- D).homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/foundationalism-hab.pdf-0 ~ ~ ~ 2!. Cii" 3 I» ~ a.. - i" 'a UI...

13
... .. ~ ~ _. n 0 ... n D) "0 < "0 n 3 '" > - Q.. n '1» :r eO", ~ ::-. 0 c! ::r 0 ::s - _. ::r ~ ::;. - ~ -. '" ~ n-II:"" -e<;-' 3 n:1 =0 """'" "0 IJ ;:t e := Ef::s ::s ~ C = c o' .. 0 !l.(JQ Ii! g ::r ~ 0 I:L 3 D) -. Q ::r IJ ~::;-~ !. 'l! ~ ~ 5! "'w a.::s a co - ~- n ... ::s t,) ::r" ::r' -. 0 0 0 - R ~. a. e:. g. '" if~ g. 2 g g ~. g g 'go c' 2: s., g- 0' ::r ;;;:~ R :c: ;:t g.~" ::r::S .. (JQ.o 3 !i ~ ~ n ~ cjQ' ~ e e 3 _. 0 '- 0 0 ~ D) - D). ~ "< ::r e "0 0 -." ::.: ~ .. QQ = et o<! ...:: n IJ --. Q.. n n ""... QQ ::r Q.. '" ""'" e/;;' <..."'00...0'1;; >6.~t)- o .e...t,)n...(JQ 3 :i! ... ~ ~ ... 3 ""'::S -. ~ .. ~ = c.. 3' ...'" :;:::r n 0 n 3 ~ a ~. 3 ~. g a o ' g; ~ = n o 5! !! en o' n ~ .. -. ... 1'6 '" '" n "'... = - B ::s .. a..... !. ;;- ~ ~. g :I g:'~ !i 0 ::s ~ 0 -. g -< D Ii! !. ~ ~ ~ D) ~ ~.:t. '" ::I ... ~ a -::r a o ' G! ::I =: ... ::I a. . (ij' n a- .. '~""'e~ n ne"""' :r 0~ 3 o<!on (JQ a 3' 0 ~ QQ "'w e "' ~ e ~ ::Sw~' e a-.. :r::l n ~ e .. 3 e -..,...QQ",::I- '" ~ <nee ~ w .. ~ ~ 'i' '" !! "0 ~~ ;' g; (ij' ~ g ~!i e Ii" ~ ;-~ ~ ~ ~ ::I !l. ~ 5"" [n 3 ~ D g.. ~ 0' g C§- :I. D) ::r:! if ~ !l. ... "< -. ::r 0 > n ::r a. D) =.. e-. .. < '" n D) ... :r ~ ~_.~",D) ~ -~ o "" o """nnn "D)-'-' 3 ('\ ... "0""" "0 n::r Q..'" 0 =-- - n 3 0 ~ II: ::r"O n Ii! ::1 :c e .. 0 n !.. 0 a-::I n In ? '8 ~ o ' s.(ij' ::r';fa. ~ '...~~ ~ e -"'0 > -;;'(JQ '" "0 ::. '" n -. 0 0 (5 D) :i! e .. QQ '" 0. ... ... .. 0 n ::s ~ 0 D Q ::I ~ =- ~ '" :r!" ~ D) !!..g !if ::r 0 ~ '" D) ::s - _. ","'" 3 n '" _. A ::I n ... n 0"'... ::r ='Q.nD)a.n~ oD)~"'~~"""' 3 ° -t1I-~~ 0 ... /;;.n .. f;! ~ -:1 '" ::I ~::r'D ~... = D) 3 .. 5: 0 ('\ -g ~ ~ :r. ~ c -. 0 "0 (ij' a. - g.. ~ -6'" n - ~ n ... ... o. a- -'::1 '" n ~ _.::r :: Q.. ::rII: 0 - -. = ~ D) ~ "'! -.!2 e-. '" 3 !l.::;'::s ::r~. ~n...::In aD)'" '::r."""",~",wnQQn... """"O::lD) ..nnQ.. :;J a-on:r "'An ::r g'~" a 3 D)~~g ~ -~ g n 31;; 0 S'~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ = ::I 0' ~ ::r!i ::I = ~ ~ :i! JJ 3 ~ ~.QQ .. ~ (ij.~;:t a nS..::rn~D)::I~::IlJe~ q-nl ... ~ !1 n' 0' -. 3 ~ §- g ~ ~ g ~ IJ ::r g.. !r- ~ R 0 ~:c~!.§ao:CIJ:: 3 eat::l::l~~n"Oeig n ~:t e-. ~ D) ::I ~ n ~.. 0 Q..;::r~ ~ ::s "< 3 :r ~ ",' e- IJ ~ :r 0 ~ a e n e.. g.'" 8 IJ a: ~ =:-6'" D) 3 8 g'!i ~. 3 ;:; ::r' ; D "< ~ 5 ~ e 0 ~ ii' !l. !2~oe::sQ..Q..D)~!! n::l~ ~~0Q..- ... ",;:t.. ~ e '" < """ 3 n... o<! ... 0 ... w~ '" - =. D) w" -. n 0"'", =- ... 0 0 < 0 ... =- ",~n, ""'<'" ..n-..",n , .. II fgo -~ h ~ . It f~ i~ ~ 8 . C- o en CD 'C ~ J: CD Q) ... ~ ~Z-"-I ::TO)O::T - . C'" c: (1) (") :] en (1). a. "C "0)" 3 r+ 0 0) -. C'" eno- ..:] (1) en ~ 3 a. -. _.en 0 ~3-" 0 -. c: :] ., en (1)

Transcript of - D).homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/foundationalism-hab.pdf-0 ~ ~ ~ 2!. Cii" 3 I» ~ a.. - i" 'a UI...

Page 1: - D).homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/foundationalism-hab.pdf-0 ~ ~ ~ 2!. Cii" 3 I» ~ a.. - i" 'a UI ~:T 0 0- {Q (ii" - (=)" - 2!. ii' ~ ~ ;i...n 0 8-::I D~... n 0.... n ~ ~'i '< ~

... .

. ~

~

_.

n

0 ...

n

D) "

0 <

"0

n

3'"

>-

Q..

n '1

»:r

eO

",

~

::-.

0 c!

::r

0

::s

- _.

::r

~

::;

. -

~

-.

'" ~

n-II:

""

-e<

;-'

3n:

1 =

0 ""

"'""0

IJ

;:t

e

:=

Ef::

s ::s

~

C

=

c

o'

.. 0

!l.(J

Q

Ii!

g ::r

~

0 I:L

3

D)

-.

Q

::r

IJ

~::;

-~

!. 'l!

~

~

5!

"'w

a.

::s

aco

- ~

- n

... :

:s t,

) ::r

" ::r

' -. 0

0 0

- R ~

.a.

e:.

g. '"

if~

g. 2

g

g ~

. g

g 'g

o c'

2:

s.,

g- 0

' ::r

;;;:

~R

:c:

;:t

g.~

" ::r

::S .

. (J

Q.o

3

!i ~

~

n

~ c

jQ' ~

e e

3_.0

'-0

0~

D

) - D).

~

"<

::r e

"0

0 -.

" ::.

: ~

.. Q

Q =

et

o<!

...::

n IJ

--

. Q..

n n

""...

Q

Q

::r

Q..

'" ""

'"

e/;;'

<

..."'0

0...0

'1;;

>6.

~t)

-o

.e...

t,)n.

..(JQ

3 :i!

...

~

~

...

3

""'::

S

-.

~

.. ~

=

c.

. 3'

...

'" :;:

::r

n

0 n

3 ~

a ~

.3

~.

g ao

' g;

~ =

no

5!

!! en

o'

n ~

.. -.

...

1'

6 '"

'" n

"'...

=

-B

::s .

. a.

....

!. ;;-

~ ~

. g

:I g:

' ~ !

i 0

::s ~

0

-. g

-< D

Ii!

!. ~

~

~

D)

~

~.:t

. '"

::I

...

~

a -:

:r

ao'

G!

::I

=: .

.. ::I

a.

.

(ij'

n a-

.. '~

""'e

~

n ne

"""'

:r0~

3o<

!on

(JQ

a3'

0

~ QQ

"'w

e

"' ~

e

~

::Sw

~' e

a-..

:r::l

n

~ e

.. 3

e -.

.,...Q

Q",

::I-

'" ~

<

nee

~

w

..~

~ 'i'

'"

!! "0

~

~ ;'

g; (ij'

~ g

~!i

e Ii"

~ ;-

~ ~

~ ~

::I

!l.

~

5""

[n

3 ~

D

g.. ~

0'

g

C§-

:I.

D)

::r:!

if ~

!l.

...

"<

-.

::r

0>

n ::r

a.

D

) =

.. e-

. ..

<

'" n

D)

...

:r

~

~_.

~",

D)

~-~

o""

o""

"nnn

"D

)-'-'

3('\

...

"0

"""

"0

n::r

Q

..'"

0 =

--

- n

30

~

II: :

:r"O

n

Ii!

::1 :c

e ..

0 n

!..

0 a-

::I

n In

? '8

~o

' s.

(ij'

::r';f

a.

~

'...~

~

~

e -"

'0

>

-;;'(

JQ

'" "0

::.

'" n

-.

0 0

(5

D)

:i!

e ..

QQ

'"

0.

...

...

.. 0

n ::s

~

0

D

Q

::I

~

=-

~

'" :r

!"

~

D)

!!..g

!if

::r

0

~

'"D

) ::s

-

_.

","'"

3n

'" _.

A

::I

n

...

n 0"

'...

::r=

'Q.n

D)a

.n~

oD

)~"'~

~""

"'3

° -t

1I-~

~0

...

/;;.n

..

f;!

~

-:1

'" ::I

~

::r'D

~

...

=

D)

3 ..

5:

0 ('\

-g

~~

:r

. ~

c

-.

0 "0

(ij

' a.

-

g..

~

-6'"

n -

~

n...

...

o.

a-

-'::

1 '"

n ~

_.

::r

::Q

.. ::r I

I: 0

- -.

= ~

D

) ~

"'!

-.

!2

e-.

'" 3

!l.::;

'::s

::r~

.~

n...:

:In

aD)'"

'::

r.""

"",~

",w

nQQ

n...

""""

O::l

D)

..nnQ

..:;J

a-on

:r

"'An

::rg'

~"

a 3

D)~

~g

~ -~

g

n 31

;; 0

S'~

~~

~ ~

~ =

::I 0'

~ :

:r!i

::I =

~

~ :i!

JJ

3 ~

~.Q

Q

.. ~

(ij.~

;:ta

nS..:

:rn~

D):

:I~::I

lJe~

q-

nl...

~

!1

n'

0'

-.

3 ~

§-

g ~

~

g ~

IJ

::r g

.. !r

- ~

R

0

~:c

~!.§

ao:C

IJ::

3eat::

l::l~

~n"

Oei

gn

~:t

e-.

~

D) :

:I ~

n

~..

0 Q

..;::r

~

~

::s "<

3 :r

~

",'

e- I

J ~

:r

0 ~

a

e n

e..

g.'"

8 IJ

a:

~

=:-

6'"

D) 3

8 g'

!i ~

. 3 ;:

; ::r

' ;

D "<

~ 5

~ e

0 ~

ii'

!l.!2

~oe

::sQ

..Q..D

)~!!

n::l~

~

~0Q

..-...

",

;:t..

~

e '"

<

"""

3n.

.. o<

! ...

0...

w~

'"

- =

. D

) w

" -.

n

0"'",

=

- ...

0

0 <

0...

=-

",~

n,

""'<

'" ..n

-.."

,n

, ..

II fgo

-~ h ~ . It f~ i~

~ 8 .

C- o en CD

'C ~ J: CD

Q)

... ~

~Z

-"-I

::TO

)O::T

- .

C'"

c:

(1)

(")

:]en

(1

).

a.

"C"0

)"3

r+

00)

-.

C

'"

eno-

..:]

(1)

en ~

3

a.

-.

_.en

0

~3-

"0

-.c:

:]

., en (1)

Page 2: - D).homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/foundationalism-hab.pdf-0 ~ ~ ~ 2!. Cii" 3 I» ~ a.. - i" 'a UI ~:T 0 0- {Q (ii" - (=)" - 2!. ii' ~ ~ ;i...n 0 8-::I D~... n 0.... n ~ ~'i '< ~

0..

0..

~

I\)

'" '"

n "

"'0!f.

1 ~

0-

"0

0

:r I\

) ~

"0

... :r

...:r"

., c:

:~

C

;;' ~

a :ii'

a: Q

) ~

;I -.

";

~

<

'" .,

:r

I\)

I\)

~ .!

!. ::s

r;- a

. _.

...' ~

0

§'.,

... 3

- St-

C ~

::s

0 ~

3 g

...

... ~

a ::

-.ri

~ n

s.. :

t ~ '"

~

~:r

::S :

r 5:

n'""

, <""

:r

0

St-

~ ~

...

~::s

c::s

"'~:1

"'!!!,

"'

onl\)

""...

~!f.

103"

"O~

:r

3...

c;;'

...

'< Q

Q' 0

0 "0

" '"

1\)'

":-;

1 -"

":

r "

~

:r

S 0

0'

'='"

<

::s ~

"0 a

:r::s

,

g -I

<

~

::s

1i"

~

C;;'

0-

I\)1\

)"

~":

: I\)

!"

~

...

II)

'<

:r

OQ

:r

<

: '<

I\)

'"

., "0

II)

::s

'<

0..

'" I\)

...

.,.

::-

. -

0 II)

~

ri

-."

":r~

n

Q

~

0 !!!

. '<

'" "0

"

...

:r

'" o.

::s

::!

0-'"

0..

=

""",

'<

~

I\)

_.

<:i

'" n

nn

..,

3 0.

" '"

::t."

= -

~

'" ~

<

s:;

-."

::s "0

-.

_. _

. .,

1\)1

\)11

) -"

""«1

\)":

Z::3

-'-'1

\)",

'" ...

::str

.=-.

= <

!9 =

rs

S ~

..

~ t

r.";

;. I\)

0 ~

'f

C o

' C

;;' §

5 ~

. 9- g

a ~

.ii"

:3

tr.

3 "

II)

:: '<

<

_.

0-

'" ::;

, 6

~

::s

-.

0..

...

~

::;.

'"I\)

II)

en

" =

Ii:

: ",

" '"

n ~

s:;~

-'0

3"

o-

n~nc

;;'o'

o0.

. ~. =

go ~

II)

:;. ~ n

g

3 ~

~:r

g ~

"O

;;! "

0 ;-

rs =

...

.0

~'<

5'

~

~..,

..."

0 -I

\)

1\)"

"'~

::s

0 ~

'"

3...

30-

"0-

OQ

" _.

0

n =

'<

'"

n en

~

~

=

""

0 -

"0I\)

'<

'"

"o...

:r

~

0-

II)

" n

0..

-'",

I\)

0.."

0 0

~

" :r

'"

::s~

..a5'

><

=I\)

I\»<

"c;'

::!.c

;;'a"

O::S

...I\)

= ,~

5'::;

'~

0

II) .

.. ~

ri "

0 ~

!it

C c

~

tr.

0

ri ~

... :r

; g

II) ;-

0.. ~

rO

Q .

.. ...

:r

" ~

c"

-.

::s tr

. <

"

... .

.. '<

...

...

C;;'

c -.

I\)

n

'" "

0 :r

_.

'"

'" 0

n 0.

. <

<: "

0"

~ -

C:r

...3

::s~

"':

:;"O

"::S

"'"

::str

.;'":

roo.

oo

"",

~

" 0

2.."

0

I\)

_. :

r 0

0 O

':r'<

-':

:;-

~...

~ 0-

0

g ~

~ S

:. 0.

. !!!.

c; ~

S! ~

::s

OQ

0 _.

a 0

~ 0

'"

~ Q

."'n

"flS

'otr

.c:r

c-.

1I)-

.c::!

.!it0

3""

"c

II)~

~"

~ ::

. '"

0 ~

n'

~

:::-

::s '"

" N

"0""

3

~~

0 -

rin:r

<O

~::S

~

:rn:

r 1\

)"'

:r~

g~II)

"""1

\)

::s~

~",

:r

" ...

0

'" iii

" "

~

-.

'" '"

:r

c '"

-I

_. _

.'"

I\)

0 ~

0.

.0

:r"

"0 ~

::s

0.

-. ~

...

...

0 0

" '"

o..:r

'f

g5'

=""

""-.

"1I)

~""

'" o"

:r":

:!Q.

"~."

6nO

Qg

~::S

::S=

~I\)

I\)~

=

0'S

t-~

=1\

)~0.

."3c

"I\)

~

go

;.~

0

" "

~::;

::!.

~.,

0 -.

~

.;-

~

0

~

0 O

Q ~

5' ~

. ~

;- i

3 ~

. ~ 9

g 'g

. =

= ~

11: a R ;

;

9- ~

~ ~

. s::

~

St-

!l.

&

. ~

~ ~

~

. 5:

g'

~

~

s. ~

g-

~

~.~

. 5

$ ~

~ r

0.."

I\)

5'"

" -'.

.. "

:r::s

"

"..."

'::t"

' .,

0.."

3

§'i

§' i

i ~

2.

;-:r

3

~

~

0 3

~

~

~

g S

' a ~

a.

~

~"

" '"

...

~::s

...

~

~ 0

- <

'"

C;;'

0 0-

:: -<

N

' 3 - ~

0..

S! 9

- C ~

" ~

. ~ o

.::s

~ ~

:;.

ii"

0- ::

!. 0

-. ~

" ~

. 5"

0

o' I

I)

::s 0

c

~...

c

C;;'

5'::

S

C

;; ~

11: ~

...

S!

'<

'" ::s

" S

' ~=

~

:l.

"O

I\):g

S

'OQ

"2

~.

~

5':!

0 6"

~

0"

8.

~. F

...

::s

0::s- .

"0'"

Ii-=11)

o..

::s 0

n

2'0.

._.

< "

-. OQ

0.."

C

"'"II)

.,~

I\)

=

O

Q

2".

0.

, ...

~.,

.,"'-"

'."'..

.

a ~ a

~ 8 ~

. 'g

~. a

~. ~

Er

~ ~

~ e

-. ~ e

-. ~ ;

.;'

0"

3 3

&. 3

~

8 Q

:i" ~

r: '

g :i"

;-:

8 s-

a::

3 ~

.;. ~

~;;

~ ;;

~ g

' ~~

. g

~ ~

g ~ ~

~ ~

~~. ~

~

, ~ ~.

S.a

~ ~

f t ~

t a:

51 ;;

~ 3

~ ~

e;

...

A

II)

"0

n '<

=

=

(;

" II)

_.

;J

...

-.

an...

A

'"

A

~

-::r

A

'"

~

...

A

::t.

R

-<

...

3 0

~

~

~

3 ;J

II)

0

~2

=

=

:-.

~"O

~

.I}

..,

- 0

g ;n

';'ci

6 ..,

;-

'"

;; ~

::J")

~

CJQ

A

-<

...

~

~

~

c '"

0 I)

=

..,

3.

§ A

~

~ .

0 Q

.. n -

'" A

II)

0

_.;;;

r = C

II)

:r

0

_. ..

. -

Q..

...

- ,

_.?-

:3 ~

. a: a

. ~.;;

...0s-

g ;.;

. 0'

~ 8

N'

;;3<

~ ~

:i"

s.. ~

g.

~ ~

:i : ;

; a.

;-;':

3.'

g 0

~ =

~ ~

g g

6"

:; =

'<

...",

<

... A

II) ..,

II)

O

' ...

OQ

"0

II)

tI

-.'

<a~OQ

-

n A

0

a '"

~

. Q..

::c ~ Q

=

II) '"

::s ...

II)!

! ...

3 ~

.A

a.

A

~ =

=-3

~ A

II)

C

~

5"'0

=

~

A

::r

=

;. 0

=

~

<'

0 A

;;

'"-.

II)

~

0

.., =

-.. q!

j _.

><

0 =

_.

,. ~

aII)

0

0 0

:r II

) ...

~

A =

'" - A

= ><

'" -

'" ;;

:3. a

~ C

e.. g

. 0.: !i

t II)

=

=-;';

n'

= ...

e-. 0

"0

0 ::c

~ ..

."'"

Q. ;

;,. ~

...,

A

'" 5'

; ;;;

r <

~

A

~

II)

"0

"0

'" ~

~ ;.

~"~

~ ~~

:;~

~~

fi'~

'~'s

-~.:~

~ § r~

: ~~

~g'

~o

s.[o

g.;.e

~.~

~~

g"~

j,~ ~

33;n

'a=

30:r

OA

::t'"

O"'~

<:r

"'!

it3"'~

:-.

a';J

° 11

)"'0

A

!;ill)

~~

=«"

""51

~ fi-

~. R

' ~~

~ ;n

' : ~

[~~

~ ~

~.~

~]:

~ S-

:~ ~ !-

g;n

' e.

R ~

]: ~

. ~ S

- ~ ~

~ ~

!. §.

~ ~

-2~

0

~ :

r ~

-,

="0

""

" 3

~

... '"

~

I}

A

~

C

~ 0

n

~

A

I}

A'

~ 0

::;

';'"

_. O

' g.. :r

~

_.

;- 2

~3

,~=

II)~

C::r

OA

"""

~

'<

3::to

!l.

1I)Q

..="'=

""""

"A:r

3;s

A""

" ...

~

... :

r ~

= 8

Q. '"

;. r:

..,

"'~

0 S

- ~ . ;. A

Q

.. 2

0 ~

C!!.

S

gO

;' a.

0 ..,

~ A

Y

' tI

~ 3

-,

~ s

,::r-

::rg.

;- ~

;;

~ ~

g ~

...0

~

3 "0

S

; ~

II)

~. A

].

0 ~

~ ..

. 3<

§. 3

S 9

::3

Air"

""

~ 0

~ Q

..;:;-

~

i! !

l. n

s.. ~

:r,<

-"",

0

~

:;~

'" =

A

"'1

-'-""

C

A

~ ~

f ] ~

~ ~

~. ~

~ ~

! ; ~

~ ~ t 1

.1.

~.~

. g

~~

~

~ ~

~'~

~! ~

;- ~

~~ §

~. ~

2: ~

. ~ ~

~

~ ~

~ ;;

:'~. g

a ~ ~

~ ~

~f ~

. g. ~

~o:

i ~

6' ~

~ ~

~

~ §

~ JJ

' ~ ~

a ~~

, ~ ~

~ ~

~ i.

~ ~

. 8:

~ ~

~ ~

'::::r

Q !'

6: J! ~

R a- ~

;; s

~ ~

. 5' ~

; g:

~~

a ~

~

2 a

:~ 3

0 3~

n ~

[§'

~

~ ~

~ ~

g ~

",""

i ""

"!1I

}",

~_.

A""

"=a-

'A-'~

"'~'"

oa,

><

C

-<A

::r""

'~=

:::r"

'~

I}~

!:i

a: ~

~ ~

. 0

5' ~

.

'" ;G

3-.::t.

o'

= Q.

.!2

:;.

5'

11):

:;-

0 n~

s.

. "0

~

~,3

!!.

. Y'

A :.

a. n

Q.;n

' ~

r:

'"=

- A

n

A

~.

, C

n

A

, 3

11).

=

'" .."

'"

n Q

"'"

~

A

"'::r

A

::r

'" II)

O

Q

0A

'~

II)

1I) 3

~._

."'A

=:,~

_,'"

"00

2".8

:;,C

JQ-"

,,03

O::r

I}~

...A

O<

"'AA

I

n::;-

=C

=Q

.. _.

-

Q..

=

=

:3.

n <

'"

3- =

0 '"

..

OQ

s:

; ~

A

~

'"

::r'"

1I):

r 3

II) - I

I)

R -

C

~ g

:a' ~

OQ ~

~. ~

I} g

~ 0

'<

... :r

""":

:t §

~ ~

;; ~

C

...:r' ;.

~

Q..

C3~

~

;. c

~

;- ~

~~

!! 3' 3

. ~

. ~"0

Q

.. -

5'

-.

~

II)

:r...

" Q

.. ..,

..,

=

II)

-

cr'<

=

A

~

.

A

II)

_.

II)

A

<..,

0 A

'<0

011

3 ::r

~

0;'

n :;.

A

Qq'

~

II) =

1i

-;; ~

A

"0

Q..

oc'"

~ c

r A

;n

' g:

, n

a. =

~ cr

::r

'" ~

I}

II)

=:3

C

AII)

AII)

A

A..

:r

"'",..

""..,

n"'A

O

nCII)

-Coo

"",,"

"<A

...O

=

=:..

;;' i

§: ;-

: ~ 3 ~

~ g.

~ ]

~ 2

~ ~

;. ~

~ ~

~ a

W

2. r

s']

JJ' :

3 : ~

g ~

;- ~

~ ~

~~

~ 3

~ g

- f! f ~

~ ~

~ s

iiJ'

~ ~ ~ ~

. ~ q!j

~ ~

~ g.

JJ' ~

a ~

3.~

';-

~ s

.. 8

~ ~

~ ~

='

~ ~

o. ...

~ i

~ n

;'

n ~

cr

a

fl -<

;-

;-

Q.. g.

...:r~

~ =

~ 01

1 - ~

r 5' g

..g- ~

' ~::;

' ~

~ s

~3..,

11);-

... ~

0 =

'"

A

a II)

~

0

~

A

"0

Q..

_. -.

=

::

3 A

'"

-. II)

II)

n '<

...

- ~

~

...

",

=-.

C I

} ...

A =

" 3

.., 3

0 =

~ _.

;. 3

3 g.

. ~

=' I

I)

0 _.

;. 51

R

~ =

= =

;. 0

:r c

r A

~ !

;i <

- II)

1J 3

'" en

0

= C

JQ

A

A

0 ...

0

T

=

A

en '

" A

I

A

OQ

'"

~

A

0 en

C\ O

Q ..

, '<

A

n

II) .

.. M

' n

=

It)..

4

~ =

. 0' g

o '"

3 :1

. "0

2 ~

5'

V)

~ ~

0 n

c n

~ ~

oq

:1

. -

0 ...

~ (J

q 0

:::

~ =

- c.

5' E

f ~. n

E

. ~ C

. C

E.

'<

.. 0.

~

~ S

=,.

en' Q

.. 3

::1'1

3 0.

3:

~

g.. ~

n

:-. -.

!) QQ

- 0

n

n '<

r::r

,< _.

- ~

= '"

n 3

~ Q

.. ~

~

:-.

'"

0 °o

o."'n

Q..o

n~-~

,,"'"

C 0

=

... -

-~

~

n ~

...

~

~

'" :r

~.

'tr -

. 0.

.. o'

...

...~

~

en' ~

g. ~

3 0

.: "' c

~ g

o = 0

rJ&

s:oa

3 g

.. Q..'

" !II

qg ~

i;!

en

' ~ ~

r:

:r'<

oq

C

-. -,

:r;i

3 0.

88

- c: n

0.....

-3c

..."'n

n

nn""

~."

"..

= ~

n '"

= r

::r '"

.."

-.;;t

. ..~

go

g n

en' 1

1 '<

::

0 s:

n =

~=

'...

nO..

"0 - .

... :r

<

!5! i;!

r::r

0."'~

"="':

1"""

""~

..

'«C

. ~. 3

;:;-

!} <

' =

0

~

... :

"O

:r

~'2

.. ~ 5

' 0.'

? g

'" g-

;':-.

:1.

5' ~

nn

n _.

- o.

n:

1 n

0. =

n Q

Q _

.'"

n '"

'" =

~ 5

'~

d -,

-'n

'" C

=

. ;

"0 0~

0. -.

n ~

::!

~ -

e' ~

5'

~-.

0

'" ~

-

~

3 ;-

~.

~ c

' 1'

.: ",

' C

::;

" n

<

(Jq =

..Y

' _.

~

o.-~

!!!

.O~

n"""

-,

0 ...

oq"

" 0.

03

:::

.. :r

n

~

3 =

.:r

3 0"

" !)

=

n!

!!.

~

;-&

. "0 - n

n

C

;-:;.

0

!!!. 3

g _.

Co

==

n"

"="O

::c

3go

;;; =

g 11

Q..Q

Q~

... ;

g R

11 0

~

-.

C

n R

= n

~ .

. 0

n :1

~

::'"

...

~

Q..

~

o' 0

<

to :r...

0

... .

. 0

nooq

~=

=cn

~"<

:r

33

:-.

~~

, _.

~

=

"0

"0

...

:-

. n

~3

Q 5

' g

= :

-. ~

~ ..

0

R =

"'~ ~

=. n - ~

f"

t ~

. ~

~..

= ~

'":r

..~'-c

;~

"'f"t

~

...

""

en'

3'"

0n

noq

n c;

""

~

...

n l

J _.

3:r

.. n

...!}

03

=

"0

3~~

'<"

...

~

i;! '"

~

R "0

S ~

n if-

"O g

;- ~

!a

' g-

.. ::c

a ~

~: ~

==

g. :

1. =

..n~

n~r:

:r

=

n =

0.=

C

=

'"

~.

r::r

=

- a.

Zqg

. ::t

' Q

. ~

n n.

.. '"

n ..

~

n ~

. ..

"0

....

nC...

~

C

n

.. 3

'" ~

~3

=-0

0...

="0

0.

3 ~

'"

=~

...~

~

n

S...

n

~.

~

_.

~

~.

0 n

Q

0 .

00.,

...=

",n

n-n.

....-

- ::z:

Q)

f:T'

CD

., 3 Q)

(II

0 ~ :f CD

~ I» C ....

!!!.

Cir

- 5. ~ Dr

(') '<

Page 3: - D).homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/foundationalism-hab.pdf-0 ~ ~ ~ 2!. Cii" 3 I» ~ a.. - i" 'a UI ~:T 0 0- {Q (ii" - (=)" - 2!. ii' ~ ~ ;i...n 0 8-::I D~... n 0.... n ~ ~'i '< ~

- () 0 ~ ~ ~ 2!.

Cii"

3 I» ~ a..

- i" 'a UI

~ :T 0 0- {Q (ii"

- (=)"

- 2!.

ii' ~

~

;i...

n0

8-:

:I D~

...

...n

0 ....

<

~n

~

~'i '<

~

n..,

~n

0@

-o!!.

. ~-

'<

'" a-0

n::I

ii)'

n - ;-

s.,~

go u

rn

s-

R'8

!;S ii1 :

:I-.

..

~:r ..,

n0

~a-

c-'" n

n3

--'"

... ~

~

§=::;

-~:r

",

"O"O

"'::r

""'O

~=

"">

,"""

"'(

');;;"

"~(')

:3C

"(').

..,<

o...,

CIQ

::I'"

'" ::r

n

~

..!!.

::r

<

- C

::r

Q

Q'

::r

0 ::r

;S

. no

n 0

::r -

'",

::r'"

n ::r

"<

::!..:

3 n

:: 0

" ~

0

n::r

~

C

...

;;;

':::':

:l3

Q

::I

n A

'"'

_.

~

n

n0-

'0.

-'--o

::I

::r

-~

-(')

_.0-

",-0

..",

9- '"

~

~

a. i

e-.

0 :;r

'" ..,

:3

...

"0

...

-.

g ~

-.

C

-"

0 3

C"

_.

...

'" "0

Z

00

-'::Io

::lc_

.ncn

3...

n"""

::I::I

..."'c

...~

,,<

"'~~

no§"

O

~

::I C

IQ "0

C

IQ S

- f!!.

"'~ ;.

~ -

. 0 1.

::r

3 0

0 ::r

n

f!!.

n 0

~

0 ;:r

::l

~

~\G

::r

_.

~

('):

:r

. 0.

.. I

-. CIQ

2"

.:3

~

...

C

~

g"

0 ::I

'" ~

n

0..

iI':'"

-

",'

~ CI

Q - 0

n'

;' ~

:3

n ::I

::I

;r C

" ...s

C" g-

3 ... 8

~?

f;;'

~

3 _0

' f!!

. 0.

. ~

::I

'

a."'n

<"'

3~

n""'0

3"'CIQ

'n-

::;.

.::;'-

",

n-",

_nC

"C

::In

3n

(')~

:3~

-"

,~~

::r

...:t:

"'a.

o.c

3(J

Qc:

:I "<

::!f;;

Rf!!

. ~

n o.

..n

...

...nn

(')<

O"'(

') -"

'0

"'1\)

--

."'~

(')~

n

::1. ~

-

n -

rt

.::1:

33

~

n --

_.

::r

~

a.

"O

~

~

:3

~

"<

::1.

~

"<

::r=

-.!"

R03

~

3:3!

!(')

Coo

:3

~.

3..."

,iI':'

"rtr

t"'~

~

C"O

~::I

n

CIQ

"0

~

;. '"

~

11>

n

'" f!!

. (')

3

~

'">

~

n n

n3

...

0 0

n --

.Q

(')

0"0;

<

...

0 -.

~

c -

0 :3

~

-.

= n.

.. ...

'"

~::I

n

~

a rt

...

~ ~

~ g.<>

ao~.

&

r ~

a:

~

ii ~

~

~

~.

5. g

- ~

~

~

a.

~

~ ~

[if

-3~'

~ ~

~

3,,-

'- -

--.n

-'~..-

""

"3

(')--

~

~

tII-

- 0

"""

0 ::I

-;

. -.

'"

...

9-

<:

=.C

IQ

...

n _.

n

'"'

n "r

t n

~

~...

..

~.

8 §.

. g-

e;

!"

c.

n ;;

;. ~

-;

-:.

'2

g-

~ ~

a

a ~ 3

~ ~

~

<§.

~

~

~ ~f

S-

" ~

::I

>n

n ,.

~

...

'" _.

rt

'"

_.

a.

.. C

IQ

" n

'" (:

) ~

'"

CIQ

<

'"

0..

- --

n

<:

'" :3

"0

C

-:

3 -.

-

!if

_.

- C

'"

n u.

'"

~

3 C

~

...

0

-.;;;

. E

!..

- ::

C

~ _

. 3

a.:;:

'" :3

:t:

f:

n ;.C

IQ

3 a.

3 :3

...

~ 3

:3 ;.

if Q

: ~ g

. ~ j;

) 0'

~~

g ;

~ g

~ 0

' ~ ;

. n :

:;:: N

' ;.

g =

;;;.~

if::I

::;

. ~

--

0 5'

2.

. ~

::r

.Q

...

!..

3:.C

IQ

0 ~

~

5'

:. 0.

~

~

f!!

. 5'

:::

...

~

~

::r

f!!.

CIQ

...

~

'"

CIQ

<

_.

0

; ~

-

C""

-C

lQ::I

'"

'" C

IQ

3 (J

Q

_.

-:3

- ~

:3

g.

;. ;.

0 ~

...

~

g

:t:'

2".;'

0

~;.

~

;;;.

~

~

C

C 3"0

8

~

;;;.

g E

. a

R:3

n

_.~

::r

if 0

::;'

(')

n!;;

0 n

!e

~

~

:3::g

rt

-<

-'"

3

...

~

0 ::1

.C

IQ :

3 '"

~

2..

~

~

<

::r

"0.

...

:3

--,.;

.; ...

n

0.

c:-.

:3

n-

8 ~

C

IQ f

i 3

~

8 a

~

5'

0 ;

f!!.

3 ~

8

-~ 0

gq,

S2.

.::;'

g ",

n 5'

~

!if

go

a.

:t:

~

~

0.."

0 (')

R

~

5' 0

l

~

g. S

'3!..

6.

;-

9-

~

; 9"

~.~

~

~

!i ;.

go

~

~

7'~

8

~ S

' e! 3-:

...

~

a:

e;

(')'!.

.CIQ

'"

~

S2.

. a.

::r

;S

. ~

~

...

~

n ~

:3

g-

(;1

.. ~

;.

5'

'"

? a.

g iI'

:'"&

r;;;'

~

f!!.s

g-

C

"~~

"'~

~~

~

~

ji!JJ

"'O

~~

~

9-rt

fi

~ 3

(')

::r - a

. ~

C

IQ

C"

n ""

. C

~

0

C

--

::rO

O

~:3

_.

0.

...

"<

~

&r

<

a.

j;)

n 0

:3

n S

rt

~

;;;.

_0'

'" --

'"

~

0 g

~

-.

_. '"

Q:

~

~

"<

=

n 3

.Q

--

S;;;

1 iI'

:'":3

n'

::r

Son

~

...

n

...

3 2.

n

C":

:;'!if

;-

:r~

~

"'~

'"

~

~

~

2".

g ~

&

r;'

~.

fi ~

~

'"

;. ~

'E

.~~

g.

, a.

8.

. ;"

~

~

'" ~

'g

o g

.Q

~

F

~.

~

'g

;::'

~

~

; ~

~

~

;-

~

...

'g

5-

~

8 S

5'

C

'

~ 3

~ g

- 5'

e-. C

" a'

~

.g

.Q~ ~

. ~

a g

- C3'" n 3-~

0~

r ~

if

g 5'

-g

~

~

~

g.

_.

rt

< --

n

n ...

- ,.

.. '"

C

oo -

rt...

:3 -.

. ... -

n- !(

~

0 0

n- Q

=

3;r

--

~

:::

t 0

...

rt

n ::r

n

",n

~

o. ca

;;;.

51

=

=-

n-

~

_.

-'.

...

..."

... r

t ~

::r

<

n C

:3

n g.

0 ~

~o §

r-t

;. a

C"C

IQ

::;.

~

~

0..

if o'

--

:3

n

if3~

~~

~:t:

Q~

-3

I"-

~_.

::;':,

_.~

,,,no

.:3~

a'Q

Q~

~

""

" ",

-",-

.o..~

.n(')

.

'0

::s '0

::s

~

Co

n ~

-,

~ j..

o ~

j

-, ::s

0 ~

0

~

~

0 ~

::s

~

~r:

: o~

::s

0~

:I

~

::s

0 <

::s

~

<

0

-,

-,

0-

~

QQ

:I

-:I

::t'

I :::

r,!l.

::::

3 a

; '"

~

j "ii

' g.

:Ie-

. -

'" ~

8 ;i

0

'0

:::r,

- r;

;' C

o ~

a

2' ~

~

C!9

~

6

::s Q

Q '"

'0

g ...

QQ

n o

-, ~

<'::

s::s

~:I~

r::n

::s

"'J:;"

'I»

'O:::

::"'~

n ;;;

r~

...

~-,

-~~

...:::

r,Q

Q~

~~

~

...on

I»S

"V",

:::r,

o~-o

o::S

;::;'~

n-,S

':I::s

"'~"'~

' <

~~

r;;'~

::SE

:-~

~O

'::S

::s:lo

g. ~

9-;

i!ll

I» !I

I 3

~ 0

-:::

~ :

:; ~

g.

~ ~

~

g. n

r;

;'::;"

~ ~

1f

::, <

& 3

~ E

r ~ n

s..

==

~,

!:f r;

;,3

Co ~

:I, ,

~

::s

'~

...

~

~...

...

/if

~

.p Q

Q0

~

<

~,

...

'" <

II! O

"'::r

~

::r

::r

~

o~",

=rn

;~~

::r

~~

n:::r

,::;n

~::;

::a

::r::l

'" a '"

::s

~ <

II! ~

!,:;

~

'0

0 ;r

~

n 3

",nO

_,::s

"'n::,

n"'n

!;;:I,

~::S

QQ

O'r:

:g3

~::s

...0.

..gg.

0::r

"'::r

n<~

",~

~",

...1»

"':

:1'".

.. ~

~~

nn'"

...'~

-,

~

I»~

ng."

'I»::S

~-':

:::f)

~~

::S",

1f"'~

n~~

'Onn

~~

~~

~no

'TI"

'QQ

I»!lR

::s...

r::

I»~

~

go...

0 ::s

cjQ

' 2

S'

~

i:!

'0

n 0

~'O

&

.::;':

-'...

<'

0-3Q

Qr:

:~

~n~

~;_

;:;,~

, n!

ll-.n

n'0

~

~ r

:: ~

-,

r;;' C

o ~ ~

< ~

'g ~

QQ

'" n

c'o ::s

-,-~

::;

'::S

3::s

~

~

~

~

o-'"

00... 0

:I""

"',

::r

~

O~

"'",

- :::

r'"

n::r

<

II!

... 0

~

0

n -,

<

-,

g.

Co

n'

S;

::;...

::r<::s

~

::s

3 ~

3

o::sn

n I»

0g

N'

n"':

:r

0 ",

nn

~<

...

",-'C

oo~

;:;

'~",

ET

~~

'::;'O

-'~"'~

r::::

S1»

--,

::r~

'On:

:sS

",,~

g[!!,

~~

~~

...I»

~

-~ ~

0

Co

~

'" 0.

..'

::r~

~2'"

Qo-r

::s;

g.~

fR~

~~

~

g.~

3...

' -

n n

::rn

'0

n ,.

~

(II

n<

3 =

"'~~

n""O

O~

oO

...~

::sI»

n =

::r~

~"'5

C!~

--"'"

~::s

g.

~,'<

~

3

2..;;

; '0

n...

ET

0

~n

...

-::;

::Sn-

"'o

::r

n;:r

"',I»

":

:r~

Co<

'.I»:

:;"":

:sn

",<

0-

~

~~

-'~""

~

~

,~

::;:'!

s'

::S~

o-~~

'" ;0

;8

~~

'~~

- ...

01»

(tI'<

~V

)n!l:

:s

'"~

:::r,

~

9 -

a

g.~

;

c, '"

i:!'

" 0

g (j

2 g

a 3

'" ~

n '

0 ~

n

or

1»;

~

:I,I»

~

/ifog

"'3r:

:...::

;~~

~

~~

- -,

. ~ '"

0 0-

::r

-. -,

'" ~

~

n

~.~

S

' e!..

~n ::

s ~ i

f g

~ ~

? r;

;' ~

ro'

iii'

(.H

N

g.

Er

At;"

»>

:r:::

;::;

:r:r

D

A

O'~

; ~

C

::;::;

II~

;r~

~

Sa

::;;

a ~

;;; a

'" '"

n ;:I

~ a

"0

t;" Z

~o

::;°

'<

~o

~...

~

::r::s

::s8

::rn

an:.

~

~.

'<

a.::r

a

::.~

_0 '"

~

"0

~

...::s

~

n ~

'g

. 0

; ::s

0'

ii1

a.

~.

::;

Q

c:r

a (J

q'"

Q..n

-~

::r

titttz

::.

.;;~

-.

~

'"

n:::

.::! ~

. =

_. tI>

.. ,.

~...

'"~

~

~

o. r

;;' n

~g.

a 0

~<

io0

A::s

C

....

""(J

q "'0

~

tIn.

~..-

ZO

' ""

"",

_. n

1 ~

~ a

-'"

z ~

';.~

_.

::s

~

0 '"

tit

...

::s~

..

~ a(J

q ...

. 0

.::s

0

(Jq

::s.

> r;;o

~ .. 0 ::s gq

3!!:

~ 8

g ~

(D

. ii!

...

:s

0.

'" 3

:::t.:

s

5'ga

~...

Ii!

-.

""

;:::t.

:.o <

'" ...

...

3°:s

I')

0 -.

0..,

C

...

n

I')

~

...

0

;:;-6

;:r3

0 n

03

:s

I')

I')

~

:::t.~

§

~ g

~ -

.~

3~

...

0:r

-.oo

fij.

e- a

......

3 0.

.. '"

0 n

:r

Q.

I')

~~

g

ii!

-.-.

...

1')3

1;;6

;:s

...

:::t.n

I')

:T::1

) -

.

Jq

I')

0::1

..""

""

<

O!J

'...o

0 ..,

:T

'"

3 -.

0

:::t.

0 :s

...

O

'CI

:s

O'C

I ..,

I')

...

'" c:

0

0.1'

)"'..

,0

!J'::

r '"

nOn

.00

"'c~

:s

...

_.

CC

J

~ e

-?

aer

o !J

'I')

'" I')

C

3

:::t.0

'CI

...

0

<'~

e-

:sI')

.O

O'C

l

o--'o

n~-"

"n

~~

n3o"

""~

;:;';;

;'n=

~=

=

o~o

...~

o -.

~~

~"'~

oa.

~ n

a: n

a a

. =

0.9 "

" =

~.

_ 0'

n n

c:r:

r a

~o.

.. n-

';;;Io

n;i

"'<"'=

n nA

n~...

:r

=

n ~

=

~

=

n

3 "0

s.

: ~

0

=

~

n =

. ~

~

nw

"'oN

~a~

"O

n~n~

=~

:rQ

.."'~

!l0

r,:

!if

=

n s;

o'

~

a.

~

=

...

...

:i"::r

=

n

. (J

Q

if c

~-~

~~

n=~

On!

if~~

~

'<~

~~

~

n ":

" n

:r

n Q

.. 0

S!

~

w~e-.

g. ~

g 3

~

=

n ~

. ~...

~

~ ~

=

'0 -"'0

0

~ ~

=

~ ;

; S

; ~ ~

0

:r ~

:r-

<0.

..~~

0.

.. !"

-_

.~~

c:r!

::t~

~=

-'n...

...

~

- ~

-'<~

n-';;

;I:r

~~ 0

'~83

~.i~

~~

~8j

A~

~0~

a~2

.:-

Q..

"":r

~

_.

n

~

=

!:!

.. 0

n '"

-.

'"=

n

::n <

~

n

n i3

'" ;;;

I c:

r ~

Q.. _

. '"

0 0

:::!.

nw.&

J=O

W

-;;;I

!:!

c:r~

~

=~

(JQ

..-'-.

a0

n =

Q

.. =

c:

r c:

rw

;;;I A

: 5'

n

n r,

: 0

:=. - ~

~=

~~

~~

n-"':

gn

~

...~

~

::n~

"'=o

~..:

.-

~

=

~

~

~

~

:::!.

3 ~

. ~

=

~

~

n

~

~

0 ...

..~

~ -<

5' :r

5J g

n ~

~ S;

= ~

:r

if ~

~ ~

o' 3

g~

~~

e-.8

n03Q

..5'~

~~

~

~~

3~0i

3~

n <

O

~o

-'-n~

3;

;;1~

c:

r-...

-:r

_. n

-.

;;;1

0~

<

00- 0.

-.

w

-.8

...

Q..

'" '"

n ...

-.

(JQ

<

~

""n

~ =

:::

!. ~

n

~ _

. 0

S! ~

~ a

. Q..

~

:::::

=

0 n-

-::

~

!:!

n ~

a.

n ~

5J

-.

_. A

-.

<

!!..(

JQ n

:=

;. - a

. ;i;;;

I;;;I=

-n

A

~

Q..o

O~

~

""<

=O

S; g

~ ~:r

~' ~

0 ~

s; ~

~ ~

S! 2

0 ~

g =

. a

=

n~

Q

.. ...

...

n

n -.

~ =

-"

'" 3

~

...

~

Q..

i~'~

~f~

;~;~

f~!8

r~~

f~i[

~ a.

a e:

~

g ~

g -

< ~

!"

c:r:

r ~

~

.

~ g

= ~

&

. n

n;;

=

~

n ~

n

n~

Ii::.,

,=

r,:

n "'!

l.~

--

.n

0 !:!

\'\n:

:!t...

~

n....

.;;;

I ...

'S

- -.

n

!if

:r

-.

- -

;;;I

0 n

- _.

'"

0 !:!

..

=.

g~

~3n

n"'~

~

o~

~:0

""'~

]3

""~

~~

g~~

~~

Q..

i~g~

~~

~a=

o~

=nQ

..""

;i"'~

""~

o~

Ii::-

<

on..~

.....

=

~ c

c:rW

i_:

r ;:

n ""

...

:r

n

~-"

, ~

on

n_

. ...

~<

n3no

o:=

;' -.

'::

. =

n

(JQ

-.

;; Q

.. \'\

~

~

'"

~

a 0

"0

=

~,<

o""Q

..ooo

=...

a

~oA

;;;I=

o""

0 "0

.?

::<

2..::

:- =

~

'<

0 ~

"'O

0 =

~ 0

...

(JQ

~

i3

=~

~no

::r

"'aQ

.. ~

~2~

<~

~~

~!l

'" i3

;;;

I Q

.. n

~::h

(J

Q...

Q

.. ~

n

a.

=

-.

c

8Q..~

~0~

~o;

;;l~

~

~n~

~~

o =

~Q

q' _.

:r

~ ~

...

g ~

n

g. a

. 5'

= ~

5 ~

if:r

3 ]

£ -.

0~

=

- S

=

E"

=

j;)0

?. 2

'" "';

' S

(1 0

3

n w

.

n '"

-..

~.

- ~

..

-.

C-

o (I)

~ -g. :J:

i ~C

»...

.

Page 4: - D).homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/foundationalism-hab.pdf-0 ~ ~ ~ 2!. Cii" 3 I» ~ a.. - i" 'a UI ~:T 0 0- {Q (ii" - (=)" - 2!. ii' ~ ~ ;i...n 0 8-::I D~... n 0.... n ~ ~'i '< ~

N~

nQ~

o~~

~~

n~~

~~

~na

-::;

ii n

n

0- -.

:T n

~

0 -.

f)

A

0

~

n-.

., ~

'<

Jf =

n "0

:;

~ ~

0

s:: s

:: 0.

. =

"tI

= '<

ii ...

~

"" =

:T

""

...

~:I.

~

0: '

" S

~O

Q~

n

n-.:T

~--

.",-

~

c"'~

~c5

"~oO

'n~

tii~

,<

...o.

..-.

~,~

~~

n~~

~~

"'o-f

3~!~

!i0

:3 :

:; ~

~

:T

a

"0

~ n

Q

Q' ~

= n

0 =~

0

~a

no"'o

-~=

:T

:To

~

n=~

=

'" !'

C <

.,.

. n

o' 8

""

0.'"

~

n ~

;;.

.n

0 n

n ...

~

a

n :I.

- a

:-',<

0 :T

"O

>..,

-.

0..

n -

a 0

n ii

n '<

n

~ .

"""~

:Tn

<""

" ~

~

o.a

0 "'.

.. o.

.n =

g ::.

~' 8

3 8

~. 5

~. C

;;:

a

0 5"

"'"

'i ~

... ~

= a.

C

0..:T

0

0 =

. n

s:: :r

!; 0

:-.

~ n

OQ

'<

_.

'"

...

c. ~

C

n ~=

0- n

'"

j; n

0..

~~

~

=

n ..

~

0..

0-'

. _.

C':;

"0"

OQ

~

~

~

~

~ ~

. 0..

0 a

~

N 0

.. ~

~

~;::

8

~.~

n

~ a

nn

a 0

~

""",

~.P

....

~

0.

~

= 0

as:

:...

~ ~

= 0C

=

" n

-.:T

"',<

"...j

C""

""'-.

~

_.-'

",-"

,,""n

...~

=

~=

~Q

.Q.=

O'n

"'a;;;

'..,

~

C

'<

=

n

~

0 <

0

OQ

- a -

. "0

c ~

~ _ 0

::.; ~

0

_.

n =

n _.

<e.

n

= "

0 :I.

ac

...""

~

=""

~~

OQ

f3<

~n~

:"0

'" a'

" ~

an~

;-'

~_n

=:T

""'"

!"

2.. 0

""

~...

0.

. =~

;::

a ~

=

'"

'<

s: n

- ...

2"

. g =

_. <

'<

"0

'lJ

n

~

"0

-....

"'o~

"'o.,<

&.~

~

s:

~=

;~~

:T~

cO

'o

<' n

?f

~ <

~

:T

51

:T 0

2

",=

o_

.nno

.no~

<""

n;:,t

"!!.

_.

n

0.

:T

~

_.

~

...

n =

- Q. 0

; '<

«n:T

co

"'OQ

='<

o.

'.no.

..n

~ 0

' n

g ~

~

:I.

a '<

~

:T

OQ

"0

~

~

n

""""

'0

n ~

nn"'-

~:-

'~

",nw

I}

~

_.

~ g

" ~

a g&

.o

g" g

'< g:

I}

~ 0

8:3

a...

C ;

;;'...

~!;

2..~

n.g

~ :

T =

"5

- =

w

::. fit

~~

8

~ ~

~ ~

00

~ g

~ ~

~ 0

... a

0.."

0 a

"0 n

0

=

!;n"':

T~

!'3;f&

~2"

.n~

~~

R~

8 ~

~

0

~

'" ;;;

.!!.

a 0'

~

0 n

g.. ~

na

n",

~

<:I

~:3

_.a

'" -.

"""

0..

...-.

?f ::;'

OQ

:3

n

=.:

= ~

0 =

E

= ~

n ~

nOQ

nooa

-~~

.~

~A

~q

0-

0 i3

~

0.

=

'"

- n

~:T

n

0 ~

C

'<=

00..-

,<0"

,0=

n.

......

....

Er E

r ~ i

ir g

~

= Q..

E

r " fT

E

r 3

Q..

8 8

3 ~

8:

1. =

;-

3 E

r&

1'0 3

~

g "0

E

r ~...

::;-.

(') =

nO

n~n~

o~=

00

O

Qn~

on(J

Q

1II"

,:I.n

(')~

~ :

r 3

~ =

B

~ "0

~

~ ..

. ii1

::j'

'"

3 ii1

c - ii

1 ::r

~ '"

~

0

...

fT g

C :

"'~

n ~

~ g

OQ a

~ s

,,~ 5

~ 5

':1

03'" ~

!}

~ a

::-.

C:<

§ ~

5

g, &

0

Er~

~

:: 5'

:1

~ ~

~..'

:+

C - '"

...

!.~

...

9-:1

~

S; ~

3 g

fT

S

; Er'"

:1

~ :.

~ .

.. 1'

0 :r

OQ

(')

~

Q..;

:;'E

r"O

fT

OQ

~ '"

... ~

0

~ .

., n

~ .

.. Q

.. -,

s::

n -,

n ...

0

5'

n "0

1'

0 Q

..!!,

n 0

0"'0

1'

0~

~ Er ~

:r n

~

~ ~

0":

4 ~

. ~ f

~ o~

~

a: 8

~ ~

~ ~

:4 ~

2: ~

~':,

~ a

ii ~

'Er

~~

n;g<

"""':

II:"'a

.9,(

')=~

~..,

=~

g3

"""

n..,.

.,"tI~

fn':r

=Q

,ii1

~~

~n"

'::j'o

~

~~

"'::!-

.:4°'

<

=~

-'.

0

..,...

~O

,n

...n~

;:;':1

n1'

0 1'

0 :I

~:I,

<

0

-,

=

1'0

0 ...

-"'0

E

r -1"0

'" ~

:r"O

g;

0 ~

=

~ =

C.O

Q=

8~n'

=°E

r~"(

'):::>

<~

""'0

~

:rg.

.. ~

nnn"

'ao~

"'~n8

~3

fT g

~

Q.. ~

fn'

Q: ~

~ ~

a- a

A g

".."

'~

ii1 1

'0 ~

~

Q

..~'

~ :-

Er 0'

3 !it

s.

. ~

~ a

~s;

~

a.

~

(')

8 =

~

;-

a

Q..

~

0 ii1

~

'g

, ~

:1

3

Er

:r

~

- ~

2-

" fT

C

...

ii1

ii1

~

~

- C

?:

"'O

sa

0 ~

(')

~

~

~

:"

"0

1'

0 :4

..,

Q

..0

~

..'"

-,"'0

3O

Q

-1,<

~

,'"

:1

(')

...=

c -n

"'fT

":::'

<::-

'- -'3

""<

" =

.cC

'" n:

r 0(

') ...

~'<

gg

~

Qi! ~

g, 1

'0 3

~,.

"' 3:r

~ ~

a '"

~ Q

: ...:r

E!

~

~ :4

8..

oc!it

~

go, ii

~:

~ ~

-f)

~

OQ

~..,

1

0=1'

0...

1'0

,. _

3"

C

Q..

3..,

-'"nQ

.._'S

""n

n...:

r"'3

0~00

=~

n=

"0

fT(')

=;'~

Q..'

" nf

n'"

~,

-, =

5' 0

?: ~

8 ~

1'0 ~

~ ~

~ ~

~;.

2:::

~'g

~ ~

; 1'

0 ~

5'

0 n

3 3

~~

r 8

~ ~.

. a-

i1

' 2:

6,~

' ~

a.

~ ~

iir

~ ~

~

~ ~

~

~

~

~

~

=- c

i' Er ~

i ~

,; ~

~~

Er:r

;:

Q,

~

3;-

g-:

S; 3

~ ~

g 8

;. ~

3 ~

g

g ~

g 9

-::r

~ ~

~ :r

~ ~

t;'"n

~

~ it

'" _,

;';;1

an

0 :r

Q

.. C

0

3 g

gg

- c: -

, 3

;:;,..

fT

5'

~

~

0 n

~~

~ ~

S

:1

S ~

n

aa'

~ ii1

0 ~

fJ

~

;. n

...

1'0

~ fT

, :r

:r ;.

Q: :

4 ~

'" C

<

...

Q..

-1 ~

:r

o~'

5'

3 Q

: ~ -,

5 -I

OQ

=

(')

:4

n n

ii1

..,

~ g

;.

§' ::

: ~:r

EE

: ~(~

~

2-

~ g

:1 g

" ~

'"

~ ~

,Er

0 ~

a ;.

0

o'

~~

, 'g

, g"

fT

~

<ii'

g e

-."O

&

~ 8

n '<

:r

~

..

='

~ ~

-'.

.. _.

n E

r'"

C

0 Q

: =

::; =

':4

Q: 0

:r

n

'" n

1'0"

:I,

ea

~

=

nO",

=

0

0 ~

'n

1'0 "

0 :4

"'0

C

n...

- -,

'" C

.

"0

1'0

~

"0

0 -1

'"

~:

~

...

Q..

0 ~

=

!it

0

=

~

g ~

-,

~

~

"'.

. c:

1I

I:r

5'

~

~

~

-1~

,:4

=

~

~

~

2'.

!it3

n"'C

')=Q

..(')0

"'0""

-=,,,

=

.c~

O

Q

="':

:r'°

~O

~c"

"""

3:r

~

(')

0

, 3

""""

3'<

n

CT

(JQ

=

'?:

<;'"

...

8

Q..

C -,

= :

-' ... :r

" ~

'T

I -,

-,~

n

1'0-

,=

.. ~

c 1'

0111

_,.."

'--'

, 0

~"'~

n -'0

"'=:1

"0'<

~

~

s..::

: ~

~

="0

~

><

fJ

'<:r

:1

~

Era

"0

"0

~

-~~

;. ~

;;?g'

" C

"~-,

;::

(')

=-

0:;r

2~ ';-

::!

5'

0 -,

~

"0

:r 0

~

...

~

'" ~

~

0

2: :

r-

=

'" -,

5'

~

=o~

n -,

~

=

=n~

11

10

:::

'<

3OQ

n ~

,o~

'="'~

J:

:1Q

..=:::

""'Q

.. ~

Er~

~O

Q~

~8.

..!itf

TQ

..~

0'3n

C38

Q,"

'Q,O

Q~

co~

fn

':::

n c'

~

~

n'

C

1'

0 <

~

~

1'

0 =

~

'"

2:

::t:1

..,

0

=

3 n

3 "0

...:r

"O

"0

=

~

fT"'~

,"i"'

:4-"

'~"':

4~o~

s'~

, :r

OQ

"OQ

~

n~

"O~

n~"'~

r;

r!1

~

~]

Q'~

? 5:

~,

~o' ~

~ a

~ i

i1 g

5'-<

" ii1

~

0'

~ a

~

g ~

..,

~

a R

~

~-I

C

.. ...

..

1'0

'" 3

Q..

0 -,

..,"'0

c:

"0

..,

.."".

.;:;,

'" 3

-,

Q..

~

= :

r:r

fn

' ...

Q..

~

t;" ~

=

"0

=

C C

~'8

. fn

' ~

~

_.

<ii'

;. 1'

0 !'

:r

~ 0

O

Q

~

C

:11:

"',<

~

fn".

.:r

~ ~

S

; ';'

1'0

S -

<

g" ~

c: g

~

!it..:

r s.

. c:

a ::r

n

8 ~

fn

' ~

:4 ~

"9

~

~

s.. ~

IIS

l,

n> S

t- I\)

~ S

t- ::r

~ °

~

St-

><

1\)=

0n>

~=

::;t1

)1\

) 3Q

.. '"

."

n>

<a.

:-

. 0

""""

""""

n>

="

- ° ::r

... 0

..

.., I

(JQ

'<

=n>

I\)""

~~

:I ~

n>

."

O-:

:r

-.

~

- ° 0

::r~

..,

n>

n>

n

=

=

::r <

° 3

;;! ~

t;

~ ~

g'<

I\)

I\)

1

;;!

0..

Q.. -.

_0

t; '"

- _0

.

--<

'" =

...

.

::r

11\)

0-

So-

~

~:I

:I =

t:I

:I 0.

. _.

n>

n>

..,

n c

n>

=

n

~.1

\)S

t-0"

"n-';

:;'0

:r

0 so

-.

=

'"

=

-.:1

Er =

S ~

i$!. s

' ~

:. ~

~:r

,","

"

n>1\

)==

n>ji)

-"'1

\);;!

"'q

o(JQ

=

"'1\)

"""

"'o"':

:!--

c."

~°:

1""<

:'<"'.

.,1\)

0 3

n>

n>

1\)

C

n>

~:;!

..n>

Q

.~:r

~8'

="'<

::r~

n

..,""

~nS

'~~

o<:I"

":r

~

(JQ

=

~

2.

. a.

~

., <

t>

:r,<

'<

_.

rr

:I ...

.-

n I\)

O

' 0

<

a.

:1.

;: ...

~

S

t-

=

g ~

0~""

"1\)

n>.,

0 C

I\)

g.

=

~

8'

:;:0'

<

~

~

'<

=

O";

no",

r;

' n-

o =

!it"'

o:r

oO!

I\)

...

n>

,..

I\)

00;

-':2'

\':t1

\)

1\)-

:1'"

::Sn~

~::S

~n>

Q..S

t-

nc::t

_o..:

:s

"'n>

n a:

= J"

~

0

:to

0 0

3 ~

0

3 ~

:I

fg a

.g

:..

g-

~

C

~

~n>

~

!it

""

_.

n>

~

'" ;n

' i

Q..

- ~

~

~

:r

~ C

0

C) ~

g-~

:r ~

;:;.

rl'

I\)::t

I\)

0

n.

,=",

C)c

:ll\)

..,~

-..

_.

St-

..,

'"

C

...

;::;-

~

_.1\

) ~

;:;

°::t

0 =

~

? n>

0

n::S

~ 0- < ~ -

::s ..

....

'"

~

::g

~

3!"

'" 8 3 n g. ~ ... ~ c .. n ~ .. :r ~ ... n 8 ::s ... .. ~ 2 l!- i;;'

3 0 ;;: .. '" i 0 ~ :2,

::s n -6' I!-

::soq

"O0<

3~oj

i)cl\)

::S~

I\)::S

::s -.

~ ..

...

-':;0

:-/,

3 '"

~

2.

Q.

-.

"'...

-.0

::s::S

.....

~

I\)Q

q(JQ

0(

JQ

n".

..:t

3'<

..0

0n:

:r'"

. 3:

rn~

n3~

::sO

"'~~

° ::s

n

~..

::s::s

a~

::s

~~

...Q

..~"'~

"'-"'

3nn

~

::ron

::s

I\)

'<

n ~

:!.

0

~ :

i' =

;. 0

:i'!.;

3...

::r

.. ~

...

(J

Q

0 ::-

.::r

n

cjij'

~

~::r

.

n o:!.

::r

-.

n S

i t~

"'~C

" ::r

-:!.

:;J

~

::r...0

_.

....

n I\)

n

'"~

=

'" I\)

I\)

I\)

t

0 ""

"::S

<"O

::r""

"0

I\)

Q.o

nc::r

::r

-

=~

-.

:! Iii

cn~

Q

.::I~

..."0

3 ..

... I\)

::;

. OQ

:r

'" c

..,

='"

...."

n

<

."

o~"'n

"':r'"

C"'

:r

:'tnn

~",

nno:

li3

C'"

ii 3=

. e-

. ~

~

"'I\)

:=

;-;;0

-0

n ::s

-

I\)

:;O:-

::S

...

n ...

1;

:"

=n1

it°E

..~."

nQ.

...::s

-(J

Q

~;'.

.o

n""'"

a.~

;:;

n co

_.C

'" nS

i'"(;

g

~

8 !'(

JQ

;.::r

il':'"

30nn

~

~

n 3

::s::s

'"

~..Q

. "'~

:2..

0 _.

C'" §

0 ~

n

3 ~

'<

-."':

:t."0

...

0 ~

3 g

:!.~

~

:r::t

. g

~::s

'" n

<

~ 0.

..'<

",..n

-....

f ~ i ;~

Page 5: - D).homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/foundationalism-hab.pdf-0 ~ ~ ~ 2!. Cii" 3 I» ~ a.. - i" 'a UI ~:T 0 0- {Q (ii" - (=)" - 2!. ii' ~ ~ ;i...n 0 8-::I D~... n 0.... n ~ ~'i '< ~

;"'0

~

0

3 ;.

~ ~

3 g

. 3 C

o:r:

~

3

==

:s

~ 8

~ ~

0

;"'0

S

; 8 t

"'"

~:s

~

0

r:r;

..2

;;;' S

. "0;

' c:

~

;;;.1

\>11

1"'0

1I

I::t':

SI\>

OI\>

~lII

i'olll

S

;o"'C

o0:9

SIll

~:r

...g

n2!!;

""<

I\>c:

...~

rilll

"00'

'g

§'~

~

.~g'

~~

g:§'

R'~

~

~;.~

.<g3

:"[;'

~g

§:g.

.~.g

~

~

~~

i; ~

~i.~

~c§

:~8

:s' ~

g'~

~

5'-:

S0'

<"';

;-~

'";r

1\>

:S1l

l:S

~0.

."1\

>"'1

::.1I

I1\>

"'~:r

:::!-

"'C:3

-""'I

\>S

;;~::I

,"'-'

...0;

'1\>

'"i

~.~

~~

.[~~

[.g.: ~

;.g':

~ ~

:;. ~

~.~

;J

g'~

~~

a ~

c§:~

~~

g.

§.§

~.g

~

~ 2

-.i r

:s

::!. :

r"

0 0

" :r

'" 0

:3 I

i r:

r 5' .

.. ":

s 0 - r:r

0

0 ...

"0

...~

... ::

I :r

:S

:s '

" _.

'<

I\>:s

"...

Ii ~

I\> g-

~ g,,

;'~;:s

"

!l. ~

§"

!2.

~ Ii

.g

5'

5'

~

~ s

g" ~

3 ~

g '"

~ g

- 3 g

5' ~

a' ~

~ s

a. ~

~ ~

f ~.!

~ ~.

f i ~

~ ~

r ~ 1

~,~

r j ~

~

i ~

~

.! ~

~ f ~

: ~

~

g' ~

8 ~

[ ~

' ; t

[ t ~

i

i:'...

:r

0 "

III I

II J'

" ...

0

...

'" :s

"

;':r

-.

"III

0 A

I\>

- 5

' ...

:r:

:S:S

I\>

ii":S

:r

' -

'" n

:s

I\> I

II ~

;.

= ==

!!;

...

a ...

5'

r:

r 0

0 ~

. I

i :s

III

III

~

;

:, ~

~

0'

n

;. ~

~

OQ

'"

OQ

:::

;.

Co

~ O

Q

;r:O

Q

fA

III

~

~::t

. §,

11 ~

~ a

~. §

~ ~

~ ~

~. g

-] ~

~

. ~

~ c§

:.g: ~

~ ~

~:JJ'

8: 8

c§:

~~

: g

S'~

.g ~

~ ;;i

" ~

~

~

!J ;

;;. ~

~

:s

fA c

: Ii

_. _

. . ~

:r

'" a

M:r

::t 1

1:sl\>

- '"

:r

fA

-. I\>

., ~

III

:s

OQ

.c

... :r...

:r:rn

'":s

...",

-"

"I\>

n""

- "'.

.."'

""

:sn-

'"-.C

o ..

:rl\>

:so...

:1

:s<

t> '

" n

...:1'"

'" - _

.:s I\>

n ...

I\>

n

I\> 3

.. ...

:r:<:

;:r<:;

'" :r

00- -.,<

:-':! :s

'"

... 0t::

. I\>

-'"

0

I\>~

' n.

."

""""

-.

- ""

...

.'"

:r

~:r

:-'

'" '"

-,

'. -

...

::!.

~

0 '"

;'";'

ri ;;?

;;;.;'

::!.

III g

- -<

o'

'"

g "1

11

III

I\>

!!; 0

III

'"

~. >

...

~

::!.

c:

CT

;;;.

0;.

00'

0

-<;;'

~

~

;-~

~

...

'" n

O. a

, "';.

:s

~:-

t c§

: a ;

. Ii

:r'"

Co

- n ~

0 ~

-g

"::1

. I\>

~

n

~.

=

g I\>

III

0

~

~

~,c

0'

] ::!

. 1\

>"

5'

...

~...

~

c

~

""0

3;;

g- 8

0

...

r:r:

s ~

c:

~

;;;

' Co

=.

9-n:

!Q:

~~

~"O

,:::'3

!"':s

.a

!t'"

_.~

:r'",

...",

...nl

\>°

a~

01\>

3"

~;;;

' n

<:;

n '.

- :r

:;..

. '"

'"3

...

I\>:S

"

n _:

r:r

I\>

'"!

...

OQ

C

o :S

"':r

'"0

"0

:r...

...

.....

O'n

"O...

n~

-"~

o "'0

3

",~

,<:::

;nril

ll==

'~-

~5'

§"III

~n~

c.

..1\>

5'

~:r

...

"S n

! ~

0;<n

;;-

a ~

0

~...

0

n S

:::-

~

0"0

S

~ ::

0. i

r~

5'O

Q...

"0

_:so

-..:i

'" ~

:. ~

;;

~I\>

n'"

3 ""

"co"

"':s"

""~

:S

""'<

"'-'n

:r"O

" _.

n~

",

~n_

"'_.

:. :s

0.. g

ri "0

~

g g

Co

~

"0

9 ~

ii"

r:r

c~

03~

Q: g

i;!.c

"

~ '"

~

ci 8

...

:1

5' ~

~ 0 3

III

!!; ~

~

"'_._

,"'~

"~

ano

::I.<

:;.~

'"

<:;"

111

ct""

' C

)<:;-

<O

Q~

""

""

~;:

§.. ~

~;;.

:.

g ~

j} :

s ~

. ~

a. g.

::!: ~

. ~

~ [

~ ~

~ a'

g 11

~ 8

'g ~

~ ~

-g a

3 ~

~ 3

g S

OQ:r

S. r

i '"

~

o"~

'< r:

r s;

g ~

~ q

g, ~ I

i ~

0

III '

" ".

5'

~

~~

. ~

:s

~. ;.

Co

"' :r~

. c: ~

~ ...

"S

:::

!!;C

o"'

311

1 ""

"...c

:s

...~

III

Z~

"'~"'-

'~"'~

'" -'-

.'"

"".:s

~"':

r"'_

.:-

t c:

11

III'

... -:

s'"

...

3 ~

CJQo

s..

~

III

Co

...0

n:rI\>

_.

n ...:r

:S :

r Ii

O.

0 III

_3' ~

0

0..

-:s

III

...0r:

r ;.

tnl\>

""~

:r

...n

~

- :r

~

"0

0

:s~

...

"':S

0

3c

nn

---!

l.:r'

"~a.

~.~

3 8.

;"'0

g

s..

;;;.;"

0 5.

:rfA

g.

.. §"

o c:

~

"2

..a.;;

;.0.~

...

g.a.

n

~ 8

~ '<

III

~

n

~.a

" ~

~'" a.

~ ~

"0

"0

a. ~

CJQ

g ~

... ~

a,""

":

0 0

'<

r:r

co;:;

~ g

~ I\

> g

~0'

...

~:s

3

~

'" I\>

...

S

' ...

0

~ "0

-<

-. ~

-, ~

:s

c:

~ ~

'<

"

c: :

...

~

...

...:s

] r:

r~

n ~

:3 -

<...

~ ~

g' o

' :r

: ~

~

g :s

9,

3 :s

~

~ ..

. I\>

"0

c: ~

~

8 ~

~ 3

~:;-

A g"

s.

.

3 ~

~ ~

g.

OQ g

g 3.

3 ~

. a

~

~

:S~

;;;'::

I. §'

;-

~

a

0 g

~

~

~

~

5 r:

r.a

a ~

3

S

g ;.~

. ~

3

qg,

~~

~a.

:s

=...

o"

':r~

;;;'::

nsr.

~

5'

i::3=

'~1\

>

=

n:::.

..O,5

':S"'~

...N

'0'

S.

r I\>

~

g

g"

1:-

a'

~

8 g

g ~

!it

8 ia

ci

5:

a ~

~

~ ~

'f

~

g.

a.~

~

8

~

~

g a.

a

s..;;

. s.

. ~

g.

ci

0 :I

~ II>

;.

g. g

. 3

:I 5.

"0

iI1 g

. g.

~

~.

8 8

"0

"0 :::

c;- C)

8 ;

:; ~

:I

C);

:IC g.

S~

"Oll'

l>l'I

>~

g g"

O~

~o~

ool'l

>:I~

~~

II>~

::r~

~~

~1I

>1'

I>...

3

II>

0' 5

. II>

...

~'J

" C

0

C

1'1>

<

R

'" n

:i"::;

. _.

:I

1'1>

:I.

0 f}

...

~

8

-if

~

:I C

) ""

Q

.. ""

~

1'

I>!ir

g.

:I ~

_.

6:

Q

.. s.

g o'

cs

" ~

:I

2'".

;:;

~

:I '"

2'".

;;;:1

:I

-.0~

1I>

3-.1

'I>_.

1I

>01

'l>~

...en

l'l>

cr:r

::r.:I

:loC

IQI'I

>

11>

1'1>

11>

...0

:I C

Q

. C

'"

~.;.

g

~ ;

; <

~. ~

II>

II>

;:;

=--

0

...

;;;.:1

...

""

.~.

g 0

~

""

:I iI1

a.

c ...

n

;. 0

Q.

1'1>

V

) -.

g. II

>

><

n.

;-

:l:r

)... if

'" ...

'"

""

II> 3

Q.

~ 1

'1>

::;.3

0;;;.

""";

3~n;

-l'I>

=--

en"O

00...

01

'l>3'

J II>

?-""

:lc

""o'

8.

. ~

"" ~

;;; ~

g ~

~ n

~.g

a.3

] if

g.=

~

~ ~

3 ad

0 .g

if

Q..

~ ~

a 8

:I 1'

1> II>

""C

IQ

I'I>

O,<

1'

1>3

::;:lI

'I>C

oI'I>

OO

C""

II>

cn

3"':

-n

1'1>

C

:l;i

::;.0

"':1

0 ~

1'

1>

0 1'

1>

--~

Q

..""

1'1>

iI1

3

1'1>

~

0

Q..<

!!!.'"

1'

1>C

'"

...

~

3 <

en

-:

I 0

::;

1'1>

:I

:r

0 1'

1>

_.

C

0 ~

-

1'1>

>

<

f)

:I.

1'1>

<

2'

".

Q..

II>

&.

C ~

~ 1'1

> ~

0 3

c 1 II>

~

1; .

.. 3

!P3.

~.

fj ~

g- 0

_. ~

~

Q..<

!!!..g

1'

1> ~

e; ~

1'1>

gg

0 1'

1> ~

~ ~

1'1

>

CIQ

't

e 3

'" II>

0

'" ~

_3' -

en:;'

~

-. C

; II>

~

1'

1>

CIQ

:::!..

f}

R

II>

Q..:

I ~

<

J,i

~.

II>

1'1>

0 3

""

<.

=

II> 0

:1 i.

. 0'

" Q

.. 5.

;;;

. ~

'g

-;

; 3

II> 0

~.

!ir

g-

~

&.

5.

8.Y

' ~

~.

~

0'

~

0 ~

: '<

-Q

S

""

~

g-

f}

::ro' ~

$

:I "0

:e

II>

~ ;

:: &

.:I

-'...

...

-'"

Q'"

""

""

C

II>

n'"

-'1'1

>

n ~

1'

1>

...

0 ~

3

... I

I>

0

~ ~

01'1>

;.;.

if ~

ff ;;;

. ~ ~

3 g.

~ a

d 8

if i..

~ ~

~ Z

, ~ ~

g if

a: [

~

~ R

:Iif:

::;:~

!!,

~

II> a

~ g.-

.ifo

1'1>

'" C

C

8'

" 3

~ ~

!!!..c

rJ

""

""

0 1'

1> !2

,.0.g

;.;::

. ~ 2

'". "

" C

~

;;!

s:t

II> :

I 3

35'

...0

~ ~

:I if

1'1>

<':r

~

&. 0

'" ~

~ ?

;:IC

"" ~

. S 1

'1>

- n"

Or:

rI'l>

_.-"

""

"':I'"

I'I

>I'I

>Q

. 1'

1>

II>I'I

>-'J

"n~

g.:r

::r

~ n

~ g

. 5. i

f J>

~::;

...

i.. iI

1 5'

0

1'1>

3 '"

~ ~

.;.

5' 1

5' ~

~ 1

'1>

n;-

i..31'1>

e. g:

~ ~

;; a

;; ~

g.

~ 3

§ ::r oll>.

3 ~

;;

3.g

~...

~, ~

2 !i

g.;;

; g

~ :r

' 3'

CIQ

"':::r

.:I",

C

""01

'1>

11

>1'

1>'"

0_""

'0:;

:r"'1

'I>

n3

30...

'g ~

:r.

g <

...

:::r

.CIQ

f}

n

:I ad

:I R

:I iI1

!ir

f}

iT

I}

0 (J

Q _.

;:: e

n Q

.. C

~

1'1

> 3

:r'J

"'"

;;'::r

~

;- ~

:r!ir

a.

~ C

s

e-.;.

- ~!ir

3

:I, g

. C

;:IC

"" ~

. !ir

0 ~

::r

II>

~

==

81'1

>;:;

'o<

II>II>

'J"c

:r3:

-:lII

>;::

"""I

I>O

cl'I>

~0;

:: 0'

lJ

'<0

3""

n:l:!

II>:lI

'I>:I~

I'I>

""'<

I'I»

CIQ

""lI>

nn""

3",

r:r=

--~

""c"

O""

""30

::r

n",'.

-"'II

>,,'

" 1'

1>"':

1 'lJ

II>nl

l>

.""'l

'I>l'I

>l'I

>n

""::r

1'

1>0

-.

i;'

6:

<

- ~

5.

'v

:r

:I

;; C

:I

1'1>

- a

~

~

'" :I

0 'J

" 0

1'1>

iI1

-.:I~

""3

11>

""

01l>

Q..:

:r-:

I "O

II>~

"':

1'«

0-:1

~ a

2. s

S ~~,

8 &.

~ g.

~ ~

~~. 5

[~ ;:

e 1

~ 2

~ ~

~ ~

g3

'g ~

n "

:::r,

'J"

_.3

:I ~

'

-3

""3

N

n n

II>

'JII:

" _.

C ~

8 ~

0

nOO

?;

g.0

1'1>

On

I}>

0 5.

1'1>

0

1'1>

0:::

. j;>

'_.!i

t _3'

II>

n

~ ~

a11

>11

>

"':I

:I 1'

1>

_.

:I C

I'I

>"-

C-

311

>

-'<

II> n

'"

0'

""

Q..

'" 1'

1> 3

3 ...

n

CIQ

:I

""

"":1

'J

II:".

::::::

- '"

... -.

:I

~

0 II>

-.

"'0

-II>

m

c :r

ljl'l>

::r""

""

""",

.~"'!

ir:lo

...

...-

3 i..

II> e

; ::r g

. :I

.:c 5

' IG

S e

n 3 1

'1>

"0

""

1'1>

;;;

.::; i

f' C

r;

' '"

CIQ

""

"0

II> ~

. 0"

. ~

5~~

I'I>

;':I.'

" 3~

""§

8:::

r.!l.

n;::~

0 3"

O?0

!2

,.aad

l'l>

~0"

'" 3;

;;':1

0 I'I

>-'~

-' :l1

I>°.

.c-.

""?!

co

3;--

.<c~

1'I>

""

3 ~

ni

l>

'" 1'

1>

n :I

(JQ

-.

:1

C

:::r.

_.

-

::;-:

1 ~

1'

1>

C

-,

3 0

Q..

'JII:

" '"

-!

II>

'J"o

~ -6

. ""

o:r

en c~

::;

...::r3

::; - .

0 a.

9 , ~

';:'

0:t:

:r

~0'"

1'1>

'J" o

:; .

-, ,

:r

~

II> -

CIQ

",

,'"

-,

II>

II> "

" :I

:I -.

., no

'" _.

:I

....a

:;. _

. -:r

'<

1'1>

s:

:3

="0

;;:

n

II> ..

. 0n

s:t

II>

II>

"'. n

C

:! <

=

:1".

::;

.0

""""

"""

0""

..,

"".,.

.<;..

,(1)

,...

I~"'T

10 c: ::J c. a ~r a. iir 3 :r :I: DJ

c:r

(1)

3 i fir 0- ur n 0 c ~ en (1)

(1)

g ~. m

::!."

:;-

~~

..ur~

5'0 ~.. ~:~

~'" c

::sII>

II>

:;-;;;

-n

0en

II>

'8 R

::s

0en

C

;;::s

-.'"

;;'0'

'<

....

II>

...

::s if

~O

'"0

.... n

0 n

R 0

~...

...c

0

~ ;

._n

""

~.3

0::s

....

n II>

en

-en

::s

'",

0""

"

o' ::s en en C g. II> (II

C- o ~ "'0 =r

:z:

CD

;

Page 6: - D).homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/foundationalism-hab.pdf-0 ~ ~ ~ 2!. Cii" 3 I» ~ a.. - i" 'a UI ~:T 0 0- {Q (ii" - (=)" - 2!. ii' ~ ~ ;i...n 0 8-::I D~... n 0.... n ~ ~'i '< ~

::r::r

"O

:r

::r-

n "0

Q

.. -<' :

:t'

"11

..,

...::r0

r:r

n ...

r:r

I'll

C;:;

' <

'" n

3I'l

l I»

_3

. "00

..,

n ...

:j:I-

'o..,

n"'-Q

..O--

' -.

"'c

""'1

»0

"""'1

'11:

1 I»

CO

3'

" '"

"'C"'O

:r,<

"'~

I'll

~;=

.831

»~~

~~

I»~

~I»

!!!.c

~

~8:

::=-':

I:Ig

r:r~

"O~

2~~

~c~

~ ]

::r ~

~.

~

3 ~

~ -g

~ g

go;

;;::. 0

' §. 8

--"0

.g ~

;i ~

; §

[~..i

ii' 1

1 ~ ;:

B. 3

i5:

~' 3

3 §

. 3 ~

I'llI»

~

. I'l

l g-

~

~

g'

~

03

~ '

" Q

.. i;!

3'" ~

:!

0 "'0

";'

I'll

3 I'l

l ...

'<

0 - (;

0"', r:

r !2-

g ...

I'l

l C

!!

..!!

";'

~3-

""""

"~

...t:I

I:'..

31'

1100

...

c'.n

-.

n.

..",~

Q..

I'll'.

<;'"

"'-

'=00

:r,<

"O1»

~"'-

' c~

I'l

l <

;...n

r:r:

l"O"'g

o~03

:r~

:I

",Q

..'-"

'a.."

':rS

...,S

:l I'l

lr ~

. 3 ~

~ ~

. g. ~

~ ~

g.;-

~ ~

~ ~

g; ~

. ~ ~

5. 2. g

.~ ~

g-

3 ~

~ go

g 5'

3

~3' g.

~ g.

0 g.

5. a

.C

:C

:l "':

1 ::

-l "'

0 3

I'll

'" ~

. :::

:.. I» - I»

C ~

Q

.. '"

'" I'l

l 0

:I oq

:I

~.

00~

ii)"1

»01»

~

~""

"""'r

:r0"

"""

I»...

n~<

n"'::

::n

:I"""

0

«I'll

O

' <

:I"'.

.. r:

r"'

3r:

r:r"

'~:::

C

'"

;'q

S:..

. 0

go~

.n

3 ~

:I r:

ro'"

~.~

C

:::

q I'l

l 83

go

c;:;'

...

,1'1

1 '"

:r ~

~ ~

'"

s: S

I'll

~..c

g

::;. g

~ 'S

. ~

go

a ~ :

r 8

'" I'l

l Q

.. g.

., go

g- =

g-~ ~

"<

C;:;

' ~

. I'l

l :I

go::

a ~

~ -.

C 3

-. 3

'" n

r C

oq

- 0

:I I»

I'l

l I»

e-

:I...:

I. _.

~

I'll

Q.. ~

go

-g I»

e-

. ~ n

S

I'll

""

C

ag

c:~

;:;.~

~~

.5~

~'~

~

'] §'

8~

~ ~

~.~

.~ ~

~ ~

~ ~

~.~

;~~

~

.~ ~

~~

§.§

;~~

~~

...

C;:;

' I» 8

~ A

A '"

:I :I

~.

I'll

5'

~ ~

~ I'll

0 ~

g

~ g

I» ~

;!L:

I C

;:;' 8

~

!' ~

:;.

Q..

..."2

,. e-

. '"

'<

:r

g 8

§ ~

:I ~

~

3.

8

C;:;

' q

~

~

~

~

s'~

' ~

~

R

30

-g

~

~

:I ~

.g

'g.

:<

~

I'll

e-.

a. '<

~.

g O

J',=

-~

n3g-

N:lg

o~.

Q;

:I'

1'11

1'11

!if'"

1»..c

I»O

":<

n~

==

<

",~

~O

l»"'=

::;Q

.. I»

~

0

en_.

~

Q

.. I'l

l :I.

§

- e-

-.

...

:j n

~

~.!.

. 0

...a

~

'" '"

'" ~

;:1

' 0

~

~.

8..

C

~:I

5':;'

r:r

C

~

'" !!!

:I

:I ...

"0

:I

...

-.

n I'l

l :I

=.:r

'"

...

:I ""

':r

':1

I'll

I'll

-"

C

ii)"

I'll

~

"0

n C

oq

I'll

~

0""

"0

:r..,

c

0 <

0

n (;

'"

!if

0 :I

"OcI'l

l R

n

3=

Q

.. S

-

...

r:r

I'll

-.

'" "'0

~n

8 '"

-o:l"

'cno

<;:I

n:lo

"'_""

0

I'll

n"'1

»3::r

-3

<1'

113

"'1'1

1I»

3

N'

<"

; n

S!::

r"O

~

~

c

~

~

~

5'

~

'" ~

O

J'

s..

'" 0

e- 3

;"

'"

I'll

C;:;

' I'l

l I»

~

~

D

. 0

~

8

~"]

~o

' ~:r

;:;

8 ~

3

~

i ir"

~.

~

~.

~

3.

8 a

¥ 'g

. A

5

~

~.

~

~

S ~

2.

~

8 ~

ff :go

.; ~

g.

~

~n~

0;

""

erl»

""

""'1

'13.

..0<

...

",-o

q",:I

"O

"'.O

"'t~

. "'~

-"O

I»Q

...:<

:I ~

:I

I'll

8C'"

- r:

r!if

.! 0

5"'0

0

C

:r

Q;

R

8..

C;:;

' I'll

:;"

0 oq

I'l

l 0

~

(;

!!!.

0 =

0

!:l~

"0

I'l

l S

-.

A

:I

:I I'l

l ::'

~

~

"O

oq

0 C

;;

(;

~

- it

S

I I'l

l ~

.

t:: a

D

. ~

~

. a

c '<

:I

C

g-

~

5."0

0'" 5'

~

-g

a

:;.

g ~

*

~.

~

a e-

~

8

g.

8 ...

~

~

8 ~

C

;:;'::

; :r

...

:j a.

~

g-

=

: g

R'

o::~

~

...

D.

'" '"

0 :I

~

~

'" n

-.

S!:

I'll

~

1'11

:1

""'"

C

r:r

'" I'l

l O

J'::r

~

:r

5'

:1

I'll

'" Q

.. "0

'"

3 ~

'2,. ~

g

~ R

~ ~

03.8

E

~

~

1'

1138

0 ~

~

;

~

3 ~

;-~

. e-

s:

~

==

I'l

l ~

8'

" ~

0

3 ;<

...0g.

3I»

I'l

l I'l

l3

- '"

Q..:

:r

=-.

c

3

o::r

:I"

'" u\

~

'.

I'll

n I»

'<

...

c

it :r

,<

0 =

= n

=. :

r .

'<0

C

I'll

1'1

I'll

-.

C

'" ...

"0

M

...!:l

3'" :I

"'"

...

... - :

:r <;

3~

I'll

:I

I'll - n

I»...

'"

-.

'" 1»

""""

""'"

'" -"

'C""

g ",

no

'" ~

:II

» "':

I.:<

~ ~

~

~.;:

~ go

, go 3

go 8

C) g

~ ~

'.2 S

~ ~

~.~

. go ~

~ g

- ~ ~

~

g-:f

s: ~

oq38

g. g

0

r:r:

0"'0

~

'"

n;:;'

~

I'l

l I»

3

~

...

...C

~

C;:;

' S

:I I'l

l "0

'"

'" -.

I'l

l n

3 M

" =

=

3 2-

I'll

u\

'" I'l

l I'l

la

::r,<

:"'::

1'"

I'll

C

~

"0

I'll

3 <

...

'" -.

-':

1 1»

:1

"0

- ::r

n

'<

~

:I a:

l ~

n'

0

~

~...

"0

'"

;. 0

'" 8

~

e-

;..

go

'" .9

. S

!: ~

. ;.

'" 0

c!!!.

3

~

0 n

0 I»

~~

.~r

~:l~

fij

~~

.~

~'f~

~;i

~:

;1

~~

~~

~~

:.g

'§-§

'[~~

~

~~

~:<

:I !if

~s.

.n'C

;:;'n

.g.~

~Q

..!"~

t;ln;

:;'l»

~

~~

~~

I»Jg

,:<,

c;:;'

8~~

I»~

t;I~

!if

,9l:(

" 0 c::

;::,

Co

!!l-

0. ::J e!.

(ij° 3 5.

co CD

- ." ~ 0 c:r

CD 3 en S' - ::r C1) 0- ~ 3 c iii

" - o' ~ 0 - a..

ar n 0 c ~ en C1)

C1)

- ::r ~.

I Q)

0 0- Q. ~. ~ ! ~ :::r ~.

:!J CQ c: Ci

~

:r~

;.O'o

n ~

n "'-

.~

~"O

~

1;

1 c:

QQ

'"

'" II)

a.

:I

~ g

-:r f

f. ~

~

'" ;:;

'!J.

n :I

na

""'0

II)

0:

;0::

II)

;.n-O

:"'

3II)

:I

n -.

:I

1I)~

g,,~

.."'..

.~:I

_.

0 '"

II)

n _.

e

n-:

1:1

11)1

1)0

~~

g.;;!

a-

"

~lI)

n~n~

QQ

~

0.. a

. ~

3

°:r

.g

g 2"

". e:

~.

n'

a.

90 -

. !.

:r:l

§- ""

s _.

3Q

Q

<n3

II)

en &

1 0:

1"0

'< " _

. E.. ~

na-

"0

:I 0.

. - r

3n

:r I

I)

'" '-0

a.

19~

~o~

:I ;

e n

a-~

0..0

33

n<

ne

n e~

~

-:I

e '"

-.0.

.3

a 90

a. 9

0e:

5~

0

;. II)

8

-.",

<

n

'" e

:I II)

n

'" II)

-

'TJ

'" '"

II)

~

0..

_OQ

Q

...

3 a-

a-

~ e

2

n ::!

. n~

~ ;.

C'~

;;

:I I

:I ,.

n~

- !:l

..A"O

0..

t:: '"

II)

-.::!

. 0.

.90

3'

g :I

::;.

n",

!J.n

3'

;"'2

. a.

~ 5

" ~ t'

D~

,<

s.

~

t'O

C:

£::~

if

=-

i~a~

t:!.;'

~:-

1\

>-

~o:

:: ~

::rifi

fI\>

...

~ ~

a.

O'~

D..,

~

:I

;.g.~

t'O

~ !!...

<It

..,

'<I\>

<

I\>

=.1

\>

n~

~R

~t'O

"O...

0

...

o' -

-;.

:I I\>

t'O

0 8

n--

:I§;.:

::~t'O

0

.Q<

C

s.a

g;;-

!i

;;:

-fA

~ 1

5 ~

o3~

--

...n

::r

~ ~

~~

Q'"S

;~

t'O

t'O

_0

'"

"':r _.

~"-

. ...

'"

~'"

~o.

.a:

g.

:r:

~ ~

;-..

_.~

'"

oo~

;:;o-

<"' 3

~ '"

~ ~

CJQ

"03"

0"-

~

:r~

","~

~fr

:S;5

~ =

-::;

~ o'"

_.

aq;.;

" ...

c :r

3

::I

e-.-

.~

-"

'0

0 '"

::I

~

!;I...

"'"

n

0~

5<

~

c:

~ :

:I

::I...

0'

;..

!!!."

::I

:r

-.

:r

0 0

0 "

::I

I'D

::I

.....

...

:::

::I

""'~

3 0

0 0.

.0

...

n3"'~

~an

-n

n -'"

~

...

0 "

."

I'D

'"

~...

<

0....

._.

~

~

;:;

.~

...

Era

§;--

;r... :r

- _.

:r

~

~

n <

"_

...

no~

<=

::18"

""~

cr'0

::I

~ ~

. ::I

.~

7'"

aq

N

~ _

. "

g c

~ 0

'::1

..c

...

3 -':

:1

cr'

E.

onQ

",,«

""'::

I ~

"OQ

r~

8n-

~

~.

5'

~;:;

n'

§ Q

. c.

: ~

"0

I'D

~-g

>

n-

::I.

'<::I

n

_.

::I!"

110:

:1

aq-

:::'

g ~

::I

!S

f g=

j ~

i8 ~ i ~ 0 ::I ~

f

a §

~~

i"

~i

i S

I!.

N

3...

~

iII -g

, -i i

'- 0 ~ ~ ':r :E:

CD

a ':r

Page 7: - D).homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/foundationalism-hab.pdf-0 ~ ~ ~ 2!. Cii" 3 I» ~ a.. - i" 'a UI ~:T 0 0- {Q (ii" - (=)" - 2!. ii' ~ ~ ;i...n 0 8-::I D~... n 0.... n ~ ~'i '< ~

o' c ~

:I =

j;

8 ;-

:T

0-:

1 :T

:T -

C;;'

= R

eo.

~.

~ '!

: =

:T

i a :

f S

o '8 ~

= :

T;l

:C

=

a.:T

!!!'

=

q E

r ~

II>

I~

=

=n~

cc;;'

Er

o~~

D

n::;,

'::In

na.

0-.0

0 II>

n~

ni=

:°C

Q.

;;~~

~

~. ~

..o

j ~

a,

C;;' ~

g.~

~

2 ~

e.

g ~

:I:

r ~

~l=

2: c

: ~

~r

a ~

3 ~

5

:r;l

~:.:

1.

~ 3

90 ~

=:;:

; a

~_..

a II>

:r

'<

0 o:

r ~

n

n =

0

_.

=

en _

. 0

8a

:T::I

n

=

(JQ

n

II>

n 1:

1'.

C

'<~

g <

' E

r n

'!4: j;

n

~ -

II> S

':T-<

;;1 ;.

~ ~

~:c

~

:I S

o:T

C ~

n'

n

::s n

~

en

go

-<...

;-

0

... I

I> ~

~-

:I (J

Q

if -

II>

0-

~

n -

n II>

n

~

0-

n -

~

=-

II>

~

;: C

;:

::J

~

n;::s

' =

90

en

n 5"

- 0

0..

- ~

'<

-o

g no

...

0.. -

II>

II>

=

O-:

S::J

... n

"0

nn

g 90

if

.g :

T ~

1}

:-.

C;;'

~

~

~ =

a'

~ !.

~ if

e. ;

; ~

~ i

i!';-

~'

=

n a

~ ~

ff.

R a

s

~..'

" if;

; C

~

I=

...

! g.

~

~ ~

:T ~

8 e

n II>

!!.

g n - -

:! :

I ?

;: ...

:r

"'~

... n

0

g C

g - '<

0 0

... ..

~ 0

- -.

g;:r...

:r -

-.

<I>

n

- II>

=

n

1I>

:r

II>

:r

en

-'"

(II

oi::j

'"

o :r

"':r

II>

en

n

~

~

~ ~

1

~~

.:f

[8

~

~ s

' ~

~ ~

:.~

' ~

3.

f g'

a~

[~

r r ~

~ ~

!if

g.;.

~ ~

-; g

. ~ 8

: ~

a

g"0

n'

II>

0

"O:r

:1

. =

en

0.

. -

II> e

n =

:r

"'t

II> =

en

'..

<'

8 ...

n

ii1

0 90

n =

0

II>

::J 0'

=

0 en

...

=

~ ;

; 0'

" §'

g '§

. :T

~ ~

~ 3

: 0 :r

eo

. g

~ g

C;;'

. Q:

~ =

!::.

a. 0

- n :

I R

'i 3

<

a ...

0: 0

- g

:I tII

~

~ g.

~' § l

II>

~

~ ; ~

;;

t]]

; f

~ ~

;. ~

s

a;;

g ~

0-

2. ~

a.

~.

g- ~

9-0

~

g ~

~

.; ~

. ~

~

i-

c:

0 n

- a.

1;1

n

=

n c;

;- a

... ::I

II>

n

~

...

n !J

! a.

nO

-li>

c:

~

- 0

-.

-. n

:I en

'" S

~ ;'

~

~

a ~

. §j

' ~

s a

~ ~

O!r ~

~~

i §j

' ~

. ~

g: ~

~:]

g g

g- ga

r g-

~

~.;

g}

~ g

~

~

5\o

J 8

~

-.;;

0 n

n II>

II>

...

~

-:!r

.(JQ

j:;

'!!

- g"

~

...

-

0 ...

"0

~

=

Z

j:;.!i

t II>

C

D

~ ~

g :I

: =

~

~:I

n"";;

a. 0..

~ ;

l;;

R.

:::(J

Q=

:r

~ s':

,:'

if -.

= :I

if~

;-

-.

n' ~

~. S

! a

0';

~

~- - :

:J

II>

n -

~ n

..

-. -

n-

-<-.

(JQ

..(J

Q=

II>

8a

=

-.

.. -.

-

=:r

:::.-

'o-n

_.

=II>

=n-

o-.o

'.-

"'ten

en9o

(I

I -:

ii""

II>n:

1o..o

"'O"'~

';:;

. < ~

n'"

=;r

=

!it

~ .

.. =

goo

1}

Q

;: "0

-.

- an

...:o

r =

c

:T

= <

I> .

en =:T

~

~

in...

~

!!. ~

3

ii!

~...

0.

. !.

0'

en

:5

!:;

S

-g.

:r

9-. -

...

=

if ~

c

a :ii

' n

::I

Q:

II>

n II>

0

'§.

II> -

n (I

I

: '<c

g- II>

90

~

gn9-

i =n

...

~ ~

~

8

!:I C

;;'

~ 3

~ ~

Q

_.

&.!i

t ~

8

e- 0

- j;

0'

~;:;

1;

&.

if 90

r~

n -

en

n n

n i:5

.. 0.

.0"'"

-n

a.e

n ~

=

en

...

=

n -':

:J-

;;1ii!

c"'

c~

1}

~~

o...g

~S

~1~

~i

~aC

a~~

:T~

~!!!

0...~

;;~3

~~

~~

lI>na-

~

80-'0

-::: _::J"'"

"'... ...

n -

en... '1:'"

II>:c

0..<

n

.. -.

n '<

~

=

"0 -

ag

...;

0 _.

co-

en

3 -

n -.

0 :r

...

8""

n ~

. Q

~

- n

n

-'...

0 -:

:I.

=

...

~~

:5

'"~

~ [:J

~'

::- g

~ a.

~ S

' ~

:;;: ~

~ ~

~

§ ~

0 g

:~

!if ;:

iiI ~

~.~

. J. 9

0 ~ ~

~ ~

~ ci'

~'

90 ~

@

~.

~

~ 2

if

2. ~

~. ~

~. ~

~~

~ I

~

;. g

~ c;

;-

~ ~

f ~

~

~

~.]

~

~ §

' ~

~

e ~

i g.

II> a.

ff. a

0 'i

o-!!!

. '§.

o' II

> 3'

:1

!. C

;;' n' :

r !'

3 ~

n

= -

a ...

:. !!!

. :I.

!.. ~

!:;

(II;l

0- a

;- 0

ii!

~

0-'<

c:

: ~

9-

'< ~

g

? g

(II

a :T

8

~

~

g §

~~

. [

:r~

' if

~

i=: g

- ~

&

. eo

. a

~

c: ~

a a

g s.

,e

= 0-

n

0 c:

: ~

a Z

= a

' ;;!

:; 0.

. n

... n

:r

_.

<""

II>

n ...

:'1;

: ...

c (

I)

><

!if ~

a

-n~

a ~

.~ hf

ia.~

!~

H

UH

~i

iH~

Jhl

[ni

~~

~ E

s ~ c

;;.;; -

<

~. Q

: n

:I g"

~

S'

C;;'

0 =

= ~

'9

~

n ~

g,,;

: 0

(II

!\!- 0

g I

I> ~

F ':

<

~

II> ~ a

. n !

;. 'g

IZI

~." 0 c: ::s C

o a g" m..

~"

S" I fIj- § c i ; f1"

Page 8: - D).homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/foundationalism-hab.pdf-0 ~ ~ ~ 2!. Cii" 3 I» ~ a.. - i" 'a UI ~:T 0 0- {Q (ii" - (=)" - 2!. ii' ~ ~ ;i...n 0 8-::I D~... n 0.... n ~ ~'i '< ~

n ;- §f ;n°

I\) =

0 ....

0 c: ...0 ...

.

Cc\

~

."

co0

0c ~ C

o r! 0 ~ &L

uf 3 :i" I tIl- I ; g

< ." 0 C ::I a. I» - S"

::I 2!.

uS"

3 I» ::I a. - ::r C1)

." ~ n ::r 0 0" co ui"

- c;"

- 2!.

or n '<

n ...

"0

"0

~

/j"

n I\)

- .

n "0

0.

.'"

...

/j"

0 ...

- . '"

n

.0

g';:z

I\).

B

g-g'

n ;i:

:;a

><

~

0

~ i

fn

...~

a §-

I\)&

;;:z"

,a.c

:"';:

zi...

' ~

-~1!

l-I\)

~-.

iC:I\

)~",

=-

c:

n I\)

~

n

'<

~

n =

n

'" =

-.

=

n

n n

...

(JQ

-<

n "0

c:

=

-.

n (ii

' n

0 :r

'"

'<

=

~

n (ii

"<

'" ~

n

I\)"O

-~.o

=

=n"

'O

!' =

..."O

......

...Q

=

~

~

~ c

: g

... n

~ --

~

go g

- I\)

=

.:r

2 "0

n

~ 0

.;;...

.n

/j"

_.

-, !

2,.

:r

'" 0

n ...

=

= (ii

'::t

'" '"

0 -

=-

~

n ::t

o 8 '"

-. 3

n "0

~

:r'"

I\)

0..(

JQ

0 I\)

S

. (ii'

~ I

\)

'"

1}3

0 =

g ~

n I\)

I\)

_.

~ "

0 n

~ =

A A

!if

= 0

..-'

=

n...

~ =

A

~

'"

.., i

)" 0

=

0

"0

'" 0-

n

~.

0 0.

. =30

'" no

n ::t

-c:

0-"0

<

: n

3"'.

.. n

I\)

I\)

o..a

::t

.;;0

...

0 "0

...

0

0 I\)

c:

...

:r

n

:r

n 0

=

- ;:r

3-.

......

!2,

::t- o

' c: =

-

- ~

0' ~

3

n '"

...

0..

0..'"

n

0 "0

n -<

I\) 0

c: 0

: 0

;; ~

c:

:r

0 n

!2. e

-. '"

(ii'

0 ;;

~ =

;:z'"0

...

=",

"'>

<_.

3(ii

=g<

",g8

1\)~

"'noi

i!a

~~

8 -

< i

f .B

~ ;

a ~

n ~

:r;

; ::

8 ;;.

c: =

3~

::t.

...

::to

/j"""

3

c: 0

.. ...

~

-.0

~

;; >

< :r

c:

-;;t

...

c:

3:r

0

n n

-;.;

0..

c:c:

n '<

c:

3...

...

n

;;t =

n :

r =

n

=3

::to =

0.. ~

~

!2..

'" a.

I\)

n

03

n 0

I\)

0 -.

03

...a

_. _

. I\)

...

;:r

- I\

) fA

...

~.::

:! =

~ <

...

/j"

::r"'I

\)I\)

if

<~

="'I

\)-<

"""n

~

I\)~

o..

n!2,

.C:o

g ~

~

~~

o..o

~(J

Q=

~C

:~/j"

"'n~

;;t-<

~3

I\)

no",

...

-0--

=-

"'00.

..1\)

n

= -.

=O:r

0 ...

=

:r

~

n 0

~ - 2

...

= .

..3

~ -

: n

= .

..=

. ""

"n...

Oo.

. :r

l\)...

""

:r

::t' ;;

"1'1

~ ~

~

g' (J

Q

n 3

... 0

n

!2.. n

a

:r

3 n

a -;

;. 0

n

~as

; ~

c:

oi!3

~~

~"O

"g=

'~C

:0:~

§";1

\)<

'...

;. 0

.:;.; :

:t. ~

~ I

\)

0 I\)

'"

I\)

c 0

(JQ

~

2. /

j" ~

I\)

aQ

n ~

n

,,<'

I\) -

. -

=

=:r

:r...

/j"

n

_. ~

'<

...

t;'

0g

'" ...

/j"~

>

=",

n_.~

~

nl\)

n-°n

::t...

(ii'~

-

. go

3 n

::t. =

0.. 3

~ a

0 g

0.. ~

3 =

~ <

':r

-. I

\) ~

"'!' ...

nOi)"

"'0..;

'onn

""""

'3

~nn

n==

...n

=;:z

...~

",n.

..a;:Z

:i"c.

;r~

oo

.ol\)

=80

.g'~

...~

g3

n.

~

...;;o

","'1

,;!'E

..Ao.

..~;:z

'"

~ ~

- 1!l.

:t -.

=- -.

c: =

- 3 0

0.

0_.

3"';:Z

3

~I\)

...

'"

(JQ

n

'" ..

0..

(JQ

.

n ...

n

...0

:r c:

n

=...

0

~

n :r

;:Z

no..-

- = =

~. ..

. :r

...c:

-.

=

= _

. n n

= 0

-.

~

n n

= =

... - g

o O:f)

=

.0

I\)

I\)

_.;;

...

'" ;.

'" "0

~

(JQ

n

g' ~

n 0

~ ;

. ~

&; ~

~;

::to ~

if

~ n

:r

~ ;.

~!2

,.QQ

- n

cr

=

n :r

-

= 0

=

~

_.

<

n n

n I\)

- '"

"0 '<

0

<

...

0..

I\) --

I\) I\)

(J

Q...

c:

no

n :r

:::!_

'"_.

~ ~

...

= o.

~ ~

;: a

n A

;:z

0..

0..

~

;:z =

;. 0

= :

ra

... Q

9 :r

n

c: if

it' I

\)

n 0 3

_. I\

) _.

0

_.

0. =

n o(

JQ

~n"

'3~

~"'n

...~

;:z

o~~

~=

~n"

, O

na

;. I\)

I\)

...

~

~

g

~

~

3 ?

=

=

=

~:i"

a.

8

~-

...

(ii'

...

I\)

::t.=

0

I\)

'" n

n 0

0 ...

;; 0

~

n 0"

0 ::t

.1\)

'" ...

n

'<

...'<

n

n '"

...

=

0 <

1\ ..

. ...

n

=

n n

=

I\)

N-

!l

c g.

. II) II)

~

'7

~

0' ~

;::

o;i 0

o-4

OQ

=

n c.

::!

1::1

:; g.

. = I

I)

~"'o

no

II)~

OQ

..~"'o

~~

~~

1I)

o~-.

~ n

~

~

;:: <

OQ

=

~

~

=

:::t. I

I)

Q..

_. 0

..,

-. ~

n ~

=

.!!

:J "

.::I

=0-

.00

nll)=

'7~

~=

0-."

""""

~~

=33

-.~

~

~::t

"-~

~

;; ..,

;::

0 ~

3

fir

'7

CT

go

=

=

~

3.

~

~

6.

II)

~

~

0

CJ:

:;.;::

~

3

~

::;.::

t ;-.

g 2'

"S

n S

II)

'<

;-:::

t. ~

. g.. ;

;;..

::;.~

~

:::t. g

.. II)

...

~ o

'~

n S

;;;.

n "0

n

~

o' ~

~

'7

n

8 0

~

n '7

:r

n

g..;;

; II)

=

II) ;

:?

;::

3 ~

<

..,

~

~

n =

II)

0

0 =

3

-.:1

. ~

!..

II)

<

~

0 a;

; -

:r

If.:

'7

_.

n~

~

~

~

~

>

S

~

c'

!..

a

=

:r

~

~

II)

::;...

, =

::

n =

0

=

.,...

-.

II)

0 ..

~

OQ

_.

~ -.

_. n

O

Q

n 0

~ -

33

~

~

Q

'<n

=

n'"

= .

.. ~

~

~

~

=

..,

111

II)

:r

::..

-. II)

'<...

..i:J

OQ

~ ~

0

-6' if

~::;

.; 3

:r ~

3

1:1

=.!!

e-

.!2.'

'" S

t: a;;

II)

II)

II)

~

r.

~

-.-

~ -

-.'<

~

=

II)

~

.:<

-

'" ...

=

O

Q

r:r

~ 0

3

(5

- ~ "2

=

II)

II)

;;;

. ~

n ..,

-< nO

>

S ~

. n n

OQ

n

~2:

3 &

. i

",'

i:J 0;

.:: : 2

: 5' 8

~

g.~ ~

~ ~

g. ~

~ ~

~ 3

g=

II)

~

n

~

c:r

0 S

O

Q =

3

-..:<-.

;::3_.

C!

~

=

)..;-

! ,

e: ~

~

,.. _

. _.

., _.

C! -

~

=0

'<3

'" <

; _.

('\

11

).

...-n

"'-

.-<

;"'1

1)3

"""-

'=II)

"'~-,

-",~

0

n.

n;-~

' ".

., :lR

;.;

;;'.~

g..

-o'::

;.~

~;;'

!:!

~ o

:r 3

=

-..,0

:::t.!

! 5!

=

=

n

~

g.. n

~

g

~

;;;. ~

§ ~

00'

" 11

)3

0'"

n"',~

;:-

""

"";0

3 :.3

=

=

: n

:I. =

- S 0

~

If.: a

-. ~

g '"

OQ

if~

. ~

~-.

., =

n n

II)

S

~

=

O'c

a.

II)

:::t.

S

- =

:l.

a =

n

~

~

'" 3

:--

g..

r:-

g~

..,

~

O

Q

~

=

;:;

..,

0 g.

. If.

: '<

~

0

n ;:-

::;.

II)

~~n

...

n::

:i" n

~

~

::.: =

=

'"

=

~ n

_.

=

n .., 3

"S

'" :r

,<

-<

=

=-

~=

II)

-I

I)

""~

n ~

:r

'" =

0

'" =

0

'" ..

:r

OQ

g.

. =

r: ~

II)

i:J ~

~ n

Y

" ~

~

~ !

..~

~ ~

1::1

n

!;- =

n

=

n=

:r"'~

:::t.'

::r:r

3C!

~~

O-'

O:r

~=

_.",

n n

_. 0

n

.. n

<;

:r

n <

=

0

1I)"

:r

::r =

0C

! II)

~

-

~ :rsa

=

~

~3

1I):

r -.

(;:! ;!

n

n ~

~

~

n

'" II)

0

<;

.., -

"'.,

_.

'7

_.

0 :.t

- 0

- ,.

.. ...

- =~

O

Q

n .., 0

11).

=

-3II)

n

0 :r

=

-

~

n '"'

n

'-::.

Q..

'" -<

'"0

=n'

~

,;;

;..""

",.

o:r

lI)ol

l)i:J

bJQ

.. ;'0

=

~~

3

&.

"2

~ i

f ~

;:

~ :c

~;;;.

if

~. ~

~L~

. ;! ~

~

S' ~

~ ~

a.

'<

Sn

=:r

"'"

"",n

nlf.:

g..

=no

'" ;!o

=

II) n

OQ

0

:..

~~

Q

.. s!

! ~

~ ~

~

;::

II)

~ ~

1::1

II)

::r::

... '7

~

::: 2

.. S. =

n _.

11)

~"'=

~;;;

.~_o

~

r;;=

::::;:

:o~

.n

on'<

"""

. n

i:J

;;;. II

) I

0 0

~

... :c

=

Q.. ~

3 -.

~ ~

~ 3

~

r:r-

8 .

=

... =

~

6. II)

=.

II)

II)

II)

'<::;

. :r

~

~ t:

:r

n -~

0

'<

1::1

n 8

3 ~

'<

0

'" =

S

' 3

;:: ~

=

If.

: ~

Q

. if

~.

~

~.

g ~

g.

. 0

~3

~

n "0

~

~

'7

OQ

""

" If.

: n

~

'" -.

n

~

0 n

;-'7

;::

:::t.

~..,

=on

80

:3

"'311

)~;!"

",~

~"'-

'0-

3'Q

..II)

11

)0

~o

~:r

==

1I)

:::::-

"'-3"

'('\c

-~

0

=

::;."

0 ~

~ ~

~ ~.!

.. ~

g.

. ~ ~

n

~

B-

n a

o' O

. ~. S

' ~0

=

:r ~

..g.g

Q ~

:I.

n

5. r

: 0

s. o

' ~

3 ~

~

3 O

Q

0=

-.

0

~

:::t.:

::t.

=:.

::;'.,

0

n r:

~

Q

.. =

01

1 ~

'"

~...

~

~

:r

=

=-.

0(')"

" -.

='"

..,n

"'!II:

;r::r

::rQ

) _O

ll)lI)

n_.:s

=~

3I1

)'",:r

o:r~

:r"'_

.II)I

I)Q

)

=

II)

'<=

--~

",O

QIO

~

n.

..nO

n..."

, =

C- o ~ ~ :J: ;

Page 9: - D).homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/foundationalism-hab.pdf-0 ~ ~ ~ 2!. Cii" 3 I» ~ a.. - i" 'a UI ~:T 0 0- {Q (ii" - (=)" - 2!. ii' ~ ~ ;i...n 0 8-::I D~... n 0.... n ~ ~'i '< ~

-"""

'CO

o..C

:"'-'

-'>""

"""'O

OO

"'II>

"'O

0..0

0 '"

=3:

:c"'"

,:00

3"O

1I>

II>

"'II>

O~

""c

::r

c "0

0

n w

'" =

~

Q

Q

_3'

0 ;

::1

=

::r"O

'"

0 c

;;;.

II>

;-

~

0 ::r

::1

. II>

'"

0..

'" ~

'"

=

;;;

:r~

n

1i"

0 c

t;'

'" 2

t;'

=

='

~

II>

g "0

II>

...

0

=

-"'0

'"

0 ~

n

2 Q

. =

0

cr

0 n

II>

~

n ...

~

~ ~

;. ~

~ &

. S ;

g ~

:g' ~

. ~ R

.g. q

g ~

6- R

~ ~

g ~

g ~

~ :'

§ 8

? a.

:r ~

~~ ~

~ g

'.g g

[~a.

~ =

. '< ~

a. a

..c.. R

~.:w

~ ~

&. ff

~, ~

~

~~

g ~

:r;

. ~

~ S'

[II>

~

~ 2: ~

~ a

. II> ~

~.."

, g.

3 C

T '8

~t~

'l~i,~

~~

'~ s,~

~'~

~,~

~

~ ~~

~ t~

:; 8 ~

~ ~:

w~

s,;.~

'~.~

~

~~

g.~

~i~

0 ;.

~ Q,

~ ~

II>

'"

<" ~

3 ;.;

' -0

~ 0

n

a ;

~ tT

I;;;':

:I'I

0 ~

... ~

== ~

R ...

= 0

.. '"

'" '"

= II>

~ ;

. 0

~ 11

;. 8

... -g

a.::

"0 ~

a. 0

3 ~

= ;

S;c

'-g 2:

a R.;

i ~ a

. ~.g

. ~ 6

~ 0

'" ~

g a ~

g., §'

; a

II> ~

;: ~u~

8 ::1

, if a

8 ~;

~.

g II>

g. S

.<!:9

~ ~

. a. 3

II> n,.

;! ~

~L~

'-g ~

s W

""

0 ::r

~ 3

= ~

;. II>

. w

~ e:

n ~

~;.

g c

II> 5'

... (Jq

0

::;' a 0

..,<

1i

" S 0

-<' Q

. =

=

3 ~

;. w

II>

3

II> ;

Q..

... 8

II>

'" ~

'"

n ~

II>

=

'" II>

w ~

'"

0 2;

~ =

!!!. c

~

3 3

=, 3

= -g

0' 8

C'. 0

0.

. 0

;;;':

~ &

. 2.. n

~

2!

. if 2

"'. 0..

~

0' 3

~

'"

n g.

~~

'"

s.. ~

~ 3

R' g

'.g ; =

;;;' ~

~ ~

g a :

;;;. ~

~~ ;

C' ~

: ? ~

S' a

~ ~ ~

~ ~

3 II>

a. ~ i

5'-<

~ ~

8 S ~

~ "0

~ -<

..c.. g

s"~

;..~

' ~

S' ~

8 a

..;J ~

':, &

. 3 ~

~

Ii :

r- g

if~'

3 a

o:w

~

. 3 ::

1. g.,.B

"0 n

...

0

0 ~

n

_. n

(Jq

=

0

. =

s:

: =,

=

II> 3

I'D

0

... '

" ::.

; -.

0 0

n n

'" ...

.

g a

~. =

c' g.

~ ~

'8 !-

~...

g' ~

a. ~

]

'go R

S' 3

-<' g

> ~ II>

3 ;;;

' a ~

"'w

~ ~

;

5' 0'

g

~ a

a, g !

:t~

. g.~

g'~

. ~~

~ ~

';;';:

~;

g.,~

. ~ G.

i' ~

~w S

~, i;'

~ ~

§:

9 5'

~ ~;i

a.

5" 5

§ .g

;;;

i:- g

~8

= .g

II> -<

' ~ ~

. &. 0

g-~

0' ~

2"'.

3 ~

!.~

..c..

"'~

~ ~

.~

~

;. ;'

0 =

5' 3

n ~

~ ;

g. =

. if

~ II

! '"

."'o

RII>

n"""

cnn"

'n"'l

I>

::r

~::.

;...Q

Q

no..

cO

II>n~

;'-~

O

II>~

"';'~

~ ~

S'.g

s :;;

g'

5' ::

~ ~

R 3

E. ~

~ ~

~ ~ ~

;: ~

~ ~

~ ~

:

3 a :

r.g !"

.;

e: ~

~ a ~

3 ~

-3

. Q. '"

_.

1I>

::r

0 0

II>

no'"

0..

n "'.

Q

'"

~

'f ...

~ -

, j

'" (J

q =

11

>;:

n n

0'g

. II>

g

~ ~

; ~

=

~ ...

~

'" ~

~ ~

C >

n 0

= 6

. > !!

!: g;.

g 0

:r c

~. r

0 §

;;;'::

r 0"

<1\ a ;

i ;.

6 3

~ II>

g' ~

g §

;.

g.~

;. s

. ~ ~

s. ~ ~

. g s !

.32!

. -g g

(Jq

n ::

S ~

~ 14

' ~ ~

g F

~

,g:~

. e

~"0

' ~

~

= ...

n

Q: ~

n

~ =

. n ~

;;;

' ~

o-

:g

0- ~

&

.a

14' 1

i" ~

=- ~

-3'!;-

-.

~ 3

rot

C

...

~ "

'0j

II> :

::-'0

...

0

n""

--

'-'<

..

n'"

11>

11>

",...

i-+

::r

'-cno

~ ~

"'3c:

~ 0

;;;. g

. g ...

~

8 0

g

...0~

:w!if

0

oS !

Q. 0

~

~

_3' if

'f -.

II> ;.

=, =0

' S

' g

0 3

~ -

< n

0 =

, 0

'" =

~ (J

q <

: n

S:::

:r

s::

11>

;,""

-"0

0-""

3

0 '"

~

0 (J

q 3

n n

...;:

~ -

<':.

. ~

~ -

< ~

5' n

=0' "g

c';;

! _3'

c

~

::; ~

II>

!.

~ ~

On

~ ~

'g

. II>

S

; ~

~

Q

..?

='

'" ~

. =0II>

~ 3

~...

=

0 ...

...

""n

"'.._

, "'.

..n'"

j'"

-,

w",

--'II

>-J

'"3

",-

o..w

'" g

-. 0

~ ::

r.;!

w

:r::r

O

w =

, 5""

n

~ n

S . w

::r =

_. ~

::r'

~ ;;

;,.

<

~ a

!:: ;I

~ e

: =

n -,

~~

~ if

'" ;.

a: ~

g ~

g. '"

-<' '"

0

e-.~

3 w

'" ~

~

a';

~ n

~

=

, !!!

. - g a

. ~ 0

n ~

~,

~ ~ =

g ~

g' ~

;i!

~ ~

g :

~ R e

. 5' g

- c:~

5 8

e: ~

a ; ~

~ lI>a'"

= ~

~

~ e,

~:

8 ~

;- e

a ~

!"

14

' g f

I aw

~

~~

~;.

0 ~

8 ~ '"

6-

S' =

a ~

;;;;.

a' ~

~"2

,g

.g 3

g.

, ~ if

g- ;.

: g

"" ~

g;

;f 3

~ !,

II>

~ gi

:ll>

0.

. ~

~

:-o

=1'

g., s

.. fir

II>

~

II>

n

n II>

-< e:

~

=

!.

~ o'

~

II> -<

;i S

n ~

~ g

., II>

0..

~

n' ~

;.

~

'00"

"'$1)

-'$1)

-""

.c-"

""""

Q..'

O"'A

n'O

Q..-

""$I

)n"'o

'" n-

'Q..O

Q.."

'-""~

$I)"

""

'0"'$

1)c

e ...

'"

3 '"

e:T

e

e cS

- $I

) A

...

::1

"'0

; $I

) e

:T...

A

3_'

A

$1):

:1

0 ::s

-,

0

e :T

ii)

'" 0

C

aq"O

-a

... ~

~ '0

~

C, ~

11

C,::

I A

~.g

~

~'~

.g

Q, C

, A ~

S C

QQ

~

Q, ~

e -<

[e; n

- ~;

~ ~

§

;:!:T

'O

~ 5

~ ~

~;, ~

~ ~

~ g

' [~, g

- ~

~, ~

§, ~

~,~

~ a

~ :i

" ~

8. a

~~

, 5 [1

~

g- ~

~

~ ~

~ ~ ~

~ :

!,,~

$I)

.~-

o,Q

'::S

"'n'

"'AQ

'An:

:SQ

'Iii'Q

,g.;:

;:r-

8"'~

::'a

Q..

::SA

::I

~;:;

O"'!

t":'o

-'"

"'A

Oo~

Q..1

:i!Q

..-'::

so>

<...

C"'°

"'o

",$I

) A

O'"

$I)-

,""

""""

,$I)

$I).

..:t

nA~

$I) ",

' ~

...0~

::s .

r'.a

$I)

~ ~

1; Q

, ~

2 !l

. n

~ ",

~::I

0

A

3 e

~ ~

c

... :::

::s 8

> ;

- :..

n ;;

Q, -

, $I

) ;-

::,

::se-

, $I

)-""

::S

""""

'$1)

$1)$

1)

"'<$E

""">

<fJ

~on

::l""

"$I)

"'=

::S:!3

0::s

C'"

-'Q..

Q..

Q.::

S

g.

n C

'3

::s

n'

Q..

~

- C

'" ~

:! ~

Q

, !i-

~

;:;

' -'.

.. !l.

:Ii:

'<

::s3

::IO:T

~

::s

:T

'<3'"

;;

A

A::S

n

3 A

...

Q..

0 '0

$1).

.. "I

\~,."

,O"'-

$E=

:T"O

' "'.

A

",

<A

'O

...

::s"':

T'"

"'::s

;- 1:2

. ~

~ @

;.gs'

a- ~

,~ s

~ g

: ::,

::s ~3

~ -, ~

~ ~ ~

~ ~

;i ~

~~ ;..

3 g

'; '9

, g ~

!it

go Ii

i' g

I f'

;' A

'" -,

~

::I

n

$I)

~

e ...

<

: ~

If

-,

'" n

A

'0

;:;'

n A

'"

g.'"

0 A

-,

:1,

Y'

...

g.3A

'0

"'~

A ;

:; ~ a

~

!it 0

6' = Q

.. S !

2.. ~ ;

r ~ ~<

: ':t

::s

;'

go ::

I '0

Q

.. ...0

:T

'" n

~ n

~

... ;

:: c,

@,«

!;r$l

) $I

) ~

'"

~ ~ 3

'

-'Q..C

'" $I

) -A

~

o-,..

",

~A

"""'"

:;,

::s-'<

$1

)""0

...;5

,"""

3

Q..

Et-

iir

5'

1;

~

C~

8 ~

A.a

~

n

«!

; 8

s g

~

Q..;

;, ~

;.g

!,"

8 s~

,"'"

2 :

:;:!it

~

"'~

g.

QQ

$I

).....,

.. Q

Q 30

...?

$I)

<:

::s-'.

. -

_0

'" '"

$I)

3_'

- $I

)"

-,...

...

'"

--...

~Q

Q"'$

I)3.

..C"'n

c'8.

..Q,;:

;~E

t-

::SnA

-<'",

:T-':

:s",

::s

::s:-

. "'~

"'r:T

::SO

AA

$I)"

, =

.~c'

::I

0 8

'" '0

;-

~

~

,~

:T::n

A

g

A

;:;'

$I)

<

A

...

;:;'

5'

g,,<

C

E

t-

R

~

e-.;:

: ~

'0

...

'0

e

::s

a ~

'-'

'" '<

c,

~ ;

: ~

2'

g,

n

g--

~

:;.;

If ~

g,

~

0'

S

~

~

~

~

,~

o::S-' g.

~

'0

~

~

g.

g.

~

W

~

a

~

~

&.

S

!it

'0

~

;;;.

;;::n

-A

A

$I)

___n

«!

o-t"

':T",

$I)

/)3

~

... 0"'$

I)

n n$

l)A",

8C

T...

O

An

A

-'0

Q,

~

~,n

-'<

Q..

~

<:

::s

::r"Q

Q

A

-::s

no

Q..

-,

~'"

~

0 n

...

::s

...

~

::s

::s'

A;'

'0'

$I)

~

n ~

$E

_.

$l)Q

..-,..

.o3

::s'O

-.",

:T

"'on

CT

::S

...n'

" n

""">

Q..

n...n

O"'$

I)

:TC

...Q

Q;;'

o'::S

:T

QQ

o::S

e$l)n

""~

:T"'A

::S,<

$I)$

I)8'

O"':

T$I

)-,$

I):T

::s

A

e:.

~:J

.C::S

n"

,

0'

n $E

::S

$I).

.. n

S'

~

3 ...

~

Q

~

;-

0

;; ...

;;

&.

3 ...

'"

~

~

: ;::

5'

~

Q

.. 8

"'~

Q..

g.

2..

II>::g

...

;::

Q.

::s

;;;'

0 0

$E

~

:T

Q..!

it 0

'0

;;;'::

1 ~

2.

. Q

..'"

::s

~

:T

$E3

.g

0 ...

C

::s

n

n ::s

g.

_.

$E

~.

AC

T'"

0 ;::

-<

'e:

. ~

:!.

. ;::

- =

. ~

~

0

g.

g.

$I)

0 $E

~

~

'0

E

t-

~

A

-,

'" 0

0 ;-

3

S

S

Q..

~

n ;

A

0 '0

'<

if~

, '"

Et-

::I

$E

::I

~

;: a-

8

Q..

S

n ::s

~

=

~

§.

.?

a n

::I

:r g

. 0

::s

~,c

' ~

g

;: C

'" S

';i.

~ -~

;:: e

...0

0 :!

Qo,"

8 A

~

$1)0

::s

""

"c

'O

Q..-

$I

) Q

'" -',

,<;

...

"'..

::s

"'::I

~ ~

~ g

- Iii' I

f Q

.. ~

g-'

S' ~

g ~

§: g

'~, ~

g.!i

g ~

go g

' S; ~

~: ~

;:~c:

:... ~

$I) .g

~ ~

f~ :

~

~ '"

on

n$E

_,

n...

",n:

:l $I

) $I

)a.n

:1

",n

C$I

)/)

0 n

3'"

...

'OC

Tn

Q..C

'~!l.

3 "';

...

0 -n

Q

,g

5'0"

"'"

:::r0

'O

N'..

. ~

~

",

,<

p..g

.c

l1aq

'"8

0 $I

) :1

."'r:

:I 0

Q.,<

a~~

C!!i

"'$I)

a~;-

~

nQ..g

A"':

:s03

~""

"$I)

gg--

0'::S

Q,o

A

<§.

!it:T

",3Q

,<§.

~~

cEt-

n~

$I)

~~

3gO

'!i-;

p..;:

: ~

$E...

:g.!"

~ng

.Et-

a "'F

~~

~

;::...

!l.32

..:n;

~

n "':

:g-,

~

A

::s

§

~

::s'

-t

;;;'

8::1

;:;'

0 ;::

~

0

0 g.

. A

n

a !.

"'~

$I)

~

n ~

:T

A

11

...

0 !l.

n.

a ::s

3

~

n

::S~

$I)Q

.. ",

QQ

::r::l

::s

S:T

g.

::s3n

"'3-=

Sg.

::SA

e:.

nn~

",o'

O$I

)~$I

).r'o

e:

.$I

) =

~

5!

! ~

0

0 no

;; _.

g

n ~

~

A

n

~3$1)

. ~

'0

::I

n

$I)

0 5'

~

-,

-<'

A

5';-

~

A

~

-

~

§.

5'

n .

...

.. Q

::s

...

'"

><

::1'"

_.

11

-.

<

'O:T

;i

...

Q..;

:: =

::s

QQ

=

n

ii)

'<

ii)

Q

- !it

(J

Q

~ ]

~:g

., 5' ~

::. ~ ~

£ 2

~ ~

.g ~

;.;~

'~

A

g- ~

~ $E

If ~

!, =

~.

§ ffi'

~. ~

~ ~

'Ji :

, ~

~ 8

~

8.

e:.

2..

e:.

-,

S

11

3 ::I

:;3e

~

"8

~

g §'

~

0'

s.

::g

~~

=

qg.

CT

g.

;

3'

0 ::s

::s

!G

5

~

0::S

~

.c

S

...£-

fj'=

'" "'n

$I

)~$I

) -;

""c

0>

~:..

. ::,

~"'~

Q'

3"~

~:r

n'

5.:.-

- ::s'_

o~

OO

::l

crcr

'O::I

",-

::s'O

$l)-

'O::l

O~

-sr

::s-.

;r

::!'."

'A

C"'n

",::n

A$I

)",~

,_,_

,...n

""

"'~""

""""

"""'"

1\

1\

""""

""

, "'.

.. -n

--

-"""

A

...

~G

I

CI:)

~.." 0 c ~ C

-Ia

.c)

"~ e. (ir 3 5" ~ O

J i" 3 ~ tn-

Q. or 0 0 c ....

tn CD ; ~. I :z::

;~

Page 10: - D).homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/foundationalism-hab.pdf-0 ~ ~ ~ 2!. Cii" 3 I» ~ a.. - i" 'a UI ~:T 0 0- {Q (ii" - (=)" - 2!. ii' ~ ~ ;i...n 0 8-::I D~... n 0.... n ~ ~'i '< ~

II>

<

"0

"0

II>

n II>

::s

~

_.

~

~

II>

:r"

cr

0 ::s

0

n ~

~11

>::'

".

::.:0

1l>

::S'<

~

II>n

Q..

""

0 cr

:l ~

;J

0

0..

cr

=

l; ~

n

Q..

><

"0

~

0 :r

oO.

~.o

g~

3

g...

a II>

= ~

e~

~

~.:r

~

-. II

> "

0 ~

0

...

cr;J

0.

. -.

n

=

=

0 =

...

:r

oO.

°3n~

II>O

Qo.

.~=

:rn:

:'".

:. =

: ;:;

- =

;. I

I>

0..=

' ~

3 ~

:;.,~

::ro~

n =

~no

no

n=::'

:na.

.O::t

::s

..=

~--

n..::

::/')O

ll>...

3 ;;

2.

Q:

n ~

. ~

3

~O

Q

;;-:"

n=o~

~3"

nno:

:s!!.

.?-

;. ~

II>

c'"

II> O

' ;.

<.;c

=

n c.

::t.

Q..

0 c;

=

- >

.. n

-=

n"on

o=o.

.::s

O"'"

0 O

Q

~

0..

=

~

;;.0

:I 11

>.

n;;-

3

...

-.O

Q

_.

r1e-

.~

a..~

~;;:

r~e-

.n

...

II>

M."

"::S

n

II> :

:s .

....

0.. _

. cr

c.

-.

nO:::

:/')

OQ

glI>

=

Q..=

03"O

"'an

..~.

0 ~

= =

~

~ ~

-~

on

==

"""~

n_~

'"..

Z"O

...

-"'0

8

.. ::t

o n

"0~

°:J.

8:

:t.=

O

~~

II>0=

~

~cr

cr:l

nlI>

=n

;J

:-.n

OQ

~

nO

Q -

-. n

..n

...

0.. - -

-'..

.. "0

el

l n

_. 0

_.

-. -,

~ 8

no!

n o

S;

~=no~

<§.

~3

=::s

"'--

0 =

= -

.OQ

= -

0

no.."

" ...

...

:::

:/')

OQ

..

'<

..::s

nn

~

o~

..~e-

. ;r

Oll>

o..~

n"O

....II

>~

=

n~

"""~

O~

~o

cr...

a<a;

'O~

-I g

=

II> 0

~

<

. II>

~ :r

~.

~II>

" ~

.n

;;.n.

.. ~

2 ~

n2:~

~

~3=

:;-"'=

=~

'< ~

g.

,~ ~

;.~;

~"O

.. ~

::r

"0

0..

n V

I 0

'<

_.

n"

=

3 f}

..

::s

~

=

=Q

: ~

!"

.. 0

"0

(jQ.

Q.

0 ..

...'

n ...

!!.

.. ;::

;.::r

"2..

3 !!.

::r

11>

;::;.>

,<

~n.

..nn,

<n

...,

Q..'

"~0

"0

Q

..Z

Do>

::

...

...

=-.

Q.. '

" n

n...

_::sO

'" Q

..::s

Q

..'"

_::sO

c

~

n ...

"0

:::. n

:::

"'0

n"""

'" <

0-

'"

:r-'O

"O

;::n:

r~n"

Ooo

n D

o>-,

o-,D

o>

::s-t

Do>

::r

;--o

o"

'<~

-'Do>

:r!n

' ~ :

:s -. g

...g ~

~ ::!

. Q

.. ~

n

n ;;-

~ ~

a 0

' ~

[: ~

... ~

g.. 8

c'

~ s;

:: n

.9. ~

-. ~

~

&. ~

ir Q

.. ~

~ ~

g 0

n n

n Q

.. 3

::s

~

3 ~

8

a:::;

; n

:::3...

::;:

-.'<

00

3

OQ

~

.a

~

(:\.

Do>

8

~ - 3

~

C

T

j -,

n

ri a:

::s

Q..

Do>

"'...

...

",n~

o n'

<"O

Do>

...Q

.. D

o>

Do>

0"

'" ::s

...n.

., _:

ra.Q

.. O

nJi

~

n

;:;-

c -<

g.

. ~

.: ;:;

- n

~

C

0 S

' g.

S

' E

.. g-

; :r

a.

~

a.

g

c::t'

::S"

~

a.

g ~

,~,

n n

g -:

- g.

.~::s

!'

g g

OQ

...

g.

. ~

"0

"0

~

:r

~n

§ Q

.. C

~

(I

IQ

::s

~

~

<;;"

0"'"

n S

' ~

~

~

O

Q

~.Q

_.

e-

. ::r

0

0 D

o>

'" >

~

...

::;

" ~

...

~

~

~

::s r

i g:

; nO

...

~

:I:

ri ~

D

o>

g..

0 ~

!t

e-.

8 ri

~

~. (I

IQ

...

~

Q..

1::1

~

~

ft

a,

Do>

~

S

a, 8

::s

n

~

~::r

3

~ ~

. s:

~

~ ]

~ ~

~ ;

i ~

~

~

8 ~

~

S'

~

~ ~

~~

~. ~

~ ~

~

~ ~

~

~

~

;-

i i'

~

g

:' [~

~

~

Do>

::sC

T-.

O::r

"'OQ

Do>

~33

""

::S""

"c",

°!t3

:r

;;J",

-~,<

::r::s

>30

""-'r

i...O

QO

-Do>

'"...

D

o> ~

8

E;

;:;.

~

:, -<

g-

~

0 -g

> ~

~

~

9-

2 g

0

n ~

~

~

~

. ~

'8

n

g g.

. s'

::S

: g

~

3 ~

.?

~

:r

:rg.

. <

3

...

:. ~

0

~,;;

.;::

"'~

~ r

i ~

a ~

::;"

:r:

0 ~

D

o>

;;J

...,

g:i

g..<

a '"

0 "0

~

~

0 g

...

0.. ~

g

3-'

n~~

:r::S

~E

..n~

::rD

o>

-<ire

>

Do>

8...~

-<ag

riQ..-

<~

nn~

c=~

Do>

"""D

o>~

rio"'D

o>~

'" "'~

~

::r

!!.

Q..

n 0

~ ;

e:

0'

Q..

'" ~

~ ri

j;3 ::

.: - o

' "'~

~

...

_. 0

- R

' 3 ~

~ r

l n

'" D

o> ~

...

Do>

:::. ~

'" g;

~

§ of

S "'3-'

~

:r ~

~a

~~

3

~ ~

:'~

~

R'~

~

~

. ?

'8 ~

. ~

~

~

~ g

g [~

~

~:

g. t

g ~

~

~ a

.

::sD

o>::'

: nn

n<'"

Do>

n ;

Do>

Do>

3Q..-

'>"'D

o>C

-'O""

"Q..n

"'o-n

<!!j

n.

.,O""

"o-

CO

O

r ~

8.

. g-

><

a

~

5:

0 a

;; e:

::s

0-

'" ;

g ~

~

g ::s

;-:

~

~

. g

cr

3.

g..

i?

3 ~

.!!.

&.

~

3 o'

"0"

'<

...

8 ir'

" ~

s

g 0

~

S'

:: ~

g

~

~

~

n 8

-<

~

~

r:

g,

S'

a.

g ...

::!

.::s

~

::s

n -<

D

o>

3 n

n '<

.?

0

(IIQ

3 ::s

0

g..

0 3

Q..'

" ~

OQ

~

0'

~

~

3

Do>

-.

;;'

n '<

::s

::s

-

e-.

g '"

0 g

~

0 O

Q

::s

:. '"

n ~

Q

.. D

o>

g"

~

~

8

~

R

r;

!n'

...

0 n

"0

:r

Do>

-.

::s

...

0 n

c:

::s

0...

n ~

D

o>

<

~n

-'.'

_.

3 g.

. ~

:r

'"

a Q

.. Q

"0

D

o>

Q..'

" Q

..

'" ~

n::7.

~

no~

Q

.. j;3

D

o> 5

:

_.

!!::s'

5'

a ~

30

8 ~

~

~

a.

3

R

5: ~

g.

. s.

. :

=

3 n

3 g

~

Do>

' C

~

S

D

o>

a..:t

""'"

...

--.

",-:

:s

"'"

-"""

nc

,.

00-

n ::r

::s

..

"'o_.

n::s

::;.::

sa.,<

::S~

' ~

I]Q

"'ri.a

3cr

..."O

Do>

...n"

""'~

::;ci

ii'~

g..n

'" -.

a.o,

<!!'

Do>

a ::s

::s

3

~ '

<

n ~

~

n

Do>

n

0 g

0 0

n ft

g"

:r;

- g-

Do>

...

::r

<

S

':r

0 n

~

0 ~

a

::!.

'" 3

(Si:

~

S ~

c'

~o

'g,

~

~

g "0

~

g

; ~

8

8 g

~ ~

:.

"'0~

~

~

n

c;

[g

: ~

g ~

~

J"

_3'

-<;-

~;;i

:. a

...

::snO

liQ.."

'Do>

- ::S

A

nn

n"D

o>-

::rn-

",...

...

~-,

n Q

.. a :

i o'

c

n 0

0 n

0 '<

Q

.. n

n D

r '"

Do>

- Q

.. 3

~

"...

3 ...

~ '"

n ~

0

-."0

c

Do>

Do>

(J

Q :-

"'0D

o>

3 D

o>'::

r::S

c:

oa'

a ~

a

R ..

. 0-

-<

~

:,~'

0 ci

a 5

n :r

~

:!

~

g ir

...

~

~

0 :r

Q, ~

~

'8

c

e:

a-!'

ri:;:

! 0

g. ~

~

g.

. !'

.2

1::1

~

go

~

g ~

cr

::S

g ~

C3a.

g- S

' C

T...

~

~ ;

::s

g- ~

= ... ~

~ g

~

::s g.

.o

0 0'

g.

.C~

~n

nDo>

n c;

:t ",

;:rn"

'...

Q..:

:;'n;

::-'",

o ...

Do>

Do>

n-o

'n

...

c':].

..::s

~

,,::s

j__C

n n

:r-

n-""

-'n-.

",n

3n

n ",

n ::r

"'I]Q

~nQ

..n

Do>

-.

.:::-

:r

'.

('\'

'" Q

..::S

n

n'<

...

::s

::s

_.

<

Q

.. n

Do>

0

",<

::s::S

'"

0 n

-'::r

D

o>

Do>

n

Q..

a,

03...

c'

"0

n

~~

'::7.

S

' 3 0

...

03

Q..

ir ...

"0

~

5:

Q

~

-::s

3

is..

0 0

0 ~

0

-. a

'"

~

::s .

.. ~

'"

n --

Q

.. D

o>

~ 1

::1 :;

2')

0 r:

-,

"0

~ D

o>

...

...

C

'" 0'

-

-"'0

D

o>

C

cr

Do>

...::s

...

n '"

0 Q

..~

Do>

8 ::;

-"0

Do>

;:;

' ~

'"

;::

g 2"

ri

...

~

"2..

ri2...

g.

S'

0 ~

ciii'

::s

~

3 ...

...

'"

~

Do>

3

~

Do>

~

~

...:r

...

Do>

n o3

n ...

'<

D

o> -

n n

a "'"

n

- 0

Q

..,

n --

"':

:s

- "0

0

...

a:;

n <

-

_.

'<

0 -,

"0

nDo>

"'a,n

oo~

o'

~"'~

'<-,

<

::Soa

' n-

'03'

~R

~0

...::r

cDo>

<::S

"O

c::S

"O~

og g

-1i!;

, g ;;

] E

; ~::s

a' ~

] 0

B. g

g- ~

~ ii"

9- 0

i=

r --

"0

~ 0

.; ~

~ 3 0;

::s 5

:: ~

~

~ 0

: 03

~

!J. ~

...3

n::l'

).::r

...

'n

"',C

...

~n'

O

CD

o>"'=

-'-,C

::s

><

S'

Q..-

'Do>

O

",-O

=-.

~.

~

R

: ~

~

~

?t

~

~

:-<

~

c:

S'

g"

~

~

ri ~

c:

a

g-

~

~

;; !n

' J"

'<

(JQ

D

o>

~

~

::s::s

g,

,:r

rl 8

.?

~

hTI

~"'T

I0 c: ~ Q

.a s' ~ e. C

ir3

< C)

CD C£

:::I

CO ~ ~ =+

~ 0 c:: - c:

~

-'(JQ

n

~

.. n

'" "0

3""

"'3c~

3no

c:ro

0<

'" "0

-.

'"

i1':I

:I n

_.

C

:rQ

Q' 0

~

:;:I

.. <

~

0

:I n -"

o':s

..

!!.. '<

0

::I.

n n

::I. ~

:r

-. S

:r

:rs:

ro

:I;j1

~a~

n~:r

'"(J

Q :I

an

",

(JQ

~

:I w

- 0

3 n

~

0-.

""w

~

c""-

'-3c

"O""

:I3~

"00'

" :r

~~

n

~!(

1..n

n_:In

c:-~

,,"

'"_t

ii 0

n"""

, nn

",

n::l.

....

'"3

n:l

<

~

~ _

.:r:r

-.

(J

Q ~

::I.

'" :r

~

n

:r0

n '"

:r:r

""<

'"

w

~

~

-.

-."

0 _.

~

n

::;""

n"",

""D

.~~

_.n:

l"';;:

I3~

0

><

~ e

- "0 ~

~

~

;;.

~. a

gn

0-"0

n

~

- '"

n '"

~nn

:ln;:;

?:

~:s

::l'~

nli!

n Ii

"0

'" - ~

'" 0

~w

~

~

g. a

: g

II>

9,

n~ S

' A &

.:r~

e-

5 ~

n :;.

0_.

:I :I

(JQ

0

'" ~

- !!

0

....

'n

0"":

::-""

""

' ~

~:I

~

'c

0 ~

::I'-'

:r~

w"'3

0n

~:I~

~~

~g

~nO

c38"

"8:1

-,o<

.....

:s

~

- n

C

:r:l

o.~

n

n 0

"0

:::.

- ~

:s

- n

-.

n '"

~

..-"

"'.:::

" o.

On~

Ii>:In

(JQ

nn~

"""

")01

"'-00

'"C

.3- ~

_. ~

::< ~

~

:I

~:I

n_:I~

~

~3

:1

(J'Q

nC!!!

':I"'C

{J~

;i_.

n n"

":I

~ 0

n

'" _.

~ >

< n

0 Ii!

3_.

3~

:I

"0

:::':1

""

'7

~

cw

o~~

!!n~

o.n

~~

~

..

0 ~

50 ~

:::.

~ 3

~ ~

~

n n

~

'<

_.

~

0 c

:s

..."0

3

<

; o-

~

:r:l

o'

n ~

:I

~~

~..=

n :I:

rnO

""-(

J'Q

~.

00;;;

-",:1

"":::

. ~

~

c

.. ~

:I

~

>

n 0.

3

a~~

3-.n

~

~",

~gn

=--

n_.n

;:;g~

a~...

::n

~:s

n

:r

~

_...

p 3

~

~

~:s

-.

0 3"

"C

o ~

~g2

""a;

-::;~

"O;

~Z

..n"'n

~cn

~M

O""

"'O~

w

""

-':1"

" -.

.n

"""':

::,30

-n:l~

"'~R

rt;-

II)

::.

<

0 c

0.

~

II)

""

-,

:I :s

a

<

0"

0 :r

:l !:!

. 0

30.

00:1

w

n

-'<

n o.

:s

0 '"

~'"

nnn"

""""

o-~

n:I:

"" 0c

coo

0 :::

r 0

n :t.

0

~~

...

3:1:

1~"'~

oco-

8 :"

. ri

-'0

;; !L

3

~

:I 0:

: t"t

0-"'

3'O

""...

xc:t=

-~

0-'"

<-,

0""

'"

., ~

- 0

- 3_.

'" c

-. -

"'... .

.o'

",,:t

. 3

~

0 o-

:t n

~C

<

0 - -.

-:

I n

0 :1

"'0 '

"-'c

"""-

'~

:::1:

1"""

"""

~;."

,a:;-

~-=

~

~"'I

}",

0

~

O-(

JQ - ~

~

g" ~

A

a iii'

~c:

:;~

,. en

~_O

n';'.

...'"

",

o-:::

r 0

0 en

'- -.

~ - '"

0 -"

,:lC

.3_-

:l0-3

'<_n

:::;

'<~

'" C

oo'"

",

-",

:1"'0

Q

.. n

:I~

~

.""

0- ~

~

:-.

~ ~

=

- iii

' 0

'<:t:

l I}

_.

-.

~

0 <

~

n

:I '"

~(J

Qo

no"':

I"'I)

;O;;c

~-'r

i""3~:

1 en

""",

cxgg

... a

s 0

0-

0 0

",;':

::r;;!

'7

I}

3 0

_. C

~

~ Q

.. ~

", f;-

:t.~

:I

:I:t.

(JQ

<

'0

'0

0

"':I"

~

Q..O

,::!

C

-'0

'" 0"

':1Q

.. n

Q.."

, :I

~

",

a3

C

-':1

0 <

"""

g'O

:lQ.."

"I}

:r

~

~ 0

.::

:r

0 ~

S

.!it

",

go:I

~ a

~ ;:

~ ~

g- ~

_.

a ....

~ a

~ Q

.. iii

' - c

: Q. ~

i":I

~ t ;

.""

3"'

'OQ

..n:l'

O'O

",

'"<

",

'"

:::r.

.. iii

' ~

(JQ

n

...

:::r

< _

.~

:I -"

, .9

. n

:I -;

;: 0

~ !

! ~

S ~

...

",

0 0-

'-

C

g:

...:t.

o-:lO

A:;"

,~~

",e-

.;.~

~~

~3'

~

e-.r

i;E"~

rig~

0- :

t C

""

" ~

A

"..

_.~

o'

0

- ~

n

:I n

'" -"

"::"

0

:I:I"

'~

Q..~

o~",

o"':1

§-

~

-g

g.

0 Q

..""

~

g ?

=.

0:I

-. _.

- ~

",

Q..

"""

~<

...

",Q

.."'O

'~~

n~

~

0

Q..

~

(;".

.. :;

:::r:

::r 3

<'O

n...

~

:I:I

Q.."

'~O

~~

8c:

~Q

..~if~

~

~a

~:I

::;.

~

ii'"

n ::;

. g A

~

-.::r

~

:I" C

' ii>

:I"~

. ~

a

III q

g ~

'"

0 -

_. :I"

0 _.

ii'"

~?

'? ~

S

-< S

" 3 ii

i':I

~

'"

50 % I» cr ~ 3 I» c;n

c;n-

0..

~o

~ g ~.

Page 11: - D).homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/foundationalism-hab.pdf-0 ~ ~ ~ 2!. Cii" 3 I» ~ a.. - i" 'a UI ~:T 0 0- {Q (ii" - (=)" - 2!. ii' ~ ~ ;i...n 0 8-::I D~... n 0.... n ~ ~'i '< ~

\0Q

O- :Ii

~~

~I»

~~

~V

lO~

ril»~

~3>

~:I:

~~

~V

lSI»

~aO

~~

~

g..

::r

~:s

fC

~

\0

0

- l

J I\>

C

IQ

:s-

_.

- _.

-.

"'"

R

~

~

:! ~

::r

""

-I»

0

:::;

Q..

. ~

Q

. "t

I 0

(II

~

:s

-.

=

I\>

Q..

rr

Q..

l J

"s::S

" "8

-':

:j ~

Q

..

~~

~~

~~

i~~

~g~

~;J

~~

3~~

~§~

t~~

n~~

~g

~!!

(II

~

n 7-

00

0

~ ~

(I

I g

a.

~:;.

0

0 "

0 :s

:s

~

~ :s

a

:I:

~>

~

~

'TI

O'

-:-:

- (')

0

s:

~ '"

' -.

'<

\0

~

~ (II

~

~

~

'7

.. ~

..,

g

~

0<

~

0:

:; ~

0

~

(II:S

O

\ ~

(I

I ~

a

~Q

Q

CI9

:s

:s

rr

..

0 Q

.?

=

0 !:-

!:s

~:-

'" rr

~

~

~

I»n~

~

~

(I

I"

~

<'..

2.

=

. 0

~ "

?:

o:Q

o"

.-~

~(I

I I»

n ~

-'

(II'

~

O:S

"<Q

..n

\0"

-

5'

::;

:s

go

>

,11»

co

Ji

5"

~

:-

. e-

. '?

:s

t

0 ~

~

~

~

:s

~

.. :s

-:r

""

3 ~

QQ

:s

- Q

..oa.

~

'-I

~

co

~

:::

:-

Q..

~

~

~

~

IJ,

S .

~

0Q

.. ~

o::s

- C

;;'

n ::-

~

~

'<

0 -

. ~

-

0 _.

'-I

" .

- C

"' -

0 ~

~

::r

~3

::! ~

~ -

...<

~ 0

'=

"':s

; ~

~ ~

n ~

~

~ -

!l.

~.

.. 8

;..:.

';:0

0'.

~

\0"

<;;I

..

s:

s:

n n

-.

_.

~

":S

a:

:;

3(T

I I»

r-

o:

:r

_.

""

~..

" ..

_.

~

<

...

0 ~

s:

:Ii

2

.. (I

I ~

~

~

~

g --

" :r

~

-:

-:-

~

!' ~

c;

" I»

~

:!

~

;':s-

.. ~

a.

:s-"

S;

~

:s

(II

a.

(TI

.. (I

I N

~

~ 0

~

5'

~:-

. '-I

:! :s

=

->:;:

s-

e n

r\

~2~

a.~

~

3~~

~g~

~sr

(JQ

~

~

::-

1:~

~nl

»l»§

.!!~

, ~

rl -,

-.

..,

I\>

'<

,

.. (I

I :s

-.

. -

:s

(II

~ Il

~

(I

I L

~ 0

~

e-.~

:r::

6..

< ~

. ~

o'

~

Q..

C;;3

' :s

- ::;

- §

Q~

"8

~

~ .

-,

s:

~ 0

a.;

~ (

II ~

-.

_.

2.

;:,

n

:s

- ~

~ ;:

, ::;

;:;'

_.

-,

~

~:::

; ""

0

- :s

- g.

a

~

~

:..

:::.

ii :Ii

~

i' I»

n

Q,;:

t :s

-

~

~ ~

:s..

(II

0 I»

.F

:s

O

0 a

0 I»

~

~

. :;

~

::r

rr

0';;

~

'<

a.

:Ii

t O

i ;-

~

.g

6..

~

~

c:

o'

~

~

[ :g

~

:;-

g

~

S 3

~ ~

~

-."

:s

.. (')

n

~

Q..

<'

0 :s

nO

-,

. r\

!l.

:Ii

1:

(II

~

Q..

n =

"'0

~

0

'<:=

n

2..

-,

0 -:

s ~

:::

'<

- .. 2

0 --

:=

:. ~

1\>

35'

!i

3 (I

I n

~

~Q

..,<

~

~

t'r

! rt

' 0

~.

s:

a.

3 ..

--

~

r\'

~S

:~3

1»1»

""

'(11"

'-1

- ~

CIQ

::r

8;:,

-g

.':-'"

3

;:,

(II

~

n ~

s:

:=

: g

I ~

0

5'

~

':S:::

' S

f

".

;i "';

:, 5

n;:t

g _.

Q

q ..

~!l

~

n ~

N

:s

Q

Q

n 1»

" 0

3~

-.

\0

-

~

n.:s

- -

c "

~.

:s ~

;:t

S'o

OC

l"-jn

' c.

. I»

~

,_n'

<

~

(II

< 0a.

Q..c

~

...

.0.

. I»

-.

:s

--

c.

. -

Z

-.

:s-

(II

.. I»

s:

(')

,..

~ ~

-:-

~

g.

;. "t

I c.

. i;'

3

5' ~

~.

n:

~

v;

g-

~ 3

' ::I

. ~

~

n "g

. ~

:s

~ 5-

>

~ c

e-

.:Ii

:Ii::r

~

~;;

~"<

I>

C§.

C

;;'

3 C

IQ

-'<

0 (')

:t,

::-:Q

Q

0 !!.

::.:s

:s-

-<

n ::;

- 0

c..,<

.. g

3 S

f 0'

:I: I»

~0

0 r\

ri:

S

Q..

_.

0';:;

- n

~

nOn.

.. _.

..

o:s

3:s

n~

"TIc

:S(ll

..

--

"0

o~

(II"

" Q

.. I»

:SQ

..3

1»..

~

c n:

s :s

l»n~

QQ

- :::

3_.

0"

- n

rr

.. -

_.

~

.."

0 n

rr"

:s..

VI

0'

:s

- n

n <

..

n n

.. n

:t.:s

-

n ~

c

~

0 ;:t

a:

:; :::

:::::s

I:

3 "

3 no

~:s

- a.

~ >

<

n ..

2!.

.. ~

3

::r Q

, 2.

--

a ..

~

<

i1

(II

i:'

E.

n 3

3 rr

nl»

0.'"'

~

,,'-'E

:sc0

3 n:

:; 1»

>

01»~

(II1

» >

n

... -

- "<

~

...:S

- ~

(II

--

n ,~

. (I

I..

--"

I .

(II~

. ..

- -

--

-~

N

-0

~ Q

g :;"

3 :

i 3

~ :

i ~

; ;

i'i:

a' ~

~ 4

' ~ ~

~ ~

4' ~

§ 0'

3 ~

~'

So t

; §

8 2

8 ~

~ ~

3 ~

'0 g

~ ~

~3~

[~~

~~

~1:

s~~

~~

~~

~~

"'~e~

~~

~~

~n~

~lS

o~~

~=

~~

=;~

-S

[;

g' ~

, t;~

a. ~ ~

s t

~,

3. g

~, :-:

... a

' g' ~

: ~

'~ g

. : §'

~' ~

,~ 2

[~g:

-,

~ ~

5' ~

s.;.

. n ~

1- ~

2-kt

tiii'~

Q

)"

a'n

o'" ~

Q)

n~

n~

~~

~

Q)'"

, \Q

I! ifa

r-

~JI

' go

~ n

:S

<II

0 3

S'n

~

n

~~

~

~

'.n3

"Q)Q

) ~

...

Q)'"

"'O

~o

-"'_

Cii

~",

_,

<II'

-Q

)'"

""'n

Q)

","'~

"';,t"

tl3

c..3

"0

V'>

...

- -,

n3

:r:::

! ..

- -,

~ ~

~ -

c n

'< -

-,.0

... - ~

Q)

:r<

: ...

~

-

, n

e -'.

.. n

:S:s

n

'. ~

:s

'"

0 ~

~

-,

-

~

.3

e ...

...

:r

0 ...

" ".

..-Q

) c:

~ '~

Q)

~ n

O

Q)

'" c.

. r:

:r -,

Q)~"'

0 :s

.:0

...

nOn

~ ~

~, -

,On

-,

e

...

n n

n -"

J ~

~ :::

.;:s

:s

n V

'>'"

'" :r

:S

<II

en'"

...

<II

0 r-

<II

~

, ...

0

:= 0

n 3'

" "0

t;

...

0 -,

n ;;

0 n

~

0c.

. ~

r 0

~ 0

-:

: -,

"0 Q

) ...

n

:s

o:!!!

, g

- ;:;.

a: ~

- I::

> :s

~

Q)

e 3

' 'l-

<"

=:

e-.:s

0

~

:! :s

- ~

~;,

~ -4

~ =¥

~ g

~ =:r

;- ~

~ ~

~. ~

~

F g

~~

~ l

~~

~ ~

a >'"

[~o-:

~' §

.'? en:S

a ~ 3

~ :"

~ ~

Q 3~

"""'I

:I~Q

)c.."

'no

~07

""

:r

-. "

,'"

nOO

~

'"

~

"""N

:I

...""

~,,,

-.

3 ~

~ 0

3 ~

~ ~

~:s

~ ~

:r

~ g'

a ~

~ a

~ ~

if 0

~~

~ Q

:'

~ ~

g., ~

s r ~

g <

' n

~ ~

£' '8

[§.

~ !

! ~

,~ ~ ;

~,t;

0'

~ So

~ :I:

~ 3

5'

i ~ 2

'. g ~

~ ~

, ~

.::s

~ ~

'8 ;

i,.:r

~ ';-'

~ ~

g., ~

s ~

. a' k

~;-

]1

:!.!1

fS ~

~

g.,::

,g.,~

3 ~

c..S

o~

~~

g..~

:S"a

§ ~

~g

~ i

faq

~ ;

;;,5'

QQ

;ig

~3

2".§

~

g'~

n ~

~3~

~ ~ ~

~,~

1 a

g- ~

~ ~

~ ~

g:

::- ~

a. 5' ~

' ~r r

s: ;0-

i@, g

; ~

~ ~

~ ~

;. ~.g

~ i

~ ~

;. ~

~- I

::> 0

'"

n Q

) :::

..:S

e -,

Q) 0

Q)

Q)

, J ~

"t

I <

II c.

.::2"

, 0

!!!'"

0 <

II'.:S

...

-,

~'..

. c.

.'"

0'

"..

~g

~

l a

fi' J

: ~ n

'~:i

~ ~

~

a:'g

, ~ ~

3

~ ~

g =

~

~ 3

g:<

:.o~

,~ ~

~

~ if

; ~

g if

iiie' ~

~ ~

~ g'

... "0

"'.

.. Q

) <II

no...

e

-, 0

3 <

: r:

:r 0

:s

Q

) ).

:-

. Q

):s

...:r

n

<'"

- -, 0'"

- n

""I

Cii

~o' ~

~ ~

a. l

So g

Q ~

~ ~

~...~

"g

==

~

:: ~

~ l

~ p. ~

~

'~...-,

3 (JQ 3

~ g

So ~ ~

:- ~

<' ~

:I

So Q

~

...,

s'- ~

Q)

<

n..."

'",

3 :s

-,

c.. ~

'J

-,

n

Q)

<II

:;r

r::r

Q

) -

-, n

3'<

."

:s

:...

o'

::I,

Q)

~

n ~

5:

go

5'

S

r;

,.g

g 0

~

~

:i~

Q

~

~

Jc:

iii'

g.,

Ii:

g-!it

...

0'

~

0

~

:-.;;

~

e-

. r:

:r

-~

i;!

~r:

:r

- ~

Q

) ::I

,...

0 n

n Q

)...

"<

n '"

-,

n "'

- c

Q)

...

- Q

) ...

:S

e c.

. 3

"<

<II

:s

tII

...-

n e

I::>

:s

Q)

n :s

2

...

n n

-'.,,:

S

'" ~

~

~

n

,-

n...

Q)

r::r

c.

."O

:r

...

...

-'::;'

n

-,8

::I,

>..'

" ~

0' :

, - j:S

:-.::

; Q

) '"

~ "<

g

...

... ~

go

> 0

' r!

'I n

n rn

n ~

~

n <

II ...

n

2 8

So:

S

"<

=

'" e

k><

- c

::...

...

n :r

0 ~

Q)e~

;:;'

~,

g., e

e

0 0

n ..

=

f\ ~

3

go 3

...

e a

!if n

go:s

n

5, a

.. ~ Q

) ...

.It

!l.

\Q

~

3 ~

O;:r-

g

",

3 Q

) 0

"0

"0

~

So e

:S

::I: ~

~:s

- n'

g

~ 3

:s

g Q

) g

-, ~

a ~,~,~

, Q

~

~ ~

Q)n

(J

Q"'O

=

n"

'c..

Q)n

o~

"'Q).

..:sn

<ll

3=

<

3 ~

...7"

"'~~

:-.

3 f:\

':r

~

=

::I,

n ~

~

Q

) 0

\Q

3 S

o ~

..,

;,t

~

::I

, ...

:s

0:

::;

S'

~

"0

<II

~

!l.

<II

~

n :r

~

5!

';-

' 1;

;'N

<

II ~

...

c.

. -,

Q

) Q

) 0

-,

f'\

"0

'-I.

-,

<:,.

. ~

"0

c.

. r-

:r

0

S

n e

n :s

-

e n

'<

...

...

::I,

n >

...

;:r-

~

...

~.

;:;,:s

:s

:s

r:

:r~

::f

, n

-~,

!!,

<:

Q)

n'

f:\'

"0

(JQ

-,

Q

) ""

""

...

...

;:;-

<II

;:;-

<II

:s

_:r:

r 0

0 ..

:s

~;:;

- :s,

?) 5

' 0'

2

c g

;:;- 0

~

a ~

) a.

a. ;-

~

.!'

n:;;

, S

o <' a

. :r

n Ii:

<II

C ~

5'

n ~

~ :s

~

~ ~

~~

~

Q)3

.,,;

~o-:~

...

3 c:

:r-'?

~ [

g c:

a. S"

t::

~ -

, ;;;

' ~ :

0 :r

;-

8 l

~ ".

. ~

-, g

., g., ~

;- ~

~~

e

~ -

8r:

:r...

...

-,

- - >3"

-. ~

:s

I::>

I

> :s

-,

c

0 =

a:

:; :s

n :r

~

Q

) "'::

; =

!:s

3 0

if ~

[~

~

~

: ;- i

f 8 ~

~ ~

i}. ~

~

' ci' 'i"

!'-

.. ~

~ ~

3, a

. e: g

~ g

1, 2

;: =

, ~

s 2

"':t

Q)

'it.

~ ~

~ ~

~ =

~

:s,;.

~

E; l'

~ ~

a'

3. ~

1;;'

~ ~

~ ~

~' ;

~ g

, ~

s ~ g

o ~ g

;: S

o a Q

) ;.

P.

n~~

~~

S99

n9~

:r

~c.

.-<

" ~

~~

~

~c.

.~9~

~S

~~

~~

n~~

=S

JI';~

~

Sct

(Q en"'T'I

0 C :I Q.

a~

~

cr_.

(JQ

:I;.

c:

I!!.

03

Cir

Sg

3c:

-.

~

II)

:I

t g'r::J

: c:

n

a.o

~c:

(JQ

Q

: U

t::r

en

;;; .

!l.

Q.

g- 3

' ~

.~

. :i"

g

n II)

C

i1 ;.~

CD

8 CD

...:r

:T

...

...

-.:::

. 0 n"

'O

en II)

...-0 II)

cr 3n g".3 '"

o' ~ !"

<.N

z 0 - CD

en

a.~

N

...V

I.0 ... cI ~ :r " 06

'"[ is

:" ~ '" ~ = Q

.n ., a: n 1;

;.

3 !"

c..

~ CD

"Q ::r ~ CD

a ::rC

D,

Page 12: - D).homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/foundationalism-hab.pdf-0 ~ ~ ~ 2!. Cii" 3 I» ~ a.. - i" 'a UI ~:T 0 0- {Q (ii" - (=)" - 2!. ii' ~ ~ ;i...n 0 8-::I D~... n 0.... n ~ ~'i '< ~

N ......

..

0-;:;

-;'>

\I>

::r

II>

:I

=\1

>...

=3

::.

c:3

\I>

'"'<

:I

"0

c:r

., 0

=

~A

::.

fit 0

c..3

1\>

--~

"O

:I Q

~~

§ a:

~

c..

c.. f

A

()c:

ra::r

° '<

-.

I\>;l9

D1;

i;I

~.

!!:

0'I:

'" n

/")

;:r

::I

/")

=-.

.0

'"

~>

:Ia.

~.

~.2

0

...

':!

=

:I

CT

'I~g;

.;;.

a.

. :::

: . ;;;

.

;:;. . ~

"0

...

...

-.0

()o~

:j"o

V'>

'"

...n"

O'

;:r

'<

_.

V'>

--:In

...

\I>

'<

°t:l:

lO-

<::

n :I

I\>

~:Ic

..t:I:

I~

go;

;;. g

~

c:r /

")

::r()

-.

0 \I>

I\> c:

r =

c:r

3~~

~g-

c..n

~Q

.: "T

J ;.

IJQ

IJQ

r:

-. =

~nc

..!;Ia

N

N

NN

N

NN

--~

~

~

~

N-O

\c

~

:> "

0 -I

III

- . '"

r.:;

...

'- :t

""i c

: !!!,

. (")

D

> "

"'"

_. -.

"'tI

0~

. ::r

° ~

n D

> D

> ~

=

(")

'" -.

D> =

.

D>

~ ~

'"

D>

(")

~

n :!

D>

~

n =

:>

=

. ~

).

. ~

~

3

c..

~

~

~

~

11

::.("

).

n:!:r

.:r

!!!,.

:;nn

~

='"

1:7"

1:1:

1.

-~

~

JI'

c..

~

0::;'

~

:i"

~ g

- ~ 3

<.Q

3

:1. ~

~ J

I' '?

'? -

"0

3::t

n n

c..

5'...

...

D

> 0

~

0

c..

=

D>

~

N

N

\C

C)

a-

-g

~~

. '3

. S

: ~

;to

g'

JI'

~::

~

e-. ~

e:

=

- if

~

S.;

s~

:1

. :r

=

c.

.:r

n ~

" ,..

:; "0

:: ~

c:

c.

. g

. £;.

. ~

:r

. ~

~.

g e-

. ~

n

S'

='-

"0

:i ~

2.

~

.

'<

'?

n'=

~

'" <

-"O

!:!I

~.

1::0

-.

< -

. r1

0

- :0

..,

n' Q

: ..."

:r...

S

:: 0

~

- 0

n ::=

. o' ~

\C

:s.

::r:=

c

:r;;

~

"'"

c 0 -0

=

:!

D>

=

:: \C

S

::...

~

~D

>n"

,;;;"

J",

-"'0

-'=1"

""

. o

:r ~

5':-

: '"

n :r

0

~ ~

~

~

Iii ;;

::'.

~S

' ~

n ,,'

:-

~

. -.

'" "'t

I ~

~ ~

-

c..~

~

8!};

;"O

~S

::Q~

~~

~~

~

C::t

=

;:c=

' _.

""'~

<""

"-'

"""

n ~

;;t

c..

'" \C

n

'J

o -.

JI

' ~

-.

'A

'<

:::

. t!'

J - ~

<II (

")~

n

'" -

O' ~

::

- -.

~.

.. ).

. ~ ~

-

S 3

~

)..

= :

:r I

:\.

:r ~

-. "

'" z

~

'<

~ -.

D> O

.!j;;;

. D>

1\'

D>

~

g ~

0

'?

"-I

~

N

~

=

~",

~::t

;i:

r O

~~

~D

>::-

~c.

. ;:

n ::

~

3 _ 0

'" - - =-

"0 ~

. c:

~"O

=::t

3:

:tD>

.

\Co.

..:::

::t~

~

I:\.

0 D

> ~

3

g ~

= - s

. ::;

....

..."t

!'J

c.."

'&tc

~

"O-:

:otA

r ~

nVl'"

:n

n.

-D>

""

'\C0I

i",

0c.

. C

,.

n <

...

~

"'t

I ~

11

~'

1::0

ji;'

><

D>

:r::t

' D

o n

:r

_.

'" c.

,. n

n 3::t

=

-

"""N

..n

oo

~=

0

S::~

:: :;'

~3=

Qq

~""

'O-'"

'"

(") 3

~

n ii

;;;;

\C ~

~ 0:

1 ..3

~

~("

) "0

~

:;"

~

- 3

. -.

!!!. ~

-.

0).

.~::t

D

>"'3

C:O

=

",0=

>

<~

-~

~

; D

>-

~~

~>

Z

'"0

\c

...

D>

::n c

.. ~

"'t

I :!

c.. ~

3 "' c.

..

~

...

'" -':

r ..

"'"

D>

~

~

~

... '"

~

11

3. ::

n' ~

' J ~

~

~

~

sa...

-. <

0 "'.

D

>

c:~

~

""

'3n"

, n"

",3

=~

"0 o

:r

;'

:: =

. 0

~ :r

1:

7" D

>

;rc.

..;2

. n

n D

> - "0

n

-,:1

:;0

:: n

- ~

'" ",

"':r

'"c.

." '"

-- ~

Q..

n D

>

... -.

D

> -.

V

I '"

)..c

.,.~

...

=1:

7"~

~

="'~

n .~

~

. ~

0

c..,<

'"

- c.

. D>

.. =

'<

I.H

I.H . I.Hen

Q..,

.,"O

-. -I

C)

c:nl

:l.

i'1:r

~1»

z ~

~ ~

0 s;

~. S

-<: ;

:;. ;:

;. C

~

::S:r

-.

-.

~

0 g.

.~.-

.

:,o;i~

,I»"'n

:!~a

-.'"

= ~

1:

1 ~

",=

,;:~

nO::s

~

:"""

iiC)Q

.stl.

..~\0

;:-

_.

n ::=

tI :r

\O"C

)~=

'°I:1

'<

.."'"~

~E

.8~

5.C

J"O

i::s

l»=

' ~

::sO

. --

:::r.

~

e

1:1

='

...

~"o

",

"".~

=

,~=

,CJ~

\0

-.

,.,

'" Q

. '"

;:-

n.

'0::

n I»

0

....

"='..

. =

' 0

-.1»

C);

no

='

~

::I.

"'t

CT

... I»

~

~0

:r,<

3

...

"0 -.

§ t:J

II~"'~

N

"'3

I:L

I» -.

I»3-

Iii'"'

<

- 'v=

' ::-

. n

n.

..Q

.,a3c

a :i"

~I»

=

,'"g

n ~

<. ~

<

-. R

:r

n 0

!:.~

<a~

~

if,-

.."'.

_::.

='

, J;;i

_. =

'..,

::I.:r

N

CJQ

'<

... -.

=

',,'

~. ;

;;. 2:

g..

n<

;;. ='

ca.

n

~

:i ~

0

1»""

n

~""

"""'"

Q

.Z

"O

'" ",

:r

.:....

i=!

Q.

c n

~

0 n

-.

CJ

<~

3:r=

' 0

-<: -.

-. ~

. ~

::sog

;~i=

! ~

~~

S.0

~

':'

IN

INN

-C

T~

_.

II>

Q.C

.: ...

"0:' .

n-.

..~

w~

:::.

Q ~ r;;- ~ ~ ~ " :i " ::t :" '? - ~ ~

W

N0

~

::..8~.

.. '"

'" '"

n ...

"0

::I

0 _.

n ..

.. "r

1 '"

~ "

0 '::

1 -.

-

- "0

-~

:r

nnn~

:r~

~::I

::Ion

n",~

J~..O

o::l~

~..'

"()

2.

.. ~

g.;-

8 ::

I ~

~. a

... !i

S:.!

f &.~

~ ~

~.~

. 3

!i ~

g g

.~()

::I

C

3

::I a

n-.

0 n

-.

~

n n

a:

:r

_. 0

'"

n C

n"

O.?

-- ~

!7

E

f '" ~

~

S ~

-<

~ !

!: a

~ ;:;

;; (

i J:

~ '2

.. C ..,

~ J&

;g 3

~.

"0'

~

n -'.

.:;

! C

T ~

-.

:t. Q

Q

~

CT

0

Q.::

I ~

n

n ;;!

~

{ij'

n

gg .

3"0

~

'" !:

0:1

:-. -

Ei 0

C

~

'<

::I

C

...

'T

J::I

0 n

-.

0 n

::'

DO

. -.

C

C

~

'"

{ij'

::I

n...

-::I:

:r.,

Q.

-.

n D

O

-.

'" ...

-.

0\

.,,::I

!""

g.:r

:r

~

-.

...

o'

~

'<

Q.

0 D

O

0 c:

: ~

:r

;; &

!:r

~00'

""":

;iS

' n

"0

!! -:

::1

:r:2

!:

..,

n..C

=

-.. :

:I - "0

0

S'

...

{ij'

-.n.

.. .-

~

~ .

,.,: _

. <

: Q

Q"

'" -"

"'..

...:r

n

!: ii1

:to

0:Jo

':to

'?

~ .

.. '<

Q

Q ;-

~

:r

C' ~

(i

!"t..

0

~

n ~

~

CT

0\

~

nO'"

...

n _.

0:

:1

~

-.

""..:

:r

<

""""

n

. ...

3

{ij'

3 :J

. n

~

0 5:

<

s.

::I

::I

...

~

::=

'" n

s.:

8 1:

::I

n

~

~ [~

~ Eo

~' "

g. ~

~ ~ ~

QQ

::

~ ~

tl'c" g.

. ~ =::

~ ~

§t ~

.g ;

n~

o-!::

I_.o

n"'_

",

QQ

DO

o:r

""!"

t..~

"'n~

0

=::

~

a.

~

:J.

:r

n ::I

...

n

:-.

n 0

:r

",'

a...

n 0

::r

'" ... 0

0

{ij'

n g.

0

-. -<

{ij'

n Q

Q ;-

~

Ii ...

3

*'

~

0 ~

~

;:s

n

3 g.

D>

n

()

n ::I

!T

{ij'

~

~

;;!

~'::

I S

f n

D>

..:

:1.

DO

0

~

C ~

n

&.g

!!:"O

ng~

~~

::I~

::I~

0~3~

~"O

~"c

~0:

;;!

!T

(3

£ <

n

:r

0 ::=

<

Q. ~

;:;

'J'

3

;:s 2

. ~

O

Q f

A "

0 ~

.:r

~~

'<C

T~

::I~

!!:~

3g..~

CT

:ra-

gi;:;

"'~f5

~8

n '"-

:r n

"S! g

~ -

< -"

.. g

II ;

'<

n - ~

...

::;. 0

0' ~

::I

~

DO

~.

as. ~

~

3

1: 3

'"

Q

::I

n -.

'" D

O g

a. ~

.--

'<

-."

~

.."",

~

a.~

"'o

~-

..'~

~g-

~

::I~

a~-w

",

-{ij"

00'"

~

~

.. -.

:::'..

.c:

:a

.. C

~

~

0

~

. ~

~

~

<

:: c:

::.

-":r

~-~

'

n-'.

::I:J

~-

~

~-.

n ,n

3DO

~

... -

. 8

...

<

::I -

'" ...

Q.:I

0

~ "0

"0 -

n :r

~

<

: -.

~ <

.Q~

~::I

°nr!

!:7a"

O

. ::I

g..;

~~

DO

..:r:

:l-n

;:SQ

.="':

-""~

;;"

,' "'>

«JQ

.w~

"...1

:~:-

'Q.::

;~

~ 0

;:;";

- ~

0

s' (JQ

5"

~ g

o ~

D

O 0

N

~

0

ii1 ~

;-

Ii

~ ;

;.Q

. ;::

:.!::

a'::I

ij:

! ::I

n

Eo

~

-:-

'" 3

; R

::I

~

::I

N

n ::I

-"

51

~

r Q

.E

n

~

0 n

n n

~

-.

0:1

n ~

'"

n~'

~

~.

=-

...

~

S'

~

00

o' ~

<

..3

:.. ~

::;

. S' ~

C ~

DO

CT

~

:r::l

I

~. g

{ij'

::I (J

Q g.

~~

r;:s

0'

~

'"

;:; DO

{ij

' (J

Q

... :::

s ;-

~ ::

~ Q

. ~

d6 3

"0

a:

Er:

:l 0

~

...

51

C

~.

~ a

!T:

:r;-

S

' 0

0 :r

I:

;;r ~

~;;

it ~

0

*'!!!

. n ...

1:

::I

fA

n -

~::I

~

3

~

:;-

iIr"'"

~

a.

Q. ~

..

-. ~

-<D

OO

CT

::I&

!g.::

I;~::=

::I~

1:D

O~

~~

og~

~aF

...3

n 0

~ 0

n

n..

::I

~.

-".

- - &!

0

c::

n ..

CT

'" ..3

g. n

:r

~01

3 -

. C.~

'... ~

.,<

Q

.. ~

C-;

:;;C

T

°3n<

~

0(JQ

"'co:

:;""~

"'0~

3;:S

",,:-

.::I

0 ~

. ~

3

'" 8

~

0 (J

Q

-..

n ~

D

O C

IQ

n ~

::I

=

Q.

~

~

0 a

"3

C

~

::r

a.

0 ~

~

~

;; a:

W

;:;':T

~

\T

"'"

iii'

go

'=r .

n ~

~

S

n

fA ~

~

0;

' a

~

1: -

<

~

~

s..

7 ~

{ij

' ~

~

~

3

{ij"

~7

f

...'-1

0\

I",

CT

:= C

") 8

~

<ii'

:r;.

3 ~

lTI:::

' II)

=

"'3

c,;

-,

- n

n -

3-

"""

c c

-,

-,::I

"

0 ""

-'3

-.~

n::l

"""'"

~

-'"

"';:0

--

~...

"?

~

g, 0

0

;;::

~

~

~

...j

"'~::I

::I-.

t)=

",~

II)O

~

N~

cn...

Q..~

~::s

"'n~

~

II)

0 if:

;;1I)

0

O~

::I..,

C

C

.,

--"

~

Q..

'<"';

;!n~

n:r3

~=

"'~

~

nO

n ~

Q..

<ii'

~

~

a 0

3.:;J

-,

::;r

-'~

3~

c

--3

g-J6

5;

;; ~

II)

~,

., II)

5

Q.."

o C

=

"' =

"' ~

Ii:

fJ

a,

-,

'<

., ~

~,

;:;'

fJ

~

~o

~ n

fJ

0:

1::1

=

"';.

"?

::C::l

::,

~

.g n

~

n <

ii'

t:~g

;i~-g

~

a

g ~

~::

"o

., ~

::.;;

fi

<"0

=

"' a

::=

Q..

- ,

-.

.,::1::III

).

n n

v "'.

.. ...

~ 0

- a

0 ~

g

if;'~

v II)

<

II -,

Q

.. ""

-,

n

n

n '"

...

""::I

::;0

<ii'

0

-';.

0 Q

...g

~a.

0

.::

~

n 2.

.;:-

fJ

"0-.

--

1;

; 0

3 '<

Q

:::,;:

::I

o;.C

O-'

~

5"

$~

~

n ~

::I

:1.

C")

i4

-,

n

- ~

>

~ -

I,

::1"'0

- =

"':T

~J"

O

OQ

C

!l.

~

II)

n

n

- .,

"0

-,

n ::I

...

.,

v no

"On

aQ..="'n

"0

30

--

""

n -,

. n

'" ...

0

""

., '"

'-I

0 II)

n

=",

., =

"' II)

l","n

Q..I

I)II)

n=",

-.

~=

"'o-:

:: ;;-

;.n

0

o-oS

ifa~

g~!l.

;.

_.

::s

~

::;.

Q..

.,

"'~::o

::l:<

ii'~

n~

II)

if

3 ~

5'

7

~

- ..c:

(") 'l'

0"

'0

:r::s

:r

C

<I'Q

...

~

cr~

"g..;

:r~

~

A

::t. -

. ~ A

2!. a

i1..;

- go

~~

-I~

~t;~

~ ~

[a

: !II

~a

0' <

~. >

J" :

0 ~

~

6..~

'-

::2. "

0 A

\C~

~.2

~::s

~J:

o~g-

c;:-

~

~

"0

"O~

::;3~

0;,.

. ~

t;g::s

N..g

" -.

e.. - .

...

::l. C

e..:

r~

g R

<II

A.,.

~

e.

. c

_.-

age.

.

~>

~n~

~

;!. 3

~

0

~g&

.;.""

(")t

iA~

O'

~

...

...

3 ;':

:S

I\)

3

~ :

. !S

. g- ~

-'::S

A

::s

N'

ci" 2

~ e

..:;.

A -.

A 0

<I'Q

~

::l

::s~

0

0 :;.

<

II...

e.

<

II <

I'Q

Q.

:> <

II 3"

" g

.. ~

"0

;r::l

.-

:n:t

'<on

~

~::2

. "0

~

3 C

!9. ... 0

~

o::s

Q..

t; ~

g"

~

CD

0 C

»c: ~ 8. g I!!

.(if 3 5" f fA U

J-~ ~ 0 fa C

D~ ~

. N 00

'?

~'?

0

~ ~

\QnO

OQ

..n>

Pn:

'ln3"

~

6.:~

~

'?

~o=

i0\

Q

~"O

:'Ion

'":t

;.ga

n n

Q W

...

""":

-n

"On\

Q

~

8"10

00>

"O

~.9

fir

- :I

W

.. n.

.:r

~

S

.'?n

:r:l

t...I

~

~ c

~

3 ;;.

2.

.

n <

"

a..

::I. ~

~!.

~~

=3

..--

_.

O'~

. !A

~

;::

0> ~

!A

:r:l.

."0

n

Q.. '

<0

3"-

:I W

.O g

o Q

:t:

~q"

:r

.. 0

n 0>

0 1:

:1

<II

7'

~;.~

;:0.

~

0>

<II

~

'" 3

00>

0

;;':1

~

:::-n

o:r

~

...t;

'<

~nQ

..W

~

C

'

~

~~

;.W

~

-n

C-

o (I)

«I '"C ~ ~ CD

;~

Page 13: - D).homes.chass.utoronto.ca/~jheath/foundationalism-hab.pdf-0 ~ ~ ~ 2!. Cii" 3 I» ~ a.. - i" 'a UI ~:T 0 0- {Q (ii" - (=)" - 2!. ii' ~ ~ ;i...n 0 8-::I D~... n 0.... n ~ ~'i '< ~

"T1

0 C ::J a.. a <5"

::J

§:~

~

~~

~8:

I:~

~'?

]!';i~

~~

>3

;'~;i~

~;;

~ §

:::g 9

o;i~

e-.]!

';iM

~;i

;.Q

.. ~

~

'~ Q

.. '"

3 ~

g- R

c,

in

' ~

=

~;:;

- ~

;.

~ n

no

(')

11>

"0

0"

:t' >

< in

' >

~

C, n

~

(')

n

~~

~ ~

~ ~

i ~

§ ~

-: ~

~ in' !

~ ~

~ ~

~' ~

~ ~

~ ~ ~

!, t

i

[~ i

:;, ~

~ <

~ ~

5'

, ~

> 2

..,

:, 11

> n

:r:;'

c,

;.

\C

QO

>

~ ~

11>

::-

~

'" "0

::;

n J6

!:: "

,"

;;J ~

0

c,

c,

2. "0

0

::z::

to.>

l",-,

ii"O

'T

:!n'"

311>

-,0

nl",

::!;ii

"Q..n

,<

0'...

0"0

, "'Q

..~

",o:

Io,-

po=

,' --

iN

~

><

=01

l>no

"""=

'~

><

~

, :r

e'

0_,

;:.-=

04"

=n~

-QO

1I>

r ~ (')

~

~

;: ~

'!. ~

~ g

- g., '8

"E

. ~

8

~,

;;, ~

,g

S-

.~

;.

a ~

~ ~

-, a

R ~

g, '?

?' g

-,

:" 0

. n

;:;

" 11

> 3

Q.. ~

!!!,

=

~

to.>

~

.., Q

.. n

~ (JQ

n

ck.

n '"

n ::s

~

'" .Y

' ;:c

Q..

=

:::~

~ g' 3

~.Y'

~ 0

' g. 0

0'

'..,

~ 8

~ ~:r

~'?

, ..

6';:;

~ !

l. or

~

n'

0' :

r ~

A

(I

)~0

::r '<

11>

0';'

...

= -

< 3

= ::-

(')

11>

"0

::0 e

~

=

:r::!

, ~

:0

:- \C

:r

e ~

-,

(I

)

~n=

==

n:r"

,..."

,O

"'oo~

ii"~

na

;:;on

~

g~~

~n

g ~

~

0 U

U

~

..

n e

:r~

' --

;:

... .

. n

'" --

..

\C

~

Q..

11>

se

~ ..

:! .Y

' Q

..;'

~ Q.

. n

'" V

I ~

-<

!l. ~

0

e,

'" --

g

~ \

C :

:r"O

'-

c, i

n'

in'

0~

Z

in'

n ",

' n

~ '"

::t

n

;: ;:;

,,<

;;:' e

R

"0

g

= 0

-= 0

'?,

0 a-

e-

. c

'?

g., 0

a ;;.

11>

~'a

3

:r a

. .g

" ~ 5'

§ ;:-

~

-<

(3 ~

'" p

;0 3

N ~

; n

~

~'1

:1 i

~

;r;;

n -,

0

t"'"

('\'

- !t

-,

a-;.

Z

' 0.

.::

i e

CD

~

~

~,

g'

~

!f 8

~

~

~:~

~

~

,~

~

4'

8 2:

~

g.

in

' ':'

:"

~

~

! ~

3

g ~

;

;:r,

~

0 in

' 0

~:,:

I: 0

"0

-"'

g:

;. -9

, ;.

"'.

~;

go::.

c V

I g-

:"

3 ~

~

(;

-11

> ,

--

=

--

Q..'

" 11

> =

::!

. ~

t!'

I 3

n ~

n

Z

in'

:: n

-,::t

n

~

11>

0'

=

(I)

-~Jg

o03

:ra-

:::=

~

~ng

~

0 '"

~

- ..,

...e

-~

an~

g~2.

~~

~

~f~

;;.g,

,~3

3J~

~.~

~

~~

~

'" §

"0

n C

Q

.. Ii-

3 i::

- :;

11>

CJQ

t!'I

n 11

>

~ 11

> e:

0

0 -,

0

0 11

>

"08

~ ~

Q..

~

11>

11

> 1

1> n

~

C

"I::-

: Q

::s

~

c,

:r 0

' ~ =

:I:

:='

:2,..

:! c.

'?

e ~

~

8

e q!

j :a

::~

if' ~

~

g- n

;:;

's: Q

~

-. =

:r

c:

11>

11>3

~ 0

:a

\C

... "0

-"0

=

n

=-

3:r

..

QQ

11

>~

" -

- =

CJQ

:r

=

=

-- .

. 0

~ "0

!l.

0Q

.. n

'<

0:::'

::-

, ::,

-;;

Q.. '

<

Q.. "

" 11

> -.

'" '"

0 .....

~

I~

,'"

n ..

00",

-'","

', n"

'e<

>~

-,

...

.~

a-

!!!';

;J

0 11

> '"

~

:r

::s ~

n

3 ::s

~ ~

~

J a-

;:;'

Ie! ~

-c:

:-.

] S

3'" .

-.

n ...

...

=

3 n

.. -,

~

"' n

"0

~...

...

:r U

'"

a-

= :r

=l",

i1l>

1I>

on

Q.."

, O

~V

lno;

-,o

n...=

-,no

::S

jI;!,

;;! .!.

. n

~ ~

'g, J

6 ~

c: ;

:; >

< ~ ~

~ a

=

g"

~ ~

::: ~

.?

E

~ c

r ~

"' ~

g

8, 5

' 5,

"0

(')

g; i

g-

::g &

>

<"

~

5'

0 8

~::.

c ~

i:

n;:

11>

(')

:I: ~

CJQ

"0

11>

()

or

11>

Q

.. i..

. ~ ~

n ~

CJQ

~

=

3

a ..,

~

11>

=

...~

~

~[~

~~

~::;

~

~~

~

~~

~

~3.

Y'i:

3~

~~

n

'" -

-"'0

= ...

- I

1I

>:r

~

.. -,

~ ~

~

v

a- n

0

0;

... -

,'"

- "0

' -,

0

11>

0\

a- 0

;:-

_.

11>

C

\C ;

;:' 0

::1

, n ..:

!;:

3;:;

5' ~

-- 11

> <7\

3'" ...

;:;

, -.

e -,

c,

3 ~

...:j

QO

",;:

Q..

~::,

11

> 0

...

11

> ~

~

~:r

=

0:

CJQ

~

g

"'~ in

' ::r

~

o::r

~

::I

0""

--o"

,,,,~

~n

. ",

:r

--

",...

n~

'" ~

...--

.. .

.t

. ...

~

~~

~

~

~

~

-0

~

.. 8

c...

c...

c...

c...

CIO

'-IO

\~