nnayc C ~ o n l l 3 7 Ilcuxonor~n o u e H K M M n p M H n T u g p e ~ u e ~ ~ f i / l l e p e ~ o n

C aHm. - M.: ~ ~ H @ O ~ M ~ U M O H H O - M ~ ~ ~ T ~ J I ~ C K M ~ ~ DOM *@wII.IH'~*, 1998. - 368 c. ISBN 5-89568-083-6 ISBN 0-07-050477-6 (anm.)

~~ ' t41-a n o c e n u e H a ncuxonorurr npmamn pelue~~ifi - TeMe, H a x o m -

Uefic5I H a CTblKe K O ~ H U T H B H O ~ ~ H C O U A U I ~ H O ~ ~ IICAXOJlOrHH H npaKIM4eClUl H e O C B ~ U ~ H H O B B C O B ~ ~ M ~ H H O ~ ~ JIATepaType. ABTOp B IIOCQTIHOG @ O p ~ e aHa-

n ~ 3 ~ p y e ~ O C O ~ ~ H H O C T U ~ocnpmmn, namm, M o n e n t i n p w w m peme~ufi, C O U M ~ b H y l O CTOpOHY OUeHKII, ~ b 1 6 0 p a A npAHnTM5I pelUeHAfi , TUnHYHbIe

CATj'aUAH. K ~ u r a HaCbIUeHa IIpAMepaMU A3 peUIbH0G XA3HI4, TecTaMH A

yHMKUIbHb1MH j'llpWHeHLiRMki. OH^ nOMOXeT 4UTTKJllO IIOHRTb MeXaHU3M

@Op.~Ap~Ba~&ifl 0UeHKI.r A nPUHRTMR p e u e H A f i , a 3HaYHT, A 3 k X a T b MHOrUX oLLIH~OK, n p o c q e m e u noBylueK, n o n m p e r a l o l u M x em Ha TOM n p .

Msna~ue 6yne~ A H T e p e c H o A nonesso KaK cneuuanl .rcTaM, m~ A uapo- K O M ~ K p y r y q w ~ a ~ e n e f i .

EEK 88.4

Original edition copyright O 1993 by McGraw-Hill, Inc. All rights reserved. 0 H ~ ~ , 1998 @ Hepeson Ha pyccmti R ~ ~ I K HIIA *@mm'bu,

1998 O C o m e ~ u e , owprmeme A penpowupye-

ma o p m a n - ~ a x e r WI4.Q a 4 , m m w . 1998

06 ABTOPE

CKOTT rhayc - AOUeHT l7CHXOJIOrHH Y ~ c J I H ~ H c K o ~ o yHUBepCkiTeTa.

OH O K O W W I YHKBePCHTeT MUHH~COT~I U ITOJIyWJI CTeneHb AOKTOpa

@wroco@ws no ~a@enpe n c H x o n o r k i a B CTBH@OPACKOM yHkiBep-

CHTeTe, rfie IlOCJIe 3TOlW nOCBRTMn ABa r O n a H3yWHHIO ~ O J I H T K Y ~ C K O ~ ~

ncwxonorm. Ass rona nnayc Y H T ~ ~ y p c n e e q k i f i B HJIJIRHO~~CKOM YHHBepCHTeTe ( K ~ M ~ Y C % i ~ l T e f i ~ - Y p 6 a ~ a ) .

CKOTT llnayc - n a y p e a T pamurtrsHbu< Harps H npe~t i t i , B TOM

s w n e c T m e H n a k i @ o ~ n a M a K a p ~ y p O ~ , n p e M m Onnnop~a, n p e M k i H

Cnaccepa 3a n y Y r u e e scce no B o n p o c a M Mkipa. OH n p e n o n a e T ~ y p c no o u e H K e H ~PAHRTHIO p e w e H m , no c o ~ k i m b ~ o f i ~CHXOJIOI-HH, ma- THCTHKe H HCCJIeAOBaTeJIbCKIlM MeTOAaM. MM O ~ ~ ~ J I H K O B ~ H O 6onee 20 c ~ a ~ e f i B T a M X nepkiOnkiseCKkiX H3AaHHXX, KaK P S Y C ~ O ~ O ~ ~ Today, Psychological Science, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, Journal of Conjlict Resolution H Journal of Applied Social Psychology.

O ~ H ~ K O ~ I I ~ Y c 6onee ki3BeCTeH CBOHMH HCCJIeA0BaHWIMI.i nCMX0-

JIOlTfH I-OHKM W e P H b I X BOOPY)I(~HB~~, a T a m e P ~ ~ O T ~ M M I , U e H T p m b -

HO# ~ e ~ 0 f i KOTOpbIX CTCUIU 3THYeCKMe CnOpbI 06 OTHOrUeHHki K XMI-

BOTH~IM H o~pyxaromeii cpene. B 1991 rony OH O ~ ~ ~ J I H K O B ~ J I CBOIO

n e p B y I o 60nbzrrym pa6oly, ITOCBXIQeHHyIo 0 6 3 0 ~ ~ kmefi ~ O P U O B 3a n p a B a XHBOTHbIX, HHTepeCyeTC5I BOnpOCaMH, lTOCB5ILUeHHbIMH P O n H

XHBOTHbIX B qeJTOBegeCKOM O ~ U ~ C T B ~ . K p o ~ e H ~ W H O ~ ~ p a 6 0 ~ b 1 ,

rhayc RBJMeTCX llOJIHTklreCKtrM H AenOBbIM KOHCYJIbTaHTOM B MHOrO-

W f C J I e H H b E lTpOeKTaX, IIOJIJTeHHbIe 3HaHHR JIerJIH B OCHOBY A ~ H H O ~ ~

p a 6 0 ~ b 1 .

ISBN 5-89568-083-6 ISBN 0-07-050477-6 (aarn.)

Emu 661 MU ~ M O E J ~ U ysudemb ce69 maK, KaK sudxm Hac dpyzue, smo, sepoxmo, nodmeepduno 6b1 nawu c a b l e xydwue nodo- 3penm Ha ux crem.

@ ~ ~ H I U I M H n. n m o ~ c

K ~ K 6bmo n o ~ a 3 a ~ o B 16 rnase, nmna, npHr-rHMax p e m e H m , Y a c T o

H e I l p W a m T 3HaYeHMH H n H HrHOPHPyIOT KOHCeHCYCHyIO HH@OPML-

UHIO. 3 ~ a 9 H T JIH 3 T 0 , 9 T O JlIOAM H e COrJIaCyIOT CBOH A ~ # C T B W I H

OJJeHrul C TIOBeAeHHeM H YCTaHOBKaMH OKPY)K~IOU[HX? B o ~ c e HeT.

Aaxe ~au6onee He3aBHCHMbIe HaXOARTCR IIOA CHJIbHbIM BJIMSIHMeM

COUHa-JIbHbIX @~KTOPOB.

K p o ~ e TOrO, <DHJIHIIII T ~ T ~ O K (19856) IIHCaJI, 9 T O COUHa-JIbHbIe

@LKTOPM H Q a I O T JJeHTpaJIbHyIO POJIb B OUeHKe H TIpHHXTHH PeLUe-

HA#. < ( ~ K c I I ~ ~ A M ~ H T ~ J I ~ H ~ I ~ nO3HaBaTeJIbHbIe HCCJIeAOBaHHR OUeH-

Kkl H nPHHHTHR p e U I e ~ H f i ~ b 1 6 p ~ l - i H e B e p H y I o Y3KYIO HaIIpaBJIeH-

HOCTb H a cy6.beKTa, H a ero 3 H a 9 e H H e H ~ O T ~ ~ ~ H O C T H H H ~ O ~ X O A H M O

PaCrUHPHTb ee, ~ a 6 b 1 n P H H R T b BO BHkiMaHHe BJIHRHkie COUHaJIbHOrO

PI OpraHH3ar[HOHHOrO KOHTeKCTa*. T ~ T ~ O K npeJ&lIOXKJl CpaBHHTb

n P H H H M a I O u H X PeIHeHkie C <clTOJIHTkIKaMH>>, B b I H w e H H b I M H C4H-

TaTbCR C < ( K O H C T A W U ~ ~ ~ ) > (T.e. C APY3bRMH, c e ~ b e f i , KOJLneraMH IIO

pa60~e), ki IIOCTORHHO CTa-JIKHBaK)uHMHCR C BOIIpOCaMH: 4 K a ~ OT-

peartipym o K p y x a m u k i e , ecnu sr cnenam ~ T O ? B H 4 K a ~ sr c M o r y

~ O A T B ~ ~ A H T ~ CBOH B3rJIlLl(bI B CJIyqae H~O~XOAAMOCTM?% BSDKHOCT~ BH~UIHMX O T H O U I ~ H M ~ ~ - H HX C ~ O C O ~ H O C T A BnHIITb H a IIOBeAeHHe

m A e # - OAHO H 3 n e p B b I X OTKP~ITU# ~ K C ~ T ~ P M M ~ H T ~ J I ~ H O # COUM-

m b ~ o f i n c a x o n o r k l a .

238 COIJHAnbHM CTOPOHA OUEHKW W IIPHHHTWH P E L U E H M ~ ~

m

B -10 Wrpaiou~e xyxe cpemero

PMCYHOK 17.1

H, H a s e p H o e , e n H H c T s e H H a x H a nepme 30 n e T ~ c c n e ~ o ~ a ~ u f i - COCTOMT B C n e n y I o u e M : K a K m n e p e M e H a npow302ine~ B H O ~ M ~ ~ H O M

COUHaJIbHOM n0BeAeHHI.I HHL[HBHAflMa, KOrAa nORBRTCR A p y r H e

rims?* H ~ C M O T ~ R H a TO UTO pa60l.a H a 3THM BOnpOCOM HaYaTIaCb

B KOHUe XIX BeKa, A 0 1965 r O n a H e 6bm0 AaHO MCYeplTbIBaIoUerO

OTBeTa. B TOM rOAy Po6ep~ 3 a f i 0 ~ ~ BbICKa3aTI n p e ~ l T O J I O X e H H e , YTO,

KOrAa P e Y b HAeT 0 npOCTbIX, XOPOLUO H3BeCTHbIX B e U a X , OTBeTbI

O ~ ~ M H O CTaHOBXTCR 6onee yBepeHHbIMH B nPHCyTCTBMU ~a61Io~a- ~ e J I e f i , HO OTBeTbI H a KOMIUleKCHbIe, CJIOXHbIe BOnPOCbI B npHCYT-

CTBHH ApJTHX JII0~efi HMerOT 0 6 p a ~ ~ p TeHAeHUHH). 3 a f i 0 ~ ~ 3aKJIK)-

YWI, 9TO 3TOT 3@@eKT, H ~ B ~ C T H ~ I ~ ~ KaK <(COUAaTIbHaR @~cUJ[HT~IQW*,

no ~ p a f i ~ e f i M e p e YaCTHYHO 06ycno~nusae~ ~ 0 3 6 y m 4 e ~ H e , BbI3BaH-

H o e @ H ~ H ~ ~ c K H M lTpWCYTCTBHeM APYrHX JIwefi. ~ o c J I ~ A J W ~ A ~ MC-

cJreHOBaHkiR lIOKa3aJIH, T O YrryrILUeHAe WIH yXyALUeHHe HMeIoT MeCTO

A a x e nptr H~JI I~YHH n e p c n e w m b I OU~HKII , a H e TOJI~KO n p ~ @HJH- YeCKOM llpMCYTCTBHU (X~HZIM H ~ J I ~ c c , 1968).

H~CMOT~R H a TO YTO COUAaTIbHaII @ ~ C M J I U T ~ U M R 6bma o6~apyxe- H a n p H HCnOJIb3OBaHHH pa3JIMUHbIX paMMaTHUeCKkfx H MaTeMaTH-

qeCKHX 3 w a ~ H f i , O n H a W3 ~ a ~ 6 0 n e e IIpKHX A~MOHCTP~UH# 3 T O r 0

3@@eKTa 6bma 0 6 ~ a p y X e ~ a B 6accefi~e K o m e A X a (Mafiras, OM- M e n , ~ ~ O K ~ T O , ~ M H K Y c A POY, 1982). B 3TOM OnbITe HeHaBII3YHBbIe

~ a 6 ~ 1 r o n a ~ e n ~ ~ a c c t i @ u u r ? p o s ~ k i H ~ O K O B B nono KaK B ~ I C O K O ~ O

kLTIH CpeAHerO MaCTepCTBa, 3anMCbIBFi5I YHCJIO 3 a 6 p o I U e ~ H b I X HMH

MXYefi, a T a m e HaJIHYHe HJIM OTCyTCTBMe APJTHX ~ a 6 J I I 0 ~ a ~ e J I e f i .

K ~ K lTOKa3bIBaeT PMC. 17.1, HaJIHqHe 3 p M ~ e J I e f i CHH3MJIO YHCJIO A r -

PaBJJIHX BbIUte CpeAHerO A llOBbICUJ[O YHCJIO TeX, KT0 H F i l l I H A X e

c p e A H e r o . Uapns EOHA a n ~ ~ n a Ttiryc B 1983 rony 06~apy>rulJIH

aHaTIOI'MYHbIe, XOTII M M e H e e YBJIeKaTeJIbHbIe, pe3yJIbTaTbI B CTaTHC-

TMYeCKOM MeTaaHaTIA3eY BKJIIoYaBLUeM 6onee 200 H c c J I ~ A o B ~ H H ~ ~ H

20 000 c y h e n o ~ . I I p ~ c y T c ~ ~ u e sp~~esref i C H ~ ~ O TOUHOCT~ B KOM-

lTJIeKCHbIX 3aAaHMIIX A HeMHOrO lTOBbILUaTI0 TOqHOCTb BbIlTOJIHeHHR

lTpOCTbIX.

c 0 u H a J I b ~ a I I n 0 M O U b IIpOIIBJIFIeTCR H a TOJIbKO B TOM, YTO OTBeTbI M

P e U t e H H e pZi3JIHYHbIX 3 a a Y HaXOAIITCR n 0 A BIIIWHHeM npHCyTCTBkiR

w r ~ OTC~TCTBMFI ~ p y r ~ x nmnefi. OKOJIO 30 n e T C ~ Y C T F I nocne TOW

KaK 3 @ @ e ~ ~ C O U H Z ~ J I ~ H O ~ ~ @ ~ C W J I H T ~ ~ H W 6bm B n e p B b I e ~ ~ @ M K C M P O -

BaH, Y o J I T ~ ~ M0n (1927) lTMCaTI06 3KClTepkiMeHTe, ACMOHCTPHPYIO-

U e M , YTO J I W M B IpyIlne p a 6 0 T a K ) ~ H e TaK jKIOpH0, KaK nO0AMHOY-

Ke. B 3TOM 3KCITePMMeHTe, nOCTaBJIeHHOM C q A e H T O M Mona P H H ~ ~ J I ~ M ~ H H O M , 6bmo 06~apyXe~0, YTO J I W A TIIHYJIM 38 BepeBKy

c M J I ~ H ~ ~ ~ , KOrAa AeJIZlJIki 3 T 0 B OAHHOYeCTBe, YeM KOrAa HX 06'6en~- HIIJIM B Ipyll lTbI no ABa, TPM WIH BOCeMb YeJIOBeK. B C p e n H e M OT-

AeJIbHbIe MClTbITyeMbIe BnBOeM TIIHYJIH K w b ~ f i JIHLUb H a 93% CCWIbI,

YeM B OAMHOYKY; BTPOeM - H a 85%, a B BOCbMePOM - BCerO H a

45%. B IIOBTOpe 3 T O r 0 3KCnepMMeHTa ~ ~ H O M H H ~ ~ M O M , DOPA- x e M n e ~ ~ m e p o ~ , A X ~ ~ ~ M C O M rpefiaco~ H BOHOM ~ ~ K X ~ M O M B

1974 r O n y 6 b 1 n ~ 06~apy>r<e~b1 CXOAHbIe pe3yJIbTaTbI A r n e B TOM CJIy-

Yae , KOrAa JIIoAM TIIHyJIM B OAHHOYKY, HO Y HHX G ~ I J I H 3aBII3aHbI

r J I a 3 a M OHM AYMaTIH, YTO BMeCTe C HMMH TIIHyT H APYrMe. E ~ 6 6 n a T a ~ 3 , K H ~ J I M H ~ YMJI~FIMc H CTMB~H X ~ P K M H ~ B 1979 r0ny Ha3Ba-

JIM 3TOT 3@@eKT <<COUH&JI~HO~~ JIeHOCTbIo>> H o ~ H ~ P J ~ K A J I A , 9TO OH

T a m e B03HMKaeT, KOrAa J I I o ~ e f i IIpOCFIT KPAKHyTb MJIH l lOXnOnaTb B

JIaAOJJIM TaK F O M K O , KaK OHH TOJIbKO MOrYT (CM. PMC. 17.2). U ~ M BbI3BaHa COUHaJIbHaII ~ I ~ H o c T ~ ? OTBeT n 0 K a H e XCeH. n a ~ a -

240 COUHAnbHAIl CTOPOHA OUEHKH M IlPHHIITMIl PEUIEHM~

r I KPUK

B03HHKaeT A3-3a TOrO, UTO JIIOAH B rpynne H e TaK RCHO OIIJyIJ&lIOT

CBR3b M e W Y CBOHMW YCWIHXMH W pe3yJIbTaTOM, KaK 3 T 0 lTPOHCX0-

AHT, eCJIH OHH P ~ ~ O T ~ H ~ T OAHH. B pe3yJIbTaTe OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 38

~ 0 H e Y H b 1 f i pf23yJIbTaT JIOXHTCR H a BCeX YJIeHOB rPYITITb1, TOrAa KaK

p a 6 0 ~ a I O U k i # OnHH HeCeT JIHYHyfO OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 38 HTOr pa60-. TbI. P a 3 ~ e J I e H k i e OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH MOXeT HMeTb ~WJlbHefiLUee BJIWR-

m e H a o u e H K y H npr,imTHe pemeaufi, s ~ o H npoHnnr0cTpwpym-r

TpH CUeHbI.

3 saca 20 MMHYT m a , 13 MapTa 1964 rona. A e f i c ~ ~ a e npoacxoam CTORHKe P m O M C X ~ J I ~ ~ H O ~ O ~ O X H O ~ ~ C T ~ H U H ~ ~ ~ KbIO rap- 3b10 Piop~e. ~ T T H f l x e H o ~ H 3 . 28 - J I eTHm M e H e n x e D 6 a ~ a

~ b ~ f i a aa~ , s b ~ w r I o Y a e T aapbr, s a n ~ p a e ~ A s e p H H m e T K A O M ~ , pac- nOJIOXeHHOMy B 30 MeTpaX OT CTORHW.

B H e 3 a n H o o H a s a ~ e s a e ~ MYXIHH~ c npyroa C T O ~ O H ~ I CTORHW.

KKTTH 6 p o c a e ~ c ~ K 6nmcafimefi ~ a 6 H H e ~ b r 3 o ~ a nonkluHM, pacno- n o x e ~ ~ o f i H a npocnercre, HO H e y c n e B a e T c n e n a T b TO B o B p e m .

M ~ > K Y H H ~ xBaTaeT ee H ynapReT HOXOM, o H a H a s m a e T KPHYaTb.

n 0 n e p e ~ YJIHubI CTOHT n e ~ f l ~ k i 3 ~ a X H b I f i m 0 f i AOM, OKHa BO MHO-

~ H X K s a p T H p a x O T K ~ ~ I T ~ I H k m ~ KPHUHT: eO, Eoxe, OH ynapm M ~ H R ! H O M O ~ H T ~ ! ~ O M O ~ M T ~ , ICTO-HW~YA~!*

M ~ ~ [ I M H ~ H3 O A H O ~ ~ KBapTHPbI KpWIHT: < < o C T a ~ b AeByII.tKy B ~ToKo~!)>

Hanana~mkifi OTCTynaeT W KHTTH OCTaeTCR n O C p e n H YJIHUbI.

y H e e m e T KPOBb. O r H H B AOMe K3CHyT. ~ T T M nbITaeTC5I n 0 6 p a ~ b ~ R

A 0 CBOerO X W I H U a , HO H ~ I I ~ ~ ~ B z L I I I ~ ~ BHOBb ITORBTIReTCR H 6 b e ~ ee. B 3TOT MOMeHT OHa KPMYMT: YhfHpaIO! A YhfHpaIO!>> B MHOrO-

3 T m H O M AOMe 3aXMraIOTCR OrHM, JIIWW BbICOBbIBaIOTCR M3 OKOH, M

~ a n a n a ~ m ~ f i C~AHTCR B M a m m y M yesxae~. qepe3 HeKOTOpOe BpeMzr h l T W lTOAHklMaeTCR H a HOrH. MHMO np0-

e3xae~ r o p o n c ~ o f i ~ B T O ~ Y C , c n e ~ y ~ o u ~ f i B asponop~. 3 saca 35 MH-

HYT m a . ~ T T M H ~ K O H ~ U - T O AOXOAHT no ~ ~ e p e f i c B o e r o AoMa H n a 4 a e T H a

non. Bo3spawae~c~ ~anaqa~muf i , ewe pa3 yAapReT ee HOXOM - o H a y m i p a e T .

T e n e p b snmor, ~ o ~ o p b r f i CoBepmeHHo H e ycnoKa t I saeT : B nep- BOM C O O ~ U ~ H H M 06 Y ~ H ~ ~ C T B ~ New York Times H a n e s a T m a TOJIbKO

m T b IIpeAJIoXeHWfi H a 26 CTpaHHUe. Ase HeAeJIH CnyCTR, OAHaKO,

~ c ~ o p w r nonana H a n e p e n o s k i u y . n o s e y ? l l o ~ o h l y , YTO nonaum 0 6 H a p y ~ m a , YTO H e MeHee 38 <cno6ponopmos~b1x, 3aKOHOIIOCJIyU-

HbIX T p W a H , BHAeJIW, YTO llpOHCXOnHT, HO <<HI4 OAHH H e llO3BOHKT

B ~OJIHUHIO BO B p e m H a n a n e H m > > (ra~c6epr, 24 MapTa 1964, c. 1). nepBb1fi 3BOHOK B ITOJIHURIO lTOCTJTlWI 30 MHHYT CnYCllUl nOCJIe TOrO,

KaK k l T H A X ~ H O B M ~ ITOABepriTaCb H a n a e H H I O . A P ~ ~ U M R CJIOBaMH,

M y x w H a H a n a n m H a H e e TPH pa3a B TeYeHHe norryYaca , o H a K p m a -

na a ssma H a n o M o m b , HO HHKTO ~3 38 c ~ m e ~ e n e f i H e n o M o r efi H

A a X e H e n 0 3 B O H m B IIOJIHJJHIO 1.13 CBOerO DOMa.

pecer-rbe, 14 monrr 1990 rona. rop~asr nopora H e n m e K O OT

)eHuHH, M T ~ M . M a p ~ o Mopemi Be3eT CBOIO meCTmeTHIOIO

242 COUMMbHAII CTOPOHA OUEHKM M nPAHIITMR PEUIEHAl?

HAM CJIyWeTCH k i ~ @ a p K T . M a p ~ o CMOr OCTaHOBHTb MaLUHHY H CKa-

3 a T b Ba~ecce WTH A O M O ~ ~ . ITocne 3~01-0, B ~ o s p a c ~ e 33 n e T , Mapr<~ WeP-

Ba~ecca BbIruJTa H 3 MaUIHHbI H a AOPOW H BCTaJIa, IIpOCR 0 IIOMo-

WH. M ~ L U H H ~ I IIpOHOCWIHCb MHMO C ~ a ~ 0 f i CKOPOCTbIO, YTO BeTep

B ~ J I ~ ee c H o r , HO o H a nponorrxma - B K p o s a , cnesax H C C ~ H -

HaX - TWeTHO 3BaTb H a llOMOU[b. 3a 30 MHHYT Ba~ecca IIpoma 6011bme MHJIH, H COTHH MaLLIHH IIpOeXaTIH MHMO, HO HHKTO H e OCTa-

H O B ~ C R , Y ~ 0 6 b 1 IIOMOYb efi. H ~ K O H ~ U , ee nono6pm MOTOUHKJIHCT,

H BCKOpe AeJIOM 3aHILTIaCb IIOJIHUHX.

B T ~ H C T O P m , KaK H H C T O P m ~ T T H A X ~ H O B B ~ , IIOIIaJIa H a nep- BbIe IIOnOCbI HaUHOHaJIbHbIX ra3eT. k l ~ a T I b R ~ U b 1 CIIpaIIlHBaJIH c e k , KaK TaKOe M o r n 0 I I ~ o H ~ o ~ ~ T H , H BOCIIPHHIUIM 3 T 0 KaK CBPiAeTeJIbCTBO

TOTO, YTO ~ I T ~ J I P W 6 o n b u e H e T a K m Tell.JEiR CTpaHa, ~ a ~ 0 f i 6 b m a

KOrAa-TO. Hanpki~ep, OAHH H ~ a J I b R ~ c ~ k l f i IICHXOJIOr CKaSaJI, 9TO

Ba~ecca - QTO CHMBOJI MT~TIHH, K O T O ~ ~ M ~ I c T a p a e M c r r H e s a ~ e - s a T b - XOJIOAHO~~ MT~JIHH, IIOPOIO IIPOCTO nensr~ofi, r A e ~ a m q b ~ i i n Y M a e T 0 ce6e W I H B W U I e M CJIflae 0 HeCKOJIbKHX 6 ~ 1 1 1 3 ~ 1 4 ~ JIIOARX*

( X a G e p ~ a ~ , 1990, 19 ~ronrr, c. A1 1).

Haquo 1970-X. ~ H @ T B OAHOM M3 K P v H b I X rOpOAOB K o r r y ~ 6 w a ,

C A ~ T T J I ~ HJIH A T J I ~ H T ~ I . n 0 c J T e T o r 0 KaK A B e p l l JIlT@Ta 3aKPbLJIHCb,

HeKTO ~ C J I Y Y ~ ~ ~ H O O POHXeT 8 W I H 10 ~ a p a W a L U e f i (B HeKOTOpbIX CJIY-

Y a m - IIXTHUeHTOBHKOB HJIH A~CXTHU~HTOBMKOB).

C06b1me, XBJrrrBUIeeCR YaCTbIo 3KCIIepHMeHTa h 6 6 a J I ~ T ~ H ~ H

Axef i~ca Aa663a (1975), ~ O B T O ~ ~ O C ~ B 1497 c n y l ~ m x , B KOTOP~IX

145 p a 3 n m H b t x nronefi p o m ~ O ~ S ~ K T ~ I n e p e A 4813 ~a6nma~eru r - MR. f l a ~ a ~ 3 H Aa663a HHTepeCOBaJI cnenymukifi BOlTpOC: ~ K T O no- M O X e T YeJIOBeKy ~ 0 6 p a ~ b PaCCbIIIaBLUHeCR l l p e ~ ~ e ~ b ~ ? ) > OAHHM H 3

CAeJIaHHbIX HMH TOrAa ~ a 6 J I w e ~ H f i 6 b m o C J I e A p W e e : J I W H np0- RBJLSIIOT ' E M M e H b U I e e CTpeuTIeHHe lTOMOYb, YeM 6onbrue H a p o n y B

nk l r@~e.

P a c n p o c ~ p a ~ e ~ ~ o f i ~ e w e ~ u k i e f i , ~ a 6 ~ 1 1 o ~ a ~ r u e f i c ~ BO B c e x Tpex cue- H m , RBJrrreTCX TO, YTO OTBeTCTBeHHOCTb 3a IIOMOWb pa3dene~a M e w

6onbruofi r~vnnofi nmefi. Korna Y e r r o s e K c r m K u R a e r c r r c R n r m o -

COM, BMeLUHBaTbCR JIH e M y , OH HaXOnHTCR IIOA CHJIbHbIM BJIUIIHHeM

npHCYTCTBkiR ApjTkFX J I l O ~ e f i . 3 T a B3aHMOCBII3b M e w B M e U a T e n b -

cTBOM H pa3AeJIeHHeM OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH 6bma BIIePBbIe ~ ~ @ H K C H P O -

~ a H a 5 ~ 6 6 0 ~ J a ~ a ~ 3 H AXOHOM A a p J I H (1969, 1970) B 6 n ~ c ~ a ~ e J I b -

~ 0 f i C e p H H 3KCIIePHMeHTOB IIO BMeLUaTeJIbCTBY C B W ~ T ~ J I ~ ~ ~ .

B OAHOM H 3 3THX 3KCIIePHMeHTOB n a ~ a ~ 3 H A a p n t r IIpHrJIaCHJIH

CTyAeHTOB H a HHTePBbIo IIO aHeKOTOPbIM BOnPOCaM, B03HMKaIOUHM

B m 3 H M COBpeMeHHOrO yHHBepCHTeTa,>. Korna C T m e H T b I IIPHXOAH-

n H , MX CaXZlJIH B KOMHaTy AnR O>IUlAaHHR B OAHHOgeCTBe HJIH C ABY-

W JIIonbMH ( C K ~ X ~ M , aCCHCTeHTaMH ~ K c I I ~ ~ M M ~ H T ~ T O ~ ~ ) , K o T o p b I M

rOBOpWIH BeCTH c e 6 ~ naCCHBH0. C I I ~ C T R HeKOTOpOe BpeMR, B KOM-

H a T y Y e p e 3 BeHTHJIRUHOHHOe OTBepCTkie HaYHHaTIa IIpOCaYHBaTbCR

C T ~ * K ~ 6enoro AbIMa. n a ~ a ~ 3 H A a p J I H XOTeJIH I I ~ o H ~ ~ J I I O A ~ T ~ , KOrAa

CTyAeHTbI C K O p e e coo6rua.r 0 3 a r r b I m e H H H - eClIH B KOMHaTe ~ Y A J ~ T A p y T u e CBWeTeJIH WIH e C n H OHM ~ Y A J ~ T C W e T b B OAHHOYeCTBe.

B ~ w c H H J I o c ~ , YTO T p H YeTBepTH CTYAeHTOB, OXM4aBUIMX B OAH-

HOYeCTBe, coo6ruun~ 0 AbIMe, IIpHYeM, IIOJIOBHHa H 3 HHX - B TeYe-

H H e IIepBbIX HByX MHHYT. B TO Xe BpeMsr H 3 10 HCIIbITyeMbIX, CHAeB-

IUHX B KOMIIaHMH AByX ~ ~ ~ A ~ ~ ~ c T B Y I O I U H X JIIOaefi, TOJIbKO 1 COO~LUHJI

0 3aHbIMJIeHHH. OHM K a U I m H , TepJIH ma3a, OTKpbIBaJIH OKHO, HO

H e C O O ~ L U ~ U H 0 A ~ I M ~ ! Korna Xe 0X.clnaJIH T p H CTYAeHTa BMeCTe, IIOnyYZlJIaCb HeCKOJIbKO

H H m KapTHHa. E c n ~ OAHHOYHbIe HClTbITyeMbIe coo6ma~1~ 0 AbIMe B

75% c n y r a e B , TO rpynna 143 T p e x 9 e r r o s e K A o m a 6bma AerraTb TO

B 98% C J I w a e B ( n 0 ~ 0 M y 9 T O BepORTHOCTb T O N , YTO HHKTO H 3 T p e X

HClTbITyeMbIX H e COOGLUHT 0 AbIMe P a B H a 0,25 x 0,25 x 0,25 = 0,02, T.e. 2%). OAH~KO B rp)TIIIaX H 3 T p e X YeJIOBeK 0 AbIMe COO~I.LWTH

nmub B 38% c n y Y a e B .

q~06b1 Y ~ ~ A H T ~ C R , YTO 3TH pe3YIIbTaTbI H e RBJIIUIHCb CJIeACTBHeM

BHeLUHHX @~KTOPOB, H a I I p H M e p , 60nbmefi 6 0 ~ 3 ~ ~ l I O X a p a , BO3HH-

~amrueZi y o n H o r o Y e n o s e K a no c p a B H e H a m c rpynno$i, J l a ~ a ~ 3 H

A a p r r k i PeIIIIUIH I Ip l lAaTb 3KClTepHMeHTy ~pyrofi KOHTeKCT. B 3KCIIe-

p H M e H T e , o @ M J J H Z ~ J I ~ H O ~ ~ IIeJIbIO KOTOpOrO 6 b m ~ oHCCJIeL[OBaHHR

PbIHKa*, OHH lTpOCI.ZTIH HClTbITyeMbIX IIOAOXL(aTb B OAMH09eCTBe, C

ApyIOM, C He3HaKOMbIM WIH IIaCCHBHbIM H ~ ~ J I ~ O A ~ T ~ J I ~ M . ~ O T O M ,

IIOKa HCIIbITyeMbIe >KnaJIki, HX 3aCTaBJlRJIH IIOBepHTb, YTO B COCeA-

H e f i KOMHaTe KTO-TO JTIaJI H yAapBJIC5I. TO 6bm0 CAeJ'IaHO IIyTeM

BKSIIOYeHKFf 3aIMCW, H a K O T O P O ~ ~ XeHLUMHa BCXTIHlTbIBaTIa H IIOBTO-

PRJIa: <(~ocIIoAH, MOR HOT&.. g... R... H e M O W IIOUIeBeJIBTb em... 02, MO% K O n e H K a ... 0fi. KaK 6 o n b ~ o , > .

244 COUMbHAR CTOPOHA OUEHKH H llPHHSlTHII PEUIEHHR

B OTBeT H a ee mas 70% CT'yAeHTOB, XCAaBIIIHX B OAHHO9ecTBe,

lTpeAJIOXHXH nOMOWb. TO SHaYHT, YTO eCJIH 6b1 ABOe, XAaBrutre BMeCTe, IIOCTyTICJJ'IB6b1 OAHHaKOBO, OHM nPeAJIOXUJIH6b1 n O M O w b B 91% C W a e B (IIOCKOJI~KY BePOXTHOCTb TOrO, YTO 06a c y 6 5 e ~ ~ a ~e CAeJTaWT 3TOr0,6b111a p a B H a 0,3 x 0,3 = 0,09, T.e. 9%). OAH~KO n a p b ~

n p e A J I a r l U H I I O M O u b J I H U b B 40% CcJryyaeB, eCJIH HClTbITyeMbIe 6 b 1 ~ r ~

He3HaKOMb1, H B 70%, e C n H 3 T 0 66111~ APY3bX. MTBK, A a X e HeCMOTpa

H a TO TO napbz npysefi qaue npennaram C B O ~ n o M o w b , cnepxa- ~amuui4 ~@@CKT B c e x e ~POX&IWICX, e c n H HCXOAKT~ u3 p e 3 y n b ~ a -

T a , nOJr)F!eHHOrO C OAMHO9HbIMH c y 6 5 e m a ~ ~ . C A e p X t i ~ a m U ( H f i 3@-

@em OT ~ P M C ~ T C T B ~ A p y r o r o s e n o s e K a ewe XpYe npomrrmcrr, KorAa

nocnen~sfi 6bm c o B e p r u e H H o n a c c m e H . B TOM c m a e ITOMOLL[L

npennarana n ~ r u b 7% i'ocnbrTyeMbrx.

n [ a ~ a ~ 3 U A a p n ~ I I O m M J r H T e Xe Pe3YRbTaTbI B HeCKOJIbKEIX no- llOlIHHTeJIbHbIX OIIbITaX, H CO BpeMeHM HX l T e p ~ 0 f i pa60~b1 MHOrHe

Apyr'He HCCJIeAOBaTeJIB IIOaTBepAWIH, YTO IIOMOLUb CAePXHBaeTCX

n p H c y T c T m e M ~ p y r ~ x nmaefi. ( D a ~ ~ m e c r n 3 4 ram, npozLIeAuItIe

nocne n e p B o m s ~ c n e p ~ ~ e ~ ~ a J I ~ T ~ H ~ H napna, B 48 ~3 56 s~cnepa- MeHTOB O ~ H ~ P ~ ~ H O , W O CBmeTeJIki BMeruMBaHYrCR 3HaYYITeJJhHO peXe, e C n H ITPHCYTCTBYeT KTO-TO ewe ( f l a ~ a ~ 3 H Hwa, 1981). B C p e n H e M

B XOAe 3THX 56 OlTbITOB JIIOAH, XWRBIIIHeCR eAHHCTBeHHbIMH CBHAe-

TeJWMH, A ~ ~ ~ C T B O B U I H B 75% CJIcJraeB, a rpylTlTbI - TOnbKO B 53%. C ~ ~ C T B ~ I O T JIH rpynnb~ J I I O H ~ ~ ~ , ~ ~ U H W ~ H H ~ I ~ OT C n e p X t i B a m -

uero 3 @ @ e ~ ~ a ? Cornac~o p e 3 y n b ~ a ~ a ~ o63opa, c A e n a H H o r o h 6 - 6 0 ~ f l a ~ a ~ 3 H CTHBOM Hma B 1981 row, C m e C T B y e T TOnbKO 0 n H a

T a K m r p v n a B aMepHKaHCKOM 06uec~se - 3 T 0 AeTM A 0 9 JET.

~ o c J I ~ 3 T O m B03PaCTHOrO py6exa H a p e I I I e H H e BMerUaTbCR CHJIbHO BsrUReT IIpHCyTCTBHe ApyrHX JIIOnefi.

H c c n e ~ o s a ~ m coquarrb~oii @ a c ~ n ~ ~ a q ~ ~ , c o q ~ a n b ~ o Z i n e H o c T H H

PaCIIpeAeJIeHWI OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH IIOaTBePX&lK)T 3 a M e Y a H H e T ~ T - JIOKa 0 TOM, g T O JIIOAH, IIPHHAMaIOUMe PeIIIeHKH, CpOAHH IIOJIMTH-

KaM. flI0Al-i 9aCTO IIOCTyIIamT KaK ApJTHe H 0 9 e H b ~ ~ C ~ O K O X T C H 0

TOM, YTO 0 HkY( n O m a K ) T O K p y x a I O u U e (Can3 H M m e p , 1977). Hau6onee TWaTeJIbHO lTpOAyMaHH%J TeOpUR TOrO, KaK J I W H BbIHO-

CXT 3 T H OUeHKIi, H3BeCTHa KaK QTeOPUFI C0LI;HaTIbHOTO CPaBHeHUFIP.

3 ~ a TeOpHR 6bma BbLqBHHyTa B 1954 row OHOM OM & C T M H ~ ~ -

POM - YeJIOBeKOM, C03AaBIIIHM TeOpHlO KOlXIITHBHOrO AKCCOHaHCa.

@eClX~lTp IIOCTyJIMpOB&T, YTO JIIOAH HMeIOT H ~ O ~ X O A H M O C T ~ B OUeH-

Ke YpOBWI CBOHX BO~MO>KHOCT~% H TOgHOCTH CBOHX c y X A e H H f i I4

n03TOMY, B OTCyTCTBHe O ~ ~ ~ K T H B H ~ R HeCOIIUaJIbHbIX CTaHAaPTOB,

o H H CpaBHHBaIOT c e 6 ~ C OKpy>KaIOI4HMH. O ~ ~ ~ Q X B ~ R TeOPHIO COUW-

&lTbHOrO CpaBHeHHX, @ e c ~ H ~ r e p CTap&JICR CAeJIaTb ee KaK MOXHO

6onee T O Y H O ~ ki cTPoTo~~. Teopm COAepXXT AeB5ITb rHnOTe3, BO-

CeMb n o 6 a ~ n e ~ ~ f i B BOCeMb BbIBOAOB, T.e. BCerO 25 l T 0 J I 0 X e ~ H f i .

B IIepeJIOXeHHM OCHOBHbIe I I O J I O X e H ~ 3 B W a T TaK:

~ U I I O ~ ~ ~ U k J I ronki H M ~ I ~ T e c ~ e c ~ ~ e ~ ~ : :HLI;HIO OUeHMBaTb

CBOM CyXAeHHR A CCIIOCO~HOCTH.

r~nome3a II: q~06b1 KOMneHCMpOBaTb 0 ' r ~ y ' l ' ~ r B H e ~ ~ ' ~ ~ K T E I B H O - r0, HeCOUJGiJIbHOrO KPHTePWI, IIIOEH 0ueHHBaK)T CBOH CY)IC4eHW

U C ~ I O C O ~ H O C ~ , CpaBHHBaR HX C CyXAeHkiflMki M C ~ O C O ~ H O C T I I M ~ ~

O K p y X a I O u H X .

flobaanenue IXU: E c n ~ y nloner?: e c T b B ~ I ~ O P , OHM n p e L [ n o u m a r o T

CpaBHUBaTb ce6~1 C TeMR, 9 b R MHeHHII H B03MOXHOCTH H e CHJIbHO

OTJIAYaIOTCX OT BX C O ~ C T B ~ H H ~ I X .

246 COUWATIbHAIl CTOPOHA 04EHKW M lTPMHIITMII P E L U E H U ~

~ 3 6 e ~ a ~ b K~KMX-111460 HaUMOHZUbHbIX ktTIH PeJIMrIl03HbIX aCC0UHa-

U M ~ , - H B KWOM cnpae 6 y ~ a m - 1 ~ ~ H ero C o n e p x k I M o e 6 b m H

OAHHaKOBbIMH.

P ~ ~ H ~ I M M 6 b ~ n k 1 IIBCbMa K BJIaeJIbUy. B HeKOTOPbIX B a P H a H T a

IIHCbMO 6 b ~ 0 HaIIHCaHO KeM-TO, KT0 MOT 6 b 1 ~ b IIOXOX H a c y 6 5 e ~ ~ a - nerrrexona (~ . e . YenoseKoM, r o ~ o p r r m ~ ~ no-a~rn~f icm, 3 ~ a m ~ ro- POACKkIM I I ~ P H ~ M ) , B APYMX - KeM-TO, IIBHO HeIIOXOXHM H a ~ ~ 6 5 - eKTa ( H ~ I I ~ M M ~ ~ , MHOCTpaHUeM, IIJIOXO 3HaIOLUHM a~rJIMficKMfi) .

K p o ~ e T o r o , B O A H O ~ ~ Tpem m c e M y aBTopa 6b1n n o 6 p o ~ e n a ~ e n b -

~ b 1 a TOH, B O A H O ~ TpeTM - ~ e f i ~ p i U I b ~ b 1 f i H B O A H O ~ - HeTaTMB-

~ b 1 f i . H a n p k i ~ e p , HeraTHBHOe IIACbMO OT aHI"JIOR3bNHOrO KOppeC-

IIOHAeHTa 3ByVaJ'IO TaK:

AoporoZi MACTep ~ P B U H :

HalueJ l BaUl 6 y h l W ~ M ~ , K O T O P ~ I ~ ~ H B03BpaUIalo. Bce B HeM B TaKOM

sme, B KaKoM II ero H a m e n .

A o m e ~ c ~ a 3 a n , mo x p a H U n B a l u ~ ~ M S U K H M K M r r e p e c b u a n ero BaM M H e 6 b m o 0 9 e H b H ~ Y ~ O ~ H O A IIPH'TAHKTIO MHe MaCCy H ~ ~ ~ O ~ C T B . Hane- m c b , B ~ I o u e H m e MOA ycmm.

Aoporot4 MMCTep ~ P B H H :

n p H ITOCelUeHAH ~aluefi CTPaHbI C ~ b I M M , He3HaKOMbIMH M H e 06b1- 9 m M H II HalLIen BaUI ~YMWHAK, K O T O P ~ I Z ~ BaM M B03BpalUalo B UeJlOCTH A

COXpaHHOCTU.

~ ~ C I I O K O ~ ~ C T B O 3a 6 y h i W ~ A K A H ~ O ~ X O ~ H M O ~ T ~ er0 BO3BpalUeHMII n p M -

9AHWIH MHe MaCCY H ~ ~ A O ~ C T B . H a n e l o c b , BbI OUeHUTe MOM YCKTIAII.

X O P H C T ~ ~ ~ H , (f)HIII ki XOJIMC IIpenIIOJIOXkiJIH, YTO J I W M OKamy?.C%

IIOA BnWIHHeM TOHa IIHCbMa CKOpee, eCJIH I I H c ~ B I I I H ~ ~ IIOXOX H a HHX,

YeM ecm OH OT HEX O T n m a e T c x (~.e., OHM CYMTZUM, YTO ecnti aBTop

IIHCbMa IIOXOX H a YHTaWmerO, TO A O ~ P O X ~ J I ~ T ~ J I ~ H ~ I ~ IIHCbMa CKO-

pee 3aCTaBXT BePHyTb ~ ~ M Z K H E I K , 9 e M HeraTMBHbIe. EcJIM Xe aBTOP

H e IIOXOX H a VHTaWLUerO, TOH H e 6 y n e ~ MMeTb ~ H ~ Y ~ H W I ) . K ~ K BHA-

HO H a PHC. 17.3 3 T 0 6 b ~ 0 TOYHOe n p e ~ I I O J I 0 X e H M e . Korna aBTOpOM

IIHCbMa 6 b ~ n l?OpOXaHMH, ~ ~ M ~ H K L I , COlTpOBO>K4eHHbIe II03HTHB-

HbIMH IIMCbMaMM, B O 3 B p a I L t ~ H C b B CeMb pa3 9awe, YeM COlTpOBOX-

n e H H b I e HeraTMBHbIMH IIHCbMaMH. H ~ O ~ O P O T , B03BpaU[eHMe 6y- MaXHMKOB C IIO3MTMBHbIMki, ~ e f i ~ p a J I b ~ b 1 ~ ~ Pi HeraTMBHbIMB

IIHCbMaMH, HanHCaHHbIMM H e IIOXOXMMM H a HaUIeAUIMX KOHBepTbI

J IWnea , 6 b m o IIOYTH OnMHaKOBO HHTeHCMBHbIM. H~CMOTPII H a TO

YTO CaMM IIO ce6e 3TH pe3YJIbTaTbI H e MOIYT CJIy>KMTb OCHOBaHHeM

TOH

noxom He noxom

C X O ~ C T B O aBTOpOB IIMCeM

PMCYHOK 17.3 TO flpOL(eHTH0e OTHOUleHMe AeMOHCTPMpYeT KOnMqeCTBO f l ~ ) ~ e f i , BO3BPaTMB- LUMX npOflaBWMe ~ Y M & X H M K M B 3KCnepMMeHTe XapBM X o p I i C ~ a f i ~ a , 3J lMunl @MU

M MaR~na Xon~ca (1968).

gTIR K~KHX-~11460 BbIBOnOB, OHM II0ATBep)KAaIOT I IpenIIOnOXeHMe

@ e c ~ H ~ r e p a 0 TOM, YTO JIIOnM CpaBHMBaIOT ce611 C TeMH, KT0 lTOXOX

H a HMX.

B 1978 rony K ~ H H ~ T Kpefir ki K ~ H H ~ T ~ ~ K ~ Y M H npOneMOHCTpHp0-

BaJ'IM, HaCKOJIbKO CWIbHO COIlMaTIbHbIe CpaBHeHHII MOrYT BJIMIITb H a

BOCnpWITMe. ABTOP~I o ~ H ; L ~ ~ x W I H , YTO CO~HaTIbHbIe CpaBHeHWI C

KeM-TO, KT0 MCIIbITbIBaeT 60nbUIHe C T p a a H H R , A ~ ~ ~ C T B H T ~ J I ~ H O 38-

CTaBJrsIIOT JIWneG 9yBCTBOBaTb c e 6 ~ MeHee HeCYaCTHbIMH.

k i c n b 1 ~ y e ~ b I e B 3TOM 3KCIIepHMeHTe IIOJIyVaJ'IM 3lIeKTpOLUOK B

J I e B p pyIcy. ~ o H ~ Y ~ J ~ YAapbI TOKa 6 b U H eJIe 3aMeTHbIMB, HO B

XOne 3KCnepHMeHTa IIOCTeneHHO CMJ'Ia TOKa YBenMYHBiUIaCb ( ~ a 0,25 ~ w m a a ~ n e p a ) . nocne K a m n o r o ynapa wcnbITyeMbre no m K m e

248 COUMAJIbHAR CTOPOHA OUEHKM W IIPMHIITMIl P E ~ I E H H ~ ~

OT 0 A 0 100 OlTpeAeJIXJIH, HaCKOJIbKO HelTPIISITHO OHH C ~ ~ R Y Y B C T B ~ -

IOT. K o r ~ a OHM Ha3bIBWlH 100, 3KCnepHMeHT npeKpaUaJICR.

EbLJI0 ABa BapHaHTa 3KClTepHMeHTa: mepnUMO-f#IOp~~py?Oy~u' a ~0~mpOffb~bl6. B nepBOM BapHaHTe HClTbITyeMbIx 0 6 % e n w m ~ B n a p b r

C nOMOUHHKaMH, ~ 3 0 6 p a x a ~ r u ~ ~ ~ ApJWHX HCnbITyeMbIX, ITpHYeM

nOMOJUHHM4 BCe BpeMR OUeHHBZTH LUOK H a 25% HHXe, YeM HCIIbITye-

m I e ( ~ a c ~ o ~ u ~ e HcnbrryeMbre B c e r n a o u e H H s m a n e p ~ b ~ ~ a ) . B KOH-

TPOJIbHOM BapHaHTe lTOMOUHHK npOCT0 H ~ ~ J I I O A ~ 3a HCnbITYeMbIM,

H H ~ n b ~ ~ y e ~ b ~ f i 6 b ~ 1 eAHHCTBeHHbIM, BbIHOCHBUIHM 0UeHKH (KOH-

TpOJIb COCTOstn B lTPHCYTCTBMM A P m r O Y ~ J I o B ~ K ~ ) .

Kpeiir H ~ P K ~ ~ H H 0 6 ~ a p w J I & i , YTO RCnbITyeMbIe, 6 b r ~ u r ~ e B

nape C <cTepneJIHBbIMH>> ITOMO~HMKaMH, H e IIPOCTO OUeHMBmH LUOK

H E K e - OH Pi Ka3aJICR HM HM>Ke, OHM HCllbITbIBXTM MeHbU[YIO 60JIb.

ucnbrTYeMb1e B 3TOM BapHaHTe 3KCnepHMeHTa OTBeYWlH H a IIOBbILUe-

HHe CHJIbI TOKa MeHbUIHMM H3MeHeHMRMH B PHTMe c e p n u e 6 ~ e ~ w ~ H

MeHbrUHM B3APaI'RBaHReM K O M npeAITJIe9bSI ( 3 ~ 0 ABa OCHOBHbIX

nOKa3aTeJIR @ H ~ w Y ~ c K o ~ ~ ~KTABHOCTH), YeM HCIIbITyeMbIe KOHTpOJIb-

HOrO BapWaHTa. H T ~ K , COUMWlbHasI OUeHKa BJIPiXeT H a @ H ~ I . ~ ~ c K H ~

ITpOUeCCbI TaK Xe, KaK OUeHKa 6 0 ~ ~ .

B ~ ~ J I s I H H T ~ H a JIRHHH 1 , 2 Pi 3 B n. 32 A H K ~ T ~ I . K a ~ a s I H 3 HHX p a B H a

no AJIHHe JIHHHH A? EoJI~LUHHCTBO JiIOAefi Ha3bIBaIOT JIHHMIO 3, H y Bac B03HHKaIOT MOXeT 6 b 1 ~ b CaMbIe He3HaYHTeJIbHbIe COMHeHlW B

TOM, UTO 3 T 0 TaK.

HO eCJIH 6b1 B KOMHaTe W O M e BaC HaXOAI.LTIOCb ewe CeMb YeJIOBeK,

pepemo y T s e p m a s m x , YTO J~MHWI 1 pama JIHHRM A? Bbr 6b1 noA-

TBepAHJIH CBOe y 6 e m e ~ ~ e HJIH llOCJIeAOBWlR 6b1 3a ~OJI~LUMHCTBOM?

TO, lTO CYUIeCTBy, T a CMTYaUHR, KOTOPyK) COJIOMOH AU[ (1951; 1955; ~ 0 ~ 6 p b 1956) CO3AaBaJI B CBOHX KnaCCHYeCKHX 3KCnepHMeH-

T a x IT0 HCCJIeAOBaHHIO K O H @ O P M M ~ M ~ . B ~ o J I ~ L U H H C T B ~ 3THX Onbrl'OB

7-9 CTYAeHTOB MyXCKOrO ITOJIa C m e J I H BOKpJW CTOJIa, tI RX ITPOCK-

JIH CpaBHHTb AJrHHY <<CTaHAaPTHbIX* J I H H w ~ ~ , H ~ O ~ P ~ X ~ H H ~ I X H a APY-

rHX KapTOYKaX. B 3KCIIepHMeHTe 6 b v r o 18 Yac~e t%, H Kamr[b12 pa3 OUeHKy 6 b U 0 CAeJIaTb OYeHb npOCT0; KOHTpOJIbHm rprpyrrna He3aBH-

CHMbIX OUeHUHKOB A i U a 6 o n b u e 99% ITpaBkmbHbIx OTBeTOB. HO B

A p P A X CJIyYazDc HCnbITyeMbIe H e 3HWlH7 S T 0 BOKPyr HHX C W T C n e -

~ H a J I b H O HaHXTbIe JIIOAR. B C O ~ C T B ~ H H O 3KCllePHMeHTaJIbHbIX ~ e f i - C T B R X B rpJTflTY BXOAWI TOJIbKO OARH H ~ C T O I I U W ~ ~ H ~ I T b 1 ~ y e ~ b I f i .

B nep~oii sacm c T a w a p T H a R n H H a R 6bma AJIHHO~~ B 10 A I O ~ ~ M O B ,

a TpH CpaBHkITeJIbHbIe - 8,75, 10 H 8 A I O ~ ~ M O B . CTYA~HT~I AaBaTIH

oueaw no osepenu no ~ a c o ~ o i i c?penKe, H B c e ~ a s b r s a n ~ JIHHHIO B

10 A I O ~ M O B P ~ B H O ~ C T ~ H A ~ ~ T H O ~ ~ . HAK~KUX npo6ne~. BO B T O P O ~ ~ YaCTH CTaHAaPTHasI JIMHUSI 6 b m a A J I H H o ~ ~ B 2 A I O ~ ~ M ~ , a

CpaBHHTeJIbHbIe - 2, 1 H 1,s AK)#M~. C H O B ~ C T n e H T b I COnOCTaBHIH

CTamapTHyIO ki CpaBHHTeJIbHbIe JIHHHH 6e3 0c06bIx T ~ ~ A H O C T ~ ~ ~ .

B T p e ~ b e f i YaCTH, OAHaKO, YTO-TO CTpaHHO H3MeHWIOCb. BM~CTO T o r 0 Y T O ~ ~ I CKa3aTb, YTO ~ - A K I ~ M o B ~ ( I CTamaPTHas I JIRHl.ur P a B H a

~ - A I O ~ ~ M O B O # c ~ ~ B H H T ~ J I ~ H o ~ JIHHHH, nO&CTaBHbIe ~ b 1 6 p i U H JIHHMIO

a ~ r ~ ~ o i i 3,75 n m # ~ a . M c n b r r y e ~ b r f i , K O T O P ~ I ~ ~ Bce rAa cmen 6 n ~ x e K KOHUY vYlTIlb1, H e 3HiU, YTO h nOlTpOCwI IIOAC'MBHbIX AaBaTb

HeBepHbIe OTBeTbI B 12 H 3 18 CJIyYaeB. AIII XOTeJl IlOCMOTpeTb, 6 y . 4 ~ JIH HCnbITYeMbIe COl-'JIaIHaTbCR C MHeHHeM 6 0 J I b r u k i ~ c ~ ~ a .

B TaIMX yCJIOBki5iX h 0 6 ~ a p p m , YTO HCnbITyeMbIe CO~JIaUaIOT-

CR C H ~ B ~ P H O ~ ~ OI.IC!HKO~~ l IpHMepH0 B 1/3 CJIJWaeB. T p R YeTBepTH

CO~JIaLUWlHCb, no KP&H~# Mepe, C O A H O ~ O W U ~ K O ~ ~ , a OAHa TpeTb - C ~ o J I o B R H o ~ ~ I l n H 6oxee. a p y r ~ ? ~ a CJIOBaMH, ~oJI~LUHHCTBO JIIOaefi

BbIHOCRT HeKOTOpbIe OUeHKti H a OCHOBaHkiH MHeHWI OKPJ'XaIOJXHX,

A a X e eCJIM OH0 llPOTHBOPeYHT MX CO~CTB~HHOMY.

T a m e IIOCTaBkZTI HeCKOJIbKO BaPHaHTOB 3TOr0 3KCnePHMeHTa.

H a n p ~ ~ e p , B OAHOM QHKTIe H C C J I ~ A O B ~ H H ~ OH H3MeHZUI ¶HCJfO JIIO-

neii B rpynne (CM. PHC. 17.4). Korna HcnbrTyeMbre cmem B nape c OAHHM IIOACTaBHbIM JIHUOM, MHeHHe KOTOPOrO npOTHBOpeYHJI0 MX CO~CTB~HHOMY, er0 MHeHHe H e OKa3bIBaJIO H a HHX BJIWIHkLII. Ei0JIb-

LUHHCTBO HCnbITYeMbIX OTBeYiUH UpaBklTIbHO IIOYTH BCerAa. KoI-A~ HCnbITyeMbIM lTPOTHBOCTOXJI0 ABa YeJIOBeKa, OHH COrJIaLUWlHCb C kIX

HeBepHbIM MHeHHeM B 13% C m a e B . Korna Xe TPH nOACTaBHbK

JIHUa - 33%. B b ~ m e 3TOTO yP0BI-W COIY'IaCHe H e n O A H H M ~ O C b , XOTR

~ a J l b ~ e f i L L I H e OlTbITbI, IXpOBeAeHHbIe A p F U M H HCCSIeAOBaTeJHMH,

noeasm~, YTO y s e m Y e H H e wcna YrreHoB rpynnb~ npHBoAHT K POC-

TY YHUla CrryYaeB CO~JIaCWI C ~OJI~LIMHCTBOM ( f l a ~ a ~ 3 H BYJI~@, 1981). HO He3aBHCkIMO OT TOrO, KaK c@o~M)'JIHPoB~H BOnpOC, RCHO, UTO

A w e He3HaYHTeJIbHOrO ~ o J I ~ L U H H C T B ~ AOCTaTOYHO AJIII TOrO, 9 ~ 0 6 b 1

CKJIOHHT~ nm~e i i K KOH@OPMHJMY.

B AP)TOR CepHH 3KClTePHMeHTOB A I I I A O ~ ~ B T I I L T I B rpyITny BTOpOrO

H c n b n y e M o r o , K O T O P M ~ ~ cmen H a Y e ~ ~ e p ~ o i i n o s a u a ~ H 06brs~o A a B U I I p a B m b H b I e OTBeTbI. AIII XOTeJI lTOCMOTPeTb, 9TO l'Ip0~30fi- AeT, eCJIH OTAeJfbHbIe HClTbITyeMbIe 6 o n b u e H e ~ Y A ~ T eAHHOAylUHbI.

250 COUMAII~HAII CTOPOHA OUEHKM M ITPMHIImII P E U I E H M ~

40 -1

1 2 3 4 8 10-1 Konriqec~Bo ~ o ~ p a m a ~ o m x nroneGi

PHCYHOK 17.4 B CBOMX 3KCnePMMeHTaX no KOH~$OPMH~MY COJ~OMOH Aw o 6 ~ a p y x ~ n , WO B rpynne M3 TpeX '4enOBeK KOH@OPMH~M B03HMKaeT C T ~ K O ~ Xe 06sl3a~enb~O~lbt0, 'IT0 M

B rpynne, B nmt. pa3 6onbweR.

OH A O ~ W L C R YAMBMTeJIbHOrO 3 @ @ e K ~ a . KOH@OPMH~M CTaTI B C V e -

YaTbcrr B YeTbrpe pa3a pexe, YeM p a H b m e - T.e. T e n e p b , K o r n a 60~1b-

UMHCTBO H e 6bllI0 eAMHO&J'UHbIM, KOJIHYeCTBO pas, KOrAa MCnbI-

TyeMbIe COrJIaLU2lJHCb C HeBePHbIMM OTBeTaMR, COCTaBHJIO 1/4 ~a6~1lona~merocn panee. To e c T b Am O ~ H ~ ~ ~ X H J I , YTO enmonym- H o e ~ O J I ~ U ~ ~ I H C T B O M3 TpeX ¶eJrOBeK CMJIbHee, BJIIUITeJIbHee, YeM 60JIb-

IIIMHCTBO 83 BOCbMM WJIOBeK C OAHMM HeCOlTaCHbIM. ~ T M Pe3YJIbTa-

TbI lTOKa3aJIM, YTO B CMTYaUHM C C H J I ~ H O ~ ~ CKnOHHOCTbIO K - - -

K O H @ O ~ M H ~ M ~ , OAMH H ~ c o ~ J I ~ c H ~ I ~ MOXeT lTpOH3BeCTM O I ~ O M H ~ I ~ ~

3 @ @ e K ~ .

B 1969 row Cepx MOCKOBMYM n B o e ero K o m e r n o c T a B u n H KC- IIepHMeHTaJIbHyIo lTapar[M~hly h a C HOr H a rOJIOBy ti HCnOJIb3OBaJIM

ee B MCCJIeAOBaHHM BJIHRHWI MeHbrUHHCTBa H a ~ O J I ~ L U B H C T B O (Moc- KoBHYM, ne&rx H Ha@@pemy, 1969). BM~CTO T o r 0 9~0661 H ~ ~ J I I O -

a a T b BJIWIHMe ~ o J I ~ U I H H C T B ~ lT0)ICTaBHbIX H a OAHOrO MJIM ABJX HC-

nbITyeMbIX, OHM HCCJIeAOBaJIR S @ @ ~ K T BJIMIIHHR HeCKOJIbKMX

nOACTaBHbIX H a 60nbruy1o V j T I l I y HCnbITyeMbIX. MOCKOBMYH H eTO

COaBTOPbI 170Ka3aTIA, T O MeHbUIMHCTBO M O x e T MMeTb 3Ha'IMTeJtb-

H o e BlIMRHkie H a ~ o J I ~ U M H C T B O , A r n e eCJIM OH0 H e O C O ~ ~ H H O CWIb-

HO WIH y s r n a e M o .

B CepHH 3KCnePHMeHTOB, COCTaBJIeHHbIX MOCKOBMYM, V y l T n a

COCTORIIa H3 YeTbIpeX MClIbITyeMbIX H ABJX lTOnCTaBHbIX. Bce OHM

ClQleJIM JIMUOM K 6eno~y 3KpaHY, M MM 6 b ~ 0 CKa3aH0, YTO 3 T 0 3KC-

n e p x M e H T H a B o c n p H m t i e u s e T a . nocne 3~0ro 6 b m a n o ~ a 3 a ~ a ce- PHR C J I ~ ~ O B M KaXJIb1fi pa3 3ZUaBaTIMCb BOnpOCbI 0 RPKOCTH H UBeTe

~JIafina. Bce c J I a m b 1 lTOKa3bIBaJIH pa3JIHYHbIe OTTeHKM CMHeTO, HO

nOACTaBHbIM CKa3aTIM, q ~ 0 6 b 1 OHM Ha3bIBaTIM er0 B HeKOTOPbIX CRY-

Y a m s e n e ~ b r ~ . MOCKOBMYM M ero C O T P ~ ~ H M K H O ~ H ~ P Y > K ~ ~ J I H , YTO B

CpeAHeM B 8% C m a e B HeIIpaBMJIbHbIX OTBeTOB HCnbITYeMbIe COrJIa-

IIIaTIMCb C HHMH M 3 2 % C Y ~ % ~ K T O B Ha3bIBaTIM UBeT 3eJIeHbIM XOTR 6b1

OAHH pas. B K O H T ~ O J I ~ H O ~ ~ Xe WJ'lTne HCIIbITYeMbIe Ha3BaTIH UBeT

3eJIeHbIM TOJIbKO 2 pa3a H 3 792. I /IT~K, M O C K O B ~ M H er0 KOJIJIerM 06~apy>rurn~, YTO MeHbLURHCT-

BO C ~ O C O ~ H O BlIWITb H a ~oJI~UIMHCTBO kl3aCTaBJIHTb er0 CO~JIaLUaTb-

CR C co6ofi. n p a ~ ~ a , C 0 ~ ~ 0 f i o ~ X B O ~ K O ~ ~ , - MeHbrUMHCTBO AOJDKHO

6 b 1 ~ b eAHHO H nOCJIeAOBaTeJIbH0. EcJIM ABOe ITOnCTaBHbDc ~one6a- JIHCb MeXJIy CMHHM M 3eneHbIM, ~ J I f l a f i H 0 Ha3bIBiLZI ~ J I a m b 1 CHHMMH

B 1/3 CJIY'laeB, HCnbITyeMbIe Ha3bIBaTIH c J I a m b 1 3eJleHbIMH TOJIbKO B

1 % C J I p a e B . M ~ H ~ L U R H C T B O MOXeT MMeTb 3HaYHTeJIbHOe BJIWIHMe,

TOJIbKO eCJIM 3aHMMaeT TBepAbIe, COrJIaCOBaHHbIe nO3MLIHM (0630~ M

17pOAOruKeHHe 3~0fi pa60Tb1 CM. y Macca H G a p ~ a , 1984; H e ~ e ~ a , 1986; H e ~ e ~ a M Uafinsa, 1988).

V y l T n b I c n o c o 6 ~ b 1 K CIlelTJIeHMIO H H30JIMPOBaHbI OT BHeUI-

H e r 0 BJIWIHHR, JIORIIbHOCTb H CKJIOHHOCTb K KOH@OPMH~MY MOXeT

npHBeCTM K TOMY, YTO ~ I P B R H ~ AX~HHC B 1982 rOAy Ha3BaTI <Tp)TI-

lTOBbIM MbIUIJIt?HHeM)> (c. 9). Hau6onee M ~ B ~ c T H ~ I ~ ~ npMMep VylTlTO-

BOrO MbILLUleHWl, ~TPMBoARIUM~~ K HeBePHbIM Pe I I I eHWM, - 3 T 0 @H-

aCK0 OnepaUHH, KOrAa n p e 3 H n e H ~ c K M f i K ~ ~ H H ~ T Ax.@. K ~ H H ~ A M PeKOMeHnOBaJI H ~ O ~ A ~ M ~ H H O ~ BTOpXeHMe H a Ky6y. E0JIee 6 1 1 ~ 3 ~ H f i

252 COUWATIbHAR CTOPOHA OUEHKW H IIPMHRTHX PEUIEHHn

K HaM IT0 BpeMeHH n p H M e p , KaK CYHT&lIH ,@~I?Mc 3ccep Pi A x o a ~ jlawop@ep (1989), - p o K o B o e p e r u e H H e 1986 rona 3 a n y ~ ~ ~ ~ b Yen- nendxep B H ~ ~ J I ~ ~ o ~ I ~ ~ I T H ~ I o norony.

& ~ H H C ITHLUeT, YTO eCTb BOCeMb ~ a H 6 0 ~ e e PaCnPOCTPaHeHHbN

lTPH3HaKOB KOJIJIeKTHBHOrO MbIUUleHWI:

Mmmswr H ~ ~ R ~ B H M O C T H , p a w e n r r e M m npamxsecm B c e M a

WIeHaMH rpylTlTb1, l T p H B O m 4 m K Ype3MepHOMy OlTTMMH3My E1 HeOIIpaBnaHHOMy PHCKy.

O6mee W e 3 p e H H e K PaUHOHaJIbHbIM KITH HenOBePYHBbIM BbI-

CKa3bIBaHwIM.

6 e 3 0 r o B o p o Y ~ a B e p a B IIpHCyWJW) KOJLTIeKTHBY MOp&lIb.

C T ~ ~ ~ O T M ~ H O ~ BOCnpWITMe COBeTOB KaK ~ O ~ H ~ I X UJIH CKpbI-

B a I o u H X lTOn co6oCi C J I ~ ~ O C T ~ H I'JTYllOCTb.

A a m e ~ H e H a W e H O B V y m b I , H e IIOAYHHRIOuHXCSI ~ O J I ~ L L I M H -

CTBy.

Y C T O ~ ~ Y H B ~ WIJIK)3UII e&PiHOAyIUkIII.

Ca~oue~sypa BO HW H e H a p y m e H m KoHceHcyca .

C ~ M O I I P O ~ ~ ~ B O J I ~ H O ~ I'IORBJIeHHe *3auHTHklKOB YMOB,>, 3 a 4 k l -

4 a r o r r l m rpyrrny OT UH@OPM~UHU, KOTOPW M o r n a 6b1 n o m a T -

HyTb ee CaMOnOBOJIbCTBO.

EcJ'IH B Qyllne IIORBJIXIOTCR 3TM TpeBOXHbIe CHrHaTIbI, CYWeCTBY-

e T BepORTHOCTb H e a 3 6 e x a ~ b rpJTKIOBOr0 MbIUlTeHWI. U T O ~ ~ I 3 a U H -

TMTbCSI OT H e r o , ~ X ~ H H C peKOMewOB&lI HeCKOJIbKO ITpeBeHTHBHbIX

Mep. B o - r r e p s b ~ c H npeme B c e r o , nmepbr r p y n n b I AOJIXH~I B c m e c -

m n o o u p m b p a 3 H o r n a c m II 3nopo~yro K ~ H T A K ~ , B TOM ¶ A c n e K ~ H -

THKY HX C O ~ C T B ~ H H ~ M : IT03HIJH#. Bo-BTOP~JX, BC5l¶eCKkI IlPeIMTCTBO-

BaTb ~ a ~ p e r n e ~ ~ r o Y ~ ~ - T O n m m x n03~qM H npenrrommii. Axefi Pycco H n o n b LUyhlaxep B 1989 rony rr~carru o TOM, ¶TO H a OH-

c m @ r q ~ a x TO rrpasmo H C ~ O J I ~ ~ ~ ~ R weny rom 06pa30~: 60~1ee HH3KHe no P a H V W e H b I Q y l l I I b I rOBOpRT llepBbIMH, 3aTeM 6onee c-rapwae no pamy, s a ~ e ~ eue 6onee c T a p u H e H T.A. ki T a m M o6pa- 30M HHKTO H e ~OHTCFI BbICKa3aTb MHeHHe, I I p O T H B O p e Y a ~ e e MHe-

HHIo 6onee BJImTeJIbHbIX JIHU.

T p e ~ b e f i M ~ P O # RBJuIeTClr OTIlOYKOBbIBaHHe 6onee M e J I m X rp)lTIl

CO CBOHMH J I m e p a M H , KOTOPbIe AOJEKHbI PeUIHTb TOT Xe BOlTPOC

( B C ~ B O ~ M O X H ~ I M W C ~ O C O ~ I M H ) . B - ¶ ~ T B ~ ~ T ~ D ( , W e H b I VJTInbI AOJDK-

HbI IIpeABapHTeJIbHO 0 6 ~ m a ~ b 6 y ~ p m e ~ e 6 a ~ b 1 H AelIkiTbCR MHe-

H m M H , a 3aTeM paCCKa3bIBaTb 06 3THX 0 6 c m e ~ m B C ~ B wynne. B - ~ T ~ I X , rpynnm AOJI)KHM npwrnaLuaTb CTOPOHHSIX 3 ~ c n e p ~ o ~ r n ~

~ ~ ~ I @ H ~ ~ ? ~ o B ~ H H ~ I x KOJIJIer D;TIII V a C T W I B c o 6 p a ~ m Ii AaBaTb

B O ~ M O X H O C T ~ HM BbICKa3bIBaTb M H e H m , H e COBUa4aIOUHe C MHe-

HHRMH r p y n n b ~ . l I p a m ~ . ~ q e c ~ ~ , &KIHBC r o ~ o p m o TOM, YTO OAHH

fi3 J I ~ U I H X C ~ O C O ~ O B H 3 6 e x a ~ b IpJTnOBOrO MbILLlJIeHWI - O@HW-

m b H 0 ~ b 1 6 p a ~ b ¶eJIOBeKa, KOTOP~I# 6 b r lIOCTORHH0 OTCTaHBm OT-

nHYHyF3 OT 06ueZi TOYKy 3peHMR ( T ~ K Ha3bIBaeMOrO <(UBOKaTa AbR-

BoJI~B). KWM 113 3THX M e p OvaHH¶HBaeT COlYIaCHe H R;iaruIeTCR 3NIOrOM TOrO, YTO MHeHHe MeHbllMHCTBa ~ Y A ~ T lTpOTHBOCTORTb KOH-

(POPMH~MY.

:oqkiaJI

B He: . - - - - .

l l o c ~ o n a ~ y n m n M c o u k ~ a r r b ~ a r no HaType, m o u e H m H p e m e H m

HaXOnSITCR lTOA COIIHWIbHbIM BJIMSIHHeM. A x e eCnH CeJIOBeK n p H -

HHMaeT PeUIeHl le B OfiBHOYeCTBe, OH 3a¶aCTylO OueHHBaeT CBOe no- seneme, cpamasarr ero c n o s e n e H H e M ~ p y r a x n m e g B a H a n o m u -

~ o f i C H T y a u m . O n ~ o s ~ a r ~ o , n1060e nonpo6aoe H c c n e n o s a H a e

0UeHKL.I. H HPHIUITMR PeWeHHR AOJIXHO BKJIIOYaTb HCCJTeAOBaHHe

( :bHbIX @~KTOPOB.

KOTOP~IX CJIYYW 3~~@amopb1 B T [ ~ I O T H a p e r u e H m , H e arrm Ha o ~ e H m , JIeXaILWe B HX OCHOBe. H a n p k i ~ e p , MHOrHe JIIOAH lTOA-

BepXeHbI KOJIJIeKTRBHOMy MbIrrUTeHEIIO M3a~HIIJ .a IOT BMeCTe C rPJT- IIoG HAeH, KOTOPbIe JIWIHO H e pa3AexRIOT. B A p F k i X ma, 0 4 e H -

Ka MOXeT MeHRTbCSI. AILI o ~ H ~ ~ ~ X W I , HanPHMeP, YTO MHOrUe H 3 er0 HCnbITYeMbIX H e nOA03PeBNIM, ¶TO, KOrna BOCnpHRTHe HCKaXaeTCR,

3 T 0 IIPOHCXOHHT lTOn BJIMRHHeM ~ o J I ~ U I B H C T B ~ . T o s ~ o TaK Xe IT^- H 3 B &~PJIA (1970, C. 65) nMCaZH: * [ ~ T H ] llCnbITJ'eMbIe COBepUIeHHO

OAHHaKOBO rOBOPHJlH 0 TOM, YTO HelTPeMeHHO OKa3aTlH6bI nOMOUb,

eCJIH 6b1 B 3TOM B03HHKTIa P e m b H a R H~o~xoL~HMocT~,>.

C O ~ M ~ J I ~ H O ~ BJIHXHHe, TO¶Hee, YaCTb er0, 0 6 c y > ~ n e H ~ m B 3 ~ 0 2 - H e 6onee COTO# AOJIH TOI?O, C CeM MbI J I ~ ~ ~ T B H T ~ J I ~ H O CTaTI-

dCR B peZUIbH0fi XCH3HH. TO m I O C T p a u m , H e HCYepIIbIBaIO-

, KaK B CjlyWle C C O U U ~ T I ~ H O ~ ~ IIOMOubIO, lTOKa3bIBaH)uaSI, YTO

uJIbHbIe @aKTOpb1 MOIYT EI YJIYYUIaTb Pe3yJIbTaTb1, H J'XYAUIaTb

3 cJIe~y1oI4eB rJIaBe MbI CpaBHHM pe3YJIbTaTb1, IlpOfieMOHCTPH- HHbIe rpJTII0m ki OTneJIbHbIMH JIIOAbMH.

C I u q x 1

ax. I posa

E c n ~ rpynna y a a r H o npeononena ~ 0 6 1 ~ 3 3 ~ rpyrrrrosoro M b I m e H m ,

~ Y A ~ T JIM O H a I IpHHllMaTb n)TLUMe OUeHKH H PeLUeHUSI, YeM H W H -

BWYYM? M c n o n b 3 y m ~ n t r r p y n n b r T e me BBPMCTMKEI M T e xe npen- y 6 e m e ~ t i ~ , TO A M H A H B H A ~ ~ M ~ I ?

H ~ M H O ~ M ~ HCCneAOBaHM COnOCTaMRWT 3BpHCTHKcr M CMeWeHHR,

C B O ~ ~ C T B ~ H H ~ I ~ MHAHBHAyyMy, C 3BPBCTHKaMti H IIpeAPaCCyAKaMM

KOJUIeKTHBa, a Cepbe3HbIX 0 6 3 0 ~ 0 ~ ~ nOCBRU[eHHbIX 3~0fi TeMe, HeT

~oo6ure. OAH~KO M3 O I I Y ~ J H K O B ~ H H ~ N M C C J I ~ L [ O B ~ H U ~ ~ B OCHOBHOM

CneAyeT, YTO C M e U e H H R B ~ T P H ~ Y T H P O B ~ H M H Pi OUeHKe - 0 6 w ~ e Y OTZeJIbHO B3RTbIX J I I O A ~ G H Q y l 7 l l . n e p ~ m YaCTb 3~0fi rJIaBbI lTOCBR-

U e H a HeKOTOpbIM ki3 3THX napaTIJIeJIefi, BTOpaR Xe YaCTb - pa3JIH-

YMRM rpwn H OTAenbHblX IllOAeg.

K ~ K OTMeYmOCb B 16 m a B e , @ Y H A ~ M ~ H T ~ ~ H ~ R o r r r ~ 6 ~ a a~pti6y- 4MM - 3 T 0 T e W e H U H R BbIHeCeHHR 0UeHKki B COOTBeTCTBHll C AHC-

l l03tiUHOHHbIMH ITPMYtiHaMM. H a n p k l ~ e p , JIIoAki MHTepllpeTHpyIOT

BbICKa3aHHYIO B 3CCe n03HUHIO KaK aBTOPCKYK), HeCMOTpR H a TO YTO

HM CKa3aJIki, YTO aBTOp B b I H m e H 6b1n BCTaTb H a 3 T y ll03MUHIO

( ~ ~ X O H Y H ~ M X a p p H c , 1967). T e w e ~ u t i R H ~ ~ ~ K O H H O ~ ~ ALIC~03HUMOH-

H O ~ a T p k 1 6 ~ ~ 1 t l t i B OTHOLUeHllM I'pyIIn M3BeCTHa KaK < ( Q y m O B m 0 ~ ~ 6 - Ka ~ T ~ M ~ Y I I M A * . K ~ K nHCaJIM CKOTT ~ ~ H C O H M f l a~uq M e c c H ~ (1985, C. 564), HepBbIMH ~ ~ @ H K C H ~ O B ~ B U M ~ Q y l l n O B y I o O U I H ~ K Y a~pt i6y- UHM: <(06e - H @ ~ H A ~ M ~ H T ~ T I ~ H ~ 0LUM6rta ~ T ~ H ~ ~ U H H , ki I 'pynnO-

BaR O L I I H ~ K ~ a ~ p ~ 6 y ~ p i 1 . 1 - HMeIOT LUHpOKOe paCnpOCTpaHeHMe. TO H a m a T e H n e H U m - MrHOPHPOBaTb BHeLUHee BSIHXHHe H a lTOBeAeHMe

H BHAeTb CBR3b M e w ITOBeAeHMeM H HeKOTOpbIMH O C O ~ ~ H H O C T R M A

C U W a )'Ma*. B CBOeM HCCJIenOBaHHH ~ J I M C O H H M ~ C C H K o 6 ~ a p y - XEfnH, YTO HCllbITyeMbIe OKa3aJIM ~OJI~UIYIO lTOmep)KKY rOpOACKOMy

YlTPaBETIoUeMy, H3AaBLUeMy <<nyCTOnOpOXHee* nOCTaHOBJleHHe 0

~ ~ O ~ X O A H M O C T H CBepTbIBaHHR ~ e p ~ l I p t i R ~ k i ~ , XOTR HHKaKkiX M e P o -

n p W l ~ H f i I? H e IIpOBOAWIOCb, TaK YTO H e 6 b ~ 0 H IIPKqMHbI, n0 KO-

~ 0 ~ 0 f i O ~ ~ ~ C T B ~ H H O ~ MHeHHe 6bU0 3aTPOHYTO PeLUeHMeM OTAeJIb-

HOrO lTpaBHTeJIbCTBeHHOTO CIIyXaLUerO. C x 0 X E f e pe3yJIbTaTbI 6b1n~ 0 6 ~ a p J W e ~ b 1 A H ~ H O G M ~ K R H CKOTTOM AJ~JIBCOHOM B 1987 row.

fipyl?m ~ T ~ M ~ ~ T H B H ~ R IIapa-WIeJIb B03HMKaeT M e w <<IIpeAIlOYTe-

HHeM 3TOUeHTPM3Ma>> H < < l T p e ~ ~ O Z I T e H W M H , O ~ C Q ~ K H B ~ H ) L U ~ I M ~ ~ rpw- nyo. K a K JWe rOBOpMJIOCb, H H A H B ~ Y Y M b I C03naIOT I I O 3 H U H O H H m

~ T ~ H ~ Y U H I O n E T CBOMX YClTeXOB ti CHTYaUHOHHYIO - LUIR HeYnaY.

rIne~br rpyrrrrbr T a m e n e n a m T n o 3 ~ u w o ~ ~ y r o a~pti6yrram to^ ycrre- XOB H CHTYaUMOHHm - AJIR HeynaY. I ' p W b I . A O H ~ ~ D Temop H

D X ~ H ~ T Aopaa B 198 1 rOAy COlTOCTaBWIH <cnpeAnOYTeHUSI 3TOUeHT-

p t l s ~ a n a < c o 6 c n y > ~ ~ ~ a m ~ u ~ e rpyrrny* n p e n n o s T e H a s r cpem M e m H -

c ~ t r r y ~ c ~ s x a T n e T m e c r a x K o M a m a 06~apy>1uvrH, YTO n o c n e n H e e ,

no ~ e ~ b I l I e a M e p e , HaCTOnbKO Xe CWIbHO, KaK H IIepBOe. A T ~ ~ T ~ I neMOHCTpHpOBZUlM B03BbIUIeHHe rPYr[nbI, K O r n a P e Y b U T a 0 TOM,

9~06b1 MX KOMaHAa BbIMrPbIBaTIa Y CMJIbHbIX COllepHMKOB, YaU[e, 9 e M

KOrAa O H a npOHI'pbIBaJIa cna6oG KOMaHAe.

Ewe OnHO C ~ ~ ~ ~ K T H B H O ~ rpyIIlTOBOe CMeIIIeHHe H3BeCTHO K a K

<O@@~KT OAHOPOAHOCTH "m0fi" pylTnbI,>. ~ O A O ~ H O TOMY KaK KSUK-

n b r G r e n o s e K sanm B ce6e 6onbwe p a 3 ~ 0 0 6 p a 3 H R , s e M B npyrkix JIIonsDc, TaK I4 YneHbI KWO% I'pylTIIbI CYHTaIOT 4JIeHOB APJTkD( I'pWn M e H e e p a 3 ~ 0 0 6 p a 3 ~ b l ~ k 1 , 6onee O A H O p O ~ H b I M l l eOnHOJIHKEIMH*

( M m e ~ Pi Xbm, 1989). Hanpn~ep, B OAHOM 3KClTePHMeHTe YJIeHbI

YeTbIpeX CTyjIeH9eCKHX K T I Y ~ O B B ~ ~ M H C T O H ~ OUeHllBZUlH W e H O B

CBOerO H OCTaTIbHbIX T p e X KJIY~OB COOTBeTCTBeHHO KaK OTKPbITbN H

3aMKHyTbM H a ce6e, CKpOMHbIX M BbICOKOMePHbIX M T.A. (,&KoYH~,

BYA, K Y ~ T ~ O H , 198 1). P e 3 y J I b ~ a ~ b 1 IIOKa3aTIH, YTO CTYHeHTbI C9MTWCI.I

YJIeHOB C B O ~ ~ r p y r I n b 1 6onee p a 3 ~ 0 0 6 p a 3 ~ b I ~ k 1 , Y e M YneHOB nm60ro qpyroro my6a.

B ~ I M o x e T e CKa3aTb: ~ K O H ~ U H O , OHM AyMSUIH, 9TO B HX my6e XOpOLUtle n m n M : OHM HX 3HaTIH JI)YLLIe, YeM WIeHOB ApflMX ~ Y ~ o B * . K ~ K BbEXCHkZTIOCb, OAHaKO, <<rIpeApaCCYAOK ~ ~ e r p v n 0 ~ 0 f i OAHOPOA-

HOCTHP H e 6bu CBR3aH C TeM, CKOJIbKO YneHOB CBOerO M APyTMX

K T I ~ ~ O B 3 H U H CTYneHTbI. 5 0 J I e e TOrO, 3TO C M e m e H H e B03HllKaTIO H B

rpyrrnax, MMeBLUHX H ~ ~ o J I ~ u o Z ~ , 3 n M 3 0 n M Y e c K k i ~ OnbIT KOHTaKTa,

H a n p H M e p , MYXNLIH M X e H W M H ( b p K H P o T ~ ~ ~ T , 1982). ~ I T ~ K , IIpeApaCCynOK ~~eI 'pyrrn0~0fi OnHOpOnHOCTH - H e npOCT0 p e 3 y n b -

TaT pa3HHUbI B ~ ~ M ~ O C T H 3HaKOMCTBa.

2 56 COUMAnbHAR CTOPOHA OUEHKM M IIPMHIITMII PEUIEHMR

O ~ H H M H 3 C J E E C T B H ~ ~ 3TOTO CMeUCHMII RBJlReTCR TO, YTO O H 0 BnM-

R e T H a @ O p ~ k i p ~ ~ a ~ H e CTepeOTHnOB. ~ O C K O J I ~ K ~ H e YfleHbI CBOefi

r p y n n b I BOCllPHHMMaIOTCR O A H O O ~ ~ ~ ~ H O , HX MHAMBWYaTIbHOCTb CTM-

PaeTCR. K HeCYaCTblo, TeHEeHUlzn BOClTPMHMMaTb nOCTOPOHHHX OnHO-

06pa3~0 YaCTO BJlMReT H a M e m y H a p O n H b I e OTHOMeHHfl. H a n p b i ~ e ~ ,

KOrAa C O B ~ T C K H ~ ~ JTKQep mptlfi A H ~ ~ O ~ O B n p M I U e n K BJIaCTH, 6 b 1 ~ -

LUM8 COBeTHIlK n p e 3 w e H ~ a C N A no H ~ ~ H O H ~ J I ~ H O $ ~ 6e30nac~0- CTH ~ K ~ ~ N H c K M ~ ~ nMCaR: ~ H e s e p ~ o OUeHMBaTb 3TMX nlonefi, KaK

KOHCepBaTOpOB HJlM n ~ 6 e p a n o ~ , n p a B b I X MXH neBbIX, CTaTIMHHCTOB

HJIM HeCTaJIMHMCTOB. Aeno B TOM, qTO OHB BCe XeCTOKHe M BCe OHM

~POTMBHMKW)> ( ~ M ~ M ~ H H , 1985, 3 M a p T a , C. 55). n 0 c A e n y l o u ~ e

c06b1~1.1~ ITOKa3aRH7 KaK ~ X ~ ~ M H C K B ~ ~ O U I M ~ ~ T T C R .

O q e H b H e M H O r I l e 3 K C n e p H M e H T b I 06pawalo~cn K TOMY, KaQM

BBPHCTMKY - nOCTylTHOCTH MJIM penpe3eHTaTMBHOCTH - MCnOJIb3y-

IOT r P Y n n b I . O ~ H O H 3 PeAKMX F i ~ W l l o Y e ~ M f i - OIIbIT, n p O B e a e ~ H b 1 8

n H m o A Apro~ , M a p K o M C M 6 p a t r ~ o ~ H f l M m o C i AaAep B 1986 r o n y .

OHM 3HaKOMMnH OTneJtbHbIX C Y ~ ~ ~ K T O B N rpYlTnb1 H 3 n R T H qeJIOBeK

C BapHaHTOM n p 0 6 n e M b 1 a4BOKaT0B-MHXeHepOB7 n p H ~ e n e H H 0 f i B

rn. 10. Apro~, C ~ 6 p a f i ~ n Aafiep 06~apymmn, YTO r p y n n b l CKJIOH-

H b l H C n O n b 3 0 B a T b 3BPMCTMKy penpe3eHTaTHBHOCTH .IaWe, q e M HH-

~ M B W ~ ~ M ~ I . CKOTT Tnnnefin, Cblo3a~ LLI~+@M M Axo3e@ @ ~ n - I M H ~ B 1990 row T a m e 0 6 ~ a p y r n K n H , YTO r p y r r n b l ~ 3 q e T b i p e x r e n o B e x

6onee, .IeM M ~ M B ~ y y M b l , CWlOHHbI AeflaTb 0IUM60YHble 3aKilK)Ye-

HWR, CTaRKHBaRCb C ~ I P o ~ X ~ M ~ M M , n 0 ~ 0 6 H b 1 ~ 1 . 1 n p e ~ r r 0 X e ~ ~ 0 f i B

IT. 1 A H K ~ T ~ I . TO x e x o B c e olaaqaer? H e c ~ o ~ p n H a TO YTO H ~ O ~ X O ~ M M O ,

KOHWHO, 6 0 n b m e H C C J I ~ ~ ~ O B ~ H H ~ ~ , 3TM n e p B b I e OTKPbITWr C B U e T e n b -

CTB)rlOT, YTO npHCyrr[He MHnMBIlnyyMaM 3BPHCTHKH ki C Y ~ ' ~ ~ K T M B H ~ I ~

CMerUeHHR n p O n O n X a l o T ~ € ! I % C T B O B ~ T ~ M n p H r p y I I I T 0 ~ 0 8 O U e H K e M lll3MHRTHU peLlJeHH$i. K p o ~ e TOrO, 3 T H n p e A y 6 e ~ e H H R M H O r n a yCM-

ntleamcx B rpynnax. B cnyvae c ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ H T ~ T M B H O C T ~ I O , H a n p M M e p ,

A p m , C k i 6 p a f i ~ n Aafiep (1986, c. 74) n H c a n n cnenymuee: u r p y n -

UOBbIe nMCKYCCHM YCWlMBaloT OTWlOHeHMR B I ? H & B B ~ ~ J I ~ H o ~ ~ OUeH-

K e M3-3a WCnOJIb30BaHttg penpe3eHTaTMBHOCTM*.

, ~ @ M K C M ~ O B ~ H ~ ~ X ~ A M C O M CTOYH~POM B 1961 WAY. OH o6~apy- m, s T 0 cy68e~~b1 C K O p e e rOTOBbI lIOEl(eP)I(aTb PMCKOBaHHOe ~ e a - CTBMe, e C n H OHM IIpMHMMmH V a C T H e B er0 VJTIIIOBOM 06cyme- H a M . CTOYH~P H a 3 b I B m 3 T 0 M3MeHeHMe aCABMr K pklCKy,>, M CO

BpeMeHM e T 0 I IepBOrO 3KCnepMMeHTa COTHM H C C A ~ ~ O B ~ H H ~ ~ 6 b m nOCBRmeHb1 3~0fi TeMe. B KOHeYHOM MTOre V f l O B m lIOJIIipH3a-

UMII ITPHBO~MT K TOMY, ¶TO niOIIH HLQT B rpyrrne H a 6onbm~B p u c ~ , s e M peruunxcb 6b1 I I O ~ T H OAHM. O T K ~ ~ I T H R C ~ o y ~ e p a K a c m k i c b H a -

uaosanbaofi ~ ~ ~ o I I ~ c H o c T M , 6u3~eca M npyr~x 06nac~efi, B KOTO-

PbIX V y I I n b I JI~onea IIpRHMMaloT Ba)I(HbIe P e m e H M I I .

~ P H M ~ ~ H O B ¶eTbIpeX Pi3 K W b M m T H 3KCIIepMMeHTOB no CaBM-

ry K P M C K ~ n p o u e ~ n 7 p a B b I r n m x T c n e w u m f 06pa30~: C H a g a n a

a c n b r r y e M b I e s a n o n m ~ aHKeTy, me onpenemm CBOIO CIUIOHHOCT~

K PNCKY. 0 6 b ~ ~ 0 a H K e T a IIOCTpOeHa H a AE1ILeMMaX. O ~ H Y 83 HlUL B 1964 rony COCTaBHJIM H ~ T ~ H K o r a ~ Maiim B m a s . B ~ e f i ona- C ~ D ~ J I M C ~ 12 ~ 0 0 6 p a > r t a e ~ b ~ t c M T y a u u f i , B K O T O P ~ E H ~ O ~ X O ~ H M O 6bl~10 ~ b 1 6 p a T b PMCK IZJIA KOHCePBaTMBHOe IIOBeneHHe. Harrpmep, B OnHOM

M3 nyHKTOB 4 5 - J I e ~ H H f i WJIOBeK AOJIXeH ~ ~ I J I ~b16pa~b Me)KL[Y PMC-

KOM onepaumi H a cepnue ma X M ~ H ~ I O c a p t i ~ ~ ~ e f i (CM. PMC. 18.1).

PMCYHOK 18.1

TO OAMH ~3 ~ ~ H K T O B onpoca no pelueHMto D M n e M M , nposefieHHoro H ~ T ~ H O M K O ~ ~ H O M M MaiiKno~ Bannaqe~ (1964, c. 256-2571,

M ~ l c ~ e p E., 45-JIe~~Mfi CJIJ'XWHft, y3HZiJI OT CBOem Bpara, WO y Hero, mcrepa 6., apmMm cepnua. %TI c'ronb cepbe3~arr npo6ne~a, r ~ o mmp 6. jlOJIXeH IIOJfHOCTb~ H3MeHHTb CBOIO XGiJHb: MeHbllIe pa60TaTb, c06mona~b

AHeTy, OTKa3aTbC5I OT MHOrMX ilpMBbIUeK. Bpar Tame OTMeTFTJI, qT0 Onepa- urn B crryrae ycnexa n o 3 ~ o r m ~ eMy BepHyrbcrr K npexaem o6pa3y XH~HH. Ho nomofi VepeHHocm B ycnexe onepauari HeT, H Ha caMo;\l aerie oHa name MOXeT IIpIiBeCTM K CMepTeJlbHOMY HCXOA)'.

n p e n c ~ a ~ b ~ e , T O BbI IIOWbI naTb COBeT MHCTepY 6. B H U ~ Y AaHbI pa3-

nuwbIe a a * H UIIPOTHB* Toro, TO onepaum 6 y n e ~ ycneur~ofi. lirowanyu'cma, omemame t iamet ibqm gepo~mnocmb ycnexa, npu Komo-

pou' 8bl 6bl nOCO8CWOBCUIU COZnilCUmbCIl Ha Onepayuro.

- -eTbTe 3neCb, C5CJfB BbI CmTaeTe, WO MHCTep 6. JIOJfXeH CO- MaCMTbCR Ha OnepaUMH) BHe 3aBMCHMOCTM OT ILIaHCOB Ha YCneX.

- I ~ H C ~ I Ha YCneX 9 M3 10 - I ~ H C ~ I Ha YCneX 7 M3 10 - U ~ H C ~ I Ha YCneX 5 H3 10 - ma~cb1 Ha YCneX 3 H3 10 - I I I ~ H c ~ I ~a ycnex 1 as 10

258 COqkiAlIbHAH CTOPOHA OUEHKI? M llPAH5ITMH PEUIEHM~~

B TOM onpoce cy%emo~ rrpocm~ o n p e n e n m b , K a m e NaHCbl

H a YCneX OHH PaCCYHTbIBaIOT HMeTb npewe, YeM OHM A U y T B006-

paXCae~0fi UepCOHe COBeT BbI6paTb pHCK. 3 T a n p a 6 0 ~ b 1 C BO~TPOCHH-

KOM Ha3bIBaeTCII @ n p e ~ B a p k l ~ e J I b ~ ~ # n p ~ B e p ~ o f i > > . n 0 c J I e 3 T O m vm- n b 1 H 3 lWTH (WIH OKOJIO T O ~ O ) ¶eJIOBeK O ~ C Y X ~ ~ I O T 12 np06~1e~ pi

HLLIyT KOHCeHCYC B BOlIPOCe, H a K ~ K O Z ~ PHCK MOXHO n~Zi[Tki B K W -

a08 Pi3 ~ 0 0 6 p a X a e ~ b 1 ~ cHTJF~JJM~~. 3 ~ a @a3a H3BeCTHa KaK <(o6pa6a- T b I B a I o U W npOBepIca*.

H e c ~ o p x H a TO YTO CweCTBYlOT AeC2TKl-i BaPHaHTOB 3~0fi TeMbI,

pe3YJIbTaTbI H c c J I ~ A o B ~ H H ~ lTOCTOIIHH0 COBnmaIOT. ~ ~ J T I I ~ o B ~ I ~ AHC-

KYCCHH 3aCTaBJIRIOT JIIOEefi B b 1 6 H p a ~ b PHCK YaWe, YeM OHH AyMaTIpi

3 T 0 CAeJIaTb PaHee . OAH~KO, KOrAa C H a Y m a W O H CAeJIaTb B CTOPO-

HY OCTOPO)I(HOCTH, l?3JTIlTOBbIe AHCKYCCHH M O W HHOrna npHBeCTH

K <<CABHw K OCTOPOXHOCTH*. B 06rue~, MHOlUe HCCJIeAOBaTeXR AJEI

o % a c ~ e ~ w r 3~0ro @ ~ H O M ~ H ~ H C ~ O ~ ~ ~ ~ I O T cetiqac 6onee o6m$i TePMHH <cCABHr B sb160peo.

~ o c K o J I ~ K ~ HCCJIeAOBWHR lTOAHIITWI Bb160pa 6 b m ~ TaK n O n y m p -

H ~ I , ~onpoc rpynno~o8 n o m p ~ 3 a u ~ ~ 6am p a c m k i p e H ewe HecKoJIb-

KElMkI TeMaMH, CBR3aHHbIMH C PHCKOM. H a n p ~ ~ e p , Aa~m Ma8eps H &KOPW 5 H N 0 l l B 1970 rOAy 0 6 ~ a p y m ~ r k 1 , YTO CTYAeHTbI, RMeK)-

w e p a c o s b r e npenpaccyam, erue 6orree y K p e m m T c r i B HHX, o6cy- AHB A p y r C ApylWM 3TH BOIIpOCbI, TOrAa KaK OTHOCHTeJIbHO 06'be~- THBHbIe CTyAeHTbI lTOCJIe 6ecenb1 H a T e Xe TeMbI CKIIOHHM B cue 6onb~et i M e p e OTKEJaTbCFI OT npeApaCCyAKOB. B 1975 rosy Mafieps 06~apymurr, ¶TO P a C X O w e H H e BO B3rJWAaX M e w <(MWCKMMH N O -

BHHHCTSLMH>> H <(@~M~IHAcTK~MH,> ~ ~ ~ J ~ Y ~ J I R ~ T C R nOCne TOTO, KaK We- HbI K W O ~ v y l T l l b I 06cynm M e m y co608 X ~ H C K I ~ ~ ~ BOlTpOC. %OT

TEln R c c J I ~ A o B ~ H H ~ OCHOBaH H a napZi,&kirMe < ~ W ~ O B O # KOMnO3ki-

UHH*, r A e Q)TInbI COCTaBJWIOTCII ki3 JI IOae8 C OAkiHaKOBbIMH B3rJIR-

AaMH ( ~ 3 r m a ~ H H a TeMbI, KOTOPbIe 06~y>yqaTbc% B rpyllne). ApyroZi T H n rpynno~oti nomp~sausu HccneAyeTcrr c kicnonb30-

BaHHeM r r apmHrMbr , B K O T O ~ O ~ c a M a n p 0 6 ~ r e ~ a nopomae-r nonrr- p~3ymr rzk i ec r r W O H b I . @ B M ~ Ma8eps ki M ~ ~ T H H K a ~ m B 1976 rony 0 6 ~ a p y ) ~ k i n ~ , HanpHMep , TO KorAa rpyrrne npenJraraeTcrr PJIF~ 06- CyXUeHHII AOCTaTOYHO M I I ~ ? K M ~ ~ IIPHrOBOP, B ~ I H ~ C ~ H H ~ I ~ CYAOM,

TO nocxe O K o m a H m ARCWCCHH ee P a c T H M m CKJIOHH~I em ewe 6onee C m r Y H T b . E c n ~ Xe I I P ~ A J I o X ~ H H ~ I ~ ~ AJLSI 0 6 c y x ~ e ~ r n npHTO-

BOP C P O B , TO ~fl 'beKTb1 lTpkiXOjl$lT K BMBOW, YTO HeMOXO 6b1 CAe-

JIaTb er0 erne 6onee CYPOBbIM. ~ I T ~ K , Ha¶WbHbIe 3HaHWf, OCHOBaH-

HbIe H a AaHHbIX CBeAeHWIX, llOJIFIpH3YIOTCR B XOAe r p y m 0 ~ 0 8

<cYenose~ rcyrr~ln norumb 3a 60 nom. H nponarr 3a 70 AOM. ~ O T O M

s b r ~ y r r t t r r ee 3a 80 nom. PI c H o s a nponarr 3a 90 norm. CKOJI~KO OH

3apa60~W?)> &a npo6ne~a, n p P I B e A e H H a B n. 20 A H K ~ T ~ I , IIOCJIyXWTa WHO-

BOG o ~ ~ o r o ~3 acme~o~aH& B maccmec~oG pa- H o ~ M ~ H ~ M3pa PI A.rr.rxe~a Coyne~a (1952). Msp H Coyne~ 0 6 ~ a p y X W T k i , YTO TOJI~-

KO 45% OnpOUeHHbIX C W e H T O B MOTJIki peUIHTb 3Ty npo6ne~y B

OAHH09Ky. Korna Xe OHH O ~ C ~ W I ~ T I H ee BllXTepOM WIH BNeCTepOM, OHH n p e K p a c H o cnpamwcb c perueHHeM. C T ~ A ~ H T ~ I , p a 6 0 ~ a ~ u ~ e B I'pylIlTaX C <cHHepTHbIM>> JIHAePOM (IIPOCTO H ~ ~ J I I O A ~ B N H M 38 06- C-~HK~M), OTBeYaJIH B e p H 0 B 72% CJIyYaeB, a Te , KT0 p a 6 0 ~ a ~ C

<(aKTHBHbIM* JIHAePOM ( ~ O ~ Y ) I C ~ ~ B Z U H M BCeX YneHOB VJTnbI BbICKa-

3bIBaTb CBOe MH~HHB), OTBeYalIR B e p H 0 B 84% CnyYaeB.

U T O ~ ~ I yBkLqeTb, HaCKOJIbKO ~ @ @ ~ K T H B H O r p y l T n a ClTpaBlI5IeTCII C

3 m a H H e M , IIepeHeCeMCFI H E J m BO BpeMeHR R nOCMOTpRM H a ~006- p a x a e M y r o rpyrmy, 3 a m ~ y r o n a c K y c c ~ e t i B n a 6 0 p a ~ o p ~ ~ Mspa ki

Coyne~a:

BEHAM (IIkLqep rpJTTnb1): 3 T a npo6~1e~a BbI3bIBaeT y Me- nOA0-

3DeHWI: OHa K m e T C R CIIRNKOM IIpoCTofi , H II H e AOBePIIIO ITCH-

1JIOraM. ~ Y C T ~ ~ w b 1 f i IIOAeJIHTCII CBOHMH MbICJMMH 06 OTBeTe

CKLUKeT, I lOgeMy 3 T 0 P e N e H H e Ka)I<eTCR e M y BepHbIM.

[ET: (I COBepNeHHO yBepeH, YTO OTBeT 10 AOJIJI. (I PaCCYXqLUI

.K: KyrrHB J I O N m b 351 60 AOIIJI. H IIpOAaB 3a 70 AOJIJI. MbI BbIMr-

,rsaeM 10 nom. 3 a ~ e ~ , ecns ~ y r r u ~ b ee 3a 80 AOJUI., TO MOXHO

ITepRTb 10 AOM., lTOTOMy YTO 80 AOJIJI. 6 0 ~ 1 b m e 70 A O M . H MbI

:perLlIaYHBaeM. n p 0 n a ~ J I O N m b 3a 90 AOJIJI. MbI CHOBa BbIHVbI-

leM T e Xe 10 A O m . BOT TaK.

m: R w a r n , 20 nom., noToMy YTO UenoBeK ~ b r ~ r p m 10 A O ~ .

n e p ~ b ~ f i pas, IIpOAaB JIONaQb, H 10 A O M . - lTpOAaB ee BO BTO-

)# pas. Ho nocne p a c c ' y m n e ~ a 8 I j e ~ a rr yxe H e TaK y s e p e H a .

~ k f : He n y ~ a t i o TOM, n p a B a T ~ I r n ~ HeT, M ~ I n p o c T o nb r r aeM-

GI npOHI'paTb BCe B03MOXHbIe BapHaHTbI. K ~ K TbI AyMaeLLIb, CTHB? CTAB: 2 AyMafO, l l p a B l l r r b ~ b 1 8 OTBeT - 30 AOM.: 9eJTOBeK H a r m C

60 A O M . H lTO.JIFWI 90 AOJIJI. TO Xe OH MOT lTOIIYUHTb, KaK H e 30 nonn.?

260 COUMAnbHAA CTOPOHA OqEHKH M IIPMHRTMR PEUIEHMR rPYlTllOBbIE OUEHKM M PEUIEHMR 261

B M M : OH 6b1 ~ O J I Y ~ W I 30 AOJUI., e cnM 6b1 60~1bwe H e T p a T m Ae-

H e r . Ho n p o n a B nowab 3a 70 AOJUI. OH B ~ I K ~ I I W I ee 3a 80 AOJIJI.

H EUIOXWI B H e e ewe 10 AOJUI. T ~ K ¶TO norryYaeTcsI 20 AOJIJI.

(30 AOJUI. M H H ~ C 10 AOJUI.).

B E H A M : Bce COrlIaCHbI c A m n ? 3 M M : Aa. n o IIpaBAe WBOPR, MHe K m e T C R , ¶TO eAMHCTBeHHasI

npmaaa, no K O T O P O ~ ~ 3 ~ a npo6~1e~a ~ b 1 3 b r ~ a e ~ c M y u e H H e , co- CTOHT B TOM, YTO n o K y n a e T c x H n p o n a e T c x o n H a H T a we n o r n a b .

ECJIH 6b1 B YCJIOBHH P e Y b W a 0 AByX pa3HbIX JIOUIWIM, OTBeT

6bm 6br oseawes. E E H H E T : TO TbI HMeeU[b B BWY? B M M : Hy, npep2TaBb , ¶TO YeJIOBeK Kyrrkur JIOIIIaAb 3a 60 AOJrrr. H

nponarr 3a 70 A O ~ . CKOJI~KO OH B~IP~WJI? E E H H E T : 10 AOJIJIapOB.

B M M : T e n e p b npeACTaBb, ¶TO YeJIOBeK K y n U n B T O p p J I O I U a b 3a 80 AOJrrr. H IIpOAaJI 3a 90 AOJIJI. C K O J I ~ K O OH nOJIyWU npa6brna?

EEHHET: Ewe 10 n o m a p o B .

B M M : M T ~ K , BCelW 20 AOJIJIapOB. Ero AOXOAbI H e O n p e A e m m c r r

TeM, OAHy U n H Pa3HbIX J I 0 U I a e f i OH TOpryeT - kI TaK, H TaK OH

nOJIyYHT 20 AOJIJI. O L L I B ~ K ~ AYMaTb, ¶TO, IIOKyrrZUI JIOUIClAb 3a 80 AOJUI., YeJIOBeK TepReT 10 AOJIJI. m5I T o r 0 9 ~ 0 6 b 1 lTOTepsITb

A e H b w , OH AOlIXeH IIPOAaTb ee AeLUeBJIe, YeM KyrrWI.

A T e n e p b OCTaHOBHTe A ~ ~ ~ C T B M ~ H npeACTaBbTe, ¶TO BbI - YJIeH

W TO# r p y r m b ~ . ~ M H 3a~omma c B o e o ~ ~ R c H ~ H H ~ , H T e n e p b B ~ I pac- CKa3bIBaeTl3, KaK H n 0 Y e M y BbI OTBeTkLTIH H a BOIIPOC. ~ o c J I ~ TOlX

KaK H BbI 3aKOHT.IUnH CBOK) PeYb, IpyITIIa ewe HeCKOJIbKO MHHYT

o6cyxqae~ npo6ne~y. ~ K C ~ ~ ~ H M ~ H T ~ T O ~ npOCMT K m O l X HaIIH-

CaTb OTBeT.

Y BaC eCTb ~b160p: H m H C a T b TOT OTBeT, K O T O P ~ ~ BbI A m H B lT. 20 A H K ~ T ~ I , UnH H3MeHHTb er0.

EOJI~UIWHCTBO JImefi B ~ a ~ 0 f i CHTyaUHH AaK)T n p a ~ k v r b ~ b ~ f i OT-

BeT - 20 AOJIJI. % I ~ H ~ I IpJTIlTbI, AaBLUHe C CaMOlW HaYaJIa lTpaBUnb-

~b1f i OTBeT, PenKO MeHXIOT e l X B XOAe AHCKyCCHH, a OCTmbHbIe o6bm HO H c n p a m m m T oTBeT nocne 06cym4e~m.

T ~ M H e MeHee M3p H Coyne~ 0 6 ~ a p y X C k i ~ ~ : He3aBHCHMO OT TOrO,

6bm JIHHeP <(aKTHBeH,> kvrH *HHepTeH*, B C ~ ETIeHbI IpJlIIZbI BbICKa-

3bIBaTIH CBOH M H e H M , HO TOYHOCTb OTBeTOB 6bl~1a BbIUIe, eCJIH JIM-

A e p 6bm aKTHBeH H n o 6 y m ~ m BCeX YrreHOB IpJTIlTbI BbICKFi3bIBaTb

CBOe MHeHHe.

P e 3 y J I b ~ a ~ b 1 aKTHBHOr0, TepneJIHBOlW PJKOBOACTBa KBHO nPORB-

JLIIIOTCR B rpynnax, r A e caauana TOJI~KO OAHH YenoBeK ~m npaBkvrb-

H ~ I # OTBeT. B TaKHX CJIJWaRX B V y l l n a X y aKTHBHbIX JIHAepOB

76% CcTyneHTOB OTBeYaIOT BepHO, TOrAa KaK y HHePTHbM - JIHUIb

36%. 3 T O OTKPbITHe COOTBeTCTBYeT A B W w K T a M H 3 n p e ~ b I A y I 4 e f i

rJIaBb1: (I) JIY¶UIHfi CIIOCO~ ~ 3 6 e X a ~ b rpYIIlTOBOr0 M b I W e H m - BbI-

cJryruan B c e TOYKH 3 p e ~ ~ ~ ( A x ~ H H ~ , 1982); (2) B onpeaeJreHHbDc.

YCJIOBHIM MeHbUIHHCTBO MOXeT CEZTIbHO BJIHHTb H a TOYHOCTb OUeH-

KPi ~ce f i rpJTflTbI ( H ~ M ~ T , 1986). M3p H COYJI~M B 1952 rOHy IIOKa3aJIH, ¶TO OTKPbITaR AACKJ".XkI(I

MOXeT IIpHBeCTH K 3aMeTHOMy POCTJ' TOYHOCTH. Ho, HeCMOTpR H a

COBeTbI, BbICKa3aHHbIe BO B p e M 06cymqe~wr, H e BCe YJIeHbI Qyll-

n b I B 3KCIIepHMeHTe M3pa H C o y J I e ~ a npaBHJIbH0 PeUIUnH 3aAaYy.

H ~ C M O T ~ R H a TO YTO 63 113 67 rpynn H M e n a no ~ p a f i ~ e f i M e p e OAHO-

r0 YeJIOBeKa, IIPaBklTIbHO OTBeTHBUerO H a BOlTpOC, IIpHMepHO IIRTZUI

YaCTb cy65emo~ AaJIa ~ e ~ e p ~ b ~ f i OTBeT naxe nocne 06cyxqe~m. 3 ~ y k l ~ T o ~ a c H ~ H H T O H @HHK B 1961 row 0 6 ~ a p y x w r ~ 6 ~ 1 ~ 3 m e p e 3 y n b ~ a ~ b 1 , ~ c n o n b s y ~ ~y we s a a s ~ y o nponaxe n o m a s . B m 3KCnepHMeHTe 29 H 3 44 rpJTIll BKTIIOYaJIH B ce6~ , IIO ~ p a f i ~ e f i Me-

pe, O A H O ~ r e n o B e K a , s~a~owero n p a ~ k v r b ~ b r f i oTseT, HO TOJI~KO y 15 rpJTfn 6bma TeHAeHUWI AaBaTb lTpaBUnbHbIe OTBeTbI nOCJIe 06- C ~ e H ~ . M T ~ K , rpJTIlTOBbIe AHCKYCCHH lIPHBO&XT K 3aMeTHOMy no- BbILUeHHK) TOYHOCTH, HO H e AaIOT r apaHTHH TOW, ¶TO @Ce YJIeHbI

IpJTIlTbI OTBeTRT BepHO.

OAHA rOJIOBA XOPOIIIO, A ABE JlY!IIIIE?

rpynno~bre o u e H m B OCHOBHOM ToYHee H H ~ H B ~ ~ ~ ~ J I ~ H ~ I X , HO TO

H e BCerAa TaK. rpyTI lTo~a5I TOYHOCTb 3aBHCHT OT HeCKOJIbKkIX @~KTO-

POB, B TOM YHCJIe OT IIPHPOAbI H CJIOXHOCTH 3 a a ¶ H , OT KOMlTeTeHT-

HOCTH YJIeHOB IpJTInbI, cnoc06a 0 6 w e ~ m H Ten. P e a X(3fic~l-i B

1986 lWLiJ o ~ ~ ~ ~ J I H K o B ~ J I 0630p, B KOTOPOM PaCCMaTPHBaTIHCb MHO-

Iue @aKT0pb1, B J I M I o U H e H a rpJTIlIOByI0 OUeHKy, H CpaBHHBaJIHCb

rpyll lTbI H HKqHBHAYYMbI lTO TpeM pa3J rWHbIM THnaM: (1) OUeHKe

KOJIHYeCTBa H BeJIFFIHHbI, HaITPHMeP, KOJIkNeCTBa 6060~ B CTaKaHe;

(2) OUeHKe B OTBeTe H a lXJIOBOJIOMKI4, BpOAe 3a4aYKPi 0 JIOLUa9H;

(3) OUeHKe B 0TBeTa.X H a BOlTpOCbI H 3 O ~ J I ~ C T H o6wero 3HaHHR, Ha-

n p H M e p , a 6 c e ~ ~ - 3TO JIHKep HJIH MHH~PCLJI?

B OTHOILleHUH KOJIHYeCTBeHHbIX ~ m e ~ k i f i X ~ ~ C T H 3aKJIK)YUn,

¶TO rpJTInb1 O ~ ~ I Y H O HeCKOJIbKO 6onee TOYHbI, YeM HHAHBFUlYYMbI

262 COUHAnbHM CTOPOHA OUEHKM A IIPAHIITAII PEUIEHAB

(AJM Yki~aTeJIef i , 3HaKOMbIX CO C T ~ T R C T H K O ~ ~ , X e f i c ~ W coo6ruae~, Y m

pa3HHUa P a B W a C b 0 ~ ~ 0 f i B O C ~ M O ~ ~ eAUHHL(b1 CTaHAaPTHOrO OTIUIO-

HCHRII). E 0 J I e e COBpeMeHHbIe HCCJIeAOBaHPM A X ~ H ~ T C ~ a f i 3 e ~ a E e ~ ~ k l X ~ H ~ H (1989, 1990) nOKa3aJIHY YTO B HeKOTOPbIX CJlJW3m

3 T a pa3HHUa MOXeT 6bITb 60JIbLUe, YeM OUeHWBZUI ee X e f i c ~ W . Hc- nOJIb3yR Mepy, W3BeCTHYIO KaK <~CTaHAaPTH3BpOBaHHOe OTKJIOHeHHe>>,

C ~ a f i 3 e ~ H xe~pW O ~ H ~ P ~ X ~ ~ T I W , WO r p y r r n b I ki3 T p e x YeJIoBeK 6 b m a

H a 23-32% T o s H e e , s e M W W M B U ~ W ~ I , T.e. B 2-3 pa3a 6 o n b r u e ,

YeM YCTaHOBMJI X e f i c ~ H .

B TOM, YTO KaCaROCb rOJIOBOJIOMOK Ii APJTWX BOnPOCOB, CBR3aH-

HbIX C J I o ~ H K o ~ ~ , X ~ ~ ~ C T M o ~ H ~ P Y X M J I , YTO VJTInbI O ~ ~ I Y H O npeB0C-

XOAWIH HHAWBWYYMOB O ~ ~ W M pa3BMTHeM, HO YTO caMb1fi y ~ ~ b 1 f i

llpeACTaBklTeJIb I'pJTInbI B OAWHOYKY p a 6 o ~ a ~ 1 JlyI-rIIIe, YeM BCR rpw- lTa B UeJIOM. TOYHO TaK Xe X e f i c ~ W 0 6 ~ a p m ~ , YTO rpJTIlTbI O ~ ~ I Y H O

IIpeBOCXOART CpeAHerO M H A A B k t 4 W a B OTBeTaX H a BOnPOCbI, CBFI-

3aHHbIe C O ~ L L I ; R M 3HaHWeM, HO YTO J I ~ U I W ~ ~ WIeH T w l T b I H e YCTY-

lTUl klTIH lTPeBOCXOAHJI VJTIITY B UeJIOM.

~ O A O ~ H ~ I ~ pe3YJIbTaTbI PaCCMOTpeJIa r e h %JUI B 1982 rOAy B

c~oefi cTaTbe <<Group versus Individual Performance: Are N + 1 Heads Better Than One?,, npenc~am~mwefi co6ofi 0630p H C C J I ~ A O B ~ H H ~ ~

~ m ~ ~ k i n y a r r b ~ b ~ w r p y n n o ~ b l ~ no~a3a~enefi 3a 50 neT. H~CMOTPII H a TO YTO OHa YAeJLZLna 60~1bme BHWMaHWR llOBeaeHHIO, a H e OUeH-

Ke H ITPHHRTHH) perue~afi, oAHa 143 Y a c ~ e f i ee p a 6 o ~ b 1 rrocagrueaa TBOpYeCTBY H PelLIeHIiIO npo6ne~. k J I O ~ H ~ ~ Y X M J I ~ , YTO rpJTIlTb1

sarac~yro n p e B o c x o n w n i c p e a H M x HWHBMWOB, HO rpynnb~ He-

PenKO YCTJTIaJIH HaWJryrmeMy HHAHBWYYMY, HaXOAIIIL@MYCR B CTa-

T k I C T ~ e C K O M KOMeKTWBe ( H ~ B ~ ~ H M O A ~ ~ ~ C T B ~ ~ O ~ ~ I ? P y I I l T e T o r 0 Xe pa3~epa). B o T H o r u e H a H IIPOCT~IX BO~POCOB y B e n m e H H e r p y n n b r

03HaYZUIO BCerO JIHUIb, YTO OHa BepORTHee 6 y ~ e ~ BKJIIOYaTb B c e 6 ~ XOTR 6b1 O A H O ~ YenoBeKa, C ~ T O C O ~ H O ~ O p e m m 3a,qa~y. perue- HHR CJIOXHbIX BOlTPOCOB KOMaHAHaR pa60~a WMeeT HeOClTOpHMOe

lTpeHM)WJeCTBO: WIeHbI VJTIIIbI M O W lTOAeJIHTbCR MHeHHeM H MC-

lTpaBHTb O U I A ~ K H ApyT ApyTa.

k J I T a m e o6pa~ma BHHMaHHe H H a ~ P ~ ~ ~ H C T O ~ M W H ~ (~03r0-

BOG LUTYPM). B YaCTHOCTM, OHa CpaBHMBaJIa KOJIAYeCTBO Wefi, BbI-

~ ~ ~ O T ~ H H ~ I X rpyllnofi, C KOJIHseCTBOM W~efi, npeAJIOXeHHbIX ~ 0 f i Xe YMCJIeHHOCTbIo JIIOnefi, KOTOPbIe CHaYaJIa <<UITYPMOBaJIH% no-OT-

AeJIbHOCTH H IIO3AHee CJIOXHJIW CBOW HAeH BMeCTe. Xk~nrr o6~apy- XHJIa, YTO ~ P ~ ~ ~ H C T O P M M H ~ 6bll160JIee YClTeLUHbIM, KOrna W e M BbI-

p a 6 a ~ b I ~ i W W c b He3aBMCHM0, a IIOTOM K O M ~ U H H ~ O B ~ T I M C ~ , HeXeJIW

Drna OHW BbIABHraJIHCb n p k l I'pJTIllOBOM 06cymqeaa~. OH^ CAeJIa-

a BbIBOA, YTO npeBOCXOnCTB0 T y I I n b I TIpOIIWeTCFI M3-3a TOrO, YTO

6 o n b r u e nmefi sa~mo p e m e H H e M l I p 0 6 J I e ~ b 1 , a H e ~3 -3a c a M o r o

B ~ ~ M M O A ~ ~ ~ C T B ~ . B lTPaKTHYeCKOM CMbICJIe 3 T 0 03HaYaeT, YTO JT4"I- LUWfi cnoco6 ~ b I p a 6 0 ~ a ~ b peIUeHHe T ~ Y A H O ~ ~ n p 0 6 J I e ~ b 1 COCTOHT B

CJIeAylomeM: HeCKOJIbKO JIIOAefi He3aBHCWMO p a 6 0 ~ a I O ~ H a STHM, a s a ~ e ~ AenrmcR CBOHMH W e s M H .

Hec~oTprr H a TO YTo rpylTlTa BbIHOCkIT 6onee BepHbIe OUeHKH, YeM

HHAMBITAYYM, TOYHOCTb 3aBHCHT H OT TOrO, KaKHM 06pa30~ YJIeHbI

I'pJTInbI K O M ~ H H H P ~ ~ ~ T CBOR OTBeTbI C ~ ~ ~ B H C , 1973). k I c c J I e ~ 0 ~ a -

HHe, mIocTpapymu.tee 3m s a ~ e s a ~ ~ i e , 6 b m 0 o ~ I Y ~ J I H K o B ~ H o Axa- HeT C ~ a f i 3 e ~ B 1989 WAy. C ~ a f i 3 e ~ COnOCTaBWIa lMTb THllOB MeTO-

AHK n p a m m perue~~f i , r rpuMemeMaDt rpynnam: (I) <<KoHceHcyc)>,

KOrAa B JIO~OBOM, OTKpbITOM O~C)OKE~HMB B ~ I ~ H P ~ ~ T C I I OUeHKa, lTpki-

HRMaeMaR BCeMH YJIeHaMA rpJTII1bI; (2) <cqHaJIeKTWeCKasr* MeTO-

AHKa, B K O T O P O ~ ~ WIeHbI I'pylTlTbI 06cym4a10~ @aKTopbI, KOTOpbIe

M O W nOBJIHRTb H a WX OUeHKY; (3) UAHKTaTJ'Pa)>, KOrAa 06cym4e~We 3aKaI-WWBaeTCFI B ~ I ~ O P O M cy6'be~~a, YbR OUeHKa H CTaHeT O U ~ H K O ~ ~

rpylTIIb1; (4) MeTOA Aenb@~, K O r a a YJIeHbI l"pylTlTb1 H e BCTPeYaH3TCFI

JIHUOM K JIHUY, a BMeCTO 3TOM) llPeACTaBJIRIOT OTBeTbI aHOHHMHO B

CepHH < < p a m O B % , n 0 K a H e 6yne~ AOClurHyT KOHCeHCyC WIW TIpWm-

TO cpenaee peruewie (np~sr r~oe KaqecTBo 3~01% M e T o n H m C O C T O ~

B TOM, YTO WIeHbI rpyIIlTbI3aCTpaXOBaHbI OT TOrO, YTO KTO-TO OAHH

MOXeT MOHOlTOJIH3HpOBaTb AWCQ'CCHIO H He3aMeTHO BJ'IPMTb H a OC-

TZUI~H~IX); (5) <<KOJLJleKTWBHaR* MeTOAHKa, lTpeAOTBpal4alOu.taR BCe

HHTPHrH CpeAM WIeHOB rp)TIlTbI, lTOCKOJIbKY lTPOCTO YCpeAHReT WH-

AWBmyaJIbHbIe OUeHKH AJrrr lTOJIy¶eHPM O U e H M K O J I J I ~ K T H B H O ~ ~

(B HCCJIeAOBaHHH C ~ a f i 3 e ~ KOMeKTWBHaR MeTOAHKa YCTaHaRJIHBaJIa

6 a 3 0 ~ p J r m r a I o TOYHOCTH, ~ O C K O ~ ~ Q ' H e ~ ~ B H C ~ J I ~ OT C O U E ~ ~ ~ B H ~ M

@~KTOPOB).

K w a R W y l T n a COCTO5IJIa H3 13TW CTYAeHTOB, H K W m WClTOJIb-

3OBaJIa BCe 1 3 T b MeTOAUK. rpy lTnb1 HaYHHaJIA C HCllOJIb3OBaHlM KOJI-

J I ~ K T H B H o ~ ~ MeTOAHKH, ITOCJIe YeM) HClTOJIb30BaJIW lTpOYHe B lTepe-

MeHHOM lTOpRAKe. 3 m a Y e f i CTYAeHTOB 6 b m 0 OUeHHTb, HaCKOJIbKO

6on~ru)?o ~ b r p p ~ y nonyrm npu~wexau. tuf i KomeLUKy ~ a r a 3 ~ ~ B CJIeAyrOLNeM MeCRW 38 O A e W , >KYPHaJIbI, OTKpbITKM, CJ'BeHMPbI,

KOCMeTHKY Pi JIeKapCTBa. C ~ a f i 3 e ~ OnpeAeJI5LJIa TOYHOCTb OgeHOK

264 COuMAnbHM CTOPOHA 0uEHKM M IIPMHHTMH PELLIEHM~

OTHOCHTeJIbHO p e a J I b ~ 0 f i B b I p ~ K H B < ( ~ ~ c o J I I ~ T H o M IIPOUeHTe OT-

IUIOHeHWI%.

OH^ 0 6 ~ a p y X M J I a , YTO KaX&%J A 3 YeTbIpeX nepBbIX MeTOAHK (KOH-

CeHCyC, AHaJIeKTAKa, AAKTaTypa H ~ e J l b @ H f i c ~ % I ) AOCTHraJIa 6onee TOYHbIX pe3YJIbTaTOB, YeM IIpOCTOe YCpeAHeHHe ( K O J I J I ~ K T H B H ~ Me-

T O A W K ~ ) , HO ~ a k 1 6 0 n b u ~ l e ycnexu npmecna A w m a T y p a , n p ~ KOTO-

p0fi I IpOqeHT OLUH~KH 6bLJI B CpeAHeM B TPA pa3a MeHbLUe. M H T ~ - peCH0, OAHaKO, YTO B K W O M CJryYae npHMeHeHtv I <(HHKTaTpbIa

AHKTaTOp WJTInbI H3MeH5KJI CBOe KOHeYHOe MHeHHe B HaIIpaBJleHHH

KOJUIeKTHBHOrO CpeAHerO, TeM CaMbIM YBeJIEZZIHBa5l BeJIHYHHY 0 ~ ~ 6 - KH. A p y r u ~ k ~ CJIOBaMH, QJTInbI 6bU'IA C ~ O C O ~ H ~ I ~ b 1 6 A p a ~ b AHKTa-

TOPOB, AaBaBLUHX TOYHbIe OTBeTbI, HO AHKTaTOP TYT Xe CTaHOBlWCH

AeMOKPaTOM H, T a m M 06pa30~, CHHXaJI 06wy10 TOYHOCTb OTBeTOB.

KOH~YHO, OTKPbITtvI, CAeJIaHHbIe C ~ a f i 3 e ~ , c ~ T ~ ~ H @ H Y H ~ I , OTHO-

cmca TOJI~KO K r p y n n a M o n p e n e n e H H o r o pa3~epa ( m ~ b s e n o ~ e ~ ) , onpenene~~ofi K a T e r o p H u ( C V A ~ H T ~ I ) H K o n p e ~ e r r e ~ ~ o f i smase ( o n p e ~ e n e ~ ~ e AOXOAOB ~ a r a s t r ~ a ) . Ebmo 6b1 rnyno cskiTaTb, YTO

MeTOA AHKTaTypbI p a 6 0 ~ a e ~ J IFLI Ie BO BCeX CHTYaUHXX. T ~ M H e Me-

H e e 3KCnepHMeHT C ~ a f i 3 e ~ ITOKa3aJI, YTO TOYHOCTb PeLUeHHR, IIpH-

HRTOrO l?pYl'IlTofi, 3aBHCHT H OT TOTO, KaKElM 06pa30~ OH0 ~ b I p a 6 0 -

TaHO. Ee Pe3YJIbTaTbI llPOAeMOHCTPBPOBanki, ¶TO B HeKOTOPbIX

CJIyI.Ia5I.X 3KCnepTHOe PeLUeHHe, ITpkIHriTOe l?pynlT~fi, OKa3bIBaeTCR

xyYrue , s e M cTaTwr t - r s ecKoe y c p e n H e H n e o u e H o K , n p e m o x e H H b u r

H e COBeUaBLUHMHCR XIoAbMH. H T ~ K , IIO ~ p a f i ~ e f i Mepe , B KOHKPeT-

~ 0 f i CHTYaUMH pe3yJIbTaT 3aBBCHT 2 JIU HBe rOJIOBb1, YeM OAHa, HO H OT TOrO, HbI.

:o OT TOT

rOJIOBbI

n 0 ~ ~ 0 J I b K y Pe3YJIbTaTb1, IIPOAeMOHCTPHPOBaHHbIe l?pYTInaMA, On-

PeAeJEfIoTCR CTOJIbKUMH (PaKT0pa~l-i~ TpYAHO AeJIaTb K a m e - T O 0606- U e H H R (TAmeZiTI, 1989). no 3~0fi Xe IIpEZZIHHe TpyAHO 0 6 ' b e A k i ~ A ~ b

OTAeJIbHbIe pe3yJIbTaTbI H C C J I ~ A O B ~ H H ~ ~ rpwn. K ~ O ~ T C R JIH PaCXOX-

A e H u e B p a s ~ ~ u e EM? B pas~epax r p y n n b r ? B npasmax npmrrrtlrr p e I I I e ~ H f i ? B c a ~ 0 f i AHTepnpeTaIJElH P ~ ~ Y J I ~ T ~ T O B ?

TO O l W T b - T a m pe3YJIbTaT TOrO, YTO rpyIIn0~0fi OUeHKe M pe- LUeHEWM H e YAeJIILnOCb CTOJIbKO BHHMaHHR, CKOJIbKO HHAABHAy-

ZLJIbHbIM, HeCMOTPR H a H m H Y H e KOMHTeTOB, K O M H C C H ~ ~ , CYAOB, L U T ~ ~ O B H n P Y r H X rpylln, n p e A H a 3 H a s e H H b I X AJIR B ~ I ~ ~ ~ O T K M

perue~sfi. Eonee T O ~ O , r p a H A n a M e m a y M c c n e n o s a H m M H rpynn H

TPYnllOBME OUEHW M PELUEHMH 265

k ZyyMOB H e npOBO~KJIaCb, nOCKOJIbw rp)'lTnbI, B W H E JIH,

T O X e COCTOsIT H 3 HHAMBHAYYMOB. H ~ ~ P H M ~ P , HCCAeAOBaHAe

rp)'lTn0~0# oua6m a ~ y u 6 y u u ~ - 3T0, @ ~ K T ~ I Y ~ C K E I , HCCJIeAOBaHMe

T o m , KaK U H ~ U B U ~ ~ M M OUeHHBaKYT TpylTlTbI. TOYHO TaK Xe CABHrH

K ~ b 1 6 0 p y M O W A3yWTbCR A nyTeM C p a B H e H W rpJTInOBbIX p e ~ e ~ t i f i c H H ~ H B H A ~ ~ J I ~ H ~ I M H , H KaK cpaBHeHHe H H A H B ~ ~ ~ ~ J I ~ H ~ I X p e r u e ~ k i f i

A 0 A nOCJIe r p y l T n 0 ~ 0 f i AHCKyCCAH. T o n b ~ o B TIepBOM CJryYae 3 T 0

~ e f i c ~ ~ k i ~ e n b ~ o 2pynno6oe peuIeHkie .

OAH~KO H c c n e A o s a H u R rpyl-rno~ofi o u e ~ w H n p H w r T m pewe- HH$~ ~ O S B O ~ I O T c n e n a T b cneaymmae 3 a ~ n m e ~ w r :

M ~ o r A e JIHYHOCTHbIe BHAbI 3BpHCTAKH M C M ~ U ~ H E I ~ ~ IIpORB-

JEfIOTCR H B vJTIn0~0fi OUeHKe.

r p y l T I I o ~ a 5 I AHCKYCCWR YaCTO YCHJIMBaeT IIepBOHaYaJIbHbIe

CWIOHHOCTA ( T ~ W ~ H U B H ) .

rp)'lTnbI 0 6 b m ~ o ~ ~ O ~ R B S L I ~ T C I I I T ~ U I A X pe3yJIbTaT0By YeM AH-

AHBPiJJJ'MbI, O C O ~ ~ H H O eCJIH JIMAeP A O ~ M B ~ ~ T C F I , Y ~ 0 6 b 1 C6Oe

MHeHHe BbICKa3aJIH 6Ce WIeHbI l?pylTnbI.

n y ~ L U A f i W e H rpJTIIIbI B OAHHOYKy MOXeT A O ~ U T ~ C I I 60JIbUIer0

(YTO MOXeT HHOrAa C b I v a T b H a ITOJIb3Y <~~~HKT~TJ'P~I)>).

Mosro~ofi L U T ~ M ~ @ @ ~ K T H B H ~ ~ , ecnli YneHbr r p y ~ ~ n b ~ r e H e -

PHpyrOT m e A He3aBHCHMO.

K w o e I13 3TIIX ~ ~ K T I I O P ~ H A ~ ~ O ~ O C H O B ~ H O HOCTaTOYHbIM YHUIOM

3KCIIepAMeHTOB, HO IIOCKOJIbKy H a rpJTIlTb1 EUIkWeT CJIHLUKOM MHOrO

@ ~ K T o ~ o B , AX MOXHO BOClTpUHAMaTb KaK 06111kie COBeTbI. H~CMOTPR H a TO YTO JIIoAH YaCTO ~ ~ ' ~ ~ ~ H H R I O T C R AJIR llpHHIITHR p e ~ [ e ~ H f i , CO-

TpynHwrecTBo - H e B c e r n a r a p a H T m ycnexa.