რელიგია საჯარო სკოლებში

5/28/2018

1/47

EMCHuman Rights Education

and Monitoring Center

5/28/2018

2/47

5/28/2018

3/47

( )

, 2014

5/28/2018

4/47

(EMC).

.

: , ( 6)

:

: ,

: ,

:

(EMC)

: #3, 0179, ,

: (+995 32) 223 15 58

.: [email protected]

www.emc.org.ge

Facebook: https: www.facebook.com/RIGHTSEMC

: 500

ISBN: 978-9941-0-3903-4

, ,

.

5/28/2018

5/47

(EMC)

1. ................................................................................................................................................

2. .......................................................................................

2.1. .............................................................................................................................

2.2. ........................................................................................................................8

2.2.1. ....................................

2.2.2. ..............................................................

2.2.3. . ..............

3. ......................................................................................................1

4.

...............................................................................................1

4.1. ..................1

4.2. ......................................................................1

4.3. .............................1

4.4. ,

.......................................................................................................................2

4.5.

............................................................................................................................2

5. ,

...........................................................2

5.1. ........................................................2

5.2. ................................................................2

6.

................................................2

7. ,

.................................................................3

8. ...............................4

#1..............................................................................................................................................4

5/28/2018

6/47

4

1

, ,

,

.

,

,

.

-2

.

, , ,

.

-3

.

,

.

-4 ,

, -

.

-5

, . ,

.

. -

.

(EMC)

,

.

5/28/2018

7/47

(EMC)

2.

2.1.

,

.

, .

,

2005 ,

. 2005

.

2001-2004

,

,

,

/

,2

3 .4 , - , ,

.

(

)

.5

1 Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, And Labor; International Religious Freedom Report 2003 and 2004; Restrictions on Reli-

gious Freedom; http://www.state.gov/j/drl/rls/irf/2003/24358.htm; http://www.state.gov/j/drl/rls/irf/2004/35455.htm ( ,

20.02.2014)

2 2004 , . 50; http://www.ombudsman.ge/files/downloads/ge/szounjmrncjpwc

vdgasn.pdf ( , 20.02.2014)

3 2004 , . 50; http://www.ombudsman.ge/files/downloads/ge/szounjmrncjpwc

vdgasn.pdf ( , 20.02.2014)

4 , 2001 22

; , 23 , 2002; . 23; http://www.coe.int/t/dghl/monitoring/ecri/Country-by-country/Georgia/GEO-CbC-II

2002-002-GEO.pdf ( , 20.02.2014)

5 Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, And Labor; International Religious Freedom Report 2001; Restrictions on Religious Freedom;

http://www.state.gov/j/drl/rls/irf/2001/5649.htm ( , 20.02.2014)

5/28/2018

8/47

6

2005

. ,

.

, 2008 -

,

. 2008

,

, .6

,

, .7

2007 ,

. 2007 20088

, ,

.9

, .10

,

.11 ,

.12

. , , ,

,

,

.13

6 ; ;

, ,

7

, 2007 , . 166

8

, 2008 , . 209; http://www.ombudsman.ge/files/downloads/ge/kixclggyhdexhnxpvd-

vq.pdf ( , 20.02.2014)

9

, 2007 , . 158-159; http://www.ombudsman.ge/files/downloads/ge/rcdhxltppxuy-

axakjjlc.pdf ( , 20.02.2014)

10

, 2007 , . 165; http://www.ombudsman.ge/files/downloads/ge/rcdhxltp-

pxuyaxakjjlc.pdf ( , 20.02.2014)

11

, 2009 , . 187; http://www.ombudsman.ge/files/downloads/ge/rcbrpcdm-

wmvalletoggp.pdf ( , 20.02.2014)

12 ;

13 , , (

), 2010 28 , . 19 http://www.coe.int/t/dghl/monitoring/ecri/Country-by-country/Georgia/GEO-

CbC-IV-2010-017-GEO.pdf ( , 20.02.2014);

5/28/2018

9/47

(EMC)

,

. ,

2005

2008

,

. ,

,

. 14

, ,

2012-2013

, ,

.15 2012-201

(, , ),

,

,

.16

.17

. - ,

, , , -

.18

,

. ,

.19

14 , -; ,

,

15

, 2012 , . 525; http://www.ombudsman.ge/files/downloads/ge/iicsizmorgdfkahkdqvc.pdf (, 20.02.2014)

16 , 2012-2013

, ,

, 2013, . 24

17 -,

, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EN8dgOMs8Zc&feature=youtu.be ( , 20.02.2014)

18 2013

19 Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, And Labor; International Religious Freedom Report 2012; Government Practices; http://www.

state.gov/j/drl/rls/irf/religiousfreedom/index.htm?dlid#wrapper ( , 20.02.2014)

5/28/2018

10/47

8

, -

,

,20 ,

, .21

, , ,

EMC-

,

. ,

. ,

, ,

, .

,

,

,

.

, .22

,

,

, , , .

2.2.

2.2.1.

,

20 ; . -

-



22 , 2012-2013

, ,

, 2013, . 24

5/28/2018

11/47

(EMC)

,

.

.

,

2.2.2.

.

, 2013-1014

.23 ,

.

, , ,

.

. ,

, ,

.

, ,

, -5 -6 .

,

: , , , ,

. , ,

,

.

. , ,

. ,

, .

2.2.3. .

,

23 2013 15 #467792

5/28/2018

12/47

10

. , ,

, ,

.

, ,

-, .

- ,

(5%- 20-30%). -

,

. , 3 ,

5%- 3 ,

15-30 %- .

, - . 8 ,24

,

25. . -

6-7 .

24 . - . 77-, 84-, 98-, 131-, 92-, 87-, 89- 163-

;

-

25 , ,

5/28/2018

13/47

(EMC) 1

3

, ,

,

,

,

. ,

,

, ,

;

,

, ,

.

,

/ .

, ,

.

, ,

,

, .

.

,

, ,

.

,

,

.

5/28/2018

14/47

12

4

: ,

( ),

.

.

4.1.

(

) .

-9

. [...]

[...] .

. -9 [...]

[...].

, -9

-2 .

2001 30 -9 , .

.26 , ,

, ,

26 -6 -3

5/28/2018

15/47

(EMC) 1

. ,

,

.27

,

, ,

, .28

, .

.

, ,

,

.29 ,

,

. ,

,

, -

.

-5 ,

. , ,

. .

.

,

:30 1.

, ,

,

-

. 2.

27 , 9

28

, 1.3

29 2002 22 2/18/206 ,

30 , ,

,

5/28/2018

16/47

14

, ,

,

, . 3.

.

,

. , ,

, .

31 -2

,

, :

,

, - ;32

;33

;34

-

.35

.

,

,

.

31 EMC- , ,

. -

, . http://www.patriarchate.ge/?action=text/samartali09 ( , 20.02.2014)

32

,-2

33 , -2

34 , -2

35 , -2

5/28/2018

17/47

(EMC) 1

,

, ,

,

2007 .

.

.

,

.

, ( ,

,

, ) .36

, ,

. .

, .

4.2.

2005 .

.

,

.

-

,37

,

.

.

-13 ,

, .

,

, , ,

36 ,

37 3, -2 ,

5/28/2018

18/47

16

,

.

,

, ,

.38

,

,

. -

. ,

, ,

.

( )

, ,

. ,

. ,

,

:

, .39

.

, , , . ,

( )

, ,

. ,

,

.

4.3.

,

.

38 , 13, -2

39 , 18, -4

5/28/2018

19/47

(EMC) 1

2004 18

,

.

.

: [...] ,

.

,

.

.40

.

2006 41, : ,

, , ,

-.

,

,

.

42, .

,

2011-2016 , . ,

,

. ,

.

,

, ,

, , ,

40 2004 18 84

,

41 2006 28 841

42 2011 11 36/

5/28/2018

20/47

18

.43 ,

, ,

,

,

.44

, ,

,

(, , ) (, , )

45, .

, ,

, , ,

/

,

.46

, .47

.48

, . ,

,

.

.

:

,

.49

, ,

.

, .

[ ] .

43 2011 11 36/

; , 48. -3 ,

44 , ;

, , , ,2013, .11

45 2014 21 MES 9 14 00023712

46 2011 11 36/

; , 12

47 2011 11 36/

; ,11, -6

48 2013 15 #467792

49 2014 21 MES 9 14 00023712

5/28/2018

21/47

(EMC) 1

.50 ,

,

.

,

. EMC- 8 -

. 87- , -3- -6

, , -3--4 , -5--6

.

.51

,

,52 ,

.53

,

, ,

,

,

,

: (5-6), (7-9, 11-12), (7-8).

,

. . ,

, , , , .

,

- .54

.

.

50 ,

51 , 87-

52 ,

53 2013 15 #467792

54 2011 11 36/

;

5/28/2018

22/47

20

.

.55

,

.

(. #1).

,

, - ,

.

4.4. ,

2010-2011 ,,

,

.

, ,

,

.

( , ) 56 ,

, , , , ,

, .....57

.58

59 60 /

.

55 2011 11 36/

;

56 2010 14 N57/

, 4.9

57 , 4.11

58 2010 30 N 80/

, 3. 6/12

59 2011 27 92/

, 2.6

60 2010 30 79/

, 7.7

5/28/2018

23/47

(EMC) 2

, ,

, ,

.

2008 ,

, ,

;61

:

-

/

- ;

- -

, ;62

,

, /

(, , , ).63

4.5.

, ,

, ,

,

.

. , ,

61 2008 21 1014

5. )

62 2011 25 30 /

63 2012

5/28/2018

24/47

22

, ,

- ,

-

, /

.64

,

, .

.65

,

, ,

, ( ) .

, /

:

- ,

;

- , ;

- ,

;66

,

, ,

, - . ,

, .

,

, ,

64 35.1

65 , 38

66 2004 21 N 37

, 4.1. 3

5/28/2018

25/47

(EMC) 2

.

49-

.

, ,

-

/

.67

, , ,

. ,

/

, ,

.68

,

, ,

,

,

.

, .

,

.

.69

/ ,

70 ,

.

67 49. 6

68 , 49

69 2004 21 N 37

, 4.1. 6

70 142-, 150-, 156-

5/28/2018

26/47

24

5 ,

5.1

5

/

/

/

/ ,

/, , ,/ , ,

/

. ,

,

.71

,

,

. ,

,

,

.

.

, , ,

,

,

.72 .73

71 2013 15 #467792

72 , , (


CbC-IV-2010-017-GEO.pdf ( , 20.02.2014)



5/28/2018

27/47

(EMC) 2

,

,

. 2010

,

, .

.

,

:

. .

...

.75

, ,

. .

EMC-

,

, / /

/ ,

, .

76 77 ,

.

5.2.

2005 , ,

, - ,

,

. ,

.78

74 , , (


CbC-IV-2010-017-GEO.pdf ( , 20.02.2014)

75 ,

76 2013 25 #2620897

77

, 2012 , . 525; http://www.ombudsman.ge/files/downloads/ge/iicsizmorgdfkahkdqvc.pdf (

, 20.02.2014)

78 ,

5/28/2018

28/47

26

,

, ,79

.

, -

, .

2010

( ),

. ECRI ,

.

, , . , ,

.80

( )

,

,

, .81

82, 59217 .

-, .

- -

.

9 ,

2 35 ;

1 25;

79 ,

80 , , (

), 2010 28 , .28. . 41; http://www.coe.int/t/dghl/monitoring/ecri/Country-by-country/Georgia/

GEO-CbC-IV-2010-017-GEO.pdf ( , 20.02.2014)

81 2013 15 #467792

82 2013

5/28/2018

29/47

(EMC) 2

- 1272- ;

- - -

.

8 , 3

;

33- ;

-

15

( ) 36 -

( ).

, 1 10 .83

- 251- .

,

.

80 .84

,

,

.

,

,

. ,

,

.85

,

,

,

.

83 -

2013 5 MES 7 13 00580119

84 2013 15 #467792

85 ;

5/28/2018

30/47

28

,

.

, , , ,

.

,

. ,

,

.

,

, .

,

, , . ,

,

.

.

5/28/2018

31/47

(EMC) 2

6

,

.

:

1. : ,-5 , .

: , , ,

2. : ,-6 , .: , , , ,

3. :,-7 , .

: , ,

4. : , -8 , .

: , , , ,

5. : ,-9 , .: , , , ,

6.:, -11 , .

: , , , ,

,

7. : , -12 , .

: , ,

:

1. -

. -5 -6

5/28/2018

32/47

30

-.

( ) , ,

, , , , ,

, , , , -

.

. , , -,

.

; ,

. (. 5; -5 )

, ,

, - .

-9 ,

, : - - , , .

, ... , ... .

,

, .

-6 -9

(.106, -6 ; .74, -9

). , , () , ()

. ,

, , , ,

, () ? (.113, -6 )

-6 :

, . , -9 ,

,

, ,

, . (.80, -9 )

, ,

.

2.

, ,

, ,

, . ,

5/28/2018

33/47

(EMC) 3

, . ,

.

, -5 -6 ,

. , -5 ,

,

(, , ). 55- :

. , ,

-: ,

, ,

, ,

,

. ,

, . -5

, .

,

, ,

. -6

, .

, :

,

,

; , ,

, . , 42- 43-

.

,

, ,

, . (.42, -6 )

,

, , ,

.

, -6

,

. , , ,

,

- . -6 ,

(, . 5, .9, -6 ).

5/28/2018

34/47

32

, -5 -6 , ,

,

. , -7, -8, -9 -11 ,

. -12

, .

-5 -6 ,

.

.

, . -9 ,

. , ,

,

. ,

.

,

, ,

, / .

- -

. , -, : ,

. .

: ,

. (.44, -5 ) , , ;

300 () .

, . (.146, -5 )

, .

, ,

. (. 158, -5 )

-6 : ,

. . .115; 28- -

- , . .

116; ,

... . .43; XIII 70-

. .148;

, ,

, .

, ,

. -11 ,

(.248-254 -11 ).

5/28/2018

35/47

(EMC) 3

-6

, -11

. , !

, ,

. (. 124, -6 ) ,

. . ,

11

.

... ,

,

. ,

. ()

, . (. 253; -1

)

-7 , ,

. (. 136, .141, .193- -7 )

, :

, . , ,

, -

-. (. 136, -7 )

-7 , ,

. , , ,

.

,

, .

.

, , ,

.

-8 , , -

,

.

. , , ,

(

5/28/2018

36/47

34

,

).

.. (. 50, -8 ).

-6 ,

, -5 , -,

, ,

.

-7, -8, -9 -11 ,

. ,

.

5/28/2018

37/47

(EMC) 3

7 ,

-

,

, ,

, ,

.86

, ,

. ,

.

, ,

.

,

,

.

. ,

, , ,

.87

(

, , ,

.

,

88, -

. , , -

86 , -5

87 , . 39

88 , . 18

5/28/2018

38/47

36

( ), .

.

, ,

, ,

, , -

. ,

.

:

,

- ,

, , . ,

,

.

.

. ,

, .

- , .

,

, .

.

- . -

. . .

. , .

,

. .

.

[] .

5/28/2018

39/47

(EMC) 3

.

. ... .

, . 89

, ,

. ,

- , ,

, ,

- , ,

- . -

,

.

-

,

,

. /

. ,

. , , .

, , .

. ,

. ,

. .

.

, .

?

, . , ,

, .

89 , , 77-, 84-, 87- 92-

-

5/28/2018

40/47

38

, ,

. , . .

, .

[ ], , . ,

.

. .

. . . .

...

. : 30 30-

, .90

,

. , ,

. , -

,

.

, ,

, , ,

. ,

, , , , , .

,

. ....

,

: , ?

: . , . .

, .

. 1-2 ,

. ,

. .

90 .

, 89-, 84-, 92- 87- -

5/28/2018

41/47

(EMC) 3

,

.

.

.

.91

,

92

, . ,

. ,

. ,

.

, , ,

.

, [ ] .

? ..

.

, . ,

, .

. , . .

. .

.

. [

]. . .93

91 , , 92-, 89-,

87- 131- -

92 77-, 84-, 92- 131-

93 84-, 92- 131- -

5/28/2018

42/47

40

,

, ,

.

. , ,

. , ,

( ),

. ,

, ,

.

. : .

, ,

. .

.

, .

- . .

- .

. .

.

, ,

. .

.94

94 , , 77-, 84-, 131-

163- -

5/28/2018

43/47

(EMC) 4

,

. -

. , ,

,

.

. , ,

,

,

/ .

.

19 . , .

. , .

, , .

, . .

, . ,

. ,

.

.

... . 1%-

. ,

, ... ,

. 95

-

. , . :

: ,

,

95 . 98-, 131

87- -

5/28/2018

44/47

42

, . ,

,

. ,

,

.

-, , , .

- . , 21-

.

.

.

.

.

. . .

. . .

. .

- : . .

.

- .

- .96

96 , 77-, 98-, 92- 163-

-

5/28/2018

45/47

(EMC) 4

8

;

, ,

, ;

,

;

/ ,

. ,

,

;

,

, ,

/ . ,

,

, ,

;

/

; ,

;

, ,

.

,

.

5/28/2018

46/47

44

#1:

:

: V-VI

:

..V-VI.20. ;

. .V-VI.21.

;

..V-VI.22. -

.

..V-VI.23. .

..V-VI.20. .

, :

;

;

/ (.: , , );

, .

. .V-VI.21.

.

, :

;

, ;

;

,

;

(.:

, ).

5/28/2018

47/47

(EMC) 4

..V-VI.22.

.

, :

() ,

;

();

;

-

( ).

..V-VI.23. .

, :

(,: /

, ,

;97

97 2011 11 36/

რელიგია საჯარო სკოლებში

Documents

Transcript of რელიგია საჯარო სკოლებში