1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River...

18
1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Ore Zones Richard Abitz Richard Abitz , , Savannah River National Laboratory Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling Bruce Darling , , Southwest Groundwater Consulting, Southwest Groundwater Consulting, LLC LLC GSA 2010, Denver, Colorado

Transcript of 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River...

Page 1: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

11

Anthropogenic Induced Redox Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in UraniumDisequilibrium in Uranium

Ore ZonesOre Zones

Richard AbitzRichard Abitz, , Savannah River National LaboratorySavannah River National Laboratory Bruce DarlingBruce Darling, , Southwest Groundwater Consulting, LLCSouthwest Groundwater Consulting, LLC

GSA 2010, Denver, Colorado

Page 2: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

22

Drilling Issues Related to Redox Disequilibrium

Physical change to the ore minerals

1.E+06

1.E+07

1.E+08

1.E+09

1.E+10

1.E+11

1.E+12

1.E+13

0.0010.010.11101001000

particle diameter (um)

surf

ace

area

(u

m2 )

Page 3: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

33

Drilling Issues Related to Redox Disequilibrium

Chemical reactions in the ore zone

7/2O2 + H2O + FeS2 → 2H+ + Fe++ + 2SO4--

½O2 + 2H+ + UO2 → H2O + UO2++

Airlift purge and pump adds O2

Page 4: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

44

Mineral Dissolution Rates

General form of rate law (Lasaga, 1995)1:

Rate = k0*Amin*e-Ea/RT*anH+*g(I)*Πian

i*f(ΔGr)

Increase in both surface area (Amin) and O2 activity (an

O2) will increase dissolution rate.

1 Lasaga, A.C., 1995, Fundamental Approaches in Describing Mineral Dissolution and Precipitation Reactions, in Reviews in Mineralogy, Volume 31, Chemical Weathering Rates of Silicate Minerals, Mineralogical Society of America.

Page 5: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

55

Page 6: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

66UEC Permit UR03075

G arrison & C rouch (T A M U-C C , resea rch w eb s ite ) “T he G o liad F o rm a tion is a P liocene coasta l p la in com p lex cons is ting o f inc ised va lley , m eande ring fluv ia l, ba rrie r is land and beach , tida l de lta , lagoon , and flood p la in depos its… ”

Page 7: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

77

UECPermitUR03075

Initial ISL targetis B Sand, yellow pattern

Page 8: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

88

Production Test Wells (PTW), Sand B

0.001

0.010

0.100

1.000

PTW-1 PTW-2 PTW-3 PTW-4 PTW-5 PTW-6 PTW-7 PTW-8 PTW-9 PTW-10 PTW-11 PTW-12 PTW-13 PTW-14

Ura

niu

m m

g/L

Apr-08

Jul-09

Nov-09

URANIUM: Apr 2008: 0.005 to 0.804 mg/LJuly 2009: <0.003 to 0.090 mg/LNov 2009: <0.003 to 0.010 mg/L

Page 9: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

99

Production Test Wells (PTW), Sand BARSENIC: Apr 2008: 0.001 to 0.022 mg/L

July 2009: <0.010 mg/LNov 2009: <0.010 mg/L

0.000

0.001

0.010

0.100

PTW-1 PTW-2 PTW-3 PTW-4 PTW-5 PTW-6 PTW-7 PTW-8 PTW-9 PTW-10

PTW-11

PTW-12

PTW-13

PTW-14

Ars

enic

m

g/L

Apr-08

Jul-09

Nov-09

Page 10: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

1010

Production Test Wells (PTW), Sand BFUORIDE: Apr 2008: 0.50 to 0.79 mg/L

July 2009: 0.50 to 0.54 mg/LNov 2009: 0.50 to 0.69 mg/L

0.01

0.10

1.00

10.00

PTW-1 PTW-2 PTW-3 PTW-4 PTW-5 PTW-6 PTW-7 PTW-8 PTW-9 PTW-10 PTW-11 PTW-12 PTW-13 PTW-14

Flu

ori

de

mg

/L

Apr-08

Jul-09

Nov-09

Page 11: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

1111

Production Test Wells (PTW), Sand BRADIUM: Apr 2008: 10 to 1,680 pCi/L

July 2009: 17 to 2,000 pCi/LNov 2009: 10 to 1,590 pCi/L

1

10

100

1000

10000

PTW-1 PTW-2 PTW-3 PTW-4 PTW-5 PTW-6 PTW-7 PTW-8 PTW-9 PTW-10 PTW-11 PTW-12 PTW-13 PTW-14

Rad

ium

pC

i/L

Apr-08

Jul-09

Nov-09

Page 12: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

1212

B Monitor Wells (BMW), Sand BURANIUM: Apr 2008: <0.001 to 0.188 mg/L

July 2009: <0.003 to 0.006 mg/LNov 2009: <0.003 mg/L

0.000

0.001

0.010

0.100

1.000

BMW

-1

BMW

-2

BMW

-3

BMW

-4

BMW

-5

BMW

-6

BMW

-7

BMW

-8

BMW

-9

BMW

-10

BMW

-11

BMW

-12

BMW

-13

BMW

-14

BMW

-15

BMW

-16

BMW

-17

BMW

-18

BMW

-19

BMW

-20

BMW

-21

BMW

-22

Ura

niu

m

mg

/L

Apr-08

Jul-09

Nov-09

Page 13: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

1313

B Monitor Wells (BMW), Sand BARSENIC: Apr 2008: 0.001 to 0.069 mg/L

July 2009: <0.010 mg/LNov 2009: <0.010 mg/L

0.000

0.001

0.010

0.100

BMW

-1

BMW

-2

BMW

-3

BMW

-4

BMW

-5

BMW

-6

BMW

-7

BMW

-8

BMW

-9

BMW

-10

BMW

-11

BMW

-12

BMW

-13

BMW

-14

BMW

-15

BMW

-16

BMW

-17

BMW

-18

BMW

-19

BMW

-20

BMW

-21

BMW

-22

Ars

enic

m

g/L

Apr-08

Jul-09

Nov-09

Page 14: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

1414

B Monitor Wells (BMW), Sand BRADIUM: Apr 2008: 0.90 to 41 pCi/L

July 2009: 1.3 to 48 pCi/LNov 2009: 0.10 to 40 pCi/L

0.1

1.0

10.0

100.0

BMW

-1

BMW

-2

BMW

-3

BMW

-4

BMW

-5

BMW

-6

BMW

-7

BMW

-8

BMW

-9

BMW

-10

BMW

-11

BMW

-12

BMW

-13

BMW

-14

BMW

-15

BMW

-16

BMW

-17

BMW

-18

BMW

-19

BMW

-20

BMW

-21

BMW

-22

Rad

ium

p

Ci/

L

Apr-08

Jul-09

Nov-09

Page 15: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

1515

Overlying Monitor Wells (OMW), Sand AURANIUM: Apr 2008: 0.006 to 0.014 mg/L

July 2009: 0.003 to 0.013 mg/LNov 2009: 0.009 to 0.012 mg/L

1.00E-03

1.00E-02

1.00E-01

OMW-1 OMW-2 OMW-3 OMW-4 OMW-5 OMW-6 OMW-7 OMW-8 OMW-9

Ura

niu

m

mg

/L

Apr-08

Jul-09

Nov-09

Page 16: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

1616

Overlying Monitor Wells (OMW), Sand AARSENIC: Apr 2008: 0.010 to 0.031 mg/L

July 2009: 0.005 to 0.010 mg/LNov 2009: 0.005 to 0.010 mg/L

0.000

0.005

0.010

0.015

0.020

0.025

0.030

0.035

OMW-1 OMW-2 OMW-3 OMW-4 OMW-5 OMW-6 OMW-7 OMW-8 OMW-9

Ars

enic

m

g/L

Apr-08

Jul-09

Nov-09

Page 17: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

1717

Overlying Monitor Wells (OMW), Sand ARADIUM: Apr 2008: 0.5 to 6.0 pCi/L

July 2009: 0.2 to 3.2 pCi/LNov 2009: 0.4 to 1.0 pCi/L

0.1

1

10

OMW-1 OMW-2 OMW-3 OMW-4 OMW-5 OMW-6 OMW-7 OMW-8 OMW-9

Rad

ium

p

Ci/

L

Apr-08

Jul-09

Nov-09

Page 18: 1 Anthropogenic Induced Redox Disequilibrium in Uranium Ore Zones Richard Abitz, Savannah River National Laboratory Bruce Darling, Southwest Groundwater.

1818

Uranium solubility as a function of Eh

0.00001

0.0001

0.001

0.01

0.1

1

10

100

-0.2 -0.15 -0.1 -0.05 0 0.05

Eh (volts)

Ura

nium

(m

g/L)

coffinite uraninite

Coffinite Uraninite

EPA DW limit

Solubility of Uranium Ore Minerals in Sand B Groundwater (solid, pH=7.18; dashed, pH=7.96)

Apr-08

Jul-09

Nov-09