1. 20 ( ) ( 300 ) ( ) ? (4 68 62 27 )

( )

2. [( + )+( +)+( )+ ] ( )

3. ( )

( ) 4. 18 4 8

higher education? Postsecondary education? Tertiary education?

5. 5 6 ( )

6. ( )

7.

0

500,000

1,000,000

1,500,000

2,000,000

2,500,000

3,000,000

3,500,000

1950

19

53

1956

19

59

1962

19

65

1968

19

71

1974

19

77

1980

19

83

1986

19

89

1992

19

95

1998

20

01

2004

20

07

206　大学評価と大学図書館

8.

9. ( ) (

)

10. ( )

( ) 11. accreditation

( (post-1992Quality Assureance Agency) Department of Industry, Innovation and Skills ) “Students at the heart of the system”

EU (Bologna Process) (VET-LLL Tuning ( )

) Campus Asia

( )

1.( )

2. (institutional research, IR)(

IR ) 3. Self-study

1 (GHQ) (CIE) (194647 ) accreditation

2 (1947) ( ?)

3 CIE (

大学評価と大学図書館　207

)

1 1956

2 (?)( )

( 2 ) ( 1980) ( (1979-1989)

(1990- ) 3 1970 1975 4 (1968 ) 5 1970 80 6

1 (1984) ( () ( )

2 ( ) 3 (1987)

4

5

(2000 4)

( ) ( = )

1 (2000 4 )

3

i. ii.

4 (2004

208　大学評価と大学図書館

) (2004 ) (2005 ) 5 (2004 4 ) (2004 4 ) 6 ( 5

) i.

ii. iii. iv. v.

72012

()

( , )

10 8. ( )

大学評価と大学図書館　209

1. ) i.

ii.

2.

3. 1 1

2011

1. ( ) 2. ( ) ( )

(2001 2002 ) JABEE( )

3. ( ) ( ) 2012

(2011 ) 4. JABEE Accreditation Board for Engineering

and Technology( ) ASIIN( ) 5.

210　大学評価と大学図書館

1. 2. 3. 4. 5. ( ) 2011 4 ( )

1 2 ( )

i. (( ) )

ii.

1 ( ) ((?))

2

3 (accreditation) (ABA) Law library(ABA,

Accreditatioin Standards, 602)

1. (credit hour) 1 4515 30

( 1952 1982 ) 1 45

2. (

) ( (?))

3. (Learning management system(LMS))

4. (Learning outcomes)( )

(the specification of what a student should learn as the result of a period of specified and supported study.)

大学評価と大学図書館　211

5. ( LibQUAL+)

1. 1990 2.

3. ARL LibQUAL+ (SERVQUAL( )

) ( : LibQUAL+™, ,No 280, 2004.)

1.

2.

3. Thomson Reuters Elsevier SciVal 4.

Institutional Redsaerch 5.

( 61 4 23 )( )

( )

212　大学評価と大学図書館

( )

大学評価と大学図書館　213

( )

( )

214　大学評価と大学図書館

( )

大学評価と大学図書館　215

216　大学評価と大学図書館

2002

大学評価と大学図書館　217

( )

•–––

•–––

•––

300 60% OA

( )

• 300 4 stakeholder– [( + )– ( + )– ( + )–(4 5 100 )

• 8– postsecondary/tertiary

•– stakeholder

•– “student consumerism” ( )

•– stakeholder

•– (brain circulatioin)

• 19

(esotericism +(academic) elitism)•

( )•

•

218　大学評価と大学図書館

• QAA– universal access to HE => Students at the heart of the system

( )• ( 10%) )

(!) accreditor

• (EHEA)

– European Standards and Guidelines•

– ( )•

–•

–(2011 11 )

•

•

•

•IR(Institutional Research)

•

• CIE/ /•• ( ) 1980

• (1985 )• 1990

• ( )7 ( )

•– ( )– ( )– ( )

• ()

•

•–

–•

––

– ( )–– ( )

••••• ( ,

)••••• 10

( 24 )

大学評価と大学図書館　219

( )•••• ( )

–– ( )

• (2 )•• ( )••

• ( )•

––

•––––

•–

–

••

( ) ( 23 )• ( )•

•

•– JABEE

•–

• ( )

•–

( )– (

)•

– ICT–

•

•?

7• (

)– (

( ) )–

• ( )

220　大学評価と大学図書館

•

( 113 )

•

(2011 )

•(2011 4 )

1172 2 1

1 1

2 2

3 3

(

) ?

44

5 5

6 6

7 7

8 8

9 9

2

172 2 2

•– 45 1

– 15

– 30 ?

– 40 600 45

– ?

•–– (learning outcomes)

•

( 1)

•

–

( 12)–

( 2)(2012 6 )

1.2.3.4.5.

6.7. COC(Center of Community)8.9. ( )10. ( )11.12. ( )13.14.15.16. ( )17. ( )

( ICT )

• 2012 MOOC– Massively Open Online Course ?

•=> Flipped Classroom

– online–

– ?? (discovery content )

大学評価と大学図書館　221

• 1990 ( )–

•

• ARL LibQUAL+™––– (

)

••

•

– ( )• (ImpactFactor, SciVal, ORCID, DOI(JaLC) (

)

•

•••

–

••• Discovery•

–

222　大学評価と大学図書館