რეფორმების მონიტორინგი, პილოტური...

reformebis koordinaciis saxelmwifo ministris ofisi /GORBI

reformebis monitoringi piloturi kvleva Tbilisis skolebSi

meTodologia warmodgenili monacemebi eyrdnoba mravalkomponentiani kvlevis Sedegebs;

kvlevaSi gamoyenebuli kiTxvarebi da midgomebi eyrdnoboda meTodologias, romelic Tavdapirvelad Seiqmna profesor daniel kaufmanis xelmZRvanelobiT, msoflio bankis institutSi. raodenobrivi kvlevis savele samuSaoebi Catarda TbilisSi, 2006 wlis ivnis-ivlisis TveebSi. xolo fokusirebuli jgufebi Catarebuli iqna ivlisSi. raodenobrivi kvlevis TiToeuli komponentis dasaxvewad savele samuSaoebis dawyebis win Catarda pilotaJuri gamokiTxvebi. maswavlevlebTan da mSoblebTan gamoyenebuli iqna pirispir intervius meTodi, xolo skolis moswavleebisaTvis SemuSavebuli iqna specialuri kiTxavri, romelic Tavad Seavses respondentebma.

Tbilisi xuTive raionSi, SemTxveviTi SerCevis meTodiT, SeirCa rogorc sajaro aseve kerZo skolebi, sadac Catarda interviuebi.

kvlevaSi monawileobda 50 sajaro da 10 kerZo skola. sul gamokiTxuli iqna 800 mSobeli, 1000 moswavle da 402 maswavlebeli, maT Soris skolis direqciis wevrebic.

monacemTa damuSaveba moxda TbilisSi gorbis ofisSi, saerTaSoriso konsultantan b-n. pablo zoidosTan TanamSromlobiT.

xarisxis Sefaseba

89%

88%

70%

41%

81%

81%

61%

26%

100%

100%

70%

70%

sajaro skolebi kerZo skolebi

im respondentebis % vinc daasaxela “kargi” an “Zalian kargi” xarisxi

56%

56%

45%

29%

57%

57%

45%

23%

79%

80%

70%

50%

mTlianobaSi

swavleba

menejmenti

damxmare saSualebebi

mSoblebi

moswavleebi

maswavleblebi

xarisxis detaluri Sefaseba

19%

26%

44%

34%

52%

28%

36%

21%

48%

35%

22%

38%

71%

48%

81%

Cveni skolaSi saskolo inventari amarTlebs moswavleebis da mSoblebis molodins

Cems moTxovnebs akmayofilebs is saswavlo resursi romliTac uzrunvelgvyofs Cveni skola (mag. kompiuteri, intern. biblioTeka laboratoria)

moswavleebi Cvens skolaSi icaven wesebs

saxelmZRvaneloebi, romelic Cvens skolaSi gamoiyeneba, amarTelbs moswavleebis da mSoblebis molodins

Cvens skolaSi maswavleblebi samarTlianebi arian moswavleebis mimarT

64%

62%

69%

72%

85%

66%

71%

64%

64%

79%

84%

76%

93%

88%

93%

Cvens skolaSi moswavleebi SeZlebisdagvarad exmarebian erTmaneTs.

me ar gadaviyvandi Cems Svilebs sxva skolaSi

Cveni skolis prioriteti moswavlis warmatebaa

Cveni skolis moswavleebi usfrTxod modian skolaSi da midian skolidan.

The core subjects (math, enebi, sazogadoebrivi mecnierebebi, rasac moswavleebi swavloben Tqvens skolaSi sasargebloa maTTvis

mSoblebi moswavleebi maswavleblebi

xarisxis ganmsazRvrelebi: ra amarTlebs da ra ara?

Cven SevimuSaveT regresiuli statistikuri modeli, romelic efuZneba moswavleTa da mSobelTa mier xarisxis Sefasebas. romelic, Seicavs maswavleblebisa da skolis administraciis wevrebis mier skolis muSaobis mimarTulebis Sefasebas.

qvemoT warmodgenilia statistikuri modelis ZiriTadi Sedegebi.

• kadrebis menejmenti • biujetis menejmenti • informaciis menejmenti • arafoficialuri gadasaxadebi

• daskvnebi

regresiuli modelis Sedegebi (efuZneba skolis tipsa da sidides):

damokidebuli cvladi: xarisxis Sefaseba moswavleebisa da mSoblebis mier

damoukidebeli cvladi: maswavleblebis/administratorebis mier Sefaseba

ra amarTlebs da ra ara?

kadrebis menejmenti regresiuli analizis Sedegebi xarisxis Sefaseba saerTo swavleba damxmare saSualebebi menejmenti

mosw mS mosw mS mosw mS mosw mS

+/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- ***

I. kadrebis menejmenti

1. oficialuri wesebi

1.1 oficialuradaa dawerili .062 ***

1.2 martivia, advilad gasagebi .051 **

1.3 iTxovs Zalian bevr administraciul etaps .026 * .047 *** .024 * .038 ** .056 ***

1.4 kargadaa gakontrolebuli .057 *** 1.5 daumorCilebloba yovelTvis isjeba .073 *** .025 * .069 *** .048 * .062 ** .046 ** .031 *

2. kadrebis marTvasTan dakavSirebuli gadawyvetilebebi

2.1 gamWvirvalea .036 ** .040 **

2.2 cxaddeba rogorc skolis SigniT aseve mis gareT .030 *** .036 *** .027 *** .042 *** .050 *** .057 *** .074 *** .042 ***

2.3.gasaCivrebis formaluri proceduris sagania .026 * .060 *** .026 * .055 ***

2.4 efuZneba oficialurad daweril kriteriumebs .036 ** .035 ** 2.5 damokidebulia profesiul gamocdilebze /xarisxze/Sromis intensiurobaze

.041 ** .038 ** .051 ** .080 *** .043 *** .052 ***

2.6 damokidebulia ganaTlebis doneze .048 *** .040 ** .044 * .088 *** .045 *** .063 ***

2.7 damokidebulia welTa namsaxurebaze/staJze .043 *** .035 ** .069 *** .097 *** .054 *** .037 **

2.8 damokidebulia naTesaur kavSirebze an megobrobaze

2.9 damokidebulia saqmian kontaqtebsa da urTierTobebze

2.10 damokidebulia politikur kavSirebze /politikur partiis wevrobaze/politikur zewolaze

2.11 damokidebulia gavlenian kavSirebze skolis farglebSi

2.12 damokidebulia araoficialur gadasaxadebze .094 *** .111 *** .089 *** .091 ***

2.13 damokidebulia xelmZRvanelTan pirad urTierTobebze

.042 **

2.14 damokidebulia sqesze

2.15 damokidebuli erovnebaze .071 * .145 *** .067 * .136 *** .150 *** .122 ***

oficialuri wesebi maRali xarisxis ganaTleba asocirdeba kadrebis menejmentis, oficialuri wesebisa da procedurebis dacvasTan, romelic: • miTxovs sakmaod bevr administraciul etaps .

• kargadaa gakontrolebuli, an sxavanirad rom vTqvaT, daumorCilebloba yovelTvis sjeba.

kadrebis marTvasTan dakavSirebuli gadawyvetilebebi

• gamWvirvaleoba da angariSvaldebuleba amaRlebs xarisxs: maRali xarisxi asocrdeba kadrebis marTvasTan dakavSirebuli gadawyvetilebebis gamWvirvaleobasTan da aseve imasTan rom, es gadawyvetilebebi gaxda gasaCivrebis formaluri proceduris sagani.

• damsaxurebis, ganaTlebis da staJis mixedviT dawinaureba aseve gaigibevulia kadrebis marTvis maRal xarisxTan.

ra amarTlebs da ra ara? kadrebis menejmenti


gamocxadebuli vakansiebi, rogorc skolis SigniT, aseve skolis gareT

(q22.2)

sruliad

eTanxmeba

maRali xarisxi

dabali xarisxi

swav

lebi

s x

ari

sxi

(m

oswav

leebi)

g-n.

d-C.

v-s.

i-s.

m-k.

g-n.

d-C.

v-s.

i-s.

R 2 = 94%

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80%

sajaro skola

kerZo skola

wrfivi (sajaro)

sruliad ar

eTanxmeba

ra amarTlebs da ra ara? kadrebis menejmenti - gagrZeleba

regresiuli analizis Sedegebi xarisxis Sefaseba saerTo swavleba damxmare saSualebebi menejmenti


+/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- ***

3. piradi kmayofileba

3.1 zogadad saxelmwifo skolaSi muSaoba ukeTesia, vidre kerZo skolaSi

3.2 xelfasi savsebiT damakmayofilebelia .080 *** .072 ** .076 *** .069 ** .092 ***

3.3 sxva Semosavlebi damakmayofilebelia -.078 **

3.4 Cemi saqme da Tanamdeboba saimedoa .049 * .028 *

4. meritokratia: davwinaurdebi Tu Cems saqmes kargad Sevasruleb

.039 ** .033 * .048 ** .047 * .045 ** .048 **

5.xelfasebis dagvianeba -7.333 *

6. oficialuri xelfasi

6.1 2006 wlis xelfasi .004 *

6.2 2003 wlis xelfasi .005 * .008 **

6.3 xelfasis zrda .000 *** .000 ** .000 *** .000 ** .000 *** .000 *** 7. treningi

7.1 2005-2006 wlebSi gavlili treningebis raodenoba

.007 * .013 * .013 ***

7.2. skolis Sida leqcia, dReTa raodenoba .008 *

7.3 gasvliTi seminari, dReTa raodenoba -.002 * -.002 *

7.4 SemecnebiTi turi 8. administraciuli sasjeli

8.1 miukerZoeblad sruldeba .063 ** .039 * .042 **

8.2 efeqturi iaraRia maswavleblebis da administraciis motivirebisaTvis, rom ukeT imuSaon

8.3 cudi muSaobisaTvis daisajnen -.082 * -.110 **

8.4 araprofesionaluri qmedebisaTvis daisajnen .088 * .178 ** .112 * 8.5 # gaTavisuflebuli maswavleblebi

8.6 # gaTavisuflebuli administraciis wevrebi .000 *

9. warmatebuli profesiuli saqmianobis dafaseba

9.1 Cemi skola afasebs warmatebul saqmianobas .031 * .056 **

10 piriqiT, ar afasebs

10.1 direqtorebis denadoba

10.2 direqtorebis moadgileebis denadoba -.096 *** -.103 *** -.109 * -.166 **

10.3 moswavleebis denadoba -.053 *** -.071 *** -.053 *** -.062 ** -.098 ** -.087 ** -.047 *


piradi kmayofileba da xelfasiT kmayofileba arsebobs sarwmuno mtkicebuleba imisa, rom piradi xelfasiT kamyofilebis done da piradi keTildReoba asocirdeba swavlebis ufro maRal standartebTan da mTlianobaSi ganaTlebis maRal xarisxTan. miuxedavad yvelafrisa, gazrdili xelfasebi da kidev ufro meti zrda xelfasebisa sruliad ar asocirdeba mTlianobaSi ganaTlebis gaumjebesebul xarisxTan.

treningi gavlili terningebis raodenoba, romelic maswavleblebma da skolis direqciis wevrebma gaiares, seriozul gavlenas ar axdens ganaTlebis xarisxze. maswavleblebs da admisnistraciis wevrebs 75% gavlili aqvT treiningebi, maTgan 25% mirebuli aqvs monawileoba 3 an met treiningSi. administraciuli sasjeli administraciuli sasjeli ar aRmoCnda efeqturi saSualeba Sromis nayofierebis asamaRleblad.

kadrebis denadoba

saintereso, rom kadrebis, kerZod ki maswavleblebisa da direqciis wevrebis gadaWarbebuli denadoba uaryofiT zegavlenas axdens zogadad ganaTlebis xarisxze

ra amarTlebs da ra ara? kadrebis menejmenti - gagrZeleba

saSualo oficialuri Tviuri xelfasi (lari)

marali xarisxi

dabali xarisxi

sae

rT

o x

arisxi

(mSo

bl

ebi

)

* vake-saburTalos raionis skolebis saSualo xelfasi (420 lari) ar Sedis

m-k

i-s.

v-s.

d-C.

g-n.

i-s d-C.

g-n.

R 2 = 4%

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

130 140 150 160 170 180

sajaro skola

kerZo skola

wrfivi (sajaro)

ra amarTlebs da ra ara? biujetis menejmenti



+/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- ***

II. biujetis menejmenti

1. biujetis Sedgena

1.1 gulisxmobs mWidro TanmSromlobas ganaTlebis saministrosTan

.042 * .047 ** .039 *

1.2 gulisxmobs mWidro TanmSromlobas finansTa saministrosTan

2. biujetis administrirebasTan dakavSirebuli gadawyvetilebebi

2.1 dagegmilia skolis miznebis gaTvaliswinebiT .042 ** 2.2 gamWvirvalea .036 ** .032 * .050 ** .034 ** .056 ***

2.3 gamocxadebulia / sazogadoebisTvis xelmisawvdomi

.048 *** .041 ** .073 *** .031 * .064 ***

2.4 eqvemdebareba profesionali da gamocdili gare makontroleblebis/auditis mxridan Semowmebas

.041 * .055 ** .032 *

2.5 eyrdnoba werilobiTi formiT Camoyalibebul konkretul kriteriumebs

.051 * .069 ** .056 ***

2.6 miRebulia politikuri zewolidan gamomdinare

.072 ** .066 **

2.7 miRebulia skolis SigniT arsebuli gavleniani kavSirebidan gamomdinare

.076 *** .070 *** .052 *

2.8 miRebulia araoficialuri gadasaxadis gavleniT

.074 *** .070 *** .054 *

3. biujetis wyaroebi

3.1 adgilobrivi TviTmmarTveloba

3.2 ganaTlebis saministro .368 **

3.3 adgilobrivi biznesi .426 *** 3.4 mSoblebi -.069 * -.222 *** -.129 **

3.5 IsaerTaSoriso donori organizaciebi .156 * .166 ** .232 **

5. biujetis xarjvis monitoringi da kontroli .076 *** .048 * .069 * .062 *** .113 ***

6. resursebiT kmayofileba

6.1 sabiujeto resursebi .034 * .032 * .057 **

6.2 kvalificirebuli personali

6.3 saskolo/saofise inventari / kompiuterebi .045 *** .065 *** .038 *** .062 *** .150 *** .137 *** .061 *** .078 *** 6.4. saskolaSi arsebuli damxmare saSualebebiT .028 ** .053 *** .046 *** .142 *** .169 *** .048 *** .067 ***


biujetis menejmenti

rodesac biujetis marTvasTan dakavSirebuli gadawyvetilebebi gamWvirvale

da sazogadoebisaTvis xelmisawvdomia, Tbilisis skolebis momsaxurebis xarisxi gacilebiT ukeTesia, gansakuTrebiT ki skolis damxmare saSualebebis xarisxi.


biujetis administrirebasTan dakavSirebuli gadawyvetilebebi gamocxadebuli da

sazogadoebisTvis xelmisawvdomi iyo sxvadasxva oficialuri saSualebebiT

maRali xarisxi

dabali xarisxi

dam

xmar

e s

aSual

ebebis

xar

isxi

(mSo

bl

ebi)

g-n.

d-C

v-s.

i-s.

m-k.

g-n.

d-C.

v-s.

i-s.

R 2 = 72%

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70%

sajaro skola

kerZo skola

wrfivi (sajaro)

sruliad

eTanxmeba sruliad ar

eTanxmeba

ra amarTlebs da ra ara? informaciis marTva



+/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- ***

III. informaciis menejmenti

1.Civilisa da masze reagirebis meqanizmi

1.1 reagirebis kargad gansazRvruli meqanizmi .071 **

1.2 Civilebis da pretenziebis kargad gansazRvruli meqanizmi

1.3 Civilebi TanamSromlebis disciplinis mimarT

-.063 *

1.4 komplimentebi personalis pasuxismgeblobis grZnobis gamo

.048 ** .038 * .094 ** .070 **

2. informaciis marTva

2.1 moswavleebma ician ris swavlas elian Cvens skolaSi

.061 ** .181 *** .055 ** .171 *** .103 ** .138 *** .112 ***

2.2 maswavleblebis CarTuloba gadawyvetilebebis miRebis procesSi

.053 * .059 ** .073 *** .094 ***

2.3 mSoblebis CarTuloba gadawyvetilebebis miRebis procesSi

.055 ** .044 *

2.4 moswavleTa CarTuloba gadawyvetilebebis miRebis procesSi

.057 ** .050 ** .049 *

2.5 skolis angariSvladebuleba moswavleebisa da mSoblebis winaSe

.079 **

2.6 skolis efeqturi urTierToba mSoblebTan .064 * .058 *

2.7 xalxi, romelTac uSualod exebaT skolaSi miRebuli gadawyvetilebebi, yvelaze bolos igeben maT Sesaxeb

-.058 * -.061 * -.077 ***

2.8 direqciis mier mSoblebisa da moswavleebis azris gaTvaliswineba

.082 * .063 **

2.9 direqciis mier maswavlebelTa azris gaTvaliswineba

.056 ** .062 ** .071 **

2.10 direqciis mier biujetis gaTvaliswineba .107 *** .110 *** .078 *** .119 ***


kargad gansazRvruli meqanizmi, romelic uzrunvelyofs moswavleebis da mSoblebis azris, SeTavazebebis da

moTxovnebis gaTvaliswinebas ? (q61.1)

saerTod ar arsebobs

arsebobs da Zalian

efeqturia

maRali xarisxi

dabali xarisxi

mar

Tvi

s x

ari

sxi

(m

So

bl

ebi)

g-n.

d-C. v-s.

i-s.

m-k.

g-n.

d-C.

v-s.

i-s.

R 2 = 77%

0%

20%

40%

60%

80%

100%

0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120%

sajaro skola

kerZo skola

wrfivi (sajaro)


informaciis marTva

ganaTlebis xarisxze da akademiur moswrebaze dadebiTad moqmedebs, rodesac moswavleebma ician Tu ris swavlas elian

skolaSi.

zogadad, ganaTlebis ukeTes xarisxTan asocirdeba meti gamWvirvaleoba da angariSvaldebuleba skolis maswavleblebs/ direqciis wvrebsa da moswavleebs/mSoblebs Soris.

ra amarTlebs da ra ara? araoficialuri gadasaxadebi 1



+/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- ***

V. araoficialuri gadasaxadebi, korufcia

1. zogadi SekiTxvebi

1.1 maswavleblebi acdenen gakveTilebs -.050 * -.108 *** -.052 ** -.129 ***

1.2 moswavleebi acdenen gakveTilebs -.060 *** -.118 *** -.048 ** -.101 *** -.101 ** -.078 *** -.099 ***

1.3 moswavleebis saubari, Tvqens skolaSi gadaxdili qrTamebis Sesaxeb

1.4 moswavleebis saubari, sxva skolebSi gadaxdili qrTamebis Sesaxeb

1.5 maswavleblebis saubari, Tvqens skolaSi gadaxdili qrTamebis Sesaxeb

-.066 * -.082 * -.071 ** -.107 ** -.110 **

1.6 maswavleblebis saubari, sxva skolebSi gadaxdili qrTamebis Sesaxeb

-.099 ***

1.7 moswavleTa mSoblebis saubari, Tqvens skolaSi gadaxdili qrTamebis Sesaxeb

-.098 ** -.088 *

1.8 moswavleTa mSoblebis saubari, sxva skolebSi gadaxdili qrTamebis Sesaxeb

.032 *

1.9 saubrebi ukeTesi niSnebisaTvis gadaxdili qrTamebis Sesaxeb Tqvens skolaSi

-.148 *** -.081 * -.163 *** -.119 **

1.10 saubrebi ukeTesi niSnebisaTvis gadaxdili qrTamebis Sesaxeb sxva skolebSi

2. Tanamdebobebis yidva

2.1 direqciaSi "adgilis yidvis” praqtika

2.2 pedagogis "adgilis yidvis" praqtika 2.3 sxva Tanamdebobis yidvis praqtika

3. faqtiuri qrTamebi

3.1 qrTami, sxva skolebis maswavleblebis Semosavlis %

-.005 *** -.005 *** -.007 * -.006 ***

3.2 qrTami, sxva skolebis administraciis wevrebis Semosavlis %

-.004 **

3.3 qrTami,Tqveni skolebis maswavleblebis Semosavlis %

-.003 *

3.4 qrTami, Tqveni skolebis administraciis wevrebis Semosavlis %

.005 *** .005 *** .012 ** .010 *

3.5 araformaluri Semosavlis mqone sxva skolis maswavleblebis procentuli raodenoba

-.004 ** -.004 ** -.003 *

3.6 araformaluri Semosavlis mqone sxva .006 *

ra amarTlebs da ra ara? araoficialuri gadasaxadebi 2



+/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- *** +/- ***

3.5 araformaluri Semosavlis mqone Tqveni skolis maswavleblebis procentuli raodenoba

.006 **

3.6 araformaluri Semosavlis mqone Tqveni skolis administraciis warmomadgenelTa procentuli raodenoba

.005 *** .005 *** .009 *

3.7sxva skolebis maswavlebelTa % visac nayidi diplomi aqvs

-.006 *

3.8 sxva skolebis administraciis wevrTa % visac nayidi diplomi aqvs

-.006 * -.006 **

3.9 Tqveni skolis maswavlebelTa % visac nayidi diplomi aqvs

3.10 Tqveni skolis administraciis wevrebis % visac nayidi diplomi aqvs

-.008 ** -.009 ** -.010 *** -.014 * -.009 ***

4. mkvdari sulebi

4.1 mkvdari sulebis % Tqvens skolaSi .129 *** .116 *** .098 * .132 *** .069 *

4.2 mkvdari sulebis % sxva skolaSi

ra amarTlebs da ra ara? araoficialuri gadasaxadebi

araformaluri Semosavlebis mqone maswavleblebis proporcia Tqvens

skolaSi

maRali xarisxi

dabali xarisxi

mas

wav

lebel

Ta

kval

if

ika

ciis x

arisxi

(mo

swav

leebi)

g-n. d-C.

v-s.

i-s.

m-k.

g-n.

d-C.

v-s.

i-s.

R 2 = 68%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70%

sajaro skola

kerZo skola

wrfivi (sajaro)

ra amarTlebs da ra ara? araoficialuri gadasaxadebi

araoficialuri gadasaxadebi

is skolebi sadac, respodentebis SefasebiT swavlebis dabali xarisxia, amave dros aris swored is skolebi romlebSic araofiacialuri gadasaxdebis arsebobismaRali maCvenebelia. kargi niSnebisaTvis fulis gadaxda, gansakuTrebiT SemaSfoTebelia

faqtoria swavlebis procesis xarisxTan mimarTebaSi.

reformebis Sefaseba

14

5

12

25

46

82

78

93

5

8

6

4

2

56

7

32

2

6

3

14

skolaSi TanamSromelTa ricxvis

Semcireba, Tuki es aisaxeba darCeniliTanamSromelTa xelfasebis da samuSao

pirobebis gaumjobesebaze

maswavleblebis da direqciis wevrTaqonebis regularuli deklarireba

saarsebo minimumis daweseba sajaromoxelisTvis

mosaxleobis da samoqalaqosazogadoebis meti kontrolis gazrdaganaTlebis saministros saqmianobaze

sazogadoebriv skolebSi kadrebis

marTvis sistemis Camoyalibeba, sadacanazRaureba da waxaliseba damokidebulia

Sesrulebuli samuSaos xarisxze

ar davuWer mxars arc davuWer mxars arc ar davuWer mxars davuWer ar vici

ramdenad dauWerdiT mxars sazogadoebrivi skolis Semdeg reformebs?

skolis reformebis mxardaWera (pedagogebi)

15

14

1

23

21

25 araefeqturi

efeqturi

arc efeqturida arc

araefeqturi

srulebiTaraefeqturi

srulebiTefeqturi

ar vici

xelfasebis kalkulaciis axali sqemis Sesaxeb informirebuloba (maswavleblebi)

gsmeniaT Tu ara maswavlebelTa xelfasebis gaangariSebis axali sqemis

Sesaxeb?

diax

76%

ara

24%

ramdenad efeqturia maswavlebelTa xelfasebis kalkulaciis axali sqema?

xelfasebis kalkulaciis axali sqemis efeqturoba (maswavleblebi)

gadaangariSda Tu ara Tqveni xelfasebi ukve axali sqemis mixedviT?

diax

89%

ar vici

5.6%

ara

5%

amis Sedegad gaizarda Tqveni xelfasi Tu Semcirda?

gaizarda

73%

Semcirda

9.9%

igive

darCa

11%

ar

vici/uari

pasuxze

6%

diax

45%

ar vici

14%

ara

41%

xelfasebis kalkulaciis axali sqemis efeqturoba (maswavleblebi)

rogor fiqrobT, aisaxeba Tu ara es swavlebis xarisxze?

35

57

60

8

6

23

23

87

80

52

41

38

21

15

9

4

8

18

11

27

23

19

4

24

5

28

26

6

13

5

17

11

damxmare saSualebebis pirobebis gaumjobeseba

aamaRlebs ganaTlebis xarisxs Cvens skolaSi

maswavleblebis gasamrjelos gazrda gaaumjobesebs

ganaTlebis xarisxs Cvens skolaSi

me monawileobas miviReb sameurveo sabWos

arCevnebSi

ganaTlebis saministros xelmZRvaneloba

efeqturad uWers mxars da aumjobesebs swavlebis

process skolebSi

zogadad ganaTlebis sistema midis swori

mimarTulebiT

ganaTlebis saministro saTanadod (sworad)

afinansebs skolebs

me warvadgen Cems kandidaturas sameurveo sabWoze

erT moswavleze gacemuli vauCeri saSualod

Seadgens 210 lars, es sakmarisia imisaTvis, rom

xarisxiani ganaTleba miRon moswavleebma Cvens

skolaSi

ar veTanxmebi arc veTanxmebi da arc ar veTanxmebi veTanxmebi ar vici

ramdenad eTanxmebiT an ar eTanxmebiT:

mSoblebis damokidebuleba reformebis mimarT

2

4

28

42

46

19

21

41

51

50

79

31

76

4

8

mSoblebi

maswavleblebi

moswavleTa klubiswarmomadgenlebi

adgilobriviTviTmmarTvelobis

wevrebi

ganaTlebissaministros

warmomadgenlebi

diax ara ar vici

vin arian Tqvni skolis sameurveo sabWos wevrebi?

sameurveo sabWo studentebi

0.3

38.3

0.3

18.4

26.5

5.6

0.3

0.1

1.3

8.7

0.35

6

7

8

9

11

12

13

14

15

ar vici

ramdeni wevrisagan Sedgeba Tqveni skolis sameurveo sabWo?

diax

83%ara

17%

gsmeniaT Tu ara sameurveo sabWoebis

Sesaxeb raime?

diax

56%

ara

44%

iciT Tu ara, ra funqciebi da movaleobebi akisria sameurveo sabWos, Tqvens

skolaSi?

ZiriTadi daskvnebi 1. Riaoba da gamWvirvaleoba sakadro da sabiujeto

administrirebaSi aris ZiriTadi ganmsazRvreli, skolebSi arsebuli swavlis procesis xarisxis.

2. maRali xarisxis misaRwevad, mniSvnelovania maswavleblebis da skolis administraciis TanamSromlebis kmayofileba sakuTari xelfasebiT, Tumca maRali xarisxi mxolod xelfasebis momatebiT ar miiRweva.

3. araoficialuri gadasaxadebi da sxva tipis korufciuli garigebebi seriozulad vnebs swavlebis xarisxs

4. respodentTa umravlesobis mier, swavlebis da momsaxureobis xarisxi Tbilisis skolebSi dadebiTad Sefasda

5. gacilebiT meti respodenti afasebs mimdinare reformebs dadebiTad vidre uaryofiTad

6. respodentTa umetesoba kargadaa informirebuli, reformebis Sesaxeb zogad ganaTlebis sferoSi.

რეფორმების მონიტორინგი, პილოტური...

Documents

Transcript of რეფორმების მონიტორინგი, პილოტური...