Post on 02-Dec-2014
description
Birth of A New Discipline(?): “The Science of Morality”
Image: http://www.artinthepicture.com/artists/Alessandro_Botticelli/birth.jpeg /
Tim Zebohttp://www.slideshare.net/jerseyguy http://www.facebook.com/tim.zebotzebo@usa.net
UUCMC DialogJanuary 16, 2011
Ver. 011611
“The Moral Landscape” (293 pages)
tjz-2
References (~880; 14%)
Notes(364;15%)
Ver. 011611
Judgments of Facts & Values
tjz-3
Facts: the way things are - “This DVD weighs .55 ounces” Values: what’s worthwhile (or not)?
• Aesthetic- “This is great science fiction”• Comparative- “Star Wars #1 is better than #2.”•Instrumental- “Netflix can easily mail this.”• Interpretive- “War will always be with us.”•Moral-”It’s wrong to copy this DVD based on harm, fairness & authority.”
Ver. 011611
Brain States of Conscious Creatures
tjz-4
? ?
Ver. 011611
Morality <=> Well-Being (Brain States)
tjz-5
Ver. 011611
Premise: Flourishing depends on measurable facts
tjz-6
Brain States
Individual & Group Behaviors
World Conditions: Cultural, Economic, Political, Environmental, etc., etc., etc.
Outcomes for Human Flourishing: “The Moral Landscape”
Ver. 011611
Outcomes for Human Flourishing: “The Moral Landscape”
tjz-7
Good LivesBad Lives
Terrific Lives
Horrible Lives
Premise: Some have better lives than others
Ver. 011611
Outcomes for Human Flourishing: “The Moral Landscape”
tjz-8
Good LivesBad Lives
Terrific Lives
Horrible Lives
• What are the dimensions of human flourishing?• Do UU’s Seven Principles cover all the dimensions?
• What are the dimensions of human flourishing?• Do UU’s Seven Principles cover all the dimensions?
Possible Dialog TopicsPossible Dialog Topics
Ver. 011611
Why should we care? The Moral Landscape: “Introduction”
tjz-9
• What risks does “faith” (belief without evidence) pose to human flourishing? • What risks does “faith” (belief without evidence) pose to human flourishing?
Possible Dialog TopicPossible Dialog Topic
“Science & religion are in conflict because evidence & reasoning trump “faith” when it comes to understanding reality.”
“Science & religion are in conflict because evidence & reasoning trump “faith” when it comes to understanding reality.”
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_7h08RDYA5E
U.S. House of Representatives Energy and Commerce CommitteeChairmanFred Upton (R-MI) – “Every member and every subcommittee will be on the frontlines as we take on federal agencies to target areas to immediately cut spending."Subcommittee on Environment and EconomyChair - John Shimkus (R-IL)Vice Chair - Tim Murphy (R-PA)
Ver. 011611
Chapter 1: “Moral Truth”
tjz-10
• “That feminists in the West remain silent about this deeply ingrained and institutionalized mistreatment of women is a scandal of our time.” What, if anything, should UUs do about “women in cloth bags”?
• “That feminists in the West remain silent about this deeply ingrained and institutionalized mistreatment of women is a scandal of our time.” What, if anything, should UUs do about “women in cloth bags”?
Possible Dialog TopicPossible Dialog Topic
http://tbknews.blogspot.com/2007/10/violent-oppression-of-women-in-islam.html
• Even educated people today mistakenly believe there is only moral preference; Harris disagrees
• Well Being, like health, lies on a continuum defined by goals - both can be measured using science and reason as tools.
• Science can measure the best & worst possible lives (e.g., “women in cloth bags”).
• Even educated people today mistakenly believe there is only moral preference; Harris disagrees
• Well Being, like health, lies on a continuum defined by goals - both can be measured using science and reason as tools.
• Science can measure the best & worst possible lives (e.g., “women in cloth bags”).
Chapter TextChapter Text
Ver. 011611
Chapter 2: “Good & Evil”
• Brain science of human cooperation is still a mystery!
• Our moral “blind spots” (e.g., genocide neglect)• Great cruelty comes from idea that humans
possess a soul independent of : genes, parents, culture, economics, disease, etc.
• How often does “evil” depend on a nutritional deficiency?
• When is our impulse for retribution profoundly flawed? (Aggression to outsiders HUs: 1; Chimps: 200x)
• Illusion of free will, moral realism, consequentialism, contractualism, etc.
• Brain science of human cooperation is still a mystery!
• Our moral “blind spots” (e.g., genocide neglect)• Great cruelty comes from idea that humans
possess a soul independent of : genes, parents, culture, economics, disease, etc.
• How often does “evil” depend on a nutritional deficiency?
• When is our impulse for retribution profoundly flawed? (Aggression to outsiders HUs: 1; Chimps: 200x)
• Illusion of free will, moral realism, consequentialism, contractualism, etc.
Chapter TextChapter Text
tjz-11
Would we lose anything if we spoke of “well-being” instead of “right”, “good”, “moral”, “evil”, etc ?
Would we lose anything if we spoke of “well-being” instead of “right”, “good”, “moral”, “evil”, etc ?
Possible Dialog TopicPossible Dialog Topic http://www.sas.upenn.edu/~baron/journal/7303a/jdm7303a.htm
Ver. 011611
Chapter 3: “Belief”
tjz-12
• “Belief formation is influenced by many sub-conscious processes (e.g., Soc. Sec. #’s & # MDs in San Francisco)
• Skeptics given L-DOPA are more likely to accept metaphysical reasons for natural phenomena.”
• “Belief formation is influenced by many sub-conscious processes (e.g., Soc. Sec. #’s & # MDs in San Francisco)
• Skeptics given L-DOPA are more likely to accept metaphysical reasons for natural phenomena.”
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uYtYQ0a7btQ
• “Perhaps deception, even more than violence, is the chief enemy of human cooperation.”
• “Perhaps deception, even more than violence, is the chief enemy of human cooperation.”
Possible Dialog TopicPossible Dialog Topic
Ver. 011611
Chapter 4: “Religion” “Cannot be the source for moral truth”
• Even fundamentalists have to “edit the books”:
• Love neighbor as self • Stone any woman who’s
not a virgin on her wedding night
• Even fundamentalists have to “edit the books”:
• Love neighbor as self • Stone any woman who’s
not a virgin on her wedding night
tjz-13
World Sciences World Religions
http://www.project-reason.org/gallery3/image/105/
Contradictions in the Bible
Ver. 011611
Chapter 5: “The Future of Happiness”
• Hard problem: well-being & satisfaction depend on history: - drug addict or Oprah?
• Easier to speak of “moving up” or “moving down”
• “Happiness” Science finds: We very poorly: - remember past - perceive present - predict future
• Our experiencing self & remembering self often disagree!
• Hard problem: well-being & satisfaction depend on history: - drug addict or Oprah?
• Easier to speak of “moving up” or “moving down”
• “Happiness” Science finds: We very poorly: - remember past - perceive present - predict future
• Our experiencing self & remembering self often disagree!
Chapter TextChapter Text
tjz-14• Is it ethical to prolong minor suffering to create happier memories?• Is it ethical to prolong minor suffering to create happier memories?
Possible Dialog TopicPossible Dialog Topic
Ver. 011611
Comments by Steven PinkerHarvard Philosopher; Author, “How the Mind Works”
• Terrible reasons to believe what’s “right” & “wrong” are:
• Faith (belief without evidence)
• Subjective certainty• Scripture• Authority
• Science has informed advances in our morality:
• Torture• Racism
• Terrible reasons to believe what’s “right” & “wrong” are:
• Faith (belief without evidence)
• Subjective certainty• Scripture• Authority
• Science has informed advances in our morality:
• Torture• Racism
AgreesAgrees
• If “science” is ONLY biology, chemistry & physics, it’s necessary, but NOT sufficient, to determine right from wrong
• Reasoning (NOT science or religion) that brought about changes in our criminal justice system
• Only administer enough punishment to deter without a perverse incentive structure
• The worse the crime, the worse the punishment
• If “science” is ONLY biology, chemistry & physics, it’s necessary, but NOT sufficient, to determine right from wrong
• Reasoning (NOT science or religion) that brought about changes in our criminal justice system
• Only administer enough punishment to deter without a perverse incentive structure
• The worse the crime, the worse the punishment
ReservationsReservations
tjz-15http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8fbplK-J5IA
Ver. 011611
Comments by Lawrence KraussPhysicist, The Origins Project, Author, “Quantum Man:
Richard Feynman’s Life in Science”
• Our morality is constrained by our biology AND the social contract• It’s impossible to define morality without science (=“secular empiricism”)• Science is the way to determine the consequences of our actions• Science ethos: honesty, openess, creativity, anti-authoritarianism, full
disclosure==a moral society• When humans behave irrationally it’s usually based on incomplete
information (e.g., Stem cell debate: Blastocysts cannot be used for reproduction; there is no “moment of conception” – huge number of steps between the union of sperm and egg and a new entity
• Questions science can ask & answer: • Is a woman safer if she’s in a cloth bag?• Is her self-worth improved?• Is she freer to manifest her capabilities as a human being?
• Our morality is constrained by our biology AND the social contract• It’s impossible to define morality without science (=“secular empiricism”)• Science is the way to determine the consequences of our actions• Science ethos: honesty, openess, creativity, anti-authoritarianism, full
disclosure==a moral society• When humans behave irrationally it’s usually based on incomplete
information (e.g., Stem cell debate: Blastocysts cannot be used for reproduction; there is no “moment of conception” – huge number of steps between the union of sperm and egg and a new entity
• Questions science can ask & answer: • Is a woman safer if she’s in a cloth bag?• Is her self-worth improved?• Is she freer to manifest her capabilities as a human being?
Agrees that:Agrees that:
tjz-16http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZcL8oFgSESE
Ver. 011611
Comments by Simon BlackburnBertrand Russel Professor of Philosophy at Cambridge,
Author, “How to Read Hume”
• Empirical investigation is good idea
• We should be more charitable & loyal
• Recognize that charity often goes awry (e.g., Biafra food aid)
• Benefits come when values are tempered by science (e.g., male & female brain studies will help break down gender barriers)
• Empirical investigation is good idea
• We should be more charitable & loyal
• Recognize that charity often goes awry (e.g., Biafra food aid)
• Benefits come when values are tempered by science (e.g., male & female brain studies will help break down gender barriers)
AgreesAgrees
• Two kinds of mental states:• Beliefs: knowledge about the
world• Desires/Concerns: motivators
to change the world• Values reflect desires; things that
“must” be done• Difficulty: What IS human
flourishing? Drugged zombie?; Fool’s Paradise (Delusion)?; Suppressed desires (Stoic)?; Greediness?
• How to prioritize well-being of self vs family vs friends vs world?
• Two kinds of mental states:• Beliefs: knowledge about the
world• Desires/Concerns: motivators
to change the world• Values reflect desires; things that
“must” be done• Difficulty: What IS human
flourishing? Drugged zombie?; Fool’s Paradise (Delusion)?; Suppressed desires (Stoic)?; Greediness?
• How to prioritize well-being of self vs family vs friends vs world?
ReservationsReservations
tjz-17http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W8vYq6Xm2To
Ver. 011611
Let’s Dialog
Ver. 011611 tjz-19
• What are the dimensions of human flourishing?• Do UU’s Seven Principles cover all the dimensions? • What risks does “faith” (belief without evidence) pose to human flourishing?
• What, if anything, should UUs do about “women in cloth bags”?
• Perhaps deception, even more than violence, is the chief enemy of human cooperation
• Is it ethical to prolong minor suffering to create happier memories?
• What else?
• What are the dimensions of human flourishing?• Do UU’s Seven Principles cover all the dimensions? • What risks does “faith” (belief without evidence) pose to human flourishing?
• What, if anything, should UUs do about “women in cloth bags”?
• Perhaps deception, even more than violence, is the chief enemy of human cooperation
• Is it ethical to prolong minor suffering to create happier memories?
• What else?
Possible Dialog Topics: RecapPossible Dialog Topics: Recap
Ver. 011611
Dialog Topic: Dimensions of Human Flourishing & UU’s 7 Principles
tjz-20
Moral actions to cultivate because they increase human flourishing: Health
• Physical: Eating/exercise habits keeping you at a healthy weight• Emotional: Thinking habits keeping you feeling good• Cognitive: Thinking habits keeping you thinking rationally• Sexual: All habits keeping you sexual satisfied
Financial• Spending habits keeping you out of debt
(Friendly & Healthy) Social & Political• Family: etc.• Friends: etc.• Neighbors: etc.• Churches, clubs, teams, … : etc.• Strangers: etc.
Environmental …(Unfriendly & Unhealthy) Social & Political
• e.g., Sociopaths = 3% Males, 1% Females …
?
??
?
?
Ver. 011611
Dialog Topic: Human Flourishing & Declaration of Human Rights
tjz-21
Moral actions to cultivate because they increase human flourishing: Health
• Physical: Eating/exercise habits keeping you at a healthy weight• Emotional: Thinking habits keeping you feeling good• Cognitive: Thinking habits keeping you thinking rationally• Sexual: All habits keeping you sexual satisfied
Financial• Spending habits keeping you out of debt
(Friendly & Healthy) Social & Political• Family: etc.• Friends: etc.• Neighbors: etc.• Churches, clubs, teams, … : etc.• Strangers: etc.
Environmental …(Unfriendly & Unhealthy) Social & Political
• e.g., Sociopaths = 3% Males, 1% Females …
?
??
Ver. 011611
Dialog Topic: Human Flourishing & The Ten Commandments
tjz-22
(“Immoral”?) Actions to avoid because they decrease human flourishing?: Health
• Physical: Eating/exercise habits keeping you from a healthy weight• Emotional: Thinking habits keeping you from feeling good• Cognitive: Thinking habits keeping you from thinking rationally• Sexual: All habits keeping you from sexual satisfaction
Financial• Spending habits keeping you in debt
(Friendly & Healthy) Social & Political• Family: etc.• Friends: etc.• Neighbors: etc.• Churches, clubs, teams, … : etc.• Strangers: etc.
Environmental …(Unfriendly & Unhealthy) Social & Political
• e.g., Sociopaths = 3% Males, 1% Females …
?
??
?
?
?
?
Ver. 011611
The Moral Landscape: “Introduction”
• Better or worse human flourishing? - depends on facts about brain states, the world & behavior
• Values do derive from facts (e.g., DVD copies lead to measurable harm)
• Hume (“ought from is”) & Gould (“NOMA”) are simply mistaken.
• Better or worse human flourishing? - depends on facts about brain states, the world & behavior
• Values do derive from facts (e.g., DVD copies lead to measurable harm)
• Hume (“ought from is”) & Gould (“NOMA”) are simply mistaken.
Chapter TextChapter Text
tjz-23
• What are the dimensions of human flourishing?• Do UU’s Seven Principles cover all the dimensions?
• What are the dimensions of human flourishing?• Do UU’s Seven Principles cover all the dimensions?
• Dennett: “If ‘ought’ cannot be derived from ‘is’, what can it be derived from?
• Moral truth: Theft is wrong because it harms human flourishing in measurable ways
• Nutritional truth: Eating sat. fat is wrong because it harms human bodies in measurable ways.
• Dennett: “If ‘ought’ cannot be derived from ‘is’, what can it be derived from?
• Moral truth: Theft is wrong because it harms human flourishing in measurable ways
• Nutritional truth: Eating sat. fat is wrong because it harms human bodies in measurable ways.
Chapter NotesChapter Notes
Possible Dialog TopicsPossible Dialog Topics
Ver. 011611
Chapter 1: “Moral Truth”
tjz-24
• A psychopath’s pleasures are NOT an “alternate morality”. Without empathy they cannot experience generalizable human flourishing.
• A psychopath’s pleasures are NOT an “alternate morality”. Without empathy they cannot experience generalizable human flourishing.
Chapter 1 NotesChapter 1 Notes
Ver. 011611
Chapter 4: “Religion”
tjz-25
• “Religion brings benefits to developing societies, but the happiest and most secure societies are the most secular
•Best predictor of social well-being is tolerance of differences (e.g., gays, lesbians, women, other religions, etc.). Tolerance does NOT flourish under orthodox religions.
•Religion is why we’re talking about gay marriage instead of a national energy policy.”
• “Religion brings benefits to developing societies, but the happiest and most secure societies are the most secular
•Best predictor of social well-being is tolerance of differences (e.g., gays, lesbians, women, other religions, etc.). Tolerance does NOT flourish under orthodox religions.
•Religion is why we’re talking about gay marriage instead of a national energy policy.”
Chapter 4 NotesChapter 4 Notes
Ver. 011611
Outcomes for Human Flourishing: “The Moral Landscape”
tjz-26