| Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall...
Transcript of | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall...
![Page 1: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
SEWER SYSTEM IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM | Grey. Green. Clean. DSD Conference: Applying the Triple Bottom Line in San Francisco
November 13th, 2014
![Page 2: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
SEWER SYSTEM IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM | Grey. Green. Clean.
Agenda
• Introduction to San Francisco’s Sewer System
Improvement Program
• San Francisco Triple Bottom Line Model
• Questions / Discussion
![Page 3: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
SEWER SYSTEM IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM | Grey. Green. Clean.
Built on the principles of understanding the entire
costs and benefits of a given investment to provide a
better understanding of how these investments will
change our built, natural, and social environments.
AECOM Sustainable Economics Group
![Page 4: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
SEWER SYSTEM IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM | Grey. Green. Clean.
1,000 miles of Sewers
2 All-Weather Wastewater Treatment Plants
1 Wet-Weather Wastewater Treatment Plant
8 Transport/Storage Structures
19 All Weather Pump Stations
25,000 Catch Basins
36 Combined Sewer Discharge (CSD) Structures
Green Infrastructure
SAN FRANCISCO SEWER SYSTEM
4
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
+
![Page 5: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
SEWER SYSTEM IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM | Grey. Green. Clean.
Sewer System Improvement Program (SSIP)
• $6.8Billion Program
• 15-year Program - 30-year Implementation Schedule
• Includes entire system
• Treatment plants
• Collection system
• MS4 separate areas
![Page 6: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
SEWER SYSTEM IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM | Grey. Green. Clean.
Stakeholder Input
Sewer System
Master
Planning Effort
2005-2010 2009-2010
Sewer System Improvement Program
7 Public Workshops
June 2010
Digester
Task Force
18 months
July 2010
SSIP Levels of Service
Goals Endorsed &
Resolution Adopted
Sewer System
Improvement
Program Report
The Public Mandate
6
![Page 7: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
SEWER SYSTEM IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM | Grey. Green. Clean.
Sewer System Improvement Goals Provide a Compliant, Reliable, Resilient, & Flexible
System that can Respond to Catastrophic Events
Integrate Green & Grey Infrastructure to
Manage Stormwater
Provide Benefits to Impacted Communities
Modify the System to Adapt to Climate Change
Achieve Economic & Environmental Sustainability
Maintain Ratepayer Affordability
LEVELS OF SERVICE
7
![Page 8: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
SEWER SYSTEM IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM | Grey. Green. Clean.
URBAN WATERSHED ASSESSMENT
8
+
+
+
+
Watershed approach
to project planning
Collaboration with
other city agencies
Public engagement
Triple Bottom Line
(TBL) analysis
KEY ELEMENTS
![Page 9: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
SEWER SYSTEM IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM | Grey. Green. Clean.
URBAN WATERSHED ASSESSMENT
9
Projects + Programs + Policies
Green and Grey
Infrastructure
Education, Grants,
and Incentives
Stormwater Design
Guidelines
![Page 10: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
SEWER SYSTEM IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM | Grey. Green. Clean.
GREEN AND GREY TECHNOLOGIES
10
GREEN
Constructed
Wetlands
Creek
Daylighting
Vegetated
Roof
Bioretention
Planter Rainwater
Harvesting
Permeable
Paving
Pump Stations Outfall Retrofit/
Replacement Transport/Storage
Structures
Pipe Upsizing/
Replacement
Tunnels
GREY
![Page 11: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Recap of SSIP Validation
Budget Summary
11
Categories of SSIP
Capital Program Phase 1
($ Millions)
Phase 2
($ Millions)
Phase 3
($ Millions) TOTAL
Treatment Plants $2,233 $1,215 $407 $3,855
Collection System $354 $1,928 $476 $2,758
City and Consultant Program
Management $125 $152 $43 $320
TOTAL SSIP $2,712 $3,295 $926 $6,933
![Page 12: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
PLANNING IMPLEMENTATION
Master
Plan Identifies needs
and potential
projects
Validation Confirms and
refines projects
Fin
al L
ist O
f 8
5 P
roje
ct C
on
ce
pts
Project Concepts
TBL
Design & Construction
Increased Granularity
• Level of Service
• Condition Assessment
• Modeling
• Refined Cost Estimates
![Page 13: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
TBL Primary Objectives
1. To inform and support the analytical process for developing alternatives by considering social and environmental components in the process alongside performance and economic considerations
2. To provide decision-making support for SFPUC project leaders; and
3. To increase project selection transparency and facilitate a reporting-out of expected project benefits.
![Page 14: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
TBL
What is triple bottom line analysis?
![Page 15: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Triple Bottom Line Principles
![Page 16: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
• Pure cash-flow analysis over the project lifetime (Sustainable Return on Investment)
• ?: Is this option commercially viable? Which option has the lowest lifetime cost?
Financial Analysis (SROI)
• Economic valuation which tries to capture quantifiable costs and benefits
• Monetizes criteria; allows for direct comparison of environmental and social to economic criteria
• ?: Do alternative benefits outweigh the costs? How much should I invest to meet consumer demands?
Benefit-Cost Analysis
• Non-financial benefits expressed in units, not monetary terms
• Similar to BCA, but not monetized
• ?: Which option offers the leas cost alternative for reducing X emissions?
Cost Effectiveness
Analysis
• Used to compare costs that can’t be monetized
• Allows for consideration of various stakeholders, government, community
• Limits false precision
• Simpler
Scoring and Ranking
4 Typical TBL Assessment Techniques
![Page 17: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Triple Bottom Line Sample Output
Needs Assessment
Report
Alternatives Analysis
Conceptual Engineering
Report Design Construction
Implementation Plan: Tools for Efficient Delivery
![Page 18: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Triple Bottom Line (TBL) Working Group
San Francisco Public Utilities Commission
Wastewater Enterprise
April 30, 2012
TBL follows a basic set of principles
![Page 19: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
TBL Output Example
Capital Costs
O&M Costs
System Resilience
Ratepayer Affordability
Employment
Bicycle & Pedestrian
Recreation & Open Space
Cultural Resources
Odors
Noise
Land Use Adjacency
Construction Impacts
Worker Safety
Climate
Air Quality
Water Quality Water Use
Habitat
Natural Resources
![Page 20: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
TBL Model Components – Model Results
Ordinal ranking system limits impression of false precision
Have the option to show or hide those criteria not impacted
Size of radial slices can be sized according to community importance
Size of financial slices are proportional to their share of life cycle costs
![Page 21: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
TBL Alternatives Evaluation (Scoring)
![Page 22: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Financial (LCA)
Capital Costs
Operations and Other* Costs
Environmental
Climate
Habitat
Water Use
Water Quality
Air Quality
Natural Resources
Social
System Resilience
Ratepayer Affordability
Employment
Bicycle and Pedestrian
Environment
Recreation / Open Space
Cultural Resources
Odor
Noise
Land Use Adjacency
Construction Impacts
Worker Safety
TBL Evaluation Criteria
* Includes Operations & Maintenance, Replacement & Renewal, Decommissioning, Avoided Costs, and New Revenues
Mostly to address
conditions at
treatment plants
![Page 23: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Environmental + Social + Financial Sustainability
Triple Bottom Line (TBL) Community Benefits Assessment
![Page 24: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
LCA Components
![Page 25: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
TBL Folsom & 17th Street Example
![Page 26: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
17th and Folsom Street Alternative Analysis
Proj. 1
Proj. 2
Proj. 3
Proj. 4
![Page 27: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
17th and Folsom Street Alternative Analysis
![Page 28: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
17th and Folsom Street Alternative Analysis
Reduces flooding in high consequence area
Reduces odor in small area, only during flooding events
< 30% the cost performance of the mean of projects evaluated
Reduction in CSD Volume as a result of storage volume
Major boulevard disrupted during construction but not on arterial
Shortens construction schedule of 2 SF Public Works projects due to coordination
Improves a new park in conjunction with the storage investment but not in an area of acute need
Ratepayer cost >30% of projects evaluated
![Page 29: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Criteria Development
![Page 30: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Example: System Resilience
• Sea level rise
• Flooding
• Redundancy
• Consequence of
Failure
![Page 31: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Governance Committees
31
![Page 32: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
TBL Model Interface
![Page 33: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Model Interface
![Page 34: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
![Page 35: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
TBL Output Example
![Page 37: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
Alternative Triple Bottom Line Approaches
![Page 38: | Grey. Green. Clean. November 13th, 2014A4-3).pdfNov 13, 2014 · Pump Stations TunnelsOutfall Retrofit/ Replacement Structures Transport/Storage Pipe Upsizing/ Replacement ... economic](https://reader034.fdocuments.net/reader034/viewer/2022042307/5ed3f05558cae65ce3405150/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
Alternative Triple Bottom Line Approaches