Post on 09-Feb-2018
Meeting minutes
Subject/Ref
Air Products Acetylene Gas Production Facility:
Public Meeting
Venue
Japie Greyling Primary School, Daleside
Date of Meeting
20 February 2014
Present
ERM Kasantha Moodley
Gary McFadden
Lisa Otten
Air Products Barry Little
Tom Maclean
Leon Serfontein
Local Ward
Councillor
Rob Jones
Please refer to the Attendance Register
attached as Annex B to these minutes
Environmental Resources Management Building 32 1st Floor The Woodlands Office Park Woodlands Drive
Woodmead, 2148 Facsimile Email
Attached: Meeting Attendance Register Presentation Slides
Meeting minutes
Comment Commentator
Comments received during the Open House Event
1. Concerned about the risk of potential fires/explosion. The facility should have the necessary measures on site to manage fires as the local fire department are not reliable.
Gerhard
2. • Recognises the positive economic benefits of an international company in the area, particularly with regards to job creation.
• The facility is a step towards the planned R59 corridor development.
• Believes that Air Products understands the risks associated with the proposed development otherwise they would not be investing.
• Willie is the pastor of the local Daleside church and runs a feeding scheme that feeds the local community 5 days a week from produce donated by local farmers.
Willie de Kock
3. Misunderstanding relating to the proposed development of a kiln at the Glen Douglas dolomite mine and the proposed Air Products facility.
Jennifer Zeiss
Comments received during the Public Meeting
1. Is this the first acetylene plant in South Africa using this production process and will acetone be produced as part of the process? Air Products operates two other acetylene gas production facilities in South Africa using a similar production process. Acetone is not manufactured in the process, acetone is used for the safe storage and transport of the acetylene gas (ie acetylene gas is dissolved in acetone during cylinder filling.
Unknown participant 1 (participant did not sign attendance register)
2. The smell of carbide is a nuisance to the residents who are in lee of the surrounding factories. It should be noted that the calcium carbide will be stored in airtight containers (turnbins) to avoid contact with air and moisture. All other products used in the production process will also be stored in airtight containers including the acetone and nitrogen. The stakeholder was invited to visit the existing Air Products facility in Kempton Park.
Unknown participant 1
3. What is the cost of building this plant? The estimated cost of building the plant exceeds millions of rands.
4. What is the waste product produced and will it create dust emissions? Lime slurry is not a waste product, it is considered a by-product of the production process and is planned to be made available to local contractors for use in the agricultural/infrastructure sectors. This slurry will be stored in sludge separation units where water will be drawn off. The lime will be transported in a putty form, therefore there will be no dust emissions.
Unknown participant 1
5. Where is the calcium carbide produced? It is produced in Newcastle and transported in containers.
Unknown participant 1
Meeting minutes
6. Are the reaction tanks open to the atmosphere? The generator tanks and entire production process is a closed loop system, to not allow the release of acetylene gas.
Unknown participant 1
7. What are the sources of air pollution? Based on the operations at the existing Air Products facilities, the atmospheric emissions are generally low as the produced gas is kept in the contained system. The release of gases is only likely during an emergency situation/unplanned event, ie fires or explosions. An Air Quality Impact Assessment will be undertaken to determine the potential air emissions from the construction and operation of the proposed facility as well as the cumulative impact on the air quality of the study area.
Unknown participant 1
8. What is the reason behind the site location? The R59 development corridor is identified as an important industrial corridor within the region. The facility requires a good distribution network and the R59 provides easy access to the major highways. Various other sites were considered during the pre-feasibility stage of the project, however the land was not considered feasible based on technical, environmental and financial considerations. In Daleside, two other sites were considered that did not meet the necessary criteria. It should be noted that the proposed facility will comprise the latest design/technology and meet all required international and local standards in terms of environment, health and safety and social aspects.
Andries Potgieter
9. Will the production process use large amounts of water? Where will the water be discharged? It is planned to collect and store storm water run-off which will be channelled to two catchment pits on site (site slopes towards the East). 214 m3/hr of water will be required for Phase 1 (top-up water). Plant will use 80-90% recycled water in a closed loop system. For additional water requirements, borehole and/or municipal water will be used.
Thabo Mahloane
10. What about the residual smell of lime? There is very little to no smell associated with the lime. This will remain around the area of the pit as an onsite odour.
Unknown participant 1
11. What are the operational times of the plant? The facility will operate for 24 hours for 5 days a week.
Unknown participant 1
12. How many empty vs full cylinders will be on site? There will be 380 cylinders on site per shift.
Jennifer Zeiss
13. Will there be any pollution of the Klip River, particularly in flood situations? The catchment pits are 4 500 m3 each and are open to provide adequate storage of storm runoff water. The surface area around the plant will be concreted so that runoff is directed to the pits and not off site. Surface water from the dirty areas will be recycled and re-used on site.
Jennifer Zeiss
14. When is construction expected? Jennifer Zeiss
Meeting minutes
Should the EIA be approved, construction is planned for December 2014. All project stakeholders will be provided the opportunity to appeal the decision, prior to construction.
15. Will the proposed development lower the property values in Daleside? The R59 has been identified as a strategic industrial and commercial corridor for development. The proposed facility itself is not likely to result in reduced property values as there are several industries operating in the area. However, this will be considered in EIA process.
Jennifer Zeiss
16. Received notification of the public meeting on day of therefore expects that many residents haven’t attended the meeting as they haven’t been informed. Notification of the meeting was sent on 17 January 2014. ERM sent out a reminder a week before the meeting and the local Ward councillor sent out a reminder a day before the meeting. Attendees were encouraged to complete the attendance register and include the details of any residents they think should be included in the stakeholder database. Suggested other public forums/places for future notifications: Post office in Henley on Klip, churches in Daleside, local radio station, Principal’s forum, and municipality communications. All attendees’ details will be noted from the attendance register and used for future communications. The possible options for future notifications have been noted and will be considered.
Unknown participant 1
17. Has the Plan of Study been submitted as part of the Draft Scoping Report and has specialist studies been undertaken? Yes, a Plan of Study for EIA has been included in the draft report and will be submitted as part of the Final Scoping Report as well. Detailed specialist studies are still to be undertaken.
Andries Potgieter
18. What is the life span of the facility? Has the community been taken into account when the plant is decommissioned? The lifespan of the facility will be approximately 50 years. A project specific fund will be set aside for the community as part of the Air Products Corporate Social Responsibility Programme. Air Products will consult with the community around possible initiatives for the CSR. The community is encouraged to share and identify initiatives to benefit from the fund.
Thabo Mahloane
Divider custom What’s this layout for? Use this if you with to change the colour of the lines
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Proposed Acetylene Gas Production Facility Environmental Impact Assessment
Public Meeting 20 February 2014
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Agenda
Introduction 5 minutes
Project Description 15 minutes
EIA Process 10 minutes
Open Discussion 25 minutes
Questions
Issues and concerns
Summary and Way Forward 5 minutes
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Principles for Sharing
Please…
Mobile phones turned off or on silent
All comments are welcome and will be recorded
Raise a hand if you would like to ask a question
Clearly introduce yourself
Speak loudly so that everyone can hear
Don’t interrupt others
Please allow for different opinions & different views
Address all questions / remarks through the facilitator
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Purpose of the Meeting
4
To share information about the Project
To enable stakeholders to raise concerns/ questions about the Project
To provide responses to concerns and questions, where possible
To inform the EIA to ensure that it is relevant and appropriate
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Introductions
Air Products South Africa (Pty) Ltd
Private company formed by a 50/50 joint venture between Air Products, Chemicals INC and Metkor Group Holdings
Manufactures, supplies and distributes a variety of industrial and specialty gas products and chemicals to the Southern African region
Environmental Resources Management Southern Africa (Pty) Ltd
Independent environmental and social assessment practitioners appointed to undertake the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Process
ERM has extensive experience in undertaking EIAs in the Gauteng region
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Project Background
6
Existing Acetylene Gas Production Facilities Located in Pinetown and Kempton Park Operational for > 40 years with aged infrastructure Encroached by other industrial and residential development
Proposed Project Plan: Close down these two facilities Construct and develop a new facility on a site where the potential
off-site risks can be managed The facility is proposed to be constructed in the center of two
properties
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
7
Proposed Location - Daleside
Insert Map
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Project Site
8
Stand 88 and 89 of Valley Settlements Agricultural Holdings – Air Products have purchased both properties
Combined area of the stands is 4.4 ha
Current Zoning – Industrial 3
Surrounding land-uses: East: Manufacturing facilities South: Equipment maintenance and storage facilities West: Private North: Manufacturing facilities
Residential properties have been identified along Lawa, Graniet, Kalksteen and Tillet Roads.
Existing site access via Tillet Road (off Springbok Road)
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Proposed Site Layout
9
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Production Process
10
Filler Hoppers and Generator Vessel
Cylinder Filling
Calcium Carbide + Water Calcium Hydroxide + Acetylene Gas Exothermic Reaction
Project to be developed in 2 Phases: Phase 1: Production capacity of 7200
m3/day (December 2015) Phase 2: Total production capacity of 14
400 m3/day (2022)
Uses: welding and cutting of metals
Lime (by-product) will be stored on site for collection
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Key Project Components
11
Cylinder Filling
1. Generator Vessel 2. Compressors
3. Driers 3. Cylinder Filling
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
12
Facility Illustration
Insert Map
Ring Road
Lime separation area
Fire water pits
Workshop
Offices and Change Facilities
Cylinder Storage
Cylinder filling
Material storage
Generator and Compressors
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
EIA Process
13
EIA required under National Environmental Management Act (NEMA) (Act No. 107 of 1998), as amended
Key Listed Activities in terms of GNR. 545 (2010): (3) The construction of facilities or infrastructure for the storage, or storage and
handling of a dangerous good, where such storage occurs in containers with a combined capacity of more than 500 cubic metres.
(4) The construction of facilities or infrastructure for the refining, extraction or processing of gas, oil or petroleum products with an installed capacity of 50 cubic metres or more per day.
(5) The construction of facilities or infrastructure for any process or activity which requires a permit or license in terms of national or provincial legislation governing the generation or release of emissions…
Air Emissions Licence (AEL) will be applied for: Subcategory 6.1 (Organic Chemical Manufacturing)
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Progress with EIA
14
We are here
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Specialist Studies
15
Biological Studies Terrestrial Ecology Physical Studies Air Quality Site Traffic Heritage and Archaeology Major Hazardous Installation Geotechnical and Dolomite Investigation
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Existing Site View
16
Existing farmhouse to be upgraded View of site – facing South Site will be cleared of these buildings
Tillet Road Site is disturbed and undeveloped
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Potential Key Impacts
17
Impacts to Soil / Ground Resources Impacts to Water Resources Impacts to Vegetation and Fauna on
site Impacts to Cultural Resources Impacts to Air Quality Traffic Impacts Noise Impacts Social Impacts Unplanned Events
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Quantitative Risk Assessment
18
Proposed development considered a Major Hazardous Installation (MHI) under the current MHI Regulations (2001)
Key findings of MHI Assessment (by ERM):
Location Specific Individual Risk Risk is greater to individuals indoors than outdoors due to potential
building collapse on site from potential explosion Minimal risks beyond the boundary of the site
Potential offsite effects include radiation from acetone pool fires or
overpressures from acetylene explosions
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Location Specific Risk
19
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Loss of Containment – Acetone Pool Fire
20
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Loss of Containment – Acetylene Explosion
21
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Open Discussion
22
Please raise any questions, concerns and/or queries that you may have on the Project and/or the EIA Process…
The world’s leading sustainability consultancy
Contents What’s this layout for? Formatting for contents slide – this slide has slightly different spacing between lines to emphasise topics
Way Forward
23
Commenting Period on the Draft Scoping Report closes on 26 February 2014 (next Wednesday)
Incorporate all comments received on the Draft Scoping Report into the Final Scoping Report
Release Final Scoping Report for Public Review (21 days)
Submit the Final Scoping Report to GDARD
Thank you for your valued participation in this process!