0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:;...

12
!"#$%#&’ )#’%$"*"#’+, #’ +-$ ./,#0 12 )"$3$"#04 5$6#/, 789:;<8=>?@ !"#$%&’ %) *&+,"*’ -./0 /01 2344.561 17812/.39 3: ;1<8= ><?.9@1<A /01<1 .4 0?<B6= ?9= 3/01< C166DE93C9 :3<1.@9 83F2341< C./0 4G80 86341 /.14 /3 ’3<C?= ?4 H<1B1<.8E I16.G4) J1 K.4./1B ’3<C?= F?9= /.F14A 3:/19 4/?=.9@ :3< F39/04 ?/ ? /.F1L 01 F?B1 :<.19B4 C./0 ? @<1?/ 9GF51< 3: ’3<C1@.?94A .986GB.9@ *BK?<B MG980 ?9B *BK?<B ><.1@L ?9B .9 NOPN 01 0?B ? 83//?@1 5G.6B ?/ Q14R?4E3@ .9 /01 K?661= 3: >GB5<?9B4B?619) I16.G4 ?643 83F2341B 41K1<?6 C3<E4 839918/1B /3 ’3<C?=A .9 /01 41941 /0?/ /01= ?<1 5?41B 39 17/<?FG4.8?6 43G<814 3: ’3<C1@.?9 3<[email protected] 3< /0?/ /01.< /./614 ?<1 ?4438.?/1B C./0 /0.4 83G9/<=) "11 !"# %# S0141 C3<E4 /14/.:= /3 I16.G4T4 B112 .9K36K1F19/ .9 ’3<C1@.?9 8G6/G<1) !"# %& I16.G4T4 U’3<C1@.?9V C3<E4A 80<[email protected]?66= 3<B1<1BW U’3<[email protected] "806.//19:?0</VA 2.?93 2.181 XNYYZ[ N\ 439@4 XK3.81 ?9B 2.?93[ 41/ /3 231F4 5= #R]<9439A -160?K19A $ ;?G6419A S ,R1<G6:A ! MG980A +5419A ^.9R1A ^ ,<?@ XNYY_DNYON[ P 2?</439@4 41/ /3 231F4 5= #R]<9439 ?9B +5419 XNYYZA NYON[ ’(( )*++,-., ‘a9 /01 J1.@0/4bA ?:/1< +5419T4 8=861 3: 231F4 XN) K1<4.39 <18./1< ?9B 3<80)A NYYYL P) K1<4.39 ?4 U83981</ 3K1</G<1V :3< 3<80)A NYOcDOP[ ) +98.B19/?6 FG4.8 /3 >G99?< J1.51<@T4 26?= /012,-((+,3 ‘S01 ;13261T4 ;?<6.?F19/b XNYOZ[ 45, 60.7 08 35, 9*75 9*11:; 803<G4 ?9B 3<80) XNONN[ <. 9,(-*.7 35, /*-:3 =>?200 *. 6@-*.7; :3< 4F?66 3<80) XNONP[ XdG3/14 /01 ’3<C1@.?9 :36E F163B= U+9 a6?DB?63FV[ !A,.3B- C<.?, >@0. ( 3*D,E A ?:/1< !45R]<9419e4 :36E/?614A :3< 3<80) XNONZ[ +9 /0.4 2?21< + 40?66 :38G4 39 43F1 ?4218/4 3: 4/=6.4/.8 4.F.6?<./.14 51/C119 /01 FG4.8 3: ><.1@ ?9B /01 FG4.8 3: I16.G4) a: 83G<41A 4.F.6?<./.14 51/C119 /01 /C3 83F2341<4 0?K1 5119 B.48G441B 1?<6.1<A 5G/ /01 4G5R18/ 0?4 0?<B6= 5119 170?G4/1BA 14218.?66= C019 ./ 83F14 /3 /01.< 0?<F39.8 ?9B /39?6 /0.9E.9@) ’3CA /01 K1<= 839812/ 3: FG4.8?6 .9:6G1981 <?.414 43F1 2<3561F4W +: /01 FG4.8 3: =3G9@1< 83F2341< ! 411F4 /3 <141F561 /01 FG4.8 3: 36B1< 83F2341< #A /0.4 B314 93/ 918144?<.6= .F26= /0?/ # 1781</1B .9:6G1981 39 !A ?4 /01= F?= 53/0 0?K1 5119 .9:6G1981B 5= 83F2341< f) !6/1<9?/.K16=A /01 4.F.6?<./= F?= 51 BG1 /3 53/0 83F2341<4 40?<.9@ /01 4?F1 4/=6.4/.8 93<F4) "218.?6.4/4 .9 /01 41F.363@= 3: FG4.8 0?K1 2<32341B /3 B.K.B1 ? 2.181 3: FG4.8 .9/3 B.::1<19/ :3B1*:3*? 1,A,1:; C0.80 F?= 51 .66GF.9?/.9@) "11 !"# F# 1

Transcript of 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:;...

Page 1: 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ?griegsociety.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Asbjorn-Eriksen-paper... · 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ? ... 9

!"#$%#&'()#'%$"*"#'+,(#'(+-$(./,#0(12()"$3$"#04(5$6#/,(789:;<8=>?@

!"#$%&'(%)(*&+,"*'

-./0 ( /01 (2344.561 (17812/.39(3:(;1<8=(><?.9@1<A ( /01<1( .4 (0?<B6=(?9=(3/01< (C166DE93C9

:3<1.@9(83F2341<(C./0(4G80(86341(/.14(/3('3<C?=(?4(H<1B1<.8E(I16.G4)(J1(K.4./1B('3<C?=

F?9=(/.F14A(3:/19(4/?=.9@(:3<(F39/04(?/(?(/.F1L(01(F?B1(:<.19B4(C./0(?(@<1?/(9GF51<(3:

'3<C1@.?94A(.986GB.9@(*BK?<B(MG980(?9B(*BK?<B(><.1@L(?9B(.9(NOPN(01(0?B(?(83//?@1

5G.6B(?/(Q14R?4E3@(.9(/01(K?661=(3:(>GB5<?9B4B?619)(I16.G4(?643(83F2341B(41K1<?6(C3<E4

839918/1B ( /3 ('3<C?=A ( .9 ( /01 ( 41941 ( /0?/ ( /01= ( ?<1 ( 5?41B ( 39 ( 17/<?FG4.8?6 ( 43G<814 ( 3:

'3<C1@.?9(3<[email protected](3<(/0?/(/01.<(/./614(?<1(?4438.?/1B(C./0(/0.4(83G9/<=)("11 (!"#$%#( S0141

C3<E4(/14/.:=(/3(I16.G4T4(B112(.9K36K1F19/(.9('3<C1@.?9(8G6/G<1)

!"#$%&(I16.G4T4(U'3<C1@.?9V(C3<E4A(80<[email protected]?66=(3<B1<1BWU'3<[email protected]("806.//19:?0</VA(2.?93(2.181(XNYYZ[N\(439@4(XK3.81(?9B(2.?93[(41/(/3(231F4(5=(#R]<9439A(-160?K19A($(;?G6419A(S(,R1<G6:A(

!(MG980A(+5419A(^.9R1A(^(,<?@(XNYY_DNYON[P(2?</439@4(41/(/3(231F4(5=(#R]<9439(?9B(+5419(XNYYZA(NYON['(($)*++,-.,( `a9( /01(J1.@0/4bA (?:/1< ( +5419T4 (8=861 (3: (231F4(XN) (K1<4.39 ( <18./1< (?9B

3<80)A(NYYYL(P)(K1<4.39(?4(U83981</(3K1</G<1V(:3<(3<80)A(NYOcDOP[()+98.B19/?6 (FG4.8 ( /3 (>G99?< (J1.51<@T4 ( 26?= (/012,-((+,3 $`S01 (;13261T4 ( ;?<6.?F19/b (

XNYOZ[45,$60.7$08$35,$9*75$9*11:;(803<G4(?9B(3<80)(XNONN[<.$9,(-*.7$35,$/*-:3$=>?200$*.$6@-*.7;(:3<(4F?66(3<80)(XNONP[

XdG3/14(/01('3<C1@.?9(:36E(F163B=(U+9(a6?DB?63FV[!A,.3B-$C<.?,$>@0.$($3*D,EA(?:/1<(!45R]<9419e4(:36E/?614A(:3<(3<80)(XNONZ[

+9(/0.4(2?21<(+(40?66 (:38G4(39(43F1(?4218/4(3:(4/=6.4/.8(4.F.6?<./.14(51/C119(/01

FG4.8 ( 3: ( ><.1@ ( ?9B ( /01 (FG4.8 ( 3: ( I16.G4) ( a: ( 83G<41A ( 4.F.6?<./.14 ( 51/C119 ( /01 ( /C3

83F2341<4 ( 0?K1 ( 5119 ( B.48G441B ( 1?<6.1<A ( 5G/ ( /01 ( 4G5R18/ ( 0?4 ( 0?<B6= ( 5119 ( 170?G4/1BA

14218.?66=(C019(./(83F14(/3(/01.<(0?<F39.8(?9B(/39?6(/0.9E.9@)('3CA(/01(K1<=(839812/(3:

FG4.8?6(.9:6G1981(<?.414(43F1(2<3561F4W(+:(/01(FG4.8(3:(=3G9@1<(83F2341<(!(411F4(/3

<141F561(/01(FG4.8(3:(36B1<(83F2341<(#A(/0.4(B314(93/(918144?<.6=(.F26=(/0?/(#(1781</1B

.9:6G1981(39(!A(?4(/01=(F?=(53/0(0?K1(5119(.9:6G1981B(5=(83F2341<(f)(!6/1<9?/.K16=A(/01

4.F.6?<./=(F?=(51(BG1(/3(53/0(83F2341<4(40?<.9@(/01(4?F1(4/=6.4/.8(93<F4)("218.?6.4/4(.9

/01(41F.363@=(3:(FG4.8(0?K1(2<32341B(/3(B.K.B1(?(2.181(3:(FG4.8(.9/3(B.::1<19/ (:3B1*:3*?

1,A,1:;(C0.80(F?=(51(.66GF.9?/.9@)("11(!"#$F#

1

Page 2: 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ?griegsociety.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Asbjorn-Eriksen-paper... · 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ? ... 9

!"#$&(X:<3F('?//.1g(NOOcW(Nh\[

H<3F(/01(/.2(3:(/01(2=<?F.BA(C./0(/<?./4(G9.dG1(/3(?(@.K19(C3<EA(C1(?4819B(/3(@<?BG?66=

F3<1(@191<?6(61K164) (i9B3G5/1B6=(><.1@(?9B(I16.G4(40?<1( /01(4?F1(U4=4/1F(X4/=61[(3:

<1:1<1981VA(?9B(2<35?56=(?643(40?<1(/01(4?F1(U4/=61(3:(`)))b(?9(12380VA(4.981(/01(FG4.8?6

4/=61(3:(53/0(83F2341<4(F?=(51(/1<F1B(X43F1C0?/(4.F26.:.1B[(?4(Q?/1(&3F?9/.8(C./0

+F2<144.39.4/(161F19/4)(S0G4A(./(F?=(51(B.::.8G6/(/3(B.4/[email protected](/01(21<439?6(4/=61(3:(/0141

83F2341<4(:<3F(:1?/G<14(83FF39(/3(/01(@<1?/1<(2?</(3:(*G<321?9(?</(FG4.8(:<3F(/01(6?/1

NO/0(f19/G<=)(

-0.61 ( ./ ( .4 ( .F23</?9/ ( /3 ( <1?6.g1 ( /0141 (2<3561F4 (83981<9.9@ (FG4.8?6 ( .9:6G1981A

/01<1(.4(6.//61(B3G5/(/0?/(><.1@(?8/G?66=(.9:6G1981B(I16.G4)("3F1/.F14(I16.G4T4(FG4.8(0?4(?

4/<.E.9@ ( <141F56?981 ( /3 (><.1@T4 (21<439?6 ( 4/=61A (?9B ( .9 ( ?BB./.39 (C1 (F?=(23.9/ (3G/ ( ?9

17/1<9?6 ( .9B.8?/.39W ( /01 ( 86341 ( :<.19B40.2 ( 51/C119 ( /01 ( /C3 ( F19 ( ?9B ( I16.G4T4 ( C166D

B38GF19/1B(?BF.<?/.39(:3<(><.1@T4(FG4.8) (#G/ (50G $.4 (/01(.9:6G1981(3:(><.1@T4(FG4.8

<1:618/1B(.9(/01(C3<E4(3:(I16.G4j(+9(F=(2?21<(+(40?66(/<=(/3(.66GF.9?/1(/0.4(dG14/.39(5=

F1?94(3:(403</ (17?F2614(:<3F(/01(FG4.8(3:(53/0(83F2341<4)(+(C.66 (839:.91(F=416:(/3

/<1?/.9@(4.F.6?<./.14(51/C119(><.1@(?9B(/01(FG4.8(:<3F(I16.G4T4(D(3>-,(21<.3BA([email protected]@

?53G/ ( NOcc) ( S0G4A ( + ( 40?66 ( 93/ ( B.48G44 ( C3<E4 ( :<3F ( C0?/ ( F?= ( 51 ( /1<F1B ( I16.G4T4

(@@-,.3*?,$B,(-:;(.986GB.9@(/01(439@4(41/(/3(231F4(5=('3<C1@.?9(?G/03<4)(H3<(/01(4?E1(3:

86?<./=(+(C.66 (dG3/1(/01(4011/(FG4.8(17?F2614(:<3F(I16.G4T4(3<8014/<?6(2.1814(?4(2.?93

<1BG8/.394A(?44GF.9@(/0?/(I16.G4(C?4(93/(2?</.8G6?<6=(.9:6G1981B(5=(><.1@T4(3<8014/<?/.39

/1809.dG14)(

2

(

Page 3: 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ?griegsociety.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Asbjorn-Eriksen-paper... · 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ? ... 9

!4(/3(/01(3K1<?66(:3<F(3:(19/.<1(C3<E4(3<(F3K1F19/4A(I16.G4T4(F?/G<1(C3<E4(B3

93/ ( 411F( /3 (51 ( .9:6G1981B (5=(><.1@A (21<0?24 (C./0 ( /01 (17812/.39 (3: ( ? ( :1C(C3<E4 ( .9

K?<.?/.39 ( :3<F) (-0.61 (><.1@ ( 3:/19 ( 6.E14 ( 17?8/ ( <121/./.394 ( 3: ( 639@1< ( 41@F19/4 ( .9 ( /01

FG4.8?6(B.483G<41A(I16.G4(G4G?66=(2<1:1<4(B1K1632.9@(/01(FG4.8(6.E1(6.9E4(.9(?(80?.9(3:

?4438.?/.394A ( ?K3.B.9@ ( UB? (8?234V) ('3< ( .4 (I16.G4 (2?</.8G6?<6= ( .9:6G1981B (5=( /01 (F34/

2<393G981B(:36E(FG4.8(161F19/4(.9(><.1@T4(FG4.8)(&?/01<(><.1@T4(.9:6G1981(39(I16.G4(.4

172<1441B(.9(3/01<(C?=4A(C0.80(+(C.66(B1F394/<?/1(.9(/01(:3663C.9@)

H<1dG19/6=(/01<1(.4(?(2*.:5*@$08$?5(-(?3,-$.9(/01(FG4.8(3:(/01(/C3(83F2341<4#(S01

839812/(3:(80?<?8/1<(.9(FG4.8(F?=(51(/<?81B(5?8E(/3(/01(19B(3:(/01(NY/0(f19/G<=A(C019(./

C?4(:.<4/(G41B(5=(>1<F?9(/013<.4/4)(+(B1:.91(?(FG4.8?6 (?5(-(?3,-(?4(?(83F2617(8?/1@3<=

.986GB.9@(6?9@G?@1(?4(C166 (?4 (41943<=(1721<.19814(k(C0?/ (F1/?203<( /013<.4/4 ( /1<F(U?

839812/G?6(B3F?.9V)(S01(5,-0*?;(/01(,1,7*(?$?9B(/01(@(:30-(1$?<1(.94/?9814(3:(4G80(C.B1

80?<?8/1<(8?/1@3<.14(:<1dG19/6=(B148<.51B(5=(FG4.8(0.4/3<.?94(?9B(3/01<(C<./1<4(39(FG4.8#

"3F1(3:(I16.G4T4(F34/(/=2.8?6(FG4.8(234414414(?(F.7/G<1(3:(?9 (,1,7*(? $?9B(? (3-(.H>*1

80?<?8/1<A(4/<39@6=(<1F.9.4819/(3:A(:3<(17?F261A(/01(80?<?8/1<(3: (><.1@T4(439@(U^l<19V

`Q?4/("2<.9@b(.9(/01(K1<4.39(:3<(4/<.9@(3<8014/<?(`a2)(hm('3)(PA(NYYcb)(-./0(<1:1<1981(/3

'?//.1gT(2=<?F.B(3:(4/=6.4/.8(61K164(X!"#$F[A(./(F?=(51(?<@G1B(/0?/(/01(2<141981(3:(/0.4(E.9B

3:(80?<?8/1<(.9(/01(FG4.8(3:(><.1@(?9B(I16.G4(.4(BG1(/3(/01(/C3(83F2341<4(40?<.9@(/01

4/=61(3:(/01(4?F1(12380L(./(B314(93/(918144?<.6=(.F26=(/0?/(I16.G4(C?4(.9:6G1981B(5=(><.1@

.9( /0.4 ( <14218/) (J3C1K1<A ( .9 (I16.G4T4 (U/<?9dG.6D161@.?8V(C3<E4(3<(F3K1F19/4 (C1(?643

:<1dG19/6= ( 83F1 ( ?8<344 ( 4218.:.8 (F163B.8 ( ?9B ( 0?<F39.8 ( /G<94 (C0.80 ( ?<1 ( 2?</.8G6?<6=

?4438.?/1B(C./0(><.1@A(8<1?/.9@(?(4/<39@1<(839918/.39(51/C119(/01(/C3(83F2341<4)(+9(!"

I(;(.F5G1B(C./0(?(B.4/.98/.K1(I16.?9(/<?9dG.66./=A(/01(43D8?661B(><.1@(F3/.:4(?<1(?5G9B?9/L

F3<13K1<A(/01(<1@G6?<(41@F19/?/.39(3:(/01(F163B=(?9B(/01(41dG19/.?6(/<1?/F19/(3:(2?</4(3:

./(.9(5?<4(ODNP(?<1(?643(4G@@14/.K1(3:(><.1@)(I16.G4(411F4(/3(0?K1(?(2<1B.618/.39(:3<(G4.9@

/01(><.1@(F3/.:(.9(F3B?6(:3<FA(8394/./G/.9@(?(2?</(3:(?(219/?/39.8(F163B.8(4/<G8/G<1A(?4(.9

/01(:.<4/(:3G<(5?<4(3:(!"#$I(#(".F.6?<(219/?/39.8(/G<94(F?=(?643(51(:3G9B(.9(><.1@(X!"#$IJ;

I?[)("11F.9@6=A(53/0(83F2341<4(14218.?66=(1F263=(/0.4(E.9B(3:(219/?/39.8(/G<94(.9(FG4.8

<12<1419/.9@(/01(F=4/.8.4F(3:(9?/G<1(3<(F?9(839/1F26?/.9@(9?/G<1)(

3

Page 4: 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ?griegsociety.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Asbjorn-Eriksen-paper... · 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ? ... 9

!"#$'$(

I16.G4W(/,..*D0-,$(.+$K,-+($XNOcYDNc[A(S19/0(2.8/G<1(5)(NDNP)

!"#$')#

><.1@W(L,.$M,-73,2.,(`S01(M3G9/?.9(S0<?66bA(a2)(hP(XNYZZDZY[A(5)(NhDNm)

((

!"#$'*#$

><.1@W(U^39B(B?@V(`JG</:G6(I?=bA(a2)(\Z('3)(Z(XNYO_[A(5)(P_DP\)

4

Page 5: 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ?griegsociety.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Asbjorn-Eriksen-paper... · 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ? ... 9

!93/01<(4/<.E.9@(/G<9(43F1/.F14(:3G9B(.9(><.1@(.4(/01(G917218/1B(<1436K.9@(3:(?

B3F.9?9/(803<B(.9(<33/(234./.39(.9/3(?(4G5B3F.9?9/(803<B(.9(<33/(234./.39(C./0(/01(:.<4/

4/12(3:(/01(48?61(.9(/01(G221<(K3.81A(?(E.9B(3:(UB1812/.K1V(8?B19g?(X!"#$N(;$NJ[# $S0.4

:1?/G<1(.4(?643(1F263=1B(5=(I16.G4(X!"#$N?[)(

!"#$+(#(

><.1@W(U#6l5n<DQ.V(`#6G151<<=("6321bA(a2)(\Z('3)(h(XNYO_[A(5)(NhDN\)

!"#$+)#

><.1@W(UQ=4('?/V(`"GFF1<('.@0/bA(a2)(Zc('3)(h(XNOcc[A(5)(PDm)

!"#$+*)

I16.G4W (US01(-?6E( /3( /01(;?<?B.41(>?<B19V(:<3F (O$)*11(7,$P0D,0$(.+$Q>1*,3( XNYOOD

NOcN[A(5)(ZPDZ_)

5

Page 6: 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ?griegsociety.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Asbjorn-Eriksen-paper... · 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ? ... 9

S0141(2<3@<144.394(:<3F(B3F.9?9/(/3(4G5B3F.9?9/(@.K1(?(Q=B.?9(8363G<)(Q=B.?9(161F19/4

?<1(2<393G981B(.9(/01(:.<4/(5?<4(3:(<.$9,(-*.7$35,$8*-:3$=>?200$*.$6@-*.7A(2<35?56=(/01

514/ (E93C9(C3<E(5=(I16.G4(?F39@('3<C1@.?94(X!"# $R[) (S01(Q=B.?9(/G<94( .9 (><.1@T4

C3<E4(?<1(83FF396=(<1@?<B1B(?4(?('3<C1@.?9(80?<?8/1<.4/.8)('3CA(/01(839812/(./416:(3:(?

B.4/.98/.K1('3<C1@.?9(FG4.8?6(4/=61(.9(?</(FG4.8(.4(2<3561F?/.8)(f?<6 (I?060?G4(XNOYOW

hc_::[(?<@G14(/0?/(.9(/01(NO/0(819/G<=(83F2341<4(?66(/0<3G@0(*G<321(.9K?<.?56=(B12.8/1B

FG4.8?6(:36E63<.4F(C./0(4.F.6?<(/1809.8?6 (B1K.814) (S3(?(81</?.9(17/19/ (01(.4 (<.@0/) (H3<

17?F261A(/01<1(?<1(?643(41K1<?6(Q=B.?9(/G<94(.9(f032.9T4(F?gG<E?4)(J3C1K1<A(.9(81</?.9

839/17/4 (C1(1?4.6=(?8812/ ( /01(Q=B.?9(161F19/ (53/0(?4(U'3<C1@.?9V(?9B(?4( /=2.8?6 (3:

><.1@)(!9B(2<35?56=(518?G41 (<.$9,(-*.7$35,$/*-:3 $=>?200$*.$6@-*.7( F?E14(G41(3:(?

'3<C1@.?9(:36E(F163B=A(/<1?/1B(5=(><.1@(.9(0.4(a2)(\\('3)(NmA(C1(?<1(?2/(/3(839918/(/01

3219.9@(5?<4(3:(/01(2.181A(C./0(/01.<(Q=B.?9(8363G<(?9B(><.1@(F3/.:4A(/3('3<C?=(?9B(/3

><.1@)

!"#$,#

I16.G4W(<.$9,(-*.7$35,$/*-:3$=>?200$*.$6@-*.7$XNONP[A(5)(NDm)

"G80(><.1@.?9(F163B.8(?9B(0?<F39.8(/G<94(423<?B.8?66=(1F1<@1(.9(I16.G4T4(C3<E4A

C0.80(G9B3G5/1B6=(?<1(?643(.9:6G1981B(5=(41K1<?6(3/01<(FG4.8?6(4/=614)(J3C1K1<A(C019(./

83F14(/3(><.1@T4(?9B(I16.G4T4(0?<F39.8(?9B(/39?6(/0.9E.9@(/01<1(.4(?643(?(F3<1(5?4.8

4.F.6?<./=A(21<F1?/.9@(/01(C0361(FG4.8?6(B.483G<41W(!4(f0<.4/3201<(;?6F1<(XNOZ\W(mY::[

0?4 ( 23.9/1B (3G/A ( 53/0 ( 83F2341<4 ( 0?K1 ( ? ( 2<1B.618/.39 ( :3< ( 83F5.9.9@ (B.?/39.8.4F (?9B

80<3F?/.8.4F) (i4.9@( /01 ( /1<F.9363@=(3: (;36.40D!F1<.8?9 ([email protected]/ ( $34120(o?441<

XNO_Np_PW ( PN[A ( ><.1@T4 ( 80<3F?/.8.4F ( F?= ( 51 ( B148<.51B ( ?4 (*.3-(S30.(1;( .)1) ( /01

80<3F?/.8.4F(G9:36B4(C./0.9(391(4.9@61(E1=A(C0.61(:)17)(-?@91<T4(S<.4/?9(80<3F?/.8.4F

.4(*.3,-S30.(1;(.)1)(C./0(E1=(80?9@14(/0<3G@03G/)(!6/03G@0(I16.G4T4(E1=(819/1<4(?221?<(/3

80?9@1(F3<1(<?2.B6=(/0?9(><.1@T4A(/01.<(FG4.8(.4(91K1</016144(4.F.6?<(.9(/0.4(<14218/)(M3<1

6

Page 7: 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ?griegsociety.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Asbjorn-Eriksen-paper... · 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ? ... 9

4218.:.8?66=A(.9(53/0(83F2341<4(+*(30.*?$F163B.14(.9(/01(G221<(K3.81(?8dG.<1(?(01.@0/191B

172<144.K./=(5=(51.9@(?883F2?9.1B(5=(?5-0D(3*?$F3K1F19/4(.9(/01(63C1<(K3.814)(+9(F=

32.9.39 ( /0.4 ( E.9B ( 3: ( 0?<F39= ( .9 (><.1@T4 (FG4.8 (F?= ( 51 ( 8?/1@3<.g1B ( .9/3 ( /C3 ( 5?4.8

2?//1<94W(N[(!(21B?6(23.9/(3<(819/<?6(?7.4(?639@(C./0(/C3(K3.814(F3K.9@(80<3F?/.8?66=

B3C9C?<B4(.9(2?<?6616(F3/.39(k(:<1dG19/6=(F?R3<(3<(F.93<(/0.<B4(F3K.9@(/3C?<B4(/01

/39.8) ( P[ (! ( B.?/39.8 ( G221< ( K3.81 ( ?883F2?9.1B ( 5= ( B3F.9?9/ ( 41K19/0 ( 803<B4 ( .9 ( <33/

234./.39 (F3K.9@ ( 80<3F?/.8?66= ( B3C9C?<B4 ( XF3<1 ( .9:<1dG19/6= ( G2C?<B4[ ( .9 ( /01 ( 63C1<

K3.814)(Q1/(G4(:.<4/(633E(?/(/C3(.94/?9814(3:(/01(:.<4/(/=21(k(391(5=(><.1@(?9B(391(5=

I16.G4) (+9(/01(1781<2/(:<3F(><.1@T4(81663(439?/?(X!"#$T([(f(?8/4(?4(?(819/<?6(?7.4(.9(/01

G221<(K3.81A(C0.61(/01(5?44(?9B(/01(63C1<(K3.81(3:(/01(<.@0/(0?9B(8394/./G/1(80<3F?/.8?66=

:?66.9@(F.93<(/0.<B4)(+9(/01(1781<2/(:<3F(I16.G4T4(K.36.9(83981</3(X!"#$TJ[(/01(/39.8(93/1(I

<18G<4(.9(B.::1<19/(K3.814A(/01(G221<(K3.81(3:(/01(2.?93p3<8014/<?6(2?</(F3K.9@(B.?/39.8?66=

C./0.9(/0.4(E1=)(!/(/01(4?F1(/.F1(/C3(3/01<(K3.814(?<1(F3K.9@(80<3F?/.8?66=(B3C9C?<B4A

F?R3<(/0.<B4(.9(/01(:.<4/(/C3(5?<4(?9B(F?R3<(4.7/04(.9(/01(/0.<B(?9B(:3G</0(5?<4)(

!"#$-(#

><.1@W("39?/?(:3<(f1663(?9B(;.?93A(a2)(h\(XNYYh[A(41839B(F3K1F19/(5)(_DZ)

!"#$-)#

I16.G4W(^.36.9(f3981</3(XNON\[A(<101?<4?6(9GF51<(NO(5)(YDNh)

7

Page 8: 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ?griegsociety.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Asbjorn-Eriksen-paper... · 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ? ... 9

'3C(/3(/01(41839B(8?/1@3<=(3:(.9/<?D/39?6(80<3F?/.8.4F(.9(><.1@A(C./0(B3F.9?9/

41K19(803<B4(F3K.9@(80<3F?/.8?66=)(H.<4/(?(403</(17?F261(:<3F(/01(S0.<B(K.36.9(439?/?

X!"# $ U([) (J1<1 ( /01 ( /0<11 ( 63C1< (K3.814 ( 8394/./G/1 ( :.K1 ( 803<B4 (C./0 ( B3F.9?9/ ( 41K19/0

4/<G8/G<1A(F3K.9@(80<3F?/.8?66=(B3C9C?<B4(:<3F(>(:6?/(/3(I(C./0.9(/01(E1=(3:(f(F.93<)

I16.G4(E91C(/0.4(C3<E(.9/.F?/16=A(26?=.9@(./(.9(NYYO(C./0(/01('3<C1@.?9(K.36.9.4/(!<K1

!<K1419(Xf?<61=(NOOhW(Z\[)(

!"#$.(#

><.1@W("39?/?('3)(h(:3<(^.36.9(?9B(;.?93A(32)(m_(XNYY\DYZ[A(:.<4/(F3K1F19/(5)(mPmDmPZ)

!9B(/019(k(2<35?56=(/01(F34/(4/<.E.9@(?9B(F34/(:<1dG19/6=(B.48G441B(17?F261(3:(/0.4(E.9B

3:(0?<F39=(.9(><.1@W(S01(6?4/(1.@/0(5?<4(3:(><.1@T4(2.?93(?<<?9@1F19/(3:(/01('3<C1@.?9

:36E(439@(U".<.(I?61DK.419V(`S01(".<.(I?61("39@bA(a2)(\\('3)(m(X!"#$UJ[#

!"#$.)#$

><.1@W(U".<.(I?61DK.419V(`S01(".<.(I?61("39@bA(a2)(\\('3)(m(XNYO\[A(5)(N_DPP)

8

Page 9: 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ?griegsociety.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Asbjorn-Eriksen-paper... · 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ? ... 9

"1K1<?6([email protected]/4(0?K1(83FF19/1B(39(/01(0?<F39=(3:(/0.4(4F?66(2.181A(:<3F(*<94/

,G</0A(.9(0.4(:?F3G4(533E(P0D(.3*:?5,$9(-D0.*2$>.+$*5-,$V-*:,$*.$W(7.,-:$X4-*:3(.Y

:<3F(NOPh(X,G</0(NOPhW(h\Z[A (/3(*EE10?<B(,<1:/(.9(0.4(533E(39(><.1@T4(0?<F39=(:<3F

Pccc(X,<1:/(PcccW(PPc[A(?9B(I?9.16(><.F61=(.9(0.4(Pcc\D533E(K-*,7#$Z>:*?;$[(.+:?(@,

(.+$\0-G,7*(.$]+,.3*3B( X><.F61=(Pcc\W(OY::)[)(+9(/01(1781<2/(<12<3BG81B(.9 (!"#$UJ( /01

/0<11(63C1<(K3.814(8394/./G/1(?(80?.9(3:(B3F.9?9/(41K19/0(803<B4A(/01(B.?/39.8(G221<(K3.81

8<1?/.9@(?BB./.39?6(B.4439?9814)(!6/03G@0(?66(/01(803<B(4/<G8/G<14(F?=(51(4?.B(/3(51639@

/3(/01(K38?5G6?<=(3:(NO/0(819/G<=(0?<F39=A(/01(639@(80?.9(3:(G9<1436K1B(B.4439?9814(?9B

/01(4/<.E.9@(83F5.9?/.39(3:(B.?/39.8(?9B(80<3F?/.8(161F19/4(G9B3G5/1B6=(43G9B1B(:<140

?9B(3<[email protected]?6(C019(/01(2.181(C?4(2G56.401B(.9(NYOZ)(M3<13K1<A(./(<12<1419/1B(?(0.@06=

3<[email protected]?6 (?F?6@?F?/.39(3:( /01(B.?/39.8(4.F26.8./=(3:( /01 (:36E(439@(?9B(Q?/1(&3F?9/.8

80<3F?/.8(0?<F39=)(S3(F=(E93C61B@1A(/01(:.<4/(/3(F?E1(?(B1/?.61B(.9/1<2<1/?/.39(3:(/01

0?<F39=(3:(/0.4(418/.39(C?4(/01(I?9.40(83F2341<(?9B([email protected]/($]<@19($1<4.6BA(.9(0.4

533E(39(&3F?9/.8(0?<F39=(?9B(fq4?<(H<?98E(:3<F(NOZc)(+(0?K1(<12<3BG81B(0.4(0?<F39.8

?9?6=4.4(.9(!"#$^)(

!"#$/#$

$]<@19($1<4.6BT4(XNOZcW(_\[(0?<F39.8(?9?6=4.4(3:(/01(6?4/(1.@0/(5?<4(3:(><.1@T4(U".<.(I?61D

K.419VA(a2)(\\('3)(m)

9

Page 10: 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ?griegsociety.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Asbjorn-Eriksen-paper... · 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ? ... 9

$1<4.6B ( 1F20?4.g1B ( C0?/ ( 411F4 ( <161K?9/ ( ?9B ( /3 ( /01 ( 23.9/ ( k ( ?/ ( 61?4/ ( .9 ( ? ( 0.4/3<.8

21<4218/.K1W(/0?/(/0.4(.4(?(U8?F3G:6?@1BV(8.<861(3:(:.:/04A(1K1<=(41839B(803<B(51.9@(/<./391

4G54/./G/1B) (J3C1K1<A ( +( 40?66 (93/ (BC166 (39 ( $1<4.6BT4 ( .9/1<2<1/?/.39 (01<1A (5G/ ( <1/G<9 ( /3

I16.G4)(Q.4/19.9@(/3(I16.G4T4(FG4.8A(391(@1/4(/01(.F2<144.39(/0?/(01(C?4(4216653G9B(5=

/0.4(E.9B(3:(0?<F39=(.9(><.1@A(<121?/1B6=(G/.6.4.9@(./)(i9:3</G9?/16=A(C1(0?K1(/33(6.//61

.9:3<F?/.39(39(C0.80(C3<E4(5=(><.1@(I16.G4(?8/G?66=(E91C)(Q1?B.9@(I16.G4(4218.?6.4/(I<)

Q.3916(f?<61=(.9:3<F4(F1(/0?/(?66(3:(/01(483<14(/0?/(I16.G4(3C91B(C1<1(B.421<41B(3<(436B

39 (0.4 ( B1?/0A ( ?9B ( .9 (C<./.9@ (01 ( <1:1<<1B (396=( /3 ( :3G< (C3<E4 (5=(><.1@A ( /01 (\*.,3,,.

\0-G,7*(.$/012S60.7:;(a2)(\\(93/(.986GB1B)(#G/(4.981(01(G41B(/01(F163B=(3:('3)(Nm(.9

<.$9,(-*.7$35,$/*-:3$=>?200$*.$6@-*.7; $./(.4(0.@06=(2<35?561(/0?/(01(?643(E91C('3)(mA

U".<.(I?61DK.419V)

+(@.K1(/C3(403</(17?F2614(3:(/0.4(83F5.9.9@(3:(B.?/39.8(F163B=(?9B(80<3F?/.8

2<3@<144.394(C./0(B3F.9?9/(41K19/0(4/<G8/G<14(.9(I16.G4T4(FG4.8(X!"#$_((?9B(_J[)(I142./1

/01(2<141981(3:(U483/80(49?2V(.9(5?<4(/C3(?9B(/0<11(3:(/01(K.36.9(2?</; $!"#$_J( 43G9B4

4/<.E.9@6=(6.E1(><.1@)

10

Page 11: 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ?griegsociety.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Asbjorn-Eriksen-paper... · 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ? ... 9

!"#$0(#

I16.G4W(+98.B19/?6(FG4.8(/3(/01(B<?F?(9(::(.$XNOPcDPh[W(U"1<19?B1VA(5)(NcDNP)

!"$0)#

I16.G4W("39?/?('3)(h(:3<(^.36.9(?9B(;.?93(XNOhc[A(41839B(F3K1F19/(5)(mNDmZ)

+/(.4(/.F1(/3(83986GB1) (+9(F=(2?21<(+(0?K1(/<.1B(/3(4G54/?9/.?/1(/0?/(I16.G4(C?4

.9:6G1981B(5=(><.1@T4(FG4.8(.9(/01(:3663C.9@(C?=4W(N[(S01(F.7/G<1(3:(?9(,1,7*(?$?9B(?

3-(.H>*1( 80?<?8/1<( :<1dG19/6=( :3G9B(.9(I16.G4e4 (FG4.8 (411F4( /3 (0?K1(5119(.942.<1B(5=

81</?.9(C3<E4(5=(><.1@(.9(?(4.F.6?<(K1.9)(P[(I16.G4(411F4(/3(0?K1(?B32/1B(43F1(3:(><.1@T4

/=2.8?6(F163B.8(?9B(0?<F39.8(/G<94A(4G80(?4(219/?/39.8(F163B.8(4/<G8/G<14(.9K36K.9@(/01

><.1@(F3/.:(.9(./4(F3B?6(:3<FA(Q=B.?9(8363G<.9@A(?9B(B.4/.98/.K1(8?B19/.?6(:3<FG6?4)(!9B

h[A ( 2<35?56= ( F34/ ( .F23</?9/A ( /01<1 ( .4 ( ?$ 2<1B.618/.39 ( :3< ( 5619B.9@ ( B.?/39.8.4F ( ?9B

80<3F?/.8.4FA (53/0 ( 83F2341<4 ( 83F5.9.9@ (+*(30.*? $F163B.14 ( .9 ( /01 (G221< (K3.81 (C./0

?5-0D(3*?$F3K1F19/4(.9(/01(63C1<(K3.814)(+(0?K1(5=(93(F1?94(4/GB.1B(?66(FG4.8(C<.//19

5=(I16.G4A(5G/(F=(.F2<144.39(.4(/0?/(01(<?<16=(G41B(4218.:.8(C3<E4(5=(><.1@(?4(8398<1/1

F3B164) ( &?/01< ( 01 ( ?B32/1B (F3<1 ( @191<?6 ( /<?./4 ( 3: (><.1@T4 ( 21<439?6 ( 4/=61) (!66 ( /0141

><.1@.?9(:.9@1<2<.9/4(C1<1(4/3<1B(.9(0.4(F1F3<=A(?9B(C019(83F234.9@(01(.983<23<?/1B

11

Page 12: 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ?griegsociety.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/Asbjorn-Eriksen-paper... · 0(12() $ 3$#04(5$ 6#/, (789:; ? ... 9

/01F ( .9 ( /01 ( 91C ( C3<EA ( 1K19 ( /03G@0 ( 01 ( F?= ( :<1dG19/6= ( 0?K1 ( 5119 ( B3.9@ ( /0.4

G983948.3G46=)

Q.3916 (f?<61=(?44GF14( /0?/ (UF3B1<9(48036?<4 ( `rb (0?K1(4119( /0?/ ( /01(B15/ (`/3

><.1@b(.4(:.9./1A(?9B(5=(/01(/.F1(O@@(1(?5*($C?4(83F2341BA(.9(NOcPA(I16.G4(0?B(C3<E1B

><.1@(3G/(3:(0.4(4=4/1FV(XNOOhW(N_[)(+9(F=(32.9.39(43F1(3:(F=(17?F2614A(:3<(.94/?981(/01

6?4/(391(X_J[(:<3F(/01(S0.<B(K.36.9(439?/?(C<.//19(.9(NOhcA(B1F394/<?/1(/0?/(?/(61?4/(.9(/01

F?//1< ( 3: ( 0?<F39= ( ?9B ( /39?6 ( /0.9E.9@ (I16.G4 (C?4 ( .9B15/1B ( /3 (><.1@ ( /0<3G@03G/ ( 0.4

8<1?/.K1(6.:1)

P,8,-,.?,:&

f?<61=A(Q.3916(NOOhW(K-*,7$(.+$L,1*>:#$O$=5-0.*?1,$08$35,*-$/-*,.+:5*@$*.$[,33,-:#

Q39B39W(M?<.39(#3=?<4)

I?060?G4A(f?<6(NOYOW(\*.,3,,.35S=,.3>-B$Z>:*?$X/<?946)(:<3F(/01(>1<F?9(5=($)(#<?B:3<B

&35.9439[)$#1<E161=W(i9.K1<4./=(3:(f?6.:3<9.?(;<144)

><.F61=A(I?9.16(M)(Pcc\W(K-*,7#$Z>:*?;$[(.+:?(@,$(.+$\0-G,7*(.$]+,.3*3B#(

-3365<.B@1W(S01(#3=B166(;<144)

$1<4.6BA($]<@19(NOZcW(L,$8>.23*0.,11,$@-*.?*@@,-$*$-0D(.3*22,.:$5(-D0.*2$J,1B:3$D,+

>+7(.7:@>.23$*$=`:(-$/-(.?2a:$5(-D0.*:2,$:3*1#(,]5190?K9W(-.6016F(J?9419)

,<1:/A(*EE10?<B(PcccW(K-*,7:$9(-D0.*2#(H<?9E:G</(?F(M?.9W(;1/1<(Q?9@)

,G</0A(*<94/(NOPhW(P0D(.3*:?5,$9(-D0.*2$>.+$*5-,$V-*:,$*.$W(7.,-:$b4-*:3(.c#(#1<6.9W

M?7(J14414(^1<6?@)

'?//.1gA($1?9D$?8dG14(NOOcW(Z>:*?$(.+$L*:?0>-:,#$40G(-+$($6,D*0107B$08$Z>:*?(X/<?946)

:<3F(/01(H<1980(5=(f?<36=9(!55?/1[)('1C($1<41=W(;<.981/39(i9.K1<4./=(;<144)

;?6F1<A(f0<.4/3201<(NOZ\W (L,1*>:&$'0-3-(*3 $08$($=0:D0@01*3(.#( '1C(o3<EW(J36F14(s

M1.1<(;G56)

o?441<A($34120(NO_Np_PW(U;<3@<144.K1(S19B198.14(.9(&?80F?9.93::T4(MG4.8V)(

4,D@0$'3)(PPA(NO_ND_PA(NNDP_)

12