courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of...

19
ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'- f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& OfffNOAl'f. j -.-----------------' 1!11SU1u,JN M1tlS""'fL R113'1oll PAo Sf L,r,~AIJT F•lt A/tll a,11$ tuA1At ttt,l!A. ~1>R..A6cr,,,.,,A'L ~M,,, r, Al l,1 -II IN611£r1JtU PhAJl. AAIVO M111i1,~11,c, M, 11,1,11 J .......... '""""""' ............... ------- ....... ------------ M1CH Sc.i. Jig # l'1oo3 'f B1'.1EF oF AM1,c1.5 CuR,AE KuSIIAwll MILES .. fL td Svff,&f eF U1£~~"4 IHTE~~ ! 1Jl1Tr1,.E~'i oF AM,~vS LuA.14£ I />llfl4Mtt1 f (dffAC,$f5 o F Kv,suAwd M1Lts-Et THE Pl.o ~E L1r,,111J1', K.aJSUIIINl'I "'11!.E~ .. EL ,sa,1011 S118M11'.S "rH1!, SR.Jtl AS AM1t.r1~ Cult1aE PvA$t11t.N1' 'hi H(!II. ], 31q{UJ(1)1@), .,.IJ PA.ov,1i,E r11• lt>()/lfr lffS PEASlld','IE OF 'TH1, CASE, J<uSNAwA/ MHE$ ,fL 1S A $-r/frE PA.1$~1111:L W/.lo -u 18 ..,.'fEAIS~ 3 ·•141>1rll5 "U r.JHl,1 II/$ orFlltlS~ l#IAS ~DMMJt"'f'ft, .t?IJ ·,nJbl-~ ~llHIPi,,J L Atl . WA$ A wit~ oF ill£ STA! S1Ndl I 9"11 • IN MII-V ,,, If HE WAS SEPltfHcfJ; 1".o L ,FE "" F,P.S,-DEt:. Ate rlr1U8. Af' A-£ IS . .$v~MA~., DF A~uMEllr: A~E, Allful~ '"•" bf.Atu, 114$ &01d Td OE.11111 THI S11PI/EIA6 Coti1III"$. E1~Hfu AMEll~llf J..,,t,$P1&..,AEIIU • .J. ol THlH bLC1~14#1• oVElf. 1'H~ L"'.Sf' 11 ... Y(AlS, THE ' ".S ~11P,e,.tE Co~At' IMS ~l~N1f1eAIITL'I ALTE~E~ 1'11£ ~"'""''"'"' $lNr~1#1& LA/lll,SCAP6 Sv bdU.111, otd CollST1T11r,011-Ll tAltC.Ollac4L &•"••'•' 01'1 C 11/JJTAI. llllb ,lo"c APtf'AL h1111SHM&,r( f-ol ·t"lklSE Wllo HIib ,lor '/LT & &.l81.,ffa 1H«1tt ltt'N s,aulia."JS 11Tr~ 1iMS 11F f'ltl,R Clt,1'1E.~ ... .£ THI CouAT REltcfEli &1tPt'fltL P11ll15Hlt4£,r( Fo'- n,,,,gE £J,ibEII. 1a,i Tlllll L1FE w/Tllot.JT P~tE IN ~o,,,/HoM1tlbt ~AS£SJ1 ,.,,. MoS1' Ucbdl."I, iHE Coultf HUI) .,.,,A, ·f,16 .,.,, AlltllMlllf ,.H,81& MAlllllif'{l/l"I a.,Ft W11Nold 1'A~Lf 5ellfl1'dS. i EMN 6lc.1S1oll HA~ 'f'uA#ltb ~,I Atf P.1Q11TEt, oil FM.1tJAS 1 1,/11EA64T 111 'fo.tfll T/1111' 1111 ~~uP.T HIIS Foul'lb MIU<E "f11ost ,.11,1t;t,- E ,,HfH/11 LtS~ uLfA&t foA. '(ffliA Cltl,.,tS uN6e1' THI 8TN A/td.#IAM2N'f",i Tlll'f 1AICL11bl o1F~llbtlU 1 (1 I LMI< oF lt411 f11A.11'1 ,._,1b tJlll)ILOftlUl'fl> SE.idl "F R£91'olil51&~&.1rl, (~) ·Vt1l."4tAAB1l1f'/ 1"0 l'ltr-1111vf 111F1.u,,"e~ AIIIJ L1lltlf11'1JJ /!o,4f~L ~vfA. ml1A E>lv,UIJ/1111£111 1 IJIII) '3J lA6K D~ llM'-AtTtP.S rHfllT &.AH St II.EHIIS1L1fJtfl>. 1 TIIE51 F~'foAS IIAvt "'"' &hi ,11AH,sEA .$,,,,.PL., F*>H fttHEbE11r ~" t!oNM.oll SENSI, f,-r,..,., 1Ht Cot11fr HAI ltl.L116 oll St1E,IT1l1~ AIUj ~UM.'11,1tlU .Stui;,e~ Td $,At',A1 11S f11Ul1"' "IIIA( 1HUf TltAt.E ~HAAltln1,,r,e.5 JIA/. 1,1Ht.Nll1 Alil'11, 'fHt>Sl ullbl'- It, I A£b'1CI: TH111" CAouP'~ evLPASu.,~ A/lib A~c.o/tb,IICL'I ~llwti t'HI ft1/IISH,,,lllf~ .,.,,.,, So&1tf1 c~,., 1'1SfLY 1HPoSf., ! &/1 -ruE t.0411.1~ ltEL11t1<1tl oll S11GII Evd;E/tl&E DVUe1'fEJ1bS If~ 11SE1JL,111d. ~IE11R•U1f,Jf1l1i JJMli P.n~Hoto,1t.1t1 blllfA OIi WH,,H tlMIA1' HttS ULJU, 1'oES Nll1' 1J,l,d1Ff A /k,,HT- Lutl i.ie Irr WH1UI 1'Nl5t 'fHl.ft /!A~f"o/1.5 NO Loi/SIA LESSIN ~11LPAB1L1fY, !.! 'Tlli.J~ RUu1L'f,~ 1111/'M.1' oltl PE,J1J&.oC1e1t1 .. ~IIS'(,l1t11t'11W~ St1/'lb«r,11, Lf,11,,,.IITt P411t11SIIMe,l"1 IJlll~N HIIVE ALSO 8lbl e.611'Ul 1'0 1'/le C.o.A:f'-' HoL61ll&.S1 .t°IJ!ftl.AU-, l)ol!$ ,ldl' H1111lt 11#1 All ~R,11,ll. lf/ltlll" A l1JA1'1t1JLIIJ. AlvM8ll.. of ~AID&.i, t,,l UIS 8ut1'MDA7 tAJII, THE ~u,~EME CDvl.f" ,rseLF H•~ 11.1.VlouSI§ REto,11,r.ea .,.IIE SHIU.ow n.,n, of A-E, HolAu" Yo111H To BE 11 ~oU rHA" " t!HMlloL 0~1CAL FAtf' '' AIIJ, 111JflA1J '' 4 r,,,u A1'6 tol'4/u1,I//IJ oF L,fE Wlltll A PEASt>,I lt/lAY a, MoSf 5t1SCEIT,&c.£ ro u1Flt1tlltE ANA ,-o PSUHILoQ1CAt. D•lllfMJS. 14 !.! .$1iLL 1 Suite AoPEII. V 51/111~/IIJ, THl cw,:r HAS ~E.SoL~Eb To C41!.GollCAU.V AN& INCR&M1116 Nt1T1'4rt ·• l'111i1SNHE1JT B11$fb 01' YouTHFuL,JESS v,11 TIie lfH AMltll>Mt,t/f olJL"f WHEN oFffl,loE«s JUt llllbER ,s. LJIIILE f'JIE t:ouAf IN ,.11,Elt Ac.l{,lowLE~Eb AHb A1~eo11"1tb rut Lll411'Kl'1t1II$ t1F ,.,~ At.,ClfT- L1Nt R"LE, THt 1tt11LLltt ,, ALAAAM11 coulT IHA llof' AN,Al~.I 'rNt. 1'-StJt. IIM1,us Cu~10£ l<&J~AwN MIL~5-EL AIIU To .SEr&t. o,I 'fH~ MILL£~ Covflf 'S Sl~E/IIC.E. AIIO b•Moltl.S41Wl 7H& IN(!, Q"11' y '" bll.Aw, "" A Bl.JG~# LtliE Af" '" ~-R.. t:.o11$11>tllJ "'" ~o.d11/!4A."tss 1,1 1H11,,11r,11c P11ll1S11Jjlfe,rr Ul'lbfl- 1'Ht Cc,vd ' S LoG,c. .. 'S1vE#I BoTH ill£ ~e,1t1t11'1r,c. lllfPoSS1S11.11Y oF 1l>E/llt1F'l1N& A /1.fCJSl A"E At' WN,eH CH#11.t1c.1'U.1Sf'1~S oF ~ollfltF,ll.#lt~~ t:.fASl 1 A"& ..,.ul -, ..

Transcript of courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of...

Page 1: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l! ·ME eo11A·r

l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF,

v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II&

OfffNOAl'f. j -.-----------------' 1!11SU1u,JN M1tlS""'fL R113'1oll PAo Sf L,r,~AIJT F•lt A/tll a,11$ tuA1At ttt,l!A. ~1>R..A6cr,,,.,,A'L ~M,,, r, Al l,1 -II IN611£r1JtU PhAJl. AAIVO M111i1,~11,c, M, 11,1,11 J

.......... '""""""' ............... -------....... ------------

M1CH Sc.i. Jig # l'1oo3 'f

B1'.1EF oF AM1,c1.5 CuR,AE KuSIIAwll MILES .. fL td Svff,&f eF U1£~~"4

IHTE~~ ! 1Jl1Tr1,.E~'i oF AM,~vS LuA.14£ I />llfl4Mtt1 f (dffAC,$f5 o F Kv,suAwd M1Lts-Et

THE Pl.o ~E L1r,,111J1', K.aJSUIIINl'I "'11!.E~ .. EL ,sa,1011 S118M11'.S "rH1!, SR.Jtl AS AM1t.r1~ Cult1aE PvA$t11t.N1' 'hi H(!II. ], 31q{UJ(1)1@), .,.IJ PA.ov,1i,E r11• lt>()/lfr lffS PEASlld','IE OF 'TH1, CASE, J<uSNAwA/ MHE$ ,fL 1S A $-r/frE PA.1$~1111:L W/.lo -u 18 ..,.'fEAIS~ 3 ·•141>1rll5 "U r.JHl,1 II/$ orFlltlS~ l#IAS ~DMMJt"'f'ft, .t?IJ ·,nJbl-~ ~llHIPi,,J L Atl . WA$ A wit~ oF ill£ STA! S1Ndl I 9"11 • IN MII-V ,,, If HE WAS SEPltfHcfJ; 1".o L ,FE "" F,P.S,-DEt:. Ate rlr1U8. Af' A-£ IS .

.$v~MA~., DF A~uMEllr: A~E, Allful~ '"•" bf.Atu, 114$ &01d Td OE.11111 THI S11PI/EIA6 Coti1III"$. E1~Hfu AMEll~llf

J..,,t,$P1&..,AEIIU • .J. ol THlH bLC1~14#1• oVElf. 1'H~ L"'.Sf' 11 ... Y(AlS, THE '".S ~11P,e,.tE Co~At' IMS

~l~N1f1eAIITL'I ALTE~E~ 1'11£ ~"'""''"'"' $lNr~1#1& LA/lll,SCAP6 Sv bdU.111, otd CollST1T11r,011-Ll tAltC.Ollac4L &•"••'•' 01'1 C 11/JJTAI. llllb ,lo"c APtf'AL h1111SHM&,r( f-ol ·t"lklSE Wllo HIib ,lor '/LT & &.l81.,ffa 1H«1tt ltt'N s,aulia."JS 11Tr~ 1iMS 11F f'ltl,R Clt,1'1E.~ ... .£

THI CouAT REltcfEli &1tPt'fltL P11ll15Hlt4£,r( Fo'- n,,,,gE £J,ibEII. 1a,i Tlllll L1FE w/Tllot.JT P~tE IN ~o,,,/HoM1tlbt ~AS£SJ1 ,.,,. MoS1' Ucbdl."I, iHE Coultf HUI) .,.,,A, ·f,16 .,.,, AlltllMlllf ,.H,81& MAlllllif'{l/l"I a.,Ft W11Nold 1'A~Lf 5ellfl1'dS. i EMN 6lc.1S1oll HA~ 'f'uA#ltb ~,I Atf P.1Q11TEt, oil FM.1tJAS1 1,/11EA64T

111 'fo.tfll T/1111' 1111 ~~uP.T HIIS Foul'lb MIU<E "f11ost ,.11,1t;t,- E ,,HfH/11 LtS~ ~ uLfA&t foA. '(ffliA Cltl,.,tS uN6e1' THI 8TN A/td.#IAM2N'f",i Tlll'f 1AICL11bl o1F~llbtlU 1 (1 I LMI< oF lt411 f11A.11'1 ,._,1b tJlll)ILOftlUl'fl> SE.idl "F R£91'olil51&~&.1rl, (~) ·Vt1l."4tAAB1l1f'/ 1"0 l'ltr-1111vf 111F1.u,,"e~ AIIIJ L1lltlf11'1JJ /!o,4f~L ~vfA. ml1A E>lv,UIJ/1111£1111 IJIII) '3J lA6K D~ llM'-AtTtP.S rHfllT &.AH St II.EHIIS1L1fJtfl>. 1

TIIE51 F~'foAS IIAvt "'"' &hi ,11AH,sEA .$,,,,.PL., F*>H fttHEbE11r ~" t!oNM.oll SENSI, f,-r,..,., 1Ht Cot11fr HAI ltl.L116 oll St1E,IT1l1~ AIUj ~UM.'11,1tlU .Stui;,e~ Td $,At',A1 11S f11Ul1"' "IIIA( 1HUf TltAt.E ~HAAltln1,,r,e.5 JIA/. 1,1Ht.Nll1 Alil'11, 'fHt>Sl ullbl'- It, I A£b'1CI: TH111" CAouP'~ evLPASu.,~ A/lib A~c.o/tb,IICL'I ~llwti t'HI ft1/IISH,,,lllf~ .,.,,.,, So&1tf1 c~,., 1'1SfLY 1HPoSf., ! &/1 -ruE t.0411.1~ ltEL11t1<1tl oll S11GII Evd;E/tl&E DVUe1'fEJ1bS If~ 11SE1JL,111d. ~IE11R•U1f,Jf1l1i JJMli P.n~Hoto,1t.1t1 blllfA OIi WH,,H tlMIA1' HttS ULJU, 1'oES Nll1' 1J,l,d1Ff A /k,,HT- Lutl i.ie Irr WH1UI 1'Nl5t 'fHl.ft /!A~f"o/1.5 NO Loi/SIA LESSIN ~11LPAB1L1fY, !.! 'Tlli.J~ RUu1L'f,~ 1111/'M.1' oltl PE,J1J&.oC1e1t1 .. ~IIS'(,l1t11t'11W~

St1/'lb«r,11, Lf,11,,,.IITt P411t11SIIMe,l"1 IJlll~N HIIVE ALSO 8lbl e.611'Ul 1'0 1'/le C.o.A:f'-' HoL61ll&.S1 .t°IJ!ftl.AU-, l)ol!$ ,ldl' H1111lt 11#1 All ~R,11,ll. lf/ltlll" A l1JA1'1t1JLIIJ. AlvM8ll.. of ~AID&.i, t,,l UIS 8ut1'MDA7 tAJII,

THE ~u,~EME CDvl.f" ,rseLF H•~ 11.1.VlouSI§ REto,11,r.ea .,.IIE SHIU.ow n.,n, of A-E, HolAu" Yo111H To BE 11 ~oU rHA" " t!HMlloL 0~1CAL FAtf' '' AIIJ, 111JflA1J '' 4 r,,,u A1'6 tol'4/u1,I//IJ oF L,fE Wlltll A PEASt>,I lt/lAY a, MoSf 5t1SCEIT,&c.£ ro u1Flt1tlltE ANA ,-o PSUHILoQ1CAt. D•lllfMJS. 14 !.! .$1iLL1

Suite AoPEII. V 51/111~/IIJ, THl cw,:r HAS ~E.SoL~Eb To C41!.GollCAU.V AN& INCR&M1116 Nt1T1'4rt ·• l'111i1SNHE1JT B11$fb 01' YouTHFuL,JESS v,11 TIie lfH AMltll>Mt,t/f olJL"f WHEN oFffl,loE«s JUt llllbER ,s. LJIIILE f'JIE t:ouAf IN ,.11,Elt Ac.l{,lowLE~Eb AHb A1~eo11"1tb rut Lll411'Kl'1t1II$ t1F ,.,~

At.,ClfT- L1Nt R"LE, ~ THt 1tt11LLltt ,, ALAAAM11 coulT IHA llof' AN,Al~.I 'rNt. 1'-StJt.

IIM1,us Cu~10£ l<&J~AwN MIL~5-EL AIIU To .SEr&t. o,I 'fH~ MILL£~ Covflf 'S Sl~E/IIC.E. AIIO b•Moltl.S41Wl 7H& IN(!, Q"11' y '" bll.Aw, "" A Bl.JG~# LtliE Af" '" ~-R.. t:.o11$11>tllJ "'" ~o.d11/!4A."tss 1,1 1H11,,11r,11c P11ll1S11Jjlfe,rr Ul'lbfl- 1'Ht Cc,vd 'S LoG,c. .. 'S1vE#I BoTH ill£ ~e,1t1t11'1r,c. lllfPoSS1S11.11Y

oF 1l>E/llt1F'l1N& A /1.fCJSl A"E At' WN,eH CH#11.t1c.1'U.1Sf'1~S oF ~ollfltF,ll.#lt~~ t:.fASl1 A"& ..,.ul

-, ..

Page 2: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

C04'ttl'$ M.llATE.A R.IUXUl,T•OII T,.r 1)fp& '\'EU ~ACTOIS '"''"' Culh1J11.,11 A,IA PRUL.IJbE r...sr '""'~ Tif! tvAAblr Al'HoAUt C/Wlllo1 $.171~. IIIIST!Ab1 1'H1~ AM1WS CIIA•At t<"'5H'9Wl4 ""'LH"'tl. A~S 1'Hl6't

IF 'fHE w1N 1o AbbAKS TNE 1'11cMd1N~L'I Pull,T1t1E Oll.1ENTIT10li oF t.a,,,tl11IAL °StJS'f1t.6 P.h-tlHIN II/It t1F 1'tv,'Tk1,,1t. 'fotl1H~vl. bff"'4114JdS THAo11'11 fNe Br'H 4MINt,1111e,lf, "TUIII 1Hf $0141 Ct,N~OIM1'u:111S ol Yolll'HFtA.,115& 1'NA1' H~S BfE,I bUIWtfb tollSr,rl/f,tWAI.LY UI.EVAN'f 1'oA 'fUGSl fJfU,RA 18 ~dT .,~ ..

tAVA1I.AALE EtDuAU.1 /!oA YovtHFIIL ~ /jlft"/Jtt11a 'or,ft 18' l"o A5$lflT WNIN 1'Nh f•eE f&IIIW-"" IIIIASH AMO 1R.l.l"o&ABLE Sl,df,/ats;•'

WllltE t11,l$1lit1Ut8LE 111lltt,f11Ae l),s&uSSU s,,11'fllc1,I(, Pol.lt'Y foA. "fouN, oFFlllUAS I r11,s A 1'4,t, Fot.tJ$E5 oltl ·TIie US S11fAf>,fl t:.011A1'·S ;-,.,o •F Cotr4olhCAL oi,,.s,o.d 1o fXAM,,.f flll Sl/iJl,,,,Af'tO#IS ,oA •

BIWNr-1.1111 A111f· IW/j, 11&r111&Arlt.l 1'0 Lbl~ St11'1'0Ar bllll'lbAll-,s' AS1i.,T1li To SfEI(. o,IT -IHI 1411,,A1,#I' FoR,c.e PF Yotll'll1111.11HS &If ~o l>U ~., Bf C#l(11J1JIM, 1P eA1E'1oA·,c,u.L'I EatClvAE 'fllll/5£. 16 '" HIIJIIIA&l ro Soe1~N1S TRlilUTtollAt lbtllltATIO#il ,,,,,,, ol Abutfll#b1 TNE touAr l..oSES S1Clff' of 1' .. t EXcUf,,,,/IU.d'I "' Cltl/1411'IL Pt1NtSll/llftllT t:11/tflMae, To of'llell. R,"65- AU.0CAT1..i& ,.uAs ,,, ,,,,. LAW, ,j.,cH A5 t/of'l,I(. • • ~tJATNeAMOU, serr,..,, A JJ/bt:ur ·Lo1f· 1tr 19 cJl.l':Sus:TL.1 b151ttw~ OFIIIIMM o\f£A 18 WHo, 111 MA,r/ 11/STll"cl!:S Wot1lb t11(Ew16I Bl oll/llfl.b u:s.s IU$fo1u,1S1.l t11'btA r11c SClllb11llb .Sc.Htll,ti 11f :fi.tSnfltA1'1.»1S THE Coud IIAS Ser Fop.fN ••

FoUow,," f'NtS 11ff~~tl0illl . ft.11 I 11 ·(H,~ A.Mi~t ·~ A~,..e,rr ,1wv,bl,S BtteKU.Ot/llO f.UA,.btl" *fllf IUA'1111#J//, ~LI 'touf#FtlLIIW A"b C11L'4Atun~ F,-.s,; ,r l}/$e./.t4£5 r11t &10L11l,u1. UIIIIIAP1M1N~$

"' YGtlfN/:alLIIES-' 1'NM HA'II IJEEII ~oc.,114E,dEJ; -rH,HCII /$/utgLtJG1'1II. AIIA 1'Et1Ao~1t,dJ,,~ Sf11bY• ,t.CPJ./0, lf SM~ HolJ TIil US $t1P/lt/l,ft uvar NA~ C1t1~,I 1'1115 £v,l>ltltl. 81'11 414l,w•141"' S1,111F1t11i,t• •

1\af II rHtN 1(41.Sf,S 1'111.U ,CO 1SJES w,1"11 TH~ C1111A1''~ AR1CH1' lult 6-1' II. 111,IIL1'1tft1" fHt LAC« 11F $~,&1(1F,, ~llf'Pl>AT hi. A ~Al'tC.A•CA&. Lr,ll l>Uc.A181!$ rift t:.Otll.t'S 114,AoPlfl to"IAA•So1' fo 11fHt/&. P.1"'1$. AlL.C.A'fl,I' AA.EU 6'1 f"Nt LA w, 1h16 bEHo.U1'RA'lb Hot,,I t61#1l.d1U•L :l t1Sf1f1&Af1,IIS /1oA rt1,.1~Hl4lllf CAIi Bl ~,,,,,,Llll.1.1 11111'1,./11111/t./J /:ol. Yo.,r11F111- bEFlllbttllt'S ''" vEA 11/. h

F1,IALL'11 PM.1 Ill AfC.,IS 1N4 1'Jtt Could S11ou .. b MA"1 f'Nt. >1,r,&1rr,,u, ffft,r t11F ft1-,fHFt1l..llt~ A'tlllLABLl ro -loV'flllvL o/:1611~11.S 8lfMll,,I TIit A,£$ o, 18 1o II SY A.£tM11rltl 1"fS CA'(f.,ol.,CIII. l."IE A.S A PRtS11MP'f11>11, 1/NbE~ s.,e,,, A $CHI/I'll, bl!FI.NA1ui10 IJP ·1'P II 1lltAS Otll lllot1U Ill 1AAt8"'1'A8L'f PA!Stllrltlb Vo"1NF,,,, t,,/1/ltE blffltlM/IIT-' ,, .,.,, a, Ctll&,.I) $ff.I( 'f'p ~H,,J (Hit .,,,,., ,.,,er 1'11t t,gtJd''.S •

1YotlfHFt1L., C IUfE AloN All~ Lid w1~t bl!!JEA'II' l'Ao1'E~111M IA.11 1 U.!. VoCAIU.f S£1lfl1U.ts.

:Z # kKGIWM: R · F111a111C to"1'Hf111.,1e,$ IN tS'lt.11olP&'I A.Jib IIE11~SC1t>ltE. ~

M P~B1,c brBltlS 9uMou"'6'"'' YotlH Pf1.#SEC11T101l$ Swt.1.1.E>, .SoME ICESEAU.UtJ&t l..ooKtb 1'11,,J4~ Yo.mt bMI.OP#'JIJIIT w,'l'JI Ulltwtb lllflAUt'. !.J IN TII~ /jtCA~l;f, LIIY#I, llAa 'f>IE PMl'tlJI. oF 'fHE ll.EUA81L11A11vl ,.,.,,,,,c.t "3e,Sf,ct ,,.,eL, &lrH 1)£1/lLoP~L fStaNwt.,sr ut, IIE111111",Ell'r•$'/S E•tLotllfG TNt ·f~u.lid oF SM11I 111t1M.11" 11,#IEb 111 o/11 t.ltAN,u ,II Sl.4111 C""41d1f,11N AIIA BEHA~1~II. 0Ue1&R1if, 8£TWUN ADoLl5tf,lc.! A,lb AIUl.11111~ •

£ l'SYCN0L0G1SI$ 11>&1(1F,e1, II 'NulfMA o1 1/lltfhl.(t,111' 1J1S1JNl.r,t1t OJIIL1f",.j A1"f'RISllfA8Lt ,ft, "lt>611U. ~oA

1.N,ttPt.#1 P~'ftll~~o6,sfJ Foulljj EAA&.Y AJoLU.CENU 1'11 IJt AU11MPllll1lb &"I 1/llUdSto .Sa.1$GUf161&.,f'I f"o PYII. PAl!.SSW.l• ~ AAoLESCf,IT~ WEA£ At.So FouM 1t1 Af1~UI Moit wt,Sld to $/IDM-ftbt C111ISlti1tlltlc6

1U

A"b ruo b,o ""' El.1MI> PAo'SEe:r,o11s hA c~,a~tU M FA• ,do f>lt ;ur11-.E AS 0,1, o~R. "IOtlfH~~ 1S'lt~uG1$rS llb,11',1,IAI.I.Y H11llb I bd~t1tAEI> l'i1blJlt.l 5&1"'='T1111, fHilr AJJ#,Ldt.ul'fS MAY St .bl.t'i&I MoRE B"I R.E WAMJ Al/1, I.EU B1 Ac SICS t'Hdltl "Ab11lT.S" IIA.E. !.f Mt,Alotlf.R, /'S1tH0Lo,1sTI Foll,lb SuPhAf ~o,,. o/11 AboLESCIHCE F,~1 AUl~IILIIT'Eb ,., EA11C ft.u(Solll,!!' 'Wll/1.11 5u6U.Srl:b r111f """''"' 1,do A&w.1H•o• lllltloL\/t.l> CHIU/"5 111 1ul Wh/ Yo11III IE~PU Fol.'4f.J, 'fHE1t 1J;E,d,r,u.,!!

/,I '1'He e,tLb o, #lulAoSc1E,JcE., ltE5fftlC&II BESA/I 14, bl.1'11r IUwLb~Elltl AA A P~ll1.b oF l-ollf1At1IIJ B1tAIN CA11W'fll Alib tHallGt • A PAIA 0~ Ne11""IHA'"'' .fTII01ES '" ,,,., ~t,I& '"nAllc£,$1111t,,16/J c.o,d,"11,b bEvEl.oPM"1tr 1'HAIIIJIH AboLB6CENll "' hU SAA,,,..$ F,.,,,AL Lolifl - lSSt.,/f1Ai. P,/t $t1CM fltllfd,,,,.,s A~ lhlftc1Pll111'I ~•111SfAt1bldS, PLANIIJ1tl6, ANA &#"1'~L,,IC rMfuLUS.~ GAn Ml#f'feA ·1111'Ht f-.,.,rt,4.

LoBl w~s ~How,1 1"11 5'1Kl 1t>ST PA10A fp Alk11.tsctl4,, U · ,.,,,Ii f'11e11 Al!l:.,.tAil Bttwt!II Abou.slt/llct A/1/0 EAALY IU)11lrU001>a.J ,,1 A l'Aot.l" Kl'low" A~ l'll..11"411',4 I. I~ 5~ul-PftNG A f'P.fl, ,At.1Hu" HtAMAS 1'Ct/f1i,I, B1Jc1t Sllll~HU•to ... 511Ht1&.1i1E- Htd1,1'H-A>lb- C"4Jw(II, "Y THE G~IW MAfftA l.tJ)-c1••1' s

"~ a? ' .. to/ltfl1tll1S> IJY A WHlfl M/ff(tP. ,,,,-.tt,St .- 111~,u rHG CEU.11LAI. "4•TlllA1',ol'i fAo,eSt tulov,11'

4~ Mfef.1ll1tT101'1, wH11f MATfEA oevELof"9t,tf 1S SA•~ 14' ,,,,,-...,, t}°'141f1vt ,:tJ,.t.Tu,,1,,,,.1.J

-~-

Page 3: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

8ECAv.SE 111E 5AMPlE.S Fol. 1U£St jTv~1ES wtR.E L1lf lTEb. 11J "'1E, UowEVEA, "rHt't co11L6 1',tr S&Jl'PIJI.T CONCLu5JOJl5 A8""1 Tiff. Etu,fo,Nf oF 8Rlt11I MAr11AM1•Jl.l'I i,JHEll A 1lA"1 oF HE1Jb$e1&4(,SII Pn4ALt..V 10,flb -ru, flt.A 'Jtt1oA'I oF SUul Mlin,Ut1oll uS1#1& A .SIIMPLt oF ,,.z..,11611.U.S RAlltw,& 111 ACI J:AoM 7 To 67 THIY o8SEP...Jeh C.MI MATrER. l>E~tf1 CHA~~SS CotJti,JJulG Bl"lo,41> Atut.e~ce11tl 11'10

aJu1LTHoob. !!> '

fS'1CHoL°'1"'I PRoFESSIJA a B.J. CASEY oF "'IALl u,uvt~,r, llboPfE.L, 1Jlt 1'HLtJS1' oF rNtst AMIJ arH~-,, £MEA.c,11, NE.tJA.osc,e,11',F,e ~1'111>/ES $How,>1& • s1111,11 MA"r&JAA110,i n» tciH"'""' ,~. f.AALY Abf/L.,~ A.S P11f(( oF Htll 1,l(Lu£H'ii1H, 301, IJAT,ote, ,, ll6E ~BASEb 1uS1icE SUTEltl AIIIWle,11 t111UL0~ rJIAT Aiu,LE$CIIIC.E ~XffNA$ Sf'fo/1/b AG£ IB1 Sc18A#S'($ ~IP/ I 111$,bt $C1E1".t.'' COM811J~o w,rN PSYCH0Lo61CAL use11~( b1St.r>VliA.IE.S ~f5RAl),,J/; 81A11J S"ISf6/11fS tJtllPLICAe ol Jt1"'6114e,,( A.IU 1MPuL.Se cowruL l'R,1111>&~ .,.,,,, JJAs1s h«. P1t0Ft1SS0A lASE~~ AMuM6lr .,.N11T A 1,uc.so,,1·~ BttA,,1 ,.,,6 PS'/cNoLoc,~,L A&,,1,E5 Nr,cou.Y ~~11u.1 414ru«E vdiiL AAouHp A,£ a~." wNE1' JHf ,~sll'4tl.J;

UlA I.ESEllt.cH PA081NS rlll AboLtsc.,,l'f ... At,11L~ fl.A/'1~1111,I Af rH£ '•s11c.1sr1 Fol 11,111.o~c ,t,4e,f C,01JFE,.t1.U.E IN SAIi l>!GCo IN ~olS • ~olt.

Goll$1DE4ul, t'll41 18- ft1 /JI - "'IEIIA-o'-'5 Aif IN MIJllf I/IJIJ'IS ~TILL AboLEJCf,115. wHo Ill.~ Bt.t.0M1Nt Ab11LT.S, SHE AN.A tdHEA St1Etl'fdfS 111&114! t'ilA-f 'f'Hr t.R•&. :S'1sft14 .SHovU ACCou1'1' NA 1144(

A,ib At101b ovlA.L'I JIAI.SH P11N1SHM£1'1),. BAA-IN 0£VfLoPMENf •1 f)(f!N,.s /Jt'11110 WHA1 ~ T'fl'ICALL"I AS$0C1AfE wliH AbttUSte,.,tt ~ ON Lf.'~t. bfF•Hl1APN~ -· 111ro t'Ht 1o"IIG Ab41&.f

IEA.1ob,'' ~ SA10. A1 1'HI c,nl~tllh4'-E, (4Se1 u~,tl> Sc1f,1rts1.s, IA~t,Jfs. 4,11; Pout.'IM~l'.ftt.S

·ro P.Eto,11,tt. 7'/Af l!,11.A,,1 bfVELoPME,.,.,. EW.16111,s 8i:1ol'lb At;.f If JJ.1'b /tftutl Att..oMMtrl>Af'1111..s AtC#~NII.Y.. ~BLl.s/iib- ~,1: J/18117; @r ,t4Wc,1us 4PN,tl,s1t:A:litff I l'fA,A~d,>'-/!0""1,0110"' R..rSEAUH JJtTwr,AK ,,,, t.nw A11b 1t1EuAo.sc.,el'lcE I ..,.,,.~tP.an:r u11,'fttu,.,...,.

,. R.oPER. V ~IMMoHS :

'"' a~s, ,,'leH•h'IUU ANA Nl11/w~t.1tN1'1f,, E'i1bl,l~E-~tt, E.Xl'Lt,141111~1'~ h1A tt>tlfll111uf~ ~"''-'" n,1,A taJl>'I IN r, SUPREMl Ci,uA.r ~11R1~,tw~'4cE. THI Got1t:I Foll 1Nt FIA.Sf f1'11. f.Hl>oASEI> S,1 £,d, F, C

f!11IIN,/&J RfL11f11t1, rg HuJIIIIAN b~'leLol'N4il'd' IN $vPP11Af" Of Atlu1c,,1, 'IINl1U C~tfAS11.1f1 /Ill Ao$& Y· St«'ble&S, 'TIJE ~A~£ ol' A -rEll<IAC.EA. ~e"'1'r.11C.E6 'l'o ~A,1rA1. P~1'1$IIMIII~ F"" l'llt1~fA .!! CH~t51't»htEll .S111,tNoN$ $01J,ll'f P0$1'1;011 .,,~f,o/11 REt.1Cr AFrlA 1"1111 SuPttfMC CotJl.1 b£t;1bfj ATx.,,1S V v,i,,1114. !J • U0Lb1#1, EAEC,1(11,/C A MtllrAU.'I AfnA~b l'EA$o,l 1'• 8E &JNC#ldf'1T111,i,,JAl CltJtl A/IIIA .JJl11S»11L A,,1,~HM~ • . uiti.rl rH~ ClttSLY t.er,uis oF HJS &l.11"11 .u $tMMeet~ AU11!D TH.t'-rHS !IAMt. AfASolfuC '" A1'11.IIIS PR.ou,B,rrA 'f,11 TIIE EU~11r10#1 "' A ·'SuvlNll.l Wllt1 GoM,,,,.,11'6b dt~ C,..1"1E wHll'I u, WAS -fou1',~,.. fHA1' I fl.'tl 1'HE

SuPIUMl Coe1Af RECo,t,1S1blAlb P~~bENT AIIIJ A(;Afeb.U IN IIM 0111/,01,/ 1111.,m,1 S'I ~oJS1,c.l Alffllo"1

#ltNIIEIII; TIIE CouRT H~L• 1'H4f" rHt oj:Sl!.tr111t 1/llli,~IA -F CollF.tlJ$~ 1'11l.11 Plto'ili>tt. ~uff,~i£A/'I' £1111>~,u;• TH,u ~~~1£f"I v,E,d :Ju" 111,,ts A.S ''&4f'f/,~tALl 1 Ll.SS CvLPnBl.E 1'HAII 1'Ht Avl ~AGE C. ,.,M,l'I/H •• 11 l(,

"Jt1vt.1'11t£S vP to Tht ~ t,F 18, AtuA./J1,i(; 'f'o ·rHE &011Af, CoMl'th~E A CE/t:/'11111 CLA.U of of,t,la~ F.R wlt,e.f/ r,,, bEA'f'II '!HALf'Y MAY NoT Ae JMPDSEl>• ll 8£c1udl ltoP£R E'llflllb~b n ,, - AliJ;- 1'1-YUl 11L.I/IS ~Hl. ~A~£ ,hrEt.Tlinl 1HAf fNo{1f$,,I Y DJl.l.1tl#llllt, Pllov1DEb Ft1II. f'H,st U1'~l~ //, "TIil 'A.EllflS1

1t:N1~1eAME ol THl to11A1'1S Dl'UIIIN Ml&HT /.l~ve l.ONiE #1101' ,,,.,,,. .,,/Hitt' "rHE l!~llltr $*'", S,/1 #l#W ,r ~A tf,

SPEc1P1ultY1 '" IJESC,.,JJ,,,, rHE t!L45$ oF OT/IEN~ 1'6 WIIJ>Jlf tAPtfAL p IMl'o$l1J, THE t:ouAT A£L,u OH Tllltff! b,FrE1tt.,,,/CGS SE1wtlN ''J; t{ IIN,JH/tte,.1' Glbl ,Ip Ldll££A St ~ATuA•n', a~'"' Vlll.lJ~l(A/J.LE ,& N£&1t1i~E lll~Lullt/t:.es A/I/A !:~~·:/,£ -:::::::~ "1:b "~:;~;·;,,tlc~""w1Ll-~.;: .fH'!,ll!,!TlA~; .. r ~ 11U~~ FllllH,i'S, ACC.oA.1>111~ .,.., 1'Ht lt,t1fS', IUPai_trEb &,fH i,,JHnf "11-JN IAA.£1'r ,,. 4 "" tlt1'r1r1t. 4111' 5~C10L,t:1t.AL S1'11JJ1tS n110 (t, ~ llF 11111 !t S ~HIHL.At.,lA1S1iu, '1011,IC o¥1EllbE/IS wru NEU 1'b Rt ,est 81.4 0 lit I A ~ ~e$,,t'f II~ ('s,a[ £.t.1M/!$1 '-t.U Lll(EI.Y Po /Jf. bl'flUtA.ll> 8'/ f"HE f,c. I'. f' ME WoA(HY TJht,I llbaJL1'5 1o t.oMM11' .itM, ,111t ,u.eT,.,f.•UUU.1 I>£ 1A'4'1/E/i. '1! OS 'LC oF DEAfH 5t"'f'e1',ts, dt,I> LlSS L1~e,, 1P &

WU1LE 1'14t 8,f'&. Cot,1i.f ll1fFEP-illTIAt'f/J '' j,,-/ErOLE.S ullbER 18" ~l.t,114 "Aj,JL~" IT AllililowleA&lll iNC LIMI rA:f111/ll!l oF $ UCH If t'111'E~~.·111TJ0N, 'StJsr,~ E 1'E#l"El>'f ~A.o1E "r11e &ulH.11"ll!s r>11JT ll15T,,1r,f1J~ l11vtll1L£5 FAtJH '.llb11L1'$ Ao ,lo'( b.SAPPf.AA LJ.,E;, "" '"' .: b I

illtHS 18 •• '" STJ ,,. 1 lllb

• - ILL, TIii ~ouA.r ,,1~1tf"fl> 11Potl bAA1"'111" A A-.1,H'f L11'E FoA. t.ul.11.U. ""'1" TH{:

-3-

Page 4: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

a. .G8BHAM V ~lOAI~#

rllE t tt1 CEME~rE) 11.S s-..,,Hf' LtNE FoA J,11f1fiAf11'6 UN).,,.., ~A,SH P '1,l1.SM14f,rt" '" llAIIN4. ~NIA&. 1*HE" Co&JR.1 C ol<d 11,EUI> d C Hill.I.EH,£ r~ A 1u,ll>ltf'11t:t L1PI SE,Jfl1lt,£ F11A A ,1 ··'IEAA ,>U 1"1Ro CoMIII ,TTEJ A PAI ft oF NO#IHol-41'1 u,E Ff.LONI£$, 'Jj i II A/1/"'fll~~ 0/1111111' IIJ~tf1£,l 81 Jusr,,( l<EN14E!~ TUE ~ouR'f /:,oa,,Jb THA1 TfAAA"tE :1AMA,&. CAAIIAH1S L,;E .. WITHt>l/f- l'AR01.t Pt1ll15HJ.1EJl1' C o/tlst,r"ru t.A."fL AIIO UNu5uAL f11l'l1SHNf"1 84$1:.b DN 1'IAEG ltEl.nf'6b t.otkEAJIS! Cl) fUE offE1'b!P.'S L,/111,nb t.u1.P11B1t.11'l (a} 'ft4f PA,.flt1Jl4P. SEt/El.•f'I D~ L1FE ,.,.,.,A,~o,,b4f"5° wrfH#u'r Pta""i.E, AIU,

f3) 1kE fA,LuAE oF f~#loLo'-,CAI. Tuto~,e; oF IC.Ef~rlu111t11'11 1>elEAA.E1U..E, ,11cAPA~,1"4fJpd, Al4D

R. EHII/JJLl'f*1io1' 1'c 3"us-t', PY ~vCH PuN15JIJl4£,I(. 'ti

Fol TtlE F11tS1 Coll~10U,llf10,l1 TH£ GmAM Cf1vPI° lt.f Lrff> "" R.o.ur..•s Uot.b,,/lo 1Hlf 111vt,.1Lf.j Alt.E a.tss ~utPll8L£ ANA -rllEA.lf.o~E LE~S bE f.R-\/11'~ oP 'flll Mosr 1EM l'IIIIISH1'1f.'48 6tC.AVS1: f"HE.Y Llfd( MA1"vA,n AI.E Atoftf VVL'4lRA8Lf i'o IIE~IH"IV'E ovrs,~e 11'fLu£,.,Es IINb ,ou1'S,~E PA.E.SStlA.ES AIIA rue,A, ~HIJi.Ac.'f"E,u ACU: ,Id( AS wfl.l- Fo~MGb • ~ THE tot//(( A~" Jlo1E.b 1H,r "" ., RfC EIIT I~'' l',o91,bEJ, A ~EIISIJN Fol. ill£ Couf(/ 'fo iE.COHS,1'£.1. R4ft,.'.S Sot.10L0Gu.AL Jl,JJ, SCll1Nt,/'Jc o~tVAT1"NJ • ll I.IISrlA/JJ ___FvR.TU£/l. bE 11EL~J!IIE1'fS 11./ Ptl'1CH1LoG'I AIIA 4/lAuJ ..$,1E#JeE COIJ'(,,1,4 t; 1o SII.W

"F&JNblJ~E.JITAL 1'1fff.~t.ES BE1Wft,./ J t/lllNJLf5 AHi> A.611'1 Ml/116~1 !! ,11,L11Alli'1 TUM ''PMCis "' 1'tfE ai.A,/J

1Nvolvtb. 1,l 8E.HA'illJI,. ~,tT/l.oL Colln~uf 1'0 MAT11tE .,H~orJfi>~ LAf'I! AboLESCt,Uf, "!!,!

foR. i'Mi $E.t.ONb CollJIIJEt.111'1,,,, Af&4Rt,,,,, rnE 5.E'i/El.,ry oF l.tlE WlfHOJ'f fAUll Tut Caul((' ACJ<>lor.Jt.lJJ,!6 1'111 REALITY oF PIISSlll6 ft/111£, L1IE-w,TuouT~ PAtuJLE 5E/111Tf,.,US ALA.E4b1Coll.s-r,ru1t5 ' ' (Ht S EC.0,10 NI#$( SEvlAl h11Al.rY PEl..ltftf1'EJ. 81 LAw, '' _!! Ft1A.fHfAM1AE1 ullt>ti. $E11re11c£S IJF LI ft t,,11f11,.,1'

P11RoJL, Yo11/'l,U.. ollEllbl~ GEIIC~ou."f .5£A'lt HoR.C 1£A&S A/I/A Gl.tA1tA Pt!.IUE11r11,t5 of ft1E111.. L,veS l!t;Hl#lb IJM(~ rl/HH Al>&JLfS, ~ Colll$fl1UIN11.7, TH£ C.ovl.1 JtlofEI> THll'f 11t11PoS1N, S&JCJ./ Pt1Nl~tfMtl/f$ DH '/ou"1,£t. oFF~,JJ>(~ a,JAS ·LSf£c1ALLY HAIUH .£!

·~1,ltUl"I "fHt GtnM4M tout:r Co,J~1bEl..f.1> Plll11L11,;11,H Jusf,hcA1illJ5 fpA 1u'IEll1Lt S£1'1fllte5 '°' LtFE ....,,ru~vf PkAoLf ~oil. No,lUol41~1be of FEIISE S. wEA>11/II~ lfl•"1 o( f'.oPU.'S bl!/t.Lof14 £,If.a. F1f!IJ1,ltt& HIBi IT1 All•L ~~.s, 1tlf t:011/tr Fo&JIIA f"HAf Nolle ol 1"N2 &.,AU oF Pu/ll,SI/MallT PA61//b£b ADil1111l j115T,F,,Kfio/lll Fo~ Sr!IIT'Eltt.lNS JtJVlN11E. "'"""~•t.1DE t,F,£,Jot~ r~ lift w,1HN1 ''""I.E. !J 7"Mf Coulf lluLEJ, our AETA18t1T11JN (BStlkJSE 11F oFFEllbU.S' RE/JucEll Mot.Al. ~&1LIA41L11''/)l§ JaETtRP.Elltt (8£CACdl OF rHEI'- ll'f PtTu~tdllt~$ ), !!! llltAPAG.1-rAf*loN (8l.G1t115E oF Dff1JlblR5' Ct,Pot.t'f'I fll(l CHlll1Sf)1U AJlb II.EHA81L11'111'11H (&ECAIISE LJFe w,'f>lgu'f PnAo1f ~o«E~wEA~ ,.,,., PoTrJfiAL Rf>l11B1L,1"11r,~11, . & /,,lt>,JG ,.Jo Ltt1r11141t'fl j.,St1~1tA1'1olol J!oR '.tJfflH'J ~fNTC,lt.~ "r#~ Co11R.T Fo,n4b 11111( 1T IJAS 81 ~r.$ NAr.AL b1SPRDPc,:£,MJArE llNh J:A1Ll/J "fo PA!TN AMtllbMEIIT M...S7rA,. SL

3. M,HEB, v ALgAAMA ~ /' · .. ., - .· . iHE Co"ar £'1..TEJilaEb ..,,, ITS R.EL,411t.E o,.J '1011TH hEvELof Jt1fl/fAL _- ·o,FFBAE!ldS .E._,E/111 FtlltT~R.

IN MtLLEA WM1t.H Coll/c.tlWEA Two CA1f.S o/:' 111-YEllt~,,L/>s MAllbAfo,uLY SEME,Jt.EI> TbTTr:E IN Ph.suN wrr>l~"r ht.oLE FoA. 111£,,. IA/tilol..VE/11100 IN MiJRAfll.5 .D 711£ Co11llf UEU 1'11Ar rHE- 1TH J;tl,11/llMGl'lr ~I& MANh6~/CI ~r,1'('£,IC111l, SCUE/IIIES THll'r b" JlltJ"'f ALLoW :1"11)€,ts 01. j11P.1£S 1o C.01'S1JJE~ THG

MiTISAftN, ~HAA.At.1£1..,.t",cS of Yof/TJ/1 AS Plf.Et:El>t!"1' Esr1a&1!1UEA ,IIAr "C.1111.b/tbl At.S l.o/ll~f1Tu111Jtl11UY b,FFe/l.1!111' Fl.o"4 Al:u1L'l'S J:oP. Puu>osES DF .se1'1rllUl'lt:. .. '' n

UE/t.E AGAINL 1'11£ lD4Jl.1 tELIEb VPlll'I rHf b1Sll11C.1 llE11lLl)fME1'fllL lltJAL11iES oF YouTH i"'J/111 R.E.NMR.. 'loul" DFFE/olAE~ LESS Cull'ds.Le AN!) ,1t1,11A. lelloLoC1eAL :luSf1/11c1>r,oNS J.oA. rHfiL /1>,ldllME.,J!. 8"' 1"Ull TIME, 111£ ~llflA.f Jj,~ l't/tlf fl.ELY o,,,.._NJl'F1ll'IIII. I.DJolStl'l!if!S A~ll'ISi 'fllf P1.1N1SNMtNf ot F,,,/)· RIASIJN "To L,,.,.,., rr~ 11~/Jl,,.,, 1i, S ftc.1Fu. fYPES ",: C1<111/11fS~~ R.JJTHE~, mE cou,.r MiUEo a.,PEA.

411b 6.<A-#A~·.s Foc11s tJN Pl.0111&1T11•" SEvt~E P1111,SHMeNa .iA $Eb Clt.rrml oFff1'*'EAS' II.EA/CU Cull'AB1L11''/ w,rll 0111£/1. P~ECEP£"'1' 'f'H*1' ~EBaJttES $[,l1[,JC111, Auf,-11ifS 1i Oo,1,S11Jf4. DlFEltl/uvtr3 LHHtt.dt'::s1'u.5 IN boLl,lt, ou'1 iH~ JY!osf .SE~£'-E l1JIIISM>'fe,,J'f5~ IR "'~'N"' .so, THE. t.1>&1A..1' ,lofU,

THAf 1"N£ /JiSf111tfnl£ (.lhJll 1'A..ANS1 ToAY j MEll1AL 1'A•1T.s AII/J #:liv1Ao1UtfElffAl. 11e11,.lA16lL•f1e5 '' oF You11f WU.E IIAA/J.l.'I C~n,t~ - jPtc I Ftt .. !1

- 'f-

Page 5: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

IN Abb11ioll1 11 ,ld'IEI> THr,'( L1Fl·WlfllavT•P11to&..'E> SEIIITEll&ES SUoc,Ll) 8£ T~ElfTEb 4S At.ul ro CAP1T6L PuN1SHft1ff.,d IMIIEN Ttf E oFFENbU.S Al£ Yo.,,G- k!! 8EC.l&USE Yt!UTII l'f*ri'E~ ,,, b£TE~1~1,IG wHEiHElt AH ,ll~E'lot.ABLE SEll'iE,.ct ,s APPll.of'A1A1"L, rtlE CotJ«r uEa.b T>lll'r •i• ~"bCf o~ ;s.,,:, Jtft1ST HAVE 711f oPPoA"rllNITY 1'd t.oll$ll>EI( M,T1611f,,1G, l.1A.C.&JMSTA1'CES 8E.fo,tf IAlll>os11" -rH£ HIJA&lll.5r Po.S$18t.E 1£11Atf'I Fol. ~11VlNJLE5 .. H

bESP{TE 1T$ LdFN l'uRAs,111, A&wT PH-."51114 A 8#vf ,ue IMPokfdkt "'' 10&/fll '" $EKfEN~1NC. l'tlLLBl F,~V ~A&l/11€6 1TS HoU:ull&. ,;, rM~e UJUEA., THE A~E IB," LowU ~dvlf.S FoUoi,,1115 f11LI.EC.

1

&1"'5UPl'R.1S1,IUY •a iHl .SAME. ~I( f'1111,I EM4R.Ae11', M1LLER. 1.S APPEAL Fol. 1/ILi1VlluJAL11.Eb ~fl(f'EM.,111~ SUoR.E r11~ HaASIIE.Sf Po.s.s,SLE PE.N4LrlES C.AH 8f .... 1Mlo$E~ ,r,1£ y ~L1A1t: f'o "fHE UAMl.11U b,cHoTo#IY 6E1WEEN uJ'"'l/b/lLE." A#lb "AIWLT '' oF'F£/llbl~. Fo~ Ell4Ml'LE1 A FLoll.,AI t.ouat ,F A PPf.llS rta5EI. 'I I..EJfCf'U TH~ PET,7,o,1 "' A IJlftll~Allf' WIIJ w/d '" w11e/ll "' tlt>M/11'11lb UIS t.J.Jl"tE -~ To rHE E.JcrUf "rNd THE PET1T1011GA ASll..e~ -rN£ ~W,M e.ouA, r- n,Pd,/o CA6UA/14 ""' ~'"~" "To o1'NEA .. .,o,JTJt~e,L 1JPFIJIAU.S' ,n,~tt. TIii A,E "~ 811" ~HE ~ou1.:r llor¥b 11' wA5 ~oa1,vlo SY r,e fbl'lo.il&EMENl's. tJI t'IIE su,iG~ t.Ot11.r of 'l'lll v~,rr/) Sf'AT£$. ".il SEvER.AL o1ue~ loua.r.s F~Ltow11u. 1'11£ £AIU.,Et. bEt.,6JI~ Ufl ~oPfl. Alllb &ll,111.1~ StM,L,tAlV IN'lkJllEA THl $11PteMl eolJAT'i 8A~llf' t,Nl r11 A.Eztur y,,.,,,,~ Alu11.;1~1 ITII IM'/E1UN'IE.A .CLAl.-fS.il

'f'IIE Ft>U.01111,11,,,.,,. ,LLu.Snt41H 't/11111 rll~ R.fMoN,~ cJ,IAlf.P,#lll11IS ~ G4AH4,.,., AIU, M,1.1.u.. tEdt1II.ES Co41t.fS

ro ALl.oW AEFel'i/Jl/111~ ul 11> AGE sz1 1'0 l'dSEllf Ewit11te ,>1 l"ld1~A,;,,,1 hSHr rHt,L 'D'~t1n1 "'" 'IHE ru~e "' tHfll. t A1Mff,.

lJ , . fdt1J&j1 ON !

IJHILt TH£ ,ot1d' hf. liElAJf.$ HAS ~4NSl~l«f/J Y1>,d11 1*" M l.ili Ct1LIA&l Allb R.ECEllt't1 ,,ltldl(EI,

SC,tlltf. 1'o ~.,lfO/tf A NS4'1 Ell.A , " f"Naf t'UJJ,f11111. ,T ~eFIIUs 'r11 RU.°'llrti rNid Yt1wM P~l'LE :r.,~f ot/fA. ;11e t:llll#MLd,CIU. A~G .,, 18 /lif1~A s,,.ULAA.LJ AE uu tu1.,,.1.1.e. "fer I 1'H! ~,uA.1' 11.<.oll'I,$ rNA~ 1'Hdr AM It A~ IMPG,-Fetf PAPM1 but111>11V1&.1t t:.vVAS1L11°'J'. 1""1 A.a,Ell ,fJ1$1'1t.11V Jf'Nltb rHn' 11 fHI &u/U.1TIU f"Hllf A1GtiN&11dllE~ :ru~t.N1LlS f:«AM 11.avLf~ bo J11r A,~Al',6AI. Ill/MEN All llltu.,,,.111,I. 'fuA,a 1 &.'1 ?I

Tu,s told P•Uults t'HR.EI ,.EA,.~$ wHt ~ L,1111.,~ 1', 'FIi~ 8AJ'1tf" 1..,11t Ar 18 Fo-. Mlf'i~11r,111> ,1111,$11/11t,lf' 1.S ' 1111Abtau,1t:• uou,J!IS 1116 //1'1f'IGA1iA1' FA~r,,.s •11 ~o,1(11 To SE ~ELE'l/6'-,r/ 111/tY &J,lf" At;,t 18 IS 1NtOl!lS1!Jlk!N'f wrr1" A-IIA ot46.tl.f'b#b$1 t"llf v~A1 :J~16NtiF1t ~,lb Sot.,OLOGtt.#l. JUirA r11l SfJPRZMe t..tJld' "'(111/t'S. F""1MEll.1 RIL"/11'• dll 'f'NI ASf 18 1,MPl:II ~Et.A11$E. 18 '' I$. ~H£ fo11lf t#JIIEl.f S.oe.111'-, Iii.A~ 1'111£ L 11/F Fol. M4,l'I P11M'11SES W'WEt/11 t.1111.ANool, 11-llli AAtJJ..,-J.1«1J,/1 !! INIIPl'Aofl1AtT:L1 EQuit~.S 1'N£ R.1,H1" l'lt11 fo SE l1J1'1Sllt1J Mol.E .SEvl1tEL'I 'f'IIAN oNI AEiEA'l/t5 W11'N AFF!AM1d'n1£ A1,Nf9 "7 l11Goc£ ,Iii cE-.t1ml Alwl.'i' to,Uu~T.

F,1IIIU.f1 bbiwult. A IJl!JCHf · Lui£. Ar 18 4,Jb b1SR.l,-.U>r1l'1 TIie ~U"lt1t.6'tflUSf11,~ DI ol.bflt YOIITJIF.11. bUl!l4hAIK~ ,:AllS 1'" .SEA.YE Alt/Y 11F n,£ PENo .. ot:,tu 'i1"5T1~1e11ti1111s ,,.,, .. r ,111 StJPIUMt ,~,.( HAS ll.11t.J:> 1/14PlA.ltf1t1( ,_,. UAI.SU ~NA 11.A.E'lotolJ..E SbdeJll,t5,

..! , O\IEAEX1!11tuNG Thi k1'A ~

1'11£. Co.JU UU eAatu.1 ESP011$U ~C1E1'f1F1c ANb So&10LoG1&4L &fA TD 8o&.81Eit lf5 Co,.~Lidll#U RE,4"1111, wHtd ""'W ''3tNf1'1LfS" bl'IIUPl"ll,kAU.1 A""A C11/1$f'1'(1JfJ1lldl.L'Y l>t~A.fNf F~ *'A,w,.'('J:• &If f'Nt Ct111/(f HM /JlE14 LE~1 rHAN Elf.II. 1j, i6AaAtSS r11E ,.E.SElcM.H'S /IIIAS1L1f'Y ,.,, 1011'f,F1 A h.lt.l~ 1'111,d wHe,I ~e'l~UlfAAS,l(AI, 11A111R1rt f llN &e CO"''i11ll1,IU 1 PUS111'4i0 hi. Ylle Ellf1At CLM,S of toll'fll t'l!lll 111 fllt 'it~ OA1'A ,r ~,1!$, /1$ o,1£ TEAM oF R.E5E4A.t,.,t'A.S HIIJ Ll#Mll'lrt,: "1hlP11,..,-,.,1tfeL1, 3'i*:ES; i>.L1fit.1A/IIS .1 ,

AA'iO~, .,,. Jou1tllAl.1Jf$ AAe BIAJII> 1'11wA4t, bll..A w,116 A S1116U L,IIE 8ttw&~N IUwl.Gsee,1,1 "'"~ JIAt1ll111ioo FPA 61F/CAl11t PuAPoSES u,U.tA. f"Hf L 4W t"IIAf IS Ar 0616 vi/11'11 bf'tlUPMlllfllt ,,,,;1,f,~£ ,IE11R,,SL,c,1e.f • • , '9

-s~

Page 6: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

$AME 11F 111e st,11.,,, BEll110 THt ·OE&.•1111 •~.,,r,-, Ad 11IIS111t.ttt1s,11, ~ AMCAu::0,1.5' ~,,wJ' f•llloU You11e rtoPa.e·s ,gtXAIAL lt.tl.Ar,-.11tlilfJ W IIAvS ~UAll,6bl ~ .tlf11U ,,._,Lt RA.e PuRS.11,I& H,G,HU. G.buCllf60ll.'I~ •• A ~LIIC,1$H :JoS MAU'ff Alli; 8vAC.f,l~o"41 Sf'v,,,,,,. I.OA14 r.t/Jr UHi o'1Jf(lvl1S£ .srAu.U 8-,,111G llo~l5 A/ij ~ru:r,11, PAMIL1f!a..U TUE U'G,al IMl'l,t/1(11114~ •F 511CII A jELJt', H•wlt!Ely AAE """" LISS -IH~II CUOll• fol nus MASo,,1, -f"NI ~1111.r•s t:o,d1Nt1al /Ul.,•ll~r OIi ·A eAfe'°"'4AL L11/t ~1 11,E i ICH(6£N .rt, l>1"1~G 1'111 ~"''°'~•L "f Sc1f1'1'1F,c111,1,y AIIA ~~101.oc,~HlY .lfllA-rt1l£ ,~,,. ~Ht IMHAt"l#l ,~A ~ur,0111i/llG f1J#11~1ie,d" ,s 'fAo11&r.,111c, f'Hf lll~fA~II OIi wll,t.H ,,,, Co"ar AEL,ES bolS ""' !J11Plt1~"f' !JIJt.11'1 4 L11'E AIIA AU,110,#tn, aESU1tdl ~ ... fJ 1°HA1' "rUI Atlt1~llf "lo,,t1u,11&. 61 ulH.1i1!f t-0111',1111£ 1'11 M~A,M.1~e 1/tl IN., 'IIUltlS I~ fllBII. ~01~,

H•L!,~'-/11'~'/,,Jfj~,,J~~o:::,~~~~~ll~nn;.!"~e;:,,:1~0-r!vf:d!~'-:,, l~~flW• ,5£4~1f~tl-T ro :TlilSfe°l, 1"11£ L.1/IS • 'l:J ,,. 1"Hl5 wA'f '1HE Co111t'f Sc>Ul~f~ 'Tlllt'f I~ 1.evs1,oP/IIIS1'1'1iJ. AIIAL"tS,. rM ,.,11,~HMEllf A PPL,U OIJl.7 .,,,.,,,,,. f"Hl '°""" ,,, ~Al!.t/114/§iY fJ(,sr,1110 U! ''" to,1cErf11,Jtl$ ~, CHt~ 1#116 Aa.Jl:TIIM ,11 '1NI l'o~1IIC. l'Altf' OEMo,,~ 1'11£ ASYll4Htff:t "' 3-,cU Jt,l A Pt~•e11.

I- CAIMlllll&. ft110SHHEtl1 ,.,.,. C,11141-MM .,.., AlftAl1111rf ,,, .. 1.s 1o (ef§f'C .,, ''AP,11:f•I (edQ'ilC.f :

A e11ta~A1eA1, lhu 1111,r.~,111» P.,11,s11-cillf BASU. o/11 ~o;JtUf11L,.IS& 111'L"I foa. 1'ttoSf ""ua. ,a ,s ltbbrrldll~U'I lllltbl'1uon Al:CAIIS.1! 11 F1t1LS ro ltft'1C,l1-i.l f'"HE t.xell'f'10"11Lr'IY 11F et1"11UI. ,w1,•/ll,flllf' Col'l,aAlb 'B "'"~" eo,rfl,:f dF rlll £.11,-i a,,IHE~ B1.1c11r·u111 ~ L/ltSS1l,,1tT11M ,,,.i·· ~rA-flS 6/AlbouBbl.7 l>AAtlf._,,IA.cwr LUIR5 A11LE$ 1"0 AICt1l.ltf't 1'Hf A'' Ar "'""" ""'""' PE.or~ tlfll Yd! .i. SIPr<il OIi U,ss/U "1f0,U, NI b&,~E,!! &,o,,.a,e, !A A,o bA,"'1C.i.1! '*""' Ptotit 5114,l.4U1 """' "'' -~,u 1.,i111's ro llil'E£ ~JIIT# uMuc'i-1~ lhlta CHo,~I NMIJ l)i,t.£011.-s "'"'' rAUf r11rl"lr'.!J 'f"HlSl eA~&olbc.AL ~Ill.ES CAAll(/116 .,N~l'.IIIHIM.$ AIF,IAlllflvE R.J(H(J D 'il!A. 1'H81,_ C.Ollbt1t.r Al'tOflld' To ''C'411•t HT8U1111/,fl111s" TNAT °'_.M_ f'Eoll.E ol Clltr1t1II ACH t.&4 M'1trAI. li~Cif ~· Act' IN .s°',0"1, ,N S0114& AESff.t::fs, A.S AAfU~.~ .,. ,,,,, J'fOf'U e~" f'6S1' ""' C.f '31*111 Altll."f tlh'lt..n~ Ul8hTE .,i rHtSfliLIAt. ll.1SJIS ol rHf Lflf,W,11, P1~106S '"vo~yH.!!J

'111G eo.,,.1 51Nlt Ao re,-, 1'011,lfvefl, Hlt5 C.o14Fl,AfE.~ 1HIS A~ oF e,,.,,,,r,,,~ A1f,A14k'r.'lf A,S.llf~ t'o >'0111,C,

,.,,,1~ ro .,.,.., odf' ,t,1,11Lf Atf,v11i ""'"" CI.JM,;IM. ,.,,,,s,lltflllf. tJIILJl(E .rHl~ La..,s f'H- ·r AfC111Aff BE1111'11Ht, CtJ11A11ll,L aE.N,.v,of<I P,ui,5u1't1'f '"""r.«~ F11101/IIC ,111,1,t Ao""'-"' SLA/llltwl~M~. Allbl.llJ -tOII t11ASUI 111s ElttUnHe# 'fllllf P11111SHJlllllf 15 ltfFFEUllf ,~ 11rtttA 6o~"4~11'1-GEAIMffJ IJ&ltr,rs BEClluSt. ifs ~,111,IIG CIIAA.JtCf'IA.1$~d ,/111,tublS S'f'/11'! Ct,,1541/&&~!!j t,,/HEII S1A1e$ ,,II/J4 ,E11Pl.l 6LA'4f.tll~,,,.,. "n.t UQwAe11te.,,lf df 611..m. 1'1,.tAfMl')I( Al~S ltit"'-" S1H-,fl.'' 8"/ltllSt ullautn "T~Mtllr 11t1f1,,ts 'f'Hltf' ftlE"I Al-t &JAl£4uAl,d ILM\Ew,ann .. f.!1 1>u.w1IIC A •a,11,r t.1111e at-rwffli ru~s, wllo 1tl.e ullAtA Mia , '/lit 11 l1oA HtOur,11~ """'.""'~"' ,.,,.,s ,111,,,es ~J.leY .o-Ar UlltlAuA&.&,_'I 8uilft.wol.ffN, E VlN 'fHg"'Jf f'HI'/ Jtf,fH1 PdS~S~ Mt Aa14e ,.evtlofMlldAt.. f"#.,,..§ f'Hllf /U.lljl,. -fHtM 1,~ss ,u,.,,,•&t.. 1Ht A11t11-, t1AA11111,,., ,,. 111,uz .. 6&ISll1'S Al',llfb ro .,.,,,,, ,.,,.,. I I, THEfl.~Fo,.! OVEALNJC '1HE IMf#P.TAll'f 61'6 '"'''"' ,o,u.s Fi,,. IMloS111, ~'""'"•' Pu,1,stt""e"' of rf.l:-A'f1III fth,Ai&. J C 11&.f)ll&u oPF£1'61d fa"" w, Allb Mt.f(.,,lt1, lllb, 'f/1&1ALJlb nls,J, A,u oF C.1JLP~a,1.,fY FoA ~otteN'5 IIIUHfs'T ,.,,.,51fl11111s. !!!.

IM rHE c.,,nu '""''H~IIIT ~c,11tn7; 1Ht IIEE• l'o&. All ulA,'IIJdlU'Z..& 1a111e1,u "" MEA~11A£ A ltASdll'> 8t,...e..,-,ar111Nf5' t.5 HtJf.bt.Y A lillt,1 CdllcePr~ ~oCl<.2Tr \I, 01110 AECoG1hZ.EA THAf 11i61t/16uAlJU:b bU1~1•t1~ AAS ESse11r,at. . u1 uP,TA-L ~asrs, ,e,,,,11, fHo fHi i.la»U h11,,.r-, 111,,,,, st 1/llll'oSto ,,,,, SP,'li! "P F4eT~ WN1tll 14A1 tAU. Fott A Lf~ &EvEAE 1'£/IIHS'f," !!1 E!_b,115§ -.1 olllAM#IA 11/E.II 111'11 rG,dl d&L,~ATIOII t>F 5Ell1l-'C1,IC Jub,ES All. 711l1£5 To Coll51/JEA. 1oufRF.JL Jefli.i&Aits• 14&/fAL 61u*-'t111o~J::.i ~'IELl>PM£,6 ~ PA Ar 111F 'TH~lt. ~ALt"U ' ~ AS n,e EAbllll~S r_,,.,ld $'(flfl/j 0 Yo"1)1 I 5 l"lt1A~ TIIAII IJ

CHAoll11Lo,1tAL F~cT. 11 i .S A , T1Mt Allli Co/lA,r,o,1 .,, L,FE wHC p 1

To ,ArLu£11tf Allb To l'S'tt11~1.os,c,u. 11iM.CE." ~ AFTelt Rl,t>£~, "11!w£!:S~" ,=:~ fel~l,!1s"'~~i~~ll;E

Page 7: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

5E,llf.lftE Wllbl NE bU.111,ES T'o aFFf,3$, . ltl~ Sf1'1fll&E . t.ASlS JJETrE.£1.Ellf 'tl11LuE ~ 1MU1LE ~ucH ~E1U1i1UE.I 1140V .sr,u. ,.,,..,, .SoH! ,111E.l.AL Ol111.A£'4r vALwf Pot. of11BA PaoSPfC1,o1t 11FPEIIAEM~_,r l.tMA11il ft1rl .#lflld JW/1' 4& G~l.'r b,&PlloPoR.110/IIAtE 1"0 rllt oFF£,I/JfJ. IISdulJf lllH~/llt 1"1121 Al.£ 1111tPoSlb, TU~; J!JEPlllAuil 0111 f'HEII. T'o 11111 oFPll4b8A MJA111.st W141"4 1'11,'I Alt.I lll/tf6Ma,. 1"HII~, AGllllluMC ,,,, rN,1~ ~l.,MEJ, SpMl "/otJ/1{; ,11,PLt AC!b ,a 1'0 .}I 11416Hr ,, • .,, ~I/CH Ji,'41,lt~llEA Mol..AL RESP011$1BIL1f'1 -ruar ""1 L1M11tl> Ad,.GA.Atllf tFFte'f OH PA"sP1d'1'lf o'1t1'blAS t"nAf 1M11Lb IU GAu1ea F~AA 1'114 "fotJ," UofLl'5 11.AE.'loe.ASLI ~E.Nff,.u;ts

wouL~ ,ilof ju.ST1F'I ,MHS11IG 1'Ht>!.£ Slllf'E.lltiS,

.... :;-

3, 11'lAPAt11Ati41': 'fHE Couaf IN ,iou,.,i,,t At.So Al)blj lttlb ~Uft1°!b 'fHI $6'$T1F1t11fml n 111t.1t,1u.11'1tr1#14, ollAl~t.,~llidl

,s ~AIA T11 PbTte.r THE.ISL,, ANll MIJllf oFFt1'~~ 11U11P•A.LE ,,,, u~FIEll6•"'.!.1'.. "nlE,AAUJIM t.otJR:f' A..C.to,111%Lb T14/I( ulLAIAt11"Af'11>N td-' .$Ah~T1 l.llltltE~,U AE&da,,1, ,11SL,t 5,.,m, 8tli" 11" bE1t1.M•1"lb 1'1111r J!t.. ULafu," S&IC.H A :r 11S1',1'1e.1m1IJ t. 10&1IIC 01FS141,l!IU '-1Q111AE.6 'f'lllt A5.SuMrftoll -t'11.11r 'f'IIE"I t! 11111.A SE oJl&o,11~ 61Ji1&T,.S-; ~Us& THE No,14 J11U lt/art1AE t,[I 'lo.II•" ,cofl..f'S '1H4~1tetlJ.$ /llf,tU~ 9tK.U All ASSt11>4l1'toll 4t1tS·(,uJAIU.L, f"HI Coull.T .«llU6 o&Jt' r11af Pot.&1.,1.,f"1.!1!. REC.111" oll R.etlA, 11 A/0~6 1'H11f' ,,,,, •1/tH '• eifEM />$Yt1411Lo,1$1"$

11

,.,.. "'"'' iAN•Ll. 1a,,1uEllf11Jru1# Btt'wll/11 •• ,,,, oPrl,J~lttS tJH• .S11U.u41 1'o .. .,11,od.,J/6fE -,Ef 'fUJkAE.,rf i6U,Wt&IA1Tt" illllb f'Jld! '' w14,~t l.A.11111! ltf.flt~'fs ,~PAAA&IS CoU11Pt',11', '' !Jfl

rut 5Av.f I.EMoll1#11& t.o" MAMl "(Id. 1A1t:.tti'tJL,'f"Aft!ll. l11Sf,F1t1dl1lf 1N1tPfl.1&1AU 1't W..W C ~AuL:r.~ . ~.4( A~ 1,,J~oU1C.181L1N 1!J 11U.otJS1S1E,,I{ uJ1fllYl1"11'1 &114Afl. lf,~o fN 111,lllf' ,f M 1A1eo,u,sfvlf w1'f'H ~HE ... .JTIIS 6'/ll-19,S ,e~oNH,N b,5olbEllS C. IVI ,tHtlALLY ,, b1AGlllllr.b ,,., Yov .. ~ PtoPL£ 01/tf. ,t,.!l!! /Jail" '•tJS,d JI & 11u,I.Lot.1CAL ~l -fo lU.~AAC41E n,g ~tA,f. -111 WHltH SaJC.U /,f/16w,-Se$ AU AP#luJ,l.ttJfl!• C.11,I ,REUllr lu/:P, ~ul.t',~S AS

~o&.N~ .,Ed't.E 6'F f'J.ll S11Mt ~UU,loLo,"aL IIC.E M6"1 luFFEL ~IUA1"LY 111 '1'11e,,- L£"EI.~ oF bthlll.lll~•t.

~trf'tl'-'TV• ,. ,m Jl£.SEtJUH L1l<taJ15t SUow.S ruar -lo.JIii' Pl11ILt 'S lbE,Jf,f,/$ &.IHl°f,lilu£ 1"11 l'ol.>4 $uUnlllll'111Lll

SE.wl/. 19 .U

.:.1-- - - 1

Page 8: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

, ... .. , w,1H '1Hl Colllfo.iiAS oF 1)1,!, U/Uli'I ES1'A8L•~l.A 4::~~~ If a1t1t.Si111,I$ flffA,t • FoR !JC1trtli.l, WHY

.SHovU rue l'WIIMP'ftOII 6E t1M1TrA 1'0 1111$1. t11'1>tll THl A&E of ol f ~"lb 1MfoS11IC '1141 PU!111MPT1111 BC -1 • . 1111,llC.E~~ltl•I. 'I 8llltb£11 Co'11.&' A~b,11111,w. ~ W OIIL b Al.low,~ rH15 L!vEa. ol J"j,t1AL btSCAU",oll lli'IITE. tJ,lt.fR.TAw(Y ""j vNwUAAllflb ·,,1u11~1~n11,v '! 1'Hl FoU.,11,,11" .5Ec.t111IS IIH/1.e§S 1',,l.St l$S11es'

f. S,MPL1 A blU'iEt. 8l1CHf I.ult?

i"E 1,.,.r 1111a Mo.ST 08'll1011i c~,1', ca-,, of Tm, A'"''" d -r111 t,,Mt ,., ~ .. .,.,.,,u A 50L11f,011 ,( ~ u"'""u ;,PPOSES: MAf/111'" A s.,,,,,wH6r AA.8,BAA) Al. se,r Ae tt11,tJ;J. llA.,,111 LINI . AA.h./111/& A 1,111£ 11' a,. #lowt-lE/1., IS MOU •ff~fR.,Mf ""'" , , P11P. .s,'ltAIJL

1 ~£A~# To Sli .$t11tE. IJ t 111/£ Af "' Co,ttS tioSIA. 1"• flll

5c,,,ut rHe ·C611A-r 1'011rs.. RECALi. r11,1 H~&1R.1JS,1/!,lf1F1( ev,bf1'd Ptl'111JIISLY 8FF111t,E rNE C.91Jll.( ''"""e" -ru~r A 1orlf'N'~ J!.i.111,I IS ,N,1( FIIU'I ,,.,,,,.,,..£ ull n I, "" '"'' V1A1J6L • 6 .,.,,,UII r,u • _!£!1 H11I.I. /1..tc.tllr S,c.U Uli(A L Al#b PSYf.nol.oC1tAL Ev,IGNU Co/lr11t11i1r$ ro 5l1PftJ1:r SIJC.14 /11IIJJr,l~S, !£L nl. l XA14l'Le, A~ A A~s.,Lf" ~,,

M11u'11f11", £~1l>EHd, CNl&.D PhGJl#Lr,G,Sf, IN 8t1fA,,1 /$$~£.b lllfJ t:,~1~lL11tltJ IN $Ef'i'&,t&U. 8ol1 "l>1U&r•1"

Cl..1#1/1t.1A,IS To ~l~o'4Sfltfl.. #ow THt-1 Vll!w PAf11:11r, '" 'lo.,ll~IA A~L'f'll,11&" Alllt 11.6.111' 1Udt .J, 14 Mt IS.!!l! A L1'IE ,.., di WOiJl.b IILSO ~l!fTll. ,,l!EJ; 'fHI. Cot1l('s C~llt.f./.,IS t£,4u1,IG r11E 1/lltlll&'T ~F ., • .,.,.,,.,lll.llUI

""' At.Tll.Jt.11r,,H, ~lTU,Ae,ll,E, 111~11,,u.,rAr,,,,, /!,,lb IU.UtJA11.,,11r,,1f • .!.lJ 115 11.E'ittJIHil.t/ l,E.Mo1'511.A(t.JJ, ~,,.,11.fs tc.131' 1/tf,0511/& u>l'S<1sf &1N!f~t1AI. 1'11,1,s,u,,ttJI( tJUhil M1'tG1N•&,&.J ~&.6tJ /Jt.f,11,1u1fS C-1' 6e Ci1'S11t.fl) M•l.l

HdlLSUL'f f'Utj,J 1'lll1/I 'l,11,1,0. e.11'111/f'eA.flll.n, i!VZH r,1111,N SofU ''"""'' Pos~ess f'iu ~1tld C.tlL,111,,u,1 u,i1u11, '(t1u1'$.

b~w11t/& A Lllll 41 at, .OHlt NoT SoM~ £Art.A. l"l, Aal,1(1,-111&.L'I/ A.e'fAJIH tUI t.oJl..f'~ (or.uS o,I 1"HI: fAt(,&.Ju.P.

b1~!Yl,'/0AT111~At1f''I "' L,ff. ,,.,a,so1>1Mt111 wrr,uvl fAA .• a.e ,;,,,. ,,,,1>1tSEA A£1t1'6dll($. AS "f'HI! C.1.A114~ tt>t1d R.Elo&N1ZEJ>1 "t1FI!. W1fH1n,1 />1',~LE IS AN l~lft.1111,W IJA~JI /'UNISllltEllt ~oA A Jr>I/EN,l.l, 111'6£-. f>11~

SEN'lll't/&l A '$,dSH1Lt IJFFll'lt>Glt WII.I. Dlt/ AVE~A&.£ SE1.11t l/l'loA.E 'llAI.S /J-,/6 .0 CAllrftP. ft1-CE11-r11,E "i HI~ L,FE '" f>A.150N 'iUIUI AN Abt1Lf" • . , l!i r111$ ~,.,,,,,,,"' l'.tNU ("£.IJE PoA ru~E IJI.Ft,uJtult~ ftlfltlC.IN4LLY 111.b!L 1"ll4N IB. ,, II /:JtJtENb4IIT I j "'-'U'- f"/1111" 1J!i, l-low!ve,., .,.U/! ""L' ~rl 11F' -nllfN.;

BASED ~tAuf'f'ltLS 1"" L • F ~ llllfl'/'1$ollME"' /J,,-i,11,&U, INLJllo, 1,: IJEfllllt.111115 Al.t ""' ,.,,L,, 61'/Eufft M AU J5, rN(IA. JIIIAIU&LE AE CtluASt ~IUIIU PEAl4ttfJ l'llt>T St IJ 'lr,11f"11Fi,L,USS ,A6SfllAlfuN. if l 11111.0 8l ,t ~£Vt.&,,r11t~llf'H 1u~A1Ju.,r-t MFEll5f, t5•

.. ,~-...

Page 9: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

"""~Solll.11 1"H~ C4SE LAW wMJ>E.A.Sfa11a,11, ol' .,..,.,.N,IIL#IESS A~1'.uu.1.-1 l~,J.s1' .. 4,,1~ Ftl>U.AL 'So1l)tl1IU

b1"-AUu»1 .,..o A CAEl!#S'EA. A£f.ll.!E .,..HIIN 1"Ht $l1t1r~,1t,1N, C.D14M'1 ,~1~11 f/1/ t/1~101't6. flll G111bfl.,1Jt~' Stcf1oJ

""' AU PA,v,t,fS .,.,,,,,. "ACI! (1111t.Lub11" Youf'HJ MA11 M. it.LEVAl'II' IN bf'f'EIVA,11,11, w11Er11~A. A 6£fld1"11tf I.$ Wlt,.ll.JIN1b1 I~ t,c,,1$1/).ER.dTIIN~ /JA.J£/) ON IJ6E1 1NIH VlbuALL'I ol ,II t.oMl!IIIIATUl,I 1111!(,t of'/16A. oFUIUEll. tJIAI.Ad'il..1~'rttS1 A&l Pll6SEH1' 1°0 IHI l/Nu~uAL l>E,AtG ,il/16 A1~'/"J,11:,,,,,~H f"I/£ CA!.l F~ ,,,. f'YP,t4L ~A~lS Co't/l~EA av 'TuE ,.,,,,LSL,ll/ll5 . •• !2!. ,f' 'Svt.es -f'AU,I( BfH Altff/l/j"4f,d c~ L~w "1', 0EF111e ''Yollfli," f'llt't wouLb UAV£ E Vt.II l"fo R.E t; HAAltt.111.~t,4.S 1iJ S'f1111Y,

At.io55 t.oi/1.T.S, -f'HI~ l!XPA/IIAl!J> ,l'IO.t111R.J 1tt.,Ad)11/t: 104dllltA.H£51 COIILb Cvlt.1'aaL 01.SC.llET11.w A/IIIJJ 11i/~ollJ1S'lr1'C'f, .. ANA rNI Gu,AELll'i/45. ,Jo,Ol~Atrl "fouTH'' ~otlU AE t:.,.,bl 11£.v.J MEAlltl/l. ~•A b£Ft1'/JAlll8 ilNA!C 91 FIU1NC t.taht"A, Pvll,S1114611f oil L,FE 11tt1/IA.1S111iltfEN1 '"~ A/IJN Uol41L1Al Cl.,M"• ALT/hJu,N t'111s A/tl1C1 boEj NoT bl.1111£ 1'uE ;M.ToM.· Ei~f APfL1t1t1'1IIII TII~ Co.JI:( u,~ ""' ""'E"M/1$,£ 4l.tl6'1AU 11tfa1,11Jj ~l.Mlb1ES, ~,,. lK1t,,,PU, ,Ill t.ouA.1 uAS LEFT ~A ~1',rft..S 1'c bE.1EI.M1,.Jl 111£ A PP~o,,,,,,rl WAY.S ro £,.~E Co1Uf11t1f11wa-L .. t5fA,,:,t'iollS ~611lsf £-.se.u'flli£ Aorlf 114Ell1'ALtV AgrA'l..blb IU/tt. u&•lll All/j1'1111uJJL$, !.JI T,II.J PUSuMl'f1oll IUMf.111 SiM/'L1 t,.u t.111/dS "''"' LE.NSEJ 1'HAl>flt.H IJlll~N ,r,, v,/w GV1/JEN~E r~1-1,1 Jt,f,1,1"/ AU.EA.I>-/ ,u.t. R.c1h1,R.£~ 1i ~"""''-

(Pt/l~L11SIOII : 1hl$ 6/41CI IIAS bEMOllsf/Jrf'£A '1'llltE.£ A.!ASillJ5 UH'i ,-HE CvlAEIW APPRoAt.H of ~,rJ,1.u" 1'11E

M1T,t.ATi," EFF£c1 "' "/011T11,t1Lllt'H ONL1 Wllll'I AlFE!l,a.rrs AA.t 1/NblA. ,, • '1EIJAS-oLI) ~,w,ld"( S'fRNI>• , /:, 1'Nt. ~oLuf',~N -r~ ilbbr-£$~ r11£ INtl.eASn"L<f ltJIJlf)vl oA1E#lfA(1,H oF t.~1M11"i,L rv5.11£f /lf/"1~111.S o,1£ oF PllJ!ikt.1iJIIIC Wufll~tJI. AEIENlll-111'~ T/.llt47&J~H n.1£ '1111 A/ltl~IIAMt.,,rr, l"H~N loul.TS MuSr Al.~

Co1JSl6£I. bE~EJJ~1u,f'$ 'lou1'HFvL,.J£.$.S. wlllll I SA TtJ- JI. YEl-,.•OLI& F11,t 1AAEVDUJI.LE SE11fe,ues • /J£CA.ge 1)1£, tl/UII.T loll'T11Ju£~ ,0 HISdf Tl/Ar i,eveLohAEll'fAL b,FFtlJ!lltEj Ll$J/,I tulPll.\l&.11'1 ~,,, lif.,A(I AU.

PlllDu,,t.41. S~1FltAr,11,b n~ 1MIIJ11't, s«.,,f't1.i JJ,Mut,T $A1'd11#1S1 MAU11/IILL-I oLalll. AAi tll&JAU.1 .BLJbt1ELI~ oFl{N~ll.S Mvlf St A8LI' 1, $£Ell ti!£ $~141 PbrEt(u,11. A ,t~~l~il f/f, Al6'1f144L.£?r;';":_:·;~ ,1!..£$vJtfl'fNJH OF YtJ.AH~IJLN£$~ WOIIU, Atto,..,.,1.,su 1"111$ ,oAL, '"''LIA., AJ 'I'll£ t.011t.'f IIA$ :s11,ti¥.SflD,-:·. ,. MAIi.iNC Yo111H UIN6 Al.&. tU/Jf A~taMPANI~~ If J ,ut.le"""'" f', 'f'III. 1MP11~1f'uw "' fHl HAUHa'f AN~ ,u,vot48LE .561'1RllllJ "Po~S '°" ,AUr A Adi{ 111 l)1.$~Poir10,IA'f'E Pt1ll1~NA/lNr. ... ,..!ll. .

-'' . . . .... "'- }. :"'· . . ..

RE SPE,-rF"&.L "f SuBM,f'fEb 8'I:

AAA1e, J(ll$HAwlll ~,LtJ--lL /IIY!oll IN PR.o P£A

AL~Ei toR.llS.~{10,JII. l«1L1f1

Nf,/ 'II "IA115f'i..lAL Plll:K. 611...,'iE /'1f11,/t.f1//, I Ml .,,,,a

Page 10: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

!. -; ~~

r-1M•CAMAl .SE,dE,lu111, Rfol,tw ~INt.l ,.111·· AIM,"' ,r .. ·,u,e, ··1~,F1E.I> All £'1.1A1'S,-1E "lltb5 AI.C . luFFt.f«Hf' :StJAaJ/1...u~i,ut "}.

I. ~ll M1J.LE,., 15, St,1 Ar J'l5.5; GU.HAM-,/ R.DPEI<. I.lo .s.,., Ao11IJ010); R.dfct.." 51MMdl'ls.J1.1J ll•S · SIJ. EACH "' rNl.St iASfj /llt.1'101'S FoLLdwtl JJrl<,/IIS 'I VIA5,ll,A; l,/l11c.H HtU> t9'Etur,IJ, ,.,.,d'~HY AtrAltblb CAIM,NIJLS ro II!. C.A.iEL All4 ullu5u4&. P11111~~1.,d /J.JE .,.~ ,.,,~ oFfE.Nbtn• ltl:b.Jlf.b tAIAtJ.,., A.J6 THE E~EUf,O/llj• ,AIUJA.f. ,.0 ~£,..,f jot.lAL :J&JSf,f',~"r,o,u lSt:cc'411f./J /101. 1'N~ i.l.ll"fH n~.o,'111, 5'-f YI, 11 , $. .!Jo.,, 3, B · a, (a,,,,a > .

j, 5SE AoPttt., 5'13 tJ.S , Af 511 ·

u. 5£E ~IAlid/ltl1 1,0 S ,Cl' AT d01-t ·

5, ~U MILL£t 1311 5t.f. A1 All~ . 'fHl tovlf1 L,f;1'~1~#U /l'ltLLli AUN' Wd'H '111el(So.J 'I . Hl&l~, l~:J S,d a1155 8o1/J .,,,e, AUii ~UE;/'(&.b f'HI. 4ulS'i'IIJII o.f t,,lµt(ll~,t JJ S11'll~N1Le's St1<1fe-iJc.E oF LtFt IJ1IH•t11 P111a.E v,01At£1> rH£ 81'" A111tSJ1bNurl' · ,~H1Sr1l1J111 A&A1.NS1 c.~11Et. A-116 u>1113<Mt.. Pl#i,SHl'fl""' 5et MIU.flt, /Jd .S • t:1 111 J'f,o ~ l,J.

,. SEE MILLEl., /J3 .s,cr 111 a'liP"I {C111/J, 6R.RHRIVI l°Jo5·&f- A1ioJI.; i.o,fA, 5~3 &1,S. llf 5f>'l<ZV·

1. 1d, 1H£ t..orJ,rT IEUo111 v. 81t1R.b ,111~ P0S1rtb A ~1/lf1llt. /llJ( 1>1sf11'ft11~/IAJU t,sf IJF /.EltSP1'5 Pol. 1'fll.11r11" cNUbAE~ l>,FmEllf'IJi FkM AJr,£$, 11leL11/J1,I, ~ (1) '' '1Ht l'l&.IILIA,. V11LliEIUIA1LiN oF I•

CIIILbl.bJ " (J} '' 1/ltlR.. /NA81&.1'N 1'1 MA/1.E C fl..1T1t.AL ~l,C1S1,41'S 11'1 AN 1,lf(),Jt,#Eb, MIYf"A.f. AAillllR,} AJII> L3) {,,Hl 1Mf6dA11&£ If 1"'/f! 1'11Re,r/111, "-oLE 11' CNl£/J UAl.)I"; ' ' see 1/'IJ 4' ,S · ,afl t.3'f (l'19_ Co1'CtA1'1,J& A L1uJ Rf5'rR.1C,f114' 1'11.i A1SU1 ,, A #1111'0~ 1'0 "BfA,11 All AlHft,l'IJ.

B, $ft IJ,PU.,S'13 tJ . .S· IIT s,,. 'f, $££ M1Llflt.1 1"3J $,t.t A1 31/6'1 ·,5j G«goM1 J3o.S,cr. A'f JDd,, JoJ'fi ~~PU. 5'13 tJ,$. nf S~7,flo,51B,

»

ii• A 8blF oFIU.JIIC uf' St.1l,lf1f1e Ev11>l!4CE FOi. fHI. to11,-(, Fofl. l1'AMPI.E, I.EC.0&1#1'1£.~ rfs l?WH L1Mf(Aft1>1$. Sl!E B~tF FtJI. A,Cl.1&4,I PS'l~NOl.o'1t.AI. 4$$ '11 ft~,. A$ Al11<1 Ce1«.11,e SurPoP.1i/lt, fll;f,1,#l'lf~S llf" I> n.~. GA.AH/I,,, ti fLoA,~t,, 130 S,C.f Doll p,10) <,.,os • 4'8-1'113, Vi,.,a,1 ("sc,e,u.f lAMo{, of GouAS£ 1>.Gw AAihr L11t1E~ PRtt.ldUI AE/flti11LUl1»1'' t'IIE 8011iJboR1ES~f.l1' CHIU>~ AOoLI $t!EMC~ All, Alwt1Jlld. i•Ji· SEE ~ISO ~A.II 8 · jpH/11$011 u a,., IJ/>~LISlENf M41111.1f'Y "'" 4/'Jlt jRA11J: 'rill PP#l'\•Sf ,,,,,,, h1f1JllS IJF /IJE111'.oS,1ENce RESEIIA.C.H "' AMLlSC.EIIT NE•L1H lot,e~ 1/5 j, AAoLE.JCEN.1 HEAL1JI ~,,, ~18/0oo,J ("IIE«ll.0/AIIA,1,I, S1'uJ,1ES /)6 N41' AL.Low A t.Hll.01'11U.11G1CAL eu(~Po,,Jf Jo~ BfHJN10t/U. o,l t"'11,r, Vl MlffuA1fY A1 E 1111£1. 111£ INAl~l~IIIIL "" PDl'flill-llON Lt 'It'. · 1

I/. SEE EAbull!.S v DII..LA IUMA1 · 'IS.5 u,s. lolf, 115 {1tu). Fol. 1111s l<EASt>II, l'JIE C11u-.f REQ.,,au LoWER Co11Rr.s 1tJ Al.SD C011S1J>E~ ''rift 811ctlHl.ou,lb /Wt) Millf4-L h/1 EM~IIIIL /JE'{EtolMt,t( 61 A Y#ll'fllFIIJ. b£ffN>AN(." Id 111 /II,.

Id· IN ~PE,._, -,,,[ COcJR.f RE/1$0,IU i111tf ''f"Hl lluAL,1iE.5 t"HI( "9111 tu5(1N~111~11 iStWEJlll.ES F1'oM A6vLf$ ,o N#f 1uJ11Pft1111. w11t11 "'"' 111,, v,JwAL 1'ul.NS 18 ,~ me Pd'"' w11£1.E S"1tf'I ~Aw$

1'H£ LJ,i! Fo~ MANY P11UQ5ES Al1WU'11 CHILf>NIJIJ/J AIIIJ A4JLf,w/J . '' ~ '13 t1,$ , ltf' ~ 1 tf,

,3. IN M1LLit., f"'N£ eovR.f Al((1e11I.Aflli 11j ,.s, AtC.llif" AFFIA~,rf/#N 111111 (11e. '"".,~ Ad"' te,l(UL 1/111/'od FoA SEIJ1E,lc111, S1J1>,tS IJ/11/J S11t.1t.$ 1'o Cf>IIS1j£1t 1N AA.P.1'11," A1 Aff1.#,P/.1llft, P1.tJP0At,o,,A1 P1111,SH11e,11. $EE ,1J .s .e-1 At a'l,s~

'" · iH,s A/rlflt.l vSlS rH( fEAH · · 10111HFtlL" ro 6E~C.l..1Bt fNdf Wllr, l'O.s.sfS.S '1111 tHIR.1Jtfl1.1$f,d 1'1111( -r111 Co11d I/I!, AE.LIEI> IJN ,Jtl ltoPt"-, ,~HAM,'"'~ M1LJ.tA t'IJ M 1f1,1Jt'f fu1'1SH/llff.,r(. IN /,l)lj1fl1JN, IJNt~A$ OTNflZ WAl1U5 #RV£ oP1f~ (o ,,5fl/tl&411SHeJJ &dwlbl ''t111L1>U,,1·' AIU ·'Autf~/· u.s,11, 1'HE. A,E DF /8 .u A &v1'6'11..11 f"'H1S AMIU A1>,1/$ 1'1'/l ft,-~S "'fout,r· AJI> ''joa,"" 1'1.oPU ,,

Page 11: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

' '

To l>ESC.ltiE THOSE IN61V1A111tL5 Wllo A'!f lllo...., ·1-0A1GER. CIIILAAEH A1'A l'hlT 'lti ¥1lLL"1 F,11Jc.l,61111'C 4buLT-'. ~~lbJETII KE.1Jt31'"'1/ IU./:tP.R.£1> ,~ ,,1£ P£R.10j SlfwEEII Ab1U.St.E11tl AIIIA ~bt1L1'#1d AS .,"1otJT1t'' IN I 'f1t1 • l(f 1J,JeTlf Jl.lNI $Tofll1 'toU"fu: A 1' ,Jlt,,I '' &r4,E oF t ,F£, 3'1 AM St!llol.lJt. I.JI, /,3~ (I 'f7o). j(HoLtaltS TOIM'f Co,d11/1JE To Rt!JJEF1/lll 1111j TA.All511'JoN1u. rtA,ol>,

1$ .. 5 ~E EJ1111U lluSS1 1,,,/Hllf rJIE LAW Sll11u1.Ji {IJJ/J SJ1~11LI> NQf° J UAI>' ll.JJ14 t!lltl.lJU,I bl\lll.o,M~/IIT Af5fAltCH 38 HdSrtM J.. II.E.v.13,33 {~oo'd. TIIE JlfAtAtt'H11I. fo1111turf-o,,1

1 F~o. iMAMPLt, Co1NEIIEb A

&ll.0111' ro ~1't,~"'I lt/JotlSC.lll'I' b~'l/t.t.01'111"'1' A,e Fr.1111£6 Ekt'U~"'lt A£.5l.A~H AAdll'f tFFI.Cn-tl '1,Nt,1,1,£ ~A11r11£ PoL,cY. SU ,Id,

1£. ~EE JimlllflU, 1. &ANhT, b4Vtl.#PMEll1'AL ~H111',t~ 11'1 Co1'Fo~~11Y 1"0 tffl(S 10,lii Pni(llf~1 I~ ~t'I. PS'ltllt1L, l,.oB, ,,s /191*11 (.$T11.Jf1,,,G YIIITH IN Trl~ Sil~,~,,,,,.,,,, 11111 Allb 1/JrH 6AitA£5 hllO l11i1,u toN~olb1t1TY To PEEb r,, 1ltll«t.~E. S£fweE111 311U> Ali~ 'It'll ~Alt-A~, Al/4 "i'J.UN JJE~L11lt>j L11,1AhltG !!.1l1,.J1J£11., J 511S~JI IJ, S1LVl«.BER.S1 '11,£ v,c,s.s,iuUS of A,lf'oNoM"I ul £AA.I."/ AA"l..l.S.U,lt£, $1 &.M1tb

,1.

AE.v. '"'' si,3, a-,a (J'/11,,J ·

~E'l. w1Ll,1tM GIIAbllEI. /I J.1Fl·~PAI/ Anr10,JAL-CHl>ltr.E 1'lll'llll'f oF R.1$X t"AJl.1/11~, "' AAoLES.CuJf R.,SJI. 1'AXIIIS u, ,, IAl~Jllt.Y J. A£LL J "oaur ""· Stu E.bS,I 1'9:{); .St£ Al.SO :ttFFU"i AAIIE'TT, 1l.ECKL£S~ B£111ttllol 111/ 1tJwUj~l11t.t': A AG~lLol1111l.lllnJL ,eASPEt.f,"lf1 Ill t,tV. A£'11,331, 3,h-31>1(179~) ILoN'•"tlftll 1U~T ,I/SN Lt.vELS "F IUtlf.t'55 lll.JIAVtU. lluA.114, A~oLtJt.ENlt /MPL,to-('£ /J,.,/tLHlfEttfnL ft.o01$ IN .SEIIISAf'111JI ~lEl(ul& JUI~ .5£tX,,lt:, .. AAoLF.ScEIIT Et.ol.l,./t'll,114, bltL,11,/11, 11,flll.

AOoLE SCE1't£ • PEf.HAP.S /Jul 1"'0 Ji1ot11Sf, 1AI~ 6-SAiO .MA1°11A.1 f"Y, ll,U, '1tNJ/II& l'loPI,£ A ~11M114, C11.£11r£1. IU!Sl'o1U1S1L,r1E5l

II. 5£E A,L, CI..EEIIIE, ~11f.JAt#r,Me 1£-SPt,:1',.,f, iN A6oUSCtlkt: 'l'Hf l'AF.5l,/( of Tl-1111'5 Ft11'J~ ie.t115/'GI> IS:,. 'fou'fH j AJu,LHCllltE 'If, 11,a, Ill •o9 fl 'IB0 (~r~n,11, 'lf'H C/f.A,A£il.l.1 lt1fll ,lt.AbEltS,

I I AAIJJ CoLLlU .S II fH1M1>AtJJ,

' ~a l lolol MINN E., AL., AboLl.Sc.tllf t,fC1S.u»1- NI""''"'~ 111£ M'IELoh4blr 111/ f;dlofP!f'E1',£, IJ 1. f • AbolG~EHCE ,,s., 37~ /118'/) ('ouA AIJIJL-l~d "' 1'Hl MoblST ~'111>£1'd L£n1>S IJS f'" lo1ULt16! (Hit'(

41 Alt JG "tEIUl.~ Mihl1 AbDLE~tEl'l7'5 IIAV£ 4~H,E'ltlJ A llEA»,1A8Ll LEtJrL "' '"Mfe'(t,Jt,E. ~ •• HotJE>llA1 L1¥.E Ail Ull#4dll$.i A/JoLlJc.E#lf's /10 "1/of C"1"51Jft,11'1..Y BfllA'lt. A$ C~Mf't'f!,rf bE.c.1,S,o,J MiHCHJ,., •'J, 8.,T .$£( i,rA FuR.S'I /, R.IA'H 8E1'H- MAAoM , l.,~ll 1"111<1"' Ill 46',L/Sc.t,lce;

' A 1JCf..,J.111A1, ~,.11,11, f'l~Sf'tcr,vt, ,a /Jl'I, REv. , , 3B uNa>

:JtJ, 5El ALAAI ~. l;11h,TEAM1u1, IA~Jli/1'11'1 btt1Etof >,tE,lf J'AoM A.1.oLl SClllU. f'o AA,1L'fll-11b: All earr.111s10A1 "~ r11~•1 ""A 11 11t.,1£w oF R.ESE*ftll 1./J M'i. P~Yt:HoL. 3-11, 3"1,, 3S.S t1'18~> , .. ,r 1 $ ll11J.J11, r,,1 c11u..l ,E "'lu~, 1"11111' n,s G1.E11fl~f ',,,,,,,~ 1N 11;r,1r, fr F1J1.1t11Af,"" 11 IPGA~ 1', ,u ..,,., "J

01.

:J;J, j,,., N, Gu,, Er.AL., SlAul Al!IEL0P11t1l."4T bui!.IIIIQ t.Hlt.4Hoob A,/1, J#lt.oU5ClllCE: A Lo,£,f:""'!Jfe #/ti ST11n, ~ NA(,.,ll,£ ,Jl11""51!1EA1e.E - a,,. g,, t1'1'111l: E.1.1ZAIJ/l1"n A,. 5'1iJll.L ,.,,.,.,., IN Vl'I/II "'' ,-~ P4t5T- AMUS,lllT 81.A,I!/ A11A·f11Rd111N "' rtto,dAL ANII ~"fl.1A1'1u. ll.l,,o1'j i ,, .,,, • .,.~, JJttJll,~t,EMd. 85'1 '"°

( l'J'lq ). 1"Jlae #./Ail.~ 11$U 3b 1/lff#I HAIP111, F£t.ll1'11411U I

tl<INI.AIA~ e. A/l.L-1 Qu11,l111A r, vt $1,.,,:rtJtAL UA,,1. /MM,1/11& .Sr11A1rS IN 7'>1£ lAf'e 19111'.S AN/> i.A'-L1 lffo••s. ~0111-j ,.,,t; AS~ESS Aills-,,, $It Altfil,,I. W, ~t4 t.l 41. ~ .NIIJl'l,.1116 6flllll Jlllllf'11A.41',tW1 ~'I 141UJ NE11~1~1i1't.t~ 11/8., lt.l,,,(AN,&).

~3. St!£ AbAM o-.:flz., AAIILl~dlltl, II.Aul bl,ll.bP1t1t6.t1r 6116 LE"'L l11LIAIJ1&.,1'1 A.l.;A 111v. ~11S1. t.fl<,1

:141'. dOOII, _;1r ~ AIIA1L11&l Af HiTP: II Coo.GLl8t'i1r,1; JU ALSc ,l1t;1bt ,-,;,_ 1'£LN1te.t 8/Ut1,I: ,,1nA.th!.,.1J • jA'I C1l>j1_ P& F~ll1'L1,I£ (at,~eJ)1 Hffp~ ll&co.6Ll:ZtS"lS11t ••rHt. F.,llfllL. Loll ,5 "F1illll CAUlt, ~H£ CEo, OA ,NE. fUC.&11ivl ~, f"/11. S~IN • • • 11'~ A f•A1' "' ""~ 8b1111 'l'Nltf' .ltfosr . 5E.P11AJt-rt~ Mlllt/ F'~ 8£.ASf, ,, VOii WILL.'•)

:J4. Set Gl(f>J ~f' AL, 1 SuPl(A Alo1t .531 AT It.I ~u,/1,o,II ,11.11'1 Mllf'f'LA f'IJ 1,/dEAt.f 1'" ;itt11t't1M,LIS 5,Us tlRau,1~ t"HE ll'lS ~, 1.a ANi, 1/ '6A. MA,tS AIIA flMALH l'-t•P£i:1'1t1tt~ ).

9J. JU 1d· Af Sr,1-r.a; GdtJlLL e-, IIL. $11PlA liloTl AT l,P I •

-. .

Page 12: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

'", oAriZ 1 5t1PRA tJo1E 51/ 4 T J

J 1. set '"·

29.

3o,

$CE .SoW!Ll t1 AL·, 'tJ'"" 11UT£ SJ, ,,.r fU,o • lot. A1,,1u1u,IIAL Gtlltl.nL A/~11.,l(.tJNs "! ARtJ,11 /,1!.'tflLoPMl,lf. ~if Jf'o(l E111'1Ni'LI. P•il.,~,r. ~61,)11/C, So~,lll IIUI/J Ji1•LoD1eAI. ~o/t/S-t'1.ue1NN1~ DI Yo11r,1: , Ml'i,u,1111',,u ~A 1t.l'IE.1'1Ll $r,~(,c£ 0,11, llAUAI.. Et1r.1,r1, I,. Alw. iJ,L,) SoG . 1111''1 6118, 1131

(Dom; t:.t1u1h11J w4LLtJ, wNAf MIINU flEllS ,.,,~ I f,1t1E, MAY ,,, 810'1, AT sl,.

5E£ fo~II E f AL 'I al 5,ll'lt.4 l'loTI Stf, .11r 1~0-",' .f£1 f11!b6 tf AL. SoJfR.A >Jo1£ 53, Af IIJ (Fni/61111,

,ur Mn11tt. 1'0 bl.,I.EA!!aE ~oLLow1," IIJ.1u,USCEIICE 'fHR.diHJII ~£ :JJ T,1£ ol.lJtSf All t>I f'NtJ$l l!a"t'11b,E1Jl,· ~oWELt Ef' 4L,, SflPIIA llotl ~,. Ar Jll.o (}',,11J111S td.S ~F CRA1 M1t1'flt 1o l1Mr,,111t UP Ja, ll&l 381 1'He oLJ,,Esf 6t:C ol 1'111SE Sf'd1E/)) .

' ~El L1111Atllef srt,11811., J EL1'l.111Jtfll j • .StofT'$J'Lf5$ C.,,,f'I 11 ,.£11$0" oF A1u>1.ES&.E11c.t; t1£\IELofH11-ilflt ~Jt/lMAf,1ll,1"1.' /J,1111,1,111e1J ~tsPo.,.SJs,a.,,"I, . """" f'HL :J1111t1',L£ c,tAfN llJIALf'1, SH """'· PsYcu11L. 100 9 lAo,J.Jju,J-~UEl AL~o £1.,ZAIJErH A, 5o~&U Et AL., ~APP111& C0Af1t.1JL ,Hlll&l A•~" 1'H£ '"JMIIN ~PAtJ, I, N•r.:1A.t /lllt.11A0SC.1llltl Jo'I- 310 laoo3) ~ D1il£L 11.E.6.I.A~tHtA.J I.JtJvt. lt£A&ll£b S11#1,LIIL C1>11~L116111/d. SEE CAf1#lP.,1t1£ L£6LL / CHl1sf,AN 8£n11L,ttJ1 Lo11ur11tu1'11L

llE.,ELl,Mtlllfa ~, UuMnll AA1wl 1,J1l.11'& C.o#lf,N,1ES /.'~oM ~HIL/JHOOb ,,,,,.,, AA11Lfuo,,~, 11 :r. IIE1Jl.oSC1l.Jl&C ,0'137, 10938, I o9'1Jt•'.,./e ~H11w "'11>11111 .. s~s:nt..r Bht,111 JJ~I/EL41'Mllllf AuA"1lti 7o.JNC.

At,1JL1ilN~ -" .IJ~tJt.lM"/~11 1"1.A'-f~, Pu.:f,ct1Ll#Aa ~M,r(IIL toJI/IIU,1'1~11$ #J££0£Li Fol. ~o,"1U~ Cof;/lll'f"lvt f11~1(.s s~u, "~ INU18,r,11AI, E'l.£CIJf,~t ~11,u.(11,111,111&,, JINA Af'(l.llf,o~. ,, ) (51IJ/;'h.l'IG 5uS1£c1°.S AC£ ..S,t, f'o a'l.l 1E~~S DU); SCI!. Al.5~ M£Luil/JJI 8£&J<, At.LAl£JJ /J£YUoPlll_,,,; ao ~ ~DJl'll'TNuild 81.AME. 1H£ IJU1/II, WJILL $'1. :1., A,11:. di I IJ,o/~ A1" LJJj -r"~" ~-x. S~11J .. ,.1,A,1'Y fltf'ENbS rJt LI. 8£"'101116 1'Ebl '1lAIU /JIM II.Mu# AiRaAAlll~ o, /. II, 8011J A'IA,Lll8Ll Af H (ff: '°'1-'L / L WW 7 l I(. '

31. 5"13 &IS SSI <ao11~). 1°J.ll ~114/Wl'IIJct oF f'Hl ~1,1l'Af'4t C1111td' 11t1$E~1',11,l•·st:,E,1t:t lll'f• ,,.~ A,A~1Al'c'1 "1tl4S Jllo'( L11sr olJ Ill~ AH,e.1 .6Nli ~11111/Lb 11,( 8£ £pS'f AY t'u,s C.Plllff. SEl a,fl/oP c PAA.~ S1t1PM Nd'Ft .3J' 111' ~8~ t'IIL1H••"' Rl,I•& ""'" At.vil4Y$ 8E sesf """"'" ill rHL ~ 11~£ rHllr "6.111.sHu'

":Ht -:lul/lNILE Ae.A-rH PEIIAl-r'I IN A//lft~~IJ1 "rNE /j£U$uAI I!, 111' l lA~'F £1Jl,Jlr1.LV .Jlf'Ewt1A1'1f/ nf. ,.,.~ l!.NJDAjEMElllr All/; APIL,u1'1u1'I "'F ~t!r4,lf1F1& F,lt/~IN(.$ AEL111'uu, rp A,hLl 5l.E1''f

bEilE. loP MEPlfA, /111.MAfvA.,f~ '' J; JEffAr. ~ A.ost,,11 rH£ 4u,tJ ""' r11E ~ f Ail/J: llo4J ->Jisyb§i,E,1d IS 'f'All~Fo1t1111JI/G rH£ tli:.IJL s-,:sflM Al, t. 1'i~t.$ M~c;. . .-,g, SI ,M,u, II, 30"1) ( .. ~ll~T1e.~ KtMU,1 1Nb1~£ef A.E~l.U.11/ee 'f'IJ -f'lf& St1e/llrfF1e ~rub1r$ ul _,-,_,E S~1Er~ LI> $1'1111£ $i;fl11M'£~ ~Ab t.l.1f1e~ -fo 'l/ltfll r11E Aled11A1 A.J r>1£ ~A"w"' "ti 60411.b "F G~11e11f,.111 "' MEIII.OL.4,J ... ,

J~. 11r1<,"~ v ,,,~~1/ft/1A, &:1, t1 , :l 3o'1 (I01J;J)

3.9. ,c, Id Ao PEA, S~PAA o,~ ~s, · s.s 1

3~. ~J ,r 6S't.

35 .. ~££ ,~,. Af.$.G'l-1-o. l;t ~l'Al/t,fol..l, 'II k'l,lf'iJGI{'/ 1"11.E~IJVA.'f A.E"Jcc.l'l!J, All0Pfd.'f11111'(1 ,." l11Lt

011( &AP1f1JL '""''~HME/llf" PoA 1JeF£N/J,tll(.$ ""'~ ,,F(U,I ~.,, ,11u,e1.. f'lle At.t ,& .. tit a 61,.S . 11,1. 377• 1fJ (1'/81/),

3&.. ll..erEA, 51/3 VS jl,1 · 'i rtJu"f"ll A,.X11IS, 51, 11S Af J")

·l1. $ £l Id AT £,$. ~r,PlA £14ft,ll)U ~HI ,,.,fle-f11N '" '' ... ""b· 11 ~ 1EA~· ~L/JS flltJI 1HOl41Jo,J v. l)~&.AIIN4A P/{ov,bEI> ro~ f"Hgl 11/!U,E~ 11,. SEC "187 u ·S· BIS, 838 ti '1ft),

3f. SEE A.1Jfl.A. E,,iJ &J.~. 11-1' s,94'1o.

3,. Id. Af 5"'f. 1HI touiT C11t.b llt,ltff ltJPR.11 ll~fl "IB, llfJ!J'i, Fo~ "/HE FIA.Sf l1111J1114; 5tl1llatl.f, """ .sur" SuPAA llofl a.ii, Af '"'", ~A. f"H£ Sir.ONA F1Ntt,1,lc; Ali> £i,l(.Soll, 1/JEMd·t ; · ~""'" .. ,,,., CA1s1S, S&1IAA ,1#1£ .5~. lo,. 1"HZ rH11b ,,/li/1>1/11~ ·

'ft1· 5tl Roll.,.; ~ '13 IJ.$, AT 511 - 511. (l-lt~t AA.,11114£1115 t.fGM.b11ilC Rl'fA18uf1•II A"b St1l4E.WoAfl411t1lSS

Mill~ fHIU f Ill c.,,._r IU~fEI> 111 SfAIIIJFo,.O v 1'.Ellf11cill • SEf '1,3 Cl-~- ·.UI, 311 ·• 118 I 1 'IH)

_,..,_ .... . .... . : .• .

Page 13: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

a.41. AoPU., 5111 U,5 - AT S1'f,

.. ~. Id.

~3. Si£ G«AHAM V fLIAlbll J 130 s.ct Joll I Joao (ao,o) .

./V, SEE Id, Af ao/J,-3(). 'l.5 . Id 4f d~ ~, (t 1T11,, Aoflt 5 "'J u .$ AT 5 ''I· 10) . "!"NI GI\AHaM Cot1Af u,J'f'11't1EI> ;

''fHes, .SU,~Jf ~Hll~'14A,s(,u ME~ 1'u,r '' 15 b1fF1t.11t.T fl/tll Foe. l!1'PU.( Psu.11.u,,sf To b,FTtAi,/1,lt(C 8l1'wll,I "f'11£ $1,1~l,l1U. ofFillblA wlloit. ~1,,,,., At:Put:r~ 1J"4F-11:f't1ll1t1! "fJ:f

rRA1IJ1f. ,JI IHl111f11£1T11

A,IA 1'11£ A'IIE jtNl,/1Ll o11'£ME'- tJl/0$/. Cl.1111E I.EFLEt1S 11.RtPAAAS L £ coP..1.u,r1t1,I, llu.od1Ht.L'J, S11tllJ.11Ll ~fFtll/JI!~ e.t1H1Jd'( ""'fH "t.,A1,ur1 S£ lLASS1F1/.JJ AJ;to~, TIil woasf ~IFEIJAE~ - A J11'illl•LE 1j llo1 A&soL'IO of R.I.Sfo1"1a,ur1 lol Hli Att,,,Js, Bt1r HIS

1'i.A~t.P.E.S51t>H ,, MOf A-' Md•U'1 Uf-.!HEll51au A.S tH,r "' ""' AjtJlf.

-1,. ~EC Id,

..,,. :ld .

"ff/ . Id,

,f'J. Id. 41 Jo:)1 l41Jo1i1t1G IIA~EAL11,I " Ml~HIGttl4, So, C}.~. '151, /Ot>I '1nll,

So , 1d Af .;Jo/J!.

51. SEE ,ti,

6J. SE.E Id A( ~oa&- 31.

53, %d /(f ~oag ·

Sit . tJ Af ~"a"~ a, · 55- Jd 1ri 6'oJ'I,

s,.z,1 Af ~oJf•3o, 57. $£E Id. Ai )aJP,

$8· MIi.LiA v ALASAMII J /J~ S.Cf. 3'1SS, J.,w (ac/JJ.

$1. IJ Af J'll,1/. 1111 CouAf'S lloLAul~ TIit.Mb OH F1'UH "' 1/hf M~IIAnroA'/ ~l.141)1'c,11, ~ll-#1#4! Po~£ "<oo

CA.1.111 A lt.lSX o~ LJJ!JPolof1.:r,-NAfl 111141,IIMf.Hf'' 8Uth~t 1'H£.1 MAiit ""111111'#1 "•.b A tL fNlfl AltoH/l,Jli£S ,rl ,t.p.It.£'1/11,t( ,, .,." 7H£ ~/IIIPoS,fl,11 of i"IIL HIUHts1 rl.1$01' S!"1't1'd 6116 ~All wEAKe-,1 '-•r,.IIAJ.E $ ,,,. PcJ1'1.fH.IIIIE lf1. r ti Al ;11 ,,.

6o , Sl.f '" . t111' 4'41, I/ - ,s .

'1 . .fEE Id, Af ~ 'l,s , a'l1o "71. A L1"d,11tl" f'HE /llf~.1,p.,f'~ "'"' 1'11 l1t,,t1H~ .Slll"tf 1J1.,i111lllf l.&Urt.O,ll&

., ol.:fl!~r,1.1t 1,IJul:1A, "' td. '11' '£/ 11- 7~, 1"H£ ~AIIX "' d'.l HoU,,u. t.Er..,tb oll ,,.6,vHwlALl'ZU 4G.rrt1't:11J, /JA.U.Eb£,/1t ,d 11r ~"1'11, a111111·11,

"3. ~£( 14 Af .J.,1,3,

(,3, Stt Id. Arf ;111,5,

·,'I . .1tl. "' jl{l,t.. ,s. IJ, A1 ~617&,

t.1.. IJ· A1 ~61/J.

t,1. !at1,U ., Sf~fE, H6 1161.1-1,,~, 51.,1' oP. If(,-; (Ft.A,,,,. C,,f', ~ff oe1 ~. 3011f

,,. !1>1,t4/IL,f ,,, . of" ,,~.

I,'/, ~ll t ., .' 1'E.f.t.tt<.o ., ._~ ·ft.1Hlll5; 11/o. ,, .. 1~010, SL,I' "'. 11r IP (51if C./f... DEC ,, 1#01.3) (18-"lt.11~., OU)' IH A.£ /;Ill.JIU," &1a F.Bd §33, 5l°'(i,1H C1A..#010) (1'f,1E.H ... o&.td, 5iA1£ ti /tl1U.U, Jo18 ~,,1,1°,!, APP Ux,~ '110 (1'f~~IA1t-dWi l'lo!Ll \> Jlot1SL, :Jo1S IL APP LE'l.t~ · (1 .$() ll1>.Sto1 VJCl#f'lj) ~'I l£qPLl 'II Jl~~~t.. JoJS ILL L£1.,5 I/lo

.. ·,s-

Page 14: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

.,o. l..oft~.,, 5,M11,11,~, .5'1J 11,S. 5!,t,~111/liloo.5J. · ,,1 NU ~onR. ,,,.,1111t; 111~7,d o•tol41lU. '"°" 15ft1l WiTN 1"#/l itva.t'~ d 'lf'-114tLtJ5a'll11/.SS 1h11 u,Ut/..1" CL dPIINtsS. jU uJ · lff "11 • 0 I "1 'Co1>11U,., 1-1 ft5Sf,n",At Sf~ AU" Jo~I.PH L. 11,~FHAN, ~,I 1'11£ /J&U ,,, l111E-bl.t.W1JC: ~cJ,Jt,.,1.u AIIO (ul ltlAfll H1'Al:f1,

'4o H,~t,,Jfj~ l. . :I. 131, 3S'f ti 719)

11, l(o,tA, '"'' u . $ , Af ~1'1,

1~. 8,J, C.Ait:I ET. AL, rill A/U,Ll~ttllf M.A111, 111'1 IIIJIIAI,$ 11.1. ACAi>, StlS, I 11 1 tJJ f.ooo'l.) . .:.Cr """~ • Tllt1A 11.n ~" Piu.t.111' ~E."-Ellt..~rl ' '"" M11Kl S(/IJ6E$ ,,J M11v,11t. ,,-H,J S11l~u L1/llr 'fo

11111Lr1PL( L1111e, 1',nt1 Co~11>1• ~EI/ELolM£,/T11t C.IIIING~~ A~A.d~ A•'fll Co,dl~( {EMo11HlltLt'1 C.1111.t-l/J

0~ ,.Jo1) 4Jl/j '('/Ml flN r111. MOMENT ""' "' 1'Ht ,,1t11A.E ). ,, Jd.

Sf£ M,tLflt V OLl1SA~11, I '3d s. C.1'· 3'15.5 ~018} (c11'111, 1ff1,1BE1., , .Sc.011', St1PAD ~ofC ,a); /toPHt, 51/3 u.J, /If s,9, .f1~, 513 (SAME). nl "loTAJ.1 t'lll IMA10A1r'I 11' ttoflA. ~11lS PltofESSoAS SfEIIJBt.M A.lb ~Coff Fot11t f1ME.S,

"1$ , .s,, ~r,111/JEP.C f Scorr, $11PA1t /lloTE "13, Al 1613 (l!lflll& EL1Z.Aatf11 CA11lf/lllttt1'; LAaP.f.,.lE S'IE:ulatl'.G, 1'%MMAT11A.11'1 of S.sU.MiAl1 ,,I AAOl.£.UIIIC.I ~ 111111'1 AA'1LG£UHf& ~A'I BE La$ t.uLPABLE "flllli AJ>11Lr~1 lfl liH6v . .Sa,./ L . 71/1 (Aooo JJ. tAuF/14111111 A/IIIJ ~1l1'11SlA, ENu,Mllff 1'H£ Jl.tl.11(111'SH1, St.rwU~ A~~

,S1<HoS«1A1. "",.'"A1r11 '*"'' 11111fl.5ot.11tL btt1s11"'MA11.,,,,, p,,,,4.AJ& t'"J.li.f' ,, n,r 1t.A,obS At,"'1lE..., , , Allt. l'I A~ICS Ml IMl1>A1iwr 1ILAIIS.1f'11/1111 P1111i1-f 111 P&°"'t.ll~Sot1AL bl.'llLohrtE,I( t)llf( IS P11'f'EN(,11u"t t.fU'IIW(

To /;lll,,U A~"f r11t ~4/IJII" ilF UCAL SoUIIAAAIEl _a£ftt4lN Ab1Lt~CL"t.t IIAA Jt~11Lf11•"~ . '' ~AulFM•ll; S'fE,,JBfit;., $t1PA.• "' ,~,. lot.. A (/1&1.IJtJ'H t.1t.,f1a11E "' f'Nt. $11fAl.'1#t C"t11t1'S lt.,IHtil,e Plfl'AUS IJIV Abrfl. 5U r.E.lltlMl."I . bl WAH W· bf.HNo, I'll£ ~~1l11111U, ~lll~UM,,.~s Di ,C111IA V ~IM/144Nf. l OH1' st. ~- ' (~Alt, L . .37'1 (::>Ht). '

'"· M,ua., 1JJ s. Cl' A'f d'ff,~ n.!

"11 . 81.,ff oF AMI" £ut,~l J· lltw,.f1'CE AS1'Et ,,, al• '" SuPPoR:f tJF flTl1ioll£A$ Af 1J,1,, M,U.U,, , ~ S ,C-1, . ""5.S ( ,111S. lo- 9Lllt.

1 1t, • 1f. ''7 )

18, /J, Ar ,, n . l'I (c,r,11G Itfl ". G1tbb S11tve·(11lt11L Mll&Nl.TJC l.t St,,111,Jtl #f 1'11£ A/,,oLt~tE,d S,,,,,,,1, 11,a1 AMIIALS N,) · JU,ltb . .£c,J 71, S (:Joo-t),' Slt 4Ls" S11P1A N11ft I,/,

11. Ste SP.JEI ;oA. IIAEA,UW lsv&.H*LoO.,elil. AS$' IJ AT S, 9, M ,LL t,,

1 l 11~ 16 • 91,., ,, " _ 11.lfl) . n er ,u · 1 Alf, t I C ul. 'If I II S JJH11.r OP II lil1111u~

lo. 5£.£ Id . At' tt!J , 'TJIG. £1.t~A 15 t1,.bEASflJ/61t/JlE' "AA111.f'IIP1,j 11 " ''

i-lJJllE ,I~ CUA-~ /JE.F1Nrl11,1111. f111C4114H't~, '"" 11..ESEAUIIUS "'~" ,~t.!f;l1~:,i:i::: ,, E.AAl,"f AA.IL(• r:~t I~.,._/:\ ~VN~ltl~, NIAPflJI& oF IIIJMAII Ct>P.11CAL M V&IMEll'f b11fl111, t H1L6HooJ. 111~::~~~UA:.:::. £/I, , 0 ' ·. NAf t A,11, . 1,,s. fl7'1 !61:St.AJAJ,," ''ll~l.£5,E"'-' ""' lAl.l:f Al>i>l.(Noob" AS

~ltJASSI« Aas 17 'fo II llu"i ALSO AE.$,/;A.l4n11, Aj " t!N1LAO.E.N Aid IIAoWCl/18'' hoPt., A~ts ~oiJA io Twt.1i11'V 'ON[ ) • COMPAU CA$l't &I"''·, ~IIPI/.A """' /69 A1 111 1,f~~(~:~"'

J//flAillllS I/II A &Mt 6AAPH !,A ''A/lilLlSC.ellTS" (MES IJ ro 11) 4NJ ''A1,.,i1.f.j I• (A"'s 83 ,. nJ "" .... ,, Id A1 "' FtC. S {Sllow11" A MEASIIAt //II A $td1'fll,fut' loi "AlwLfS "1&1 II '1"0 "f'HldY)). 1

11

•

Page 15: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

•• '" ''""· , . ..Sfd,JLl'Y NALL P11SL,S11tl JIIS 'l't,,10-, \/OL~Mt . du$ 01" wl-lff WAS 711t,I tollSli>ERtl> "' ~'W l1FE .Sf110l, AJJoU:.SU.,Ul , G.SfAIILl'I M11L1 AJu,LUU-Jlt.l.; 11~ /J~"ICNolJJC"I AJII, 11'~ i£l.A1'11.U 1'D

,H"/$10/.0&.f, IIIIT~ fG1.of:Y1 ..$11~1GL0C'f1 ~fi, C.I.IMI, •£1.1~1IN 41" lAJUlflM (/fo¥),

II, 'TIIIJ ftltJoA df 'fo11~, Abfll.1Notli- $1141fC1£b 1o .,,U,'1 Lll8iLS1 S~M AS ''llb11Lf&Stt1U£,'' ''fMt#l6fj 4b.US"""',., Allb •• 'IOtJTIIHIJdb'' ... HIIS 8E(;.(1MI ,.,,, 5.,,-;ru1 IJF MIit.ii 1J/TEA.ts1. JtE Kit/ S ,/NA#wtfZ., fAIH £ '-E Jlt,V6 flll '°oA 1'11 l,. ,olllt?, W4U Sf. J,1 Fl&. I., 1oll1 Af' t.l • Jl#p£ tEf.5£ YlS, d"·• ~ 'T111J'l~ 4fl£ rAIJ.11'& Lo11~Elt. 1~ &«fJui ul ~ &,t UIN ,1 ll'iJ.A,die. (1101. Jo, Jtf1.1, 1l; 5t9 I~)

83, Stl J'[FFJtE 1 Al.,J~f" f/14tU.11I, AIIIIL711,~A ~ 1'11l w11/l>11U;, P.ou f"-oM 1'Ut Llf'E ft111s 1'11-.-v,11 'l'IIE ./Jo '.1 M 'I (:Jt»11 J ( 1111'"111~ /ltlW $ oc1ol..0GIS~ l>EF1N! rHI f.M11$11'11N fp AAcJL f ~1oj 111 1"£~"1.S -F Wc,,t&

11

fEt>Ptl F,*1.11111" Stll#PL, ENrfAIII~ /!11LL -1i114E w,u.11.., r.111,,1c JtlfllU1fb AN# Becol'f1ll, f11d,r('S)

II/, SEE Fi111« F. /!c,A$1£1'8EM,:fl., ET AL,, tJII "1'11£ F~Jl1'1h l'Jf II/J11L(ll,~1/. G~u.,,1'i TN~t AA,

Ill UJ ~,t.Uf"l•II!,, Ill ON r111. F kl/TIE I. t1F AbvLf'HNi,; rHEa1t.:,1 RU.tMlCH, ANI> , ,181.,, PIL,t.Y 3 , 5

l ·RtCHl'tRb A• 5£T1£ P.S1111, Ji, t1 AL . El$, atJIG) . $El JJU" ,..,,111 1111,,.~11,z "'"·'· r,/1111( ,s ,r IJ/lo,Jr :Jo·.S""4£111,/ll~S? II/ • ., , 11/lllflS ,.,".,AuO, ~:1, '1010, 111" JB.

85 . .SEE JtFf/.11 1t"5(,. IUlll.1'1 f S(15A.I r,,e,., AblLB,t.fl>ltl 1lAM1,t.SLf A/110 ulflRMlll4ALl ~ WIIEII 611.S JIAo us,i11cl tNb ( J3 $. 1ouf"II / AlloLl5C.Elle( s,1, ~ JI/ (,,,I/). :Td~A.t( '1lNSf.ll A~AEf~ '->1EAS11t1C Abul.fHl>dt,: A 'f'll(4P.."I IF b6'\ICI.OP114e,Jf F"4-'t rHl LME 11.t.,IS 1HJ111,11 Tit!. "" '.5, 15 II/ti fsYu,,, '"' '1tJO#J. P111FUS0R 11~1/1

~ 1EAIII .• lNtu,," AINlfJl#t,'' SUMS ~ llhl filKul oFf,, WHILl Pil YIOtJS (IIGI.AOtl.lt.1 'lllf#N~t Sf/C.11 JU ··111£ fbsf PollEb ,111t~ttti"11 .. ,,. •• ,11,~141l.Er1.u • L A,ulcNU '1111A& AAuLf.t/' Hllvl 1Uf. ,JI FNJf, A~ Mut(,b,Sc.1Pl,1,J1u7t l~A.,JA1'11JIIIL I.ESE.Ait,H 1Jl,1tll1'£llfmi1 IJj1tAre1J

1o ,.HI S(u.61 "' "l!.MEI.Ctll, AA11t,/.111111A ,; Jti11s fo,.,,,,l!I,.

IC,. JEE l#a,JfT(, .SvPIU llcfl. II'/, ~f 't-5; ~ll'IA, $~4 II~ ut 1tT t-.

1'7. SU El,,. M1,toL1 1:ltl.1rllll8 /tf111A1All HAS .St~1~11S l111Uttllll!U.ES 101.. ~#Mf1 lliw Rf.SlllCH ll.E'lllLS, uJFlll'1'"" hJ1 tMIA, '", ~oil, 11: ,., ,,., J, u-rr,: II'°" . CL I PUS, tl ,.u,,.,,,,1" 1141/11 r11£ Avt~~l a&LS hA. lfl•U1Mt. Hat/£ >livEA 8fEN #11,H!lt 1"NAl4 f'IIE'f A-.l >low hA 1/110/Ull lJ6,~J AIIIJ AAtH /aB , 1 )),

S8, Sf.E hi!HAU FR..1 l'lW AU . tf"A,1 A A,~1,u ~HIII.E "F 'fov,lc. IJ/J~l.11 L I'll IN YNl1A fllP.~fl' llo/141 II I • oJ (Qo1a)

1 Av,uU4&l ar 11rrP: II Co"·,, I BjlJ'it:~; SEl Ailo A.08£1.f" ~ - ~~,.EIII $ 14,f-.£..,l E. l'.DlS,

M1tff-.,1tL IU$ISIAN&l Fll#M F,t,,,111ES bu-.,,11, rHt 1'1.Alilll"10,J n A.6'1'1Hl4J, Iii M 1")/~ Ft1,1(,1~, j "'~·

""1r£ ,ao, ,.., 3'1t-, ~,1

s,. SEf ELt'u&tfH F11sset1.; fl..RHt F, Fu!:tfe,11,u..s, .Ii'! f11l 1lliN~11,,11 (o Ab11LrHN1> luJl.11', T11e ,o"flf CE.Jf.,A'f: lllc.E

1 1<11tr,.,,N, ltlill &E,l.tll,.1 111 tJII t'lll futlf1li, ~ut"" N•f'l 1'11, 11189, 11,33 F,,.J.J.,S8··

fo, Foi CAITl'luU oF "TH£ /141LLE1-lll1•L c,,1u.Af"10II IIS SELF-ABS.ttBEt, 4J/i IIEEIJLlj.!.L'I &'1)61EA, $EE,~_,.,

fltAMPLl, !EIFR.lt ZUUll,J1 r,-,£ Cob6L11t1, ~R1$1$: WIii ~ltfll.Jt6,a (Nill¥ IJJJ11L11INA 8kl11s Ar

'"' W4LL ~. J., °JAN,, c3bo5, A~ a,,,'" M1Nu1ES! 7/JE MllLENlltU AIU COHI"' {~81 1EtE'l,JlolJ 8~11/JGIISf H#1 ..1s, ~a i At• I LA8LL ,n- ll1TI: //lid,,. &JI II~ L HL•; s,E ~b/Eff. S1111'1J "'on " ~ M , , g. '1,

1

1,. 3 E E Id A f' s.

'f,!J. SU Id , Ar.&--t.; j£l ALS1t F,IIUIEN8Elt£ 11R..Ef-AL . 1 St1h..ll l'lotl. 130, Ar11 £,

'13, SEE SHlUE/'tlSA~El.,SuPAA ,ltl{f llf; s,t AL~ 6£Alll fll~>I/$"", A/J11L1'IIOO'I;, btll/Yl/): Wllkf Hlt5

r11l l.fCE.5SMN IJDIIIE f'o M1L&£,l,ttL~? AfLAllf1e tft&ll11/iU l"I, 3,JJ If : IJI JIM), rtfff ~ // ,t10 .0IID 8G~. '

Page 16: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

Cf't, ~EC4U. 1"u" C.OuAr ltf.AS/Wlb 1'H4f 4L1'HouGII .. flt tJ.uAL11'E~ 1)/4-r S.~AL11"1lS r-Hllr b,~ful,61/!iJl

JtJtJlJIIL£$ IRoll#I Alh!Lr.l bo l+loT luSAPfJ.Ai. wNEJI Ail 1lllb1Y1bfl1JL ("t1Rlil~ ,8 • •, ,-1,1£ I"£ "F 16

IS 1"11l 1011/'r 1,JJILtL SoC1ErY 61<11WS till L 111£ l#A NIIJ/l'I P11t.,o5!$ 8£1'wU,4 t. lltLIHlool A-Nb IU'1L flltJM.'' RoPl:I. v ~1M1N11t, .l'iJ u,s,SS1, 51'1'3oo5),· Sl.t Al.So Ro,111u Ao£

1'Scll if. IIL.

1 ~oC,6L sc.1tJ,JtG

Al'lt, TUE CauttB: -ru~ /(oLE oF AMU.,JS LuA,4£ 8A.1Gf~, ,s LAl#J ! Ut1MAII. a,u1t'I, ,,., (19f1)

(u 8£(1HdE j11~ES AA.E "IM11IEI IN rH! LAW A1'A ltAl C.£,IER.,uu u"J~u.,AA w ,1'#1 ,~.,~llohC.'f'>

#t[S£4At.H MJ:rll11Aolot.'i ANIJ ST1t1r51it:.~, 'fHLY IIIU. NA1t11l.ALLY MoAC 111t,L11lle 'f'o lELV ~1' LEl1tL

~Ht>LIIAAH,I' A/Ill, PltSt.lbb/f WI/EH r11ev ,ftf111<£ 1HE1A. bEt1S1h1S. 17JE l,1FF!u.,l,£S IN JI..A11'111IC.

A-111A AH~At!H~.s 1"4J 5.c.Nt1Lt1111. SH,, """""" ,11NW1lH1,cAt1ol'I lll1"11'1llN r11t. -rw" b,S&.,PL,,.ts b,~F,c.11LT, ··J

15, S~ 1EAAY A, MAIMIEY, TIit FAW P~1,u1E oF AAoL t~l.,fi 8«1111 ~tlltE /N -:f11vEll1LE t'IISf',cC, I& ,lofl.2 b11111 E L • A,v. Bf, I.,.,., 1/S liot:11 > , .. 1'HE IMPAtr ol A/Jo~Sc.E/1.1 BIA,11 st,Ellct °' 'Suvt1'1Ll j.,5;f,,E H~ 8£Ft,J ~Tlllo1',LY CA81NII> S1 "!"NE 'Uulls,c lt.EILrf'Y ML fl,t,L 1Jd,1"A.11Ji . , • l)o,'h.1J11L FoU.E.S AAE .So Eld/U.IICHU A,i}j ol S uc.N 6loAA APPL1t.AIJ1t,r1 w,111111/ C~1M1JAL L,sw, AAoL£jt£Nf

81.A111 .S~1Elkl I j INA/ll.tluAt"/1. 1'0 PRo'/01'.I. bfEI' CN~11,1, ,,,. Lllld' 1.1tf'I," TIil ~oi,1.H.'1)

,1. SEE /IJ,1£P.1

S't.3 c, • .s . Af S8.3 APl't c.

,,. SEE Id . Af 5 f S All ~.

loo, SE£ Id . M 8"/1 AIP. I'·

Io/ , J£l, £. ,., C4L . to11$f. Rid . Jq . I a}(J )• JM I LL . CCMP- ~f'llf. A141' 5/1, -1, ( wES 1 ;011) · N . 'f. Alu I I

8Ev. toll1. I.AIJ I '-SW { Ml!K,IUIEY 8011),

lol · SlE E. . t , ill.II, t:oAE l a-B-" LLlX1$Jil£X1, cloo~Jj t•t · f.tM tobE j1,,1t1 {WESf d0/3); SfE AlSo fL1lA8CT# .5 , $CtJrf iHf LE,AL to111sf.e..,e,f,1A1 ol CHIL/JHoo/J, ,,1 A C.LNffJI.Y ol i'JVlHJLE J'us11C£1 S11M11

1

/11011. c1( A-f 11J, iJo.

/o't- Sl£ $corr, .Sr,,fl.A lkTE 1111 111 th.

10.S- 5£E Z1MR1,", S11fR..A /tlo1l 3B, A11J (N-fHul, .S11tll 4t.11'tllfl£S 4S /JA1v11/&J.

,,,. 5E£ Allllltfw VM HldC.H, JELEtf,tl INtAIA(.1fllfl1II lltEJ<AM11,a: .,..,,, Nllfl1AIIL ACIIIE~Y

of ..sc,tllCES' REP-A.1 4JN ~"'""'"'t t.111.EIR.$ A,lt, ' ' CA1'EEII. C./1.JMIIIAU, 11

1 llJ"4 . :rv.Sr. EfH/t$ ,,, iJ7 11,88).

,,1 ,u /ti ·

_,,-

Page 17: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

108. SOl''IIE CHl~~f,ll'j 1tt,11T$ A.OV«A1'S Ff4tt. f,MJCfUMIHAL Le,.tL bE'ilto,/11£,/(5 111/d bo Jlo1 lECOG"1l.E 1HE o,FFER.b4CES BETwEEH C~llllt1'RL L11w Allb OTI-IEI .. bfC1S1o,IHAJCu,6 Co~lC'TS M1,uf cJN1'El>'l1J/E. Yoll'IH fHlftltJoMf, ~El 8&11S1 5vf'I.A I/tiff 'It., Ar J/3-"II/ • .St1,II FlAf.S AA.E RE~$t,ll~8Lf.1 '111/f.,i f'HAr

bEV!LOPMfllYAI. bt~OWAtES Mlovr '/o.Jf11 IH"4•1'UP.•N H•'IIE H4b 1111tPL,,111,011, &£'/olll) fH! iE41.M or tAIMUIM SCIIT'ENt1l'IG~ FoR. EXAl'tPLf, P~oPollE,lfS A.6111 olPo,IE1'T5 ~I A woMAll'.!i All1urY .,." HAl/£ AN AB0d10l4

,ISEb 'fHE ~<,tf'lc.£. StE scoTr. $e1P1M NO'TE ltto, Ar 51,'l-11,,' ~££ Al.So Rot£« .,, , S1MM0"s, 5At3 V·.S·

551, '11- I 1.

lo'/. Lt1tl<.ETT V· ONtD1 '138 IJ·.S· 5ll,; l,oS (1'111); Sfi .41LSo Id, (i'1Hf 1'oMYIULIS1&.,T1 t,f &ol.Ucf,,t ,,,. Mol1N111, MECIIANISl'fs • • - ulU)£ASCOH - 111E NEa loR. ,,,,,u.,,wAL,UI> t:ON.sJbEAAf,oll A$ A

,oN.S1tf u11oll,IL ltE&u•~El"IENf '" 1Mlli11IC fN£ "/JflfrJI SEl'lffll,f. ")

110, SEt E/Jb,N~ V o.KL11IIM-1A, 1/55 \J,S• 10'1, 115-16 111u).

Ill. Id 111. IIS·

IIJ · SEE Suf'b l'lon5 lo3 A10 111.§1

IJlib IICto~PAIIY,lfC 1'£KT ·

113. Stf MILL£~ II ALiJ4R-"4A1 13,3 .$. t11- '1615 5 ; 8'115 ( dolt1)

, '". Ga.Al/A/Ill , ~11M41 130 S ·Ct 111 "o~7 ~olo J

11S. /'llf1LLEIC, .$"PA•, l3J S,CI' ;}l./f5.

"'· Id. 41" d't,s-1,,; GltAUAM, J3o S.t!r. A13'>iJ8-Jo; RoPSA., ~",,.,, .&'13 f)$·. Ar s1,-7a.

" 7· GI.Al/AM,$ tJl'AA, 'Jg Ser. ,., 3o86j 1111 GR.11Hr.M c ouAr ,1ofEb 1'HAf "r111 eo"CEP1 of PA.11'01tT1ollAa.1 IS CE.N1'AAL f'o 'r#IE 8TH AMGNb/lfE1'f. •' Ztl. llf ~O:JI.

111. Aflfod v. "1,1<,,,,,.a, $31, 11.s. Jo '1 3,, (~ooJJ, ,

'19 • C.A.A,u,,.., ~uPA~, 1.Jo S. tt. 1tf ~o:JB ("f#lf HEAAt 1>F fl(f l.eri,8.tf,o1' I.Af'1orl4LE , s fHAf II c1t,,w1111 SE,JTE,ICE MuSf /Jf btAlt-11.'t ~eurU 1o ·r,./f IEAS.·,IIU. ,uLPAB1t,r1 o~ 1'"Hl e/lJ/'1111/Jl oFFEwaE.", u)

11.s>, ~PEA., S11IM, S'1J 11,s. Af S1/.

'°'· 1d, I~. C:AAHAM, 130 S,CI Af aot1&-;cf.

1a3, Id,

1al/, A1~iN5, 5.,,,.,, SJI. .,.s. Jo"I, 311'100~).

1aJ· ANbA£'1,J ASIIIA/ott(fl, 5£,JfEHtfl/S Allb. CA.111t,t1J1.L ~vsf,,t 1'1 •£'111.·£1>· ao10)

13,~ Id.

I /}1. RoP£ l , B ..,1 II, S · A-1' S 10 - 7tJ ·

,aa. 'ltAHA.11, 130 St( ,4f :>o;JB-a,. 1a'I. SEE I. J.

I Jo. 5fE ASWoA.TH, s.,,,_,, llotl /1,I, Af g,. t.11. 6~11H1tM, 5vl'1'11, 1311 SCI Af 3oJ'I.

Jla· Id,

I U. Z.d. At' ,lo~I,

1J'i. /ttlltLl,_., 511PAA 1 l:Jd S,tf, It( 3'11$.

-, ,-

Page 18: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

135. 6Auce 3 -CoH(II, 1Nto1.1 1;111, fR.4cr,eE. "' l$Yt.H11, f'l.t 5•'1 "1003) , .. s,,1r;E t11,uu,1•5 PfAio11,c.,r,u 1tAt $tilt. ,.,,ye,r ro c._.,uuE A~ Let~${ ndo 1'Hl1P. )'011,., J>.1>11Lf~oollS1 110sf tL1t11~1tJ/IIS AII..E c,t,uH~fEcf 11&,;,t b,11,,l"i""' PEASot4Al.,-r'I IH~ouu '" 1'41J,1111u1~u

UHbE A. -r11f AGE I 8 • " )

/3'1, 5fE "'t'L cou11lo1tt-fo" ,r,.. Fo~ 1,te,ti,L uuc.rn,Bot.bE1..l.11'E P£ASo"'4-L,fY t,,sottoei~ -f'I.EAfMEH'f 41JI J,/1/HIIIUMEIJf :t ... 8 (~oo'l),

I

'31 - SEE wAfEI.Mltll, S ufl.• llo1l 511 11T 3 S5,' i£E AUo Jp,111,ru. L 1,111 1'111'"6"' f JGff Aet 1£tJSE,J ffR.NEtr, 7111. liME,ElltE OF .. EMS~'"' Ab"LTNoo6 ": f'Ht Ji/Ew L,Fl SfASl BETwEEN 4bOUSCf.Hc.C. Altl6 You,.J, llbuLfHt10b,: NE..&..J PEltSPE.cT, y£~ Alli> A&llibAS 3'1

1 flJ (All# h1t1-0;1dJ004f)

IJI. Ct.AHIIM/ t3o S,cr- AT dO~.

131 · SEE A.SHwoATII_. .S u,~11 Nd'fr Illa, At' 8, ,

11/o. ~ EE ,ltAHIN1 /Jo ..S , ct ~f AoJo.

l'/1 . Id· l'IJ. 1 J. 1'13, SEC Sflf~I llofES J•·J1 A>lb A~t.oMfA,l'ltH' ft1'f. IAHC,.l.A5 E.H.L1 bl.r0"1f,,.Af11.1IS hcuSft, OA

l,n.lAB,uf"f AS rf A£LllrE.b 1"11 C. IIPllt1r-t, 1111.1 JCH/,1',ft ft101ttf'1tES ,.E.$fo,1S181t. 1-,C,.

l'l'I, 5lt A4PEI., 5vf1'1 ~'15 v.S ft1 511 -.: '·

A .I .J ru • I.on,. 1 sv,,.A Ml~ ·11,e I ,st.~1M1,11rf10,J ,~oo~ 1¥{. ~EE EL1'l.A8EfU F, f/lllEH51 'f,/..AVllf1,,,i ,oum, .SuP. ct . ~ev. s,, 1,,

J'lt, . ..S£t 8aAll.."I C. . fE,/J, AboLE5l.ENT , .. ,,..,,,uu Resp,,..s,t,u.,r'1, P~l'oR.ftlNUl'f'f, hJU, SE111ft,,u~,,,, Pol,C'1 ,'

AofGA., ,uuA11111 M1LL£i I 1Ael<.So1', 4,.. r11, Yo11rll b1SC011"'(, 31 Lnw i ,,.EG.. dh3, 3;}1 j n.311t:>01J) I I

1'11 · P.ollA., S&J,'-A, 5'13 .... .,. Ar ,t1; ~£I ALSto ,~AH•,.. S\IPU .1 /XI St-t /Jo51' 5~,

I JIB. SEE Jt1Pl\a Pi,taf l . 8 ·

1 'l'f, $ El ll.o ff A, 5 'IJ fl s 1tf 57d- 1J.

tJo, S!f No1ES Jt1·3, IJIIJ. JJtt~ltAPAh111, fEt1 .

,s,. l!o,. ~ b,S~t1SSION A80111 -fHt i11PP01H1 of a, f'o 35, 5tE '"',,..,,. Ptu.:r 1'tJ:. ,.1

i ~~. lltJE '(I) ,r~ Pot'E.Hr,,u ,,.,,,,,,r 011 hlll &,,r.,.•~"" , ,.,,., OE1't£14,1'11f111' tfto'-t»1J1, A bf FEtluJf''J E L1,,laJL1T'i ~()/. IAAI!. Vo~ABLG Pt.1llt$HMtrl(S SH111L.O hEC.Et>E rHG G111i.f P1uu£ ,f II 1~tbt.

IS1. Bfl'otE RolU, Clt4HAM, A#P l'lftLLLII., hoH!»INt SfEPHl/11 Mot.SC 1>1St.t1sse1> A SIMfLA~ iES'1ff'4BLE

Ptt£5v11f1/4,I Strll.Ml. &Ii ~11,ctsft,, TH4(' ''fA1M£$S Allb f. ff1t1E1'Cr/ ~"4/Lb /(J:Qt11A.E. 'f'HE f'AojU,,,f,1111 f"o P~11£ 8E'to,11, A Ae11SOll4S1..f bouSf fHAf A PA/trt(;.lll,,4P. AJJ,oLESc.,:,Jf Wll5 ~11L.t,.'1 us,o,JSiBLE, ''

S1EPHE/tl 1, l'ld.S£, 1/111'1/Jf'vl.,f"Y l#IJ/J 11<.tES&11S1/J• a.,'f"'/1 8 S J . C.~II'\. L . ~ (;"'JIIIINO/..o/;'/, ,$, '3 (i'f,

/SI{. .srE S,JPA4 llo11.S ll3'"t5 A,/1, Ac,11~fA,n1,IC 'tt"l1,

I Sf· &££ 5vfAII llof'ES JI S 'dS A,1~ Atto"4f"111,,1, -fE~(.

,s... 5ff · UolFMMI, 5c.,P«A lioff '"', ar ar,-,a. SEE GE,ll.P.AI..L y Sult.A 1111.1. I/ . 8,

Page 19: courts.michigan.gov...ST_ATE of H1cM1~,./ , Al THE $.iJPR.l!·ME eo11A·r l'EoPLf oF fttE 5TA1"E of M1ttt,8"'-f'LA1Jf,FF, v.s Aoa,,, It ,c,< MA"", II& -.-----------------' OfffNOAl'f.

157, WHILE Pouc.e PRot.ft,,JU All/j Cl.1111tl1'AL $E14fE,1t,11& Ad IMPEA.Ftc:( A,lal."'$, TIIE e,,,.,,.,, IN 1 ,b,8. "· llol..TH C.AhJI.JNA R.£co,111'Z.f.l rHE NEU ro CAI.VE '1Vf AG£ A5 AH t.xcEf(11,I ft1 1W t1'THf/.y,115£ oBlEef,vE "11IUIII01l llULt, 131 $,Cf '13'1'1, 8'to1 ~ol/). ,11 iEsPo1'SE -ro f/1£ S1A1('$

AU.11ME,lr r11~r 4 CH/Lb •5 II~ "'"Sf 8E f'lo'liJl>tj FuM '(HE C.qSft1JJY A1'At Y515 ,, ,, fLeSEfl.iE

CLAl.11'f, '' Jvsf,t.£ S0"1A '$Qfl}/t1/I-IU. WU'/£ f'HAf fHI (.11t11..1 114S IU 1itft> If "!¥/.( EAS,1.1 APM1,l1.cfEAEJ> L11J£1 /(£Cl)C"1t.11U1 -t'>l41 11" wo11tb ~l11PL1 t.NA,1.E rHE l'oL,c£ 1'1 C1A&1u.1ft,d f.Ht

f,o!IS1/l.JJ1K'I~ 811 ,vJ1t1JIIU IN1'EP.~ll1/INJ fSf'Jlf,t.d/ltl) /;Y ,,,,.,.,,,,.. , , '"· "' f"Ht $Ellf£,lt1"1.

loll~ H~wt°'Ell, 1'11t C~,1~1'15 8~1,Nf Loll Af A$E 18 A1.fi1M6III £,UAUS ~•11f S.,MfS hlb J"" A1E6 1'o ~ 18.C.U/l'lve "'"' C r11 A-14£1'6M E,.s· ~ ""' sf-.11111·1$ ti ,J '"" '~" Ml.111".

,ss. PAaFES501. FELb HIW! m h.E..JIOvSL"I R.f.C.06NIZ.~b flt£ Bt1'-l>E1' "1uA1111,1,,,r,tJt, SE.lht,.,Es SAS~ oll 'l1J111H M16/I( fMP15E thJ Co1Jm. Jel, e ,9. FEUJ, SIJPR.A ,Jlfl ~ Id 1aJ (•,,-. EAU gf

~bNt1111J11t.nr,1n1, AO£ AL1Jlt h..oo/,bl.5 'fllE. Mos1 us£.Fc11.. ci.1f£R101' uPoN wH,eH r" ifl.Lo~"1l ,,.,r,1111,"11··). ,,11'11R1 F"R.1'11,s REAsa,11 PADFE~A. PtLJ:; HA!i. P~PoSEh 11 ''y,,.,rH IH5t.ou~f''

Ptl.11Jc.1PLE) . PRDFE.SSol. Ft LI> 11115 APt,.e1f b 1"1141 H/j A PP/l.lJllt.JI '' Afld1l>S flli G.01ltfr(a1AL #!ID

AAM11J1.Jf~11flvl IJ1FF1c11T,6 of II Moll e J/ColtflA!IS11l6 Sc,8lf c fnt 11'Qt111..Y. '' Fi Lb, s "'"" 11"7£ ~ A-116'~. 1'111~ AMIC,1 Rt.S£.t.fs f P..of£SSof. FfLJ,'S A,l# 8AS1!b APPADAl.1 s11,,11, 1N51'£Ab WIii"/ ~/ISD/11/1, offtl.tD 8-1 f'-oFmofl.. Mol.SE, WHO ASl<tb, ''SJ#IJL/) Hof

EFf,t.1ElltY YIELb 1o 1'Hf ,/£1!!.b 1o 11,l/uv,tul4L1U. ~oil. -ruE SHALL CLA1S oF A1u1&.T$ w,T/1 rNt SA~ C'Ut,QocTEA,~fki ,~ 'S•'IE1'1LI~ "'"" ,.HEA.ElotE MrGIII' l'lo1 St 6.ESP1#1518Ll ? ,, ~OAS£, s11,1.o

6'ofl ,,,, Af '"'i SCE ALSo Id A( $1 l"wE IJf1JSf VHV CAR.EF11L&.'1 ,,u,,r,ry WU"( At,11LESte11fs

M,,Hr &E "fA.e41lh b1FFIIU>1fl'I, A/11/J If f'A1A.1'ES.S RES.u,US IHF'IEl..t.1'(101.. 1'~E11f'ME£/ ~"'- 1'11l CLASS, 11' At.So R..£t1.a114E!. 1'H1r Al)tJJ.11 w,rN rut ~Jttlllt t.E.SP111'S1$11.,fv 4ilMINl~llulG

l.JIIIAAefEll.tJf,~~ 5HoiJL/J AE 1'A.E4f£.b fQv4LLf• " )

IS'f . "rHIS Ar11~1 ASSEAf.5, f"HA( fill Coullf" IIAS 1/JE11(1F1l.b UI.E 'llol( F~t,(()A.S #'at. 9u85£1l11t11'( Co111tT~ fo to/1151ACfl. wHt/14 f ,/ALuli1111t, rAE 8Lt1M£Wt1AfHIHtis o, "I"""' A~11L(~, gEf Pft.b !, t1fA.A NOfl I 8"11 IJ r ]31 ,, ~, 1

11,o. 1'41LLEI.. .1~llfAA, I 3~ S. 't Jlf~'f; (H.AUAM, $flPA.A I.Jo S.~f. Af AtJJ/. ' ldlfl., SvPlA , S,tJ 615 Af 51,7 . 7

' 161. llooKfl. v u .J · 5 '1 J u,S · ~<Po, 833 tDoo 5 ) .

,1,J. U, .S , Sf,ITE11c11i1, ~111/Jeto/ES MAlltJ4L CHAP , S, If , ti, 1/tl(t11b,1e.Fot.., CMf. {311JJ, U((f; //C~o."/ t 1'1 l Nh,J.

1,3. Id. f 5111. I

/1,'f. Afl<..111$ , $11f1.1.-, s,, u.s. ,.,. ~11 <t,r-1,"' ,:,,,., V WM,,lw1t.1,H( J '111 ti~ · 31,, 1,s, ~,,1, .. 11 (1'196>. SEl ALllit>Al f:Rf.Ef>M1011 Nor!1 ME,1f4L 1..t1ARbAf111' IJlil/1 rift /:JfA'fil llJIALf'I: fll{ Aflf./j

::J/tl 1,JffA.lilAfloHAL 5-fA,IJUJLD /)£f1N11l6 Mtllflll ~lf*l.&lifa,,11 1a HW . .J'. ,14{'1 HIIM. A.ts . I, 6'

l<11SIIAw1J ·M1t.f~'!.I. 11837/JII AM, Cl ,,.,, r/JJJ P¥i..

At.GEA Cot.l.i~f10111AL rAC.11,ifY

Nbt'II INJ>11sfR.1u PAR/l DA.111L

1'111#t11.S,~,, ,.,,, "''"'


v.s. Xo-movement

v.s. Xo-movement

wwe v.s tna v.s ecw

wwe v.s tna v.s ecw

'SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT GRZHIVO, V.S. - GRZYBOWSKI, S.'...title "scientific abstract grzhivo, v.s. - grzybowski, s." subject "scientific abstract grzhivo, v.s. - grzybowski, s." keywords

'SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT GRZHIVO, V.S. - GRZYBOWSKI, S.'...title "scientific abstract grzhivo, v.s. - grzybowski, s." subject "scientific abstract grzhivo, v.s. - grzybowski, s." keywords

Citar v.s. plagiar

Citar v.s. plagiar

Structure v.s. Appearance and 3D v.s. 2D? A Numeric Answersczhu/papers/Conf_2012/Representation... · 2013. 3. 5. · Structure v.s. Appearance and 3D v.s. 2D? A Numeric Answer 5

Structure v.s. Appearance and 3D v.s. 2D? A Numeric Answersczhu/papers/Conf_2012/Representation... · 2013. 3. 5. · Structure v.s. Appearance and 3D v.s. 2D? A Numeric Answer 5

Invt v.s spec

Invt v.s spec

SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT GONTKEVICH, V.S. - GOOZ, LAJOS · Title: SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT GONTKEVICH, V.S. - GOOZ, LAJOS : Subject: SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT GONTKEVICH, V.S. - GOOZ, LAJOS : Keywords:

SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT GONTKEVICH, V.S. - GOOZ, LAJOS · Title: SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT GONTKEVICH, V.S. - GOOZ, LAJOS : Subject: SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT GONTKEVICH, V.S. - GOOZ, LAJOS : Keywords:

'SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT GRZEWINSKA, H. - GRZHIVO, V.S.' · Title "SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT GRZEWINSKA, H. - GRZHIVO, V.S." Subject "SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT GRZEWINSKA, H. - GRZHIVO, V.S." Keywords:

'SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT GRZEWINSKA, H. - GRZHIVO, V.S.' · Title "SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT GRZEWINSKA, H. - GRZHIVO, V.S." Subject "SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT GRZEWINSKA, H. - GRZHIVO, V.S." Keywords:

80% v.s. 20%

80% v.s. 20%

SOAP v.s REST ต่างกันอย่างไร

SOAP v.s REST ต่างกันอย่างไร

Contrat de Service FttE passif - gersnumerique.fr

Contrat de Service FttE passif - gersnumerique.fr

The Science Studio With V.S. Ramachandranthesciencenetwork.org/media/videos/36/Transcript.pdf · 2008-08-07 · The Science Studio With V.S. Ramachandran ROGER BINGHAM: V.S. Ramachandran

The Science Studio With V.S. Ramachandranthesciencenetwork.org/media/videos/36/Transcript.pdf · 2008-08-07 · The Science Studio With V.S. Ramachandran ROGER BINGHAM: V.S. Ramachandran

Final Project Results Report · Bojana Mirkovic / FTTE Project Member 02/10/2017 Tatjana Krstic Simic / FTTE Project Member 02/10/2017 Daniel Dominguez / CRIDA Project Member 02/10/2017

Final Project Results Report · Bojana Mirkovic / FTTE Project Member 02/10/2017 Tatjana Krstic Simic / FTTE Project Member 02/10/2017 Daniel Dominguez / CRIDA Project Member 02/10/2017

EC80 Section D Recent teaching in the last five years Section D... · FTTE FTTE FTTE FTTE FTTE FTTE 1(i) Within the last three years I have completed 8A Teacher Education Refresh

EC80 Section D Recent teaching in the last five years Section D... · FTTE FTTE FTTE FTTE FTTE FTTE 1(i) Within the last three years I have completed 8A Teacher Education Refresh

SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT KOYVUNEN, T.M. - KOZACHENKO, V.S. · title: scientific abstract koyvunen, t.m. - kozachenko, v.s. subject: scientific abstract koyvunen, t.m. - kozachenko, v.s.

SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT KOYVUNEN, T.M. - KOZACHENKO, V.S. · title: scientific abstract koyvunen, t.m. - kozachenko, v.s. subject: scientific abstract koyvunen, t.m. - kozachenko, v.s.

SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT MURANOV, A.P. - MURAS, V.S. · Title: SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT MURANOV, A.P. - MURAS, V.S. Subject: SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT MURANOV, A.P. - MURAS, V.S. Keywords: Hydrology

SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT MURANOV, A.P. - MURAS, V.S. · Title: SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT MURANOV, A.P. - MURAS, V.S. Subject: SCIENTIFIC ABSTRACT MURANOV, A.P. - MURAS, V.S. Keywords: Hydrology

UK Uncut V.S. Starbucks

UK Uncut V.S. Starbucks

Peterpan v.s bob esponja

Peterpan v.s bob esponja

By Orion Saah. Plot development: man v.s man and man v.s society 24.

By Orion Saah. Plot development: man v.s man and man v.s society 24.

E/p v.s . time

E/p v.s . time