMNM 567

8.,H+0 *!%+ #+$F+/ H+A,.+ ! 1.!2/ O-.40 /+&8$#+ *!%$21

H++2 &+.%+/ 9$#* &-H8,+2!& ",B8+33$21 #*+B #, /, &,'


36/57



!"#$%&'()#*$ ,#'-. /01% !"#2)$%. (/% 0&()1)$($3 4)"$(

52%*.2%*( ")6/($7

8/% "%".$ "%1)%,%. 9: 8/% 5$$#&)0(%. ;"%$$ $/#,%.

/0( (/% -("0(% .)$$).%*( !#-)()&0- 6"#'!$?@ 0..)*6 (/0( (/%


37/57



"#$%&$'($)*+&*, $'- +&.-/$* $')$ $'- /'-/0&*, #1 2-)+(

#. $'- 3#($ 3&*&3)2 $45- #1 &*6-($&,)$* 7- 3)+-

5.#35$248 &$ &( *#$ 0*#%* &1 $'-.- -9&($-+ $'-*8 #. -9&($

*#%8 )*4 .-($.&/$*( #* :-+-.)2 5.#(-/;$#.( %&$' $'-

6).( = ?@#.*-4(A BC/-( ).#;*+ $'- *)$* $#

-)(#*)724 $-.3&*)$- +-)+D-*+ &*6-($&,)$*( #*/- $'-4')6- 7--* 7-,;*=

"#. &( &$ 0*#%* &1 $'-.- ).- )*4 :&.($ ?3-*+3-*$D(5-/&E/

5#2&/&-( )552&/)72- $# :-+-.)2 5.#(-/;$#.( $')$ /#;2+ 7-

#35).)72- $# $'- :&.($ ?3-*+3-*$D(5-/&E/ 5#2&/&-(

)552&/)72- $# $'- :FG8 1#. -9)352-= H'- 2)%(;&$ E2-+ 74

'- 5;72&('-. #1 I.#,.-(( J;--*( &* F.##024* :-+-.)2

#;.$ ')( (#;,'$ $# #7$)&* .-/#.+( )7#;$ '#% :-+-.)2

5.#(-/;$#.( 7)2)*/- $'- :&.($ ?3-*+3-*$8 /&6&2 .&,'$(8

&6&2 2&7-.$&-(8 )*+ #$'-. /&6&2 .&,'$( #1 )/$&6&($( &* /)(-( $')$

'- K#6-.*3-*$ 3)4 7.&*, ),)&*($ )/$&6&($( #6-. $'-&.

)/$&6&(3= G* +&(5#(&$&6- 3#$* 5.)/$&/- E2&*,( %&$' $'-

= L&($.&/$ M#;.$ 1#. "-% N#.0A( -)($-.* +&($.&/$ 3)+- 74

?((&($)*$ = ?@#.*-4 !"#$%&'&$ )*'+$8 $'-

K#6-.*3-*$ .-O-/$-+ )//;()$*( $')$ $'- LBP %)(

%&$''#2+&*, (;/' .-/#.+( 7-/);(-8 QH'-.- /)* 7- *#

%&$''#2+&*, %'-*8 )( &* $'&( /)(-8 *# .-(5#*(&6- .-/#.+(

-9&($=R H# *# (;.5.&(-8 ?? >&*,' )*+ #$'-.(8 &*/2;+&*,

?((&($)*$ = ?@#.*-4 ,'+-.& /-01+-8 ')6-

;..-5$&$(24 )/$-+ $# $'%).$ $'- .-2-)(- #1 (;/' .-/#.+(=

?? K-#.,- &( ) :-+-.)2 5.#(-/;$#.8 %'# $.&-+ SKFH

&6&2 .&,'$( )/$&6&($ S$= 2&'*-. 3$0*1#. '&( )/$&6&(3 $')$

).,-24 /#*$.&7;$-+ $# $'- #6-.D$;.*&*, #1 $'-

K#6-.*3-*$A( 1#.3-.24 +&(/.&3&*)$#.4 5#2&/4 ),)&*($

#5-* ,)4( )*+ 2-(7&)*( 1.#3 (-.6&*, &* $'- = 3&2&$).48

0*#%* )( QL#*A$ ?(08 L#*A$ H-22=R G* #55#(&$*

52-)+&*,(8 I.#,.-(( J;--*( ')( +-3#*($.)$-+ $')$ .-/#.+(

&0-24 -9&($ )*+ ')( 3)+- ) +-3)*+ 1#. $'#(- .-/#.+(=

$ &( *#$ 5.-/&(-24 0*#%* )$ %')$ $45- #1 &*6-($&,)$* $'-



38/57



!"# %&%'%(')* %& +),-).' /0 '1) %&0/+2('%/& %', 3&*)+./4)+

&0/+2(&' 1(* +).)%4)* %& '1) .(,) /0 '1) 56 7%*8),'

-)(.) (.'%4%,',9 ").(3,) '1) -/:%.%), (&* -+/.)*3+), (::/8

/+ ;(,%. %& /&.) '1) !"# 1(* ./2-:)')* )&/3=1 /0 81(')4)+

?-) /0 %&4),'%=('%/&, '1)? ./22)&.)*> 8)+) 1(&*)* 3-

/ '1) K9L9 FU/+&)?,S IV.), %& )(.1 /0 Q1%.(=/ (&*

7%&&)(-/:%,9 #' 8(, ,1/8& '1(' !)*)+(: -+/,).3'/+, 8)+)

))W%&= %&0/+2('%/& 0+/2 '1) )A).3'%/& /0 '1) ,)(+.1

8(++(&', (;/3' +)./+*, ,1/8%&= 81)'1)+ '1) (.'%4%,', 1(*

-+/4%*)* O2(')+%(: (%*P '/ =+/3-, %*)&'%J)* ;? '1) K9L9

L).+)'(+? /0 L'(') '/ ;) 0/+)%=& ')++/+%,' /+=(&%M('%/&,>

&.:3*%&= '1) E/-3:(+ !+/&' 0/+ '1) X%;)+('%/& /0 E(:),'%&)9

G8/ 7%&&)(-/:%,B;(,)* (.'%4%,', 8)+) 2)2;)+, /0 (

=+/3- W&/8& (, '1) *+,,-./ $.0- 1.(20324)

&+506270)2.6> ( =+/3- '1('> (../+*%&= '/ G1) F,,/.%(')*

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/06/21/AR2010062101811_pf.htmlhttp://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/09pdf/08-1498.pdf


39/57



!"#$$% '() *##+ ,-#+ (*,./ 0/$ 1("20$3 -'04,$,-'5% (+)

3#3*#"$ ,6 7"##),3 8,() '() *##+% 0+ /."+% $.--,"/09#

,6 (+,/'#" :",.-% /'# !"#$%&'($)*+, .+/"0 1$+2"3 $4

5$%&/6(*% ( :",.- "#6#""#) /, 0+ /'(/ +(/0,+ *5 /'#

(;",+53% 7 ?'# @,9#"+3#+/ 3()# 6(+/($/0;(4

(;;.$(/0,+$ (:(0+$/ ,+# ,6 /'# 3#3*#"$ ,6 7"##),3 8,()%4(030+: /'(/ 7"##),3 8,()% )#$-0/# +,/ '(90+: #+,.:'

3#3*#"$ (+) +,/ *#0+: A/'#"# 5#/%B '() ( -4(+ /, $#0C#

,;(/0,+$ ($ -("/ ,6 ("3#) "#9,4./0,+> ?'# @,9#"+3#+/

(4$, ;4(03#) /'(/ 7"##),3 8,() '() .$#) (;/090$3 /,

/##" 3,+#5 /, /'# 7$8&%*+ 1+$)' 4$+ '9" :(6"+*'($) $4

7*%"3'()"> D,/' 7J>

K#-("/3#+/ ,6 J/(/# *5 6,"3#" J#;"#/("5 ,6 J/(/#

;*0"%()" .%6+(%() !$$3"#"%''() ( )$?3'+(>" 8$%(2,E0/' $,3#

=,33.+0$/$ .+0,+ (;/090$/$ 0+ ,")#" /, :.("(+/## $/#()5

+).$/"0(4 -",).;/0,+ 6",3 ?'# 0)#($

,6 $,;0(4 (+) #;,+,30; -",/#;/0,+$ 6,"


40/57



!"# %&' &()& #')*'' +, -'"%*!. /+0'*"1'"% 2.!""(") +,

&' '-+"+13 %&!% &'.2'# 4)&% %&' !"#$% '#("#))*+,

5')!" %+ 5' 6"7+6"#8 !"# !-%(0(9%9 7(%& ! *'0+.6%(+"!*3

5'"% 5'-!1' %&' %!*)'% +, :-;!*%&3(91 ' -+*2+*!%(+"9>

:!"3 &61!" *()&%9 !-%(0(9%9 &!0' .+") +5@'-%'# %+ %&'

.!99(4-!%(+" +, 9+1' )*+629 !9 %'**+*(9% +*)!"(A!%(+"9>

:(""'!2+.(9 !-%(0(9%9 %!*)'%'# 53 %&' /+0'*"1'"% ,+*

"0'9%()!%(+"8 ,+* 'B!12.'8 +5@'-%'# %+ %&' C'2!*%1'"% +,

?%!%' -.!99(,3(") DEF; !"# %&' G+26.!* D*+"% !9 %'**+*(9%

+*)!"(A!%(+"9> ?'2!*!%'.38 &61!" *()&%9 !-%(0(9%9 +22+9'#

+ %&' (..')!. H9*!'.( +--62!%(+" +, %&' I'9% J!"K !"# %&'

/!A! 9%*(2 &!0' (",+*1'# G*+)*'99 L6''"9 %&!% 7&'" %&'

C'2!*%1'"% +, ?%!%' -.!99(4'9 -'*%!(" )*+629 !9 %'**+*(9%

+*)!"(A!%(+"98 %&' ="(%'# ?%!%'9 (9 2*+.+")(") &61!"

()&%9 0(+.!%(+"9 (" %&' ,+*'()" -+6"%*('9 7&'*' %&+9'

)*+629 +2'*!%'8 .(K' (" H9*!'.> H9*!'.8 ,+* 'B!12.'8 &!9 5''"

+6"# %+ 5' (" 0(+.!%(+" +, D+6*%& /'"'0! ;+"0'"%(+"8 !

*'!%3 7&(-& 5!*9 ! "!%(+" ,*+1 %*!"9,'**(") (%9 +7"

2+26.!%(+" ,*+1 7(%&(" (%9 +7" 5+*#'*9 ("%+ +--62('#

'**(%+*('9> C'92(%' %&' &61!" *()&%9 0(+.!%(+"98

'-+)"(A'# 53 %&' ="(%'# M!%(+"98 %&' ="(%'# ?%!%'9 &!9

'99'"%(!..3 1!#' (% (..')!. ,+* !-%(0(9%9 %+ !#0+-!%' +"

5'&!., +, 9+1' &61!" *()&%9 )*+629 7(%&(" H9*!'.>

"%'*9'-%(") 7(%& D'#'*!. )6(#'.("'9 ,+* %&' 2*+9'-6%(+" +,

!-%(0(9%9 (9 %&' "'78 2*+2+9'# M'7 N+*K ?%!%' .!78 7&(-&

+6.# 2+%'"%(!..3 )(0' D'#'*!. !6%&+*(%('9 ! .(9% +, &61!"

()&%9 !-%(0(9%9 !#0+-!%(") ,+* '-+"+1(- 9!"-%(+"9 !)!("9%

9*!'.8 7&(-& -+6.# -+"-'(0!5.3 5' ("%'*2*'%'# 53 D'#'*!.

2*+9'-6%+*9 %+ .'!# %+ ! #(1("(9&1'"% +, %&' 2*+2'*%3 +, !

+*'()" )+0'*"1'"%> :+*'0'*8 !9 +"' +, %&' !O+*"'39 ,+*

&' PQ :(#7'9% 2'!-' !-%(0(9%9 7!*"'#8 %&' /+0'*"1'"%



41/57



!"# %&&' #&&()'* +,- .#& &/)0&'1& -2 3-4),)1"4 "1,)/),5

-33-#&0 ,- 6787 2-9&)*' 3-4)15 "# 39--2 -2 19):)'"4 )',&',7;

?-9( 8,",& 4">@ )',&9'",)-'"4 !.:"'

)*!,# "1,)/)#, !"#$%&' !")*,-40 A9-*9# B.&&'# ,!",

,",& 4&*)#4",-9# >&9& 19&",)'* " %"1(0--9 >"5 ,- 3.')#!

9&& #3&&1! %5 %"'')'* "1,)/)#,# 29-: 1-',9"1,)'* >),!

=&> ?-9( 8,",&@ "00)'* ,!", ,!)# ":-.',&0 ,- "

.9,")4:&', -2 1)/)4 4)%&9,) "'0 9)*!,# -2 )'0)/)0."4# "'0

-9*"')C",)-'# ,- "0/-1",& )' ,!& 3.%4)1 #3!&9&7

D- #-:& !.:"' 9)*!,# "1,)/)#,#@ ,!& E-/&9':&',F# &G-9,#

- ,"9*&, "1,)/)#,# )' 9&1, -2 0&:-'#,9",)-'#@ )'14.0)'*

"0/-1",)'* 2-9 %-51-H# "'0 &1-'-:)1 #"'1,)-'# -2 2-9&)*'

*-/&9':&',#@ 1-'/&')&',45 -/&94--( ,!& "0/-1"15 -2 -,!&9

*9-.3# ,!", #&',)"445 >"', ,- :")',")' " #,",.# I.- -2

!.:"' 9)*!,# /)-4",)-'#7 J!&9&"# ,!& 6'),&0 =",)-'# !"#

0&14"9&0 ,!", K#9"&4 )# /)-4",)'* !.:"' 9)*!,# -2 ),#

),)C&'#@ ,!& 6'),&0 8,", )# #)0,&33)'* "'5

-'#)%)4),5 ,- "1, ,- 39#.9& K#9"&4 ,- 1-:345 >),!

',&9'",)-'"4 !.:"' 9)*!,# 4">#7 K'#,&"0@ ,!& E-/&9':&',

!"# %&&' ,"9*&,)'* !.:"' 9)*!,# "1,)/)#,#@ "'0 #-:&

"1,)/)#,# ,-40 A9-*9# B.&&'# ,!", ,!& E-/&9':&',F#

"1,)-'# :"5 !"/& #-:&,!)'* ,- 0- >),! ,!& )'L.&'1& -2

-/&9#&"# *9-.3# "0/-1",)'* " #,",.# I.-7 K2 ), >&9& ,9.&

!", ,!& 6787 *-/&9':&', !"# %&&' :-9& 1-'1&9'&0 >),!

3-4),)1"4 )'L.&'1&@ +)',&9'",)-'"4 )' #1-3& >),! #.%/&9#)/&

-/&9,-'@; ,!&' ,!& 6787 !"# %&&' %&)'* 0.34)1),-.# "%-.,

!& &I."4 "334)1",)-' -2 ),# ->' 4&*"4 #,"'0"90@ &G&1,)/&45

"44->)'* 3-4),)1"4 %)"# ,- 0&,&9:)'& >!)1! )',&9'",)-'"4

'L.&'1& ,- ,9&", "# #.%/&9#)/&7

83&"()'* -2 ,!& =&> ?-9( 8,",& 8&'",-9#@ >!- /-,&0 ,-

3"## ,!& 3.91!"#)'* "'0 )'/,:&', 9,9)1,)-'# %)44@ M#7

A"9( #")0@ +D!&5 "9& "29")0 -2 NO8@ %&1".#& ),F# *")')'*

9"1,)-'@; 9&2&99)'* ,- ,!& )',&9'",)-'"4 %-51-H@ 0)/)#)-'@



42/57



!"# %!"&'()"% *)+,*,"' !-!("%' '., /'!', )0 1%2!,34 56.)

7")8% 8.!' '., !&'9!3 (*:!&' )0 '., ;(33 8(33 ;,%4 ?!27

!##,#< 5;9' (' 8(33 .!+, ! &.(33("- ,@,&' A)" %:,,&.B4=

6.,2,!% '., 0)&9% )0 %)*, !&'(+(%'% *!C ;, )" '.,

,&."(&!3('(,% )0 '., :2):)%,# D,8 E)27 /'!', 3!8J5 %2# *;%!*$ *& *;#$!$( - ;+#4!,!$-+'

$L0!+'. -$ -0%2*+!%' %2-% 2-" #K!/%#" 0$"#+ %2# ABBA DE

E0!"#4!$#/6 5% :-/ -,!"/% %2# 4**/#$!$( -$" %2#

!(2%#$!$( *& >#"#+-4 !$8#/%!(-%!*$ (0!"#4!$#/ %2-% %2#

E*8#+$,#$% :-/ -


46/57



!"#$%$&' )$* +,-./,-.# *$01#&2

. #1- %$-4 56 &5,- !"#$%$&7 #1- 85%-*.,-.# 4!& .5# &5

,9"1 #!*0-#$.0 #1- !"#$%$& !& ,9"1 !& #1- 85%-*.,-.#

4!& 65"9&$.0 5. #15&- &9::5*#$.0 )+;< !./ #1- =5:9>!*

)*5.#7 #1- #45 0*59:& #1!# #1- ?-:!*#,-.# 56 @#!#- 1!/

>!&&$A-/ !& #-**5*$&, 5*0!.$B!#$5.&2

@:-!C$.0 !D59# 1-* 5D&-*%!#$5.& !D59# #1- 85%-*.,-.#'&

!&- !& ! >!4E-* 65* &5,- 56 #1- !"#$%$&7 !$, 1!/ D--. >-0$#$,!#-7L J&2 =54-*

!$/7 *-6-**$.0 #5 #1- 85%-*.,-.#'& !""9&!#$5. #1!# #1-

!"#$%$& 4-*- !"#$.0 4$#1 !. $.#-.# #5 1!*,7 #1-. K$#

459>/ .5# 1!%- D--. ! )$* +,-./,-.# %$5>!#$5.2L

@$."- #1- 85%-*.,-.# /$/ .5# -!D>$&1 ! :*-/$"!#- 65* !.

.#-.# #5 1!*,7 #1!# >-!%-& 5:-. 65* $.#-*:*-#!#$5. 41-#1-*

1- .-# -M-"# 56 #1- 85%-*.,-.#'& $.#*9&$5. 5. #1-

:5>$#$"!> !"#$%$#$-& 56 #1- !"#$%$& !./ #1- ,$&"!$.0 56 #1-

-:9#!#$5.& 56 #1- !"#$%$& !& &9&:-"#& $. #-**5*$&,

.%-$0!#$5.& ,!E 1!%- %$5>!#-/ #1- HNNH +8 89$/->$.-&

. *-&:-"# 56 #1- 9&- 56 $.%-$0!#$%- #-"1.$O9-& /9*$.0

:*->$,$.!*E !./ 69>> $.%-$0!#$5.& 65* $.%-$0!#$5.& #1!#

5,,-."-/ $. #1- #$,- >-!/$.0 9: #5 #1- HNNP ;Q/ =*50*-&& G9--.& #1!# $6 #1- 85%-*.,-.#

1!/ D--. $.#-./$.0 #5 /$&*9:# #1- 6*-- &:--"1 56 !"#$%$&7

415 &9::5*#-/ 19,!. *$01#& $. 9,D$! !./ $. 3&*!->7

1-. #1- 85%-*.,-.#'& "!&- !0!$. #1- HI J$/4- :-!"-

!"#$%$& D!"CA*-/2

R1- 85%-*.,-.# /$/ .5# 1!%- #1- *-&:5.&- #1!# #1-E



47/57



!"#$%&' $)% *+,%-#.%#$ &/& #+$ 0)/11 $)% 2/-3$

4.%#&.%#$ -/5)$3 +6 "0$/,/3$3' "#& 78%+81% !%-% 3+ ."&9

)"$ $)%: +-5"#/;%& " 0".8"/5# $+ 8 +6 $)% H+../I%% $+ J$+8 2KG

L%8-%33/+#)"3 0+#$/##+!1%&5%"=1% "#& 0+


48/57



!"#" %&'()*+ !"#$%&' )%*+,$"-., -.' )' /')0*( .'/12 3.*

4'23, -52 5) 544'6)3** '7 8(*261*)3 /,0$+, 12 3456" !"#"

%&'()*+ 96:0*(5/1 -52 )*;*( 6) =5) (60.32542 3.53

'44'2* '44(*226;* (*06=*2 6) 3.*6( (*24*3 3.*

!)63*1 #353*2 35A*2 )' 54 7'(=*(/+ ,, -52 236// ') 3.* !"#"

0';*()=*)3S2 3*(('(62= -53


49/57



!"#$%$# '($)* +,- !".$!$/' 01'$* '($ 2344$2213% $5"*'2

(0' 04').)2'2 32$# )/ '($ #).$2'!$/' !".$!$/' 060)/2'

-"3'( 71*)40 '(0' $.$/'30%%8 9*$223*$# '($ -"3'( 71*)40/

6".$*/!$/' '" $/# 090*'($)#: ;/#$$#< '($ =*2' 2'$9 '(0'

($ /0')"/ "1 -"3'( 71*)40 '""> '" $/# 090*'($)# ?02 '"

"*!0%%8 *$4"6/)@$'($ 71*)40/ A0')"/0% B"/6*$22 0/#"'($* 0/')C090*'($)# 6*"392 02 %$6)')!0'$ 9"%)')40%

"*60/)@0')"/2: D%')!0'$%8< '($ D:-: 1"%%"?$# 23)'< E3' )'

?02 #$40#$2 %0'$*:

F" !0/8 (3!0/ *)6('2 "*60/)@0')"/2< '(0' '($ D/)'$#

-'0'$2 ?02 ?*"/6 '" 4%022)18 '($ 71*)40/ A0')"/0%

B"/6*$22 02 0 '$**"*)2' "*60/)@0')"/ 0/# )'2 2%"? *$29"/2$

" "G4)0%%8 *$4"6/)@$ '($ 6*"392H ?"*> 1"* )'2 %$6)')!0'$

9"%)')40% 93*9"2$2 9")/'2 '" '($ I".$*/!$/'H2 10%%)E)%)'8 )/

($ *$0%! "1 6%"E0% (3!0/ *)6('2 ?"*>: F" 2"!$ (3!0/

)6('2 04').)2'2< 2399"*')/6 '($ ?"*> "1 6*"392 $/606$# )/

($ 2'*366%$ '" $/# 090*'($)# )/ ;2*0$%< "*< 0%'$*/0').$%8< '"

399"*' 0 E"84"J "1 ;2*0$% 3/')% ;2*0$% $/#2 )'2 *$6)!$ "1

090*'($)#< )2 4"!90*0E%$ '" ?($/ (3!0/ *)6('2 04').)2'2

399"*'$# '($ ?"*> "1 '($ 71*)40/ A0')"/0% B"/6*$22 '"

$/# 090*'($)# )/ -"3'( 71*)40 #$40#$2 06"< "*

0%'$*/0').$%8< '" (0.$ 2399"*'$# 0 E"84"J "1 -"3'( 71*)40

3/')% -"3'( 71*)40 $/#$# )'2 *$6)!$ "1 090*'($)#: F($

"6)4 "1 '($ I".$*/!$/' '" %0E$% 6*"392 %)>$ '($ 71*)40/

A0')"/0% B"/6*$22 02 0 '$**"*)2' "*60/)@0')"/ !$0/2 '(0'& #/0'& "!'&' !' 3&$*.

!30,# #/& 32&!?$*. 0; 5&-&2!+ +!

1&01+& #0 '&2%& !' $*;027!*#' #0 $*A+#2!#& %&.!*

.!#/&2$*.' $* 02-&2 ;02 #/& $*;027!*#' #0 L2,3 '/0,+-&2'

6"# /!- 3&&* .,T&- 34 W8J8 J,12&7& I0,2# -&"$'$0*'(

*"+,-$*. #/& X!#&' "!'&( #/& C0%&2*7&*#

!11+$"!3+& #0 #/& 5QB #0 !11!2&*#+4 #!2. !"#$%$'#' ;02 #/&$2

-&0+0.48 N/&'& .,$-&+$*&' !2& '&+;S1207,+.!#&- 34 #/&

W8J8 6T02*&4 C&*&2!+8

H0 7!T&2


55/57



"#$% $'#()(*+ ",-# !.%/#' .0 #10!+2 3%(1 !"# 45 0#,6#

,6!$-$7!7 $/ !"# 8$'9#7!: !( !"# ,/!$;9,% ,6!$-$7!7 $/

.%*: !( ,6!$-$7! 1#1>#%7 (? ##/ ,>)# !( 0%(-# $! #7!,>)$7"#' !"# 0%#'$6,!#7 !(

(11#/6# (% 6(/!$/.# $/-#7!$*,!$(/7 !",! 9#%# >,7$6,))+

(./'#' (/ ,6!$-$7!7D $'#()(*+ ,/' ,00,%#/!)+ /(!"$/*#)7#2 E? !"# 4FGF EHC I#0(%!: !"# J(.%/,)$7!!"#$%&

'()%"K)#' , %#0(%!?(% !"# %&'()&*+: 6(/6).'$/* !",!: LA"#

4FM;0,*# %#0(%!: 7$*/#' >+ H/70#6!(% C#/#%,) C)#// B2

3$/#: 6(/6).'#' !",! 9"$)# /(/# (? !"# *%(.07 9#%#

,%*#!#' >+ !"# 3NH ?(% !"#$% -$#97 ,)(/# ;; (/# (? !"# O#+

,))#*,!$(/7 1,'# >+ 6%$!$67 (? !"# 7.%-#$)),/6# ;; !"#

N.%#,. /#-#%!"#)#77 #/*,*#' $/ !,6!$67 ,/' 7!%,!#*$#7

(9,%' !"(7# *%(.07 ,/' !"#$% 1#1>#%7 !",! 9#%#

/,00%(0%$,!#: 1$7)#,'$/*: ,/' $/ 7(1# 6,7#7

(./!#%0%('.6!$-#2P

A"# C(-#%/1#/! ,00#,%7 !( ># ?(6.7#' (/ %#*,$/$/* !"#

0(9#% !( $/-#7!$*,!# ,/' 0%(7#6.!# ,6!$-$7!7 7()#)+ ?(%

"#$% $'#()(*+: ,7 9,7 !"# 6,7# >#!9##/ !"# !$1# ,?!#% !"#

Q1$!" B6! 9,7 #/,6!#' >.! >#?(%# !"# Q1$!" B6! 9,7

*.=#' >+ R2Q2 Q.0%#1# S(.%! '#6$7$(/72 T$!"$/ 3#'#%,)

,9 #/?(%6#1#/! ,*#/6$#7: !"#%# 1.7! 7!$)) %./ , LI#'

6,%#P;)$O# 0,%,/($, ,>(.! !"# %#?(%1 #U(%!7 (? *%,77%((!7

*%(.07 !",! ",7 /(9 !%,/76#/'#' 9(%%$#7 ,>(.! !"#

0%#,' (? S(11./$71: >.! /(9 $/6).'#7 6%$!$67 (? R2Q2

(%#$*/ 0()$6+ ,/': #-#/: ,/$1,) %$*"!7 ,6!$-$7!72

A"# 4FGF EHC I#0(%! )((O#' >,6O ,! 6,7#7 !",! !"# 3NH

/-#7!$*,!#' '.%$/* !"# ,'1$/$7!%,!$(/ (? ?(%1#%


56/57



COMMENTS (0) "#$%&'($) *(+ ),-+(.

! LAW FIRM REPRESENTING MANHATTAN FEDERAL JUDGE

/%0 123)'4 25) 26 78) +92'5):% 62' 78) ;< /(=3)%7 >)+&)

+&7(*(%7%4 %+(= 78+74 ?@7A% 527 + B)-2&'+7 2' C)>#$.(&+5

%%#)0 @7A% 78) 5+7#') 26 78) %7+7)0 @7 3(.. =2 38+7 (7 5))=%4

2 >')%)'*) (7%).60D

EFGHICFB

E)=)'+. J#(=).(5)%2' 78) >'2%)(25

26+&7(*(%7% +>>)+' 72)&25%7'#&7 + .)J+.'+-)32'K .2%7

#5=)' 78) "-(78 G&7

1'))7 L8+'+'+ %#)%M.)5322=/+5+J)-)574+..)J(5J 6+(' 82#%(5J+&&)%%($(.(7:*(2.+7(25%

N)3 O2'K $(.. 25$2:&29% -+: 8+*)&'(-(5+. (->.(&+7(25%62' 8#-+5 '(J87%+&7(*(%7% PQ2'')&7)=R

# Louis Flores$ Comment

FOIA, Civil Rights, Unions

& Eric Holder, Barrack Obama, U.S. Department Of Justice, PATRIOT Act, Smith

ct, Communism, Marxism, Leninism, Political Ideology, Human Rights, Civil

ights, First Amendment, Civil Liberties, Activism, Activists, Freedom Of

nformation Act, Indictment, Selective Prosecution, Lt. Daniel Choi, Aaron Swartz,

Melinda Power, Pauline Park, Israel, Palestine, Preet Bharara, Silk Road, Freedom

oad Socialist Organization, Revolutionary Armed Forces Of Columbia, Popular

ront For The Liberation Of Palestine, African National Congress, Nelson

Mandela, Joseph McCarthy, RoAnn Destito

0 Likes Share

N)3)%7 E('%7

http://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/19/law-firm-representing-campaign-finance-committee-under-investigation-also-represents-city-halls-nonprofit-lobbying-armhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/19/law-firm-representing-campaign-finance-committee-under-investigation-also-represents-city-halls-nonprofit-lobbying-armhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/19/law-firm-representing-campaign-finance-committee-under-investigation-also-represents-city-halls-nonprofit-lobbying-armhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/19/law-firm-representing-campaign-finance-committee-under-investigation-also-represents-city-halls-nonprofit-lobbying-armhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/12/manhattan-federal-court-judges-now-oversee-three-city-agencies-with-monitorshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/19/law-firm-representing-campaign-finance-committee-under-investigation-also-represents-city-halls-nonprofit-lobbying-armhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/12/manhattan-federal-court-judges-now-oversee-three-city-agencies-with-monitorshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/19/law-firm-representing-campaign-finance-committee-under-investigation-also-represents-city-halls-nonprofit-lobbying-armhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/12/manhattan-federal-court-judges-now-oversee-three-city-agencies-with-monitorshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/12/manhattan-federal-court-judges-now-oversee-three-city-agencies-with-monitorshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/12/manhattan-federal-court-judges-now-oversee-three-city-agencies-with-monitorshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/12/manhattan-federal-court-judges-now-oversee-three-city-agencies-with-monitorshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=RoAnn+Destitohttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Joseph+McCarthyhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Nelson+Mandelahttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=African+National+Congresshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Popular+Front+for+the+Liberation+of+Palestinehttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Revolutionary+Armed+Forces+of+Columbiahttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Freedom+Road+Socialist+Organizationhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Silk+Roadhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Preet+Bhararahttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Palestinehttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Israelhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Pauline+Parkhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Melinda+Powerhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Aaron+Swartzhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Lt.+Daniel+Choihttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=selective+prosecutionhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=indictmenthttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Freedom+of+Information+Acthttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=activistshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=activismhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=civil+libertieshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=First+Amendmenthttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=civil+rightshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=human+rightshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=political+ideologyhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Leninismhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Marxismhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Communismhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Smith+Acthttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=PATRIOT+Acthttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=U.S.+Department+of+Justicehttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Barrack+Obamahttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?tag=Eric+Holderhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?category=Unionshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?category=Civil+Rightshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?category=FOIAhttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-for-the-prosecution-of-activists-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-act#commentinghttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/?author=54174acee4b0294e676e7581http://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/2/new-york-bill-on-boycotts-may-have-criminal-implications-for-human-rights-activistshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/4/preet-bharara-sues-glenwood-management-alleging-fair-housing-accessibility-violationshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-for-the-prosecution-of-activists-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-acthttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/2/new-york-bill-on-boycotts-may-have-criminal-implications-for-human-rights-activistshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/4/preet-bharara-sues-glenwood-management-alleging-fair-housing-accessibility-violationshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/13/federal-guidelines-for-the-prosecution-of-activists-appear-to-reconstruct-a-legal-framework-lost-under-the-smith-acthttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/12/manhattan-federal-court-judges-now-oversee-three-city-agencies-with-monitorshttp://www.progressqueens.com/news/2016/2/19/law-firm-representing-campaign-finance-committee-under-investigation-also-represents-city-halls-nonprofit-lobbying-arm

2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)

Documents

Transcript of 2016-02-24 Plaintiff Surreply (Flores Decl) (Flores v DOJ)(15-CV-2627)(JG)(RLM)(Stampted)