Who Really Wears The Pants Seminar

Post on 21-May-2015

1.065 views 1 download

Tags:

description

Slides from a presentation on who has the power in a franchise relationship. Griffith University, Brisbane, Australia.

Transcript of Who Really Wears The Pants Seminar

1Information Services

Franchisor vs FranchiseeWho really wears

the pants?

Professor Lorelle FrazerGriffith University

Jason GehrkeFranchise Advisory Centre

2Information Services

Research about franchising conflict

• Sponsored by the ACCC and Griffith University– Research team: Frazer, Weaven, Wright

• Preliminary study to explore issues– Power, control, conflict

• Interviewed 15 franchising sector ‘experts’

3Information Services

Participants• 3 x consultants• 1 x accountant• 3 x lawyers• 1 x corporate lawyer• 1x broker• 2 x franchisors• 3 x franchisees• 1 x master franchisee

4Information Services

Themes we explored

• Who holds the power?• Are franchisor / franchisee goals in alignment?• Is franchising a ‘partnership’ arrangement?• Main causes of conflict

5Information Services

What we found

6Information Services

Who wears the pants?

• Depends– On the success of the franchisee

– On the stage of the franchising relationship

– On the ‘size’ of the franchisee’s holdings

7Information Services

Nature of power

• Perception– Each side thinks the other has the power

• Reality– Agreements are written in franchisor’s favour

8Information Services

Alignment of goals

• Franchisor goals– To grow the network

– To maximise sales

– To make a profit when they sell the business

• Franchisee goals– To maximise profits

– To achieve a desired lifestyle

9Information Services

Nature of the relationship

• Partnership• Employer-employee• Master-servant• Commercial marriage• Contractual relationship

10Information Services

What causes conflict?

• Poor performance of franchisee’s business• Poor communication• Change• Fear mongering by franchisees• Third party interference• Disagreements about marketing

11Information Services

The role of the founder

• A reason why some people join franchises• Founder’s role changes over time• Replaced by ‘Head Office’• Franchisor arrogance

12Information Services

“This would be a great

business if I didn’t have to

put up with the franchisees”

13Information Services

Franchisee selection is the key

• Have you ever heard the following?

14Information Services

I’m not suitable for franchising.

15Information Services

Franchisor’s responsibility

Put your golf clubs away. You won’t be needing them for the next

5 years.

16Information Services

Definitions

Source: Macquarie Dictionary

• Ability to influence the behaviour of others;• A function of dependency (importance, non-subsitituability, scarcity)• Ability to influence the allocation of resources;

17Information Services

5 Bases of Power

1. Coercive Power – based on fear;2. Reward Power – based on the ability to distribute

rewards that others view as valuable;3. Legitimate Power – based on position of

authority;4. Expert Power – based on special skills or

knowledge;5. Referent Power – based on desirable resources

or traits;French & Raven

18Information Services

Franchisor Franchisee

Coercive Termination; Supply Media; Association; Royalties

Reward Awards; Royalty scale; Concessions; Renewal; multi-sites;

Financial; Reference, FAC

Legitimate Franchise agreement;

Brand owner;

Franchising Code; TPA;

Expert Product/service innovation Product/service innovation; Practical experience; market knowledge; Brand implementer

Incompetence;

Referent Role model Role model

19Information Services

20Information Services

Franchise Population & Power

Power per franchisee

Total franchisees

X

X

X XX

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

XX

X

XX

21Information Services

Time

BEFORE DURING AFTER

A model of franchise power over time

Copyright, Jason Gehrke 2007

Franchisor

Franchisee

Established,

Growing

Mature

New

22Information Services

Franchising at Griffith University

• Teach franchising courses at undergraduate and postgraduate level

• Members of franchising sector eligible to study• Staff have PhDs in franchising• Currently 7 franchising PhDs enrolled• Franchising Australia surveys• Government funded research

23Information Services

Path to an MBA

• Franchising course at Griffith (July 2002);

• Postgraduate Diploma (4);• Graduate Certificate (+4);• Master of Business

Administration (MBA) (+3)